Key pointers from Gwadar & Pakistan’s “Frontier” & rising trouble for Imran
HTML-код
- Опубликовано: 28 дек 2021
- #ImranKhan #Balochistan
Imran Khan's government has completed negotiations with a popular uprising led by Maulana Hidayat ur Rehman in Balochistan's Gwadar. Shekhar Gupta looks at its implications on China's CPEC & growing rifts between civilian government & army administration in the region. In Episode 908 of CutTheClutter, we also look at Pakistan's politics where there is a storm in the making.
Brought to you by @KiaInd
---------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
Read 'the challenges ahead' here: www.dawn.com/news/1666444/the...
Read 'In Gwadar protest success, you are missing out this war within Pakistani establishment' here: theprint.in/opinion/in-gwadar...
Read China’s BRI Crown Jewel Joins The Era Of Defiance And Dissent - Analysis here: www.eurasiareview.com/1712202...
---------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
Join our channel to get access to perks. Click 'JOIN' or follow the link below:
/ @theprintindia
---------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
Connect with ThePrint
» Subscribe to ThePrint: theprint.in/subscribe/
» Subscribe to our RUclips Channel: bit.ly/3nCMpht
» Like us on Facebook: / theprintindia
» Tweet us on Twitter: / theprintindia
» Follow us on Instagram: / theprintindia
» Find us on LinkedIn : / theprint
» Subscribe to ThePrint on Telegram: t.me/ThePrintIndia
» Find us on Spotify: spoti.fi/2NMVlnB
» Find us on Apple Podcasts: apple.co/3pEOta8
Early access, exclusive content, special privileges - Discover the great benefits of being a Member of ThePrint’s RUclips channel. Take a Paid Membership today. It costs just Rs 159/month. ruclips.net/channel/UCuyRsHZILrU7ZDIAbGASHdAjoin
Neither Tibet or Xinjiang(East Turkestan) are chinese provinces Uncle. That renminbi has hit the account I See
BTW, imran khan looks younger than shekhar chacha.
¹11¹¹1
the ground realities in land of fascist that are still there i.e. Australian Christian father and his two young sons 10 and 6yrs old were burnt to death by Fascist Hndu Terrorists. Those were not one and two but the whole mob backed by those in power. Just last week Church vandalized, school stormed, Xmas celebration were disrupted by the fascist hindutwa goons backed by the local govt administration. Or not too long ago the cow vigilantes in India lynching at least 44 people. The serial blasts that rocked the Mahabodhi Budhist temple in Bihar’s Gaya district. The first persecution of Buddhists in India took place in the 2nd century BC by King Pushyamitra Shunga. cruelly persecuted genocide Buddhists Hundreds of the Buddhist statues, Stupas and Viharas were destroyed in India between 830 AD and 966 AD in the name of the revival of Hinduism.
Let’s keep in mind that gwadar is an isolated town in an extremely underdeveloped part of Pakistan. Had China truly wanted to build a Shenzhen in Pakistan then they would have built in either near Karachi or the relatively developed northern Punjab region. The main goal of gwadar is only increasing the military presence of the Chinese. We should pay close attention to these protests for sure but let’s not act like this is a victory that will benefit us as China is unlikely to stop developing a military base due to these.
No. Karachi is under Sindh government. There's no alternate universe in which PPP would want development of Sindh. Not to mention until few years back Karachi was far more unstable than Balochistan has ever been.
A port can't be built in Punjab.
Many inds are of the view that Pak is becoming a Chainese colony , but they ignore USA's influence on Pak
Pak is a creation of the west for a very strategic purpose of the US.
Pak is a miltry mercenary state of US
The entire country is like it's millitary base , a mad dog which is controlled by US ,strategically located between Afg , Iran Ind , Chinaaa
If any countries in this region go against US it will unleash this mad dog on them .They unleashed it on Afghan and India, and now it intends to unleash it on chaaina .
Ever wondered amerika the champion of democracy , elections ,
Why it's so easy going on a army rule of Pak ? Why does Pak army enjoys and sustained so much power over pak ? Bcz of USa
Chaaina gave some bones to the mad dog , to lure it and try to calm it down and make it a friend .
and now it's trapped btween both of them
I think Either it has to help US if not then I think afg Pak region will be turned into next iraq n Syria .
@@mk-cb7vc May Allah have mercy on India...
@@mk-cb7vc Your comment would have been accurate 10 years ago however the Americans have dropped Pakistan for more than one reason. Remember Pakistan tried to hide Bin Laden which the Americans saw as a major betrayal and then it was obvious that Pakistan has long supported the Afghan Taliban via the Pashtuns. The Americans also do not work with Pak because they now buy most of their weapons from the Chinese. Pakistan is under Chinese influence in every way possible while the Americans have completely withdrawn even where they cannot use Pak airspace for their drone operations.
@@mk-cb7vc USA understand that Pak doblecrossd them and droped frm the good book long back, till not US Prasident has not even give a call to Pak PM, that show the importance of the relationnishp
That’s the basic difference between Chinese and Americans. Both work on extreme self interest but Americans leave you little window of opportunity but Chinese doesn’t. And as we know the nature of Pakistan is to limit India and they may have succeeded at very minuscule level but they have kept paying extreme price for it. Their generation are going to pay for it. Their obsession with Kashmir is hurting them the most and their leaders (army and civilian) knows this very well but they can’t back off otherwise it will backfire. Interesting to see how things unfold in Pakistan in next 10 years.
most countries have an army, but Pakistan's army has a countryMost countries have, so maintain the army, to fund the army they need a enemy, so army keep the Kashmir pot boiling, Pak have very little interest in what Kashmirs wants
Ten years time is too long....it will disintegrate before that.
@@ramdalwani6956 You guys have been saying that since 1947.. i'm glad B'desh went their own way, it was never truly part of pakistan, geographically or mentally.. But otherwise, Indian and Pakistani destinies are intertwined.. before Pak, india will soon be in civil war, hopefully Modi is reelected, his promise of "Hindustan" is too tempting for common folks to ignore
Your that "good" wishes been there since 1947 and Pakistan is still there and will be there even when your 1000th generation will come but look at yourself, your own govt is about to start a civil war in own country, look at your northeast, there is always insurgency but your media will only tell you when something big happens and a video go viral. As you people are at path of Nazi Germany, remember end of Nazi Germany too and same Indian Saffron govt is doing, 10 years for India is very long, maybe as things going its just matter of less than 5 years India will disintegrate. To speedup that process i hope BJP will win next general elections again with even bigger majority.
@@MKSRM1 absolutely there exists a Pakistan even after 10000th generation. Honestly, we are not interest an inch of the land of Pakistan. It’s yours. You have to maintain it. No foreign country have any interest in Pakistan’s progress. Not even your all weather friend China. Believe me. All countries work on self interest. Loans and Aid Packages will not determine countries progress. This is the basic thing you need to understand. And that’s why I said it’s interesting to see how things unfold in Pakistan in next 10 years.
Balochistan is a little larger than Rajasthan with a population of just 1.23 crores (2017) but Rajasthan has more than 8 crores.
And Rajastan is the biggest state in India
Rajsthan has 150 billion gdp and balochistan has 8 billion
@@oliverqueen5095 one of the basic and best thing India did after its independence was to abonden that Mughal and then British era provincial (Suba) system and create more autonomous states within its land. That is probably the sole reason that has kept India united. Pakistan on the hand unfortunately stuck to that old rotten system and hence all the unrest. India is five times bigger than Pakistan but still doesn't have a state as large as Baluchistan. We could've atleast 10 provinces/states if we adopted the Indian model but it has been made such a sensitive issue that creating more administrative units is equated with country's division.
@@drsalmanh5199 No you are wrong even now we have state's like UP,Bihar, Maharastra... Which are bigger than Paxtan most populas province, Karnataka,Tamil Nadu, Andhra,Gujrat... All of these state's are bigger than Sindh both area wise as well as population wise still they are among richest Indian states
Paxtan is poor because of their military and m@ulvi , you guys are spending 5% of your GDP on military where as India is spending 2% of GDP on military
@@drsalmanh5199 also, the so called Indian model is just dividing states based on language, and creating new states whenever a big protest happens.
Imran as PM is turning out to be beneficial to India 😄
I wish he Rules there for another 25 Years 😂🤣
@@gouthamsudheer2080 i pray and wish that Modi rule india for another 25 years.
@@tahiriqbal543 Till Recently I didn't know that Imran Khan was an Indian Agent working for India Indirectly. What India couldn't do to Pakistan after 1971 your Imran Khan is Doing that for us Indirectly 😂😂😂
@ afterall you are our neighbors. We wish good for you
One very important thing many are missing about the Chinese debt is a huge part of the infra debt money is going back to china directly in the form of contracts to chinese firms even in countries that have local expertise which is detrimental to the growth of the country taking debt. If IMF or any other international organization gives loan they don't add strings as to who should build the infra and part of it can be built by local firms of that country. That way the money circulates in the country creating wealth/ generating jobs while the debt is being repaid by the govt.
Ethiopia subway built by China cost 475million for 34km with 39 stations. USD14million per km, USD12million per station and $0.12 full fare
Dakar, Senegal subway bulit by France cost 1.7 billion for 36km with 14 stations. USD47million per km, 121 million per station and $3 full fare
Stations are a lot more expensive to build than railway tracks but more stations makes it convenient for commuters and standard is 800m apart. By stations it is 10 times more expensive. By km it is 3 times. So average is more than 6 times. By fare it is 25 times.
@@stunstar4553 doesn't tell much, biggest variable is land acquisition cost, material cost, type of metro etc
@@stunstar4553 do you know at what intrest percent china given loan to pak.even your present govt dont know about these intrest.
@@RIPHitchens Ethiopia is in East Africa，Their subway was opened in 2015. Senegal is in West Africa,their subway was opened a few days ago. Both are poor countries. If it were you, would you choose to take the subway with a $0.12 ticket or the subway with a $3 ticket
@@knowhubvideo I don't know the interest rate , but I know that three times more cost means three times more loan. Even at the same interest rate, you have to pay three times more interest. In addition, the more loans, the greater the possibility of debt crisis
It'll be so nice to have Imran as Pakistani PM for the next 10 year's. Inshallah.
Next comes beloved LALA
Yes. Also Modi with all the great work he's been doing and how safe everyone in India especially minorities feel under him. Jai krisha jai jesus
Also modi will be counterpart
Pakistan doing same stuff that Mir Jafar did in 1757 April, getting help from a ruthless international power to defeat a arch rival in tactical terms. What Pakistan has not learner that such power will extract high cost in lieu of its support and ultimately take over most of business and strategic affairs. We all know what happened to Mir Jaffar and his associates.
That's a really great point. Unfortunately, we do not learn.
To think about the cultural impact, Muslims in Bengal province don't name their children as Mirjafar till this day!!
Because Pakistan considers India the biggest enemy and China a friend!
Who Ever said History Repeat ,just proved correct again
Imran Khan did not say 'No'. He said. "Absolutely Not".
😀
Big fan of Shekhar sahib! Always great to hear India's perspective from such a great personality without hostility. China's ever growing influence in Pakistan is always concerning but I don't think Pakistan got options here. It would be best if India/Pakistan solve their differences for greater good otherwise we are in for never ending arms race to say the least.
Alas! If only people of subcontinent were that wise, British wouldn't have ruled hundreds of millions of our people with just 40,000 of English officers (rest of the law enforcement consisted of local Indians)... We are children of the lesser gods, there's no hope for this region...
Well said
It's very Important for us Indians to understand the geography, maps etc so that we can understand Geo politics.
A common Indian should Geo understand politics
As someone,who obsess with maps,I totally agree with you.
Exactly by understanding map. Every ndian will know abt how much land China already taken from Indian in just last 2 years.
@@nillavachakraborty4481 How can one scientifically learn to read maps? Any suggestion Nillava?
@@Madhu2405 For example,view this video full 21.08 Min.Then check the Political & geographical map of that part....You will understand the issue.
If any Pakistani leader wanted to do something great for der people and country, they have only one options -
Have a great relationship with India even if Kashmir is not resolved. Stop terrorism and Pakistan will be main beneficiary of this.
India will get many benefits also, but Pakistan will get its pride and economic prosperity both at the same time.
Not possible..then how politicians from both sides garner votes...all shout pak agent or indian agent..
And china is also involved now which will not allow this development
@@VishalKumar-xp6gz In Pakistan, Army is the beneficiary of this conflict,not politicians.
Nawaj Shariff won his last election on the promise of peace with India. Pak Army doesn't like that and hence they sabotaged it.
In India, BJP is the beneficiary of Pakistan India conflict. I think a Prime Minister from Southern India will be great in this regard.
@@BruceWayne-qe7bs U cannot say that it is impossible. Modi is from Gujarat. Who CLD hv thaught that PM from Gujarat is possibility?
Only 25 Loksabha seat?
Karnataka , Telangana and Andhra has great possibility. They also know Hindi.
Yes, For Kerala and Tamilnadu,it will be difficult.
Pakistan can get economically strong even without india.
In 60s Pakistan had more economic growth than india and china.
When Bhutto came to power, he made wrong economic policies and that made Pakistan go downwards.
Now we are revising our economic policies.
But yes if Pakistan and india have trade with each other, it will benefit both.
But Kashmir issue can not be left unresolved.
indo pak wars will continue if Kashmiris are not given their right of self determination.
@@sanjaymandal6572 lmao politicians from north have been ruling this country for more than 70 years and you have created a messhole . Politicians either from south /North east will build a better india . Both BJP and congress are useless parties
In retrospect, the PM and his colleague ministers took a strategically wise decision to help Iran to construct the Chabahar port.
So CPEC is basically a road built by China for China by Chinese money loaned to Pakistan who pay for this road and allied infrastrucure. Once road is built what will be the revenue stream for Pakistan to repay the loan? Tolls, Taxes, Port usage fee? Will it be enough??
Yeah. That would be enough.
Ikr. One of the greatest things about infrastructure projects is that it provides a lot of employment to people from low scale labourers to engineers. As far as I know most of the Indian roads are being built by indians. In Pakistan on the other hand the whole thing is being maintained and done by Chinese. I dont see how this is actually beneficial for Pakistanis living there.
CPEC= Colonization of Pakistan for Enriching China. 🤪
@@pratyushojha The best way to put it..lol
@Miya The thing is our missiles and fighter planes can range the CPEC corridor in Northern Kashmir (Siachen to be specific). That's why the Chinese keep on whining whenever we build any kind of infrastructure in that region. In the war times, we can stall their trade at least.
One minor correction: The twelve mile zone is the territorial waters of the nation. That’s a country’s exclusive property. Activities e.g. fishing next to the coast exclusively by a country’s fishermen can be done upto anywhere 200 miles from coastline. That’s exclusive economic zone. No other country’s fishermen are allowed in one’s EEZ to obtain anything of value, be it fish, or any other natural resource. Beyond the EEZ, i.e. beyond the 200 Miles is the high seas which is a free for all area. Ref: UNCLOS. United Nation Convention on Laws of Sea.
Right.
At times I think that it was a very wise decision on the part of our forefathers in 1947 to create a buffer land ruled by opportunists and delusionists to keep India away from many kinds of potential problems. ;)
EXACTLY
It was a master stroke, look where Pakistan is and where we are
Yah exactly this afg bordering region was always a problem historically even during pre 1947 time
JO HOTA HAI …VO ACHHEE KE LIYE HOTA HAI
🙏🏼
So does with us in naga & mizo
2005 : Gwadar is next Dubai
2015 : Gwadar is next Dubai
2025 : Gwadar is next Dubai
2035 : Gwadar is next Dubai.
😂
😂😂
@Ashok Mehta 🤣🤣🤣
@Ashok Mehta yes !!! Next to Dubai , not next Dubai
SG, all praise for you. 1. Apt illustrations, maps, photographs and a pointer that is helpful when viewing the maps. 2. You have done an in-depth analysis and drawn useful tentative conclusions on the "rising trouble for Imran." 3. Hopefully, your C-t-Cs on our neighbour become for them what BBC is to the world. 4. Good to see Imran asserting himself with the Pak Army.
Arey Shekhar sir, one correction. Gilgit-Baltistan borders Xinjiang and not Tibet. Tibet kind of ends near depsang plains 😁
Thats wrong, Chain border naver toched india or Pak border, Tibet was there as buffer
@@mail4srini It is not China. It is China-occupied Kashgar, which they call Xinjiang.
Pakistan is in a debt trap. Anything can happen now, Pakistan has a really tough challenges to overcome. CPEC is dead as of now.
shah saab aap to pehle he badd dua kr rahe the k ye kahee kamyaab na ho jai. it is what it is. shah g.
@@darjavaid8478 The point of our bad wishes is that if you guys aren't able to pay those loans, which is very likely to happen, the port is then no longer urs too, and then the Chinese are free to jump on it.You guys aren't our main concern, the Chinese are...
@@roshankhengare9088 Dude they the Chinese are already sitting inside your country. Try to address that concern first and stop worrying abt us Pakistans.
@@darjavaid8478 lol its only their wishful thinking. A country never truly goes bankrupt. Even india was bankrupt 30 years ago, nothing happened
@@sarakhan-gq6mf yes maam he is talking about not able to pay to the IMF and the chinese just like what happened to sri lanka and yes thats why india liberalised in 1990s and so did China in mid 80s but pak started to do it in early 80s and what other options are there to boost its economy rather from funds from other countries and IMF
Pakistan will keep heading towards anarchy untill they give up the idea of snatching the state of J&K from India.
Can someone having their jugular vein outside their body survive for long??
Great episode as always. Love your content 😎👍🏻
Nice appraisal of the situation in Gwadar. I think you should have referred to another article, Rogue leaders are quietly planning mischief, published in The Times today.
It is not ribbon shaped, it is dog shaped.
4:38 Never heard of marble from Makran coast (Baluchistan). Makrana (west of Saambhar lake), 30 km west of Jaipur, is a rich source of marble for India & Taj mahal was built of this.
Onyx is world's rarest and priciest marble.
@@RonakKogta
Yes. But Onyx isn't used as a building material like marble.
Gwadar was Omani territory and Omani want to sell it to India but Congress refused.
Congress even refused application of Baloch Princly states to join India.
Can you share the source? Of your claim/comment?
@@chandubaiwhatsapp pe mamaji ne bheja hoga to sahi hi hoga
@@eisa8014 i am not in India, just you can search these facts. Gwadar was Omani n they wanted to sell it to India. Anyway do some research before commenting.
@@eisa8014 no go check fack
@@Kenkalsi gwadar was oman territory true. But they didnt want to sell it to india.🤣🤣lol
Shekhar, guess the stage is being set for the next big geo-political drama planned for 2022! The only issue things are getting too close to home for comfort! The reassuring silver lining - our people in the uniform! They are as always watching over so that we can rest!
An interesting ctc would be this:
The following geopolitical developments in the Islamic world:
Oil on the decline.
Saudi Arabia trying to break away from tradition/orthodoxy.
Turkish economy falling.
Taliban take over of Afghanistan.
Poor economic situation of Pakistan.
Aspiring Bangladesh and Indonesia.
Iran.
What does it mean for the rest of the world?
Also, the CCP being scared of the Chinese people. Recently, its behaviour has been very defensive.
Always watching your show thanks for cutting the clutter Mr Gupta ☮️From BIRMINGHAM ENGLAND 🇬🇧
Many Pakistani were in opposition of CPEC project. They have warned Pakistani establishment about the non viability of this project and the benifit will be totally goto China and Pakistan will be paying for this.
SG Sir thanks for sharing this insightful and significant analysis on current situation in Pakistan.
Very informative and in-depth article 🙏
Thanks
Yet another riveting episode with insightful info.
Thank you Shekhar sir for this video.
If possible, kindly make a CTC on doctors' protest.
Sir, Please talk about China economy reality.
I watched every of your video and recommended to my family and friends.
Thanks
Cut the clutter is a staple diet for me.
thanks shekhar , very full of info & elaboration.
Sakher ji, today while scrolling my utub I saw a vedio in which KLAM sahab was thare and u ware also thare in it, Why don't u talk about klam sahab and his legacy in someday CTC
Thanks!
Sir, your analysis on international affairs is unparalleled..very informative, educating!
@@devtiwari9185 bhai dhawan sir sirf article se info provide karte hai, SG ne khud berlin wall, Tiananmen square massacre, operation blue star, north east insurgency, arab-israel war jaise events khud cover kiye hai. Dhawan sir is like baby in a diaper in front of SG
absolutely
@@devtiwari9185 does it make any sense?? Jo aadmi khud taliban se mila, world leaders ka interview liya, unka opinion liya, contacts banaye countries se, more than 30 years ka geopolitics experience experience possess karta hai..and u are saying dhawan sir ka analysis SG se accha hai🤣🤣🤣 bhai kaha se ho tum?
@@akshay_wakodikar In the end, SG is a reporter. He sells news. Therefore he can't keep aside his biases. Simple hai. But tumhe samajh nahi aa raha kya? Darsheel Safari ho kya?😂😂😂
@@devtiwari9185 I m not darshil safari, btw darshil was not stupid in that movie. he was am extraordinary artist. i think aapko movie bhi nai samjhi🤣🤣🤣 aur yaar comme t kyu delete kiya?
@ThePrint Shekhar ji. Wishing you and The Print a happy new year on behalf of the print community. Wishing you and your team grow to heights.
Hit like to wish SG and team.
Thank you for sharing once again on Pakistan, a country that you cannot get out of your heads, especially after the saffron warriors/terrorists of Modi brigade came to power and surely after losing US$3 bn in Afghanistan.
1. Pakistan always wanted Gwader to be a developed port for economic reasons. That was the reason why Pakistan bought it from Oman in the first place. The reasons are (i) deep waters, (ii) proximity to economic lanes into the Gulf region and beyond, and (iii) earning money for the development of Balochistan. Why it was not developed, is another story and I can share why.
2. USA was never a long-term ally of Pakistan. The book titled, 'No Exit from Pakistan' by Daniel Markey shares the inside papers from American establishment and clearly states that USA cannot exit from Pakistan and that it cannot let Pakistan develop economically or to get totally destroyed; it can only allow the country to continue in a 'managed destabilized' situation.
3. The stories of rifts between Pakistan and China are, at best, FAKE NEWS. This is all FAKE is evidenced by China supplying semi-stealth J-10Cs, submarines and advanced frigates at almost no cost to Pakistan. I have researched Pakistan budgetary forecasts and there is no significant amount earmarked for such expensive acquisitions. It seems that either they are all on negligibly small EMIs, get now and pay later, or even simply China running its PLAAF, and Navy through Pakistan using Pakistani personnel. I predict that Pakistan will soon be getting Chinese full stealth jet fighters.
Will be looking forward to a CTC after Pakistani budget, if it is fully IMF compliant. Librealising SBP an cutting out exemptions on GST
I think this issue was already resolved by imran Khan...there is no more agitation ..
Why are you discussing about Pakistan? Are there no issues in India to discuss about?
Would like to believe that it was not throat-clearing, but a Freudian cough at 17:09.
Quite detailed. Well articulated and lucid.
Excellent 😊👍👍😊 analysis
Sir, i watch lot of channel that ask for contribution. How to decide.
Thank you for your clear explanation and simple manner in which you always help us get through subjects like this, great job and thanks again
Why chinese purchasing oil from middle East ? They have an affordable , accessible supplier like Russia . I didn't get the logic behind that , may be for influence ? Or more demand ?
They want option and also influence
@@BruceWayne-qe7bs are you a malayali?
Also the quality of the fuel matters. Part of the reason Germany lost world war 2 was that they were lacking good quality fuel even though they had the best fighter craft designs. While the allied nations had ample of it.
Kindly do an episode on the Chinese visit to the Tamil region of Sri Lanka. Is there any Chinese sinister motive to build a naval base at Kachatheevu?
@Putler ☢ - I don’t think it is now possible unless Srilanka willingly parts with it.
@Putler ☢ - a simple rule is that a big brother has to be accommodative.
SG, what will happen if pak become bankrupt? just curious to know u. Thanks
They'll have to go into austerity. Most developing countries, even India, don't have a population that can easily survive austerity so they'll likely fail and have to go through economic reforms or suffer a meltdown of the state and the economy. It would starve many common Pakistanis.
@@sanatshirwaicar4579 okay. but what will be the end ? like, will IMF or WB will initiate pak to divide into small states and fund each states and later become sovereign country?
@@shijoshiila it won't bankrupt. Western powers and China will save them.
@@shijoshiila The IMF and the World Bank don't have those powers. The economy will keep melting until someone willing to do the right thing is elected.
A state can't truly go bankrupt.
Detailed information.
What has to be done to eliminate the political employment?
Thank you doing this piece versus the cricket match
Very precise explanation....
As Pakistani we can work with China in limitations we should not handover our assets to china
4:37 I think you mistook makarana of Rajasthan famous for marble with Barren makaran coast
Pakistani interest in trade with India should not be the criteria for opening up any trade.
This is the time to liberate Baluchistan and pok
Gwadar port was offered to India by the Sultan of Oman before it was sold to Pakistan.
Thanks to the great great Jawaharlal, we rejected it just like we rejected a seat on the UN security council in the 50s. For no reason at all
That was news to me
Thanks
@@beonmouth5821 all of Balochistan requested to be a part of India as well, we refused
@@architjain30
1- Controlling Makran Coast without any land border wasn't possible, nor did Pak was ready to let it go. It was smart decision to avoid unnecessary confrontation.
2- UN permanent seat wasn't ever offered to India! Read authentic reports or talk to any IFS officer (or friend if have any)
@@pp_01123 respectfully sir, i work in the UN in NYC. I'm not a victim of propaganda. We were offered in 1950 and then again in 1955 before China.
Why there is an officer in uniform , always sitting behind Pak PM?
Pakistan's self invited predicament can be summed up as : garib ki biwi sab ki joru
Why there is no laugh react in youtube comment 🤣🤣🤣🤣
Thanks SG . Pl tell us more about pakistan n their news
THANK YOU SHEKHARJI...!!!
Not interested in pure politics.
Gupta ji 🙏
shekhar gupta you should start podcasting.
twenty minutes aren’t enough mate
A very important development explained again in a very simple language. Lets see how this unravels.
A extremely interesting episode coming as it does soon after the events in Afghanistan. Also of late Nawaz Sharif has been showing signs of returning...
The Print is doing well .
Shekhar gupta excellent journalist
Great man
BTW, imran khan looks younger than shekhar chacha.
aapna ghar jal gaya hai padosi ki fikar hai.
Shekhar Gupta metamorphosing into Zee News Sudhir Chaudhary....
Find something to relevant for India rather than worrying about Pakistan...
The moment a journalist gets into the Godi Media group he starts worrying about Pakistan more than our own Nation...
Pity a good investigative journalist who worked for INDIAN EXPRESS with courage has now turned into this state..
y u r not showing full pak map
seems like youtube is targeting this channel. i have been subscribed to the channel and notifications are turned on for all posts, yet i do not receive any notification of new uploads. i have seen youtube do that for other channels also.
Pakistan and Imran Khan
Sekhar sir's all time favorite
SG sir - Please do an episode with Najam Sethi on Indo-Pak issues.
Bolochistan area 134,051 mi², Rajasthan area 132,139 mi², UP area 93,933 mi²
.
Regardless of your political persuasion SD’s videos are extremely educational with very few other journalists taking time to do research
Day 2 : SG if u have any story on Yugoslavia please make a video on its fall
Brilliant analysis 🧐 Balochistan is the New Tibet for China 🇨🇳 🗳🎉
ruclips.net/channel/UCjk7V7Rw2jJSflLXYxBOY0g
An unstable neighbor, that too a hostile one like Pakistan, is not necessarily a good news for India. India doesn’t usually fish in the troubled waters of the neighbourhood. Who knows? The next government may be headed by the religious extremists like TTP, TLP, etc, which doesn’t bode well for India. Baloch breaking away from Pakistan is not a likely scenario. There’s no friend next door to help them as India helped in the formation of Bangladesh. So I expect more headaches for India.
Eagerly waiting for the top 10 highest views of the year
Bharat and like minded countries should depict Balochistan as an occupied territory in text books and all other maps... International awareness should be created about the plight of Balochistan people
If Chinese coming bought liqor what about pork!?
The editor of the print speaking is top class godi. Note it.
India should exploit every opportunity arising in Pakistan.
Not much info
Amazing journalist
Looks like the Frontier corps present could be what is being tried for BSF in India recently..
Read more
I think Your comparison of Assam Rifle and the Pak frontier force is very incorrect
SG’s love for Pakistan is ok full display!
Imran Khan is Great and Honest leader in Asia
Thank you. Please set aside one day every week for ctc on Pakistan.
So....... East India Company has really entered Pakistan?
This is colonialism of 21st century. Pakistan didn’t learn its lessons.
Pakistan is still a feudal society(in an economic pov) , that kind society is vulnerable to colonialism
How and when near to true, strong & sustnable democracy can come to Pakistan... in my view, It is in the interest both Indian & Pakistani people at large...
Lol Agarwal i think you should learn about the fundamentals of Islam 😅
Islam and democracy cannot co exist 👍
Shekhar - extremely perceptive and fascinating take full of perspectives, as always. Loved it. Two aspects you could've woven in are:
1. The sensitivities around Durand line resurfacing since the Taliban has never accepted it as the border.
2. In a geographical quirk, when China built a port in Pakistan's Baluchistan, India built a tit-for-tat port in Iran's "Baluchestan", another vast sparsely populated region with a lot of cultural continuity.
Please use complete map of Pakistan (Kashmir & Junagarh States missing)
🤭😅🤭🤭🤭🤭🤭🤭🤭