Hi Jordan! I am from Baghdad/Iraq and I would like to tell you that Sunni and Shiites live together in Iraq peacefully, some of our families contain a Sunni mother and a Shiite father or vice versa. Some of my best, lifelong friends are Christians and I walked by a church the last month and saw a priest saying goodbye to a smiling family leaving the church. Rest assured that the majority of Muslim people are peaceful and loving, but the actions of some bigoted minority sometimes, unfortunately, leave a stronger impression.
@@husaynqarsh5662 Funny thing is, I have shiite friend pulled me aside this morning after I wrote this comment yesterday at night (he doesn't know about it) and asked how I am doing. He also told me that he's worried about me because he didn't hear from me in a week or so.
you are a subject matter expert and you have been an inspiration to me and to countless others. I listen to you very carefully and I am proud of you and all the hard work that you do. I am only asking that you do not stretch yourself too thin. some topics such as islam and the muslim world which I have experienced personally (I grew up in a muslim country as a christian) are simply too complex. please tread carefully. Suni's do not hate shia's, islam does not hate jews or christians. I'm afraid that you might be falling victim to the same media that you are fighting against. there are a few radical, fanatic, extremist muslims who I've encountered personally, just like any other group. don't get trapped.
I'm a muslim too and I've seen extremism as the majority. you can see many IMAMS declaring each other as kafir. molanas and maulwis declaring each other kafirs. people quite literally burn people alive on the name of blasphemy. come to a country like pakistan and you will see this live.
Well if they're fanatic extremist then they're not Muslims. Muslim is a belief system not an ethnicity. Unfortunately, 90+% of mosques and "Muslim" teaching in the west are wahabi, which is a free masonic invention.
Unfortunately not all Muslims agree with you. I've spoken to Muslims who openly speak of their hatred for Jewish people. They speak about hating Hindus. They speak about hate more than love. Not all btw but enough to be an issue
As a Muslim who respects Dr.Peterson and has followed him for quite some time, My 3 issues with this video: 1-This message could easily apply to Jews and Christians aswell,did Jordan ever make a message directed to Jews or Christians telling them to stop seeing Muslims as enemies?I don't think so. 2-There is anti-Jewish sentiment in the Muslim community,but the majority of Muslims don't even see Christians as their enemies,so I don't see why Jordan was speaking as if there was a significant anti-Christian sentiment in the Muslim community. 3-As for the Jewish point:imagine if a man made a RUclips video in 2022 encouraging Ukrainians to seek peace with Russians as if it's a simple task,the response to said video would be outrageous since it would be ignoring the complexity of the situation between Russians and Ukrainians and ignoring that there's a war between them. The same could be said to Jordan encouraging Muslims to stop vilifying Jews. Firstly,Muslims have trouble with Israel and Zionism more than they do have trouble with Jews and Judaism as a religion. Secondly,like my Ukrainian example,the issue of "Jews and Muslims" is very complex and there's a war going on in Palestine,so telling muslims to seek peace with the "Jews" or Israelis in such a situation would be ignoring the complexity of the situation and treating it as if it's some playground squabble that could be solved simply and easily. And ofcourse Jordan used the term "Jews" rather than "Zionists" or "Israelis" even though the latter would've been more correct to use,this word choice is dishonest and doesn't tell the whole story. --- That's all.
I see what you’re saying, we all have our blind spots, he has his. I’m sure is open to correction, just as I would say you aren’t aware of the full story in Ukraine. The Russian speaking Ukrainians have been slaughtered since 2014, under the orders of interim president Oleksandr Turnochyv. They’re infested with an ideology older and more odious than Nazism, and their actions could hardly be seen as forgivable by the Russian speaking Ukrainians who’ve suffered untold torture, kidnap, and extrajudicial ethnic cleansing at the hands of Ukrainian officials. This is in fact a message applicable to almost every other major religion as you said and should be said to them too, although there exist no such divide today between Jews nor between Christians. And I recognize that the vast majority of this is actually nationalism rather than theological conflict. Alowites are seen as heretics for example by a great deal Muslims though as are Sufis by fewer. Salam brother.
@@RubiaStorm You misunderstand my analogy,I do not want to delve into the deep details of the Ukrainian conflict,that doesn't matter to our argument right now. I only mean to say that if you were to tell a Ukrainian to seek peace with the Russians,he would reasonably be angry at you. The same could he said with telling a Muslim to seek peace with a Zionist colonizer.
@@Sincerely_MrX Assalmu Alaykum! Firstly,I appreciate you replying to my argument with your own points. Secondly,if you want my reply,please look at what I said to the other person who replied to me.
I think there's something you still don't know, because the bitterness and inferiority complex that exists is from Ishmael to Isaac. I am a bit of my ancestors, so there are Muslims who are the face of Abraham's first son, resentful, bitter, because he was born first, but Abraham took Isaac to sacrifice, that's why Israel wins wars. That's not me saying it, but it's the psychology of the collective unconscious, and Jesus would bring Israel back. I'm sorry don't think badly of me, but know, I'm a Christian, a Zionist, and in the State of Israel even Muslims live with more freedom. Shalom .
As for why are such messages meant for muslims: it's because islam is the only religion in the 21st century that has a widespread track record of modern religion-endorsed violence, sometthing that the Christians and Jews phased out in the middle ages and Roman times, respectively. Islam is violent by nature, and muslims seem to have little problem with it. Christianity and Jewish faith are like.. herpes, but Islam is like cancer, so it's more important to deal with that at the moment.
Exactly but some people think all this are fairytale movies they can direct by their emotions rather than realizing that there's an already written script.
Plan to dismantle Israel/Palestinian/Muslim Apartheid, settle all religious disputes, and bring peace to the "Middle East". Plan does not need to be absolute truth nor believed by it's implementors (or the implemented). Can the plan be pulled off with success is what I wish to lay out to you if the above title is a goal you wish to achieve regardless. [They wait for the success of the plan after the fact before they TRULY believe in the plan anyway] The plan is to promote and force the hand of Israel to enthrone me, Edward Nathan Schwarz, as King of Israel according to Torah law and I would have absolute rule over the interpretation of all the Holy Writ [Tanak, Gospel, Qur'an] and settle all religious and legal disputes TO EVERYONES BENEFIT AND SATISFACTION. And you can flesh that out with me ahead of time what that settlement would be and see if any side would feel a ruling would not be Just for them or in their interests. What do Palestinians want? No walls surrounding them? They're gone. What do Muslim's want? No apartheid in Jerusalem? Done away with. What do the Rabbis want? A Temple? They'll settle for the Tabernacle. What does Egypt want, what does Jordan want, what does Iran want? The Davidic King, according to ALL their Lore, holds the Lord's power of attorney in Israel's affairs. Except for cases in idolatry, this king can amend the covenant laws at will among other powers. I got plenty of resources to share. Who wants to be my friend? Anybody please tell me, What can I give you that you be my friend? I'll open an office and stock it with Santa's helpers for you to send in your requests. I got resources and "stuff" warehouses busting their seems. I'll bring an oasis to your desert if that is what you need or want - spare no expense. So whoever this is I'm speaking to please forward this plan to concerned parties for consideration and refining if interested. -Cheers
I’m a Christian, at one time I often traveled to Turkey where my company had offices. I talked with my Muslim co-workers about faith. I realized that the wedge between us is fake. Various leaders weaponize religion for their own gains. We have more in common than we think. Even if we never overcome our differences the simple fact that we have bigger more dangerous enemies should be uniting.
Islam and Christianity are fundamentally incompatible. Islam denies, not only the divinity of Christ, but also the crucifixion. Christianity holds that there are no prophets that follow after Christ and thusly, Muhammad must be a false prophet. Christians and Muslims may be able to get along for a time, but Christianity and Islam cannot.
This video is proof that even the most intellectual and educated people like Jordan Peterson can share wrong info or misguide people. I just wanted to say, as a Lebanese muslim, that despite all the differences between Sunni and Shia ideologies, we live with each others in peace. All the problems/wars happening in the muslim world are purely political, and they shove religions in the conflicts to sustain the same amount of violence. As a sunni, i have tons of shia and christian friends, and i dont have jewish friends because simply there are none in my country. And I believe that you know very well that muslims in general have a problem with Zionists,and not jews. You just chose to share certain info in a certain way to support a certain political group, and this is very predictable. Finally, and in conclusion, you're 100% wrong.
Islam is 85% politics and les than 14% religious faith so there's your own question answered. In just the past 70 years 12 million+ muhammadans have died fighting other muhammadans in conflicts .. . and yet here you are and many other muhammadans in absolute utter denial about the elephant in the room and look to blame the messenger and or everyone else for problems in your own system
Plan to dismantle Israel/Palestinian/Muslim Apartheid, settle all religious disputes, and bring peace to the "Middle East". Plan does not need to be absolute truth nor believed by it's implementors (or the implemented). Can the plan be pulled off with success is what I wish to lay out to you if the above title is a goal you wish to achieve regardless. [They wait for the success of the plan after the fact before they TRULY believe in the plan anyway] The plan is to promote and force the hand of Israel to enthrone me, Edward Nathan Schwarz, as King of Israel according to Torah law and I would have absolute rule over the interpretation of all the Holy Writ [Tanak, Gospel, Qur'an] and settle all religious and legal disputes TO EVERYONES BENEFIT AND SATISFACTION. And you can flesh that out with me ahead of time what that settlement would be and see if any side would feel a ruling would not be Just for them or in their interests. What do Palestinians want? No walls surrounding them? They're gone. What do Muslim's want? No apartheid in Jerusalem? Done away with. What do the Rabbis want? A Temple? They'll settle for the Tabernacle. What does Egypt want, what does Jordan want, what does Iran want? The Davidic King, according to ALL their Lore, holds the Lord's power of attorney in Israel's affairs. Except for cases in idolatry, this king can amend the covenant laws at will among other powers. I got plenty of resources to share. Who wants to be my friend? Anybody please tell me, What can I give you that you be my friend? I'll open an office and stock it with Santa's helpers for you to send in your requests. I got resources and "stuff" warehouses busting their seems. I'll bring an oasis to your desert if that is what you need or want - spare no expense. So whoever this is I'm speaking to please forward this plan to concerned parties for consideration and refining if interested. -Cheers
Really you Lebanese out of all people want to talk. In Lebanon it's divided for each sect of each religion it is regionally divided politically divided on all kinds of levels. Doesn't matter eventually Doesn't affect the main point that he wants to deliver, it still remains true.
Iam lebanease too, you are 1 of 1% u can speak for yourself, there is always hatred race .. religions etc.. cause the old mindset is still alive , in some countries tend to be less , but if some shia go to saudi arabia for example racism occurs as well as anything happend before but i hope we will have "true" peace someday
As a Muslim myself, the most ignorant thing I've seen any of us do is to stop thinking for ourselves with the excuse that thinking will turn into a lack of faith and then you are doomed.
WHY: It is very clear that Islamic States are hateful. They need an enemy to justify the brutal treatment of their own people. It's all about hateful domination to think "I have the right and only answer."
@pleasestudy745 yeah.... why bother thinking when all thinking is controlled by a misogenistic theoracy? The movie 'the great wall '(2016) depicted an army of monsters controlled by a mother monster- one bleat from her controlled all the monsters. Their goal? Destruction of humanity...The misogenistic theocracy's (and its proxies) written, stated, policy? the destruction of the state of Israel, the expulsion of any surviving persons of any jewish link from the entire middle east... I'd rather deal with a fictional monster tbh... the US is always depicted as the 'great satan' by the misogenistic theocracy. Time for the west to wake up.
Someone once said”As an outsider you have no idea of how much you don’t know about what you don’t know, even you are blind to your own ignorance,” I think the glove fits here Dr. Peterson.
Peculiar statement which demonstrate the cardinal issue with some Muslim after all your fate in named Piece and you are the youngest half brothers in the Abrahamic fates, thus, stop trying so heard to be “enfant terrible”
U r ignorant of the truth, Jordan is right, u r trying to defend Islam and its ideology, there are several dangerous things which u r not aware of, so u r ignorant and I agree 💯 with you, u r ignorant willingly...
Speaking as a Christian I can say this message applies equally to Christians. Before you call your neighbor evil because you do not agree with their ideology, seek out and root out any evil that lies within. Let he who is without evil cast the first stone. Love God. Love your neighbor. No exceptions.
I want to agree with you to be “fair” as my modern western indoctrination tells me that fairness is the pinnacle but I can’t. When was the last time Christians stormed a village and beheaded and raped non believers?500 years ago? 300? A long time so long you can’t recall off the top of your mind. Yes we should all band together against the post modern ideologues etc but first acknowledge that Christianity is ahead of the curve when it comes to civility.
As a muslim I respect Dr Jordan Peterson alot but in this video I'm sure he didn't do his study and research well . As muslims we can agree with Dr Jordan Peterson that the Quran it is mentioned that we muslims should respect the people of the book ( jews and Christians ) but it's mentioned in the Quran chapter 60 : verse 8 " God does not deprive you of those who did not fight you in religion and did not deprive you from your home " and what did the jewish settlers do to the Palestinians ? Between 1920 and 1939 the Balfour declaration promised to facilitate Jewish immigration under suitable conditions and the jewish population focused on purchasing lands from the arab owners so by controlling both the land and the labor that gave them the opportunity to occupy Palestine and over 700000 Palestinians fled from their homes and became refugees in neighbouring arab countries and they became stateless . Now here's an honest question. How do you want us to make peace with those who fought us , kicked us out from our homeland , and declared war on us ? Palestinians are living under isreali military occupation and the Israelis treat the Palestinians as they are sub humans in their own land . Just last year ago when the battle started between the Palestinians and the Isreali government , there were Zionist mobs marching through the streets of Jerusalem chanting " Death to Arabs " and smashing in Palestinians own stores with protection of Isreali police . And they were kicking Palestinians out from their homes in sheikh Jarrah east Jerusalem to make way for Jewish settlers . And yet people say that God promised them this land and the they have the right to live there . How do you think Isreal was built ? Do you think that millions of Palestinians decided to leave their homes behind burn down their own villages for no reason ? Isreali forces are bombing and shooting people praying inside Al Aqsa mosque and airstrikes are hitting the Gaza strip and what are the Palestinians supposed to do ? Their homes are being destroyed, their places of worship are being bombed and their families are being killed . Are you expecting from them to remain quiet and to sit back and accept it ? Some jews claim that it was their land so if history is to be taken to throw people out from their homes then why doesn't the US give back the land to the native Americans ( the red Indians ) . Don't you feel like as if Palestinians are still living under colonialism ? As muslims we have no problem with the jews at all . The Quran doesn't say that the Jews and the muslims should fight , it says that the strongest enemies to the muslims are the jews and this is actually a fact and it proves the Quran is right and the proof for that is easy . Just let the jews get together and decide to stop the war on the Palestinians and to give the stolen land back to them . Will they do it ? We are not anti-Jewish , we are anit-Zionists. We don't want war , we want justice . We are not fascists , Nazists nor racists . The Palestinians were uprooted from their homes by " God's promise " and when you call us anti-semitic infact the Palestinians are semites because arabic is a semitic language . So our problem is with the Zionists because zionism is a political movement not a religious movement and history proves that muslims Christians and jews were coexisting and they were living in peace when the Islamic warrior Salah El Din Al Ayubi conquered the crusaders and took control of Jerusalem he entered into an agreement that muslims should protect synagogues and Churches .
I read your post and you stated that the quran does not call for the fighting af jews ...according to your logic Turkey should give isanbul back because they took it from Christians right? Look I am sympathetic but the land is what it is now folks need to get along Quran : Curse Jews/Christians- Surah 9:29 , 9:30 / Take Jews nor Christians as friends 5:56 / Jews and Christians worse of creatures -98:6 / Jews, Christians turned into apes - 5:60 (64) / Enmity for Christians - 5:14 / Do not befriend nonbelievers-3:28 / Fight unbelievers 9:123 HADITH: Kill Children -Sahih Muslim vol 4 verse 4457 / Kill Jews behind talking stones - Sahih Muslim book 41 6985
As a Muslim I can assure you that all those you mentioned and pointing your message to are and have been living together peacefully for centuries. It's the politicians who cause divisions and fights among us...
no not really in nigeria muslims live in peace becuase they agree with what they are doing recently some muslims killed a 20 year old teacher in Nigeria and shot up a church of 50 people killing women and children. This has been going on foe years in Nigeria and the muslim leader, Scholars etc are trying to justify it instead of denouncing it. Some Zanadiqa (atheists) were brought to `Ali and he burnt them. The news of this event, reached Ibn `Abbas who said, "If I had been in his place, I would not have burnt them, as Allah's Messenger (ﷺ) forbade it, saying, 'Do not punish anybody with Allah's punishment (fire).' I would have killed them according to the statement of Allah's Messenger (ﷺ), 'Whoever changed his Islamic religion, then kill him.'" the teacher was actually stoned and burned to death on video because she balsthemed
I’m very tired of everyday people talking to us Muslims like we are idiots. I don’t know when us Muslims will wake up and realize we only have each other. We spend so much time looking for approval in places that don’t want us or care for us.
It's all a game to them Brother. They are obsessed with Muslims because they know that Muslims are the most authentic and its much easier to understand Islam than the revised Christianity and Judaism. Notice how Muslims don't ever talk or think about the West or Christianity, yet the West ONLY talks bad about Islam, and is obsessed with slandering and persecuting us. Stay strong Brother and Salaam!
Everyday people don't give two fucks about Muslim culture or religion minus the radical Sharia Law that set you all back decades. Stop letting fanatics that practice this archaic and barbaric sect rise to power, then and only then will the world stop demonizing Muslims.
@@cameronminor2255 the conflict is not nearly like portrayed in social media . The message is definitely a great one from Jordan. However it’s a must for us to say what we are really living . That mentioned conflict is not really reflective of reality .. i guess that’s the msg mostly we are trying to explain 🌸
Nothing is as bad as the media claims, but there still are issues in the areas. Not everywhere, and not all Muslims, but he touched on issues that have been going on for hundreds of years. But really, all I got from the entire message was that we need to communicate and learn to love each other. If all you can get out of his message is criticism then maybe you're focusing on the wrong things.
@@cameronminor2255 No no some of the things he is saying are totally accurate, if we were in 632 AD. I won't ruin all the fun for you and let you find out why on your own, unlike Peterson did. (and I'm not being sarcastic, it's actually pretty interesting). Otherwise, everything he said is fiction.
Started reading the Quran recently, it is blowing my mind with timeless articulate inspiration on every page so far. If a book is inspiring almost 2 billion people over 1000 years since it was first written, it would be arrogant to assume that oneself is somehow beyond its relevance before even reading, as I was arrogant during my atheistic past of assuming that I could figure everything out based on my own limited intuition.
@@zxctgb i find science to be amazing and inspirational, constantly leading me to ask more questions , seek more knowledge and shed light on how much we still dont understand.
With all due respect, Dr. Peterson, you once said that you are "ignorant about Islam". Has there been any change to convey this message to your Muslim audience?
*Muslims* Read these Verses (The Jews and the Christians will never be pleased with you until you follow their religion. Say, “The guidance of Allah is the [true] guidance.” If you were to follow their desires after the knowledge that has come to you, then you would have no protector or helper against Allah.Those to whom We have given the Book recite it as it should be recited, it is they who believe in it. As for those who disbelieve in it, it is they who are the losers.) Ch 2 Verse 120-121
@@rdsa1 "The Jews and the Christians will never be pleased with you until you follow their religion. Say, “The guidance of Allah is the [true] guidance." it's not even in Quran, I am a Christian and I know this is not Quran
Maybe he did that on purpose under influence of his christian-zionist exclusive right-wing club, the daily wire, he joined, with that robot zionist with a metallic annoying voice Shapiro as one of the main characters...
I have been following JP for years now and have learned so much from him. Years ago he was asked about Islam and he said he didn't have enough knowledge to speak about it. Something I admired. But he should have stuck to that. This message is disappointing. He's clearly ignorant of Islam and the history of the Middle East, or he has an agenda.
"Among people there is a kind whose sayings on the affairs of the world fascinate you:he even calls on God to bear testimony on his sincerity; yet he is most fierce in enmity." Qur'an (2:204)
But it in Peterson case he maybe mistaken, ask the majority of people what causes wars they will say religions (even some Muslims believe that) yet Encyclopedia of Wars," authors Charles Phillips and Alan Axelrod document the history of recorded warfare, and from their list of 1763 wars only 123 have been classified to involve a religious cause, accounting for less than 7 percent of all wars and less than 2 percent of all people killed in warfare. Yet "far more lives were lost in the Second World War than in the First (more than 60 million. Moving beyond soldier deaths, the total number of both civilian and military casualties during World War One is estimated at around 37 million people." according historyonthenet.
@@ZAINABKHAN-ir7rl I read that 3 or 4 years ago so here is what i can find now: "Encyclopedia of Wars," authors Charles Phillips and Alan Axelrod document the history of recorded warfare, and from their list of 1763 wars only 123 have been classified to involve a religious cause, accounting for less than 7 percent of all wars and less than 2 percent of all people killed in warfare. " so I may have read different source, or confused the 2% of death caused by religiosly motivated wars with number of total war. thanks for reminding me to check it again and can't recall the other site I read it on.. May Allah increase your knowedlge sister Zainab , love your name, and give you Jannah and your family and all of us amin :)
Unlike many never thought of peterson as a beakon of hope in the age of despair. But this address of his to muslims is way out his league. He understands almost nothing about Islam
Yep he knows nothing about sharia Fistula laws Or the 30 different qurans. He just keeps talking about the unabrogated verses. He actually still has hope for you guys.
@@sz4205 They're not perfectly preserved cause Uthman burned all the original copies. Where are the pages that Aisha had hidden underneath her pillow? Is 111 or 114? No there are too many holes in SIN for you to convince me otherwise.
Mr. Peterson had credibility on other topics he talked about, but in this case, I have first-hand experience with many Muslim countries, and this message is simply talking about a totally different planet.
You have "first-hand experience with many Muslim countries", you say, so now tell us about the treatment of Christians and Hindus in Pakistan, and of Christians in Egypt, Afghanistan, Somalia, Iran, Syria, Turkey, Nigeria. Tell us about Al-Shabaab's actions in Ethiopia, Kenya and Mozambique. where a few months ago they invaded and murdered widely, even decapitating ten-year old children and displaced more than 500,000 people. So yes, tell us about this.
There is a war against Jews, Christians, Buddhists and Hindus pretty much everywhere. Been this way for centuries. Some people still can’t connect the dots.
@@robertporter4501 christians in egypt???! You don't know what you are talking about im Egyptian and i can tell you That many Christians get treated better than muslims And other countries you said I don't know about it but if you lied about egypt then you lied about every other countries you said
@@mostafaahmed9441 because he is another racist white man who wants his racist opinion to matter because deep down his way of thinking are the dinosaurs of extinc. He won't matter and the world would be better off him.
After watching this video and reading the comments I can’t help but feel a little patronised if I’m honest. While the intention of this message may have been innocent and in good faith, It plays into this false narrative that all Muslims have a percentage of hate towards Christian’s and Jews. There is no hate amongst the majority of Muslims and other faiths. Our hate internally is towards the sin and not the sinner with our common enemy being Satan/Shaitaan. Our differences are very few but what Muslims feel is sinful, they will try their best to avoid and to partake in. I live in the UAE a country which follows Sharia law, it has one of the lowest crime rates in the world and there is peaceful coexistence between many faiths. This message of tolerance and peaceful coexistence is in the teachings of this beautiful religion for 1400+ years but what Islam also teaches us is to have a little backbone and stick to our values and beliefs. Tolerance doesn’t mean you give up your values and traditions to take part in what others do. Tolerance is to accept that others are different and the whole world can take something from this message. As for the Sunni/Shia comments this is down to political/regional understandings of the religion the same way there are many branches of Christianity who don’t agree with one another’s interpretations. The message is one amongst all Muslims and Allah will judge us on how we have understood and followed that message. Also baffled by the number of Muslims in the comments section who seem to crave validation from a prominent speaker and say they agree with “everything” but then disagree with certain points. We don’t need Dr JP’s validation or validation from anyone else. That’s the beauty of our religion we are not slaves to the “norms” of society. We answer to a higher power than man. The laws we follow internally encompass everything we will face in our lives and push us to be kind to others and be held accountable for every single one of our actions. Our religion has had this message and guidance for 1400 years and our validation will be found within us if we respect and follow the teachings of Allah (swt) and his messenger ﷺ May peace and guidance reach all who read this comment and watch this video ameen
LIES! That all sounds good but you want find many Christians and Jews moving to Muslims countries in masses but you will found Muslims moving to the West in masses. People are not stupid or blind, we see what happens to Christians or non-Muslims in Nigeria, Egypt, Sudan, Pakistan, Afghanistan, Iran or any Muslim majority country.
Despite that I agree with JP on a lot of stuff, this message seemed judgemental and condescending. I feel like message for muslims was 'Be less aggressive' in contrast to message to christian churches which was 'Promote christianity better'. That feels very one-sided and not at all unviersal.
Plan to dismantle Israel/Palestinian/Muslim Apartheid, settle all religious disputes, and bring peace to the "Middle East". Plan does not need to be absolute truth nor believed by it's implementors (or the implemented). Can the plan be pulled off with success is what I wish to lay out to you if the above title is a goal you wish to achieve regardless. [They wait for the success of the plan after the fact before they TRULY believe in the plan anyway] The plan is to promote and force the hand of Israel to enthrone me, Edward Nathan Schwarz, as King of Israel according to Torah law and I would have absolute rule over the interpretation of all the Holy Writ [Tanak, Gospel, Qur'an] and settle all religious and legal disputes TO EVERYONES BENEFIT AND SATISFACTION. And you can flesh that out with me ahead of time what that settlement would be and see if any side would feel a ruling would not be Just for them or in their interests. What do Palestinians want? No walls surrounding them? They're gone. What do Muslim's want? No apartheid in Jerusalem? Done away with. What do the Rabbis want? A Temple? They'll settle for the Tabernacle. What does Egypt want, what does Jordan want, what does Iran want? The Davidic King, according to ALL their Lore, holds the Lord's power of attorney in Israel's affairs. Except for cases in idolatry, this king can amend the covenant laws at will among other powers. I got plenty of resources to share. Who wants to be my friend? Anybody please tell me, What can I give you that you be my friend? I'll open an office and stock it with Santa's helpers for you to send in your requests. I got resources and "stuff" warehouses busting their seems. I'll bring an oasis to your desert if that is what you need or want - spare no expense. So whoever this is I'm speaking to please forward this plan to concerned parties for consideration and refining if interested. -Cheers
With all do respect the problem is with the Zionist not the Jews I am a Arab Christian woman we always lived Muslim Christian’s and even Jews with each other as Arabs , like Syria , Palestine , Iraq This division you see in this region were made to divide and rule by the western world starting from Britain to the United States , they put a lot of money to do this , for in this region religion is a big part of the individual identity , so to start conflict between a nation , they used religion as a target
Many Muslim leaders are just as bad. They incite hatred in followers and exploit them. This is all about power and money. The common people should refuse this nonsense.
But again if you were Jewish and had there history. Would you have not been a Zionist. It's the way the Isreall government has behaved there after. The chance was missed with Rabbine sorry if I spelt his name wrong
Hmmm. I really like Jordan Peterson. He is a genuine, logical, thoughtful speaker who truly wishes the best for people. However, as well as his intentions may have been, I found this video to be a bit condescending towards Muslims. It represents a very shallow understanding of the world, Islam, and the situation of Muslims in general. I find it slightly hypocritical that he is only addressing this message to the Muslims and fails to implement his own advice to other divides such as those between the left and the right. I know that Peterson joined the Daily Wire recently, but I hope that that he stays true the principals of honesty, rationality, and fairness that I’ve seen within him much more than I have in other right-wing speakers (left-wing as well).
This is one of the first Jordan Peterson videos i have seen that could not captivate me entirely, it felt too much ''built up'' instead of his many mesmerizing videos ''from the heart''. I sense the Abraham Accords are not truly meant to bring Sunni-Shia peace. It feels like an un-Jordan Peterson video. A missed chance now we seem to head to a global religious strife beside the military-economical-nationalistic-ideological-linguistic clashes?
Plan to dismantle Israel/Palestinian/Muslim Apartheid, settle all religious disputes, and bring peace to the "Middle East". Plan does not need to be absolute truth nor believed by it's implementors (or the implemented). Can the plan be pulled off with success is what I wish to lay out to you if the above title is a goal you wish to achieve regardless. [They wait for the success of the plan after the fact before they TRULY believe in the plan anyway] The plan is to promote and force the hand of Israel to enthrone me, Edward Nathan Schwarz, as King of Israel according to Torah law and I would have absolute rule over the interpretation of all the Holy Writ [Tanak, Gospel, Qur'an] and settle all religious and legal disputes TO EVERYONES BENEFIT AND SATISFACTION. And you can flesh that out with me ahead of time what that settlement would be and see if any side would feel a ruling would not be Just for them or in their interests. What do Palestinians want? No walls surrounding them? They're gone. What do Muslim's want? No apartheid in Jerusalem? Done away with. What do the Rabbis want? A Temple? They'll settle for the Tabernacle. What does Egypt want, what does Jordan want, what does Iran want? The Davidic King, according to ALL their Lore, holds the Lord's power of attorney in Israel's affairs. Except for cases in idolatry, this king can amend the covenant laws at will among other powers. I got plenty of resources to share. Who wants to be my friend? Anybody please tell me, What can I give you that you be my friend? I'll open an office and stock it with Santa's helpers for you to send in your requests. I got resources and "stuff" warehouses busting their seems. I'll bring an oasis to your desert if that is what you need or want - spare no expense. So whoever this is I'm speaking to please forward this plan to concerned parties for consideration and refining if interested. -Cheers
@@miso9788 Plan to dismantle Israel/Palestinian/Muslim Apartheid, settle all religious disputes, and bring peace to the "Middle East". Plan does not need to be absolute truth nor believed by it's implementors (or the implemented). Can the plan be pulled off with success is what I wish to lay out to you if the above title is a goal you wish to achieve regardless. [They wait for the success of the plan after the fact before they TRULY believe in the plan anyway] The plan is to promote and force the hand of Israel to enthrone me, Edward Nathan Schwarz, as King of Israel according to Torah law and I would have absolute rule over the interpretation of all the Holy Writ [Tanak, Gospel, Qur'an] and settle all religious and legal disputes TO EVERYONES BENEFIT AND SATISFACTION. And you can flesh that out with me ahead of time what that settlement would be and see if any side would feel a ruling would not be Just for them or in their interests. What do Palestinians want? No walls surrounding them? They're gone. What do Muslim's want? No apartheid in Jerusalem? Done away with. What do the Rabbis want? A Temple? They'll settle for the Tabernacle. What does Egypt want, what does Jordan want, what does Iran want? The Davidic King, according to ALL their Lore, holds the Lord's power of attorney in Israel's affairs. Except for cases in idolatry, this king can amend the covenant laws at will among other powers. I got plenty of resources to share. Who wants to be my friend? Anybody please tell me, What can I give you that you be my friend? I'll open an office and stock it with Santa's helpers for you to send in your requests. I got resources and "stuff" warehouses busting their seems. I'll bring an oasis to your desert if that is what you need or want - spare no expense. So whoever this is I'm speaking to please forward this plan to concerned parties for consideration and refining if interested. -Cheers
The great Muslim scholar of hadith Imam Bukhari said: "Knowledge is before speech and action" Dr. Peterson, though he is knowledgeable about so many things, he knows very very little about Islamic scriptures and history of Muslims. Far from sufficiency to give the kind of claims he made in this video.
His opinions constantly change as his knowledge is updated. I respect that greatly about him. His earliest views on Islam are drastically different to the point he is at now. He seems to be very sincere about knowledge, and someone who is discussing rather than lecturing
Read Hadith Iman Bukhari to know about how lovely and friendly way Muslim treat no Muslim particularly Jews. And please let us know also how respectful was Islam with other religions like polytheist originally worshiping at Mecca. Where did non Muslim people go , did they remain in Mecca and in Muslim countries ?
@@Sea-qv4sd We captured excellent women for ransom. We decided to have sex with them but by observing 'azl (Withdrawing the male sexual organ before emission of semen to avoid-conception). We asked Allah's Messenger (ﷺ), and he said: It does not matter if you do not do it, for every soul that is to be born up to the Day of Resurrection will be born. Sahih Muslim 1438a
Appreciate the sentiment JP, but i don't get this western misconception that sunnis and shias are sworn eternal enemies. As a sunni Muslim living in the west and has travelled to many Muslim countries in the east, befriended many shia and sunni Muslims, the tension between both groups has been widely blown out of proportion (no pun intended lol). Have sunnis and shias "beefed"? Yes, of course. There have been wars and conflicts that we all know of, I'm sure, but for the majority of time and in most places they have in fact co-existed peacefully. These events are small specs in the time line . Yes, you'll get your certain areas that are dangerous but I'm sorry i need to call a spade a spade! It's no where near as bad as the blood spilled between catholics and protestants. You'll honestly feel a lot more disharmony and tension in the atmosphere in northern Ireland between Catholic and protestants than you would in the majority of the Muslim world!
As an Irishmen I agree, but I feel like hes speaking to the more exteme casses that arent like yourself who are worldly and have had the opportunity to sit and understand. Its the same problem in Ireland as you mentioned. Its not everyone but those that are indoctrinated at a young age and the excuse for behave is "thats how I was raised". Best,
JP is a cunning Zionist supporter who wants the general muslim population to not be hostile towards Israel by normalising relationship with them. Taking Jews and Christians as allies in the fight against feminism liberalism LGBTQIA by compromising on Palestine issue. World is taking a traditional turn but some muslims in the heat of fighting liberalism will directly or indirectly support Zionist agenda
Oh muslims do not follow them into the lizard hole they are saying that they are peacemaker but indeed they are the ones who cause c o r r u p t i o n. He wants normal muslims to not be hostile towards Israel and support the occupation. Didn't you hear him say about Abraham Accord and how we Sunni Shia are responsible for the destabilization of ME. Don't you know how the Zion st s, US along with all European powers invaded muslim lands of Iraq Afghanistan and fuelled the sectarianism. Please watch Muslim Skeptic latest short and Sajid Lipham reacting to this video.
Quran 5 : 51 O believers! Take neither Jews nor Christians as guardians-they are guardians of each other. Whoever does so will be counted as one of them. Surely Allah does not guide the wrongdoing people. - Dr. Mustafa Khattab, the Clear Quran
It’s amazing to see that people who understand where Jordan Peterson is wrong correct him with respect and care that you’d rarely expect online. It’s heartwarming to know that people are willing to give others the benefit of the doubt instead of canceling them right away. I wish it was more common on the internet
"benefit of the doubt" There is no doubt. He join daily mail (ben shapiro). Then tries to lecture on normalizing zionism (abraham accords). There is no doubt. He doesn't give a f.. about understanding Muslims and their problems.
We captured beautiful women for ransom. We decided to have sex with them but by observing 'azl (Withdrawing the male sexual organ before emission of semen to avoid-conception). We asked Allah's Messenger (ﷺ), and he said: It does not matter if you do not do it, for every soul that is to be born up to the Day of Resurrection will be born. Sahih Muslim 1438a
Living in the United States i feel Muslims have been disrespected by a political agenda, specifically after 9/11 . I am Christian, but it was not until i did my own research into the Muslim faith and people did i truly understand and respect what they stood for. I have nothing admiration for the Muslim people and their faith. It is one thing to speak words anyone can do that however, i find that most Muslims practice what they preach. It is their dedication to their Religion and Faith not just by mere words but by their actions such as fasting at certain times of the year. I have never seen more respectful people, even when they disagree, it is done with respect . The world can learn so much from the Muslim people and hopefully one day God willing that will happen for it can only help unite us in this wild world of division we live in today. The media and certain political agendas are the true evil all people of all religions face in my humble opinion, for they are the ones creating the false narratives and dividing us as a people
Burying women up to their necks and throwing volcanic rocks at them until they're dead, because they were raped... so much respect for that! They certainly do practice what they preach. Unfortunately that often comes with casualties!
Theres a reason the Sunni and Shiite wage war. And there is a reason 1 religion in particular has suicide extremists. One side has extreme gender morals and allows abuse toward wives. Yes all the people have value as Gods creations, but Allah is not God and the religion is a satanic deception. The muslim world has painted the image and reputation on the world stage for itself, it had nothing to do with American propaganda.
It's just the fact that a majority of radicals exist in Muslim faith. It makes sense being the biggest religion in the world. All religions have radicals...something about the Muslim faith does seem to breed more though? I do understand that a VAST MAJORITY of Muslims are great people. But there are huge swaths of people who will murder for their religion. Burn a Quran in front of Muslims and you'll find the radicals immediately. Look at what Sweden is going through. They loved the idea of immigrants and bringing immigrants to their country and even providing for them.....one man burns a Quran...and they are ready to burn cities to the ground. It's insane. Immigrants must understand that if you move to a Western country....burning a Quran is legal and everyone has the right to do it. Just as you would have the right to burn a bible or whatever other symbolic thing you want to burn. Learn to live in a world of freedoms....don't bring your stone age ideologies to another country. There's a reason you left those stone age countries behind no?
We appreciate people like you who don’t rush to negatively judge Islam and Muslims without trying to understand, experience, and research first. God bless you. Thank you for your kindness.
Behind every word this Jordan says has an insult towards people who are in reality the Victims! Instead of asking Why do you (Muslims) hate the Jews? Why did White Christian Europeans kill and murder and Torture 6 Million Jews and persecute them for centuries then kick them out of Europe by exterminating Palestinians and replace them by Jews they the White Christian Europeans kicked from Europe. Who is the Monster ?
His message in one sentence: "You should understand the importance of being an individual (rather than being just a member of a group) who can realize what is right and what is not."
WHY: It is very clear that Islamic States are hateful. They need an enemy to justify the brutal treatment of their own people. It's all about hateful domination to think "I have the right and only answer."
@@g1y3 "This man don't have idea of what's he's talking about" Could at the same time mean that it is you who has no idea. He just wants peace, you appearantly not.
I really appreciate your intentions, Dr Peterson. However, I don't think that this message is thought through enough as it is predicated on a few presumptions that are not accurate. First: Muslims and Christians have been living together in relative peace in the Muslim world for decades although one might argue the opposite but I'm telling you this from my experience as an Egyptian Muslim who's got Christian friends and I'm sure I'm not the only one and that it's not a narrow perspective I'm looking from but that's what we grew up on. Second: The differences between Sunnis and Shiites although they're theological in their essence but we reached a phase in Iraq for example before the American invasion where both Sunnis and Shiites actually married from each other and the same applies to Lebanon and Syria. Until the geopolitical game that's started between Iran and Saudi Arabia under the supervision of the west definitely. Third and the most important: your emphasis on the tolerance with the jews implies that you assume that we as Muslims are against the Jewish people themselves, but that's not the case at all. We're against Zionism which happens to be dominantly jews, but again as an Egyptian who's slightly aware of how my grandparents lived, jews used to coexist peacefully in my home city, Alexandria and other cities in Egypt pre -immigration to the Zionist so called country. I'm not by any chance denying the fact that there's a fair amount o Muslims that might be intolerant to other religions and that's why I can see where you're coming from, but that's not the accurate representation of the Muslims all over the world. Lastly: I couldn't thank you enough for teaching me things that I wouldn't have learned and most importantly, you did that honestly and genuinely. Excuse my poor written English.
Your comments is a good one, but your mistake here is thinking that Jordan Peterson has a desire to know the nuances of Muslim sentiment. There are three things going on here, a sort of God complex on Peterson's part of the type that assumes that he can unite the religious under one umbrella. Second is the degeneration of his intellect since his illness caused by his addiction to and use of benzodiazepines - there is a distinct difference in his persona before and after. Lastly, Peterson is in the process of finding a new audience or 'calling' as he sees it in his deluded mind, an audience that will financially support him, since his days in academia and as a public intellectual are well behind him. For these reasons engagement with Peterson or his arguments may be a waste of your time, however, if his followers read your message it may prove useful to them.
If Muslims were Christians or jews friends why do they behead them on national television.....as a matter of fact just a few years ago and muslim man behead a Christian woman in Oklahoma for not denouncing the one true God and turning to the Muslim Allah. I dont think peace has ever been reached in this manner at all. Where you live may be more accepting but your religious beliefs demand that someone who does not accept the muslim Allah as God they must die and that there can and will never be peace between the jew and Muslim. Peace will not happen till the second coming.....when they preach peace and safety surely destruction will follow.
This message felt more like an insult. It started off well by appreciating the muslim audience but it quickly went downhill. I think the tone was a little bit condescending but let's not be oversensitive and focus on the message. By starting with the Abrahamic accords, i guess Dr Peterson confuses between Israel and Zionism with Judaism and Jews. Throughout this message it felt like Dr Peterson has the assumption that muslims are at the origin of the problem and that they're the ones who regard the christians and the jews as enemies. As a matter of fact, all parties lived peacefully together for hundreds of years (let's take my country for example, Morocco, a muslim country where a lot of jews used to live peacefully and actually were protected in many occasions by the King Mohammed V). Muslims do not regard christians and jews as their enemies and the problem is not with communication but rather it is with misrepresentation and the demonization of muslims by the western media making the christians and jews believe that muslims are terrorists and barbaric and that they're trying to kill them etc etc. It would have been better if this message was adressed to all parties and not just lecture the muslims.
Peterson said let's make peace but here you are disregarding the message and inciting a non-peaceful stand. Again less hate and more love. Look within.
After Jordan's battle with health issues he's not just back to full strength, he's coming out swinging, more focused and bold than ever. Absolutely love this man. Dr Peterson, I first discovered you right before my father passed away (lost my mother when I was thirteen) and you gave me the strength to handle everything alone, then write and read a lengthy heartfelt eulogy at the graveside to his friends and family. You helped me through the hardest time of my life and I remain forever grateful. After all the people you've helped and continue to help, you exemplify what it means to live a meaningful life. Sending love and support, always 🫂
@IM+VE I hate to break it to you but the right translation here is 'our Miracles' not 'our verses'. Like saying if you don't believe in the miracles that the prophets have come with from god, don't expect a good ending. Arabic is such a cumbersome language, you really won't get any accurate results with google translate. For example is 'عبس وتولى' this one has another tragic mistranslation story of its own. It might sound demanding but I believe people should learn Arabic first if they wanna learn something meaningful from Muslims and their book.
Dear mr Peterson.... Do you know what purim ceremony in juice is??????? 🥺🥺🥺🥺 PURIM ceremony is the celebration of juice people of sluthering 77000 persian 2500 year a go. Now a day this ceremony celebrate in 21st century within juice people.... Do you think juice people are good one?????
Sir Peterson, I am a Muslim and I do not regard Jews and Christians as my enemy. I believe we should speak up about the atrocities that Zionism and Israel commits on a daily basis. I hope your affiliation with Ben Shapiro will not keep your voice surpressed regarding this issue. I and many other Muslims will like to hear your views regarding this.
If he is going to portend to lecture Muslims on their faults and all but hold them responsible for the current conflicts in a certain part of the world, then Dr. Peterson can and should make a video addressed to Zionists who's ear he has caught as well. And yes, his connection to Shapiro makes me wonder just how objective he actually is on the topic of Israel and Zionism.
@@jeanpaulmichell7243 huge respect for you and as Muslim i don't have any problems with Jew , our problem with Zionists , and we will never be a friend with them not now not ever , we teaching our kids that Palestine was taken by force and we will get by force , with Blood or with Peace , with Zionists logic the US should be rule by native Americans. anyhow am sure my opinion is at least 90% of Muslims.
@@takiyaazrin7562 A girl three years and one day old is betrothed by intercourse. And if a Levir has had intercourse with her, he has acquired her. And one can be liable on her account because of the law prohibiting intercourse with a married woman. And she imparts uncleanness to him who has intercourse with her when she is menstruating, to convey uncleanness to the lower as to the upper layer [of what lies beneath]. If she was married to a priest, she may eat food in the status of priestly rations. If one of those who are unfit for marriage with her had intercourse with her, he has rendered her unfit to marry into the priesthood. If any of those who are forbidden in the Torah to have intercourse with her had intercourse with her, he is put to death on her account, but she is free of responsibility [M.Nid. 5:4]. Sanhedrin 7/55B [132] - Talmud (Jewish book)
As a Muslim I can tell you that the people you describe are not people with a genuine interest in Islam you must Understand they are terrorist using the name Islam to unlawfully violence to pursue their political aim, and at the end who are the victims? J.Peterson I love your dedication to finding the truth and I pray u shall find it.
"As a Muslim..." said the Muslims who bombed the 911 and other places. You are not the gatekeeper of Islam. And, in terms of people killed in the name of Islam, the terrorists are closer to the Prophet PBUH than you are, so are you implying that the Prophet PBUH is not a genuine Muslim?
Dr. Peterson, let me first confirm that you got the attention of many Muslims by this message, but unfortunately with an opposite impact than your intention. your message is full of untruth about Muslims and a lot of typical stereotyping that makes nothing but misleading people who actually don't know anything about Islam and give them a wrong perception about Islam. But as usual I will be hopeful that your message will push some people to go and read more about Islam and come out eventually with a positive outcome. we never hate jews, we hate Zionists who are leading and occupation state (by the definition of the United Nation). we never hate Christians we live peacefully in our countries with Christians and never had this problems. don't impose your idea about us on others and assuming your view is right. you still need to learn more about Muslims, Islam, Islamic history before speaking about Islam in such way. with full respect. Assalamo Alaykom.
Surah 60 ayah 4 Indeed there has been an excellent example for you in Ibrahim and those with him, when they said to their people: "Verily, we are free from you and whatever you worship besides Allah, we have rejected you, and there has started between us and you, hostility and hatred forever until you believe in Allah alone,'' -- except the saying of Ibrahim to his father: "Verily, I will ask forgiveness for you, but I have no power to do anything for you before Allah.'' "Our Lord! In You we put our trust, and to You we turn in repentance, and to You is the final Return.''
It sounds somewhat funny that u talk about truth and history while twisting them quite a bit. Jew, christians and muslims have always been living together in harmony? No. Not today and not in Medieval times. We have enough historical sources which report about progroms. Moreover, the fact alone that the prophet advised to let non-muslims pay a special tax is enough proof that there was some kind of apartheid. And in regards to the occupying of territory: if someone loses a war which he initiated then he has to pay the price for it. Nothing unusual here. And btw, wasnt it muslims who took away Palestine from the Byzantian Empire and since then occupied jewish and christian soil? Improvements start with self reflection and honesty. Please try it.
Be mindful, aware, and cautious of your inner self Mr. Peterson. He who has brought you to fame because of your humbleness and truth seeking can easily take it all away when your intentions change. You yourself said that one of the most things you fear in life is that people NEVER get away with wrongdoing. It always seems to catch up to them. Always !
- Plan to dismantle Israel/Palestinian/Muslim Apartheid, settle all religious disputes, and bring peace to the "Middle East". Plan does not need to be absolute truth nor believed by it's implementors (or the implemented). Can the plan be pulled off with success is what I wish to lay out to you if the above title is a goal you wish to achieve regardless. [They wait for the success of the plan after the fact before they TRULY believe in the plan anyway] The plan is to promote and force the hand of Israel to enthrone me, Edward Nathan Schwarz, as King of Israel according to Torah law and I would have absolute rule over the interpretation of all the Holy Writ [Tanak, Gospel, Qur'an] and settle all religious and legal disputes TO EVERYONES BENEFIT AND SATISFACTION. And you can flesh that out with me ahead of time what that settlement would be and see if any side would feel a ruling would not be Just for them or in their interests. What do Palestinians want? No walls surrounding them? They're gone. What do Muslim's want? No apartheid in Jerusalem? Done away with. What do the Rabbis want? A Temple? They'll settle for the Tabernacle. What does Egypt want, what does Jordan want, what does Iran want? The Davidic King, according to ALL their Lore, holds the Lord's power of attorney in Israel's affairs. Except for cases in idolatry, this king can amend the covenant laws at will among other powers. I got plenty of resources to share. Who wants to be my friend? Anybody please tell me, What can I give you that you be my friend? I'll open an office and stock it with Santa's helpers for you to send in your requests. I got resources and "stuff" warehouses busting their seems. I'll bring an oasis to your desert if that is what you need or want - spare no expense. So whoever this is I'm speaking to please forward this plan to concerned parties for consideration and refining if interested. -Cheers
Lovely content ,Prof! I resonated with this Message, I posit that it will have equal ramifications which are beneficial, on non Muslims, because of the commonality in the Message: An end to Wars, An end to Self righteous beliefs, An end to geopolitical Warfare.. Christians are not exempt from imperfection and Impurity, However i believe that the predominant End of listening to this video is Improving personally, on all frontiers Of Spiritual and Emotional nature,
00:45 "The *Abraham Accords* are a joint statement between the State of Israel, the United Arab Emirates, and the United States, reached on August 13, 2020. Subsequently, the term was used to refer collectively to agreements between Israel and the United Arab Emirates (the Israel-United Arab Emirates normalization agreement) and Bahrain (the Bahrain-Israel normalization agreement)." I loved this video until I understood this reference. I was definitely not ready for this disappointment. P. S. And trust me, dr. Peterson, you would not get a single like or comment of support here from any reasonable Muslim had you mentioned "normalization of relations with Israel" in an explicit manner. No ammount of pacifistic words can cover their crimes. We can and certainly do live in peace with Jews and Christians as a rule (btw, check out the history of Jerusalem and under whose rule did the Jews, Christians and Muslims all live there in peace) - but not with Zlonists. I just can't describe my disappointment at the fact that this came from *you* . Part of my map of meaning is seriously damaged.
It’s human to be wrong sometimes. Muslims aren’t treacherous. Our faith calls for patience and positive interpretations of one’s words. Jordan is misinformed, hope he researches the Muslim faith and world better.
He isn't wrong. There has been century long infighting continued to this day. Just because you live abroad, or in an islamic country that doesn't hate other schools of islam, doesn't mean he's wrong.
We captured excellent women for ransom. We decided to have sex with them but by observing 'azl (Withdrawing the male sexual organ before emission of semen to avoid-conception). We asked Allah's Messenger (ﷺ), and he said: It does not matter if you do not do it, for every soul that is to be born up to the Day of Resurrection will be born. Sahih Muslim 1438a
I am a Sunni muslim, I had an Iraqi Shia friend who wanted to sell his car. He invited me to his house, made me tea, treated me with great hospitality. We rode together in his car for the test drive. He would greet me with a smile whenever we meet down the street.
Humility and humbleness are the key to any belief especially in Islamic faith … We Muslims try our best to follow the guidance of Islam , if I do wrong then I am to blame not my religion…
Depends what you mean by "unite," it is easily to say that common ground can be found but the common ground Peterson uses is superficial whereas what divides us is fundamental. Let's definitely recognize that, agree to see the vital differences for what they are in a manner of mutual respect
Wow, the tone!! The gall to lecture us!! And The Abraham accord?!!!? Well now you’ve shown your true colors. I am glad you said this. An eye opener for those muslims who follow you and listen to you.
I think that this message applies to most religions. I am a Christian and I’ve seen some absolutely awful people who also call themselves christians. People who literally call for violence and even murder against other groups of people. Which is completely the opposite of what Jesus taught. There are extremists on all sides
Quran 2:62 Indeed, those who believed and those who were Jews or Christians or Sabeans - those [among them] who believed in Allāh and the Last Day and did righteousness - will have their reward with their Lord, and no fear will there be concerning them, nor will they grieve إِنَّ ٱلَّذِينَ ءَامَنُوا۟ وَٱلَّذِينَ هَادُوا۟ وَٱلنَّصَٰرَىٰ وَٱلصَّٰبِـِٔينَ مَنْ ءَامَنَ بِٱللَّهِ وَٱلْيَوْمِ ٱلْءَاخِرِ وَعَمِلَ صَٰلِحًا فَلَهُمْ أَجْرُهُمْ عِندَ رَبِّهِمْ وَلَا خَوْفٌ عَلَيْهِمْ وَلَا هُمْ يَحْزَنُونَ
I follow all of your lectures and have watched mostly all your RUclips links, I must say that you have your information incorrect about the enemy. I am a muslim and my best friend is jew he is dying, and I am his carer. Don’t judge people on situations that governments have created. Thank you.
Well it considers them as Kafar. Which even touching non Muslims is prohibited. As someone who was under Islam's influence for most of my age I think Muslims need to be more welcoming to other faith. Not to try inforce their own faith not to try to gain political power. Coexistence is the key. None of the religious are right or wrong. They need to clean old beliefs and just live together.
With all the respect to this channel and its author, there needs to be firstly an argument established that Muslims are fundamentally seeing themselves as enemy's to Jews or fighting to each other and then inviting them to be in peace and respect. I can't see such an argument here and there seems to be a pre-judgement here (if not biased) Also, your facial expression and language is not that kind when compared with your other message to the Christian Churches which shows your discomfort in your message. All the best and trust your goodwill on this.
If I may reply the Quran is clear with regard to your first statement as ' Muslims are fundamentally seeing themselves enemy of the jews' If you are a Muslim and follow the sunnah then would these verses not support the very statement that you are trying to disprove. I ask only because there seems to be a contradiction and if i am wrong please correct context etc Quran : Curse Jews/Christians- Surah 9:29 , 9:30 / Take Jews nor Christians as friends 5:56 / Jews and Christians worse of creatures -98:6 / Jews, Christians turned into apes - 5:60 (64) / Enmity for Christians - 5:14 / Do not befriend nonbelievers-3:28 / Fight unbelievers 9:123 HADITH: Kill Children -Sahih Muslim vol 4 verse 4457 / Kill Jews behind talking stones - Sahih Muslim book 41 6985
@@iluvucuzjesus5347 when you reference a script please use a trusted source as this makes no sense why would god tell us to hate the people of the religions that he sent down. The Quran and the sunnah state that all the people of the book (there are 4 books 1 sent by the prophet David 1 sent by the prophet Moses and 1 sent by the prophet esa or Jesus and 1 sent by the prophet Mohammed) who have a drop of belief in there heart shall enter paradise but god knows best as he will judge us all for our sins on the day of judgment
I taught English as a second language, in England, in a town that had many immigrants from all over Europe plus a well settled Muslim community. I was impressed with the dedication to their religion and their respect paid to me as a teacher and a as white Christian.
As a muslim, we don't hate chirstian, or jews or any race. The problem is there are "zionist" who take some land in Palestine. If Bible is discarded by atheis in trash or toilet, we as muslim Will be angry because there are name of Jesus (our phrophet) and Maria (name of one surah in Al Qur'an) being disrespectful.
Plan to dismantle Israel/Palestinian/Muslim Apartheid, settle all religious disputes, and bring peace to the "Middle East". Plan does not need to be absolute truth nor believed by it's implementors (or the implemented). Can the plan be pulled off with success is what I wish to lay out to you if the above title is a goal you wish to achieve regardless. [They wait for the success of the plan after the fact before they TRULY believe in the plan anyway] The plan is to promote and force the hand of Israel to enthrone me, Edward Nathan Schwarz, as King of Israel according to Torah law and I would have absolute rule over the interpretation of all the Holy Writ [Tanak, Gospel, Qur'an] and settle all religious and legal disputes TO EVERYONES BENEFIT AND SATISFACTION. And you can flesh that out with me ahead of time what that settlement would be and see if any side would feel a ruling would not be Just for them or in their interests. What do Palestinians want? No walls surrounding them? They're gone. What do Muslim's want? No apartheid in Jerusalem? Done away with. What do the Rabbis want? A Temple? They'll settle for the Tabernacle. What does Egypt want, what does Jordan want, what does Iran want? The Davidic King, according to ALL their Lore, holds the Lord's power of attorney in Israel's affairs. Except for cases in idolatry, this king can amend the covenant laws at will among other powers. I got plenty of resources to share. Who wants to be my friend? Anybody please tell me, What can I give you that you be my friend? I'll open an office and stock it with Santa's helpers for you to send in your requests. I got resources and "stuff" warehouses busting their seems. I'll bring an oasis to your desert if that is what you need or want - spare no expense. So whoever this is I'm speaking to please forward this plan to concerned parties for consideration and refining if interested. -Cheers
A muslim living and working in Japan. Like not I am bullied or stuff, but being critized or thought to be weird by my not being promiscuous and waiting for marriage to have sex, and felt lonely of not being understood, this massage, just hit right into the heart. The Japanese, really does respectful and they actually respect religious rules of others, but still, they subtly or explicitly blame religion for group conflicts, and advertising atheism as the right way to be individualistic. Me here just to be not understood can came with huge sadness sometimes. But your message, searching for satan inside yourself, being the light and being the example by your actions, was what I had as a stance for like 15 years(I am 31) as a stance of life. You should show what you are and strive for good, and be good example, so people will admire your thoughts. I could not even think whether there is more wonderful service to your religion and your society, given you believe truthfully to your religion and consider it to be righteous.But, it is not that my/your religion just have the good people. We should compete for goodness both inside our religions, and across religions, so we can just be an example to "Nah, not all of them are bad / useless / satanistic / terrorist. I know a brilliant/kind guy from that religion", and it would be huge. That was what I have always thought, do my best to follow rules of religion, try to understand why they are there(so I would not be blinded or ignorant), and apply them to my life as much as I can (or at least strive for it). And I thought that everyone must have the equality of opportunity, after then (whether religious or ideological) the truly good beliefs will shine through. And I thought we must give it to all that opportunity, and so people would strive and lift up themselves, and would make their society better. And I am working toward that goal in work, not that it gone a long way yet though, trying to make education better and cheaper, while being with truly different ideologies in the company, the mission of better and cheaper for everyone is the same Still, I was lonely of not being understood on some part, especially on theological front that my religion being center of my life rather than it being some "(minor) tradition", so, your beautiful words, and they are directed to Muslims, I just thought I wouldn't cry, but it made me cry (even I had tears writing this). Just there is someone, at the other side of globe, whom I respect, believing (or acting accordingly to) another religion saying the almost same thing, just got me in the heart. Thank you Peterson. Thank you Dr. Jordan. PS. I have took your personality tests and occasionally watched your lectures in 2019, more intensely this year, and had many agreements. I am not taken your self-authoring course (yet?), but I am also trying to write my fears / shortcomings of now and past, and long/medium/short term future goals and analyze them to get my shit together, which the concept of your course inspired me to do. I am somehow autistic ( not diagnosed but less like ADHD and more like asperger maybe?) and still got over its shortcomings, I can relate to your ideas on the wokeness front as well, similar to the religious/ideology front, I think people should get their shit together if they can (instead of self-victimazing) to represent their group better while keeping individuality. And society should focus on those who cannot do that because of poverty/(real) disability.
WHY: It is very clear that Islamic States are hateful. They need an enemy to justify the brutal treatment of their own people. It's all about hateful domination to think "I have the right and only answer."
Hello Dr Peterson, I’ve been following your work for years now (since 2015, I believe), and your lessons helped me process and go through a lot of challenges I had in life. However, I’m disappointed by how shallow and presumptuous this video was. I’m a Palestinian, and as a young adult, I faced many challenges in gaining the right to exist and work anywhere in the world. Those challenges fundamentally stemmed from Palestine’s impossible human conditions and the ongoing illegal occupation of our people. In many ways, I’m much luckier and more privileged than many Palestinians who have their houses demolished, freedom stolen, and lives taken every single day by the Israeli government and army. Our problem was never with Judaism or its people but rather the inhumane practices and attitudes of Zionism. I’m doing much better now, earning enough to sustain myself and help my family, and I can pursue what’s meaningful. Your books and lectures influenced me to reach this state. So thank you. Finally, while I’ll be the first to criticise the Muslim world, your critique has come off as misinformed and shallow. Consider learning more about the subject matter from its people. Perhaps you could form a pen pal partnership with someone from Palestine? That ought to give you a glimpse into the reality there and might give you an insight that many westerners don't have.
Nah brah, you just haven't cleaned your room well enough. When you do, you'll understand that JP knows more about palestinians than you do. Otherwise, an educated person like JP would know what he doesn't know. They were wrong when they said he's uninformed around marxism, they were wrong when they said he's uninformed around gender, they were wrong when they said he's uninformed around feminism. Bashar, let me be the first to tell you that you too are just woke. You just need a penpall.
--Plan to dismantle Israel/Palestinian/Muslim Apartheid, settle all religious disputes, and bring peace to the "Middle East". Plan does not need to be absolute truth nor believed by it's implementors (or the implemented). Can the plan be pulled off with success is what I wish to lay out to you if the above title is a goal you wish to achieve regardless. [They wait for the success of the plan after the fact before they TRULY believe in the plan anyway] The plan is to promote and force the hand of Israel to enthrone me, Edward Nathan Schwarz, as King of Israel according to Torah law and I would have absolute rule over the interpretation of all the Holy Writ [Tanak, Gospel, Qur'an] and settle all religious and legal disputes TO EVERYONES BENEFIT AND SATISFACTION. And you can flesh that out with me ahead of time what that settlement would be and see if any side would feel a ruling would not be Just for them or in their interests. What do Palestinians want? No walls surrounding them? They're gone. What do Muslim's want? No apartheid in Jerusalem? Done away with. What do the Rabbis want? A Temple? They'll settle for the Tabernacle. What does Egypt want, what does Jordan want, what does Iran want? The Davidic King, according to ALL their Lore, holds the Lord's power of attorney in Israel's affairs. Except for cases in idolatry, this king can amend the covenant laws at will among other powers. I got plenty of resources to share. Who wants to be my friend? Anybody please tell me, What can I give you that you be my friend? I'll open an office and stock it with Santa's helpers for you to send in your requests. I got resources and "stuff" warehouses busting their seems. I'll bring an oasis to your desert if that is what you need or want - spare no expense. So whoever this is I'm speaking to please forward this plan to concerned parties for consideration and refining if interested. -Cheers
We don't see other religions as enemies, you live in same planet and you know that almost all of others see us as enemies, it's better if you switch this message, with all respect
sometimes it can be hard to see things objectively. but no other religion propagates and promotes their religion in the manner Muslims do. you people have jihad for Gods sake. but he is saying that everyone including Christians and Muslims should be at peace. if you cant understand that then im sorry the message flew over your head.
@@justiceegwabor3218 please look up what "Jihad" means, not literally but conceptually in Islam, before making such comments. Jihad is not war in the name of god, it is struggle and work in the name of god. Even picking up litter and throwing it into the trash bin could be considered jihad, if you truly do it because you know that god wants you to do the right things. What those terror organisations do is a perversion of the word, and in no way, shape or form has to do anything with what Islam is about. What you are doing is taking a tiny radical minority and projecting their ideals to the general Muslim population, which is just plain wrong.
@@justiceegwabor3218 It look like you are the one with short neck and the message flew over your head. All the issues nowadays that Muslims countries suffer from are from countries that believe in Christianity starting from Afghanistan, Iraq, Syria, Libya and most Africa. Christians killed more Muslims throughout history. and by the way, Jihad came useful when Muslims fought and defeated crusaders and Mughals. Muslims will never stop Jihad against all enemies especially Christians and Jews until they kicked them out of their lands.
Why someone like you a well read person suddenly doesn’t appear to be well read about islam ?! why you want to paint this picture of us almost like an isolated society and we hate everybody (according to you) it’s actually sad to see someone like you doing this, i lost respect for this man
Me too bro, what he do is false imagery. Sorry bro that I recommending Jordan Peterson to some muslim community All this time just to watch his arrogance together
I am a Sunni Muslim and have 12 siblings who are Sunni Muslim as well. The youngest is 28, and not one of us hold any form of animosity towards Shia’s. It’s never crossed our minds. I’ve prayed beside Shia’s growing up, studied with them during “bible school” and still hold friendships with people of Shia faith. What in the hell is this man talking about? 😂😂😂 Edit - To all my Muslim brothers and sisters, am I ignorant to think that Shia’s and Sunni’s are not at war with one another?
I’m a Shia muslim who lives in Saudi Arabia and I have many friends who are Sunni and we live in harmony like our ancestors did at least in my city. and I believe the majority of the muslim world have nothing but love and respect to our Fellow people of the book, both christians and jews and respect to our fellow humans of all other religions. the majority of muslims don’t have a problem with Jews at all in fact we share more with them in term of linguistic and religion than any other people. our problem is with Zionism and occupation only.
Mr peterson doesn not really KNOW the muslim world. May be he never experience it in real muslim world. I mean he never travel or stay in muslim country for some months atleast and see what truly happened. I am a sunni muslim. May Allah bless us all.. Aamiin. 💕
The jews having a nation and land is okay. If Muslims and Christians and Atheist in China and Russia can own land. Buddhist and shinto can own land and a soverign nation why canr they?
@@dantesinferno373 the problem is that I can't take your house and divide it to two uneven parts and say I should own a house because everyone one has one what about the owner ?🤣
As a Muslim, I like some of the topics Jordan speaks about. However, after all the interviews you had with Muslims, you never tried to even understand our religion. You spout things like Shia and Sunni Muslims fighting each other, yet you don't know why either term exists or who each sect is. Also, you are blaming Muslims and claiming we hate Christians and Jews, yet it's your Christian and Jewish governments brainwashing your people into hating Muslims and instigating fights against them since the times of Romans. How about you read some religious history, our brother Hamza Yusef told you in an interview, yet you didnt listen to him. You need to always remember, that your governments have always been the oppressors in most cases through out history. Muslims brought knowledge and ethics into your degraded cultures during the European dark ages, you took it, denied it ever came from us, and now, you are doing the same thing. You are denying Muslims by your worthless words of how we should be with Christians, Jews or with each other. Yes, Muslims fight each other sometimes, but we never caused a world war. Christians caused 2 world wars already, and on the verge of a 3rd world war, yet you want to preach Muslims philosphical non sense about clearing hate? What a contradiction. We all saw the hate and racism towards Muslims when they migrated to Europe during the wars which Christian and Jewish governments caused in the Middle East, but when Ukranians migrated because of the wars you caused, you welcomed them with open hands. Our authority in life comes from the one only, and that is, Allah all mighty. We listen to what Alllah tells us in the Quran, and what our Prophet Muhammad peace be upon him tells us, not you, or anyone else in this world for that matter. We know who our enemies are while you don't. Allah told us in the Quran (Surah 5 Al-Ma'idah, Ayat 82-85) that Jews and polytheists hate the Muslims the most, so we will always be on guard with them, while Christians are the most friendly, so we have no issues with Christians. Also, we know about the fight against ourselves, Allah already told us in the Quran, old news. Jordan, if you actually read the Quran you would know, but you haven't obviously, you show no sign of any respect to Muslims, you read books about LGBT stuff yet you never tried to read and understand the Quran. So contradicting. Also, in general, most Christians and Jews will never accept Islam, Allah all mighty told us in the Quran in Surat al Baqara verse 120. We understand Christians and Jews more than you understand us. And it's your governments wrekcing havoc in the Muslims countries by placing dictator hypocrite butchers in our countries because Allah all mighty gave your countries science and military ability. This is all a test to see what you do with it. Your governments corrupt the earth and skies with your technologies, steal resources from other countries, kill the planet, kill the people, and then you want to give us a lecture about making peace with ourselves? You dont even understand the basics of peace. Soon enough, your countries will pay for what they did, and every oppressor will pay for what they did in this life or the next. Your words have no effect on educated Muslims. To my Muslims brother and sisters, don't be flattered with his words, becareful, this person doesn't care about Muslims, heed my warning. If he did, he would not say these things to us after all the interviews he did with Muslims. It seems that Jordan is part of the propaganda to unite Christians Jews and Muslims under the new movement of Abarahamic religion, which is utter non sense. I had my doubts about Jordan and now this is it. No more trust, unsubscribe. To my fellow Christians, what I wrote is not because of any hate towards you, these are the realities of your governments, and if you study and research about the topics I spoke about, you will find the truth. I live and work in America, I find Christian Americans to be very nice people. I don't want war against anyone, but I won't be quiet and will fight anyone who tries to attack our religion, insult us, and act as a hypocrite authority to Muslims like you Jordan. You as Christians need to figure out the truth about your own governments, we already know about our corrupt governments in the Muslim world and are fighting to fix it. A true Muslim never has any issue with establishing peace with anyone offering it.
What actually troubles me is the fact that Mr.Peterson you just said that, and I quote, “I have developed an audience in the muslim world” and “the comments from the muslim watchers and listeners to my RUclips channel and podcast have been extraordinarily positive” then you go on to say we refuse to affiliate ourselves with anything or anyone who isn’t adherent to the religion of Islam or even go as far to say that we consider them our enemies. And that is just a tad bit contradicting don’t you think.
It doesn't necessarily contradict, he states that there was a positive response from people from the Muslim community *that watched the video* , he did not refer to the whole community. This is about different people, while you could argue that the generalisation of the Muslil community is not fair to make, it is the general impression witch gives these claims their own right.
@@DamianForReal perhaps… visit a Muslim-majority country first? Generally speaking, have you noticed that literally everything that does not come from the west is demonized by the media in a propaganda campaign? ( black people. Migrants, foreigners, non-western religions, other countries, indigenous…literally EVERYTHING). That just can’t be true. Misinformation allow the west to keep its hegemony. Based on the media narrative “good” can only come from the west. When it comes to “others” it should be bad. Its like “I am good and anybody else can be nothing but bad”. The only way to get out of the propaganda bubble is to travel and see the world with your very eyes.
@@princessfanta8247 I'm sorry that to bring it to you but I actually got my impressions and opinions from other Muslims, some of my friends are (not radical) but the most I encounter on a day to day basis is unhuman to me. Even they say what others do is bs. I won't go on a rant because I am convinced that they do not represent Islam as they say they do. And *not everyone is the same*, that is why there can be "contradicting" statement over certain groups because generalisation of groups is human nature to understand the word, subconsciously or consciously, it is part of being a human. How bad or good a perception might be can be influenced by 1 what othet people say (media politics etc) or 2 individual encounters (what my opinion is based on)
@@DamianForReal The point of his video or “message” was to advise us to not limit our interconnections to muslims only and to be more open to interacting with ppl outside the muslim community. You can rewatch the video if you didn’t exactly understand his “message”. Anyways it’s fine to have the impression that muslims do not affiliate themselves with ppl of different faiths bcuz of what’s portrayed by the media. But it’s another thing when you have a platform and tou see many muslims supporting you specifically despite not being a muslim yourself. So you become aware that the impression you had was false bcuz here you are as a non Muslim but yet gaining a lot of appreciation from their community. So Clearly stating that and then negating the statement by advising muslims against what he confirmed himself in the beginning of the video to be false is indeed very contradicting.
I'm one of the Muslim fans of Dr Peterson who's been following him for several yrs now. I usually find his opinions and views brilliant because of all the research and wisdom that goes into every sentence he speaks. This time, however, I do believe Dr Peterson's views lack research and some are downright baseless ideas that it seems he's observed superficially. These are issues that have deep, deep roots and are extremely complex. Like another viewer pointed out, you cannot ask Ukrainians to seek harmony with Russians just because that's a nice thing to do. The matter is much worse than an ego battle of two tribes. And like another viewer pointed out, sunni and shias live in harmony. I have many shia friends and know of many other sunnis who have close friendships with shias. We look at each other as brethren, not outsiders or disbelievers. It's only when there are actual miscreants seeking to create political disruption that trouble arises. With all due respect, I suggest you read more about the history of Palestine and the birth of Zionism in the 1940s. That explains our hurt and pain more than anything anyone says.
I remember I had a shia muslim friend in our school in Turkey. And we were respecting her beliefs about the religion. So we are not in a fight against people with different beliefs. West media is just such manipulative against us.
Dr Peterson, I’ve been a supporter of yours for years and I am a Muslim revert as well. I found the tone and message in this video to be off putting and seems as if there are some things unclear to you about Muslims. There is a gracious response from one of our brothers by the name of saajid lipham that you should probably review carefully. Would love to hear you explain where this message is coming from on another video with Mohammed Hijab. I think he’s able to handle the complexities of this topic very well with you. Please continue seeking clarity on this topic as this is clearly not it. Wish you well. Take care.
Have you seen all the response videos? I'd like you rank your feelings and thoights about each fro which uou think is best and why to least good, anyone can do this and please reply back here and let me know.
That's it, just like other intellectuals JP decided that he can instruct anyone on any issue. Too bad, 'cause it's no less ridiculous than other academics who are not aware of their limitations and simply lack of understanding of the issue at hand.
I actually think he has a point. You do not at all see Muslims joining hands with other religions to fight against common issues, such as transgenderism. That is his main point. We fight these issues alone and/or within our own Muslim communities. In addition, no....there are issues between Sunnis and Shiates for SURE...rooted in history and differences in the faith itself. HOWEVER, we do, indeed, have an issue with accepting the other completely when again, it comes to common schools of thought, and I think that it's due to a general lack of unity amongst the Muslim ummah. You see a divide among the community now for such topics as the hijab, the Sunnah, dress code, manners, etc. So essentially, I agree with Jordan B. Peterson because we DO have these issues, and people just don't like acknowledging the truth 🤷♀️
How do you go from "abandon ideology" to "support zionism"? I just can't get over this. (For anyone who doesn't know what Abraham accords - 0:45 - are, look it up.) So many times I've been filled with respect, love and compassion for you, dr. Peterson, while listening to your lectures and talks. I was one of those who kept excusing your misstatements about Islam, claiming that you simply don't know better but are well-intentioned. But how naive can you really be? How far with that "not obvious" BS can you go? How much more people need to be killed or expelled from their homes for so called country that didn't even exist 80 years ago, for you to understand that Muslims are not the problem there? Or are you completely aware of everything that was and is being done in the name of Israel and knowingly support it? I just cant reconcile that with that old psychology professor whose lectures, ideas and character I enjoyed so much. You can easily see from this comment section that Muslims genuinely want to see the good will in non-Muslims and always welcome that. I myself also liked this video until I realized that you didn't really mean "Jews" but "Zionists". I'm sure that none of those Muslims who wrote positive comments are aware of what exactly you suggested there. Not sure what's going on with you lately, but if after everything you've been preaching for decades, you drift into some deadly ideologies, just like that ... I'd argue that even you wouldn't recognize yourself anymore, let alone we who used to have so much respect for you. How I wish that you fix this somehow. May Allah protect us all from evil, and from supporting evil.
"The *Abraham Accords* are a joint statement between the State of Israel, the United Arab Emirates, and the United States, reached on August 13, 2020. Subsequently, the term was used to refer collectively to agreements between Israel and the United Arab Emirates (the Israel-United Arab Emirates normalization agreement) and Bahrain (the Bahrain-Israel normalization agreement)."
"Angels on Earth -- Love Letter to Lily", Asra Nomani, YT. Well worth checking out. This brave and dignified Muslim woman could teach you how to become open-minded. May Allah protect us all from evil, and from supporting evil.
@@fieldmarshal7081 I don't know how familiar you are with his yt content. I was listening to his university lectures on "Maps of meaning", and later many of his interviews and talks. I had a strong impression that he is genuinely seeking to understand the truth about the existence, and as you probably know many of his stances were (are) completely in line with Islam. He managed to understand that there can not possibly be clash between the religious truth and the scientific truth, which I think is not that simple for someone who is raised in an enviroment that it seriously opposed to that idea. I think he has kind of "prophetic conscience", i.e. he really feels the urge to act out his beliefs. And he did stand up for his beliefs against one of the strongest lobbies of our time, and continues to do so. Listening to those lectures from psychology, I thought that he had developed extraordinary coherent worldview, given the fact that he *didn't* refer to the authentic God's revelation, the Qurʾān. (I wasn't and I'm not approving his worldview in its totality, just trying to say that it's impressive that he managed to make sense of many things, many big questions of life and existence in general, that bothered him, and then articulate all that in a way that can be really helpful for orienting oneself in everyday life.) Also, much can be learned from his familial relationships. Those are some things that come to my mind now. But as he started to engage in conversations with Muslims, and continued to fail to really understand the simple message of Islam, I started to think that the time and effort he invested into building his worldview is preventing him to see or truly appreciate anything that might damage it, or anything that would require him to make any serious adjustment to his philosophy. Which is obviously extremely ironical, considering his own teachings. Still, there are many amazing things about him; I can't just dispense it all away. I just don't know what to make of this now. It's hard for me to believe that he could suggest that we make peace with israel while actually understanding what's going on with Palestinians. But if he's really aware of everything, that's really devastating, since many of us used to see him as a voice of healthy reasoning. But anyway, if that was all just an illusion, it's definitely better off broken.
no one have to find a middle way. as we dont need a middle way. we, muslims are not enemies of anyone. if a muslim needs a middle way, we can find it with our neighbours, relatives etc. This, what you said about told by a terrorist group by ending fighting with its own people.
As a muslim, majority of us dont hate anyone based on their religion, yet only on their hate action toward us Muslims . Also As a Muslim i respect you regardless of your religious beliefs, because i see you to be a man of God, a free thinker, & a non hypocrite & an overall a good human being
Why should God let you into Heaven? Have you lied (even once in your entire life), looked with lust (sexual desire), dishonoured parents, stolen anything, had hatred towards someone, had premarital sex, adultery etc If you answered yes to any one of the above then you are a sinner like the rest of us. So, I ask you again, why should God let a sinner into Heaven? Sinners don’t go to heaven they go to hell, But we are blessed to have Jesus (God incarnate) die on the Cross and rise from the dead. If you Repent (forsake your sinful, unholy ways and live righteous instead) & Believe in Jesus as God, you will be seen as a Saint and welcomed into Heaven. John 3:17 For God did not send His Son into the world to condemn the world, but that the world through Him might be saved
@@thereisnonegoodbutgodjohn363 People have different believe. And each believe their religion is right. So,it's useless for you to ask us why God would let us to heaven. I ask which GOD? Yours or mine? For there is only one GOD. وَٱلَّذِينَ ءَامَنُوا۟ وَعَمِلُوا۟ ٱلصَّـٰلِحَـٰتِ سَنُدْخِلُهُمْ جَنَّـٰتٍۢ تَجْرِى مِن تَحْتِهَا ٱلْأَنْهَـٰرُ خَـٰلِدِينَ فِيهَآ أَبَدًۭا ۖ وَعْدَ ٱللَّهِ حَقًّۭا ۚ وَمَنْ أَصْدَقُ مِنَ ٱللَّهِ قِيلًۭا ١٢٢ And those who believe and do good, We will soon admit them into Gardens under which rivers flow, to stay there for ever and ever. Allah’s promise is ˹always˺ true. And whose word is more truthful than Allah’s? (An-nisa verse 122) And also as a Muslim, I ask the same question that you asked my brethren. Why Allah should let you into heaven? وَٱلَّذِينَ كَفَرُوا۟ لَهُمْ نَارُ جَهَنَّمَ لَا يُقْضَىٰ عَلَيْهِمْ فَيَمُوتُوا۟ وَلَا يُخَفَّفُ عَنْهُم مِّنْ عَذَابِهَا ۚ كَذَٰلِكَ نَجْزِى كُلَّ كَفُورٍۢ ٣٦ As for the disbelievers, they will have the Fire of Hell, where they will not be ˹allowed to be˺ finished by death, nor will its torment be lightened for them. This is how We reward every ˹stubborn˺ disbeliever. Thank you.
@@thereisnonegoodbutgodjohn363 1st ayah in Quran : in name of Allah . The most merciful. We enter paradise not cuz of our doings , but cuz of his MERCY .
I've heard this phrase" a majority of Muslims don't hate" based on what data do you make this statement? Maybe it's only 49%, or 40% or 15% ? Would you concede 10% of all Muslims hate based on religious differences, and envy.. I'm not trying to construe that Dr Peterson's comments toward Muslims' imply a majority of Muslims hate other" Muslims. I don't have too ,apparently its a big enough problem for him to comment on it.. What is the percentage,, you don't know, and I don't know. So what do you base your hate on? Politics? I am dubious about the level of acceptance in the majority of Muslims and people in general. The problem is Islam and many sects seek the destruction of those that are different from themselves.
@@jeffs7915 yes, I think all religion or belief is subjected to that notion. But you can say also, not all the followers of that religion or belief done so either. And to support my brethren opinion, muslim and all religion teach peace, and the majority of followers hold to that idea. If not, God forsake, there will be another crusade, or another holocaust, or another world war. And why do we have to percent majority? What's the purpose? To know? It's clearly visible to our eyes. What I'm saying is not everything have to be calculated in numbers. I'm sorry if I'm wrong. Thank you
I like and respect Dr. Peterson. A lot. He is one of the greatest intellectuals alive today, and his talks have helped me immensely. However, I agree with the majority of the comments on this video. I will tell you that I am an Orthodox Christian, so you will understand my perspective as a non-Muslim. Dr. Peterson fails to account for the role of Zionists in the modern-day animosity between Jews and Muslims. It is true that Jews were persecuted horribly during World War II, but I do not see how this entitles them to their own ethnostate formed by forcibly ejecting other people from their lands. There were many millions of people persecuted horribly during the 20th century, and one could argue that Jews represent a minority of that number. Do all the other victims deserve their own ethnostate, too? Dr. Peterson recently released a video, Butchers and Liars Reprise, where he gives examples of the Left and Right taking their ideologies too far. In the case of the Right, he says trying to form your own ethnostate would be an example of going too far. Why are the actions of the Zionists not going too far? I am careful to call out Zionists specifically and not Jews in general as we know that there are places around the world where Muslims, Christians and Jews are able to peacefully and respectfully coexist. I feel that Dr. Peterson’s recent affiliation with Daily Wire prevents him from properly addressing this topic. I am not egotistical in my opinions, so I invite any and all criticism of what I just wrote.
Thank you for your kind words. I read it all. And I agree with most if not all of what you say. Followup question, is Daily Wire a Zionist funded organization by any chance? That would explain why JP would post such a One World Order “come let’s go to heaven together” message.
I actually agree with you on most of your points. For context, I am a middle-eastern muslim and I never had any problem with jews. We have never been taught to hate jews. Our only issue is with zionists who wrongfully invaded a country of ours and dragged our brothers out of it. Not only, muslims, there are even jews who stand against zionism. I've been following Dr Peterson for quite a while now and I agree with much of what he says and the reason for that is the fact that he is a man of science who says nothing without a scientific proof. He has never been ignorant, but in this video, unfortunately he is. I haven't even started to talk about all the obstacles muslims are facing everywhere.
Thanks this is just awesome. As a Palestinian my father had to leave and I was born elsewhere, am over 30 now and I have never seen what I call my hometown! It's not nice to live as a Palestinian
“The best place to find Satan is within” ! Absolutely POWERFUL! This line applies to us ALL! We have the choice to do good or to do evil. Be a warrior of light and peace 💛
Very well said. No matter how rich or poor, no matter the color of our skin or social standing, we all have a choice between committing acts of good or evil in every aspect of our lives.
Divisions are sustainable only by the hatred that comes from exceptionalism which depends on division. ~ VF Luvall Reach across the sectarian divide. ~ JB Peterson Jordan's statement is what our political divides should heed.
Satan is another word for "insecurity," it's most potent within ideologies and that is why they cling so rigidly to colloquial phrasing and script of whatever "ideology" or "political affiliation" they believe "needs them." Satan~insecurity is within us when we stray from observing the present moment rather than our emotions as they invariably guide our imagination into the darkest of places.
My sheer existence debunks your entire shia and sunni point Mr Peterson. My mother's side of the family is majority shia and my dad's side is majority sunni, and in general we don't fight each other and we have no segregation with each other, we co exist peacefully, we are Muslims above all else.
The “Abraham Accords” didn’t lead to any sort of peace whatsoever. Those countries were already at peace with Israel, all they did was officially make their ties public. In fact, they divided the Muslim world and normalized violence against Palestinians.
It meant that Israelis could (1) travel on their Israeli passports (2) directly from Israel to these countries instead of jumping through hoops on both counts. When you consider that Malaysian passports have printed on the inside 'This passport is valid for all countries except Israel,' this is not nothing. In fact I would say it's a pretty good start. It helped break the stigma that if you are Mulsim you have to be against Israel's existence. No doubt Trump would have done more if he had more time.
I wonder if JP and you would say the same thing about breaking the stigma and peacemaking with the Axis Powers during ww2. Israeli occupation is a symbol of hate and murder and no ornate speech is going to change that. Despite current events, Palestinian and Muslim blood is not cheap.
@@asherisraeli3715 Oy vey, that's some esoteric nonsense, Mr. J. There will always be people that will never forget the crimes. You want people to sing Kumbaya while the split blood is still wet?
Dear Dr.Peterson we never considered the Jew as our enemy, matter of fact our prophet did trade with Jews and had commercial and non commercial relations with them. Our problem with Israel and Zionism policies and with all what it present from discrimination and racism against Palestinian ( Muslim & Christine). We are not antisemite because simply we are Semite as well!! Thank you for you enlightening videos.
Really??? 😂 Get real... *@-JP,* Well, what you dont realize is what you said lies at the very core of the materialist soulless secular liberal individualist exclusive fascist western civilization, that kills the soul of man & the humanity in/of man, against which Russia is now fighting in Ukraine, & rightly so. In other words, *its that despicable* *western feeling of superiority at the* *very core of modernity &* *"enlightenment" thats* *THE main source of all trouble.* When you consider yourself & your culture, religion....superior (what a joke) to the rest of humanity to the point that you impose your liberal fascist ideology on the whole planet as if it is *the one* *& only universal truth, while it has* *been just the product of your local historic cultural socioeconomic... Eurocentric circumstances, then you're looking for extinction, for a nuclear armageddon as the current events are showing....
@@KrwiomoczBogurodzicy What do you mean, you idiot??? Didnt you know that jews were treated under muslims much better than anywhereelse?, when your ancestors used to be persecuted everywhere in medieval Europe, killed in pogroms, burned at the stake under the (Spanish) inquisition, expelled from Spain, England...converted to christianity with force...you name it....& all that culminated in the holocaust in ...Europe, not in Japan lol, & by Europeans nazis & others... and then Palestinians had to pay for all that, while they had nothing to do with any of that, by witnessing their land taken from them, their property, lives....The jewish problem wad mainly a European problem....Get real, you ignorant fool.
@@KrwiomoczBogurodzicy antisemitism was always a christian thing, muslims always welcomed jews in their land when they were fleeing persecution. which eventually the zionists took advantage of to create israel.
As a Muslim and a fan of yours, I must say that I’m kind of disappointed. There is no doubt in my mind that your message was out of good will, but you got some things wrong. First of all, this sort of message, a pacifistic one, should not be towards Muslims only, but also towards Jews and Christians. Yes, you also mentioned them in the video, but the title is only towards Muslims. Then there is a big difference between Jews and Zionists. A Jew and a Muslim could live together in peace, and neither should hate the other, but that is not the case with Zionists. We as the Muslim Ummah do not have any hate towards a regular Jew, but this is not the same for Zionists, as the latter only aims and strives to achieve the Great Middle East - Project. Last but not least, Sunnis and Shias are not killing each other on the streets. We do live peacefully, and their whole difference dates back more than a thousand years back. This is my message to Muslims: Instead of trying to unite with Christians and Jews, we should first unite with ourselves. This does not mean that we have to be intolerant towards them. Iraq, Syria, Yemen, Libya, Palestine, Afghanistan.. all of these beautiful Islamic countries have been ruined, because we as a Ummah failed to come together when outside forces invaded our homelands.
Stop lying and using taqiyah . Koran teaches to never be friends with Christens or Jews and to kill them sura 9:29 9:5 5:51, ... The fruit of islam is wicked " you know them by their fruits" the Lord says.
@@AA123TD Unfortunatly in that united muslim ummah as you know there is little room for other religions without a tax or subjugation, We can see in many Muslim countries Christians can not build churches are accused of blasphemy and killed . I say this to start a conversation not an argument
its your quran and hadith that teach muhamadans to kill and enslave and humiliate Christians and Jews with jizyah, and claims Jews and Christians are worst of creatures and allow rape of captive women, and allow rape of prepubesent girls. not the Old Testament nor New Testament. If you dont believe those things and think they are wrong, then you are not consistent with your religion's teachings.
My friend regardless of what he said you should understand and get the message and truly we should listen to it and stop our disagreements and fighting. Sunnies and shia are killing each other taliban is a prime example, and syria and Iraq, and soon Saudi Arabia maybe you are from a country where that's not the problem but other countries are having big issues with this, believe i have lived it and seen it and it's just mindless hatred of their own muslim brothers
Glory to Almighty Allah, the Lord of heaven and earth, encompassing infinite mercy and wisdom. Praise be to: 1. The Beneficent 2. The Merciful 3. The Eternal Lord 4. The Most Sacred 5. The embodiment of Peace 6. The Infuser of Faith 7. The Preserver of Safety 8. All Mighty 9. The Compeller, The Restorer 10. The Supreme, The Majestic 11. The Creator, The Maker 12. The Evolver 13. The Fashioner 14. The Great Forgiver 15. The all-prevailing One 16. The Supreme Bestower 17. The Provider 18. The Supreme Solver 19. The All-Knowing 20. The Withholder 21. The Extender 22. The Reducer 23. The Exalter, The Elevator 24. The Honourer, The Bestower 25. The Dishonourer, The Humiliator 26. The All-Hearing 27. The All-Seeing 28. The Impartial Judge 29. The Utterly Just 30. The Subtle One, The Most Gentle 31. The All-Aware 32. The Most Forbearing 33. The Magnificent, The Supreme 34. The All-Forgiving 35. The Most Appreciative 36. The Highest, The Exalted 37. The All-Heedful and All-Protecting 38. The Preserver 39. The Sustainer 40. The Reckoner 41. The Majestic 42. The Most Generous, The Most Esteemed 43. The Watchful 44. The Responsive One 45. The All-Encompassing, the Boundless 46. The All-Wise 47. The Most Loving 48. The Glorious, The Most Honorable 49. The Infuser of New Life 50. The All Observing Witnessing 51. The Absolute Truth 52. The Trustee, The Disposer of Affairs 53. The All-Strong 54. The Firm, The Steadfast 55. The Protecting Associate 56. The Praiseworthy 57. The All-Enumerating, The Counter 58. The Originator, The Initiator 59. The Restorer 60. The Giver of Life 61. The Inflicter of Death 62. The Ever-Living 63. The Sustainer, The Self-Subsisting 64. The Perceiver 65. The Illustrious, the Magnificent 66. The One 67. The Unique, The Only One 68. The Eternal, Satisfier of Needs 69. The Omnipotent One 70. The Powerful 71. The Expediter, The Promoter 72. The Delayer 73. The First 74. The Last 75. The Manifest 76. Knower of the Hidden 77. The Patron 78. The Self Exalted 79. The Source of All Goodness 80. The Ever-Pardoning 81. The Avenger 82. The Pardoner 83. The Most Kind 84. Master of the Kingdom, Owner of the Dominion 85. Lord of Majesty and Generosity 86. The Just One 87. The Gatherer, the Uniter 88. The Self-Sufficient, The Wealthy 89. The Enricher 90. The Withholder 91. The Distresser 92. The Propitious, The Benefactor 93. The Light, The Illuminator 94. The Guide 95. The Incomparable Originator 96. The Everlasting 97. The Inheritor, The Heir 98. The Guide, Infallible Teacher 99. The Forbearing, The Patient May His names be exalted and revered in all realms.
bruh, I'm shia and the love of my life is sunni. maybe you think we should fix things between us but there's really nothing wrong except for some who are politicaly motivated negatively but thats still their freedom. lets not be stupid, the world doesnt work the way we want it to work because theres things called governments, politics, economies. not human and humanities, therefore sadly the picture painted to the west about muslims is very negative and ive never thought you'd fall for it as a wise man. and in our modern world, we the people are not fighting, and we dont hate on other religions, all of that is painted by the big people with power and control. they want to divide us and make us believe that we are divided so we would fight and they would benefit. yes in history there was divide after the death of the prophet PBUH, but what you see today has nothing todo with that because its built from governments and powers and politicians so that they would benifit. so how about the people around the world educate themselves properly about muslims and not through political media and then they could accept us as literally the same type of humans with just difference in beliefs instead of waiting for to supposedly fix something that doesnt make sence lol because what difference does it make if the rest of the world dont fix their ways of looking at us negatively.
TO EVERY CRITICAL MUSLIM: DR. Peterson IS RIGHT It's not just about shiet and sunni! Look up الإمام المتغلب.. LITERALLY " the strong man imam".. Dictatorship is literally a fikh in our SICK culture! way before even becoming swamped with cultural lacking, that mires us with an abundance of murtads, and monafiks who actively want to fight islam for their own alternative national projects. You really think egypt's sisi doesn't believe in Secularism?! Even if the west bursts into flames? You think the LOSERS of turkish nationalism would just chill, all of a sudden, if the west disappeared?! What did you learn from watching syria? The ONLY REASON WHY BASHAR STILL EXISTS IS EXACTLYYYYYYYYYYYYYYYYYYYYYYYYYYYYYYYYYYYYY BECAUSE OF WHAT PETERSON SAID. That very very very heartbreaking reality.. So heartbreaking.. In slow motion.. For 11 years... ONLY BECAUSE MUSLIMS DIVIDE INTO TONS OF GROUPS, AND CAN NOT UNITE TO EVEN SAVE THEIR LIVES.. LITERALLY Syrian free army Syrian democratic forces Syrian blah blah Allepo blah blah The nusra front Isis, Alqaeda, Freemen of sham, The YPG The PKK Blah blah FKING BLAH! The Islamists I egypt literally bickered OVER TRINKETS, during the "revolution".. JUST LIKE PETERSON SAID.. And that's why EVEN WHEN THEY WON, THEY'RE NOW ALLLLLLL IN JAIL! Egypt had salafi noor party, gamaa islamya party, the brotherhood freedom and justice party, and lots of other Islamists.. And THEY LITERALLY BICKERED TO THE LAST FKING MINUTE.. LIKE ID!0TS AND THEY F'D UP!! 😠 AND IT'S THEIR FAULT.. BECAUSE THEY HAD IT! THEY HAD THE MAJORITY PARTIES, THEY HAD THE POPULARITY AMONGST THE PEOPLE, THEY HAD EVERYTHING 😠😠😠😠😠😠😠😠 AND THEY F'D IT PETERSON IS RIGHT 😠
There is divide among Muslims. I’m a Muslim living in a Muslim country and despite the few that really don’t care what sect you are there is still plenty that do. You can still see favoritism in the workplace, a lack of inter-sect marriage, all kinds of discrimination. It’s saddening but very much real. Compare the different sects harmony in Islam with that of Catholics, Baptists and other religions and you get what we’re talking about. Denying a problem doesn’t make it disappear. I think Dr. Peterson came a long way during the past year in regards to his views on Islam and Muslims. You belittling the effort he had put in does not do us any good. His message is coming from a kinder and kind place. It’s quite general, nonetheless, straight to the point and we must not be sidetracked by whatever pointless discrepancies that his understanding may contain.
What a fake person you are Ibn Taymia, in if the so respected Sunni Preachors of all time, had called Shia as “Kofaar” khawarej What are you talking about ? Peterson has right in every single word he said If you don’t see the truth you need help You making the problem worse
@@mas1158 Ignorance has nothing to do with academic degree, intellectual status, or even the extent of social impact Ignorance is not making the effort to learn about a specific topic before speaking about it, let alone trying to advise or influence those who adopt this topic, as this is doubly ignorance. He did not read that the first pluralistic society to coexist safely was the Islamic society, which began with Yathrib and ended with the Ottoman Empire Even with the absence of Islamic government, the Islamic society remained the most pluralistic and coexisting Of course, until the West, under the Zionist leadership, began to establish a Zionist entity in the middle of the Islamic world (Palestine) and to enable a criminal takfiri ideology in Iran with the aim of ensuring the instability of the Islamic world Despite this, Islam is the fastest spreading religion in the world, despite the noses of everyone who tried to distort the image of Islam, knowingly or ignorantly.
Well Jordan as a person who watched mostly all of your videos and podcasts, you have to know we aren’t the type of people who become a fan of a person and get effected to what ever he says, we accept the truth from you, and don’t accept the false, and unfortunately this video has some false statements, I agree with some of them, I agree there is a huge conflict between Sunnis and Shias, but that conflict is getting bigger dur do political issues and not religion issues, shias lives in peace in iraq, Yemen, Syria, and Lebanon, but after The world wars the conflicts got much bigger, but its political reasons, for example Germany and UK and France and USA killed millions from each other and they are all Christians, but it was not due to religious issues it was all political related, so is the shia Sunni conflict which is mostly due to Saudi vs Iran, each one wants to be dominant in the Middle East...
خلي نكون واقعين اكثر الاشخاص الي يتأثرون بكلام الناس هم المسلسمين, ابسط مثال اطلع على المفسرين للقرآن، اذا عايش بأي دولة اسلامية راح تلاحظ مدى تأثير الناس بكلام الاخرين و انجرارهم له، ابسط مثال مقتدى الصدر اله ملايين الاتباع داخل البلد و هو شخص لا يعرف رأسه من اخمس قدمه، رغم ذلك راح يضحون بحياتهم من اجله. +مو قبل فترة ليست ببعدية خلصنا من حرب اهلية قائمة بين السنة و الشيعة ؟ و بعدها معركة كراهية بين العرب و الكرد ؟
@@Aro_2002 اذا تعتقد بانه الناس تبحث عن رأي صادق فا أنت عايش داخل فكرك بعيدا عن الواقع، غالبية البشر يحبون أن يقوم المقابيل بالثني على افكارهم و اعتقاداتهم حتى لو ما يقوله كذب و بدع
I really appreciate this heartfelt message from Dr. Peterson. I disagree with the notion that Muslims inherently have issue with Christians and Jews based solely on the fact that they are of a different religion. While there are some Muslims out there that are like this I don’t think it’s reflective of how the majority of Muslims think about Jews and Christians. I think it’s more of an issue of politics rather than religion. For example Muslims are upset with Israel not because the population of Israel are Jews but because of policies the Israeli government are implementing in Palestine, it’s politics not religion. Either way I think we can all agree with Peterson’s theme that betterment starts within and on an individual level. May we all have a hand in changing the world into a better place no matter how small it might be.
This guy's is talking bs and he knows it very well! He had good dialogue with Muslims recently , so he must prove his anti Muslim credentials to stay relevant
Well, if what you say is true and how most Muslims feel and think about it, concerning "it’s politics not religion" I must ask how can that be? I mean, as ignorant as I may sound, when I look at a map of the Middle East Muslim countries totally dominate that region. Why would political issues from a small slice of land affect the vast Muslim world? If true, there's a saying I grew up with, which sort of explains my misunderstandings on it all, "making a mountain out of a mole hill."
You got that wrong we Muslims don’t view people of other religions as enemies. We have our religion and you have yours. We re focused on our selves. Do with your lives what you please as long as it doesn’t hurt us.
With all my respect Dr Peterson, This message wasn’t well prepared and needs to be reconsidered. I was so happy when you interviewed Hijab, an Mr Hamza Yusuf later to lightning western about islam which was sabotaged through media for years. Our admiration and support as muslims was based on some characteristics that you demonstrated that were in alliance with islam teachings and not something that is missing in our faith and we looking to fulfill somewhere else or because of the « abraham accords » as you mentioned wish i will suggest to conduct a pole or something to find out by yourself how much muslims support it. As a highly educated person as yourself, it’s not acceptable from you to state that muslims hate Christian or jews knowing that both Christians and Jews lived in harmony in the muslim world for decades with no issues. Also it is weird that you didn’t condemn any practices of Israel against Palestiniens (the country that most of high tech companies and western media deleted from the world map) instead you narrowed our issues to evil within???. I don’t want to make this comment longer than it is, but i recommend you review your message and reconsider both the content and the tone.
@@ellagardener538 far right conservatives love each other ideas as long as they don’t have to share them lol, as you said conservative white Christians have no interest whatsoever in having Muslims around, they would rather have Latinos or Filipinos, at least they are Christians. Same with any religious and ethnic group to be fair, but catholics love to bring the moral high ground in those debates.
I doubt that. I have heard a very disturbing phrase that some Muslims use to describe Jewish people. They say that "Jews are descendants of", and the second part rhymes with "grapes and jigs". I didn't know Muslim hospitality towards Jews would also extend to comparing them to swine and simians.
Very valid points. These conflicts have all been perpetuated by politics and not religion. Whoever controls the mass media will control perception. We need more love in this world.
Am a Muslim, never considered any Christians nor Jew as my enemy. In fact a large percentage of my friends are actually christians Deep respect for Peterson ✊
"Make of yourself and your Muslim practice something so admirable that the light shining from your well constituted psyche and productive generous and wise actions is so intense that people convert to your faith from sheer admiration." There's a goal!
Islam is the fastest growing religion in the world for a reason. And in our religion, prophet Muhammad declared that he was the final prophet to come and that the religion of god was finally completed when the Quran came down from heaven. All the proof we need is the fact that is muslims believe in all the prophets, not just Jesus, or not just moses, but all the prophets and that we believe that Muhammad is the final prophet to be and there is no more prophets. That’s all islam is in terms of the difference in Islam to all else. The facts that Islam has been the final serious massive religion to come and there hasn’t been another great religion or prophet ever since is all the proof needed that proves the words of Islam. But if you need more proof of Islam, just checkout the miracles of the original Qurans, thousands of years later the book is still completely in a prestige condition without any sign of deterioration) proving the Qurans invincibility as well as the fact that it could not have been made of earthly material. Moreover, it explains how to run society to a T, from how to greet people or go to the toilet all the way to how to run a country. It couldn’t have been made by a human furthermore the undeniably crystal clear predictions of the major signs of judgement day are all occurring just as forewarned to a terrifyingly accuracy that it cannot be labelled a coincidence. Most of the miracles of Islam that cannot be proven wrong have already be documented everywhere they’re all on RUclips etc. Just just need to watch listen and see for yourself and you’d know it for yourself. At the minimum you can give it a watch.
As an atheist, I've noticed many times that Мuslims do not respect those who are not religious. Presicely, I've also experienced bad treatment from Мuslim males as a woman. However, I've never noticed such a treatment from Christians regarding me being an atheist or a woman.
As a muslim I’m sorry for that..they should advice you not hate you. Also Islam actually ask Muslims to treat others right doesn’t matter the religion. Which makes Islam perfect but not Muslims.❤
As a Muslim who is one of your audience and loved many of your videos I have watched before in this video your message to the Muslims was full of arrogance not what I was expecting
JP cant understand and falls victim to Tribalism propoganda . it resides in the amygdala. thrives on us v them ( he is on side of "us" christian-jew and muslims are "them" ). as a PhD clinical psychologist professor, he is unable to use the justice in his pre-frontal cortex to overcome the hate-fear of his amygdala. if he did, he would give a similar advice to his christian tribal members and jew tribal allies considering their history within each other ( catholic-protestant slaughter ) and with each other (genocide and ethnic cleansing of european jews ) not to speak of their acts against muslims (crusades, zionism).
Number one if you studied islam,you will understand that the chiaa aren't Muslims,the only true Muslim are the sunna Number two Muslims aren't against jewsh people and if they pay the jizyah for there protection they will be no problem, Muslims are against zionest who occupied Palestine Number 3 if only usa and their allies leave the Islamic world alone ,the hole word will be okay Finally islam will e Invade the hole word it's a fatal fact
@@freeman4380 Sahih Muslim 1767 a It has been narrated by 'Umar b. al-Khattib that he heard the Messenger of Allah (ﷺ) say: I will expel the Jews and Christians from the Arabian Peninsula and will not leave any but Muslim.
I generally think Jordan Peterson is an intelligent, well-reasoned man, but his reasoning has failed him when speaking in this video. This video is disappointing. I am not Muslim, but I agree with many of their remarks and replies here and elsewhere. It only addresses Muslims and definitely appears to single them out. Jordan Peterson seems pro-Christian and -Jewish, and he implies that it's the Muslim people who need a change of mindset and a desire to become more inclusive, cooperative, and peaceful. If his remarks were spurred by The Abraham Accords, then address those representatives and what you'd like to see happen in any dialogue related to or concerning negotiations and agreements and not make generalizations about all Muslims. Because anyone can have serious flaws in reasoning, I try to always carefully reflect on and analyze what's being presented to me. I wish the Daily Wire had the presence of mind to question Peterson on this video release because it was a big mistake on many levels.
I am surprised to see how many comments simply stating that Dr. Peterson is not knowledgeable enough about the topic or we love eachother so well. I disagree. I think he has a point. There is nothing wrong about admitting the facts and try to be better in our relationships. I am far away from being perfect. If you don't detect the problem, you can never solve it.
I do respect Jordan in a few other accords, however it's surprising this is coming from him. Because as he is known for his detailed analysis, this conclusion lacks so many analysis especially regarding the religion itself and why we do what we do. It feels a bit condescending to come to this conclusion without further analysis into the religion itself and its belief. I see this as generalizing conflict and basically saying, "we don't want to understand you, but we don't want to see you fight, so stop fighting" even though you barely understand the context.
My dear Brothers and Sisters in Islam. Heed my warning. From Al-Qur'an Surah al-Baqarah And the Jews will never be satisfied with you, neither will the Nasara (i.e., the Christians) till you (closely) follow their creed. Say, "Surely the guidance of Allah is the Guidance." And indeed in case you ever (closely) follow their prejudices, after the (share of) knowledge that has come to you, in no way will you have from Allah either a constant Patron or a ready Vindicator. also; My fellow Muslims. As Narrated by Abu Sa'id al-Khudri reported Allah's Messenger (may peace be upon him) as saying: You would tread the same path as was trodden by those before you inch by inch and step by step so much so that if they had entered into the hole of the lizard, you would follow them in this also. edit: listen to him if you want, but never take it to your hearts and minds for Allah Subhanawataala have given you HIS warning about these people.
maybe he is just as clueless in other fields and he gets away with what he says in other videos because you aren't as familiar with the subject matter? He is definitely not someone i consider to have detailed analysis and his conclusions are generally flawed (imo)
I'm one of those Muslim fans of Dr Peterson and I truly admire his work and content since it is based on serious research but this one doesn't seem to be like it. Let me assure you that the problem with sunnis and shiis is related to geopolitical reasons and not religion Muslim people do not hate jews but zionists. In fact you could do some more research about it : when the jews were kicked out of spain at the end of Al Andalous in 1492 they went to Muslim countries in North Africa who did welcome them and they lived there. I'm from Morocco and my dad used to tell me a lot of stories about their Jewish neighbours as well as Christian. They preferred to live in groups but it didn't mean that they weren't welcomed . That's the reason why Morocco has a lot of Jews. I hope you can get to study more about Islam not just what you have heard or seen. *excuse my english it's my 3rd language
Muslims are against the Jewish people themselves, but that's not the case at all. We're against Zionism which happens to be dominantly jews, but again as an Egyptian who
I’m one of Your greatest fans Mr. Peterson. Although the content of the “lecture” is mostly agreeable, it somehow strikes me, as a Muslim, as insulting. Listening to the video I felt though you are pointing “The Finger”, (which you have taught us not to point), at the Muslims. Though we ALL share a fault and a responsibility in the well being of the world it seems odd you have singled out the Muslims. I feel as if my defenses are up now. Maybe My opinion will change when I see a “lecture” directed to our fellow Christians and Jews. Respectfully.
There is a lecture dedicated to Christian Churches. I would not see it as insulting in any way, shape or form. What he stated was nothing but the ugly truth that we are experiencing as Muslims.
He sounds very dishonest, how can a learned person make these comments without knowing the history. So according to him it is We muslims who are at fault. He is comprimised, he is used for a certain agenda.
Don't hold your breath for a video lecturing Christian's about the atrocities committed all over the globe and mass genocides or to the Zionists for their heinous crimes against the Palestinians (Muslims and Christians). This felt like an initiation step because he signed with the daily wire and he needed to show his stance against Muslims. The last part was an assumption, but hey, if the shoe fits... And I don't believe in coincidences.
I love Mr Peterson but I laughed so many times during this. When I seen the title, I was like ‘oh boy! He’s got something good for an entire culture!’ 😂😂😂. His heart is one after my own, in a mi-nute way.
As a Catholic, when I meet and talk to my Muslim friends I realize they share more values with me then anyone I know. We are not so different! In a day and age when so many people lack faith I can appreciate theirs.
I know this sounds kinda negative but its not meant to,, but,, i think its so close because its the fake version of the true religion... which i consider to be the Catholic faith... The devil is wiley but the small print reads 'Jesus didnt die for you' - 'God has no Son'- 'it wasnt Jesus on the cross'.. And for that reason, I'll continue to love Muslims as people, but i will NOT respect or consider the basis of their faith as anything other thsn 'antiChrist'. It IS against Jesus being our salvation.
@we coming ..see now that's the difference.. even you as a non believer,who denies salvation in Christ...we are commanded to love you. Why do you hate non believers? Hate what they do, whst they belive in...but dont hate them, they are after all, people, and God made them also. If God loves them and is continually merciful then why do you not have the same attitude?
@we coming nah bro what are you even saying you're not a real a muslim if you think Allah only loves muslims, you need to go read the quran with translation man and stop blabbering about stuff you dont even know about. Im muslim btw and all humans are equal, hate results to more hate.
This video is the first time i have the feeling JP doesnt really understand something (and i think it is, that he doesnt really know why muslims are watching him). he doesnt feel in his element. Muslims are facinated by him as a non muslim preaching the things islam teaches us already. The way the western world has structured itself nowadays it is unheard of that a non muslim man (intelectual or not) succesfully and comprehensivly preaches such "old fashioned" ideals that we hold so dear and are sometimes scutanized over as beying old fashioned. I respect that he askes forgivens for his presumpions beforehand, but after that the speach is loaded with regional steriotypes. Not his best work, but I like the fact that he tries.
I respectfully don't agree. Although as a Muslim I don't feel he is speaking to me because I agree with what he says. I'm not one of those Muslims who hate because someone has another view on life or religion. But that doesn't mean there aren't any. So maybe this message wasn't for you, and we should give dr JBP the chance to get to know the Muslims who do read and follow his work. 😊
@@mohamedaf4044 The spiritual war will never be won with violent aggression like goofy mohamad(GOG MAGOG) or the goofy vatican or the goofy elite(GOG MAGOG) fake jew zionists who stole palestine. Violence is goofy indoctrination. The only shedding of blood that makes sense of it all is YAHUWSHUWA'S SACRIFICE ON THE CROSS: The shedding of blood of goats and bulls will not remove sin because the shedding of Christ's blood gives understanding. When you hate Christ and His sacrifice, you hate your Creator and His sacrifice when He took flesh and had His blood spilled. Abel was chosen over Cain because it is Christ's blood sacrifice that will save mankind, which is why YHWH accepted Abel's sacrifice. It was Cain who became like mohamad and decided to spill blood in rage over God. Christ came with the right blood sacrifice that shows Abels sacrifice was prophecy as Abel pleased The Father and was killed for it, just like Christ would eventually do. Same with the passover Lamb sacrifice that protects Ysreal and Abraham sacrificing the lamb for his Son. Christ being the Lamb of ALAHYM, fulfilled these rituals that only served the purpose to prophecy the sacrifice of The Messiah. Every ritual commanded by YHWH to the Ysraalites only served the purpose of prophesying YAHUWSHUWA HAMASHIACH. Islam and judaism both give no meaning to anything the Ysrealites did. They both remove all significance and those rituals become nothing more than routine religious rituals with the vain purpose of making people seem holy. Islam and Judaism makes The Father's mission totally ambiguous and do not follow through or have connections like The Gospel and Christ does to EVERYTHING THAT HAPPENED IN THE OLD COVENANT. CHRIST FULFILLS THE OLD COVENANT BY GIVING THE OLD COVENANT A MEANING AND PURPOSE THAT GIVES MEANING AND PURPOSE TO THE NEW COVENANT WHICH IS NOTHING MORE AND NOTHING LESS THEN ACKNOWLEDGING AND UNDERSTANDING THE MOST PERFECT MAN AND DEITY IN THE FLESH, YAHUWSHUWA HAMASIACH AS HIS LIFE IS THE PERFECT EXAMPLE OF HOW TO FOLLOW THE CREATOR OF ALL AND ACHIEVE THE PERFECT LOVE TO YOUR FAMILY, FRIENDS, NEIGHBOURS AND EVEN THOSE WHO HATE AND PERSECUTE YOU. SO YOU WILL BE LIKE YOUR FATHER IN HEAVEN AS HE INTENDED FOR ALL.
I can not be a (blood)brother or sister with a muslim cause its a different family but they can be my friends! Blood brothers and sisters are the ones that believe in the same bloodsacrifice.
B U &!@ m recently sl it the throat of a tailor in India just coz he supported someone on FB who brought out reality of Muham'mad' the r pist popat . Reality of c h u &!@ m . The more you act meek in front of a d I c tatorship like I &!@ m the more it will try to subdue you
You hsve it backwars because we are extremely tolerant to other people who have different faithes from ours. We have no enemies, but after all it is just a ”presumption ” as you said.
Hi Jordan! I am from Baghdad/Iraq and I would like to tell you that Sunni and Shiites live together in Iraq peacefully, some of our families contain a Sunni mother and a Shiite father or vice versa. Some of my best, lifelong friends are Christians and I walked by a church the last month and saw a priest saying goodbye to a smiling family leaving the church. Rest assured that the majority of Muslim people are peaceful and loving, but the actions of some bigoted minority sometimes, unfortunately, leave a stronger impression.
interesting
That's quite godless tbh.
@@j0kez708 if you can't see god in ll you can't see god at all
Whoever told you Muslims and Shias live together in peace lies
@@husaynqarsh5662 Funny thing is, I have shiite friend pulled me aside this morning after I wrote this comment yesterday at night (he doesn't know about it) and asked how I am doing. He also told me that he's worried about me because he didn't hear from me in a week or so.
you are a subject matter expert and you have been an inspiration to me and to countless others. I listen to you very carefully and I am proud of you and all the hard work that you do. I am only asking that you do not stretch yourself too thin. some topics such as islam and the muslim world which I have experienced personally (I grew up in a muslim country as a christian) are simply too complex. please tread carefully. Suni's do not hate shia's, islam does not hate jews or christians. I'm afraid that you might be falling victim to the same media that you are fighting against. there are a few radical, fanatic, extremist muslims who I've encountered personally, just like any other group. don't get trapped.
I'm a muslim too and I've seen extremism as the majority.
you can see many IMAMS declaring each other as kafir. molanas and maulwis declaring each other kafirs. people quite literally burn people alive on the name of blasphemy. come to a country like pakistan and you will see this live.
Thank you
Well if they're fanatic extremist then they're not Muslims. Muslim is a belief system not an ethnicity. Unfortunately, 90+% of mosques and "Muslim" teaching in the west are wahabi, which is a free masonic invention.
Unfortunately not all Muslims agree with you. I've spoken to Muslims who openly speak of their hatred for Jewish people. They speak about hating Hindus. They speak about hate more than love. Not all btw but enough to be an issue
“I’m afraid that you might be falling victim to the same media that you are fighting against”. Perfectly said ❤️👌🏻🤝
As a Muslim who respects Dr.Peterson and has followed him for quite some time,
My 3 issues with this video:
1-This message could easily apply to Jews and Christians aswell,did Jordan ever make a message directed to Jews or Christians telling them to stop seeing Muslims as enemies?I don't think so.
2-There is anti-Jewish sentiment in the Muslim community,but the majority of Muslims don't even see Christians as their enemies,so I don't see why Jordan was speaking as if there was a significant anti-Christian sentiment in the Muslim community.
3-As for the Jewish point:imagine if a man made a RUclips video in 2022 encouraging Ukrainians to seek peace with Russians as if it's a simple task,the response to said video would be outrageous since it would be ignoring the complexity of the situation between Russians and Ukrainians and ignoring that there's a war between them. The same could be said to Jordan encouraging Muslims to stop vilifying Jews. Firstly,Muslims have trouble with Israel and Zionism more than they do have trouble with Jews and Judaism as a religion. Secondly,like my Ukrainian example,the issue of "Jews and Muslims" is very complex and there's a war going on in Palestine,so telling muslims to seek peace with the "Jews" or Israelis in such a situation would be ignoring the complexity of the situation and treating it as if it's some playground squabble that could be solved simply and easily. And ofcourse Jordan used the term "Jews" rather than "Zionists" or "Israelis" even though the latter would've been more correct to use,this word choice is dishonest and doesn't tell the whole story.
---
That's all.
I see what you’re saying, we all have our blind spots, he has his. I’m sure is open to correction, just as I would say you aren’t aware of the full story in Ukraine. The Russian speaking Ukrainians have been slaughtered since 2014, under the orders of interim president Oleksandr Turnochyv. They’re infested with an ideology older and more odious than Nazism, and their actions could hardly be seen as forgivable by the Russian speaking Ukrainians who’ve suffered untold torture, kidnap, and extrajudicial ethnic cleansing at the hands of Ukrainian officials. This is in fact a message applicable to almost every other major religion as you said and should be said to them too, although there exist no such divide today between Jews nor between Christians. And I recognize that the vast majority of this is actually nationalism rather than theological conflict. Alowites are seen as heretics for example by a great deal Muslims though as are Sufis by fewer. Salam brother.
@@RubiaStorm You misunderstand my analogy,I do not want to delve into the deep details of the Ukrainian conflict,that doesn't matter to our argument right now. I only mean to say that if you were to tell a Ukrainian to seek peace with the Russians,he would reasonably be angry at you. The same could he said with telling a Muslim to seek peace with a Zionist colonizer.
@@Sincerely_MrX Assalmu Alaykum! Firstly,I appreciate you replying to my argument with your own points. Secondly,if you want my reply,please look at what I said to the other person who replied to me.
I think there's something you still don't know, because the bitterness and inferiority complex that exists is from Ishmael to Isaac. I am a bit of my ancestors, so there are Muslims who are the face of Abraham's first son, resentful, bitter, because he was born first, but Abraham took Isaac to sacrifice, that's why Israel wins wars.
That's not me saying it, but it's the psychology of the collective unconscious, and Jesus would bring Israel back. I'm sorry don't think badly of me, but know, I'm a Christian, a Zionist, and in the State of Israel even Muslims live with more freedom. Shalom .
As for why are such messages meant for muslims: it's because islam is the only religion in the 21st century that has a widespread track record of modern religion-endorsed violence, sometthing that the Christians and Jews phased out in the middle ages and Roman times, respectively. Islam is violent by nature, and muslims seem to have little problem with it. Christianity and Jewish faith are like.. herpes, but Islam is like cancer, so it's more important to deal with that at the moment.
1 year later and we're all still breathlessly waiting for part 3.
Any word on when he will release part 3?
Oy vey
Don’t worry, it will drop at the same time as Michelle Obama’s pregnant photos
Lesson learned. Never advice or criticize a faith group based on what you have heard, without reading their scripture and history
Exactly but some people think all this are fairytale movies they can direct by their emotions rather than realizing that there's an already written script.
@johny utah idiocy is painful to listen to too
This is the missing lesson
Plan to dismantle Israel/Palestinian/Muslim Apartheid, settle all religious disputes, and bring peace to the "Middle East".
Plan does not need to be absolute truth nor believed by it's implementors (or the implemented). Can the plan be pulled off with success is what I wish to lay out to you if the above title is a goal you wish to achieve regardless. [They wait for the success of the plan after the fact before they TRULY believe in the plan anyway]
The plan is to promote and force the hand of Israel to enthrone me, Edward Nathan Schwarz, as King of Israel according to Torah law and I would have absolute rule over the interpretation of all the Holy Writ [Tanak, Gospel, Qur'an] and settle all religious and legal disputes TO EVERYONES BENEFIT AND SATISFACTION.
And you can flesh that out with me ahead of time what that settlement would be and see if any side would feel a ruling would not be Just for them or in their interests.
What do Palestinians want? No walls surrounding them? They're gone. What do Muslim's want? No apartheid in Jerusalem? Done away with. What do the Rabbis want? A Temple? They'll settle for the Tabernacle. What does Egypt want, what does Jordan want, what does Iran want?
The Davidic King, according to ALL their Lore, holds the Lord's power of attorney in Israel's affairs. Except for cases in idolatry, this king can amend the covenant laws at will among other powers. I got plenty of resources to share. Who wants to be my friend?
Anybody please tell me, What can I give you that you be my friend? I'll open an office and stock it with Santa's helpers for you to send in your requests. I got resources and "stuff" warehouses busting their seems. I'll bring an oasis to your desert if that is what you need or want - spare no expense.
So whoever this is I'm speaking to please forward this plan to concerned parties for consideration and refining if interested. -Cheers
Why is one religion behaving in a radical way and fights everyone?
I’m a Christian, at one time I often traveled to Turkey where my company had offices. I talked with my Muslim co-workers about faith. I realized that the wedge between us is fake. Various leaders weaponize religion for their own gains. We have more in common than we think. Even if we never overcome our differences the simple fact that we have bigger more dangerous enemies should be uniting.
Everyone SHARE this video, please !!! Dr. Jordan B Peterson you are my Hero. ❤❤❤
Islam and Christianity are fundamentally incompatible. Islam denies, not only the divinity of Christ, but also the crucifixion. Christianity holds that there are no prophets that follow after Christ and thusly, Muhammad must be a false prophet. Christians and Muslims may be able to get along for a time, but Christianity and Islam cannot.
They do not follow the One True God of the Judeo-Christian Bible.
This sort of bromide is commonly spouted by those completely ignorant of the Qur'an, the Hadith and the history of islam.
You mean the woke?
This video is proof that even the most intellectual and educated people like Jordan Peterson can share wrong info or misguide people.
I just wanted to say, as a Lebanese muslim, that despite all the differences between Sunni and Shia ideologies, we live with each others in peace. All the problems/wars happening in the muslim world are purely political, and they shove religions in the conflicts to sustain the same amount of violence.
As a sunni, i have tons of shia and christian friends, and i dont have jewish friends because simply there are none in my country.
And I believe that you know very well that muslims in general have a problem with Zionists,and not jews.
You just chose to share certain info in a certain way to support a certain political group, and this is very predictable.
Finally, and in conclusion, you're 100% wrong.
Islam is 85% politics and les than 14% religious faith so there's your own question answered. In just the past 70 years 12 million+ muhammadans have died fighting other muhammadans in conflicts .. . and yet here you are and many other muhammadans in absolute utter denial about the elephant in the room and look to blame the messenger and or everyone else for problems in your own system
Plan to dismantle Israel/Palestinian/Muslim Apartheid, settle all religious disputes, and bring peace to the "Middle East".
Plan does not need to be absolute truth nor believed by it's implementors (or the implemented). Can the plan be pulled off with success is what I wish to lay out to you if the above title is a goal you wish to achieve regardless. [They wait for the success of the plan after the fact before they TRULY believe in the plan anyway]
The plan is to promote and force the hand of Israel to enthrone me, Edward Nathan Schwarz, as King of Israel according to Torah law and I would have absolute rule over the interpretation of all the Holy Writ [Tanak, Gospel, Qur'an] and settle all religious and legal disputes TO EVERYONES BENEFIT AND SATISFACTION.
And you can flesh that out with me ahead of time what that settlement would be and see if any side would feel a ruling would not be Just for them or in their interests.
What do Palestinians want? No walls surrounding them? They're gone. What do Muslim's want? No apartheid in Jerusalem? Done away with. What do the Rabbis want? A Temple? They'll settle for the Tabernacle. What does Egypt want, what does Jordan want, what does Iran want?
The Davidic King, according to ALL their Lore, holds the Lord's power of attorney in Israel's affairs. Except for cases in idolatry, this king can amend the covenant laws at will among other powers. I got plenty of resources to share. Who wants to be my friend?
Anybody please tell me, What can I give you that you be my friend? I'll open an office and stock it with Santa's helpers for you to send in your requests. I got resources and "stuff" warehouses busting their seems. I'll bring an oasis to your desert if that is what you need or want - spare no expense.
So whoever this is I'm speaking to please forward this plan to concerned parties for consideration and refining if interested. -Cheers
Really you Lebanese out of all people want to talk.
In Lebanon it's divided for each sect of each religion it is regionally divided politically divided on all kinds of levels.
Doesn't matter eventually Doesn't affect the main point that he wants to deliver, it still remains true.
Iam lebanease too, you are 1 of 1% u can speak for yourself, there is always hatred race .. religions etc.. cause the old mindset is still alive , in some countries tend to be less , but if some shia go to saudi arabia for example racism occurs as well as anything happend before but i hope we will have "true" peace someday
We all know that the west has been always expert in "Divide and Rule Policy"
As a Muslim myself, the most ignorant thing I've seen any of us do is to stop thinking for ourselves with the excuse that thinking will turn into a lack of faith and then you are doomed.
WHY: It is very clear that Islamic States are hateful. They need an enemy to justify the brutal treatment of their own people. It's all about hateful domination to think "I have the right and only answer."
Finally a muslim who thinks like
i'm so glad you said that
@@extremeresponsibilityplease learn the knowledge before speaking about islam
@pleasestudy745 yeah.... why bother thinking when all thinking is controlled by a misogenistic theoracy? The movie 'the great wall '(2016) depicted an army of monsters controlled by a mother monster- one bleat from her controlled all the monsters. Their goal? Destruction of humanity...The misogenistic theocracy's (and its proxies) written, stated, policy? the destruction of the state of Israel, the expulsion of any surviving persons of any jewish link from the entire middle east... I'd rather deal with a fictional monster tbh... the US is always depicted as the 'great satan' by the misogenistic theocracy. Time for the west to wake up.
@@suaramuslim-v1k Please Think
Someone once said”As an outsider you have no idea of how much you don’t know about what you don’t know, even you are blind to your own ignorance,” I think the glove fits here Dr. Peterson.
Everyone can see what a terror religion Islam is. I don't need to be a nazi to see that fascism is bad.
Well said
Peculiar statement which demonstrate the cardinal issue with some Muslim after all your fate in named Piece and you are the youngest half brothers in the Abrahamic fates, thus, stop trying so heard to be “enfant terrible”
U r ignorant of the truth, Jordan is right, u r trying to defend Islam and its ideology, there are several dangerous things which u r not aware of, so u r ignorant and I agree 💯 with you, u r ignorant willingly...
What do u mean by outsider
Speaking as a Christian I can say this message applies equally to Christians. Before you call your neighbor evil because you do not agree with their ideology, seek out and root out any evil that lies within. Let he who is without evil cast the first stone. Love God. Love your neighbor. No exceptions.
That’s very naive e
uh no it doesn't
Amen.
100%
I want to agree with you to be “fair” as my modern western indoctrination tells me that fairness is the pinnacle but I can’t. When was the last time Christians stormed a village and beheaded and raped non believers?500 years ago? 300? A long time so long you can’t recall off the top of your mind. Yes we should all band together against the post modern ideologues etc but first acknowledge that Christianity is ahead of the curve when it comes to civility.
As a muslim I respect Dr Jordan Peterson alot but in this video I'm sure he didn't do his study and research well . As muslims we can agree with Dr Jordan Peterson that the Quran it is mentioned that we muslims should respect the people of the book ( jews and Christians ) but it's mentioned in the Quran chapter 60 : verse 8 " God does not deprive you of those who did not fight you in religion and did not deprive you from your home " and what did the jewish settlers do to the Palestinians ? Between 1920 and 1939 the Balfour declaration promised to facilitate Jewish immigration under suitable conditions and the jewish population focused on purchasing lands from the arab owners so by controlling both the land and the labor that gave them the opportunity to occupy Palestine and over 700000 Palestinians fled from their homes and became refugees in neighbouring arab countries and they became stateless . Now here's an honest question. How do you want us to make peace with those who fought us , kicked us out from our homeland , and declared war on us ? Palestinians are living under isreali military occupation and the Israelis treat the Palestinians as they are sub humans in their own land . Just last year ago when the battle started between the Palestinians and the Isreali government , there were Zionist mobs marching through the streets of Jerusalem chanting " Death to Arabs " and smashing in Palestinians own stores with protection of Isreali police . And they were kicking Palestinians out from their homes in sheikh Jarrah east Jerusalem to make way for Jewish settlers . And yet people say that God promised them this land and the they have the right to live there . How do you think Isreal was built ? Do you think that millions of Palestinians decided to leave their homes behind burn down their own villages for no reason ? Isreali forces are bombing and shooting people praying inside Al Aqsa mosque and airstrikes are hitting the Gaza strip and what are the Palestinians supposed to do ? Their homes are being destroyed, their places of worship are being bombed and their families are being killed . Are you expecting from them to remain quiet and to sit back and accept it ? Some jews claim that it was their land so if history is to be taken to throw people out from their homes then why doesn't the US give back the land to the native Americans ( the red Indians ) . Don't you feel like as if Palestinians are still living under colonialism ? As muslims we have no problem with the jews at all . The Quran doesn't say that the Jews and the muslims should fight , it says that the strongest enemies to the muslims are the jews and this is actually a fact and it proves the Quran is right and the proof for that is easy . Just let the jews get together and decide to stop the war on the Palestinians and to give the stolen land back to them . Will they do it ? We are not anti-Jewish , we are anit-Zionists. We don't want war , we want justice . We are not fascists , Nazists nor racists . The Palestinians were uprooted from their homes by " God's promise " and when you call us anti-semitic infact the Palestinians are semites because arabic is a semitic language . So our problem is with the Zionists because zionism is a political movement not a religious movement and history proves that muslims Christians and jews were coexisting and they were living in peace when the Islamic warrior Salah El Din Al Ayubi conquered the crusaders and took control of Jerusalem he entered into an agreement that muslims should protect synagogues and Churches .
Lmao jews were there first cry about it
What a comment, perfect!
@@josemou6172
Let's enjoy the peace before the keyboard warriors come
I read your post and you stated that the quran does not call for the fighting af jews ...according to your logic Turkey should give isanbul back because they took it from Christians right? Look I am sympathetic but the land is what it is now folks need to get along
Quran : Curse Jews/Christians- Surah 9:29 , 9:30 / Take Jews nor Christians as friends 5:56 / Jews and Christians worse of creatures -98:6 / Jews, Christians turned into apes - 5:60 (64) / Enmity for Christians - 5:14 / Do not befriend nonbelievers-3:28 / Fight unbelievers 9:123
HADITH: Kill Children -Sahih Muslim vol 4 verse 4457 / Kill Jews behind talking stones - Sahih Muslim book 41 6985
TL;DR
"And We have not sent you but as a mercy to all the worlds." (Quran 21:107)
As a Muslim I can assure you that all those you mentioned and pointing your message to are and have been living together peacefully for centuries. It's the politicians who cause divisions and fights among us...
among us
I think he is aware of that but none the less chose to say muslims because of how he wants the cultures to integrate, not cause further division...
no not really in nigeria muslims live in peace becuase they agree with what they are doing recently some muslims killed a 20 year old teacher in Nigeria and shot up a church of 50 people killing women and children. This has been going on foe years in Nigeria and the muslim leader, Scholars etc are trying to justify it instead of denouncing it.
Some Zanadiqa (atheists) were brought to `Ali and he burnt them. The news of this event, reached Ibn `Abbas who said, "If I had been in his place, I would not have burnt them, as Allah's Messenger (ﷺ) forbade it, saying, 'Do not punish anybody with Allah's punishment (fire).' I would have killed them according to the statement of Allah's Messenger (ﷺ), 'Whoever changed his Islamic religion, then kill him.'"
the teacher was actually stoned and burned to death on video because she balsthemed
he knows but he choose to not know.
@@haniffsalafi566 facts 💯👍. He was corrected before but he has clearly chosen the side of the Islam haters
I’m very tired of everyday people talking to us Muslims like we are idiots. I don’t know when us Muslims will wake up and realize we only have each other. We spend so much time looking for approval in places that don’t want us or care for us.
It's all a game to them Brother. They are obsessed with Muslims because they know that Muslims are the most authentic and its much easier to understand Islam than the revised Christianity and Judaism. Notice how Muslims don't ever talk or think about the West or Christianity, yet the West ONLY talks bad about Islam, and is obsessed with slandering and persecuting us. Stay strong Brother and Salaam!
Everyday people don't give two fucks about Muslim culture or religion minus the radical Sharia Law that set you all back decades. Stop letting fanatics that practice this archaic and barbaric sect rise to power, then and only then will the world stop demonizing Muslims.
Unfortinately your fellow muslim friends are leaving too, like me. Goodbye
Muslims are the only major religion who forbids believers from visiting their holy lands, so reality is the opposite of what you paint
@@IAm-zo1bo that’s a shame
“I’m afraid that you might be falling victim to the same media that you are fighting against”. Perfectly said by Hans Stechi ❤👌🏻🤝
Thats true 👍
By asking for people to come together instead of hate one another?
@@cameronminor2255 the conflict is not nearly like portrayed in social media . The message is definitely a great one from Jordan. However it’s a must for us to say what we are really living . That mentioned conflict is not really reflective of reality .. i guess that’s the msg mostly we are trying to explain 🌸
Nothing is as bad as the media claims, but there still are issues in the areas. Not everywhere, and not all Muslims, but he touched on issues that have been going on for hundreds of years. But really, all I got from the entire message was that we need to communicate and learn to love each other. If all you can get out of his message is criticism then maybe you're focusing on the wrong things.
@@cameronminor2255 No no some of the things he is saying are totally accurate, if we were in 632 AD.
I won't ruin all the fun for you and let you find out why on your own, unlike Peterson did. (and I'm not being sarcastic, it's actually pretty interesting). Otherwise, everything he said is fiction.
Started reading the Quran recently, it is blowing my mind with timeless articulate inspiration on every page so far. If a book is inspiring almost 2 billion people over 1000 years since it was first written, it would be arrogant to assume that oneself is somehow beyond its relevance before even reading, as I was arrogant during my atheistic past of assuming that I could figure everything out based on my own limited intuition.
@ 52 I am reading physics/ bio and chem books as i am searching for truth-
@@brettharman8921 Any inspirational finds so far?
That’s exactly why I reverted to Islam like exactly. Wow that’s wild that you said that In Sha’Allah brother
@@zxctgb i find science to be amazing and inspirational, constantly leading me to ask more questions , seek more knowledge and shed light on how much we still dont understand.
@@devintamblyn1320 Was there a specific turning point for you that made you know it was the path for you?
With all due respect, Dr. Peterson, you once said that you are "ignorant about Islam". Has there been any change to convey this message to your Muslim audience?
Yeah, there's been a change in who is paying his bills
Ben Shapiro becoming his boss is what changed. Every. Single. Time.
@@fire_rises this is the answer
@@fire_rises source: of joy
Unfortunately, he's still ignorant
I can't believe this is what he came up with after he had spoken to some of our Muslim brothers... wow
*Muslims* Read these Verses (The Jews and the Christians will never be pleased with you until you follow their religion. Say, “The guidance of Allah is the [true] guidance.” If you were to follow their desires after the knowledge that has come to you, then you would have no protector or helper against Allah.Those to whom We have given the Book recite it as it should be recited, it is they who believe in it. As for those who disbelieve in it, it is they who are the losers.) Ch 2 Verse 120-121
@@rdsa1 "The Jews and the Christians will never be pleased with you until you follow their religion. Say, “The guidance of Allah is the [true] guidance." it's not even in Quran, I am a Christian and I know this is not Quran
@@caret4812 surah 2 verse 120. U gonna teach us our book now . When u barley read yours 💀
Maybe he did that on purpose under influence of his christian-zionist exclusive right-wing club, the daily wire, he joined, with that robot zionist with a metallic annoying voice Shapiro as one of the main characters...
@@misshouda1740 this thread is exactly opposed to everything Jordan just said
I have been following JP for years now and have learned so much from him. Years ago he was asked about Islam and he said he didn't have enough knowledge to speak about it. Something I admired. But he should have stuck to that. This message is disappointing. He's clearly ignorant of Islam and the history of the Middle East, or he has an agenda.
I think it's Agenda according to the channel he hosted by !!
An agenda seems more like it.
And you don't ?
Yeah I didn't like it either
The history of the Middle East is well documented. Found the closet leftist that denies historical texts to feel better.
This aged well!
"Peace unto him".
LOL
How about no😂
Hi Davina Woodina :D
@@marcuswright8418 Forthrightly
"Among people there is a kind whose sayings on the affairs of the world fascinate you:he even calls on God to bear testimony on his sincerity; yet he is most fierce in enmity." Qur'an (2:204)
«وَمِنَ ٱلنَّاسِ مَن يُعْجِبُكَ قَوْلُهُۥ فِى ٱلْحَيَوٰةِ ٱلدُّنْيَا وَيُشْهِدُ ٱللَّهَ عَلَىٰ مَا فِى قَلْبِهِۦ وَهُوَ أَلَدُّ ٱلْخِصَامِ»
wow
But it in Peterson case he maybe mistaken, ask the majority of people what causes wars they will say religions (even some Muslims believe that) yet Encyclopedia of Wars," authors Charles Phillips and Alan Axelrod document the history of recorded warfare, and from their list of 1763 wars only 123 have been classified to involve a religious cause, accounting for less than 7 percent of all wars and less than 2 percent of all people killed in warfare. Yet "far more lives were lost in the Second World War than in the First (more than 60 million. Moving beyond soldier deaths, the total number of both civilian and military casualties during World War One is estimated at around 37 million people." according historyonthenet.
@@sutil5078 Are you sure about the stats, I can't find it, share the reference please
@@ZAINABKHAN-ir7rl I read that 3 or 4 years ago so here is what i can find now:
"Encyclopedia of Wars," authors Charles Phillips and Alan Axelrod document the history of recorded warfare, and from their list of 1763 wars only 123 have been classified to involve a religious cause, accounting for less than 7 percent of all wars and less than 2 percent of all people killed in warfare. "
so I may have read different source, or confused the 2% of death caused by religiosly motivated wars with number of total war.
thanks for reminding me to check it again and can't recall the other site I read it on..
May Allah increase your knowedlge sister Zainab , love your name,
and give you Jannah and your family and all of us amin :)
Unlike many never thought of peterson as a beakon of hope in the age of despair. But this address of his to muslims is way out his league. He understands almost nothing about Islam
I agree. It shows he hasn't done his research enough
He’s being told what to say by his Jewish handlers
Yup, imma do a reaction to it
Yep he knows nothing about sharia Fistula laws Or the 30 different qurans. He just keeps talking about the unabrogated verses. He actually still has hope for you guys.
@@sz4205 They're not perfectly preserved cause Uthman burned all the original copies. Where are the pages that Aisha had hidden underneath her pillow? Is 111 or 114? No there are too many holes in SIN for you to convince me otherwise.
Mr. Peterson had credibility on other topics he talked about, but in this case, I have first-hand experience with many Muslim countries, and this message is simply talking about a totally different planet.
You have "first-hand experience with many Muslim countries", you say, so now tell us about the treatment of Christians and Hindus in Pakistan, and of Christians in Egypt, Afghanistan, Somalia, Iran, Syria, Turkey, Nigeria. Tell us about Al-Shabaab's actions in Ethiopia, Kenya and Mozambique. where a few months ago they invaded and murdered widely, even decapitating ten-year old children and displaced more than 500,000 people. So yes, tell us about this.
There is a war against Jews, Christians, Buddhists and Hindus pretty much everywhere. Been this way for centuries. Some people still can’t connect the dots.
@@robertporter4501 christians in egypt???!
You don't know what you are talking about im Egyptian and i can tell you
That many Christians get treated better than muslims
And other countries you said I don't know about it but if you lied about egypt then you lied about every other countries you said
@@robertporter4501 and why you didn't talk about what happens to muslims in india by Hindus and in china and even many countries?
@@mostafaahmed9441 because he is another racist white man who wants his racist opinion to matter because deep down his way of thinking are the dinosaurs of extinc.
He won't matter and the world would be better off him.
This guy is beyond self-absorbed
Jordan You Can't beat the " a message for all of humanity " - Charlie Chaplin
After watching this video and reading the comments I can’t help but feel a little patronised if I’m honest. While the intention of this message may have been innocent and in good faith, It plays into this false narrative that all Muslims have a percentage of hate towards Christian’s and Jews. There is no hate amongst the majority of Muslims and other faiths. Our hate internally is towards the sin and not the sinner with our common enemy being Satan/Shaitaan. Our differences are very few but what Muslims feel is sinful, they will try their best to avoid and to partake in. I live in the UAE a country which follows Sharia law, it has one of the lowest crime rates in the world and there is peaceful coexistence between many faiths.
This message of tolerance and peaceful coexistence is in the teachings of this beautiful religion for 1400+ years but what Islam also teaches us is to have a little backbone and stick to our values and beliefs. Tolerance doesn’t mean you give up your values and traditions to take part in what others do. Tolerance is to accept that others are different and the whole world can take something from this message. As for the Sunni/Shia comments this is down to political/regional understandings of the religion the same way there are many branches of Christianity who don’t agree with one another’s interpretations. The message is one amongst all Muslims and Allah will judge us on how we have understood and followed that message.
Also baffled by the number of Muslims in the comments section who seem to crave validation from a prominent speaker and say they agree with “everything” but then disagree with certain points. We don’t need Dr JP’s validation or validation from anyone else. That’s the beauty of our religion we are not slaves to the “norms” of society. We answer to a higher power than man. The laws we follow internally encompass everything we will face in our lives and push us to be kind to others and be held accountable for every single one of our actions. Our religion has had this message and guidance for 1400 years and our validation will be found within us if we respect and follow the teachings of Allah (swt) and his messenger ﷺ
May peace and guidance reach all who read this comment and watch this video ameen
LIES! That all sounds good but you want find many Christians and Jews moving to Muslims countries in masses but you will found Muslims moving to the West in masses. People are not stupid or blind, we see what happens to Christians or non-Muslims in Nigeria, Egypt, Sudan, Pakistan, Afghanistan, Iran or any Muslim majority country.
Finally a comment that makes sense, a true reflection of what truly Islam is! Thank you!
I dont know what was he thinking, but he is a product of his environment
I am glad he makes us reflect and think... These are unprecedented times...
lol thank you for showing everyone exactly why islam wont rise ...thanks for your embarrasing typical comment
Despite that I agree with JP on a lot of stuff, this message seemed judgemental and condescending. I feel like message for muslims was 'Be less aggressive' in contrast to message to christian churches which was 'Promote christianity better'. That feels very one-sided and not at all unviersal.
He is forced to do this to keep his status... What a sad sight. Disgusting
If you are denying to accept the truth that some Muslims hate Jews with all their intentions then you're a liar. Don't deflect.
@@baraistatieh5749 stop defending Jordan Peterson muslims should simping for this fraud
Plan to dismantle Israel/Palestinian/Muslim Apartheid, settle all religious disputes, and bring peace to the "Middle East".
Plan does not need to be absolute truth nor believed by it's implementors (or the implemented). Can the plan be pulled off with success is what I wish to lay out to you if the above title is a goal you wish to achieve regardless. [They wait for the success of the plan after the fact before they TRULY believe in the plan anyway]
The plan is to promote and force the hand of Israel to enthrone me, Edward Nathan Schwarz, as King of Israel according to Torah law and I would have absolute rule over the interpretation of all the Holy Writ [Tanak, Gospel, Qur'an] and settle all religious and legal disputes TO EVERYONES BENEFIT AND SATISFACTION.
And you can flesh that out with me ahead of time what that settlement would be and see if any side would feel a ruling would not be Just for them or in their interests.
What do Palestinians want? No walls surrounding them? They're gone. What do Muslim's want? No apartheid in Jerusalem? Done away with. What do the Rabbis want? A Temple? They'll settle for the Tabernacle. What does Egypt want, what does Jordan want, what does Iran want?
The Davidic King, according to ALL their Lore, holds the Lord's power of attorney in Israel's affairs. Except for cases in idolatry, this king can amend the covenant laws at will among other powers. I got plenty of resources to share. Who wants to be my friend?
Anybody please tell me, What can I give you that you be my friend? I'll open an office and stock it with Santa's helpers for you to send in your requests. I got resources and "stuff" warehouses busting their seems. I'll bring an oasis to your desert if that is what you need or want - spare no expense.
So whoever this is I'm speaking to please forward this plan to concerned parties for consideration and refining if interested. -Cheers
They do need to be less aggressive
With all do respect the problem is with the Zionist not the Jews
I am a Arab Christian woman we always lived Muslim Christian’s and even Jews with each other as Arabs , like Syria , Palestine , Iraq
This division you see in this region were made to divide and rule by the western world starting from Britain to the United States , they put a lot of money to do this , for in this region religion is a big part of the individual identity , so to start conflict between a nation , they used religion as a target
Many Muslim leaders are just as bad. They incite hatred in followers and exploit them. This is all about power and money. The common people should refuse this nonsense.
sounds like you got your education from ISIS.
But again if you were Jewish and had there history. Would you have not been a Zionist. It's the way the Isreall government has behaved there after. The chance was missed with Rabbine sorry if I spelt his name wrong
Of course, and western world -USA, GB, EU, etc.- used time travel to get back to 7th century to create the suni-shia divide. OMG
You are missing one Pete ✡
Hmmm. I really like Jordan Peterson. He is a genuine, logical, thoughtful speaker who truly wishes the best for people. However, as well as his intentions may have been, I found this video to be a bit condescending towards Muslims. It represents a very shallow understanding of the world, Islam, and the situation of Muslims in general. I find it slightly hypocritical that he is only addressing this message to the Muslims and fails to implement his own advice to other divides such as those between the left and the right. I know that Peterson joined the Daily Wire recently, but I hope that that he stays true the principals of honesty, rationality, and fairness that I’ve seen within him much more than I have in other right-wing speakers (left-wing as well).
This is one of the first Jordan Peterson videos i have seen that could not captivate me entirely, it felt too much ''built up'' instead of his many mesmerizing videos ''from the heart''. I sense the Abraham Accords are not truly meant to bring Sunni-Shia peace. It feels like an un-Jordan Peterson video. A missed chance now we seem to head to a global religious strife beside the military-economical-nationalistic-ideological-linguistic clashes?
Plan to dismantle Israel/Palestinian/Muslim Apartheid, settle all religious disputes, and bring peace to the "Middle East".
Plan does not need to be absolute truth nor believed by it's implementors (or the implemented). Can the plan be pulled off with success is what I wish to lay out to you if the above title is a goal you wish to achieve regardless. [They wait for the success of the plan after the fact before they TRULY believe in the plan anyway]
The plan is to promote and force the hand of Israel to enthrone me, Edward Nathan Schwarz, as King of Israel according to Torah law and I would have absolute rule over the interpretation of all the Holy Writ [Tanak, Gospel, Qur'an] and settle all religious and legal disputes TO EVERYONES BENEFIT AND SATISFACTION.
And you can flesh that out with me ahead of time what that settlement would be and see if any side would feel a ruling would not be Just for them or in their interests.
What do Palestinians want? No walls surrounding them? They're gone. What do Muslim's want? No apartheid in Jerusalem? Done away with. What do the Rabbis want? A Temple? They'll settle for the Tabernacle. What does Egypt want, what does Jordan want, what does Iran want?
The Davidic King, according to ALL their Lore, holds the Lord's power of attorney in Israel's affairs. Except for cases in idolatry, this king can amend the covenant laws at will among other powers. I got plenty of resources to share. Who wants to be my friend?
Anybody please tell me, What can I give you that you be my friend? I'll open an office and stock it with Santa's helpers for you to send in your requests. I got resources and "stuff" warehouses busting their seems. I'll bring an oasis to your desert if that is what you need or want - spare no expense.
So whoever this is I'm speaking to please forward this plan to concerned parties for consideration and refining if interested. -Cheers
So once again lets miss the whole point and be like animals .
'a bit'. Stop the simp please. Whats next on his plan? Rewrite history? He's already joined his voice to his masters and you still dont see.
@@miso9788 Plan to dismantle Israel/Palestinian/Muslim Apartheid, settle all religious disputes, and bring peace to the "Middle East".
Plan does not need to be absolute truth nor believed by it's implementors (or the implemented). Can the plan be pulled off with success is what I wish to lay out to you if the above title is a goal you wish to achieve regardless. [They wait for the success of the plan after the fact before they TRULY believe in the plan anyway]
The plan is to promote and force the hand of Israel to enthrone me, Edward Nathan Schwarz, as King of Israel according to Torah law and I would have absolute rule over the interpretation of all the Holy Writ [Tanak, Gospel, Qur'an] and settle all religious and legal disputes TO EVERYONES BENEFIT AND SATISFACTION.
And you can flesh that out with me ahead of time what that settlement would be and see if any side would feel a ruling would not be Just for them or in their interests.
What do Palestinians want? No walls surrounding them? They're gone. What do Muslim's want? No apartheid in Jerusalem? Done away with. What do the Rabbis want? A Temple? They'll settle for the Tabernacle. What does Egypt want, what does Jordan want, what does Iran want?
The Davidic King, according to ALL their Lore, holds the Lord's power of attorney in Israel's affairs. Except for cases in idolatry, this king can amend the covenant laws at will among other powers. I got plenty of resources to share. Who wants to be my friend?
Anybody please tell me, What can I give you that you be my friend? I'll open an office and stock it with Santa's helpers for you to send in your requests. I got resources and "stuff" warehouses busting their seems. I'll bring an oasis to your desert if that is what you need or want - spare no expense.
So whoever this is I'm speaking to please forward this plan to concerned parties for consideration and refining if interested. -Cheers
The great Muslim scholar of hadith Imam Bukhari said: "Knowledge is before speech and action"
Dr. Peterson, though he is knowledgeable about so many things, he knows very very little about Islamic scriptures and history of Muslims. Far from sufficiency to give the kind of claims he made in this video.
Bukhari 💩
His opinions constantly change as his knowledge is updated. I respect that greatly about him. His earliest views on Islam are drastically different to the point he is at now. He seems to be very sincere about knowledge, and someone who is discussing rather than lecturing
Read Hadith Iman Bukhari to know about how lovely and friendly way Muslim treat no Muslim particularly Jews. And please let us know also how respectful was Islam with other religions like polytheist originally worshiping at Mecca. Where did non Muslim people go , did they remain in Mecca and in Muslim countries ?
@@Sea-qv4sd We captured excellent women for ransom. We decided to have sex with them but by observing 'azl (Withdrawing the male sexual organ before emission of semen to avoid-conception). We asked Allah's Messenger (ﷺ), and he said: It does not matter if you do not do it, for every soul that is to be born up to the Day of Resurrection will be born.
Sahih Muslim 1438a
@@takiyaazrin7562 ok?
Appreciate the sentiment JP, but i don't get this western misconception that sunnis and shias are sworn eternal enemies. As a sunni Muslim living in the west and has travelled to many Muslim countries in the east, befriended many shia and sunni Muslims, the tension between both groups has been widely blown out of proportion (no pun intended lol). Have sunnis and shias "beefed"? Yes, of course. There have been wars and conflicts that we all know of, I'm sure, but for the majority of time and in most places they have in fact co-existed peacefully. These events are small specs in the time line . Yes, you'll get your certain areas that are dangerous but I'm sorry i need to call a spade a spade! It's no where near as bad as the blood spilled between catholics and protestants. You'll honestly feel a lot more disharmony and tension in the atmosphere in northern Ireland between Catholic and protestants than you would in the majority of the Muslim world!
As an Irishmen I agree, but I feel like hes speaking to the more exteme casses that arent like yourself who are worldly and have had the opportunity to sit and understand. Its the same problem in Ireland as you mentioned. Its not everyone but those that are indoctrinated at a young age and the excuse for behave is "thats how I was raised". Best,
JP is a cunning Zionist supporter who wants the general muslim population to not be hostile towards Israel by normalising relationship with them. Taking Jews and Christians as allies in the fight against feminism liberalism LGBTQIA by compromising on Palestine issue.
World is taking a traditional turn but some muslims in the heat of fighting liberalism will directly or indirectly support Zionist agenda
Oh muslims do not follow them into the lizard hole they are saying that they are peacemaker but indeed they are the ones who cause c o r r u p t i o n.
He wants normal muslims to not be hostile towards Israel and support the occupation. Didn't you hear him say about Abraham Accord and how we Sunni Shia are responsible for the destabilization of ME. Don't you know how the Zion st s, US along with all European powers invaded muslim lands of Iraq Afghanistan and fuelled the sectarianism.
Please watch Muslim Skeptic latest short and Sajid Lipham reacting to this video.
Quran 5 : 51
O believers! Take neither Jews nor Christians as guardians-they are guardians of each other. Whoever does so will be counted as one of them. Surely Allah does not guide the wrongdoing people.
- Dr. Mustafa Khattab, the Clear Quran
Divide and conquer, that’s why they’re so obsessed with it.
Why does he sound condescending?!
because he is , just look how he talked about the palestenians .
@@musashi542u don’t wanna go down dat road
@@Papi_Luis2001the one where Peterson justifies gen-cide?
Because his wife has an Israelite-Cannuck dual citizenship
It’s amazing to see that people who understand where Jordan Peterson is wrong correct him with respect and care that you’d rarely expect online. It’s heartwarming to know that people are willing to give others the benefit of the doubt instead of canceling them right away. I wish it was more common on the internet
yessss
This is going to become a regular thing with him sadly, He's jumped on Ben Shapiros payroll and their is going to be some serious Zionist cucking
"benefit of the doubt"
There is no doubt.
He join daily mail (ben shapiro).
Then tries to lecture on normalizing zionism (abraham accords).
There is no doubt.
He doesn't give a f.. about understanding Muslims and their problems.
We captured beautiful women for ransom. We decided to have sex with them but by observing 'azl (Withdrawing the male sexual organ before emission of semen to avoid-conception). We asked Allah's Messenger (ﷺ), and he said: It does not matter if you do not do it, for every soul that is to be born up to the Day of Resurrection will be born.
Sahih Muslim 1438a
@@takiyaazrin7562 Ephesians 6:5: “Bondservants, obey your earthly masters with fear and trembling, with a sincere heart, as you would Christ.”
Living in the United States i feel Muslims have been disrespected by a political agenda, specifically after 9/11 . I am Christian, but it was not until i did my own research into the Muslim faith and people did i truly understand and respect what they stood for. I have nothing admiration for the Muslim people and their faith. It is one thing to speak words anyone can do that however, i find that most Muslims practice what they preach. It is their dedication to their Religion and Faith not just by mere words but by their actions such as fasting at certain times of the year. I have never seen more respectful people, even when they disagree, it is done with respect . The world can learn so much from the Muslim people and hopefully one day God willing that will happen for it can only help unite us in this wild world of division we live in today. The media and certain political agendas are the true evil all people of all religions face in my humble opinion, for they are the ones creating the false narratives and dividing us as a people
Burying women up to their necks and throwing volcanic rocks at them until they're dead, because they were raped... so much respect for that!
They certainly do practice what they preach. Unfortunately that often comes with casualties!
as an outsider you depicted the right picture of Muslims thanks brother
Theres a reason the Sunni and Shiite wage war.
And there is a reason 1 religion in particular has suicide extremists.
One side has extreme gender morals and allows abuse toward wives.
Yes all the people have value as Gods creations, but Allah is not God and the religion is a satanic deception.
The muslim world has painted the image and reputation on the world stage for itself, it had nothing to do with American propaganda.
It's just the fact that a majority of radicals exist in Muslim faith. It makes sense being the biggest religion in the world. All religions have radicals...something about the Muslim faith does seem to breed more though? I do understand that a VAST MAJORITY of Muslims are great people. But there are huge swaths of people who will murder for their religion. Burn a Quran in front of Muslims and you'll find the radicals immediately. Look at what Sweden is going through. They loved the idea of immigrants and bringing immigrants to their country and even providing for them.....one man burns a Quran...and they are ready to burn cities to the ground. It's insane. Immigrants must understand that if you move to a Western country....burning a Quran is legal and everyone has the right to do it. Just as you would have the right to burn a bible or whatever other symbolic thing you want to burn. Learn to live in a world of freedoms....don't bring your stone age ideologies to another country. There's a reason you left those stone age countries behind no?
We appreciate people like you who don’t rush to negatively judge Islam and Muslims without trying to understand, experience, and research first. God bless you. Thank you for your kindness.
سورة البقرة{ومِنَ النَّاس مَن يُعْجِبُك قولُهُ في الحيَاةِ الدُّنْيَا ويُشْهِدُ اللهَ عَلَى مَافي قَلْبِهِ وهُوَ ألَدُّ الخصَام}صدق الله العظيم
Behind every word this Jordan says has an insult towards people who are in reality the Victims!
Instead of asking Why do you (Muslims) hate the Jews?
Why did White Christian Europeans kill and murder and Torture 6 Million Jews and persecute them for centuries then kick them out of Europe by exterminating Palestinians and replace them by Jews they the White Christian Europeans kicked from Europe.
Who is the Monster ?
حياك الله
❤❤❤❤❤
يَا أَيُّهَا الَّذِينَ آمَنُوا لَا تَتَّخِذُوا الْيَهُودَ وَالنَّصَارَىٰ أَوْلِيَاءَ ۘ بَعْضُهُمْ أَوْلِيَاءُ بَعْضٍ ۚ وَمَن يَتَوَلَّهُم مِّنكُمْ فَإِنَّهُ مِنْهُمْ ۗ إِنَّ اللَّهَ لَا يَهْدِي الْقَوْمَ الظَّالِمِينَ
@@konoeyoshito6105 هاهاهاهاهاهااهاهاه hahahahahahahahahahahahaah
His message in one sentence: "You should understand the importance of being an individual (rather than being just a member of a group) who can realize what is right and what is not."
His views others just as apart of group whom he assigns certain values (like sunni hates shia). This man don't have idea of what's he's talking about
WHY: It is very clear that Islamic States are hateful. They need an enemy to justify the brutal treatment of their own people. It's all about hateful domination to think "I have the right and only answer."
@@g1y3 "This man don't have idea of what's he's talking about"
Could at the same time mean that it is you who has no idea.
He just wants peace, you appearantly not.
I really appreciate your intentions, Dr Peterson. However, I don't think that this message is thought through enough as it is predicated on a few presumptions that are not accurate. First: Muslims and Christians have been living together in relative peace in the Muslim world for decades although one might argue the opposite but I'm telling you this from my experience as an Egyptian Muslim who's got Christian friends and I'm sure I'm not the only one and that it's not a narrow perspective I'm looking from but that's what we grew up on.
Second: The differences between Sunnis and Shiites although they're theological in their essence but we reached a phase in Iraq for example before the American invasion where both Sunnis and Shiites actually married from each other and the same applies to Lebanon and Syria. Until the geopolitical game that's started between Iran and Saudi Arabia under the supervision of the west definitely.
Third and the most important: your emphasis on the tolerance with the jews implies that you assume that we as Muslims are against the Jewish people themselves, but that's not the case at all. We're against Zionism which happens to be dominantly jews, but again as an Egyptian who's slightly aware of how my grandparents lived, jews used to coexist peacefully in my home city, Alexandria and other cities in Egypt pre
-immigration to the Zionist so called country. I'm not by any chance denying the fact that there's a fair amount o Muslims that might be intolerant to other religions and that's why I can see where you're coming from, but that's not the accurate representation of the Muslims all over the world.
Lastly: I couldn't thank you enough for teaching me things that I wouldn't have learned and most importantly, you did that honestly and genuinely.
Excuse my poor written English.
Well said
Excellent!
Thanks for your reply. You are on point!
Your comments is a good one, but your mistake here is thinking that Jordan Peterson has a desire to know the nuances of Muslim sentiment.
There are three things going on here, a sort of God complex on Peterson's part of the type that assumes that he can unite the religious under one umbrella. Second is the degeneration of his intellect since his illness caused by his addiction to and use of benzodiazepines - there is a distinct difference in his persona before and after.
Lastly, Peterson is in the process of finding a new audience or 'calling' as he sees it in his deluded mind, an audience that will financially support him, since his days in academia and as a public intellectual are well behind him.
For these reasons engagement with Peterson or his arguments may be a waste of your time, however, if his followers read your message it may prove useful to them.
If Muslims were Christians or jews friends why do they behead them on national television.....as a matter of fact just a few years ago and muslim man behead a Christian woman in Oklahoma for not denouncing the one true God and turning to the Muslim Allah. I dont think peace has ever been reached in this manner at all. Where you live may be more accepting but your religious beliefs demand that someone who does not accept the muslim Allah as God they must die and that there can and will never be peace between the jew and Muslim. Peace will not happen till the second coming.....when they preach peace and safety surely destruction will follow.
Well said 👏👏
This message felt more like an insult. It started off well by appreciating the muslim audience but it quickly went downhill.
I think the tone was a little bit condescending but let's not be oversensitive and focus on the message.
By starting with the Abrahamic accords, i guess Dr Peterson confuses between Israel and Zionism with Judaism and Jews. Throughout this message it felt like Dr Peterson has the assumption that muslims are at the origin of the problem and that they're the ones who regard the christians and the jews as enemies. As a matter of fact, all parties lived peacefully together for hundreds of years (let's take my country for example, Morocco, a muslim country where a lot of jews used to live peacefully and actually were protected in many occasions by the King Mohammed V). Muslims do not regard christians and jews as their enemies and the problem is not with communication but rather it is with misrepresentation and the demonization of muslims by the western media making the christians and jews believe that muslims are terrorists and barbaric and that they're trying to kill them etc etc.
It would have been better if this message was adressed to all parties and not just lecture the muslims.
He's a sellout to the right wing platform called Dailywire. It's become clear he's a bigot, arrogant to his own "intelligence", and a racist!
This
Absolutely!
Peterson said let's make peace but here you are disregarding the message and inciting a non-peaceful stand.
Again less hate and more love. Look within.
zionism just means the support of a Jewish state/ homeland
After Jordan's battle with health issues he's not just back to full strength, he's coming out swinging, more focused and bold than ever. Absolutely love this man. Dr Peterson, I first discovered you right before my father passed away (lost my mother when I was thirteen) and you gave me the strength to handle everything alone, then write and read a lengthy heartfelt eulogy at the graveside to his friends and family. You helped me through the hardest time of my life and I remain forever grateful. After all the people you've helped and continue to help, you exemplify what it means to live a meaningful life. Sending love and support, always 🫂
@ IM+VE Why didn't you put all those verses in context?
@IM+VE I hate to break it to you but the right translation here is 'our Miracles' not 'our verses'. Like saying if you don't believe in the miracles that the prophets have come with from god, don't expect a good ending. Arabic is such a cumbersome language, you really won't get any accurate results with google translate. For example is 'عبس وتولى' this one has another tragic mistranslation story of its own. It might sound demanding but I believe people should learn Arabic first if they wanna learn something meaningful from Muslims and their book.
At the end of the day, it won't be up to humans how the future pans out. We had our chance and blew it.
@IM+VE I had to scroll very very much to find a reasonable comment. Thank you
Facts
Dear mr Peterson....
Do you know what purim ceremony in juice is??????? 🥺🥺🥺🥺
PURIM ceremony is the celebration of juice people of sluthering 77000 persian 2500 year a go.
Now a day this ceremony celebrate in 21st century within juice people....
Do you think juice people are good one?????
Sir Peterson, I am a Muslim and I do not regard Jews and Christians as my enemy. I believe we should speak up about the atrocities that Zionism and Israel commits on a daily basis. I hope your affiliation with Ben Shapiro will not keep your voice surpressed regarding this issue. I and many other Muslims will like to hear your views regarding this.
I'm truly Glad to hear that friend! ♡🙏
But as Mr. Peterson stated: *unfortunately many do* :-(...
Many Zionists view you as an enemy though.
If he is going to portend to lecture Muslims on their faults and all but hold them responsible for the current conflicts in a certain part of the world, then Dr. Peterson can and should make a video addressed to Zionists who's ear he has caught as well.
And yes, his connection to Shapiro makes me wonder just how objective he actually is on the topic of Israel and Zionism.
@@jeanpaulmichell7243 huge respect for you and as Muslim i don't have any problems with Jew , our problem with Zionists , and we will never be a friend with them not now not ever , we teaching our kids that Palestine was taken by force and we will get by force , with Blood or with Peace , with Zionists logic the US should be rule by native Americans. anyhow am sure my opinion is at least 90% of Muslims.
sadly the Quran has to change, it regards, Jews as enemies, and also all infidels
Knowing how much intelligent is Dt Peterson I can't believe he made such mistakes to the extent the video looks like paid advertisement
This is a paid advertisement by the daily wire
@@takiyaazrin7562 A girl three years and one day old is betrothed by intercourse. And if a Levir has had intercourse with her, he has acquired her. And one can be liable on her account because of the law prohibiting intercourse with a married woman. And she imparts uncleanness to him who has intercourse with her when she is menstruating, to convey uncleanness to the lower as to the upper layer [of what lies beneath]. If she was married to a priest, she may eat food in the status of priestly rations. If one of those who are unfit for marriage with her had intercourse with her, he has rendered her unfit to marry into the priesthood. If any of those who are forbidden in the Torah to have intercourse with her had intercourse with her, he is put to death on her account, but she is free of responsibility [M.Nid. 5:4].
Sanhedrin 7/55B [132] - Talmud (Jewish book)
Because it is, for Ben "I'm a proud Zionist" Shapiro's Daily Wire
It seems as if ge is running for an election and us trying to earn votes from muslims
It is, it's paid by zionists
As a Muslim I can tell you that the people you describe are not people with a genuine interest in Islam you must Understand they are terrorist using the name Islam to unlawfully violence to pursue their political aim, and at the end who are the victims?
J.Peterson I love your dedication to finding the truth and I pray u shall find it.
Ask this guy how Christians fund Islamic extremists to destroy Islamic nation
"As a Muslim..." said the Muslims who bombed the 911 and other places.
You are not the gatekeeper of Islam.
And, in terms of people killed in the name of Islam, the terrorists are closer to the Prophet PBUH than you are, so are you implying that the Prophet PBUH is not a genuine Muslim?
😂
Don't play victim card mujahid
was muhammad a terrorist, if u ask me he was pretty terrible
Islam is in dire need of reformation
This aged like milk
why
@@the_guy7305 Ask yourself why
@the_guy7305 the quran is evil and copied from the bible
Give them h e l l, yeah he is a b as t ard
Dr. Peterson, let me first confirm that you got the attention of many Muslims by this message, but unfortunately with an opposite impact than your intention. your message is full of untruth about Muslims and a lot of typical stereotyping that makes nothing but misleading people who actually don't know anything about Islam and give them a wrong perception about Islam. But as usual I will be hopeful that your message will push some people to go and read more about Islam and come out eventually with a positive outcome. we never hate jews, we hate Zionists who are leading and occupation state (by the definition of the United Nation). we never hate Christians we live peacefully in our countries with Christians and never had this problems. don't impose your idea about us on others and assuming your view is right. you still need to learn more about Muslims, Islam, Islamic history before speaking about Islam in such way. with full respect. Assalamo Alaykom.
Love you my brother for Allah's sake. Jazakallahu kheiran for saying the truth
Surah 60 ayah 4 Indeed there has been an excellent example for you in Ibrahim and those with him, when they said to their people: "Verily, we are free from you and whatever you worship besides Allah, we have rejected you, and there has started between us and you, hostility and hatred forever until you believe in Allah alone,'' -- except the saying of Ibrahim to his father: "Verily, I will ask forgiveness for you, but I have no power to do anything for you before Allah.'' "Our Lord! In You we put our trust, and to You we turn in repentance, and to You is the final Return.''
As a typical North American I have no insight on the deep details of Muslims but yes I am now pushed to look up what a Zionist is. It’s a start.
It sounds somewhat funny that u talk about truth and history while twisting them quite a bit.
Jew, christians and muslims have always been living together in harmony? No. Not today and not in Medieval times. We have enough historical sources which report about progroms. Moreover, the fact alone that the prophet advised to let non-muslims pay a special tax is enough proof that there was some kind of apartheid.
And in regards to the occupying of territory: if someone loses a war which he initiated then he has to pay the price for it. Nothing unusual here.
And btw, wasnt it muslims who took away Palestine from the Byzantian Empire and since then occupied jewish and christian soil?
Improvements start with self reflection and honesty. Please try it.
Fool
*For great men, religion is a way of making friends; small people make religion a fighting tool.*
*-APJ Abdul Kalam..*
That hits hard, I really loved that man
Ola hu Uber
Then Mohammad was a really, really small man.
This is typically the statement of the new age religions, don't be trapped
he was a legend,mashallah
Be mindful, aware, and cautious of your inner self Mr. Peterson. He who has brought you to fame because of your humbleness and truth seeking can easily take it all away when your intentions change.
You yourself said that one of the most things you fear in life is that people NEVER get away with wrongdoing. It always seems to catch up to them. Always !
- Plan to dismantle Israel/Palestinian/Muslim Apartheid, settle all religious disputes, and bring peace to the "Middle East".
Plan does not need to be absolute truth nor believed by it's implementors (or the implemented). Can the plan be pulled off with success is what I wish to lay out to you if the above title is a goal you wish to achieve regardless. [They wait for the success of the plan after the fact before they TRULY believe in the plan anyway]
The plan is to promote and force the hand of Israel to enthrone me, Edward Nathan Schwarz, as King of Israel according to Torah law and I would have absolute rule over the interpretation of all the Holy Writ [Tanak, Gospel, Qur'an] and settle all religious and legal disputes TO EVERYONES BENEFIT AND SATISFACTION.
And you can flesh that out with me ahead of time what that settlement would be and see if any side would feel a ruling would not be Just for them or in their interests.
What do Palestinians want? No walls surrounding them? They're gone. What do Muslim's want? No apartheid in Jerusalem? Done away with. What do the Rabbis want? A Temple? They'll settle for the Tabernacle. What does Egypt want, what does Jordan want, what does Iran want?
The Davidic King, according to ALL their Lore, holds the Lord's power of attorney in Israel's affairs. Except for cases in idolatry, this king can amend the covenant laws at will among other powers. I got plenty of resources to share. Who wants to be my friend?
Anybody please tell me, What can I give you that you be my friend? I'll open an office and stock it with Santa's helpers for you to send in your requests. I got resources and "stuff" warehouses busting their seems. I'll bring an oasis to your desert if that is what you need or want - spare no expense.
So whoever this is I'm speaking to please forward this plan to concerned parties for consideration and refining if interested. -Cheers
that sounds like a threat
@@heartless5268 “He” as in God.
@Scott Scotty “He” as in God. And I’m not perfect either. But I don’t point fingers !!
Lovely content ,Prof! I resonated with this Message, I posit that it will have equal ramifications which are beneficial, on non Muslims, because of the commonality in the Message: An end to Wars, An end to Self righteous beliefs, An end to geopolitical Warfare.. Christians are not exempt from imperfection and Impurity, However i believe that the predominant End of listening to this video is Improving personally, on all frontiers Of Spiritual and Emotional nature,
00:45
"The *Abraham Accords* are a joint statement between the State of Israel, the United Arab Emirates, and the United States, reached on August 13, 2020. Subsequently, the term was used to refer collectively to agreements between Israel and the United Arab Emirates (the Israel-United Arab Emirates normalization agreement) and Bahrain (the Bahrain-Israel normalization agreement)."
I loved this video until I understood this reference.
I was definitely not ready for this disappointment.
P. S. And trust me, dr. Peterson, you would not get a single like or comment of support here from any reasonable Muslim had you mentioned "normalization of relations with Israel" in an explicit manner. No ammount of pacifistic words can cover their crimes.
We can and certainly do live in peace with Jews and Christians as a rule (btw, check out the history of Jerusalem and under whose rule did the Jews, Christians and Muslims all live there in peace) - but not with Zlonists. I just can't describe my disappointment at the fact that this came from *you* .
Part of my map of meaning is seriously damaged.
Well said Edina,God bless you
Thank you, was going to write about it but you got it on point.
The Zionists are major problem
We don't have any problem with Jews or Christians
When he is wrong I love that these comments don’t bring out hate,there are instead guiding him to gain more knowledge on the topic
It’s human to be wrong sometimes. Muslims aren’t treacherous. Our faith calls for patience and positive interpretations of one’s words. Jordan is misinformed, hope he researches the Muslim faith and world better.
He isn't wrong. There has been century long infighting continued to this day.
Just because you live abroad, or in an islamic country that doesn't hate other schools of islam, doesn't mean he's wrong.
Thats Islam for ya
He’s not wrong
We captured excellent women for ransom. We decided to have sex with them but by observing 'azl (Withdrawing the male sexual organ before emission of semen to avoid-conception). We asked Allah's Messenger (ﷺ), and he said: It does not matter if you do not do it, for every soul that is to be born up to the Day of Resurrection will be born.
Sahih Muslim 1438a
I am a Sunni muslim, I had an Iraqi Shia friend who wanted to sell his car. He invited me to his house, made me tea, treated me with great hospitality. We rode together in his car for the test drive. He would greet me with a smile whenever we meet down the street.
Iraqis are very kind and warm hearted. My good friend is Iraqi Sunni and I am Iranian Shia we never cared about the sect or ethnicity
Allah is The Greatest!
Actually not.
Yeah, Sunnis' don't hate Shias or vice versa...
In the 1980s Iran and Iraq managed to slautter a million of each other. Lots of love there.
Humility and humbleness are the key to any belief especially in Islamic faith … We Muslims try our best to follow the guidance of Islam , if I do wrong then I am to blame not my religion…
How many people have actually spoken like this to try and unite people? Well done sir, please continue striving to unite us all...
Not many that ppl might actually listen to 🤔
Depends what you mean by "unite," it is easily to say that common ground can be found but the common ground Peterson uses is superficial whereas what divides us is fundamental. Let's definitely recognize that, agree to see the vital differences for what they are in a manner of mutual respect
@@dyawr Yes! Mr. Peterson is somewhat of an “outsider” to all of us. Hearing it from him has more of an impact.
@@simplycj5460 Let's hope so 🙂👍
@@simplycj5460 I don’t think so. It’s sounds unrealistic. Especially when you know what the teachings of Islam are about.
Wow, the tone!! The gall to lecture us!!
And The Abraham accord?!!!? Well now you’ve shown your true colors.
I am glad you said this. An eye opener for those muslims who follow you and listen to you.
You muslims and your ability to take offense at pretty much everything is amazing. Go away, you won't be missed
Indeed. May Allah humiliate him
His tone and attitude 🤦♂️
I'm done with him
You guys are clowns really
@@mainaad537 believe me, you won't be missed.
I think that this message applies to most religions. I am a Christian and I’ve seen some absolutely awful people who also call themselves christians. People who literally call for violence and even murder against other groups of people. Which is completely the opposite of what Jesus taught. There are extremists on all sides
Read about your religion and you will find everything other than peace! Thats why they act as you described!
Yeah, so true. Such hate-preachers (religious and political alike) should be ashamed of themselves.
@@w.a.3733 Show me
@@w.a.3733 It's the same for all religions
@@w.a.3733 so as your religion. hypocrite spotted. most of the muslim majority countries are under developed.
Quran 2:62
Indeed, those who believed and those who were Jews or Christians or Sabeans - those [among them] who believed in Allāh and the Last Day and did righteousness - will have their reward with their Lord, and no fear will there be concerning them, nor will they grieve
إِنَّ ٱلَّذِينَ ءَامَنُوا۟ وَٱلَّذِينَ هَادُوا۟ وَٱلنَّصَٰرَىٰ وَٱلصَّٰبِـِٔينَ مَنْ ءَامَنَ بِٱللَّهِ وَٱلْيَوْمِ ٱلْءَاخِرِ وَعَمِلَ صَٰلِحًا فَلَهُمْ أَجْرُهُمْ عِندَ رَبِّهِمْ وَلَا خَوْفٌ عَلَيْهِمْ وَلَا هُمْ يَحْزَنُونَ
I follow all of your lectures and have watched mostly all your RUclips links, I must say that you have your information incorrect about the enemy. I am a muslim and my best friend is jew he is dying, and I am his carer. Don’t judge people on situations that governments have created. Thank you.
Read the Quran , to know what Islam thinks about Jews and Christians
@@kurikanjo5214 make sure you read the whole Kuran with the full understanding before opening your mouth
Well it considers them as Kafar. Which even touching non Muslims is prohibited. As someone who was under Islam's influence for most of my age I think Muslims need to be more welcoming to other faith. Not to try inforce their own faith not to try to gain political power. Coexistence is the key. None of the religious are right or wrong. They need to clean old beliefs and just live together.
@@majid3263 first of all kafir mean non Muslims and you allow to teach non Muslims. Don’t a lie
@@mohanadkhaled9969 Don't accuse people. Be respectful. Good luck!
With all the respect to this channel and its author, there needs to be firstly an argument established that Muslims are fundamentally seeing themselves as enemy's to Jews or fighting to each other and then inviting them to be in peace and respect. I can't see such an argument here and there seems to be a pre-judgement here (if not biased)
Also, your facial expression and language is not that kind when compared with your other message to the Christian Churches which shows your discomfort in your message.
All the best and trust your goodwill on this.
No argument is needed for that, it's plain obvious.
If I may reply the Quran is clear with regard to your first statement as ' Muslims are fundamentally seeing themselves enemy of the jews' If you are a Muslim and follow the sunnah then would these verses not support the very statement that you are trying to disprove. I ask only because there seems to be a contradiction and if i am wrong please correct context etc
Quran : Curse Jews/Christians- Surah 9:29 , 9:30 / Take Jews nor Christians as friends 5:56 / Jews and Christians worse of creatures -98:6 / Jews, Christians turned into apes - 5:60 (64) / Enmity for Christians - 5:14 / Do not befriend nonbelievers-3:28 / Fight unbelievers 9:123
HADITH: Kill Children -Sahih Muslim vol 4 verse 4457 / Kill Jews behind talking stones - Sahih Muslim book 41 6985
I believe he wants it to be motivating in a tough way , it's like : get up and go nail it man ! I trust his goodwill too
He was some what patronising. The tone he used in his speaks h didn’t sit right with me
@@iluvucuzjesus5347 when you reference a script please use a trusted source as this makes no sense why would god tell us to hate the people of the religions that he sent down. The Quran and the sunnah state that all the people of the book (there are 4 books 1 sent by the prophet David 1 sent by the prophet Moses and 1 sent by the prophet esa or Jesus and 1 sent by the prophet Mohammed) who have a drop of belief in there heart shall enter paradise but god knows best as he will judge us all for our sins on the day of judgment
I taught English as a second language, in England, in a town that had many immigrants from all over Europe plus a well settled Muslim community. I was impressed with the dedication to their religion and their respect paid to me as a teacher and a as white Christian.
God bless you for your testimony!❤
Just wait
@@devanshusingh3174 for what, for you to come out as gay? that won't be long
As a muslim, we don't hate chirstian, or jews or any race. The problem is there are "zionist" who take some land in Palestine. If Bible is discarded by atheis in trash or toilet, we as muslim Will be angry because there are name of Jesus (our phrophet) and Maria (name of one surah in Al Qur'an) being disrespectful.
Plan to dismantle Israel/Palestinian/Muslim Apartheid, settle all religious disputes, and bring peace to the "Middle East".
Plan does not need to be absolute truth nor believed by it's implementors (or the implemented). Can the plan be pulled off with success is what I wish to lay out to you if the above title is a goal you wish to achieve regardless. [They wait for the success of the plan after the fact before they TRULY believe in the plan anyway]
The plan is to promote and force the hand of Israel to enthrone me, Edward Nathan Schwarz, as King of Israel according to Torah law and I would have absolute rule over the interpretation of all the Holy Writ [Tanak, Gospel, Qur'an] and settle all religious and legal disputes TO EVERYONES BENEFIT AND SATISFACTION.
And you can flesh that out with me ahead of time what that settlement would be and see if any side would feel a ruling would not be Just for them or in their interests.
What do Palestinians want? No walls surrounding them? They're gone. What do Muslim's want? No apartheid in Jerusalem? Done away with. What do the Rabbis want? A Temple? They'll settle for the Tabernacle. What does Egypt want, what does Jordan want, what does Iran want?
The Davidic King, according to ALL their Lore, holds the Lord's power of attorney in Israel's affairs. Except for cases in idolatry, this king can amend the covenant laws at will among other powers. I got plenty of resources to share. Who wants to be my friend?
Anybody please tell me, What can I give you that you be my friend? I'll open an office and stock it with Santa's helpers for you to send in your requests. I got resources and "stuff" warehouses busting their seems. I'll bring an oasis to your desert if that is what you need or want - spare no expense.
So whoever this is I'm speaking to please forward this plan to concerned parties for consideration and refining if interested. -Cheers
A muslim living and working in Japan.
Like not I am bullied or stuff, but being critized or thought to be weird by my not being promiscuous and waiting for marriage to have sex, and felt lonely of not being understood, this massage, just hit right into the heart. The Japanese, really does respectful and they actually respect religious rules of others, but still, they subtly or explicitly blame religion for group conflicts, and advertising atheism as the right way to be individualistic. Me here just to be not understood can came with huge sadness sometimes. But your message, searching for satan inside yourself, being the light and being the example by your actions, was what I had as a stance for like 15 years(I am 31) as a stance of life. You should show what you are and strive for good, and be good example, so people will admire your thoughts. I could not even think whether there is more wonderful service to your religion and your society, given you believe truthfully to your religion and consider it to be righteous.But, it is not that my/your religion just have the good people. We should compete for goodness both inside our religions, and across religions, so we can just be an example to "Nah, not all of them are bad / useless / satanistic / terrorist. I know a brilliant/kind guy from that religion", and it would be huge. That was what I have always thought, do my best to follow rules of religion, try to understand why they are there(so I would not be blinded or ignorant), and apply them to my life as much as I can (or at least strive for it). And I thought that everyone must have the equality of opportunity, after then (whether religious or ideological) the truly good beliefs will shine through. And I thought we must give it to all that opportunity, and so people would strive and lift up themselves, and would make their society better. And I am working toward that goal in work, not that it gone a long way yet though, trying to make education better and cheaper, while being with truly different ideologies in the company, the mission of better and cheaper for everyone is the same
Still, I was lonely of not being understood on some part, especially on theological front that my religion being center of my life rather than it being some "(minor) tradition", so, your beautiful words, and they are directed to Muslims, I just thought I wouldn't cry, but it made me cry (even I had tears writing this). Just there is someone, at the other side of globe, whom I respect, believing (or acting accordingly to) another religion saying the almost same thing, just got me in the heart. Thank you Peterson. Thank you Dr. Jordan.
PS. I have took your personality tests and occasionally watched your lectures in 2019, more intensely this year, and had many agreements. I am not taken your self-authoring course (yet?), but I am also trying to write my fears / shortcomings of now and past, and long/medium/short term future goals and analyze them to get my shit together, which the concept of your course inspired me to do. I am somehow autistic ( not diagnosed but less like ADHD and more like asperger maybe?) and still got over its shortcomings, I can relate to your ideas on the wokeness front as well, similar to the religious/ideology front, I think people should get their shit together if they can (instead of self-victimazing) to represent their group better while keeping individuality. And society should focus on those who cannot do that because of poverty/(real) disability.
longgggg
very well said brother!
WHY: It is very clear that Islamic States are hateful. They need an enemy to justify the brutal treatment of their own people. It's all about hateful domination to think "I have the right and only answer."
Hello Dr Peterson, I’ve been following your work for years now (since 2015, I believe), and your lessons helped me process and go through a lot of challenges I had in life. However, I’m disappointed by how shallow and presumptuous this video was.
I’m a Palestinian, and as a young adult, I faced many challenges in gaining the right to exist and work anywhere in the world. Those challenges fundamentally stemmed from Palestine’s impossible human conditions and the ongoing illegal occupation of our people. In many ways, I’m much luckier and more privileged than many Palestinians who have their houses demolished, freedom stolen, and lives taken every single day by the Israeli government and army. Our problem was never with Judaism or its people but rather the inhumane practices and attitudes of Zionism.
I’m doing much better now, earning enough to sustain myself and help my family, and I can pursue what’s meaningful. Your books and lectures influenced me to reach this state. So thank you.
Finally, while I’ll be the first to criticise the Muslim world, your critique has come off as misinformed and shallow. Consider learning more about the subject matter from its people. Perhaps you could form a pen pal partnership with someone from Palestine? That ought to give you a glimpse into the reality there and might give you an insight that many westerners don't have.
You don't want peace, you want only death.
couldn't of said it better
Nah brah, you just haven't cleaned your room well enough.
When you do, you'll understand that JP knows more about palestinians than you do. Otherwise, an educated person like JP would know what he doesn't know.
They were wrong when they said he's uninformed around marxism, they were wrong when they said he's uninformed around gender, they were wrong when they said he's uninformed around feminism. Bashar, let me be the first to tell you that you too are just woke.
You just need a penpall.
--Plan to dismantle Israel/Palestinian/Muslim Apartheid, settle all religious disputes, and bring peace to the "Middle East".
Plan does not need to be absolute truth nor believed by it's implementors (or the implemented). Can the plan be pulled off with success is what I wish to lay out to you if the above title is a goal you wish to achieve regardless. [They wait for the success of the plan after the fact before they TRULY believe in the plan anyway]
The plan is to promote and force the hand of Israel to enthrone me, Edward Nathan Schwarz, as King of Israel according to Torah law and I would have absolute rule over the interpretation of all the Holy Writ [Tanak, Gospel, Qur'an] and settle all religious and legal disputes TO EVERYONES BENEFIT AND SATISFACTION.
And you can flesh that out with me ahead of time what that settlement would be and see if any side would feel a ruling would not be Just for them or in their interests.
What do Palestinians want? No walls surrounding them? They're gone. What do Muslim's want? No apartheid in Jerusalem? Done away with. What do the Rabbis want? A Temple? They'll settle for the Tabernacle. What does Egypt want, what does Jordan want, what does Iran want?
The Davidic King, according to ALL their Lore, holds the Lord's power of attorney in Israel's affairs. Except for cases in idolatry, this king can amend the covenant laws at will among other powers. I got plenty of resources to share. Who wants to be my friend?
Anybody please tell me, What can I give you that you be my friend? I'll open an office and stock it with Santa's helpers for you to send in your requests. I got resources and "stuff" warehouses busting their seems. I'll bring an oasis to your desert if that is what you need or want - spare no expense.
So whoever this is I'm speaking to please forward this plan to concerned parties for consideration and refining if interested. -Cheers
Apparently Zionists, like Jordans boss Benjamin Shapiro, don't have internal ancient demons.
Only Zionism's victims have them.
We don't see other religions as enemies, you live in same planet and you know that almost all of others see us as enemies, it's better if you switch this message, with all respect
sometimes it can be hard to see things objectively. but no other religion propagates and promotes their religion in the manner Muslims do. you people have jihad for Gods sake. but he is saying that everyone including Christians and Muslims should be at peace. if you cant understand that then im sorry the message flew over your head.
@Roc they won’t see their own hypocrisy
@@justiceegwabor3218 please look up what "Jihad" means, not literally but conceptually in Islam, before making such comments. Jihad is not war in the name of god, it is struggle and work in the name of god. Even picking up litter and throwing it into the trash bin could be considered jihad, if you truly do it because you know that god wants you to do the right things. What those terror organisations do is a perversion of the word, and in no way, shape or form has to do anything with what Islam is about. What you are doing is taking a tiny radical minority and projecting their ideals to the general Muslim population, which is just plain wrong.
@@justiceegwabor3218 It look like you are the one with short neck and the message flew over your head. All the issues nowadays that Muslims countries suffer from are from countries that believe in Christianity starting from Afghanistan, Iraq, Syria, Libya and most Africa. Christians killed more Muslims throughout history. and by the way, Jihad came useful when Muslims fought and defeated crusaders and Mughals. Muslims will never stop Jihad against all enemies especially Christians and Jews until they kicked them out of their lands.
do we now? and here you are making threats... its better if you switch your message? realy?
Why someone like you a well read person suddenly doesn’t appear to be well read about islam ?! why you want to paint this picture of us almost like an isolated society and we hate everybody (according to you) it’s actually sad to see someone like you doing this, i lost respect for this man
Me too bro, what he do is false imagery. Sorry bro that I recommending Jordan Peterson to some muslim community All this time just to watch his arrogance together
Daily Wire contracted with Joker Peterson recently which is founded by Ben Shapiro who has a record of dehumanizing the Palestinians.
Same brother
Cause he is under Daily Wire, not surprising
Same , he looks so different now
I am a Sunni Muslim and have 12 siblings who are Sunni Muslim as well. The youngest is 28, and not one of us hold any form of animosity towards Shia’s. It’s never crossed our minds. I’ve prayed beside Shia’s growing up, studied with them during “bible school” and still hold friendships with people of Shia faith. What in the hell is this man talking about? 😂😂😂
Edit - To all my Muslim brothers and sisters, am I ignorant to think that Shia’s and Sunni’s are not at war with one another?
I’m a Shia muslim who lives in Saudi Arabia and I have many friends who are Sunni and we live in harmony like our ancestors did at least in my city. and I believe the majority of the muslim world have nothing but love and respect to our Fellow people of the book, both christians and jews and respect to our fellow humans of all other religions. the majority of muslims don’t have a problem with Jews at all in fact we share more with them in term of linguistic and religion than any other people. our problem is with Zionism and occupation only.
Mr peterson doesn not really KNOW the muslim world. May be he never experience it in real muslim world. I mean he never travel or stay in muslim country for some months atleast and see what truly happened.
I am a sunni muslim. May Allah bless us all.. Aamiin. 💕
Hope we get out of this sectarian divide brother.
Love from a Shia brother
The jews having a nation and land is okay. If Muslims and Christians and Atheist in China and Russia can own land. Buddhist and shinto can own land and a soverign nation why canr they?
@@dantesinferno373 the problem is that I can't take your house and divide it to two uneven parts and say I should own a house because everyone one has one what about the owner ?🤣
As a Muslim, I like some of the topics Jordan speaks about. However, after all the interviews you had with Muslims, you never tried to even understand our religion. You spout things like Shia and Sunni Muslims fighting each other, yet you don't know why either term exists or who each sect is. Also, you are blaming Muslims and claiming we hate Christians and Jews, yet it's your Christian and Jewish governments brainwashing your people into hating Muslims and instigating fights against them since the times of Romans. How about you read some religious history, our brother Hamza Yusef told you in an interview, yet you didnt listen to him.
You need to always remember, that your governments have always been the oppressors in most cases through out history. Muslims brought knowledge and ethics into your degraded cultures during the European dark ages, you took it, denied it ever came from us, and now, you are doing the same thing. You are denying Muslims by your worthless words of how we should be with Christians, Jews or with each other. Yes, Muslims fight each other sometimes, but we never caused a world war. Christians caused 2 world wars already, and on the verge of a 3rd world war, yet you want to preach Muslims philosphical non sense about clearing hate? What a contradiction. We all saw the hate and racism towards Muslims when they migrated to Europe during the wars which Christian and Jewish governments caused in the Middle East, but when Ukranians migrated because of the wars you caused, you welcomed them with open hands.
Our authority in life comes from the one only, and that is, Allah all mighty. We listen to what Alllah tells us in the Quran, and what our Prophet Muhammad peace be upon him tells us, not you, or anyone else in this world for that matter. We know who our enemies are while you don't. Allah told us in the Quran (Surah 5 Al-Ma'idah, Ayat 82-85) that Jews and polytheists hate the Muslims the most, so we will always be on guard with them, while Christians are the most friendly, so we have no issues with Christians. Also, we know about the fight against ourselves, Allah already told us in the Quran, old news. Jordan, if you actually read the Quran you would know, but you haven't obviously, you show no sign of any respect to Muslims, you read books about LGBT stuff yet you never tried to read and understand the Quran. So contradicting. Also, in general, most Christians and Jews will never accept Islam, Allah all mighty told us in the Quran in Surat al Baqara verse 120.
We understand Christians and Jews more than you understand us. And it's your governments wrekcing havoc in the Muslims countries by placing dictator hypocrite butchers in our countries because Allah all mighty gave your countries science and military ability. This is all a test to see what you do with it. Your governments corrupt the earth and skies with your technologies, steal resources from other countries, kill the planet, kill the people, and then you want to give us a lecture about making peace with ourselves? You dont even understand the basics of peace. Soon enough, your countries will pay for what they did, and every oppressor will pay for what they did in this life or the next. Your words have no effect on educated Muslims.
To my Muslims brother and sisters, don't be flattered with his words, becareful, this person doesn't care about Muslims, heed my warning. If he did, he would not say these things to us after all the interviews he did with Muslims. It seems that Jordan is part of the propaganda to unite Christians Jews and Muslims under the new movement of Abarahamic religion, which is utter non sense. I had my doubts about Jordan and now this is it. No more trust, unsubscribe.
To my fellow Christians, what I wrote is not because of any hate towards you, these are the realities of your governments, and if you study and research about the topics I spoke about, you will find the truth. I live and work in America, I find Christian Americans to be very nice people. I don't want war against anyone, but I won't be quiet and will fight anyone who tries to attack our religion, insult us, and act as a hypocrite authority to Muslims like you Jordan. You as Christians need to figure out the truth about your own governments, we already know about our corrupt governments in the Muslim world and are fighting to fix it. A true Muslim never has any issue with establishing peace with anyone offering it.
What actually troubles me is the fact that Mr.Peterson you just said that, and I quote, “I have developed an audience in the muslim world” and “the comments from the muslim watchers and listeners to my RUclips channel and podcast have been extraordinarily positive” then you go on to say we refuse to affiliate ourselves with anything or anyone who isn’t adherent to the religion of Islam or even go as far to say that we consider them our enemies. And that is just a tad bit contradicting don’t you think.
Exactly
It doesn't necessarily contradict, he states that there was a positive response from people from the Muslim community *that watched the video* , he did not refer to the whole community. This is about different people, while you could argue that the generalisation of the Muslil community is not fair to make, it is the general impression witch gives these claims their own right.
@@DamianForReal perhaps… visit a Muslim-majority country first?
Generally speaking, have you noticed that literally everything that does not come from the west is demonized by the media in a propaganda campaign? ( black people. Migrants, foreigners, non-western religions, other countries, indigenous…literally EVERYTHING). That just can’t be true. Misinformation allow the west to keep its hegemony. Based on the media narrative “good” can only come from the west. When it comes to “others” it should be bad. Its like “I am good and anybody else can be nothing but bad”. The only way to get out of the propaganda bubble is to travel and see the world with your very eyes.
@@princessfanta8247 I'm sorry that to bring it to you but I actually got my impressions and opinions from other Muslims, some of my friends are (not radical) but the most I encounter on a day to day basis is unhuman to me. Even they say what others do is bs. I won't go on a rant because I am convinced that they do not represent Islam as they say they do. And *not everyone is the same*, that is why there can be "contradicting" statement over certain groups because generalisation of groups is human nature to understand the word, subconsciously or consciously, it is part of being a human. How bad or good a perception might be can be influenced by 1 what othet people say (media politics etc) or 2 individual encounters (what my opinion is based on)
@@DamianForReal The point of his video or “message” was to advise us to not limit our interconnections to muslims only and to be more open to interacting with ppl outside the muslim community. You can rewatch the video if you didn’t exactly understand his “message”. Anyways it’s fine to have the impression that muslims do not affiliate themselves with ppl of different faiths bcuz of what’s portrayed by the media. But it’s another thing when you have a platform and tou see many muslims supporting you specifically despite not being a muslim yourself. So you become aware that the impression you had was false bcuz here you are as a non Muslim but yet gaining a lot of appreciation from their community. So Clearly stating that and then negating the statement by advising muslims against what he confirmed himself in the beginning of the video to be false is indeed very contradicting.
I'm one of the Muslim fans of Dr Peterson who's been following him for several yrs now. I usually find his opinions and views brilliant because of all the research and wisdom that goes into every sentence he speaks.
This time, however, I do believe Dr Peterson's views lack research and some are downright baseless ideas that it seems he's observed superficially.
These are issues that have deep, deep roots and are extremely complex. Like another viewer pointed out, you cannot ask Ukrainians to seek harmony with Russians just because that's a nice thing to do. The matter is much worse than an ego battle of two tribes.
And like another viewer pointed out, sunni and shias live in harmony. I have many shia friends and know of many other sunnis who have close friendships with shias. We look at each other as brethren, not outsiders or disbelievers. It's only when there are actual miscreants seeking to create political disruption that trouble arises.
With all due respect, I suggest you read more about the history of Palestine and the birth of Zionism in the 1940s. That explains our hurt and pain more than anything anyone says.
Are you serious bro? Don't be blind just look the way who talking to you as Muslim, the white man way who think he is better than other races.
Well said
Zionism wasn't born in the 1940s..
But would you continue to leave in the past?
@@GameFap zionism do born on that time, but the dream about state of jew was already exist since sporadic on roman empire.
I remember I had a shia muslim friend in our school in Turkey. And we were respecting her beliefs about the religion. So we are not in a fight against people with different beliefs. West media is just such manipulative against us.
Dr Peterson, I’ve been a supporter of yours for years and I am a Muslim revert as well. I found the tone and message in this video to be off putting and seems as if there are some things unclear to you about Muslims. There is a gracious response from one of our brothers by the name of saajid lipham that you should probably review carefully. Would love to hear you explain where this message is coming from on another video with Mohammed Hijab. I think he’s able to handle the complexities of this topic very well with you. Please continue seeking clarity on this topic as this is clearly not it. Wish you well. Take care.
I second this! Another video with hijab is needed.
I liked the response video of SMILE2JANNAH
@@sisterfleur7523 i dont know of about smile 2 jannah, but sajid Lipham has responded so clearly to evey statement jordan peterson made.
Well said
U04R can you explain yourself a little more please?
Have you seen all the response videos? I'd like you rank your feelings and thoights about each fro which uou think is best and why to least good, anyone can do this and please reply back here and let me know.
That's it, just like other intellectuals JP decided that he can instruct anyone on any issue. Too bad, 'cause it's no less ridiculous than other academics who are not aware of their limitations and simply lack of understanding of the issue at hand.
correct
I actually think he has a point. You do not at all see Muslims joining hands with other religions to fight against common issues, such as transgenderism. That is his main point. We fight these issues alone and/or within our own Muslim communities. In addition, no....there are issues between Sunnis and Shiates for SURE...rooted in history and differences in the faith itself. HOWEVER, we do, indeed, have an issue with accepting the other completely when again, it comes to common schools of thought, and I think that it's due to a general lack of unity amongst the Muslim ummah. You see a divide among the community now for such topics as the hijab, the Sunnah, dress code, manners, etc. So essentially, I agree with Jordan B. Peterson because we DO have these issues, and people just don't like acknowledging the truth 🤷♀️
You just said it sister .
How do you go from "abandon ideology" to "support zionism"? I just can't get over this.
(For anyone who doesn't know what Abraham accords - 0:45 - are, look it up.)
So many times I've been filled with respect, love and compassion for you, dr. Peterson, while listening to your lectures and talks. I was one of those who kept excusing your misstatements about Islam, claiming that you simply don't know better but are well-intentioned. But how naive can you really be? How far with that "not obvious" BS can you go? How much more people need to be killed or expelled from their homes for so called country that didn't even exist 80 years ago, for you to understand that Muslims are not the problem there?
Or are you completely aware of everything that was and is being done in the name of Israel and knowingly support it?
I just cant reconcile that with that old psychology professor whose lectures, ideas and character I enjoyed so much.
You can easily see from this comment section that Muslims genuinely want to see the good will in non-Muslims and always welcome that. I myself also liked this video until I realized that you didn't really mean "Jews" but "Zionists". I'm sure that none of those Muslims who wrote positive comments are aware of what exactly you suggested there.
Not sure what's going on with you lately, but if after everything you've been preaching for decades, you drift into some deadly ideologies, just like that ... I'd argue that even you wouldn't recognize yourself anymore, let alone we who used to have so much respect for you.
How I wish that you fix this somehow.
May Allah protect us all from evil, and from supporting evil.
"The *Abraham Accords* are a joint statement between the State of Israel, the United Arab Emirates, and the United States, reached on August 13, 2020. Subsequently, the term was used to refer collectively to agreements between Israel and the United Arab Emirates (the Israel-United Arab Emirates normalization agreement) and Bahrain (the Bahrain-Israel normalization agreement)."
Facts. Jordan really dissapointed us with this.
"Angels on Earth -- Love Letter to Lily", Asra Nomani, YT.
Well worth checking out.
This brave and dignified Muslim woman could teach you how to become open-minded.
May Allah protect us all from evil, and from supporting evil.
@@edinam.5080 much respect for waking up but why did you feel in love with guy in the first place if you don’t mind me asking?
@@fieldmarshal7081 I don't know how familiar you are with his yt content. I was listening to his university lectures on "Maps of meaning", and later many of his interviews and talks. I had a strong impression that he is genuinely seeking to understand the truth about the existence, and as you probably know many of his stances were (are) completely in line with Islam. He managed to understand that there can not possibly be clash between the religious truth and the scientific truth, which I think is not that simple for someone who is raised in an enviroment that it seriously opposed to that idea. I think he has kind of "prophetic conscience", i.e. he really feels the urge to act out his beliefs. And he did stand up for his beliefs against one of the strongest lobbies of our time, and continues to do so.
Listening to those lectures from psychology, I thought that he had developed extraordinary coherent worldview, given the fact that he *didn't* refer to the authentic God's revelation, the Qurʾān. (I wasn't and I'm not approving his worldview in its totality, just trying to say that it's impressive that he managed to make sense of many things, many big questions of life and existence in general, that bothered him, and then articulate all that in a way that can be really helpful for orienting oneself in everyday life.)
Also, much can be learned from his familial relationships. Those are some things that come to my mind now.
But as he started to engage in conversations with Muslims, and continued to fail to really understand the simple message of Islam, I started to think that the time and effort he invested into building his worldview is preventing him to see or truly appreciate anything that might damage it, or anything that would require him to make any serious adjustment to his philosophy. Which is obviously extremely ironical, considering his own teachings.
Still, there are many amazing things about him; I can't just dispense it all away. I just don't know what to make of this now. It's hard for me to believe that he could suggest that we make peace with israel while actually understanding what's going on with Palestinians. But if he's really aware of everything, that's really devastating, since many of us used to see him as a voice of healthy reasoning.
But anyway, if that was all just an illusion, it's definitely better off broken.
no one have to find a middle way. as we dont need a middle way. we, muslims are not enemies of anyone. if a muslim needs a middle way, we can find it with our neighbours, relatives etc. This, what you said about told by a terrorist group by ending fighting with its own people.
As a muslim, majority of us dont hate anyone based on their religion, yet only on their hate action toward us Muslims . Also As a Muslim i respect you regardless of your religious beliefs, because i see you to be a man of God, a free thinker, & a non hypocrite & an overall a good human being
Why should God let you into Heaven?
Have you lied (even once in your entire life), looked with lust (sexual desire), dishonoured parents, stolen anything, had hatred towards someone, had premarital sex, adultery etc If you answered yes to any one of the above then you are a sinner like the rest of us.
So, I ask you again, why should God let a sinner into Heaven?
Sinners don’t go to heaven they go to hell, But we are blessed to have Jesus (God incarnate) die on the Cross and rise from the dead. If you Repent (forsake your sinful, unholy ways and live righteous instead) & Believe in Jesus as God, you will be seen as a Saint and welcomed into Heaven.
John 3:17 For God did not send His Son into the world to condemn the world, but that the world through Him might be saved
@@thereisnonegoodbutgodjohn363 People have different believe. And each believe their religion is right. So,it's useless for you to ask us why God would let us to heaven. I ask which GOD? Yours or mine? For there is only one GOD.
وَٱلَّذِينَ ءَامَنُوا۟ وَعَمِلُوا۟ ٱلصَّـٰلِحَـٰتِ سَنُدْخِلُهُمْ جَنَّـٰتٍۢ تَجْرِى مِن تَحْتِهَا ٱلْأَنْهَـٰرُ خَـٰلِدِينَ فِيهَآ أَبَدًۭا ۖ وَعْدَ ٱللَّهِ حَقًّۭا ۚ وَمَنْ أَصْدَقُ مِنَ ٱللَّهِ قِيلًۭا ١٢٢
And those who believe and do good, We will soon admit them into Gardens under which rivers flow, to stay there for ever and ever. Allah’s promise is ˹always˺ true. And whose word is more truthful than Allah’s? (An-nisa verse 122)
And also as a Muslim, I ask the same question that you asked my brethren. Why Allah should let you into heaven?
وَٱلَّذِينَ كَفَرُوا۟ لَهُمْ نَارُ جَهَنَّمَ لَا يُقْضَىٰ عَلَيْهِمْ فَيَمُوتُوا۟ وَلَا يُخَفَّفُ عَنْهُم مِّنْ عَذَابِهَا ۚ كَذَٰلِكَ نَجْزِى كُلَّ كَفُورٍۢ ٣٦
As for the disbelievers, they will have the Fire of Hell, where they will not be ˹allowed to be˺ finished by death, nor will its torment be lightened for them. This is how We reward every ˹stubborn˺ disbeliever.
Thank you.
@@thereisnonegoodbutgodjohn363
1st ayah in Quran : in name of Allah . The most merciful.
We enter paradise not cuz of our doings , but cuz of his MERCY .
I've heard this phrase" a majority of Muslims don't hate" based on what data do you make this statement? Maybe it's only 49%, or 40% or 15% ? Would you concede 10% of all Muslims hate based on religious differences, and envy.. I'm not trying to construe that Dr Peterson's comments toward Muslims' imply a majority of Muslims hate other" Muslims. I don't have too ,apparently its a big enough problem for him to comment on it.. What is the percentage,, you don't know, and I don't know. So what do you base your hate on? Politics? I am dubious about the level of acceptance in the majority of Muslims and people in general. The problem is Islam and many sects seek the destruction of those that are different from themselves.
@@jeffs7915 yes, I think all religion or belief is subjected to that notion. But you can say also, not all the followers of that religion or belief done so either. And to support my brethren opinion, muslim and all religion teach peace, and the majority of followers hold to that idea. If not, God forsake, there will be another crusade, or another holocaust, or another world war. And why do we have to percent majority? What's the purpose? To know? It's clearly visible to our eyes. What I'm saying is not everything have to be calculated in numbers. I'm sorry if I'm wrong. Thank you
I like and respect Dr. Peterson. A lot. He is one of the greatest intellectuals alive today, and his talks have helped me immensely. However, I agree with the majority of the comments on this video. I will tell you that I am an Orthodox Christian, so you will understand my perspective as a non-Muslim. Dr. Peterson fails to account for the role of Zionists in the modern-day animosity between Jews and Muslims. It is true that Jews were persecuted horribly during World War II, but I do not see how this entitles them to their own ethnostate formed by forcibly ejecting other people from their lands. There were many millions of people persecuted horribly during the 20th century, and one could argue that Jews represent a minority of that number. Do all the other victims deserve their own ethnostate, too? Dr. Peterson recently released a video, Butchers and Liars Reprise, where he gives examples of the Left and Right taking their ideologies too far. In the case of the Right, he says trying to form your own ethnostate would be an example of going too far. Why are the actions of the Zionists not going too far? I am careful to call out Zionists specifically and not Jews in general as we know that there are places around the world where Muslims, Christians and Jews are able to peacefully and respectfully coexist. I feel that Dr. Peterson’s recent affiliation with Daily Wire prevents him from properly addressing this topic. I am not egotistical in my opinions, so I invite any and all criticism of what I just wrote.
My criticism: not based enough brother 💪
I agree 100% this to me feels like an orchestrated propaganda by his new employer/partner from Daily Wire, Ben Shapiro, a Zionist.
Thank you for your kind words. I read it all. And I agree with most if not all of what you say.
Followup question, is Daily Wire a Zionist funded organization by any chance? That would explain why JP would post such a One World Order “come let’s go to heaven together” message.
I actually agree with you on most of your points. For context, I am a middle-eastern muslim and I never had any problem with jews. We have never been taught to hate jews. Our only issue is with zionists who wrongfully invaded a country of ours and dragged our brothers out of it. Not only, muslims, there are even jews who stand against zionism. I've been following Dr Peterson for quite a while now and I agree with much of what he says and the reason for that is the fact that he is a man of science who says nothing without a scientific proof. He has never been ignorant, but in this video, unfortunately he is.
I haven't even started to talk about all the obstacles muslims are facing everywhere.
Thanks this is just awesome. As a Palestinian my father had to leave and I was born elsewhere, am over 30 now and I have never seen what I call my hometown! It's not nice to live as a Palestinian
“The best place to find Satan is within” ! Absolutely POWERFUL! This line applies to us ALL! We have the choice to do good or to do evil. Be a warrior of light and peace 💛
Very well said. No matter how rich or poor, no matter the color of our skin or social standing, we all have a choice between committing acts of good or evil in every aspect of our lives.
"Be still and know that the Kingdom of God is within you!"
A mash up of the scriptures that the Holy Spirt turned me on to.
Divisions are sustainable only by the hatred that comes from exceptionalism which depends on division. ~ VF Luvall
Reach across the sectarian divide. ~ JB Peterson
Jordan's statement is what our political divides should heed.
Satan is another word for "insecurity," it's most potent within ideologies and that is why they cling so rigidly to colloquial phrasing and script of whatever "ideology" or "political affiliation" they believe "needs them."
Satan~insecurity is within us when we stray from observing the present moment rather than our emotions as they invariably guide our imagination into the darkest of places.
Exactly and the same God as my God is his GOD....
My sheer existence debunks your entire shia and sunni point Mr Peterson.
My mother's side of the family is majority shia and my dad's side is majority sunni, and in general we don't fight each other and we have no segregation with each other, we co exist peacefully, we are Muslims above all else.
The “Abraham Accords” didn’t lead to any sort of peace whatsoever. Those countries were already at peace with Israel, all they did was officially make their ties public.
In fact, they divided the Muslim world and normalized violence against Palestinians.
It meant that Israelis could (1) travel on their Israeli passports (2) directly from Israel to these countries instead of jumping through hoops on both counts. When you consider that Malaysian passports have printed on the inside 'This passport is valid for all countries except Israel,' this is not nothing.
In fact I would say it's a pretty good start. It helped break the stigma that if you are Mulsim you have to be against Israel's existence. No doubt Trump would have done more if he had more time.
What PaLiestians?
I wonder if JP and you would say the same thing about breaking the stigma and peacemaking with the Axis Powers during ww2.
Israeli occupation is a symbol of hate and murder and no ornate speech is going to change that. Despite current events, Palestinian and Muslim blood is not cheap.
Clearly you haven't understood what was it all about. Because it's a major statement and different reality for the countries.
@@asherisraeli3715 Oy vey, that's some esoteric nonsense, Mr. J.
There will always be people that will never forget the crimes. You want people to sing Kumbaya while the split blood is still wet?
Dear Dr.Peterson
we never considered the Jew as our enemy, matter of fact our prophet did trade with Jews and had commercial and non commercial relations with them.
Our problem with Israel and Zionism policies and with all what it present from discrimination and racism against Palestinian ( Muslim & Christine).
We are not antisemite because simply we are Semite as well!!
Thank you for you enlightening videos.
He is a Zionist puppet
Really??? 😂
Get real...
*@-JP,*
Well, what you dont realize is what you said lies at the very core of the materialist soulless secular liberal individualist exclusive fascist western civilization, that kills the soul of man & the humanity in/of man, against which Russia is now fighting in Ukraine, & rightly so.
In other words, *its that despicable* *western feeling of superiority at the*
*very core of modernity &* *"enlightenment" thats*
*THE main source of all trouble.*
When you consider yourself & your culture, religion....superior (what a joke) to the rest of humanity to the point that you impose your liberal fascist ideology on the whole planet as if it is *the one*
*& only universal truth, while it has* *been just the product of your local historic cultural socioeconomic... Eurocentric circumstances, then you're looking for extinction, for a nuclear armageddon as the current events are showing....
Never? Really? Nothing of the sort before Theodor Herzl?
@@KrwiomoczBogurodzicy What do you mean, you idiot??? Didnt you know that jews were treated under muslims much better than anywhereelse?, when your ancestors used to be persecuted everywhere in medieval Europe, killed in pogroms, burned at the stake under the (Spanish) inquisition, expelled from Spain, England...converted to christianity with force...you name it....& all that culminated in the holocaust in ...Europe, not in Japan lol, & by Europeans nazis & others... and then Palestinians had to pay for all that, while they had nothing to do with any of that, by witnessing their land taken from them, their property, lives....The jewish problem wad mainly a European problem....Get real, you ignorant fool.
@@KrwiomoczBogurodzicy antisemitism was always a christian thing, muslims always welcomed jews in their land when they were fleeing persecution. which eventually the zionists took advantage of to create israel.
As a Muslim and a fan of yours, I must say that I’m kind of disappointed. There is no doubt in my mind that your message was out of good will, but you got some things wrong.
First of all, this sort of message, a pacifistic one, should not be towards Muslims only, but also towards Jews and Christians. Yes, you also mentioned them in the video, but the title is only towards Muslims.
Then there is a big difference between Jews and Zionists. A Jew and a Muslim could live together in peace, and neither should hate the other, but that is not the case with Zionists. We as the Muslim Ummah do not have any hate towards a regular Jew, but this is not the same for Zionists, as the latter only aims and strives to achieve the Great Middle East - Project.
Last but not least, Sunnis and Shias are not killing each other on the streets. We do live peacefully, and their whole difference dates back more than a thousand years back.
This is my message to Muslims:
Instead of trying to unite with Christians and Jews, we should first unite with ourselves. This does not mean that we have to be intolerant towards them.
Iraq, Syria, Yemen, Libya, Palestine, Afghanistan.. all of these beautiful Islamic countries have been ruined, because we as a Ummah failed to come together when outside forces invaded our homelands.
Stop lying and using taqiyah . Koran teaches to never be friends with Christens or Jews and to kill them sura 9:29 9:5 5:51, ... The fruit of islam is wicked " you know them by their fruits" the Lord says.
@@AA123TD Unfortunatly in that united muslim ummah as you know there is little room for other religions without a tax or subjugation, We can see in many Muslim countries Christians can not build churches are accused of blasphemy and killed . I say this to start a conversation not an argument
its your quran and hadith that teach muhamadans to kill and enslave and humiliate Christians and Jews with jizyah, and claims Jews and Christians are worst of creatures and allow rape of captive women, and allow rape of prepubesent girls. not the Old Testament nor New Testament. If you dont believe those things and think they are wrong, then you are not consistent with your religion's teachings.
perfectly stated... no need to say more
My friend regardless of what he said you should understand and get the message and truly we should listen to it and stop our disagreements and fighting.
Sunnies and shia are killing each other taliban is a prime example, and syria and Iraq, and soon Saudi Arabia maybe you are from a country where that's not the problem but other countries are having big issues with this, believe i have lived it and seen it and it's just mindless hatred of their own muslim brothers
Glory to Almighty Allah, the Lord of heaven and earth, encompassing infinite mercy and wisdom.
Praise be to:
1. The Beneficent
2. The Merciful
3. The Eternal Lord
4. The Most Sacred
5. The embodiment of Peace
6. The Infuser of Faith
7. The Preserver of Safety
8. All Mighty
9. The Compeller, The Restorer
10. The Supreme, The Majestic
11. The Creator, The Maker
12. The Evolver
13. The Fashioner
14. The Great Forgiver
15. The all-prevailing One
16. The Supreme Bestower
17. The Provider
18. The Supreme Solver
19. The All-Knowing
20. The Withholder
21. The Extender
22. The Reducer
23. The Exalter, The Elevator
24. The Honourer, The Bestower
25. The Dishonourer, The Humiliator
26. The All-Hearing
27. The All-Seeing
28. The Impartial Judge
29. The Utterly Just
30. The Subtle One, The Most Gentle
31. The All-Aware
32. The Most Forbearing
33. The Magnificent, The Supreme
34. The All-Forgiving
35. The Most Appreciative
36. The Highest, The Exalted
37. The All-Heedful and All-Protecting
38. The Preserver
39. The Sustainer
40. The Reckoner
41. The Majestic
42. The Most Generous, The Most Esteemed
43. The Watchful
44. The Responsive One
45. The All-Encompassing, the Boundless
46. The All-Wise
47. The Most Loving
48. The Glorious, The Most Honorable
49. The Infuser of New Life
50. The All Observing Witnessing
51. The Absolute Truth
52. The Trustee, The Disposer of Affairs
53. The All-Strong
54. The Firm, The Steadfast
55. The Protecting Associate
56. The Praiseworthy
57. The All-Enumerating, The Counter
58. The Originator, The Initiator
59. The Restorer
60. The Giver of Life
61. The Inflicter of Death
62. The Ever-Living
63. The Sustainer, The Self-Subsisting
64. The Perceiver
65. The Illustrious, the Magnificent
66. The One
67. The Unique, The Only One
68. The Eternal, Satisfier of Needs
69. The Omnipotent One
70. The Powerful
71. The Expediter, The Promoter
72. The Delayer
73. The First
74. The Last
75. The Manifest
76. Knower of the Hidden
77. The Patron
78. The Self Exalted
79. The Source of All Goodness
80. The Ever-Pardoning
81. The Avenger
82. The Pardoner
83. The Most Kind
84. Master of the Kingdom, Owner of the Dominion
85. Lord of Majesty and Generosity
86. The Just One
87. The Gatherer, the Uniter
88. The Self-Sufficient, The Wealthy
89. The Enricher
90. The Withholder
91. The Distresser
92. The Propitious, The Benefactor
93. The Light, The Illuminator
94. The Guide
95. The Incomparable Originator
96. The Everlasting
97. The Inheritor, The Heir
98. The Guide, Infallible Teacher
99. The Forbearing, The Patient
May His names be exalted and revered in all realms.
bruh, I'm shia and the love of my life is sunni. maybe you think we should fix things between us but there's really nothing wrong except for some who are politicaly motivated negatively but thats still their freedom. lets not be stupid, the world doesnt work the way we want it to work because theres things called governments, politics, economies. not human and humanities, therefore sadly the picture painted to the west about muslims is very negative and ive never thought you'd fall for it as a wise man. and in our modern world, we the people are not fighting, and we dont hate on other religions, all of that is painted by the big people with power and control. they want to divide us and make us believe that we are divided so we would fight and they would benefit. yes in history there was divide after the death of the prophet PBUH, but what you see today has nothing todo with that because its built from governments and powers and politicians so that they would benifit. so how about the people around the world educate themselves properly about muslims and not through political media and then they could accept us as literally the same type of humans with just difference in beliefs instead of waiting for to supposedly fix something that doesnt make sence lol because what difference does it make if the rest of the world dont fix their ways of looking at us negatively.
cia work on your bots
TO EVERY CRITICAL MUSLIM:
DR. Peterson IS RIGHT
It's not just about shiet and sunni!
Look up الإمام المتغلب.. LITERALLY " the strong man imam"..
Dictatorship is literally a fikh in our SICK culture!
way before even becoming swamped with cultural lacking, that mires us with an abundance of murtads, and monafiks who actively want to fight islam for their own alternative national projects.
You really think egypt's sisi doesn't believe in Secularism?! Even if the west bursts into flames?
You think the LOSERS of turkish nationalism would just chill, all of a sudden, if the west disappeared?!
What did you learn from watching syria?
The ONLY REASON WHY BASHAR STILL EXISTS IS
EXACTLYYYYYYYYYYYYYYYYYYYYYYYYYYYYYYYYYYYYY
BECAUSE OF WHAT PETERSON SAID.
That very very very heartbreaking reality..
So heartbreaking..
In slow motion..
For 11 years...
ONLY BECAUSE MUSLIMS DIVIDE INTO TONS OF GROUPS, AND CAN NOT UNITE TO EVEN SAVE THEIR LIVES..
LITERALLY
Syrian free army
Syrian democratic forces
Syrian blah blah
Allepo blah blah
The nusra front
Isis,
Alqaeda,
Freemen of sham,
The YPG
The PKK
Blah blah FKING BLAH!
The Islamists I egypt literally bickered OVER TRINKETS, during the "revolution"..
JUST LIKE PETERSON SAID..
And that's why EVEN WHEN THEY WON, THEY'RE NOW ALLLLLLL IN JAIL!
Egypt had salafi noor party, gamaa islamya party, the brotherhood freedom and justice party, and lots of other Islamists..
And THEY LITERALLY BICKERED TO THE LAST FKING MINUTE..
LIKE ID!0TS
AND THEY F'D UP!! 😠
AND IT'S THEIR FAULT..
BECAUSE THEY HAD IT!
THEY HAD THE MAJORITY PARTIES,
THEY HAD THE POPULARITY AMONGST THE PEOPLE,
THEY HAD EVERYTHING 😠😠😠😠😠😠😠😠
AND THEY F'D IT
PETERSON IS RIGHT
😠
There is divide among Muslims. I’m a Muslim living in a Muslim country and despite the few that really don’t care what sect you are there is still plenty that do. You can still see favoritism in the workplace, a lack of inter-sect marriage, all kinds of discrimination. It’s saddening but very much real. Compare the different sects harmony in Islam with that of Catholics, Baptists and other religions and you get what we’re talking about. Denying a problem doesn’t make it disappear. I think Dr. Peterson came a long way during the past year in regards to his views on Islam and Muslims. You belittling the effort he had put in does not do us any good. His message is coming from a kinder and kind place. It’s quite general, nonetheless, straight to the point and we must not be sidetracked by whatever pointless discrepancies that his understanding may contain.
What a fake person you are
Ibn Taymia, in if the so respected Sunni Preachors of all time, had called Shia as “Kofaar” khawarej
What are you talking about ?
Peterson has right in every single word he said
If you don’t see the truth you need help
You making the problem worse
@@mas1158 Ignorance has nothing to do with academic degree, intellectual status, or even the extent of social impact
Ignorance is not making the effort to learn about a specific topic before speaking about it, let alone trying to advise or influence those who adopt this topic, as this is doubly ignorance.
He did not read that the first pluralistic society to coexist safely was the Islamic society, which began with Yathrib and ended with the Ottoman Empire
Even with the absence of Islamic government, the Islamic society remained the most pluralistic and coexisting
Of course, until the West, under the Zionist leadership, began to establish a Zionist entity in the middle of the Islamic world (Palestine) and to enable a criminal takfiri ideology in Iran with the aim of ensuring the instability of the Islamic world
Despite this, Islam is the fastest spreading religion in the world, despite the noses of everyone who tried to distort the image of Islam, knowingly or ignorantly.
Well Jordan as a person who watched mostly all of your videos and podcasts, you have to know we aren’t the type of people who become a fan of a person and get effected to what ever he says, we accept the truth from you, and don’t accept the false, and unfortunately this video has some false statements, I agree with some of them, I agree there is a huge conflict between Sunnis and Shias, but that conflict is getting bigger dur do political issues and not religion issues, shias lives in peace in iraq, Yemen, Syria, and Lebanon, but after The world wars the conflicts got much bigger, but its political reasons, for example Germany and UK and France and USA killed millions from each other and they are all Christians, but it was not due to religious issues it was all political related, so is the shia Sunni conflict which is mostly due to Saudi vs Iran, each one wants to be dominant in the Middle East...
He is forced to do this to keep his status... What a sad sight. Disgusting
خلي نكون واقعين
اكثر الاشخاص الي يتأثرون بكلام الناس هم المسلسمين, ابسط مثال اطلع على المفسرين للقرآن، اذا عايش بأي دولة اسلامية راح تلاحظ مدى تأثير الناس بكلام الاخرين و انجرارهم له، ابسط مثال مقتدى الصدر اله ملايين الاتباع داخل البلد و هو شخص لا يعرف رأسه من اخمس قدمه، رغم ذلك راح يضحون بحياتهم من اجله.
+مو قبل فترة ليست ببعدية خلصنا من حرب اهلية قائمة بين السنة و الشيعة ؟ و بعدها معركة كراهية بين العرب و الكرد ؟
هو عارف وبيستعبط
@@David-gr6li
غير صحيح
كل الناس حاليا تبحث عن الرأي الصادق
@@Aro_2002 اذا تعتقد بانه الناس تبحث عن رأي صادق فا أنت عايش داخل فكرك بعيدا عن الواقع، غالبية البشر يحبون أن يقوم المقابيل بالثني على افكارهم و اعتقاداتهم حتى لو ما يقوله كذب و بدع
I really appreciate this heartfelt message from Dr. Peterson. I disagree with the notion that Muslims inherently have issue with Christians and Jews based solely on the fact that they are of a different religion. While there are some Muslims out there that are like this I don’t think it’s reflective of how the majority of Muslims think about Jews and Christians. I think it’s more of an issue of politics rather than religion. For example Muslims are upset with Israel not because the population of Israel are Jews but because of policies the Israeli government are implementing in Palestine, it’s politics not religion. Either way I think we can all agree with Peterson’s theme that betterment starts within and on an individual level. May we all have a hand in changing the world into a better place no matter how small it might be.
Boko Haram would disagree.
This guy's is talking bs and he knows it very well! He had good dialogue with Muslims recently , so he must prove his anti Muslim credentials to stay relevant
And he knows, but because he's a zionist as well he doesnt care
Your words represent mine brother..
Well, if what you say is true and how most Muslims feel and think about it, concerning "it’s politics not religion" I must ask how can that be?
I mean, as ignorant as I may sound, when I look at a map of the Middle East Muslim countries totally dominate that region. Why would political issues from a small slice of land affect the vast Muslim world? If true, there's a saying I grew up with, which sort of explains my misunderstandings on it all, "making a mountain out of a mole hill."
You got that wrong we Muslims don’t view people of other religions as enemies. We have our religion and you have yours. We re focused on our selves. Do with your lives what you please as long as it doesn’t hurt us.
With all my respect Dr Peterson, This message wasn’t well prepared and needs to be reconsidered.
I was so happy when you interviewed Hijab, an Mr Hamza Yusuf later to lightning western about islam which was sabotaged through media for years.
Our admiration and support as muslims was based on some characteristics that you demonstrated that were in alliance with islam teachings and not something that is missing in our faith and we looking to fulfill somewhere else or because of the « abraham accords » as you mentioned wish i will suggest to conduct a pole or something to find out by yourself how much muslims support it.
As a highly educated person as yourself, it’s not acceptable from you to state that muslims hate Christian or jews knowing that both Christians and Jews lived in harmony in the muslim world for decades with no issues.
Also it is weird that you didn’t condemn any practices of Israel against Palestiniens (the country that most of high tech companies and western media deleted from the world map) instead you narrowed our issues to evil within???.
I don’t want to make this comment longer than it is, but i recommend you review your message and reconsider both the content and the tone.
Muslim men should simping for Jordan Peterson the western far right conservatives will never tolerate Islam.
lol
@@ellagardener538 far right conservatives love each other ideas as long as they don’t have to share them lol, as you said conservative white Christians have no interest whatsoever in having Muslims around, they would rather have Latinos or Filipinos, at least they are Christians. Same with any religious and ethnic group to be fair, but catholics love to bring the moral high ground in those debates.
I doubt that. I have heard a very disturbing phrase that some Muslims use to describe Jewish people. They say that "Jews are descendants of", and the second part rhymes with "grapes and jigs". I didn't know Muslim hospitality towards Jews would also extend to comparing them to swine and simians.
Very valid points. These conflicts have all been perpetuated by politics and not religion.
Whoever controls the mass media will control perception.
We need more love in this world.
Am a Muslim, never considered any Christians nor Jew as my enemy. In fact a large percentage of my friends are actually christians
Deep respect for Peterson ✊
But you cannot make jews and christians as friends in Quran
Exactly. True enemies are the pagans, Hindus, Buddhists, Jains and the atheists
May Allah guide you bro
Quran commands Muslims not to make friends with Jews & Christians. Muslims are to fight all infidels until the whole world submits to sharia.
@@anonymousnoticer lol
"Make of yourself and your Muslim practice something so admirable that the light shining from your well constituted psyche and productive generous and wise actions is so intense that people convert to your faith from sheer admiration." There's a goal!
Search on RUclips . ' ' Zionist Behind Islamophobia Propaganda Campaign . '
Well that is how it is supposed to be, our Prophet did it like that, but unfortunately a lot of us have forgotten it
Islam is the fastest growing religion in the world for a reason. And in our religion, prophet Muhammad declared that he was the final prophet to come and that the religion of god was finally completed when the Quran came down from heaven. All the proof we need is the fact that is muslims believe in all the prophets, not just Jesus, or not just moses, but all the prophets and that we believe that Muhammad is the final prophet to be and there is no more prophets. That’s all islam is in terms of the difference in Islam to all else. The facts that Islam has been the final serious massive religion to come and there hasn’t been another great religion or prophet ever since is all the proof needed that proves the words of Islam. But if you need more proof of Islam, just checkout the miracles of the original Qurans, thousands of years later the book is still completely in a prestige condition without any sign of deterioration) proving the Qurans invincibility as well as the fact that it could not have been made of earthly material. Moreover, it explains how to run society to a T, from how to greet people or go to the toilet all the way to how to run a country. It couldn’t have been made by a human furthermore the undeniably crystal clear predictions of the major signs of judgement day are all occurring just as forewarned to a terrifyingly accuracy that it cannot be labelled a coincidence. Most of the miracles of Islam that cannot be proven wrong have already be documented everywhere they’re all on RUclips etc. Just just need to watch listen and see for yourself and you’d know it for yourself. At the minimum you can give it a watch.
That's happening everyday and people are converting by theleselves more and more everyday.
its literally how it is bro peterson didnt do his research on sunni or shias or how muslims think ofchristians and jews
As an atheist, I've noticed many times that Мuslims do not respect those who are not religious. Presicely, I've also experienced bad treatment from Мuslim males as a woman. However, I've never noticed such a treatment from Christians regarding me being an atheist or a woman.
As a muslim I’m sorry for that..they should advice you not hate you. Also Islam actually ask Muslims to treat others right doesn’t matter the religion. Which makes Islam perfect but not Muslims.❤
Sadly…
@@asmae6361 ❤️
As a Muslim who is one of your audience and loved many of your videos I have watched before in this video your message to the Muslims was full of arrogance not what I was expecting
Same. Im genuinely disappointed by one guy who has had my full respect.
JP cant understand and falls victim to Tribalism propoganda . it resides in the amygdala. thrives on us v them ( he is on side of "us" christian-jew and muslims are "them" ). as a PhD clinical psychologist professor, he is unable to use the justice in his pre-frontal cortex to overcome the hate-fear of his amygdala. if he did, he would give a similar advice to his christian tribal members and jew tribal allies considering their history within each other ( catholic-protestant slaughter ) and with each other (genocide and ethnic cleansing of european jews ) not to speak of their acts against muslims (crusades, zionism).
Same here.
Number one if you studied islam,you will understand that the chiaa aren't Muslims,the only true Muslim are the sunna
Number two Muslims aren't against jewsh people and if they pay the jizyah for there protection they will be no problem, Muslims are against zionest who occupied Palestine
Number 3 if only usa and their allies leave the Islamic world alone ,the hole word will be okay
Finally islam will e
Invade the hole word it's a fatal fact
@@freeman4380 Sahih Muslim 1767 a
It has been narrated by 'Umar b. al-Khattib that he heard the Messenger of Allah (ﷺ) say:
I will expel the Jews and Christians from the Arabian Peninsula and will not leave any but Muslim.
I generally think Jordan Peterson is an intelligent, well-reasoned man, but his reasoning has failed him when speaking in this video. This video is disappointing. I am not Muslim, but I agree with many of their remarks and replies here and elsewhere. It only addresses Muslims and definitely appears to single them out. Jordan Peterson seems pro-Christian and -Jewish, and he implies that it's the Muslim people who need a change of mindset and a desire to become more inclusive, cooperative, and peaceful. If his remarks were spurred by The Abraham Accords, then address those representatives and what you'd like to see happen in any dialogue related to or concerning negotiations and agreements and not make generalizations about all Muslims. Because anyone can have serious flaws in reasoning, I try to always carefully reflect on and analyze what's being presented to me. I wish the Daily Wire had the presence of mind to question Peterson on this video release because it was a big mistake on many levels.
He made a video to Christian Churches, just before this one. You should check it out.
Lol
Actually, he completely misses it about Christianity - don't feel picked on!
More intelligent gives stupidity
@@Aletheia_official Nope. You can't just write Lol. You have to provide supporting info and reasoning as to why.
I am Indonesian and its populated moslem majority..and i am Christian and people here live in harmony and so much tolerance
Indonesian muslim here, peace and love tania✌️❤️
@BeeP Official masa sih..hehehe suka banget JP
I am surprised to see how many comments simply stating that Dr. Peterson is not knowledgeable enough about the topic or we love eachother so well. I disagree. I think he has a point. There is nothing wrong about admitting the facts and try to be better in our relationships. I am far away from being perfect. If you don't detect the problem, you can never solve it.
I do respect Jordan in a few other accords, however it's surprising this is coming from him. Because as he is known for his detailed analysis, this conclusion lacks so many analysis especially regarding the religion itself and why we do what we do. It feels a bit condescending to come to this conclusion without further analysis into the religion itself and its belief. I see this as generalizing conflict and basically saying, "we don't want to understand you, but we don't want to see you fight, so stop fighting" even though you barely understand the context.
False
He is comprimised, he is now used for a certain agenda.
My dear Brothers and Sisters in Islam. Heed my warning.
From Al-Qur'an
Surah al-Baqarah
And the Jews will never be satisfied with you, neither will the Nasara (i.e., the Christians) till you (closely) follow their creed. Say, "Surely the guidance of Allah is the Guidance." And indeed in case you ever (closely) follow their prejudices, after the (share of) knowledge that has come to you, in no way will you have from Allah either a constant Patron or a ready Vindicator.
also;
My fellow Muslims. As Narrated by Abu Sa'id al-Khudri reported Allah's Messenger (may peace be upon him) as saying:
You would tread the same path as was trodden by those before you inch by inch and step by step so much so that if they had entered into the hole of the lizard, you would follow them in this also.
edit: listen to him if you want, but never take it to your hearts and minds for Allah Subhanawataala have given you HIS warning about these people.
Exactly! Well put
maybe he is just as clueless in other fields and he gets away with what he says in other videos because you aren't as familiar with the subject matter? He is definitely not someone i consider to have detailed analysis and his conclusions are generally flawed (imo)
I'm one of those Muslim fans of Dr Peterson and I truly admire his work and content since it is based on serious research but this one doesn't seem to be like it.
Let me assure you that the problem with sunnis and shiis is related to geopolitical reasons and not religion
Muslim people do not hate jews but zionists.
In fact you could do some more research about it : when the jews were kicked out of spain at the end of Al Andalous in 1492 they went to Muslim countries in North Africa who did welcome them and they lived there. I'm from Morocco and my dad used to tell me a lot of stories about their Jewish neighbours as well as Christian. They preferred to live in groups but it didn't mean that they weren't welcomed .
That's the reason why Morocco has a lot of Jews.
I hope you can get to study more about Islam not just what you have heard or seen.
*excuse my english it's my 3rd language
Muslims are against the Jewish people themselves, but that's not the case at all. We're against Zionism which happens to be dominantly jews, but again as an Egyptian who
Arabs never complain about “Israili” or “Syouni”. It’s always “al Yahud” they hate. You don’t need to be an Arabic expert to understand.
Arabs never complain about “Israili” or “Syouni”. It’s always “al Yahud” they hate. You don’t need to be an Arabic expert to understand.
Arabs never complain about “Israili” or “Syouni”. It’s always “al Yahud” they hate. You don’t need to be an Arabic expert to understand.
Arabs never complain about “Israili” or “Syouni”. It’s always “al Yahud” they hate. You don’t need to be an Arabic expert to understand.
I’m one of Your greatest fans Mr. Peterson.
Although the content of the “lecture” is mostly agreeable, it somehow strikes me, as a Muslim, as insulting.
Listening to the video I felt though you are pointing “The Finger”, (which you have taught us not to point), at the Muslims.
Though we ALL share a fault and a responsibility in the well being of the world it seems odd you have singled out the Muslims.
I feel as if my defenses are up now. Maybe My opinion will change when I see a “lecture” directed to our fellow Christians and Jews.
Respectfully.
There is a lecture dedicated to Christian Churches. I would not see it as insulting in any way, shape or form. What he stated was nothing but the ugly truth that we are experiencing as Muslims.
He sounds very dishonest, how can a learned person make these comments without knowing the history. So according to him it is We muslims who are at fault.
He is comprimised, he is used for a certain agenda.
Don't hold your breath for a video lecturing Christian's about the atrocities committed all over the globe and mass genocides or to the Zionists for their heinous crimes against the Palestinians (Muslims and Christians). This felt like an initiation step because he signed with the daily wire and he needed to show his stance against Muslims. The last part was an assumption, but hey, if the shoe fits... And I don't believe in coincidences.
Well said. Thank you. I also felt the same feeling when I heard the video.
you will get his message when your read more books not only one(the quran)
I love Mr Peterson but I laughed so many times during this. When I seen the title, I was like ‘oh boy! He’s got something good for an entire culture!’ 😂😂😂. His heart is one after my own, in a mi-nute way.
As a Catholic, when I meet and talk to my Muslim friends I realize they share more values with me then anyone I know. We are not so different! In a day and age when so many people lack faith I can appreciate theirs.
Yeah no shit, you both believe in fairies and wizards. You just give them different names.
I know this sounds kinda negative but its not meant to,, but,, i think its so close because its the fake version of the true religion... which i consider to be the Catholic faith...
The devil is wiley but the small print reads 'Jesus didnt die for you' - 'God has no Son'- 'it wasnt Jesus on the cross'..
And for that reason, I'll continue to love Muslims as people, but i will NOT respect or consider the basis of their faith as anything other thsn 'antiChrist'. It IS against Jesus being our salvation.
@we coming ..see now that's the difference.. even you as a non believer,who denies salvation in Christ...we are commanded to love you.
Why do you hate non believers? Hate what they do, whst they belive in...but dont hate them, they are after all, people, and God made them also.
If God loves them and is continually merciful then why do you not have the same attitude?
@@tvnorminstudio3080 except from tolerance of intolerance. That is also progress - to hell.
@we coming nah bro what are you even saying you're not a real a muslim if you think Allah only loves muslims, you need to go read the quran with translation man and stop blabbering about stuff you dont even know about. Im muslim btw and all humans are equal, hate results to more hate.
This video is the first time i have the feeling JP doesnt really understand something (and i think it is, that he doesnt really know why muslims are watching him). he doesnt feel in his element. Muslims are facinated by him as a non muslim preaching the things islam teaches us already. The way the western world has structured itself nowadays it is unheard of that a non muslim man (intelectual or not) succesfully and comprehensivly preaches such "old fashioned" ideals that we hold so dear and are sometimes scutanized over as beying old fashioned.
I respect that he askes forgivens for his presumpions beforehand, but after that the speach is loaded with regional steriotypes. Not his best work, but I like the fact that he tries.
Well said. I would go further to say Mr JP has shown himself to be a total fool today.
Yeah yeah that's what I thought, I couldn't express it like this
Quite right
Exactly never seen him more wrong than that
I respectfully don't agree. Although as a Muslim I don't feel he is speaking to me because I agree with what he says. I'm not one of those Muslims who hate because someone has another view on life or religion. But that doesn't mean there aren't any. So maybe this message wasn't for you, and we should give dr JBP the chance to get to know the Muslims who do read and follow his work. 😊
Born again Christian here. This message was beautiful. I just want to say I love you to all my Muslim brothers and sisters.
Love you too my friend. Much Blessings to you and your family.
And we love you too bro 🙏🏼❤️
@@mohamedaf4044 The spiritual war will never be won with violent aggression like goofy mohamad(GOG MAGOG) or the goofy vatican or the goofy elite(GOG MAGOG) fake jew zionists who stole palestine. Violence is goofy indoctrination. The only shedding of blood that makes sense of it all is YAHUWSHUWA'S SACRIFICE ON THE CROSS:
The shedding of blood of goats and bulls will not remove sin because the shedding of Christ's blood gives understanding. When you hate Christ and His sacrifice, you hate your Creator and His sacrifice when He took flesh and had His blood spilled. Abel was chosen over Cain because it is Christ's blood sacrifice that will save mankind, which is why YHWH accepted Abel's sacrifice. It was Cain who became like mohamad and decided to spill blood in rage over God. Christ came with the right blood sacrifice that shows Abels sacrifice was prophecy as Abel pleased The Father and was killed for it, just like Christ would eventually do. Same with the passover Lamb sacrifice that protects Ysreal and Abraham sacrificing the lamb for his Son. Christ being the Lamb of ALAHYM, fulfilled these rituals that only served the purpose to prophecy the sacrifice of The Messiah. Every ritual commanded by YHWH to the Ysraalites only served the purpose of prophesying YAHUWSHUWA HAMASHIACH.
Islam and judaism both give no meaning to anything the Ysrealites did. They both remove all significance and those rituals become nothing more than routine religious rituals with the vain purpose of making people seem holy. Islam and Judaism makes The Father's mission totally ambiguous and do not follow through or have connections like The Gospel and Christ does to EVERYTHING THAT HAPPENED IN THE OLD COVENANT.
CHRIST FULFILLS THE OLD COVENANT BY GIVING THE OLD COVENANT A MEANING AND PURPOSE THAT GIVES MEANING AND PURPOSE TO THE NEW COVENANT WHICH IS NOTHING MORE AND NOTHING LESS THEN ACKNOWLEDGING AND UNDERSTANDING THE MOST PERFECT MAN AND DEITY IN THE FLESH, YAHUWSHUWA HAMASIACH AS HIS LIFE IS THE PERFECT EXAMPLE OF HOW TO FOLLOW THE CREATOR OF ALL AND ACHIEVE THE PERFECT LOVE TO YOUR FAMILY, FRIENDS, NEIGHBOURS AND EVEN THOSE WHO HATE AND PERSECUTE YOU. SO YOU WILL BE LIKE YOUR FATHER IN HEAVEN AS HE INTENDED FOR ALL.
I can not be a (blood)brother or sister with a muslim cause its a different family but they can be my friends! Blood brothers and sisters are the ones that believe in the same bloodsacrifice.
B U &!@ m recently sl it the throat of a tailor in India just coz he supported someone on FB who brought out reality of Muham'mad' the r pist popat . Reality of c h u &!@ m . The more you act meek in front of a d I c tatorship like I &!@ m the more it will try to subdue you
You hsve it backwars because we are extremely tolerant to other people who have different faithes from ours. We have no enemies, but after all it is just a ”presumption ” as you said.