I own a 1991 bottle of green Irish tweed, and the closest to that original in terms of smell is definitely parfum vintage Emerald Isle it’s really really close
Okay, I know that this is an older review from you but helpful nonetheless. I purchased two bottles of Amber Oud Carbon and I am so glad that I did! I received the package this morning, unboxed it, and made it my scent of the day. I needed to make a run to the grocery store. While walking through the store, I received three compliments in less than 20 minutes. Great smelling stuff.
I love my Carbon Edition. I like the boxes as they protect the fragrance from horrible delivery people out there. As per the bottle size, they did make the 120ml for the Gold Edition
Glad to see this review. The other reviewer that I saw was too much of a fanboy to give an open-minded review of this fragrance. I’m definitely not saying that he should want to replace the OG with this clone, but for the purpose of reviewing for people who are on a budget, it would have been nice to see him review Carbon from that standpoint. Thanks. Holla.
I just feel like it's opening is extremely strong. Yes it's decent. I like tres nuit by armaf much better for the scent especially initially but carbon is definitely strong!
Usually I trust your reviews and don't get disappointed, I blind buy a lot of perfumes with your directing. However this one is not even close to green irish tweed. It's a lot more alike to cool water, I don't recognize the green in it.
I'm really surprised you didn't even mention the original Raghba for man as I find that one to be a pretty decent alternative, especially for the price. That being said I still enjoy 'Tres Nuit' as the best 'bang for your buck' and that still smells nice and performs decent. That line from Al Haramain is definitely a high(er) quality but I believe it's a bit overhyped which led them to be overpriced as well.
Hard to believe that anything replaces Tres Nuit in terms of value for your dollar as far as Green Irish Tweed clones go. 20 to 25 bucks, amazing longevity, and really close on the smell.
Based on one of your videos, I bought the al haramain " l'aventure" that's supposedly a creed aventus clone. Which maybe it is, but I never smelled aventus yet. But the clone smells just ok.
My recommendation is to do a search if you see a video of a fragrance you like ... watch multiple reviews. Different people may have different opinions and it may work differently on different people's skin chemistry.
@@christopherw2233 I use to think Aqua di gio was expensive 😂.. Never knew about Niche fragrances until recently and it blows my mind what people pay for that stuff ( Creed, BR 540, ROJA, etc)
I don’t understand these clone companies having two clones in two different lines. They already have L’aventure knight. Armaf doing stuff like sillage and the derby clubhouse or whatever it’s called. Why?
Maybe it is just my nose but man all I smell is overly metallic burnt rubber opening that singes the nose hairs and even aired out this carbon edition is the worst offering in the line. The tobacco edition and gold extreme edition are fantastic but this one is just nauseating this one is just a major dud. Great amount of respect to you my friend and I very much appreciate all the reviews you put out there for the community.
I think Ash waffled a bit but then said he liked this one better because of the performance. My question is 'if you have one do you need the other?' Or is there really not that huge of a difference?
The regular Amber Oud (not Tobacco, Ruby, Rouge, Gold, Carbon, Exclusif Sport, Exclusif Emerald, etc.) is a clone of the blue beast, Amouage Interlude Man.
@@terrwes2807 as I just said, Amber Oud is Amouage Interlude Man. Gold is Xerjoff Erba Pura, Tobacco is Tom Ford Tobacco Vanille, and Rouge/Ruby is MFK Baccarat Rouge 540 extrait.
Bro it only comes in 2.0 !!?? I'm getting it on ebay 100 % authentic 6.7 amber oud carbon edition so I'm guessing that changed on only having it in 2.0's ?? Can u let me kno if that's correct
where do you live Mr Scents? I'm from Scotland so my idea of Summer may be a lot different to you haha PS big fan love watching your stuff.. also seems like your personality is really shining through at the minute. keep it up brother
Bought this on the basis of this review. Very disappointed. Nothing like Green Irish Tweed, little to no projection straight out of the bottle and extremely over priced.
Thanks as always Ash!!
I own a 1991 bottle of green Irish tweed, and the closest to that original in terms of smell is definitely parfum vintage Emerald Isle it’s really really close
Facts
Have you compared Emerald isle to Verbena fields?
How do they compare performance-wise?
@@ryanramirez329 yes , Emerald Isle smells like vintage creed the other doesn’t
If you can find some source that ships this one to mainland Europe, please let me know.
Okay, I know that this is an older review from you but helpful nonetheless. I purchased two bottles of Amber Oud Carbon and I am so glad that I did! I received the package this morning, unboxed it, and made it my scent of the day. I needed to make a run to the grocery store. While walking through the store, I received three compliments in less than 20 minutes. Great smelling stuff.
I love my Carbon Edition. I like the boxes as they protect the fragrance from horrible delivery people out there. As per the bottle size, they did make the 120ml for the Gold Edition
Majority of the high end colognes i own come in cheap poorly made boxes, for some reasons the dupes have better packaging
Just bought this one and this one is quite SICK!
Glad to see this review. The other reviewer that I saw was too much of a fanboy to give an open-minded review of this fragrance. I’m definitely not saying that he should want to replace the OG with this clone, but for the purpose of reviewing for people who are on a budget, it would have been nice to see him review Carbon from that standpoint. Thanks. Holla.
I just feel like it's opening is extremely strong. Yes it's decent. I like tres nuit by armaf much better for the scent especially initially but carbon is definitely strong!
Which is better quality
What about l'aventure knight?
Have you ever reviewed Al Haramain Tobacco Edition? I think that one is the best from the line.
Was curious about that
how does this compares to L'Aventure Knight?
Did u ever get to find out the difference? Im curious too!
But they already have Laventure Knight so what's the point? They are ripping off their own brand!? 🤦
Yeah, I'm nterested in the comparison to L'Aventure Knight.
.
Yeah, I have la venture knight
Is this better than Emerald Isle or Verbena Fields from Parfums Vintage?
F**** no!
Nice review sir. Which do you prefer… this or Verbena Fields by Pineapple Vintage?
Usually I trust your reviews and don't get disappointed, I blind buy a lot of perfumes with your directing. However this one is not even close to green irish tweed. It's a lot more alike to cool water, I don't recognize the green in it.
I'm really surprised you didn't even mention the original Raghba for man as I find that one to be a pretty decent alternative, especially for the price. That being said I still enjoy 'Tres Nuit' as the best 'bang for your buck' and that still smells nice and performs decent.
That line from Al Haramain is definitely a high(er) quality but I believe it's a bit overhyped which led them to be overpriced as well.
Yep theyre worth like $40-$50 tops
Umm did something happen to L'Aventure Knight? 🤔
I hope not I love it
How does L’adventure Knight fit in to the comparison???
Amber Oud Gold is 98% close to Xerjoff Erba Pura. Looking forward to try out this one
If you like gold try Orientica Luxury Collection Royal Amber
It is far better and stronger. Last forever!!!
love the consistency
Hard to believe that anything replaces Tres Nuit in terms of value for your dollar as far as Green Irish Tweed clones go. 20 to 25 bucks, amazing longevity, and really close on the smell.
am thinking of getting the Tres Nuit.
Rasasi Egra
@@ajaxk5522... there are better Rasasi to start with Hawas, Daareq ...
Seriously? I don't think it's close at all and the longevity is like an hour. Imo it's the worst Armaf.
@@burner27 I agree. I think tres nuit is far to metallic in its opening
Don’t forget about Al Haramain’s La’venture Knight you should compare them.
for a decent clone you forgot: L HARAMAIN L'AVENTURE KNIGHT
What about AL haramain l'aventure knight?
2 Other middle eastern clones of C:GIT are Rasasi Egra (cheap, it's ok and Al Haramain L'Aventure Knight.
Based on one of your videos, I bought the al haramain " l'aventure" that's supposedly a creed aventus clone. Which maybe it is, but I never smelled aventus yet. But the clone smells just ok.
My recommendation is to do a search if you see a video of a fragrance you like ... watch multiple reviews. Different people may have different opinions and it may work differently on different people's skin chemistry.
L avanture is amazing, smells way better than CDNIM in my opinion, I have both
Did you mean L'Aventure intence ??? That would be the closer choice to creed Aventus...Not so much the original L'Aventure..
In a previous video I think you mentioned Al Haramain L'Adventure Knight was also a clone of Green Irish Tweed? Which Al Haramain clone is better?
This one is far better.
@@retrozone6043 and expensive
Keep the clone coming please
Green Irish tweed is the best!
Some people say that carven pour homme also smells close to green Irish tweed
Thanks for this review
Do you like green Irish tweed more than bleeker street...?
Are u sure it only comes in a 2.0? Cause I see it comes in a 3.4 also??
I have 100 mil
Could you do for the Ruby edition
Which is better, Carbon Edition or Tres Nuit 🤔
Carbon edition
I've been out of the fragrance world a while, when did colognes start costing $650 a bottle!? 😳
If you mean expensive in general then Long ago with the luxury brands like creed I'd personally never pay near that much for a fragrance.
@@christopherw2233 I use to think Aqua di gio was expensive 😂.. Never knew about Niche fragrances until recently and it blows my mind what people pay for that stuff ( Creed, BR 540, ROJA, etc)
Review Rasasi Egra. It's 10x better than Tres Nuit.
I don’t understand these clone companies having two clones in two different lines. They already have L’aventure knight. Armaf doing stuff like sillage and the derby clubhouse or whatever it’s called. Why?
Laventure knight is solid too, at $30 idk what the point is either
Maybe it is just my nose but man all I smell is overly metallic burnt rubber opening that singes the nose hairs and even aired out this carbon edition is the worst offering in the line. The tobacco edition and gold extreme edition are fantastic but this one is just nauseating this one is just a major dud. Great amount of respect to you my friend and I very much appreciate all the reviews you put out there for the community.
Have you smelled Aqua Di Parma’s Colonia Club???
Tres de nuit Or this?
I think Ash waffled a bit but then said he liked this one better because of the performance. My question is 'if you have one do you need the other?' Or is there really not that huge of a difference?
is there a clone from Ard Zaafaran ?
You should try Blue edition it’s a clone of Bleu de Chanel but longer lasting you’ll love it
What about fougere l'aube? I've heard it has some stuff in common
Did you get this one for free or you bought it?
Nunya
They have a sport edition and a few others from this line. Could you review them all? All the ones I have tried have been really great for the price.
Try L'Aventure Knight please.
Great review and I enjoyed it and I'm going to try it and have a blessed day
Do you have any opinion of Penhaligon's scents?
I asked this same question! They are the only niche fragrances I own! Roaring Radcliffe and Blazing Mr. Sam.
would love to see also similar review of the same house doing t.m tobacco vanille
What about afnan's incense? (clone of interlude). I would wanted to see a review for that)
Just picked this up for $50.
We get the point Ash, just buy Green Irish Tweed if you want Green Irish Tweed lol
I have Amber oud classic. It's 🔥 I don't know what it's a clone of but it's nuclear beast mode
The regular Amber Oud (not Tobacco, Ruby, Rouge, Gold, Carbon, Exclusif Sport, Exclusif Emerald, etc.) is a clone of the blue beast, Amouage Interlude Man.
@@Nepharian what do you think the classic version is a clone of? I thought the gold edition was urba pura
@@terrwes2807 as I just said, Amber Oud is Amouage Interlude Man. Gold is Xerjoff Erba Pura, Tobacco is Tom Ford Tobacco Vanille, and Rouge/Ruby is MFK Baccarat Rouge 540 extrait.
Green Irish Tweed = the original cool water by Davidoff. even the bottle is green!
I love L’Aventure Knight already!!
How close is it to Green Irish Tweed?
How could you recommend Aspen? that stuff smells nasty ended up using it as toilet air freshener! 😂
Bro it only comes in 2.0 !!?? I'm getting it on ebay 100 % authentic 6.7 amber oud carbon edition so I'm guessing that changed on only having it in 2.0's ?? Can u let me kno if that's correct
Must have been the first wave. Yeah I'm looking into a 6.7 tester to go with tres I have.
Nothing beats L'aventure knight
Can you review the ‘Irish Power’ by Chez Perfumes a New clone
Best clone is Irish Verbena from Montagne
I appreciate the box more than you do
where do you live Mr Scents? I'm from Scotland so my idea of Summer may be a lot different to you haha
PS big fan love watching your stuff.. also seems like your personality is really shining through at the minute. keep it up brother
Tennessee I believe ... feel free to correct me if I'm wrong Ash.
ash is wrong on the size it does come in a 100 ml size
Please review Detour Rouge from Al Harmain
He already did. Search it.
I can care less about a box that I'm ripping up and throwing away......
So you still care some amount? Personally, I *couldn't* care less, since you can't care less than nothing.
@@rockpaperscissors6521 you caught me slipping.....I guess I'm a dum-dum
The feeling of absolute power that I experience from this definitely compensates for my father never loving me as a child.
I always store my fragrances in the original box, so i absolutely do care about it.
Well I only keep my Amouage boxes because I own over 1400 bottles of fragrances and wouldn't have the room for all those boxes......
Try raghba for men is better clone the
Than alharmarian
Ashton what are your Top 5 fragrances? Thanks
... and my $200 bottle of sauvage comes in a thin cardboard box...
Smells more like Cool Water to me
Didn't get a check huh????😀😀😀
Cool 😎
Ash you spelled 'watching' wrong at the end of the video 😆
Rasasi Egra.
Oud for greatness opens to the same kind of box 📦 in my best Indian voice India India India! Pick it Up! A Proper Pic a Polk a pec a pick a Pakistan!
Yooo
Just got 200ml for 50 euro 😂
Gentsscentsssssssssssssssssssssssssss
you misspelled watching 😂
👍👍👍👍
Bought this on the basis of this review. Very disappointed. Nothing like Green Irish Tweed, little to no projection straight out of the bottle and extremely over priced.