I’m an Indian and I have been following Pakistani domestic affairs and history for over a decade now. The constitutional questions particularly interest me because I’m also a practising lawyer. Salman Akram Raja is one of my favourite lawyers in Pakistan. I’ve greatly enjoyed all your content. Thanks. ❤
Through this converstation, Salman Akram Raja has ripped apart the judiciary and system of Pakistan as well as the whole narrative of PDM government against Imran Khan. Hats off to his knowledge and cognition level.
Delighted listening to Salman Akram Raja. Happy to see there are people like him in the system who keep their head in the game without being distracted by emotions. "Mistake of someone doesn't give you right to do wrong as well". I hope Shehzad will keep this in mind next time making a falacy arguement.
Despite the podcast's intellectual content and Mr. Salman's insightful information about our judicial system, one notable observation is that the host consistently centers most questions around Imran Khan. This approach seems to paint a picture as if Imran Khan is solely responsible for all wrongdoing and he is corrupt while other leaders are portrayed as innocent and they had done nothing.
he was constantly trying to vindicate nawaz. shamelessly defending him with his witty replies. But at the end of the day, you are clever or stupid. Your bias makes you do stupid things
Few well educated in Pakistan . But they are sidelined. Unless have political backing. Rich have it. Most Pakistanis talk like Lucknowi not punjabis. They are ashamed of punjabi. They have recreated Lucknow in lahore. Sad. Lahore was amritsar like. Its become a UP town . Oversea Pakistanis are shocked to hear indian punjabis fluent confident punjabi. They start crying. They realise its been ages since they spoke their own language. They have tears in their eyes,they realise they killed their language, identity. Its not an exaggeration. They feel punjabi but they cant own punjabi language. Dance, food culture of Punjab has been suppressed .
Salman Akram Raja, you are one of the finest and brilliant mind in Pakistan, Please lead our nation to better Pakistan, I have full confidence you, you can du much bigger for Pakistan than you think
This session should be used as a guidance for would be law students, law students and people with open mind and clear thinking who can differentiate the finer concepts of segregation of issues and its implications. Great session, very good job.
One of the best podcast brother, well done for bringing the gentleman on this platform, I would also like to see similar debate with Aitzaz Ahsan, not only on Pakistan’s judicial history but also on the change in general consciousness of this part of Indus Valley civilisation. Kind regards. Raheel (UK)
Not gonna lie these discussion requires more knowledge and understanding than I have. This is definitely an episode that require a rewatch or multiple rewinds to truly understand for common person.
I am typically against your biased questions, but today I learnt a lot from Salman Akram Raja... Again Not because of your questions , it's mainly how he answers with such an elaboration...
If you find questioning to be biased, question your cult mentality. Questions should not anger any critical Thinker. If our platform was biased, we wouldn't have invited SAR.
بہت خوب سلمان اکرم راجہ صاحب آپ کا یہ انٹرویو بہت سیر حاصل ہے اس انٹرویو کو تمام ججوں تمام اداروں کو دیکھنا چاہیے اور اپنے آپ سے ایک عہد کرنا چاہیے کہ آئندہ تمام اداروں مروجہ اصولوں پہ چلائیں گے۔
Many respect, sir Salman Akram Raja. Well educated nd well Consciousness Maa'sha'Allah. Maa'sha'Allah, sir ! Allah subhana give you those both blessings. You are a blessed person. May Allah subhana give Consciousness those all well educated people ( Ameen 🤲🏻🙏).
Excellent intellectual and very high standard of discussion. My regards to Salman Raja sb . Best of luck for such bold discussion encouraging transparency in practice of law regardless of political affiliations. JazakAllah
Probably the only time this channel scored so many views? I am surprised that Raja showed up here but he is an intelligent articulate marvelously qualified human being as we can all see and can take on all comers, including this host whose anti PTI anti Imran khan animus is his calling card.
Keshvanand Bharti Vs. Union of India is a landmark judgement, heard by the largest constitutional bench of 13-judge, it came during a time when there was a tussle going on between Indian Parliament, led by the then Prime Minister of India Indira Gandhi, who made many significant changes in the constitution, and Supreme Court. There are many series of judgements before the Keshvananda Judgement, where Parliament would amend the constitution then Supreme Court would struck down the said amendment citing the unconstitutionality of the amendment. Finally, in the Keshvananda case Supreme Court said to the Parliament cool bro make as many changes as you can but dare not touch the Basic Structure of the constitution. Though Supreme Court didn't define what exactly Basic Structure is but through the precedents and various case laws it is not a settled position that Secularism, Parliamentary System, Federalism etc are Basic Structure. If Parliament ever passes any such law which challenges the Basic Structure, it will be held unconstitutional.
@@durgeshsingh5220nani fali and soli..the holy trinity. It has been my honour to have met fali and soli many times one-on-one in delhi HC and the SC and even heard them argue.
Great debate really and very well carried by Shehzad. Salman Akram was at his best as always. Our youth must listen to this that how can we talk to each other even if we have different opinion. Great Work.
A very interesting overview of Pakistan’s legal system by Salman Akram Raja, one of Pakistan’s leading lawyers today. He covers a wide range of issues, including the structure of the judiciary, the elevation to the superior courts and the formation of benches, the overly intrusive role of the establishment, the bad judgements as a result to the intrusion, as well as some biased benches, and yet his belief that we must accept the SC judgements and must not be selective in doing so, as otherwise it can only lead to the complete breakdown of order. *Equally impressive are the quality of questions raised by Shehzad Ghias Shaikh, the podcast host, he has done excellent homework before hosting this talk*. Something he always does before his podcasts on a variety of subjects. *Pakistan’s hope of breaking out of our dismal situation, is our youth like him*.
Wonderful Discussion ❤ From this discussion one can conclude that Military Establishment to a large extent is responsible for the loss of credibility of whole system .
Just recently re-subscribed. I had to accept that even though you have anti Imran sentiments but you are doing important work to help people think. Good job bro 👍🏻
Usually I sleep at 11, but its 12:55am in shanghai and I watched complete interview. Very much moral boosting answers from Salman Akram Raja however host (I don't even know his name) was very much against IK/PTI.
what a fascinating conversation man, wow! Had come back from office around 10.00 PM was looking for a movie to watch ... but then saw that Mr. Rashid is there with you. Am already a subscriber to his youtube channel and really like his true typical unbridled punjabi spirit! Bataiyye aapne toh yousuf salli makeen-haveli barood khana, navasa-e-shair-e-mashriq allama iqbal sahab ki bhi bajwa di. Aur DNA wale belipuri, quam ko tezab se ghusl dene ke khwahismand sahab ko toh aapne shuru mein hi salman sahab se wahin ghuswa diya jahan cricket ghusa hua hai. Great episode! Loved it!
Salman is always very articulate. Whereas he referred to YRG’s disqualification based on non compliance with SCP orders, he forgot to refer to the similar situation where Showbaz refused to hold elections as per SCP orders.
Very much impressive interview. The question of the will of the people will remained unresolved untill people know the philosophy of chosen resentative. . It has not been mentioned any where in Constitution that public servants will chose the public representatives. We will have to fallow the Constitution, otherwise we are advancing toward blind street.
فرق صرف یہ ہے کہ نواز شریف نے ووٹ کو عزت دو لیکن اس نے اس کے لیے قربانی سے انکار کر دیا اور ڈیل کر لی اس کے برعکس عمران خان نے حقیقی آزادی کا نعرہ لگایا اور عوام کے ساتھ مل کر کھڑا ہوگیا
Pakistan is paying price for not limiting military to barracks like India after partition... I believe JINNAH saab had that opportunity to go for proper democracy...
Very valid and pertinent comparison of decisio to dissolve provincial adsemblies being political as against trial of civilians by military cour which is purely legal and constitutional decision.
اگر یہ مان بھی لیا جائے کہ 2017 میں نواز شریف کے خلاف فیصلہ عدلیہ سے فوج نے دلوایا تو: 1. کیا نواز شریف نے بطور وزیر اعظم اقامہ نہ رکھنے کا انکار کیا؟ 2. کیا نواز شریف نے آج تک اپنے لنڈن فلیٹس خریدنے کے ذرائع عدالت یا عوام کو بتائے؟ چاہے اس کے بیٹوں کی ہی ملکیت مان لی جائے تو بیٹے کیوں کوئی ذرائع نہیں بتا سکے؟ 3. کیا تحقیقات لو اس لئے ردی کی ٹوکری میں ڈال دینا چاہئے کہ وہ غلط ہیں یا صرف اس لئے کہ کسی فوجی افسر نے کیں بجائے سویلین افسر کے؟ اخر تحقیقات پیش تو عدالت میں ہوئیں اور نواز شریف کے وکلاء کو ان تحقیقات پر بحث کا مکمل موقع بھی دیا گیا۔ اس کے مقابلے میں عمران خان کے تو واضح طور پر نہ کوئی اثاثے ہیں جن کا اس نے حساب نہیں دیا اور نہ ہی کوئی بھی اور غیر قانونی و بغیر میرٹ کے تقرری ہے۔
I’m an Indian and I have been following Pakistani domestic affairs and history for over a decade now. The constitutional questions particularly interest me because I’m also a practising lawyer. Salman Akram Raja is one of my favourite lawyers in Pakistan. I’ve greatly enjoyed all your content. Thanks. ❤
❤
Although I am not related with the legal industry in any way but the style and arguments presented by Raja Akram is very impressive.
For me being a student of law, it was a treat to listen to the insights of Salman Akram Raja. Well done team 'The Pakistan Experience'.
🙌
Student if something that’s non existent in pakistan?
Through this converstation, Salman Akram Raja has ripped apart the judiciary and system of Pakistan as well as the whole narrative of PDM government against Imran Khan. Hats off to his knowledge and cognition level.
Delighted listening to Salman Akram Raja. Happy to see there are people like him in the system who keep their head in the game without being distracted by emotions. "Mistake of someone doesn't give you right to do wrong as well". I hope Shehzad will keep this in mind next time making a falacy arguement.
No he won't keep that in mind the next time also because Benazir is still alive in his heart.
Listening to intellectuals like Salman Akram Raja is always fascinating.
Despite the podcast's intellectual content and Mr. Salman's insightful information about our judicial system, one notable observation is that the host consistently centers most questions around Imran Khan. This approach seems to paint a picture as if Imran Khan is solely responsible for all wrongdoing and he is corrupt while other leaders are portrayed as innocent and they had done nothing.
The host is definitely biased.
he always been pro-Nawaz
he was constantly trying to vindicate nawaz.
shamelessly defending him with his witty replies.
But at the end of the day, you are clever or stupid. Your bias makes you do stupid things
He speaks Urdu so eloquently 👌
Punjabi + Rajput yet Urdu of like someone from Lucknow amazing.
wait until you hear his english. Magnificient
ruclips.net/video/km0Fv1ljfuM/видео.htmlsi=Ipv22bl9aut12fC-&t=141
Few well educated in Pakistan . But they are sidelined. Unless have political backing. Rich have it. Most Pakistanis talk like Lucknowi not punjabis. They are ashamed of punjabi. They have recreated Lucknow in lahore. Sad. Lahore was amritsar like. Its become a UP town . Oversea Pakistanis are shocked to hear indian punjabis fluent confident punjabi. They start crying. They realise its been ages since they spoke their own language. They have tears in their eyes,they realise they killed their language, identity. Its not an exaggeration. They feel punjabi but they cant own punjabi language. Dance, food culture of Punjab has been suppressed .
Salman Akram Raja, you are one of the finest and brilliant mind in Pakistan, Please lead our nation to better Pakistan, I have full confidence you, you can du much bigger for Pakistan than you think
With Salman Akram Raja on the seat, 'The Pakistan Experience' is at its Best. Keep it up.
🙌
@@ThePakistanExperienceq
Q
@@ThePakistanExperiencehu76542❤😂i7866 7vn
Salman Akram Raja’s father was also a great lawyer. He has always taken cases against the establishment. He is one of my favourite people in Pakistan.
This session should be used as a guidance for would be law students, law students and people with open mind and clear thinking who can differentiate the finer concepts of segregation of issues and its implications. Great session, very good job.
This Guy is Soo intelligent and decent, i am hella impressed by him......
Raja sb is always with facts and figures.
Very deep knowledge of history and strong observation.
🙌
His grip on urdu is awesome.❤
Shahzad despite being your critic, i would like to thank you for this conversation. Such a delight.
just finished the whole podcast . 6:24 morning .He is rare in digital ocean
🙌
Finally, one of the worth watching podcast.
I understood loads of the judicial issues through this video...Both had a amazing discussion
🙌
One of the best podcast brother, well done for bringing the gentleman on this platform, I would also like to see similar debate with Aitzaz Ahsan, not only on Pakistan’s judicial history but also on the change in general consciousness of this part of Indus Valley civilisation. Kind regards. Raheel (UK)
🙌
Delighted to listen to such learned people. Thanks for providing this opportunity
🙌
A fine, scholarly conversation. Thoroughly impressive
Not gonna lie these discussion requires more knowledge and understanding than I have. This is definitely an episode that require a rewatch or multiple rewinds to truly understand for common person.
Salman Akram Raja , the erudite , consummate Jurist whose intimate knowledge of jurisprudence and articulate style informs all his arguments .
I personally like Raja Sahib as a lawyer a brilliant young man and very different from other lawyers.
His every word means something.
Thanks very much for this precious opportunity to learn from Sir. (Btw nice trick to get engagement IMRAN KHAN'S LAWYER😅😅)
🙌
Another gem of a session, thoroughly enjoyed it.
🙌
I am typically against your biased questions, but today I learnt a lot from Salman Akram Raja... Again Not because of your questions , it's mainly how he answers with such an elaboration...
If you find questioning to be biased, question your cult mentality. Questions should not anger any critical Thinker.
If our platform was biased, we wouldn't have invited SAR.
Very well played Barrister Sahib. You are a principled person. Wish to see you as a justice in Pakistan.
بہت خوب سلمان اکرم راجہ صاحب آپ کا یہ انٹرویو بہت سیر حاصل ہے اس انٹرویو کو تمام ججوں تمام اداروں کو دیکھنا چاہیے اور اپنے آپ سے ایک عہد کرنا چاہیے کہ آئندہ تمام اداروں مروجہ اصولوں پہ چلائیں گے۔
Many respect, sir Salman Akram Raja. Well educated nd well Consciousness Maa'sha'Allah.
Maa'sha'Allah, sir ! Allah subhana give you those both blessings. You are a blessed person.
May Allah subhana give Consciousness those all well educated people ( Ameen 🤲🏻🙏).
Akram Raja is one of the top lawyers we look forward to... 💯
I asked for it once, and now I'm enjoying it thoroughly, thank you @ShehzadGhias
🙌
very impressive discussion. Mr. Salman Akram Raja stance on the issues strongly force to ponder. we have very complex dual system.
Very well spoken by Mr. Salman Akram Raja. God bless you.
Excellent intellectual and very high standard of discussion.
My regards to Salman Raja sb .
Best of luck for such bold discussion encouraging transparency in practice of law regardless of political affiliations.
JazakAllah
🙌
The whole discussion was worth of my time _ first time _ and after long time!!
🙌
such brilliant lawyer should be made a supreme court judge
Man how its just so refreshing to listening TPE. Welcome back bro after the brief hiatus.
🙌
Probably the only time this channel scored so many views? I am surprised that Raja showed up here but he is an intelligent articulate marvelously qualified human being as we can all see and can take on all comers, including this host whose anti PTI anti Imran khan animus is his calling card.
Very truthful and brave man Suleman Raja is..i wish Imran have another opportunity to improve pakistan with new team.
Thanks for asking my question... it's an amazing podcast in the contemporary Times 💯
🙌
Listening to such a brilliant man is a delight.
😂S.Akram Raja Sahab, What an honour to hear your brilliant analysis. Someone of your views,knowledge and integrity be CJP to help Pakistan .
Great analysis by a very competent highly qualified law expert.
Keshvanand Bharti Vs. Union of India is a landmark judgement, heard by the largest constitutional bench of 13-judge, it came during a time when there was a tussle going on between Indian Parliament, led by the then Prime Minister of India Indira Gandhi, who made many significant changes in the constitution, and Supreme Court. There are many series of judgements before the Keshvananda Judgement, where Parliament would amend the constitution then Supreme Court would struck down the said amendment citing the unconstitutionality of the amendment. Finally, in the Keshvananda case Supreme Court said to the Parliament cool bro make as many changes as you can but dare not touch the Basic Structure of the constitution. Though Supreme Court didn't define what exactly Basic Structure is but through the precedents and various case laws it is not a settled position that Secularism, Parliamentary System, Federalism etc are Basic Structure. If Parliament ever passes any such law which challenges the Basic Structure, it will be held unconstitutional.
Thanks
That case was argued by the best Lawyer that India ( including Pakistan) has ever produced: NANI PALKHIWALA
👏
@@durgeshsingh5220nani fali and soli..the holy trinity. It has been my honour to have met fali and soli many times one-on-one in delhi HC and the SC and even heard them argue.
Anchor ki awaz muja achi lagi...so cool
بہت دلچسپ ڈیبیٹ ۔دونوں قابل شخصیات ماشاءاللہ
It is wonderful that the discussion was enlightened and without partisan tilt.
آج کا وی لاگ خاصا دلچسپ ہے شکریہ
What a great debate. Loved it. Impressed with the intellectual level of Raja Sb.
🙌
Very Nice talks of Lawyer of Imran Khan Advocate Salman Akram Raja. Video looked good.
No doubt Slalman Akram Raja is the top lawyer of Pakistan.
Beautiful talk
Thank you Salman 🙏
Feel confidence where Lawyers like Akram Raja exist.
And there are few other respected lawyers too.
You are exceptionally brilliant “ The Pakistan Experience”
🙌
Thanks for another amazing podcast ❤
❤
Great debate really and very well carried by Shehzad. Salman Akram was at his best as always. Our youth must listen to this that how can we talk to each other even if we have different opinion. Great Work.
🙌
A very interesting overview of Pakistan’s legal system by Salman Akram Raja, one of Pakistan’s leading lawyers today. He covers a wide range of issues, including the structure of the judiciary, the elevation to the superior courts and the formation of benches, the overly intrusive role of the establishment, the bad judgements as a result to the intrusion, as well as some biased benches, and yet his belief that we must accept the SC judgements and must not be selective in doing so, as otherwise it can only lead to the complete breakdown of order.
*Equally impressive are the quality of questions raised by Shehzad Ghias Shaikh, the podcast host, he has done excellent homework before hosting this talk*. Something he always does before his podcasts on a variety of subjects. *Pakistan’s hope of breaking out of our dismal situation, is our youth like him*.
🙌❤
SALMAN AKRAM GREAT KNOWLEDGE GREAT INFORMATION !
Always love and support Imran khan ❤❤❤❤
Wonderful Discussion ❤ From this discussion one can conclude that Military Establishment to a large extent is responsible for the loss of credibility of whole system .
Just recently re-subscribed. I had to accept that even though you have anti Imran sentiments but you are doing important work to help people think. Good job bro 👍🏻
Salmam Akram is a legal luminary. Love from India
thankyou thank you @thepakistanexperience for Salman Akram raja . he is the Real and fruitful
🙌
What a man of reason. Hats off. Raja esq .
Thoroughly enjoyed the podcast👍👏👏👏 thank you
🙌
One of the best podcast ever. Thanks.
Please have one with Dr Hassan Askari Rizvi.
🙌
Usually I sleep at 11, but its 12:55am in shanghai and I watched complete interview. Very much moral boosting answers from Salman Akram Raja however host (I don't even know his name) was very much against IK/PTI.
It is the hosts podcast. Why did he record and post this if he's so anti?
Only came to hear Mr. Salman Akram Raja. Sir thanks for fighting our leader's case. ❤
Bro enho ne nawaz shareef ka case be lara tha
@@faisalaslam2344 ji bhai i know.
what a fascinating conversation man, wow!
Had come back from office around 10.00 PM was looking for a movie to watch ... but then saw that Mr. Rashid is there with you.
Am already a subscriber to his youtube channel and really like his true typical unbridled punjabi spirit!
Bataiyye aapne toh yousuf salli makeen-haveli barood khana, navasa-e-shair-e-mashriq allama iqbal sahab ki bhi bajwa di.
Aur DNA wale belipuri, quam ko tezab se ghusl dene ke khwahismand sahab ko toh aapne shuru mein hi salman sahab se wahin ghuswa diya jahan cricket ghusa hua hai.
Great episode! Loved it!
🙌
Great intellectual video, rare discussion seen in pakistan, kerp up great work
Salman Akram Raja is a Honest Man....
بہت اچھی گفتگو بہت سی معلومات حاصل ہوئی ہے
Salman is always very articulate. Whereas he referred to YRG’s disqualification based on non compliance with SCP orders, he forgot to refer to the similar situation where Showbaz refused to hold elections as per SCP orders.
Boht achi discussion hui hai.boht Maza aya.mera knowledge be update huwa hai.❤
❤
Very much impressive interview. The question of the will of the people will remained unresolved untill people know the philosophy of chosen resentative. . It has not been mentioned any where in Constitution that public servants will chose the public representatives. We will have to fallow the Constitution, otherwise we are advancing toward blind street.
1:05:40 Kesvanand Bharti case 13 judges bench 7:6 in favour
Bro his urdu and his voice superb. Sir salman, salam apko sir
Allah subhan o taala is Great to listen to our
Absolutely right from Salman Sahib.
Salman akram sb, stand for democracy is most admirable....
Very interesting and informative discussions appriciated
Very well explained Raja sb ❤❤
What an amazing speaker this guy is
ruclips.net/video/uophJhTIrtM/видео.html
Got a glimpse of why they say the Salman Akram Raja. 💯
راجہ صاحب آپ پر اللہ کی رحمت ھو آپ کی سچائی ھمیشہ سلامت رھے ❤❤❤
You are doing a brilliant Job. Please do a podcast with Ahmad Noorani.
🙌
Great discussion
🙌
فرق صرف یہ ہے کہ نواز شریف نے ووٹ کو عزت دو لیکن اس نے اس کے لیے قربانی سے انکار کر دیا اور ڈیل کر لی اس کے برعکس عمران خان نے حقیقی آزادی کا نعرہ لگایا اور عوام کے ساتھ مل کر کھڑا ہوگیا
Pakistan is paying price for not limiting military to barracks like India after partition... I believe JINNAH saab had that opportunity to go for proper democracy...
Very valid and pertinent comparison of decisio to dissolve provincial adsemblies being political as against trial of civilians by military cour which is purely legal and constitutional decision.
Salman sahab is our national treasure..
Salman Akram Raja sahab
اگر یہ مان بھی لیا جائے کہ 2017 میں نواز شریف کے خلاف فیصلہ عدلیہ سے فوج نے دلوایا تو:
1. کیا نواز شریف نے بطور وزیر اعظم اقامہ نہ رکھنے کا انکار کیا؟
2. کیا نواز شریف نے آج تک اپنے لنڈن فلیٹس خریدنے کے ذرائع عدالت یا عوام کو بتائے؟ چاہے اس کے بیٹوں کی ہی ملکیت مان لی جائے تو بیٹے کیوں کوئی ذرائع نہیں بتا سکے؟
3. کیا تحقیقات لو اس لئے ردی کی ٹوکری میں ڈال دینا چاہئے کہ وہ غلط ہیں یا صرف اس لئے کہ کسی فوجی افسر نے کیں بجائے سویلین افسر کے؟ اخر تحقیقات پیش تو عدالت میں ہوئیں اور نواز شریف کے وکلاء کو ان تحقیقات پر بحث کا مکمل موقع بھی دیا گیا۔
اس کے مقابلے میں عمران خان کے تو واضح طور پر نہ کوئی اثاثے ہیں جن کا اس نے حساب نہیں دیا اور نہ ہی کوئی بھی اور غیر قانونی و بغیر میرٹ کے تقرری ہے۔
This man is a gem❤.
What an excellent discussion!
🙌
And the Divine Guidance
For humanity
❤ problems arise because
We want to make our own
Laws constitution 46:03 thanks 🙏 mrs ghazanfar
Salman Sahib is an honorable man who got stuck with this… nation😢
Great show 👏🏼
🙌
you nailed it Shehzad. keep going.
🙌
Very informative. excellent podcast.
🙌
Listen just because of Salman Akram Raja