Casting Survivor: Old School vs. New School
HTML-код
- Опубликовано: 6 окт 2024
- DISCLAIMER: This video has been on the back burner for a while now due to some more impromptu videos and is coming out over a month after it was originally meant to. If this was made more recently, I would not have Kellee on the cast as she has talked about not wanting to play again. Hatch would also not make the cut if I were to redo this video as its pretty clear now that Hatch is never going to play Survivor again.
In this video, I talk about who I would like to be cast on a season of Survivor: Old School vs. New School.
![Eminem - Temporary (feat. Skylar Grey) [Official Music Video]](http://i.ytimg.com/vi/ZaK9Wi5ho0o/mqdefault.jpg)
could you rank the last boots of survivor? A lot of great players are in this category.
HobbesTheMyth I agree!
Zane knight 😎
@@thegraylink8269 i think hobbes means 4th or 3rd place missing out on the finals
So ranking Semi-Finalists
wentworth, for example?
I feel like in the next returning season we may see Reem be asked back, just due to her online popularity
I dont think she woul wanna be back
@@OriRozenthal I think that she’s come back for her fans
I feel like so many people forget about Lex. He dominated Survivor Africa and was one of the more dominant players overall through the first several seasons when the show started out (not to mention he also won three immunity challenges on Africa as well). He is also still in the casting pool. I read that he was asked to be on BvW with his son but had to decline last minute. He was also one of the finalists to be on season 40 before they made it an all winners season. Lex would make a great old school returnee on pretty much any all stars season and it appears that production still wants him to come back at some point, as they should. Very underrated player in my opinion.
Sounds like a great cast. You left out one thing about Rick Devens, though: Making two fake Idols, and getting both out at the same Tribal. That is the quintessential cut-throat move.
He’s on the cast
Honestly would have rather had Colleen than Jenna.
I think Jenna is more likely to play again. But i agree that i would rather see Colleen.
I would love Colleen to come back. I had the biggest crush on her during Borneo.
Same
i would still love reynold back
“I picked Carolyn. I feel like I that’s the theme of these videos.”
I’m not complaining. Justice for Carolyn!
Hey cast a USA vs Australia season
Yes!
US: Parvati, Rob, Sandra, Cirie, Russell, Tony, Kelley, Natalie, Joe, Spencer
AUS: David, Harry, Kristie, Shonee, Jericho, Flick, Luke, Michelle, Janine, Lee
I want Dean Kowalski on my television again
Dk chilln for life
No thanks
Dear god no
Honestly, I'd love to see Gina Crews from Marquesas return again. I felt like she had so much potential and she got kinda screwed early on in the game
Do "Survivor Unfinished Business" (best players to never win)
Yesssssssssss!!!!!
Ozzy, cirie, russell, stephen ,aubrey , chrissy , Amanda, Spencer, coach, dom. Momma c
R. P. malcolm
Pretty sure this is what second chance was, but I’d love a second chance season again.
@@kwads1909 no. Second chance was players that only played once. Ones i named most had played multiple times and were in final 3 and imo deserved the win or played a good game
Kevin Wadsworth No, not at all. Second Chance was players who only played once before and featured a LOT of players who were early boots on their respective seasons. What I'm talking about is a whole cast of players who were extremely close to winning (some of them multiple times) but for various reasons they fell short. In some ways I think it would be more interesting than all winners because the hunger to finally win would be intense. I haven't sat down and thought about a full cast. But off the top of my head Domenick Abbate, Russell Hantz, Amanda Kimmel, Cirie Fields, Aubry Bracco, Colby Donaldson, Rob Cesternino, Ozzy Lusth all fit the theme.
Cast a fans vs favorites 3 for the favorites
Yessssss love this keep up the videos plss
Would have been cool if the New School tribe was headed by the most recent winner (Tommy) so it's winner vs winner.
Dorian Carter Tommy is very old school though. It would be interesting in a paradoxical sense that the guy who should be the epitome of new school is old school tho.
Tommy? 💤💤💤
Man enough if this "they said they'll never play again" I've heard that multiple times from former players and they still come back so there no logic for that.
I want to see Missy from IoI again, to
Having the earlier tribe so heavily skewed to the first few seasons and the later tribe so heavily skewed to the last few seasons greatly magnifies the age gap that already favored the newer tribe.
One also has to consider what the rules for this season will be. Back to basics, or some crazy advantage in the crotch of every tree? That certainly would favor one side over the other. I'd suggest back to basics as a way of mitigating the age difference.
I want Jason from Kaoh Rong back
Brian from Guatemala was robbed of making the cast 😔😔😔
I would’ve replaced Missy with either Karishma or Lauren
Greg and Coleen?? Who cares if they wouldn’t adapt that’d be an amazing stroyline!
It's been done. It was called Winners at War and the results were devastatingly decisive.
Why do you think Cook Islands cast sucks? It spawned some of the greatest survivor characters ever. I mean...how many other seasons have 5 returnees? I mean sure, there were some duds, but not that many more than other seasons. Billy, Cao Boi, And Nate are all fun characters. Saying that cast sucks strikes me as odd
Australian outback has 6 I guess...
Erric Malankar true, I forgot about that one
Hey! Another great video! Keep it up!
BrantSteele Version
Episode 1
Immunity: New School
(Used Island Of The Idols format)
Kelly Goldsmith goes to the Island Of The Idols with Tony and Sandra
Kelly looses fire-making. She loses her vote.
Tribal Votes:
Burton: Ami, Jenna, Richard, Sean, Teresa, Terry
Sean: Burton, Earl, Twila
6-3 Burton goes home
Episode 2
Davie gets an Idol from Island Of The Idols
Immunity: Old School
Tribal Votes:
Christian: Domenick, Jessica, Missy
Domenick: Carolyn, Christian, Davie, Kellee, Michael, Rick, Victoria
7-3 Domenick goes home
Episode 3
Earl finds an idol
Richard doesn’t play
Immunity: New School
Rick finds an idol
Tribal votes:
Earl plays an idol
Earl: Ami, Kelly, Sean, Teresa, Terry, Twila (Cancelled)
Twila: Earl, Jenna, Richard
3-0 Twila goes home
Episode 4
Christian does not play
Immunity: Old School
Tribal votes:
Davie plays idol
Rick plays idol
Kellee: Christian, Jessica, Rick, Victoria
Rick: Carolyn, Davie, Kellee, Michael, Missy
4-0 Kellee goes home
Episode 5
Swapped Tribes:
Old School: Carolyn, Christian, Davie, Earl, Jenna, Jessica, Michael, T-Bird
New School: Ami, Kelly, Missy, Richard, Rick, Sean, Terry, Victoria
Reward: Old School
Immunity: New School
Tribal votes:
Earl: Jenna
Jenna: Carolyn, Christian, Davie, Earl, Jessica, Michael, Teresa
7-1 Jenna goes home
Episode 6
Michael finds an idol
Reward: New School
Kelly finds Vote Blocker advantage
Immunity: Old School
Kelly uses vote blocker on Ami
Tribal votes:
Vote #1
Ami: Kelly, Missy, Richard
Missy: Rick
Richard: Sean, Terry, Victoria
Vote #2
Ami: Kelly, Missy, Rick
Richard: Sean, Terry, Victoria
Victoria draws the wrong rock and is out
Episode 7
Reward: Old School
Earl wins Safety Without Power
Immunity: Old School
Tribal votes;
Ami: Richard
Missy: Rick, Sean
Sean: Ami, Kelly, Missy, Terry
4-2-1 Sean goes home
Episode 8
Merge
Missy finds an idol
Immunity: Earl
Tribal votes:
Carolyn: Christian, Davie, Jessica, Michael, Missy, Richard, Rick, Teresa, Terry
Jessica: Earl, Kelly
Richard: Ami, Carolyn
9-2-2 Carolyn goes home
Immunity: Rick and T-Bird
Tribal votes:
Vote #1
Ami: Davie, Jessica, Kelly, Missy
Kelly: Ami, Christian, Earl, Teresa
Missy: Richard, Rick, Terry
Vote #2
Ami: Davie, Jessica, Missy
Kelly: Christian, Earl, Richard, Rick, Teresa, Terry
6-3 Kelly goes home
Episode 9
Immunity: Earl and Michael
Tribal votes:
Missy play idol
Jessica: Ami
Missy: Earl, Richard, Teresa
Richard: Jessica, Missy
2-1 Richard goes home
Tribal votes:
Davie: Terry
Terry: Christian, Davie, Michael, Rick
4-1 Terry goes home
Episode 10
Immunity: Ami
Tribal votes:
Vote #1
Missy: Ami, Earl, Rick, Teresa
Rick: Davie, Jessica, Michael, Missy
Vote #2
Missy: Ami, Earl
Rick: Davie, Jessica, Michael, Teresa
4-2 Rick goes home
Episode 11
T-Bird finds an idol
Immunity: T-Bird
Tribal votes:
Earl uses Safety Without Power and leaves Tribal
Ami: Davie, Jessica, Michael, Missy
Missy: Ami, Christian, Teresa
4-3 Ami goes home
Episode 12
Michael wins Extra Vote
Immunity: Davie
Tribal votes:
Earl: Davie, Jessica
Jessica: Christian, Earl, Teresa
Teresa: Michael, Missy
3-2-2 Jessica goes home
Immunity: Earl
Tribal votes:
Michael uses Double vote
T-Bird uses idol on Christian
Missy: Christian, Davie, Earl, Teresa
Teresa: Michael, Michael, Missy
4-3 Missy goes home
Episode 13
Michael finds an idol
Michael finds an idol at Island Of The Idols
Immunity: Davie
Tribal votes:
Michael uses idol
Michael uses idol on Earl
Micheal uses idol on Christian
T-Bird goes home because she is the only one who can recieve votes
Immunity: Earl
Fire Making:
He gives immunity to Christian and saves Davie
Michael beats Earl in Fire Making
Final 3: Christian, Davie, Michael
Ami votes Christian
Carolyn votes Michael
Earl votes Christian
Jessica votes Michael
Kelly votes Davie
Missy votes Davie
Richard votes Christian
Rick votes Christian
Sean votes Michael
T-Bird votes Davie
Terry votes Christian
5 votes Christian, 3 votes Davie, 3 votes Michael
WINNER: Christian
They really should've done this format with winners at war with the tribe divisions
I think you missed a Golden opportunity to bring back Jean-Robert and Matty Whitmore
Erm what? Cydney has never said she doesn’t want to play again. She’s said she would love to. She was nearly on Game changers instead of Debbie but she just couldn’t come back so soon due to physical effects on her and her bodybuilding career
Old school: Coach, Cirie, James, Eliza, John Fincher, Randy, Rupert, Shii Ann, Steph, and Twila.
New School: Andrea, Ciera, Davie, Domenick, Elaine, Hali, Wentworth, Malcolm, Devens, and Tai
Lot of people from HvV
Smash Mansion Id love a Hali return
This would be a good cast, wish this was a actual season
Should have chosen Chrissy over Jessica
Boston Rob wasn't picked for an Old School vs. Newschool? WHAT?
I like the idea of Old School vs New School. But the problems here are that if the season were to happen, it would mostly likely be heavily in favor of the new-schoolers.
There is very little chance that Survivor is going to tone down with the twists and advantages, which the new-schoolers have more experience in. And in terms of challenges, its basically divided by age. Older vs younger.
The only advantage the old schoolers have is that they are less likely to be eliminated come the swap and merge.
I dont see survivor bringing anyone back from Island of idols. I think they want to bury that season and never ever bring it back up which is unfortunate for some of the interesting players that we will most likely never see play again .
R. P. i hope not. besides dan, i loved this cast. lauren karishma kellee janet elaine jamal missy etc all deserve to come back
@@matthewdamario7082 im not a fan of missy, what she did was gross. But i do agree with the rest of your picks. Some great characters, but i still think its VERY unlikely to see anyone return especially not anytime soon since WAW is such a good season so far and a great distraction from the last season. I also think the fact they dropped Richard hatch the first winner ever from this season just because of season 39 is very telling that cbs wants to really avoid any controversy and i see that continuing for a long time
R. P. it’s so sad. especially because i know lauren REALLY wants to return and wish she wasn’t on 39 because she wants to return on a normal seaosn
@@matthewdamario7082 i really liked lauren too. I was rooting for her to win and break the streak of only men winning since game changers
R. P. same haha i literally cried when she lost firemaking
This is just like your video for Second Chance 2
Another thing people seem to forget about Victoria is that she was the only person up until the final 6 to have been included in every single vote out. That’s really one of the reasons why she is such a good player and deserves more credit
No DK Chillin? 😭😭😭
loving these vids! I would like to see a fan vs favorite 3
my cast old school: Rich, Jonny, Earl, Burton, Sean, T, Natalie, Taj, Kelly, Amy
New school: Dom, Angelina, Chrissy, Janet, Wentworth, Andrea, Davie, Malcolm, Devons,David
Janet didn't play a new school game
Some user yeah that’s true maybe replace her with Lauren Rimmer
I think it could be interesting to put old school time-wise players but they played with a new school mind set, and vise versa, to see how alliances would be formed and how games would morph and change
can u make a contenders for waw now that we are a few episodes in
My Cast
Old School
Seasons 1, 8 Richard Hatch
Season 3 Kelly Goldsmith
Season 3 T-Bird
Season 4 Sean
Seasons 9, 16 Ami
Season 9 Twila
Seasons 12, 31 Terry
Seasons 13, 16, 25 Penner
Season 14 Earl
Season 16 Natalie
New School
Season 21 Marty
Season 23 Jim Rice
Seasons 23, 40 Sophie
Seasons 25, 40 Denise
Seasons 29, 31, 38 Kelly Wentworth
Season 30 Carolyn
Season 36 Dominick
Season 37 Christian
Season 37 Gabby
Season 38 Rick Devens
I think it should of been only one person from one season max so we have more diverse old school
What about libby
I think you need to put two winners on new school if you put two on old school
Great vid! You have got to do a US vs Australian Survivor season even if it won't ever happen
Wasn't Nathan Gonzolas on another reality show really recently?
Is it bad that i really want Shii Ann to be on another season i love Shii Ann she's one of my favorite survivor characters (i also feel really bad for people who get purpled)
Diera? You actually made me look up the cast again
You should post this on Reddit, your casting videos are great. I think you need more subscribers and that’s a way to do it.
They should have a season of survivor where everyone has alzheimer's
I eat food u were in Russell Hantz livestream last night
@@wallya1954 yeah lol
What about christa for old school?
so wut school will 41-60 be
Those 5 he named from Cook Islands has to be amongst the top of a season
You forgot Rafe from Guatemala.
I think Cirie has to be brought back just on principle. Maybe they could find a new way for someone to get screwed over. Plus she could break ozzy’s record for days in the game
I think you can do three tribes with old school, middle school and new school because the game got different when the idol became a thing but change again after hero vs villian
I like Sean, but maybe John Carol would be a better pick.
You should put the survivor that played only once.
Todd
Lex
Dude that cane 3rd in S11
Kenny (18)
Shane powers
Amanda
Vee
Hannah?... chick that dame 3rd in S18
Natalie Bolton
Shi Ann? S5 and S8
Kyle or Jason (red beard)? (31)
Devon
Rick devons
Davee
Hayden
Tony
Lauren (EoE)
Kelly (39)
Chrissy (35)
Brenda
Kim
I would love to see Earl Cole play again because I couldn’t see him the first time
Didn’t Richard go to jail
Kelly Goldsmith is so underrated. I feel like she might have a chance of getting on a ballot for Second Chance 2, but not a chance of getting voted in.
I haven't watched yet, but I'm going to guess that the exception is Terry.
OMG YESSS
Kelly Goldsmith needs to come back but she’s so far in the past and forgotten about that it won’t happen.
Wait just watched the video and he said she’s been in the casting pool recently? 😳
Missy and Jenna YASSS!
Rob C is too dynamic to be on the cast? I thought that was the point
Jina has been admitted to season 20 so there's a big chance that if they do this kind of season she will participate but what about Shai-Anne
Season 5
love this cast as a Devens fan!
Missy is a new school player but a disgusting human being for what she was willing to do. I agree with the other 19 though.
I wonder if Sue or Alicia would ever play again 🤔
Too many really recent players. I'd rather see sth. like five of them from 1-10, 5 from 11-20, 5 from 21-30 and 5 from 31-40. I see no reason to see Vic or Missy as a returning player, I'd rather see f.ex Holly from Nicaragua + I miss Jay from Gen-X and Ian from Palau, Josh or Reed from San Juan del Sur (rather Josh). Bring back Reynold as well
You gotta have both richard and russel the two fathers of old school and new school
A lot of people u put on the new school I don't really need to see again
Dean is super New School
not allowing people that have already played is kind of dumb since a lot of those people define new school and old school gameplay, cool video tho
Don’t know why Rich is on the cast
Rafe from Guatemala tho.
If Dean isn’t the last person
I wanna see kenny, crystal, or nate.
Haydon definitely should’ve been on the cast as well Natalie cole instead of ami cosack
Dean instead of Missy
Ready? Jenna Lewis? Why so she can complain all the time? Or get carried to the end?
Rank the merge boots!
Good video
HELL YEAH, TWILA!!!
Earl Wouldve been on s40 had his wife not had a pre mature birth, sucks, hope he comes back.
Chris noble? The cornball rapper?
Aubry and Karishma!!!!
hatch will never play again greg would be more likely if he said yes & could get the time off
Dude Greg will Never play
This whole thing About old school players being to dynamic makes no sense. Why would you just bring back people that don’t play the game.
They need to call me!!!!!!
Why is Johnny FairPlay never gonna return?
Probably because he lied about his grandmother dying when she clearly hadn't.
And quit Micronesia, Jeff hates quitters
@@pizza123able that's not why lol. Him lying about his grandma is what made him so famous. It's because he quit FvF
Missy is never coming back lol
i wanna see a becky return ( cook islands )
What about an all pre-merge season?!
karishma would’ve been a good one tbh, she found an idol, played it correctly, was an underdog and flipped on her tribe. tbh a perfect returnee
Thomas Garvey she was the worst person to ever be on the show. Since when is crying for 20 days straight a good player? And literally anyone with half a brain would’ve played the idol there, she was obviously the target and she didn’t even do anything with her vote when she could’ve blindsided a big dog
The crying aside, what exactly makes her a good player? She admits that she is terrible at the game, and there aren't any good moves at her disposal.
Hey man I was just wondering what’s your favourite fast food and soda?
i dont like your rules. that cast would suck
ghandia