This is the WORST remake in Geometry Dash...

Поделиться
HTML-код
  • Опубликовано: 29 сен 2024

Комментарии • 133

  • @SuperSomieStuff
    @SuperSomieStuff 5 месяцев назад +27

    I think Silent Acropolis looks really good, but I don't think it's a good remake of Acropolis, since it doesn't capture the claustrophobic feeling Acropolis had, travelling through ruins and performing tight timings to barely squeeze through. I can't say I like anything about THIS remake though...

    • @GadoGD
      @GadoGD  5 месяцев назад +4

      yeah that's what I mean, ig silent acropolis looks good

    • @maximushank1115
      @maximushank1115 4 месяца назад +1

      I disagree... Acropolis is not themed around claustrophobia.. it's themed around a castle of some sort and I are invading it... Silent acropolis just emphasises the theme to 11.. looks great and is a really good remake of the original.. not perfect as the silent version has some parts that have different gameplay like the 2 player cube before the 1st ship.. it's great but by no means perfect so I can give u that

  • @thatonecat2748
    @thatonecat2748 5 месяцев назад +1

    great vid oomf now beat twinkle toes cause i said so

    • @GadoGD
      @GadoGD  5 месяцев назад

      meow cat i dont want to because gd boring at the moment

  • @farma_z4901
    @farma_z4901 5 месяцев назад +13

    I agreed with some parts of this video, but i think the problem is that a big part of the arguments are essentially shitting or just make fun of the level, and that's not bad at all, but the lack of serious well-constructed arguments are what could be improved. Its important for you to keep a firm position while explaining your point, otherwise it will be hard for people to take you seriously.
    For the rest i would like to point how you should not always group the whole team projects as one. What i mean, you mentioned the Purgatory and Cherry teams to only make "unoriginal remake levels", and this felt again like shitting over them as teams as a whole, involving all their projects, when in reality is not like that at all. Cherry team has some amazing original levels (Shinigami, Neur Abscence, Cytokinesis), and the same with Purgatory (Bete Noire), they do have some original levels, and even if they tend to make more remakes, you still you can't generalize in that way.
    For the rest i'd say both teams have super talented creators who know what they are doing, and its certain that they may not choose what they build for, since its the host choice, but under a level creation standpoint, they do a really greay job in the levels (if we see them as separated levels and not as linked to others like remakes or sequels). Its kinda the "objetive viewpoint" but i dont like to use that word a lot.
    Thats pretty much all i have to say as feedback, just make sure if you are gonna give an argument, make it so its well constructed and can be defended without depending on fallacies. Aswell as keeping more serious arguments than "make-fun" ones.
    So yeah.
    Also please lower the music and effects volume, your voice gets lost at times because of this

  • @DecidiousGreens
    @DecidiousGreens 4 месяца назад +3

    you sound like you're crying for like half the video

  • @davidbobavid
    @davidbobavid 5 месяцев назад +3

    this is a really good video, it was very understandable and you made good points explaining why the level is bad. However, I feel that the amount of hate you put on the level was a little unnecessary. like, at the end you read ThePurgatory's description on their showcase video. You basically said he did an awful job and he repeatedly said he was proud of his work and he worked really hard on it and he was excited for the public to see it, but you completely disregarded his hours and hours of work and repeatedly called it a pile of garbage. I feel like some of that was a little unnecessary, given that he spent the last couple years trying to make this level as good as he can, and you just completely broke him down. Maybe instead of that you could've used constructive criticism and explained everything that he did wrong in a way that doesn't sound like you're just hating on him for his hard work. Thanks for reading this Long comment, and it was a really good video, thanks for making it

    • @GadoGD
      @GadoGD  5 месяцев назад +2

      thanks, when you say I should give "constructive criticism", I did by saying why the level was bad. no matter how hard someone works on a level, they are not exempt from me saying that it's bad if that makes sense

    • @davidbobavid
      @davidbobavid 5 месяцев назад

      that's true, thanks for explaining your reasoning

  • @SohnnyD
    @SohnnyD 5 месяцев назад +13

    I agree with 90% of this video. The only thing I disagreed with is that I actually really like Silent Acropolis('s decoration). I've always loved art levels. And I think it looks stunning.
    Anyways, yeah that why Boreas is a much better level than this. While people try to spread misinformation about the level, Boreas is NOT in any way a remake of Black Blizzard.
    Boreas is able to create it own identity and it even has a story. And the gameplay is extremely enjoyable and welcoming for players who want to start beating extreme demons. And the sfx for it you have to go out of your way to get it. It's not on by default, it's a NONG. (because it's a 2.1 level, before people spammed sfx everywhere in levels now.) It's a travesty that it only got a star rate.
    I could keep going on and on about how good that level is but I think you get my point.

    • @GadoGD
      @GadoGD  5 месяцев назад +2

      idek what boreas is honestly, and yeah, silent acropolis LOOKS good, but silent acropolis' charm came from it's original deco. that's what I don't like about it :)

    • @SohnnyD
      @SohnnyD 5 месяцев назад +2

      @@GadoGD Ah got it. Yeah, maybe if Silent Acropolis wasn't made as remake then it could find it's own charm.
      But yeah I'd highly recommenced giving Boreas a try. All of his rated levels try to have an on going story to it. Unfortunately the creator quit the game after almost a decade. It's because he is just sick and tired of the gd community. He most likely won't come back, but if he decided for some reason to come back, it probably won't be for a very long time.
      If your curious about the story of Boreas here it is.
      You’ve been sent on a recon mission. Some remote island. There’s been evidence of some sort of cult that’s been up to some shady business, to put it lightly. You can’t afford any slip-ups. Your career is riding on this. And not just that, but who knows how far this rabbit hole goes?
      You set sail, embarking for the island. A storm catches you off-guard. It’s a tough battle, and the storm is winning. Land is in sight however, you’re almost there.
      The ship is destroyed. Unfortunately, no one else made it; you’re the only survivor. It’s dark, you can’t see the moon through the clouds. After scrounging through what you can find, you make your way to what appears to be a lighthouse, illuminated by the lightning in the distance. Clearly the island is inhabited. By who, still has yet to be made known.
      There’s no one here. This place clearly hasn’t been in use for a while. The door is boarded up shut, but that’s not enough to deter you. You need shelter to make a fire in the rain, or hypothermia is going to set in. Using a crowbar you managed to salvage from the shipwreck, the fragile wood blocking the entrance didn’t stand a chance. You light a fire, and prepare yourself for a long night.
      Morning comes. You weren’t killed in your sleep. That’s a good start. Even though your team is dead, the mission must be completed. You collect your things and move out.
      Exploring the island shows more signs of civilization, though extremely old and torn down. You find wood pillars that may have been houses at one point, but nature has reclaimed the forest. Then it catches your eye. A clear path that leads to a cave. With how run down the rest of this place is, it’s very odd that there’s something that looks relatively new. Perhaps what you’re looking for is in there. It’s also probably a good idea to get out of the cold.
      The inside of the cave is just as run down as the exterior. Pushing further in, you begin to see signs of activity: footprints. Treading with caution, you venture forward, only to be interrupted with a sharp blow to the head from behind.
      Waking up once again you find yourself at the shipwreck the night prior. You unfortunately do not have any memories of what happened and are doomed to repeat the same events again.
      The island is stuck in a time loop. If you collect certain items during the loop (coins), you can break the cycle, and escape the island.

    • @TheGm688
      @TheGm688 4 месяца назад +1

      @@GadoGD Don't be trash talking Cherry Team, the best team in gd history by far, name 1 remake cherry team has done?

    • @GadoGD
      @GadoGD  4 месяца назад

      @@TheGm688 yeah I think cherry is OK actually, I should've said ap team instead

    • @TheGm688
      @TheGm688 4 месяца назад

      @@GadoGD Ap team actually sucks ass

  • @DuckMasterVR
    @DuckMasterVR 4 месяца назад +2

    I don’t like Dark Dimension but I do like Silent Acropolis,

    • @GadoGD
      @GadoGD  4 месяца назад

      i thin that's fair, silent acropolis looks good, I just wish it was a different level

  • @ideac.
    @ideac. 5 месяцев назад +3

    so much wasted potential and time
    they literally couldve done anything else but this, they completely messed up the artist vision o BB
    its not because its more detailed that it looks good, the amount of non monochromatic colors in the "remake" is also pathetic, i dont know what they were think
    oh yeah, lets add more colors to BLACK BLIZZARD

  • @MatrixTetrix
    @MatrixTetrix 5 месяцев назад +3

    i feel like you confused "bad remake" with "bad level"
    is dark dimension a bad remake to black blizzard? yes, i would say so
    is dark dimension a bad level in general? no, its a very good level
    a remake does not have to be better than its predecessor, all it needs is a resemblance to the original material

    • @GadoGD
      @GadoGD  5 месяцев назад

      no, it is not a good level.

    • @MatrixTetrix
      @MatrixTetrix 5 месяцев назад +3

      No?
      The deco is good and the gameplay is decent enough.
      Also, never had the chance to bring it up but sayingsilent acropolis is just “glow slop” is such a fucking bad opinion like holy shit the entire level has Culuc levels of deco what are you on

    • @GadoGD
      @GadoGD  5 месяцев назад

      @@MatrixTetrix no, silent acropolis and dd are mainly terrible just because they are remakes right, there's no need for them to exist. in silent acropolis the deco looks alright sure, but silent acropolis, all it's charm came from how old it was and the original deco. same goes for black blizzard. dark dimension makes terrible gameplay choices (as the video points out) and the deco is mid at best

    • @MatrixTetrix
      @MatrixTetrix 5 месяцев назад +3

      the og silent acropolis was a buffed version of acropolis made from memory. all the "charm" and deco were directly copied from acropolis. the level does not have "charm" like acropolis does

    • @MatrixTetrix
      @MatrixTetrix 5 месяцев назад +1

      also, what happened to letting people remake levels for fun. there doesnt NEED to be a reason for the level to exist.

  • @Unidentleiden
    @Unidentleiden 5 месяцев назад +1

    I dont agree with anything you said except that the sfx are trash but i respect your opinion.

  • @ksjerrytwine2
    @ksjerrytwine2 4 месяца назад +3

    who ordered a Yappuccino

    • @GadoGD
      @GadoGD  4 месяца назад +1

      ur just mad that I'm right 🥱

    • @RealRednax
      @RealRednax 4 месяца назад

      @@GadoGD🔛🔝

    • @ksjerrytwine2
      @ksjerrytwine2 3 месяца назад

      @@GadoGD my fault gng I didn't know you'd actually reply 🙏🙏🙏🙏

  • @idqe
    @idqe 5 месяцев назад +5

    pirates used to raid people

  • @Sinless_Ash
    @Sinless_Ash 4 месяца назад +1

    ngl i personally disagree with the title id why

  • @TheSideCharacter129
    @TheSideCharacter129 4 месяца назад +1

    i think i agree with 95% of this video. the only thing is that you say cherry team is bad when they arent. like not even close and also silent acropolis looks good as well. but i do think dark dimension is a very mid level, its just way too cluttered.

    • @GadoGD
      @GadoGD  4 месяца назад

      i think rather than cherry team I should've said ap team

  • @catredphantomtm
    @catredphantomtm 5 месяцев назад +2

    a lot of remakes dont understand things like design philosophies or what the original is. so much just turns it into a glow extreme demon with samey structures and visuals. yeah it looks pretty and all but its completely stripped of all identity. you can make something look pretty and keep the philosophies of the original

  • @MuffinCat
    @MuffinCat 5 месяцев назад +2

    problem is all remakes are just glow spam by the same ppl and it feels boring asf
    levels dont need remakes, and if they do not like this

  • @Walterpalava
    @Walterpalava 5 месяцев назад +2

    And Stop Hating On Actually Cool Levels

    • @GadoGD
      @GadoGD  5 месяцев назад

      its not a cool level

    • @Walterpalava
      @Walterpalava 5 месяцев назад +1

      @@GadoGD Well AtLeast Dont Hate On It Or Say Other Peoples Opinions dont matter

    • @GadoGD
      @GadoGD  5 месяцев назад

      @@Walterpalava bro does not understand satire

  • @Zallitz
    @Zallitz 4 месяца назад

    what im saying bruh dark dimension so bad 😭

  • @shiek106
    @shiek106 4 месяца назад +2

    Kocmoc Unleashed is good tho

    • @GadoGD
      @GadoGD  4 месяца назад

      no it has 2.2 camera effects it just looks like a tik too edit half the time

    • @DecidiousGreens
      @DecidiousGreens 4 месяца назад

      ​@@GadoGD that's actually so true, especially with the song

  • @astrolab5389
    @astrolab5389 5 месяцев назад +1

    I understand some of the critics but i have a few things to say : 1st i think (my opinion ofc) that dark dimension isnt that shitty, not awesome but not bad neither, 2cnd, silent acropolis is one of the bes deco ever+they didnt make the level, they just decorated it and 3rd, the purgatory made and are making original levels such as clock tower, atlantis, etc...

    • @GadoGD
      @GadoGD  5 месяцев назад

      yeah, the purgatory are making not copy levels, but their most famous ones are remakes. if u say dark dimsnion isn't that bad then u should say why. silent acropolis does look good but it removes the originals personality

    • @astrolab5389
      @astrolab5389 5 месяцев назад

      @@GadoGD I think that even if it doesn't work as a remake, it is good looking, it's not as unoriginal as generic glowspam, and the added gameplay is good. Once again it's my opinion, i totally understand that you don't like it. And i think silent acropolis's redeco has more personality because it has a very uncommon theme and a lot of thought put into it, while the original is stolen from acropolis. And with the verification going on, the new silent acropolis has almost more history than the old

    • @WifeBeatingGD
      @WifeBeatingGD 4 месяца назад

      @@GadoGDhow does it remove the original’s personality? They are two separate levels 😭😭

  • @indneon7581
    @indneon7581 5 месяцев назад +2

    1:10 the fucking CuluC styled blocks on the stupid black orb stairs is genuinely hilarious. SO out of place

  • @inrusane_n
    @inrusane_n 4 месяца назад +2

    1:04 perfect sync between level and music lmao

  • @ThePastaNebula
    @ThePastaNebula 5 месяцев назад +1

    fire video

  • @itsorenji
    @itsorenji 5 месяцев назад +1

    British people with a following of -6 have a weird affinity for this level lol. I'm pretty in the middle on Dark Dimension. Having watched the way it's progressed from the first preview it's clear they care about making something 'good' and it's a decent job at bringing Black Blizzard up to modern standards. It probably shouldn't exist, but I'd still say it's a 6/10, with something as good as Black Blizzard the best they were going to get would be a semi-decent reimagining of the level if it was built in 2022-2024, and they did that.

    • @GadoGD
      @GadoGD  5 месяцев назад

      what is this generalisation of British people?? dark dimension doesn't reimagine black blizzard at all, just slaps some pretty deco on it and added terrible gameplay elements imo

    • @itsorenji
      @itsorenji 5 месяцев назад

      @@GadoGD I'm also British with a following of -6 people. Reimagine was probably the wrong word, I guess it's closer to remastering. It's a decent remaster at that, not going to argue that the gameplay is terrible though, much like all extreme demons now it has no reason to be as hard as it is for any reason besides money.

    • @astrolab5389
      @astrolab5389 5 месяцев назад +1

      agreed. Even if the atmosphere isnt as good as bb, the deco is still better than generic glow imo, and the added gameplay isnt bad

  • @Jesse-ns3xj
    @Jesse-ns3xj 4 месяца назад +1

    Stop Saying this level is bad, your just used to your non-existent girlfriend, ("aka" nothing interesting)

    • @GadoGD
      @GadoGD  4 месяца назад

      LOL

    • @Jesse-ns3xj
      @Jesse-ns3xj 4 месяца назад

      I WAS HONESTLY THINKING YOU WERE GONNA DELETE THE COMMENT, (if you can, I don't really know,)

    • @GadoGD
      @GadoGD  4 месяца назад

      @@Jesse-ns3xj no I don't delete comments this is just funny to me

    • @Jesse-ns3xj
      @Jesse-ns3xj 4 месяца назад

      LOL

  • @MrMarcusGD
    @MrMarcusGD 3 месяца назад

    Based video + based opinions

  • @fearme7184
    @fearme7184 5 месяцев назад +2

    #weglazekrmalforagoodreason

    • @GadoGD
      @GadoGD  5 месяцев назад

      he deserves glazing !

    • @fearme7184
      @fearme7184 5 месяцев назад +1

      @@GadoGD for real he has been my favorite since like 2016-2017

  • @Abqwkjg
    @Abqwkjg 5 месяцев назад +1

    Based

    • @GadoGD
      @GadoGD  5 месяцев назад

      thanks!

  • @kxenyy
    @kxenyy 4 месяца назад

    Lmao dude i honestly love your commentary. You give off Wherwin and Sea1997 (ik he was before your time but still) vibes by being direct about your opinions while making it funny too. Good shit

    • @GadoGD
      @GadoGD  4 месяца назад

      aw thanks so much!

  • @kamiwrld
    @kamiwrld 5 месяцев назад +1

    common gado w take

    • @GadoGD
      @GadoGD  5 месяцев назад +1

      thankyou kami!

  • @kakaks32
    @kakaks32 5 месяцев назад +1

    oomfs fav creator is krmal 💔

    • @GadoGD
      @GadoGD  5 месяцев назад

      you best believe it!!

  • @theactualmydoorfellintoperson
    @theactualmydoorfellintoperson 4 месяца назад

    While I do feel like the level doesn’t come near the original in terms of quality I still think it looks decent and besides the sound effects the level is perfectly fine. A level doesn’t have to be a masterpiece or live up to standards to not be a massive pile of hot garbage

    • @GadoGD
      @GadoGD  4 месяца назад

      yeah i think the level looks kinda cool but it needs to be origibal to be good imo

  • @bloodreptil
    @bloodreptil 4 месяца назад

    Ngl I think silent acropolis is the perfect remake. The deco is really good and fits the theme very well while also doing its own thing.

    • @GadoGD
      @GadoGD  4 месяца назад

      yes i think its a pretty good remake, it's just a shame that it's a remake

  • @kenny_yo
    @kenny_yo 4 месяца назад +2

    why are we hating, level is sick asf

    • @GadoGD
      @GadoGD  4 месяца назад

      it looks cool, but that means nothing

    • @kenny_yo
      @kenny_yo 4 месяца назад

      @@GadoGD ig it means nothing

    • @GadoGD
      @GadoGD  4 месяца назад

      @@kenny_yo character, individuality and personality matter much more than pretty deco imo

    • @kenny_yo
      @kenny_yo 4 месяца назад

      @@GadoGD but the deco is what makes that happen no?

    • @GadoGD
      @GadoGD  4 месяца назад

      @@kenny_yo yeah it would make that happen. the deco needs to be individual. not generic glow garbage

  • @Shiroiniko_
    @Shiroiniko_ 5 месяцев назад

    W takes

  • @CorgiLoverGD
    @CorgiLoverGD 4 месяца назад

    I think the lvl is good ngl black blizzard is kinda bland ngl and cherry team can probs do better than u maybe even the purgatori (my opinion) if u don’t like something what’s the point of ranting abt it others like it?

    • @GadoGD
      @GadoGD  4 месяца назад +1

      this is probably rhe most stupid opinion I've ever seen but ok

    • @CorgiLoverGD
      @CorgiLoverGD 4 месяца назад

      @@GadoGD it’s mine tho so deal with it please

  • @thepriestgodneverpaid
    @thepriestgodneverpaid 5 месяцев назад

    how do you fuck up a remake of a krmal level that bad lmao
    the entire point of krmal's deco style was like the start of anti-conventional style levels and to do a cherryteam ass glow remake of the level is,, idek how to put it into words how dumb it sounds

    • @thepriestgodneverpaid
      @thepriestgodneverpaid 5 месяцев назад

      also hi gado i didnt think you were actually gonna do actual videos lmao

    • @GadoGD
      @GadoGD  5 месяцев назад +1

      @@thepriestgodneverpaid it goes against the levels personality entirley

  • @Edge_of_Defeat
    @Edge_of_Defeat 4 месяца назад

    I agree with this very much. They did not need to massacre black blizzard for the sake of it 😒.

  • @VTB_GD
    @VTB_GD 5 месяцев назад

    Black blizzard is my favorite of all time. I couldnt have picked a better level to do as a hardest. This level is just simply without heart

  • @Totoro_yessir
    @Totoro_yessir 5 месяцев назад

    Tbh its true that the remake destroys the feeling of the old one and i like old levels too like Krmal (one of my fav creators) but as GD moves on we gotta move on too yknow? i guess the meta now is to make glow abused levels.

    • @GadoGD
      @GadoGD  5 месяцев назад

      yes, it's fine to make different, more modern levels, but don't try and turn an older level into that, it ruins it.

  • @Ojbfour
    @Ojbfour 4 месяца назад

    i mainly do remakes and sequels (basically i have no creative ideas) and they normally turn out pretty well. keep in mind i just do layouts, fuck decorating that shit is far too difficult. this video made me doubt myself again 😭

    • @GadoGD
      @GadoGD  4 месяца назад

      theres nothing wrong with making remakes as a bit of fun, but like you said, they're aren't creative whixh I think is a pretty bad downside to levels like that

    • @Ojbfour
      @Ojbfour 4 месяца назад

      @@GadoGD well i made not a remake or sequel but just super inspired level that's getting decorated and verified atm so... also what do you think of eod then

    • @GadoGD
      @GadoGD  4 месяца назад

      @@Ojbfour eod is a good remake of a really good level, but it loses points for it's lack of creativity i suppose

    • @Ojbfour
      @Ojbfour 4 месяца назад

      ⁠@@GadoGDso remakes and sequels can still be good and rateworthy then, right? bc i personally love remakes, it takes good gp (hopefully) and changes it up just enough so it feels like a new experience and is still fun

    • @GadoGD
      @GadoGD  4 месяца назад

      @@Ojbfour yes if a remake is good a remake is good, I have like silent acropolis AS A REMAKE but as a level as a whole it's a waste of a lot of potential like EoD

  • @beepduck
    @beepduck 5 месяцев назад

    i wouldnt compare cherryteam as a whole to stuff like this, some levels like cytokenesis are genuinely awesome levels. also very detailed and realistic sequels can sometimes work amazingly, such as edge of destiny, but thats mainly bc BoJ was kinda going for that in the first place

    • @GadoGD
      @GadoGD  5 месяцев назад

      yeah cherry team make a few good levels, I'm mainly talking about their remakes and old stuff

    • @astrolab5389
      @astrolab5389 5 месяцев назад

      cherry team didnt made edge of destiny. and the purgatory is making really cool original levels too, like clock tower

    • @beepduck
      @beepduck 5 месяцев назад

      @@astrolab5389 i didnt say cherryteam made eod, the eod/boj thing was a separate point to show that this extremely detailed decoration style can sometimes work in sequels and isnt always bad

  • @Walterpalava
    @Walterpalava 5 месяцев назад

    Krmal Is Bad Most Of The Time So yea

    • @GadoGD
      @GadoGD  5 месяцев назад +1

      no

    • @wafflesoncrack
      @wafflesoncrack 4 месяца назад

      krmal gameplay is bad, but NOT the deco

    • @GadoGD
      @GadoGD  4 месяца назад

      @@wafflesoncrack the gameplay is really good actually, super unique and interesting. it just isn't very fun, whixh isn't very important honestly

    • @Walterpalava
      @Walterpalava 4 месяца назад

      Ok @GadoGDAND @wafflesoncrack But Come on What About hungry humphery that with is dog crap