Canon C200 VS Blackmagic URSA Mini Pro G2! WHICH ONE WINS?!
HTML-код
- Опубликовано: 11 июл 2024
- We brought the Canon C200 and the Blackmagic URSA Mini Pro G2 head to head to see which one is the best camera in all lighting situations - pushing the settings to the limit! Which one would you choose?
Canon C200
B&H: bhpho.to/2Crtkr8
Amazon: amzn.to/31DDe4N
Blackmagic URSA Mini Pro G2
B&H: bhpho.to/2Jn3qwX
Amazon: amzn.to/2MFE6S8
Follow The Slanted Lens-
Facebook: / theslantedlens
Twitter: / theslantedlens
Instagram: / theslantedlens
---
GEAR USED:
Canon C200
B&H: bhpho.to/2Crtkr8
Amazon: amzn.to/31DDe4N
Blackmagic URSA Mini Pro G2
B&H: bhpho.to/2Jn3qwX
Amazon: amzn.to/2MFE6S8
__
Jay P. Morgan has been working as a Commercial Photographer and Film Director in the Los Angeles area for more than 20 years developing an impressive list of clients from Paramount to McDonald's. Jay P.'s experience with elaborate set design and extensive lighting are key to the success of his illustrative work.
Support The Slanted Lens by shopping our affiliate links:
Weekly Photography Deals & More: bhpho.to/2AxlpH2
Amazon- amzn.to/1T7Z20D
---
Subscribe to The Slanted Lens and get new videos every Thursday
bit.ly/1RgdYoM
Visit the webpage: theslantedlens.com
Visit our SPONSORS
Tamron Lenses: bit.ly/2mZgkoz
Blackrapid: www.blackrapid.com
Platypod: www.platypod.com/
Morgan Photo Retouch: www.morganphotoretouch.com
Datacolor: bit.ly/2lZk8Bi
Vanguard: www.vanguardworld.us/
Triple Scoop Music: www.triplescoopmusic.com
SKB: www.skbcases.com/
TSL Store: theslantedlens.com/tsl-store/
I've owned and used both cameras and find the Ursa Mini G2 to look a bit more filmic and the C200 a bit more "video-ish." I wish Canon would have done more for the raw file workflow. The Braw is SO much more flexible and easy to work with and change on the fly in post - That's a HUGE selling point if you're working in raw. The interchangeable lens mount option is what sold me on the Ursa. It has way more visual possibilities through lenses, codecs, frame rates, and raw workflow.
Steve Schriemer really good points all around! It definitely depends on the intended use as well.
"Ursa Mini G2 to look a bit more filmic and the C200 a bit more "video-ish." is the reason why I chose Ursa G2.
You’re dead on.. C200 is not so impressive. Have owned both. The C500ii on the other hand really holds its own against everything up to even the amira for Sooc
Great comparison! I personally like the color of skin tones coming out of the C200.
Thanks so much Derrick! Yes, Canon always does a great job with skin tone!
I agree. Canon rocks for skin tones. I also think the URSA is too contrast-y.
My vote goes to the Ursa Mini. Having ProRes is a major advantage, and a great tool!
Great point!
Nothing what cant be added by Software update
ProRes is indeed such a great option.
Everyone has a different taste, but one of the main reasons I personally chose to get a C200 over an ursa was actually the form factor, and I shoulder the camera quite a bit. With the C200 you can strip it down or build it out, and anything in between. You can rig it specifically for whatever the job requires. It can be small and light weight for gimbal use or run and gun type shoots. Or it can be fully rigged up to a healthy weight for balancing well on your shoulder and studio setups. With the ursa it just always felt very clunky to me, and no matter how you rig it it's essentially one form factor, where as with the C200 you have lots of options and versatility. Codecs and frame rates are the main advantage of the ursa I'd say. But both are great cameras.
Excellent review, thank you!
You are welcome! Glad you enjoyed it!
I love my c200, I bought a CC Tech Cfast to msata adapter with 1TB little msata drive I can shoot Raw for 2 hr and edit in the same drive in the Cfast reader!
Jaime Jr King links?
Creative Films just search for CFast to SSD on eBay
It would be nice to see a 4K upload
LOL
C200 has more cinematic touch colors more filmic less digital love it 😍
I only shoot RAW on my C200. Just slap on a Solidpod, and you have a very cheap mSata drive solution 😀
Im not sure if you remembered to auto black balance the camera, when changing ISO.
If not the RAW footage can get a bit noisy. In general, RAW footage can benefit from a slight noise reduction 😀
Great points Thomas! Really helpful to hear your perspective from owning the C200! What do you typically shoot with the C200?
@@TheSlantedLens At the moment it is testimonial videos for a customer, 10 pcs. in total. One day of shooting, and one days editing, that's it.
I'm also starting to put my nerdy mindset in play on LinkedIn, creating videos, where I will give my take on a solution, to technical difficult issues, regarding photo/video, giving something back to the creative community ;0)
*⚠️Will there be a comparison with the camera Z-Cam E2 ???*
Nice & Thanks :)
That cute model again❤️
Thanks for watching. Have a great week-end!
Hi! How’d do you like that Benro Tripod of yours?
I kinda like C200 colors.
Agreed!
Three years running and still a great review. Canon really has the color figured out. The downside, as you've pointed out is the limited codecs... it's like they took the C100mk II (which already has 4K sensor) and added internal RAW + 4:2:2 10bit capability. If they included prores, they'd kill C300 sales. Of course, you can get a great deal on a C200 right now... they're almost giving them away...
Good points. Thanks for sharing your thoughts!
Thanks for the great video!.
A few months ago you did a similar comparison with the Ursa Mini Blackmagic vs. the Arri Amira. After watching that video, I concluded that the Blackmagic Ursa Mini would be what I would use for a (not high budget) independent feature film (not documentary). In this video you state that the Canon C200 may be a better choice than the Ursa Mini. Am I right? This is the same camera, right? So if the Canon C200 beats out the Ursa Mini G2 (outside of the "personal preference") and the Ursa G2 beat out the Arri Amira does that mean that the C200 would beat out the Arri Amira also? Still in my camera purchase decision trying to determine which camera under $10,000 (not including rig/lenses) is the best option. Now I'm a bit more undecided as to whether there is something that is the best option for the film. Any final thoughts? My film school is complete and I'm still in the procrastination/research phase but will be making a purchase. Thanks again.
Hey man! Just to be clear, I would say in no world does the C200 OR the Ursa Mini beat out the Arri Amira. Neither one has the color accuracy, dynamic range, or usability of the Arri. Of course, neither one costs nearly as much either! Between the C200 and the Ursa Mini it's a really hard choice. I personally think the C200 raw codec is phenomenal, but having the option with ProRes on the Ursa Mini is also very very nice. They're both great cameras honestly. If I had to choose between the two myself, I would go with the C200, as Canon cameras are built like tanks and extremely reliable, while BlackMagic cameras have had QC issues in the past. My biggest piece of advice is to purchase used. You can often save a good chunk of money buying used over new.
@@kennethcmerrill Thanks man! Much appreciated.
@@kennethcmerrill I was also looking at the Canon C300 MKII. Would that be an upgrade, in your opinion, from these two cameras? It's priced at $10,000 new and probably a few thousand less on the used market. Thanks again for making all the informative videos and bonus interaction!
Neither of these cameras beat ARRI
Maybe I missed it and sorry if I did but what’s your colour grading process for these? Did you grade the ursa footage in davinci and shoot with gen5?
Yes, we did grade it in DaVinci.
I got G2 and i never use LUT from BM becouse its crap and atenuate real latitude of G2, real power of this is when You grade from scratch and recover highlights than IT shine! C200 great cam, build like a tank great tool, but no 120fps at full res (4.6), no 300fps,(HD) no evf, depends on needs.cheers! Thanks for conparision
Does the C200 have a larger sensor? Why does the depth of field look shallower on the side by side?
The Blackmagic is slightly larger. So that would account for a little bit of difference. Good eyes!
The Slanted Lens interesting. Hard to decide between the two. Thanks!
Theres more light in the background when you filmed the URSA for the dynamic range test so are not comparing like-for-like. Should've filmed them simultaneously.
That is always our goal but sometimes it doesn't work out.
Really can't lose with both of them.. just comes down to personal preference
True. Both are great cameras. Thanks for watching!
Were you using ND's for this test? I guess the brownish tint on the URSA could be caused by IR pollution :S
Good question.I will have to get back to you on that one. Thanks for watching.
Which codec did you use for both camera tests?
Black magic 3:1 and Canon Raw lite.
The skintones on URSA look better to me. Better color contrast with C200 as it pushes out the yellows and greens are a bit more towards the blue, that looks but not natural.
I prefer canon's greens. Not a fan of the brown hue the greens have on BM cameras
You can adjust the colors to be whatever you want them to be... You can achieve the exact same colors as the Canon with 1 node in Resolve.
@@TonyDae that's true but if I can get the look in camera it will be much faster. Also I think it can be pretty hard to match since the greens are kinds brown which is in the same range as the skintones. So it will be hard to change it without affecting skintones
@@Aviciiz You can literally mathematically transform colorspaces to each other or make your own luts which can include colorspace transformations if you wish which will provide the same or close to the same colors without negatively affecting the skintones.
You can apply a lut and bake that into your shot if you want with the blackmagic camera, so you can do exactly what you are talking about and get the look you want straight out of camera.
Either way, you are either baking a look into the footage via LUT or using a LUT or grading in post, either can be equally as fast using either camera and ge thte exact same color results with little to no effort.
If you shoot braw, even 12:1 has a huge amount of room to make the colors whatever you want them to be with little effort at all.
@@TonyDae I think a large part of this brown look of the Ursa comes from IR pollution. So unfortunately that isn’t easily fixable with grading.
How about compering them to the new Sony pxw z750, now there's a proper camera wirh three 4k global shuttered imaging sensors
Ooo now there's an idea! Thanks, Peter!
Is the ursa shot with film mode or extended video?
Too long ago to remember. Sorry about that.
What does stops mean?? (I a rookie on film knowledge )
1 stop = 1EV, means 2 times brighter or darker.
Which ISOs have you used?
There is a complete ISO test in the video. Look at the results and see which one works for you.
C200 colors looks closer to the Amira from your other video, than to the Ursa G2.
Yes, that is how I felt. That Ursa looks pretty good though.
2:50 no way ursa looks better then c200 and 6:25 ursa clipping red channel on a dress while c200 maintain red color and highlights rolloff much better I think you could not go wrong with c200 for a price and size it’s the best out there
It is looks like ursa is the more reliable for inside filming and c200 is a very nice for outside filming
I think they both work great inside and outside!
I prefer the c200 for the color science in motion. What I mean by that is that it's easy to compare images from different cameras when the point of interest isn't moving. But when there's movement, then you get to see the colors in action from regular 24fps to 120fps.
Canon C200 FTW =)
Thanks for sharing you vote!
Canon. Every time.
Thanks for sharing your preference. And thanks for watching!
Keep your C200... crappy 8 bit huh? You didn’t say that on the original C200 review 🤦🏻♂️
I will take either one if someone wants to be generous and buy one for me..
Haha, that'd be a very generous gift! But agreed!
First
HI! Dang you're speedy!!!
JP Morgan...wait. What?
Yep. Crazy name huh. Thank my parents!
The colour on the C200 is way too bright..
It's awfull.
No.