Hello, Chuck, I love all your videos! You were a great help in searching for speakers for my Stagepiano! I bought the Presonus E5 after I could compare it to the MTMs of ILoud. I think the Presonus will give the sound of a piano more natural and realistic than the MTMs. I saw the MTMs as a very tight and sound like plastic. The Presonus sound more honest and are even more favourable in the price. I paid for the Presonus 215 euros. The MTMs are also a few nearly 800euros! Thank you very much for your work. You were a very helpful help! Thank you, Roland
Nice content. )) Yesterday, I've compared the Yamaha MSP 3 (smallest version of the MSP series) - the studio monitors of a good friend - with my Presonus Eris 3.5 (smallest version of the Presonus series). And somehow, I liked the more airy, very detailed hi-res sound and the better panorama staging of the Yamaha MSP 3 a bit more. Although... my mixes sounded kinda similar concerning the frequency response levels (Presonus makes a bit more bass, but lacks a bit in the top end frequency spectrum), some of my tracks I would have mixed slightly different at some parts at which the Presonus Eris 3.5 have shown me a clean mix, but the Yamaha MSP 3 gave me a little warning that there could be some minimally muffled mids at some parts of the tracks. But most of my mixed tracks sound really good on both studio monitor systems - so, I guess the decision between both is not a deadly one for a beginner or advanced composer or audio engineer. ... Edit: After mixing my first track on the Yamaha MSP 3 and my Fostex PM-SUBmini 2 Subwoofer, I can definitely say, that the MSP 3 are much more accurate for mixing than the Presonus Eris E3.5. Even the smaller Yamaha MSP 3 show ya all the weaknesses of your mix really straight in the face - and if you solve those issues, the soundtrack will indeed sound really awsome if you check the final mix on every other system. Meanwhile, I'm still fully satisfied with the MSP for studio puposes. And for my gaming and movie corner in my new flat I've upgraded the former Presonus Eris E3.5 to the new model of the Presonus Eris E4.5 (where you can finally fine-tune the bass frequency band between +/- 6dB and the high frequency band between +/- 6dB like you could do this at the Presonus Eris E3.5).
Thanks for the review its what im looking for somebody who will give me info about the product and give me audio samples!!! Pls do more videos like these as i have subscribed to your channel.You just helped me decide which one to buy,thank you sir😊
Thanks! I got the Eris 5's based on my friend telling me why the MSP5's are better than the HS5's: both the Eris's and MSP's have Kevlar cones, meaning both are extremely accurate.
Hello Chuck..good vid thanks, with no trumpets/sensationalism. Im leaning towards the yamis and compensate for mids in the mix. Top and bottom end were richer/ thicker with the piano sound but thinner with the Organ and the preset rythm. (According to my ears on this vid).The ns10 reference got me.... Ive always had trouble with final mix levels. Im gleaning from this vid that the yamis are built "radio edit" friendly.
I have the Eris E8s, and I like them. Usually $500 for a pair, sometimes on sale for $400. Very good for the price, but I've heard the Focal Alpha 50 ($600 for a pair) and they're better than my monitors. Generally speaking the Presonus monitors aren't especially outstanding (except for the price).
Man, thanks so much for this. I think you summarised it all very well: both brands and models have been around for quite a while, old brands have marked the paths and new brand have their own ways into it. I will go for the Presonus because of budget. Thanks again.
I'm glad someone finally made a video about studio monitors for digital pianos. I'm sure you are not allowed to do these comparisons in lots of shops. Instead, they provide you with headphones to try out but I figure there can be significative differences between the two. Thanks for the information. I hope there will be more in the future.
Good shops will take the time to wire all of their monitors into a switch panel so that you can hear whatever monitors you wish, and A/B them! Unfortunately, shops like that are hard to find.
@@PianoManChuck I live in Spain a a few weeks ago I went to Madrid and visited a lot of shops to try DP's. I liked the Kawai MP7 SE but I didn´t dare to buy it without try it hookep up to a pair of monitors (it's for home). I'll get a Casio DX-560 instead.
@@josemiguelcarrizo7373 - you mean PX-560. Excellent choice! PX-560 gives you the best bang for your bucks. I've been using mine for years without problems.
PreSonus is a quality company. Studio one 4 is a great DAW. They both sound very good but as you showed PreSonus is equal if not better sounding and the price point makes it a great buy. Thanks Chuck. You rock!
I used to try and mix using the MSP5 but could never get the hang at all. Once I used the HS80m it was a lot easier with a learning curve of about half an hour. What you hear is what you get with the HS80
Thanks, this video really helped me to decide that I didn't need to spend the extra cash on the Yamaha's. Bought the E5's today! :) They'll be great for what I am doing!
How did it sound. Did you like them at the end? I’m trying to purchase some new studio monitors but of course I would want to play my keyboard through it
@@1face Presonus sounds amazing trust me you can’t go wrong no matter which you buy. They make excellent sound for the price sounds better than the more expensive ones in my opinion. You pay more sometimes for the name of the brand, and they don’t even sound as good. Hope this helps
@@MightyMonk360 thanks for that I’m actually using them now. That’s what I got on Monday and boy this badboys are fascinating so glad now that I got them
Hello. I was curious as to how you’re connecting these from piano to monitor. A lot of the monitors I have been looking at say it takes in TRS in the back while our pianos (mine is a NOrd Stage 3) are line level TS
Personas have this by a long shot better phase alignment with the presonus is richer sound, they have some voicing with yamahas and some cabinet colouration
First off it's Presonus, not Personas. Secondly you don't want monitor speakers to be 'rich', you want 'em flat so you can hear what your music production actually sounds like.
Hi, thanks as always for the information... I've recently bought a Roland FA-08, and I'm frankly struggling to decide a set of monitors.... The presonus are at the top of my list, albeit a bigger size...? I'd love to get away with a 6 or 7 inch, just for looks really.. Moneys not the issue, but I'm used to playing everything through a pa... For enjoying, not always recording....(vocals too). Perhaps, mackie, Jbls, 🤔 Thanks again.
Go Yamaha MSP series all the way - you won't regret it. ... Those are some of the most accurate studio monitors with the best high definition sound (and no disturbing inherent noises!!!) at studio monitors I've ever listened to (and I've listened to many studio monitors like Adam TV & AX series, KRK, Focal Audio, Yamaha HS series, Presonus Eris series, M-Audio. Even if most of your tracks might sound less impressive on MSP studio monitors - but if you manage to create an impressive mix on your Yamaha MSP studio monitors (I'm working just with the smaller Yamaha MSP 3 + Fostex PM-SUBmini 2 subwoofer since a few months), your soundtrack will sound even more impressive on your Presonus Eris studio monitors (was working with Presonus Eris E3.5 + Fostex PM-SUBmini 2 before - but I wanted to use the Presonus Eris studio monitors for my gaming corner, especially for enjoying the sound of modern games on a much higher level and they perform really well in this case - got the chance to get the MSP 3 from a good friend for my studio environment for a while and I think I'll buy them soon). ... If I mix on Yamaha MSP 3, the drums sound much punchier on other audio systems and the mid frequency section is much cleaner - no muffled stuff going on anymore. ... Maybe I'll upload a first remix I've mixed on the Yamaha MSP 3 + Fostex PM-SUBmini 2 in a few months to show the difference.
Nice video! been mixing on yamaha MSP series for years both the msp5 & msp7's. For mixing they get me where I need to go and the titanium tweeters definitely seem pretty direct and not fatiguing at all. For older monitors they're remarkable in their translation for mixing IMHO and still fit right in with the newer monitors of today.
I dont mean to be so offtopic but does anybody know a trick to log back into an Instagram account? I somehow lost the password. I love any tricks you can offer me.
@Juelz Van i really appreciate your reply. I got to the site through google and im trying it out atm. Looks like it's gonna take a while so I will reply here later with my results.
Great video Chuck. The Yamaha's have less colorisation of sound, more flat and neutral which of course is what you need for accurate mixing. I actually prefer the Presonus but that's because I also use monitors for general multi-media. I have the Presonus Eris 4.5's at the moment and ok they are not what I would call "pro" level monitors but they do the job for me. Also they have the volume control on the front :)
Actually the Yamaha's are not accurate at all! They're purposely lacking in the midrange because if you can make your mix sound good on the Yamaha's (especially in the midrange) then it will sound good on commercial speaker systems, car stereos, home entertainment systems, and other systems where sound is colored toward what the typical consumer wants to hear. This is why the NS-10's were so popular in recording studios! In addition to NS-10's, typically a 2nd set of near field monitors were there for accuracy! Good engineers mixed using the combination of both!
@@PianoManChuck Yeah that is what I was saying Chuck. The NS-10's are flat, neutral, no colourisation of the sound which is what you need for a good mix. I prefer the Eris because I don't just use speakers for mixing, in fact hardly ever except for YT videos. So the Eris is a more "all round" speaker :)
Presonus sounded more real. yamaha is abit loss in the frequencies. you noticed it too but then yamaha sounded better at the organ. damn this is hard. but if you really want certain sound you gonna need to record it with different speakers. no deny. techniques and etc. this one is really matter of preferences. a debatable review. both has its pros and cons.
I'm fixing a hole...and some Zep..awesome analysis!.. I have an old cp33 stage piano that desperately needs speakers being on a budget I would have to go with the presonus..however from my end the bananas sound better
Those Presonus monitors sound quite nice through my MSP5s (hee, hee) but seriously, what I take away from the video and comments is that the MSP5s probably have the edge in studio monitoring, and the Eris E5s are probably nicer for monitoring while practising your digital piano - which is what this video is about. I'm revisiting the video with my old MSP5s connected to both my computer and my digital piano via an audio interface. They serve well enough for both functions, particularly since the piano's own built-in speakers are doing some of the work, including the lowest notes, curiously. It's an old video, and I realise that the MSP5s are no longer on sale, and that Yamaha's HS5s are the replacement - very popular too! The Eris 5s seem to be fantastic value for money however, and they are great candidates for digital piano monitoring, though I might go for something nearer 8" if they were my only piano monitors. One thing though: We can't be very sure what speakers do like sound like when we listen via our own speakers/headphones to a video recording uploaded to RUclips. But Chuck has done all that can be done to present these speakers to us in the fairest way possible, and I know I'm grateful.
Thanks Mike. Whenever I do a video on speakers/monitors, or even microphones, it will almost always be as a comparison to another speaker/monitor or microphone. That way the listener/viewer gets to hear/see first hand how one sounds as compared to another. To simply present a video on a single speaker (pair) or microphone, is practically worthless unless you have something to compare it to.
Just made the decision to get the E5 with Scarlett Solo Gen 3 and I can't wait for them to get here, Thank you for the great review. Btw have you tried the E3.5? How do they sound compared to E5 when it comes to Piano sounds?
Thanks for the great movie but its hard to tell the quality when you listen through PC speakers or any other speakers and if any body says different there are wrong ive been an audio technician for over 20 years before my current job. still love your movies on RUclips looking forward for your review on the Nord Grand Thanks again
Year 2023 I feel that they both sound good, and I guess it depends on what's coming out. But somehow the Presonus seems to be somewhat better. But not certain, since I wear hearing aids. Lol. Terry
I think the difference is the wattage that makes the Presonus richer and Yamaha sound thinner. But Yamaha is more detailed and clear and Presonus is kinda muffled in the piano sample.
Certainly msp5 is better than boring e5 personus , personus is hi-fi system Note : for testing monitoring you should try with a sound in mixing not piano playing 😅
MusikOne it’s very incorrect to compare the top line Yamaha monitors with budget Adam. They’re even in different price categories. You'd better compare the MSP series from Yamaha to the AX series from Adam.
Let me tell you, the first time I heard a meaty kickdrum through the MSP5s it blew the hair off my face. It felt like those eye tests you get where they blow air in your eyeball. The bass and sub bass response is incredible as long as your audio is rich to begin with. The MSP5s don't flatter you with scoops or boosts.
Simply answer for me…………………………MSP5’s are twice the price. BUT nowhere near twice as good AND they are lacking i. The mid range. So it’s the Presonus Eris E5’s for me (or rather,I should have said the uprated E5 XT’s). Which are even better than the original E5’s
The only thing lacking in midrange will be your audio as the MSP5s are as flat as can be. No boost, no scoop. Perfect recreation. The Eris E5s are more flattering to the audio as they aren't as flat. They're closer to media speakers than production monitors.
Hello, Chuck, I love all your videos! You were a great help in searching for speakers for my Stagepiano! I bought the Presonus E5 after I could compare it to the MTMs of ILoud. I think the Presonus will give the sound of a piano more natural and realistic than the MTMs. I saw the MTMs as a very tight and sound like plastic. The Presonus sound more honest and are even more favourable in the price. I paid for the Presonus 215 euros. The MTMs are also a few nearly 800euros! Thank you very much for your work. You were a very helpful help! Thank you, Roland
Nice content. ))
Yesterday, I've compared the Yamaha MSP 3 (smallest version of the MSP series) - the studio monitors of a good friend - with my Presonus Eris 3.5 (smallest version of the Presonus series).
And somehow, I liked the more airy, very detailed hi-res sound and the better panorama staging of the Yamaha MSP 3 a bit more.
Although... my mixes sounded kinda similar concerning the frequency response levels (Presonus makes a bit more bass, but lacks a bit in the top end frequency spectrum), some of my tracks I would have mixed slightly different at some parts at which the Presonus Eris 3.5 have shown me a clean mix, but the Yamaha MSP 3 gave me a little warning that there could be some minimally muffled mids at some parts of the tracks.
But most of my mixed tracks sound really good on both studio monitor systems - so, I guess the decision between both is not a deadly one for a beginner or advanced composer or audio engineer.
...
Edit: After mixing my first track on the Yamaha MSP 3 and my Fostex PM-SUBmini 2 Subwoofer, I can definitely say, that the MSP 3 are much more accurate for mixing than the Presonus Eris E3.5.
Even the smaller Yamaha MSP 3 show ya all the weaknesses of your mix really straight in the face - and if you solve those issues, the soundtrack will indeed sound really awsome if you check the final mix on every other system.
Meanwhile, I'm still fully satisfied with the MSP for studio puposes.
And for my gaming and movie corner in my new flat I've upgraded the former Presonus Eris E3.5 to the new model of the Presonus Eris E4.5 (where you can finally fine-tune the bass frequency band between +/- 6dB and the high frequency band between +/- 6dB like you could do this at the Presonus Eris E3.5).
I have the E5 XT's, and they are absolutely amazing!
Thanks for the review its what im looking for somebody who will give me info about the product and give me audio samples!!! Pls do more videos like these as i have subscribed to your channel.You just helped me decide which one to buy,thank you sir😊
Oh man this video was so wholesome. Love the way you take your time to explain everything so nicely!
Thank you...very informative !!! Just what i needed to make the choice.
I love this review. Thanks so much!
Love yours Studio sound , well done ! 👍👍👍
Thanks! I got the Eris 5's based on my friend telling me why the MSP5's are better than the HS5's: both the Eris's and MSP's have Kevlar cones, meaning both are extremely accurate.
Hello Chuck..good vid thanks, with no trumpets/sensationalism. Im leaning towards the yamis and compensate for mids in the mix. Top and bottom end were richer/ thicker with the piano sound but thinner with the Organ and the preset rythm. (According to my ears on this vid).The ns10 reference got me.... Ive always had trouble with final mix levels. Im gleaning from this vid that the yamis are built "radio edit" friendly.
Great video, awesome Chuck!
Thank you for the review it helped a great deal!
Are you connecting directly to the speakers? Line out to line in?? Thanks!
Sir,if you were to pick one which would it be? I personally loved Presonus in terms of clear tonality
I have the Eris E8s, and I like them. Usually $500 for a pair, sometimes on sale for $400. Very good for the price, but I've heard the Focal Alpha 50 ($600 for a pair) and they're better than my monitors. Generally speaking the Presonus monitors aren't especially outstanding (except for the price).
hello, I would like to ask for your opinion regarding the "KRK RP-5-G4 Rokit" as to use for a stage piano.
Thank you Chuck. Spot on, very useful.
Man, thanks so much for this. I think you summarised it all very well: both brands and models have been around for quite a while, old brands have marked the paths and new brand have their own ways into it. I will go for the Presonus because of budget. Thanks again.
Can you do a video on the Nord Monitors vs. your recommendation
Awesome! Are the E5s better than E5XT? It’s confusing
I'm glad someone finally made a video about studio monitors for digital pianos. I'm sure you are not allowed to do these comparisons in lots of shops. Instead, they provide you with headphones to try out but I figure there can be significative differences between the two. Thanks for the information. I hope there will be more in the future.
Good shops will take the time to wire all of their monitors into a switch panel so that you can hear whatever monitors you wish, and A/B them! Unfortunately, shops like that are hard to find.
@@PianoManChuck I live in Spain a a few weeks ago I went to Madrid and visited a lot of shops to try DP's. I liked the Kawai MP7 SE but I didn´t dare to buy it without try it hookep up to a pair of monitors (it's for home). I'll get a Casio DX-560 instead.
@@josemiguelcarrizo7373 - you mean PX-560. Excellent choice! PX-560 gives you the best bang for your bucks. I've been using mine for years without problems.
Great to know the midrange is good cause I’m playing using these with guitars.
PreSonus is a quality company. Studio one 4 is a great DAW. They both sound very good but as you showed PreSonus is equal if not better sounding and the price point makes it a great buy. Thanks Chuck. You rock!
you still play the Kawai?
спасибо за качественный материал )
😊
I used to try and mix using the MSP5 but could never get the hang at all. Once I used the HS80m it was a lot easier with a learning curve of about half an hour. What you hear is what you get with the HS80
Thanks, this video really helped me to decide that I didn't need to spend the extra cash on the Yamaha's. Bought the E5's today! :) They'll be great for what I am doing!
How did it sound. Did you like them at the end? I’m trying to purchase some new studio monitors but of course I would want to play my keyboard through it
@@1face Presonus sounds amazing trust me you can’t go wrong no matter which you buy. They make excellent sound for the price sounds better than the more expensive ones in my opinion. You pay more sometimes for the name of the brand, and they don’t even sound as good. Hope this helps
@@MightyMonk360 thanks for that I’m actually using them now. That’s what I got on Monday and boy this badboys are fascinating so glad now that I got them
Hello. I was curious as to how you’re connecting these from piano to monitor. A lot of the monitors I have been looking at say it takes in TRS in the back while our pianos (mine is a NOrd Stage 3) are line level TS
You might try actually watching the video as that's all explained during the first minute!
PianoManChuck hahaha got em
Personas have this by a long shot better phase alignment with the presonus is richer sound, they have some voicing with yamahas and some cabinet colouration
First off it's Presonus, not Personas. Secondly you don't want monitor speakers to be 'rich', you want 'em flat so you can hear what your music production actually sounds like.
Hi, thanks as always for the information... I've recently bought a Roland FA-08, and I'm frankly struggling to decide a set of monitors....
The presonus are at the top of my list, albeit a bigger size...?
I'd love to get away with a 6 or 7 inch, just for looks really..
Moneys not the issue, but I'm used to playing everything through a pa... For enjoying, not always recording....(vocals too).
Perhaps, mackie, Jbls, 🤔
Thanks again.
Go Yamaha MSP series all the way - you won't regret it.
...
Those are some of the most accurate studio monitors with the best high definition sound (and no disturbing inherent noises!!!) at studio monitors I've ever listened to (and I've listened to many studio monitors like Adam TV & AX series, KRK, Focal Audio, Yamaha HS series, Presonus Eris series, M-Audio.
Even if most of your tracks might sound less impressive on MSP studio monitors - but if you manage to create an impressive mix on your Yamaha MSP studio monitors (I'm working just with the smaller Yamaha MSP 3 + Fostex PM-SUBmini 2 subwoofer since a few months), your soundtrack will sound even more impressive on your Presonus Eris studio monitors (was working with Presonus Eris E3.5 + Fostex PM-SUBmini 2 before - but I wanted to use the Presonus Eris studio monitors for my gaming corner, especially for enjoying the sound of modern games on a much higher level and they perform really well in this case - got the chance to get the MSP 3 from a good friend for my studio environment for a while and I think I'll buy them soon).
...
If I mix on Yamaha MSP 3, the drums sound much punchier on other audio systems and the mid frequency section is much cleaner - no muffled stuff going on anymore.
...
Maybe I'll upload a first remix I've mixed on the Yamaha MSP 3 + Fostex PM-SUBmini 2 in a few months to show the difference.
@4:20 organ low MSP5
@3:53 organ low Eris E5
@4:15 organ mid MSP5
@3:48 organ mid Eris E5
@4:10 organ high MSP5
@3:43 organ high Eris E5
Nice addition! Thanks!
@@PianoManChuck you're welcome ;-) . Thank you too !
Nice video! been mixing on yamaha MSP series for years both the msp5 & msp7's. For mixing they get me where I need to go and the titanium tweeters definitely seem pretty direct and not fatiguing at all. For older monitors they're remarkable in their translation for mixing IMHO and still fit right in with the newer monitors of today.
I dont mean to be so offtopic but does anybody know a trick to log back into an Instagram account?
I somehow lost the password. I love any tricks you can offer me.
@Luca Felipe Instablaster =)
@Juelz Van i really appreciate your reply. I got to the site through google and im trying it out atm.
Looks like it's gonna take a while so I will reply here later with my results.
@Juelz Van it worked and I finally got access to my account again. I am so happy!
Thanks so much you really help me out :D
@Luca Felipe you are welcome :)
Great video Chuck. The Yamaha's have less colorisation of sound, more flat and neutral which of course is what you need for accurate mixing. I actually prefer the Presonus but that's because I also use monitors for general multi-media. I have the Presonus Eris 4.5's at the moment and ok they are not what I would call "pro" level monitors but they do the job for me. Also they have the volume control on the front :)
Actually the Yamaha's are not accurate at all! They're purposely lacking in the midrange because if you can make your mix sound good on the Yamaha's (especially in the midrange) then it will sound good on commercial speaker systems, car stereos, home entertainment systems, and other systems where sound is colored toward what the typical consumer wants to hear. This is why the NS-10's were so popular in recording studios! In addition to NS-10's, typically a 2nd set of near field monitors were there for accuracy! Good engineers mixed using the combination of both!
@@PianoManChuck Yeah that is what I was saying Chuck. The NS-10's are flat, neutral, no colourisation of the sound which is what you need for a good mix. I prefer the Eris because I don't just use speakers for mixing, in fact hardly ever except for YT videos. So the Eris is a more "all round" speaker :)
@@yamahamusicians - Absolutely! Eris are a pleasure to mix with and to enjoy music with.
Presonus sound better
Eris and ceres 3.5 are also great for Digital Piano sound!!
Presonus sounded more real. yamaha is abit loss in the frequencies. you noticed it too but then yamaha sounded better at the organ. damn this is hard. but if you really want certain sound you gonna need to record it with different speakers. no deny. techniques and etc. this one is really matter of preferences. a debatable review. both has its pros and cons.
To me, the Yamahas seems more reveilling in the mid range section than the E5 wish seems a bit scooped to me
lol ur not hearing a scoop ur hearing a boost on the yamaha's their known for that
@@keepmovinent7679 The MSP5s aren't known for boost in the mids whatsoever, they're flat as can be.
I'm fixing a hole...and some Zep..awesome analysis!.. I have an old cp33 stage piano that desperately needs speakers being on a budget I would have to go with the presonus..however from my end the bananas sound better
Yamaha not banan
Those Presonus monitors sound quite nice through my MSP5s (hee, hee) but seriously, what I take away from the video and comments is that the MSP5s probably have the edge in studio monitoring, and the Eris E5s are probably nicer for monitoring while practising your digital piano - which is what this video is about. I'm revisiting the video with my old MSP5s connected to both my computer and my digital piano via an audio interface. They serve well enough for both functions, particularly since the piano's own built-in speakers are doing some of the work, including the lowest notes, curiously.
It's an old video, and I realise that the MSP5s are no longer on sale, and that Yamaha's HS5s are the replacement - very popular too! The Eris 5s seem to be fantastic value for money however, and they are great candidates for digital piano monitoring, though I might go for something nearer 8" if they were my only piano monitors. One thing though: We can't be very sure what speakers do like sound like when we listen via our own speakers/headphones to a video recording uploaded to RUclips. But Chuck has done all that can be done to present these speakers to us in the fairest way possible, and I know I'm grateful.
Thanks Mike. Whenever I do a video on speakers/monitors, or even microphones, it will almost always be as a comparison to another speaker/monitor or microphone. That way the listener/viewer gets to hear/see first hand how one sounds as compared to another. To simply present a video on a single speaker (pair) or microphone, is practically worthless unless you have something to compare it to.
@@PianoManChuck That's a very good point. Yes at least there is a reference that way.
There's a bit too much level from the Yamaha's tweeters, which is why I cover mine with a piece of cloth.
Just made the decision to get the E5 with Scarlett Solo Gen 3 and I can't wait for them to get here, Thank you for the great review. Btw have you tried the E3.5? How do they sound compared to E5 when it comes to Piano sounds?
Had them for years, they're great value but more of a bookshelf speaker than something useful for mixing.
Great job Chuck on the review. To me, the Presonus win.
Hi. What You play at 6:13? That strings.
"All of my Love" by Led Zeppelin.
@@PianoManChuck sounds better tam oryginal:)
Thanks for the great movie but its hard to tell the quality when you listen through PC speakers or any other speakers and if any body says different there are wrong ive been an audio technician for over 20 years before my current job. still love your movies on RUclips looking forward for your review on the Nord Grand
Thanks again
I'm listening through headphones because my Mackies crapped out. To me, Presonus has a richer sound the the Yamahas.
Year 2023 I feel that they both sound good, and I guess it depends on what's coming out. But somehow the Presonus seems to be somewhat better. But not certain, since I wear hearing aids. Lol. Terry
I think the difference is the wattage that makes the Presonus richer and Yamaha sound thinner. But Yamaha is more detailed and clear and Presonus is kinda muffled in the piano sample.
Certainly msp5 is better than boring e5 personus , personus is hi-fi system
Note : for testing monitoring you should try with a sound in mixing not piano playing 😅
Next compare the Yamaha vs. adam audio T7V.
The T7V's will BLOW THE DOORS off the Yamahas for sure.
MusikOne it’s very incorrect to compare the top line Yamaha monitors with budget Adam. They’re even in different price categories. You'd better compare the MSP series from Yamaha to the AX series from Adam.
E5 sound nicer, but Yamaha sound accurate (too accurate) I hope you can compare to BBC LS3/5A in future video...
Just now i buy msp5
If Yamaha one has bass it would be great.
Let me tell you, the first time I heard a meaty kickdrum through the MSP5s it blew the hair off my face. It felt like those eye tests you get where they blow air in your eyeball. The bass and sub bass response is incredible as long as your audio is rich to begin with. The MSP5s don't flatter you with scoops or boosts.
I heard more mid range in Yamaha
I prefer Presonos
I didn't like the way the Yamaha sound sounds dead, tini like he said , the presonus sounds horrible. Compared to the presonus .
Simply answer for me…………………………MSP5’s are twice the price. BUT nowhere near twice as good AND they are lacking i. The mid range. So it’s the Presonus Eris E5’s for me (or rather,I should have said the uprated E5 XT’s). Which are even better than the original E5’s
The only thing lacking in midrange will be your audio as the MSP5s are as flat as can be. No boost, no scoop. Perfect recreation. The Eris E5s are more flattering to the audio as they aren't as flat. They're closer to media speakers than production monitors.