I have three reservations: 1. You are willing to accept English which is a foreign language than any of the Indian Language. bravo what a solution. Also do you think all the villagers of south where banks post offices are situated will understand English. We also face even being a Hindi speaking challenge while travelling . In our villages we have South Indian people posted who doesn’t speak their native language and tuti footi Hindi but we do not ask them to leave or learn Maithili, bhojpuri Bengali etc. 2. Madam for North India even Hindi is not a native language to all the states and people around. However Hindi has been originated from the same root from which languages like Bengali Nepali Punjabi Merathi have their roots so for all the native North Indians it is easy to understand and speak Hindi. Comparatively South Indian languages have originated from different roots and south India also have several languages hence we cannot even if we want to learn and speak these languages. But supposedly you people are actually opposing Hindi for sake of opposing only. If you dig into origination of Hindi it was not even a native language of any of the North Indian states it have been developed in course of time for having a common language. 3. Do you really think that bank and civil servants will be posted only in Kanndda/tamil/Telugu speaking area they will not be transferred to other places. What if a person speaking Kannada only transferred to malyali speaking area. Your culture will not get hamper ? How he will manage to communicate. On top of that even southern states have many languages apart from these 4 languages and have several dialects. Madam the problem will remain and will be managed the way it has been managed till now. diminishing languages is a problem and it is there in North as well for which we should take some measures but the way you people are reacting is not going to solve anything this is called Ego.
@@Frfirex Do you know the extent of hastinapur or as you call Bharatvarsh in those times? MahaBharat specifically says land where black buck roams is Aryavart--the bishnoi gangs are given importance coz of that. Rest of India--South, N.East, Punjab+Kashmir(the undivided one), Bihar, Awadh, Bengal(the undivided one) is mlecha land.
@@Frfirex That and definition in Epic Mahabharat are different. if giving reference of mahabharat, then stick to it. Otherwise mention republic of India.
@@Frfirex Stop living in your pathetic bubble, get out more and travel the world. You might learn--you and your language are not the centre of universe.
South Indians are soft -- Allow north Indians sit on ur head and that is the problem -- Push back on same coin .. There are some tools .. Start talking in Kannada every where including 5 star hotel -- Do not ask " do you know Kannada" -- If they do not know kannada speak in ENGLISH ( high class English with tough english words ) .. let the other guy feel bad .. I have tried this -- it works -- HINDI People respect English ..
lol nobody is forced to speak Hindi or regional language..have some Mallu friends born and brought up in Ahmedabad. They have been living there for years, still can't speak 10 sentences in Gujarati, he or his family never faced any issue there.
@IndianTamil-b6eLol! No language should be made the National Language of India be it Sanskrit or Tamil. Do you want to change the Constitution by making Sanskrit as the National Language of India?
Two languages are sufficient: 1 - Mother tongue; 2 - English - Communicate with wider world (including other parts of the country and outside the country)....This gives maximum benefit with minimal time spent on learning other languages....
@@bsoundharajan1830 3 language system should be brought.. First regional language, 2nd cultural language like Sanskrit and 3rd English which should be optional.. Maximum benefit is not should be our goal.. Our goal should be decolonization.. If not then this slave mentality will remain for eternity
@@SHU-be2lryou want to take indians backward. colonization gives jobs and economic growth mandarine and japan gives economic growth why should we leanr languages that dont give economic growth
@@vsansanv29101_sd I don't think you understand the meaning of imposition here.. But imposing you are also Imposing that language in working sector... Just like Japan has imposed Japanese in working sector instead of English...
Finally...non Tamils are opening their eyes...so far only we Tamils were taking the bullet for the welfare of the country. Giving special status is a blunder. Hindi is not unifying India. It is diving India. Non Hindi speakers are termed as anti nationals.
Don't be so quick to give yourself credit. Tamilians cause as much problem in Bengaluru as North Indians do. Some nonsense about ancient language and you look down upon all other languages. There is NOTHING special about Tamil and you are also pushing your ordinary language on other people. FIrst learn that and then you can take credit for fighting back Hindi imposition.
@sudeepkumar3310 you telugus still speak urudu in Hyderabad. Your answer is irrelevant to the topic under discussion. Of the south Indians hindi is spoken most among telugus
@@జైతెలుగు yup too much already happened . Hyderabadis are too delusional that everyone in Telangana speak Urdu and Telugu. Except Hyderabad no one knows urdu and hindi in Telangana or amdhra. it's time to implement strict telugu in these states.
Support From Gujarat... I wish Our Leaders were like Southern States That would oppose Hindi, Migrant have not learned our language and expect locals to speak with them in Hindi in all nationalized banks. Hindi is foreign language to us
@IndianTamil-b6e Kannada has similarity with Sumerian Language with is 5000BCE which is older than Sanskrit. We have won military victories in Bihar Nepal Iraq Sudan Cambodia. We have achieved a lot more than anybody else, so Kannada & English should be national language of India.
Hindi is not our language. If anybody try to impose on us then who tried to impose we consider them as worst than our enemies and we treat them as worst enemies than Britishers.
@@RatnaMaharaj so you hell bent to push your persian language down our throats and destroy our 3000 years old language and culture and treat us like second grade citizens. Shame on you. We will never let it happen.
Yeah cause you consider Britishers as your papas.. I'm not saying this to make you accept Hindi cause I'm also against Hindi imposition... I'm saying this to show your slave mentality
@IndianTamil-b6eit's ironic to see how much they hate Sanskrit.. Yet they still have names in Sanskrit.. And those British slave who have their name changed like Stalin still keeping alive divide and rule legacy of Britishs
Hindi has lot of influence from arabic and Persian..So the ppl who are arguing English as a foreign language, even hindi is a foreign language developed during delhi sultanate and Mughal era.. so if Mughal and delhi sultanate were invaders so is Hindi a foreign language..Sad part is north india lost its language and culture long back, south indians wants to preserve it and will preserve it
Sorry, Hindi is a derivative of Khariboli or the Kauravi language that is native to Delhi, upper West UP, North Haryana and the Southern plans of Uttarakhand. It is a descendant of Shauraseni Prakrit, the same Prakrit that has given birth to Punjabi, Haryanvi, Braj, Bundeli and Kannauji.
As the Tamilnadu minister said, dont pull us down to Hindi, level up to speak English. One should be blessed to speak Kannada, unfortunately, many don't realize this.
Ok. Speak English then. Migrants in Bengaluru know English. But the Kannada goons don't. Migrants already know 3 languages. But locals refuse even to learn 2 language.
@@rajx7120 if you stay in Karnataka, it's your responsibility to learn the local language not the locals responsibility to learn your language. It's the same everywhere, if I stay in Delhi, I don't expect them to speak kannada or english.
@@nandishnan5680 If I don't see any Kannadiga around me, then why should I learn Kannada, and why should you be worried, what two random strangers are speaking? I am not asking you to stop speaking Kannada. I just have no need, and you can't force me.
@@rajx7120 it's the same way, you can't force locals to speak ur language, kannada is what they speak, for example my mom doesn't speak any other language other than kannada, in bank people expect her to speak Hindi. How fair is that. Video is all about hindhi imposition, I don't have any advantage learning hindi, instead I can learn German Spanish. It's only making local life tough, that's what the video tells.
@@nandishnan5680 Hindi is not my language. If you don't like Hindi, then atleast know English. Migrants already know 3 languages. You are asking them to learn a 4th while refusing to learn a 2nd.
Honestly, we speak Kannada only at home. Nowhere even vegetable vendor, petrol station everywhere nobody understands kannada. Im a foreigner in my own city!!!! Disgusting!!!
Start speaking Kannada every where -- MALL / 5 star hotel / PVR cinemas / Airport etc.. Do not hesitate .. Just speak normally -- If the other gu y does not understand use ENGLISH / never use HINDI .. I tried this -- It works
I know, that's the sad part in Bangalore. U know that, Kannadigas problem is Kannadigas only. They speak Hindi and lost their ground. I am Tamil. This was not the case 15 years back, now North Indians took over the City and Hindi has become a kind of official language in Bangalore. Karnataka having a population of 6.7 crores why people are not coming for job to Bangalore. Be it IT or labor or delivery job hardly there are Kannadigas in Bangalore.
Ironically, this is what tamizhians have been saying forever, while being accused of being regionalistic and narrow minded lol Whatever you may say, and they may have their drawbacks but TN people are clear about who they are and what's acceptable to them. You reap what you sow. Being "cosmopolitan" shouldn't come at the cost of forgetting your identity. If language goes, then culture goes too. When you suppress your natural identity in order to look more modern, it leads to resentment and division in the long run.
@@santhoshc86 it’s funny to hear from you this brother .. sorry .. but you go to Ulsoor, jogupalya , Cox Town, Frazer Town,dodda Banaswadi, Thippasandra and HAL you will see people responding in Tamil when you talk to them in Kannada ..
இல்லை சகோ.. 1920 களில் சமசுகிருதம் கலக்காத தனித் தமிழ் இயக்கம் (மறைமலை அடிகள், தேவநேயப் பாவாணர்) . 1960 ல் ஹிந்தி, 1990 ஆல்கிலக் கலப்பு, இப்போது மீண்டும் ஹிந்தி....
Same way english has been impossed on us. Its not even our local language, most of the time student memories the concept instead of understanding bcz of English imposition. We are not allowed to give interview in hindi, if we speak then they look down on us. Majority of india 🇮🇳 speaks, understand hindi despite of their local language so "Hindi " is a uniting language . Why most of famous and popular youtubers are making videos in hindi ? We north indians 🇮🇳 don't fight with each other for language, we also have our own state language and we respect each others reigional language and speak in hindi to understand each other while a person from tamil nadu can't talk with person from Kerala or karnataka (except if they speak in English) . U expect people who goes to south india to speak ur language from day 1 ? If u force them they will not learn but naturally they will addopt to local language. I support 3 language implementation in schools (Hindi , english, religional language)
Yes, we are all aware of what the Tamils have done in the past decades. If anything is to be learned from that, it is that we should try our best to be unlike the Tamils.
It’s ironic how the Prime minister and home minister struggle to convey their ideas in English interviews and yet they cannot empathise with the struggle of communicating in an unfamiliar language.
@@RatnaMaharajRahna Maharaj ji..our ancient Indian android with Devnagari software is still untraceable. Also our google and RUclips and the motor vehicles you travel in land, air and sea. Lets move forward ' Vasudaiva Kudumbakam'.
I stand with South Indian people. I like their policies for saving regional culture. I am a Gujarati. I don't like Hindi. I wish my state becomes like South Indian. Hindi is important for RSS Sanghi. So they want to impose it. We have to oppose it. 👍🏻
Gujarat hindi both same family Almost same language Very easy for u guys learn Hindi Hindi also helpful for north Indian states South Indias choose english because South Indian language very different
@@rockjn in Rajasthan Sanskrit is the 3rd language, I may learn another like Sindhi, Punjabi , Marathi, Gujrati if I were born there. I mean we learn 3 languages why don't you
Is it true north India is one of the most backward region in the whole world ? Is Hindi being imposed so that north Indians can get employment in progressive south ?
@@kddraco333 is everyone just as cooked as you in the south? I've been to the south many times, and most people aren't as F'd as you. I hope there is still hope for Dakshin Bharat.
This is another nonsense reasoning, that does not have any self-respect or dismisses there is a nature's purpose in having diversity. Go read science literature of why linguistic-diversity is better for having diversity of thought/ideas. Any monoculture language/crop/any will have higher penalty on life thats why nature creates diversity.
North indians call English a foreign language. But for south states Hindi is more foreign than English. We are not even culturally close to hindi compared to English. We watch more content in English than in Hindi - bollywood is on the decline, i don't remember the last time i watched a hindi movie. Hindi is the foreign language for us
People need to ask the question Why Hindi? Conducting state level competitive and entrance exams in Hindi is a gross injustice to the locals. Why we shy away from cultural & Linguistic diversity is just beyond me.
@@praveenpayiran BJP is trying to impose Hindi today. But Congress is the one who started itm The things is, Nehru and others were big time fanbois of the USSR. And they copied their policies as well. 5yr plans, one language for the union etc were all directly pulled from the Soviet Union playbook. And look what happened to them. Those guys pushed Russian everywhere like current govt is pushing Hindi everywhere. It will only lead to more disunity.
I will speak in hindi in only states like up bihar where hindi is the local language...and sameway if hindi speaking persons come in karnataka, they should speak in either kannada or in English...
This mentality shows you hate Hindi and there is no other reason why you don't bear Hindi. More than 70% of the population in india knows Hindi, Hindi is 3rd largest language in the world. Who the hell are you to remove hindi 😂
South India should have its own central government. All the union government does is loot our taxes and barely gives back anything in return while overfeeding the useless states that serves as their precious votebanks and then have the gall to try and shove their language down our throats as well.
@@yourend3177 it's too late to save your languages. You are half to almost dead. unlike South, other non hindi speaking states have already allowed hindi to the extent that it has fully taken over and destroyed local language. For example maithali, Bhojpuri, bihari, Chattisgarh, garhwali, dogri and indigenous tribal have all been wiped out. Languages like Marathi, Bengali, rajasthani have suffered severe erosion. In all these Hindi media, Hindi cinema, Hindi literature and all the Hindi things have replaced local languages. S
@@EriOliyanVaenthi I don't about them but I am from Punjab. Punjab and Kashmir do not and will never accept Hindi. Gov tries to impose it--some years back it was English. But none works in long run. People here do not accept things imposed on them. They will change from within and by themselves if they feel change is required. We never accepted any religion imposed on us(goes for all religions here, languages and cultures for 2000 years now. 75 years of India rule can change us? Nope. 80's and 90's in Punjab and Kashmir never changed people here. You think BJP rule can change us? NOPE! As for Hindi and Hindi speakers--they already have the worst reputation in the world and in this part of India--frankly hated. So we are with South as regards to Hindi imposition. We will never accept Hindi--EVER!!! Not even Urdu, Persian(under Mughal rule), Pashto and Dari(under Afghan invasions),English(under British rule) could change us. And they were autocratic. You think cowbelt can change us?LOL.
English is a neutral language and the only language for common communication. People arguing that English is a foreign language, please note that Hindi is also a foreign language brought to India by moguls and sultans.
This is what happens when people gain education in the Indian system. 0 brain cells detected. "Hindi is also a foreign language brought to India by moguls and sultans" - read it again.
@@manjunathgowdara3101 Moreover, English has been Indianized to the point that there exists Indian accent English now, and which is recognized world over.
English as a communicating language is ok as it provides a sort of neutral ground. Hindi is actually closer to English and has many similar roots. Although hindi speakers will get a slightly unfair advantage, English is the best option available. In banking and other sectors English with communicable local language should be made compulsory.
most of the locals in north indian don't understand proper hindi. it only exist in text books, northindian commoners have language their ancestors spoke for 1000 years. hindi came only after 1880
So if a north Indian who does not speak Kannada and English is laying down on your road crying for help - U will not help him unless he speaks in Kannada. Asks your Deepika to get out of the Hindi film industry. She is not needed.
@@tanujaphadke8219 Y should she ? She speaks hindi , she respects the language unlike ignorant north indians.There are more northies working in south film industry than south indians working in Bollywood.
@@tanujaphadke8219 in hathras a hindi speaking girl was raped and killed. hindi speaking police freed the culprit and set fire on body of the victim without knowledge of her family. amnd those neighbours and people around defended the criminals and spread derogatory lies about the victim. i can assure you that Hindi speakers will get better help from the south than the castist North.
Yes but many of us can understand and speak hindi. That doesn't mean we would be happy if they start imposing their foreign language and culture on us.
@IndianTamil-b6e - Sanskrit is dead, man. Nobody is going to learn that. Why are you pushing Sanatana here? What is your profession? Are you ready to change your caste based on your job as per Sanatana darma? Summa inga vandhu kathikitu
Hindi imposition means unfair treatment to 60% of Indian population. Language is not merely a mode of communication. Govt must understand this. Language is root of the community since ancient times, their culture, identity, thought process. Just bec Hindi speaking is majority ie 40%. One can not impose that on others . Unjust.....
I have been to the border with China in Arunachal Pradesh. In this corner of the world, where they couldn't any more different from the population of the rest of Bharat, they spoke in fluent Hindi with me, with large smiles on their faces. In fact, 70-80% of the population of this country is able to find work very easily simply due to the fact that they speak the language that connects this nation - Hindi. No amount of seething will change that fact.
@@IvanMend you need to understand the fact that southern Bharatiyas are not a martial people. They have never been martial people. They have always been protected by the "naarthies" from the Huns, the Pashtuns, the Turks, the Iranis and various others, and now from the Chinese Hans. Never forget the fact that Madras was the first land to fall into the hands of the British, by a huge margin.
Ratna Maharaj..my respectful naarthee..hope you read my reply on Pangea, origin of alooparatta you ate. Now plz read about Marthanda Varma and Kulachal war with Dutch. India has been colonized by Portugal and France too. Read about Samoothiri, kunjalimarakkar, Keezhadi etc Also kalaripayattu, silambam. Madrasis fell to Britishers, but not their culture, moral values and language.
Recently there was a case in Canara Bank rural branch SIRA ( 90 KM from THUMKUR ) .. A Farmer came for Tractor loan which is priority sector -- The Bank clerical staff from BIHAR spoke in HINDI only ans started insulting the farmer .. Farmer went to PANCHAYAT head who came and talked to Branach manager and made video viral .. The question is why BIHARI has to come down to rural Karnataka for Bank work ?. since hindi is used for bank exams he could pass it .. Start using Kannada , Kannadiga also will get jobs in Karnataka
I live in a village in Bengal and our SBI branch manager was from Manhaluru. He neither could speak Bengali, nor a workable Hindi nor an understandable English. We were fcked for so many months. Now the new manager is from Bengal and that's a relief.
@@spg6651 Anyway I don't want to insult Bihari. Biharis should first fight for their Bhojpuri language which is very beautiful and start respecting their mother tongue and land. Hindi is not our National language. Don't lose your identity for political reasons and financial gain. Have self respect and do everything to develop your lands and people. Make your NRIs and billionaires set up start-ups in your state. English is a must if you have to excel internationally. In South we will never accept subordination by outsiders.
Pakistan tried to impose Urdu on the Bengali people in erstwhile East Pakistan. It was seen by the locals as attack on their culture. We should learn from history. But a similar mind-set is prevalent here. An insensitivity that creates further division. Just talking about business and access to jobs etc...is missing the point.
Kannadigas friends have failed to know the hidden face of RSSBJP...Karnataka will fast proceeding on the path of some lazy divisive backward north-western states....
@@rssiddharth3134 it's ironic to see how much you hate hindi Sanskrit.. Yet your name is in Hindi Sanskrit.. May be you should change your name first so it can match your brits papas
@@SlimJim3082 Whoever are doing that are certainly being barbarians. No language, culture, music, literature are greater than any other. I really condemn every such effort. I shall rather like to learn new languages than imposing myself on any other.
This type of "philosophy" is exactly why this nation has been the dark age since centuries. Thank you for your contribution to this nation's demise. You are a true patriot, an example for that is bad in this nation.
To Ratna maharaj..pz read geography since Pangea. Human evoled to current state of intellect because of absorbing multiple languages and cultures. All Indian languages are huge mix, where the least mixing happened in Tamil. Because of anthropological reasons, lets respect all languages. Next is food. Do you know that wheat is Persian, tomato, chilli and potato are South American? Can you eat only the Indian origin rice, millets and dal three times? A true patriot is the only who invest time selflessly in nations development forward in the globalized world eg. APJA Kalam. We are just wasting on reading comments and reacting to it.
@@subysb9616 do you know when Pangea supposedly split apart? Do you know the difference between a hypothesis and a scientific theory? Do you know that Pangea is accepted in mainstream science only because we don't have enough data with accurate timelines? Yes, languages are a mix. Hindi is a mix of various languages, but the lion's share comes from Sanskrit, making it the perfect lingua franca for this nation. Also, we are all aware that potatoes, tomatoes and chilies are from the Americas, but from what I understand "Persian" is from west Asia. Go ahead and correct that comment of yours hahahaha
Well Done Kannadigas, full support from Maharashtra, Maharashtra is also fighting against Hindi Language, Hindi Language should not be allowed in Non-Hindi speaking states, Marathi people do not like Hindi language as well, Marathi is extremely ancient and a classical language and far far above Hindi language, same goes for the Marathi culture. Maharashtra does not need Hindi language, why go for plastic when you already have gold.
@@banhindipeopleandlanguageMarathi people were the first ones to be at up and ki ck out North Indians from Maharashtra. So from where did you get this nons ense and li es that Marathi people support North Indians sometimes? Marathi culture is closest to Konkani, Kannada and Tulu culture. Marathi and Konkani are literally twins.
@@mangopudding5979bro i have been in Maharashtra but most of the people speaks hindi 😢 even i try to speak in Marathi they respond in hindi basically i am from Karnataka ( northern Karnataka)
Its about attitude, problem is some hindi people showing chauvinism and thinking south india is their property....just say politely you dont know local language and people will help
I can personally relate to this. The arrogance at auto drivers not understanding hindi despite them being in Chennai was shocking. Needless to say the driver took her to the wrong place.
Exactly! I am a Tamil who barely understand Kannada and when my auto anna or street vendors speaks in kannada I politely say Sry I dont know Kannada. They wont even show any kind of anger or inconvenience. They speak in Tamil that they know and are very very sweet. I haven't learned Kannada yet coz I am not planning on staying here for long. The culture of Hindi speakers is ruining this city. The diff is very palpable when you go to other cities in Karnataka. When Kannadigas are in majority, the place is sooo much more safe and pretty. Not blaming all Hindi speakers but quite some of them are causing nothing but problms here, be it IT professionals or daily wage workers.
If Hindi is National Language for them...For me Tamil is the National language and English is the global language ❤ தமிழ் வாழ்க, தமிழ் வளர்க, தமிழ்நாடு வளர்க😊❤ யாதும் ஊரே யாவரும் கேளீர்.... எனது மண் எனது பெருமை - தமிழ் மன்னர்களான சேரன், சோழன், பாண்டியன் வம்சமடா 🐯 🏹🐟
@@Frfirex Our Tamil, Telugu, Kannada, Malayalam is older and has a rich history da and these are older than your so called Hindi🤡... Better give respect
It's ironic to see that you ppl have names in Sanskrit and you hate Sanskrit soo much.. And how you all have rejected that your state never used Sanskrit in past... Nah.. Even Sage Agastha was a Aryan who gave you ppl grace of a beautiful language like Tamil.. Doesn't this makes Tamil and aryan language?
For people saying English is a foreign language: Yes, it is and I don't care. There are LOTS and LOTS of things we use which are foreign. Everything from toothbrushes to electric motors to jet engines were invented by the British and are foreign. Just because the British brought English to India, and the British did bad things to us, it doesn't mean that there is something wrong with the English language itself. Nobody is trying to push English down my throat. I learnt it because it is useful. Hindi on the other hand, is not only useless, but is also being forced on us and is dividing India.
i never seen more hypocrite man as you in my entire life 😂, you don't have any problem with foreign language but you treat hindi as foreign or outsider language, second this learn some basic history, English is also forced on us , before 16th century no one use english in India
You learn English because you like it then why do you get higher education in your own language, in India education from KG to PG is available only in English not in other languages, none of indian no likes to learn English but the government and English speaking intellectuals force them don't want to end English, they don't know what they will do if English ends. India became independent but their dogs are still alive
Shut up and get Lost, I'm Native to Karnataka. Most of us Kanndiga people have no problem with Hindi or Northt Indians, This is Congres inventd Propaganda to stop BJP from having influene in South INdia, THey are playing Divide and Rule. We are all one India, Bhaarat. We will break thelegs of anyone who dare divide us based on Caste or Langauge.
@@lipun1531 Hindi is the language of the colonizers just as English is. But English is much more useful these days so it is better to choose English. Hindi was created by the Delhi Sultanate, go and do your own research. The Sultans who hated Hinduism took out as much Sanskrit as possible from the local languages of UP to create Hindi.
@@lipun1531 Hindi is nothing but Urdu written in Nagiri script. It is just a broken Persian brought to Indian sub-continent by the Mogul invaders. Hindi is not having any root words of its own or any grammar. Learning Hindi will limit ones potential.
For hindi speaking people English is a foreign language, for non hindi speaking people both English & hindi are like foreign language as it is not mother tongue.
One of these two languages is a lot more foreign than the other. Also, to be noted, Hindi is not the mother tongue of most Hindi speakers, it is in fact the lingua franca of this nation.
@@RatnaMaharaj india has the second largest English speaking population in that world. Following what you said , we already have a language which everyone can communicate in and it's not Hindi for sure
@@nujjigram, No, not everyone can communicate with English. Pick a lingua franca/common language for 4 southern states and one for 25 Northern states. It's already a great favour in terms of distribution. It's their choice if they want English or any one out of 4. Kannada itself is an imposition on Tulu and Konkani speakers.
@@Rajan_Rout "no not everyone can speak english". I'm glad you recognise that. Now , let's get you to understand the same about Hindi. Although it should be pointed out that English is more relevant from an educational and professional stand point. Hindi is not. All states should have freedom to choose their own language. If a state chooses Hindi, then it's their choice. If southern or eastern states reject it, then it's their choice. It's getting boring to watch someone from the north constantly tell someone in Bangalore that they should learn Hindi for the sake of the nation. Southern states have clearly rejected Hindi while NE states have been mixed about it.
Hindi did not exist 250 yrs ago. The world did exist and communicated. People from many parts of the world came to today's India 3500 yrs ago. They live here until now. Hindi is not imposed by people from UP or Bihar. Then who are imposing the Hindi language on every state? This is a very important question. Every Indian should find out the answer.
there are uppercast prople, who can't directly impose sanskrit on people, they don't want lower cast people to learn sanskrit and read vedas. at the same time they want to impose devnagiri script upon everybody. they already succeeded in replacing original scripts of maratha, gujarati, bihari etc
hindi definitely work as bridge between people from different state, language and culture , this is a fact, no one is forcing you to learn hindi in fact you guys force north Indians to learn your language, we also respect local language but this doesn't means you will force us to learn Kannada, India have so many local language how can you expect from someone to learn completely new language from sketch when people generally switch their location and city in every 2-3 years, are you really expecting them to learn completely new language in every 2-3 years, why only south people have hatred toward north indians , come in our up ayodhya where we have mention all sign boards in Kannada and tamil as well for south devotees but you kannada and tamil people are filled with hatred towards own people, you guys treat north indians as outsiders
@@sanatanihindu383 we have no problem english to be the bridge language, it can be a bridge within in india as well as outside india. north indians are the only ones against this. why?
@@mshamilna Hindi is nothing but Urdu written in Nagiri script. It is just a broken Persian brought to Indian sub-continent by the Mogul invaders. Hindi is not having any root words of its own or any grammar. Learning Hindi will limit ones potential.
It is only by non-Hindi speakers because there is a value. Because people already know Hindi and it is easier to build on what U already know. U must find a middle path
I would like to share a recent incident that occurred at the Kolkata metro in this context. A Hindi speaker, female (probably a visitor here), accused a Bengali woman of being 'Bangladeshi' for speaking Bengali in West Bengal. According to her, Hindi is the national language, and if you are in India, you have to only speak in Hindi. I don't know whether I should call her dumb or be angry for this audacity. Bengali is literally the 2nd spoken language after Hindi and an official language, including other 22 languages like Hindi and other Devnagari and Dravidian languages. How dare these people question someone's nationality when they don't have basic knowledge about their own country? These so-called native Hindi people intigrate Urdu words in their sentences and struggle to speak in pure Hindi too often. As per this absurd logic, should we call them pakistani? as Urdu and Hindi are widely spoken in Pakistan. That doesn't sound right, no? I think we Bengalis are too generous; we never create an issue for people from other states speaking in the language they are comfortable with. I could never imagine this kind of incident happening in Bengaluru or another south region. I think we should be more loud and open enough as much as them. I'm not one of those people who divide languages based on religion. Hindi and Urdu are both Hindustani languages that originated in the Indian subcontinent and share similar roots and young languages. I don't hate either of these languages; anyone can speak any language based on their region, historical base, or community instead of their religion. But imposing Hindi forcefully might be alerting for these Hindi-speaking states too, because their native languages might become endangered, which are old and contain more historical values. This is my personal opinion, though.
Thank you Pooja for giving such insightful news, I belong to Madhya Pradesh a Hindi speaking state and I agree with your views you have presented in a video. We need to preserve our different states language identity by giving them equal status, so that every Indian can feel proud for his/her language and cultural identity.
These South Indians are baby crying for an year and decades cuz that's their way to get finance ministry and other cabinet ministries to hijack projects and blackmail the union government. Being your brother from UP, I urge MP brothers to never fell for South Indian trap. Freight equilisation was a thing which we should never forget.
Hindi is not a native language of any place in India.. It was a language assembled from arabic, farsi, Urdu and north indian native languages. A cocktail is made and was names hindi. This was basically used by the construction labourerers, coolies and road layers of the 16 century communicate with the mughal high ranking officers as they understood only Arabic and Farsi. Initially for 100 years it's was only in spoken form. Later the devanagari script was stolen and used for hindi. How bad is this. You stole the word kithab (an arabic word for book) and wrote in devanagari and called it hindi foe the past 400 years. And you guys want us to destroy our 50,000 years old tamil telugu kannada with your 400 years old half baked language. Mannnnn this is gross
this doesnt make any sence merely 2-3% people understand odia language in our country 99% of them is from oddisa itself , why should someone learn odia in those state where no one use or understand odia language , again I am not against odia people , I love odia people and their culture but I am stating facts while hindi is understand and used by 60-70% population in India,
Kick out hindi ... Jai karnataka Jai kannada All our South Indian languages have thousand years of heritage.. But hindi even don't have its own script, it uses devanagari. Hindi is a mixture of Persian, hindustani & sanskrit.
@@iii0988ha ha u haven't read the history properly, if you please get time please learn about the legacy of other south indian languages and their rulers too
@@iii0988 you are proven yourself stupid or you should be a hindi guy in disguise, ( who have always benefitted by division of south ) Mr ,the Eastern chalukyas under pulikeshi ruled up to godavari in North and our rashtrakuta dhruv had conquered kannauj ,rashtrakuta krishna l built ellora's Kailasa monument which is one and only monolithic rock cut temple to be built top down . Vijaya nagara Kings had ruled entire Tamil nadu by making the Kings their as subordinates . Learn history properly.
Hindi was defense against arabic script and language, Hindi is local language of small part of UP with heavy sankritization and devnagari script. To compete with persian with arabic words and script. We were never fighting tamil. Hindi won by 1 and persian lost by 0 . This is essence of hindi hindu hindustan movement. When this was happening south was only serving british masters whose English they love so much .
People from North India come down South for Jobs, Let them learn 4 South Indian Languages apart from English & come to South India for jobs, instead of asking US to learn Hindi for their livelihood !!
In Bengaluru why you go yo malls, hotels, Market, shop vendors, only delivery, food delivery everywhere filled with up, Biharis, nepalis. Bengaluru is won't feel like a kannada city. If you know hindi people servey more compare to kannada. Idk when our people will wake up, our Government is not doing anything for local Kannadigas.
All PSUS & central government offices , the employees are indirectly forced to learn hindi. All circulars are in hindi & English only , waste of papers & printing charges. Even hindi speaking people are not using hindi forms & application forms. unnecessary waste of printing expenses.
hindi definitely work as bridge between people from different state, language and culture , this is a fact, no one is forcing you to learn hindi in fact you guys force north Indians to learn your language, we also respect local language but this doesn't means you will force us to learn Kannada, India have so many local language how can you expect from someone to learn completely new language from sketch when people generally switch their location and city in every 2-3 years, are you really expecting them to learn completely new language in every 2-3 years, why only south people have hatred toward north indians , come in our up ayodhya where we have mention all sign boards in Kannada and tamil as well for south devotees but you kannada and tamil people are filled with hatred towards own people, you guys treat north indians as outsiders
Hindi is nothing but Urdu written in Nagiri script. It is just a broken Persian brought to Indian sub-continent by the Mogul invaders. Hindi is not having any root words of its own or any grammar. Learning Hindi will limit ones potential.
Hindi is an Indo European language which is not rooted in India. Kannada is a proper Indian rooted language which has a history of more than 2500 years. Hindi is not even a classical language. We are proud of Kannada. No need of Hindi in Karnataka
Karnataka standing with Tamilnadu in state rights is heart-warming to our brotherhood. Of course we have issues but these wont separate us. I think we south Indians need to make peaceful compromise to stand united against north Indians who's always trying to loot our rights for thousands of years throughout history. 💪
❤ you are very lucky you have great leadership. We Gujarati are very late to save our language. See when any foreign tourists come to India and struggle to communicate with local people. They say sorry to locals for that but Hindi bhashi, They believe just ruin others culture values. They like drinking Gaumutra and expect to others to same.
@@akashpadmanabhanl2270 Language i top most national issue -- every one needs langauge for Jobs .. There is no need for BIHARI clerical staff in rural Karnataka in Nationalized bank .. We have betetr colelge betetr talent here -- Banking exam in HINDI made this possible -- We need all central government exam in Kannada as well
@@spg6651and here we have state level racism within the same country. Wow. Language could be implemented, however hatred based on states, so unnecessary.
Look what happened to Soviet Union? They wanted all states within the Union to speak , write and do business in Russian. They forced it in people. But in the end, Soviet Union fell apart and most of its erstwhile states became Russia's staunch enemies. Coercing someone to talk other than their native language always ends up in disaster - not union
Same reason why Bangladesh separated from Pakistan because Pakis wanted everyone to speak Urdu. But these arm-chair nationalists and the Hindi lunatics can't learn anything from history.
Agreed with you, but that was not the only reason for the breakup. The people in the erstwhile republics were fed up of communism being forced down their throats, other than the language issue
@@FinalBoss-ey7xethen you must learn the case studies of Urdu imposition of East Pakistan leading to Bangladesh formation and also the case of Discrimination of Sri Lankan Tamils leading to Sri Lankan civil war. Language is an integral part of a culture and playing with it will invite brutal consequences.
I am a rajasthani and I live in bangalore since 2 years. I am in full support of learning the state language and am against hindi imposition. I speak hindi and rajasthani with only my family members and speak kannada and english with everyone else. Services should always focus on convenience of the people paying for it, locals should be able to access it in the comfort of their own mother tongue. That is what true unity in diversity will be, when diverse employees are hired to cater to diverse consumers, not forcing hindi speaking employees and inconveniencing the locals they are meant to help.
In karnataka why we need to speak in hindi...let those come to my land speak kannada.....if they cant learn n speak let them go whereever they wants to leave....
I am from Karnataka, this is true from my 7th standard to till date I am in my post graduation every bank manager who came talked in Hindi , our fishermen , farmers , rural women always needed a mediator to speak , whenever I went to bank most of the time I was their mediator. Nowadays even manager as well as assistant managers both are Hindi or malayalam speakers we are at pathetic condition
Kashmir and Manipur is not enough!? Want another issue!? 😢 just leave it however it is.. Hindi is not national language.. Hindi people add peanut to the economy of India but eat the bulk.
Hindi is nothing but Urdu written in Nagiri script. It is just a broken Persian brought to Indian sub-continent by the Mogul invaders. Hindi is not having any root words of its own or any grammar. Learning Hindi will limit ones potential.
As a Tamizhalan we have been fighting against Hindi Imposition many decades now, slowly other non-Hindi speaking states are waking upto. We have been fighting against NEET hope other states don't take decades to understand and start supporting us. When I joined Indian Air Force in the 90's I had limited knowledge of Hindi and many often I get comments that I'm unpatriotic when in reality I was giving prime of my age serving in the military while most of my college mates were happily getting their Green cards in US. While in Air Force academy I was chatting with my batchmate and he said during the interview he informed them he has difficulty in English so will reply in Hindi this made me think how the system has been rigged against Non-Hindi speaking states, to me learning Hindi would be same as learning English but I don't have the choice of responding in Tamil. How many would have lost their opportunity because of this.
If i got a job in Bombay i will definitely learn hindi. Same should be the case for people in other states. Moreover no language in India is upto the mark as english as far as science is concerned. If this idea is followed India will be united. If a mumbaikar comes to TN he should be willing to learn tamil.
@@proudindian-73Marathi speakers have lost their identity to hindi speaker, what percentage of people don't accept hindi in mumbai and wants to speak in Marathi?
This is what utter ignorance is. If you get a job in Mumbai, by your logic you should learn Marathi, not Hindi. The era of the permanent private job location is gone. In your 35 years of professional life you don't know how many locations you have to change. 25 Northern states use Hindi as common while 4 southern states use English as a common language. Yes, Hindi native speakers will get an advantage, but isn't it the same with English as well? Look, no issue in learning an additional southern language, but language should be common to all 4 southern states. Make it happen and ten complain.
Yes!!! 100%. Mass migration into Bangalore has economically progressed but culturally becoming disastrous!! We have more or less lost our culture in the city. It doesn’t feel home anymore and feel like we are invaded culturally and destroyed!!!! It’s very sad!!! Especially when we see hindu arrogance around us!!! It’s painful. An ancient rich culture went to the dogs in the name of development and democracy!!!
@@shashikalanarayan585 edit you first comment..First... And most importantly no one speaks Hindi in this nation You ppl also hate Sanskrit..? Or consider it to be yours.?
@@SHU-be2lrhindhu is not equal to hindhi. all non abrahamic religions in india come under hindhuism. south indians have their own religions too, ofcourse tats under hindhuism. some of us have scriptures in our own language. get some basics before posting such bs
Very well explained. It should be an eye opener to see the bias that local language speaking people face. That's why local people are not getting employment.
@@VibesCheck00 our tamil language in world wide reached but you hindi ? Hindi is paani poori language only paani poori ppl only accept hindi national language says . Joke 🤣 our tamil language 5000 years old but you hindi 🤣
I noticed that normal workers like chef, cooks, vendors, sellers etc from other state people especially Hindi speakers learn local language and speak but these corporate workers have egoistic behaviour with not even trying to learn local language. We in TN never support imposing Hindi and will stick to it. As if everyone is coding in hindi.
@@sanatanihindu383 sanskrit Indo-European language not indian language you go anywhere search research it the history it's also not indian language europian migrated people's language
I am from Maharashtra... I know marathi, hindi, Gujrati, and odia... Because I lived in those state..as a Doctor. ....so I have to learn...not fluent...but broken... So In my openion everyone who is working in other state should learn the native language...even though you would be not fluent...but public will appreciate....❤❤❤ India is diverse nation.. nobody can impose anything on anyone... Common people appreciate... In our Ordinance Factory colony Maharashtra , we all lived in quarters , and our neighbours are from different state.. My mom used to talk in Marathi and my Neighbour talk in talgu, hindi, Tamil, and they at last understand each other...thats India...😂😂😂 And never had any quarrels And we want that India...No Hate on language, religion,caste ...
learning native language is not possible sir, I am it engineer I always move to different places in every 2 to 3 years how can someone expect me to learn totally new language from sketch in every 2 to 3 years
I am not Kannadiga but Hyderabadi. I believe Central even trying to destroy the Bangalore and trying to create new Silicon valley. Everyone knows which state they would select. Either Gujarat or UP. They don't even care about South. I haven't seen CM of Gujarat or UP went abroad to attract investments. But centre supporting them immensely to establish industries and service sector.
Let them go to hell, but let them leave us alone. We Kannadigas know how to get our investments with English as our trade language and Kannada as our state language.
😂😂😂 South Indian cry babies, you people are really good at baby crying and blaming others. If you South Indians were really good then investments would be coming to South India rather than Gujarat and UP
you are totally wrong, the environment of Banglaore is so toxic and ruined by cheap language-based politics, local people treat north indians as outsiders, people are now hesitating to come to Karnataka, which will result into the movement of companies from Karnataka to other state, for example recently congress government in karnatak proposed 100% reservation for kannada people in all private jobs, what do you think what will happen if these type of policies are applied in karnatak, people will leave bangalore to other state then companies will also move out of Bangalore to different state, Kannada people are responsible for upcoming downfall of bangalore
@@sanatanihindu383lowda they're hesitating 😂. Even for public toilets maintenance of Karnataka, Bimaru guys are coming from 2000kms. Always busy in communal fights and using our maryadaha purshottama Ram's name for politics without focusing on job creation and development.
Bravo Kannadigars, India is a union of states NOT vassal states of North India. All culture is important for its people and all languages have equal staus. How can one language become superior and imposed on others? If you want to make one language make it Kannada all over India. Keep your Hindi Hindu Hindia for yourself only. It is not welcomed here.😢
Don't impose english by calling it a neutral language. India's literacy rate was less than 20% before independence, out of that very little English. It's the southern states who took our minerals under freight equalization policy and imposed english on us.
Bruh I hate hindi too because of it our Bhojpuri is considered a dialect of hindi even though Bhojpuri has kaithi script and There are Many other Langauges Which lose to hindi 😢 There is more 23 Langauges but goverment is foolish to understand it
❤ Till now, I cannot read Hindi. I started learning spoken Hindi only by watching Sharukh movies. Any language comes when you are desperate to communicate and I also learnt, initially Bengali and then Hindi. Once tou learn Hindi, your ability to learn more languages, especially regional languages, comes down. Imposing the reading and writing of Hindi is absolutely an undemocratic practice, especially to those who are not literate in the language.
Dear sir north labours are coming here more only last 10 years only. If you want create opportunities and keep your labours with. We know how to protect our language and culture which we are doing even before independence. Keep your rubbish language with you we have not asked anyone to teach any alien language to us.
Hypocrisy of kannada people they will hate bjp or Hindi speaking people but at the same time the great Karnataka state makes compulsory Urdu learning in anganwadi
@@mayankthakur-p9g Hindi is nothing but Urdu written in Nagiri script. It is just a broken Persian brought to Indian sub-continent by the Mogul invaders. Hindi is not having any root words of its own or any grammar. Learning Hindi will limit ones potential.
Iam from Karnataka & it's not possible to accept Hindi as our national language.Our identity is Indian & Kannada should be given priority in Karnataka.
Hindi is nothing but Urdu written in Nagiri script. It is just a broken Persian brought to Indian sub-continent by the Mogul invaders. Hindi is not having any root words of its own or any grammar. Learning Hindi will limit ones potential.
I don't know why we in south of India are lerning 3 languages, when UPs and Biharis are learning only 2 languages ànd getting jobs in Railways easily,.😶
Are you going to pay us for freight equilisation.. every finance minister is a Tamilian, are you going to take back your Tamilians? We never complain about those things, so it's better if you will not complain about stupid things.
Bro I am from Bihar we have 3 languages in school 3rd one is Sanskrit. Initially the plan was to keep one southern language as the third language but it never got implemented.Instead schools opted for sanskrit/urdu because teachers were available for those language. Anyway In this era of tech we need to focus on translation tools Just simple.
I am okay with Hindi taught in all states of India, only if Hindi speaker state are taught either one South Indian or North Eastern Language. This will level all of them. No fight over language will solve issue permanently. Let them choose any either one South Indian or North Eastern Language than its absolutely fine for me to learn Hindi in schools.
I am not kannadiga but these north people are surely entitled and think everyone should know Hindi. Sorry Hindi is not even an ancient language of India. It is just a recently developed language. In the past we had Prakrit, Pali and Sanskrit.
Hindi is nothing but Urdu written in Nagiri script. It is just a broken Persian brought to Indian sub-continent by the Mogul invaders. Hindi is not having any root words of its own or any grammar. Learning Hindi will limit ones potential.
Both national parties are fond in imposing Hindi. I mean, look at their tweets and social media handles, 70% of the time it's only Hindi Hindi Hindi. Better for South India to vote regionalist
Regional Language- Required for communication within a region English- required for communication with the world Hindi- For what? If you can't learn English, why should we learn Hindi?? Why do we need a small door for the small dog and a big door for big dog??
They are saying when a Tamilian speaks with a Bengali they both should speak in Hindi with each other instead of English because of "cultural" reasons😂
@@tsMuthuraman-hm6wg They feel we should only use everything Bharatiya including the language we speak. What about cricket, mobile phones, internet, jeans etc? The hypocrisy is very funny😂
Like Pooja’s LME show? Become a subscriber: www.thenewsminute.com/subscription
Or contribute to our reporting fund: rzp.io/l/reporting-fund
please make a video on damagundam mass deforestation project by indian navy .. 12 lakh trees are gettiing deforested!!!
I have three reservations:
1. You are willing to accept English which is a foreign language than any of the Indian Language. bravo what a solution. Also do you think all the villagers of south where banks post offices are situated will understand English. We also face even being a Hindi speaking challenge while travelling . In our villages we have South Indian people posted who doesn’t speak their native language and tuti footi Hindi but we do not ask them to leave or learn Maithili, bhojpuri Bengali etc.
2. Madam for North India even Hindi is not a native language to all the states and people around. However Hindi has been originated from the same root from which languages like Bengali Nepali Punjabi Merathi have their roots so for all the native North Indians it is easy to understand and speak Hindi. Comparatively South Indian languages have originated from different roots and south India also have several languages hence we cannot even if we want to learn and speak these languages. But supposedly you people are actually opposing Hindi for sake of opposing only. If you dig into origination of Hindi it was not even a native language of any of the North Indian states it have been developed in course of time for having a common language.
3. Do you really think that bank and civil servants will be posted only in Kanndda/tamil/Telugu speaking area they will not be transferred to other places. What if a person speaking Kannada only transferred to malyali speaking area. Your culture will not get hamper ? How he will manage to communicate. On top of that even southern states have many languages apart from these 4 languages and have several dialects.
Madam the problem will remain and will be managed the way it has been managed till now. diminishing languages is a problem and it is there in North as well for which we should take some measures but the way you people are reacting is not going to solve anything this is called Ego.
@@Frfirex Do you know the extent of hastinapur or as you call Bharatvarsh in those times?
MahaBharat specifically says land where black buck roams is Aryavart--the bishnoi gangs are given importance coz of that.
Rest of India--South, N.East, Punjab+Kashmir(the undivided one), Bihar, Awadh, Bengal(the undivided one) is mlecha land.
@@Frfirex That and definition in Epic Mahabharat are different.
if giving reference of mahabharat, then stick to it. Otherwise mention republic of India.
@@Frfirex Stop living in your pathetic bubble, get out more and travel the world.
You might learn--you and your language are not the centre of universe.
north indian never respect regional languages while working in south india .But south indian are force to learn Hindi while working in north india
South Indians are soft -- Allow north Indians sit on ur head and that is the problem -- Push back on same coin .. There are some tools .. Start talking in Kannada every where including 5 star hotel -- Do not ask " do you know Kannada" -- If they do not know kannada speak in ENGLISH ( high class English with tough english words ) .. let the other guy feel bad .. I have tried this -- it works -- HINDI People respect English ..
Blah blah... Not all North indian speak hindi
lol nobody is forced to speak Hindi or regional language..have some Mallu friends born and brought up in Ahmedabad. They have been living there for years, still can't speak 10 sentences in Gujarati, he or his family never faced any issue there.
@IndianTamil-b6eLol!
No language should be made the National Language of India be it Sanskrit or Tamil.
Do you want to change the Constitution by making Sanskrit as the National Language of India?
@@sohailkhan-un8fc - Blah Blah you North Indians speak Hindi = Urdu
Two languages are sufficient: 1 - Mother tongue; 2 - English - Communicate with wider world (including other parts of the country and outside the country)....This gives maximum benefit with minimal time spent on learning other languages....
@@bsoundharajan1830 3 language system should be brought.. First regional language, 2nd cultural language like Sanskrit and 3rd English which should be optional..
Maximum benefit is not should be our goal.. Our goal should be decolonization.. If not then this slave mentality will remain for eternity
@@SHU-be2lryou want to take indians backward. colonization gives jobs and economic growth
mandarine and japan gives economic growth why should we leanr languages that dont give economic growth
@@vsansanv29101_sd I don't think you understand the meaning of imposition here.. But imposing you are also Imposing that language in working sector... Just like Japan has imposed Japanese in working sector instead of English...
@@SHU-be2lr - Nobody wants a dead language, if you want one it's ur choice to learn. Non Hindi speakers don't want Hindi or Sanskrit.
@@SHU-be2lrlearning sankrit is waste.Its a dead language. Only 2 languages are inof
Finally...non Tamils are opening their eyes...so far only we Tamils were taking the bullet for the welfare of the country.
Giving special status is a blunder.
Hindi is not unifying India. It is diving India. Non Hindi speakers are termed as anti nationals.
🎉🎉🎉
Don't be so quick to give yourself credit. Tamilians cause as much problem in Bengaluru as North Indians do. Some nonsense about ancient language and you look down upon all other languages. There is NOTHING special about Tamil and you are also pushing your ordinary language on other people. FIrst learn that and then you can take credit for fighting back Hindi imposition.
when you are ruled by fake patriots or terrorists being called antinational by them is supposed to be a medal of honour!
Lawde, it was telgu people who first demanded language based state.
@sudeepkumar3310 you telugus still speak urudu in Hyderabad. Your answer is irrelevant to the topic under discussion. Of the south Indians hindi is spoken most among telugus
First tamilnadu, now Karnataka. Lets go🎉
Soon Telugu states will Join 💪
@@జైతెలుగు yup too much already happened . Hyderabadis are too delusional that everyone in Telangana speak Urdu and Telugu. Except Hyderabad no one knows urdu and hindi in Telangana or amdhra. it's time to implement strict telugu in these states.
Please fight otherwise north Indians will destroy your language just like they did in our goa @@జైతెలుగు
Support From Gujarat... I wish Our Leaders were like Southern States That would oppose Hindi, Migrant have not learned our language and expect locals to speak with them in Hindi in all nationalized banks. Hindi is foreign language to us
@@AndhraTiger-b8q Nuve chepu
Hindi is not our national language
@IndianTamil-b6e Kannada is from the times of Sumerian civilization.
@IndianTamil-b6eno dude. English is the national language. Even you write your comments in english. 😂
@IndianTamil-b6enut job.
@@Jesssco: It is only Official language. You better Google it and know.
@IndianTamil-b6e Kannada has similarity with Sumerian Language with is 5000BCE which is older than Sanskrit. We have won military victories in Bihar Nepal Iraq Sudan Cambodia. We have achieved a lot more than anybody else, so Kannada & English should be national language of India.
Hindi is neither our national language or nor my mother tongue...then why should I accept it?
Because Modi knows only Hindi.😂😂
@@Nawongyonten-yp4fz and Gujarati
@@Jeebs544 And a bit of Teleprompter English.
😂😂😂 @@dip-tree
@@dip-tree 🤣
Hindi imposition should be unacceptable to every state who has its own culture. Kashmir should oppose it too
@IndianTamil-b6e not Tamil, only Sanskrit.
@@dli6651 nice joke
@@raghuls1515 it's reality. Others reality is always a joke for goons and fake show offs.
@@dli6651 invaders have no rights to talk about the greatest civilisation ..
@@dli6651unfortunately kannada people have became anti hindi because of khangress
Hindi is not our language.
If anybody try to impose on us then who tried to impose we consider them as worst than our enemies and we treat them as worst enemies than Britishers.
Nothing in that statement made sense, but then that is expected from the likes of you.
I support you. I hate Hindi.
From Gujarati.
@@RatnaMaharaj so you hell bent to push your persian language down our throats and destroy our 3000 years old language and culture and treat us like second grade citizens.
Shame on you. We will never let it happen.
Yeah cause you consider Britishers as your papas..
I'm not saying this to make you accept Hindi cause I'm also against Hindi imposition...
I'm saying this to show your slave mentality
@IndianTamil-b6eit's ironic to see how much they hate Sanskrit.. Yet they still have names in Sanskrit.. And those British slave who have their name changed like Stalin still keeping alive divide and rule legacy of Britishs
Hindi has lot of influence from arabic and Persian..So the ppl who are arguing English as a foreign language, even hindi is a foreign language developed during delhi sultanate and Mughal era.. so if Mughal and delhi sultanate were invaders so is Hindi a foreign language..Sad part is north india lost its language and culture long back, south indians wants to preserve it and will preserve it
Not Punjab. Punjabi is withstanding up to now, at least.
Sorry, Hindi is a derivative of Khariboli or the Kauravi language that is native to Delhi, upper West UP, North Haryana and the Southern plans of Uttarakhand. It is a descendant of Shauraseni Prakrit, the same Prakrit that has given birth to Punjabi, Haryanvi, Braj, Bundeli and Kannauji.
@@brar1320 PUNJABI will be spoken till this earth exists.
It will never die down. God promise!
It is also said that hindi is a corrupted version of Urdu.
Hindi is not native to any parts of Uttarakhand .Uttarakhand just has huge migration of Up people@@gaurangkarmakar4046
As the Tamilnadu minister said, dont pull us down to Hindi, level up to speak English. One should be blessed to speak Kannada, unfortunately, many don't realize this.
Ok. Speak English then. Migrants in Bengaluru know English. But the Kannada goons don't. Migrants already know 3 languages. But locals refuse even to learn 2 language.
@@rajx7120 if you stay in Karnataka, it's your responsibility to learn the local language not the locals responsibility to learn your language. It's the same everywhere, if I stay in Delhi, I don't expect them to speak kannada or english.
@@nandishnan5680 If I don't see any Kannadiga around me, then why should I learn Kannada, and why should you be worried, what two random strangers are speaking? I am not asking you to stop speaking Kannada. I just have no need, and you can't force me.
@@rajx7120 it's the same way, you can't force locals to speak ur language, kannada is what they speak, for example my mom doesn't speak any other language other than kannada, in bank people expect her to speak Hindi. How fair is that. Video is all about hindhi imposition, I don't have any advantage learning hindi, instead I can learn German Spanish. It's only making local life tough, that's what the video tells.
@@nandishnan5680 Hindi is not my language. If you don't like Hindi, then atleast know English. Migrants already know 3 languages. You are asking them to learn a 4th while refusing to learn a 2nd.
Honestly, we speak Kannada only at home. Nowhere even vegetable vendor, petrol station everywhere nobody understands kannada. Im a foreigner in my own city!!!! Disgusting!!!
Start speaking Kannada every where -- MALL / 5 star hotel / PVR cinemas / Airport etc.. Do not hesitate .. Just speak normally -- If the other gu y does not understand use ENGLISH / never use HINDI .. I tried this -- It works
@@spg6651Speak kannada everywhere it will work if required use English but no hindi it will work, they will definitely know the language trust me
I know, that's the sad part in Bangalore. U know that, Kannadigas problem is Kannadigas only. They speak Hindi and lost their ground. I am Tamil. This was not the case 15 years back, now North Indians took over the City and Hindi has become a kind of official language in Bangalore. Karnataka having a population of 6.7 crores why people are not coming for job to Bangalore. Be it IT or labor or delivery job hardly there are Kannadigas in Bangalore.
Ironically, this is what tamizhians have been saying forever, while being accused of being regionalistic and narrow minded lol Whatever you may say, and they may have their drawbacks but TN people are clear about who they are and what's acceptable to them. You reap what you sow. Being "cosmopolitan" shouldn't come at the cost of forgetting your identity. If language goes, then culture goes too. When you suppress your natural identity in order to look more modern, it leads to resentment and division in the long run.
@@santhoshc86 it’s funny to hear from you this brother .. sorry .. but you go to Ulsoor, jogupalya , Cox Town, Frazer Town,dodda Banaswadi, Thippasandra and HAL you will see people responding in Tamil when you talk to them in Kannada ..
This is what we were doing from 1960s in TN
You have DMK. We have idiot RSS Sanghi. Difference between TN and Gujarat. You are growing and we are losing.
Correction from 1930s
@@williamsatish25 you don't even have a native name.. Lmao 😂
@@MrBharanish I am unaware of this, can you share more information published from the archives ???
இல்லை சகோ.. 1920 களில் சமசுகிருதம் கலக்காத தனித் தமிழ் இயக்கம் (மறைமலை அடிகள், தேவநேயப் பாவாணர்) . 1960 ல் ஹிந்தி, 1990 ஆல்கிலக் கலப்பு, இப்போது மீண்டும் ஹிந்தி....
People should learn from tamils on preserving language & culture..
Yes very true
Especially malayalees.
Same way english has been impossed on us. Its not even our local language, most of the time student memories the concept instead of understanding bcz of English imposition. We are not allowed to give interview in hindi, if we speak then they look down on us. Majority of india 🇮🇳 speaks, understand hindi despite of their local language so "Hindi " is a uniting language . Why most of famous and popular youtubers are making videos in hindi ? We north indians 🇮🇳 don't fight with each other for language, we also have our own state language and we respect each others reigional language and speak in hindi to understand each other while a person from tamil nadu can't talk with person from Kerala or karnataka (except if they speak in English) . U expect people who goes to south india to speak ur language from day 1 ? If u force them they will not learn but naturally they will addopt to local language. I support 3 language implementation in schools (Hindi , english, religional language)
Yes, we are all aware of what the Tamils have done in the past decades. If anything is to be learned from that, it is that we should try our best to be unlike the Tamils.
@@sanjaychauhan1116majority of your north Indian must not come South. We love English
It’s ironic how the Prime minister and home minister struggle to convey their ideas in English interviews and yet they cannot empathise with the struggle of communicating in an unfamiliar language.
If English is more familiar of a language to you than Hindi, it is a clear example of how this nation has failed.
@@RatnaMaharajyour nehru created failed because of hindi
@@IvanMend I've heard better English from a from a drunk monkey that fell off a horse.
@@RatnaMaharajRahna Maharaj ji..our ancient Indian android with Devnagari software is still untraceable. Also our google and RUclips and the motor vehicles you travel in land, air and sea. Lets move forward ' Vasudaiva Kudumbakam'.
@@subysb9616 bro wut. You're cooked.
I stand with South Indian people. I like their policies for saving regional culture. I am a Gujarati. I don't like Hindi. I wish my state becomes like South Indian. Hindi is important for RSS Sanghi. So they want to impose it. We have to oppose it.
👍🏻
Your state people is the number 1 problem creators in india.
Gujarat hindi both same family
Almost same language
Very easy for u guys learn Hindi
Hindi also helpful for north Indian states
South Indias choose english because South Indian language very different
@@tsunami3880but Kannada has Sanskrit and shudh Hindi words they speak better than other South Indians why this hate
Once upon a time a Gujarati led us to freedom. Now the same Gujaratis are destroying India through mega scams and hindutva fascism.
Only you. Not all Tamils.@IndianTamil-b6e
Why should I learn hindi since I have my own language as mother tongue
In Northern India we learn 3 languages Hindi, English and Sanskrit. What you learn as a 3rd language?
@@riteshmahawarSanskirt= a dumb and useless language that serves no purpose in day to day life. What kind of idiot are you?
Why do we need another burden Hindi ?@@riteshmahawar
Sanskrit is a dead language.. what is the use of learning that?? @@riteshmahawar
@@rockjn in Rajasthan Sanskrit is the 3rd language, I may learn another like Sindhi, Punjabi , Marathi, Gujrati if I were born there. I mean we learn 3 languages why don't you
Is it true north India is one of the most backward region in the whole world ? Is Hindi being imposed so that north Indians can get employment in progressive south ?
Parts of north Bharat are indeed backwards, then there are parts of north Bharat that way ahead of almost all of south Bharat. Apples and Oranges.
@@RatnaMaharajYes, apples and oranges are the boost for the Indian economy and it Amounts to 75% of GDP.
@@kddraco333 is everyone just as cooked as you in the south? I've been to the south many times, and most people aren't as F'd as you. I hope there is still hope for Dakshin Bharat.
💯
Northindia Also a 3 world 😂
We Tamils stand for KANNADA in Karnataka, one of the Dravidian Languages.
😂😂😂😂saar
Dear Lenin, one keralite female CA died due to overwork, the comments said by one person of South India descent in Delhi was just sad.
@@VibesCheck00Hello British Rani.😂
Saaar kaveri river is ours saaar...
@@c-zanasu5749 Saar, we Hindiwala prefer to poop on train tracks instead of toilet ;)
In today's world English is probably only language that will takes us ahead.
England is a dying country.
This is another nonsense reasoning, that does not have any self-respect or dismisses there is a nature's purpose in having diversity. Go read science literature of why linguistic-diversity is better for having diversity of thought/ideas. Any monoculture language/crop/any will have higher penalty on life thats why nature creates diversity.
Well said.
North indians call English a foreign language. But for south states Hindi is more foreign than English. We are not even culturally close to hindi compared to English. We watch more content in English than in Hindi - bollywood is on the decline, i don't remember the last time i watched a hindi movie. Hindi is the foreign language for us
That's called colonial mindset@@doncorleone3901
Karnataka should start two language policy in schools with immediate effect
Tulu in Mangalore and udpi, kannada in Bangalore
@@nielsbohr4299 also beary, konkani in mangalore and udupi as they form 60% in those districts.
Tamilnadu two language policy start at 1967. The great Tamil leader
C.N Annadurai 🗿🗿🗿
@@nielsbohr4299 We support Tulu language. Tulu experts should come up with a syllabus and curriculum.
You guys hate Sanskrit too..?
People need to ask the question Why Hindi? Conducting state level competitive and entrance exams in Hindi is a gross injustice to the locals. Why we shy away from cultural & Linguistic diversity is just beyond me.
Some people don't value languages
even central level .. What is so speacil about HINDI ?
we can ask them all we want but the bjp is arrogant and will not respect or respond and will continue to do as they wish
@@praveenpayiran BJP is trying to impose Hindi today. But Congress is the one who started itm The things is, Nehru and others were big time fanbois of the USSR. And they copied their policies as well. 5yr plans, one language for the union etc were all directly pulled from the Soviet Union playbook.
And look what happened to them. Those guys pushed Russian everywhere like current govt is pushing Hindi everywhere. It will only lead to more disunity.
@@praveenpayiran Congress is also arrogant. Rahul Gandhi's granny was the epitome of arrogance.
I will speak in hindi in only states like up bihar where hindi is the local language...and sameway if hindi speaking persons come in karnataka, they should speak in either kannada or in English...
See .. The day I have to code and write office emails in Kannada I will quit my job.
Speak kannada in Karnataka or move out @@jaspreetmatharu3499
True
@@jaspreetmatharu3499😅 feel sad for u bro.kya se kya ho gaya..
@@jaspreetmatharu3499 And you can write those code and emails in Hindi?
FYI-F Hindi--from another Punjabi.
South India states, should unite and remove hindi in these states completely
This mentality shows you hate Hindi and there is no other reason why you don't bear Hindi. More than 70% of the population in india knows Hindi, Hindi is 3rd largest language in the world. Who the hell are you to remove hindi 😂
South India should have its own central government. All the union government does is loot our taxes and barely gives back anything in return while overfeeding the useless states that serves as their precious votebanks and then have the gall to try and shove their language down our throats as well.
Other Non-Hindi states too--esp North. We dont want to associate ourselves with illiterate goons of UP and Bihar.
@@yourend3177 it's too late to save your languages. You are half to almost dead. unlike South, other non hindi speaking states have already allowed hindi to the extent that it has fully taken over and destroyed local language. For example maithali, Bhojpuri, bihari, Chattisgarh, garhwali, dogri and indigenous tribal have all been wiped out. Languages like Marathi, Bengali, rajasthani have suffered severe erosion. In all these Hindi media, Hindi cinema, Hindi literature and all the Hindi things have replaced local languages. S
@@EriOliyanVaenthi I don't about them but I am from Punjab.
Punjab and Kashmir do not and will never accept Hindi.
Gov tries to impose it--some years back it was English.
But none works in long run. People here do not accept things imposed on them. They will change from within and by themselves if they feel change is required.
We never accepted any religion imposed on us(goes for all religions here, languages and cultures for 2000 years now. 75 years of India rule can change us? Nope. 80's and 90's in Punjab and Kashmir never changed people here. You think BJP rule can change us? NOPE!
As for Hindi and Hindi speakers--they already have the worst reputation in the world and in this part of India--frankly hated.
So we are with South as regards to Hindi imposition.
We will never accept Hindi--EVER!!!
Not even Urdu, Persian(under Mughal rule), Pashto and Dari(under Afghan invasions),English(under British rule) could change us. And they were autocratic. You think cowbelt can change us?LOL.
Hindi is not needed for Indian patriotism. The world is globalized now. So English as common language and states language for local is enough.
English is a neutral language and the only language for common communication.
People arguing that English is a foreign language, please note that Hindi is also a foreign language brought to India by moguls and sultans.
This is what happens when people gain education in the Indian system. 0 brain cells detected. "Hindi is also a foreign language brought to India by moguls and sultans" - read it again.
@@manjunathgowdara3101 Moreover, English has been Indianized to the point that there exists Indian accent English now, and which is recognized world over.
What does neutral language mean? Don't create your own definition. Hindi is a pure India-originated language.
English as a communicating language is ok as it provides a sort of neutral ground. Hindi is actually closer to English and has many similar roots. Although hindi speakers will get a slightly unfair advantage, English is the best option available. In banking and other sectors English with communicable local language should be made compulsory.
@@sanjayk3170 Learn something before you spew utter garbage.
Kannada with English is more than enough. Hindi is required if one wants to move to North India.
most of the locals in north indian don't understand proper hindi. it only exist in text books, northindian commoners have language their ancestors spoke for 1000 years. hindi came only after 1880
So if a north Indian who does not speak Kannada and English is laying down on your road crying for help - U will not help him unless he speaks in Kannada. Asks your Deepika to get out of the Hindi film industry. She is not needed.
@@tanujaphadke8219 Y should she ? She speaks hindi , she respects the language unlike ignorant north indians.There are more northies working in south film industry than south indians working in Bollywood.
@@tanujaphadke8219 in hathras a hindi speaking girl was raped and killed. hindi speaking police freed the culprit and set fire on body of the victim without knowledge of her family. amnd those neighbours and people around defended the criminals and spread derogatory lies about the victim. i can assure you that Hindi speakers will get better help from the south than the castist North.
@@tanujaphadke8219 Ask them to learn few basics in Kannada
we hardly speaks Hindi in nagaland
Good, that is self esteem.
Yes but many of us can understand and speak hindi. That doesn't mean we would be happy if they start imposing their foreign language and culture on us.
That's Great. Keep the spirit.
@IndianTamil-b6e - Sanskrit is dead, man. Nobody is going to learn that. Why are you pushing Sanatana here? What is your profession? Are you ready to change your caste based on your job as per Sanatana darma? Summa inga vandhu kathikitu
No one speak hindi in manipur 😂
Hindi imposition means unfair treatment to 60% of Indian population. Language is not merely a mode of communication. Govt must understand this. Language is root of the community since ancient times, their culture, identity, thought process. Just bec Hindi speaking is majority ie 40%. One can not impose that on others . Unjust.....
I have been to the border with China in Arunachal Pradesh. In this corner of the world, where they couldn't any more different from the population of the rest of Bharat, they spoke in fluent Hindi with me, with large smiles on their faces. In fact, 70-80% of the population of this country is able to find work very easily simply due to the fact that they speak the language that connects this nation - Hindi.
No amount of seething will change that fact.
@@RatnaMaharajSouth money wasying to save Himalayas
@@IvanMend you need to understand the fact that southern Bharatiyas are not a martial people. They have never been martial people. They have always been protected by the "naarthies" from the Huns, the Pashtuns, the Turks, the Iranis and various others, and now from the Chinese Hans.
Never forget the fact that Madras was the first land to fall into the hands of the British, by a huge margin.
@@RatnaMaharaj most courageous are Kerala and Tamil people. Your north Indian raped by turks Uzbekistan etc. no one defeated Travancore.
Ratna Maharaj..my respectful naarthee..hope you read my reply on Pangea, origin of alooparatta you ate. Now plz read about Marthanda Varma and Kulachal war with Dutch. India has been colonized by Portugal and France too. Read about Samoothiri, kunjalimarakkar, Keezhadi etc
Also kalaripayattu, silambam. Madrasis fell to Britishers, but not their culture, moral values and language.
Recently there was a case in Canara Bank rural branch SIRA ( 90 KM from THUMKUR ) .. A Farmer came for Tractor loan which is priority sector -- The Bank clerical staff from BIHAR spoke in HINDI only ans started insulting the farmer .. Farmer went to PANCHAYAT head who came and talked to Branach manager and made video viral .. The question is why BIHARI has to come down to rural Karnataka for Bank work ?. since hindi is used for bank exams he could pass it .. Start using Kannada , Kannadiga also will get jobs in Karnataka
I live in a village in Bengal and our SBI branch manager was from Manhaluru. He neither could speak Bengali, nor a workable Hindi nor an understandable English. We were fcked for so many months. Now the new manager is from Bengal and that's a relief.
@@lazy_wolf_unofficialwhat kind of a manager is that 😄😄
@@lazy_wolf_unofficial I don't believe a bank manager from Mangalore could not speak English. May be his accent is unfamiliar to you.
@@dr.jayasankarvn3940 its a rural area, ofcourse his accent will be unfamiliar with rural bengali people.
@@spg6651 Anyway I don't want to insult Bihari. Biharis should first fight for their Bhojpuri language which is very beautiful and start respecting their mother tongue and land. Hindi is not our National language. Don't lose your identity for political reasons and financial gain. Have self respect and do everything to develop your lands and people. Make your NRIs and billionaires set up start-ups in your state. English is a must if you have to excel internationally. In South we will never accept subordination by outsiders.
Pakistan tried to impose Urdu on the Bengali people in erstwhile East Pakistan. It was seen by the locals as attack on their culture. We should learn from history.
But a similar mind-set is prevalent here. An insensitivity that creates further division.
Just talking about business and access to jobs etc...is missing the point.
Kannadigas friends have failed to know the hidden face of RSSBJP...Karnataka will fast proceeding on the path of some lazy divisive backward north-western states....
And those Bengalis tried to impose their language in Assam and Tripura. Remember that too.
@@w.a.4972 it's still being imposed by many Islamic fundamentalist groups.. So what are you yapping?
@@rssiddharth3134 lmao which northwestern state is backwards..? Are you taking about Gujarat..?, Rajasthan..? Or punjab..? Or Haryana? 😂 Lmao
@@rssiddharth3134 it's ironic to see how much you hate hindi Sanskrit.. Yet your name is in Hindi Sanskrit.. May be you should change your name first so it can match your brits papas
Hindi imposition is unacceptable to Bengalees too.
No it's not. Just learn another language. I am a bengali.
@@kousikdutta3279 How much do you know about me? Or how much am I hindi literate?
@@kousikdutta3279 I'm having a feeling that you don't understand the difference between learning and slavery.
Then why did you people try to impose your language here in Assam and also doing the same in Tripura?
@@SlimJim3082 Whoever are doing that are certainly being barbarians. No language, culture, music, literature are greater than any other. I really condemn every such effort. I shall rather like to learn new languages than imposing myself on any other.
Unity not required any language,
Acceept all language
This type of "philosophy" is exactly why this nation has been the dark age since centuries. Thank you for your contribution to this nation's demise. You are a true patriot, an example for that is bad in this nation.
To Ratna maharaj..pz read geography since Pangea. Human evoled to current state of intellect because of absorbing multiple languages and cultures. All Indian languages are huge mix, where the least mixing happened in Tamil. Because of anthropological reasons, lets respect all languages. Next is food. Do you know that wheat is Persian, tomato, chilli and potato are South American? Can you eat only the Indian origin rice, millets and dal three times? A true patriot is the only who invest time selflessly in nations development forward in the globalized world eg. APJA Kalam. We are just wasting on reading comments and reacting to it.
@@subysb9616 do you know when Pangea supposedly split apart? Do you know the difference between a hypothesis and a scientific theory? Do you know that Pangea is accepted in mainstream science only because we don't have enough data with accurate timelines?
Yes, languages are a mix. Hindi is a mix of various languages, but the lion's share comes from Sanskrit, making it the perfect lingua franca for this nation.
Also, we are all aware that potatoes, tomatoes and chilies are from the Americas, but from what I understand "Persian" is from west Asia. Go ahead and correct that comment of yours hahahaha
I only know that current human life to live with able mind is 60-90. So lets maximize and be constructive and productive.
Tell that to your chaiwala PM
Well Done Kannadigas, full support from Maharashtra, Maharashtra is also fighting against Hindi Language, Hindi Language should not be allowed in Non-Hindi speaking states, Marathi people do not like Hindi language as well, Marathi is extremely ancient and a classical language and far far above Hindi language, same goes for the Marathi culture. Maharashtra does not need Hindi language, why go for plastic when you already have gold.
But many times you all take the side of the Northies.
@@banhindipeopleandlanguageMarathi people were the first ones to be at up and ki ck out North Indians from Maharashtra. So from where did you get this nons ense and li es that Marathi people support North Indians sometimes? Marathi culture is closest to Konkani, Kannada and Tulu culture. Marathi and Konkani are literally twins.
@@mangopudding5979bro i have been in Maharashtra but most of the people speaks hindi 😢 even i try to speak in Marathi they respond in hindi basically i am from Karnataka ( northern Karnataka)
Its about attitude, problem is some hindi people showing chauvinism and thinking south india is their property....just say politely you dont know local language and people will help
Politeness does not work .. I tired -- Dadagiri works .. I tried that also
@@spg6651Hindi need sickle and axe not stick
I can personally relate to this. The arrogance at auto drivers not understanding hindi despite them being in Chennai was shocking. Needless to say the driver took her to the wrong place.
Exactly! I am a Tamil who barely understand Kannada and when my auto anna or street vendors speaks in kannada I politely say Sry I dont know Kannada. They wont even show any kind of anger or inconvenience. They speak in Tamil that they know and are very very sweet. I haven't learned Kannada yet coz I am not planning on staying here for long. The culture of Hindi speakers is ruining this city. The diff is very palpable when you go to other cities in Karnataka. When Kannadigas are in majority, the place is sooo much more safe and pretty. Not blaming all Hindi speakers but quite some of them are causing nothing but problms here, be it IT professionals or daily wage workers.
@@tamizhachimadurai3786 True .. I also experienced this.
If Hindi is National Language for them...For me Tamil is the National language and English is the global language ❤ தமிழ் வாழ்க, தமிழ் வளர்க, தமிழ்நாடு வளர்க😊❤ யாதும் ஊரே யாவரும் கேளீர்.... எனது மண் எனது பெருமை - தமிழ் மன்னர்களான சேரன், சோழன், பாண்டியன் வம்சமடா 🐯 🏹🐟
True -- I fully agree
@@Frfirex English gives you job... What Hindi gives you da Panipuri Gutkha boys?
@@Frfirex Our Tamil, Telugu, Kannada, Malayalam is older and has a rich history da and these are older than your so called Hindi🤡... Better give respect
It's ironic to see that you ppl have names in Sanskrit and you hate Sanskrit soo much.. And how you all have rejected that your state never used Sanskrit in past... Nah.. Even Sage Agastha was a Aryan who gave you ppl grace of a beautiful language like Tamil.. Doesn't this makes Tamil and aryan language?
@@SHU-be2lrBy your idiot logic if you use RUclips you should speak English because RUclips is American. What Hindi medium dump did you study in?
For people saying English is a foreign language: Yes, it is and I don't care. There are LOTS and LOTS of things we use which are foreign. Everything from toothbrushes to electric motors to jet engines were invented by the British and are foreign. Just because the British brought English to India, and the British did bad things to us, it doesn't mean that there is something wrong with the English language itself. Nobody is trying to push English down my throat. I learnt it because it is useful. Hindi on the other hand, is not only useless, but is also being forced on us and is dividing India.
English is also forced on us
i never seen more hypocrite man as you in my entire life 😂, you don't have any problem with foreign language but you treat hindi as foreign or outsider language, second this learn some basic history, English is also forced on us , before 16th century no one use english in India
@sid: Why are you typing your comments in English then ??? 😆
@@FinalBoss-ey7xe The impact of the imposition of the English language
You learn English because you like it then why do you get higher education in your own language, in India education from KG to PG is available only in English not in other languages, none of indian no likes to learn English but the government and English speaking intellectuals force them don't want to end English, they don't know what they will do if English ends. India became independent but their dogs are still alive
For us Kannada, Tamil, Telugu, Marathi, Bengali etc., and all other regional languages are more and more important than national language.
What national language ?
What is its history ?
😂😂😂2 plate idli
@@VibesCheck00 One plate pani poori. !
@@tsMuthuraman-hm6wg some black cobra from south selling pani puri in pune 🤣🤣
@@tsMuthuraman-hm6wg black cobra 2 plate pani puri lga aur Idli hath saf karke
ನಾವು ಕನ್ನಡಿಗರು, ಕನ್ನಡವನ್ನು ಹೆಚ್ಚೆಚ್ಚು ಬಳಸಬೇಕು.
Hindi is a foreign language south India languages should be the national language
Shut up and get Lost, I'm Native to Karnataka. Most of us Kanndiga people have no problem with Hindi or Northt Indians, This is Congres inventd Propaganda to stop BJP from having influene in South INdia, THey are playing Divide and Rule.
We are all one India, Bhaarat. We will break thelegs of anyone who dare divide us based on Caste or Langauge.
Why?? Your English is foreign language
@@lipun1531 Hindi is the language of the colonizers just as English is. But English is much more useful these days so it is better to choose English. Hindi was created by the Delhi Sultanate, go and do your own research. The Sultans who hated Hinduism took out as much Sanskrit as possible from the local languages of UP to create Hindi.
Hindi ‘s 90% words are from Uruthu!
@@lipun1531 Hindi is nothing but Urdu written in Nagiri script. It is just a broken Persian brought to Indian sub-continent by the Mogul invaders. Hindi is not having any root words of its own or any grammar. Learning Hindi will limit ones potential.
For hindi speaking people English is a foreign language, for non hindi speaking people both English & hindi are like foreign language as it is not mother tongue.
One of these two languages is a lot more foreign than the other. Also, to be noted, Hindi is not the mother tongue of most Hindi speakers, it is in fact the lingua franca of this nation.
@@RatnaMaharaj india has the second largest English speaking population in that world. Following what you said , we already have a language which everyone can communicate in and it's not Hindi for sure
@@nujjigram,
No, not everyone can communicate with English. Pick a lingua franca/common language for 4 southern states and one for 25 Northern states. It's already a great favour in terms of distribution. It's their choice if they want English or any one out of 4. Kannada itself is an imposition on Tulu and Konkani speakers.
@@Rajan_Rout "no not everyone can speak english". I'm glad you recognise that. Now , let's get you to understand the same about Hindi.
Although it should be pointed out that English is more relevant from an educational and professional stand point. Hindi is not.
All states should have freedom to choose their own language. If a state chooses Hindi, then it's their choice. If southern or eastern states reject it, then it's their choice.
It's getting boring to watch someone from the north constantly tell someone in Bangalore that they should learn Hindi for the sake of the nation.
Southern states have clearly rejected Hindi while NE states have been mixed about it.
@@RatnaMaharajFor southerners, Hindi os definitely more foreign than English.
Hindi did not exist 250 yrs ago. The world did exist and communicated. People from many parts of the world came to today's India 3500 yrs ago. They live here until now. Hindi is not imposed by people from UP or Bihar. Then who are imposing the Hindi language on every state? This is a very important question. Every Indian should find out the answer.
there are uppercast prople, who can't directly impose sanskrit on people, they don't want lower cast people to learn sanskrit and read vedas. at the same time they want to impose devnagiri script upon everybody. they already succeeded in replacing original scripts of maratha, gujarati, bihari etc
hindi definitely work as bridge between people from different state, language and culture , this is a fact, no one is forcing you to learn hindi in fact you guys force north Indians to learn your language, we also respect local language but this doesn't means you will force us to learn Kannada, India have so many local language how can you expect from someone to learn completely new language from sketch when people generally switch their location and city in every 2-3 years, are you really expecting them to learn completely new language in every 2-3 years, why only south people have hatred toward north indians , come in our up ayodhya where we have mention all sign boards in Kannada and tamil as well for south devotees but you kannada and tamil people are filled with hatred towards own people, you guys treat north indians as outsiders
@@sanatanihindu383 we have no problem english to be the bridge language,
it can be a bridge within in india as well as outside india. north indians are the only ones against this. why?
@@mshamilna Hindi is nothing but Urdu written in Nagiri script. It is just a broken Persian brought to Indian sub-continent by the Mogul invaders. Hindi is not having any root words of its own or any grammar. Learning Hindi will limit ones potential.
It is only by non-Hindi speakers because there is a value. Because people already know Hindi and it is easier to build on what U already know. U must find a middle path
I would like to share a recent incident that occurred at the Kolkata metro in this context. A Hindi speaker, female (probably a visitor here), accused a Bengali woman of being 'Bangladeshi' for speaking Bengali in West Bengal. According to her, Hindi is the national language, and if you are in India, you have to only speak in Hindi. I don't know whether I should call her dumb or be angry for this audacity. Bengali is literally the 2nd spoken language after Hindi and an official language, including other 22 languages like Hindi and other Devnagari and Dravidian languages. How dare these people question someone's nationality when they don't have basic knowledge about their own country? These so-called native Hindi people intigrate Urdu words in their sentences and struggle to speak in pure Hindi too often. As per this absurd logic, should we call them pakistani? as Urdu and Hindi are widely spoken in Pakistan. That doesn't sound right, no?
I think we Bengalis are too generous; we never create an issue for people from other states speaking in the language they are comfortable with. I could never imagine this kind of incident happening in Bengaluru or another south region. I think we should be more loud and open enough as much as them.
I'm not one of those people who divide languages based on religion. Hindi and Urdu are both Hindustani languages that originated in the Indian subcontinent and share similar roots and young languages. I don't hate either of these languages; anyone can speak any language based on their region, historical base, or community instead of their religion. But imposing Hindi forcefully might be alerting for these Hindi-speaking states too, because their native languages might become endangered, which are old and contain more historical values. This is my personal opinion, though.
Thank you Pooja for giving such insightful news, I belong to Madhya Pradesh a Hindi speaking state and I agree with your views you have presented in a video. We need to preserve our different states language identity by giving them equal status, so that every Indian can feel proud for his/her language and cultural identity.
@@ramaharwar1010 at least ,and at last one sane voice from a northie
This is the way to be united
Give respect and take respect.
These South Indians are baby crying for an year and decades cuz that's their way to get finance ministry and other cabinet ministries to hijack projects and blackmail the union government. Being your brother from UP, I urge MP brothers to never fell for South Indian trap. Freight equilisation was a thing which we should never forget.
Hindi is not a native language of any place in India.. It was a language assembled from arabic, farsi, Urdu and north indian native languages. A cocktail is made and was names hindi. This was basically used by the construction labourerers, coolies and road layers of the 16 century communicate with the mughal high ranking officers as they understood only Arabic and Farsi. Initially for 100 years it's was only in spoken form. Later the devanagari script was stolen and used for hindi. How bad is this. You stole the word kithab (an arabic word for book) and wrote in devanagari and called it hindi foe the past 400 years. And you guys want us to destroy our 50,000 years old tamil telugu kannada with your 400 years old half baked language. Mannnnn this is gross
Odisa should remove Hindi as a language in school education unless Hindi-speaking state teach Odia language in their school
Right mu samarthan karuchhi
Matra 3 year Hindi padhichu ete katha
this doesnt make any sence merely 2-3% people understand odia language in our country 99% of them is from oddisa itself , why should someone learn odia in those state where no one use or understand odia language , again I am not against odia people , I love odia people and their culture but I am stating facts while hindi is understand and used by 60-70% population in India,
Kick out hindi ...
Jai karnataka
Jai kannada
All our South Indian languages have thousand years of heritage..
But hindi even don't have its own script, it uses devanagari. Hindi is a mixture of Persian, hindustani & sanskrit.
Correction: only Tamil have rich history in south indian languages
@@iii0988ha ha u haven't read the history properly, if you please get time please learn about the legacy of other south indian languages and their rulers too
@@mithunr496
What???
Top 3 longest ruled empires in world history are Tamil kings.
@@iii0988 you are proven yourself stupid or you should be a hindi guy in disguise, ( who have always benefitted by division of south )
Mr ,the Eastern chalukyas under pulikeshi ruled up to godavari in North and our rashtrakuta dhruv had conquered kannauj ,rashtrakuta krishna l built ellora's Kailasa monument which is one and only monolithic rock cut temple to be built top down .
Vijaya nagara Kings had ruled entire Tamil nadu by making the Kings their as subordinates .
Learn history properly.
The Hindi wallahs act as if they own the country and we are supposed to bow down to them and speak in their language...!
Hindi was defense against arabic script and language, Hindi is local language of small part of UP with heavy sankritization and devnagari script. To compete with persian with arabic words and script. We were never fighting tamil. Hindi won by 1 and persian lost by 0 . This is essence of hindi hindu hindustan movement. When this was happening south was only serving british masters whose English they love so much .
@@programmersdiary6859 Defense against Arabs? Hindi was created by the Mughals!
@@programmersdiary6859 lol like savarakar who was licking british boots
We have to secede.
@@programmersdiary6859 lol what a shameles logic ,it was savarkar and Rss which were licking the british boots
People from North India come down South for Jobs, Let them learn 4 South Indian Languages apart from English & come to South India for jobs, instead of asking US to learn Hindi for their livelihood !!
Unity is achieved through respecting each others diversity , some people are not ready to accept this , they are the real problem.
In Bengaluru why you go yo malls, hotels, Market, shop vendors, only delivery, food delivery everywhere filled with up, Biharis, nepalis. Bengaluru is won't feel like a kannada city. If you know hindi people servey more compare to kannada. Idk when our people will wake up, our Government is not doing anything for local Kannadigas.
All PSUS & central government offices , the employees are indirectly forced to learn hindi. All circulars are in hindi & English only , waste of papers & printing charges. Even hindi speaking people are not using hindi forms & application forms. unnecessary waste of printing expenses.
Say no to Hindi imposition
hindi definitely work as bridge between people from different state, language and culture , this is a fact, no one is forcing you to learn hindi in fact you guys force north Indians to learn your language, we also respect local language but this doesn't means you will force us to learn Kannada, India have so many local language how can you expect from someone to learn completely new language from sketch when people generally switch their location and city in every 2-3 years, are you really expecting them to learn completely new language in every 2-3 years, why only south people have hatred toward north indians , come in our up ayodhya where we have mention all sign boards in Kannada and tamil as well for south devotees but you kannada and tamil people are filled with hatred towards own people, you guys treat north indians as outsiders
😂😂saar educated oouth
*regardless of state difference let's unite to eradicate Hindi imposition* ❤😊
Hindi is nothing but Urdu written in Nagiri script. It is just a broken Persian brought to Indian sub-continent by the Mogul invaders. Hindi is not having any root words of its own or any grammar. Learning Hindi will limit ones potential.
Hindi is an Indo European language which is not rooted in India. Kannada is a proper Indian rooted language which has a history of more than 2500 years. Hindi is not even a classical language. We are proud of Kannada. No need of Hindi in Karnataka
Karnataka standing with Tamilnadu in state rights is heart-warming to our brotherhood.
Of course we have issues but these wont separate us. I think we south Indians need to make peaceful compromise to stand united against north Indians who's always trying to loot our rights for thousands of years throughout history. 💪
Yes thambi ❤
Love from Karnataka
@@being5411 Nanri sago 😇 ❤️
I am a Malayali. But I love South Indian unity.
This should become the main election issue in Southern States
❤ you are very lucky you have great leadership. We Gujarati are very late to save our language. See when any foreign tourists come to India and struggle to communicate with local people. They say sorry to locals for that but Hindi bhashi, They believe just ruin others culture values. They like drinking Gaumutra and expect to others to same.
Major election issues must be Adressing Unemployment, Job creation, Inflation, Healthcare, Taxation, Infrastructure etc..
@@akashpadmanabhanl2270 Language i top most national issue -- every one needs langauge for Jobs .. There is no need for BIHARI clerical staff in rural Karnataka in Nationalized bank .. We have betetr colelge betetr talent here -- Banking exam in HINDI made this possible -- We need all central government exam in Kannada as well
@@spg6651and here we have state level racism within the same country. Wow. Language could be implemented, however hatred based on states, so unnecessary.
@@spg6651learn some English first.
Look what happened to Soviet Union? They wanted all states within the Union to speak , write and do business in Russian. They forced it in people. But in the end, Soviet Union fell apart and most of its erstwhile states became Russia's staunch enemies. Coercing someone to talk other than their native language always ends up in disaster - not union
Same reason why Bangladesh separated from Pakistan because Pakis wanted everyone to speak Urdu. But these arm-chair nationalists and the Hindi lunatics can't learn anything from history.
Agreed with you, but that was not the only reason for the breakup. The people in the erstwhile republics were fed up of communism being forced down their throats, other than the language issue
@@FinalBoss-ey7xethen you must learn the case studies of Urdu imposition of East Pakistan leading to Bangladesh formation and also the case of Discrimination of Sri Lankan Tamils leading to Sri Lankan civil war. Language is an integral part of a culture and playing with it will invite brutal consequences.
even bangladesh did
Hindi is a foreign language to non-Hindi states just like English. All south + east states.
Mother Tounge + English end of conversation, no need of Hindi
Kannada people are doing what tamil people did to protect Tamil in 1960. To late kannadigas 😂. Tamils are always forward looking
We are last. Gujarati. 😊
We have been fighting even before you, you just less educated. We started in 1949. This is the second wave.
Yes we need to follow you in this case.
Karnataka started in 1949 even before states were formed.
@@prashanthb6521TN in 1937 when first congress govt started, even before independence.
Learn history bro...
I am a rajasthani and I live in bangalore since 2 years. I am in full support of learning the state language and am against hindi imposition. I speak hindi and rajasthani with only my family members and speak kannada and english with everyone else. Services should always focus on convenience of the people paying for it, locals should be able to access it in the comfort of their own mother tongue. That is what true unity in diversity will be, when diverse employees are hired to cater to diverse consumers, not forcing hindi speaking employees and inconveniencing the locals they are meant to help.
In karnataka why we need to speak in hindi...let those come to my land speak kannada.....if they cant learn n speak let them go whereever they wants to leave....
I am from Karnataka, this is true from my 7th standard to till date I am in my post graduation every bank manager who came talked in Hindi , our fishermen , farmers , rural women always needed a mediator to speak , whenever I went to bank most of the time I was their mediator. Nowadays even manager as well as assistant managers both are Hindi or malayalam speakers we are at pathetic condition
English should be the official language of India!
It already a official language among 22
@@lipun1531Only two hindi and english
Kashmir and Manipur is not enough!? Want another issue!? 😢 just leave it however it is.. Hindi is not national language.. Hindi people add peanut to the economy of India but eat the bulk.
Hindi is nothing but Urdu written in Nagiri script. It is just a broken Persian brought to Indian sub-continent by the Mogul invaders. Hindi is not having any root words of its own or any grammar. Learning Hindi will limit ones potential.
As a Tamizhalan we have been fighting against Hindi Imposition many decades now, slowly other non-Hindi speaking states are waking upto. We have been fighting against NEET hope other states don't take decades to understand and start supporting us.
When I joined Indian Air Force in the 90's I had limited knowledge of Hindi and many often I get comments that I'm unpatriotic when in reality I was giving prime of my age serving in the military while most of my college mates were happily getting their Green cards in US.
While in Air Force academy I was chatting with my batchmate and he said during the interview he informed them he has difficulty in English so will reply in Hindi this made me think how the system has been rigged against Non-Hindi speaking states, to me learning Hindi would be same as learning English but I don't have the choice of responding in Tamil. How many would have lost their opportunity because of this.
If i got a job in Bombay i will definitely learn hindi. Same should be the case for people in other states. Moreover no language in India is upto the mark as english as far as science is concerned. If this idea is followed India will be united. If a mumbaikar comes to TN he should be willing to learn tamil.
@@ganesankrishnamurthy8658 shouldn't you learn Marathi, then? Why Hindi?
@@proudindian-73 That is because even in Marathaland, they speak and understand Hindi, the language that connects this nation.
@@proudindian-73because your spineless maraghis speak mugal soldiers kids language
@@proudindian-73Marathi speakers have lost their identity to hindi speaker, what percentage of people don't accept hindi in mumbai and wants to speak in Marathi?
This is what utter ignorance is. If you get a job in Mumbai, by your logic you should learn Marathi, not Hindi. The era of the permanent private job location is gone. In your 35 years of professional life you don't know how many locations you have to change. 25 Northern states use Hindi as common while 4 southern states use English as a common language. Yes, Hindi native speakers will get an advantage, but isn't it the same with English as well?
Look, no issue in learning an additional southern language, but language should be common to all 4 southern states. Make it happen and ten complain.
Yes!!! 100%. Mass migration into Bangalore has economically progressed but culturally becoming disastrous!! We have more or less lost our culture in the city. It doesn’t feel home anymore and feel like we are invaded culturally and destroyed!!!! It’s very sad!!! Especially when we see hindu arrogance around us!!! It’s painful. An ancient rich culture went to the dogs in the name of development and democracy!!!
Hindi arrogance not hindu sorry!!! Im a kannadiga against imposition of HINDI!!!
Hindi arrogance not hindu. Typo error. Dont communalise smart phone spelling mistakes 😊
@@shashikalanarayan585 edit you first comment..First... And most importantly no one speaks Hindi in this nation
You ppl also hate Sanskrit..? Or consider it to be yours.?
@@shashikalanarayan585 don't forget that your culture is also hindu.. Or do you consider tipu as your papa
@@SHU-be2lrhindhu is not equal to hindhi. all non abrahamic religions in india come under hindhuism.
south indians have their own religions too, ofcourse tats under hindhuism. some of us have scriptures in our own language.
get some basics before posting such bs
Very well explained. It should be an eye opener to see the bias that local language speaking people face.
That's why local people are not getting employment.
Im tamil guy from TAMIL NADU hindi not national language
But 80% indians Knows Hindi
Only 5% idli eaters Knows Tamil😂😂
@@VibesCheck00 our tamil language in world wide reached but you hindi ? Hindi is paani poori language only paani poori ppl only accept hindi national language says . Joke 🤣 our tamil language 5000 years old but you hindi 🤣
@@VigneshVignesh-vg6kh where world wide only 5% idli kallua knows tamil
@@VigneshVignesh-vg6kh india,Nepal,Uae,saudi,singapore, bangladesh, pakistan, afghanistan, knows hindi
But only 5% Black cobra knows tamil🤣
@@VigneshVignesh-vg6kh 5000 year old source-trust me bro
I noticed that normal workers like chef, cooks, vendors, sellers etc from other state people especially Hindi speakers learn local language and speak but these corporate workers have egoistic behaviour with not even trying to learn local language. We in TN never support imposing Hindi and will stick to it. As if everyone is coding in hindi.
Hindi not indian language it's (Farsi) Persian language
It is not at all a language, it is mixture of words stolen from all other languages. It doesn't have any history.
hindi is indian language, hindi comes from sanskirt, hindi share same grammar, letter, words , and even same script dev nagri script as sanskrit
@@sanatanihindu383 sanskrit Indo-European language not indian language you go anywhere search research it the history it's also not indian language europian migrated people's language
I am from Maharashtra...
I know marathi, hindi, Gujrati, and odia...
Because I lived in those state..as a Doctor. ....so I have to learn...not fluent...but broken...
So In my openion everyone who is working in other state should learn the native language...even though you would be not fluent...but public will appreciate....❤❤❤
India is diverse nation.. nobody can impose anything on anyone...
Common people appreciate...
In our Ordinance Factory colony Maharashtra , we all lived in quarters , and our neighbours are from different state..
My mom used to talk in Marathi and my Neighbour talk in talgu, hindi, Tamil, and they at last understand each other...thats India...😂😂😂 And never had any quarrels
And we want that India...No Hate on language, religion,caste ...
learning native language is not possible sir, I am it engineer I always move to different places in every 2 to 3 years how can someone expect me to learn totally new language from sketch in every 2 to 3 years
@@sanatanihindu383 then use English, don't accept from someone to talk with you in hindi...
Make Hindi speaking states to learn kannada as third language, as we are forced to learn Hindi, which is not needed for us in Karnataka.
If the government wants to be a federal govt. The central govt should learn and address every language
I am not Kannadiga but Hyderabadi. I believe Central even trying to destroy the Bangalore and trying to create new Silicon valley. Everyone knows which state they would select. Either Gujarat or UP. They don't even care about South. I haven't seen CM of Gujarat or UP went abroad to attract investments. But centre supporting them immensely to establish industries and service sector.
Let them go to hell, but let them leave us alone. We Kannadigas know how to get our investments with English as our trade language and Kannada as our state language.
😂😂😂 South Indian cry babies, you people are really good at baby crying and blaming others. If you South Indians were really good then investments would be coming to South India rather than Gujarat and UP
you are totally wrong, the environment of Banglaore is so toxic and ruined by cheap language-based politics, local people treat north indians as outsiders, people are now hesitating to come to Karnataka, which will result into the movement of companies from Karnataka to other state, for example recently congress government in karnatak proposed 100% reservation for kannada people in all private jobs, what do you think what will happen if these type of policies are applied in karnatak, people will leave bangalore to other state then companies will also move out of Bangalore to different state, Kannada people are responsible for upcoming downfall of bangalore
@@sanatanihindu383lowda they're hesitating 😂. Even for public toilets maintenance of Karnataka, Bimaru guys are coming from 2000kms. Always busy in communal fights and using our maryadaha purshottama Ram's name for politics without focusing on job creation and development.
@@sanatanihindu383 lol says the one who demolished babri masjid
Bravo Kannadigars, India is a union of states NOT vassal states of North India. All culture is important for its people and all languages have equal staus. How can one language become superior and imposed on others? If you want to make one language make it Kannada all over India. Keep your Hindi Hindu Hindia for yourself only. It is not welcomed here.😢
English is the neutral language for hindi and non hindi speaking peoples..and also world wide benefitial..
போடா
Don't impose english by calling it a neutral language. India's literacy rate was less than 20% before independence, out of that very little English. It's the southern states who took our minerals under freight equalization policy and imposed english on us.
@@Rajan_Rout there is no geographical relationship between north and south india..... Without westerners india will be more shit like now...
@@Rajan_Rout You want to talk about stealing southern taxes ?
@@Rajan_RoutLet Kerala have hindi, here in Karnataka only Kannada and English. People who don't like this can go to Hindi speaking areas.
Bruh I hate hindi too because of it our Bhojpuri is considered a dialect of hindi even though Bhojpuri has kaithi script and There are Many other Langauges Which lose to hindi 😢
There is more 23 Langauges but goverment is foolish to understand it
Let the govt make South Indian languages mandatory for students in Hindi speaking states also...
No need. Just respect other language. Don't impose hindi.
Yes, I like that - 3 language rule. but, other course should be less
It’s better to create a separate country for 5 South Indian states
❤ Till now, I cannot read Hindi. I started learning spoken Hindi only by watching Sharukh movies. Any language comes when you are desperate to communicate and I also learnt, initially Bengali and then Hindi. Once tou learn Hindi, your ability to learn more languages, especially regional languages, comes down. Imposing the reading and writing of Hindi is absolutely an undemocratic practice, especially to those who are not literate in the language.
As a guy from Delhi, I'm just tired of Government imposing Hindi on non-hindi speaking states.
But you're also part of the problem
Dear sir north labours are coming here more only last 10 years only. If you want create opportunities and keep your labours with. We know how to protect our language and culture which we are doing even before independence. Keep your rubbish language with you we have not asked anyone to teach any alien language to us.
But these Kannada people themselves gave 19 seats to BJP🤦♂️🤦♂️
What is the relation of Hindi and BJP. They never said Hindi is our National Language.
Your state is under central party
@@Adity2223Karnataka Hindi people party
Yeah they did said about one nation one language, but our minister will not allow it even bjp leaders also
Hypocrisy of kannada people they will hate bjp or Hindi speaking people but at the same time the great Karnataka state makes compulsory Urdu learning in anganwadi
We need a separate country for south India
TRAITOR
@@mayankthakur-p9g Why? India is a union of states. Is not it? India's budget is called "The Union Budget of India"
@@mayankthakur-p9g Hindi is nothing but Urdu written in Nagiri script. It is just a broken Persian brought to Indian sub-continent by the Mogul invaders. Hindi is not having any root words of its own or any grammar. Learning Hindi will limit ones potential.
Hindi imposition is slow and soft colonization.
I don't know why we give so much importance to Hindi which is barely 100 -150 years old.
Iam from Karnataka & it's not possible to accept Hindi as our national language.Our identity is Indian & Kannada should be given priority in Karnataka.
Hindi is nothing but Urdu written in Nagiri script. It is just a broken Persian brought to Indian sub-continent by the Mogul invaders. Hindi is not having any root words of its own or any grammar. Learning Hindi will limit ones potential.
I don't know why we in south of India are lerning 3 languages, when UPs and Biharis are learning only 2 languages ànd getting jobs in Railways easily,.😶
Are you going to pay us for freight equilisation.. every finance minister is a Tamilian, are you going to take back your Tamilians? We never complain about those things, so it's better if you will not complain about stupid things.
Without English no one gets a job in the government sector. South doesn't have 1 link language. Why is the north learning 2 languages
Not even 2, only 1
Bro I am from Bihar we have 3 languages in school
3rd one is Sanskrit.
Initially the plan was to keep one southern language as the third language but it never got implemented.Instead schools opted for sanskrit/urdu because teachers were available for those language.
Anyway In this era of tech we need to focus on translation tools Just simple.
@@Mr_faltuji1 True, South Indian languages are useless for us. Why we should even learn it
First ban Gujarati and then impose Hindi!😂😂😂😂😂😂
Why !! ?
Stop hindi imposition this not good Shame on hindi people 😡
I am okay with Hindi taught in all states of India, only if Hindi speaker state are taught either one South Indian or North Eastern Language. This will level all of them. No fight over language will solve issue permanently. Let them choose any either one South Indian or North Eastern Language than its absolutely fine for me to learn Hindi in schools.
South indians made English as an official language of india
I am not kannadiga but these north people are surely entitled and think everyone should know Hindi. Sorry Hindi is not even an ancient language of India. It is just a recently developed language. In the past we had Prakrit, Pali and Sanskrit.
Hindi is nothing but Urdu written in Nagiri script. It is just a broken Persian brought to Indian sub-continent by the Mogul invaders. Hindi is not having any root words of its own or any grammar. Learning Hindi will limit ones potential.
Why Karnataka governments continued three language policy? Switch to two language policy.
Only Kannada and English
They still have hindi in schools I'm tamil we live in Bengaluru for 30 years
Yes kannada and English
Both national parties are fond in imposing Hindi.
I mean, look at their tweets and social media handles, 70% of the time it's only Hindi Hindi Hindi.
Better for South India to vote regionalist
Mother tongue and English will be more good globally.
Regional Language- Required for communication within a region
English- required for communication with the world
Hindi- For what? If you can't learn English, why should we learn Hindi??
Why do we need a small door for the small dog and a big door for big dog??
They are saying when a Tamilian speaks with a Bengali they both should speak in Hindi with each other instead of English because of "cultural" reasons😂
@@Zak-qh5tb What cultural reasons ?
@@tsMuthuraman-hm6wg They feel we should only use everything Bharatiya including the language we speak. What about cricket, mobile phones, internet, jeans etc? The hypocrisy is very funny😂
@@Zak-qh5tb True. !