@@zhuangcorp First one has better pacing IMO and is a lot shorter, both have similar mechanics but requiem is a much bigger adventure with new mechanics like the crossbow. Requiem is graphically better too.
Hard to understand how they managed to make the sequel even darker, they nailed the incredible medieval setting. The story and writing of these two games is just incredible. Few games these days nail emotional resonance. And I’m glad they added new gameplay elements to the stealth.
@@zz-uq2ow agreed.. it is 100% story because you are basically forced to follow a very linear storyline without any options unless it is the part where you are sneaking past guards to move on to the next area.. that was the only aspect of the game that was nice.. 0 difficulty in puzzles.. pretty obvious.. you are in a big room with all the doors and side rooms convenietly blocked by debris etc.. you know that the only one available to get into will have either a collectible or something to be used.. and unless you get crossbow 3 or alchemy 2, you pretty much stuck to killing the archers or javelin throwers with your sling
There were 4-5 moments where the game mechanics were just horrible and frustrating, and some more times were it all got too slow and repetitive, but other than that the game was great. An 8 is the perfect rating for me
Just finished the game, without a doubt 10/10 masterpiece. This would even be a fantastic movie opportunity if done right or a series like they have done with The Last of Us. Hope the 3rd Plague Tale does not take ages to release!
@@hmm6667 the massive size of the game, the compelling story, the interface, the graphics and the fact its a worldwide success why wouldn't i give it a 10
You can't wait until everyone gets to play it? Did you yourself beat it already? Why do you care if everyone else plays it? There are much better games out there.
@@StopFear It's strange behaviour that you've commented rather aggressively against their opinion though. Not every situation in which someone expresses an opinion needs to be met with you expressing a different one (if you have it). Especially when not asked.
This Game Totally Deserves To Be Game Of They Year. Props To The Voice Actors, The Studio & Writers. The Story Is A Whole Different Level, It Will Touch Your Heart.
The game is amazing. The graphics are incredible, second only to Horizon: Forbidden West. The music is heavenly. The voice acting and story is phenomenal. Got me crying 😢.
@@MrSPIDEY21 horizon was made for both PS5 and PS4, obviously the graphic will take a hit. Because it wasn't created with ps5's fullest potential in mind like the games you mentioned
@@damilolaowolabi6716 your point is?? Lol. You said the graphics are only 2nd to horizon. But there are games on ps5 that have better graphics than horizon. All you did was just give a reason as to why I’m right lol. Graphics are still amazing tho lol.
@@MrSPIDEY21 I've never seen someone miss a so obvious and clear point. But just real quick, you seem a bit agitated, calm down buddy "lol" . Point is, is that if HFW was made strictly for PS5 then the graphics would have been even better and that's w the fact that HFW already gets universal praise for its graphics so you could only imagine how much better they'd be at full potential, it would literally be in a league of its own. Also you must be getting cross faded every night to think R&C has better graphics than HFW lol
The scariest part for me the whole game never even got my heart pumping but running from the count got me literally outta my sit tryna escape lol Idk why
Only gripes, combat feels very annoying at times because Amicia is so slow and lacks tools to defend herself in a pinch (which is probably intentional but still) also Amicia has a bit of unrealistic plot armor. There’s are about 3 times in the story were she absolutely should’ve died but just didn’t. Aside from those things loved it.
Yeah Arnold could have killed her when she was trying to cut the rope with the rock Taking an arrow to the stomach... Dislocated shoulder... The Count slice her body pretty bad but didn't kill her right and there... Even Lucas mentions how it's possible she's still standing.. haha
Masterpiece of a game. Best graphics, soundtrack and narrative. Left me thinking about the game days after playing it. A must play. Simply unique experience.
😭😭😭😭😭😭😭 you can't do this to us Asobo for all love and respect we give you and in return you are giving us Pain deprrssion that we can't forget. If anyone really wants to see what Feminism is then they should really see Amacia in this game what real femisim is she's now in my Top pragonists list along with Arthur Kratos and many more And Amicia as top Female protagonist.
This should be minimum 9.5/10, everything about this game was pure perfection. IGN will give washed up COD a 9/10 every year with the same boring formula. What a joke IGN.
You probably should have mentioned it's capped to 30fps and has no performance mode. After being spoiled by nearly all new releases being 60fps or higher on ps5 and xsx, this simply doesn't wash with me. Deal breaking.
@@SeanJohn127 lmao. Will not be buying or playing this game until there's a competent 60fps patch. It's not even running at 4k at 30fps. Joke. No thanks.
One if the best games ever!! This is what you get a ps5 for,,The graphics,music ,gameplay and story are all 10/10 Little warning thou the ending of this game will break you like no other game has.
Why? You XB fans don't like 3rd person, action adventure, one and done, walking simulators... Or do you guys just change your mind for 3rd party games. 🙄🙄🙄
They will, right after the Activision deal comes through. They don't want to do to much. Flight simulator is also on game pass, same studio. Not confirmed, but that's the rumor.
You might as well start passing on pretty much everything going forward as the last gen is being ditched. The only reason why you're so used to 60fps on current gen is because the games have to run on last gen. When the lowest common denominator is eliminated, the current gen is the lowest, meaning better visuals and physics at the cost of performance. Only way to overcome this is going PC where you can buy far better hardware than current gen to power through it
@@nopenope7482 next gen would be about a big leap of physics, animations, graphics. Look out how Gears 5(2019 game) has worse physics than Gears 2(2008 game)
Not gonna lie the first couple sentences of this review sounded like the reviewer did not like what the game was was going for. So it gave me literal whiplash when they started praising it.
8 is really harsh, just finished playing this on psplus and for me its an easy 10. Perfect story, fun gameplay. If you want a challenge don't go for the crossbow upgrade, makes the game too easy
Linear games are the most enjoyable games till date never been disappointed Talking with a tounge of an employee who does not have much time to finish every single game...
This game and the first one would work a lot better as a movie or at least a series. The story and immersion is definitely there but man, the gameplay is one of the most boring things I've ever played, definitely doesn't work as a videogame.
It's an 8, you can leave now
based
Ty
Thanks mate, saved me watching this video
hero
Appreciate it
I’m 2 hours in and enjoying it. Do try play with headphones because the 3D audio is pretty cool. The music is great too.
Do u recommend a controller for this or mouse and keyboard would be fine ?
Namaste jee.
Love your videos Karl.
You mean without headphones…… on a full Dolby Atmos surround sound system
My boy Karl Rock is in the building!
Guys, if you haven't played innocence, do it. Then play requiem. Insanely underrated games.
Which one is better?
@@zhuangcorp hard to say. Both amazing.
@@zhuangcorp First one has better pacing IMO and is a lot shorter, both have similar mechanics but requiem is a much bigger adventure with new mechanics like the crossbow. Requiem is graphically better too.
I'm considering replaying the first one before going into the second one
Just finished the first one. Requiem still wrapped and ready to play.
Hard to understand how they managed to make the sequel even darker, they nailed the incredible medieval setting. The story and writing of these two games is just incredible. Few games these days nail emotional resonance. And I’m glad they added new gameplay elements to the stealth.
is it more difficult. the first was too easy
Reminded me of Gears 3…The amount you lose in this game is devastating..
@@wanderer10k yes stealth wise it is incredibly difficult until you get the knight
I'm surprised how they made two games one after the other so awesome. Love the story, adventure, characters, gameplay; well everything ❤❤
Just finished it and agree 😢
Man this game is a 10 just for the story, the ending hit me like a truck. Absolute masterpiece!
BRO SHUT UP THE GAMEPLAY WAS AMAZING DONT WHINE JUST CUZ IT WAS TOO HARD FOR YOU DUMBASS
@IV-qd8by it really isn't it's Mediocore
But that's not the point
Think of the game as a playable book instead of a video game
@@zz-uq2ow agreed.. it is 100% story because you are basically forced to follow a very linear storyline without any options unless it is the part where you are sneaking past guards to move on to the next area.. that was the only aspect of the game that was nice..
0 difficulty in puzzles.. pretty obvious.. you are in a big room with all the doors and side rooms convenietly blocked by debris etc.. you know that the only one available to get into will have either a collectible or something to be used..
and unless you get crossbow 3 or alchemy 2, you pretty much stuck to killing the archers or javelin throwers with your sling
@@zz-uq2ow there's plenty of better TV series to watch than this.
Just finished it. That ending hit HEAVY. Both games are AMAZING.
it hit me so hard .. my hart is broken :(
Same. Honestly a masterpiece
What is your opinion - keyboard and mouse or joystick is better, especially for this game?
@@vasiovasiofor every story game controller is far better imo, gives it an relaxed feeling
@@lbreindl6 Thank you!
I'm 33yo, and this is the first video game ever to make me cry. Absolutely heartbreaking story that's masterfully been delivered.
Why do you lie?
@@MeWojakbro how is he lying
Play RDR2, and you cry again :)
you are not the only one brother :(
Play ghost of tsushima, and you cry again😢
“May earth remember how much you loved it”
Hit me right in the feels 😭
IGN gotta do something with the spoilers in their reviews
He may be talking about 3:00
@N dreams crushed People you care for are dying 3:00
@@nikhil0021 hes been dying since the day he was born its the entire concept of both games at their core try and save your sickly dying infant brother
@@sneaky5141 but why we're playing it then, when we've to do your hands dirty at end😭 Steps to avoid some thing will leads to that thing.
At least a 9. If you the love the story it’s a ten. Beautiful. Just staggering. Favourite game this year
This game was 10/10! What a masterpiece!
Just finished and just wow, how you could give that an 8 is beyond me. The story the pacing all just 😘
Bro what you can't even fight enemies
@@ShadowTheHedgehog003 ????
There were 4-5 moments where the game mechanics were just horrible and frustrating, and some more times were it all got too slow and repetitive, but other than that the game was great. An 8 is the perfect rating for me
@@ShadowTheHedgehog003 it's a stealth game.
Just finished the game, without a doubt 10/10 masterpiece. This would even be a fantastic movie opportunity if done right or a series like they have done with The Last of Us. Hope the 3rd Plague Tale does not take ages to release!
Its definetly not 10
@@hmm6667 the massive size of the game, the compelling story, the interface, the graphics and the fact its a worldwide success why wouldn't i give it a 10
@@xXPLiiCiTx its a game with no gameplay
@@noahleach7690 there was loads of gameplay?
@@noahleach7690 literally every last of us game)
Man this game was absolutely awesome. Can't wait until everyone gets to play it
You can't wait until everyone gets to play it? Did you yourself beat it already? Why do you care if everyone else plays it? There are much better games out there.
@@StopFear lol... They're just your typical over excited delusional fan.
@@dl30wpb or someone just has a different opinion to you? strange behaviour honestly.
@@TheApexHound we can argue about different opinions
@@StopFear It's strange behaviour that you've commented rather aggressively against their opinion though. Not every situation in which someone expresses an opinion needs to be met with you expressing a different one (if you have it). Especially when not asked.
The first one already gave me anxiety and panic attacks, cant wait to experience it again with twice the intensity.
Is this a remake ?
You say it as if anxiety and panic attacks are fun.
@@Alexthelion93 no one who has ever had a real panic attack would praise that about a game. He's overexaggerating fear, that's all.
Ever played Alien Isolation?
@@BigMek667 true dat
This series is a masterclass in story telling and atmosphere
*Who else thought it was going to be a 6/10 when you moved the scroller to the end of the video??* 😅
The same. 🤣
same lmfao
Yeah that got me. My heart sank hehe.
who else actually watches the review and sees the real reasons for it's existence instead of looking for an arbitrary number?
@@Umbojug Crazy people lmao
Game Pass Day One for those that are subscribers. Looks like a must play, whether you are buying or renting. Amazing work from an amazing studio!
A must play, people. It´s a raw, dark and heartfelt adventure.
You didn't even play it yet.
@@jeffghant4760 anyone who says "people" is an autobot
This Game Totally Deserves To Be Game Of They Year. Props To The Voice Actors, The Studio & Writers. The Story Is A Whole Different Level, It Will Touch Your Heart.
Elden ring
Hell no! Elden ring is…and horizon is way better than this game already😂
@@asvphios9996 LMAO HORIZON. Please, it's either elden ring or gow ragnarok
Why Do You Type Like This
Definitely elden ring
The game is amazing. The graphics are incredible, second only to Horizon: Forbidden West. The music is heavenly. The voice acting and story is phenomenal. Got me crying 😢.
But horizons graphics aren’t better than ratchet and clank or demons souls
@@MrSPIDEY21 horizon was made for both PS5 and PS4, obviously the graphic will take a hit. Because it wasn't created with ps5's fullest potential in mind like the games you mentioned
@@damilolaowolabi6716 your point is?? Lol. You said the graphics are only 2nd to horizon. But there are games on ps5 that have better graphics than horizon. All you did was just give a reason as to why I’m right lol. Graphics are still amazing tho lol.
@@MrSPIDEY21 I've never seen someone miss a so obvious and clear point. But just real quick, you seem a bit agitated, calm down buddy "lol" . Point is, is that if HFW was made strictly for PS5 then the graphics would have been even better and that's w the fact that HFW already gets universal praise for its graphics so you could only imagine how much better they'd be at full potential, it would literally be in a league of its own. Also you must be getting cross faded every night to think R&C has better graphics than HFW lol
This was way better than horizon. 10/10 masterpiece!
Just finished it today, what a masterpiece game with one of the best storytelling and narration this year besides GOW. 9/10 for me.
The scariest part for me the whole game never even got my heart pumping but running from the count got me literally outta my sit tryna escape lol Idk why
Pentiment 10/10 masterpiece
The first game was great, can't wait to play this.
what was the 1st game this has got my attention
@@vpetronzio same name without requirm
@@vpetronzio innocence
One of the best story game ever and most dark and sad too. It's 9.5/10
10/10 masterpiece! GO play it !!!
The end broke my. Brillant story, brillant game !
The ending was absolutely heavy and hard to forget.
One of the best games I've ever played, 10/10!
Absolutely loved the game and the prequel as well. The ending was kinda sad though.
Very sad. will not get over the story 😭😭
"kinda sad": understatement of the year haha
Damn that ending was rough
? is he finaly taking her ? 😂😂😂
Just finished it, was a great story
@@bobbyfagan7760I know right? When Amicia says: Why is it still so hard...?
That killed me
Memorable game for sure
Only gripes, combat feels very annoying at times because Amicia is so slow and lacks tools to defend herself in a pinch (which is probably intentional but still) also Amicia has a bit of unrealistic plot armor. There’s are about 3 times in the story were she absolutely should’ve died but just didn’t. Aside from those things loved it.
Well what do u want from a woman ? To be like Bruce Lee?
Yeah Arnold could have killed her when she was trying to cut the rope with the rock
Taking an arrow to the stomach...
Dislocated shoulder...
The Count slice her body pretty bad but didn't kill her right and there...
Even Lucas mentions how it's possible she's still standing.. haha
Aggression upgrades.
@@YuniorGamboa Should've said "Arrow to the knee" :D
Masterpiece of a game. Best graphics, soundtrack and narrative. Left me thinking about the game days after playing it. A must play. Simply unique experience.
Just finished this game and it's a masterpiece.
😭😭😭😭😭😭😭 you can't do this to us Asobo for all love and respect we give you and in return you are giving us Pain deprrssion that we can't forget.
If anyone really wants to see what Feminism is then they should really see Amacia in this game what real femisim is she's now in my Top pragonists list along with Arthur Kratos and many more
And Amicia as top Female protagonist.
This is a definite win for xbox gp especially in light of no big exclusives for 2022.
True. But the over reliance on third party and indies is getting out of hand. Lets hope 2023 is different.
Does grounded not count as a big exclusive?
@@therealbalto24 grounded has been out for a few years
This isn’t an exclusive, it’s also on ps5.
@@ronthorn3 no one said it was exclusive to Xbox. Read better.
This should be minimum 9.5/10, everything about this game was pure perfection. IGN will give washed up COD a 9/10 every year with the same boring formula. What a joke IGN.
This is how games have to be crafted. I'm not really into story games, but this one is a gem.
PS Plus buddies... *where you at??* 😏
Lol have you played yet?
@@lateforitalways no 😅
Anyone else here after it came out on ps plus!
Here
Started playing this today. The intro story combining tutorial is so touching
This reviewer is amazing! He's clearly in love with this franchise
This reviewer is a s***head! He's an ign urinalist! Get this guy a job reiewing toilets!!
@@evil1989pl an 8
@@evil1989pl Someone didn't watch the video and merely skimmed through the end with their mouse
@@evil1989pl you obviously didn't actually see the end lmao he gave it an 8
a true masterpiece... this game is right up there with the uncharted series in terms of sheer entertainment
Never played the Uncharted games , there is a new one on Steam for the PC called Uncharted Legacy off thieves collection, , would it be worth buying.
@@patanoster387 totally worth it ..
yes it was 10/10 for me
10/10 Strong contender for game of the year
Might wanna tell people the game is locked 30fps on PS5 & Series X/S
Only tiny channels keep it that real
Still plays well tho lmao
Who cares?
This game is amazing. only halfway thru chapter 2 and im so intrigued
You probably should have mentioned it's capped to 30fps and has no performance mode. After being spoiled by nearly all new releases being 60fps or higher on ps5 and xsx, this simply doesn't wash with me. Deal breaking.
Would love it . If it ran 60 fps. There should of Definitely been a performance mode. The fps is rough on sx. Which makes me sad
Oh grow up and stop whinging. 60 FPS is overrated and hardly makes a difference. No one is impressed that you can make a big deal over nothing.
@@SwordTune actually it makes a fuckin huge difference. In the enjoyment of the game you playing
@@SwordTune I'm not whining it's an observation. You on the other hand are whining.
Gotta get it on PC got it running capped at 75
If only the game achieve 60fps on ps5. Definetly going to buy it.
25 on ps5, 30 on xbox
@@SeanJohn127 lmao. Will not be buying or playing this game until there's a competent 60fps patch. It's not even running at 4k at 30fps. Joke. No thanks.
Yeah i'll just buy this on steam.. byebye haptic feedback 😭
@@mattyork7625 Meh. Get over it.
My Series X plays it fine at 40fps at 1440p.
Looks gorgeous
If you have Dolby Atmos headphones you have to play this. The sound design is unlike anything I've heard before
This game really went above and beyond. The game play was amazing and the emotion stirring and plot was just insane. A worthy sequel.
Not really tho lol
This game is great, deserves a 9 imo. Need more games like this
The game does look amazing.
Just started playing it! Wow!!! It’s incredible so far. Amazing graphics and the 3D sound through my headset is unreal.
What is with all the spoilers? Why say die and show someone die? Why say batrayal and show a character that we now know will betray us
So Mario and Rabbits and this game are back to back greatness.
And we had two of the best ports Switch has ever had in Nier automata and Persona 5 Royal this month too..
Ok
One if the best games ever!! This is what you get a ps5 for,,The graphics,music ,gameplay and story are all 10/10
Little warning thou the ending of this game will break you like no other game has.
Microsoft needs to acquire Asobo Studios.
Why? You XB fans don't like 3rd person, action adventure, one and done, walking simulators... Or do you guys just change your mind for 3rd party games. 🙄🙄🙄
@@benjamincurtis1412 how do you know this? Did you interview everyone with an Xbox?
They will, right after the Activision deal comes through. They don't want to do to much. Flight simulator is also on game pass, same studio. Not confirmed, but that's the rumor.
If this was a PS Exclusive it could have got a 10. Great work IGN..
Game Pass looking real sexy in these streets.
No 60fps performance mode? Hard pass. Unacceptable for a next gen title.
You might as well start passing on pretty much everything going forward as the last gen is being ditched. The only reason why you're so used to 60fps on current gen is because the games have to run on last gen. When the lowest common denominator is eliminated, the current gen is the lowest, meaning better visuals and physics at the cost of performance. Only way to overcome this is going PC where you can buy far better hardware than current gen to power through it
Nope all next gen games should run perfectly period. That's why we bought one in thr first place
@@nopenope7482 next gen would be about a big leap of physics, animations, graphics.
Look out how Gears 5(2019 game) has worse physics than Gears 2(2008 game)
Not gonna lie the first couple sentences of this review sounded like the reviewer did not like what the game was was going for. So it gave me literal whiplash when they started praising it.
Only 8/10 ? You must be completly mad. Game is a true masterpeace
This games incredible 9/10 for me
8 is really harsh, just finished playing this on psplus and for me its an easy 10. Perfect story, fun gameplay. If you want a challenge don't go for the crossbow upgrade, makes the game too easy
Looks great! Downloaded and ready to play on Game Pass when it unlocks.
Is it coming on game pass?
@@Mulholland1974 yup
Day One on GamePass!
The ending though 😢
Yes my rating is also a 10!!!!!! But my rating is because of playing in vr2 in big cinema style!!! Its better than on my oled tv!
we just need another Kingdom Come
Incredible game in every aspect
“Graphics that has me GAHWKING” 🤨📸
Thank you Gamepass🙏🏽 can’t wait 😭
Ign should rename their channel to spoiler alert
Another absolute banger for gamepass.
What's the other one?
@@tikiman1900 scorn
@@tikiman1900 Persona 5 Royal in 3 days, also Scorn and Ni No Kuni if you haven't play it.
@@alpinthor bro don't forget about the yakuza series
Is it on game pass on Xbox
The story is amazing
Can't waitttt so glad this is on Gamepass as well
IGN is the worst! 8/10 wtf? its a masterpiece!
yes
Remember this studio is still AA and not AAA. This game is a 10
Ive played the original...its a great game but 10 is reaching bro in my opinion atleast
@@BigJerm4200 this isn't the original though
This isn’t TLOU so no.
@@Omegaslashbuster1 understandable, but also TLOU probably had four times the budget and a way larger team.
10 out of 50 maybe.
Playstation owners: (takes out wallet)
Xbox/PC owners: *laughs in Game Pass*
🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣👿👿👿👿👿
This game is so emotionally draining, it's one of the most depressing games I've ever played.
This is such a thorough review and analysis
This is GOTY nothing even comes close. What a story. The ending was so shocking
Masterpiece IMO
Play elden ring and come back
@FightNight elden ring is all gameplay minimal story average graphics
Elden Ring still isn't my GOTY.
That isn't an opinion you're just stating a fact that this game is indeed an absolute Masterpiece
@@hmm6667 Elden ring is a completely different game... It's like comparing gears of war to hitman
This is an improvement over the previous game for sure and the overall graphics and sceneries are much prettier
No 60 fps on ps5? Hope patch for performance in near future
A proof that a great game doesn't depend on the studio label, whether it SquareEnix nor Capcom
Why is there no 4k resolution available? This is 2022, not 2008......
Even an rtx 4090 barely holds 60 fps on 1080p and you want 4k?this game has abysmal pc performance
And the game is 30 FPS.. yikes
Cuz the game is garbage
Ask the devs
looks a lot like the first plague tale at a glance. that game was great gonna have to try this on on the Xbox !
70$ for Subway Surfers? No thanks
Lmao
If you got game pass , then you in for a treat
looking forward to this one!
Linear games are the most enjoyable games till date never been disappointed
Talking with a tounge of an employee who does not have much time to finish every single game...
Yaya it's on xbox game pass!
30fps don't install! We deserve better 2022..
This game and the first one would work a lot better as a movie or at least a series. The story and immersion is definitely there but man, the gameplay is one of the most boring things I've ever played, definitely doesn't work as a videogame.
Absolutely disagree with u
This game was an absolute 10!!!!!!!!!
The best way to describe this game is calling it a flawed masterpiece.
Feel like I've already played the game after watching this review YAWN
If it isn’t broke, don’t fix it. Can’t wait to play this.
Currently playing on xbox series S, great game I’m impressed