Now imagine this alright. Imagine if Darth Vader was never teased or shown in the movie, and were sitting in our seats wondering what’s going to happen, then we see this seen... it would have been so much damn better.
Man anakin's dark deeds is such an amazing theme. Really adds that tension and intensity to a scene, clone wars was a great example when they used it for order 66
Much better than the original mate, and timed perfectly. Anakin's Dark Deeds should be his main theme in my opinion. It's really powerful and fits his tragic character a lot more.
Well, that's difficult to say. Dark deeds is Anakin his theme when he tragicaly transitioned to the dark side. However Darth vader is not Anakin he killed him (according to vader himself) Which is why the theme could not be used by williams because its someone else's theme.
Technically, Vader making Anakin into another person was his way of coping with doing all these bad deeds. Therefore he says he killed his good side. But yeah I see what you mean.
I personally like the "hope" theme (the original music) for this scene, it transmists more despair, and also that theme has Vader's theme in it (during the corridor secquence, camouflaged in), for me it's a better fit.
The original is good, but if they've used this music instead, at 0:00 I would immediately be in state of alert in the cinema watching this for the first time, knowing some serious shit involving vader would happen. Then at 0:48 I'd simply start to cry
This should be Vader theme, Dark,Powerful and tragic like his persona This is the way Vader should be in every media, An unstoppable and full of hate force of nature a freaking creature that strike fear in someone heart and remind you that: "There is no escape" Darth Vader
Good job, I think if you would have emphasized the “Open Fire!” And “Help Us!!” Lines alittle more it would have helped blend it alittle more and give it an overall better sound. This was still cool to see and hear tho!
I feel like the rebels firing out of fear and impulse as soon as Vader turns his lightsaber on as being more fitting. should have left the line out in the original movie.
@@dilung4250 I'd say them being paralyzed with fear until someone screams to open fire is much more interesting. It showcases how rare and terrifying of a sight Vader was much better than them just opening fire as soon as they see him, which would be a more appropriate reaction for seeing an imperial soldier.
Imagine Vader in his Anakin form having a scene like this in the 2025 remaster of Revenge of the Sith. Where you see him a similar hallway in the Jedi Temple, killing all of those younglings....
This proves how invaluable the original John Williams’s soundtrack is. The dark and boring rogue one has become alive and emotional. Actually this scene alone is literally the best scene in the whole movie.
I’ve seen other versions of this that utilize the entire Anakin’s dark deeds but the brief tease you have and then have it flow into “I’m so sorry” was perfect. Always leave the viewer wanting more
This is a really powerful edit. It completely changes the feel of the scene. It's like you changed it from the rebels' perspective to Vader's perspective just by swapping out the music!
Magnificent.. just magnificent.. I wish they had used this track in the actual movie and timed it perfectly like the way it's been done here. Wish this was the Canon version, only true fans and creative artists like this can make something so excellent.. don't misunderstand.. I loved Rogue One.. but this version with Vader's entrance in combat.. just awesome. Well done 👏👍
I love how Star Wars has really been emphasized lately on how much of an actual force of nature Vader/Anakin was. Clone Wars S7 seeing how he effortlessly treats droid armies that he was fearful and wary of at the start of the series. Rogue One and Fallen Order where he literally feels less like a person and instead like an unstoppable force constantly moving towards you no matter how good you think you are or what you throw at him. Like he’s a spirit or something in a horror movie that WILL kill you if it gets ahold of you but that you can’t physically harm no matter what you do so you just keep running. Sort of like the Terminator in the first movie. This soulless, emotionless machine skeleton that just looks like a man and is always pursuing you no matter what you do. No matter if you need to stop and rest. He’s still coming for you and you are not going to beat him in a fight. Lol like not you have the smallest chance of beating him. That if you give it everything you’ve got, if you fight him without any tricks he WILL kill you😅. That’s how I want him to feel and I’m glad we’ve been getting that more often when they go back to Vader.
Ignore the haters man , they’re low life trash people who probably can’t even use a computer let alone do an edit like this? I really like it man keep things like this up bro! I appreciate you 🙌
IVN Dude stfu, imagine getting this worked up that someone took their time on this, and that it wasn’t good enough for you. If you hate it so much make it yourself lmao, it’s like you’re criticizing an artist for not making art that appeals to your specific criteria. What a child. Get off of the internet edgelord.
What I remember about the rise of the Empire is.... how quiet it was.During the waning hours of the Clone Wars, the 501st was discreetly transferred back to Coruscant. It was a silent trip; We all knew what was about to happen, what we were about to do. Did we have any doubts? Any private traitorous thoughts? Perhaps, but no one said a word. Not on the flight to Coruscant, not when Order 66 came down, and not when we marched into the Jedi Temple. Not a word.
I wish this was in the movie... There's no point in hiding from the audience that a Vader scene is coming up and plot is ending at this point in the movie. Might as well prepare the audience for what's to come rather than surprising them last second
God, I love the stillness of the audio editing, how you can't hear the rebels talking. I know it probably wasn't intended for any reason other than replacing the music, but it works so fucking well. The frantic nature of the mission feels so real and everything feels as tunneled as that hallway.
Now that Andor Season 1 has been out for a while, I really think that the entirety of Rogue One needs to be re-edited or at least re-scored. Michael Giacchino is a talented composer, but he was rushed and tried too hard to make Rogue One sound like regular Star Wars without being regular Star Wars, and the sousdtrack just falls a bit flat overall. Nicholas Britell did such an amazing job with scoring the first season of Andor, because he was given the time he needed to create something that fit the show and didn't need to sound like John Williams. I think Rogue One would benefit from a fresh score that does a good job of bridging the gap between the Nicholas Britell and John Williams scores. 😊
Idk. I loved this scene and the music with the Imperial March is so good. However, the end of Anakin’s Dark Deeds gets me every single time. Going from the F to the E’s and back to the F’s for the strings is just one of the best sequences in music. I wish that they would use it more in the films, like when Luke is revealed to be a holo on Crait.
They really need to use more themes other than the force theme. Which they don’t know when it’s appropriate to use it. Like it should not be playing when some guys are getting blown tf up
Damn its cool, idk if it works with the tone of the scene they were going for, but it really makes me want a vader stand alone, with that music in the background
The first bit of the hallway didn't really do it for me on the music side of the house, but 1:16 onward just kills dude. Slightly muffled voices and everything. A cacophony of chaos, just how it'd actually be
The impreals worked for the Sith. The Stormtroopers will always be weak to the Sith. Escaping from the Sith isn't never easy. That ship was attacked in episode 4 1:36
If this was the only scene that had Darth Vader and they used this soundtrack it would’ve been worth it! Not seeing him the entire film and then his soundtrack and followed by his iconic hallway entrance
It changes the mood completely, but I don't like it that much. Not because it's bad, but because the anxiety turns down a lot. It seems like a sad scene instead of a terrifying one. As much as Anakin is a tragic figure, we must see him as Vader in this as in every scene from the original trilogy and in rebels, a figure that everyone fears at the sight of it. The original score gives us that, a chill running down our spines at the sight of this cyborg filled with anger whom is set to kill anyone who's on his way without mercy, and on the other hand we have fear and desperation from all the rebels trying to save their own lives even though they know they don't stand a chance, they know they will die in that corridor. Anakin's dark deeds does not inspire that feeling, it keeps the mood of the fallen Jedi that is still trying to save his wife, a man who fell trying to do good and ended up doing the worst... Now there's only hatred and pain. That's why the original score fits the scene better. We're not seeing a fallen warrior, we're seeing a death machine.
The music really does change this scene. It was nice before, but hearing the same score that played while he slaughtered the separatists is just so much more impactful.
Now imagine this alright. Imagine if Darth Vader was never teased or shown in the movie, and were sitting in our seats wondering what’s going to happen, then we see this seen... it would have been so much damn better.
Well, not shown on the Star Destroyer. I'd have kept the scene on Mustifar.
Imagine if this was how Darth Vader was introduced in Episode IV. That would've been crazy.
Yeah, that would have been extra crazy if he just showed up!
@@kenthefele113 dude. It would make everyone freak at how good of a villain he would be
@@kenthefele113no it wouldn't have, you just don't understand the importance of Vader's introduction
I love how Vader breaths before attacking it shows how dangerous he can be. If only padme could see what he has become.
She'll probarly die of a broken heart. Twice.
@@aiosquadron i agree
@@aiosquadron Padme: Ok nvm I'll die again
@@rollerjumps And probarly redeem Vader in the process. Probarly.
Commander Cody , the time has come , execute like 66
I was like 66 BTW
I heard that Maul did the same thing but without a lightsaber!
Wasn't nearly as cool as Vaders though
@@joemama-ib2lh honestly, I think it was
@@irrelevanterr I know its your opinion but fuck you
See I feel like Vader isn’t even trying tho
casual commenter lol
You did great brother! It certainly changes how the scene feels overall by a large amount, thank you for sharing this.
Thank you, sir!
@@AaronMosmeyer no, thank you my lord.
@Ivan D no one gives af about your opinion
Dude imagine having this in the movie
@IVN N I G G A
IVN Fine, it's your opinion but at least the creator thought it was good, just let him do his thing and let us like it if we do
@IVN so you're gonna respond to every comment like that? Stop using reddit you fat greaseball and get off the Internet
@IVN just laughing at your pathetic life 😂
@IVN what is your problem? Why are you ruining it for everyone here??
Man anakin's dark deeds is such an amazing theme. Really adds that tension and intensity to a scene, clone wars was a great example when they used it for order 66
The original music expresses what one would feel as an external viewer, this music expresses what Vader himself feels inside as he does this.
Much better than the original mate, and timed perfectly.
Anakin's Dark Deeds should be his main theme in my opinion. It's really powerful and fits his tragic character a lot more.
Well, that's difficult to say. Dark deeds is Anakin his theme when he tragicaly transitioned to the dark side. However Darth vader is not Anakin he killed him (according to vader himself) Which is why the theme could not be used by williams because its someone else's theme.
Technically, Vader making Anakin into another person was his way of coping with doing all these bad deeds. Therefore he says he killed his good side. But yeah I see what you mean.
ZABBAS I agree...Anakin’s Dark Deeds is a perfect score/theme for Darth Vader.
I personally like the "hope" theme (the original music) for this scene, it transmists more despair, and also that theme has Vader's theme in it (during the corridor secquence, camouflaged in), for me it's a better fit.
No original was much better
The original is good, but if they've used this music instead, at 0:00 I would immediately be in state of alert in the cinema watching this for the first time, knowing some serious shit involving vader would happen. Then at 0:48 I'd simply start to cry
This is good, but the SFX and voices felt off a bit.
Had to add in all new sound effects. They're not from the movie.
@IVN boooooo 🍅🍅🍅
@IVN and nobody asked for your opinion
IVN what? Lol
@IVN
And you badly need to shut up
This should be Vader theme,
Dark,Powerful and tragic like his persona
This is the way Vader should be in every media,
An unstoppable and full of hate force of nature a freaking creature that strike fear in someone heart and remind you that:
"There is no escape"
Darth Vader
I think this music fits better because of the tense-ness of it. At the end it emphasizes the defeat vader suffered because of the plans being lost.
Seriously just imagine being in the theatre if this was the music. My pants would be entirely soiled... and that’s okay
Good job, I think if you would have emphasized the “Open Fire!” And “Help Us!!” Lines alittle more it would have helped blend it alittle more and give it an overall better sound. This was still cool to see and hear tho!
Guess it was just difficult to get that audio!
I feel like the rebels firing out of fear and impulse as soon as Vader turns his lightsaber on as being more fitting. should have left the line out in the original movie.
@@dilung4250 I'd say them being paralyzed with fear until someone screams to open fire is much more interesting. It showcases how rare and terrifying of a sight Vader was much better than them just opening fire as soon as they see him, which would be a more appropriate reaction for seeing an imperial soldier.
"You have failed me Inquisitor."
Imagine Vader in his Anakin form having a scene like this in the 2025 remaster of Revenge of the Sith. Where you see him a similar hallway in the Jedi Temple, killing all of those younglings....
🙁
That's messed up.
@@Xominus I know right!
Imagine Padme walking into the room full of dead younglings... then you hear Darth Vader's theme.😃😁😁😁😁
After fallen order every shocking Vader appearance needs dark deeds
Please someone tell me I wasn’t the only one who realised he added Lego Star Wars death sounds into this 😂
I heard it as well it is..humorous
Beautifully done nice
This proves how invaluable the original John Williams’s soundtrack is. The dark and boring rogue one has become alive and emotional. Actually this scene alone is literally the best scene in the whole movie.
Thanks! Rogue One has a few good scores, but none hold a candle to Williams!
You’re high bro lmfao
Boring?
The soundtrack was great idk what ur talking about. Although I have to agree that John Williams score will always be the best.
bro what do you mean it’s invaluable, what would Star Wars be without it
Brother.This scene is way better with this song
The 'I'm so sorry' little part always hits hard
Was just thinking about how great it would be if the “Dark Deeds” music was put over this scene, and then I found this. Thanks!
This makes the whole scene eerie....like in fallen order. Fukn love it.
I’ve seen other versions of this that utilize the entire Anakin’s dark deeds but the brief tease you have and then have it flow into “I’m so sorry” was perfect. Always leave the viewer wanting more
You really made this scene feel darker.
This is a really powerful edit. It completely changes the feel of the scene. It's like you changed it from the rebels' perspective to Vader's perspective just by swapping out the music!
This is incredible. I don't know how they didn't use this originally.
I need to say. I really like Rouge One and that original scene was really cool but now i love it
This music really changed how I feel about this scene
Not bad bro 👍
Magnificent.. just magnificent.. I wish they had used this track in the actual movie and timed it perfectly like the way it's been done here. Wish this was the Canon version, only true fans and creative artists like this can make something so excellent.. don't misunderstand.. I loved Rogue One.. but this version with Vader's entrance in combat.. just awesome. Well done 👏👍
I love how Star Wars has really been emphasized lately on how much of an actual force of nature Vader/Anakin was. Clone Wars S7 seeing how he effortlessly treats droid armies that he was fearful and wary of at the start of the series. Rogue One and Fallen Order where he literally feels less like a person and instead like an unstoppable force constantly moving towards you no matter how good you think you are or what you throw at him. Like he’s a spirit or something in a horror movie that WILL kill you if it gets ahold of you but that you can’t physically harm no matter what you do so you just keep running.
Sort of like the Terminator in the first movie. This soulless, emotionless machine skeleton that just looks like a man and is always pursuing you no matter what you do. No matter if you need to stop and rest. He’s still coming for you and you are not going to beat him in a fight. Lol like not you have the smallest chance of beating him. That if you give it everything you’ve got, if you fight him without any tricks he WILL kill you😅. That’s how I want him to feel and I’m glad we’ve been getting that more often when they go back to Vader.
Bro, this is EPIC
Ignore the haters man , they’re low life trash people who probably can’t even use a computer let alone do an edit like this? I really like it man keep things like this up bro! I appreciate you 🙌
@IVN It's much better than what you did 🤷♂️
Thanks for the positivity brother, we need more people like you!
@IVN Bitch you got nothing to prove
@IVN Says you 😂😂
IVN
Dude stfu, imagine getting this worked up that someone took their time on this, and that it wasn’t good enough for you. If you hate it so much make it yourself lmao, it’s like you’re criticizing an artist for not making art that appeals to your specific criteria. What a child. Get off of the internet edgelord.
Fuccing....amazing
What I remember about the rise of the Empire is.... how quiet it was.During the waning hours of the Clone Wars, the 501st was discreetly transferred back to Coruscant. It was a silent trip; We all knew what was about to happen, what we were about to do. Did we have any doubts? Any private traitorous thoughts? Perhaps, but no one said a word. Not on the flight to Coruscant, not when Order 66 came down, and not when we marched into the Jedi Temple. Not a word.
The real Battlefront 2.
1:17 now where have I heard that before in the same episode as a scene just like this
Jedi fallen order or revenge of the sith
@@benman92 or clone wars episode shattered
@@plutovr5192 true.
The clone wars season 7 episode 11: shattered when rex and the 501st/322nd turn against ahsoka
i love this one way more
I wish this was in the movie... There's no point in hiding from the audience that a Vader scene is coming up and plot is ending at this point in the movie. Might as well prepare the audience for what's to come rather than surprising them last second
This is actually surprisingly better than the film’s version.
Those extra screams made it 20x better
Pity for the kinda crappy SFX, because this fits like a glove. Well done nonetheless !
I always argue with my friends that music is everything, its the final breath of soul into a scene or form of media
Imagine this during order 66
This just got dark!
God, I love the stillness of the audio editing, how you can't hear the rebels talking. I know it probably wasn't intended for any reason other than replacing the music, but it works so fucking well. The frantic nature of the mission feels so real and everything feels as tunneled as that hallway.
I said the real Vader. No the real Vader... Perfection.
I still can't unhear the Jedi Temple cutscene from the 2005 Star Wars Battlefront 2
chills!
This is awesome
Holy crap, makes me wish they would've used this as an awesome callback to RotS.
Now that Andor Season 1 has been out for a while, I really think that the entirety of Rogue One needs to be re-edited or at least re-scored. Michael Giacchino is a talented composer, but he was rushed and tried too hard to make Rogue One sound like regular Star Wars without being regular Star Wars, and the sousdtrack just falls a bit flat overall. Nicholas Britell did such an amazing job with scoring the first season of Andor, because he was given the time he needed to create something that fit the show and didn't need to sound like John Williams. I think Rogue One would benefit from a fresh score that does a good job of bridging the gap between the Nicholas Britell and John Williams scores. 😊
Pov: youre in those tight ass corners of kessel with a max level vader running towards you
Honestly this should've been the soundtrack during this scene, holy shit this gave me the same chills I got from Luke in the Mandalorian
better than the movie
The screams 😂
Maul did the same thing with a door.
that short addition of im so sorry is perfect
That was amazing
Idk. I loved this scene and the music with the Imperial March is so good. However, the end of Anakin’s Dark Deeds gets me every single time. Going from the F to the E’s and back to the F’s for the strings is just one of the best sequences in music. I wish that they would use it more in the films, like when Luke is revealed to be a holo on Crait.
Imagine this was before a scene Vader suffering and he takes his anger out of the rebels.
Vader is probably like Sidious is going to kill me!
what?
They really need to use more themes other than the force theme. Which they don’t know when it’s appropriate to use it. Like it should not be playing when some guys are getting blown tf up
I love how the guy that takes the Death Star plans just yells when he escapes Vader
When ur sibling steals ur snack
I think if you muted the sounds and just leave the music I would have ben better but this is still good
Damn its cool, idk if it works with the tone of the scene they were going for, but it really makes me want a vader stand alone, with that music in the background
I can’t take this scene seriously with the added in sound effects…
The first bit of the hallway didn't really do it for me on the music side of the house, but 1:16 onward just kills dude. Slightly muffled voices and everything. A cacophony of chaos, just how it'd actually be
Perfect.
The Command and Conquer scream were a nice touch.
The impreals worked for the Sith. The Stormtroopers will always be weak to the Sith.
Escaping from the Sith isn't never easy. That ship was attacked in episode 4 1:36
draws some great parallels between this defeat and the defeat on mustafar
I **LOVE** Rogue One, but how I wish this had been Vader's big reveal and that they deleted that middle scene with him and Krennic. 😎🍿🎬
Perfection
Some of the rebels sounded like SMG4 and SMG3
the second half of this song plays as mustafars hub theme in lego star wars the skywalker saga.
I’ve always said that scene could have used more fear in their screams.
Man I like the Vader hallway scene but i’m starting to think Disney’s over using it and it’s starting to appear in all there work.
Knights of the Old Republic
If this was the only scene that had Darth Vader and they used this soundtrack it would’ve been worth it!
Not seeing him the entire film and then his soundtrack and followed by his iconic hallway entrance
Jedi Fallen Order vibes now
I'm picturing hayden christensen in the vader suit massacring the rebels
Obi wan said u killed young lings
The spirit of sors bandium was present
Amazing! How do you remove the orignal music
It changes the mood completely, but I don't like it that much. Not because it's bad, but because the anxiety turns down a lot. It seems like a sad scene instead of a terrifying one.
As much as Anakin is a tragic figure, we must see him as Vader in this as in every scene from the original trilogy and in rebels, a figure that everyone fears at the sight of it. The original score gives us that, a chill running down our spines at the sight of this cyborg filled with anger whom is set to kill anyone who's on his way without mercy, and on the other hand we have fear and desperation from all the rebels trying to save their own lives even though they know they don't stand a chance, they know they will die in that corridor.
Anakin's dark deeds does not inspire that feeling, it keeps the mood of the fallen Jedi that is still trying to save his wife, a man who fell trying to do good and ended up doing the worst... Now there's only hatred and pain.
That's why the original score fits the scene better. We're not seeing a fallen warrior, we're seeing a death machine.
If they had actually put Anakin's Dark Deeds in this scene, that would have been a nice connection between the prequels and the OGs
Stormtroopers are one thing the Sith are another.
Those goofy ass noises tho💀
Great edit tho
I still think it would be better without any music. I just wanna see what it sounds like. Nothing but the screams of men and Vader's breathing
Dark deeds is so good wtf
More of stuff like this this scene makes you understand how frightening DV is
That’s a bf1 death scream at 1:20 lmao
Lol yup. A lot of the sounds are from Battlefront.
Bro I’m watching this now, love it! Did you legit do your own sounds?
IDK Why, But It Sounds Like Lord Of The Rings, In Star Wars
You would be wise to surrender ~Vader
Yeah, probably
The music really does change this scene. It was nice before, but hearing the same score that played while he slaughtered the separatists is just so much more impactful.
I wonder if Vader could’ve force pulled the ship or something
When your girlfriend has so many ex boyfriends
😂😂😂