I think if we want to avoid from being disappointed, we shouldn't expect anything 'crazy' in terms of improvement. A little improvement is better than none. just my 2 cents.
Is impressive how Adobe, being a giant, only walks tiny steps with roto... Mask Prompter and Davinci´s Magic Mask are insane; for Rotobrush 3 we need to test it and see if it crash all the time as rotobrush 2; do you know if rotobrush 3 uses gpu acceleration or just cpu?
Trying it right now, been on resolve but was curious with the update. But honestly I'm shocked how slow the processing still is. Resolve has been much faster personally. But I haven't given it the fairest shot yet still testing but just saying on first trial not amazed tbh. Ahem although the accuracy has been better
i really wish our company(which has Nuke based comp system) to take AEs Rotobrush seriously. In baking core matte circumstances, it really works absolutely fantastic... edge matte goes ehh sometimes but still kinda usable sometimes. Thanks for the video. didnt expected that one-time-selection works this well.
I just bought The Total Collection and I gotta say it is amazing! I've tested on my PR work flow to make simple RUclips videos and I highly recommend for the purchase as it shaves off a lot of time!
Anyone whose been in the industry and spent hours/days on these nightmare shots can really appreciate the advancements. The 'refine edges' is the killer part, putting it above Runway and Resolve in a GUI that is easy to understand and functional enough for fine tuning. Adobe got something right. heh Roto as an entry level position is going to go the same route as a tape room operator: dead as a dodo. Sad, but that's tech progress.
I mean fine and dandy for fast action where you can get away with missing fingers, but man, I still really struggle to use it with the slower shots I've been given and on 4K shots, oof, it takes so longer to render - better to just pre-render a matte if you're doing projects where things will change.
I tested on my side, Rotobrush 3.0 on After Effects and Magic Mask on Davinci Resolve After effects complated same work in 6.5 minutes and had to cache same clip for 2.5 minutes to watch. 9 Minutes total. Davinci Resolve complated it in 4 seconds. Instant playback When we ignore waiting time and watching for results: After effects is far behind from Davinci. I think adobe may remove that feature, its just doesn't work.
Every time I use this it’s like laggy moves slow and playback is horrible… I have 3060 series with acer predator, with upgraded 32 ram …. Should run smooth right ?
Instead of doing the list based videos of top 10 effects, transitions and text animations which anyone hardly uses, please do a breakdown of this video about all the ones used in this video itself. Would be greatly helpful.
🔅The "AI" roto brush in RunwayML is really not very good. Yes, for people who move against an nonkeyed BG, it's much easier to get a matte than Mocha Pro. But when you get into the details, and _roto is all about the details_, you'll find edges get cut off, hair strands especially go missing, and the first frame often has jaggy edges (in Runway greenscreen). 🔅I've found if you crank up the contrast before sending to Runway, then use the export matte as a luma or alpha layer over the original (without high contrast) clip, Runway works better. Sometimes I add a red border for clips where the character comes into or out of frame, then get rid of the border from the Runway export. That can help b/c Runway doesn't like characters touching the frame edge either. 🔆If Rotobrush 3.0 can capture hair strands and deal with low contrast edges better in nonkeyed clips, then it'll be a major step forward.
Rotobrush 3.0 is disappointing if you compare it to what Runway ML and Resolve have done with their rotoscoping tools. I love After Effects, but Adobe is making it easier to look for better alternatives, at least for these tasks.
Your not wrong it isn’t crazy in improvements yet again it is in beta. I think 3.0 will do better in weird contrast senerios with your footage but that may be jumping the gun a bit in hope.
Honestly, I am looking forward to being able to single click cut somebody out. It's going to make a ton of projects I've been putting off because of complexity achievable
Why RUclipsrs always use videos that don’t exist in real filmmaking? Of course the tool will work with stock footage perfectly shot, tu filmmaking isn’t always perfect. Cámara shake, camera defocus, lighting issues, etc…..you’re cheating people by showing this tools this way. 99% of footage has camera blur, and this tool is proven to malfunction with blurred edges…..so….
The whole video was smooth and the transition were cherry on the top.
I think it's too early to name it Rotobrush 3.0. Rotobrush 2.5 would be acceptable.
I think if we want to avoid from being disappointed, we shouldn't expect anything 'crazy' in terms of improvement. A little improvement is better than none. just my 2 cents.
Adobe is the best, first one, break two
😂 well said!
Yeah with all the advancements in AI, I'm a bit underwhelmed by all of these roto tools to be honest.
Man i love how you put this video with these smooth transitions
Hey bro what up? What do you think about mask prompter? It's an AEscript. Have you heard of it?
Is impressive how Adobe, being a giant, only walks tiny steps with roto... Mask Prompter and Davinci´s Magic Mask are insane; for Rotobrush 3 we need to test it and see if it crash all the time as rotobrush 2; do you know if rotobrush 3 uses gpu acceleration or just cpu?
I'm hoping gpu. Considering the speed of it
Nice. I used the Roto on a project just yesterday and it was very cool to isolate a product from client who didn't provide source files.
Trying it right now, been on resolve but was curious with the update. But honestly I'm shocked how slow the processing still is. Resolve has been much faster personally. But I haven't given it the fairest shot yet still testing but just saying on first trial not amazed tbh. Ahem although the accuracy has been better
Love the new slow-ish elegant style of the video!
This is pretty cool! I need to try it. I was hoping that Adobe would add a powerful "Select Subject" like is available in Photoshop.
i really wish our company(which has Nuke based comp system) to take AEs Rotobrush seriously. In baking core matte circumstances, it really works absolutely fantastic...
edge matte goes ehh sometimes but still kinda usable sometimes. Thanks for the video. didnt expected that one-time-selection works this well.
5:50 That's def true. A hell of a lot has changed since I started working as a motion graphics artist 24 years ago. OMG it's been 24 years. geez..
Es cierto, me acuerdo cuando salió ROTO BRUSH 1.0 hace como 12 años, y fue impresionante poder mover a un sujeto de cualquier vídeo
Amazing effects! Subbed for sure
considering this video is the only time i’ve heard about rotobrush 3, it’s hard to say it’s overhyped lol
Then after this comment the Algo sent the firehose of rotobrush 3 your way 😝
I just bought The Total Collection and I gotta say it is amazing! I've tested on my PR work flow to make simple RUclips videos and I highly recommend for the purchase as it shaves off a lot of time!
I LOVE getting comments like this. Could you add me on IG (@JoshOlufemii) and tell me specific packs you liked the best?
@@Olufemii I'll make a comment now with my account 😎
Amazing.....after a half century of development, Adobe has almost caught up to what Runway was able to do in 6 months.
Where do you get your sound effects for zooms and swipes etc, quite nice
insane sound design btw
this is insane in comparison to roto 12 years ago
it's good for the hardkey step
Hey, Josh. Missing herman's tutorial from a long time. Bring that guy on channel.
Anyone whose been in the industry and spent hours/days on these nightmare shots can really appreciate the advancements. The 'refine edges' is the killer part, putting it above Runway and Resolve in a GUI that is easy to understand and functional enough for fine tuning. Adobe got something right. heh
Roto as an entry level position is going to go the same route as a tape room operator: dead as a dodo. Sad, but that's tech progress.
Nice to hear a win vs. whining here. 👿 is in the details
I mean fine and dandy for fast action where you can get away with missing fingers, but man, I still really struggle to use it with the slower shots I've been given and on 4K shots, oof, it takes so longer to render - better to just pre-render a matte if you're doing projects where things will change.
Great tutorial. Love the content style keep it up brother 😊
Fantastic! Excited to see it in the stable version of After Effects!
Bro! did you edit this it's very similar to your style!
😉@@funikiedits8383
I knew it! you deserve it man congrats@@ApurvDas
@@funikiedits8383exactly!
@@funikiedits8383 Apurv is an editing KING. Yes he did
I tested on my side, Rotobrush 3.0 on After Effects and Magic Mask on Davinci Resolve
After effects complated same work in 6.5 minutes and had to cache same clip for 2.5 minutes to watch. 9 Minutes total.
Davinci Resolve complated it in 4 seconds. Instant playback
When we ignore waiting time and watching for results: After effects is far behind from Davinci. I think adobe may remove that feature, its just doesn't work.
what did you use to get the glow around all the icons you popped up , it's clean
Roto3 is insanely better idk wtf yall talking about im a roto artist and the improvement is minimum 2 fold
What do you think of magic mask in davinci compared to this?
Glad to see its constant evolution
Every time I use this it’s like laggy moves slow and playback is horrible… I have 3060 series with acer predator, with upgraded 32 ram …. Should run smooth right ?
Love your Content, greetings from Brasil! Obrigado pelo excelente conteúdo amigo!
at 0:05 how did you zoom in on 3D and emphasizing the subject? Is this a Premiere Pro preset that you made?
He made that on after effects with camera
Great video. The visuals of this video is just dope! Kuddos to the editor.🫂
comparing to davinci resolve's magic mask? whats your thoughts?
Wasn't all bells and whistles. Maybe just an incremental improvement at best.
Instead of doing the list based videos of top 10 effects, transitions and text animations which anyone hardly uses, please do a breakdown of this video about all the ones used in this video itself. Would be greatly helpful.
🔅The "AI" roto brush in RunwayML is really not very good. Yes, for people who move against an nonkeyed BG, it's much easier to get a matte than Mocha Pro. But when you get into the details, and _roto is all about the details_, you'll find edges get cut off, hair strands especially go missing, and the first frame often has jaggy edges (in Runway greenscreen).
🔅I've found if you crank up the contrast before sending to Runway, then use the export matte as a luma or alpha layer over the original (without high contrast) clip, Runway works better. Sometimes I add a red border for clips where the character comes into or out of frame, then get rid of the border from the Runway export. That can help b/c Runway doesn't like characters touching the frame edge either.
🔆If Rotobrush 3.0 can capture hair strands and deal with low contrast edges better in nonkeyed clips, then it'll be a major step forward.
Quality compared to Runway's "green screen"?
How does it compare to Resolve's Magic Mask?
Rotobrush 3.0 is disappointing if you compare it to what Runway ML and Resolve have done with their rotoscoping tools. I love After Effects, but Adobe is making it easier to look for better alternatives, at least for these tasks.
Not a major update I would say. Neural engines still got it a way better
Your not wrong it isn’t crazy in improvements yet again it is in beta. I think 3.0 will do better in weird contrast senerios with your footage but that may be jumping the gun a bit in hope.
Honestly, I am looking forward to being able to single click cut somebody out. It's going to make a ton of projects I've been putting off because of complexity achievable
bro i think you don't have an idea for brush size when rotoscoping :D
Magic mask in Davinci Resolve is way better.
I would have rather you have recorded a side by side on the same clip for roto 2 and 3.
I got a couple tutorials coming up:
Rotobrush 1, 2, 3 comparison
Rotobrush vs Mask Prompter Comparison
Rotobrush vs DaVinci Comparison
@@Olufemii nice, I’m looking forward to it :)
This seems to be a lot like Magic Mask in Davinci Resolve but somehow worse.
will do a comparison soon.
Support bhai please please me 0:22 ❤
let's be honest runway is way ahead still
it's so bad with the possibilities of AI these days
It's ok. I think the AI rotobrush is still better.
Why RUclipsrs always use videos that don’t exist in real filmmaking? Of course the tool will work with stock footage perfectly shot, tu filmmaking isn’t always perfect. Cámara shake, camera defocus, lighting issues, etc…..you’re cheating people by showing this tools this way. 99% of footage has camera blur, and this tool is proven to malfunction with blurred edges…..so….
Estoy de acuerdo contigo, esa herramienta no es para hacer magia, el cine trabaja con imágenes muy bien filmadas, para evitar confusión al software
yeah....sorry, i don't see that it has improved very much. disappointing