Ratko, I just love your appearance, youre the DUDE! Someone very important in my life passed away and this gives me a smile in a very very hard time. Hope you and your family is well!
Siempre que oido esta pieza y que la toco pero mucho más lenta😅😅😅hay estoy., ...me suena muchísimo a la música del tetris( videojuego) podria ser? Fue en mi época y jugue bastante...por supuesto que antes de todo es una pieza😢 clásica😂😂😂😂😂
@@PaPyRene No two people can play the same piece in the same way, even staccato, for example. There will be different dynamics and a difference in tempo, for example, but the score reads correctly no matter how many times you repeat the same thing. The pianists did not compose it to make changes to it.
The tempo fluxes and isn’t a robot but that doesn’t mean its terrible, music isn’t meant to be played with a robotically consistent tempo, if this isn’t what your critic was about I’d urge you to be more specific
couldn't agree more with nikolo. it's not too fast or too slow, the point is, if i wanted to exaggerate, there is no tempo at all. one has to choose a tempo and is then free to make some rubato or accelerando, depending on the piece and the place inside of it (we're still talking about classical western music), but the tempo choice underneath should remain intelligible. here is all too fluctuant and one ends up completely disoriented. it's like being on the passenger seat of a crazy old man or lady's car driving with the manual. jokes apart, just to make sure one doesn't take it too personal, maybe i was too harsh, but i know what i'm talking about and criticism should be accepted as such, as something neutral and constructive. and i purposely focused on the thing that didn't work so well. needless to say, technique was flawless. but musicality, mmh, not at the same level of the technique. keep up playing and refining these interpretation aspects: sometimes it is already all written down in the score, other times not and then one should first ask himself the right questions and study the piece not only from a technical pov, if he or she wants to play in front of somebody else, otherwise one should declare his free interpretation choices or improvise or play something of his own. Jeez, sorry for all of this wordiness. I just wanted to be as fair as possible 😂
What a cool piece of music. And your piano is just amazing. Thanks fot this!
Thanks, appreciate
Ratko, I just love your appearance, youre the DUDE! Someone very important in my life passed away and this gives me a smile in a very very hard time. Hope you and your family is well!
Thanks for asking, all good.
The playing was enjoyable, but what was more interesting was the cinematography. The way this song is presented makes it extra sophisticated, bravo!
I like this. Some parts maybe just a little bit too fast. But I like it.
Lovely!
Thanks
Super cool! I enjoyed your interpretation of the song and love seeing old mechanical action!
Beautiful!
Thank you
It's the wink at the end for me🎉
Великолепное исполнение.Браво!
Спасибо
Tempo is not a matter
Just one of individuality
Awesome playing ❤
Прекрасно! Привет из России!
Lindo
Siempre que oido esta pieza y que la toco pero mucho más lenta😅😅😅hay estoy., ...me suena muchísimo a la música del tetris( videojuego) podria ser? Fue en mi época y jugue bastante...por supuesto que antes de todo es una pieza😢 clásica😂😂😂😂😂
Very nice vertical piano and good technical performance. One question: What is the rush to finish this beautiful piece of music? Sorry, my opinion.
Supper
Thanks
Too fast and it must be staccato from the begining to the end.
@@PaPyRene One must read the score correctly as the composer wrote it. Everything else is interpretation!
@@PaPyRene No two people can play the same piece in the same way, even staccato, for example. There will be different dynamics and a difference in tempo, for example, but the score reads correctly no matter how many times you repeat the same thing. The pianists did not compose it to make changes to it.
How much time you practice this etude?
It's for a long time on my repertoire list, so I can't tell specific…
Not too fast, listen to Wang, very nice performance congrats, just learning the piece,
The tempo, and feeling is missing. Aggh!
Cmon, too fast.
Funny! But love it!😅
Lost the melody...
0:30
perfect technique but the tempo is terrible, sorry
Is it slow?
The tempo fluxes and isn’t a robot but that doesn’t mean its terrible, music isn’t meant to be played with a robotically consistent tempo, if this isn’t what your critic was about I’d urge you to be more specific
I have different opion, this tempo is fast inav, if its faster it perhaps went little porridge. This piano is very old and it doesnt keep up faster.
couldn't agree more with nikolo. it's not too fast or too slow, the point is, if i wanted to exaggerate, there is no tempo at all. one has to choose a tempo and is then free to make some rubato or accelerando, depending on the piece and the place inside of it (we're still talking about classical western music), but the tempo choice underneath should remain intelligible. here is all too fluctuant and one ends up completely disoriented. it's like being on the passenger seat of a crazy old man or lady's car driving with the manual.
jokes apart, just to make sure one doesn't take it too personal, maybe i was too harsh, but i know what i'm talking about and criticism should be accepted as such, as something neutral and constructive. and i purposely focused on the thing that didn't work so well. needless to say, technique was flawless. but musicality, mmh, not at the same level of the technique. keep up playing and refining these interpretation aspects: sometimes it is already all written down in the score, other times not and then one should first ask himself the right questions and study the piece not only from a technical pov, if he or she wants to play in front of somebody else, otherwise one should declare his free interpretation choices or improvise or play something of his own.
Jeez, sorry for all of this wordiness. I just wanted to be as fair as possible 😂
Too fast terrible technique
Ужас)