This is a very "classical" RUclipsr/small-filmmaker gear video. It's slick and informative. I miss videos like this one, which are becoming rarer. The traditional "trusted" names aren't doing this kind of product review as much as they used to, but there's still a need. Please keep up the good work.
Great review. I pretty much came to the same conclusion. If you're building a studio go Amaran, if you're just starting out and need a case go Smallrig!
Take the cardboard box from the Amaran go to a thrift shop find a three dollar duffle bag that the box will fit into... then you can remove or fold back the cardboard flaps, and keep the foam inserts... And you have a ridiculously cheap soft sided case for the light fixture with a few extra pockets to boot. The trick is just finding the right size duffle bag
@@WTG194 sidus link was what I needed . I have to factor in both smaller jobs I do and collaborating and renting gear for bigger projects and apertures app makes scaling up much simpler.
Since version 3 on the smallrig u can triple click the reset button(RC220D) and go into silent mode. With it the fan is always off and the output is reduced. Perfect when u need a quiet environment! normal mode is now with the fan always turned on and more silent than before. (no more turning on and off because of temperature easy to get rid in post if picked up by mic). I think this is the best solution in the case of the fan here!
You’ve also got the ‘eco system’ with Amaran, everything can be operated from the 1 app, with multiple different lights. And while smallrig are bringing more and more out, Amaran and Apature have a good range to pick from as it stands. I’m a sucker for trying to keep brand specific with my tools haha
We have 4 Amaran 200D heads, my only real complaint is that all the control knobs have broken off, mostly during transport. The unit remains operational without the knob but it doesn't look very pro. We transport all 4 lights, power blocks and leads in 1 old Bowens rolling case. Easily carried as the equipment is such light-weight. The lights are fantastic, just need 1 unit that's twice as bright for our purposes. Thanks for a great review. Very clear, concise and we'll presented.
Video idea maybe, but lots of streamers already use elgato style flat LED panels… what are the differences with these softbox style lights? I want to move away from game streams to actual content… I know I could try to use my existing panels, but I rather leave them on my game streaming desk & get a dedicated talking head setup/shot. I’m also torn between the Dome Mini II vs the bigger one (SE).
I’ve had that video idea on my list for a while now actually! The biggest difference is flexibility. With these lights I can make them soft or hard using modifiers. With the panels you’re more stuck with what you’ve got. I recommend the light dome SE if you’ve got space. I have 2 of them and they’re great.
I completely agree on you comments about the knobs. I often have my Ameran 200x higher than I can see. I love pressing for the presets. Very easy to set the output to something specific. I like 45 power in my garage situation so two clicks up from bottom then five “turns” up. Sooooo useful.
the small rig locking handle is bad quality. Mine broke within 2 years and I haven't even used the light that much... maybe 50 times. Waiting on SmallRig to send me a new handle or idk.. charge me for one? tho they don't sell it.
These two and the new iFootage ANGLERFISH series are three top new lights just released. Thanks for creating this video l. I am keen to find the right lights for my current studio upgrade
Other brands would be too late to the budget LED game after Aputure releases the Amaran line. They should've at least streamlined the ecosystem before that.
I have an AMARAN 100x and love it but in looking at how to batter power it out in the woods for a fantasy film shoot the battery plate thing is like $200 whereas the one for the smallrig is just a xlr to d tap cable. I'll be grabbing a Smallrig 220B as my next light
I am a bit disappointed in my Amaran. It broke 2 times on me and for the same issue! The light just stopped working it was something with the connections. The first time it was under a warranty so I managed to fix it, but now i got the small rig to try it.
I have the godox vl 150, love it but definitely on the hunt for more lights...haha the aperture may be the next one, thanks for the video, very helpful
its funny one of the main reasons i went with the amaran p60c and the amaran 60d were specifically because of the cases they came with the p60c actually comes with a bag but the 60d comes in one of those fitted foam packages the old phantom drones and old ronin S gimbals.
I'm also interested in this Amaran 200X S, thanks for the video! For portrait lighting as a key light, is it powerful enough compared to a Godox VL150 (which I'm considering replacing)? The color accuracy also seems to be a convincing factor.
Pretty similar to the last space like 9’x9’. The big issue is that the ceilings are a lot lower in the new place so I can’t get things “up” out of the way.
It's a pity that Aputure doesn't include a case, but I suppose an alternate case could be found. The fan noise, funky controls and weaker phone app of the SmallRig are all deal killers for me.
I would definitely need this type of light for RUclips but it's kinda expensive and ... not fun gear to buy ahah but what I got right now feels a bit cheap ... And I neeeeddd to learn lightning properly ... thanks for the video Donna !
if looking for cheaper if your budget is tight then take a look at the GVM one, $169 and it comes with the softbox kit, it also even includes a honeycomb grid attachment.
I have the 200x at work, and are happy with it so far. For me the fan noise is a really important factor when it comes to what I would choose, so Im happy we went for the 200x 😅 great review though! 😎🤩
Hey Dunna, thanks for this nice Video! I have a Neewer SL 150 which run I think 150 days last year :-P like I used it so much. But well tha fan...I hate it. So definitly a big point when considering the next gear. I am about to buy 2-3 new Bi Lights. I wanne go with 350W since I feel its better to invest in prime gear (have full time line of coming projects) but I am also unsure...like wheter its better to buy three 200W or 2 350W, or even invest in 450W. (I think its better to run a 350 at 60% than always maxing out your gear, or to put it different I like to be at 60% so I chose this setting over to be just limited. But maybe a 450W is even to bright at 1% more noisy etc....I know you dont have a glas sphere and cant tell me what to do, but I would highly appreciare youre feedback. The purpose is very diverse. Lots of interviews, Image filmes etc. I feel my 150W are not enough but have no clue how strong the other is. Thanks so much for all your Videos!!!!!
Thank you for the review! I was about to pull the trigger on the SmallRig but didn't know about the fan noise being an issue with this COB light. I'll look into Amaran and other brands (maybe Godox?) instead.
100 is fine and dandy for so much, and then there are these little situations that you run into every once in a while where you just need a little more power hey!? I used to run into that when I had the 120d and then eventually bought the 300d. Most of the time, the 300 didn’t go over 20%, but when I needed the power… oh yeah I was happy to have it.
Do you still have 220B? Seems Smallrig silently updated their firmware and introduced SILENT mode + improved fan control. Are you able to update us on this?
I just use a similar GVM that also came with a softbox kit and a stand for half that price. Downside is that it only has 5600k and not adjustable on that end. I never personally use the apps since the same thing, all these apps drive me crazy and it seems like I need a new app every week for a new product. I think the app allows color temp changing but I cant remember now.
From my experience, the amaron in shocking bad quality. My flashlight received a small hit and immediately broke. It's not meant to run and gun protection.
For fill, I typically use something similar to my key light or I just throw something white on the opposite side of the key to reflect. I use a amaran 60c as a back/rim light.
THank you. This was so helpful. I think I'm going with the Amaran, even though I wish you could control the special efects on the rig. THat was a big plus of the small righs. I'm curious, what stand do you recommned for hte amaran that would be sturdy. I'm taking mine into a mansion.
Yeah, quite some time ago, though every once in a while I wish I still had them. Especially in this new room with less space. Those big domes take up a lot of space.
That noise factor is important, especially in small spaces. What about mounting a light dome to those lights? They are so small, what light-dome would you recommend?
I personally really like the aputure light dome SE. it’s light weight and a bit smaller than the full sized light dome. A bit harder to set up and tear down but it’s worth it in my opinion. That’s what I used for the shots of me standing against the wall. I even got away with it just in cheap flimsy light stands too.
I have had both these lights for a while now and the build quility of the smallrig seems to be much better, the knobs on the Amaran broke of after a couple of days of use. The smallrig bag is awesome and actually fits both lights and their respective adapters and bowens reflectors. Powering the Smallrig with V mount is an absolute win over the Amaran form me. Go with the Smallig.
Thank you for the comparison! I I have the Aputure Amaran 200D and considering adding a Godox VL300 as a replacement for my keylight. Different brands , but daylight balanced. Do you think it would cause a problem in output ?
I use the neewer c stands from Amazon (they were the cheapest, decent ones I could find) and I prefer the aputure lightdome SE for its lightweight and size (and price) C-stands → geni.us/Iaj8LBC Light dome se → geni.us/ldse
Haha thanks squad. Long intros always bug me so I keep making it shorter. About a year ago there was like a 7 second version but I think I’m down to like 3 now
@@dunnadidit I think most people want to get directly to the main content. For me, when I watch YT videos I don't mind longer intros because I am a fan of long-form content. @dunnadidit I'd love to hear your take on short form vs. long form content one of these days!
I've go the Amaran and can confirm, the sound from the engine is next to nothing and I shoot interviews. It's great. It's also small and I can usually find spare for it in my camera bag.
I just bought the 200X and I find the fan noise to be pretty bad tbh…Only is smart mode it’s quiet. But for how long…Medium mode is too loud for an interview I would say. When you say the sound is next to nothing, do you have it in smart mode or medium mode?
just got the smallrig cause I heard it was quieter than the Amaran 200d, but now I'm considering returning it for the 200x if it's actually that much quieter. Would that be worth it?
@@rogue0192 I ordered the Nanlite 150B after watching this video because I wanted the single portable battery option. The small rig fan is terrible for interview style shoots or any audio capture. The fan is generally loud, I think.
As I’ve been piecing my home studio together I needed to know which lights to work towards next! Although I want something a little more mid range budget.. my rs3 pro combo comes in today and I want to work towards lighting next. Is it weird that I hardly want to film until I feel like my set is complete?
Nice! I totally hear you on not wanting to film until your setup feels complete, but if you’re anything like me… that might be never. I’m always updating and swapping things out and trying something different.
Very nice comparison. Thanks for it. I like the bi color lights because that 5600k white light really bothers me and feel unnatural but I went for the latter one because lights are cheaper and brighter when compared to the bi ones especially for entry levels. I bought this week lights from the Jinbei brand that has been tested by one of your fellow RUclipsrs and I must say I compared a lot of models and brands and finally went for them for the price/quality. For 700€/$ I got a 200+W, a 60+W, many light modifiers including huge quick octabox, plus few good lighstands and holders. No brand comes near that.
@@markshirley01 I received both lights today and barely turned them on at 100%, but the fan was pretty quite, nothing that a mic can pick especially in a normal room pressure. I'll receive the light stands very soon and will test if my Røde mic mounted on xt4 or phone pick something at reasonable distance and I'll come back to you.
@@hcrespo3 Absolutely. So the fan noise is in my opinion pretty high volume on the 60W version and more audible because it's a higher pitch. On the 200W it's a bit lower volume and more of a lower pitch noise. Problem is I have no choice than put my lights close to what I'm filming (1m and 2m) and my RØDE Videomic definitely picks up the noise. So I wouldn't recommend those lights to someone who needs absolute silence. But, and it's a positive thing, I'm pretty handy with electronics so I'm gonna definitely disassemble the lights and mod them with silent fans for computers. Pretty sure it's gonna work and won't cost a lot. It's gonna definitely cost way less than buying high end silent lights. I'm also going to mod my portable induction cooktop with silent fans so I can capture food sounds. Overall, lights are great, quality is fair, a bit less on the 60w version, speed light modifiers are just awesome and very fast to setup, light is consistent and very powerful on the 200W (I didn't exceed 15% for my low key video style), app is great on the 200W, 60W not compatible but the remote is like 20 box, stands are very okay for the price but not high quality.
I think maybe the scope of what video lights typically cost isn’t kept in mind when calling these “high dollar lights”. Comparable powered lights can go for closer to $1500, $2000, even more depending on build, brand etc… believe me, I bought an aputure 300d ii a few years ago and the 200d basically does the same job for 1/3 the price or less.
Just to be clear, I totally get where you’re coming from. It’s just interesting how we all see the words “bang for buck” or “budget” as something different. I look at the $2500 lights that I want and think of the $350 lights as such a great deal! Whereas if all you’ve been looking at are cheap lower quality or diy rigs on amazon, these might look expensive.
@@dunnadidit The title "Best Bang for your Buck for RUclips Videos?" is not the same as "Best Bang for your Buck for a Professional Studio." We don't look at $2500 lights for a RUclips video and nor should anyone who isn't paying their mortgage with RUclips videos.
I think you’d be surprised. I bought an aputure 120d before I was full time RUclips and it cost double what these do. And I know I’m not alone because the 120d with an aputure lightdome was a HUGELY popular setup amongst RUclipsrs. So I don’t think the “we” that you speak of is as universal as you believe. I never said that these were the cheapest option, just that I thought that they were the best bang for buck, which includes expandability, flexibility, power, etc. Obviously everyone’s budget is different and you can get the job done with gear that’s cheaper for sure. But I know plenty of people who are getting into RUclips and understand the value of investing in quality lights. And luckily, options like this exist now so that the 120d and 300d aren’t the only things available.
Thank you for the comparison! I thought the Amaran is better too, but the amaran Bay Battery Power Station is too huge for carrying around on location. So I chose the smallrig.
This is a very "classical" RUclipsr/small-filmmaker gear video. It's slick and informative. I miss videos like this one, which are becoming rarer. The traditional "trusted" names aren't doing this kind of product review as much as they used to, but there's still a need. Please keep up the good work.
I agree!
Great review. I pretty much came to the same conclusion. If you're building a studio go Amaran, if you're just starting out and need a case go Smallrig!
Take the cardboard box from the Amaran go to a thrift shop find a three dollar duffle bag that the box will fit into... then you can remove or fold back the cardboard flaps, and keep the foam inserts... And you have a ridiculously cheap soft sided case for the light fixture with a few extra pockets to boot.
The trick is just finding the right size duffle bag
Love this!
The Godox CB05 works perfectly for me
@@WTG194 sidus link was what I needed . I have to factor in both smaller jobs I do and collaborating and renting gear for bigger projects and apertures app makes scaling up much simpler.
Since version 3 on the smallrig u can triple click the reset button(RC220D) and go into silent mode. With it the fan is always off and the output is reduced. Perfect when u need a quiet environment!
normal mode is now with the fan always turned on and more silent than before. (no more turning on and off because of temperature easy to get rid in post if picked up by mic). I think this is the best solution in the case of the fan here!
This comment is clutch!
You’ve also got the ‘eco system’ with Amaran, everything can be operated from the 1 app, with multiple different lights. And while smallrig are bringing more and more out, Amaran and Apature have a good range to pick from as it stands. I’m a sucker for trying to keep brand specific with my tools haha
We have 4 Amaran 200D heads, my only real complaint is that all the control knobs have broken off, mostly during transport. The unit remains operational without the knob but it doesn't look very pro. We transport all 4 lights, power blocks and leads in 1 old Bowens rolling case. Easily carried as the equipment is such light-weight. The lights are fantastic, just need 1 unit that's twice as bright for our purposes.
Thanks for a great review. Very clear, concise and we'll presented.
The lack of a carrying case is definitely an effective but subtle way of saying, this isn't meant to be moved a lot.
Haha truth
Video idea maybe, but lots of streamers already use elgato style flat LED panels… what are the differences with these softbox style lights? I want to move away from game streams to actual content… I know I could try to use my existing panels, but I rather leave them on my game streaming desk & get a dedicated talking head setup/shot. I’m also torn between the Dome Mini II vs the bigger one (SE).
I’ve had that video idea on my list for a while now actually! The biggest difference is flexibility. With these lights I can make them soft or hard using modifiers. With the panels you’re more stuck with what you’ve got.
I recommend the light dome SE if you’ve got space. I have 2 of them and they’re great.
Bowens mounts make a world of difference.
I completely agree on you comments about the knobs. I often have my Ameran 200x higher than I can see. I love pressing for the presets. Very easy to set the output to something specific. I like 45 power in my garage situation so two clicks up from bottom then five “turns” up. Sooooo useful.
Wow the timing is unreal, especially when done by my fav Channel… I was just about to decide which one to buy for my new studio 🙌🏽
Niiice! Hope this helped!!
Amran for the win! ;)
the small rig locking handle is bad quality. Mine broke within 2 years and I haven't even used the light that much... maybe 50 times. Waiting on SmallRig to send me a new handle or idk.. charge me for one? tho they don't sell it.
how about just buying the daylight version and using gels if needed? 🤔
Totally doable!
Fantastic thorough concise comparison review
These two and the new iFootage ANGLERFISH series are three top new lights just released. Thanks for creating this video l. I am keen to find the right lights for my current studio upgrade
Ooh I’ll have to check that one out!
Great video. Contemplating upgrading to the Amarans. May I ask what diffusion you’re using for them in your small studio.
Other brands would be too late to the budget LED game after Aputure releases the Amaran line. They should've at least streamlined the ecosystem before that.
I have an AMARAN 100x and love it but in looking at how to batter power it out in the woods for a fantasy film shoot the battery plate thing is like $200 whereas the one for the smallrig is just a xlr to d tap cable. I'll be grabbing a Smallrig 220B as my next light
Thanks!! I was searching for this video since smallrig lights where announced!
Yeah this one took me a while to get to haha.
Thank youuu
I am a bit disappointed in my Amaran. It broke 2 times on me and for the same issue! The light just stopped working it was something with the connections. The first time it was under a warranty so I managed to fix it, but now i got the small rig to try it.
How much power does one need for a talking head or for this video you did? Prob gong to use an Octagon soft box.
I have the godox vl 150, love it but definitely on the hunt for more lights...haha the aperture may be the next one, thanks for the video, very helpful
I feel similarly except that I had the Godox UL-150
I just started the video but when it comes down to deciding what is best and he says it depends. I’m gonna be very angry! Lol
its funny one of the main reasons i went with the amaran p60c and the amaran 60d were specifically because of the cases they came with the p60c actually comes with a bag but the 60d comes in one of those fitted foam packages the old phantom drones and old ronin S gimbals.
I'm also interested in this Amaran 200X S, thanks for the video! For portrait lighting as a key light, is it powerful enough compared to a Godox VL150 (which I'm considering replacing)? The color accuracy also seems to be a convincing factor.
Nice! Glad the video was helpful!
they the same lol, smallrig better the bag is cool, how could you carry in that paper box lol
Another 'lit' video, D! Pun intended! Like you, I'd pick the Amaran. I love Smallrig stuff that said. How big is your new studio space?
Pretty similar to the last space like 9’x9’. The big issue is that the ceilings are a lot lower in the new place so I can’t get things “up” out of the way.
aputure amaran 100d vs godox sl100d
It's a pity that Aputure doesn't include a case, but I suppose an alternate case could be found. The fan noise, funky controls and weaker phone app of the SmallRig are all deal killers for me.
Yeah, cases can be found, those other things are harder to fix
I would definitely need this type of light for RUclips but it's kinda expensive and ... not fun gear to buy ahah but what I got right now feels a bit cheap ... And I neeeeddd to learn lightning properly ... thanks for the video Donna !
Yeah, not the sexiest gear, but arguably amongst the most important
if looking for cheaper if your budget is tight then take a look at the GVM one, $169 and it comes with the softbox kit, it also even includes a honeycomb grid attachment.
@@Jakereviewsall Thanks I'll take a look at it ! :)
Youre a good youtuber.
I have the 200x at work, and are happy with it so far. For me the fan noise is a really important factor when it comes to what I would choose, so Im happy we went for the 200x 😅 great review though! 😎🤩
i cannot decide to go with 200D or 200X, is the X better than D model? :D
Get the X!
Hey Dunna, thanks for this nice Video! I have a Neewer SL 150 which run I think 150 days last year :-P like I used it so much. But well tha fan...I hate it. So definitly a big point when considering the next gear. I am about to buy 2-3 new Bi Lights. I wanne go with 350W since I feel its better to invest in prime gear (have full time line of coming projects) but I am also unsure...like wheter its better to buy three 200W or 2 350W, or even invest in 450W. (I think its better to run a 350 at 60% than always maxing out your gear, or to put it different I like to be at 60% so I chose this setting over to be just limited. But maybe a 450W is even to bright at 1% more noisy etc....I know you dont have a glas sphere and cant tell me what to do, but I would highly appreciare youre feedback. The purpose is very diverse. Lots of interviews, Image filmes etc. I feel my 150W are not enough but have no clue how strong the other is. Thanks so much for all your Videos!!!!!
Thank you for the review! I was about to pull the trigger on the SmallRig but didn't know about the fan noise being an issue with this COB light. I'll look into Amaran and other brands (maybe Godox?) instead.
Will these lights be suitable for tele classes? Regards.
I have an amran 100x and I love it, wish I had the 200x however, just more power. I love it however.
100 is fine and dandy for so much, and then there are these little situations that you run into every once in a while where you just need a little more power hey!? I used to run into that when I had the 120d and then eventually bought the 300d. Most of the time, the 300 didn’t go over 20%, but when I needed the power… oh yeah I was happy to have it.
Good job you have definitely earned my click!
Do you still have 220B? Seems Smallrig silently updated their firmware and introduced SILENT mode + improved fan control. Are you able to update us on this?
I just use a similar GVM that also came with a softbox kit and a stand for half that price. Downside is that it only has 5600k and not adjustable on that end. I never personally use the apps since the same thing, all these apps drive me crazy and it seems like I need a new app every week for a new product. I think the app allows color temp changing but I cant remember now.
They also make Bi color. Cheap and awesome for the price. Just got mine 300w for 357 usd with stand, bag and softbox
The only issue of the smallrig is the weight
From my experience, the amaron in shocking bad quality.
My flashlight received a small hit and immediately broke.
It's not meant to run and gun protection.
Thanks for this Dunna! The Amaran it is.
Cheers!
i really hate multifunction knobs... big fan of individual controls
Amen to that. I like that they found a cool function for the button press on the amaran without complicating it.
The Amaran looks like a great buy! Thanks for sharing
They've got some new ones too that look great!
Nice. What is your favorite fill light? I have an LED stick right now over my right, but don't love the light from it.
For fill, I typically use something similar to my key light or I just throw something white on the opposite side of the key to reflect. I use a amaran 60c as a back/rim light.
@@dunnadidit got it. Noted. Thank you.
THank you. This was so helpful. I think I'm going with the Amaran, even though I wish you could control the special efects on the rig. THat was a big plus of the small righs. I'm curious, what stand do you recommned for hte amaran that would be sturdy. I'm taking mine into a mansion.
Looking at this and your new studio set up. Sounds like you decided to retire the faconeyes?
Yeah, quite some time ago, though every once in a while I wish I still had them. Especially in this new room with less space. Those big domes take up a lot of space.
As a huge newb just getting in to things the Amaran 100d has not been disappointing so far
Harbor Freight sells a large pelican style case for under $100 if you’re looking for a case that can handle these smaller COB units.
In Dec 12, smallrig launched a firmware update that "improve" the cooling system
That noise factor is important, especially in small spaces. What about mounting a light dome to those lights? They are so small, what light-dome would you recommend?
I personally really like the aputure light dome SE. it’s light weight and a bit smaller than the full sized light dome. A bit harder to set up and tear down but it’s worth it in my opinion. That’s what I used for the shots of me standing against the wall. I even got away with it just in cheap flimsy light stands too.
@@dunnadidit that’s what I was thinking about - just because it’s so small 👍
I have had both these lights for a while now and the build quility of the smallrig seems to be much better, the knobs on the Amaran broke of after a couple of days of use. The smallrig bag is awesome and actually fits both lights and their respective adapters and bowens reflectors. Powering the Smallrig with V mount is an absolute win over the Amaran form me. Go with the Smallig.
Fun fact: In europe the smallrig is actually about 50€ cheaper than the aputure
can this be used as a flash ?
Thank you for the comparison! I I have the Aputure Amaran 200D and considering adding a Godox VL300 as a replacement for my keylight. Different brands , but daylight balanced. Do you think it would cause a problem in output ?
That's cool but what are the tube lights at the background?
Does small rig have barndoors that can be purchased for their light?
Great video. Will buy the Amaran. Thanks!
Pretty bueno sir Dunna. I'm down for the Amaran - quality seems higher and I have 2 other Aputure lights that connect to the Sidus app.
I already own 2 200D’s I need help finding good budget C-Stands and choosing the light dome to put on my lights.
I use the neewer c stands from Amazon (they were the cheapest, decent ones I could find) and I prefer the aputure lightdome SE for its lightweight and size (and price)
C-stands → geni.us/Iaj8LBC
Light dome se → geni.us/ldse
@@dunnadidit thank you!
My pleasure!
@@dunnadidit I added to my watch list hoping for deals on prime day!
What’s the difference between the 200 X and the 200 X S?
Love your “intro” every video btw. It’s literally 2 seconds long.
@@joshua.butler 🙏 Yes Sensei *bows deeply* Lol
Haha thanks squad. Long intros always bug me so I keep making it shorter. About a year ago there was like a 7 second version but I think I’m down to like 3 now
@@dunnadidit I think most people want to get directly to the main content. For me, when I watch YT videos I don't mind longer intros because I am a fan of long-form content. @dunnadidit I'd love to hear your take on short form vs. long form content one of these days!
Кепку сними
Great video as always. Good breakdown
Thanks boss!
I've go the Amaran and can confirm, the sound from the engine is next to nothing and I shoot interviews. It's great. It's also small and I can usually find spare for it in my camera bag.
Love it!
I just bought the 200X and I find the fan noise to be pretty bad tbh…Only is smart mode it’s quiet. But for how long…Medium mode is too loud for an interview I would say. When you say the sound is next to nothing, do you have it in smart mode or medium mode?
I appreciate this review so much. Was looking at both of them, but you def steered me towards the Amarran. Thank you.
just got the smallrig cause I heard it was quieter than the Amaran 200d, but now I'm considering returning it for the 200x if it's actually that much quieter. Would that be worth it?
In my opinion, yes
I did the same as you and the small rig needs adjustable fan noise control or I'll buy the amaran. It's turning off and on and off and on
@@dunnadidit thanks! I ordered one so I'll have to do my own comparison and return one lol
@@rogue0192 I ordered the Nanlite 150B after watching this video because I wanted the single portable battery option.
The small rig fan is terrible for interview style shoots or any audio capture. The fan is generally loud, I think.
They’re actually the same hardware underneath lol
I dont know what battery to buy to power these
Excellent review as always my friend.
Thanks dude man!
As I’ve been piecing my home studio together I needed to know which lights to work towards next! Although I want something a little more mid range budget.. my rs3 pro combo comes in today and I want to work towards lighting next. Is it weird that I hardly want to film until I feel like my set is complete?
Nice! I totally hear you on not wanting to film until your setup feels complete, but if you’re anything like me… that might be never. I’m always updating and swapping things out and trying something different.
@@dunnadidit you’re too right, I think I may have to just jump into the metaphorical fire.
As long as it’s metaphorical… I support this
I feel like the litemons 200 is the better buy between them.
Studio tour Please bro
Your wish is my command! 🧞♂️
Newest one… ruclips.net/video/8pbSltz2OCQ/видео.html
Previous one… ruclips.net/video/1QLKJrBHwOY/видео.html
Desk setup tour… ruclips.net/video/_QJD6BaTVNQ/видео.html
godox vl300 on sale for 400. or the amaran?
saving up for the amaran such a dope light
Very nice comparison. Thanks for it.
I like the bi color lights because that 5600k white light really bothers me and feel unnatural but I went for the latter one because lights are cheaper and brighter when compared to the bi ones especially for entry levels.
I bought this week lights from the Jinbei brand that has been tested by one of your fellow RUclipsrs and I must say I compared a lot of models and brands and finally went for them for the price/quality. For 700€/$ I got a 200+W, a 60+W, many light modifiers including huge quick octabox, plus few good lighstands and holders. No brand comes near that.
Thanks for the advice - I took a look at their site. How is the fan noise
@@markshirley01 I received both lights today and barely turned them on at 100%, but the fan was pretty quite, nothing that a mic can pick especially in a normal room pressure. I'll receive the light stands very soon and will test if my Røde mic mounted on xt4 or phone pick something at reasonable distance and I'll come back to you.
@@REMY.C. Thanks thats very helpful
Hi @R. C. could you tell us how was your experience with the fan noise please?
@@hcrespo3 Absolutely. So the fan noise is in my opinion pretty high volume on the 60W version and more audible because it's a higher pitch. On the 200W it's a bit lower volume and more of a lower pitch noise. Problem is I have no choice than put my lights close to what I'm filming (1m and 2m) and my RØDE Videomic definitely picks up the noise.
So I wouldn't recommend those lights to someone who needs absolute silence.
But, and it's a positive thing, I'm pretty handy with electronics so I'm gonna definitely disassemble the lights and mod them with silent fans for computers. Pretty sure it's gonna work and won't cost a lot. It's gonna definitely cost way less than buying high end silent lights. I'm also going to mod my portable induction cooktop with silent fans so I can capture food sounds.
Overall, lights are great, quality is fair, a bit less on the 60w version, speed light modifiers are just awesome and very fast to setup, light is consistent and very powerful on the 200W (I didn't exceed 15% for my low key video style), app is great on the 200W, 60W not compatible but the remote is like 20 box, stands are very okay for the price but not high quality.
The fan sounded louder on the smallrig tho
Isn't that what I said in the video?
Great job thank you 🤙🏿
Smallrig mount is not a true bowen.. you can't add some modifier like spotlight, fresnel,..
You will be almost limited to smallrig accessories
Not in my experience, I almost exclusively used aputure Bowens accessories on it, including a fresnel.
I returned my 220b for this reason.. a small millimeter which made it not fit in my accessories (aputure too) it was maybe just a manufacturing defect
Weird!! Yeah, I’ve had no issue with any of my bowens stuff, in fact, like I mentioned in the video, I found the bowens better on the smallrig
Great video; thanks for sharing!
Thanks for watching!
First again lol
You’re all over it on these Wednesday releases!
@@dunnadidit I like your Sony 18-105 f4 review, I got mine and its perfect!
Nice!!
one of the BEST comparisons! THANK YOU~!!!
yay figured it out and texted
Please don’t text those telegram things they are a scam, it’s not me
@@dunnadidit 🤦🏻♂️🤷🏻♂️
bang for buck with 2 high dollarr lights.... hm neither.
I think maybe the scope of what video lights typically cost isn’t kept in mind when calling these “high dollar lights”. Comparable powered lights can go for closer to $1500, $2000, even more depending on build, brand etc… believe me, I bought an aputure 300d ii a few years ago and the 200d basically does the same job for 1/3 the price or less.
Just to be clear, I totally get where you’re coming from. It’s just interesting how we all see the words “bang for buck” or “budget” as something different. I look at the $2500 lights that I want and think of the $350 lights as such a great deal! Whereas if all you’ve been looking at are cheap lower quality or diy rigs on amazon, these might look expensive.
@@dunnadidit The title "Best Bang for your Buck for RUclips Videos?" is not the same as "Best Bang for your Buck for a Professional Studio." We don't look at $2500 lights for a RUclips video and nor should anyone who isn't paying their mortgage with RUclips videos.
I think you’d be surprised. I bought an aputure 120d before I was full time RUclips and it cost double what these do. And I know I’m not alone because the 120d with an aputure lightdome was a HUGELY popular setup amongst RUclipsrs. So I don’t think the “we” that you speak of is as universal as you believe. I never said that these were the cheapest option, just that I thought that they were the best bang for buck, which includes expandability, flexibility, power, etc. Obviously everyone’s budget is different and you can get the job done with gear that’s cheaper for sure. But I know plenty of people who are getting into RUclips and understand the value of investing in quality lights. And luckily, options like this exist now so that the 120d and 300d aren’t the only things available.
Thank you for the comparison! I thought the Amaran is better too, but the amaran Bay Battery Power Station is too huge for carrying around on location. So I chose the smallrig.
Glad you found what works best for you!