The cars in GTA V seem so disposable. They have a more “personal” and intimate quality in GTA IV, despite not being able to modify anything except a randomized paint job at Pay ‘n Spray.
thats the reason why. not being able to customize that much in gta 4 meant that when you found a car with a nice color you would be grateful and treat it like treasure. you had to actually look for something you liked. also pay and spray was exciting cuz you never know what the new color will be.
Just one example. GTA IV actually has more dynamic shadows from multiple light sources, and often you will see it recreate the "multiple shadow" effect you get when you're in a dense urban environment. It's actually really cool. V actually lacks graphically when you look deeper. It's more simplistic. IV was also created using thousands of real world images. Almost the entire map is made of them.
And since almost everything is exaggerated in GTA IV, and everyone praises it either because of nostalgia or because of the influence of those close to them
@@Lo0pingGGgta 5s physics do my head in on every slight collision my car spins out. On gta 4 if a car has momentum and is heavier it will crash but it’s weight will push the other car forward and keep going. Gta 4s is definitely more realistic whether its exaggerated or not
@@hezhez97 Wow. It's been 2 months and you're replying to my comment. Well, first of all, when you talk about the physics of GTA IV compared to GTA V, GTA V is much more realistic in other parts, compared to GTA IV. For example, the steering of a sports car. The body roll in GTA V is more in line with real life than GTA IV. Likewise the motorcycle, the steering in GTA V is more realistic. Furthermore, there is also something that does not exist in GTA IV: the weight of the car or motorcycle is caused by the driver or passenger. In other words, if there are 4 cars in a row, one with a person in the vehicle, another with two in the vehicle, another with three and another with four. The speed will consequently be caused more and more by the amount of people in a vehicle. This also applies to motorcycles. Anyway, Saying that GTA IV is more realistic than GTA V isn't as accurate as you might think.
I've seen real car accidents. I say that the Car damage of GTA4 is exaggerated, because the deformation of the car in GTA4 is much exaggerated, but it will not lose too many parts. The PS3 version of GTA5 is better combined, parts will fall off, and the car will be deformed@@JimmyJohnson7077
I don't like how cars explode twice with the RPG in gta5. You have the explosion of the rocket and then the explosion of the fuel tank, instead of a one big explosion like in Gta4. Also I don't understand why cars are so light in this game. A tiny explosion can make a car fly.
No it’s because he added armor to the vehicle, the first two swings on the quarter panel by the passenger wheel should’ve bent in but because it has armor it won’t ever bend with a low damage melee weapon
@Cescaarthur00 yeah? like SA and V overshadowing GTA IV for years until recently when it starts gaining popularity again and people are now giving this game more love than ever, where people like you come in and tell them to stop? that kind of overdone?
В гта 4 на байках теряется управление из-за всякого ФПС. Из-за этого также могут миссии зависать во время прогрузки. Нужно делать ограничение в 30 кадров и тогда будет нормально.
@5:09 actually no there’s more damage to the front of the car. Although the car exploded in gta 5 there were no dents or scratches at the front of the car, where it landed
2:24 - Moonbeam is not the car from release for GTA 5/Online, so it has less damage. In GTA Online you can make more bends for another car. Cars in GTA Online sometimes have less damage in comparison with GTA 5.
Different studios worked on gta4 and 5 i think,gta5 was technicaly downgrade from 4 in many aspects.Still suprised that gta 4 never saw light in Remastered or Remake version,even Rstar had 4 sure a lot of time 4 it to make.
GTA V on the original version i.e. Xbox 360 and PS3 actually had more when it came to vehicle deformation but after the first person was added to new gen consoles and pc they made it to where the cab of a vehicle doesn't get deformed most of the time. 😁
How many can be compared, and the answer will be this. GTA 4 is a realistic game, and the crimes in it are the same as in reality. GTA 5 is an arcade game in which crimes are similar to Hollywood movies. (Although I admit that new cars like Dorado Bravado, Impaler XS, Terminus and many others have suspension comparable almost to GTA 4)
@harveyanimations8974 i know they aren't and don't need to be but gta 4 driving fun and engaging like Jack Daniel's and gta 5 driving is sticky and gross like sprite
I think GTAV's is arcady, GTAIV's is excessive. Especially the body roll on sports cars. A Porsche 911 for example doesn't lean nearly as much irl as the Comet does in GTAIV.
The difference in damage and physics between GTA 4 and GTA 5 wasn't properly reflected. When playing the story on a current PC, the huge advantage of GTA 4 becomes much clearer than in that video.
I know a lot of gamers might disagree with me, but GTA 4's car physics are on another level-especially with how the weight shifts during sharp turns. The realism in every movement was unmatched. I just dropped a full video showing why GTA 6 needs to bring these features back from GTA 4. Check it out, and see if you agree
La verdad esperaba que gta 4 ganara completamente como dicen muchos pero la verdad es que en la mayoría son completamente iguales e incluso gta 5 gana en algunas. Y en las que gana gta 4 algunas es porque los coches en gta 5 tienen camara en primera persona y si se deforma demasiado atravesaría el techo, o es porque no existe gravedad alguna enp gta 4. Por lo que para mí esto es un empate y no hay downgrade.
GTA IV feels like an experiment into the 3d universe with its new physics and graphics. Amazing gameplay for its time and the story was deep storyline and dark side of liberty city, differed from the rest of the franchise.GTA V has an amazing storyline and is a masterpiece as far as graphics and gameplay! Now we are in the 4K UHD OLED universe.. so let’s see what GTA VI will bring.
GTA 4 had only one problem and thats the overall colouration or saturation problem, if gta 4 had a colouration like gta 5 than i think people would have played gta 5 much more than it already has
@@SfântCăpitanul Why is GTA V worse and less fun than GTA IV, even though GTA IV is terrible? The same argument you use of "Ah, but the cars in GTA V are lame" is the same when you ride a GTA IV motorcycle. Check out a showcase of a mod that takes away this horrible handling and makes it realistic, just like GTA V. This doesn't mean that one GTA is more realistic than the other in terms of physics, which doesn't exist to this day, but it seems that what you who like GTA IV say is not true! I was fooled all this time, thinking that GTA IV was this wonderful thing. I just played it, to see that this game is a complete overkill
@@MohammedTaybi-wp9tz Developers made the vehicles more rigid in Gta 5. Therefore, there is very little deformation/bending in the car body. (The most obvious damage is the tearing of the side panels and bumpers, nothing else) You have to hit the wall many times to deform/bend. This is not realistic at all. Even; Panto, Fire Truck, Bus, Mule, Trashmaster and most super vehicles don't deform/bend. They are immune to deform/bend for some reason. In Gta 4, "all" vehicles are soft deformed/bend in a realistic way. There even metal crumple in the vehicle.
Tbf, even tho i personally prefer the driving in gta4, ive heard that "the physics should match the map", and it does kinda make lots of sense tbh. It also makes it easier to accept & enjoy the handling in gta5 imo. =P Also, as others have mentioned (yet never enough); the bikes in 4 are glitched due to higher fps! Theyre actually pretty damn nice on Ps3/360 lol
Which one is realistic?
If gta5 had gta4 Physics that would have made Gta5 the best game ever because of the physics.
Hi pro:)🎉
Gta iv
GTA iv
GTA 5!
GTA IV: physics
GTA 5:GrApHIcS
GTA 6: Physics and Graphics
No. 50% of physics is more realistic in gta 5
@@Teimo_Pielinen01GTA V has better collision physics, but GTA IV Has better Ragdolls
How can you say that intill the game isn't even out yet 😢@@Alex_the_airbender
Ne alaka ya. Ümit edebiliriz öyle olmasını@@erenlegend7869
We need a mix of both. Gta 4 felt more loose and soft and gta 5 felt more stiff and stable.
Well hopefully next year we get that with GTA 6
It would be nice if we could adjust this in settings to our individual preferences.
@@SkierniewickiRockefeller now this is what I want
The cars in GTA V seem so disposable. They have a more “personal” and intimate quality in GTA IV, despite not being able to modify anything except a randomized paint job at Pay ‘n Spray.
thats the reason why. not being able to customize that much in gta 4 meant that when you found a car with a nice color you would be grateful and treat it like treasure. you had to actually look for something you liked. also pay and spray was exciting cuz you never know what the new color will be.
@ovalon08 There are tons of unique variations of vehicles in gta 5 that you can't just customize
Only problem with gta 4 is the graphics and the sky is pretty depressing
Cause its newyork and pollution
@ethangotbanned yeah and if gta 4 had gta 5 graphics it wouldn't feel as serious anymore
@YannickWadeJr i wish gta went more on gta4 side
A few mods and some reshade and the game looks better and way more atmospheric than GTA V.
Just one example. GTA IV actually has more dynamic shadows from multiple light sources, and often you will see it recreate the "multiple shadow" effect you get when you're in a dense urban environment. It's actually really cool. V actually lacks graphically when you look deeper. It's more simplistic.
IV was also created using thousands of real world images. Almost the entire map is made of them.
0:41 cap your fps dude. high fps causes that
yes
Exactly
the community already fixed this a long time ago with a mod
Yeah anything over 60fps turns bikes into a slip n slide
Love the gta IV physics 🎉
Me too, i love doing races with Comet and other sports cars
Actually, GTA 4's bikes aren't supposed to lose control like that. It's a glitch due to high fps.
"Glitch"??!
Gta sa has better physics when you lean to much you fall in gta 4 looks like you're clued with you bike
Exactly
@@fabiomucaj9767 nah
@@Portgas_D_Ace_69 exactly!
The thing that pissed me off the most when playing GTA five from GTA four is how easily any car would explode when it fell.
Agreed
True
And since almost everything is exaggerated in GTA IV, and everyone praises it either because of nostalgia or because of the influence of those close to them
@@Lo0pingGGgta 5s physics do my head in on every slight collision my car spins out. On gta 4 if a car has momentum and is heavier it will crash but it’s weight will push the other car forward and keep going. Gta 4s is definitely more realistic whether its exaggerated or not
@@hezhez97 Wow. It's been 2 months and you're replying to my comment. Well, first of all, when you talk about the physics of GTA IV compared to GTA V, GTA V is much more realistic in other parts, compared to GTA IV. For example, the steering of a sports car. The body roll in GTA V is more in line with real life than GTA IV. Likewise the motorcycle, the steering in GTA V is more realistic. Furthermore, there is also something that does not exist in GTA IV: the weight of the car or motorcycle is caused by the driver or passenger. In other words, if there are 4 cars in a row, one with a person in the vehicle, another with two in the vehicle, another with three and another with four. The speed will consequently be caused more and more by the amount of people in a vehicle. This also applies to motorcycles. Anyway, Saying that GTA IV is more realistic than GTA V isn't as accurate as you might think.
The reason why motorcycles drift easily in GTA4 is because the frame rate is too high.
GTA 4 is better
If we talk about physics
Gta V is on top
Driving physics goes to gta 5. Don’t feel like driving a boat.
Cap
@@Lego. No
GTA5: what are physics?
GTA4: hold my beer.
The player car is always stronger in a car to car collision ,then the NPC car.
I remember that the car damage effects in the PS3 version of GTA5 were the best.
yeah，beacuse GTA4 was so exaggerate
I've seen real car accidents. I say that the Car damage of GTA4 is exaggerated, because the deformation of the car in GTA4 is much exaggerated, but it will not lose too many parts. The PS3 version of GTA5 is better combined, parts will fall off, and the car will be deformed@@JimmyJohnson7077
Yes it wasnt
@@Renander_bink u mean realistic
Yes PS3 era GTA V was different damage to vehicles because it didn't have 1st person view.
I don't like how cars explode twice with the RPG in gta5. You have the explosion of the rocket and then the explosion of the fuel tank, instead of a one big explosion like in Gta4.
Also I don't understand why cars are so light in this game. A tiny explosion can make a car fly.
all of the gta 4 sounds are better too
Nop, is just your opinion. In GTA V we have details in sounds, but in GTA IV, no.
@@Lo0pingGGwow so "sigma".But u dont know about gta 4 helps to made gta 5🔥
@@ClaudeSpeed-l2v And?
@@Lo0pingGG and ?????
@@ClaudeSpeed-l2v Just because GTA IV was used as a base, can't GTA V be better than it?
2:51 if you’ll keep beating it in GTA V there will be bends
No it’s because he added armor to the vehicle, the first two swings on the quarter panel by the passenger wheel should’ve bent in but because it has armor it won’t ever bend with a low damage melee weapon
@@JustTone. its because of Next Gen Version. On the Ps3 Version it was much better, and even the roofs had damage models
GTA 5 felt more like a hollywood movie when it came to physics and damage
Both are best games.People start war about gta 4 and 5.But both are made on R*
Gta 6 waiting for this content again
:D
I'm sorry but gta 6 has worse driving physics than gta 5 and it looks very arcade
@@Notbestflags bruh
Source : But it's actually true tho
gta 4 is better in phisics and story
5 is better in just graphics
i prefer 4 than 5
They gotta add more of gta4 physics into Gta6
motorcycle physics breaks at high fps in gta 4
I swear some physics were better in GTA 5 but most were better in GTA 4
Love ur videos
Thank you :D
Эта рубрика очень интересная!! Прожолжай не теряя дух, чувак.
Gta4 is better. Gtav rockstar made it difficult because of gtaonline so the players car don’t get to munch weak and won’t run.
Big fan
Amazing video bro ❤️
Thank you :D
GTA 4 it's much better physics
Little bit bro, somethings is so overdone.
@Cescaarthur00 yeah? like SA and V overshadowing GTA IV for years until recently when it starts gaining popularity again and people are now giving this game more love than ever, where people like you come in and tell them to stop? that kind of overdone?
(My potion) gta 4 :good physics
:not colorful theme
Gta5:low physics
:colorful theme
Gta 5 is for suspension, weight and details
Gta 4 is for handling and destruction
В гта 4 на байках теряется управление из-за всякого ФПС. Из-за этого также могут миссии зависать во время прогрузки. Нужно делать ограничение в 30 кадров и тогда будет нормально.
افضل فيزياء للسيارات لحد الان في سلسلة GTA هي GTA 4 ❤
@5:09 actually no there’s more damage to the front of the car. Although the car exploded in gta 5 there were no dents or scratches at the front of the car, where it landed
I actually hated the vehicle physics so much in GTA V after what they were in GTA IV. Felt like a retrograde step.
1:14 semi standing on nose for 5 seconds, turning with magic. Very realistic.
I remember the first time playing GTAV, the graphics starts to feel less and less interesting after playing for a while because of the damn physics.
2:24 - Moonbeam is not the car from release for GTA 5/Online, so it has less damage. In GTA Online you can make more bends for another car. Cars in GTA Online sometimes have less damage in comparison with GTA 5.
I still don't get how gta 4 did a better job at this than 5.... hopefully 6 will be better!
Bruh gta 4 fanboy
@@ej_phatboy1124tengo el gta 5 y me desemciono, me pase su modo historia
@@ej_phatboy1124 bruh i like 5 more than 4 💀
GTA IV is in lots of things more realistic than GTA V.
Different studios worked on gta4 and 5 i think,gta5 was technicaly downgrade from 4 in many aspects.Still suprised that gta 4 never saw light in Remastered or Remake version,even Rstar had 4 sure a lot of time 4 it to make.
The water testing with the car actually amazed me
Good video👍
Thank you :D
GTA V on the original version i.e. Xbox 360 and PS3 actually had more when it came to vehicle deformation but after the first person was added to new gen consoles and pc they made it to where the cab of a vehicle doesn't get deformed most of the time. 😁
GTA IV has a better physical engine by far. But GTA V is better on the burnt texture ^^
Hey Bro
Hello bro
Gta san andreas: features
I love San Andreas
How many can be compared, and the answer will be this. GTA 4 is a realistic game, and the crimes in it are the same as in reality. GTA 5 is an arcade game in which crimes are similar to Hollywood movies. (Although I admit that new cars like Dorado Bravado, Impaler XS, Terminus and many others have suspension comparable almost to GTA 4)
I like how the airplane in GTA4 just hovered like it was designed to do.
2:40 thats because Moonbeam in GTA5 Can't bend
It’s not like coke and Pepsi, it’s like sprite and jack daniels whiskey
Two different things. One is not “better” than the other
gta 4 is jack Daniel's because it's better
@ yes but they are not direct competitors
They don’t need to be better than each other
@harveyanimations8974 i know they aren't and don't need to be but gta 4 driving fun and engaging like Jack Daniel's and gta 5 driving is sticky and gross like sprite
@ both driving models are fun in their own ways
0:42 If you operate it properly, it will bend properly.
I think GTAV's is arcady, GTAIV's is excessive. Especially the body roll on sports cars. A Porsche 911 for example doesn't lean nearly as much irl as the Comet does in GTAIV.
Bike is drifting☠ 0:41
Bikes tend to do that bro 😂😂😂 when you turn suddenly, average gta 5 player iq 😂
@@Harvey-12xyou never drove one
@momo_mez And you know this how?
I literally own a dirt bike
@ then you should know gta 4 is exaggerated with bikes
Amazing how perspective can change in 15 years.
GTA 4 is realistic
Not
@Megagoldman666 that's gta 5
@@ugandanchungus8455oh my God, man, look at one Russian guy with subtitles and you'll understand why Gta 5 is better
@@Megagoldman666sht up cant u understand both are better???
Molto bello il video io sono un tuo grande fan continua così la serie gtia5
GTA IV this realist
Gta 4 is just way too good bro
I have always said and will continue to say that the physics in GTA 4 are better than in GTA 5!
Gta 4 physics
Gta 5 graphics
If graphics+ real physics in one game = 💥
The difference in damage and physics between GTA 4 and GTA 5 wasn't properly reflected. When playing the story on a current PC, the huge advantage of GTA 4 becomes much clearer than in that video.
I know a lot of gamers might disagree with me, but GTA 4's car physics are on another level-especially with how the weight shifts during sharp turns. The realism in every movement was unmatched. I just dropped a full video showing why GTA 6 needs to bring these features back from GTA 4. Check it out, and see if you agree
1:20 bro you dropped two trucks but in gta 5 maybe 50 meters and in gta 4 even 300
GTA 4 ist thebest
La verdad esperaba que gta 4 ganara completamente como dicen muchos pero la verdad es que en la mayoría son completamente iguales e incluso gta 5 gana en algunas.
Y en las que gana gta 4 algunas es porque los coches en gta 5 tienen camara en primera persona y si se deforma demasiado atravesaría el techo, o es porque no existe gravedad alguna enp gta 4. Por lo que para mí esto es un empate y no hay downgrade.
1:26 *tactical nuke inbound*
today gta v turns 11 years
You mean 12 because GTA 5 was released 2013 now 2013 to 2024 is 12 years old
@@AbayAtay Bro can't count 💀
@@taqiyyan Bruh you can't count 2013 to 2024 is 12 years old are you kidding me count by yourself then kiddo
@@AbayAtay 2023 to 2024, how many years have passed? Count it again, is it 11 or 12?
@@romaatac21 2023 2024 is 2 years
Niko bellic gta 4 ❤❤
GTA IV feels like an experiment into the 3d universe with its new physics and graphics. Amazing gameplay for its time and the story was deep storyline and dark side of liberty city, differed from the rest of the franchise.GTA V has an amazing storyline and is a masterpiece as far as graphics and gameplay!
Now we are in the 4K UHD OLED universe.. so let’s see what GTA VI will bring.
Recuerdo k cuando jugaba GTA V en la ps3 los daños a los vehículos eran mejores
GTA IV physics 😻 but gameplay experience 😿
GTA 4 had only one problem and thats the overall colouration or saturation problem, if gta 4 had a colouration like gta 5 than i think people would have played gta 5 much more than it already has
They have gone from one extreme to the other, I would have liked a middle ground.
Если бы в гта 5 была физика гта 4, в нее было бы невозможно играть из-за сложного рельефа и большой карты
I remember spending all day on that super power swing with mod manu so when I get kicked across map I can repeat car and do it again 😂
Devs don't understand. It's the little unnecessary details that make games best
7:09 QUE CHINGAZO!!!🗣️🗣️
Hello please how do save gta IV❤️🙏🙏🙏
1:48 AYO THE FIF BUFFALO
GTA 4
where supecars feel like trophy trucks
The thing people don't understand about the driving in gta 4 it's more realistic
The first one is literally the same damage, all the gta 4 stans are tripping
both are great
True
Hi
Hello
Half of these felt unfair towards GTA 5, as if your just catering to what people say online.
How is it unfair, exactly?
Sport bike doesn’t lose control when you turn left or right
It’s evolving, but backwards.
No
@@grilled_turkey8yes
Gta4 is better 🎉❤😊
Lame
Because if you don't have PC PS3 or Xbox 360 that's on you
@@ej_phatboy1124 What are you talking about?
@@MinecraftvsBurnout what am I talking about? What you talking about physics
@@ej_phatboy1124you're onto nothing here. Just saying.
Gta4:quality and seriousness
Gta5:none of the above
Optimization?
i hope gta 6 brings back realistic physics again
GTA V's cars physics are completely lame
And GTA IV's cars physics are so exaggerated
@Lo0pingGG Much better and fun to play than that V's shit
@@SfântCăpitanul Why is GTA V worse and less fun than GTA IV, even though GTA IV is terrible? The same argument you use of "Ah, but the cars in GTA V are lame" is the same when you ride a GTA IV motorcycle. Check out a showcase of a mod that takes away this horrible handling and makes it realistic, just like GTA V. This doesn't mean that one GTA is more realistic than the other in terms of physics, which doesn't exist to this day, but it seems that what you who like GTA IV say is not true! I was fooled all this time, thinking that GTA IV was this wonderful thing. I just played it, to see that this game is a complete overkill
@@SfântCăpitanul GTA 4 cars physics are completely lame
@@SfântCăpitanul GTA 5 is much better and fun to play than that IV shit
Is GTA 4 available for console (xbox)?
yeah you can still buy it
@scottish_lunatic tested it myself thanks tho
Gta 4 is way too realistic for it's time but the controls of the vehicle were hard especially bikes
OH COME ON LAN GTA V IS RELASTIC WHEN THE CAR IS CRASHED INTO THE WALL ONE SIDE BENT
@@MohammedTaybi-wp9tz Developers made the vehicles more rigid in Gta 5.
Therefore, there is very little deformation/bending in the car body. (The most obvious damage is the tearing of the side panels and bumpers, nothing else)
You have to hit the wall many times to deform/bend. This is not realistic at all.
Even; Panto, Fire Truck, Bus, Mule, Trashmaster and most super vehicles don't deform/bend. They are immune to deform/bend for some reason.
In Gta 4, "all" vehicles are soft deformed/bend in a realistic way.
There even metal crumple in the vehicle.
Gta 4👑
GTA 4 is not better
Не думал что в гта 5 на чем то с экономят
Sup
Tbf, even tho i personally prefer the driving in gta4, ive heard that "the physics should match the map", and it does kinda make lots of sense tbh. It also makes it easier to accept & enjoy the handling in gta5 imo. =P
Also, as others have mentioned (yet never enough); the bikes in 4 are glitched due to higher fps! Theyre actually pretty damn nice on Ps3/360 lol
@1:26 you dropped from WAYYYY higher
I still don’t understand how they managed to downgrade GTA V so much
Because of first person you can see GTA V has no roof damage.