GTA V Beta vs Final Release Comparison

Поделиться
HTML-код
  • Опубликовано: 28 окт 2024

Комментарии • 1,3 тыс.

  • @sicknickeroni
    @sicknickeroni 2 года назад +4548

    Anyone curious about the tree removal, the devs while playtesting took notes saying the game's performance was so bad on the current hardware at the time it was unplayable.

    • @samurai8548
      @samurai8548 2 года назад +717

      So they were literally just wayyyy ahead of their time

    • @yourstruly9879
      @yourstruly9879 2 года назад +788

      I said for years this game should have NEVER released on the 360 and PS3 🤦🏽‍♂️

    • @farazsiddiqui1312
      @farazsiddiqui1312 2 года назад +304

      @@yourstruly9879 yeah games should be first realeased on pc to unlock their full potential

    • @coloradoing9172
      @coloradoing9172 2 года назад +393

      @@yourstruly9879 Consoles have been holding games back for years. We always have to wait for them to catch up. It's the unspoken contract between console companies and major game studios.

    • @yourstruly9879
      @yourstruly9879 2 года назад +212

      @@coloradoing9172 they should honestly do what they did in the 80s and 90s. They released the games on arcade first then downgraded them for console. Today, they should release it on PC first then downgrade it to console.

  • @reallytho1943
    @reallytho1943 2 года назад +7212

    Crazy how all those trees make beta feel so much more realistic

    • @desse8069
      @desse8069 2 года назад +171

      agreed

    • @amaliauto1390
      @amaliauto1390 2 года назад +1225

      that is because when they tested it on the early consoles(ps3) they were getting 14 fps max so they had to remove a lot of trees and a reduce the "realism" in the trees lol gta 5 was wayyyyyyy ahead of it's time

    • @kriuw
      @kriuw 2 года назад +338

      gta 6 will hace so much trees

    • @bjarkiagnarsson
      @bjarkiagnarsson 2 года назад +57

      Because it does.
      But I don't understand why they showing this now..

    • @paraphax
      @paraphax 2 года назад +189

      The blurriness and screwed colors of the beta images also add to the realism

  • @rsatonyplayz5186
    @rsatonyplayz5186 2 года назад +2945

    They removed many trees/plants to reduce game size and to boost performance.

    • @X3RNEA5
      @X3RNEA5 2 года назад +278

      I mean the first build of GTA 5 was literally running on 5 to 10 FPS because of the foilage

    • @SeriousDragonify
      @SeriousDragonify 2 года назад +93

      And now with so many updates runs worse than on released version on next gen.

    • @Nunvalt223
      @Nunvalt223 2 года назад +82

      Well they launched the game on the ps3 and xbox 360, if they kept the plants and trees the game would lag a lot more...

    • @DaxyGamer
      @DaxyGamer 2 года назад +20

      they removed the trees to the countryside

    • @norvinzor
      @norvinzor 2 года назад +7

      Wrong there’s a mod on pc where you can mod the tress in and it’s still 60 fps

  • @jimmyjudefilms4757
    @jimmyjudefilms4757 2 года назад +2183

    This is fascinating. I like to think that the beta pictures could be what LS looked like in the 80s/90s/early2000s compared to 2013

    • @desse8069
      @desse8069 2 года назад +243

      I always thought Beta looked and felt more like California rather than current game

    • @youmakenosense7437
      @youmakenosense7437 2 года назад +184

      @@desse8069 It's because of the brownish countryside and heavy lighting which is certainly how California looks in real life, GTA V was just too green and flat looking, it also lacked a lot of trees.

    • @eetuthereindeer6671
      @eetuthereindeer6671 2 года назад +14

      So you're into roleplaying? The world of a game loses its charm for you if you think about it just being a programmed bunch of pixels so you have to fake a history for beta versions? Like no the developers didn't make it up, they just put that real story in some another universe into a game?
      I understand

    • @isaacsrandomvideos667
      @isaacsrandomvideos667 2 года назад

      yeah

    • @HupCapNinja
      @HupCapNinja 2 года назад +71

      @@youmakenosense7437 Exactly. I lived in LA all my life and GTA V kinda failed to feel like you’re in California. There’s like barely anything to do in the map besides the story plus the game just looks very flat and washed out while in real life it’s bustling with life everywhere you go. Downtown is a joke in the game.

  • @user-ot8wl7oh9s
    @user-ot8wl7oh9s Год назад +472

    0:35 that looks honestly really cool. No wonder i feel so uncanny in the game sometimes when i see just plane grass with no trees at all.

    • @psylina
      @psylina Год назад +24

      Pretty hard to feel uncanny unless theres no peds or traffic

    • @oye2240
      @oye2240 Год назад +1

      Nah I won’t want to make a full turn to go there lol

    • @FitchTV
      @FitchTV Год назад +24

      @@FranSauce crashing accidentally into a tree isn't a gameplay hindrance. Drive on the roads.

    • @JRC99
      @JRC99 Год назад +5

      @@FranSauce
      GIT
      GUD

    • @ganjackbogle876
      @ganjackbogle876 11 месяцев назад +1

      That’s how it is in la

  • @Kurdzo
    @Kurdzo 7 месяцев назад +27

    Because of the low quality images, these beta images literally look like real life

  • @mazda9624
    @mazda9624 2 года назад +558

    I like the more saturated look of the Beta, but what people seem to forget is that the game actually did used to look more saturated even after the original release. While it never quite looked like the Beta, GTA 5 for Xbox 360 and Playstation 3 looks quite different when compared to later releases. I personally really like the deep, saturated look of the game on the 7th gen consoles. I'd love to see this same comparison, but with the Beta locations, then Playstation 3, then Playstation 4/5.

    • @curiousmind_
      @curiousmind_ 2 года назад +36

      True. The atmosphere feels better on PS3

    • @pedinhuh16
      @pedinhuh16 2 года назад +44

      The atmosphere change can be achieved on PC by merely changing the timesys, I do not understand why they added this awful white and blue-ish fog for the PS4/X360 and PC versions.

    • @MeowMeow-ul4su
      @MeowMeow-ul4su Год назад

      Console gaming sucks all console games have terrible graphics rendering with major removal from the pc look.

    • @pedinhuh16
      @pedinhuh16 Год назад +11

      @@EggEnjoyer nonsense, if that were the case then PS3 and X360 versions would also have the same ugly fog and it would be even more intense on those consoles.
      It was a deliberate choice made by the devs that was also carried to PC, so it's definitely not for performance reasons.

    • @pedinhuh16
      @pedinhuh16 Год назад +15

      @@EggEnjoyer the fog on PS3 and X360 were less intense, as a result the atmosphere on those versions had a bit more color and contrast.

  • @bakadesu2575
    @bakadesu2575 2 года назад +837

    Gta 6 pre alpha looks like gta 5 imagine how it would look on final

    • @abuelitomalito78yq35
      @abuelitomalito78yq35 2 года назад +127

      Looks like red dead 2

    • @cudanmang_theog
      @cudanmang_theog 2 года назад +31

      GTA 6 leaks were not pre alpha launch as rockstar wants, its already developed but accidentally hacked and leaked.

    • @MalleeMate
      @MalleeMate 2 года назад +106

      Honestly, mannequin NPCs aside, the texture work is like 10 times better. The models also look much crisper, and the finished NPCs are a big step up. I’m not sure what everyone was stressing about, but it’ll look as good or better than cyberpunk, and that’s a high bar.

    • @GreenSlug420
      @GreenSlug420 2 года назад +15

      @@abuelitomalito78yq35 No it doesn't.. Wtf are you smoking?

    • @monsesh1316
      @monsesh1316 2 года назад +9

      @@cudanmang_theog I thought it says 2019?

  • @aminuabdullahi5922
    @aminuabdullahi5922 2 года назад +225

    We have to remember the game was originally made for 360 and ps3. Alot of things and features had to be removed to compensate

    • @SeriousDragonify
      @SeriousDragonify 2 года назад +11

      Game runs currently on next gen like on ps3 and xbox360.

    • @PlumbCarton5607
      @PlumbCarton5607 2 года назад +16

      @@SeriousDragonify what used to be "next gen"
      Yeah it now runs worse than the 360 version

    • @SeriousDragonify
      @SeriousDragonify 2 года назад +2

      @ZionXs Sure i did, with The Sims 3 expansions.
      But that game had issues after 2nd expansion aka World Adventures.
      For game like GTA 5 it is just updates shoved in.
      DLC's were always considered to be optional without forcing you to download them.
      Why i need "DLC's'" that don't bring me anything in sp?
      They are just forced updates.
      Not DLC's at all.

    • @andrewzasidko6595
      @andrewzasidko6595 Год назад +2

      You are wrong on that. It was exactly made for PS4 and X-One, and later compressed and limited in every possible way for PS3/X360. They simply had to since there were more than 100 mil consoles around and no PS4/X-One even on store shelves. You just don't get the graphical improvements from PS3 to PS4 version (PC too) by only tweaking some effects and using uncompressed textures. You can read somewhere on the internet about it.

    • @lamydora457
      @lamydora457 Год назад +3

      Why would they even release it on ps3 gta 5 came out in 2013 thats when the ps4 came out. It would of cost them nothing to wait a couple months and take advantage of the ps4s hardware but nope we got a trash ass game on ps3.

  • @sametayaz4891
    @sametayaz4891 Год назад +70

    In 2013, the hardware of most consoles and computers should not be ignored. PS3 and Xbox 360 had 512MB of RAM and also still using HDD. Despite this, they provided a great gaming experience. Optimization at its best.

  • @diggy1147
    @diggy1147 2 года назад +235

    It's amazing what they thought they could accomplish, and how the PS3 limited their vision. Some of the environments looked better in beta in my opinion, like the palms trees in the first image.

    • @vincentoconnor5640
      @vincentoconnor5640 Год назад +10

      PS3 probably could have handled it much better than the Xbox given that it was more powerful. And could run games that the Xbox could not. But probably still would have run at like 20fps lol.

    • @BananaSlug911
      @BananaSlug911 Год назад +26

      @@vincentoconnor5640 Nah, xbox 360 was way more powerful in 90% of the games, because of directx. Ps3 Literally always have 5-15 fps less and even 576p sometimes. I own Ps3, but xbox versions were superior.

    • @treezz6798
      @treezz6798 Год назад +20

      @@BananaSlug911 "the 360 was more powerful in 90% of games because of directx" thats the stupidest thing I've ever read in my life. ask anyone who knows what they're talking about. they'll always tell you the PS3 was the strongest console of the 7th generation. more powerful than the 360. the 360 only performed better in most games due to a simpler processor architecture, while the PS3 required more time/effort to get running well, which most companies didnt bother. it certainly has nothing to do with the graphics API used. and besides, gta v on ps3 and xbox 360 performed virtually the same. the PS3 version was in no way worse than the 360 one.

    • @9gsJota
      @9gsJota Год назад +2

      it was an horrible decision to don't add all the cut content to PS4, Xbox One and PC on the first Next Gen release. The second release didn't even have this. 💀

    • @mccombo1512
      @mccombo1512 Год назад +13

      GTA IV ran 720p on Xbox 360. PS3 didn’t even hit HD and was a blurry mess. I can see why the ps3 held them back because its a pain in the ass to develop

  • @_Devil
    @_Devil 2 года назад +199

    Major differences between the atmosphere of the beta versus final release:
    -The lighting is HELLA realistic, like one of those lighting mods you see on Nexus Mods or Patreon or something. I'm assuming it was changed to the familiar vibe we all know and love due to performance issues
    -There is a suspicious lack of palm trees in the final version. Hopefully that gets fixed with GTA 6 and so Vice City will actually feel like a game set in Florida lmao
    -The minimap is more akin to GTA 4, however I can see it was split into 3 sections still so I believe Rockstar had the idea of special abilities since the inception of GTA 5
    Final note: Just by looking at this beta, I know the game itself ran at like 15 fps on a good day but I still wouldnt pass up a chance to play it. I bet it'd be so weird to drive around Los Santos before most of the buildings and highways were placed down

    • @robertvalenica8999
      @robertvalenica8999 2 года назад +21

      That’s because it was using a heavily modified version of the rage engine that GTA 4 ran on. I recommend watching GTA 4 map mods were they port LS into the game. The lighting looks exactly like it was in the beta and has similar performance that you expect.
      Also, the main reason why the performance was probably awful was because of awful GTA 4 PC port, the build they were using still had that code which probably is why the game ran at 15-20 fps and hardware limitations. I mean, that Port ran like at 20 fps at everything max with BEST technology during that time. It wasn’t just recently that hardware has gotten so good that we can finally play that game at a stable 60 FPS with 12 Gen and Ryzen 5000 series of CPUs.

    • @turgor127
      @turgor127 Год назад +5

      Fog settings in release all fucked up. You can see that cars even in 50 meters have bluish foggy tint. Which is looks ugly.

    • @akuisbestgirl2448
      @akuisbestgirl2448 Год назад +8

      The lighting is definitely not "hella" realistic, how do you even gather that from these incredibly low quality images? Also, incredibly realistic lighting could not be achieved on those consoles, especially on a game like GTA

    • @ImNotActuallyChristian
      @ImNotActuallyChristian Год назад +14

      @@akuisbestgirl2448 people think high contrast, high saturation = realistic.

    • @_Devil
      @_Devil Год назад +1

      @@jerrytoonsz665 yeah i made this comment just days before the GTA 6 leaks so I do know that the game looks better

  • @aliciaevans7966
    @aliciaevans7966 2 года назад +303

    So removed so many trees. Must of been hard on the performance

    • @gary5116
      @gary5116 2 года назад +75

      Yup, apparently they had originally planned on placing a lot of trees but were experiencing 9-10 fps so they had to remove a lot

    • @aliciaevans7966
      @aliciaevans7966 2 года назад +45

      Understandable. Vegetation in any game is performance heavy if not properly optimized.

    • @djwarwick3588
      @djwarwick3588 2 года назад +5

      Bruh then how did they maid the trailer

    • @djwarwick3588
      @djwarwick3588 2 года назад +2

      And they should have brought back the cut trees to the pc version

    • @mac_-mtlmcal
      @mac_-mtlmcal 2 года назад +2

      @Why did I move here? indeed that would be a very bad business move for them

  • @alonemax2912
    @alonemax2912 Год назад +77

    Beta version looks more natural. Actually, i always preferred the look from the first GTA V trailer, it looked so nice and atmospheric.

    • @themadtitan7603
      @themadtitan7603 Год назад +20

      Agreed. The beta version looks closer to life, grittier and more authentic. But Rockstar always seem to ultimately go with a desaturated, washed out look which can also be seen in RDR2 compared to its first trailer.

    • @bramblifr
      @bramblifr Год назад +1

      @@blacksecondmissionstillcan1027gta 6 probably wont come out on the ps4

    • @asus99
      @asus99 11 месяцев назад +1

      Razor 1911 gta v beta

  • @user-fs8rn4cb6c
    @user-fs8rn4cb6c 2 года назад +39

    Great, thank you 👍
    Remembrer the desert screenshots surfaced several years ago, but never seen those Los Santos ones

    • @misanthrope5063
      @misanthrope5063 2 года назад +2

      The skyline of Ls looks terrible😂 like the skyscrapers in gta iv but worse

  • @IQ371
    @IQ371 2 года назад +314

    the old terrain and nature looked so much better

    • @mTrader1
      @mTrader1 2 года назад +3

      Looks don't matter man

    • @私の名前を翻訳しないでください
      @私の名前を翻訳しないでください 2 года назад +55

      @@Extreme-eb3ze Dude you actually need to get your eyes checked if you genuinely think that the beta footage is from real life. Look closely at the low-quality prison and yellow line textures at 1:04. The mountain in the background should also give it away lmao.

    • @Extreme-eb3ze
      @Extreme-eb3ze 2 года назад +2

      @@私の名前を翻訳しないでください get some life 😂

    • @DinaricUbermensch
      @DinaricUbermensch Год назад +1

      @@mTrader1 in rockstars case they do because their gameplay has never been great

    • @13Percent52PercentYikes
      @13Percent52PercentYikes Год назад +6

      @@Extreme-eb3ze homie thought this was real life lmfao 🤓🤓🤓🤓🤓🤓🤓😭🤧😭🤧😭🤧😭🤧😭😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂

  • @pedinhuh16
    @pedinhuh16 2 года назад +26

    1:48
    I really want to see more of that beta Mount Chilliad in the background, and it's incredible how that place looked so different and so vast in the beta, even though it also looks so dead.

    • @matushka__
      @matushka__ 2 года назад +9

      Well I guess when they drew up the map and then made a 3d model of it they kinda made a "mountains up there" for now, untill they figured out how they wanted to make chilliad look, so they just made a low-poly mountain and slapped it in.

  • @ACE-777.
    @ACE-777. 2 года назад +70

    Those who are crying about GTA 6 leaks need to see this video.

    • @ViceZone
      @ViceZone 10 месяцев назад +3

      Well, in this case, the beta looks better than the final version

    • @basilplushie2534
      @basilplushie2534 6 месяцев назад

      ​@@ViceZone
      Performance wise it no doesn't

  • @jaywayytoofresh9670
    @jaywayytoofresh9670 2 года назад +308

    Usually beta versions look bad but in this case it looks better than the final version

    • @maciejgrabowski2228
      @maciejgrabowski2228 2 года назад +27

      @@Extreme-eb3ze this is not true

    • @skye_music
      @skye_music 2 года назад +11

      @@Extreme-eb3ze If you can't distinguish a real life tree from a game then you have a problem

    • @smollathunderphucc6070
      @smollathunderphucc6070 2 года назад +1

      @@skye_music look at his pfp man. He's an npc from Los Santos.

    • @skye_music
      @skye_music 2 года назад +6

      @@smollathunderphucc6070 He deleted the comment now :D

    • @yourarseismine1016
      @yourarseismine1016 2 года назад +2

      @@skye_music
      What did he say?

  • @GeneralLee131
    @GeneralLee131 Год назад +10

    Had to cut it down a lot to make it work on 360 and PS3. It'll be interesting to see how the next GTA will be given multiple generations of systems will have been released in between.

  • @bluejayriot
    @bluejayriot 2 года назад +94

    Am I the only one that thinks it looks... hotter in the beta? Like the temperature looks like real LA summer heat.

    • @sanjivsrivastava6758
      @sanjivsrivastava6758 2 года назад +14

      Coz it the graphics and engine of gta 4 bro

    • @BARelement
      @BARelement 2 года назад +5

      It looks hot currently but wasteland like lol

    • @dayburks
      @dayburks 2 года назад

      Yeah it looked very accurate with the temperature and texture

    • @matushka__
      @matushka__ 2 года назад +1

      It's just how it looks on old gen still.
      You just have to change the time cycles.

    • @matushka__
      @matushka__ 2 года назад

      @@sanjivsrivastava6758 actually no, it's cause they changed the time cycles. Which controls lighting, saturation, weather effects. Etc etc.

  • @Dom-HSK
    @Dom-HSK 2 года назад +98

    There’s something about the beta that just looks.. better, like yeah, more tree wow but I mean in general, I think that film grain that seems to be there effects it too but, stuff like shadows an just, environment just feels better, sad, to be honest.

    • @wulf7744
      @wulf7744 2 года назад +5

      It’s sad in your opinion, the games been out for over 8 years and is still one of the most sold games of all time

    • @Js16108
      @Js16108 2 года назад

      I agree, it goes from nice shrubbery with nice lighting and shadows, to hey here’s this green construction paper

    • @kubamax9kubowski176
      @kubamax9kubowski176 2 года назад +7

      The environments were better? Man look at how much detailed they missed, from grass, buildings to even very low quality terrain. Only difference is more trees, which were cut due to performance trouble.

    • @Karmalu
      @Karmalu 2 года назад

      Hard disagree.

    • @lautaro7958
      @lautaro7958 2 года назад

      Yes, me too. That film grain feels cool

  • @koraegi
    @koraegi 2 года назад +9

    The more contrasted lighting along with the graininess makes the graphics look more lifelike

  • @estefez
    @estefez 7 дней назад +2

    Sad they went with the flat lighting for the final: that's completely a design choice: how bright the sun is vs ambient lighting- the Beta levels look so much more realistic but maybe it made things harder to see in-game

  • @its999wrld4
    @its999wrld4 2 года назад +15

    Gta 6 pre alpha version looks like fully developed gta 4/5 imagine the final Gta 6

  • @DuPz0r
    @DuPz0r 2 года назад +16

    Nice comparison! 👍

  • @ns6438
    @ns6438 Год назад +18

    It would've been nice if you had the final games mini map on screen as well so we could see how the surrounding areas changed.

    • @matushka__
      @matushka__ Год назад +3

      Not much, most of the map stayed the same. Especially Los Santos, some roads in Blaine County got changed around (but not by much, only slight shift of location) So the map has stayed the same since, but trees, NPC behaviours, etc. Were cut.

  • @llJeezusll
    @llJeezusll Год назад +51

    The lighting in some parts in the beta looked alot more realistic than what we got now. Almost looks similar to the lighting in RDR2 or the GTA 6 leaks

    • @Overqualification
      @Overqualification Год назад +2

      You don’t say. A beta looking like another beta by the same company.. of the same series.

    • @Andrewtate200
      @Andrewtate200 Год назад +3

      Rock star was way ahead of their time..

    • @iwavrQwpX4uB39nilBlQ
      @iwavrQwpX4uB39nilBlQ 11 месяцев назад

      ​@@Overqualification lmao and those games he mentioned are next gen that's why he's mentioning them smart ass 💀

    • @Overqualification
      @Overqualification 11 месяцев назад

      @@Andrewtate200 Same engine, 💩💩💩💩 for brains. Obviously it’s going to look similar.

    • @Andrewtate200
      @Andrewtate200 11 месяцев назад

      @@Overqualification I think your dad should have used condom that night to avoid a mistake like you😂

  • @DaveGee420
    @DaveGee420 Год назад +6

    Love how the GTA 5 beta was using the GTA 4 map and health display but still adapted to the ability in orange

  • @ericsgabbs
    @ericsgabbs 11 дней назад +2

    This is why I always feel like Los Santos is always barren and dull. And it also looks like it’s in the middle of a desert sometimes

  • @politicallyincorrect7236
    @politicallyincorrect7236 2 года назад +75

    I would of preferred to play the beta with gta 4 physics. Gta 5 has a good story but the world just feels empty and dull compared to 4

    • @xboxsuccs3652
      @xboxsuccs3652 2 года назад +7

      @@Extreme-eb3ze they're not real life photos lmao.

    • @私の名前を翻訳しないでください
      @私の名前を翻訳しないでください 2 года назад +2

      @@xboxsuccs3652 Bro's illegally blind, he's gotta be 💀

    • @someguy8951
      @someguy8951 2 года назад

      Gta 5 still has plenty going on tho

    • @zofar9565
      @zofar9565 2 года назад +16

      The same GTA 4 that has no nature, smaller map than the half of GTA 5, has no jets, has no vehicle and gun modification, has terrible aiming and overexaggerated physics

    • @paquito4147
      @paquito4147 2 года назад +2

      @@Extreme-eb3ze they are real screenshots of GTA V beta though

  • @kriuw
    @kriuw 2 года назад +10

    the trees make the game feels better soft and looks more beautiful

  • @themanfromthesouth1861
    @themanfromthesouth1861 2 года назад +41

    looked closer to LA in the beta

    • @Violator225
      @Violator225 2 года назад +16

      That's what I'm saying it looks less catoony

    • @desse8069
      @desse8069 2 года назад +15

      Agreed, it felt more like California.

    • @silentcarnage8696
      @silentcarnage8696 2 года назад +3

      @@desse8069 but they couldn't keep it like that the old gen consoles wouldn't of been able to handle it

  • @Bishengsx
    @Bishengsx 11 месяцев назад +5

    The vegetation was so rich in the early days, it feels so monotonous now

  • @reetial
    @reetial 2 года назад +11

    Ngl beta looks like red dead redemption 1 and gta 4, just more foliage.

    • @venkatkrishna8278
      @venkatkrishna8278 2 года назад +2

      yeah even the colour tone looks similar to rdr1 , rockstar really does take examples from its rdr games , gta 5 takes a lot of inspiration from rdr1 and as we saw from the leaks , gta 6 has a lot of stuff from rdr2

  • @theaagamingEmpire
    @theaagamingEmpire 2 года назад +24

    Am I the only one who feels that beta version is realistic.🤔🔥Jaw dropping pics!

  • @ovelhanerd
    @ovelhanerd 2 года назад +39

    I hope people that say that GTA 6 is ugly see this video

    • @MrLaidback
      @MrLaidback 2 года назад +15

      Exatcly. Thats why i came here. GTA 6 alpha looks pretty promising. Hope it delivers.

    • @SeriousDragonify
      @SeriousDragonify 2 года назад +3

      Gta 6 is indeed ugly.
      Knowing rockstar they will make game to run again at 30 fps then over time will make it like on next gen to run like garbage as it did on ps3 and xbox 360 after many updates.
      Just remember when they released unoptimized RDR2 on PS4 and XONEX.
      It had a lot of fps issues at Saint Denis and game was blurry which is why they decreased details in there and decreased NPC population to very low.
      Now that game has stuttering-freezing for couple seconds issues and "Ghost" aka Online pfp issue where ghost in the swamp appears.
      Also now both GTA 5 and RDR2 has lot of texture pop ups.
      They're really terrible with optimizing the game properly.
      Either they screw it on day one or after couple updates.

    • @fezzy5591
      @fezzy5591 2 года назад +11

      @@SeriousDragonify 🤡🤡🤡

    • @JaseHDX
      @JaseHDX 2 года назад +1

      @@SeriousDragonify um what, the population density stays the same on every platform lol, the game isnt blurry on one x, its running at 4k, ps4 pro is using a checkboard method for 4k which when combined with TAA creates a much blurrier image

    • @SeriousDragonify
      @SeriousDragonify 2 года назад

      @@JaseHDX Not at all.
      Did you even check DigitalFoundry?
      It doesn't run 4K on previous gen.
      Just on next gen.
      Only runs at 1080p.
      You really need to get your eyes checked bud.
      I played on both and GTA 5 is much more clear and sharper on PC.
      Less quality, less pixels.
      More quality, more pixels.

  • @mlodygonzo
    @mlodygonzo Год назад +4

    and people hate GTA VI leaks for "bad graphics" when it's like in pre-alpha
    imagine how beautiful it's gonna look if it already is pretty good looking in pre-alpha

  • @edwin99901
    @edwin99901 2 года назад +16

    Is the final version being captured on 7th generation consoles? I want an accurate comparison between test build and final ps3/360 build.

    • @YondaiTV
      @YondaiTV 2 года назад +2

      Thank you !

    • @farazsiddiqui1312
      @farazsiddiqui1312 2 года назад +3

      @@YondaiTV ??

    • @smokinwoodz
      @smokinwoodz 2 года назад +1

      @@farazsiddiqui1312 ?? what are you confused by?

    • @curiousmind_
      @curiousmind_ 2 года назад

      @@farazsiddiqui1312 you sound surprised for no reason. Don't be like that

  • @universeisherestudytime8701
    @universeisherestudytime8701 Год назад +3

    man beta looks more realistic like a real CCTV footage

  • @pariah87
    @pariah87 2 года назад +1

    sick video bro, it amazes me how much better gta v looked in its beta stages to me... and the game was only developed in 5 years with other projects being developed/released at the same time lmao

  • @S.T.R.Y.K.E.R.
    @S.T.R.Y.K.E.R. Год назад +4

    wouldn’t have minded more trees and shrubs, but that also allowed the game to run so much faster.

  • @TheBigdan217
    @TheBigdan217 2 года назад +1

    Jeezuz got your brightness turned up to max dude

  • @TheGamingMackV
    @TheGamingMackV 2 года назад +12

    Now imagine if these images leaked in 2009/2010. People would be complaining about how bad it looks.

  • @thatemocat
    @thatemocat Год назад +5

    I’m seeing some gta 4 and red dead assets being used in the beta images. Looks quite nice

  • @Tommyknocker.
    @Tommyknocker. 7 месяцев назад +4

    GTA 5 never had the LA or California vibe, and it's weird.

  • @MkGamerz15
    @MkGamerz15 Год назад +8

    The graphics and details of this game are incredible 👏

  • @jaxontheboss2319
    @jaxontheboss2319 Год назад +7

    Btw GTA 6 already looks amazing tho but obviously you can tell it still needs a LOTTTT of work still but the graphics overall and NPCs are already pretty good already nearly beaten cyberpunk also GTA 6 isn't even in alpha yet!!! And it's already looking this good

  • @InfamousJRP
    @InfamousJRP 2 года назад +14

    1:47 Mount chiliad looks weird in the beta version.

    • @themostawfulcomment393
      @themostawfulcomment393 2 года назад +9

      It looks wider in the beta but taller in the final game

    • @smokinwoodz
      @smokinwoodz 2 года назад

      @@themostawfulcomment393 no shit bro.. like why are you stating what people can already see

    • @themostawfulcomment393
      @themostawfulcomment393 2 года назад

      @@smokinwoodz Dude I was just saying why it looks weird ok don't loose your shit over a dumbass comment which has nothing to do with you I mean for gods sake this video is literally about gta v's beta build is it so fucking wrong of me to state my opinion like goddamn what is it world war 2 or somethin? just calm the fuck down my guy

  • @StarlightLancer01
    @StarlightLancer01 Год назад +4

    Would've been nice to have a little more vegetation but this is PS3 and Xbox 360 we're talking about. Limitations may have been substantial.

  • @ozandog
    @ozandog 3 месяца назад +3

    Looking at gta 5 beta pictures you can tell how this game grew from gta 4

  • @UmfaDaRockstarGames
    @UmfaDaRockstarGames 11 месяцев назад +4

    É impressionante isso cara, a Pré Alpha do GTA já tem gráficos de Red Dead Redemption 2, imagine a versão final, e olha que eles vão ter mais 2 anos de desenvolvimento ainda, já que o trailer vai ser lançado no início do mês que vem e provavelmente o jogo será lançado em 2025

    • @ichigonordwird9837
      @ichigonordwird9837 11 месяцев назад +3

      Esse é o gta 5 beta mano. É melhor que o original em algumas partes por que eles tiveram que remover muitas coisas pro jogo rodar no ps3 xbox 360.

    • @UmfaDaRockstarGames
      @UmfaDaRockstarGames 11 месяцев назад +2

      ​@@ichigonordwird9837 eu sei que é o GTA 5 Beta, tá escrito no vídeo, no meu comentário acima tava me referindo a Pré Alpha do GTA 6, só me esqueci de colocar o número

    • @ichigonordwird9837
      @ichigonordwird9837 11 месяцев назад +2

      @@UmfaDaRockstarGames ah desculpa mano. Vlw por esclarecer.

  • @viniciusnascimentomaeda9456
    @viniciusnascimentomaeda9456 10 месяцев назад +2

    In the beta version, they were still using the GTA IV mini-map

  • @Roblox_Max_Verstappen
    @Roblox_Max_Verstappen 5 месяцев назад +3

    Ngl sometimes the beta looks better than the final

  • @ImStormyMyDude
    @ImStormyMyDude 6 месяцев назад +1

    There's this mod called Beta Map Restoration that aims to bring back all those map elements that were removed from the game like the vegetation for example

  • @theonlygoofygoober
    @theonlygoofygoober 2 года назад +16

    I wish GTA V was like GTA IV style, i mean the vehicle damage, the ragdolls, the guns..

    • @El_Gomes
      @El_Gomes 2 года назад +3

      I have a feeling that R* is finally going to make his best for a "realistic" game (RDR2 GTAIV style) with GTA 6, something they haven't done/can't manage to make on GTA V and the old gen consoles.
      Just wait to see, it will blow our minds

    • @smokinwoodz
      @smokinwoodz 2 года назад +1

      @@El_Gomes i agree buddy, i think that they're using the past two gta games as a learning experience to formulate the best grand theft auto yet...

    • @El_Gomes
      @El_Gomes 2 года назад +3

      @@smokinwoodz With all leaks about GTA 6 and the actual console standards, without mentioning about R* saying that "we wanna make our next work as better as our last" (RDR2), this sh*t might be good asf, bro

    • @theonlygoofygoober
      @theonlygoofygoober 2 года назад +1

      @@El_Gomes BRO, I WATCHED THE LEAKS, YOU CAN LITERALLY BUY GUMBALLS FROM GUMBALL MACHINES, IMAGINE THE RELEASE AND THE
      GAMEPLAY CANT WAIT.. damn, i need to wait..

    • @El_Gomes
      @El_Gomes 2 года назад +1

      @@theonlygoofygoober And that's probably only the top of the iceberg... so imagine what will be

  • @chrysis666
    @chrysis666 11 месяцев назад +2

    I believe they were working from the beginning on a Next Gen version, either for the new PS4 or PC, but they wanted to release it first on the current generation. So, they used that version and cut a lot of assets, mostly vegetation, and then added them back for the new versions. That's my opinion.

  • @PARSA-POWER
    @PARSA-POWER 2 года назад +7

    About vegetation , they had to remove so many of them because the game on ps3 was running on 17fps and never went higher then 20fps. Also the RAGE engine has come a long way since then.

    • @TheyWantMeGone69
      @TheyWantMeGone69 10 месяцев назад

      You would think the expanded and enhanced versions would be a chance to add it all back but no.

  • @TatumKo100
    @TatumKo100 Год назад +2

    The lighting seems more realistic in the beta version with all the foliage. Obviously they did introduce more foliage in the PC / xbox one / ps4 versions of the game.
    They just had to make a lot of sacrifices it seems in the old days.

  • @Bertrumes_Shiney_Factory
    @Bertrumes_Shiney_Factory 2 года назад +5

    Some ideal scenery in beta but due to the overall map data probably made cuts to work better

    • @matushka__
      @matushka__ 2 года назад +2

      It was cut cause it was running at 10-15 fps lol.
      They should've just released the game on PS4 and Xbox one tbh.

  • @trosenthal3711
    @trosenthal3711 10 дней назад +1

    I don't care why they removed trees, it would be so much better if they were still there

  • @The.420.Riders
    @The.420.Riders 2 года назад +15

    The view distance at 1:46 shows how much bigger gta v was gunna be.
    I bet they were gunna add San Fierro and Las Venturas and than gave up.

    • @SkippyHunkleChuck
      @SkippyHunkleChuck 2 года назад +11

      They just weren’t finished putting objects

    • @fbyi2940
      @fbyi2940 2 года назад +6

      Putting sf would be a time bomb

    • @mmmmm4986
      @mmmmm4986 2 года назад +4

      Yeah they had a decision add all 3 cities or focus on los santos and expand the world and make it feel like a real living city

    • @InfamousJJ420
      @InfamousJJ420 2 года назад

      Now they can add different regions like in GTA SA into GTA VI.

  • @Andrewtate200
    @Andrewtate200 Год назад +1

    0:59 wtf lighting is so good.. They just made it more cartoony

  • @huracan360
    @huracan360 2 года назад +8

    I hope one day the beta version gets leaked

    • @ERTChimpanzee
      @ERTChimpanzee 2 года назад

      It is leaked here lol.

    • @outlaw9858
      @outlaw9858 2 года назад

      @@ERTChimpanzee I think he means to play jackass. 🤡

    • @huracan360
      @huracan360 2 года назад +1

      @@ERTChimpanzee I mean like an actual playable version

    • @matushka__
      @matushka__ 2 года назад +1

      @@huracan360 if ur on PC there are mods to restore some beta components, one of which is a map mod which adds alot of this beta stuff back.

  • @mikkellauterbach6286
    @mikkellauterbach6286 2 года назад +2

    are the beta pictures from the PS3? version of gta5? :D

  • @92kosta
    @92kosta 11 месяцев назад +4

    GTA V Beta looks like San Andreas.

  • @Sezarioooo
    @Sezarioooo 5 месяцев назад +1

    Removing a lot of objects was just to boost the performance back then, RDR 2 is a prime example of what Rockstar can make, all the vegetation, weather, lightning is still my favourite till date

  • @walkcycle5436
    @walkcycle5436 2 года назад +11

    is it just me or does the beta look better than the final? idk

    • @smokinwoodz
      @smokinwoodz 2 года назад +3

      thank god yall aint game devs

    • @walkcycle5436
      @walkcycle5436 2 года назад

      @@smokinwoodz i am though

    • @walkcycle5436
      @walkcycle5436 2 года назад

      :skull:

    • @walkcycle5436
      @walkcycle5436 2 года назад

      @@smokinwoodz im talking about the way the game looks in actuality

    • @walkcycle5436
      @walkcycle5436 2 года назад

      @@smokinwoodz not in detail or any of that

  • @EmeraldIsle1978
    @EmeraldIsle1978 11 дней назад

    the entire map , lacks a lot of vegetation . .because i swear some of those beta buildings look fire

  • @kylejj1998
    @kylejj1998 Год назад +4

    The beta version in the city look in a different way also verry realistic. The final version looks a bit blurry.

  • @louskunt1066
    @louskunt1066 Год назад +2

    0:58 this looks so good almost like real life and gives me skate 3 vibes too lol

  • @xshock__
    @xshock__ 11 месяцев назад +10

    1:18 was that niko bellic lmfaoo

    • @Iz4kiTiago
      @Iz4kiTiago 10 месяцев назад

      lol

    • @NotHimIGuess
      @NotHimIGuess 10 месяцев назад

      GTA 4 was used as an asset as GTA 5 was for GTA 6

    • @lunarlynxt
      @lunarlynxt 2 месяца назад

      Niko bellic with anim Michael

  • @UseroneGaming
    @UseroneGaming 10 месяцев назад

    1:24 I love the classic GTA IV HUD

  • @Steven-uk2fz
    @Steven-uk2fz 2 года назад +5

    Ah man they shoulda just waited for Ps4/ xbox one and they'd have a way bigger map

    • @smokinwoodz
      @smokinwoodz 2 года назад

      you realize that would mean they would have had to postpone development for like 6 years? and it took R* about 4 years to make both 4 and 5 respectively, so by your logic gta v woulda been released in 2018.. in other words thats 10 years of rockstar hardly making any income.. just so looking at it logically and drawing conclusions from the past, its safe to say waiting for the next console generation woulda been retarded as hell

    • @smokinwoodz
      @smokinwoodz 2 года назад

      not to mention when gta v started development the ps3 was only 2-3 years old.. thats the same age the ps5 is now.. so what you said about gta v is the same as telling rockstar now to wait until the ps6 releases to start working on gta 6

  • @flip7194
    @flip7194 10 месяцев назад +1

    The warm green tint and softer shadows in the final really makes it a lot more cartoony. It's one thing I'm so glad GTA 6 is ditching.

  • @anshulsingh8326
    @anshulsingh8326 2 года назад +6

    Gta 6 alpha looks even better than gta 5.

  • @PrideCraft
    @PrideCraft 9 месяцев назад +1

    Makes the map look smaller without the shrubbery and tree cover

  • @rallejensen3795
    @rallejensen3795 2 года назад +11

    I liked the beta better

  • @snackeaterz
    @snackeaterz Год назад +2

    Fun fact: they were going to add way more trees into the game but the old gen consoles couldn’t handle the amount of foliage they added so they just got rid of a lot of them

  • @Nunvalt223
    @Nunvalt223 2 года назад +6

    1:17 haha Niko over there chilling

    • @arshonpishkari3996
      @arshonpishkari3996 7 месяцев назад

      That’s Alpha Michael if you zoom in

    • @Nunvalt223
      @Nunvalt223 7 месяцев назад

      @@arshonpishkari3996Maybe it's just a test dummy skin

    • @lunarlynxt
      @lunarlynxt 2 месяца назад

      ​@arshonpishkari3996 it's niko with Michael anim🤔

  • @drmangler6475
    @drmangler6475 2 года назад +2

    Looks like what is now the leaked GTA VI images and videos.

  • @darianalexander5503
    @darianalexander5503 Год назад +3

    You can really tell how they originally built V using what they had from IV, and then overhauled it to be it's own.

  • @dudebro6350
    @dudebro6350 10 месяцев назад

    I understand the limited software made them have to take all the shrubbery and trees out. But goddamn, when attention to detail in the natural environment is put in it looks so good.

  • @fathergabrielstokes4706
    @fathergabrielstokes4706 2 года назад +5

    Hyped for GTA VI 🔥

  • @zachb1706
    @zachb1706 10 месяцев назад +1

    The Beta looks so much better, but I also noticed the lighting and textures to really pay homage to the artstyle of GTA:SA.

  • @IamAshik_yt
    @IamAshik_yt 2 года назад +6

    Why Beta images look real😑

  • @MoonSarito
    @MoonSarito 17 дней назад

    I understand the removal of trees due to the limitations of the Xbox 360 and Playstation 3 at the time, but why didn't they bring these details back in the PC/PS4/Xbox One versions or even the PS5 and Xbox Series X versions?
    The most we had was the addition of grass details on PS4 and PC (which they didn't include on Xbox One for some reason) and some basic ray-tracing effects on PS5 and Series X.

  • @CutriaSala
    @CutriaSala 10 месяцев назад +3

    PS3 really bottlenecked GTA 5, it could have been so much crazier on launch if the consoles were a bit more powerful

  • @fusion4373
    @fusion4373 2 года назад +2

    As a resident of california the beta version is much prettier but the finished version is much more realistic, we don’t have that many trees everywhere

  • @derbayer8710
    @derbayer8710 11 месяцев назад +3

    The beta looks much better...

  • @mexicanninja8634
    @mexicanninja8634 2 года назад +12

    Hopefully in VI they add more natural materials in to add more of that realism feeling to the game

  • @I_gemelli_di_Youtube
    @I_gemelli_di_Youtube 3 месяца назад +1

    The beta's photos seems like real life photos

  • @Lucas.mp4
    @Lucas.mp4 2 года назад +5

    where did you find those first images?

  • @theaviator1152
    @theaviator1152 Год назад +1

    1:18 1:23 Whoa, look at those minimaps! They look so much like GTA IV.

  • @lucifer_69960
    @lucifer_69960 2 года назад +7

    Technically it's alpha vs final

    • @THELIONMAN7
      @THELIONMAN7 Год назад

      Why not beta ?

    • @lucifer_69960
      @lucifer_69960 Год назад

      @@THELIONMAN7 in beta the game looks like the final product, but it has a lot of bugs when compared to the final product.

    • @freaking1418
      @freaking1418 8 месяцев назад

      @@THELIONMAN7because the limitations on xbox 360 and ps3 are too lag and low fps

  • @DakotaGreen-ky6oj
    @DakotaGreen-ky6oj 3 месяца назад +1

    I like the lighting and the shadows in the beta version better

  • @TaccRaccoon
    @TaccRaccoon 2 года назад +5

    So many trees gone, kinda like real life

  • @juan9383
    @juan9383 9 месяцев назад +1

    Crazy how the beta images are actually way more realistic than the actual game we have today

    • @xxe2
      @xxe2 2 месяца назад

      For a fact game keep getting downgrade every update

  • @theonlygoofygoober
    @theonlygoofygoober 2 года назад +3

    i say the Beta is more done lookin'

  • @SammEater
    @SammEater Год назад

    From where the city screenshots came from? I remember the leaks at the time being most of the desert area.