AFSPA, tribes, Geography and politics behind tragedy in Mon & anger in Nagaland
HTML-код
- Опубликовано: 6 сен 2024
- #CutTheClutter #NagalandViolence #AFSPA
After civilian killings took place in Nagaland, Shekhar Gupta looks into these killings, why Modi Govt looks so shaken & contrite, and why India cannot afford to anger the tribes in Nagaland with peace talks at a crucial stage. And factors of ethnicity, geography, story behind these killings. And how AFSPA came about. Episode 892 of CutTheClutter
Brought to you by @KiaInd
---------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
Watch the CutTheClutter Ep 304: • A primer on Nagaland, ...
---------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
Join our channel to get access to perks. Click 'JOIN' or follow the link below:
/ @theprintindia
---------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
Connect with ThePrint
» Subscribe to ThePrint: theprint.in/su...
» Subscribe to our RUclips Channel: bit.ly/3nCMpht
» Like us on Facebook: / theprintindia
» Tweet us on Twitter: / theprintindia
» Follow us on Instagram: / theprintindia
» Find us on LinkedIn : / theprint
» Subscribe to ThePrint on Telegram: t.me/ThePrintI...
» Find us on Spotify: spoti.fi/2NMVlnB
» Find us on Apple Podcasts: apple.co/3pEOta8
Early access, exclusive content, special privileges - Discover the great benefits of being a Member of ThePrint’s RUclips channel. Take a Paid Membership today. It costs just Rs 159/month. ruclips.net/channel/UCuyRsHZILrU7ZDIAbGASHdAjoin
Law like afspa, sedition are contrary to our democratic system, rather than piece meal approach, comprehensive law which protect individual liberty along with robust national security
Raise the issues of Kashmiri people also Shekhar Gupta Ji.
Thank you for a brief information ... We are very sad and angry ... And hope the government of India look thoroughly into this matter and justice be served to my Naga brothers who were slaughtered by cruel evils
To let you know, the video shared by General Secretary Mr.Zhimomi is not authentic. The workers shown in the video are from another village and not the villagers who were killed the next day.
@@Sky-os2bu How do you know?
I AM A NAGA (KONYAK)....I got slide shot in my head which made the bullet to stuck in head....well im here laying down being hospitalised... Thanks to God mercy im alive to watch your video today... Well appreciated Sir for letting others know about the situation 👍❤️
@@apatriot4400 Thanks you so much bro for your concern... Even i hope for early recovery and early #JUSTICE.....ONCE again thank you for your 1 year life😘❤️
Get well soon. Justice shall prevail.
May you recover fast.. 🙏.. justice should be delivered fast, culprits need to be courtmarshelled and adequate compensation should be given to deceased persons.. support and prayers from mainland india🙏
Man, so sorry what you went through. May justice deliver to you.
@@nakshsanson9518 Thanks you Brother.... even me Looking forward for Speedy Justice ✊
People in Nagaland are not asking for revenge but Justice.
Justice that should be served.
👍🏻👍🏻
What Assam Rifles did to Manorama Devi is enough to remind entire NE regarding 'Justice'
What about that which happened to Army officer and his family who were blasted earlier??
@@rajaanvesh1129 two seperate incident occuring in a different state.
@@rajaanvesh1129 I hope you know that One of the Army personnel who died in earlier blast was from same Mon district.
I'm glad that SG put that previous episode of the situation. That helped a lot. I joined here after around 700 epiodes.
?
@@abseiduk Didn't ypu watch that episode. It was put out on Sunday
@@gonpachirokamaboko3180
Oh yeah, that one was bit of a coincidence, just in time to understand before this event
Ya koi web series nahi hai paji
Screenshot this comment for future reference...
"Killing civilians in NORTHEAST is not a new thing to Indian Army. This same thing will happen in the near future, this is not the end. Speaks volumes of Indian Army and its Intelligence. Many incidents like this happened in the past but not known to the world as there was no internet in olden days. "
Thank you THE PRINT for covering this tragic incident.
You have very rightly said. And believe me too....... similar incidents will occur again and again. but this is the first incident in history where the army has accepted its mistake.
@@malabikabarua1163Incidents like these have become a rarity since the 2000s u believe it or not and since 2010 especially The indian army has klled negligible civlians in the north east
@@byron-ih2ge agree with you, comparatively , such incidents have come down in last few years, more so because of restraint as Northeast news also reaches mainland fast due to activate media. But I am not so optimistic that this is the last incident of this type.
There are numerous eyewitnesses' accounts of Armed forces carrying out untold sufferings on Naga civilians during the early 90's. On mere suspicion they would arrest innocent Naga civilians and subjugated them to the most inhuman methods of torture. My mate's uncle still bear the scars of these torturous acts from that time. His head's crown part is scarred and bald due to one torturous act that was meted out on him by army personnel. He was tied upside down with his head touching the concrete floor, then the army personnel would viciously kick his head. It's a miracle that he is still alive today, although in a frail condition. Many of his friends were simply gunned down while they were working on their fields. Their dead bodies would later be carried to their respective homes not in a dignified manner but like pigs tied to bamboo poles while their guts and brains would drip and fall on the way.
Heart breaking..... I don't want to comment early. I worked as a CRPF doctor in Manipur for a short period. We had good relationship with villagers.
Then you must be knowing about iron sharmila and what happened in 90s
@@GolbalEduVentures
CRPF raped a lot of women in Assam.. During 80's and 90's
@@siyang105 I never knew that like most Indians you guy need to do have proof and taker action
I am becoming your fan Mr. Shekhar , plz don’t stop bringing up incident of your personel experience from old times in your stories. Because that is what differentiate you from other journalist.
@@apatriot4400 I second that ..
I echo that - one of the reasons I started liking him!
@@saurabhdharmadhikari4874 Bhai eisa kuch bhi nahi hai.. College may fight kar chuka hu 2 nagas ke sath ek sath..mai koi itna strong bhi nahi hu..bas 6 feet height hai 78 kg wajan hai aur thodi gym ki hui body hai. Par Army may select nahi ho paya yaar bus iss baat ko malal hai
@@thorhax0r41 khud ko Zyada khatarnak soch raha hoga gym ja ke uff....😂😂😂
@@nzanthungezung8889 Sochna kya hai bae ismae ? Hu Khatarnak Samajha bae ? By the way ye tere DP may chuhaa ka foto kyu hai ?..Hahaha....Hahaha ...lol...lol
Outreach to the north eastern states should continue regardless of what ever happens. With a cunning PLA nearby who are waiting for a cause to create instability, the govt should read the situation carefully.
PLA supplying support since long and Nehruvian chauvinism destroyed this land
Well , an ineffective Army unit security it is tasked with .AFSPA has given Army great immunity and also has made them complacent,less innovative relying on old tactics.An ineffective Army unit will destroy before a PLA have any chance.
As far as the people of Nagaland are concerned they are no longer in conflict with the security forces either mentally or physically. We have been enjoying peace since 1997.
Children born after 97 have little understanding or taste of the bitter past. In fact the people of the state were eagerly awaiting the final peace accord which our PM and Home minister had promised would be coming soon.
Then this incident happened. AFSPA is relevant in terrorist infested regions not in places where there is no more wars and people living peacefully. The govt must deliver justice in this case.
Bhai tera koi karibi nhi gaya na waha isliye aisa bol raha. No organisation should be given the powers to kill the citizens at will. Its like superman turning rogue.
Don't oversimplfy this issue by add PLA name . PLA has to cross 2 indian state to reach that place and Chinese never claimed land from Nagaland .
The one very important detail you are missing sir is that, the army was caught trying to hide the bodies of the six civilians after they killed them due to mistaken identity or so they claim. There were stuff kept above the bodies with the intention to hide and they were sitting on it when the villagers came searching for the missing persons upon hearing gunshots. And after confirming the horrifying truth , the angry villagers obviously retaliated leading to more shootings and deaths.
They didn't admit right away but was compelled to as they were caught red handed.
yea..they(army) try to hide 6 dead body.. when VILLAGE found that army started to shoot village again.
@@worldview5433 well there's video evidence for starters.
@worldview heard the heartbreaking news from the get go n didn't wana believe but commenting here only after watching the video evidence. Also, everyone in media keeps saying "mistaken identity, mistaken identity" and not the full story as to what made or is making the situation escalate further.
@@worldview5433 got all the video evidence and itz circulate in social media WhatsApp I myself have watch it.
@@worldview5433 they did not manage to killed everyone so you can go and ask the survivor k
This is high class journalism. Filled with facts and empathy
Manipulated leftist facts ki baat kar raha hoo
Sorry to Naga people on behalf of Indian Army🇮🇳you are as important as any other citizens of this country..once again sorry 😞
Thank you sir, we are contributing the same to the nation like every normal Indian citizen does. We don't blame the entire army but it was the work of 21 para sf. Hopefully Justice will be delivered by our indian judicial system. 👍
Sorry not enough
Sorry is not enough to address all the physical and mental tortures army has given To NE states under AFSPA
What all we want is ⚖️ Justice. 🙏
Today is World Human Rights Day so shall we all start peace to each other... Respect and forgiveness is more important than taking revenge.....We Nagas r the peace loving citizens and we r also contributing same love to our nation...
This is serious issue. It has to be taken very seriously and justice delivered. AFSPA also has to be revoked.
@कुजो जितेंद्र । Kujo Jitendra Yes
@Abdullah Saud why??
@Abdullah Saud why?
Why do u say so..
Why, my friend to see us as a animals?
Sir, it would have been great if you mentioned Irom Sharmila. Albeit her journey towards the end is not very popular, but the ''Iron lady of Manipur" fasted for 16 years! in an attempt to repeal the draconian colonial-era law AFSPA. After 74 years of Independence, how free are we really yet from bondage, oppression and exploitation?
When bordered by an enemy that constantly meddle with our affairs and has ripped land out of our nation, how confidently can any Government in India can leave out AFSPA in these regions?
I'm not supporting the act, but stating the situation that can't be solved. We can't go ahead and wipe out rebellious clans or attack China and unite the region. This world lives in cruel bureaucratic BS.
@@abhishekunni2433 is that your excuse? If there are enemies in the border, army should be at the border, not inside the country killing citizens. If some people cannot continue in an union they'll democratically break away. Nobody can enslave them for hundreds of years
@@badbad-cat If only it was that easy. The enemy at the border has already entered into India and is focusing on destabilizing the region. Wiping them out is like picking needle in the haystack and AFSPA is the only tool that can at least contain the situation.
I'm from Kerala and we ourselves have many problems and disagreement with the Union, but you don't see us raising slogans for independence or greater autonomy. Because we don't have nations like China, Pak and Myanmar next to us to supplement the hate.
@@abhishekunni2433 Who needs other nations to supplement hate against India when India itself is the main reason. There is racism against North Easterners, negligence by the central govt. and then this draconian law called AFSPA. There was a period in the 90s when Indian Armed Forces killed more innocent civilians then the insurgents did which led to more people joining the insurgent groups. I hope History doesn't repeat itself. And also not everything wrong in India is China, Pakistan Or British fault. Many of the internal problems and mistrust in India are our own creation.
@@abhishekunni2433 by your logic, there should be AFSPA in Punjab, Rajasthan and upper Gujarat too. But you coolly forget that.
Why are Indians not angry? Imagine the shootout had happened in Delhi or Mumbai, would we be still sitting quietly like this?
No one cares. NE region is an adopted child.
Welcome to our world, i. e NE Indians. It has been always like this for us
It is not about region stop creating mistrust ,nowadays so much us happening in some or the other name we have stopped coming to streets,we only shout on RUclips and Twitter.
20 hindu temples were destroyed in Tamil Nadu,did you see any outrage from Hindus ,did you see any major news coverage.
So much has been happening Shaheen Bagh, farmer protest,now laws are repealed still that tikait doesn't go.
We have realised foreigners are playing their hand to destabilize India and goverment is coward so we have stopped responding.
Already so many protests happening,ppl want to work and feed families,ppl are not sitting at home
No one cares cause we were never supposed to care. Tell me when the NE news become the main news in the media except like this violent news. There are so many things about NE our media doesn't even cover then how the hell we would know what's happening there unlike delhi Or mumbai where a idiots like dakait or swara get the headlines!
Media control the narrative and at this time they don't care about NE as much as they care about disgusting bollywood!
Angry?? Why?? It's a thing to get sad about not angry. People lost their lives, they didn't shoot them on purpose. Why 1 mistake is enough on the Army's end to make them evil?
It's very sad. Government is investing heavily in North East, there is an Assam to Manipur highway, hills are cut and big highways are constructed gas pipelines are being laid bringing development to this region. Such incidences derails this process.
Hmm
Most of the times tragic incidents are being excused or being forgotten after some angers....but this time this is a serious problem....we should get justice...and should be justified...🖤🖤
Yes jihadi
@@ravigurjar3107 Bhai itna gussa, usne kuch galat to nahi bola
@ProudIndian_M see those kinds of concept makes India slow bro...we never enjoy anyone's death...
@ProudIndian_M It's because of ignorant people like you which further fragments our country.
@ProudIndian_M bro two wrongs don't make a right. If terrorists killing minorities or anyone is wrong, so is security forces killing civilians (even if accidentally). And bhai usne kya bola yahi na ki justice hona chahiye, isme kisi ko jihadi bolne ki kya bat hai bhai?
Sir, Ethiopia seems mere days away from falling. Kindly consider a CTC.
@Vladimir Putin Watched it few hours back but it naturally doesn't covers implication for India. An unstable Africa will naturally draw China US.
Ethiopia ? Good grief …
@Vladimir Putin no I didn't. I think only the channel owner or RUclips mods can hide/delete comments. You name might have flagged it as possible bot.
Dear Naga Brothers/Sisters. I only want to tell you that most Indians have deep respect for you and you are just as 'Indian' as we are. Unfortunately, racial and liguistic discrimination is a sad reaility and is prevalent everywhere. I have faced it myself...
The incident in Mon is a highly unfortunate one and a detailed investigation should happen and the culprits must be called out. But please dont feel alienated owing to this incident, and please dont have negative feelings for us. You are Big a part of our Indian Family. Yaa I understand it might not be a perfect family largely owing to our divisive politics, but despite that India stands for a lot of Good things and the world and many other civilizations still admire India for a lot of good reasons..
For us you will always remain a fellow Indian brother/sister and we all Love you irrespective of what you feel about us.
That was so sweet of you . Thank you for those kind words
people feel betrayed when the Home Minister himselves just spiited out lies instead of speaking the truth and didnt bring justice
Year our problems is Amit Shah lies that there were 2 checkpoint, what's the point of investigation of you have already made a conclusion. We want fair investigation
Sir ji. If history teacher are like you then students would have scored top in any exam.
They didn't came back to fight....they went to check a gun sound in a nearby village and found out the jawans hiding the dead bodies... and the few people who came to check tried to fight back and the jawans fired back....the commander of the coy is responsible for it.....imagine killing 15 young energetic male from a small village...some family lost 2-3 members brothers....the commander of the coy is responsible for it....
Bring the commander the justice. Sad.
💔💔💔
That's what I was thinking all this new channel painted picture in my mind that army fired on unarmed citizens and 15 civilians along with 1 army officer died. Now I was confused why the hell they killed there own guy until I watched study iq video then I got to know that actually 6 died in open fire while others died afterwards and 1 army officer was killed by civilians not the army itself!
I think we need better coverage over there✌
Army didn't do it on purpose. One incident shouldn't justify the hate for army. And where did u got all this information?
@@siddhantgarodia3381 the commander is responsible for it....
The profundity with which Mr.Gupta speaks about the North East is always awe inspiring. Thank you for your work, sir 😁
In Manipur alone since 1979 there have 1500+ extra judicial killings. Court chose randomly 6 cases out of these and found all 6 to be fake encounters.
Just imagine how many innocents have died like this in whole of NE since AFSPA curse started upon the region.
Also so many women were raped were armed forces, Manorama’s case in 2004 is just one example.
Nothing happens to the guilty, they just go for trial under military court and later live scot free.
Thanks!
Thank you Siddharth!
I feel that AFSPA has similarities to Colonial act and unless this is abolished it will be difficult to gain back normalcy. Despite the regrets there was no commitment from the Home Minister to punish those responsible for this cowardly act therefore it seems that AFSPA is more precious than life. Here I think that the Major who led to this tragedy must be stripped of his position and this should be made as an example to all in charge of such operations. Here his decision to fire at the pick up truck carrying the miners at 4p.m.when visibility was there should have asked the vehicle to stop and thereon checked the vehicle but he did not do so and also the army trying to unclothed the dead and put on camouflage clothes to give a wrong impression was caught red handed by the president of the BJP unit from that area and the fact that even the SDPO had to flee because of the firing from the AR jawans says it all. I think that Assam Rifles should be given a new face and integrate them to the main defence not Paramilitary. Please correct me if I am wrong. Thank you for your coverage of North East and bringing the Regions History to all of Mainland India.
Look everyone agrees that it's unfortunate but remember both Nagas as well as Para SF are ours.
In military operations, sometimes these things happen.
But strict action must be taken.
I am optimistic about it.
Have faith in Your Forces 🙏🏻
@@ashutoshrai3369 you have faith in the forces. Exactly what I also want that people of NE should have faith in the forces. For that strict punishment must be given who led the operation. Both forces and People of Nalgaland are Indian. Definitely agree. But one side killed innocent and one side demand for justice.
@@mdr6714 Like Gupta ji said, Indian govt and Army announced their mistake which is unusual
Hence I believe Justice will be Served
@@ratangopalsaha558 Shut up and Stop spreading Hate
Its Para SF we are talking about
Those who conducted 2016 Surgical Strikes
@Susan Joseph yes that what I am saying. Yeah but Army trid to hide their bodies. Accountable means what? Punishment who did this. Isn't it. That is i am s
This is a very unfortunate situation. But still we just cannot stop there just by saying that what has happened is unfortunate. The family of the deceased deserves justice. And justice should be served to them.
Thank you sir for your neutral and detailed analysis of recent Nagaland incidents.
Thankyou for making us understand the national and international issues with much convenience and ease. Further, immense support to the young and enthusiastic team of ThePrint. Keep up the amazing work!
Sir your in-depth knowledge of Naga history is commendable and hats of to your unbiased journalism.
Feel very sorry for those poor people. Thanks to SG for showing this to us. That explains every thing...
So sad, we have to do the best to take care of them. 🇮🇳
Mera Bharat Mahan..
They should feel safe and secure and happy as shown in this video...
🇮🇳🙏🇮🇳🙏🇮🇳
The pronounciation u made for the names n palaces, well versed! good to listen kudos!!
Really very unfortunate incident. Hope it will not trigger any sudden increase in insurgency which has been stable for a while.
I have been trying to retrace a splendid article by Shekhar Gupta many years ago in TOI on how the Naga leaders allowed the Indian troops in the Indo-China war to escape right under the nose of the Nagas who could have easily devoured our troops who were hemmed in from both sides. I hope it is reprinted.
sir, I am from Mon, NAGALAND . you miss out important point Indian army they fire innocent civilian who were back from work and killed 6 civilian . while the villager heard the gun sounds they rust to area but Indian Army they try to hide 6 dead body but they were red handed. and again they (army) started to shoot civilian and kill 7 more.
Yes.. please do something about this
@Susan Joseph if itz is mistaken why they try to hide dead body. all the evidence video is spread in WhatsApp.
I thank u because only through u i have understood naga problem through no of cut the clutter .
Thanks again sir. Really appreciate the hardwork The Print team has been doing. As regards subscriptions, is there a possibility you'd let us choose a monthly amount ourselves? Pretty sure a lot more people would be able to join.
The army couldn't cooked up a story because the villagers arrived before they could leave, I think. Otherwise, it's quite common in north eastern region to cook up a story. When I was in class 8, a young man who probably had some links with insurgents ( actually many people from extreme poverty used to have such links) was arrested while he was watching cricket while we were playing. He didn't offer any sort of resistance, he was completely unarmed, not even wearing a shoe. They carried him some 200 metres away and we were shouted to vacate the place. Soon, he was surrounded and we heard gunshots. The next day, the newspapers headlined he was killed in encounter and recovered so and so. I don't think most of the armed forces are of these type, but there are many officers and their favourite members who indulge in such type of activities either to get quick promotion or gallantry awards or in certain cases, due to hasty decisions. The AFSPA has been in force for almost 70 years in Manipur without achieving anything while causing violence and creating terror in the minds of people. People are very much Indian here, so they shouldn't be alienated further.
The barbarism of Indian army has been stressed from Kashmir to Nagaland....No one is safe from this barbarism.
Free Nagaland. Freedom for the people of Nagaland from India..💪💪
😆 wait till 2025 we'll free Balochistan from Pakistan just like bangladesh just wait and watch
NSCN(k) is the first fraction after some issues NSCN (IM) split, according to my knowledge and the last singing video is not them, it's internet rumor, anyway thank you so much for sharing our history, I learn a lot. Pls support repeal AFSPA 👍
was waiting from an expert like you, in Northeast matters
This is heart wrenching. My heart cries for my brothers and sisters.
So sorry for your loss. We are with you in your grief.
No single word of NE part national anthem of India
no single word or single sentence of history syllabus central government edition educational books but we are nominal citizen of India is it true?
Repeal AFSPA to solve NE peace problem. Don't forget Manipur now an independent country to be followed by all NE states including Sikkim. Now NE people irrespective of ethnic diversity would love freedom and independence. Why India is unhappy for our unique reason.
@Miya yes its indepandent Nation before it join indian union kid dnt simply laugh without any knowledge other will think your not normal
@Miya dnt pull your ears and talk big again 😂😂
🙏. Thank you for the mention.
I am very worried how Para units are being used both as part of RR in J&K and now NE. Para units are elite strategic units. Who and how are these ops sanctioned?
First of all para have been fighting Insurgency and terrorist for decades they get the job done while no else could. Because of the failure of state police who are under armed and under staffed. After galwan they are lot of group's empowered by Chinese operating from Myanmar border its a failures of intelligence this incident happened the CO must be court martialed just coz of one insident dony forget the all the good stuff Para has done for this country. And PLZZ enlighten us on how para must be used other then fighting indian enemies external and internal. Go research US Navy seals, green barret,sayeret matkal,spetnaz see the kind of mission they perform. Hindsight is 50/50
That is the problem. SF Para and Para are really tip of the spear strategically. Not just CO or intelligence, multiple things have to go wrong for Para to be used in CI/CT ops. RR, Assam rifles, CRPF or BSF can have their own commando force. Para are nations strategic assets .
It is high time that NSA, Chiefs of IB, RAW, CBI and NIA are subject to parliamentary oversight of some sort. Otherwise these things will happen and no one will ever know how.
@@nicpirate007 Spetnaz , sayeret matkal , SAS , Navy seals all perform CI/CT operation nothing new on the operation. If they had accurate intelligence I think this incident wouldn't have happened just my opinion
@@nicpirate007 True they must face the parliamentary committee every year like what their USA counter parts do
Soulful singing in the video.. deeply touched
The HM Amit Shah claims a mistake of oversight on the Army's behalf while seated in New Delhi, on the other hand villagers who were first on site speak of attempt to conceal and frame, as observed by the discovery of naked corpses hastily being dressed in fatigues and guns being planted. Who anyone chooses to believe is a matter of morals and principles. The one thing that is inarguable is that these were innocent, poor laborers.
Nagaland has been a land under siege for decades now and encounters and operations have been seared into the public consciousness. Any outsider who seeks the truth need only ask one question. What is different this time? It is all well and good to talk about national integrity, neutralizing hostiles, and regrettable mistakes, but to those on the receiving end only regret and rage reverberate. Louder than gunshots, hotter than the sting of widows' tears.
You are correct buddy.
We as a nation should do the best to take care of them. It is not fair.
beautifully and sadly iterated.
💯%👍
Packed with information and details, this was a rich episode of yet another greater tragedies and a shame on democracy. Thank you for bringing this to us. It is one thing to watch pain; and another, to go through it. RIP all you who lost life.
Very unfortunate incident, but how come it’s a shame on democracy. If it wasn’t a democracy, you wouldn’t even be hearing about this.
We shouldn't have blindly inherited the British expansion. They were colonial imperial power and the casual way they draw India's border was highly silly especially some people who knew nothing about Indian history were given job of drawing borders and we are facing the consequences of that even today.
First Indian government should have done more to negotiate in a proper way to settle this early instead of leaving it to future generations who only wanna play politics over it now.
Supreme court should Intervene, that's not fair at all.
It has gone Woke
Leave them
Trust your Forces.
They will deliver Justice
Its unfortunate
And remember both innocent citizens amd our forces are ours 🙏🏻
It can't be a mistake , it may be a political Plan . Our forces may have been misguided by there superiors
@@VarunMGole tu khangressi hai kya??
@@adrpatr5338 bhai desh me har koi us attack ki ninda kar raha hai, bhale woh BJP supporter hi kyu nahi ho. 15 bekasur logo ki mara gaya .
@@VarunMGole Sahi kaha
Salute to the print. Respect and appreciation from Nagaland
Army should give hefty compensation to the families and also help these villages with everything. The atonement of this miserable act would be providing better healthcare, education, supplies to these poor people. Army should take all these responsibilities. Afsa should be repelled by GOI.
Thank you sir for such a nice episode of CTC. No news channel covers the story in such a depth.
It is not the job of army. It is job of people representives. Let them work.
Three villages of Fazilka district, pangi village and many others were modernized by Army as a good gesture. Army does that. It is not something out of the book. You google and you would find lot of such cases.
@@sahilgthakur394 army has done many good things like this in the borders of Nagaland. Just when we were having good relations with armies after decades of rough years this happened. AFSPA should goo immediately🙏😭
@Abdullah Saud normal state means??
@Abdullah Saud ...what do you mean by normal state....
Waooo,....I'm impressed by your in-depth knowledge of Naga insurgents and it's demographic
The nation's head lies hung in shame over the loss of innocent lives in Nagaland
Thank u for bringing the story in an impartial way.
With this kind of intelligence we compare ourself with China 😂😂😂😂
Recently USA killed an inocent family including children in afghanisthan in drone strikes,counter insurgencies/terror operations are way more complex than your pea size brain can accomodate
@@vedprabhudessai4989 feel sad for you boy , you cant accept the bitter pill . Grow up boy.
@@vedprabhudessai4989 US is thousand kilometres away Afghan.. Well to you may be Nagaland is at opposite of the earth away from India.
What US did was drone strike without clear visibility.
Well to you may Para SF shot those people from space at night with their eyes closed.
Trying to compare US with Afghan?
You mean you mainland are US and we are Afghan?
Get yourself some common sense delivered on Amazon from US through Afghanistan.
@Susan Joseph security forces had ample time to identify and confirm the identity of those people before firing. The terrain is hilly and it road condition is really bad. Pick up van couldn't have moving fast with so much load. What kind of mistake is that. They even tried to hide the bodies and tried to dress those dead bodies with camo but they were caught in the act. The government officials were also fired upon when they arrived the spot even though they clearly stated their identity. National media don't cover these reports.
There are videos on villagers going to the area after hearing the gun shots but guess what? Those courageous Armies hiding the body by putting things above the body. But they saw the blood... And when they discovered the body... Their voices on seeing the body... Goshhh... Its sad
Thank you Sir.. So much appreciate it..❤
Forget everything, Nagas climbed the hills in kargil and killed pakistanis, nagas died for this nation, high time respect is given
True.
Thanks for de cluttering the issue. Appreciate the concern. Finally the song clip at the end was very thoughtful.
Mon is a beautiful place my father was in Assam rifles we always love & respects local culture I have my local frnds their , something may went totally wrong I wish my both side families should restrain keep cool guys
It is an example of how inefficient is the Indian military intelligence.
We have a part-time home minister now. This is the main problem.
Those two boys Merrily singing at the end of the video work in the same coal mining area but not the ones who were killed. They are still alive. Commenting from Mon Nagaland.
I believe, the correct way to go about this unfortunate incident is to make all the details leading up to the operation public. The Indian armed forces are by far a professional ,moral and motivated group so this incident can''t be some mischief. But we the people want to know what happened. Indian civilian lives matter. Jai HInd!
@Susan Joseph thanks, it was reported that SF carried out the ops. And it's unusual that they couldn't make out civilians from militants.
@@tony-pc4kd please sir, while there maybe the odd incidents by and large India is very fortunate to have our armed forces serving the nation. Jai hind! No it's not blind patriotism. From poor helmets to subpar weapons they serve.
These days most of the mirrors got replaced with Lcd screens which have filters and even show ugly faces(reports or news) beautiful.
The Print is still mirror🔍🔍.
I am feeling sad about the news story today. However will continue my stay and subscription to The Print. Mirrors don't lie.
The govt. Should apologize and compensate...
Very informetive
Innocent 15 civilians have been killed and shekhar spends the entire video speaking about everything except the brutality. Shame. Any words of condemnation for the army?
Very good explanation. And a patriot from northeast India
Thank you team@theprint for bringing out mining issue in NE
Well explained and highly informative! Thanks Shekhar Sir!
Very informative. Thanks sir for bringing up the issue to bigger platform.
Sir, u May have ur reasons but in this series u really went around the bushes.
Background story is much needed but then was hoping u will hit the main points after some time.
Some body is badly in need of a medal and promotion RIP
True👍mostly fake encounter.
Northeast is playing field of indian army.
@@theshekhar5 when it will happen with your kind then you will feel the grivences
@@theshekhar5 finally china 😁😁😁 China did it what a joke .......
@@theshekhar5 Never accept your failures and mistakes like a true mainlander
@@theshekhar5 😂 when moron like you speaking and giving shit opinion from 5'*7' room seating far 10000 km who never interacted who never stepped foot in the state is giving his ridiculous it's seems very funny. You have seen the worst THE WORST😂😂😂
If Indian Army's claim their effectiveness on battlefield comes from AFSPA,it is really a shame to this 200 year old institution.From the reports I have read ,this situation was certainly been avoidable if they had done a thorough checking ,attacking a Truck filled with labourers only incites helplessness and gives an impression of brutality of I.A which it is certainly not.AFSPA which gives immunity to I.A,has made them complacent and reliant on hollow and brutal tactics ,any world class Army worth of their salt do not possess such immunity.Govt should remove this draconian law, and come with new innovative tactics.Such a shame and we have just begun to integrate N.E into mainstream.This will push us back decades.
Hello keyboard warrior,come join the army n the SF,be part of an counter insurgency op if you have any balls,it's easy to sit in comfort rooms n talk
@@vedprabhudessai4989 I know it will be tough for army but think how insufferable condition NE people facing there with this law, they repeatedly saying they don't feel safe with this law, now tell me shouldn't we hear the pain of our NE brothers?
@@jayati6693 without this law,army is a tooth less tiger,unless you won't want army to operate in these areas then it's fine,we use army only when the situation were put of hand n couldn't be tackled by paramilitary n local police,it's a near war situation
Just love the way Mr Shekhar explains everything. Very informative. What is the best way to support The Print. youtube membership or website ?
Perfect speech here 👍👍 this is the one of the best translation here 👍👍👍
I am falling for the way Mr. Shekhar explains everything. Beautiful!
Sir , you forgot to mention Manipur Govt. which is also under BJP administration.
This is the most neutral analysis I have come across. Rest others are blaming army heavily.
SG sir kindly do a CTC on the Dam Safety bill that was passed in Rajya Sabha recently.
Always respected you sir- always will. Thank you for being unbiased.
No one is better than you sir.....
You are alone.... 🙏🏻🙏🏻🙏🏻🙏🏻
We need to make a fund for these miners where all citizens can contribute
Heartborken after watching video in the end 😢
I hope Gupta Ji, is fine why there isn't any new episode of cut the clutter, I am waiting eagerly.
No apology expressed....just a regret by the Home minister. This is inaccessible. Please don't try and appease us just like that.
The greatest feat of solidifying peace and bringing about a honorable solution to the decades old naga political issue, would be repealing the draconian and inhuman act of AFSPA.
Modi and BJP govt with majority in the lok sabha has the opportunity to act. The concerted efforts under modi can have stronger conciliation with the naga people if this act is repealed and talks continue.
Thnk you sir shekhar ji for covering a contentious issue.
India whilst being the largest Democracy in the world has lot to answers to it's people.
Sir ,
Let’s make one condition clear respectful to Nagaland .
India remains undisputed - Undivided .
May I rest my humble case .
Every condition/s could be discussed by the people in power in both regional and country capital /s .
It really pains me about this festering Naga issue .
Good wishes from London
Just praying that that was not the last song the boys were singing.
Anyway ( SG style!), I have decided to pay The Print. In KIND.
THANKS!
My salute to you Mr Sekhar Gupta for this informative, empathetic and very engaging news story . I have just subscribed to your channel .
Thank You Sekhar Gupta for covering issues of Northeast India
Iam damn sure that 90% of viewers of ur channel are regular viewers. We will constantly support you
Best history class ever had!!!
When is cut the clutter letter published?
I am using this platform to voice a concern regarding the payment options available to prospective clients like me. I am surprised that net banking is not available as a payment option. Print's finance team is also not forthcoming enough as to why this platform is not available. I am sure Print clientele will increase if net banking is also available as a payment option.
Dont waste money on this librandu propogandist.
Good information.
I am here to watch this after the pure politics episode on this. It provided clarity and I wanted to understand more.
nicely explained