You are a Dalek, you should not have feels! Emotional instability detected! Exteminate! In all seriousness though, all of the pain can be felt while listening to this.
Somewhere, somewhen, a women lay, dying on a bed in some hospital. A man entered the room. He looked familiar, wearing a brown, casual suit with some great, great hair. He came over, the women barely able to register his movements. He leaned forward, touching her forehead with his hands. And then, for one moment, for one shining moment, she remembered that she was once the most important women in all of creation, her mind burning with images of impossible and amazing things. And then, she was gone.
@@wolfbaron59 Donna's memory was wiped in "Journey's End" and this person is imagining her death, and the doctor coming by one last time to see his best friend.
What's worse is that this song doesn't represent Donna's sadness, she doesn't even remember. It represents the pain the doctor felt about more or less killing his best friend. Imagine how screwed up that would make you... That's what this song is.
That's why it's picking notes from Doomsday. The Doctor is the only one who remembers all of his companions. He's the one who says goodbye as much as he says hello. The one person that knows loss better than gain. The one person who remembers losing Rose, Donna, and so many more
What really kills me about Donna's fate is that she had such low self-confidence to begin with, and when she finally believed herself to be brilliant and special, it all got taken away from her. By the Doctor of all people, the man who she trusted with her life. And she's back to "shouting at the world because she thinks no one will listen". So no only did she lose her memories, she lost her sense of self-worth.
Capri and that shows how miserable the Doctor’s life is, having to take all that away from his best friend because it’s the only way to save her! Hats off to the Doctor for living with all that pain!
The Doctor didn't do it because he wanted to. He _had_ to. Otherwise, she would have died. The parting grace I can take out of the whole situation is what he said to her mother. To treat her better, like she matters. Because she does. She's the most important woman in the entire universe.
Joseph Schultz Yes, that really hit a nerve with her mother, and I think she was offended because the doctor made her realise what damage she had done to Donna as a parent and that truth hurt
This is the one song on the soundtrack I can't bear to listen to. "Doomsday" and "Vale Decem" are generally viewed as the saddest, but both of them are bittersweet: although the characters of Rose and the Doctor are leaving, we know that Rose will continue to live on and well in Pete's World, and a new Doctor is coming to take Ten's place who will journey on. Donna, however, gets no continuation: her adventures, her personal growth, and her last-minute discovered importance was made as though it never existed, and she regresses to exactly how she was before. Donna Noble deserves the world, and she doesn't get anything of it.
Very true. It’s like a fate worse than what rose head, or maybe even a fate worse than death. To become someone you used to be, and have not progressed or become better and less angry at the world at all, and never know you did all these things. I cry every time I watch doomsday or hear the music.. but now I agree with you there. And this music is indeed truly heartbreaking too
I think Donna represents a lot of people perhaps very many - those that think they're nothing special and nothing will become of them, but in one way or another, they have their own brilliance, and to one if not more people, they are the most important person in the entire universe. One of my favourite lines was from Donna's mother - after being initially shown to be somebody who had a rather strained relationship with Donna, with disappointment in Donna's life decisions and was a bit of an unlikeable character, but redeemed herself when the Doctor said "for one moment she was the most important woman in the entire universe" and she says "She still is, she's my daughter", with such maternal pride.
+Assoluta So true. Donna is possibly my favorite companion of the New Who series because of her relatableness. I admit I'm a lot like her, I don't think I'm very important though I want to be, and I wish my life was more exciting. I still don't know what I wanna do for a career (I'm in college btw). Goddammit Doctor Who, goddammit.
Assoluta Kinda sad how when it comes to it, you could argue that Donna didn't care about all their crazy adventures, but rather that somebody could make her feel like somebody, as opposed to just some temp as she'd put it.
The sad thing is that the tragedy of her character is what makes her so great (and is also probably the reason I didn't appreciate her when I watched it as a kid when it was originally airing, because I didn't get it). Because for one moment she was the most important person in the universe only to regress back to being what she was when we first saw her.
@@mossyproductions7451 Well,it´s not that hard to me;Donna,Rose,Amy,Clara...these compannions wore amazing...Really.And maybe Donna had the saddest "end"as compannion.
Donna: I thought we’d try the planet Fellspoon. Just ’cause. What a good name. “Fellspoon.” Apparently it’s got mountains that sway in the breeze. Mountains that move. Can you imagine? The Doctor: And how do you know that. Donna: Because it’s in your head. And if it’s in your head, it’s in mine. The Doctor: And how does that feel. Donna: Brilliant! Fantastic! Molto bene! Great big universe packed into my brain. You know you could fix that Chameleon circuit if you just tried hotwiring it into the fragment-links and superseding the binary- binary- binary- binary- binary- binary- … I’m fine! Nah, never mind Fellspoon. You know who I’d love to meet? Charlie Chaplin. I bet he’s great, Charlie Chaplin. Should we do that? Should we go see Charlie Chaplin? Charlie Chaplin Charlie Chester Charlie Brown. No, he’s fiction friction fiction fixing mixing rixton Brixton. Oh my god! The Doctor: Do you know what’s happening? Donna: Yeah. The Doctor: There’s never been a Human-Time Lord metacrisis before now. And you know why. Donna: Because there can’t be. I want to stay. The Doctor: Look at me. Donna, look at me! Donna: I was gonna be with you. Forever. The Doctor: I know. Donna: Rest of my life. Traveling. In the TARDIS. The Doctor Donna. Oh, oh my god, I can’t go back. Don’t make me go back. Doctor, please! Please don’t make me go back. The Doctor: Oh, Donna Noble. I am so sorry. But we had the best of times. The best. Goodbye. Donna: No! No! Please! No! ☹️😥
Donna was the best companion. She had fun with the doctor and challenged him. She was strong and brave and then she had the saddest exit. Rose was sad but in the end she got a doctor, who could grow old with her and love her, Martha got Mickey, and still got to save the Earth but Donna, she got nothing, not even a scrap of the doctor and it was so sad that a brilliant companion had to go the way she did.
That's what makes it so powerful. I absolutely agree with RTD's choice to memory-wipe her instead of having her die. It's absolutely heartbreaking, knowing that she doesn't get a scrap of the Doctor, yet also never being able to come to terms with it, as she's _still_ _alive._ And I hate and love RTD for it.
I hate this episode, absolutely hate hate hate it. By far the saddest ending for a companion, and probably one of the most polarizing as well. She was by far my favorite companion and the only one to ever truly temper and challenge the Doctor. She tempered him, she was his conscience and as was seen in the specials, he was lost and reeling and dangerous without that moral Compass. The most important woman in the universe...
Exactly one of the only new who companion that didn’t feel like a puppy dog with wide eyes always saying yes to doctor and never challenging him I miss Donna😥
@@negamewtwo5535 Well in a nutshell the 6th Doctor was arrogant and egotistical even by the doctors standards, strangled his companion (in his defense he had only just regenerated) and constantly insulted everyone he met more than even Capaldi did.
@@liamtaylor849 you're supposed to hate it. That's good writing, making you feel as much pain as the characters. It's a fantastic ending for her character and I'm glad they didn't pull any punches in giving her a tough exit. Because that's life, its tough. (Donna is my favourite companion btw)
So much stronger then Amy and Rory leaving. They get to keeps their memories, their thoughts, and had their hope and dreams all come true. Donna Noble, the woman who had forgotten it all.
The saddest farewell of new Who. Full stop. Classic Who, it has to be Jamie and Zoe, literally forced from his side and only able to remember their first adventure with the Doctor.
I don’t know how Murray Gold does this, but he has a VERY particular talent for pairing specific instruments and songs completely tailored to a character’s personality. Like he can compose a song and that song will tell you almost everything about the scene without you having to watch it. This man is a legend… Doctor Who will NEVER be the same again. EVER.
This episode was doubly depressing because Donna had the most horrifying ending or forgetting everything, and her family had to watch her forget. And then there's Rose and the Doctor. Rose got the Doctor (sort of), but the Doctor was just... left to watch. And I suspect that for the rest of her life Rose will feel some guilt about how things ended up, and Donna will keep feeling like there's something just on the edge of her mind that she can't quite recall.
Everyone talks about this playing when Donna's mind gets wiped, but I will always remember this song from when it plays in Turn Left, as Donna is laying in the street, dying a woman who has been helping Donna realise the truth walks up and whispers in her ear two words, two words that will completely wreck and his world The Doctor: Bad Wolf.
I may sound stone-hearted here, but I never got sad about DW until this episode. Rose? When I saw Doomsday, I knew she was still fine in an alternate universe (in DW). Martha? She just... left. The Master? I didn't really like him until I watched the episode again. Then I was sad. Still, he's a Timelord. He can regenerate. He can come back somehow. Lynda? Astrid? Both not there long enough. I never really saw enough of them. But Donna... She can't remember. She can't even think of all the good times she had with The Doctor. That just seems so sad to me; all the others can remember. Tate and Tennant were 'molto bene' together.
“I was going to be with you… forever; my whole life, travelling in the TARDIS - the Doctor Donna.” Oh Christ, makes me sob *every* time ! I *screamed* at the TV when Donnas mind was wiped; everything she did, all the people she saved and she can’t even remember a *second* of it ! Yes, many companions have died - I sobbed and blubbered when Amy, Rory, Clara and Bill died - but Donna can’t even remember a *second* of this life; a better life. One in which she didn’t always have to be the best, one in which she enjoyed her life and one in which she was *absolutely* adored ! Now… she can’t remember a thing. Oh, Donna, oh Donna Donna Noble… You will always be remembered as the Saviour of Worlds.
"For one - shining moment.... she was the most important woman in the universe. She still is, she's my daughter! Well maybe you should TELL her that once in a while!"
Donna was amazing and I miss her so bloody much! She was brave, she was funny, she was a little bit crazy and her madness complimented the Doctor's so well. She wasn't afraid to let the Doctor know when he was going too far or when he was being a great big outer space dunce. When she left, it was… well, you've no doubt seen Waters of Mars. That's what happens when the Doctor is left to his own devices. Vale, Donna. You were molto bene :(
It's been *years* and every time I watch this episode I still cry. Donna was my favourite companion and she was honestly the one that represented everyone the best. She didn't want to be loved romantically by the Doctor, she didn't even want more or less. All she wanted, all she _needed_ was to feel special. Someone with such low confidence and low self-esteem, being swept away by the Doctor, finally believing she's important for something, and then having it taken all away. It's honestly the worst fate out of all the Doctor's companions. She's back where she started. And the worst part was she didn't want to. Every time the same line kills me: "I was going to stay with you forever." _Was going to._ No matter how tough Donna acted or how sarcastic she was towards him, it doesn't change the fact that they were going to be two friends, traveling in space, forever. Donna finally found a friend that she loved, and then she was ripped away from him. Never Forget Donna Noble.
I emphasize with her character so much .. I didn’t realize that back when I first watched Donna’s episodes and I was younger. Now I recognize how stuck and bored she felt.. but most of all feelings like you don’t matter.
FROM 'TURN LEFT' 1:48 *The Doctor Moves a Curtain out of the road* 'Everything Alright?' *Donna Looks at him before stepping forward and hugging him* 'Okay, what was that for!?' 'I dont know, it's just...I dont know!'
speaking from experience, when you lose someone you care so much for, you wish you could forget all the good times because it just makes it so hard that you just wish that you would go to sleep and never wake up
I wish there was a way to bring Donna back, even for a guest role. If they can freaking bring Rose back from another dimension(which they said she would never be able to escape), they can figure out a way to bring Donna back!
To me Donna's ending with the Doctor was both horrible and heart-breaking. It feels like that there are many Donna Nobles in the world who feel like they have no true importance in the world at that moment but they may have an importance in the future. It could be from anything from standing up for someone or stopping a thief from robbing others to something big such as stopping a terrorist or saving the world. But sadly like Donna's time with the Doctor, it may be only for a short while before they have to die and could be forgotten.
Years later and it just hit me that the sound from 1:48-1:50 is a piano note played backwards as her memories were taken from her in reverse ending with the moment she met him in her wedding dress... 😭
this song is so touching and AWSOME at the same time which is now and always my favourite song in the whole series R.I.P Donna noble we all loved you 😿
leo langwade yeah!!! I don't blame matt Smith.... he's a good actor but Moffat is just killing it! And he is not a bad writer... He is good at creating one offs but bad at show running... I wish to Davies was back!!! Moffat has made every season almost episodic!
PresidentSnow yes that's why I said almost.... but none of those are as good as anything we saw from season 1-4 like bad wolf the master or season 4 with Donna! DOCTOR DONNA!
kbg12ila I like Moffat's episodes, the only thing I don't like is how he over used the Weeping angels and that he doesn't give too much continuity to other seasons. Still I prefered the 1-4 seasons (specially the end of seasons, they were more "shocking")
This has got to be the sadest leave of a companion ever just the thought of not being able to remeber a great person and also remember donna saved the universe and she dont even know about it :(
One of the tracks to this day I still cannot listen to without tearing up. You can tell based on the writing, that Davies really took a liking to Donna and the Doctor as the series hasn't been the same since.
Itz Jaden yeah rose gets a happy ending she atleast gets her own version of the doctor she can look back and spend the rest of her life with. Donna does not even get to remember the times with the doctor her ending is a sad one not rose.
Elly Mae In my opnion rose is overrated and shit! she full on wanted to have sex with a 900 year old alien plus she is a whiny bitch when the 9th doctor regenerated and when they left.
I can't put into words the sadness and despair that overcame me when that first note hit. It was a sadness bryond tears, it made me shake and shudder, this music is so beautifully powerful and gut-wrenching. Donna's end was utterly heartbreaking, I've never been more upset over any other thing fictional.....
The beloved Donna Noble. The most important woman in the universe. And the Doctor's friend when he had none. We laughed with her, cried with her, but we will never forget her.
1:53 "I just want you to know, there are worlds out there, safe in the sky because of her. That there are people living in the light, and singing songs of Donna Noble, a thousand, million light years away. They will never forget her, while she can never remember".
we need to hear this in the 60th anniversary specials. Maybe once as they first meet and the Doctor realises who she is. Then one more time as she remembers.
This season gave me so much feels. The feeling when he has no companion anymore again and that Donna forgets everything. It's a feeling that is worse than what I felt on Doomsday. I just can't accept it! When I was planning to watch season 5, I didn't feel like continuing to watch Doctor Who that time. So I went asleep and even dreamed of Doctor Who and Donna. When I tried watching season 5, it just makes me so sad and gloomy. I need to get used to 11th doctor and accept what happened to season 4. Sorry, Doctor Who really carried me so much because this was one of my escape to reality that I can't hardly accept what happened. ;__;
in my own way when i was younger i was someone who yapped yapped yapped as a child cause i felt no one ever listened. Donna is by far one of the best companions.
Donna Noble; the most important woman in the whole of creation, yet still doubts whether she is good enough. A song that will always be sung throughout the univers, but will never be heard by her. Her time was filled with adventure, danger, excitement… but her menories have been perished and if she ever remembers, she will die. She is known as the most important woman in creation by everyone and she knows nothing, living her life as it was… like nothing even happened.
Sadder than doomsday even and that is saying something. Rose got to remember to doctor, be with the doctor, feel special and the doctor got to say goodbye. All 10 got from Donna was a distracted “yeah see ya”.
ALL the Doctor Who music reduces me to tears. Doctor Who will always have a special place in my heart. It's something I'm the most protective of. It's helped distract me from the thing that is life. I just wanted to say Thank you.
Great music, albeit a tear jerker. Donna had to be my favorite primary companion since Sarah Jane and Ace (my two personal favorites of all time) She was so far the first (and thus far ONLY) companion of the modern era to act like a classic era companion.
"I was going to be with you. Forever."
"I know."
MY FEELS CANNOT HANDLE THIS.
She didn't want to go.
That’s mAkiNg it wOrsE-
* sobbing *
You are a Dalek, you should not have feels! Emotional instability detected! Exteminate!
In all seriousness though, all of the pain can be felt while listening to this.
@@infinitium8460 I very much agree, the song fits perfectly
"In the TARDIS" 😢
Somewhere, somewhen, a women lay, dying on a bed in some hospital. A man entered the room. He looked familiar, wearing a brown, casual suit with some great, great hair. He came over, the women barely able to register his movements. He leaned forward, touching her forehead with his hands. And then, for one moment, for one shining moment, she remembered that she was once the most important women in all of creation, her mind burning with images of impossible and amazing things. And then, she was gone.
Why? Why do you do this?
my heart:(
This is canon to me now
What is this i don't get it
@@wolfbaron59 Donna's memory was wiped in "Journey's End" and this person is imagining her death, and the doctor coming by one last time to see his best friend.
What's worse is that this song doesn't represent Donna's sadness, she doesn't even remember. It represents the pain the doctor felt about more or less killing his best friend. Imagine how screwed up that would make you... That's what this song is.
That's why it's picking notes from Doomsday. The Doctor is the only one who remembers all of his companions. He's the one who says goodbye as much as he says hello. The one person that knows loss better than gain. The one person who remembers losing Rose, Donna, and so many more
I hope that this plays into the Time Lord Victorious arc
@@StupidWeb Even if he forgot Clara Oswald, he got the memories back, the Impossible Girl...
@@StupidWeb doomsday son/:badwolf theme/roses theme (many names for it) kills me inside.
What really kills me about Donna's fate is that she had such low self-confidence to begin with, and when she finally believed herself to be brilliant and special, it all got taken away from her. By the Doctor of all people, the man who she trusted with her life. And she's back to "shouting at the world because she thinks no one will listen". So no only did she lose her memories, she lost her sense of self-worth.
Even the Doctor says, nothing is ever truly forgotten. Not completely.
Capri and that shows how miserable the Doctor’s life is, having to take all that away from his best friend because it’s the only way to save her! Hats off to the Doctor for living with all that pain!
The Doctor didn't do it because he wanted to. He _had_ to. Otherwise, she would have died.
The parting grace I can take out of the whole situation is what he said to her mother. To treat her better, like she matters.
Because she does. She's the most important woman in the entire universe.
@jeremy ray Reminds me an old song !... 🎼🎶🎵Never say never... 🎼🎶🎵Never say never again !... 🎼🎶🎵
Joseph Schultz Yes, that really hit a nerve with her mother, and I think she was offended because the doctor made her realise what damage she had done to Donna as a parent and that truth hurt
This is the one song on the soundtrack I can't bear to listen to. "Doomsday" and "Vale Decem" are generally viewed as the saddest, but both of them are bittersweet: although the characters of Rose and the Doctor are leaving, we know that Rose will continue to live on and well in Pete's World, and a new Doctor is coming to take Ten's place who will journey on. Donna, however, gets no continuation: her adventures, her personal growth, and her last-minute discovered importance was made as though it never existed, and she regresses to exactly how she was before. Donna Noble deserves the world, and she doesn't get anything of it.
Very true. It’s like a fate worse than what rose head, or maybe even a fate worse than death. To become someone you used to be, and have not progressed or become better and less angry at the world at all, and never know you did all these things.
I cry every time I watch doomsday or hear the music.. but now I agree with you there. And this music is indeed truly heartbreaking too
60th anniversary 🔜🔜
This music is so fitting, it feels so isolated, so sad, just like Donna would feel.
Obsidian Narwhal donna will never know how special she is
I think Donna represents a lot of people perhaps very many - those that think they're nothing special and nothing will become of them, but in one way or another, they have their own brilliance, and to one if not more people, they are the most important person in the entire universe.
One of my favourite lines was from Donna's mother - after being initially shown to be somebody who had a rather strained relationship with Donna, with disappointment in Donna's life decisions and was a bit of an unlikeable character, but redeemed herself when the Doctor said "for one moment she was the most important woman in the entire universe" and she says "She still is, she's my daughter", with such maternal pride.
+Assoluta So true. Donna is possibly my favorite companion of the New Who series because of her relatableness. I admit I'm a lot like her, I don't think I'm very important though I want to be, and I wish my life was more exciting. I still don't know what I wanna do for a career (I'm in college btw). Goddammit Doctor Who, goddammit.
Assoluta Kinda sad how when it comes to it, you could argue that Donna didn't care about all their crazy adventures, but rather that somebody could make her feel like somebody, as opposed to just some temp as she'd put it.
Assoluta great
The sad thing is that the tragedy of her character is what makes her so great (and is also probably the reason I didn't appreciate her when I watched it as a kid when it was originally airing, because I didn't get it). Because for one moment she was the most important person in the universe only to regress back to being what she was when we first saw her.
Just brilliant
What if we've all traveled with the Doctor....we just had to forget it..
oh my god ...I like you your awesome
+Ouatfan Chelsea If you're talking about me then thankyou, that really brightened the bad day I was having :)
+Anna McQuillan your welcome
We wouldn't even remeber.... sorry what did you say?
Maybe we met Charlie Chaplin or Charlie Brown no he's fiction miction friction brickston........
It hurts to know Donna won't remember the Doctor...and she was brilliant. By far my favorite companion
Yea
11th Doctor R.I.P Doctor Donna 2008 - 2008
It's incredibly hard to say my favourite. There are so many
@@mossyproductions7451 Well,it´s not that hard to me;Donna,Rose,Amy,Clara...these compannions wore amazing...Really.And maybe Donna had the saddest "end"as compannion.
:)
Donna: I thought we’d try the planet Fellspoon. Just ’cause. What a good name. “Fellspoon.” Apparently it’s got mountains that sway in the breeze. Mountains that move. Can you imagine?
The Doctor: And how do you know that.
Donna: Because it’s in your head. And if it’s in your head, it’s in mine.
The Doctor: And how does that feel.
Donna: Brilliant! Fantastic! Molto bene! Great big universe packed into my brain. You know you could fix that Chameleon circuit if you just tried hotwiring it into the fragment-links and superseding the binary- binary- binary- binary- binary- binary- … I’m fine! Nah, never mind Fellspoon. You know who I’d love to meet? Charlie Chaplin. I bet he’s great, Charlie Chaplin. Should we do that? Should we go see Charlie Chaplin? Charlie Chaplin Charlie Chester Charlie Brown. No, he’s fiction friction fiction fixing mixing rixton Brixton. Oh my god!
The Doctor: Do you know what’s happening?
Donna: Yeah.
The Doctor: There’s never been a Human-Time Lord metacrisis before now. And you know why.
Donna: Because there can’t be. I want to stay.
The Doctor: Look at me. Donna, look at me!
Donna: I was gonna be with you. Forever.
The Doctor: I know.
Donna: Rest of my life. Traveling. In the TARDIS. The Doctor Donna. Oh, oh my god, I can’t go back. Don’t make me go back. Doctor, please! Please don’t make me go back. The Doctor: Oh, Donna Noble. I am so sorry. But we had the best of times. The best. Goodbye.
Donna: No! No! Please! No! ☹️😥
Wilf: they're here they're here
Doctor: help me
Wilf: donna...
Donna was the best companion. She had fun with the doctor and challenged him. She was strong and brave and then she had the saddest exit. Rose was sad but in the end she got a doctor, who could grow old with her and love her, Martha got Mickey, and still got to save the Earth but Donna, she got nothing, not even a scrap of the doctor and it was so sad that a brilliant companion had to go the way she did.
She still had Wilf. ;) That's something.
She was had all the world in her hands but she couldn't keep it for herself
That's what makes it so powerful. I absolutely agree with RTD's choice to memory-wipe her instead of having her die. It's absolutely heartbreaking, knowing that she doesn't get a scrap of the Doctor, yet also never being able to come to terms with it, as she's _still_ _alive._ And I hate and love RTD for it.
I hate this episode, absolutely hate hate hate it. By far the saddest ending for a companion, and probably one of the most polarizing as well. She was by far my favorite companion and the only one to ever truly temper and challenge the Doctor. She tempered him, she was his conscience and as was seen in the specials, he was lost and reeling and dangerous without that moral Compass.
The most important woman in the universe...
Mate, nobody ANYWHERE can say that this scene was not sad. I cried me eyes out the first 2 times I saw it.
Leftenant Simon Riley
She loved to give the Doctor a hard time. That's facts
@@leftenantsimonriley6800 I was too stubborn to cry. Still I wish I did, but I couldn't
Exactly one of the only new who companion that didn’t feel like a puppy dog with wide eyes always saying yes to doctor and never challenging him I miss Donna😥
Imagine the 12th doctor with Donna as his companion. The arguments wouldn't stop 😂😂😂😂
You think that would be bad? Imagine NINE with her
@@negamewtwo5535 Imagine Donna and 6. I'd give it a day before one of them ends killing the other.
@@cameroncaws8506 I'll admit, I never watched the Classic Who episodes. They just have a format that's weird to find the order
@@negamewtwo5535 Well in a nutshell the 6th Doctor was arrogant and egotistical even by the doctors standards, strangled his companion (in his defense he had only just regenerated) and constantly insulted everyone he met more than even Capaldi did.
@@cameroncaws8506 I'm betting on Donna killing him before he kills her
We had the best of times... The best...
Goodbye...
11th Doctor Roll credits!
i honestly hated that bit...imagine loosing all that wonder...
Liam Taylor - and going back to hating yourself.
@@liamtaylor849 you're supposed to hate it. That's good writing, making you feel as much pain as the characters. It's a fantastic ending for her character and I'm glad they didn't pull any punches in giving her a tough exit. Because that's life, its tough. (Donna is my favourite companion btw)
its just heartbreaking to know she was the best companion and had the worst fate... :(
truest thing I've heard all day.
Donna: i was gonna be with you forever Doctor: I know, Donna: rest of my life travelling in the tardis, the doctor donna. I wanna stay,
Zak Rosenfeld Look at me
Zak Rosenfeld Donna,Look at me!
WiLL Fellas don’t make me go back!
So much stronger then Amy and Rory leaving. They get to keeps their memories, their thoughts, and had their hope and dreams all come true. Donna Noble, the woman who had forgotten it all.
but she remembered in The End of Time
Geoff109
She remember for one second and because of the failsafe she is knocked out. if she remembered any longer she would die.
Thank fuck im not the only one who thinks this :D
The saddest farewell of new Who. Full stop. Classic Who, it has to be Jamie and Zoe, literally forced from his side and only able to remember their first adventure with the Doctor.
*****
Stronger in actually being something permanent instead of being easily fixable.
I don’t know how Murray Gold does this, but he has a VERY particular talent for pairing specific instruments and songs completely tailored to a character’s personality. Like he can compose a song and that song will tell you almost everything about the scene without you having to watch it. This man is a legend… Doctor Who will NEVER be the same again. EVER.
As the old saying goes, never say never
This episode was doubly depressing because Donna had the most horrifying ending or forgetting everything, and her family had to watch her forget. And then there's Rose and the Doctor. Rose got the Doctor (sort of), but the Doctor was just... left to watch. And I suspect that for the rest of her life Rose will feel some guilt about how things ended up, and Donna will keep feeling like there's something just on the edge of her mind that she can't quite recall.
Everyone talks about this playing when Donna's mind gets wiped, but I will always remember this song from when it plays in Turn Left, as Donna is laying in the street, dying a woman who has been helping Donna realise the truth walks up and whispers in her ear two words, two words that will completely wreck and his world The Doctor: Bad Wolf.
I may sound stone-hearted here, but I never got sad about DW until this episode. Rose? When I saw Doomsday, I knew she was still fine in an alternate universe (in DW). Martha? She just... left. The Master? I didn't really like him until I watched the episode again. Then I was sad. Still, he's a Timelord. He can regenerate. He can come back somehow. Lynda? Astrid? Both not there long enough. I never really saw enough of them. But Donna... She can't remember. She can't even think of all the good times she had with The Doctor. That just seems so sad to me; all the others can remember. Tate and Tennant were 'molto bene' together.
Same thing here!
+Dil Howlter as if I like the same tv shows as Dil. this is brilliant
@Alfie Thomas i wondered and looked the TV shows. SuperWhoLock. Perfect!
The first episode to make me cry was The Girl Who Waited
"BINARY BINARY BINARY BINARY BINARY BINARY" Donna.exe has stopped responding
Donna needs to be restarted. All work unsaved will be lost. Doctor'sadventure.txt cannot be found.
+Krisztian Bari get out. go. Just go.
Chaotic RUclips
I'm sorry. I'm so sorry..
O My God, You've killed me! XD
;-;
“I was going to be with you… forever; my whole life, travelling in the TARDIS - the Doctor Donna.” Oh Christ, makes me sob *every* time !
I *screamed* at the TV when Donnas mind was wiped; everything she did, all the people she saved and she can’t even remember a *second* of it ! Yes, many companions have died - I sobbed and blubbered when Amy, Rory, Clara and Bill died - but Donna can’t even remember a *second* of this life; a better life. One in which she didn’t always have to be the best, one in which she enjoyed her life and one in which she was *absolutely* adored ! Now… she can’t remember a thing.
Oh, Donna, oh Donna Donna Noble… You will always be remembered as the Saviour of Worlds.
BUT WE HAD THE BEST OF TIMES
"For one - shining moment.... she was the most important woman in the universe. She still is, she's my daughter! Well maybe you should TELL her that once in a while!"
Donna was amazing and I miss her so bloody much! She was brave, she was funny, she was a little bit crazy and her madness complimented the Doctor's so well. She wasn't afraid to let the Doctor know when he was going too far or when he was being a great big outer space dunce. When she left, it was… well, you've no doubt seen Waters of Mars. That's what happens when the Doctor is left to his own devices.
Vale, Donna. You were molto bene :(
Just so heart-breaking and powerful. :'( Best companion, saddest exit.
Erm rose was the best
Omg, just freaking crying right now again...
This music, it is so fitting. It just sounds so depressing and hopeless though... ugh, so sad... it hurts in the feels.
It's supposed to. It's the sing played when Donna realized her fate. And when her memory is taken.
It's been *years* and every time I watch this episode I still cry.
Donna was my favourite companion and she was honestly the one that represented everyone the best. She didn't want to be loved romantically by the Doctor, she didn't even want more or less. All she wanted, all she _needed_ was to feel special. Someone with such low confidence and low self-esteem, being swept away by the Doctor, finally believing she's important for something, and then having it taken all away. It's honestly the worst fate out of all the Doctor's companions. She's back where she started.
And the worst part was she didn't want to. Every time the same line kills me: "I was going to stay with you forever." _Was going to._ No matter how tough Donna acted or how sarcastic she was towards him, it doesn't change the fact that they were going to be two friends, traveling in space, forever. Donna finally found a friend that she loved, and then she was ripped away from him.
Never Forget Donna Noble.
I emphasize with her character so much .. I didn’t realize that back when I first watched Donna’s episodes and I was younger. Now I recognize how stuck and bored she felt.. but most of all feelings like you don’t matter.
Donna needs to come back
How?
Wibbly wobbly timey wimey
It's been 7 years since this comment, and you've gotten your wish :)
Brain: Calm down, it's fiction. It's okay, Donna and the Doctor never lived, it's a T.V show.
Heart: SHUT UP AND LET ME CRY IN PEACE ;o;
FROM 'TURN LEFT'
1:48
*The Doctor Moves a Curtain out of the road*
'Everything Alright?'
*Donna Looks at him before stepping forward and hugging him*
'Okay, what was that for!?'
'I dont know, it's just...I dont know!'
+Ryan Howard hey! your right. such a good epsiode
speaking from experience, when you lose someone you care so much for, you wish you could forget all the good times because it just makes it so hard that you just wish that you would go to sleep and never wake up
The soundtrack of my life.
The day I moved away from literally everyone I knew.
All the way across the country.
BaBooTube Videos aye same here it sums up my life and people ive lost
Damn I could've made that in haiku...
"I was going to stay with you... Forever."
"Rest of my life... Travelling."
"The Doctor Donna."
I wish there was a way to bring Donna back, even for a guest role. If they can freaking bring Rose back from another dimension(which they said she would never be able to escape), they can figure out a way to bring Donna back!
I know this is 8 years later but she is gonna be in the centinarary(I think thats the right word) soecial next year for the 60th anniversary
This comment aged well 😂
@@generalkenobi8204 it really did lol
Well at least after all this, her and 14 got to live happily together in 2023
To me Donna's ending with the Doctor was both horrible and heart-breaking. It feels like that there are many Donna Nobles in the world who feel like they have no true importance in the world at that moment but they may have an importance in the future. It could be from anything from standing up for someone or stopping a thief from robbing others to something big such as stopping a terrorist or saving the world. But sadly like Donna's time with the Doctor, it may be only for a short while before they have to die and could be forgotten.
I miss Donna Noble so much. She is my favorite companion of all of Who. This ending was truly one of the saddest moments of the show.
Same. But you know the news for Doctor Who I suppose!!
Years later and it just hit me that the sound from 1:48-1:50 is a piano note played backwards as her memories were taken from her in reverse ending with the moment she met him in her wedding dress... 😭
I'll always remember the doctor saying
"but we had the best of times" ... "the Best" (whisper) :( I miss the Good old days of Dr who
Catch me ugly sobbing in the background
Best soundtrack. Hands down!
this song is so touching and AWSOME at the same time which is now and always my favourite song in the whole series R.I.P Donna noble we all loved you 😿
I hope this song comes back for the specials next year 🤞🏻
"And it was sad, but it was Beautiful!"
Ashieldr
Oh my what this shining diamond of a show has descended into.
“Nothing is ever forgotten, not completely. And if something can be remembered, it can come back.”
The problem is that matt smith seems like he never even knew donna!
thats the problem with steven moffat
leo langwade yeah!!! I don't blame matt Smith.... he's a good actor but Moffat is just killing it! And he is not a bad writer... He is good at creating one offs but bad at show running... I wish to Davies was back!!!
Moffat has made every season almost episodic!
kbg12ila The Silence, the crack in the wall, finding out who river song is, the silence and the crack have been going through every season so far.
PresidentSnow yes that's why I said almost.... but none of those are as good as anything we saw from season 1-4 like bad wolf the master or season 4 with Donna! DOCTOR DONNA!
kbg12ila I like Moffat's episodes, the only thing I don't like is how he over used the Weeping angels and that he doesn't give too much continuity to other seasons. Still I prefered the 1-4 seasons (specially the end of seasons, they were more "shocking")
This has got to be the sadest leave of a companion ever just the thought of not being able to remeber a great person and also remember donna saved the universe and she dont even know about it :(
This was definitely used in Klurty34’s Hero of the Rails’ Wind-Up remake.
Everyone's got Journey's End quotes, talking about Journey's End, for this track.
Y'know what I got for this track? One word:
"Please..."
"I was going to stay with you forever" that broke my heart
This song. It's just brutal.
One of the tracks to this day I still cannot listen to without tearing up. You can tell based on the writing, that Davies really took a liking to Donna and the Doctor as the series hasn't been the same since.
Wow ok, hearing this again was like depression in music form ow-
And people say Rose's departure was sad...spoiled brat. Donna doesn't even get to remember.
Oh god, I'm crying all over again. Poor Donna.
TwiTheVillain and Rose gets a Doctor for herself
Itz Jaden yeah rose gets a happy ending she atleast gets her own version of the doctor she can look back and spend the rest of her life with. Donna does not even get to remember the times with the doctor her ending is a sad one not rose.
Elly Mae In my opnion rose is overrated and shit! she full on wanted to have sex with a 900 year old alien plus she is a whiny bitch when the 9th doctor regenerated and when they left.
Rose was willing to leave her mother forever to be with the Doctor. What a bitch.
I'll always love my precious Rose Tyler! 😈 (Totally not creepy).
I was gonna stay with you, forever.
Donna was and is still my favourite companion from new who.
"That's right, isn't it? I don't die?"
Such a powerful line, Turn Left is a momentously amazing episode.
I was going to be with you. Forever.
The Doctor Donna
don't make me go back....
Rueful - expressing sorrow or regret, especially when in a slightly humorous way.
I can't put into words the sadness and despair that overcame me when that first note hit. It was a sadness bryond tears, it made me shake and shudder, this music is so beautifully powerful and gut-wrenching. Donna's end was utterly heartbreaking, I've never been more upset over any other thing fictional.....
The beloved Donna Noble. The most important woman in the universe. And the Doctor's friend when he had none. We laughed with her, cried with her, but we will never forget her.
1:53 "I just want you to know, there are worlds out there, safe in the sky because of her. That there are people living in the light, and singing songs of Donna Noble, a thousand, million light years away. They will never forget her, while she can never remember".
goosebumps. S4 4ever. it was so good.
Donna was always my favorite.
For me, this is the most tragic and tearful companion departure in Doctor Who. Not Rose, not the Ponds, but Donna's.
Poor Donna, she has nothing, before she met The Doctor, then she forgot it all, all those amazing adventures,
Genuinely the saddest music I've heard...
This scene always makes me cryy... Like a lot;)
I like how in the suggested videos, "Somebody That I Used To Know" is in there.
we need to hear this in the 60th anniversary specials. Maybe once as they first meet and the Doctor realises who she is. Then one more time as she remembers.
Been looking for this music for awhile. Thanks for uploading
No. No, you can't! Doctor, please. No- N-
This season gave me so much feels. The feeling when he has no companion anymore again and that Donna forgets everything. It's a feeling that is worse than what I felt on Doomsday. I just can't accept it! When I was planning to watch season 5, I didn't feel like continuing to watch Doctor Who that time. So I went asleep and even dreamed of Doctor Who and Donna. When I tried watching season 5, it just makes me so sad and gloomy. I need to get used to 11th doctor and accept what happened to season 4.
Sorry, Doctor Who really carried me so much because this was one of my escape to reality that I can't hardly accept what happened. ;__;
COUGH series COUGH COUGH
Catherine Mae same:(
#RIPDOCTORDONNA
“I’m going to wipe Clara’s memory, I’ve done this sort of thing before”
in my own way when i was younger i was someone who yapped yapped yapped as a child cause i felt no one ever listened. Donna is by far one of the best companions.
She didn't deserve that fate. Not at all.
Just listening to it makes me cry.
it's so sad... and beautiful
"She was better with you!"
"Don't say that!"
"No, she was!"
This goes beyond fiction for me. Have a look at a book called 'Remember Who You Are'.
Donna Noble; the most important woman in the whole of creation, yet still doubts whether she is good enough. A song that will always be sung throughout the univers, but will never be heard by her. Her time was filled with adventure, danger, excitement… but her menories have been perished and if she ever remembers, she will die. She is known as the most important woman in creation by everyone and she knows nothing, living her life as it was… like nothing even happened.
This was probably the first thing in any kind of fiction that I was actually sad about
i love this soundtrack
SOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOO GOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOD
Ok, now I'm crying.
This song breaks me every time...Poor Donna,one of the BEST companion ever! :´(
Sadder than doomsday even and that is saying something. Rose got to remember to doctor, be with the doctor, feel special and the doctor got to say goodbye.
All 10 got from Donna was a distracted “yeah see ya”.
ALL the Doctor Who music reduces me to tears. Doctor Who will always have a special place in my heart. It's something I'm the most protective of. It's helped distract me from the thing that is life.
I just wanted to say
Thank you.
I hope Russel T.D. brings back Murray gold
Great music, albeit a tear jerker. Donna had to be my favorite primary companion since Sarah Jane and Ace (my two personal favorites of all time) She was so far the first (and thus far ONLY) companion of the modern era to act like a classic era companion.
I can't believe that after all this time, I can't listen to this without crying.
Doctor: for one moment one shinning she was the most important woman in the whole wide universe.
Can't listen without crying, I loved Donna so much.
It makes me think of a giant spaceship flying somewhere far away from Earth more than it makes me think of Donna, it's weird.
Still sad tho
sometimes i cry because donna noble and ten and pain.
Step 1 Lay down
Step 2 try not to cry
Step 3 cry alot
she was a real friend for the doctor, everyone else just lusted over his body, especialy jack, but she was a tru friend, a true companion