MTG GOLDFISH VS PLAY TO WIN GAME 2-Rograkh/SilasRenn VS The First Sliver VS Rograkh/Ardenn VS Edric

Поделиться
HTML-код
  • Опубликовано: 9 янв 2025

Комментарии • 193

  • @emptynest4103
    @emptynest4103 3 года назад +207

    Deeeaamm that Richard generous gift was the biggest brain ever!!!!!

    • @juliofranciscogomezstoppel1860
      @juliofranciscogomezstoppel1860 3 года назад +19

      he is a really strong player overall. He regularly plays weak decks and manages to win with them because he is REALLY GOOD at reading the table. It looks like he plays commander as 1vs1, focusing on the biggest threat at the moment, and playing the politics needed to stop the key plays. Even if he doesn't win, he usually leads big moments in the table that either fizzle combos, or end games.

    • @kingfuzzy2
      @kingfuzzy2 3 года назад +7

      Yep richard is one of the best player ive seen at politics and threat assessment. He keeps all of his scary cards in his hand until he wins which a skill very few people are even aware of.

  • @VRanger100
    @VRanger100 3 года назад +59

    I'm not surprised by Richard's hot plays. The man has won with Bird tribal, Spider tribal, and even Horse tribal.

  • @matthewbowen9893
    @matthewbowen9893 3 года назад +84

    100% here for more goldfish crossovers.

  • @hammernnaila7031
    @hammernnaila7031 3 года назад +75

    Learning that Richard really likes cEDH really makes me want to watch him play more jank cEDH decks like this.

  • @pauljaton5128
    @pauljaton5128 3 года назад +6

    7:54 “hell yeah you fuckin got me bro” -Dylan
    this is the funniest moment ever

  • @paulmcclain642
    @paulmcclain642 3 года назад +71

    I’m a simple man, I see Ardenn/Roger I smash like. And then Roger smash face. Lots of smashing all around.

    • @niklasrombekker2998
      @niklasrombekker2998 3 года назад +3

      I totally agree. And this was a super episode. My favorit so fare

  • @Gingerbreadley
    @Gingerbreadley 3 года назад +46

    Man that Richard play hot damn

  • @oddball_covers
    @oddball_covers 3 года назад +22

    That generous gift was so nutty, DAMN YOU BIRD!! Amazing content as always!

  • @esrohm6460
    @esrohm6460 3 года назад +27

    what else could Rograkh be then a god. Tyrite Sanctum is just revealing the truth to us all.
    ps.: Aven Mindcensor is on off my favorite cards of all time and this game shows why.

  • @Repaurcas
    @Repaurcas 3 года назад +84

    So... Tyrite sanctum is a cEDH staple, that was new to me.

    • @rexone9564
      @rexone9564 3 года назад +4

      I don’t know about staple, but it sure did work there

    • @1ntegrator
      @1ntegrator 3 года назад +2

      So is Mana Tithe^^

  • @isaactodd1256
    @isaactodd1256 3 года назад +7

    Love the collab with goldfish. Hearing you guys complain about the bird made it even funnier. Richard and his damn birds 😂😂

  • @frankdetank9126
    @frankdetank9126 3 года назад +3

    By far my favorite video of yours so far. That says a lot too because I genuinely like all your other videos. This was just super fun to watch. I'm glad that MTG Goldfish was able to rattle the cEDH table a little bit.

  • @kellyperry5009
    @kellyperry5009 3 года назад +5

    That was really cool! We have all been there, where the game just gets away from the person leading and then someone unexpected just grabs the win. Perfect game to show new cedh players or those who think the format is always over by turn 2 or 3

  • @HaydenSkinnerFine
    @HaydenSkinnerFine 3 года назад +20

    This is my favorite cross over event by far! ❤️

  • @splitthesoulgaming7431
    @splitthesoulgaming7431 3 года назад +53

    I honestly think a lot of the forgetting about aven mindcensor came down to these proxies, they just don't look like the iconic magic cards we all know and looking at them doesn't trigger the "ohh that's on the board..." In our brains.

    • @rexone9564
      @rexone9564 3 года назад +1

      Yea and this way, Goldfish gets to advertise its new ‘proxy’ feature

    • @andy19934
      @andy19934 3 года назад +19

      Honestly I think that's just Cam doing Cam things. I agree that the iconic image could help, but I do like those proxies. Half the time I can't see what the card is anyways, so having the large text name really helps with everyone being webcam these days

    • @splitthesoulgaming7431
      @splitthesoulgaming7431 3 года назад +8

      @@andy19934 hmm interesting I have the exact opposite experience playing against these proxys... Like nothing against proxies, but it is not clear what is on the board with these...
      At least to me anyway, and I'm sure I'm not the only one.

    • @andy19934
      @andy19934 3 года назад +15

      @@splitthesoulgaming7431 I think the biggest thing against them is when most of your deck are them as they all look alike

    • @TheRasuo
      @TheRasuo 3 года назад +1

      Yeah, sure. I agree the first time. But the very next turn, there is no excuse

  • @geeganasaw3895
    @geeganasaw3895 3 года назад +3

    You guys are the most underrated magic channel on the platform! Keep up the great content!

  • @Eiyaa90
    @Eiyaa90 3 года назад +5

    I love how Aven Mindcensor did that much work.. also Tyrite on Roger.. thats gold!
    Also Richard's generous use of proxys makes me smile :) My playgroup loves seeing stuff like that ^_^

  • @SuperPacMan1143
    @SuperPacMan1143 3 года назад +13

    Is no one going to bring up the perfect it’s always sunny reference and as always great game and quality content keep it up 👍🏼

  • @ModAnonMTG
    @ModAnonMTG 3 года назад +5

    Wow COULDNT BELIEVE how good that Generous Gift play was! What a game, very well played everyone

  • @MaxMckayful
    @MaxMckayful 3 года назад +1

    That game was fantastic. So glad you decided to post it :)

  • @bloodbaron6165
    @bloodbaron6165 3 года назад +16

    Oof that Hinterland Habor hurt to watch

  • @alexhoude
    @alexhoude 3 года назад +11

    Oooo a new video hope this one is good
    Edit: holy I thought this was two games that was a really long game

  • @jessemcfarland1682
    @jessemcfarland1682 3 года назад +3

    That was the better game between my 2 favorite channels . Loved it

  • @tehfurbolg4960
    @tehfurbolg4960 3 года назад +1

    Great game and it really helped me that you had the names displayed, thanks!

  • @CorsairJoshua
    @CorsairJoshua 3 года назад +13

    Richard is an absolute GOAT player. We're lucky he just plays Bird tribal and shit when he plays.

  • @bryandrake9122
    @bryandrake9122 3 года назад +18

    Richard's deck is a blast to watch. Off meta going ham.

    • @ODIRGO
      @ODIRGO 3 года назад

      which deck? I just saw a bunch of white paper with some letters on it, hehe.

  • @jstrobel3620
    @jstrobel3620 3 года назад +7

    Richard really is a great player. This is why he wins commander clash often lol

  • @rexone9564
    @rexone9564 3 года назад +4

    That was a great game of Last Man Standing. 😆. Both Richard and Tomer had some NICE plays.

  • @blakemcconnell6213
    @blakemcconnell6213 3 года назад +1

    This may have been your best game yet. This was a barn burner!!

  • @Drazatis
    @Drazatis 3 года назад +1

    People meme on Richard’s deck choices over at Commander Clash, but he has to handicap himself to compensate for his MASSIVE FUCKING BRAIN.

  • @Rulox665
    @Rulox665 3 года назад +3

    Richard is such an incredible player. There is no wonder how he wins so many games on the mtggoldfish channel

  • @buddadragonmtg4848
    @buddadragonmtg4848 3 года назад

    Wow that was a great match. Loves the interaction and showing that even the best decks in the game can be stopped.

  • @09nickdenis
    @09nickdenis 3 года назад +3

    Amazing episode guys. More content with Richard (or maybe Seth?) would be sick!

  • @Metsani44
    @Metsani44 3 года назад +5

    i NEED an explanation for that “flynthorn elves”

  • @jbs6614
    @jbs6614 3 года назад +3

    Mindcensor reminding us who the OG oppressive agent is.

  • @1h3artn1nj4s
    @1h3artn1nj4s 3 года назад +1

    Dylan Sevinne’s Reclamation copies itself when you flash it back!

  • @johnpaulson7000
    @johnpaulson7000 3 года назад +2

    I love this content! Thanks for being so entertaining. I learn a lot

  • @BooksOfTheFallen
    @BooksOfTheFallen 3 года назад

    Fantastic game, I must say I'm loving the Sunday morning PtW tradition, this toast just wouldn't taste the same without ya guys

  • @wesleybohult4956
    @wesleybohult4956 2 года назад +1

    I came here for the MTG Goldfish crossover episode (banger btw), and then the "Dee you bitch! Idiot bird!" got me so good 😂

  • @josephmitchell6077
    @josephmitchell6077 3 года назад +1

    Hyped to see these playmats available 😍

    • @josephmitchell6077
      @josephmitchell6077 3 года назад

      Just to abuse the heart pin. Can I make a recommendation to the play to win merch? Just putting the logo on the back of the hoodies and an option of putting it on the back of the shirts? I think it might look better. Still ordered one though :D

  • @joshuahabiger691
    @joshuahabiger691 3 года назад +7

    When you flashback Sevinne's it copies itself, right? Tomer would've needed 2 pieces of interaction if I'm not mistaken

    • @splitthesoulgaming7431
      @splitthesoulgaming7431 3 года назад +4

      The copy is made as part of the first spells resolution. So if it doesn't resolve there is no copy.

    • @keep7smiling
      @keep7smiling 3 года назад +3

      @@splitthesoulgaming7431 not true. It copies when it's being *cast* from a gy. Please read the card before you correct someone

    • @ChristianKleineidam
      @ChristianKleineidam 3 года назад +5

      @@keep7smiling Sevinne reads: "If this spell 𝘄𝗮𝘀 cast from a graveyard, you may copy this spell and may choose a new target for the copy." This is past tense. It doesn't read: "When this spell is cast from a graveyard..."

    • @splitthesoulgaming7431
      @splitthesoulgaming7431 3 года назад +6

      @@keep7smiling check rulings on gatherer mate, you're wrong on this one. One of the rulings specifically states if the spell is cast for its flashback cost and the target is removed before it resolves it will fail to resolve and a copy will not be made.
      This shows that the copy is made as part of the resolution, also it's an "if this was, you may" trigger not a "when you cast this card for its flashback cost/from a graveyard" trigger

    • @TensyCL
      @TensyCL 3 года назад +1

      @@splitthesoulgaming7431 Cast and Resolution are 2 different steps, and the copy is made on cast.

  • @rdumalaog
    @rdumalaog 3 года назад +1

    The rage against the Mindcensor just made my night

  • @GoldSabertooth
    @GoldSabertooth 3 года назад +2

    Ah yes, the return of the mythical Flinthorn Elves 😹

  • @somefishhere
    @somefishhere 3 года назад

    Fail to find Sacred Foundry hilarious!! Great games here, both Tomer and Richard are great edh guests!! Also can’t wait for the Malcolm Tana now that it is on everyone’s radar haha.

  • @TripsAhoy
    @TripsAhoy 3 года назад +9

    Richard go get some damn cards!!! ;)

    • @rexone9564
      @rexone9564 3 года назад +2

      Hey, it’s not like he runs the largest Magic The Gathering site or anything.

    • @bhuddy
      @bhuddy 3 года назад +3

      We have to clear out his garage

  • @TheRDRipley
    @TheRDRipley 3 года назад

    Yalls merch is sick. I would get the playmat but I LOVE my Winnie the pooh Cthulu playmat. Yes you heard that right 🤣

  • @didupaytheone2678
    @didupaytheone2678 2 года назад

    Cam reading the card explains the card? Top for only bro, one day , was a great game ,thank for Richard and tomor for playing

  • @MythicalDaemon
    @MythicalDaemon 3 года назад

    This is the first Play to Win video I've watched, and I fucking love the IASIP Dee's a Bird refrences!

  • @illbetthisnameisnttaken6598
    @illbetthisnameisnttaken6598 3 года назад +1

    Fantastic IASIP reference there!

  • @didupaytheone2678
    @didupaytheone2678 2 года назад

    Richard let's go!!! That's some good magic there, love to see combat damage wins, need to see more 😆

  • @redwoolsocks
    @redwoolsocks 3 года назад +1

    Yes I was waiting for this!! Great game!

  • @oscarperezcame
    @oscarperezcame 3 года назад +2

    Great game! And no Consultation/Oracle! It made it funnier

  • @jaibell4835
    @jaibell4835 3 года назад

    love the episode, love the play by Richard but most importantly i love my 2 new playmats

  • @jeanvictor4723
    @jeanvictor4723 3 года назад +1

    This game has proven that actualy BIRD IS THE WORD lol

  • @dakotawalters5358
    @dakotawalters5358 3 года назад +1

    BIRDDDDDDDDDDDDD!!!!! Reminds me of the crows from Rapturepalooza. Lmao.

  • @aarongill5176
    @aarongill5176 3 года назад

    Like always, I've been waiting for this all week!!

  • @SvviftDeath
    @SvviftDeath 3 года назад +1

    I might be mistaken on how control effects work with players dying but when Richard died doesn't the control effect of Gilded Drake end and shouldn't Dylan regain control of Gilded Drake? This wouldn't have changed the end but I always like to find out these type of rules scenarios since they come up so infrequently.

    • @PlaytoWinMTG
      @PlaytoWinMTG  3 года назад +2

      Nah drake gets exiled when Richard dies

    • @SuddsyZomby
      @SuddsyZomby 3 года назад

      @@PlaytoWinMTG nope blogs.magicjudges.org/rulestips/2012/08/multiplayer-monday-what-happens-when-a-player-leaves-the-game/

  • @supermaxguy
    @supermaxguy 3 года назад +2

    Richard's jank decks are always amazing. I have three or four decks inspired by this man.

  • @williamthompson3981
    @williamthompson3981 3 года назад +25

    gotta say i love richards proxies

    • @MstrKipper
      @MstrKipper 3 года назад +3

      If you go to MTGGoldfish website using the deckbuilder there is now an option to print proxies, and I believe they print like that style that's really good for a webcam

    • @rexone9564
      @rexone9564 3 года назад +1

      @@MstrKipper confirmed

  • @TensyCL
    @TensyCL 3 года назад +1

    When you flashback Sevinne's Reclamation you get 2 copies which can target the same card. So, I'm not sure where your copy was.

  • @kameleon761
    @kameleon761 3 года назад

    Damn Mindcensor, lol.. Happy Sunday guys.. Positive vibes from Colorado!!

  • @reganking7870
    @reganking7870 3 года назад +1

    can you guys play the temur pirates list at some point!

  • @kylehill
    @kylehill 3 года назад +9

    So I’m fine with proxies, but having only text printed out? Eww no

    • @rizesp
      @rizesp 3 года назад

      Same thought... and there are so many of them 😅!

    • @Stampee23
      @Stampee23 3 года назад

      I think it's because Richard doesn't really play paper magic so he doesn't have a particularly big collection.

    • @kylehill
      @kylehill 3 года назад

      @@Stampee23 then don’t offer to play on a large public channel idk dude

    • @bigwig8657
      @bigwig8657 3 года назад +2

      Missing the entire points of proxies then. Sounds very "What could a banana cost 10$?"

    • @joseisrael597
      @joseisrael597 3 года назад +1

      @@Stampee23 he plays paper magic, he doesnt like proxies that look like legit magic cards so he came up with those. To each their own

  • @LocalChamp
    @LocalChamp 3 года назад +2

    Not going to lie I may have went into this underestimating the MTGGoldfish people as "casuals". I gotta say they played well.

  • @nestorcarrera
    @nestorcarrera 3 года назад

    This was the best game ive watched I a while hahahaha. Richard dominated

  • @mohammadkhalifa3176
    @mohammadkhalifa3176 3 года назад +2

    oh god now I want a DEE proxy for aven mindcensor LMAO

  • @calubras
    @calubras 3 года назад

    Another week another video, great content as always!

  • @matthewmartin9983
    @matthewmartin9983 3 года назад +1

    I love my new play mat guys. Now I just gotta find you at a command fest so y’all can sign jt

  • @AceOfShamrock
    @AceOfShamrock 3 года назад +3

    Last time I was this early was never. I'm always late.

  • @bigwig8657
    @bigwig8657 3 года назад +2

    Super cool game.

  • @erikgrundy
    @erikgrundy 3 года назад

    I saw tyrite sanctum do work as a combat trick, but I'm still not sure what it's doing in the deck...

  • @terrymartin4952
    @terrymartin4952 3 года назад +1

    This was great!

  • @awrenfaussa8887
    @awrenfaussa8887 3 года назад +2

    Lets be real, if you replace Ardenn with Tymna, it might actually be considered as a cEDH deck. Regardless, Richard really played it well and shows how politics will always play in any level of Edh.

    • @shadow29livecom
      @shadow29livecom 3 года назад

      But you get card like Colossus hammer which only works with ardenn which threats player removal in a blink of an eye. Also ad nas is so much worse

    • @awrenfaussa8887
      @awrenfaussa8887 3 года назад

      @@shadow29livecom I doubt you'd be running ad naus in a voltron deck. but you're able to run Dark Confidant and Opp Agent as value creatures that can swing (and live via Jitte/Sword of x&x).
      Though at first, I was joking about how Tymna can make any deck cEdh viable, but there's nothing stopping you from playing Ardenn in the 98 with the number of tutors and draw Tymna brings to the deck.

  • @somefishhere
    @somefishhere 3 года назад +1

    Wow Richard is GOOD. His talk around Swords Silas and then... wow. Generous Gift. Great play

  • @jaybrown7880
    @jaybrown7880 3 года назад +1

    So hype for game 2

  • @g8eo3
    @g8eo3 3 года назад +1

    When Dylan cast Sevinne's Reclamation from his graveyard, wasn't a copy created? So wouldn't one get countered but not the other?

  • @maximilianjack1764
    @maximilianjack1764 3 года назад

    What site do they make those proxies on??? I've been looking for text-only proxies.

    • @maximilianjack1764
      @maximilianjack1764 3 года назад

      that's not an answer!

    • @hammernnaila7031
      @hammernnaila7031 3 года назад +2

      @@maximilianjack1764 Richard's website MTGoldfish, just make a deck and there's the option to make the proxies at the bottom left.

  • @MrSuperiorTech
    @MrSuperiorTech 3 года назад

    16:45 was the best

  • @misohappy1070
    @misohappy1070 2 года назад

    Just realized that Dylan has a Team Valor tat on his arm, freaking awesome.

  • @screebb
    @screebb 3 года назад

    I’m a fan of CEDH, but GOD 90% proxies really grinds my gears. Just throws off the aesthetic of the game. But solid content as usual gents!

  • @samdalfthegray4495
    @samdalfthegray4495 3 года назад

    Really fun crossover!

  • @jfb-
    @jfb- 3 года назад

    That generous gift play way galaxy brain

  • @collinnutt6711
    @collinnutt6711 3 года назад

    Hey Dylan and cam I just got the new T shirt in and wanted to know if I could post a picture of the new shirt somewhere but can't find your discord

    • @PlaytoWinMTG
      @PlaytoWinMTG  3 года назад +1

      Absolutely!! We give out our discord link on Parteon at the $1 level. You can also find us on social media

  • @laytonjr6601
    @laytonjr6601 2 месяца назад

    So this is why Richard said Fierce Guardianship is worse than Pact of Negation!

  • @gluttonne
    @gluttonne 3 года назад

    Awesome game 2!

  • @adamblake7423
    @adamblake7423 3 года назад

    I don't understand how the Tyrite Sanctum activated the third time. It sacrifices to put the indestructible counter on.

  • @PhoenixRNH
    @PhoenixRNH 3 года назад +2

    Sick game, Richard's deck was sweet

  • @lukastrucka9447
    @lukastrucka9447 3 года назад +1

    So this is exactly why Ben Wheeler calls it the Idiot Bird, and yes I play Idiot Bird as well. Anyways great video as always. Thank you 🤗

  • @playmaker448
    @playmaker448 3 года назад

    Oh my God this vid was just pure hilarity

  • @cristianprado8559
    @cristianprado8559 3 года назад +1

    not a huge fan of those proxies there
    I mean if it's easy to loose track on what's on board because of cameras, imagine dealing with those white proxies cards
    I get why cam tutored and forgot about the Mincesor being on the battlefield...
    anyway it was a lot of fun
    ggs

  • @davidpipes6805
    @davidpipes6805 3 года назад

    Anyone else wondering where Richard got all those dope proxies??

  • @RageofVaddix
    @RageofVaddix 3 года назад

    A little birdy did so much that game, maybe I should run it again, lol

  • @faresalbahrani4392
    @faresalbahrani4392 3 года назад +1

    showcase Omnath Locas Of Creation

  • @lucassloan1960
    @lucassloan1960 3 года назад

    tbh thats probably why for my Korvold deck its just not a food chain deck it has multiple avenues of infinite combo its just whatever i wanna do overall

  • @omghackslol
    @omghackslol 3 года назад

    I couldn't stop watching after I noticed it, but Cam why did you keep taking cards after your deck was fanned out?? Was this to keep track of time? storm count? i couldn't figure it out

  • @grimbourne
    @grimbourne 3 года назад

    Such a great game!

  • @joefjunior
    @joefjunior 3 года назад +1

    RICHARD YEAH!

  • @brandondrake4609
    @brandondrake4609 3 года назад

    Richard is my mtg spirit animal

  • @michaelrichards5253
    @michaelrichards5253 3 года назад

    We gotta get some color or something added to those proxies to spice them up. Maybe some rainbows. That plain ol' white... -_-

  • @johnayala771
    @johnayala771 3 года назад

    Hey have y’all considered making a more minimalistic ptw shirt? Similar to the food chain wins games. Like a little ptw logo on the shirt?