@@Mugetsu2021 I think that was more of a writing issue, not an acting one. Yes she did not resemble book Annabeth, AT ALL. But the way her character was written, like a cross between Annabeth and Clarisse, didn’t give her much room too be like book Annabeth
@@Mugetsu2021normally I actually try to defend the movie as I actually kinda like them, but I have to agree 100%. They made Annabeth more like clarifies for whatever reason
Whoa there......many movies absolutely suck because of the actors. Twilight was one of the worst. The remake of Clash of the Titans. Batman & Robin. Battlefield Earth. Showgirls. Alexander. After Earth.
I gotta say most of the episodes of the disney + series have been worse than the movies, acting and script wise, episode 4 wasn't terrible thanks to the percy actor who truly is carrying the series as the other 2 kid actors are not exactly good at acting.
It would be so cool if they gave him a small cameo doing something and he sees Walker swinging Riptide around, but being a mortal, he turns to whoever he’s walking with and goes: “That’s a pen. Do you see that? That is a pen!” The whole “this is a pen” line is one reason he’s so loved as Percy despite the movies’ terrible production
How could they be book accurate when in the first book the 3 main characters are 12 years old? Logan and the others were already too old back when the movie was made
Nahh, they're supposed to appear around 12 years old, but they look over 18. It would be odd to see someone who looks like an 18-year-old behaving like a child. If the movie had been filmed 5 years earlier, when Logan was 12 or 13 years old, it might have been more convincing.
I don’t totally agree with u on that one everyone has their own opinions but in the books they were 12 so the casting wasn’t completely accurate to the books but I still think Logan was pretty good at playing Percy
I personally never read the books, and only grew up on the movies when I was in elementary. The movies will always have a special place in my heart, and i'm currently watching the new series! ITS SO GOOD! It's great to know that the original percy jackson actors support the new cast! These kids are really talented! Every time I see kids and teenagers acting in a movie, it makes me wish I could do it too! Cuz acting looks like so much fun!
I hope if that's your dream and you believe in it passionately that you follow it, wherever it leads. You could maybe start with school plays and see what you think of the work. Then college, if you'd like, and more theatre with acting classes--some schools teach film and TV acting as well as standard Theatre. If you find you love acting more than anything else, and if you're good at it, I urge you to pursue your dream and to give it all you've got. If you don't want to go to college, start auditioning for community theatre productions. The more experience you get, the better you'll be. I wish you the absolute best! It's very hard work--very hard--but if it's for you, you'll know it.
@@elijahevergreenuhmmm did you read the books? It’s incredibly similar - Rick has said he didn’t want it to be the exact same because then you’d just be watching the same thing you read and it would be like “why is it even a thing if you can just read the books”. It is really really similar, with just a few differences. But I don’t think people really expected it to be an exact copy of the books because then it would be boring. It’s clearly just based off the books, and it follows the same storyline.
@@elijahevergreen Have you even read the books? True, some changes have been made, but most of them are for the better. If you’re trying to defend the movies, I’d recommend doing so after reading the books and rewatching the show.
@@elijahevergreen The series is very similar! Obviously some adaptations have to be made otherwise it wouldn’t suit the medium, but otherwise it’s quite faithful. Some people refuse to accept that it’s faithful bc they’re pissy about the casting decisions (not saying that’s what ur doing tho) but Rick Riordon himself is heavily supportive of them, and the appearances of characters are certainly not most defining thing about the series.
@@morningglory.2I honesty do not mind the actors being chosen,but some of the changes are not really the best such as Medusa being revealed so quickly,the scene in which Percy becomes known as Poseidon’s son not having the bowing scene which could have give some interesting world building and the Ms Dodds scene which honestly was the most underwhelming. While I don’t hate the series it being a good adaption might not make it a great series if they decide to take stuff which honestly would done good for the it and the changes in itself (except for the Medusa story which I kinda liked) honestly did not do much to improve the series or give it a new lens.
am i one of the only people that actually enjoyed the movies? there were little movies id actually watch as a kid and the Percy Jackson films were one of the few i really liked
Ikr, I feel like going through anything to do with Percy Jackson, ppl say the movies were horrible, and I always don't agree. Well maybe bc I never read the books but the movies were great as a storyline and by itself, if the movies weren't connected to the books maybe it would be more loved.The movies are great and I still love them after rewatching it ❤
As a fan of the books, I absolutely enjoyed the movies. They may not have followed the books word for word, but they used them to establish a foundation and did their own thing with it. Loved the action sequences and the CGI. The movies were definitely their own thing and the show is going to be its own thing, people need to stop being butt-hurt over the silliest of things and just enjoy it for what it is.
I read the books many times and also watched the movies. I love the movies as their own. They are great, really. But they suck as a book adaption. But as their own they are great. So there is nothing wrong in liking the movies. Some people just have a stick up their ass and can't separate the movies from the books.
with that statement from rick i‘m very firm in my belief that no crossover casting will ever occur and going on to fancast logan lerman in various roles isn‘t productive unless rick buries the hatchet and even then i think it‘s just going to lead to a two second cameo at best.
Regardless of rather u like or dislike the movies, they did help people to find out about the books. Some of the times people don't know about the novels until the movies comes out, and I'm one of them. There were also humors in the 1st film I loved which kills me 😅, Grover with Medusa's head "Guys, I can't pee with her watching me" and Persephone "What will u do! I'm already in Hell". The books r better, but those humors and 2 others give the movie some pointers. The others r Percy can heal other with water which he doesn't in the books, and Annabeth explains that the Gods r only deadbeat parents cause of one of Zeus's laws.
but his hate twards the films is extending twards the actors, who had no fault and tryed their best. it wont hurt anyone to have the movie cast appear for a small scene. they seem to support the children and the children look up to them
@@elijahevergreenWhile I would not say it is terrible,I will say I can kind of see what you mean.The actors while maybe are thought to be the right choice are very undeveloped as actors and have little experience,it does not help that while Rick Riordan might know what he wants he has no experience in the film industry so is not the best when it comes to deciding how they should act or (as he is a writer for the show) what dialogue needs changes in the film and how they would sound when real people act it out and say said lines. The director from my understanding also have not worked with kids to this extent that the show meaning that the kid actors don’t have the best sign of direction as let say someone like Christopher Columbus might have(though Columbus has stated to dislike working with kids). It’s honestly best to wait and give the show a try for at least the 1st season and see where it could go from here.
Yeah, the actors in the show aside from the well known actors are very stiff with delivery and motion. Not to mention the costume design. They couldn't have made Annabeth's armor smaller to not make her look like a fucking idiot??
Well that’s your opinion. There are many people who really like the changes, sets and costumes etc. It’s a mostly subjective thing, you can’t just simply tell people who say they like this series because they like the dialogue that they are wrong. They are just the same amount of wrong as you. @@elijahevergreen
@@abc.animal5143Yeah, but it was more the script and direction that was so terrible. For the character he was presented with, he acted well. It just isn’t the same character as in the book.
I like the movie grover better than the new one and I hate the movies but the new grover just isn't a good grover. In the books grover is Percy's best friend he would never snitch on him like that
That’s disgusting, for people to sit there and harass previous actors for a role THEY DIDNT EVEN WANT. it’s pathetic and some people just need to stfu and is never that serious
Maybe I’m wrong, but I feel like I just had a stroke of genius in this idea: For whatever book (at least I’m fairly certain, there was a point in time where the story of Perseus was told a bit) the story of Perseus could be shown with a portion of his story portrayed, it would be awesome to have him be the original Perseus for that moment, as a wink.
Im still very disappointed in the fans for doing that to Leah. The literal author casts her and says she is perfect as Annabeth and they couldn’t get over her being black. So much so they harrass the CHILD on social media. Her parents must be fuming. The same people who harrasd her is probably now praising her because damn 3 episodes in and its already evident how well she played her character. Im with Rick on this personality is all that should matter. Shame on eveyone who did that to her.
Yeah about that, they aren’t praising it they’re most likely just sitting there being stubborn waiting for it to get worse so they can complain. Although I want accuracy I’ve come to learn that people will complain until it turns out to be good or will just be stubborn. But if it’s bad they’ll rag on any changes harder. And I wasn’t even upset with the movie casting, I was disappointed they didn’t even act like the characters. And that was mostly due to the writing. So far the kids are acting like them but they do need another take in some scenes
Was Annabeth described as black in the books? If she wasn't given a skin description it shouldn't matter if she was black. It should only piss people off they decided to race swap the actor for no reason other than to be diverse.
@@tacotruck5009 she was described as white and blonde. Many times it brings it up because being the "blonde girl" made people doubt her. I think it was for diversity but that's just IMO. Im not really pressed about it
Rick is a sell-out and a hypocrite, seeing as he himself criticizes Alexandra Daddario for not being blond in the OG film. And anyone who says looks don't matter didn't really read the books. Seeing as looks mattered a lot, as each god left distinctive features to their kids. Like crazy smiles from Hermis, stormy gray eyes from Athena, sea-green eyes from Posidion, and so on. The least they could do was CGI or use lenses to give the current actress some mist gray eyes as an indicator that she's the daughter of Athena. As for the blond part, it was part of the character herself, her being blond was why everyone underestimated her intelligence, and she hated that a lot. They really could have made Leah blond and given her storm-grey eyes, and that would have been enough. I don't care if she's black or white, as long as the key features of the character are present. And as for perfect actors, don't know what TV show you were watching, but none of the main cast can act even if their life depended on it. There are no emotions expressed and just looks like a bunch of kids are reciting lines for a school play. The only 2 exceptions are the guy who plays Grover, who is doing a banger job for the character, and the man they picked to be Dionysius, that one acts and perfectly fits for the role.
I'm honestly on Rick's side here. Having any cast members of the movies make celebrity cameos would be too forced and distracting. It's one of the (many) reasons the 2016 _Ghostbusters_ reboot was so grating. Because of the forced celebrity cameos, it just felt like the movie wasn't allowed to be its own thing.
At the end listening to Leah’s statement brought tears to my eyes, this girl will be an inspiration and role model to me and many others for a long time.
Like fr tho, the people who have an issue with Annabeth being black aren't true fans; it's shouldn't matter what they look like as long as they play the role the best they can. And so far she's playing the role perfectly
@@RobiHasNoTime one of the major things people were super angry about with the movies was that annabeth wasnt blonde, and to see those same people criticize people who complain about the race swap is just insane, i dont care about race swaps, it can be good, like samuel l jacksons nick fury. but i do have a problem with the show for being a piss poor show, even kids think its boring.
@@gregorycope6099 nah the show was great. The only thing I would change, would be adding few more episodes to adapt more of the camp chapters. And give us more scenes in general, especially for the big moments and fights. I hope they move into 10-12 episodes format for next books.
@@mjm3091 glad you can lie to yourself, i cannot. the show was horrendous, especially on a budget of 15 million per episode. rick riordan is a coward if he can actually say he likes the show but criticizes the movie for being a better form of media regardless of its ability as an adaptation, which btw the show sucks at too.
i think it's really sad how ppl put more weight on the looks of a character being "right" than the actor/actress doing a good job. Unless it's vital to the story - like truly vital - I will not care if the looks from the book or a previous adaptation will be met. Everyone deserves a chance to play a role, regardless of the looks they were born with. If they hit the vibe of the character, they're the right ones.
Someone I know thinks the entire first 2 eps were idiotic and said Luke and Percy's actors should have switched roles. Even when there's evidence Walker Is His Character. And he walk. :3
What made me optimistic is that Rick himself picked and approved the actors. If anyone knows they'd be a good fit, it'd be him. He knows his characters better than anyone else.
People who put so much emphasis on the looks of the characters have clearly also missed the entire point of the Percy Jackson series. The message of the series was that you can accomplish great things no matter what your background is. It would literally be more of a disservice to the books to cast based on physical features instead of casting based on talent.
@@hydragaming4265 why- like why would anyone care? HP is already comparatively divers in the sense that characters of indian or chinese descent attent hogwarts as well as black people. So heritage in that sense is already not important in the story, so it would literally change nothing if Hermione were hispanic (or black or south east asian) for that matter. The only things important to her character are muggle parents who are dentists and other than that her being book smart. Whether her curly hair is important or not you could argue about but the thing with curly hair is that there are enough hispanic, black or south east asian people (just as examples) who have curly hair. So even then it would not matter at all. In the stage play Hermione is also played by a black actress - because she was the best at portraying her and - as controversial as JKR might be - the author herself approved of her portrayal of the character. I really could not care less. And neither should you.
I think we can do a cameo of Logan like this. A monster attacks Percy in public, and Percy pulls out Riptide and changes it into sword. Logan can be clear-sighted or he sort of saw through the mist the moment Percy turned his pen into the sword, and then Logan goes "That was a pen, it was a pen" to himself or his friends played by Alexandra and Brandon (Movie Annabeth and Grover). This also can be a tribute to the line "This is a pen", which is the best lines in the movie.
I think another difference between the show and movie is that, in the movie the characters look about 14 or 15, but in the show you could actually believe that they’re 12
Love the series, love Walker, Arian, and Leah! If I ever had the chance, I would want to tell all of them thank you! I love the books and the show so much!
Of course Logan and Alexandra support them that is not a shocker to me at least! I also do feel like it would be weird for Logan to be Posiedion but I think majority would love a small cameo, like how Stan Lee did cameo's for his movies. Did the movies do the book justice? Not at all. Nope. But were the movies entertaining and enjoyable as a stand-alone when you separate it's inaccuracy to the book? In my opinion, Yes! The editing for the water when it first healed Percy was really cool and the delivery of “This a pen... This is a PEN!” and "What are you doing? Don't walk on my roof." and others, it was hilarious and the actors did amazing and Logan was a perfect Percy in my opinion, it was just for a lot of people the biggest problem was the fact it didn't really align with the books which made it hard for the acting in the movie to make up for it not matching the books. In short the movies aren't a good adaptation of the amazing books but seperate from that it's an enjoyable alternate version. About this Percy Jackson series we've got now - the casting choices are spectacular! The acting, the writing, the editing, the set and props, the whole production it's looking so freaking amazing and it feels like it's really diving into the book series. So far it's pretty similar to the books, my recollection is kinda fuzzy as it's been years since I've read the start of the series but from I do recall it's being brought to life so freaking beautifully!! Overall: Books, AMAZING! Movies - don't do books justice at all but are ENJOYABLE as stand-alones! The Series so far - BEAUTIFUL! I'm loving it so much and I can't wait for another episode!!
I‘m a massive fan of the books and was glad to see that it got made into a tv series. I have no issues at all with the cast, though I haven‘t quite managed to connect with the Annabeth character yet. One thing I feel a bit iffy about though is how disjointed the cutting of scenes is sometimes (s1 e3 so far) which is especially jarring when the same disjointed feeling is used to represent the halfblood visions/nightmares. Also, I felt the whole seriousness and urgency for the quest was lost in 2 sentences of exposition by Chiron… at least, the first movie managed to set the tone for the whole reason of the quest in the scene between Zeus and Posidon at the very start.
He would be like 40 then. Nah - Walker already will be kinda crossing the age line too much, as HoO is meant to happen in one year (so he will be playing a 16-17 years old himself being 16-26).
I'm honestly mostly hyped because Percy is played by the kid that played mini-Ryan Reynolds in The Adam Project, and had all of his attitude nailed down. I love watching that kid tbh :D
i feel like atleast making logan a worker at the empire state building would have been a nice cameo like no reason not to also just a nice little homage
Someday, hopefully soon, the haters will realize that their racism is unwelcome. Our new Annabeth is Rick’s choice. That is enough for me. People dont understand art. Bad enough they revolted over race. Anyone have an opinion about the cast’s sexual orientation?
So anyone who supports a white actor or actress is racist even though the character is supposed to be white? Why don’t you just create a new character? Oh yeah. Cause you can’t have ANY success on your own unless you steal it from white people. What a joke
See I don’t cate abt the cast’s sexual orientation, they can love who they want it doesn’t matter. I just don’t want them to hop on the marvel trend and make everything woke, like change the characters sexual orientation nd shit
@@richmargin6082 so, you think that now, since Rick wrote the book with a different Annabeth, he is forever locked into that choice? Perhaps he wants to explore a different side of the character.
I honestly get dissapointrd on the current series that they didn't stick to the physical description of the characters like Percy, Annabety, Grover and what more. BUUTTT! As the series goes on, they portray tge characters through their acting skills so it's ok. I'm just really shocked specially to Annabeth, but she got the talent
Is it fair that Alexandra Daddario had to dye her hair during the second film to "better stick to the character", while Disney obviously does not care about the characters in the books ?
I’d actually be down for the original actor Peter whatever to make a cameo as a different character or a long term running counselor at camp half blood in the background of a bunch of shots all blurry or just in the background clearly visible.
Nostalgia is all it is. I will forever love the movies and the action scenes were way better and emotions were displayed better than the show and Grover being older like the movie is better since he is the protector. However, the show despite a few setbacks ended gloriously and Walker is doing his best. If Lerman were to cameo, yes it would be cool but it would feel off at the same time
i feel sorry for the new actor of annabeth, it's not her fault although it would be nice to get a character who fits the role of annabeth its not the most important
When it comes to book character adaptations it’s a touchy subject due to the expectations of those who played them before or the character itself. It’s harsh criticism that comes with that expectation so for the actor/actress the pressure is high. PJO is no exception. It’s never about WHO plays the character it’s about HOW they play the character. Remember that.
I enjoyed the movies until I read the books, I saw myself in Percy as I also grew up with a dead beat dad. I was worried Disney would ruin the series but I has been great so far and the casting was damn near perfect!
Hmm ... you know who Logan probably could do justice to later in the series? I think he'd make a great Quintus ... I mean, it would be another four years before we might see that book and Logan with some silver hair is a possibility. It's a long shot ... but of all the future characters, it seems he could really do something with that role. Though it will likely go to someone older ... would still be interesting
I REAAALLY want rick to make Percy look canonically more like Walker, because I saw the series before I started reading the books and trust me I significantly prefer that Percy rather than the one that looked like Logan.
as a huge Percy Jackson fan this was amazing i'm literally crying that's amazing and I love all the actors and think the show is amazing and the new actors along with the old ones❤❤❤❤
Bruh at the beginning of this video she said that rick riordan didnt like the direction the movies were going in,...she shouldve also added that rick riordan is a sell out who ruins the books
Obviously the writer doesn’t want anyone from the movies to be involved in ANY way with the series. So why does everyone think the old cast should have any connection? Stop asking Logan to be involved. The new actors shouldn’t be asking for anything. The direction is that they make the series their own. Forget the cameos, the Poseidon role, the words of advice. Just move on. If you don’t like it then complain to the writer and Disney in the direction they chose.
To be fair in the books, Rick never says directly the skin tone of Annabeth. I wish they have given Leah a blond wig because Annabeth is defiantly supposed to be blond. In terms of what they did in the show to my favorite character from the books, it didn't feel Annabeth for me all the way thru. For example in the last episode, Annabeth is saving Percy from Luke and able to find him. Book readers would know that Annabeth can never raise a blade against Luke, this is a major part of her character arc and they destroyed it. I am happy that the old cast is supportive and I am too. I wish the actors nothing but success and good in their lives, I can only hope characters will act like themselves in future seasons.
Logans beautiful 🤭 But I do personally like the show better than the movies, but Logan was the one thing they got right him being Percy and all. Walker is killing it though.
I love both of them but the inappropriate scenes in the movie , I hated them but apart from that all I really enjoyed it Maybe if the movie didn't contain the inappropriate things then it would have been great , like, you know - been a hit or something and more productions could have taken place 😊
I love the movies They brought me to the PJO world I would have never even heard of Percy Jackson without the movies And I prefer them over the show not because of race or anything but because they introduced me to PJO
I loved the movies growing up but I never got around to checking out the books- after watching the TV series now and hearing people say its more accurate to the books I've realized I definitely won't be reading them
The original cast was fine. Those directors need to be fired though. Rick stated constantly that they shat all over his original creation and he wasn't really involved with anything.
Развлечения
The movies were bad. The actors were fine
Annabeth was terrible not resembling a single thing that made her great in the book
@@Mugetsu2021 I think that was more of a writing issue, not an acting one. Yes she did not resemble book Annabeth, AT ALL. But the way her character was written, like a cross between Annabeth and Clarisse, didn’t give her much room too be like book Annabeth
@@lillianmonk yep I’m 100% blaming the writing, but it’s not like a 26 year old would ever convince me she was Annabeth, doomed from the start tbh.
@@Mugetsu2021normally I actually try to defend the movie as I actually kinda like them, but I have to agree 100%. They made Annabeth more like clarifies for whatever reason
The actors were too old, the characters in the sieres were 12, not teenagers
This is the reason why we don't blame the actors for being in bad movies
Whoa there......many movies absolutely suck because of the actors. Twilight was one of the worst. The remake of Clash of the Titans. Batman & Robin. Battlefield Earth. Showgirls. Alexander. After Earth.
@@HappyBuddhaBoyd X-man: Dark Phoenix as well. I know. I meant the PJO movies in particular
I gotta say most of the episodes of the disney + series have been worse than the movies, acting and script wise, episode 4 wasn't terrible thanks to the percy actor who truly is carrying the series as the other 2 kid actors are not exactly good at acting.
@@HappyBuddhaBoydThat’s true, but that’s not the case here
@@HappyBuddhaBoydagain don’t blame actors for being in bad movies
It would be so cool if they gave him a small cameo doing something and he sees Walker swinging Riptide around, but being a mortal, he turns to whoever he’s walking with and goes: “That’s a pen. Do you see that? That is a pen!” The whole “this is a pen” line is one reason he’s so loved as Percy despite the movies’ terrible production
Yes. Btw i love your profile picture.
lmao yeah that’d be cool
@@Lyric813 is that taylor swift?
It would also be interesting if he could play triton Percy's older half brother
NO NO
I honestly think the actors in the movies could’ve been great and book accurate if they’d just been given a better script
How could they be book accurate when in the first book the 3 main characters are 12 years old? Logan and the others were already too old back when the movie was made
Nahh, they're supposed to appear around 12 years old, but they look over 18. It would be odd to see someone who looks like an 18-year-old behaving like a child. If the movie had been filmed 5 years earlier, when Logan was 12 or 13 years old, it might have been more convincing.
Given how they weren’t 12 they would’ve never been booked accurate
I agree. Their appearances were more book accurate then the actors' in this adaptation. (They could've/should've been younger though)
the age of the characters is a central matter of the plot, is not just some detail that can be easily ignored, so no, they couldn't been accurate
Logan was so so beautiful as Percy, the casting was phenomenal in the movies. And tbh, I liked the movies too.
And he’s still beautiful!
I don’t totally agree with u on that one everyone has their own opinions but in the books they were 12 so the casting wasn’t completely accurate to the books but I still think Logan was pretty good at playing Percy
The actors did good, but you have to remember that they were full grown adulta and in the books they were all around 12-14 years old
The movies weren't really that bad but they're not better than the show or the books.
Real!!
I personally never read the books, and only grew up on the movies when I was in elementary. The movies will always have a special place in my heart, and i'm currently watching the new series! ITS SO GOOD! It's great to know that the original percy jackson actors support the new cast! These kids are really talented! Every time I see kids and teenagers acting in a movie, it makes me wish I could do it too! Cuz acting looks like so much fun!
I hope if that's your dream and you believe in it passionately that you follow it, wherever it leads. You could maybe start with school plays and see what you think of the work. Then college, if you'd like, and more theatre with acting classes--some schools teach film and TV acting as well as standard Theatre. If you find you love acting more than anything else, and if you're good at it, I urge you to pursue your dream and to give it all you've got. If you don't want to go to college, start auditioning for community theatre productions. The more experience you get, the better you'll be. I wish you the absolute best! It's very hard work--very hard--but if it's for you, you'll know it.
Why dont you read the books?
@@kimfrankenwewe Cuz I just don't read books. I find books boring. Movies and shows are way more entertaining.
@@CoolMan1_SonicAndOtherStuff ok sad
@@CoolMan1_SonicAndOtherStuff but I get it
Logan would be great as Paul Blofis
You mean Blowfish😂
Yo...you got a point
OMG I SEE IT
RIGHT?!
O Damn/pos
Ok i liked the movies but the series is WAY more like the book and thats why i love it
Way more like the book? How? 69 paid bots liked your comment from Disney. The show is NOTHING like the books.
@@elijahevergreenuhmmm did you read the books? It’s incredibly similar - Rick has said he didn’t want it to be the exact same because then you’d just be watching the same thing you read and it would be like “why is it even a thing if you can just read the books”. It is really really similar, with just a few differences. But I don’t think people really expected it to be an exact copy of the books because then it would be boring. It’s clearly just based off the books, and it follows the same storyline.
@@elijahevergreen Have you even read the books? True, some changes have been made, but most of them are for the better. If you’re trying to defend the movies, I’d recommend doing so after reading the books and rewatching the show.
@@elijahevergreen The series is very similar! Obviously some adaptations have to be made otherwise it wouldn’t suit the medium, but otherwise it’s quite faithful.
Some people refuse to accept that it’s faithful bc they’re pissy about the casting decisions (not saying that’s what ur doing tho) but Rick Riordon himself is heavily supportive of them, and the appearances of characters are certainly not most defining thing about the series.
@@morningglory.2I honesty do not mind the actors being chosen,but some of the changes are not really the best such as Medusa being revealed so quickly,the scene in which Percy becomes known as Poseidon’s son not having the bowing scene which could have give some interesting world building and the Ms Dodds scene which honestly was the most underwhelming.
While I don’t hate the series it being a good adaption might not make it a great series if they decide to take stuff which honestly would done good for the it and the changes in itself (except for the Medusa story which I kinda liked) honestly did not do much to improve the series or give it a new lens.
am i one of the only people that actually enjoyed the movies? there were little movies id actually watch as a kid and the Percy Jackson films were one of the few i really liked
Ikr, I feel like going through anything to do with Percy Jackson, ppl say the movies were horrible, and I always don't agree. Well maybe bc I never read the books but the movies were great as a storyline and by itself, if the movies weren't connected to the books maybe it would be more loved.The movies are great and I still love them after rewatching it ❤
It's because the book readers hated the movies because the movies had nothing to do with the books
As a fan of the books, I absolutely enjoyed the movies. They may not have followed the books word for word, but they used them to establish a foundation and did their own thing with it. Loved the action sequences and the CGI. The movies were definitely their own thing and the show is going to be its own thing, people need to stop being butt-hurt over the silliest of things and just enjoy it for what it is.
I also enjoyed it
I read the books many times and also watched the movies. I love the movies as their own. They are great, really. But they suck as a book adaption. But as their own they are great. So there is nothing wrong in liking the movies.
Some people just have a stick up their ass and can't separate the movies from the books.
with that statement from rick i‘m very firm in my belief that no crossover casting will ever occur and going on to fancast logan lerman in various roles isn‘t productive unless rick buries the hatchet and even then i think it‘s just going to lead to a two second cameo at best.
Regardless of rather u like or dislike the movies, they did help people to find out about the books. Some of the times people don't know about the novels until the movies comes out, and I'm one of them. There were also humors in the 1st film I loved which kills me 😅, Grover with Medusa's head "Guys, I can't pee with her watching me" and Persephone "What will u do! I'm already in Hell". The books r better, but those humors and 2 others give the movie some pointers. The others r Percy can heal other with water which he doesn't in the books, and Annabeth explains that the Gods r only deadbeat parents cause of one of Zeus's laws.
In both it is because the big three are horny
I agree with Rick. The movies were bad, we need to leave them behind if we want this to be a good thing on its own.
but his hate twards the films is extending twards the actors, who had no fault and tryed their best. it wont hurt anyone to have the movie cast appear for a small scene. they seem to support the children and the children look up to them
The movies were WAY better and had better acting and dialogue than the show. The show is TERRIBLE.
@@elijahevergreenWhile I would not say it is terrible,I will say I can kind of see what you mean.The actors while maybe are thought to be the right choice are very undeveloped as actors and have little experience,it does not help that while Rick Riordan might know what he wants he has no experience in the film industry so is not the best when it comes to deciding how they should act or (as he is a writer for the show) what dialogue needs changes in the film and how they would sound when real people act it out and say said lines.
The director from my understanding also have not worked with kids to this extent that the show meaning that the kid actors don’t have the best sign of direction as let say someone like Christopher Columbus might have(though Columbus has stated to dislike working with kids).
It’s honestly best to wait and give the show a try for at least the 1st season and see where it could go from here.
Yeah, the actors in the show aside from the well known actors are very stiff with delivery and motion. Not to mention the costume design. They couldn't have made Annabeth's armor smaller to not make her look like a fucking idiot??
Well that’s your opinion. There are many people who really like the changes, sets and costumes etc.
It’s a mostly subjective thing, you can’t just simply tell people who say they like this series because they like the dialogue that they are wrong. They are just the same amount of wrong as you. @@elijahevergreen
“Stop it, don’t walk on my roof” best line on the damn franchise
And “this is a pen”
*dam
I still think Grover’s actor was great in he movies, just the way they portrayed him was bad
He did not act like Grover
@@abc.animal5143Yeah, but it was more the script and direction that was so terrible. For the character he was presented with, he acted well. It just isn’t the same character as in the book.
I like the movie grover better than the new one and I hate the movies but the new grover just isn't a good grover. In the books grover is Percy's best friend he would never snitch on him like that
@@urmadcausebad the new Grover fits the character better, the nervous type.
@@abc.animal5143 he's fits the nervousness but in the books he was extremely loyal to percy and percy would literally sneak away from him to be alone
I like how Alex rally behind Leah right off. And I like Leah's response, so perfect.
Ok also in my opinion the movie would have been better if more like the book. But the actors fit the characters PERFECTLY!! And so do the new cast
The new grover doesn't fit
Dawg old groover was to old
@@urmadcausebadhe may not be perfect, but he is pretty damn good either way
@mastere6115 the kids a good actor im sure but his grover just doesn't feel like grover
That’s disgusting, for people to sit there and harass previous actors for a role THEY DIDNT EVEN WANT. it’s pathetic and some people just need to stfu and is never that serious
I didn’t Harrass anyone but even I know it serious how she needs to be portrayed
@@alexchaser320 what are you on
@@jayshawn what r u talking bout
Maybe I’m wrong, but I feel like I just had a stroke of genius in this idea: For whatever book (at least I’m fairly certain, there was a point in time where the story of Perseus was told a bit) the story of Perseus could be shown with a portion of his story portrayed, it would be awesome to have him be the original Perseus for that moment, as a wink.
That’s an awesome idea and would be so cool
Walker is gonna be next heart throb for the little kids :) Logan is my generation so Logan was mine growing up
I just enjoyed the fact that the movie was created and led me to read the entire series and appreciated that they tried to make them into movies
Im still very disappointed in the fans for doing that to Leah. The literal author casts her and says she is perfect as Annabeth and they couldn’t get over her being black.
So much so they harrass the CHILD on social media. Her parents must be fuming.
The same people who harrasd her is probably now praising her because damn 3 episodes in and its already evident how well she played her character.
Im with Rick on this personality is all that should matter.
Shame on eveyone who did that to her.
Yeah about that, they aren’t praising it they’re most likely just sitting there being stubborn waiting for it to get worse so they can complain. Although I want accuracy I’ve come to learn that people will complain until it turns out to be good or will just be stubborn. But if it’s bad they’ll rag on any changes harder. And I wasn’t even upset with the movie casting, I was disappointed they didn’t even act like the characters. And that was mostly due to the writing. So far the kids are acting like them but they do need another take in some scenes
Was Annabeth described as black in the books? If she wasn't given a skin description it shouldn't matter if she was black. It should only piss people off they decided to race swap the actor for no reason other than to be diverse.
@@tacotruck5009 she was described as white and blonde. Many times it brings it up because being the "blonde girl" made people doubt her. I think it was for diversity but that's just IMO. Im not really pressed about it
Rick is a sell-out and a hypocrite, seeing as he himself criticizes Alexandra Daddario for not being blond in the OG film. And anyone who says looks don't matter didn't really read the books. Seeing as looks mattered a lot, as each god left distinctive features to their kids. Like crazy smiles from Hermis, stormy gray eyes from Athena, sea-green eyes from Posidion, and so on. The least they could do was CGI or use lenses to give the current actress some mist gray eyes as an indicator that she's the daughter of Athena. As for the blond part, it was part of the character herself, her being blond was why everyone underestimated her intelligence, and she hated that a lot. They really could have made Leah blond and given her storm-grey eyes, and that would have been enough. I don't care if she's black or white, as long as the key features of the character are present.
And as for perfect actors, don't know what TV show you were watching, but none of the main cast can act even if their life depended on it. There are no emotions expressed and just looks like a bunch of kids are reciting lines for a school play. The only 2 exceptions are the guy who plays Grover, who is doing a banger job for the character, and the man they picked to be Dionysius, that one acts and perfectly fits for the role.
@@wertygospiner2245 Can you show me where he criticized Alexandra not being blonde?
I'm honestly on Rick's side here. Having any cast members of the movies make celebrity cameos would be too forced and distracting.
It's one of the (many) reasons the 2016 _Ghostbusters_ reboot was so grating. Because of the forced celebrity cameos, it just felt like the movie wasn't allowed to be its own thing.
At the end listening to Leah’s statement brought tears to my eyes, this girl will be an inspiration and role model to me and many others for a long time.
Like fr tho, the people who have an issue with Annabeth being black aren't true fans; it's shouldn't matter what they look like as long as they play the role the best they can. And so far she's playing the role perfectly
@@RobiHasNoTime one of the major things people were super angry about with the movies was that annabeth wasnt blonde, and to see those same people criticize people who complain about the race swap is just insane, i dont care about race swaps, it can be good, like samuel l jacksons nick fury. but i do have a problem with the show for being a piss poor show, even kids think its boring.
@@gregorycope6099 nah the show was great. The only thing I would change, would be adding few more episodes to adapt more of the camp chapters. And give us more scenes in general, especially for the big moments and fights. I hope they move into 10-12 episodes format for next books.
@@mjm3091 glad you can lie to yourself, i cannot. the show was horrendous, especially on a budget of 15 million per episode. rick riordan is a coward if he can actually say he likes the show but criticizes the movie for being a better form of media regardless of its ability as an adaptation, which btw the show sucks at too.
@@gregorycope6099 like what did you not like? Aside maybe pacing, which again - 8 episodes issue, hopefully they can have more next few seasons.
i think it's really sad how ppl put more weight on the looks of a character being "right" than the actor/actress doing a good job.
Unless it's vital to the story - like truly vital - I will not care if the looks from the book or a previous adaptation will be met. Everyone deserves a chance to play a role, regardless of the looks they were born with. If they hit the vibe of the character, they're the right ones.
Someone I know thinks the entire first 2 eps were idiotic and said Luke and Percy's actors should have switched roles. Even when there's evidence Walker Is His Character.
And he walk. :3
Bruh the only thing is I don’t want hermione to be hispanic in the new hp series
What made me optimistic is that Rick himself picked and approved the actors. If anyone knows they'd be a good fit, it'd be him. He knows his characters better than anyone else.
People who put so much emphasis on the looks of the characters have clearly also missed the entire point of the Percy Jackson series. The message of the series was that you can accomplish great things no matter what your background is. It would literally be more of a disservice to the books to cast based on physical features instead of casting based on talent.
@@hydragaming4265 why- like why would anyone care? HP is already comparatively divers in the sense that characters of indian or chinese descent attent hogwarts as well as black people. So heritage in that sense is already not important in the story, so it would literally change nothing if Hermione were hispanic (or black or south east asian) for that matter. The only things important to her character are muggle parents who are dentists and other than that her being book smart. Whether her curly hair is important or not you could argue about but the thing with curly hair is that there are enough hispanic, black or south east asian people (just as examples) who have curly hair. So even then it would not matter at all.
In the stage play Hermione is also played by a black actress - because she was the best at portraying her and - as controversial as JKR might be - the author herself approved of her portrayal of the character.
I really could not care less. And neither should you.
I think we can do a cameo of Logan like this. A monster attacks Percy in public, and Percy pulls out Riptide and changes it into sword. Logan can be clear-sighted or he sort of saw through the mist the moment Percy turned his pen into the sword, and then Logan goes "That was a pen, it was a pen" to himself or his friends played by Alexandra and Brandon (Movie Annabeth and Grover). This also can be a tribute to the line "This is a pen", which is the best lines in the movie.
I think another difference between the show and movie is that, in the movie the characters look about 14 or 15, but in the show you could actually believe that they’re 12
Love the series, love Walker, Arian, and Leah! If I ever had the chance, I would want to tell all of them thank you! I love the books and the show so much!
Logan still looks way too young to be playing someone’s dad. That would’ve been weird to me.
fair but gods can also choose how they appear!
Thank u movie fans just don’t get it
Of course Logan and Alexandra support them that is not a shocker to me at least! I also do feel like it would be weird for Logan to be Posiedion but I think majority would love a small cameo, like how Stan Lee did cameo's for his movies. Did the movies do the book justice? Not at all. Nope. But were the movies entertaining and enjoyable as a stand-alone when you separate it's inaccuracy to the book? In my opinion, Yes! The editing for the water when it first healed Percy was really cool and the delivery of “This a pen... This is a PEN!” and "What are you doing? Don't walk on my roof." and others, it was hilarious and the actors did amazing and Logan was a perfect Percy in my opinion, it was just for a lot of people the biggest problem was the fact it didn't really align with the books which made it hard for the acting in the movie to make up for it not matching the books. In short the movies aren't a good adaptation of the amazing books but seperate from that it's an enjoyable alternate version. About this Percy Jackson series we've got now - the casting choices are spectacular! The acting, the writing, the editing, the set and props, the whole production it's looking so freaking amazing and it feels like it's really diving into the book series. So far it's pretty similar to the books, my recollection is kinda fuzzy as it's been years since I've read the start of the series but from I do recall it's being brought to life so freaking beautifully!! Overall: Books, AMAZING! Movies - don't do books justice at all but are ENJOYABLE as stand-alones! The Series so far - BEAUTIFUL! I'm loving it so much and I can't wait for another episode!!
i loved the original movies
I‘m a massive fan of the books and was glad to see that it got made into a tv series. I have no issues at all with the cast, though I haven‘t quite managed to connect with the Annabeth character yet. One thing I feel a bit iffy about though is how disjointed the cutting of scenes is sometimes (s1 e3 so far) which is especially jarring when the same disjointed feeling is used to represent the halfblood visions/nightmares. Also, I felt the whole seriousness and urgency for the quest was lost in 2 sentences of exposition by Chiron… at least, the first movie managed to set the tone for the whole reason of the quest in the scene between Zeus and Posidon at the very start.
Leah makes a great annabeth! I know she doesnt look how she's described in the books, but her personality is spot on!
I think he could be one of the dead pirates in the second book that would be a cool cameo
I would love for Logan to be Poseidon but I completely understand Rick and the fact he wants a fresh start.
LOGAN LERMAN playing 20 year old Percy in the future percy story makes sense ( Heroes of Olympus series)
That would be awesome
He would be like 40 then. Nah - Walker already will be kinda crossing the age line too much, as HoO is meant to happen in one year (so he will be playing a 16-17 years old himself being 16-26).
I'm honestly mostly hyped because Percy is played by the kid that played mini-Ryan Reynolds in The Adam Project, and had all of his attitude nailed down. I love watching that kid tbh :D
I felt really old when I looked up Logan and found out hes is actually old enough to have a 12 year old son
Haven't watched the series, but the movies were very fun, same with the characters especially Grover.
as someone who never read the books i loved the first movie
I can't wait for the expanded universe! I hope we get Heroes of Olympus (Camp Jupiter), Kane Chronicles and Magnus Chase!
Any Harry Potter fans who noticed that Emma Watson is in the video:
traitor
Logan should be cast as triton, he had a few seconds in the final book so perfect for a cameo
looking back at the movies they definitely weren’t good back they gave us some iconic scenes
i feel like atleast making logan a worker at the empire state building would have been a nice cameo like no reason not to also just a nice little homage
Im starting to feel like i am the only one that actually loves the movies 😂
Someday, hopefully soon, the haters will realize that their racism is unwelcome. Our new Annabeth is Rick’s choice. That is enough for me. People dont understand art. Bad enough they revolted over race. Anyone have an opinion about the cast’s sexual orientation?
So anyone who supports a white actor or actress is racist even though the character is supposed to be white? Why don’t you just create a new character? Oh yeah. Cause you can’t have ANY success on your own unless you steal it from white people. What a joke
See I don’t cate abt the cast’s sexual orientation, they can love who they want it doesn’t matter. I just don’t want them to hop on the marvel trend and make everything woke, like change the characters sexual orientation nd shit
If annabeth was Rick’s choice then why did he write her with blonde hair and gray eyes? The actress is nothing like that
@@richmargin6082 so, you think that now, since Rick wrote the book with a different Annabeth, he is forever locked into that choice? Perhaps he wants to explore a different side of the character.
@@teuchiotsutski6124 so, woke is about race and not other differences? You can have a preference. So can Rick .
Logan and Alex were absolutely breathtaking to look at in the movies. And i do think they have characters that exists in the PJ reboot universe 🙌
I think it’d be funny if he was just like a person on the train or something, no lines, nothing like that
I personally could never be disappointed in Toby Stephens being cast in any role. The man is a brilliant actor.
I was praying that the original cast played the main character’s parents and I’m glad I wasn’t the only one
I LOVE how unbiased you are (sarcasm)
Good to see the original cast of Percy Jackson have been supportive of the newer cast.
Logan looks too young to be Poseidon!!
Agreed
I feel like it would be cool if he was a cameo in the lotus casino or something
So far this series is SOOOOO good. I'm shocked. Really well done. Great stuff.
I wish they made references or cameos with this actors i mean we stil lgot alot of season man
As someone who was a kid when the movies came out and didn’t read the books and still haven’t i think the first movie was really good
I honestly get dissapointrd on the current series that they didn't stick to the physical description of the characters like Percy, Annabety, Grover and what more. BUUTTT! As the series goes on, they portray tge characters through their acting skills so it's ok. I'm just really shocked specially to Annabeth, but she got the talent
Is it fair that Alexandra Daddario had to dye her hair during the second film to "better stick to the character", while Disney obviously does not care about the characters in the books ?
I’d actually be down for the original actor Peter whatever to make a cameo as a different character or a long term running counselor at camp half blood in the background of a bunch of shots all blurry or just in the background clearly visible.
Nostalgia is all it is. I will forever love the movies and the action scenes were way better and emotions were displayed better than the show and Grover being older like the movie is better since he is the protector.
However, the show despite a few setbacks ended gloriously and Walker is doing his best. If Lerman were to cameo, yes it would be cool but it would feel off at the same time
Dude I never noticed that Logan Lerman looked like Timothee Chalamet
when uncle rick be speaking FACTS
Do they mean the Peter Johnson movies ? (NOT THE SHOW THEY ATEEEEEE)
i feel sorry for the new actor of annabeth, it's not her fault although it would be nice to get a character who fits the role of annabeth its not the most important
I like that nobody is talking about how this is clickbate, there was no reacting in this video.
When it comes to book character adaptations it’s a touchy subject due to the expectations of those who played them before or the character itself. It’s harsh criticism that comes with that expectation so for the actor/actress the pressure is high. PJO is no exception. It’s never about WHO plays the character it’s about HOW they play the character. Remember that.
I enjoyed the movies until I read the books, I saw myself in Percy as I also grew up with a dead beat dad. I was worried Disney would ruin the series but I has been great so far and the casting was damn near perfect!
Hmm ... you know who Logan probably could do justice to later in the series? I think he'd make a great Quintus ... I mean, it would be another four years before we might see that book and Logan with some silver hair is a possibility. It's a long shot ... but of all the future characters, it seems he could really do something with that role. Though it will likely go to someone older ... would still be interesting
I enjoyed the movies and the t.v. I'm still watching
was it just me who had to pause the video and breathe when the said walker scobull instead of scobell
(not a walkie stalkie), but YESS FR. (also when she said “rick roidien”)
I REAAALLY want rick to make Percy look canonically more like Walker, because I saw the series before I started reading the books and trust me I significantly prefer that Percy rather than the one that looked like Logan.
I enjoyed Logan as Percy and the new one looks good I bet they will kill it
as a huge Percy Jackson fan this was amazing i'm literally crying that's amazing and I love all the actors and think the show is amazing and the new actors along with the old ones❤❤❤❤
Ok tho Logan and Daddario (specially Daddario
It would be cool if they made logan the actual hero perseus in like some kinda flashback to greek mythology.
Should be a pirate on circes Island
Bruh at the beginning of this video she said that rick riordan didnt like the direction the movies were going in,...she shouldve also added that rick riordan is a sell out who ruins the books
Obviously the writer doesn’t want anyone from the movies to be involved in ANY way with the series. So why does everyone think the old cast should have any connection? Stop asking Logan to be involved. The new actors shouldn’t be asking for anything. The direction is that they make the series their own. Forget the cameos, the Poseidon role, the words of advice. Just move on. If you don’t like it then complain to the writer and Disney in the direction they chose.
To be fair in the books, Rick never says directly the skin tone of Annabeth. I wish they have given Leah a blond wig because Annabeth is defiantly supposed to be blond. In terms of what they did in the show to my favorite character from the books, it didn't feel Annabeth for me all the way thru. For example in the last episode, Annabeth is saving Percy from Luke and able to find him. Book readers would know that Annabeth can never raise a blade against Luke, this is a major part of her character arc and they destroyed it. I am happy that the old cast is supportive and I am too. I wish the actors nothing but success and good in their lives, I can only hope characters will act like themselves in future seasons.
You know a movie is bad when not only fans hate it but the actor too
Logans beautiful 🤭
But I do personally like the show better than the movies, but Logan was the one thing they got right him being Percy and all.
Walker is killing it though.
it would be cool if they did something like they did with lin manuel miranda
I love both
I love both of them but the inappropriate scenes in the movie , I hated them but apart from that all I really enjoyed it
Maybe if the movie didn't contain the inappropriate things then it would have been great , like, you know - been a hit or something and more productions could have taken place 😊
it would be nice if he ends up on the roll of Quintus/Dedalo
Although Logan was the best part of the movies, I don’t know how I would feel about him playing Poseidon. He’s doesn’t really give daddy vibes
I didn't read the books, that probably why I had no complaints about the movie
I love the movies
They brought me to the PJO world
I would have never even heard of Percy Jackson without the movies
And I prefer them over the show not because of race or anything but because they introduced me to PJO
I wouldn't know how to judge the movies since I never read the books.
the problem i have with the movies was the writing
It would be cool If Logan was in one of Percy’s dreams.
I loved the movies growing up but I never got around to checking out the books- after watching the TV series now and hearing people say its more accurate to the books I've realized I definitely won't be reading them
I don't really remember the movies but I love Logan in a lot of other films
and now they met
if he would come in the tv series it would make more sense if he would play the percy jekson when the carakter is like 14-15 so in the middel
The original cast was fine. Those directors need to be fired though. Rick stated constantly that they shat all over his original creation and he wasn't really involved with anything.
Hear me out hear me out... what if he was cast as a random high school teacher
Logan was a perfect Percy Jackson he is an amazing actor
Any chance Lerman ends up appearing briefly as Hermes? I think that would be perfect.
*_cough_* Lin Manuel Miranda...