Even at that young age, Emmy had such an incredible screen presence! Supposedly, Andrew Lloyd Webber walked in for her vocal audition, and was quite brusque....and after Emmy sang for him, he smiled, and introduced himself as "Andy". Guess she stunned him, too!
People love to forget she was only 16 and this was for film. The stage performers are usually in their 30s and they are supposed to have a stronger style of singing for the stage. I can't stand when people hate on her because they're comparing her to the stage Christine. I love the stage version too, but you can't compare. This movie is very different from the stage in many ways. Her voice and acting was incredible for the film and will always be iconic. Recognize that film and stage are different
She didn't have the strong saprano that the usual stage christine has. But thats okay, because this was film and not stage. I hate it when people compare the two. She was so beautiful and likeable and relatable in this role. Her face delicately conveyed every emotion that she was meant to be feeling beautifully. and her voice, while not large is still beautiful and sweet. I just love her.
Yes plus she was like 16, the other actresses are normally 25 or something, once I saw someone comparing her with Sierra, and it's clear that Sierra is an amazing singer but she was like 29 when she played the 25th anniversary and her profession was musical theater while Emmy was a teenager and was in cinema
@@maggieaishalee3829 I don’t know what age has to do with this. Age doesn’t equal skill level. Emmy was perfect for the role WHEN SHE WAS CAST. And that’s apparent because she was cast. I don’t understand how I made this post talking about the difference of singing for screen vs. stage. And it still turned into a skill conversation.
She was such a young terrified little thing! This clip is a treasure because it shows the change from that, to her current confident adult self now a days. I love it!
this makes me feel so much better about audition in general because while there is so much i would say about it, her potential really showed and she produced an amazing end result in the movie ❤
que dulce es! su mirada lo dice todo, la más linda de las christines!! su voz se oía muy caprina e inmadura aún , pero me alegro tanto que la hayan elegido , nadie como ella
Me gusta mucho la elección de esta actriz por su voz tan suave. Se supone que Christine era muy joven en la historia y Emmy es ideal para el personaje. Me gusta más que las versiones de teatro
Opino igual. Las artistas de teatro tienen una voz mucho más fuerte y aunque son excelentes, no transmiten esa dulzura e ingenuidad que Christine se supone que tiene.
It sounds like it’s been edited up a half step which makes her voice sound higher. This ends on a B natural and the original key/key in the movie ends on a B flat. On Broadway they eventually moved it to a C but I’ve never heard this key used before. The key change and the voice quality difference makes it seem pitched up.
@@animationflow1055 Do you have a source? This video sounds pitched to avoid copyright, and when you edit it down so the song is in the right key she sounds like she did in the movie.
I think she was just nervous, like I sing a lot too and when I'm nervous, I can't breath so well, so the notes get shorter and more shakey and I feel like thats kinda what happend here too, at least it seems that way to me
I used to think she was amazing when I was 12 and first watched it. Then I grew up and realized how underdeveloped her voice was. Just very shaky, small, and tense sound. She was trained classically but never reached “opera singer” status. Of course phantom of the opera isn’t full opera but should be more opera like than what she gave. It should have been someone with a more developed voice
Emmy is actually my favorite Christine. I can tell she sounded nervous in the screen test and was a little shakey. Her voice was much better in the actual movie. Remember Sarah brightman was in her 30s during phantom Emmy was only 17 here!
Her voice wasn't strong enough for the songs but it didn't matter because Butler was so much worse, the film was a campy disaster and so badly directed, and the whole thing a flop
i dont get it their voices sound so good sure theyre not professional ive seen the actual play and it was obviously better but the movie and the songs are GREAT especially since gerard butler wasnt even familiar with singing he tired his best and he did well , i guess i can see why you wouldnt like his voice , i do , but Emmy did incredibly well and as for the movie. id like to hear some of your reasonings as to why its so bad , sure has its flaws , but i enjoyed it a LOT thats why i also watched the play too.
The whole time I couldn't stop staring at her face and I couldn't stop staring into her eyes because it was as if she was singing directly to me. Oh my god she blew me away with that Oh my god she did blow me away with that. 🥹🥹 I could just hold her in a hug right now
I wish I can sing those very high notes so clearly like her but I can’t hit those high notes flawlessly like her cause I’m a regular soprano not those sopranos who can hit those impossible high notes like Emmy. I’m certainly no Whitney Houten or Celine Dion but I do have a very good yet decent singing voice. I can sing very well but I’m definitely NOT a professional opera singer. But that’s just me being humble and honest.
She was super nervous. It's also astonishing how much she grew as a singer during the process.
The character is supposed to be nervous anyway at the beginning.
Even at that young age, Emmy had such an incredible screen presence! Supposedly, Andrew Lloyd Webber walked in for her vocal audition, and was quite brusque....and after Emmy sang for him, he smiled, and introduced himself as "Andy". Guess she stunned him, too!
He knew without a doubt in his mind, as soon as she finished the song, that she was likely the one.
People love to forget she was only 16 and this was for film. The stage performers are usually in their 30s and they are supposed to have a stronger style of singing for the stage. I can't stand when people hate on her because they're comparing her to the stage Christine. I love the stage version too, but you can't compare. This movie is very different from the stage in many ways. Her voice and acting was incredible for the film and will always be iconic. Recognize that film and stage are different
@@RebekkaJensenJust the actors who play Christine Daae on stage like Broadway or West End.
Agreed completely! I didn’t even realize she was so young!
She didn't have the strong saprano that the usual stage christine has. But thats okay, because this was film and not stage. I hate it when people compare the two. She was so beautiful and likeable and relatable in this role. Her face delicately conveyed every emotion that she was meant to be feeling beautifully. and her voice, while not large is still beautiful and sweet. I just love her.
Yes plus she was like 16, the other actresses are normally 25 or something, once I saw someone comparing her with Sierra, and it's clear that Sierra is an amazing singer but she was like 29 when she played the 25th anniversary and her profession was musical theater while Emmy was a teenager and was in cinema
@@maggieaishalee3829 Emmy was 18 in this film but still , it’s very impressive .
Compare the two what?? She is 16 and everyone who played this character was 35. Anyone can be a great anything at the age of 35.
@@felixthecat2786 many people like to compare every actress with Sierra Boggess
@@maggieaishalee3829 I don’t know what age has to do with this. Age doesn’t equal skill level. Emmy was perfect for the role WHEN SHE WAS CAST. And that’s apparent because she was cast. I don’t understand how I made this post talking about the difference of singing for screen vs. stage. And it still turned into a skill conversation.
She was such a young terrified little thing! This clip is a treasure because it shows the change from that, to her current confident adult self now a days. I love it!
She shoulda been Belle in Disney Beauty and the Beast live action
No kidding! Such a better singer than Emma Watson.
I think Anne Hathaway would be an amazing Belle, but Emmy is second in my book.
That's what I'm saying!!! I can't believe they took her into consideration and STILL chose Emma.
@@melissajohnson8050 I love Anne, but she was way too old for the role
100! Would have been such a better choice.
She was ABSOLUTELY gorgeous Christine.
What does she lack as a performer?! Stunning in beauty, voice and sweetness:)
Voice projection is one.
@@yellowRose806 good thing its film and not stage
@@savspicious Might as well dub her like the rest, right?
She's so sweet and simple with natural voice.
Her voice is so beautiful
She ha a perfect voice, and is absolutely, 1OO% beautiful. They found the perfect actress for the role.
Love her character as Christine, one of the best! She's so young only 16, beautiful performance, Bravo🌹👏❤️
Her career has deserved so much more. Love Emmy
lovely voice. 16 and such a nice voice, thumbs up to Emmy
Such kind eyes. I loved her in the role.
I wish she was in more shows, she’s probably my favorite actress by far
She was good at singing and she was good at playing the “innocent card” which was crucial for somebody to play Christine
I watched her for 10 seasons of Shameless. REALLY hard to imagine that she had this character and voice deep inside
she was only in nine season seasons of Shameless.
I agree. ❤❤❤
Those high notes really ring so clearly😍
I wish I can hit those high notes so clearly like hers but I’m frankly not a trained opera singer.
Inspired casting. Emmy was brilliant as Christine!
Those eyes holy moley! What a great audition!
To me, she was the best Christine ever.❤️
And … she nailed it. Bravo!!!
Ugh, she’s so gorgeous and her voice is just beautiful!
this makes me feel so much better about audition in general because while there is so much i would say about it, her potential really showed and she produced an amazing end result in the movie ❤
Absolutely flawless ✨
she is one of my favorite actors and she is very unique which i love
She is a Beautyful Actress and her voice is amazing she is my favourite
This is beautiful!
que dulce es! su mirada lo dice todo, la más linda de las christines!! su voz se oía muy caprina e inmadura aún , pero me alegro tanto que la hayan elegido , nadie como ella
She is gifted with those high notes
She was amazing in the movie. She became my favorite Christine.
Great play.. they did good turning this into a movie
Se oye nerviosa pero cuando ya tiene el papel es maravillosa
Me gusta mucho la elección de esta actriz por su voz tan suave. Se supone que Christine era muy joven en la historia y Emmy es ideal para el personaje. Me gusta más que las versiones de teatro
Opino igual. Las artistas de teatro tienen una voz mucho más fuerte y aunque son excelentes, no transmiten esa dulzura e ingenuidad que Christine se supone que tiene.
I love her with Patrick Wilson... surprise at the fragility, innocence and emotional integrity in both their Christine and Raoul's characterizations
Thank you for such a valuable video❤
she's sooo cute😭😭🥺
Its she best actress in her role in this phantom of opera or nominated only
They could have easily dubbed her voice with someone more experienced, but they didn't. I'm glad they didn't. :)
I understand why she was chosen as Christine.
The best Christine ❤
This needs to be in American Archives. Exceptional
Emmy Rossum was perfect Christine Daae
I also love from
One of the best Masterpiece RUclips Video of all time
Am I crazy in saying that I love how she sounds here more than in the actual film? Has this been altered at all?
It sounds like it’s been edited up a half step which makes her voice sound higher. This ends on a B natural and the original key/key in the movie ends on a B flat. On Broadway they eventually moved it to a C but I’ve never heard this key used before. The key change and the voice quality difference makes it seem pitched up.
@@RileyKmusicsurprisingly, this is Rossums natural singing voice. She wasn’t edited in this tape.
@@animationflow1055 Do you have a source? This video sounds pitched to avoid copyright, and when you edit it down so the song is in the right key she sounds like she did in the movie.
Now let's see Gerard's audition tape
She sounded MUCH STRONGER AND LOUDER in the actual movie!! I can hardly hear her here
I think she was just nervous, like I sing a lot too and when I'm nervous, I can't breath so well, so the notes get shorter and more shakey and I feel like thats kinda what happend here too, at least it seems that way to me
Yes, very thin and trembly, not enough breath support. She was probably very nervous
@@einfachnursilvi9382 I am the same way as a fellow Soprano..but still ..I've always loved her..
The Best Christine no doubt
She was so scared lol
With good reason
I still appreciate her as christine since she should be someone that's not fully professional singer in the story but starting to be a prima donna
wonderful i seen it in los ANGELIS.
She should have been in the play as well , especially on broadway
A small voice, but very melodious and her manner charming.
2024 yay😄
Even though Emma was 18 or younger here, she sang as if she was 30 go Emma 👏👏👏
She sounds like Snow White
I Thought Think of me is because fiona Is from shameless.
She could’ve played Snow White
Se ve muy nerviosa
I used to think she was amazing when I was 12 and first watched it. Then I grew up and realized how underdeveloped her voice was. Just very shaky, small, and tense sound. She was trained classically but never reached “opera singer” status. Of course phantom of the opera isn’t full opera but should be more opera like than what she gave. It should have been someone with a more developed voice
All I see is who Belle should have been in Disney’s live action. 😭😭 Emma Watson was great in Harry Potter but definitely not Disney’s Belle. 😥
There is NO DIFFERENCE between Sarah Brightman and Emmy Rossum. They are the Best in their Parts as Christine Daae.
Her voice is not as strong as Sarah Brightman, but she did well And is pretty.
Emmy is actually my favorite Christine. I can tell she sounded nervous in the screen test and was a little shakey. Her voice was much better in the actual movie. Remember Sarah brightman was in her 30s during phantom Emmy was only 17 here!
@@ericac88 And she performed like a 17 year old. Her acting greatly improved later, but that does nothing to save the movie.
@@ericac88 And Sarah Brightman was 26 when she performed in the Phantom.
looking back gerry was good but i imagined Gary Busey as phantom lol
III VI IX 😍😘
No. Incorrecta voz para una cantante espectacular de ópera que enamora a un fantasma.
Her voice wasn't strong enough for the songs but it didn't matter because Butler was so much worse, the film was a campy disaster and so badly directed, and the whole thing a flop
🤡
Something's wrong with you.
i dont get it their voices sound so good sure theyre not professional ive seen the actual play and it was obviously better but the movie and the songs are GREAT especially since gerard butler wasnt even familiar with singing he tired his best and he did well , i guess i can see why you wouldnt like his voice , i do , but Emmy did incredibly well and as for the movie. id like to hear some of your reasonings as to why its so bad , sure has its flaws , but i enjoyed it a LOT thats why i also watched the play too.
Get out
Why are you so rude and mad?😆 This movie is a masterpiece!!!!!
The whole time I couldn't stop staring at her face and I couldn't stop staring into her eyes because it was as if she was singing directly to me. Oh my god she blew me away with that Oh my god she did blow me away with that. 🥹🥹 I could just hold her in a hug right now
Very beautiful singing!!! I'm glad she got the part. 🤩🤩🤩🤩👏👏👏👏
I wish I can sing those very high notes so clearly like her but I can’t hit those high notes flawlessly like her cause I’m a regular soprano not those sopranos who can hit those impossible high notes like Emmy. I’m certainly no Whitney Houten or Celine Dion but I do have a very good yet decent singing voice. I can sing very well but I’m definitely NOT a professional opera singer. But that’s just me being humble and honest.