*NB: Please read our rules before commenting. Please alert us by emailing report@carteblanche.co.za should you see any comments or threads that contain the below: Racist and/or homophobic comments will not be tolerated and users will be banned immediately. 1. Hate speech, defamation & hostility inciting comments. 2. Harassing (incl. sexual), threatening, embarrassing, swearing at, or abusing of another participant. 3. Acting as employees of Carte Blanche. 4. Spam links or comments. 5. Crude or offensive language. Your privacy is important to us. Please do not share personal details in the comments as they will be removed for your safety.
Dear Carte Blanche… there’s much more to this story. As a vet working there often years ago… it’s a sad situation and I predicted this… maybe too late now
The Residents are too blame. You want to keep animals on a property that is not sufficient to support the animals that reside on the property,That’s the real cruelty. The Kruger park should remove the animals off the property and fence out Marloth Park. Regardless of red lines and where the meat goes. You have to look at the root of the problem . Bunny huggers and their inability to face the reality that if you fence in game you have to cull in order to stop the animals from starving to death. Marloth park cannot manage the wildlife nor the municipality. Wildlife should not be kept there.
@@Mary-JaneMoolman FYI I grew up in the Umbabat game reserve and still own there today. A real game reserve that is managed by real conservationists and wardens and falls under the APNR not some incompetent municipality. But your response is expected as the truth hurts.
This is a great opportunity to adapt, and learn. In Africa, that is a great learning curve and an opportunity for a unique development, people and nature living in perfect harmony.
The totally out of controll Sekelbos and other invasive plants in Marloth have destroyed the grazing as well. Its not only the overpopulated game . There is zero veld management.
The sekelbos will increase because of overgrazing. Overgrazing lays the ground bare and increases invasive plants and soil erosion. Basic veld management principles.
@@tshidisomoraka8861I don't think the people living there want to domesticate the animals, they feed them because there's no food, it's that or let them die of starvation and because of foot and mouth disease they can't be sent anywhere.
“The state does not create wealth, the state destroys it. The state can give you nothing, because it produces nothing. And when it attempts it, it does so poorly..” Javier Milei
3 points 1. Humans invaded the animals area without a gameplan for the future. 2. Well done for feeding. That won't stop breeding which will further escalate the problem. 3. The familiarity of the animals with humans is a potential for disaster.
"...clearly shows the rangers inexperience with a firearm. Instead of making the rifle safe immediately after the shot, the ranger reaches for his ears". It's almost certainly a bolt action rifle and more than likely only loaded with 1 round. In a built up area where consideration about backstops (should the bullet pass through or the shooter miss) make a quick second shot unwise should the animal run off, a single round in the rifle would probably be preferred. I can't see the bolt being worked after the shot to eject the case so it probably is a rifle with a spent case in only, which is not "unsafe" in the literal meaning of the word. Yes, the shooter probably should have had ear protection on and one could maybe suggest inexperience outside of a gun range, as you generally only make that mistake once. However your point is more a suggestion of safety which you fail to establish. In a hunting reserve with healthy animals, you would have more than 1 round loaded in the mag and even with the animal down, you would not fully clear the weapon until confirming the animal is dead. That side on shot going for the heart/lungs is not always instantanious termination. The non-shooter was still walking up to likely check when the clip ends. You appear a bit premature in your timings on when to "make safe", which is at times, like this, a double checking concept of gun safety rather than a suggestion that the rifle was unsafe before being "made safe".
Animals always have to suffer because of the greed of mankind. You can’t interfere with the ecosystem , there is clearly a balance issue here , there are no predators to maintain the balance . Humans are the problem . Not the wildlife . Take responsibility !
Some people are greedy, they don't want to share with animals. If we don't speak out about this kind of people, these animals will become extinct. Here in SA, just because animals can't talk, they're "bullied"
Any game farmer will be able to assist. Game management through informed culling might offend those who place their feelings above the welfare of animals, however if there is no natural predators, it is kindness.
When I saw the food(is it pellets) being delivered in sealed bags I got a sense of another fat tenderpreneur overcharging for that and getting fatter. This could have been a reason why they made the municipality to manage the place. 💔
Is the next video on the Mjejane lions that have been moved to the North of Kruger? Previous lions that were moved from the South to the North of Kruger were poisoned and snared within three months. So why did these lions get moved, and why is SanParks not answering our questions?
WE ARE ALL BIG GROWIN UP PEOPLE AND CAN MAKE A RIGHT DESITION . FO THE RIGHT THING DO NOT BUILD HOUSES WHERE OUR BEATUFULL ANIMALS BELONG. SHAME ON YOU
When Rhinoes are in decline we usually move animals between parks, these animals can also be moved across parks in habitats they are well suited for. No need for culling.
I think Public participation process was done or done correctly subsequently its questionable how the residents got Environmental Authorization to turn a nature reserve into a residential site.
This is a very sad & sorry state of affairs. Unfortunately housing developments will take place everywhere in SA. These poor animals are part of our heritage & should be treated as such & obviously sustainability is very important. Why not chip these animals, screen them for diseases & rehome the healthy wildlife? It is unacceptable that we as a South African people & in particular our government either do not have the proper knowledge or the desired will to handle any kind of crisis...human or otherwise.
@@dirkrenierswart6947 telescopes are not set to shoot at 10meters. The telescope is higher than the barrel and most of the time set for the sight and bullet to intersect at 100meters. This can definitely cause the bullet to hit way lower than the spot where he aimed, wounding the animal and it running away.
That ship has sailed. I stayed in Marloth Park a couple of years ago and the animals are basically like pets now. They came right up to the verandah looking for food.
@@Natalie-em5pn very true and I agree with that 100% but life can be circumstantial and circumstances change. Also, if they can sell game meat in spar for profit they can feed local communities. There's absolutely no reason for human beings to starve when the food is readily available
Some of them are migrating animals but their movement is monitored and it makes it difficult for them to get to their food,i don't think he's right by saying the animals would have died if they weren't there....stand to be corrected
@@CaseyWiggin Likewise Casey , I agree on that one , to an extend . There's much more worries in this country , as stealing from our own people etc , and so much more , but let me see the positive in life otherwise i seems like a politician
I think you guys are running out of content.What do you expect when you live in the bush?.... This is normal all over the world if decide to live close to animals.
Don’t call them Wild animals anymore, they are no different to my goats, sheep, horses and donkeys at home… nothing wild about them, they are fed like pets mos 🤷🏽♂️🤷🏽♂️
![Blox Fruits Dragon Rework Update [Full Stream]](http://i.ytimg.com/vi/EqDAp8udhm0/mqdefault.jpg)
*NB: Please read our rules before commenting.
Please alert us by emailing report@carteblanche.co.za should you see any comments or threads that contain the below:
Racist and/or homophobic comments will not be tolerated and users will be banned immediately.
1. Hate speech, defamation & hostility inciting comments.
2. Harassing (incl. sexual), threatening, embarrassing, swearing at, or abusing of another participant.
3. Acting as employees of Carte Blanche.
4. Spam links or comments.
5. Crude or offensive language.
Your privacy is important to us. Please do not share personal details in the comments as they will be removed for your safety.
Is there anything left in SA thats not been broken? Just so very heartbreaking .
public employers have no right to privacy under duty. You ca video them
You dont know how happy i am to see people in my career on the show. Caring for the environment is a heavy and lengthy task to carryout. ❤
The animals have nowhere to go because the people invaded their space,they built houses and left these animals with no grazing land
I am shocked that they are surprised by this.
The only solution is for humans to move so that the animals can have a place to stay😢😢
Dear Carte Blanche… there’s much more to this story. As a vet working there often years ago… it’s a sad situation and I predicted this… maybe too late now
Please share what you mean by so much more? I'm so interested in this since there is an interest in a similar setup in the EC.
It's more like ..Humans on the Kudu's stoep
They gotta give this to qualified and experienced people.
i don't understand why the ratespayers association just appoints a PH to do it
Thank you for keeping us in the loop. I hope there will be a resolve soon.
The Residents are too blame. You want to keep animals on a property that is not sufficient to support the animals that reside on the property,That’s the real cruelty. The Kruger park should remove the animals off the property and fence out Marloth Park. Regardless of red lines and where the meat goes. You have to look at the root of the problem . Bunny huggers and their inability to face the reality that if you fence in game you have to cull in order to stop the animals from starving to death. Marloth park cannot manage the wildlife nor the municipality. Wildlife should not be kept there.
@@marcderover9802 Up yours, you don not know what you are talkingabbout
@@Mary-JaneMoolman FYI I grew up in the Umbabat game reserve and still own there today. A real game reserve that is managed by real conservationists and wardens and falls under the APNR not some incompetent municipality. But your response is expected as the truth hurts.
This is a great opportunity to adapt, and learn. In Africa, that is a great learning curve and an opportunity for a unique development, people and nature living in perfect harmony.
This is heartbreaking 💔
Only in SA... Both humans and animals beg for food on the road side. Surely this is a sign that things must change now.
@@irlonconstantine8793 deep
And pigs are fed humans.
love it
you got a point
The consequences of BEE, even the wild lives are feeling the pinch
The totally out of controll Sekelbos and other invasive plants in Marloth have destroyed the grazing as well.
Its not only the overpopulated game .
There is zero veld management.
The sekelbos will increase because of overgrazing. Overgrazing lays the ground bare and increases invasive plants and soil erosion.
Basic veld management principles.
Why do you want to domesticate wild animals?
@@tshidisomoraka8861I don't think the people living there want to domesticate the animals, they feed them because there's no food, it's that or let them die of starvation and because of foot and mouth disease they can't be sent anywhere.
“The state does not create wealth, the state destroys it. The state can give you nothing, because it produces nothing. And when it attempts it, it does so poorly..” Javier Milei
3 points
1. Humans invaded the animals area without a gameplan for the future.
2. Well done for feeding. That won't stop breeding which will further escalate the problem.
3. The familiarity of the animals with humans is a potential for disaster.
Exactly, why domesticate wild animals?
2. sounds like the same problem with humans?
It’s a disastrous situation. It’s unfortunately the only way to manage it fir the residents
So if I buy a farm without any game on it, can I come to Marloth Park with a big trailer and load up some kudu and bwb?
"...clearly shows the rangers inexperience with a firearm. Instead of making the rifle safe immediately after the shot, the ranger reaches for his ears". It's almost certainly a bolt action rifle and more than likely only loaded with 1 round. In a built up area where consideration about backstops (should the bullet pass through or the shooter miss) make a quick second shot unwise should the animal run off, a single round in the rifle would probably be preferred. I can't see the bolt being worked after the shot to eject the case so it probably is a rifle with a spent case in only, which is not "unsafe" in the literal meaning of the word. Yes, the shooter probably should have had ear protection on and one could maybe suggest inexperience outside of a gun range, as you generally only make that mistake once. However your point is more a suggestion of safety which you fail to establish. In a hunting reserve with healthy animals, you would have more than 1 round loaded in the mag and even with the animal down, you would not fully clear the weapon until confirming the animal is dead. That side on shot going for the heart/lungs is not always instantanious termination. The non-shooter was still walking up to likely check when the clip ends. You appear a bit premature in your timings on when to "make safe", which is at times, like this, a double checking concept of gun safety rather than a suggestion that the rifle was unsafe before being "made safe".
The residents should do the necessary to render the situation sustainable. Feeding is a stop gap, not a solution.
Prof Rylie my former lecture at tut well experienced in conversation
Meanwhile in Namibia...a town named oranjemund there are no such problems wildlife and humans can live together...
Animals always have to suffer because of the greed of mankind. You can’t interfere with the ecosystem , there is clearly a balance issue here , there are no predators to maintain the balance . Humans are the problem . Not the wildlife . Take responsibility !
What did you expect to happen when you went and built in their backyard? 🤷🏾♂️
Some people are greedy, they don't want to share with animals. If we don't speak out about this kind of people, these animals will become extinct. Here in SA, just because animals can't talk, they're "bullied"
They colonize everything soon they'll claim ownership of those animals.
One thing though, that was a bolt action rifle, it was not loaded after he shot the wildebeest, because he did not reload it
The animals have nowhere to go. People invaded their space.
Any game farmer will be able to assist. Game management through informed culling might offend those who place their feelings above the welfare of animals, however if there is no natural predators, it is kindness.
When I saw the food(is it pellets) being delivered in sealed bags I got a sense of another fat tenderpreneur overcharging for that and getting fatter. This could have been a reason why they made the municipality to manage the place. 💔
Is the next video on the Mjejane lions that have been moved to the North of Kruger? Previous lions that were moved from the South to the North of Kruger were poisoned and snared within three months. So why did these lions get moved, and why is SanParks not answering our questions?
What are they doing in the centre of the wild in the first place.
WE ARE ALL BIG GROWIN UP PEOPLE AND CAN MAKE A RIGHT DESITION . FO THE RIGHT THING DO NOT BUILD HOUSES WHERE OUR BEATUFULL ANIMALS BELONG. SHAME ON YOU
Surely there are some private reserves close that would accept some of the animals.....
not if there is a drought plus you have to pay for the capture and transport.
Oranjemund in Namibia our people and animals specific Oryx live with hamorny in Henties bay jackals live like dogs.
residents must pay for the food, since those house have such a high value !
You are mistaken. Money hunters with huge properties yes
When Rhinoes are in decline we usually move animals between parks, these animals can also be moved across parks in habitats they are well suited for. No need for culling.
Humans generally damage everything they touch
They don't care about animals.Why did they build houses there in the first place😢
I think Public participation process was done or done correctly subsequently its questionable how the residents got Environmental Authorization to turn a nature reserve into a residential site.
This will keep happening cos first nation people are still not being recognized. Poor animals miss proper care by the owners of this soil.
Definitely cull or introduce predators but that’s tricky with tourists
@@matthewlee4193 my guy it's an estate they can't introduce predators
@@boiells4191 😂😂😂I rode a bicycle around here once, it would be wild if I ran into lion.
they already have predators - the staff.
Some animals are not meant to be kept as pets that's y their facing this problem
This is a very sad & sorry state of affairs. Unfortunately housing developments will take place everywhere in SA. These poor animals are part of our heritage & should be treated as such & obviously sustainability is very important. Why not chip these animals, screen them for diseases & rehome the healthy wildlife? It is unacceptable that we as a South African people & in particular our government either do not have the proper knowledge or the desired will to handle any kind of crisis...human or otherwise.
BEE at work again!
So so SAD!😢
Cruelty to animals because they don't have enough to eat
Marloth Mafia did this
10 mtrs from the buck, dead rest on the braai and telescope, and he misses. Must be ex MK
@@dirkrenierswart6947 telescopes are not set to shoot at 10meters. The telescope is higher than the barrel and most of the time set for the sight and bullet to intersect at 100meters. This can definitely cause the bullet to hit way lower than the spot where he aimed, wounding the animal and it running away.
@@MR555SNAKE555 Im aware of that, but more importantly, the shooter, should know that too
@@MR555SNAKE555 only the distance between the center of the bore and the center of the scope which is about 40mm?
Sad. Our species and so called interventions.
And you can't feed them because then they get reliant on humans
That ship has sailed. I stayed in Marloth Park a couple of years ago and the animals are basically like pets now. They came right up to the verandah looking for food.
😂 well done da rangers 👏 viva da comrades viva eeeyes!..
Yes, nice idea but why are you there (residents)??? What did you think was going to happen??
still enyoying the Proceeds
Feed the South African people who are starving and dying of hunger!
@@Natalie-em5pn very true and I agree with that 100% but life can be circumstantial and circumstances change. Also, if they can sell game meat in spar for profit they can feed local communities. There's absolutely no reason for human beings to starve when the food is readily available
They poach enough as it is…
True ,these 'extra' animals can become food
@@DesmondVEVO we suffer now under the ANC regime mismanagement of this country 🤦
@@ErnestGouws We've suffered under all regimes.
8000 / 450 homes = 17.77 per moth per residence
Could some of the game be moved to other game parks in SA.
But they chose to live there!
Are the kids living there going to school? Surely education will help bring solutions
Send some of the animals to other game farms; Shamwari; Addo etc.
Risk of disease
😢
Some of them are migrating animals but their movement is monitored and it makes it difficult for them to get to their food,i don't think he's right by saying the
animals would have died if they weren't there....stand to be corrected
The animals space has been invaded and why can’t they just relocate the animals into the Kruger in batches or can’t they just farm Lucerne and feed
Where the lions at?
Can i come take a kudu or two once in a while...just to help the situation😎 I love venison
Marloth needs some elephants
This is só sad!!
It's not under sanparks and it's not private owned so who is actually response
It's easy,just get professional game cullers to do it.
This is so sad
Casey , don' t always believe what you see is true , what you see my seems so , but this ppl can take things out of preportion😢
@@rudismit4773I believe it is true to an extent - it is still sad
@@CaseyWiggin
Likewise Casey , I agree on that one , to an extend . There's much more worries in this country , as stealing from our own people etc , and so much more , but let me see the positive in life otherwise i seems like a politician
Introduce Non ammunition based hunting measures.
Bows and trapping and well as utilising the Lionspruit nature reserve idea is perfect.
Mmhh nice life problems for a certain group in SA
Yebo, only white rhinos, no black rhinos. What a disgrace, siesa!!
Meaning?????
Disgusting. 😢
Stunning lady in red. Absolutely gorgeous.
Sell them to game farms
I think you guys are running out of content.What do you expect when you live in the bush?....
This is normal all over the world if decide to live close to animals.
starving to death how disgusting
How do you complain but you have free meat?!but mara what must happen, 'human' killing???
Only in Africa 😏
Is it nature or human problem
Human problem
Don’t call them Wild animals anymore, they are no different to my goats, sheep, horses and donkeys at home… nothing wild about them, they are fed like pets mos 🤷🏽♂️🤷🏽♂️
I would like to hear a slayer or pan-Africanists' opinion on this since they so vocal about land.
Human beings should stay away from wild animals we have enough land for humans as it is problem is some don't want to share the land.
Cull
These guys can't shoot 😂
Really can't😂
Haha..kry vir julle..Marloff..rykmans plek..natuur gone!!
😂😅
Jy te arm of wat
Dit is n skande!!
@@JacoKrige
Vrek erg , as dit so is. Is dit maar so
Keep your comment to yourself if you do not know what you talking about
This vision was never an ANC vision
Thats why it will fail
There i said it as a 🇿🇲🇿🇲🇿🇲