The Battle of Brothers: Porsche 718 Spyder vs. 718 Spyder RS! Is the RS Worth it?!

Поделиться
HTML-код
  • Опубликовано: 30 ноя 2024

Комментарии • 69

  • @waltvancourt5052
    @waltvancourt5052 Год назад +8

    The RS will not be attainable for 99 % of us after ADM.
    Was lucking to find and afford a slightly used sypder, but also had a 2018 cayman gts to trade in, which made it affordable to trade up for.
    More like this, good video.

    • @Pcarwhisperer
      @Pcarwhisperer  Год назад +1

      Awesome! What do you think of your Spyder opposed to your 18 Cayman?! Thank you! That’s the goal 😊

    • @waltvancourt5052
      @waltvancourt5052 Год назад

      @@Pcarwhisperer cayman 4 yrs, I and everyone loved it, pdk, track days a few times. BUT, spyder, 5 mths,First manual, harder to drive and I feel like its always in race car mode ! Gts was a looker but the sypder is even better, both chalk color.
      I also have a 17 c2s convertable pdk. I'm in south louisiana.
      Take care buddy.

  • @TGCREken
    @TGCREken Год назад +5

    Love my 23 Spyder.
    The RS conversation is only dreaming. Both price and availability. Only the very best Porsche long time customers will be given an allocation.

    • @Pcarwhisperer
      @Pcarwhisperer  Год назад +1

      What color is your Spyder Kenneth? And you have the final year 😊 hold on to that puppy!

    • @TGCREken
      @TGCREken Год назад +1

      @@Pcarwhisperer gentian blue.

    • @Pcarwhisperer
      @Pcarwhisperer  Год назад +1

      @@TGCREken 😊 I love Gentian!!

  • @kineticU
    @kineticU Год назад +10

    RS is for flexing. The roof of on the RS…sure very analog, and nostalgic. GT4 RS makes sense if you track. I wouldn’t spend 2.5x of my 718 Spyder MT that’s used in city and country roads. Rather have a 911 CS + a 718 Spyder.

  • @dangilchrist8614
    @dangilchrist8614 Год назад +3

    I would take the 718 spyder looks like an awesome car

  • @gtsspeed2619
    @gtsspeed2619 11 месяцев назад +2

    The Spyder RS is a quid pro quo. Yes I get that “proper” 4.0 engine but you have to give up the manual. I’ll keep my 718 Spyder true manual. My last sports car purchase I think. A modern naturally aspirated Mid engine drop top with a third pedal. Who else is making those other than Gordon Murray? That says it all.

  • @got_gt3612
    @got_gt3612 Год назад +3

    Cool vid , I own 992 gt3 and 000 spyder, the biggest difference to me between RS and regular spyder is manual transmission, PDK in RS us different from regular, gears shorter, suspension is different. I say it’s a totally different experience, similar but different. It’s kinda when people say : my 911 GTS is almost like gt3 , I tell you it’s not. If you drive RS and spyder back to back really hard I guarantee you take your check book and sing check for RS 😂 unless you die hard manual guy

  • @dcDOC19
    @dcDOC19 Год назад +4

    This video is a good change of pace for your content. Keep up the great work! Question, could you please provide any information on the new incoming Taycan Turbo GT?

    • @Pcarwhisperer
      @Pcarwhisperer  Год назад

      Woow thank you so much! Going to work on getting more cool cars! Yes!!! Don't have anything super official yet looks to be 1000 hp and and 3 motors! Once I know more I will make a video

  • @niten1972
    @niten1972 Год назад +3

    Love it Mason!! Great job 👏 😊

    • @Pcarwhisperer
      @Pcarwhisperer  Год назад

      Thank you for the opportunity! Glad you enjoyed it!!

  • @marcimouse2271
    @marcimouse2271 Год назад +1

    Awesome video Mason! 🔥

  • @vagabond1776
    @vagabond1776 Год назад +4

    LOVE the manual soft top on the Spyder RS, but with no manual tranny option I’m happy to give Lotus my money. If Porsche decides to offer a GT3 manual version of the Spyder RS then I’ll happily cancel my Emira order. Why buy a PDK or any automatic, for that matter….if speed and numbers were my main concern, I might as well just get an EV and have the performance AND practicality.🤪 There’s nothing more blissful than rowing your own gears.

    • @HGUlmke
      @HGUlmke Год назад

      GT3 Touring has manual clutch if you wish.

    • @vagabond1776
      @vagabond1776 Год назад

      @@HGUlmke the 911/GT3 is too big (for me) and I’m not a fan of the new interior. I would’ve purchased the last gen TTRS if Audi had offered a manual. I’ll likely pick up a “regular” 718 Spyder if I can make a deal…just not convinced my Emira ownership will be as blissful.😬🤪

    • @lucrej-vb1yi
      @lucrej-vb1yi 7 месяцев назад

      You're a lucky guy, you can save 60k euros or even 80k euros if the spyder has the weissack package on it, driving a manual lotus with a toyota camry v6 and 400hp instead of 500. Dreaming your next tesla..🤣

    • @vagabond1776
      @vagabond1776 7 месяцев назад +1

      @@lucrej-vb1yi if it was all about 0-60 and track times I would only consider an EV. An automatic can never provide the same driver engagement and enjoyment of rowing your own gears. ⚙️

    • @lucrej-vb1yi
      @lucrej-vb1yi 7 месяцев назад

      @@vagabond1776 trust me, drive a porsche pdk and you can have a very good and exiting experience. After that, you can continue prefearing the manual gearbox, and i totally respect your choice.But a pdk is not to consider a normal AT.
      I like too the engagement that a manual shift can give me, but with the 420 hp of my 991.2 c4s i prefear to hold my hands on the steering wheel :D
      Have good road with the car you love, lotus emira is a really fantastic car!

  • @23kamyar
    @23kamyar Год назад +1

    Awesome video bro!

  • @888mf4
    @888mf4 Год назад +1

    A little difficult to answer this question without driving the Spyder RS!

    • @Pcarwhisperer
      @Pcarwhisperer  Год назад

      I agree with you! I have driven a 4RS being virtually the same set up without a top and although an amazing car its hard for me to wrap my head spending twice the amount on track focused convertible when 90% won't see the track and just sit in a garage somewhere being taken out occasionally for the weekend run. 😞 If someone wants a track toy get a 4RS like you've done!

    • @888mf4
      @888mf4 11 месяцев назад +1

      ​@@Pcarwhisperer The Spyder RS is designed for the road, hence the softer suspension set up. They have also stopped making the Boxster Spyder, so you don't have that as an option anymore. The list price of the Spyder RS in the UK is £123,000 and a 12 month old Boxster Spyder would set up back £95,000 - £105,000 with the PDK gearbox.

    • @brianhimmelman420
      @brianhimmelman420 5 месяцев назад

      @@888mf4which would you choose Mark?

  • @STORM3SHADOW
    @STORM3SHADOW 4 месяца назад

    That ridiculous removable top on the Spyder RS is a deal breaker for me. I'd rather just opt for the 718 Spyder if I wanted the drop-top experience and go for the GT4 RS if I wanted the extra performance and that glorious induction sound.

  • @DrNerdo
    @DrNerdo Год назад +1

    Great topic !!!!!

  • @darkangel3oooo
    @darkangel3oooo 6 месяцев назад

    The real question is why is this the only video I found on RUclips that compares the Spyder and Spyder RS? That's just weird.

  • @Macedonia270
    @Macedonia270 Год назад +1

    Most, if not all Spyder RS will be garage queens....NOT what Porsche stands for or was intended for....

  • @TWHISPERER
    @TWHISPERER Год назад +1

    Are these as fast as the 911 Carreras, say like the 4s?

    • @Pcarwhisperer
      @Pcarwhisperer  Год назад

      Great question the 0-60 times are virtually the same from a Spyder to a C4S 👍🏼

  • @982spyder5
    @982spyder5 Год назад +1

    At 10:40 you ask, what does the Spyder have that the other 718's don't have?
    And you mention all kinds of inconsequential items like color and the supplemental restraint color, sport chrono and yet you never mention the GT suspension!
    Ugh.

    • @slg8063
      @slg8063 Год назад

      So what? I felt like I was on this drive. This video was great and he said there were other options he didn’t mention. I’d love to see you do a video on the fly knowing all this information whilst being filmed.

    • @Pcarwhisperer
      @Pcarwhisperer  Год назад +1

      I mention GT suspension at 5:14

    • @richardcatchlove9115
      @richardcatchlove9115 Год назад +2

      Price of RS in US an issue? In Australia, same car is US$300k

    • @waltvancourt5052
      @waltvancourt5052 Год назад +1

      ​@@richardcatchlove9115
      After dealer markup, 300k in usa too.

  • @mikerusznak
    @mikerusznak Год назад +1

    Dig it!

  • @filoniz
    @filoniz 11 месяцев назад

    Title is very misleading. Couldn't even see the RS! You can't have versus without having two cars to compare.

  • @muffinman4353
    @muffinman4353 Год назад +1

    NO SEVEN SPEED MANUAL???

    • @Pcarwhisperer
      @Pcarwhisperer  Год назад

      Yes one of the few that didn't have one 🤔

  • @pietervanschaik1442
    @pietervanschaik1442 Год назад

    i saw only the spyder never the RS?

  • @MWS1960
    @MWS1960 10 месяцев назад

    Im thinking the guy that owns that is British 😂😂

  • @hbullock
    @hbullock Год назад

    You’re comparing a car you’ve don’t even have in the video? WTH?

  • @911aircooled5
    @911aircooled5 Год назад +1

    Really good summary and well articulated. You should consider doing more Porsche road reviews, and it's by someone who is invested (knows) in the product.
    Good great out in a spyder. Well done Mason.

    • @Pcarwhisperer
      @Pcarwhisperer  Год назад

      Woow thank you so much 🙏🏻 my goal is bring a video like this once a month! 👍🏼 glad you enjoyed it!

  • @Nexus-lm9xz
    @Nexus-lm9xz Год назад +3

    Absolutely without sense the video you can not compare what you never have driven.

    • @Pcarwhisperer
      @Pcarwhisperer  Год назад +1

      How do you know I haven't driven one? I have driven a GT4RS and it is virtually the same as a Spyder RS with a top

  • @brianhimmelman420
    @brianhimmelman420 5 месяцев назад

    PDK … seriously?

  • @Yogi5D
    @Yogi5D Год назад

    This german junk isnt worth more than 35k fully loaded

    • @Seaward1224
      @Seaward1224 7 месяцев назад

      Right, let me guess you have a corvette or a mustang that so good that’s why you can’t leave your driveway without seeing 5 identical models and colours as yours right? Lol. Porsche is not for you my man! Porsche owners wouldn’t want it any other way! Enjoy!

  • @landonbarretto4933
    @landonbarretto4933 Год назад +4

    I have a 2023 being delivered any day now. I would never buy a PDK Porsche which is what the new models are.

    • @Pcarwhisperer
      @Pcarwhisperer  Год назад

      Fantastic! Congrats Landon! So happy to hear! What color?

    • @landonbarretto4933
      @landonbarretto4933 Год назад +1

      @@Pcarwhisperer - white with the red top. red interior.

    • @Pcarwhisperer
      @Pcarwhisperer  Год назад

      @@landonbarretto4933 beautiful! 🥰

    • @TGCREken
      @TGCREken Год назад

      Congrats! I have a 23 manual Spyder and it’s crazy. Impossible to explain in words. You’ll love every moment!

    • @Nexus-lm9xz
      @Nexus-lm9xz Год назад

      Bullshit PDK best you can get