Channel Support - Patreon: www.patreon.com/idguy Latest Releases: ruclips.net/channel/UCzf6rqsEBni5G2TSevD6F4Afeatured Follow me on Instagram: instagram.com/id.guy/
IDGuy Could you possibly do a video on the two experimental watches that went to the bottom of Mariana Trench from Omega/Rolex? The Rolex Deepsea challenge watch (2012) and The Omega Seamaster Planet Ocean Ultra Deep?
It’s been 15 yrs. since I bought my first luxury timepiece. It was Rolex Date Just, 116200. I still love it. I was in Tokyo and bought it at an AD in Ginza. During the financial transaction the saleswoman asked me if I was ill. I was pale and sweating a bit. I told her I wasn’t, but it was a lot of money. She smiled and said, “I understand, but it’s exciting isn’t it?”. It lightened the mood. It’s a great experience. You’ll remember it forever. Savor the moment. You’ll cherish it forever.
@@Spook291 Freaking brilliant suggestion! You won't believe, but I've just finished a writeup on the Tudor P01 and mention the "Deep Sea Special" (complete coincidence) I'd love to look at those two super watches and discuss their designs! Thanks a million for the idea N D
@@ashken3985 Thanks a million for this Ash. There are so many amazing watches out there and this whole "rationalising process" has made such a difference (hell, the audience feedback has been amazing too) In the end it really is about thinking of the future. What would I feel like with the watch in fifty years? it's a great thought!
Perfectly said (and that is a huge driving factor for me) All of the above, but also a watch that not only highlights that I "practice what I preach" but also one that'll make many, many memories. Thanks a million for your comment!
IDGuy Anytime! Honestly, I’d go for a more classical design. I’d go for a Glashütte Original Iconic Sixties with a flinqué dial. Something that will still be beautiful 100 years from now.
IDGuy Oh yeah - another good technique is to hold two models, one in each hand, to compare. If you’re after a sports watch - don’t forget to consider a Blancpain Fifty Fathoms. Make mine the blue guilloché dial version with X-71! The quality of the Fifty Fathoms is mind-boggling when you pick one up and hold it. One time I compared one side-by-side with a Submariner. They’re not even remotely comparable. There is not one square millimeter of the Fifty Fathoms that wasn’t unbelievably well thought out.
IDGuy Oh yeah, one last thing. There are a lot of great insider’s tips. I’m personally considering the Jaquet-Droz Grande Heure Minute Quantième Côtes De Genève. Jaquet-Droz is Patek Philippe quality for 1/4th the price.
Totally agree! In fairness, though, others do not like/wish to lead...those who tread their own path are oftentimes alone. I will always choose to be alone for the right reasons over joining the group. Love the Glashütte, BTW!
I feel as if I lean towards the Tudor side. I really do enjoy Rolex's designs and history, but their brand cache doesn't entirely line up with me and my personal style...but if i were to get one, id get an Explorer 214270 because its super under the radar in the metal. While i can appreciate Omega, i dont like their case proportions in person... The black bay lineup feels like its a great balance of wrist presence, design and feeling of overall value. in house movements or not, i think its a killer watch. i feel like Tudor is what Rolex used to be, which is also what appeals to me.
Very nicely said "Tudor is what Rolex used to be". I'm slowly but surely weighing up the options (and can't deny that the bb58 is a gem) Thanks a lot for the comment Nabrowne!
Notwithstanding the brand, the Tudor is not too simple. They are just right for the average man. We all like Rolex but Tudor let's you go unnoticed and yet it is a fine time piece.
I remember crossing this bridge in the 2000's. Fresh out of the military and college. Had a hole burning in my pocket. I didn't even consider anything else but Rolex. Went to Switzerland, walked into an AD and scooped up a sub no date. Then my next three watches would be all Rolex. If I could make my self go back into time, I would have done some more research and look at other brands. Most likely, would have gone with Omega as my first purchase. I have my Omega SMP 300 (2018) and never looked back. Truly, the perfect one piece for me. Wouldn't be caught dead with a Tudor. Over hyped hipster watch that will always be Rolex's little brother. I will say, Rolex will always have a special place in my heart because it was my first purchase. Back in those days, it actually ment something. Today, can't say the same thing. Especially the silliness with Rolex and their marketing. Killing the brand name but scooping up money and getting all the kids to buy em. Smart, but not for me anymore.
Wow. Eye-opening and thank you for the comment! Your words really ring true (honestly the Seamaster is always a model I return back to... when we look at all of the factors, uniqueness, value for money, movement) I know exactly where you're coming from. So! We'll see! Great story from your side and thank you again!
Bell end wanna take the Pepsi challenge?let's play concors?my Tudor vs your swatch? Sorry omega?winner hats both watches and a grand?my Tudor will smash your omega to bits!your a clown m8
@@glenroberts8699 congratulations on making yourself look like a complete imbecile........ people like you really should refrain from commenting on adult conversation. PS it's spelled Conkers
I thought long and hard about this very decision for 4-6 months before finally pulling the trigger on a Seamaster 300. Highly accurate. Screw down crown. Waterproof. Looks great on a leather strap or a Omega nato. Excellent bracelet construction. Timeless design.
I own multiple watches from all 3 brands, with tudor being the latest brand I've got into..considering the value and the design language, tudor became my favourite in a matter of weeks
I have the Tudor GMT and I love it. I’ve had it for about 3 weeks and it’s wonderful to know what time it is in Japan at a glance. Truth is I could have gotten a Rolex GMT Master but I would be too worried about losing or scratching it. For me the Tudor is the perfect workhorse.
I actually like the colors and simplicity of the Tudor GMT more than the Pepsi. I do however find it so freaking thick, that i just cant see myself wearing it. What did they put in there, a car engine?
Great video. For me I opted for Tudor. I guess in line with Hans Wilsdorf’s initial idea for the brand, Tudor just seemed to offer such a compelling package that for me I couldn’t justify spending more. I have the North Flag and Pelagos, both have an interesting story, an aesthetic I adore and superb build quality.
I'm saving up for my first luxury watch purchase, and this analysis has really helped cement my initial focus on going with Omega, it will be a while yet though!!
Thanks so much Neel. I'm a bit hardcore with the details of this "choosing" process (but it's sort of my job, right?) But Omega is such a great choice... I'm slowly but surely edging to the brand. And don't worry, it took a good year for me to save up the right amount (remember to take your time) ;)
I am between the omega seamaster 300 or a Rolex explorer ii 42mm. Love both of these, recently tried them on in store. My first luxury watch that I want to wear everyday. Want to hand it down to kid some day... I am just trying to think 20-30 years from now will my kid want a omega or Rolex? I think Rolex is the more wow watch brand.. Omega also sells for 50% less used.. But, I am learning with omega 😆.. such a hard choice..
I promised myself I wouldn't watch anymore videos pitting watches against each other. It brings out the worst in people, myself included. But I still watched this and I didn't half regret it. As much as I respect and admire the idea of a single watch, there is no way that I could ever pull it off. I have a very diversified life and I have yet to find a watch that can handle it all. I have managed to keep the same 4 piece collection for more than a decade though. But that changed a couple of years ago when I was nearing 40 and decided to mark the occasion with a watch purchase.
I alway avoid the versus videos where possible too! I really wanted to try and put the "designs of the brands" against each other instead. But it is difficult. Finding a brand is a good start at least ;) The ONE WATCH collection, I feel, is a pipe dream too hahaha! Thank you for the comment Jimmy!
@@ID-Guy I will not deny that I'm a bit curious as to what you have decided to go with. However, I doubt that you will stop at one watch :) Maybe for a few years, but more are coming. Cheers!
I think you’re right. It’s the only thin black bay. The spectre omega looks unique but might be too thick. The newer seamasters are polarizing and have to fit your style. Rolex is expensive but now might be the best time if you ever want to do it. There is no perfect watch and it takes wrist time to truly know.
I had somewhat similar brands and models choice to make as my first watch. And instead of one Rolex, got 2 omegas (Aqua Terra blue 2018, and Seamaster 300m black rubber). Very happy with both.
Love your content, been watching your channel from the beginning, thanks for your articulate and deep content! Great vid. I love most of your choices but to me the omega 300 is the ultimate, it just ticks all the right ticks.
amazing content. i went through the exact same process you are going through now. i ended up falling in love with a white AT 38mm after going in the Omega boutique multiple times over the course of months. one interesting thing i did was take the measurement of my wrist width and divide it by the diameter of my watch. funny enough, it comes out to almost exactly the golden ratio of 1.62. this seems great for my everyday watch (and my beater is my blue Orient Ray which i will never get rid of) and i plan on getting probably an Omega NATO for the summer and a bespoke ostrich leg strap for formal events. still need to try this out on a NATO though, as the omega rubber strap on 38mm is just too small. a 41mm size would work better with the rubber, but be a less dressy look. Good luck on your choice!
Of the models that you've shown I would say the OP39 black dial. I've never tried on this watch but it does sing to me. Love it has no date, clean and legible dial with a superb bracelet although no micro adjustment. 14060m (I own one) .It's a fabulous watch. Wears great, nice and slim, no date, simple uncluttered dial with a bezel that adds a touch of interest and has a use too, but everyone has one and they certainly aren't cheap. Seamaster 300 MC (I owned the Spectre LE version. It wears thick and the over protruding end links make it wear large for a 41mm. Also having a 21mm lug width is a bit annoying if you would change up the straps which leads me onto the NATO. It really suits the watch but the added thickness takes it to almost 19mm! For the record I also have the Omega Planet Ocean Liquidmetal LE which I bought new back in 2011 and an Omega Aqua Terra 38.5mm 'Skyfall' Choosing to have just one watch is difficult for someone who truly loves watches as we constantly find ways to justify how a watch would fit into our lives and imagine wearing it at certain times in certain places. If I had to keep just one of my three it would be the 14060m even though I've owned it for the least amount of time as its the most comfy and has a timeless design compared to the more contemporary Omega's. Good luck and I look forward to part 2 of this though process.
For six years I was a one watch man. Rolex Sea Dweller (ref. 16600) was my choice when it came to a sports watch but I am seriously considering getting an Omega now. They design beautiful pieces. They manufacture quality movements. And they don’t require the same investment as Vacheron, Rolex or JLC - the brands I am usually looking at.
Great video! I really enjoy the content of your channel. Your reviews and discussion about watches are very objective and well thought out. Congratulations!
My very first high end watch is my 2010 first generation Omega Seamaster Planet Ocean 2500 42mm, matte black dial/ black bezel with white numerals, absolutely love this watch and and think it really has a classic design that I've grown to appreciate even more over the years, this is a watch that will always stay with me.
I'm in the same situation as you, saving for my first luxury watch! At the moment I can't think of a better piece than a Zenith El Primero - you can get them for just about the same price as a Rolex Explorer, comes with an epic movement, 38mm, and the design elements on the dial and color choices make it was more interesting than any black dial steel sports watch.. on my opinion, of course :) cheers!
I've been where you were 2 years ago. I took 18 months of deliberations. I considered every single option. I too dislike a date cyclops. Therefore I chose the explorer and I absolutely love it!!!! Such a joy and never ever tire of looking at it. It's the finest and purist horological design out there.
Thank you ! I really appreciate the time & research you put into your channel ,I'm always looking forward to the next video you don't need my advice your sharp enough to figure it out your self !!
A great selection of watches on show here. Some really top contenders! I am confident however that you will make the right decision for your new watch. Another great video as always my friend. ✊
Based on your criteria, I would ask yourself only one question: which watch will give you just as much joy and satisfaction at 30 years old, and when you’re 70 years old? If you have questions about some of these pieces don’t hesitate to email me, brother! I’ve owned and/or sold the Omega SMP 300m, PO 39.5mm, Tudor BB 36, BB58, and the Explorer 214270.
Brilliantly said, Orry. I definitely have been thinking about my "fifty year old / seventy year old" self a lot (and that has definitely helped with the process) - the whole idea of it being slightly smaller than average etc. all plays into the formula. There's one watch that I never mentioned in this video that may have ended up being the final contender ;)
Hahaha! I'd say that is a thinly veiled compliment ;) BUT! Remember that this is pretty much my job at the moment (looking into watches & brands and tearing them to pieces). Too much scrutiny might make the process impossible...
"The Tudors are all too thick except for the 36" the 58 is too thick!!!!??? No! As someone that had a similar choice recently, and yes 1 watch is a wonderful idea, rather than an Explorer, or Seamaster 300m, I got a Tudor 58 and a GMT and couldn't be happier. They give much more flexibility as a pair than any one watch from the Omegas or Rolex you mention, great video man, love your stuff!
Fantastic video. Im aiming for the same 'one watch collection'. I laughed a few times because you've articulated exactly the same variables I've been weighing up in my head. Your shortlist is very similar to my own! Thanks for your channel, I've only recently discovered it and I'm happy I have done so :)
I went through the process for a year and ended up going for the Rolex OP39 grey dial. Love it one year later and can’t believe how well it goes with a suit or jeans or anything and catch myself looking at it regularly and take pictures of it on my wrist!!!!!!!!
Very interesting! As someone who gives massive amounts of thought to each piece in my own collection, I really appreciate this thoughtful approach. For you, I tend to lean toward the First Omega in Space or Rolex Explorer. I like the Aqua Terra, especially the newly-released green dial version (which you should check out if you haven’t), but most people I know who have gotten one end up selling it, ultimately unsatisfied that it doesn’t have the punch they were looking for. You really seem like an Explorer guy, but it is a bit cliché, especially recently. That seems to be the model everyone is suddenly gravitating toward. Ultimately, the First Omega in Space could make for an awesome one watch. It’s historically significant, a wonderful size, fantastic value pre-owned, and different from the typical Speedy Pro. Looking forward to the next part in this series!
My first brand - Rolex. Model - Explorer 214270 In my opinion, it makes one of the best daily watches you can get and is a great start to a watch collection. Understated so it doesn't attract just anyone. But those who know, love you for it!
If you want a great diver, at a great value, just take the Seamaster Professional. It's an amazing watch that is technically probably better than the Submariner, at half the price. It is a bit bulkier overal, but the movement is better and personally I find the bracelet and the clasp also better on the Seamaster. If you want a diver as your only watch though, I would go for the Sub 114060 because even the maxi-case is still very slim compared to other divers and the bracelet/clasp is much better than those on the 5-digit Subs. You can wear it in your board shorts and your tuxedo, while the Seamaster is a bit too sporty for the latter, so you would probably need an additional dress watch . If you are serious about only getting one watch that can do it all, and you want something that is somewhat original, just take the Explorer 214270. It's absolutely gorgeous, can be worn for any occasion and most people won't even notice it's a Rolex.
Good choices! The Explorer, the Aqua Terra, and Black Bay 58 or GMT would be my picks. I remember when you reviewed homages, so I'm happy that you're able to get The Real Thing!
Thanks a million. It's crazy how far the channel (and I have come) and hell, it's going to be amazing when the day (unveiling) happens. All of the watches you've mentioned are in my Top 5... so we're getting warmer ;)
My first luxury watch (and only that I've bought with my own money), is the Speedmaster Professional. Absolutely love it. So many other watches that look gorgeous in photos leave me cold in the flesh, but not this one. Shame it lacks water resistance.
My first one was a Speedmaster professional - 8 years ago. It took me 2 years to decide. I always came back to it. Though it’s not a slim peace, the unique profile allows it to appear slimmer than it is. And now, some watches later - I still adore it and love my decision of 2012. Though I need to admit that a Daytona wears better...much better. It’s my reference for wearability.
Hopefully in Part Two you narrow it down to three! Too many choices right now. I have a gut feel for what you might choose based on your vid synopsis. May the choice games begin!
It's going to be very, very interesting Reed... that's all I'll say ;) Some have pointed out a few interesting models (that may or may not have been included in the video)
Another excellent video. I managed to forget about ‘you know what’ for 14 mins 49 secs. I recently bought bought the Smiths Everest and the BB36. Both are excellent and quite similar in some ways. I know that you have issues with the snowflake hands, but this piece is very different to other Tudor models. It doesn’t try too hard and is its own thing. I suggest you try to spend some time with it? It’s so understated and comfortable. BTW, after 2 weeks of continual wear, I’m getting +\- 0.5 secs/day. I’m so glad I didn’t go down the well-trodden BB58 route. Picked mine up from an AD for £1,600.
Lucky to own an Explorer, BB58, Planet Ocean (39.5) and Aqua Terra (38). After much rotation over the years, the ones that sit on my wrist most are the BB58 and AT and, of those, the AT wins. The 38mm with white face is superbly proportioned and the co-ax movement very accurate. Even learned to love the PCL on the bracelet.
So many factors, but yes take your time! Firstly get the watch that looks the best on your wrist not one that ticks other boxes. Other factors include, can you afford other watches later down the line? If not will this watch satisfy you? If you can only afford 1 luxury watch and you really want a Rolex then save for it. My first luxury watch was an Omega Speedmaster Professional with hesalite, I still love it 4 years later and got it grey market for 3,000 euros. I recently got a Rolex GMT Master II 126710 BLNR at retail and love it as well. I think you really can't go wrong with anything from the brands mentioned.
I’d bet that either the Omega Aqua Terra or Seamaster 300m would be picked. I’m also on the same journey of finding one watch to be worn for the rest of my life. Can’t wait for part 2.
My first was an Omega Seamaster 2254.50. Wore it daily for 18 years and just retired it for the Tudor BBB with the in house 5602 movement. It's a gorgeous piece with a subtly refined, yet still rugged elegance.
Buying the first luxury watch is so much harder than buying the second. It’s an agonising process, but in a wonderful way. After a lot of back and forth I went Omega SMP. It pulls at my heart strings just as it did when I was a wee lad watching Goldeneye. Had the exact same problem when I was buying my first proper electric guitar as well. It took a lot of time and energy. If you haven’t bought or decided yet; good luck and happy hunting, brother.
I own watches from the three brands. I think with Omega you get a lot of watch for the money as long as you buy preowned. Tudor is the perfect watch when you want a high quality watch, and fly under the radar. Regarding the brand with the crown, I never felt attracted until I got my first one. I expect to have always a Rolex around, and I hope to give one to each of my kids when they graduate from college.
Out of the watches you listed these would be my top choice from each brand. I think the Explorer is the best of the bunch. 1. Rolex Explorer 2. Omega Seamaster Professional 300m 3. Tudor Black Bay GMT However, I'm a bit surprised that you didn't consider the Rolex Milgauss. I would imagine that model fits your interests.
I was researching and “choosing” a watch for over a year, and had similar watches on my list. I ultimately went with explorer 39mm mk2 and i’ve been in love with it ever since
Great video #IDGuy, this could have been my exact video of what first luxury watches I have been shopping for; Omega Aqua Terra, Tudor BB GMT, Rolex Explorer, Grand Seiko SBGA375. Same comments around Omega's bracelet taper or lack there of, Tudor's case thickness and rivet bracelet, Rolex's price, couldn't fault the GS too much though. Visited the local Rolex and Tudor boutique and put my name down for either the Tudor BB GMT or the Rolex Explorer thinking it would be ages to get the call for either. But a few weeks later, I got the call for an Explorer and could not be happier with my purchase. Love the Explorer and can not fault it after wearing everyday for the past few months, better than I could have expected.
I knew nothing about luxury watches except that as a long-time F1 fan going back to the late 60s, Heuer was the coolest brand (but I was only a youg teen at the time). So I learned a lot in the last 4 months, and decided to get a milestone Birthday, one time luxury piece. I put myself on three different waiting lists for a Tudor GMT Pepsi and was told there were extensive lists. I lucked out the other day, was called by one of the out-of-state ADs and....got my GMT! Say, it is a chunk, but so are most chronographs. And no one complains about those being too thick! Just get the watch as close to your wrist as possible without being uncomfortable, and all is good! Great choices of watches on part one! I look at it this way. If you are fortunate enough to get one of the watches IDGuy is choosing, then you have arrived! Smile!
I just went through this decision making process myself, with these brands and a few more. I went for the Omega Speedmaster Professional Moonwatch (sapphire sandwich). My 2nd choice would be the white dial Seamaster.
You pretty much have the same taste as myself. Almost every watch you mentioned I either own or have owned and since sold. My current collection now though is refined down to: Rolex GMT Master 2 Ceramic Pepsi 126710BLRO Rolex Submariner Date 16610T Rolex Submariner Ceramic 114060 Rolex 1984 Datejust 16013 Omega Speedmaster Moonwatch Omega Seamaster 1957 Trilogy Omega 1970's Pave Deville Tudor Black Bay 58
All these watches are amazing! I own the Rolex Explorer 114270 and the Tudor BB58 from your shortlist and they are both incredible! I think you should go for the Explorer or the Submariner after hearing your thoughts though.
I just purchased a new 41 mm Aqua Terra Blue Dial. For years I have committed myself to owning a submariner as my first luxury watch. Unfortunately for me, 2021 was no the best year to pull the trigger when considering Rolex. The AT though, has so much going for itself that just fits my wants and needs. A submariner at this point would be more of a trophy than my first watch I can enjoy. Still an absolute amazing piece but I don't know if I'd still enjoy wearing it considering the inflation and attention in the last couple years.
Go for the Omega Sea Master 300. It really seems to suit you and what your looking for in a watch. It's more unique, has a beautiful movement, priced right and has a classical vintage style.
Looking at these choices, your aesthetic is pretty clear. There is another item that should be on the short list in my opinion. JLC Polaris automatic, black dial. Perhaps eliminated because of case size, this piece fits like a dream. Ball room to ball game, it goes anywhere and makes the 'subtle statement' for those that know horology, and those that just like beautiful things that work. Keep up the great work.
Excellent video! I can really relate to your search. I have many watches (including 3 Rolex) but if I had to go to one watch it would likely be my explorer II polar. Checks every box. Or at least the most boxes.
Have you had the chance to see some of these watches in person and try them on your wrist? It can make a world of difference to see and try them on rather just going on videos and pictures. The hard part may be finding a store that has enough of the models that you’re interested in.
I have absolutely! Ever since November last year I've been going to many, many boutiques, met up with friends who own the pieces. I'd never make a purchase like this without experiencing the watch first, don't worry ;) Thanks a lot of the comment, man!
I'm so split down the middle at the moment... but there's no denying that the Explorer would satisfy many, many needs and wants ;) Thanks for the comment, brother!
If only ONE watch, then it has to do more. I would want the Omega Planet Ocean GMT. Great dive watch, plus GMT complication, and its still dressy enough for almost any situation, and still FAR cheaper than a Rolex.
I think the top 4 candidates for you are (in no order): OP34 Olive: You love the green dial. Simple, yet full of character. Perhaps too small? Speedy FOIS: Iconic to Omega, robust, reliable, nicely sized and proportioned. Perhaps too common? OP39 White: Well sized, simple, elegant, dress up or down. Perhaps a bit boring? AT38: Similar to the OP39, but with more character. Perhaps a little thick and not particularly iconic to the brand? Subs are expensive. You already have an Exp1 in the Smiths. The Seamaster 300, Diver, Planet Ocean, and BB GMT are too chunky for your taste. BB36 is a cheap substitute to the OP or AT, which you would be better off with. The BB58 is a great option, but it sounds like you just aren't in love with it.
Omega Aqua Terra all the way. Simple, classy, dress up or dress down, will last a life time and never look outdated. You won't be able to escape the sentimental pull of your grandparents. Stay well! From Canada.
I believe the Rolex explorer 214270 to be the perfect daily. 36 or 39 mm are very comfortable sizes and the watch remains thin enough not to catch on clothes etc. I believe it is still a true tool watch, as you put it on and forget about it for 2 or 3 months until the itch to wear something different is eventually felt. You can workout with it, you can sleep and shower with it, you can swim with it, go to work and (perhaps the ultimate tribute to a great tool watch...) you can forget about it and move on with your life, it will always be there when you need it. It really becomes part of you, no matter what your lifestyle is.
This is really an exceptional video. I've been shopping for months and so many of the things you talk about have been going through my mind. I bought a Rolex 114270 last week and sent it back. I've been going around this thing so many times I'm dizzy. With the world coming to end I have more reasons than ever to get one and yet I feel it's a waste of money at the same time. I have $100 Seiko watches i absolutely love and the 6k Rolex went back.... Looking forward to part 2. It must be the 39mm Explorer....right?
Great work, as always. I spent a whole year (!!??) making a v similar decision. I opted for the 114300-004 and haven’t looked back, clean, simple, reliable and robust. Picked up from the AD in Jan 2020 and am over the moon! Enjoy your choice, whatever that might be (214270 I expect!)
1 watch collection: JLC Reverso with steel back (sport, dress, and everyday) 2 watch collection: Rolex Explorer I, and JLC Master Calendar (to me no other combination of two covers everything) 3 or more: there are nearly infinite possibilities. (at this point, you are covering niche interests and uses which will be different for every person)
I think you should choose the Explorer. It has presence. It’s understated. It has history. And it comes in a couple of size options which seems to be important to you. You might even argue is the original Bond watch since you brought that up. Let us also not forget it is the most accurate and least likely to depreciate, long warranty and service intervals.
I feel like most cannot withstand the tuffest choice: Is it a watch I like, do I really by this for my satisfaction OR is there the urge for recognition....? Imagine yourself on an island, cast away.... what watch would you want with you? Personally, the watch i feel is the most complete out of all the brands, models you showed is the planet ocean. It has the pizzas, the beauty, ruggedness, high level finishing and quality. I have an 17 cm wrist and own the 2016 po 42 mm. It wears so comfortably. It’s the watch when i come back to it, it does the same thing as when i just bought it, it amazes me. The others just are ‘back’ and i appreciate them, but not the same magic.... the 42 is not really 42mm, it’s smaller and for me 38-39 is perfect, but this one, because of its construction is just proportioned so well.
I have been through the exact same thing last year! At the end I finally go for the 216570 explorer 2, and here's where my thought process: In the end of 2018 someone in the same department introduce me into watches, and i start to dive into this hobby. I have no idea about anything about watches and i bought a Glycine combat sub Gl0185 as a beater, luckily my mom got a brand new eta movement Pelagos kicking around for no reason and i start wearing these two watch in rotation. (Pelagos as daily and go for Glycine when i want to get my hand dirty. p.s. i dont wear watches while working) Around the middle of 2019, i knew the pelagos is lacking a little bit of bling factor for me as a daily wearer, so i start to look for a hopefully the first and final luxury watch for the rest of my life.The first thing i do is to list down different criteria for the watch to meet. I want a sport watch, black dial, some polish surface in the dial, great contrasting colour, tone down enough to not let people spot it a few meter away, and finally a brand that are well known for shock resistance and ease of service. Now, i got three watches in my rotation to wear, and there is still one or two more watches in my "want" list. Hopefully they will never appear in my "need" list, so i will always have a few empty space in my watch box to fill, a few "dream watch" to look forward to. (But still, i am considering to swap the combat sub out for a SRPE35K1 samurai)
Rolex, Tudor, Omega and other brands like IWC and SINN are all top notch. If you are going to spend a few thousand dollars on a high end luxury/tool watch do your research and buy what speaks to you. Right now I am torn between three totally different watches, all of which speak to me: Omega Speedmaster Professional Rolex Explorer -39mm Tudor Black Bay with Blue Bezel Tudor Pelagos I am leaning towards the Speedmaster, but the Black Bay is also calling to me hard. I cannot go wrong with any of them.
Great vid as always mate ,I used to think Rolex was the be all and end all, but recently I have been thinking Omega is where the true value is, my opinion of course.I'm really thinking of getting the 2254.
I feel almost like Omega is offered at the prices that made Rolex watches so appealing back in the day (if that makes sense) and I've been studying their models religiously... And the 2254 is a lil cult classic in our community ;) Thanks for the comment Rob!
@@ID-Guy makes sense to me mate , I was also looking at the midsize 2252 some real good prices for them as I presume they are not so popular , hope you and family are healthy and happy in these troubling times.
Wonderful video and discussion. It is really difficult to ignore the outstanding design of the Omega Seamaster 300 heritage models. I have been deciding weather to hold out for one of those or to take advantage of recent market drops to pick up a very comfortable fitting BB58. I really want the BB GMT Diet Pepsi, but fear it's thickness when I tried it on and worry about wishing I had something that disappeared on the wrist more. I think Tudor needs a thinner GMT.
Speedmaster, always Speedmaster. Has the most interesting heritage, gives great interaction being a manual wind, hesalite so much nicer than any sapphire and looks amazing on pretty much any strap you can try. All good options but the Speedy is such an overall win for the money.
It is a banger. Great history, unique styling, a cornerstone watch for the brand... Ah, the thinking is so intense! Thanks as always for the comment, brother!
@@watchesoflondon2333 technically no, but very simple to effectively hack when setting with a slight back turn of the crown which stops the seconds from running.
Awesome vid! Fellow ID guy here! Had to decided between the Exp 1 and the 58 and ended up choosing the 58. The Exp 1 is an extremely beautiful watch, just felt that I'd get bored with it and living in HK where everyone wears a Rolex, the Exp 1 (including the sub and GMT) felt way too common.
Just the choice I am facing right now and the pieces are the ones that I am looking at, however I am on a waiting list for an Explorer, the omegas don’t have the same appeal, something about them doesn’t match the feel of a Rolex. All the power to you if you are content with an Omega I think they are a terrific watches, especially the speedmaster professional (which I think is so far the one most worth it), however not my cup of tea at this point. Great video, I am looking forward to part 2, guess I have to subscribe and just wait for that notification then.
Only 1 of the 3 shows you what’s inside...plus, Co-Axial is just so cool. Hard to pay thousands and not see what’s going on inside the case. One thing I dislike about my IWC. But, it does have the iron magnetic protection, so...forgiven. Good stuff as always mate!
I've found happy middle ground in defining a slightly less minimalist 3 watch collection for myself. The way things are looking now, I will have all bases covered with an Omega Seamaster PO for travel and adventure, a Breguet Type XX Transatlantique for unobtrusive daily wear (I also have a personal history with this particular model) and a JLC Grande Reverso Ultra Thin DuoFace in rose gold for special and/or formal occasions. I think those would be three absolute keepers for me. Side note: I tried to get into Rolex but I just can't justify playing their game. I'm absolutely in love with the Batman, because of how its colour scheme speaks to me and the GMT Master basically being the first ever smartwatch in my opinion. However a 5513 would be my holy Rolex grail but I think I'll do just fine without the headaches that come with owning and maintaining such a piece. Rolex is beautiful but at the same time it has become generic and in my estimation not worth the money. My $0.02 to this wonderful contemplative video. Cheers.
It is absolutely bizarre how much I agree with your choices. Not just the models, but the ranking as well. I’d never buy a SM300P, I do adore the watch, but it’s just not for me personally. I would never buy an olive explorer 34 either, but virtually all the rest..
Great advice that, "take your time". Of the watches you're considering, I have the olive dial 114200 and a few LE Speedy Pros. I've also recommended pretty much every dial variant of the 114300, the Omega 300m Master Coaxial (which is a great value buy in the grey market) and the Black Bay 58. I'll be getting a Submariner soon enough myself. Overall some great choices here. Before even seeing your next video I'm going to tell you to get either the 114200 or 114300 with a white dial. I prefer the indices on the 114200 and it definitely wears like a 36mm Explorer I. And you won't see as many of those out there as you think.
I think a Rolex OP 36mm in black or white would make an ideal first luxury watch. It's elegant, very well made and will never go out of fashion. It sits well on the wrist and isn't too big or bulky, will hold it's value well and isn't too flashy. The price is also pretty reasonable for a luxury watch. I feel that this would establish a sound base on which to build a collection.
I totally agree - couldn't have said it better. I have had plenty of luxury watches, but am not sure I've found 'the one' yet. Water resistance is also key to settling for one watch, in my opinion, which I guess you'll agree with, looking at your selection. Having tried both the 114270, 14270 and 1016 36mm Explorers, I lean very much towards that design, but I've ended up selling them all. I love the design (the case, dial and bracelet) especially the older less clunky ones, but their 36mm size just seemed a little too small for me, despite having very small wrists. My sweet spot, I guess is 38 mm. My number 1 candidates for a 'one watch' however would be the 114200 36mm Oyster Perpetual (as you say, the quintessential Rolex) or another 1016 Explorer. Thanks for making great videos - I'm a big fan of your channel.
I chose the black Tudor Pelagos as mine. Not because of brand but I loved how understated (although large) it was compared to a polished Rolex or omega which I would have ended up babying and feeling gaudy in.
Great analysis, IDGuy. If I were you, I would delay gratification a bit longer, skip the derivative Tudors and awkwardly proportioned Omegas, get the Rolex Explorer or No Date Submariner, and don't look back. You love your Smiths Everest and Submariner homages. You're the one buying the watch, so don't worry about others perceiving you as being unoriginal, since they don't know how you arrived at that watch. If you're still hankering for an Omega, then consider adding a Speedmaster later. My friend spent big money on getting his 16600 Sea Dweller, but the value came when he discovered that it was all the watch he could ask for, and he hasn't taken it off his wrist since. Not even for his Oris, Zodiac, vintage Baume et Mercier, or even his Grand Seiko. Rolex might be expensive relative to what you get on paper, but their wearability, versatility, timeless designs and robustness all add up.
Very nicely said, Chi-Town. I am so, so close to make a decision. At the end of the day I really want a watch that not only is something that I can cherish, but also one that proves that I practice what I preach (if you know what I mean?) It's going to be great regardless! I cannot wait for the unveiling day (whenever that might be) Thanks a million for the comment, brother
The Yachtmaster has escaped my attention. Do not remember being exposed to it online. Sometimes I disregard Rolex’s because they receive most of the hype. I understand many people strive to obtain one, due to all the attention given them. This is a very nice watch. Deserves more exposure. Almost like the stepsister who is forgotten. Will be interesting to see how it does going forward.
Thanks . Very interesting video . I am going with the Tudor BB58 . The Rolex OP 39 and the Omega Aqua Terra ( blue ). Right now I only have a Stienhart Ocean one 39 . A Hamilton khaki field automatic 38 and a Seiko sarbo35. I'm ok with my watches . I'm happy.
Interesting and comprehensive thought process. Hope you chose the right one in the end. Would like to say I've done the same but the reality is serial flipping of watches over many years. There's something almost intangible about Rolex over the others in terms of how the watches feel. Even though smaller (40 vs 41/42mm), Rolexes feel more substantial and that's what sets them apart for me... at least at this price point. Try twisting the bezel on a sub versus a pelagos and a seamaster and it's more solid. Same story when comparing the crown and pushers on a daytona versus a heritage chrono and speedmaster. Yes, more expensive and maybe a small factor, but for a one watch collection, I think it's worth the extra. Personally, I'd go for an AP...
I've bought my first luxury watch for over half a year now. I wanted a GADA with a black dial with less than 40mm and the contenders were: Rolex Oyster perpetual 34mm, omega aquaterra 38.5, tudor black bay 36 and Grand Seiko SBGR253 I leaned towards the tudor black 36 because the value and size were great but after the rolex OP34MM to me even though it has a simple design it had the x-factor for the proportions and quality of the watch and i will know that after decades it will look great. the aquaterra looked great in person but i felt it will look dated 5 years from now. the grand seiko is beautiful but i liked the rolex much more and the price wasn't huge between them.
Seeing this I value my Explorer even more. It stands out because of its versatility, its laid back charm, tool character and great wearability. Plus, it's a Rolex, so you get the history and value that the brand offers. The OPs can sometimes be too simple.
I'm impressed that you can even fathom only having one of these. Too many great brands, too many great models...You settle on one and a few months later, you start lusting for another. It's a sickness! Good luck!
Channel Support - Patreon: www.patreon.com/idguy
Latest Releases: ruclips.net/channel/UCzf6rqsEBni5G2TSevD6F4Afeatured
Follow me on Instagram: instagram.com/id.guy/
IDGuy Could you possibly do a video on the two experimental watches that went to the bottom of Mariana Trench from Omega/Rolex? The Rolex Deepsea challenge watch (2012) and The Omega Seamaster Planet Ocean Ultra Deep?
It’s been 15 yrs. since I bought my first luxury timepiece. It was Rolex Date Just, 116200. I still love it. I was in Tokyo and bought it at an AD in Ginza. During the financial transaction the saleswoman asked me if I was ill. I was pale and sweating a bit. I told her I wasn’t, but it was a lot of money. She smiled and said, “I understand, but it’s exciting isn’t it?”. It lightened the mood. It’s a great experience. You’ll remember it forever. Savor the moment. You’ll cherish it forever.
@@Spook291 Freaking brilliant suggestion! You won't believe, but I've just finished a writeup on the Tudor P01 and mention the "Deep Sea Special" (complete coincidence) I'd love to look at those two super watches and discuss their designs! Thanks a million for the idea N D
@@ashken3985 Thanks a million for this Ash. There are so many amazing watches out there and this whole "rationalising process" has made such a difference (hell, the audience feedback has been amazing too) In the end it really is about thinking of the future. What would I feel like with the watch in fifty years? it's a great thought!
IDGuy www.hodinkee.com/articles/live-photos-of-james-camerons-rolex
Don’t choose a brand. Choose a model. Don’t buy something merely because it’s popular. Buy what you love and what you’ll proudly pass to your kiddos.
Perfectly said (and that is a huge driving factor for me) All of the above, but also a watch that not only highlights that I "practice what I preach" but also one that'll make many, many memories. Thanks a million for your comment!
IDGuy Anytime! Honestly, I’d go for a more classical design. I’d go for a Glashütte Original Iconic Sixties with a flinqué dial. Something that will still be beautiful 100 years from now.
IDGuy Oh yeah - another good technique is to hold two models, one in each hand, to compare. If you’re after a sports watch - don’t forget to consider a Blancpain Fifty Fathoms. Make mine the blue guilloché dial version with X-71! The quality of the Fifty Fathoms is mind-boggling when you pick one up and hold it. One time I compared one side-by-side with a Submariner. They’re not even remotely comparable. There is not one square millimeter of the Fifty Fathoms that wasn’t unbelievably well thought out.
IDGuy Oh yeah, one last thing. There are a lot of great insider’s tips. I’m personally considering the Jaquet-Droz Grande Heure Minute Quantième Côtes De Genève. Jaquet-Droz is Patek Philippe quality for 1/4th the price.
Totally agree! In fairness, though, others do not like/wish to lead...those who tread their own path are oftentimes alone. I will always choose to be alone for the right reasons over joining the group. Love the Glashütte, BTW!
I feel as if I lean towards the Tudor side. I really do enjoy Rolex's designs and history, but their brand cache doesn't entirely line up with me and my personal style...but if i were to get one, id get an Explorer 214270 because its super under the radar in the metal.
While i can appreciate Omega, i dont like their case proportions in person...
The black bay lineup feels like its a great balance of wrist presence, design and feeling of overall value. in house movements or not, i think its a killer watch. i feel like Tudor is what Rolex used to be, which is also what appeals to me.
Very nicely said "Tudor is what Rolex used to be". I'm slowly but surely weighing up the options (and can't deny that the bb58 is a gem) Thanks a lot for the comment Nabrowne!
Notwithstanding the brand, the Tudor is not too simple. They are just right for the average man. We all like Rolex but Tudor let's you go unnoticed and yet it is a fine time piece.
I remember crossing this bridge in the 2000's. Fresh out of the military and college. Had a hole burning in my pocket. I didn't even consider anything else but Rolex. Went to Switzerland, walked into an AD and scooped up a sub no date. Then my next three watches would be all Rolex. If I could make my self go back into time, I would have done some more research and look at other brands. Most likely, would have gone with Omega as my first purchase. I have my Omega SMP 300 (2018) and never looked back. Truly, the perfect one piece for me.
Wouldn't be caught dead with a Tudor. Over hyped hipster watch that will always be Rolex's little brother. I will say, Rolex will always have a special place in my heart because it was my first purchase. Back in those days, it actually ment something. Today, can't say the same thing. Especially the silliness with Rolex and their marketing. Killing the brand name but scooping up money and getting all the kids to buy em. Smart, but not for me anymore.
Wow. Eye-opening and thank you for the comment! Your words really ring true (honestly the Seamaster is always a model I return back to... when we look at all of the factors, uniqueness, value for money, movement) I know exactly where you're coming from. So! We'll see! Great story from your side and thank you again!
Bell end wanna take the Pepsi challenge?let's play concors?my Tudor vs your swatch? Sorry omega?winner hats both watches and a grand?my Tudor will smash your omega to bits!your a clown m8
@@glenroberts8699 congratulations on making yourself look like a complete imbecile........ people like you really should refrain from commenting on adult conversation.
PS it's spelled Conkers
I reckon the final choice will be the 39mm 1957 Trilogy Seamaster 300 :)
Just for clarity, it's 38.6mm's ;)
I predict the same.
@@ID-Guy like you could tell the difference
I thought long and hard about this very decision for 4-6 months before finally pulling the trigger on a Seamaster 300. Highly accurate. Screw down crown. Waterproof. Looks great on a leather strap or a Omega nato. Excellent bracelet construction. Timeless design.
I own multiple watches from all 3 brands, with tudor being the latest brand I've got into..considering the value and the design language, tudor became my favourite in a matter of weeks
I have the Tudor GMT and I love it. I’ve had it for about 3 weeks and it’s wonderful to know what time it is in Japan at a glance. Truth is I could have gotten a Rolex GMT Master but I would be too worried about losing or scratching it. For me the Tudor is the perfect workhorse.
I actually like the colors and simplicity of the Tudor GMT more than the Pepsi. I do however find it so freaking thick, that i just cant see myself wearing it. What did they put in there, a car engine?
I have a Tudor BB GMT and sits perfectly on my wrist, looks thinner than it is.
Great video. For me I opted for Tudor. I guess in line with Hans Wilsdorf’s initial idea for the brand, Tudor just seemed to offer such a compelling package that for me I couldn’t justify spending more. I have the North Flag and Pelagos, both have an interesting story, an aesthetic I adore and superb build quality.
Omega, my 1st was speedy Schumacher, it's on my wrist today 15years later
I'm saving up for my first luxury watch purchase, and this analysis has really helped cement my initial focus on going with Omega, it will be a while yet though!!
Thanks so much Neel. I'm a bit hardcore with the details of this "choosing" process (but it's sort of my job, right?) But Omega is such a great choice... I'm slowly but surely edging to the brand. And don't worry, it took a good year for me to save up the right amount (remember to take your time) ;)
I am between the omega seamaster 300 or a Rolex explorer ii 42mm. Love both of these, recently tried them on in store. My first luxury watch that I want to wear everyday. Want to hand it down to kid some day... I am just trying to think 20-30 years from now will my kid want a omega or Rolex? I think Rolex is the more wow watch brand.. Omega also sells for 50% less used.. But, I am learning with omega 😆.. such a hard choice..
I promised myself I wouldn't watch anymore videos pitting watches against each other. It brings out the worst in people, myself included. But I still watched this and I didn't half regret it.
As much as I respect and admire the idea of a single watch, there is no way that I could ever pull it off. I have a very diversified life and I have yet to find a watch that can handle it all. I have managed to keep the same 4 piece collection for more than a decade though. But that changed a couple of years ago when I was nearing 40 and decided to mark the occasion with a watch purchase.
I alway avoid the versus videos where possible too! I really wanted to try and put the "designs of the brands" against each other instead. But it is difficult. Finding a brand is a good start at least ;) The ONE WATCH collection, I feel, is a pipe dream too hahaha! Thank you for the comment Jimmy!
@@ID-Guy I will not deny that I'm a bit curious as to what you have decided to go with. However, I doubt that you will stop at one watch :) Maybe for a few years, but more are coming. Cheers!
@@jimmyjay122 What was your 4 watch collection and which watches do you currently own?
The Tudor Black Bay 58 seems to fulfill what Rolex lacks in value for money, and what Omega lacks in correct size and wearability.
Maybe i agree. However the new Omega pieces are technically superior
I think you’re right. It’s the only thin black bay. The spectre omega looks unique but might be too thick. The newer seamasters are polarizing and have to fit your style. Rolex is expensive but now might be the best time if you ever want to do it. There is no perfect watch and it takes wrist time to truly know.
I had somewhat similar brands and models choice to make as my first watch. And instead of one Rolex, got 2 omegas (Aqua Terra blue 2018, and Seamaster 300m black rubber). Very happy with both.
Love your content, been watching your channel from the beginning, thanks for your articulate and deep content!
Great vid. I love most of your choices but to me the omega 300 is the ultimate, it just ticks all the right ticks.
Thanks a million, Alon! The Seamaster is calling to me... that's all I'll say (and your 300 as your avatar is just stunning...)
IDGuy hi, I’d like to send you a wrist pic, how please?
amazing content. i went through the exact same process you are going through now. i ended up falling in love with a white AT 38mm after going in the Omega boutique multiple times over the course of months. one interesting thing i did was take the measurement of my wrist width and divide it by the diameter of my watch. funny enough, it comes out to almost exactly the golden ratio of 1.62. this seems great for my everyday watch (and my beater is my blue Orient Ray which i will never get rid of) and i plan on getting probably an Omega NATO for the summer and a bespoke ostrich leg strap for formal events. still need to try this out on a NATO though, as the omega rubber strap on 38mm is just too small. a 41mm size would work better with the rubber, but be a less dressy look. Good luck on your choice!
I went with white AT 41 on rubber! Never looked back . . .
Of the models that you've shown I would say the OP39 black dial. I've never tried on this watch but it does sing to me. Love it has no date, clean and legible dial with a superb bracelet although no micro adjustment.
14060m (I own one) .It's a fabulous watch. Wears great, nice and slim, no date, simple uncluttered dial with a bezel that adds a touch of interest and has a use too, but everyone has one and they certainly aren't cheap.
Seamaster 300 MC (I owned the Spectre LE version. It wears thick and the over protruding end links make it wear large for a 41mm. Also having a 21mm lug width is a bit annoying if you would change up the straps which leads me onto the NATO. It really suits the watch but the added thickness takes it to almost 19mm!
For the record I also have the Omega Planet Ocean Liquidmetal LE which I bought new back in 2011 and an Omega Aqua Terra 38.5mm 'Skyfall'
Choosing to have just one watch is difficult for someone who truly loves watches as we constantly find ways to justify how a watch would fit into our lives and imagine wearing it at certain times in certain places. If I had to keep just one of my three it would be the 14060m even though I've owned it for the least amount of time as its the most comfy and has a timeless design compared to the more contemporary Omega's.
Good luck and I look forward to part 2 of this though process.
For six years I was a one watch man. Rolex Sea Dweller (ref. 16600) was my choice when it came to a sports watch but I am seriously considering getting an Omega now. They design beautiful pieces. They manufacture quality movements. And they don’t require the same investment as Vacheron, Rolex or JLC - the brands I am usually looking at.
Great video! I really enjoy the content of your channel. Your reviews and discussion about watches are very objective and well thought out. Congratulations!
My very first high end watch is my 2010 first generation Omega Seamaster Planet Ocean 2500 42mm, matte black dial/ black bezel with white numerals, absolutely love this watch and and think it really has a classic design that I've grown to appreciate even more over the years, this is a watch that will always stay with me.
I'm in the same situation as you, saving for my first luxury watch! At the moment I can't think of a better piece than a Zenith El Primero - you can get them for just about the same price as a Rolex Explorer, comes with an epic movement, 38mm, and the design elements on the dial and color choices make it was more interesting than any black dial steel sports watch.. on my opinion, of course :) cheers!
I've been where you were 2 years ago. I took 18 months of deliberations. I considered every single option. I too dislike a date cyclops. Therefore I chose the explorer and I absolutely love it!!!! Such a joy and never ever tire of looking at it. It's the finest and purist horological design out there.
Thank you ! I really appreciate the time & research you put into your channel ,I'm always looking forward to the next video you don't need my advice your sharp enough to figure it out your self !!
A great selection of watches on show here. Some really top contenders!
I am confident however that you will make the right decision for your new watch.
Another great video as always my friend. ✊
Based on your criteria, I would ask yourself only one question: which watch will give you just as much joy and satisfaction at 30 years old, and when you’re 70 years old?
If you have questions about some of these pieces don’t hesitate to email me, brother! I’ve owned and/or sold the Omega SMP 300m, PO 39.5mm, Tudor BB 36, BB58, and the Explorer 214270.
Brilliantly said, Orry. I definitely have been thinking about my "fifty year old / seventy year old" self a lot (and that has definitely helped with the process) - the whole idea of it being slightly smaller than average etc. all plays into the formula. There's one watch that I never mentioned in this video that may have ended up being the final contender ;)
@@ID-Guy A spoiler, eh?
Channels like yours really make my decision for my first luxury piece extremely hard
Hahaha! I'd say that is a thinly veiled compliment ;) BUT! Remember that this is pretty much my job at the moment (looking into watches & brands and tearing them to pieces). Too much scrutiny might make the process impossible...
"The Tudors are all too thick except for the 36" the 58 is too thick!!!!??? No! As someone that had a similar choice recently, and yes 1 watch is a wonderful idea, rather than an Explorer, or Seamaster 300m, I got a Tudor 58 and a GMT and couldn't be happier. They give much more flexibility as a pair than any one watch from the Omegas or Rolex you mention, great video man, love your stuff!
Fantastic video. Im aiming for the same 'one watch collection'. I laughed a few times because you've articulated exactly the same variables I've been weighing up in my head. Your shortlist is very similar to my own! Thanks for your channel, I've only recently discovered it and I'm happy I have done so :)
I went through the process for a year and ended up going for the Rolex OP39 grey dial. Love it one year later and can’t believe how well it goes with a suit or jeans or anything and catch myself looking at it regularly and take pictures of it on my wrist!!!!!!!!
Very interesting! As someone who gives massive amounts of thought to each piece in my own collection, I really appreciate this thoughtful approach. For you, I tend to lean toward the First Omega in Space or Rolex Explorer. I like the Aqua Terra, especially the newly-released green dial version (which you should check out if you haven’t), but most people I know who have gotten one end up selling it, ultimately unsatisfied that it doesn’t have the punch they were looking for. You really seem like an Explorer guy, but it is a bit cliché, especially recently. That seems to be the model everyone is suddenly gravitating toward. Ultimately, the First Omega in Space could make for an awesome one watch. It’s historically significant, a wonderful size, fantastic value pre-owned, and different from the typical Speedy Pro.
Looking forward to the next part in this series!
Excellent video on the three iconic brands, right on spot on chosen models.
My first brand - Rolex.
Model - Explorer 214270
In my opinion, it makes one of the best daily watches you can get and is a great start to a watch collection. Understated so it doesn't attract just anyone. But those who know, love you for it!
My wager....Rolex Explorer black dial. Can't wait to see what you choose.
If you want a great diver, at a great value, just take the Seamaster Professional. It's an amazing watch that is technically probably better than the Submariner, at half the price. It is a bit bulkier overal, but the movement is better and personally I find the bracelet and the clasp also better on the Seamaster. If you want a diver as your only watch though, I would go for the Sub 114060 because even the maxi-case is still very slim compared to other divers and the bracelet/clasp is much better than those on the 5-digit Subs. You can wear it in your board shorts and your tuxedo, while the Seamaster is a bit too sporty for the latter, so you would probably need an additional dress watch . If you are serious about only getting one watch that can do it all, and you want something that is somewhat original, just take the Explorer 214270. It's absolutely gorgeous, can be worn for any occasion and most people won't even notice it's a Rolex.
Good choices! The Explorer, the Aqua Terra, and Black Bay 58 or GMT would be my picks. I remember when you reviewed homages, so I'm happy that you're able to get The Real Thing!
Thanks a million. It's crazy how far the channel (and I have come) and hell, it's going to be amazing when the day (unveiling) happens. All of the watches you've mentioned are in my Top 5... so we're getting warmer ;)
@@ID-Guy Looking forward to seeing what it is! Out of curiosity, do you still have your homages?
My first luxury watch (and only that I've bought with my own money), is the Speedmaster Professional. Absolutely love it. So many other watches that look gorgeous in photos leave me cold in the flesh, but not this one. Shame it lacks water resistance.
My first one was a Speedmaster professional - 8 years ago. It took me 2 years to decide. I always came back to it. Though it’s not a slim peace, the unique profile allows it to appear slimmer than it is.
And now, some watches later - I still adore it and love my decision of 2012.
Though I need to admit that a Daytona wears better...much better. It’s my reference for wearability.
Hopefully in Part Two you narrow it down to three! Too many choices right now. I have a gut feel for what you might choose based on your vid synopsis. May the choice games begin!
It's going to be very, very interesting Reed... that's all I'll say ;) Some have pointed out a few interesting models (that may or may not have been included in the video)
@@ID-Guy To be honest, much like you I would be very happy with one luxury watch. Regrettably, what I currently own isn't it.
A Speedmaster and a handful of straps makes a great one-watch collection. You can change its character for any occasion.
Shaun Patrick O'Jameson I second this comment.
Another excellent video. I managed to forget about ‘you know what’ for 14 mins 49 secs.
I recently bought bought the Smiths Everest and the BB36. Both are excellent and quite similar in some ways. I know that you have issues with the snowflake hands, but this piece is very different to other Tudor models. It doesn’t try too hard and is its own thing. I suggest you try to spend some time with it? It’s so understated and comfortable. BTW, after 2 weeks of continual wear, I’m getting +\- 0.5 secs/day. I’m so glad I didn’t go down the well-trodden BB58 route. Picked mine up from an AD for £1,600.
Lucky to own an Explorer, BB58, Planet Ocean (39.5) and Aqua Terra (38). After much rotation over the years, the ones that sit on my wrist most are the BB58 and AT and, of those, the AT wins. The 38mm with white face is superbly proportioned and the co-ax movement very accurate. Even learned to love the PCL on the bracelet.
So many factors, but yes take your time! Firstly get the watch that looks the best on your wrist not one that ticks other boxes. Other factors include, can you afford other watches later down the line? If not will this watch satisfy you? If you can only afford 1 luxury watch and you really want a Rolex then save for it. My first luxury watch was an Omega Speedmaster Professional with hesalite, I still love it 4 years later and got it grey market for 3,000 euros. I recently got a Rolex GMT Master II 126710 BLNR at retail and love it as well. I think you really can't go wrong with anything from the brands mentioned.
I’d bet that either the Omega Aqua Terra or Seamaster 300m would be picked. I’m also on the same journey of finding one watch to be worn for the rest of my life. Can’t wait for part 2.
My first was an Omega Seamaster 2254.50. Wore it daily for 18 years and just retired it for the Tudor BBB with the in house 5602 movement. It's a gorgeous piece with a subtly refined, yet still rugged elegance.
I love my 2254.50. A undervalued and underrated watch
Tudor black bay 58 best watch I have bought in a long time or explorer 1
The BB58 is definitely at the top of my list (top 5 for sure) Maybe it'll end with me just flipping a coin ;) Thanks for the comment Marlito!
Buying the first luxury watch is so much harder than buying the second. It’s an agonising process, but in a wonderful way. After a lot of back and forth I went Omega SMP. It pulls at my heart strings just as it did when I was a wee lad watching Goldeneye.
Had the exact same problem when I was buying my first proper electric guitar as well. It took a lot of time and energy.
If you haven’t bought or decided yet; good luck and happy hunting, brother.
I own watches from the three brands. I think with Omega you get a lot of watch for the money as long as you buy preowned. Tudor is the perfect watch when you want a high quality watch, and fly under the radar. Regarding the brand with the crown, I never felt attracted until I got my first one. I expect to have always a Rolex around, and I hope to give one to each of my kids when they graduate from college.
Out of the watches you listed these would be my top choice from each brand. I think the Explorer is the best of the bunch.
1. Rolex Explorer
2. Omega Seamaster Professional 300m
3. Tudor Black Bay GMT
However, I'm a bit surprised that you didn't consider the Rolex Milgauss. I would imagine that model fits your interests.
Why buy an anti-magnetic watch for $2000 more than the Explorer? I don't think it's anti-magnetic feature would ever be used.
I was researching and “choosing” a watch for over a year, and had similar watches on my list. I ultimately went with explorer 39mm mk2 and i’ve been in love with it ever since
Great video #IDGuy, this could have been my exact video of what first luxury watches I have been shopping for; Omega Aqua Terra, Tudor BB GMT, Rolex Explorer, Grand Seiko SBGA375. Same comments around Omega's bracelet taper or lack there of, Tudor's case thickness and rivet bracelet, Rolex's price, couldn't fault the GS too much though. Visited the local Rolex and Tudor boutique and put my name down for either the Tudor BB GMT or the Rolex Explorer thinking it would be ages to get the call for either. But a few weeks later, I got the call for an Explorer and could not be happier with my purchase. Love the Explorer and can not fault it after wearing everyday for the past few months, better than I could have expected.
Wonderful video - i'm considering my first luxury purchase and this gave me a lot to think about. Appreciate your insights.
From the watches I've seen here today my choices would be the Sub, the Explorer and the Speedmaster.
I knew nothing about luxury watches except that as a long-time F1 fan going back to the late 60s, Heuer was the coolest brand (but I was only a youg teen at the time). So I learned a lot in the last 4 months, and decided to get a milestone Birthday, one time luxury piece. I put myself on three different waiting lists for a Tudor GMT Pepsi and was told there were extensive lists. I lucked out the other day, was called by one of the out-of-state ADs and....got my GMT! Say, it is a chunk, but so are most chronographs. And no one complains about those being too thick! Just get the watch as close to your wrist as possible without being uncomfortable, and all is good! Great choices of watches on part one! I look at it this way. If you are fortunate enough to get one of the watches IDGuy is choosing, then you have arrived! Smile!
I just went through this decision making process myself, with these brands and a few more. I went for the Omega Speedmaster Professional Moonwatch (sapphire sandwich). My 2nd choice would be the white dial Seamaster.
You pretty much have the same taste as myself. Almost every watch you mentioned I either own or have owned and since sold. My current collection now though is refined down to:
Rolex GMT Master 2 Ceramic Pepsi 126710BLRO
Rolex Submariner Date 16610T
Rolex Submariner Ceramic 114060
Rolex 1984 Datejust 16013
Omega Speedmaster Moonwatch
Omega Seamaster 1957 Trilogy
Omega 1970's Pave Deville
Tudor Black Bay 58
All these watches are amazing! I own the Rolex Explorer 114270 and the Tudor BB58 from your shortlist and they are both incredible! I think you should go for the Explorer or the Submariner after hearing your thoughts though.
I just purchased a new 41 mm Aqua Terra Blue Dial. For years I have committed myself to owning a submariner as my first luxury watch. Unfortunately for me, 2021 was no the best year to pull the trigger when considering Rolex. The AT though, has so much going for itself that just fits my wants and needs. A submariner at this point would be more of a trophy than my first watch I can enjoy. Still an absolute amazing piece but I don't know if I'd still enjoy wearing it considering the inflation and attention in the last couple years.
Go for the Omega Sea Master 300. It really seems to suit you and what your looking for in a watch. It's more unique, has a beautiful movement, priced right and has a classical vintage style.
Looking at these choices, your aesthetic is pretty clear. There is another item that should be on the short list in my opinion. JLC Polaris automatic, black dial. Perhaps eliminated because of case size, this piece fits like a dream. Ball room to ball game, it goes anywhere and makes the 'subtle statement' for those that know horology, and those that just like beautiful things that work.
Keep up the great work.
Looking forward to Pt 2 but I have a feeling what you may get 😁👏👊
Explorer II😉
Lawrence G Nah 😁
@@Mark..P I think you have a good idea already, Mark ;)
@@lawrenceg7341 What a classic bait and switch that would be? Hahaha! Great idea!
IDGuy 😁
Excellent video!
I can really relate to your search. I have many watches (including 3 Rolex) but if I had to go to one watch it would likely be my explorer II polar. Checks every box. Or at least the most boxes.
Have you had the chance to see some of these watches in person and try them on your wrist? It can make a world of difference to see and try them on rather just going on videos and pictures. The hard part may be finding a store that has enough of the models that you’re interested in.
I have absolutely! Ever since November last year I've been going to many, many boutiques, met up with friends who own the pieces. I'd never make a purchase like this without experiencing the watch first, don't worry ;) Thanks a lot of the comment, man!
IDGuy Thank you for the great content! I’m new to this watch obsession so I’m learning a lot from you guys!
One watch to rule them all! Get the Rolex Explorer and be done with it 😀
but as he says its boring
pilotstyle123 no way it’s boring. But it is common. Hard to beat the versatility of the Rolex Explorer though....
I'm so split down the middle at the moment... but there's no denying that the Explorer would satisfy many, many needs and wants ;) Thanks for the comment, brother!
If only ONE watch, then it has to do more. I would want the Omega Planet Ocean GMT. Great dive watch, plus GMT complication, and its still dressy enough for almost any situation, and still FAR cheaper than a Rolex.
@@knightwhite99 it's also a huge brick of a watch that lacks the class and heritage of a watch like the explorer
I think the top 4 candidates for you are (in no order):
OP34 Olive: You love the green dial. Simple, yet full of character. Perhaps too small?
Speedy FOIS: Iconic to Omega, robust, reliable, nicely sized and proportioned. Perhaps too common?
OP39 White: Well sized, simple, elegant, dress up or down. Perhaps a bit boring?
AT38: Similar to the OP39, but with more character. Perhaps a little thick and not particularly iconic to the brand?
Subs are expensive. You already have an Exp1 in the Smiths. The Seamaster 300, Diver, Planet Ocean, and BB GMT are too chunky for your taste. BB36 is a cheap substitute to the OP or AT, which you would be better off with. The BB58 is a great option, but it sounds like you just aren't in love with it.
White dialed Omega 300M or the Tudor Black Bay Steel and Gold Chronograph would be perfect single watches of you ask me
I'll put money on you going with the explorer in the end..
That's a bold claim! We could actually take Paypal bets on this! Maybe more want to get on this deal? Thanks for the comment as always Flippin ;)
@@ID-Guy I'd bet Seamaster Prof white dial. I also have a sweet spot for the JLC Polaris 9008480
@@ID-Guy yup let's set up a pool! Good call!
I’d bet you he won’t go with Explorer ... it’s too cliche.
I went with Omega Aqua terra, with the same layout of choices, and for similar reasons.
Omega Aqua Terra all the way. Simple, classy, dress up or dress down, will last a life time and never look outdated. You won't be able to escape the sentimental pull of your grandparents. Stay well! From Canada.
Yes. But no micro adjustment on the clasp and that sucks big balls
I like the Golf version with the tan leather bracelet.
I believe the Rolex explorer 214270 to be the perfect daily. 36 or 39 mm are very comfortable sizes and the watch remains thin enough not to catch on clothes etc.
I believe it is still a true tool watch, as you put it on and forget about it for 2 or 3 months until the itch to wear something different is eventually felt.
You can workout with it, you can sleep and shower with it, you can swim with it, go to work and (perhaps the ultimate tribute to a great tool watch...) you can forget about it and move on with your life, it will always be there when you need it. It really becomes part of you, no matter what your lifestyle is.
This is really an exceptional video. I've been shopping for months and so many of the things you talk about have been going through my mind. I bought a Rolex 114270 last week and sent it back. I've been going around this thing so many times I'm dizzy. With the world coming to end I have more reasons than ever to get one and yet I feel it's a waste of money at the same time. I have $100 Seiko watches i absolutely love and the 6k Rolex went back.... Looking forward to part 2. It must be the 39mm Explorer....right?
Great work, as always. I spent a whole year (!!??) making a v similar decision. I opted for the 114300-004 and haven’t looked back, clean, simple, reliable and robust. Picked up from the AD in Jan 2020 and am over the moon! Enjoy your choice, whatever that might be (214270 I expect!)
1 watch collection: JLC Reverso with steel back (sport, dress, and everyday)
2 watch collection: Rolex Explorer I, and JLC Master Calendar (to me no other combination of two covers everything)
3 or more: there are nearly infinite possibilities. (at this point, you are covering niche interests and uses which will be different for every person)
The best watch content video I’ve saw. Lovely, thanks for sharing.
I think you should choose the Explorer. It has presence. It’s understated. It has history. And it comes in a couple of size options which seems to be important to you. You might even argue is the original Bond watch since you brought that up. Let us also not forget it is the most accurate and least likely to depreciate, long warranty and service intervals.
I feel like most cannot withstand the tuffest choice: Is it a watch I like, do I really by this for my satisfaction OR is there the urge for recognition....?
Imagine yourself on an island, cast away.... what watch would you want with you?
Personally, the watch i feel is the most complete out of all the brands, models you showed is the planet ocean. It has the pizzas, the beauty, ruggedness, high level finishing and quality.
I have an 17 cm wrist and own the 2016 po 42 mm. It wears so comfortably. It’s the watch when i come back to it, it does the same thing as when i just bought it, it amazes me. The others just are ‘back’ and i appreciate them, but not the same magic.... the 42 is not really 42mm, it’s smaller and for me 38-39 is perfect, but this one, because of its construction is just proportioned so well.
I have been through the exact same thing last year! At the end I finally go for the 216570 explorer 2, and here's where my thought process:
In the end of 2018 someone in the same department introduce me into watches, and i start to dive into this hobby. I have no idea about anything about watches and i bought a Glycine combat sub Gl0185 as a beater, luckily my mom got a brand new eta movement Pelagos kicking around for no reason and i start wearing these two watch in rotation. (Pelagos as daily and go for Glycine when i want to get my hand dirty. p.s. i dont wear watches while working)
Around the middle of 2019, i knew the pelagos is lacking a little bit of bling factor for me as a daily wearer, so i start to look for a hopefully the first and final luxury watch for the rest of my life.The first thing i do is to list down different criteria for the watch to meet. I want a sport watch, black dial, some polish surface in the dial, great contrasting colour, tone down enough to not let people spot it a few meter away, and finally a brand that are well known for shock resistance and ease of service.
Now, i got three watches in my rotation to wear, and there is still one or two more watches in my "want" list. Hopefully they will never appear in my "need" list, so i will always have a few empty space in my watch box to fill, a few "dream watch" to look forward to. (But still, i am considering to swap the combat sub out for a SRPE35K1 samurai)
Nicely done bro! Can’t wait for the next one ☝️
Thanks brother, here's hoping I make the right choice ;)
This guy should be a professional narrator.... best watch channel ever.
Rolex, Tudor, Omega and other brands like IWC and SINN are all top notch. If you are going to spend a few thousand dollars on a high end luxury/tool watch do your research and buy what speaks to you.
Right now I am torn between three totally different watches, all of which speak to me:
Omega Speedmaster Professional
Rolex Explorer -39mm
Tudor Black Bay with Blue Bezel
Tudor Pelagos
I am leaning towards the Speedmaster, but the Black Bay is also calling to me hard.
I cannot go wrong with any of them.
Great vid as always mate ,I used to think Rolex was the be all and end all, but recently I have been thinking Omega is where the true value is, my opinion of course.I'm really thinking of getting the 2254.
I feel almost like Omega is offered at the prices that made Rolex watches so appealing back in the day (if that makes sense) and I've been studying their models religiously... And the 2254 is a lil cult classic in our community ;) Thanks for the comment Rob!
@@ID-Guy makes sense to me mate , I was also looking at the midsize 2252 some real good prices for them as I presume they are not so popular , hope you and family are healthy and happy in these troubling times.
Wonderful video and discussion. It is really difficult to ignore the outstanding design of the Omega Seamaster 300 heritage models.
I have been deciding weather to hold out for one of those or to take advantage of recent market drops to pick up a very comfortable fitting BB58. I really want the BB GMT Diet Pepsi, but fear it's thickness when I tried it on and worry about wishing I had something that disappeared on the wrist more.
I think Tudor needs a thinner GMT.
Speedmaster, always Speedmaster. Has the most interesting heritage, gives great interaction being a manual wind, hesalite so much nicer than any sapphire and looks amazing on pretty much any strap you can try. All good options but the Speedy is such an overall win for the money.
It is a banger. Great history, unique styling, a cornerstone watch for the brand... Ah, the thinking is so intense! Thanks as always for the comment, brother!
I love the history but all that ,only for a movement that doesn’t even have hacking!!!
@@watchesoflondon2333 technically no, but very simple to effectively hack when setting with a slight back turn of the crown which stops the seconds from running.
@@ID-Guy good luck IDGuy, you have some wonderful choices. It's just that one is more timeless than the others ;-)
Awesome vid! Fellow ID guy here! Had to decided between the Exp 1 and the 58 and ended up choosing the 58. The Exp 1 is an extremely beautiful watch, just felt that I'd get bored with it and living in HK where everyone wears a Rolex, the Exp 1 (including the sub and GMT) felt way too common.
One year on my wrist the Tudor black bay bronze .my first watch love it
Just the choice I am facing right now and the pieces are the ones that I am looking at, however I am on a waiting list for an Explorer, the omegas don’t have the same appeal, something about them doesn’t match the feel of a Rolex. All the power to you if you are content with an Omega I think they are a terrific watches, especially the speedmaster professional (which I think is so far the one most worth it), however not my cup of tea at this point. Great video, I am looking forward to part 2, guess I have to subscribe and just wait for that notification then.
Only 1 of the 3 shows you what’s inside...plus, Co-Axial is just so cool. Hard to pay thousands and not see what’s going on inside the case. One thing I dislike about my IWC. But, it does have the iron magnetic protection, so...forgiven. Good stuff as always mate!
I've found happy middle ground in defining a slightly less minimalist 3 watch collection for myself. The way things are looking now, I will have all bases covered with an Omega Seamaster PO for travel and adventure, a Breguet Type XX Transatlantique for unobtrusive daily wear (I also have a personal history with this particular model) and a JLC Grande Reverso Ultra Thin DuoFace in rose gold for special and/or formal occasions. I think those would be three absolute keepers for me.
Side note: I tried to get into Rolex but I just can't justify playing their game. I'm absolutely in love with the Batman, because of how its colour scheme speaks to me and the GMT Master basically being the first ever smartwatch in my opinion. However a 5513 would be my holy Rolex grail but I think I'll do just fine without the headaches that come with owning and maintaining such a piece. Rolex is beautiful but at the same time it has become generic and in my estimation not worth the money. My $0.02 to this wonderful contemplative video. Cheers.
I think it will be interesting that you make more videos of your top 10, top5, top3, the one clips announcing your let go watches and why-s :)
It is absolutely bizarre how much I agree with your choices.
Not just the models, but the ranking as well. I’d never buy a SM300P, I do adore the watch, but it’s just not for me personally. I would never buy an olive explorer 34 either, but virtually all the rest..
Great advice that, "take your time". Of the watches you're considering, I have the olive dial 114200 and a few LE Speedy Pros. I've also recommended pretty much every dial variant of the 114300, the Omega 300m Master Coaxial (which is a great value buy in the grey market) and the Black Bay 58. I'll be getting a Submariner soon enough myself. Overall some great choices here. Before even seeing your next video I'm going to tell you to get either the 114200 or 114300 with a white dial. I prefer the indices on the 114200 and it definitely wears like a 36mm Explorer I. And you won't see as many of those out there as you think.
I think a Rolex OP 36mm in black or white would make an ideal first luxury watch. It's elegant, very well made and will never go out of fashion. It sits well on the wrist and isn't too big or bulky, will hold it's value well and isn't too flashy. The price is also pretty reasonable for a luxury watch. I feel that this would establish a sound base on which to build a collection.
I totally agree - couldn't have said it better. I have had plenty of luxury watches, but am not sure I've found 'the one' yet.
Water resistance is also key to settling for one watch, in my opinion, which I guess you'll agree with, looking at your selection.
Having tried both the 114270, 14270 and 1016 36mm Explorers, I lean very much towards that design, but I've ended up selling them all.
I love the design (the case, dial and bracelet) especially the older less clunky ones, but their 36mm size just seemed a little too small for me, despite having very small wrists. My sweet spot, I guess is 38 mm.
My number 1 candidates for a 'one watch' however would be the 114200 36mm Oyster Perpetual (as you say, the quintessential Rolex) or another 1016 Explorer.
Thanks for making great videos - I'm a big fan of your channel.
I chose the black Tudor Pelagos as mine. Not because of brand but I loved how understated (although large) it was compared to a polished Rolex or omega which I would have ended up babying and feeling gaudy in.
Great analysis, IDGuy. If I were you, I would delay gratification a bit longer, skip the derivative Tudors and awkwardly proportioned Omegas, get the Rolex Explorer or No Date Submariner, and don't look back. You love your Smiths Everest and Submariner homages. You're the one buying the watch, so don't worry about others perceiving you as being unoriginal, since they don't know how you arrived at that watch. If you're still hankering for an Omega, then consider adding a Speedmaster later. My friend spent big money on getting his 16600 Sea Dweller, but the value came when he discovered that it was all the watch he could ask for, and he hasn't taken it off his wrist since. Not even for his Oris, Zodiac, vintage Baume et Mercier, or even his Grand Seiko. Rolex might be expensive relative to what you get on paper, but their wearability, versatility, timeless designs and robustness all add up.
Very nicely said, Chi-Town. I am so, so close to make a decision. At the end of the day I really want a watch that not only is something that I can cherish, but also one that proves that I practice what I preach (if you know what I mean?) It's going to be great regardless! I cannot wait for the unveiling day (whenever that might be) Thanks a million for the comment, brother
The Yachtmaster has escaped my attention.
Do not remember being exposed to it online.
Sometimes I disregard Rolex’s because they receive most of the hype.
I understand many people strive to obtain one, due to all the attention given them.
This is a very nice watch.
Deserves more exposure.
Almost like the stepsister who is forgotten.
Will be interesting to see how it does going forward.
Thanks . Very interesting video . I am going with the Tudor BB58 . The Rolex OP 39 and the Omega Aqua Terra ( blue ). Right now I only have a Stienhart Ocean one 39 . A Hamilton khaki field automatic 38 and a Seiko sarbo35. I'm ok with my watches . I'm happy.
Interesting and comprehensive thought process. Hope you chose the right one in the end.
Would like to say I've done the same but the reality is serial flipping of watches over many years. There's something almost intangible about Rolex over the others in terms of how the watches feel. Even though smaller (40 vs 41/42mm), Rolexes feel more substantial and that's what sets them apart for me... at least at this price point. Try twisting the bezel on a sub versus a pelagos and a seamaster and it's more solid. Same story when comparing the crown and pushers on a daytona versus a heritage chrono and speedmaster. Yes, more expensive and maybe a small factor, but for a one watch collection, I think it's worth the extra.
Personally, I'd go for an AP...
I've bought my first luxury watch for over half a year now. I wanted a GADA with a black dial with less than 40mm and the contenders were:
Rolex Oyster perpetual 34mm, omega aquaterra 38.5, tudor black bay 36 and Grand Seiko SBGR253
I leaned towards the tudor black 36 because the value and size were great but after the rolex OP34MM to me even though it has a simple design it had the x-factor for the proportions and quality of the watch and i will know that after decades it will look great. the aquaterra looked great in person but i felt it will look dated 5 years from now. the grand seiko is beautiful but i liked the rolex much more and the price wasn't huge between them.
Seeing this I value my Explorer even more. It stands out because of its versatility, its laid back charm, tool character and great wearability. Plus, it's a Rolex, so you get the history and value that the brand offers. The OPs can sometimes be too simple.
I'm impressed that you can even fathom only having one of these. Too many great brands, too many great models...You settle on one and a few months later, you start lusting for another. It's a sickness! Good luck!