Come on Marshall! 😑 Stanmore III vs Woburn III vs Acton III Review [Sound Samples]

Поделиться
HTML-код
  • Опубликовано: 18 окт 2024

Комментарии • 103

  • @aaronloudnwireless
    @aaronloudnwireless  Год назад +8

    Whoops! 4:39 to 5:37 Images for Stanmore and Acton are inverted as pointed out by a viewer.

  • @maximilian_k.2453
    @maximilian_k.2453 Год назад +96

    Since you specifically asked, i think there is still a big market für "old school" speakers with no wifi connectability or other fancy gadgets. I much prefer the plain and solid, sound-cost prioritising model, rather then the fancy "have a thousand applications and tell you the weatherforcast" device. All it should do is play music as best as possible. Everything added is raising the price and the margin of error.

    • @avssify
      @avssify 10 месяцев назад +2

      I agree with you. This speaker is 50% in my country right now. And I can see why. What the hell is the point of it other than looking beautiful when there's so many great sounding speakers out there that can be played on battery and can connect into stereo

    • @ZeroZeroThirteen
      @ZeroZeroThirteen 10 месяцев назад +1

      On point, maximilian

    • @thennekcdcdthennek6417
      @thennekcdcdthennek6417 9 месяцев назад +1

      the market never revolves around you.

    • @maximilian_k.2453
      @maximilian_k.2453 9 месяцев назад +4

      @@thennekcdcdthennek6417 thanks, didn't expect such swift reply from our economics professional here

    • @kuriabraham
      @kuriabraham Месяц назад +2

      I tell you. How I miss the good old days and stereo sound!

  • @MrRyanchester
    @MrRyanchester Год назад +19

    So I had an original Stanmore I (one??) and I LOVED it for years. I moved and gave it to my mom and after a year and a half I treated myself to an Acton III in my new smaller apartment and all I can say is WOW… the Acton III is WILDLY impressive and to be honest for its size savings and cost savings I can’t imagine the Stanmore being worth it. I feel like the choice really boils down to Acton III or go all in on Woburn III. 2 generations later and I can TOTALLY hear the upgrades in sound quality!

    • @afrolintin
      @afrolintin 10 месяцев назад +2

      Does your moms stanmore you gave her still work? How old is it now? I want to get a marshall speaker, but want to make sure they will last

  • @SamSoulTrop
    @SamSoulTrop Год назад +22

    My choice was made between the woburn and the stanmore and I eventually didn't pick the woburn because it was a bit ovesized/priced for my intended use of a wireless speaker. And I definitely can tell the stanmore III sounds really great in my bedroom and helps me listening to my cds again through the RCA input. I'm just annoyed with the loss of bluetooth pairing that occurs when I don't use my pc after 10 minutes or so, forcing me to pair again, and the latency when watching a video. I think I'll keep the bluetooth for the smartphone, and plug the pc to the jack input.
    But yes, the Stanmore surely is the right choice for a bedroom!

    • @joan17258
      @joan17258 Год назад

      I had a Marshall 5 years ago and I have to returne it because the bluetooth problem. Still with the bluetooth 5,2 ?

  • @KlipschHead281
    @KlipschHead281 Год назад +17

    The Action and Stanmore sounded more compressed compared to the Woburn through my Klipsch HP-3 headphones, I agree the Stanmore and Action sounded very similar to each other. The Woburn sounds like a winner but for the money it should.

  • @oiccollector3935
    @oiccollector3935 10 месяцев назад +11

    constructive criticism: i wish there was no purple light (should have proper white balance) so people can appreciate the color and finish of the product.

  • @markhalstead2386
    @markhalstead2386 Год назад +8

    I have two Woburn IIIs as a stereo pair with an external Bluetooth dac going to the left and right speakers with a RCA splitter at each speaker. Both are volume matched and it sounds awesome.

    • @atish4523
      @atish4523 8 месяцев назад

      Woah!

    • @thefalliblebeliever3470
      @thefalliblebeliever3470 7 месяцев назад

      Can you run me through your setup

    • @markhalstead2386
      @markhalstead2386 7 месяцев назад +2

      @@thefalliblebeliever3470 An ifi Zen One dac with left RCA to left speaker and right RCA to right speaker. At both speakers is a single to dual RCA cable so the signal goes to both left and right of each speaker. I then volume matched both speakers and control overall volume with the dac.

  • @steveuk9162
    @steveuk9162 Год назад +8

    Quality review Aaron. Nice to hear you’ve noticed some improvement in the mids, it’s the one area Marshall speakers disappoint in previous models so fingers crossed they continue to improve. Keep up the great content 👍🏼

    • @aaronloudnwireless
      @aaronloudnwireless  Год назад

      Thanks!

    • @gamechanger114
      @gamechanger114 Год назад

      ​@@aaronloudnwireless Will you be reviewing the JBL Authentic 500? I'm curious of your thoughts on how you think it sounds, and how it compares to the Woburn 3.

  • @robertcorona3362
    @robertcorona3362 Год назад +6

    Woburn III is definitely the better sounding and clearer of the 3. The Acton and Stanmore sounded exactly alike to me. Will definitely be buying the Woburn III.

  • @Tanya_V
    @Tanya_V Год назад +8

    Woburn is hands down the best out of all 3, don't see a point smaller ones.

  • @Starch-Wreck
    @Starch-Wreck Год назад +6

    All of these in this video still sound exactly like the earbuds I’m listening to this on.

  • @carlw8072
    @carlw8072 9 месяцев назад +4

    I’ve got action 3 and Woburn 3 and obviously the Woburn is better but I won’t let my action 3 go because it really is good for the size and price, Stanmore is same as action but is a bit louder.

  • @JillScott-v9t
    @JillScott-v9t Год назад +2

    They are BT LE however , which makes it a first. This will allow for multi room set up. So I suspect Marshall are backing this option rather than wifi as a simplistic set up.

  • @covallrms
    @covallrms 9 месяцев назад +2

    Hì Aaron, thinking of getting a small speaker and want to know which is a better buy, the Acton 3 or Aura 4? Thanks

  • @chessee
    @chessee 10 месяцев назад +2

    Very useful thank you so much, helped me make a decision.

  • @kahpoh8795
    @kahpoh8795 Год назад +5

    At first, my choices were between Stanmore and Woburn. In terms of sound quality, Woburn definitely nailed it, but it's too big and bulky, and it doesn't really aesthetically fit in my room. Then I found out that Marshall has another model named Acton. I'm getting an Ikea Vittsjo shelf just like the one in the video 0:30 , both Stanmore and Acton fit perfectly on the shelf. Now my choices will be between Acton and Stanmore.

    • @sathira_anuk5179
      @sathira_anuk5179 9 месяцев назад +3

      What you ended up getting?

    • @kahpoh8795
      @kahpoh8795 9 месяцев назад

      i gt acton iii.@@sathira_anuk5179 stanmore is a little too big for my room

  • @tristanredding8640
    @tristanredding8640 Год назад +1

    The Stanmore isn’t to big isn’t to small, it’s the perfect fit if your not going with a killer volume and bass sound.

  • @joan17258
    @joan17258 Год назад +1

    Woburn II it has a brutal difference. between Action and stanmore , i only feel the base, but when you play Woburn, all the sound changes. I will go for this one.

  • @GOLFADDICT65
    @GOLFADDICT65 Год назад +1

    ..awesome review....ACTON 3 is currently 299 ( Canadian ) ... 215 ( US ) ......would you say thats a great deal and worth the money ? thx bud....cheers from Canada

    • @rf_wbg
      @rf_wbg 3 месяца назад

      Damn in india it's double that price 😢

  • @epicop9719
    @epicop9719 Год назад +2

    Thank you for this! So helpful 🙏

  • @AMPathi
    @AMPathi 2 месяца назад

    @Aaron X Loud and Wireless, Could you confirm what material is used on the speaker driver? Is it paper cone or Kevlar or any other material?
    Why does this information is not available even in Marshall site?

  • @codylawson8443
    @codylawson8443 Год назад +4

    Any idea where I can buy Woburn III? Or when Marshall will restock? I can’t seem to find them available anywhere

    • @TheSergio1021
      @TheSergio1021 Год назад

      You can sign up for a notification on their website. They're regularly out of stock

  • @karananubhav
    @karananubhav Год назад +1

    I have a Kilburn 2 portable speaker currently. And I am looking to stack up another Marshall speaker along with it to play songs on both the speakers. Can you help clarify which all Marshall speakers can be stacked together with Kilburn 2?

  • @Weyjx
    @Weyjx Год назад +1

    I just bought the Marshall action l l. Because liked the old school bass and treble control. Suits me fine.

    • @davidharvey4059
      @davidharvey4059 Год назад

      I have one of those in black
      It's by FAR the best speaker I've owned and plenty good enough for me, the high volume performance is fantastic

    • @AP-ci2vz
      @AP-ci2vz 5 месяцев назад

      I just bought the 3 today

  • @prodrivebrasil
    @prodrivebrasil Год назад +1

    Great review! Thank you!

  • @plainflavour
    @plainflavour 3 месяца назад

    You cant create a stereo system with these via bluetooth, but what about with physical cables?

  • @85amitray
    @85amitray 13 дней назад

    To me .. The primary objective of a speak is the sound system. Tech like wifi or mutimedia streaming etc are secondary.

  • @lalaha4241
    @lalaha4241 Год назад +1

    They all got LE audio built in - the next gen bluetooth protocoll a broader bandwith that is supposed to enhanc sound quality, let's see when phines or devices will be able to bradcast in throught that...

  • @MohitKumar-ri3yv
    @MohitKumar-ri3yv 9 месяцев назад

    In STANMORE 2, Below 50-60% volume, it sounds pretty low, and when changed to 70%, it use to get pretty loud. Is it the case?

  • @PixelPop_Officiel
    @PixelPop_Officiel Год назад +2

    Just for to be sure. Did you configure all the Marshall with the same bass and same trebble volume ?

  • @jitapriyadas9601
    @jitapriyadas9601 4 месяца назад

    Which one would you recommend to watch movies/living room speaker for a living room of 20 m2?

  • @trendbyswag
    @trendbyswag Год назад +2

    Great video.. with lots of details. thank you..

  • @joan17258
    @joan17258 Год назад

    i heard the sound of Marshall and i felt in love. I boutht one 4 years ago and i had to give it back after tree times trying to fix the bluetooth by garantee. In Amazon i cannot find the Woburn III, only the Woburn II. Wich is the difference between those two. And wich other brand do you reccomend better than woburn.

  • @rf_wbg
    @rf_wbg 3 месяца назад

    Whats the difference between these speakers and sound bars ? Somebody please explain. I just want to experience a good sound stage, not that much keen on bass but want the sound to be pure. Im thinking of marshell speakers or JBL sound bars - 500 pro, sonos beam 2, samsung sound bars ? Pls do help with your opinion.

  • @rodrigomoyano6346
    @rodrigomoyano6346 7 месяцев назад

    Compared with authentics 200? Wich wins?

  • @HansiesKanal
    @HansiesKanal 5 месяцев назад

    Even worse that all the Marshall III-line speakers does not have WiFi streaming, the Stanmore II does have great WiFi streaming support AND multi-room. Why would anyone REMOVE great features like that?? Makes no sense to me.
    Now I need to replace my two beloved Stanmore II, and there is nothing from Marshall that can do what these did 5 years ago!!
    Come on Marshall!! 😢😢😢😢😢😢😢😢😢

  • @barkhasirothia4848
    @barkhasirothia4848 Год назад +2

    Marshal acton 3 or Bose portable home speaker?

  • @sda6415
    @sda6415 11 месяцев назад

    Hi, thanks for the review, how do I know if my Woburn 3 is genuine if the serial numbers on the box and the app don't match?
    Please help

  • @DraganBB
    @DraganBB Год назад

    Which one should I buy, what do you recommend? I want to pair it with a Rega Planar 2 record player, I would listen mostly to hip hop, I like good and strong bass :), it would be placed in a room of 18m2

    • @Alex.R.O.P
      @Alex.R.O.P 7 месяцев назад

      I would get the woburn 3 no matter what.. The sub bass, mid range and tweeters are worth it and will make music sound the best..

  • @lygiahungg
    @lygiahungg Год назад +3

    Please compare the standmore 3 with the harmon kardon soundsticks 4. Thank you.

  • @trainspotteruk9291
    @trainspotteruk9291 9 месяцев назад

    is the acton 3 and Stanmore 3 the same sound

  • @ricardokohatsu5588
    @ricardokohatsu5588 Год назад +1

    Marshall Acton vs Stanmore are showed inverted in the video..(4:39 to 5:37)

  • @lukona_melento
    @lukona_melento Год назад

    Acton and Stanmore sounded similar. The Stanmore offers a little more base.

  • @vahekaramyan318
    @vahekaramyan318 Год назад

    So the stanmore 3 does not have multi room feature

  • @Milos596
    @Milos596 Год назад +5

    Stanmore is kinda disappointing comparing to other 2.

  • @zakbignami
    @zakbignami Год назад +1

    I saw the video and thank you but I have a question. I currently live mainly in an apartment. On low volume would you still recommend the Woburn or can I take the little ones? I really like the mids and in the Acton II they were very poor. Do you think Woburn is too much for an apartment?

    • @aaronloudnwireless
      @aaronloudnwireless  Год назад +1

      Definitely the Woburn.

    • @zakbignami
      @zakbignami Год назад

      @@aaronloudnwireless So would you still advise me to get an Acton or Stanmore for a small apartment, despite the poorer mids quality? :)

  • @deykno87
    @deykno87 Год назад +13

    Nothing sucks by Marshall it’s just all overpriced

    • @rae_halvi6392
      @rae_halvi6392 Год назад +3

      it's worth investing tho if you love listening to music.

  • @FilipGierszewski
    @FilipGierszewski Год назад +4

    Quite recently ... 3 months ago or so ... I asked Marshall support if they are planning to add AAC support to their speakers. They replied that there is no such plan at the moment.

    • @aaronloudnwireless
      @aaronloudnwireless  Год назад +1

      That's sad

    • @kuba7329
      @kuba7329 Год назад +2

      I'm using SBC codec instead of AAC through developer options on android and the sound to my ears is much better, less compressed and peaks cleaner.

    • @alokmurmu7682
      @alokmurmu7682 Год назад

      I think with LE audio this speaker support lc3 codec which is now not available

    • @somek1992
      @somek1992 9 месяцев назад

      ​@@alokmurmu7682 bro when they add this . What u Think? I need couple mode ...😢

  • @ДмитрийДашимолонов

    Woburn the best!

  • @dancorolevschi5244
    @dancorolevschi5244 Год назад +1

    good video

  • @mistermushroom652
    @mistermushroom652 Год назад

    what's the wattage of each?

  • @jblfan6603
    @jblfan6603 Месяц назад

    woburn 2 and middle ton is the best and ok on max vollume and for outside

  • @frozengamer3030
    @frozengamer3030 Год назад +1

    I recently bought the Acton III

    • @aaronloudnwireless
      @aaronloudnwireless  Год назад

      Good speaker! Better sound than expected.

    • @frozengamer3030
      @frozengamer3030 Год назад +2

      @@aaronloudnwireless You are right. I also have the Willen too

  • @seoyeonan7345
    @seoyeonan7345 Год назад +2

    on/off not hearing mashall sound?(drum sound)?

  • @Hub3rtus
    @Hub3rtus Год назад

    how about sounds from mac via bt on Woburn 3?

  • @vamsikrishnareddy6682
    @vamsikrishnareddy6682 Год назад +2

    Can u compare woburn 2 vs woburn 3

  • @danbasic
    @danbasic 5 месяцев назад

    Acton???

  • @mackomacko6126
    @mackomacko6126 Год назад

    Moja propozycja testu to Marshall tufton vs JBL party box 110

  • @kahpoh8795
    @kahpoh8795 Год назад

    4:36

  • @kristopherbell7158
    @kristopherbell7158 Год назад

    The stanmore seems not good for the money just listening off this... I mean for full price i could build a better sounding setup

  • @Vascodecaprio
    @Vascodecaprio 11 месяцев назад +1

    W😅o😅w😅

  • @fazalkmd
    @fazalkmd 3 месяца назад

    ✂️✂️✂️

  • @DiCarpio-yk9pd
    @DiCarpio-yk9pd 7 месяцев назад

    Dude is expecting sound of some high end stereo from a $300 broootooth speakers 🤣😆

  • @jamestanny849
    @jamestanny849 8 месяцев назад +1

    For anyone wondering it is a huge disappointment, "it fills the room" they say... it barely fills 30 Square meters.
    The bass is so bad it doesn't even make the leaf blow. Also the sound is so sharp even with treble at 0 some songs screams like nails on the chalkboard.
    This was the greatest disappointment of a speaker purchase in my life.
    Absolutely no doubt about that, I'm so disappointed by the performance of this (i would even call it a speaker) that I will stay as far from Marshall products as possible. I will never touch their products again.
    I purchased this product from a verified Marshall vendor too, brand new, $600.
    I've never purchased Marshals products before also, so I wouldn't say I had any bias towards them. This product definitely sucks, so I'll be returning it back tomorrow morning.
    This also makes me loose all my respect to these "RUclips partners channels" claiming it to be "the deal". What a joke, y'all must be paid and bought for by Marshall. Anyway, I'll never come back to any of these types of channels nor buy any marshall products ever again.
    I just hope for anyone caring to read this, please stay away from this garbage brand. I heard rumours that they were sold to someone else, maybe this is the reason they are now terrible? I don't know. I also can't say anything about the other models as I haven't tried them. However, for sure stay away from Wooburn III its a scam!

  • @ashishbarick
    @ashishbarick 7 месяцев назад

    you had less than 80k subscribers at the time you made this video. how could you afford all these gadgets?

  • @afsaruddin346
    @afsaruddin346 Год назад

    Im Bangladesh

  • @casto8134
    @casto8134 Год назад

    Español 😡