The pc version was prolly the first computer game I ever played. I remember putting the cd in and hearing the loud droid beep with the startup menu. My dad even found all the cheat codes for it (including the millennium falcon and at-at “chickenwalker”). I never got far into it but flying around mos eisley using an early 2000’s Logitech controller was awesome.
Another very cool comparison video! I played a lot of Star Wars: Rogue Squadron on my N64 back in the day. I hope they bring the PC port for current generation consoles like they did for Star Wars: Episode I Racer.
@@Kelphelp Even better! Considering the Switch has become a port's machine for older games, I wouldn't be surprised if this collection became a reality.
I recently played for the first time the Steam version and was amazed with how well it holds up not only in gameplay, but also compatibility, with native controller support. Only thing I didn’t like was the lives/continue system, but it was the standard with most of the games LucasArts made back then. Definitely a worthwhile purchase. Great video as always Kelphelp.
Thank you dude! It really was such a huge surprise to see that it's a pretty nicely optimized game and runs super well when the settings are dialed in! A beautiful and pleasant surprise tbh.
What I don't get with the lives system is a mission failed resets the whole mission but it counts as a lost life, so if you fail the mission you should always abort the mission rather than continue to reset your lives counter.
I remember playing a retail version of this game on Windows 98 and I’m pretty sure it didn’t have any camera issues or “bouncing” enemies. These problems started after the Windows XP and sadly they were never fixed.
Its an oversight in the sense where the game was most likely designed to be played at 30, but at 60fps you seem some of the flaws. Many titles suffer through that. Resident evil 4 is one example
I recently played the PC version and I have an issue with the camera, everytime I boost the ship the distance between the camera and the ship increase until the ship is too far.
Cool man thank you x Added to my Steam wishlist to play for the first time since the N64 days xx Obviously, the difference between N64 and PC ports is always very noticable, but this is one of the biggest contrasts I've seen.
@@Kelphelp Cheap on Steam too! Nice. Will have to see what it looks like on Project 64 vs the Steam version myself when I get it 😊 Very few N64 games I’ve played have aged well, so will be cool for this to be one of the rare exceptions. I rented it so much I might aswell have bought it lol
It's pretty different and you might have compatibility issues due to it being a native Win95 title but for the most part you should be okay. I definitely prefer it over Project 64
I´m back and forth between the PC and the N64 Version. I have both Versions, and while your Video Series might be not about Emulation, it still worth taking a look. On the PC i got that Game successfully working with DxWnd, the Problem is, i never could get any Controller working, despite what some Reviews on Steam say. I have an Ultrawide too (3440x1440), and seeing this old Game in this Resolution is really cool. On the other hand, i just tried out the N64 Version on an Emulator. And what we got here? Upscaling Resolution without a problem, Controller Support as good as it gets from the start. Of course the Framerate was not better then the PC Version, but it was noticeable better then on an actual N64 Console. On specific Emulators you can even disable the Fog. The only problem i found so far is that the Widescreen Hack makes the sides a little "woobly", i didn´t tested that with 21:9 yet. So at this point i don´t really know what to keep at this point. There is a second Game in the same Engine called "Battle for Naboo". On PC it has even fewer "Hacks" like Rouge Squadron, so best way to play this Game is on a Emulator.
@@eshoosca It´s over a year ago, i can´t really remember. Sadly to me, there is still no definitive N64 Emulator which you can use and then be completely satisfied with the result. I am back and forth between Project64, Mupen, Retroarch. But i think i will end up with "Rosalie´s Mupen GUI", which is based on Mupen. So far i get good results with this, but didn´t test a lot with N64 Emulation in general the last year.
I loved this game as a kid! I own this on Steam, but sadly I have an issue where the camera is always zooming out when I’m flying, and I can never switch to cockpit view
Its a tough one to play on Steam, I found it significantly easier to play on retro PC hardware, but that of course can be a crapshoot. These old 95 titles are a tough one to get through.
Whoa I never knew that but that's great to know! Thabk you so much for reporting back, I think I'll have to go back and check out how this works as well! This is exciting!
I can definitely say with a fact the video quality and production does get better, so I think you gonna have a great time with what's coming up. Thanks for watching Mr Megaman Best Villan
I always played it on PC with a joystick (starting with a super cheap Saitek with four buttons back when I bought the big box version and finishing with my current Gladiator NXT). It even supports the throttle axis, but if your throttle piece uses another USB port you might need a software like Joystick Gremlin to be able to use it.
I thought I should mention this: it is impossible to map the left and right triggers on your Xbox controller for this game. Not sure why, but the game does not register these buttons. Luckily, I'm playing on an Elite Series 2 controller and use a program called reWASD. This let's you remap buttons on your controller with keyboard/mouse keys, which adds a ton of utility. With this, I was able to map my trigger buttons. Took some tinkering around to find a button layout that felt comfortable to me but once I did, it was a ton of fun to replay this masterpiece!
@@Kelphelp reWASD is super nifty! You can connect Steam, Nintendo, PlayStation, Xbox, mice, and a few other peripherals to this program and edit a lot of features. It does require a license to use, but it was like $5 if I remember correctly. So super reasonable.
Just picked up Episode 1 Racer on Xbox One and it address pretty much every issue it and Rogue Squadron had on the N64. Hopefully Rogue Squadron comes to Xbox too.
That would be lovely Rogue Squadron on newer consoles. I'm hoping a Aspire will be able to bring them as well just like they did Jedi Academy and Jedi Outcast
Rogue Squadron was awesome. I think N64 had a slight technical advantage over PC when it was first released in 1996. Once the 3dfx Voodoo came out, PC took the lead, and stayed ahead. The PC version of Rogue Squadron is so much better. I originally played it with a Pentium 233 MMX with a Voodoo Banshee.
RA Def has some issues similar to Shadows of the Empire where the FPS is tied to the games CPU speed, but I'll test out Battle for Naboo on a Pentium 4. Very curious to see how it runs
@@Kelphelp I'm not sure if because the computers processing power is way more than an N64 the enemy AI seems harder (or I'm old now and bad at gaming). Currently stuck in Escape From Fest. "THE AT PTs HAVE BEEN DESTROYED" is burned in my head and reactivated childhood memories, pretty sure i heard that dozens of times in childhood, and about 10 times last night lol.
Hmmm there are alot of factors or reasons why. Keep messing with it, and try different comps. I am running this on a Windows 10 AMD Ryzen Comp so that should give you an idea.
Should prolly note that Rogue3D AI is dumber and more ruthfull than in the N64 version. However, it has a Force Feedback support, so a proper flight stick is vetter on PC than a pad.
Wait dumber and more ruthless? How do those two go hand and hand? And tbh since the review I've really been able to check it on a Windows 98 PC and it is a world of difference. Lots going on I feel I do prefer it on PC than 64
@@Kelphelp I know what you mean, I just picked up a 27" for free and its hard to deal with the size change 🤣 its slightly too big for my original xbox kiosk too
So on further research thr game is one of those CPU sensitive titles. At higher CPU mhz raises the framerate so making jt more difficult to play. At 100Mhz is the perfect cpu for this.
The pc version was prolly the first computer game I ever played. I remember putting the cd in and hearing the loud droid beep with the startup menu. My dad even found all the cheat codes for it (including the millennium falcon and at-at “chickenwalker”). I never got far into it but flying around mos eisley using an early 2000’s Logitech controller was awesome.
I wish I could update this review but coming back to trying it on a flight stick is kind of u real but a fun experience.
Thank-you for taking the time to produce and narrate this comparison video. Subbed👏🏻
Pleasure is all mine man. Thank you so much for watching my video man!
Another very cool comparison video! I played a lot of Star Wars: Rogue Squadron on my N64 back in the day. I hope they bring the PC port for current generation consoles like they did for Star Wars: Episode I Racer.
Rogue Squadron collection on the Switch man. A man can dream...
@@Kelphelp Even better! Considering the Switch has become a port's machine for older games, I wouldn't be surprised if this collection became a reality.
I recently played for the first time the Steam version and was amazed with how well it holds up not only in gameplay, but also compatibility, with native controller support. Only thing I didn’t like was the lives/continue system, but it was the standard with most of the games LucasArts made back then. Definitely a worthwhile purchase. Great video as always Kelphelp.
Thank you dude! It really was such a huge surprise to see that it's a pretty nicely optimized game and runs super well when the settings are dialed in! A beautiful and pleasant surprise tbh.
Kelphelp for real, it runs better than many LucasArts games released way after!
What I don't get with the lives system is a mission failed resets the whole mission but it counts as a lost life, so if you fail the mission you should always abort the mission rather than continue to reset your lives counter.
Another great video, Kelp.
Always appreciate the love Turbo. Thanks a ton man 😌
I remember playing a retail version of this game on Windows 98 and I’m pretty sure it didn’t have any camera issues or “bouncing” enemies. These problems started after the Windows XP and sadly they were never fixed.
Its an oversight in the sense where the game was most likely designed to be played at 30, but at 60fps you seem some of the flaws. Many titles suffer through that. Resident evil 4 is one example
I recently played the PC version and I have an issue with the camera, everytime I boost the ship the distance between the camera and the ship increase until the ship is too far.
Yea that's a for sure issue with thr game. If you switch the camera back it should be fine. Some cameras just don't work
Cool man thank you x Added to my Steam wishlist to play for the first time since the N64 days xx Obviously, the difference between N64 and PC ports is always very noticable, but this is one of the biggest contrasts I've seen.
Right?! It really is a night and day experience and with the right hardware runs great!
@@Kelphelp Cheap on Steam too! Nice. Will have to see what it looks like on Project 64 vs the Steam version myself when I get it 😊 Very few N64 games I’ve played have aged well, so will be cool for this to be one of the rare exceptions. I rented it so much I might aswell have bought it lol
It's pretty different and you might have compatibility issues due to it being a native Win95 title but for the most part you should be okay. I definitely prefer it over Project 64
Amazing job as always ❤️
You know that you were such a huge help for this right? 😗
I´m back and forth between the PC and the N64 Version.
I have both Versions, and while your Video Series might be not about Emulation, it still worth taking a look.
On the PC i got that Game successfully working with DxWnd, the Problem is, i never could get any Controller working, despite what some Reviews on Steam say.
I have an Ultrawide too (3440x1440), and seeing this old Game in this Resolution is really cool.
On the other hand, i just tried out the N64 Version on an Emulator. And what we got here? Upscaling Resolution without a problem, Controller Support as good as it gets from the start. Of course the Framerate was not better then the PC Version, but it was noticeable better then on an actual N64 Console. On specific Emulators you can even disable the Fog. The only problem i found so far is that the Widescreen Hack makes the sides a little "woobly", i didn´t tested that with 21:9 yet.
So at this point i don´t really know what to keep at this point.
There is a second Game in the same Engine called "Battle for Naboo". On PC it has even fewer "Hacks" like Rouge Squadron, so best way to play this Game is on a Emulator.
Which emulator did you use?
@@eshoosca It´s over a year ago, i can´t really remember.
Sadly to me, there is still no definitive N64 Emulator which you can use and then be completely satisfied with the result.
I am back and forth between Project64, Mupen, Retroarch.
But i think i will end up with "Rosalie´s Mupen GUI", which is based on Mupen. So far i get good results with this, but didn´t test a lot with N64 Emulation in general the last year.
@@FloppyFred thanks
I loved this game as a kid! I own this on Steam, but sadly I have an issue where the camera is always zooming out when I’m flying, and I can never switch to cockpit view
Its a tough one to play on Steam, I found it significantly easier to play on retro PC hardware, but that of course can be a crapshoot. These old 95 titles are a tough one to get through.
@@Kelphelp I actually discovered a way to fix the camera zooming out. I press F1 whenever I start a mission and it went back to normal for me :)
Whoa I never knew that but that's great to know! Thabk you so much for reporting back, I think I'll have to go back and check out how this works as well! This is exciting!
@@Kelphelp no problem! :)
7:18 in order to fix this issue Pres Ctrol+J and controls will be normal.
Hey great video! First video of yours I've seen, will check what else your channel has to offer! :)
I can definitely say with a fact the video quality and production does get better, so I think you gonna have a great time with what's coming up.
Thanks for watching Mr Megaman Best Villan
I always played it on PC with a joystick (starting with a super cheap Saitek with four buttons back when I bought the big box version and finishing with my current Gladiator NXT). It even supports the throttle axis, but if your throttle piece uses another USB port you might need a software like Joystick Gremlin to be able to use it.
I haven't tried Joystick Gremlin but happy to give a shot. I'll try it with my XP machine to see how it goes
I thought I should mention this: it is impossible to map the left and right triggers on your Xbox controller for this game. Not sure why, but the game does not register these buttons.
Luckily, I'm playing on an Elite Series 2 controller and use a program called reWASD. This let's you remap buttons on your controller with keyboard/mouse keys, which adds a ton of utility. With this, I was able to map my trigger buttons. Took some tinkering around to find a button layout that felt comfortable to me but once I did, it was a ton of fun to replay this masterpiece!
Damn some good tips to use and I never heard of reWASD! I'll give it a shot! Thanks for the update
@@Kelphelp reWASD is super nifty! You can connect Steam, Nintendo, PlayStation, Xbox, mice, and a few other peripherals to this program and edit a lot of features. It does require a license to use, but it was like $5 if I remember correctly. So super reasonable.
And if it works for many different computers it's worth it imho
I got it for Christmas but could not get it to work on my PC.
Like at all? Won't boot or anything? Can you be more specific?
Playing keyboard alone with out the mouse works fine, i agree if you can get controler working on it its a much better expirence
Exactly, I was alright with the mouse and key board but controller is where it's at here.
Came here bc I picked this up on GoG recently and it was pretty obvious that I need to modify the resolution
It takes a bit to get it going but you can play it in 1080p. Def takes a bit
My expansion pack always overheated while playing Rouge Squadron
Daaaaamnnnn to the point of overheating?! Now that says alot to me tbh
how do you even get to run this on modern pcs? Im having so much trouble getting this to run on windows 11
Hmmmm alot could have changed from 10 to 11 since I made the video. I wil l need to test it out one day
Just picked up Episode 1 Racer on Xbox One and it address pretty much every issue it and Rogue Squadron had on the N64. Hopefully Rogue Squadron comes to Xbox too.
That would be lovely Rogue Squadron on newer consoles. I'm hoping a Aspire will be able to bring them as well just like they did Jedi Academy and Jedi Outcast
1:06 the game came out 1998 not 1996
Type-o
Ah, the nostalgia.
Who better to hear this from than the main boi Kyle Katarn!
Rogue Squadron was awesome. I think N64 had a slight technical advantage over PC when it was first released in 1996. Once the 3dfx Voodoo came out, PC took the lead, and stayed ahead. The PC version of Rogue Squadron is so much better. I originally played it with a Pentium 233 MMX with a Voodoo Banshee.
Bruh those were the days. Wish it was a bit easier to play now
RA Def has some issues similar to Shadows of the Empire where the FPS is tied to the games CPU speed, but I'll test out Battle for Naboo on a Pentium 4. Very curious to see how it runs
Wow Ryzen 1600x that’s basically a retro PC itself lmfao
That's why I made a fucking retro pc you dolt
I literally commented that a minute ago to you.
So you wanna get a controller for the PC port?
Yes. And?
I'm currently replaying it on an emulator apC (N64 version)
Nice, should work well on there.
@@Kelphelp I'm not sure if because the computers processing power is way more than an N64 the enemy AI seems harder (or I'm old now and bad at gaming). Currently stuck in Escape From Fest. "THE AT PTs HAVE BEEN DESTROYED" is burned in my head and reactivated childhood memories, pretty sure i heard that dozens of times in childhood, and about 10 times last night lol.
my game just bugs out on the menu on pc so I can't play this game
Hmmm there are alot of factors or reasons why. Keep messing with it, and try different comps. I am running this on a Windows 10 AMD Ryzen Comp so that should give you an idea.
As Lisa Simpson said........FOALEEEEAGE. haha
Wait what?
I played this on PC as a kid with a joy stick
Damn here you are living in year 3000 with s goddamn joystick.
Should prolly note that Rogue3D AI is dumber and more ruthfull than in the N64 version. However, it has a Force Feedback support, so a proper flight stick is vetter on PC than a pad.
Wait dumber and more ruthless? How do those two go hand and hand?
And tbh since the review I've really been able to check it on a Windows 98 PC and it is a world of difference. Lots going on I feel I do prefer it on PC than 64
@@Kelphelp Ruthfull, not ruthless. PC version's also missing the Buick.
Should try rogue squadron on n64 with a crt
I lobe how CRTs are but man they take toooooooo much space
@@Kelphelp I know what you mean, I just picked up a 27" for free and its hard to deal with the size change 🤣 its slightly too big for my original xbox kiosk too
@@BonScottForever1 I will never disagree that it's the best way to play but my god...why do they take up so much space?!
@@Kelphelp those tubes in them are massive. It takes up a good 60%-70% of the inside of those old TV's
Did you really play this on PC purchased at - 98?
Now that I have a Retro PC to actually do comparisons I can go along this route. Lowkey thought about redoing reviews foe this reason.
👍
Seems about the same.
Naw it's definitely different. They both have their positives and negatives but FPS is...not good on switch
emulators make N64 look worse. You need the original N64, the janky controller, and the expansion pack to properly enjoy Rogue Squadron
In a sense but going back to this and playing it on Windows 98 has been a great experience, one I prefer than 64
The moment you insinuated that Rogue Squadron was better in any way, shape or form when compared to X Wing Alliance you lost me mate. Bye.
Don't let the door hit ya on the way out.
@@Kelphelp Oh, that explains your numbers, I get it now, your future looks very bright indeed.
Wow what a shitty thing to say lmao just don't comment on the video if you didn't like it.
@@foxdie49 And meanwhile, your future is as dark as your skin LOL
@@m00nmayn86 I wish the dislike button on comments actually did something
The PC version does not feel right…
So on further research thr game is one of those CPU sensitive titles. At higher CPU mhz raises the framerate so making jt more difficult to play. At 100Mhz is the perfect cpu for this.