Pour moi tout est parfait mais je dois reconnaître que je suis hypnotisé par le regarde expressif de cette grande actrice. Les prises de vue reflètent le professionnalisme du réalisateur et des cameramen . Grand merci pour ces instants de bonheur.
I mean, some music genres are meant to be immortal: At least one person made a fan edit of the 1960s Soviet version’s Natasha/Andrei dance and set it to the Shostakovich “Jazz” Waltz and it still worked. ❤🎉
This is one of my favorite scenes in the mini-series War and Peace. Did you notice the way he looked at her? Oh, it really feels good to be in love! Mabuhay!
Natasha is only 16 or 17 at this her first ball, and although all the actresses who have taken on this part have done well, none have fully captured for me the teenage girl overwhelmed by her emotions on this momentous occasion in her life. Clemence Poesy has a wonderful fragility to her looks, albeit looking more Polish to my mind than Russian. But Khatchaturian's music is still in 2nd place in my opinion behind Ovchinnikov's wonderful waltz for Bondarchuk's 1967 film adaptation. Ovchinnikov captures the "swept off her feet" character of the ball.
+gc123x My view is the BBC 2016 production is made for a young audience and this is reflected in the casting. Lily James is good but it is not a good production, imo.
Almost all period dramas feature music composed in the 80’s-2000’s anyway. Imo, Khachaturian’s waltz encapsulates all the uncertainty and turmoil of falling in love much better than Beethoven.
Very nice! I love how they actually made it historically accurate. A unmarried couple like Andrej and Natasha would barely have been touching while waltzing.
Hahaha love your comment sir. I share the sentiment. The motive of a proletarian struggle shouldn't be to shut down bourgeois culture but rather to bring the material conditions where it might be accessible to the working class while negating the bourgeoisie. If you look at it this way, bourgeois aspirations of the working class are in fact revolutionary.
+DivineChronometer also i thought the interiors were highly baroque.. but the women clothing are contrasting.. i thought i was confused or maybe the arrangement of this movie is really quite faulty? no?
Книгу Толстова ,видимо,режиссер не читал. Даже внешне и Наташа и князь - другие.Здесь Наташа похожа на купчиху Грицацуеву ( тоже не знаете ,что за книга??)
Pour moi tout est parfait mais je dois reconnaître que je suis hypnotisé par le regarde expressif de cette grande actrice. Les prises de vue reflètent le professionnalisme du réalisateur et des cameramen . Grand merci pour ces instants de bonheur.
Lovely. My very favorite version and scene
this waltz was written not in the time of the story intended...but works out...
I mean, some music genres are meant to be immortal: At least one person made a fan edit of the 1960s Soviet version’s Natasha/Andrei dance and set it to the Shostakovich “Jazz” Waltz and it still worked. ❤🎉
This is one of my favorite scenes in the mini-series War and Peace. Did you notice the way he looked at her? Oh, it really feels good to be in love! Mabuhay!
Natasha is only 16 or 17 at this her first ball, and although all the actresses who have taken on this part have done well, none have fully captured for me the teenage girl overwhelmed by her emotions on this momentous occasion in her life. Clemence Poesy has a wonderful fragility to her looks, albeit looking more Polish to my mind than Russian. But Khatchaturian's music is still in 2nd place in my opinion behind Ovchinnikov's wonderful waltz for Bondarchuk's 1967 film adaptation. Ovchinnikov captures the "swept off her feet" character of the ball.
+mcmanpa What did you think to Lily James version for the BBC?
+gc123x My view is the BBC 2016 production is made for a young audience and this is reflected in the casting. Lily James is good but it is not a good production, imo.
mcmanpa ----Great comment! Everything is just like that!
Natasha è bruna, Con gli occhi neri.
Perché hanno preso una bionda?
Also as a non book reader: Is it true that the book version of Natasha actually has light brown or blond hair?
Amazing performance! Amazing version of War and Peace! Thank you for uploading it!
During that period of time there were loads of grate composers (Tchaikovsky, Beethoven), and they choose Khachaturian, who was born decades later.
Tchaikovsky was BORN three decades later also🤣
Almost all period dramas feature music composed in the 80’s-2000’s anyway. Imo, Khachaturian’s waltz encapsulates all the uncertainty and turmoil of falling in love much better than Beethoven.
@@TheMagicAroundYeah, he’d be more contemporary to the plot of Anna Karenina or Resurrection than of W&P. 😂❤
Wow, I wasn't expecting my native Czech language because I searched for this in English 😂😂
Very beautiful scene! 👏🏼😍
Very nice! I love how they actually made it historically accurate. A unmarried couple like Andrej and Natasha would barely have been touching while waltzing.
War and Peace takes place in 1805... The Masquerade Waltz written by Khachaturian in 1941.... almost historically accurate, but not quite..😁
Clémence Poésy! She was Fleur Delacour in Harry Potter :D
I call her Kirsten Dunst à la française.
Utterly bourgeois. Love it.
Hahaha love your comment sir. I share the sentiment.
The motive of a proletarian struggle shouldn't be to shut down bourgeois culture but rather to bring the material conditions where it might be accessible to the working class while negating the bourgeoisie.
If you look at it this way, bourgeois aspirations of the working class are in fact revolutionary.
@@Ari-ne2ybIf a society is less rigid it’ll make fewer people want to try revolutions.
C'est si beau la valse et de plus que j'ai toujours aimé valser, c'est gracieux, fait pour les grands amoureux qui savent bien danser.
Coś wspaniałego!!! Szostakowicz geniusz muzyczny!!
Who cares that the music is anachronistic. It's great.
1:30.... the smile.... *tears*
er, this wasn't written till 1941, so maybe khachaturian's music is a time-traveller
Une belle réussite européenne...chose suffisamment rare pour être remarquée.
EXTREMELY BEAUTIFUL COMPOSITION - do you know wat film si this? please. thanks.
War and Peace
Vicky Vichy it´s very kind of you for the ifnormation that the film is war and peace - hugs from anna brazil
Wojna i Pokój
Beautiful ...
Wow what a man.
Shax Bp oh yeah 😍👍🏻😜 nice hunk
Ksiaze Andrzej 💝
Beautiful!
Very beautiful !
Énigme du Futur : )
Ó, jen tak jsem klikla na první vhodné video a ono je to česky! Hezkýýý... ^_^
Pięknie to wygląda!
SHALOM FROM POLAND 👋🇵🇱❤️
It feels so good to be in love. Smile!
Wow, this really fleshed out a chapter in that novel.
What adaptation is this?
2007
she isn't holding his hand so I'm thinking this is a special waltz figure...does it have a name?
Is it French movie?
이지선 Russia, Italy, Germany, Poland ..
Natasha plays Frenchwoman.
No
Není ten zvuk nějak "out of sync?"
That valse was written more than 100 years after the events in this movie took place. Totally inaccurate.
They could have replayed an oldie like we do nowadays
katsan88 No, the Waltz is from the early 1900s. The movie takes place in the early 1800s.
+DivineChronometer also i thought the interiors were highly baroque.. but the women clothing are contrasting.. i thought i was confused or maybe the arrangement of this movie is really quite faulty? no?
+Negumi09 i thoughy baroque was in the late 1600-early 1700? and women gowns were really wide and...
+lazalazareviclaza I don't really care, I love that valse! ;)
wish the guy was more handsome
Книгу Толстова ,видимо,режиссер не читал. Даже внешне и Наташа и князь - другие.Здесь Наташа похожа на купчиху Грицацуеву ( тоже не знаете ,что за книга??)
Ужас какой. Кроме музыки Хачатуряна, разумеется. Полковник, молодой князь Болконский - сутул, как старый дед. Про Поэзи вообще промолчу. Мда...
Your eyes are so beautiful, my love♥♥
GOOD ARMENIA
Les cheveux de Natasha sont noirs. Pourquoi ont-ils choisi une actrice aux cheveux clairs ?
There are a lot of factual mistakes in the plot. For me it is a very bad serial.
at 0.37 thats PUTIN!!!!