Yeah the whole "i kept thinking about eminem,and would do anything to see him,before he got famous" is bs. The dad,marshall,had other children after debbie "left".
Believe it or not it really wasnt that uncommon back in those days. The age of concent actually went up over the years so itd really not that crazy if you think about it.
Eminem has a point in my opinion There was no Excuse to Leave your kids and Abandon Them If i Have Kids im gonna do anything and everything to stay in my kids life
Yes very true, even if Marshall bettered his life later on it’s still Eninem’s decision to get in contact with him. He wasn’t there for him when he needed him the most (as a child)
Now according to him, he did not abandon him, he returned home and Eminem with his mother were missing. This could be a lie, sure. But how can we trust his mother? What do you think?
Please do. My dad abandoned me and my sister when we were small. It has done mental damage to us both, do what you can to keep your family together if you do have kids one day x
I believe the mother, just look at the age gap. If he was able to reply to Eminem 's letter that were supposedly sent back that means he had the address. If you truly wanted to see him at any point he could have popped up when school was letting out. It was the money and fam he was after.
As his biological father, he would have had legal rights to see Eminem if he really wanted to. He could have gotten the police involved. If he was abusive it may have worked out for the best that he wasn't in Eminem's life.
Marshall left Em when he was 6 months old. Then Marshall said that his wife stopped him from seeing Em. There is no reason to stop seeing your kids if you and the mother split up. No reason whatsoever. Marshall is talking BS.
So your 15/16 year old baby mama fled with her baby? Even if that's true (which it probably isn't) then Debbie probably saw sense and fled. I'm amazed that Eminem got out of all that shit relatively unscathed, and raised daughters that he and Kim can be proud of. He truly broke the cycle, and I hope that he forgave his mother despite her nutty litigious moment.
I wanna say it sounds like they both are bad parents. But we don't know whats true. Eminem as a child has many thoughts going through his head and his feelings aren't wrong to what he went through and what he heard. Only God knows what happened. And since Marshall ii died in 2019 he had so much time trying to find Eminem and Nathan (eminem's little brother) Eminem has been a big deal since he came out and all the way to 2019 and Marshall had enough time. There was no "giving up" trying to find your kids as a father and grandfather.
Wow that is surprising that the fact Debbie was only 15 years old and Eminem’s Dad was 22 and managed to get away with dating a minor & no jail time all these years later!!? Wtf 😬 Em’s dad sure got lucky I suppose but RIP to his only late dad though ❤ Wether they both had beef with each other or not I figured I would pay respects for MMJR. 😎🍻🍻🍻🙏🏾
The way I see this is that he knew where em was growing up he could have went out and found him regardless what his mom said he was old enough to make that choice
The fact that Eminem has mentioned many times what a sh*tty mother Debbie was, I wouldn't be surprised if she tried to stop Marshall from knowing his son after he abandoned them, he was basically already a pedophile for being 22 dating Debbie at 15 that he could've been more disturbing towards Debbie that she took Eminem and kept running away from Marshall out of fear, and that fear could have been what caused her to be a sh*tty mother from mental illness. With the letter that got sent back, Marshall could've kept moving without Debbie or Eminem knowing that someone else who lived at the address could've sent it back. It's a shame Eminem didn't have that one meeting with his dad before he died, it could've been a great closure for Eminem or more traumatizing, but Eminem seems healed from all of that nonsense he was raised in and instead has become a great father himself 🙏
One thing is clear tho, his dad left and never contacted him until he was famous,which is kinda obvious why, and was never present/involved in his son's life.
1:17 is hilarious to me. Like AI paraphrasing the real lyrics lol😂 “In the song, he wonders if his dad even gave him a kiss goodbye, but then later stating that he actually doesn’t care, and expresses a desire that Marshall would lose his life” “He split, I wonder if he even kissed me goodbye No I don’t, on second thought I just wish he would die” 😂😂😂
I didn’t meet my dad till later in life and as you can imagine my parents had different versions but honestly IDC who was telling the truth. Cause no one could keep me from my daughter. Eminem said it best in his song Headlights. “One thing I never asked was Where the fck my deadbeat dad was Fck it, I guess he had trouble keepin' up with every address But I'da flipped every mattress, every rock and desert cactus Owned a collection of maps And followed my kids to the edge of the atlas If someone ever moved 'em from me That you coulda bet your asses If I had to come down the chimney, dressed as Santa, kidnap 'em”
I think EMINEM's mother and father are both bad parents. But why did Marshall wait until his son was rich and famous to try and reconnect with him? Why didn't he try when EMINEM was eighteen? I smell a rat.
His dad can’t face what he did so he makes up his own reality of his trying to find his son and he lives in delusion. My dad was the same way and he blames my mom for not being in my life but he’s an idiot because I remember my mom on the phone begging him to show up as a dad. So please do not believe Eminem’s dad and I’m surprised you don’t have the insight to see that his dad is a LIAR
I don't think so. Have you listened to Leaving Heaven, which was released the year after Em's dad passed away? This song is full of anger and hatred toward his late dad.
Eminem never grew up and to this day he has psychological complexes. As a stan I feel bad for him, he should've given his dad chance to talk to him and explain. I bet he is regretting his decision to ghost his dad or maybe I'm wrong and Em is still maximalist kid.
Imo Em has grown a lot, especially after getting sober and not meeting his dad is his choice after all , which is understandable. But i agree that he has some sort of complexes
It's not easy having a shady past. We keep going. If it's Real, it always comes back. Choices and Actions are what make this the facts. Bottom Dollar "Family Matters" 🗻🗣️🫂 #eminem
![BULLY Doesn't Know POOR KID Is A RAP GOD [Inspired By Eminem] (PG-13) | Dhar Mann Studios](http://i.ytimg.com/vi/odIoBdfLaMs/mqdefault.jpg)
Yeah the whole "i kept thinking about eminem,and would do anything to see him,before he got famous" is bs. The dad,marshall,had other children after debbie "left".
Fr
she was 15... DAMN
..now everything makes more sense!
Right!? I never knew that.
Oooooó nice job R.f
Believe it or not it really wasnt that uncommon back in those days. The age of concent actually went up over the years so itd really not that crazy if you think about it.
It was not common. It was wrong then and wrong now.
@@blacknosugarnocreamnot really
Trust me Eminem has no regrets.
"Leaving Heaven" he HATES Marshall.
Facts
Eminem has a point in my opinion There was no Excuse to Leave your kids and Abandon Them If i Have Kids im gonna do anything and everything to stay in my kids life
Yes very true, even if Marshall bettered his life later on it’s still Eninem’s decision to get in contact with him. He wasn’t there for him when he needed him the most (as a child)
Now according to him, he did not abandon him, he returned home and Eminem with his mother were missing. This could be a lie, sure. But how can we trust his mother?
What do you think?
@@ferred3056 That we will never know for sure.
@@rik8556 Indeed
Please do. My dad abandoned me and my sister when we were small. It has done mental damage to us both, do what you can to keep your family together if you do have kids one day x
I believe the mother, just look at the age gap. If he was able to reply to Eminem 's letter that were supposedly sent back that means he had the address. If you truly wanted to see him at any point he could have popped up when school was letting out. It was the money and fam he was after.
Don’t blame Em not wanting to meet with his father whether he walked out or not he still didn’t try it contact him until he was famous
As his biological father, he would have had legal rights to see Eminem if he really wanted to. He could have gotten the police involved. If he was abusive it may have worked out for the best that he wasn't in Eminem's life.
Marshall left Em when he was 6 months old. Then Marshall said that his wife stopped him from seeing Em. There is no reason to stop seeing your kids if you and the mother split up. No reason whatsoever. Marshall is talking BS.
also, another fact, Em's mother Debbie was only 17 when She was giving birth to Eminem, it took 48 hours to the delivery of Eminem.
Em's father ain't the greatest
But Em is goddam legendary father
Just imagine Em's dad and Em had a photo together today, even though the story is sad, rest in peace Marshall Jr
TRYNA STRIKE A CHORD AND ITS PROBABLY A MINORRRRRRRRRRRR (to Eminem’s dad)
Bros dad is a pdf file
So your 15/16 year old baby mama fled with her baby? Even if that's true (which it probably isn't) then Debbie probably saw sense and fled. I'm amazed that Eminem got out of all that shit relatively unscathed, and raised daughters that he and Kim can be proud of. He truly broke the cycle, and I hope that he forgave his mother despite her nutty litigious moment.
I wanna say it sounds like they both are bad parents. But we don't know whats true. Eminem as a child has many thoughts going through his head and his feelings aren't wrong to what he went through and what he heard. Only God knows what happened. And since Marshall ii died in 2019 he had so much time trying to find Eminem and Nathan (eminem's little brother) Eminem has been a big deal since he came out and all the way to 2019 and Marshall had enough time. There was no "giving up" trying to find your kids as a father and grandfather.
Marshall is lying. Like Eminem said, if his dad wanted to find him nothing woulda stopped him.
his mom was 15?? Bro i would run away too
Wow that is surprising that the fact Debbie was only 15 years old and Eminem’s Dad was 22 and managed to get away with dating a minor & no jail time all these years later!!? Wtf 😬 Em’s dad sure got lucky I suppose but RIP to his only late dad though ❤ Wether they both had beef with each other or not I figured I would pay respects for MMJR. 😎🍻🍻🍻🙏🏾
The way I see this is that he knew where em was growing up he could have went out and found him regardless what his mom said he was old enough to make that choice
The fact that Eminem has mentioned many times what a sh*tty mother Debbie was, I wouldn't be surprised if she tried to stop Marshall from knowing his son after he abandoned them, he was basically already a pedophile for being 22 dating Debbie at 15 that he could've been more disturbing towards Debbie that she took Eminem and kept running away from Marshall out of fear, and that fear could have been what caused her to be a sh*tty mother from mental illness. With the letter that got sent back, Marshall could've kept moving without Debbie or Eminem knowing that someone else who lived at the address could've sent it back. It's a shame Eminem didn't have that one meeting with his dad before he died, it could've been a great closure for Eminem or more traumatizing, but Eminem seems healed from all of that nonsense he was raised in and instead has become a great father himself 🙏
Why'd he abandon Eminem like that 😢
Resonates 💗💗
I've always wondered this
Well im glad i could clarify 🎉
we will never know the truth tbh
One thing is clear tho, his dad left and never contacted him until he was famous,which is kinda obvious why, and was never present/involved in his son's life.
Em the great dad❤❤❤❤Mary from Greece❤
Usually it is somewhere in between. Not sure where in between but most of these kinds of disputes are somewhere in there
1:17 is hilarious to me. Like AI paraphrasing the real lyrics lol😂
“In the song, he wonders if his dad even gave him a kiss goodbye, but then later stating that he actually doesn’t care, and expresses a desire that Marshall would lose his life”
“He split, I wonder if he even kissed me goodbye
No I don’t, on second thought I just wish he would die”
😂😂😂
I swear that just how it was back in the day either the man left the woman or she took the kids n ditched the loser
Nope. That's not how it was.
I didn’t meet my dad till later in life and as you can imagine my parents had different versions but honestly IDC who was telling the truth. Cause no one could keep me from my daughter. Eminem said it best in his song Headlights.
“One thing I never asked was
Where the fck my deadbeat dad was
Fck it, I guess he had trouble keepin' up with every address
But I'da flipped every mattress, every rock and desert cactus
Owned a collection of maps
And followed my kids to the edge of the atlas
If someone ever moved 'em from me
That you coulda bet your asses
If I had to come down the chimney, dressed as Santa, kidnap 'em”
eminem would have down the chimney dressed as santa
underrated
Debbie has 3 different names and has died 3 times and has 2 different publics
I think EMINEM's mother and father are both bad parents. But why did Marshall wait until his son was rich and famous to try and reconnect with him? Why didn't he try when EMINEM was eighteen? I smell a rat.
Eminem is SO HOT!!! He is my celebrity crush!!! 😍
His dad can’t face what he did so he makes up his own reality of his trying to find his son and he lives in delusion. My dad was the same way and he blames my mom for not being in my life but he’s an idiot because I remember my mom on the phone begging him to show up as a dad. So please do not believe Eminem’s dad and I’m surprised you don’t have the insight to see that his dad is a LIAR
Wish I could drink some "Vitamin Ǝ" milk
To each there own
Theyre all telling there own truth and perception
Wrong.
They met each other and talked, why didn't you mention that?
They did?
@@thebearrrrrrrr no, they didn't
Ngl as far as i know they didnt really talk that much but i will do some research thanks for letting me know
Eminem tried to fix the relationship with his dad before he passed...
I don't think so. Have you listened to Leaving Heaven, which was released the year after Em's dad passed away? This song is full of anger and hatred toward his late dad.
Walter white?
29
Both parents are at fault his parents both suck ( my parents played the same games )
Well we all know women NEVER lie. So dad has to be the bad guy!
Money grab
Always 3 sides to every story
Speaking of Eminem, no offense but you look like a 2003 Eminem cosplaying as Post Malone
Eminem never grew up and to this day he has psychological complexes. As a stan I feel bad for him, he should've given his dad chance to talk to him and explain. I bet he is regretting his decision to ghost his dad or maybe I'm wrong and Em is still maximalist kid.
Imo Em has grown a lot, especially after getting sober and not meeting his dad is his choice after all , which is understandable. But i agree that he has some sort of complexes
LMFAO
It's not easy having a shady past. We keep going. If it's Real, it always comes back. Choices and Actions are what make this the facts. Bottom Dollar "Family Matters" 🗻🗣️🫂 #eminem