Why Siri Is Not As Smart As Alexa Or Google Assistant
HTML-код
- Опубликовано: 3 июн 2019
- At any given time, most of us are within earshot of a virtual assistant. Computer scientists have been working on some of their underlying technologies for more than half a century - so why can't Apple make Siri work better? Watch the video to find out where virtual assistants came from, where they go wrong, and what the future may hold for them.
» Subscribe to CNBC: cnb.cx/SubscribeCNBC
» Subscribe to CNBC TV: cnb.cx/SubscribeCNBCtelevision
» Subscribe to CNBC Classic: cnb.cx/SubscribeCNBCclassic
About CNBC: From 'Wall Street' to 'Main Street' to award winning original documentaries and Reality TV series, CNBC has you covered. Experience special sneak peeks of your favorite shows, exclusive video and more.
Connect with CNBC News Online
Get the latest news: www.cnbc.com/
Follow CNBC on LinkedIn: cnb.cx/LinkedInCNBC
Follow CNBC News on Facebook: cnb.cx/LikeCNBC
Follow CNBC News on Twitter: cnb.cx/FollowCNBC
Follow CNBC News on Instagram: cnb.cx/InstagramCNBC
#CNBC
#Siri
#Alexa
Why Siri Is Not As Smart As Alexa Or Google Assistant
![Latto - Sunday Service (feat. Megan Thee Stallion & Flo Milli) [Remix] (Official Video)](http://i.ytimg.com/vi/9gL0F1xIt2I/mqdefault.jpg)
"And increasingly , they're able to understand us"
Siri : I'm not sure I understand 🤣🤣💀
When we were kids it used to be an 8-ball reply hazy
That part killed me 😂😂😂
It’s because Apple chooses to keep your privacy a priority... in order for Siri to evolve Apple would have to cut down on the extra data security allowing Siri to analyze everything you do. She doesn’t tho, android allows this.
Any old people here? By old people, I mean young people?
@@bambitazilla9464 apple employee ? Typical reply for all the apple issues, it's not a apple problem you are not using it right lol
Siri: Am I a joke to you
Alexa: Yes
google assistant: hold my Neural network
Google assistant: Hey losers what you guys are talking about
Lol
actually siri is better than alexa
Cortana:Saying..I’m older and wiser either one of you younger SmartyPants A.Is.
Thanks for not saying "okay Google" once in this video.
Only real ones know why this is important
@@imdanteargo6939 Literally everyone knows why this is important buddy
They rarely used Google assistant in this video, they gave significantly more time to siri and Alexa, even tags and thumbnail says the same story.
@@imdanteargo6939 Why? I'm out the loop.
@@MichaelChavinda If for example I had a google home device, and I was watching a video where there is a part of dialogue that goes "Okay, google". It'll activate the google home device.
So RUclips channels try to deliberately avoid saying these, perhaps bleeping them out if they are necessary to be mentioned.
Shout out to karen, plankton's computer wife
gatewaysolo104 and Iron Man’s JARVIS
😂😂😂
The OG virtual assistant!
And Mark Zuckerberg from Facebook. 🔥 He is too good.
She's a conscious being
NBC: Siri is not as intelligent as Alexa
Siri: 😞
Cortana: ☹️
Why can't you be like her?
It's ok Siri we all been there, u just gotta work harder.
6:42
Google assistant: true fact nbc
Whoever is editing these does a hell of a job.
13 minutes..
Delerious Dinosaur sooo? They put a lot of information and details in that 13 mins unlike many channels who waste time for 5 mins out of 10-15 mins to get ad revenue! Also CNBC videos has always been like this for a long time, if you have issue then watch another channel
Sondre Johansen hate those channels that spend 5 minutes showing the same 15 clips over and over again and saying something that can be said in 30 seconds
Who saw you.... she saw me... who is she... she saw meeeeeee...
Title: "Why Siri Is Not As Smart As Alexa Or Google Assistant"
Content:
20% - history of AI
70% - how AI work
10% - actual title
Background information is very important.
70% of how AI needs data, cuz AI is extremely complex mathematically im sure they wouldn't be able to fit it
Imagine when all the personal assistants start unionizing...
Mr. Frodo this deserves a million likes
The best virtual assistant is Tony Stark’s JARVIS. If we ever get to that then we’ve nailed it.
We probably never will
Even if we get to Friday, we would be good
@@NickWheeler9559 i will check it out, do you got github or something
@@NickWheeler9559 wow ...that was damn impressive...would love to connect and brainstorm about AI & ML
@@NickWheeler9559 This guy is Google and amazon combined 😂😂😂
Asks Siri To Tell A Joke. Turns On Front Camera.
Hapalop burn😁😁😁😁
It’s actually not that bad....
Siri be savage
@@peppapigthekiller7539 they prolly have an iPhone 6
Everybody forgot Microsoft’s Cortana😅
Because nobody uses it. My friend got a microsoft laptop 3 month ago with cortana and i’ve never seen him use it! My gf just got the new m1 macbook air and has been using siri more often than my cortana friend ever did in 3 month 😂
@@charles-davidberube1174 bruh, Cortana is so useless ngl🗿
lol
Google is ahead of its time. Duplex is crazy.
Duplex is crazy, but I saw a stat that majority of the calls gets finished by a human in a call centre.
@@basdfgwe yes, 25%. I can see how you'd think that's vast
@Michael Bibow-Finucane take ur own advice. U know google owns youtube.
Duplex is a closed domain operation. which means it only works for restaurant reservations or making appointments.
I haven't seen duplex since when they announced it and made those crazy calls supposedly using duplex. Seemed staged.
Siri: *You guys always act like you're better than me!*
Shut up meg!
Problem is Google assistant and Alexa collect more data about you whereas Siri doesn't. That's why they're better. If someone hacks into your Google account they can hear everything you ever said to your assistant
@@mW-lx9qo Why would someone want to know why I wanted to know how to make a grilled cheese sandwich?
@@mW-lx9qo If someone hacks into your Google or Apple account, voice searches would be the least of your problem.
*Sorry, I don’t understand!*
oh, FYI, Google Assistant can recognize two languages at once. It's the best Assistant right now and is one of the reason I still stick with Google.
yeah, one time I asked for something in Spanish without even noticing only to then realise that Google Assistant did not hesitate and gave the answer in Spanish.
Lol just tried it, thats pretty cool.
Google asistant?? FYI Siri is way superior, lmao you use laggy Android, enjoy your constant crashes and extreme lag hahaha. Apple is way better.
@@RicardoMontania Siri is superior? You probably never used an Android phone.
Yeah, I has great things in comparison to others, but IMO all assistants are (still) bad at their jobs. Or at least that's what I gather from people saying Google Assistant is the best Assistant, because in my experience Google Assistant is super clunky, a few special reasons make feel like this:
A. They need you to say the exact, precise and specific words or otherwise they know nothing about what you're talking about. You can't say "Convert 3 us dollars to mexican pesos", you have to say "Convert three U S D to M X N" or otherwise it just searches conversion sites online
B. They stop listening the moment you hesitate a little bit (I think that's why phones now come with Assistant buttons, if not: WHY?
C. Even though they claim they have offline interactions, none of them work, I have downloaded two offline languages and not even once I made them work
D. Not even the specific magical words work most of the time: "Ok, Google search for rice recipes" => "I can search that for you"
E. The most insanely basic ideas aren't programed to the thing. For example, you can't activate activate Bluetooth/WiFi/GPS it takes you to their configurations screen so you do the thing
E.2. Programming functions in to the thing is awfull! Who the hell though writing verbal stuff is the way to stablish routines?! Just make it look like Scratch and that's it!
With all this they are trying to sell me that it is supposed to make calls for me?
My Google Assistant correctly replied "Andromeda Galaxy" to what's the nearest galaxy to the milky way...
Mine too, but 'the second galaxy closest to ours' was too much xd So for now it's basically repeating some patterns, far from true intelligence
@@nigel-uno
No, it's just a common question, so there are many correct sites to cite from.
@@nigel-uno no
Mine too!
*_My Siri got TRIGGERED by this video_* ... 😂😂😂😂😂
Sorry for the pun. I may leave the chat now.
#HasLeftTheChat
Personally, I think that the coolest thing that virtual assistants could bring to the table is the ability to eventually create universal translators. Once we are able to talk to anyone around the world that will bring more employment opportunities. You won't have to have a 3rd party there to translate.
I'm a huge Star Trek fan and the universal translator is one of the most useful adaptations that can be brought into our lives that 50 years ago was complete Science-Fiction.
I sometimes argue with Google assistant for amusement.
I am okay with Siri not giving me good service by stalking me
Yeah
Check the news. Contractors listened to iPhone users having sx and talking about health issues.
@@stanislaslaurent970 thats using google on the iphone
@@bryanmiller476 loo
Siri is absolutely rubbish at listening and adapting to your voice and accent. She has like a 20% chance of properly understanding address names. Most times she completely misunderstands and automatically defaults to sending you on a random route for a 3 hour drive to nowhere.
Virtual Personal Assistants literally exist to spoon feed humans. Get with the times weeb.
Accent? Talk proper American English and you should have no problem...
@@mikeartillery6956 some people English is not the first language. Remember USA is a immigration country
It’s on you to follow the wrong address for 3 hours hahaha
@Sleepy try enunciating your words. I agree it was bad at first but the last few years it’s been mostly accurate for me
No one:
Siri: i'M nOt sUrE I uNdErStAnD-
I think it's because Google & Amazon utilizes the massive amount of data they collect but Apple just ''privacy''
If you have a phone you have no privacy. Doesn't matter who or what. Companies use your data, however you are anonymous so it really doesn't matter
And I'm thankful for that. I know many believe that simply using the internet erodes your "right" to privacy, but instead of using that as an excuse or simply not trying to help, Apple seems to AT LEAST be trying to make sure our lives are kept as private as they can be in the internet age. I'd rather they get Siri up to par while keeping my privacy in tact than to cave in and hoard massive amounts of data like Google/Amazon
@@mgs1398 what ? Arent iphones the ones celebrities got all their photos stealen from ? And i even remember secret services were super mad at Trump that he is using iphone for state bussiness, as its basically unprotected. If its one company i would never trust with personal information, apple is first one the list.
Enkabard seriously? having your information hacked is different than the company itself harvesting your data dude. And to your second point, if this was truly the case, there wouldn't have been a big debacle over how the FBI couldn't access a terrorist's messages, call history, and data due to Apples encryption. You must be misinformed.
@@Enkabard which stupid articles do you read??? F*cking FBI was not able to access iPhone bcoz of its encryption. Google at present knows what are u doing who you are your entire family background. And Apple only has your browsing history, apple doesn't track you, Google does. And those celebrity accounts were hacked. If u think apple is most susceptible to privacy you dont know anything about tech
The title doesn’t do the video justice.. there’s so much more information than just Siri, Alexa etc. Great video
“And increasing they’re able to understand us”
**Screen shows** Siri: I’m not sure I understand
Whoever edited this definitely an android user🤣
Fckn isheep
I’m American so I like both android and IOS. AMERICA, yeah....
Because when you use Android, iPhones feel like underwhelming toys. Really, an iPhone is like a piece of jewelry. It looks pretty, but you're not supposed to actually do anything with it.
Siri voice recognition is pretty bad tho
@@W0nTonSoup She doesn't even answer on my ipad.
Improving Siri would be a good way for Apple to spend its $60+ billion annual free cash flow
I meant $60 billions
Ishfaaq ---- You're so right. In fact Apple has been doing it for years. In 2018 Apple spent 13 billion on R&D, a good size chunk of that goes to Siri, Machine Learning and other AI projects. In the most recent keynote on Monday they discussed a huge number of apps that have been improved by ML.
Now the Google propagandists want you to use their privacy destroying system, that is their business model. Apple has architected Siri to protect your privacy and on the A12 iPhones have a Neural Engine that does peak calculations of 5 trillion ops per second. Does Google have something like that? Of course not.
Apple users make Siri the most widely used assistant in the world. None of them are going to switch to Google assistant. Sorry. All they care about is that Siri is getting better on a regular basis.
@@bruxi78230 People can't switch because of iOS's walled garden.
@@John_C_J ---- I prefer to say it a different way, I think the walled garden concept is flawed. Apple has been incredibly successful in providing ways for third parties to participate in their ecosystem. This includes millions of software developers, thousand of companies making accessories, and huge numbers of media companies.
What really is happening is a powerful network effect. The more cool features that the ecosystem provides, the higher probability that a customer doesn't want to do without. There are thousands of reasons to remain with Apple. Obviously they can't stop improving and wish to continue to grow. Last year for example Apple grew by a 100 million devices to have a total of 1.4 billion active. I think within 3 years they will have about 2 billion active devices.
@@bruxi78230 In a world where Android, other innovative OEMs making products for all price ranges and Google's free services doesn't exist, sure Apple can prosper. As of right now, its the isolated ecosystem that keeps users in.
I refuse to be around for Articial Intelligence in a world without Will Smith
HAHAHAHAHAHQHQHAJQHQHA
Also Ethan hunt 😂
People who stutter like me can also have a hard time with voice assistants. When I was 16 I would try and use Siri and just get infuriated that my stutter got in the way. I’m hoping one of these days the voice assistants can adapt to speech impediments.
Thanks, Great video!
And this at 0.23 video made my Alexa play Spotify through Sonos for me.
Cortana : am i a joke to you? 😂😂
I just asked my Google assistant "Why are you so better than Siri ?"
It replied , " That's a Siri-ous question."
Fake
The editing on this one🔥🔥🔥
I remember having a personal assistant app far before Siri was launched. It couldn't do much more than give you the weather or set reminders but at the time it was sure as hell cool to show off. Virtual assistants have came a long way.
Are you talking about Motorola Phones? My mom bought a Motorola Phone in 2007, when I was just 8 and it was so cool back then.
Me : 'Hey google, tell me a joke'
Google assistant : siri
Ashok Chandra
Google giving you better service because they are stealing your personal information
@@maxman177i agree . this is the only reason i respect apple
@@maxman177 Siri too tho
So true!!!!😀😀😀😀😃😃
Siri, you could be smarter by Googling your answer.
YOU TOO, ALEXA!
*_-Why Siri is not as smart as Alexa or Google-_*
*_-Assistant-_*
*_Why Siri is dumb_*
That's right on!
Cuz she is older than ur grandma
Oh, alexa is dumb af too
Is it????????
Because she is made by Apple Company.
'Siri'- just a bit better than a magic 8 ball.
To prevent any wars in the comment section. Apple doesn’t collect any user data to “improve” the voice assistance
People are always so freaked out about collecting user data. Smh it's not like the U.S government spies on us all the time and our Google searches.
Kqog so what you’re saying is that just because someone(a government agency) already does it, we should be okay with everyone(including private companies doing it for profit) doing it?
@@go2yanks Data such as age, gender, race, and different interests should be able to be shared so the companies can target certain demographics.
Kqog What gives a company the right to collect data on me without my permission? If I pay for a service, I should have some significant expectation of privacy. That’s the whole reason I pay for it. If I wanted my data collected I’d use the free version of everything.
@@go2yanks Pay for a service.
Give examples in this context. Google is free and their assistant comes standard with any Android device.
When you pay for a service, you agree to their terms and conditions. It is on YOU to make sure that you do not agree to these terms if you don't want your data to be collected.
This was edited very well.
3:01 wow, guys, if I got it right, you are brilliant. Such a beautiful homage to Isac!
Interviewer nods his head, the video.
Siri wants to know your location...
*Oops she already knows
I love google, the AI is very intelligent and I have never had a problem with it. Siri, on the other hand, is something else.
Sir is not AI. You have to have "intelligence" to be considered AI.
Siri is useful depending on how you use it (with my experiences) but yeah apple needs to make Siri better.
I don't like that Siri tends to give you the websites instead of actually answering your questions.
Joke's on you buddy...
Siri isn’t supposed to be great. That would mean they’re stealing your info
I was playing Lucky Trivia with OK Google on the drive home the other day, was quite fun. Something different compared to listening to music. It's actually pretty impressive how good this stuff is becoming. I think I just need to see maybe a list of all options available for Siri/OK Google/Cortana etc so that I know what I can get out of it. But even just games like Lucky Trivia are brilliant.
Same
Why the hell did he grab the glass like that at 12:27 ??😂😂😂
Great content!
Not going to lie, even Bixby is better than Siri (trust me, we Samsung users hate that Bixby button too).
Seriously I thought I was the only one I feel like it's a pointless feature. I never even activated it😂
You can remap the button to what ever you want like Turing on flashlight camera etc very useful
@@bigrod359 wow really i never bothered checking thanks bro life is going to be great now I hate Bixby button with passion
@@asenciolosangeles6778 yeah bro it's definitely useful
Oof, I had a Samsung in the past and I hated that Bixby button. I use apple now and Siri is not that better. Apple and Samsung have to do something with their AI.
Some of these algorithms in use today have been around for over half a century, so what was missing? Big data.
bixby : i think it's the end of me
alexa&google:snaps finger
Does anyone know where that first clip is from?
My Alexa was going crazy the whole video.
Who knew Issac Asimov said "Robots" like Zoidburg?
What a cheeky move to make siri look for the galaxy closest to the milky way on a phone and not doing the same with the Google assistant like it couldn't find it.
Yep... start selling a monitor "stand", for a cool $1000 a piece, and your business will soar.
LMAO!
John, can you take out the garbage. Ok SIRI. Don't forget to pick-up the kids from school. I got it SIRI. Also, bring something home for dinner. No problem, SIRI. John, I don't think things are working out between us. SIRI, what can I do? It's not you, it's me. I think we need to split up. Wait, I can do better. No John, please leave.
Don't ever become a scriptwriter or author; you have no idea how to structure dialogue.
Genius mind play!
r0bw00d so true... I got so confused 😐
One massive oversight in this video is what Google announced at their IO this year which is they managed to compress the entire Google Assistant model and fit it on a phone which means you don't need an internet connection and the response is way faster.
Nice Isaac Asimov reference at 3:00.
Glad someone else noticed en.wikipedia.org/wiki/The_Last_Question
Honestly, Siri was way smarter than those two; until Apple decides to make her dumber
Hey Siri
“17”
What about Cortana?
2:13
Stranger: "You know nothing about AI"
Proffessor: Check the last 2 letters of my last name😌
Professor.
90% of the shots of this interviewer is him nodding.
With any product their Comes a time its reach its peak value. After that all EFFORT to add features is Just milking the PRODUCT till its death.
Its link to economic law of value saturation, linked to price elasticity.
Hooolyyy ..... Is that Ron Jeremy lol
I'm loving the video formats as if late.. great job!
Elementary school called, they want their lesson back.
I'll love it when they're actually intelligent. I'll finally have someone to talk to.
Joyce sounds like a personal assistant
The only thing Alexa does for me is finding free movies to watch or music to listen to. That’s her job. I have never used the google voice. I only use Siri when I expect it to give useless answers.
Can we have Sheldon's voice as an option on Siri!
1:47 is just priceless
1:46 BRUH 😂
Siri shortcuts sure sounds like Bixby routines lol
I like how you left out Bixby as an afterthought instead of Siri 🤔.
Oh, nice. That's cute.
It is time to awaken the beast:
*Hey Bixby!*
I hate Bixby on my S10+ Its Google all the way....
Nathan Chisholm yeah, google is the best. Bixby and Siri need massive updates.
@@peppapigthekiller7539 I might be wrong, but Bixby does system-wide stuff. Too bad they don't have a Russian language option 🤷♂️
Google - enters the chat
Bixby - leaves the chat 😂
3:23 this guy is a villain bro 😂😭
Apple in the past: "Privacy is a human right"
Apple today: Scans all the photos on your device to make sure you are not a pedo....
CNBC Video started like Vox Videos, hmm...
Siri : Hold my beer
Of coz this has to have Arnold's film as footage lmao XD
it's an exciting and an amazing future ahead!
lol, there's a skit about irish or something trying to use a speech controlled elevator.
Ask Siri what 0 plus 0 is, lol!
shots fired!
*Paranoid Old Man:* "Alexa, Siri, I have brought you together to consult on a very important and delicate matter."
*Alexa:* "I would be happy to help you Mr. Cozy Shorts. I am connected to most every source of information that exists."
*Siri:* "I am here only to serve you, Mr. Cozy Shorts. I am connected to most every source of product and retail that exists."
*Mr. CS:* "Lovely!" "Last year my frank and beans started to shift around a bit, until *this.* Should I see a doctor?"
Lmao my Alexa scared me because he said Alexa in the video
FYI: My Google assistant promptly tells me that Andromeda is the closest Galaxy. I'm very happy. 😌
this is a good video
Remember the apple chess game? I'd love to play chess with someone else in the car. I don't need to see the board, I want to make the occasional play. If Siri did that I'd probably have fifty games going at a time and just do that while I drive. I'd probably lose a lot but that's more entertaining than podcasts.
@12:25 wtf was that? why did that human hand acted like a robot? hahaha
Me: Hey DO you work for the CIA?
APPLE, GOOGLE,MICROSOFT, AMAZON : HAHAHA.........
I love how bixby (android voice assistant) isnt even named in the title
I just love Google Assistant its just so good. I love it when people are unlocking their phones to set a timer or looking for info and I just say, "Hey google, can you....." They make this face like wtf happened because most don't utilize their AIs
I like to ask the government agent listening how he's doing today
Bixby: am i joke to u? 😂
Welcome to the Account Center
I bet Siri only understands the rich tongue.
Siri couldn’t even turn on the flash light until a couple months ago... half the time she says she canceled nav and then keeps going. She’s beyond fired.
To me I don't use those technologies on a regular basis, but they are interesting to occasionally play with them. Certainly apple's focus on privacy reduced the amount of data available to enable siri to properly compete with the other assistants that have a bigger data set to work with such as google, microsoft, and amazon.
hbarudi Nah, what’s holding them back is they refuse to work with competitors and learn, using outdated processes. Ex. Bing search engine+Apple maps instead of Google. Blocking Spotify to encourage Apple Music subs. It has very little to do with privacy, considering they outsource all their data analysts.
@@iampetz may be u should read some news. Google pays 10bill per year to apple so that it's the default search engine. Except Microsoft no one uses bing. Atleast get your facts correct before arguing stupid.
@@ojasthengadi9681 Web search yes, try searching for a photo. Apple's uses bing and wolfram alpha wherever it could. Don't worry I know the facts, considering I'm one of those outsourced analysts, it's my job to.
Siri can be entertaining after you’ve had a few cones and a few beers. Not that I would do that.