Implications as Zelensky surprises Putin with his Kursk incursion in Russian mainland & F-16s arrive
HTML-код
- Опубликовано: 9 сен 2024
- Russia-Ukraine war is back in focus after Zelensky's elite forces managed a shock incursion into Kursk. In Episode 1500 of Cut The Clutter, Editor-in-Chief Shekhar Gupta discusses Kyiv's military objectives and other successful raids in the backdrop of November US polls and the possibility of an Iran-Israel escalation and Putin's 4 courses of action.
Read the article here: www.understand...
---------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
Exclusive content, special privileges & more - Subscribe to ThePrint for Special benefits: theprint.in/su...
---------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
Connect with ThePrint
» Subscribe to ThePrint: theprint.in/su...
» Subscribe to our RUclips Channel: bit.ly/3nCMpht
» Like us on Facebook: / theprintindia
» Tweet us on Twitter: / theprintindia
» Follow us on Instagram: / theprintindia
» Find us on LinkedIn : / theprint
» Subscribe to ThePrint on Telegram: t.me/ThePrintI...
» Find us on Spotify: spoti.fi/2NMVlnB
» Find us on Apple Podcasts: apple.co/3pEOta8
Congratulations on 1.5K episodes to the whole THE PRINT team
The office is looking lovely !
;-)o:-)o:-)
Love your reporting. Most Indian media outlets glorify Russian successes, but glad to see that you support the underdog against aggressor.
I do not think he supports anyone. It's just good journalism.
@@sankhitoYes, but he tells reality as it is and the reality is Russia is the aggressor and has no justification for what it is doing and what it has done.
@@The_ZeroLineGo penetrate your mom you zionist supporting p£!ck.
@@The_ZeroLineGo penetrate your mom.
People are just paying the bills by shilling for russia.... We have a ton of them in the United States of the americas
1500 🎉🎉 Another milestone achieved! Congrats to the print team. I have enjoyed all your content since the pandemic. onwards and upwards 🚀🚀🚀
HIs hand motions are mesmerizing.
some of his motions are literal
some are amplifiers of his words
He is conducting an emotional orchestra which can only be heard with your third eye
Lol shutup... But yes
putin-russia has no border
ukraine-yes
The problem with war is that you enter with ego, and get humbled by the infinite ways it can be waged beyond your calculations.
Every body has a " special operation" till they get punched in the mouth.😅
This proves the danger of Ukraine in NATO...if Ukraine was in NATO and staged a raid like this, Russia would retaliate and NATO and Russia would be in a REAL war.
Every body is a comedian till the Nukes come out 😅
@@HowardEllis-xt9bi ur gonna nuke me bro?!?!
@@Thomas_Anders0n Ruzzia lost 550k invaders to a comedian in something that's not even a war. Talking about nukes.... AGAIN?!!! LOL
It's always nukes when notting else works
First time I've seen this RUclips channel. I really like how you started with general global and political considerations to provide context before providing detailed analysis of the news, while returning to the general context as necessary. Top notch. Subscribed.
congratulations on 1.5k episodes, each episode has been equally good and we all love your consistency.
Congratulationss SG on 1500 episodes. Thank you so much for making these videos. Stay healthy and hope you reach 3000+ ❤❤
One other thing to consider on the options that have become available to Ukraine is to attack the critical reliance on rail transport by the Russian military. Ukraine can cut off rail lines supplying Russian offensives further south, and it brings their artillery closer to target other rail lines further east and deeper in Russia that can flow material southward.
If Ukraine had more manpower, it could also use this force as a blocking force while it deploys other forces to “roll” the Russians southward on their right flank. This would bypass the prepared defenses that the Russians have built up all along the front. This would be far preferable to sending what few troops Ukraine has directly into the prepared Russian defenses.
Excellent recap
"Kursk" is the name of the city, it is also the name of the Oblast (Province). The ground taken is definitely from Kursk Oblast.
Embarrassment for Russia.
Russia is strong, but they don’t knw how to fight a war, remembered Ukraine whole government is still in tight.
Thanks
Don't blame a shark for being a shark - russia have always being a shark. So more embarrassing for a peaceful country like India being on russias side until now
It's not for the Russians BUT for RashPutin.
He has absolutely NO business to invade the Ukrainians.
Thanks!
Dear Arko,
Thank you for contributing to our journalism.
Wishing Zelensky all the best
This proves the danger of Ukraine in NATO...if Ukraine was in NATO and staged a raid like this, Russia would retaliate and NATO and Russia would be in a REAL war.
Since May 21, 2024 he is not a president and acts in violation of the Constitution.
For what? Who is he your relative?
He is your mother
“The best” is that what Russia calls those 3.5 ton glide bombs ?
Your indepth take on Bangladesh, awaited!
It is not improtant bro, just some illiterate trash protest nothing much
Watch episode 1496
@@captainjackuniversalwho? Is proyestong
Started as special military occupation and ended up losing Kursk, classic Putin.
Kursk is not lost... Russia is a bit bigger than Ukraine 😂
@@leo-db5do 1) Lost doesn’t mean permanent in any sense, it could be reclaimed back by Russia. Same goes with Crimea too.
2) And how is Russia being bigger than Ukraine change the fact that they lost Kursk to Ukraine ?
Your argumentative skills are poor.
@@sid1290why you are updated him? He knows everything very well, it's khisiyani billi khambha noche 🤪 this type of Shekhar' s viewers are hypocrite librandu like Shekhar 👍
@@sid1290 looks like you want debate and who is less in country of argumentative Indians.
My point is, all is good but why did you used the word "classic" Putin
Did he ever in past repeated the same mistake or your wannabe as s wanted to use the english idiom ending with Classic?
Please highlight the classic ie pattern in making wrong decision by Putin.
(No putin fan boy here but wanted to check your argumentative skills only)
@@aatmaDipoBhava Classic as in making making wrong bets
Ukraine taking back its ancestarl lands. Slav Ukraine
Kursk region never became Ukraine land...
Congrats for the 1500 episode 🎉
No celebrations for 1500 episodes??
Shekhar ji pls wear your chain wali desi ghadi.. that has a different charm!
Finally !! Unusual but important topic. Ungaurded or Undergaurded areas often prove to be turning points in a war. This isn't a gospel analysis but whatever little military history I know about Russia, it seems Russia may be due to its sheer size compared to its neighbors keeps on pursuing the same front with enormous firepower or manpower & a little difference in tactics rather than looking for othe fronts
You know your invasion is going bad when your invasion gets invaded
Indians are with Ukrain although government is with Russia due to historic USSR backlogs
Yep just like ANDH BHAKT use to say whole INDIA is with modiji and then 2024 election result came.😅😅
Who says I support russia it's called defensive offence now no body in the vicinity will join nato.india is bring challenged by even maldived and joining china😂
@@pam4840 too much meddling and threats can lead to that type of response.
no , due to economic benefits
If you're losing advantage and time is against you, Stop defending and go on the offensive cause you know that you're going to loose anyway.
So much guts and strength when Russia is taking very lightly.
Its good to see more objective journalism from this side of the world. Regardless of who's side you're on, objective facts are needed to get better understanding of the situation. Typically a lot of media from India is very pro-Russian, mindlessly mimicking the Russian propaganda.
You talk like propaganda only comes from one side. This is exactly why India does not like Western hypocrisy. Maybe stop arming the country that was literally harboring Bin Laden with F16s and we will take your views on anything more seriously.
Small corrections sir : last major city/town taken by the russians is avdyvka.. additionally, while you can fairly characterize this as a stalemate but both sides are facing tremendous losses on a daily basis due to the nature of warfare, i.e. mass artillery pummelings
It's not a stalemate, Russia has been advancing fast for the last few months. Check the map. Literally dozens of towns and villages have been occupied by Russia. The major city of Pokrovsk is just a few kms away from Russian army.
He knows he really dislikes Russia, look at him saying Russia only has 15% of Ukraine, while the reality is close to 30%
Suggests peace negotiation is coming up...both will try and strengthen their positions to have a better outcome at the negotiation table😊
Israel-iran war would have much smaller geopolitical impact than Ukr-rus war, not bigger.
Quite an insightful analysis.
Yes,its not invasion by Ukraine,but strategic defence by Ukraine because Russia is launching the attack from Kursk.
Hats off Shekhar to talk on something which can divert attention from Bangladesh and situation of minorities there
Keep it up man
YOU ARE ABSOLUTELY 💯 CORRECT .
MR. SHEKBAR OVER JOYFUL OF UKRAINE INCURSION 🇺🇦 IN RUSSIA 🇷🇺 TERRORISES..
WHAT A SHAME..
HE FORGET THE BIG ROLE PLAYED BY THE RUSSIA DURING INDIAN/ PAKISTAN WAR ,,WHEN USA +UK SUPPORTED PAKISTAN AGAINST INDIAN.
SLAVA UKRAINE ❤❤❤❤
Congratulations Print media on 1500 episodes 🎉
Is Putin prolonging the special exercise? Is he sacrificing his army? Would love to be a fly on the wall during Putin's briefings..
Great information. All according to the plan. As usual. Very honest commentator
Ukraine can't win over Russia in Ukraine, but let's try winning against Russia in Russia🤣
Always remember that both Ukraine and Russia were part of Soviet Union. Russia is not soviet union.
This
Well theoretically I live in the former something also.... Things change
I think this territory was french?! Isn't Florida French? My part?! I forgot my murika history we are young country
@@notmethnx that's not the context in India. Here the narrative is that Murcia always supported India's enemies whether that was in 1971 Bangladesh's independence war or in 1965 war against Pakistan while Soviet Union supported India. This is why Indians don't share the hate that the west has for Russia. OP reminds people that Ukraine too should get the same credit for supporting India in the past when they were part of USSR
@@shashwattripathi4559 yeah I understand that 👍🦜
Today's episode is all about shekhar trying to pronounce UHKHRAINE and not YOUKRAINE
oOoOO Kearney?!
Heartiest Congratulations Dear Print Team on achieving this Big Milestone 🎉
Ukraine advance probing troops have been reported 45 km from the border and the army is now consolidating its position at the 10 km front to support forward troops
You are lying
@@germaingollo5637Advance recon units can be 20-30 miles ahead of their main units. It's not unfeasable for gaps to be the lines. In 1971 recon units were even further in Bangladesh
India for your military equipement.
No need to depend on RF or US. Some known other players Germany, UK, France, CZ etc. Yet there is always South Korea and Ukraini 😉😊
LMAO.
Great eoisode, SG!
Congrats to you and the whole team.
Excellent Reporting as always!
whoever that thought of this move is a genius
hey shekhar,, plz do 1 ctc on the whole Waqf issue plz
With the prisoner exchange last week, I really though this was it for the war, as those were big names being exchanged. I think Putin wants out now, but Zelensky may not want as all the aid, military supplies will reduce and eventually stop. Actually we should do a CTC on the prisoner swap. Big names!
Please Do a Episode on Obsolete Russian Naval Power
But then you will have to know about the derelict aircraft carrier that India bought from Russia for three billion dollars and is the flagship of the Indian Navy. That would hurt the pride of the Indian navy
@@endribardhyli1340 TRUE 💯 Ukraine War Has Exposed The " Pathetic Quality " of Russian Military ( All 3 Forces) Hardware We Have
@@TapanPal-yw7rs The tanks don't work in high altitude because the L22 engine is air hungry, reverse gear is 7km an hour. The turret tends to flip and vaporize the crew, the APC and IFV are trash. The artillery range is underwhelming. The planes are flying coffins. The Airforce has lost more men to the mig 21 than all of the wars combined. Billions lost to Ruskie propaganda. And we are still continue to buy it. For God sakes we have bought snowplows from them to use in the jungle. That is how absurd it is
Sir, Crimea was occupied by Russia in 2014 and not 2015
It's an embarrassment, humiliation and a mounting challenge for Putin. The war he started was getting nowhere earlier but is getting out of control now. The offensive operation has turned into a defensive one. By taking over kursk it's a major political victory for zelensky which will lend him an upper hand in the ceasefire talks and post war arrangement between the two nations. Kursk also has a historical and symbolic value. It was the battle in the above mentioned city that the Soviets defeated Nazis and Putin led the celebrations of WW2 victory here last year. The West is happy and egging kyiv, Moscow suffers a setback and the global South is dismayed, frustrated and agitated at the continuation of what it calls "the war of the rich world" that is having economic ramifications for them.
Congratulations Team Print
Hope it does not escalate further.
Congrats on 1500th episode 🎉
Very good summary
'replace the F16 with F22 and F35' says Mr editor. No lines of F22 any more, from where will the nato partners get F22's? Just say F35's sir
Lol they are selling F16 which was made in 60s thwy will sell F22 till 2060s atleast.
Do you throw Jaggery when you get sugar? F35 is costly beast. F22 is still undefeated
Only one country has F-22's and only one country ever will.
This proves the danger of Ukraine in NATO...if Ukraine was in NATO and staged a raid like this, Russia would retaliate and NATO and Russia would be in a REAL war.
No way they are giving f35s to ukraine
@@robinphilip2294 not to ukraine but nato partners
Excellent summary and analysis. Impartial and neutal
Congratulations on 1.5k episodes Print team
Once in a while these anecdotal episodes of the Ukraine war are always welcome. The reporting on Indian main stream media is very sparse and in terms of tactical nitty-gritty of war , this particular one is extremely interesting.
Is Zelensky a showman, 200%, he was an actor/comedian
Do whatever it takes to win...
Slava Ukraini!
Zelensky defines heros of lore.
2:32 152mm not 155mm
Too many mistakes,In 2014 they've taken Crimea and Not F-22s coz US itself is retiring F-22s and 3000 Tanks from German Wehrmacht & 5000+ From the Red Army were involved even though T-34s were way Inferior to Advanced German Tanks, Quantity won over Quality
There was a huge "Tractor" factory in Stalingrad that was originally constructed under Stalin's "First 5 Year Plan" by International Harvester in the 1930s. This "Fordism based" facility was capable of both producing new T-34 tanks and also quickly "repairing" older ones with extensive battle damage brought to it from the "nearby front". The Heer had to ship their own seriously damaged tanks all the way back to Germany where skilled specialists were tasked with determining their ultimate fate.
When life is cheaper than animals then you can do it. But now the Ruskies have been breaking their heads on the wall in Ukraine and they have the Baltics, Romania and Poland to go through.
Big pain in the ass of the Supapower...
Exactly
Shekhar ji, please bring out a cut the clutter on the rape and murder of the 2nd year intern in a government hospital inside Kolkata. The general law and order situation and the effect of Bangladesh migration on West Bengal and its effects
Facts on the ground are the only real bargaining chips.
Big gungho weapons are being humbled by small toy drones dynamics of modern warfare
As a European (Swedish), I found this a fair and balanced report and summary. That made me happy, as the little I've learned of reporting from India, it has been very unbalanced in favour of Russia. Something I frankly find very strange, as this completely unprovoked invasion by Russia on Ukraine is probably one of the most clear-cut cases of right and wrong. Borders were agreed and internationally recognized since 1991.
And of course the much smaller country Ukraine would never pose any serious security threat to Russia. Ukraine had even extended the lease to Russia of the Crimean naval base in Sevastopol (to 2047 I believe) - yet Russia in spite of this occupied Crimea. Which now seems a very bad strategic choice, as is pointed out in this video, Russia has now instead been forced to completely evacuate it's navy from there, following the sinking of some 30% of the Russian Black Sea navy.
This is a very, very sad war, where the Russian Putin regime has turned the Ukranian brother people into enemies of Russia for generations to come. For no good reason at all, except wanting to restore the Soviet / Russian empire. There were no cultural, ethnic, religous or security conflicts motivating an invasion. (Even Ukranian President Zelensky was borne in a Russian speaking home. Many Ukranian soldiers even communicate in Russian language on the battlefield.)
If Russia is internationally aknowlidged to be allowed to keep Ukranian territory, it would open a whole can of worms. The risks of countries going to war onto eachother, to actually expand their territories would increase.
What's your opinion on the genocide in gaza and apartheid in the west bank
@@SuperSanic.. Don't change the subject! This video wasn't about that. The interconnections are relatively weak.
It's same as US first asking to act the way they want and when the vassal country doesn't complies, they topple the government and place their own pawns. I don't understand what's so confusing here for you. Ukraine is an ant being crushed to fuel American arms industries and Russia's ego to control its border.
If Zelensky is so hellbent to align itself with western bloc he should've thought about Crimea. He can't ignore Russia and put her concerns aside. The war has cracked open the Nato alliance, how Nato with all its sanctions, military supplies etc is enable to bring down Russia on its feet and how west is so vulnerable without US. It took just one statement from Trump for them to realise how US can ditch its allies for money and EU needs to do more for its security.
Anyways my point here is if Zelensky wanted peace he would've never wanted to join Nato and again if he really wanted peace in Ukraine he should've invited Russia in peace talks that was held recently.
Anders your understanding of Ukraine Russian very patchy..there is nothing like Small big country does not matter in war...Crimea has historically been Russia for centuries if you are not aware..
Ukraine has not supported Indias position on various issues post 1991 which we are well aware of in India ..
@@Arihant997 you meant India went nuclear while Ukraine had just scrapped its nuclear arsenal?
Ukraine has no idea what they will do once inside 😮..this will become chakravyuh for them..they won't get supplies after some time they can't go back ..
Wayanad seems to be still out of sight for CTC
I think US has lost the influence on Kiev, UA knows that they will not get US for long regardless of who wins the White House, they take initiative while they have US weapons. On the future they will rely on EU who doesn't put conditions for using the weapons.
Three brigades' worth of troops / equipment is no small task to surprise the Russians especially with all their ISR, intel assets, and surveillance assets but Ukraine did surprise the Russians. Not sure what their motivation was to commit that many resources, but I hope they are successful with all their objectives.
Can be a trap as well
Good bye Gazprom
They are failing and would fail.
Among all this who bothers about the forgotten soldier 😢
That's said
No report on neighborhood where hindus are killed
dude, russia ukraine. You've not had your GM?
Lol, I turned off the volume, and watched. I know you were conducting some kind of Raag orchestra. Jai ho bole ji ki. Funny you also mentioned Lahore, where India has been dreaming of an afternoon Tea for 50 years.
Hey, one question, Russia has nuclear arsenal, even with this embarassment and Russia losing ground, why is there no mention or intention for them to use it? Can someone help me understand?
Nothing Russia can't deal with. 👍
What country is broadcasting this russo Ukrain war out of???
RUSSIAN SUPPORTERS OF WAR MUST UNDERSTAND THE CONSEQUENCES OF WAR 😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂
Pro Westerners should keep in mind for everything there's a season.
The IAEA have proof, Ukraine using missile to attack their own ZNPP, because ZNPP in Russian Control
@@albertthilakaratne3432We are still waiting. The coco is getting cold.
Do your points still stand? A load of nonsense that you dished out 😂 😂
Repeated show someone vedio , unknown quo
Sir, you need to update your knowledge on Russian accomplishments in Ukraine. The war has been lost by Ukraine and won by Russia. Russia did not fight Ukraine, it fought the entire NATO. Further, Global South is a major term of geopolitical reference. Its alternately called the Global Majority. You may not like it, but it reflects reality. Lastly, the world accepted the seizure of Crimea almost a decade ago....again, your cold war era thinking is showing poorly.
What a load of BS! Even if Russia somehow would get to keep some Ukranian territory, Russia will remain a poor man's country at least for two generations to come. Also the border with NATO has doubled in length with Finland (and Sweden) having joined. All of NATO is also spending more on military - something Russia simply can not match. It's plain impossible. NATO countries have some 30-40 times (!) the size of the economy of Russia. Putin is one of the worst rulers of Russian history.
Russian navy has completely evacuated from Crimea... after Ukraine first having sunk 30% of the Black sea fleet.
This is the damage so far to Russia, that Putin has "accomplished", and the war hasn't ended yet...
1) When/ how did russia win the war?? What was kremlin's goal to begin with?? If they already won why isn't putin claiming victory "officially" on one of his state propaganda channels??
2) How is russia fighting NATO?? Are there troops deployed by NATO member countries fighting this war in Ukraine or now in russia??
3) Which "world" do you mean, that has accepted seizure of Crimea?? UN recognised map still puts Crimea under Ukraine as Autonomous Republic of Crimea. Cuba, Nicaragua, Venezuela, Syria, Afghanistan, North Korea- is that the "world" for you??
So don't really know what you actually mean😂
Nonsense and at phases almost apologetic while announcing Russian losses. However you may claim, you are biased. The motives mentioned are nonsense.
Abhi tak laga tha unbiased media hain aap log. Bangladesh pe kab ayega cut the clutter?
You mean
Russians did not know
Accumulation of Ukraine forces and planning to attack kursk, Russia
Please stick to local affairs. International affairs are beyond your ability.
Shekhar Ji - Any particular reason you do not like the term “Global South”? Very curious
It means irrational, underdeveloped people.
Sir now the emperor is free from internal politics, Russian goes for half of Ukraine with its Air force sitting for such a long time .
whut.
Petition for the next Cut the clutter on Hindu genocide denialism. Support 👇
The plight of Hindus" were limited to the Awami league party members, not the Hindu community as a whole. Same happened to the Muslim members of Awami league. Bangladeshi people condemns these attacks as well as tried to guard temples as much as possible. But Indian godi media unfortunately painted a whole different picture, one that helps BJP's divide and rule agenda . Mr Shekhar knows it very well.
Reply
@@ratuls21 thanks for the sample
No masjids were destroyed@@ratuls21
@@rutvikrs what kind of dumbfuck logic is that?
It's like saying Dekho tum log yeti ke existence ko deny kar rahe ho, and the moment someone tries to help you see that's it's not the truth, you fire back 'see!'
There is no credible evidence of systematic or even widespread violence against Hindus and I spent literally hours looking for it across multiple first hand sources. If you have one, share or else stop spreading fear. This isn't WhatsApp
@@ratuls21 Noi masjids were destroyed, why? selective targeting clearly. shame shame shame shame
The Ukranians are heading right for the Kursk NPP, the 3rd largest in Russia.
It provides power for 48% of iron ore production, 13.5% of steel, 19% of all ferrous metals, 9.6% of meat and 19.5% sugar of Russia's entire state production.
If the Ukranians can shut it down then russia's economy will end.
this guy knows
That's just a few missile strikes away --- But I doubt the Ukrainians are capable of such a Strike !!!
Ukraine try to attack Kursk NPP using Missile and will cause nuclear disasters like Chernobyl, even IAEA have proof Ukraine using missile to attack their own ZNPP because ZNPP in Russian Control...
Ukraine doesn't have a navy, in a sense. Russia black sea losses are solely attributed to NATO. With NATOs ISR assets above and their SF forces managing the attacks. However, from a propaganda point of view the presenter is 100% right.
It's called Jeneu Ecole, look it up .
This man is proberbly the best story teller on youtub
To long. Lacking focus
The Russians has aircraft to counter F-16. And there is no use sending military aid peacemeal and that is why, UKRAINE has never been able to do a proper counter attack.
Russia has Flying Coffins Mig which they dump it to Stupid India
You do not cut the clutter you rather add a lot of clutter with lot of side explnations and deviating from the main story it takes a lot of guts to view a half an hour story please cut the clutter and make your story lean
Side explanations are very important to understand the context for someone who lives halfway across the world and has only a basic knowledge on the areas history and geography
I stopped watching cut the clutter as it starts with advertisement
A very important question that has not been addressed is the question of what are the strategic Russian objectives.
I suggest that the immediate Russian objective is the attrition of Ukraine’s human and material resources.
This objective can be fulfilled just as easily on the Kursk theatre as any others.
The Ukrainians cannot penetrate deeper without outrunning their supply lines.
They are therefore left with two objectives. Withdrawal to preserve their forces or remaining to await the responding Russian forces.
If they withdraw, they can preserve their human and material resources but they lose the propaganda effect of this raid.
If the Ukrainians dig in, they are just going to get pounded in situ once the Russian air power and artillery comes into play and the troops will just be sacrificed for nothing.
In the mean, Russians are still attacking on other fronts and the a Ukrainians are still losing men and material.
I therefore suggest that in the greater scheme of things, this Kursk raid while tactically brilliant, is likely to have as much effect as the Battle of the Bulge.
Russia no longer can bring in air assets to the kursk region UK brought with them significant air defence and electronic jamming assets with them into russia. This is a no go zone now for russian air.
Somehow I trust that Ukranian comand is more knowlidgeable in this matter than you @stevek4813 Throuout this war, Ukraine has shown a lot more competence than Russia. And Ukraine does not do "suicide"-style war.
Thank you very much Sir , for your great elaborate info. very experienced you are really .Defense vice n stretagic .