If you Liked the Video, Kindly Support Us - PayTM/GPay - 9829255606 UPI - fcbizjddigital@freecharge PayPal - paypal.me/jddigitalin Patreon - www.patreon.com/thejaipurdialogues CC/DC/IB - www.jddigital.in/support/
No, we dont like it. The concered person is incorrect. And the moment you this, you will be labeled as sadhguru follower or andhbakdh,without considering what other has said. when the other party himself is ignorant about many things..ask them what they know about om apart from reading? Mr sanjay dixit is very critical or in defame mode w.r.t sadhguru From previous mahashivratri because of ali mola song. I am very much aware of his biases. What he has done as sanatani? What impact does he made ? Anything which scale the indian culture, Compare it with sadhguru, baba ramdev..etc. Nothing!!
@@Narayananarayana143 exactly. Those who do sadhna knows about the restrictions. Since he do mass programs. You make those sound available in public which if one utters or chants, does general well being.
just few mins ago saw sadhguru's video where he was saying he wasn't influenced by any religion but he worships shiv and have seen many of his videos specially he says this around american christians....
@@theorder1548 ap mere dimag se kyu samjhna chahte h Sadhguru ko? Ap khud k dimag se samjajiye unko, wo na ho paye toh Osho ko samaj lijiye aur wo bhi na ho paye toh J.Krishnamurti ko samajh lijiye.
Problem with Sadhguru is, he speak lot of nonsense and irrational point of view, however when you counter with critical questions??? His plot twists and start saying I'm uneducated, never read any books, very far from logic and reasoning.
@@ham4553 tell me one example where a question was asked to him and he got proven wrong. Or tell me one critical argument against him which is true. I'll be here in comments
@@annusingh4694 Not everybody is capable of understanding what Sadhguru is trying to explain. It took me more than 9 months to start understanding just a few things. So, let the book people do their own things. I call them "Abrahamic Hindus". They'll shout and fight for defending the books. Even if Shiva comes and says something, they'll say you are not Shiva because you are not matching with the books. Shiva of this time may not come in same form as earlier. One needs receptivity to identify him 🙏
Sound is important not the words. When you chant OM sound starts from chest area. Where as if you do AUM, the sound of AAAA comes (or felt) from below the navel, notice the vibrations. It tries to activate/warm up the chakras by creating vibrations or heat. You can try to do it on your own and comment here
While West is trying to Remove Yoga of it's Hindu Origins, Sadhguru is propagating that the Source of Yoga is Shiva as Adiyogi & Adiguru who gave knowing to Sapta Rishis. He's building huge Stone Temples & creating Mercury Lingams spaces for self Transformation. He's been heavily targeted by Chirstian Missionaries in Tamilnadu. Hindus don't need enemies they have themselves!
Yes indeed there are many hindus who are helping the West to disregard yoga as a product of hindus....nd more cultural digestion... I haven't seen west claiming tea was introduced by them..... Propagating culture nd religion is gud.. Giving guidance is gud... But ignorance nd stupitidy is altogether woke... Be it a woke secular or a woke sanatani!.... To counter attack missioneries one needs to gain nd read nd become aware of our scriptures then to blindly follow someone.
Those enemies will be bramhins like this asshole......Sadhguru is enlightened guru and this guy represent bramhnical mindset which is responsible for decline of dharma
No one is denying the facts that he is doing all this. But criticism is on his knowledge. Also he has said Yog is not Hindu in one of his speeches. What about Ali maula in Mahashivratri? Those mistakes has been commited. And everyone should be criticised. It doesn't mean that Jaipur Dialogues is trying to bring him down.
@@nikhildeshmukh6221 lol 😂 again self acclaimed gyani like u can only point it out towards brahmins nd cry hypocrisy..... If it's his fault that he's brain washing u then it's also ur fucking job to do a proper research on ur own.... Chote bacche ho kya ✌
Definitely Sadhguru should be informed about this and he should correct his mistake gracefully. Actually he is doing gd work by standing as a stumbling block against converting Christian missionaries, facing cases against him
Aum/Om signifies Sabda Brahman - the Supreme Self or Absolute - whether it is considered an expression/manifestation of it or by others as creation of the universe in Cosmic Sound. By a simple search it is clear that Amen in Semitic, Hebrew and Greek is merely a word affirming the fixed, firm, reliable, true or veritable character of a preceding statement. Logically no remote connection between the meanings of the two words.
just few mins ago saw sadhguru's video where he was saying he wasn't influenced by any religion but he worships shiv and have seen many of his videos specially he says this around american christians....
- moreover, even while disseminating Vedic Knowledge to the West, he should be careful to not be #unjust by conveying WRONG ideas/interpretations. (There's a robust Guru Parampara etc., he can adhere to the same for seeking the right knowledge/means & ways)
I was at Swami vivekanand Memorial at kanya kumari. Outside, there was a plaque saying the same thing "AUM"...as universal sound...when I read this it sounded secular nothing else. In my understanding its English which is a funny language. 😁 Like we have great words like devi, devta, bhagwan ishwar which have wonderful meanings, and they are called "GOD" in english and Upperwaala by Bollywood and both of the words are just idiotic in meaning but still most commonly used by sanatani's.
@@thehawkseye3412 सोऽयमात्माध्यक्षरमोङ्कारोऽधिमात्रं पादा मात्रा मात्राश्च पादा अकार उकारो मकार इति ॥ Now this the Self, as to the imperishable Word, is OM; and as to the letters, His parts are the letters and the letters are His parts, namely, A U M. अथ, यह है 'आत्मा', और 'अक्षर-शब्द' है 'ओम्'; और 'उसके' पाद (अंश) हैं उसके वर्णाक्षर, तथा वर्णाक्षर हैं 'उसके' पादांश-'अकार', 'उकार' तथा 'मकार'।
@@mohansamant278 The debate is not to maling some one but to defend knowledge and concepts which Sadhguru malings. One should not manipulate truth to gain popularity and attract viewers in other religions and other countries. Shadguru is a master manipulator using words. Truth should not be manipulated.
@@shravani111-y9 And ultimately truth is what Sadguru said, but we will never understand because we are in attachment of physical body and bonded by all rules of Grammer .But real Irony is Om or aum is not a word to be physically pronounce ,it is a vibration in Bramharandhra so he said is absolutely correct. And if you think in physical way that is panini Grammer you may go on your way.One of the drawback of higly educated people is to use their brain to criticize and to propagate their physical knowledge which is always half...
Sanjay Dixit I Respect or support you but please don't talk about dharm you are not a capable person. if you really want to listen that "what is Dharma" then go to Osho Lecture.
It's really sad to see Hindus hitting on Hindus only. I don't know why suddenly Jaipur Dialogues is getting interested in teaching people Sanskrit! There are other people, scholars who have devoted their lives in spirituality and sanskrit. Let them teach us. What Sadhguru is doing is bringing the Sanatan Culture to the world. And we are busy cutting the roots of such people by nitpicking small small clips from some talk and making it a topic of discussion. PS. Inner-Engineering is a not a one-day program that you just go and attend, that too two times. It's a way of living in harmony with oneself and nature. I feel sorry for Jaipur Dialogues right now. 🙂
we must learn yoga from Sadguru but do not take philosophy from him.... instead, we must learn from Gita.... and for shatrubodh we must read Quran and bible....
@@sachinthakur7606 sad guru: promotes aryan invasion, calls shri ram an invader. uses derogatory things about maa yashoda. says hindus shouldnt take credit of yoga saays karna could kill shri krishna and arjun if he wanted says he hasnt read scriptures but he will poke his nose without reading them dances on ali maula on mahashivratri claims onm and amen are same 😂😂😂😂😂🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣 kuch bhi bane par fraud na bano.....or tumhe itna hi accah lag rha hai to tum bhi ali mola pe nacho mahashivratiri ko
☝️🙏☝️🙏☝️Enlightening and in-depth analysis. Thank you. Om Namah Shivaya. Sadhguru Ji must be informed to have it corrected.....or else he will been confusing everyone. 🕉️🇮🇳🕉️ Jai Hind.
This is very factual, research based, realistic but candid discussions between the two Learned personalities. So many other controversial sayings often noticed but nobody discusses, actually Learned Dharmacharyas should come forward to initiate discussions with him on such issues. 👍👍👍👍👍
A person is never 100 percent right on this planet.. in the material realm, we are all trying our best to find the absolute truth.,that aside..i still respect the guy cause he has transformed many atheist minds towards sanatan dharam which is more important. according to me... his sole purpose is like a bridge for this generation kids who are so full of themselves. lets not brew more hatred or critics among our own kind would be my humble request. Hari Om namah shivaya. Hare krishna.
Criticism is necessary to call a stupidity ,a stupidity. This sad guru is a kid ,so dont give him much space to become an idiot. If om & amin is same then shiva would say amin not om. Who is this stupid to say shiva said-- amin. omg . knowledge is superior to guru. Ok .
Absolutely , it is well known that if sadhguru makes his institution a hindu temple like organisation it will come under govt tax laws . So his intelligence must be actually credited to his inclusiveness yet giving Hinduism the patronage to other child religions
First of all he never talks nothing about sanatan dharma even though everything he teaches is from Sanatan dharma. If you closely listen what he says like forgot Ramayan, Mahabharata or the he support aarayan invasion theory, he says hindus should not ask for all temples just ask for 4-5 temples and forgot about other,how he allowed maula ali on the night of shivratri and justified it, there are so many more incidents. After thinking and analysing Jaggi Vasudev’s statements and actions I have stopped following him. Don’t follow anybody blindly is also taught by Sanatan dharma. Please look into our history and you will find 100s of examples of how Hindus were fooled, manipulated and harmed. In today’s world we can easily know about any body. I was his follower did inner engineering session, contributed also but then realised something is really wrong and there after stopped following jaggi vasudev. Om Namah Shivay!
Really Good. Even I had done Inner Engineering Online and went through Shambhavi Mahamudra, though not practicing it. And the secularization of OM was where I had a problem with initially, but over a period I accepted it, as the three sounds vibrating, differenting parts. Still I never felt "a" sound vibrating naval region as claimed. Thanks for this video. I will reconsider going back to roots, as I knew before I encountered this secularized AUM when I try re-connecting with Bhagwan using simpler & more intuitive ॐ. 🙏🙏🙏
a, u and ṃ - two vowels, and the anusvara at the end In Sanskrit phonology, a and u vowels, when placed next to each other while uttering result in a third vowel, o. That decides the matter once and for all. Accordingly, it's a+u+ṃ → o+m → om. About Pa, Pa has A in it. Moreover, the process is about chanting a mantra. Which is to be pronounce correctly. There are many ways of chanting OM or AUM for specific purposes.
Exactly this is what I have also commented is Sanskrit vayakran doesn’t solve the purpose od chanting the mantra. Just OM doesn’t bring any reverberation on the navel region. And you can’t say Pa after A & U because the mouth is being closed.
Amen of Abrhanmics comes from "Amun", god of the air, which was one of the eight primordial Egyptian deities. All of Torah and then Quran are traceable to pagan Egyptian religion, including their concept of monotheism (which came from Akhanaten) .
It is very easy to pick up famous personalities, But Hindus Very rarely found targeting , digging verbatim of other religious personalities , trait of DNA utilised by foreigners to divide and rule . Hope we learn something from History 🙏🏻
But it's interesting to note the sanskrit scholar does not know that Pranav in Yogic Shastra is not a 'word' of sanskrit or any language but the primordial sound of the universe reverating in the Anahata Chakra which any one can hear through yog sadhana. So pranav is a Naad or Brahma Naad not a word of any language. So if it is not a sanskrit word then how can there be sandhi viched??🤔 Any way as per the Agamas pranav consists of three sounds Aakaar, Ukaar and Maakar. This sanskrit scholar should learn a bit more on agamas before commenting. Little knowledge is a dangerous thing.
just few mins ago saw sadhguru's video where he was saying he wasn't influenced by any religion but he worships shiv and have seen many of his videos specially he says this around american christians....
डेढ़ चावल की खिचड़ी ,अति उपयुक्त समीकरण के साथ आपने जो समीक्षा की है , यह हमारे अनादि काल से चली आ रही सत्य सनातन संस्कृति धर्म के आधार पर सत्यपूर्ण है । हर हर महादेव। जय श्री राम। वंदे मातरम।
I would say because of Sadhguru thousands of woke youth has become sanatanis. He is the greatest gift to our country. He filled life to our culture back. Does Jaipur Dialogue produced any sanatani? People may like your channel but it’s takes something else to become sanatani. That thing Sadhguru is doing.
sad guru: promotes aryan invasion, calls shri ram an invader. uses derogatory things about maa yashoda. says hindus shouldnt take credit of yoga saays karna could kill shri krishna and arjun if he wanted says he hasnt read scriptures but he will poke his nose without reading them dances on ali maula on mahashivratri claims onm and amen are saME
Being Sanatani means to look at facts and find truth. Not blindly follow 1 person. To answer your question - yes Jaipur Dialogue has awakened ShtruBodh in Hindus. Now I have followed both Sadhguru and Jaipur dialogues. Even I started my meditation with him. But his knowledge is lacking and wrong.
Bro but it's wrong if you support any thing which is misleading how our great sage told us how to chant correctly who also get inner experience like sadguru and it's not good if your guru told you Aum and ameen same...I support sadguru but not everything...it's your duty if your guru teaching you something in wrong manner you correct this...For example Vagban Shiva tested his all students by doing thing that is adharm all his students accepted this but not parsuram he opposed him... what we can learn from this we can learn that if your closer one teaching in wrong manner you should correct it...
मैं तो कोई ज्ञानेश्वर नहीं हूं मगर इतना जानता हूं कि ॐ जो है वो कोई इंग्लिश से नहीं आया है। बल्कि बहुत सारे इंग्लिश शब्द संस्कृत से निकला है। ॐ केवल ॐ है। पृथ्वी जब घूमती है तब ऐसा ही कुछ ध्वनि आती है।🙏
Some people are unlucky enough to have attended the Inner Engineering program twice and still miss the point 🤣. They are trying to comprehend AUM with logic which is a bridge between Physical and non physical ??? Awesome.
Chanting AUM is not something that sadhguru invented, this is common in other lineage of kriya yoga as well, also taught by paramhansa yogananda ... Pls don't disrespect spiritual guru s just because you don't know anything about those aspects of knowledge
'Aum' is not about grammar. It is about sounds and their effects on the human body. If you wish to verify it you can experiment with pronouncing 'Om' and 'Aum', and then see the effects. Many Hindu books have described it as 'Aum' instead of 'Om.' for example the Srimad Bhagavatam.
Good point about grammar, grammar follows language does not preceeds it. However I have been to Kaivalyadham a very respected yoga school, students from all over the world. We were taught to chant ॐ Short ओ + अ in a second and then along as possible म as . Same as A + U + M = ॐ The etymology of amen linking it to ॐ is pure nonsense. Like saying that Scotland, England, London we can all lay claim to because they contain a Hindi word. Politicians and today's Gurus however have a certain right to spout nonsense and we shouldn't take them too seriously, nitpick I.e.
@@19683 If Amen can do similar things as AUM to some extent. That leads to similarity. The chant is supposed to activate your stomach, chest and throat region. When we twist the sounds slightly, there is certainly going to be a difference. For large scale people to agree to this needs experimental demonstration.
Are you guys mad? You are taking a spiritual practice of AUM chanting and rebutting it with grammar? If you have tried AUM chanting and OM chanting even once, you will automatically feel the difference in how your body reacts. Sadhguru is not talking about grammar or Vedas. He himself says he is not someone who has read spiritual texts. His teachings are based on spiritual energies and their effect on Ida and Pingla. Any system he teaches are based on his experience. Please try it out before putting rubbish out on internet. Sanjay ji 🙏🏻 Very respectfully your channel is becoming rabid and radical. Sadhguru is doing a phenomenal job of defending and spreading Hindutva. Go visit his ashrams you will only see stark Hindu practices being followed. You are targeting him because he told Islam that Ameen is a corrupt version of Aum? I think you should be happy that someone is teaching Islam the correct history. Shame on you Sanjay ji 🙏🏻 Respectfully.
Don't use grammar rules to deny what time can do naturally to how we say things. Sadhguru makes sense and you guys instead of challenging him directly are creating divisions within Hindus.
It's Aum only, if u practice and feel it starting at the base of your stomach and travel upward ending at your aagya Chakra with the sound 'mmmm'...stop maligning somebody unless you have practiced and mastered it yourself just because they are successful!
Stopped taking him seriously long back and unfollowed him from everywhere the moment i saw him dance on Ali Maula on the auspicious occasion of SHIV-RATRI. This man changes colour accordingly.
Nityanand ji and Sanjay ji 🙏. Fine Analysis by learned Nityanand ji who has hit the head of the nail. Objective of Sadguru ji is Popularity which is a parameter of success.
Sadhguru doesn't say AUM equals AMEN . We end up pronouncing OM as almost AUOM in pranayama and as only OM during simple mantra ucharan. So its having words like AMEN in other scriptures with different usage
@@vikaskashov1165 Fir to buddha guru hi nahi hain tumhare hisaab se,experience is what makes them guru. 4 forms of yoga hain gyaan,karma,bhakti & kriya….Kriya yogis need not know scriptures.Paramhansa yogananda kon sa scriptures pdhe the??
@@RISHABHKUMAR-jg9dv Kriya yogis need not know scriptures because the knowledge of scriptures lies in their heart. they already know it without reading any book. But their claims have to be consistent with scriptures or else how will one verify what they are saying is not gibberish ?
@@gauravshah89 sadhguru teaches shambhavi mahamudra kriya and his ashram raises niravan ashtakam all day , they practised bhairavi tantra and linga dhyanam consistent with shiva purana teachings. Why do u say it's not consistent
Sanjay ji, when you try to fit a sound into a language it will cause distortions. Esp if the language is a poor one like English. Focus on the sound, do not try and analyse it by the alphabet you use or Sadhguru has used. The sound (nada in Sanskrit) is important NOT the alphabet you use to try and write it in. All alphabet -even Sanskrit - is a human creation and quite inadequate to capture the real "form" of the sound. Finally, a suggestion - your forte has been and is social & political analysis and discourse - stick with it. DO NOT venture into such issues and controversies. It is quite unnecessary for you.
Perfectly said. And Sanjay doesn't realise the harm he is doing this way resulting in splitting the Hindus. As left liberals never realised how they began with Modi hate and became Bharat haters, so does people like Sanjay don't realise how they started with one thing and now reached undermining their own roots!
In Sanskrit "M" of AUM is half-sound (it has halant). In English transliteration it becomes full sound, which is technically wrong but there is no way to depict this sound without using special symbols. Sadhguru has read Hindu scriptures only in English it seems.
Sadhguru has said multiple times that he doesn't know Sanskrit and whatever he is, comes from experiences. Not a lot of people can say that. Whatever is said by Miśra is right in the grammatical and spoken language but less to do with chants, mantras and consecration. When it comes to the true understanding of nature and Human Being, Sadhguru is definitely skilled than anyone who has come out publicly. I'm not trying to belittle anyone here. I just feel that to really raise a point against what Sadhguru has said you need to be on equal footing of him in terms of the skills he has. If you have genuine doubts then one needs to be a proper student and ask his Guru.
He is no Rishi (mantra drashta) but a popular cult guru. He should not impart distortions of ancient concepts as "experiential" knowledge which breaks down under such scholarly analysis. Why should he distort traditions which he neither understands nor respects?
@@thrinethran2885 I don't understand on what basis anybody can conclude that he is cult guru. Every guru in our culture had followers ranging from a few people (Shiva) to a thousands (Buddha), when they were alive. Neither me nor you are seer enough to judge a man like him. Even when Krishna was here, there were a particular set of people trying to bring him down instead of truly seeking. All we can really do is come to the level of enlightenment first and then make accusations. This sort of blind disbelief will lead one nowhere.
@@123459136 He isn't daring to disgrace. In fact, he has done more than what 99% people have done to bring our culture to the forefront. When he is unsure about something he has openly admitted to it. Why is it wrong if he found experientially that Aum is better suited than chanting Om for people of this age. How can one be 100% sure that he is wrong. Even in law, we have innocent until proven guilty. I think the same applies here. If you are truly seeking, you can spend the time doing dhyana and find it out yourself. However, once you have, there will be some people waiting to accuse. It is not wrong to question, but simply unhelpful to accuse.
The logic is not about how we write (anyway writing is all about english letters 'AUM' or 'OM' whatever it is). The logic is about generating vibration at certain parts of the body
Problem with Sadhguru is, he speak lot of nonsense and irrational point of view, however when you counter with critical questions??? His plot twists and start saying I'm uneducated, never read any books, very far from logic and reasoning.
What I have gotten from Sadhguru is that.... 1.when you open your mouth with sound and close it one sound comes from there that is AUM and Sadhguru saying this is the basis of all sounds that you can utter. 2. AUM, Amen, ... All these are like Dhyaan,Dhyana and Dhyanam . He trying to say that they may have their own version of AUM.
Sadguru is enlighten one he might have experienced these sound like AUM but explanation grammatically might be wrong according to the evidences gathered.
Already great sage also tridev informed us through scriptures how to chant Om...I will support sadguru if this is about language pronounce prblm among continet but if you want to do ritual or japa you must chant correctly there is no problem if pronounce prblm among different language...also if you here Om sound coming from space you can here a u m sound openly...a dedicated to bramha u dedicated to Vishnu and m dedicated to Mahesh...you must chant u longer then a and m ... already our scriptures told us how to chant Om
I agree with your respect towards Guru but whatever we listen should go through threefold test...Guru Sadhu and Shastra. Guru says sadhu agrees but shastra doesn't support by reference in that case shastra says we should not only reject that concept but reject that guru also. E.g . Somebody follows Gandhiji as guru but in the original Vaishnav bhajan where is that sentence of ISHWAR Allah tere naam sabko sanmati de bhagvan , in that case we should reject these mental speculations and planned concoctions.
@@anantyuvabharat5874 yeah I know that sir and my guru only told me that and My guru isn't some self proclaimed old age citizen...He is from a bona fide guru param Para.. From BHAMA-Gaudiya Madhava sampraday. So be unallarmed what He would say would follow Guru Sadhu and Shastra.
You 2 guys talk about hinduism here, but sadhguru alone has spread our culture across the world better than anyone else. Now many outsiders are following hindusim and india's resprect has increased more because of sadhguru. Many youth has turned into our culture, our own indian youths was westernised, he bought them back into this culture, just 4 days back he concecrated shiv linga in bangaluru and you guys are critizing him on Aum ?, So this channel is just critizing not looking at postive things thats very bad. A real guru is the person who gives us the tools, Thats the Sadhguru, not just sitting like you guys on youtube channel and giving knowledge.
मेने इन भाऊसाहेब की वीडियो लिंक शेयर की थी नीरज अत्री जी के चैनल के कॉमेंट में कि इनको अपने चैनल पर लाइए बहुत ज्ञानी मानव है। और यह मुझे आज दिखे JD चैनल पर। आनंद है। लगभग 10-15 दिन पहले मेने लिंक शेयर की थी। मित्रों ऐसे ही वीडियो शेयर करते रहिए। मेने APOSTATE IMAM की भी वीडियो अत्रिजी के साथ शेयर की थी ट्विटर पर उसके बाद वह अत्रीजी के चैनल पर भी आए थे। 🙏 जय सनातन राष्ट्र। 🚩🕉️💪😊
Swami Dayananda Saraswati(Arsha vidya Gurukulam)- OM is a profound single syllable word. In sanskrit Om means that which sustains, or that such protects, अवति, रक्षति. Om is the NAME OF THE LORD who pervades everything in the form of the order नियति, that sustains. That नियति is Īśwara, the Lord and the meaning of OM. When I say Om, if you understand its meaning, you can see it is non-separate from the Lord- from "Prayer Guide" book Swamiji has explained much more 🙏 🙏
Sadguru is a businessman. He said yogi is not Hindu like gravity is not Christianity. This is foolish. He said he doesn’t read Hindu scriptures but he talks sadashiv all the time, who is sadashiv? That is bhagwan Shiv. We have too many fake gurus exploiting Hinduism. This needs to stop. My respect to Jaipur dialog for speaking the truth. This is much needed. People are so blinded by these fake gurus who are greedy for money. That is not a guru
Like political parties, a Guru doesn't need votes or funds. Lakshmi is at their feet. The divine gives safbuddhi to donors who donate for noble works like Sadhguru's. Sadhguru is not using money for personal gains. Using it only to spread spirituality or to uplift mankind. His actions may not appear logical, but then saints who have conquered their minds are beyond dharma. Lord Rama also sided with Bibhishan. Sadhguru having good relationship with people disliked by right wingers is like Sadhguru' is supporting Bibhishans. Saints' behavior is beyond our comprehension. Sharda Mata used to say " I am the mother of good as well of the evil" .For them good and bad ppl are same because both operate at the level of mind and not soul. Sadhguru is in atma consciousness, so all discrimination drops
I truly doesn't get why are people in comment section are so angry. I know about cultural digestion which is going and Sadhguru statement make it easy for them to lure people. But try to understand it has been done by all gurus who have went to west but that doesn't mean that they don't have Self Knowledge and identity of the enemy. Instead of this rhetoric why don't educate yourself and your community and reach out to Sadhguru at the same time about the various things which is he saying is getting used against our own civilization and tradition.
Super 👌 explaination and a wonderful counter. Great 👍 discussion and explaination by Shri Misra Ji and Shri Dixit Ji. 👏👏💥🔥 Wish we need not have wokes and lies to propagate anything, it will have its impact - whether we like or not. So, threading the path of Dharma is very important and lies and misrepresentation is simply a downfall. Whether it is in the name of Sadhguru or in the name of Bhagavan, better we be aware of these and stick to genuine seeking and knowledge.
If you Liked the Video, Kindly Support Us -
PayTM/GPay - 9829255606
UPI - fcbizjddigital@freecharge
PayPal - paypal.me/jddigitalin
Patreon - www.patreon.com/thejaipurdialogues
CC/DC/IB - www.jddigital.in/support/
No, we dont like it. The concered person is incorrect. And the moment you this, you will be labeled as sadhguru follower or andhbakdh,without considering what other has said. when the other party himself is ignorant about many things..ask them what they know about om apart from reading?
Mr sanjay dixit is very critical or in defame mode w.r.t sadhguru From previous mahashivratri because of ali mola song. I am very much aware of his biases.
What he has done as sanatani? What impact does he made ? Anything which scale the indian culture, Compare it with sadhguru, baba ramdev..etc. Nothing!!
But the problem is Pranav Beej mantra should not be publicly chanted
May be that is why he chants ot differently.
@@Narayananarayana143 exactly. Those who do sadhna knows about the restrictions. Since he do mass programs. You make those sound available in public which if one utters or chants, does general well being.
pathan pe chup kyu ho aap?
Sadguru is CIA and ISI agent employed to destroy Sanatan and destabilize Bharat internally. He is on their payroll.
Life goal - to speak like this guy.
Same !!!
ph.D in sanskrit
सद्गुरु हिन्दुओ के अतिरिक्त, अन्य समुदायों को प्रसन्न करने में लगे हुए हैं।
विश्वगुरु बनने निकले है गाँधीजीकी तरह सद्गुरु जी!
Apke pas Sadhguru ko samajhne layak dimag nhi h. Fir bhi Jai Sri Ram 🙏
तो आपका दिमाग समजाये सद्गुरु जी क्या है भाई !
just few mins ago saw sadhguru's video where he was saying he wasn't influenced by any religion but he worships shiv and have seen many of his videos specially he says this around american christians....
@@theorder1548 ap mere dimag se kyu samjhna chahte h Sadhguru ko? Ap khud k dimag se samjajiye unko, wo na ho paye toh Osho ko samaj lijiye aur wo bhi na ho paye toh J.Krishnamurti ko samajh lijiye.
Interpretation of Nityananda ji is absolutely based on facts of grammar of Panini ji
Thanks for a befitting rebuttal to SAD-Guru
असाधदुर्गुरु
Problem with Sadhguru is, he speak lot of nonsense and irrational point of view, however when you counter with critical questions??? His plot twists and start saying I'm uneducated, never read any books, very far from logic and reasoning.
@@ham4553 tell me one example where a question was asked to him and he got proven wrong. Or tell me one critical argument against him which is true. I'll be here in comments
@@annusingh4694 Not everybody is capable of understanding what Sadhguru is trying to explain. It took me more than 9 months to start understanding just a few things. So, let the book people do their own things. I call them "Abrahamic Hindus". They'll shout and fight for defending the books. Even if Shiva comes and says something, they'll say you are not Shiva because you are not matching with the books. Shiva of this time may not come in same form as earlier. One needs receptivity to identify him 🙏
@@visheshnath4833 💯
You forgot to mention...when you chant Aum
Aa: your body below the chest vibrates
Uu: your chest vibrates.
Mm: your entire face vibrates.
Sound is important not the words. When you chant OM sound starts from chest area. Where as if you do AUM, the sound of AAAA comes (or felt) from below the navel, notice the vibrations.
It tries to activate/warm up the chakras by creating vibrations or heat. You can try to do it on your own and comment here
Exactly!!
They are only literature yogi, not life sensitive 😅
While West is trying to Remove Yoga of it's Hindu Origins, Sadhguru is propagating that the Source of Yoga is Shiva as Adiyogi & Adiguru who gave knowing to Sapta Rishis. He's building huge Stone Temples & creating Mercury Lingams spaces for self Transformation.
He's been heavily targeted by Chirstian Missionaries in Tamilnadu. Hindus don't need enemies they have themselves!
Yes indeed there are many hindus who are helping the West to disregard yoga as a product of hindus....nd more cultural digestion... I haven't seen west claiming tea was introduced by them..... Propagating culture nd religion is gud.. Giving guidance is gud... But ignorance nd stupitidy is altogether woke... Be it a woke secular or a woke sanatani!.... To counter attack missioneries one needs to gain nd read nd become aware of our scriptures then to blindly follow someone.
Those enemies will be bramhins like this asshole......Sadhguru is enlightened guru and this guy represent bramhnical mindset which is responsible for decline of dharma
No one is denying the facts that he is doing all this. But criticism is on his knowledge.
Also he has said Yog is not Hindu in one of his speeches. What about Ali maula in Mahashivratri? Those mistakes has been commited. And everyone should be criticised. It doesn't mean that Jaipur Dialogues is trying to bring him down.
@@nikhildeshmukh6221 lol 😂 again self acclaimed gyani like u can only point it out towards brahmins nd cry hypocrisy..... If it's his fault that he's brain washing u then it's also ur fucking job to do a proper research on ur own.... Chote bacche ho kya ✌
Yeah world is trying to remove yoga of its origins and Sadhguru is helping us by saying that yoga is not hindu... 🤡
Definitely Sadhguru should be informed about this and he should correct his mistake gracefully. Actually he is doing gd work by standing as a stumbling block against converting Christian missionaries, facing cases against him
He will not. I have posted numerous times on his website. Also on delinking yoga from its Sanatana dharma roots.
Aum/Om signifies Sabda Brahman - the Supreme Self or Absolute - whether it is considered an expression/manifestation of it or by others as creation of the universe in Cosmic Sound.
By a simple search it is clear that Amen in Semitic, Hebrew and Greek is merely a word affirming the fixed, firm, reliable, true or veritable character of a preceding statement. Logically no remote connection between the meanings of the two words.
just few mins ago saw sadhguru's video where he was saying he wasn't influenced by any religion but he worships shiv and have seen many of his videos specially he says this around american christians....
- moreover, even while disseminating Vedic Knowledge to the West, he should be careful to not be #unjust by conveying WRONG ideas/interpretations.
(There's a robust Guru Parampara etc., he can adhere to the same for seeking the right knowledge/means & ways)
@@vish2553 Yes, Yoga belongs to Aryan Invaders, should not practice. Save Tamil.
He is doing for the same reason BJP is doing triptikaran. BJP thinks Hindu votes are saturated and Sadguru thinks Hindu followers are saturated...
🤣 👍
Problem is Sadguru has become cult and people are now following blindly without questioning any of his logic
Sadhguru be like, " It's buisness you don't understand but it's buisness ".
True that. Ganda hein par dhandha hein yeh.
Certainly
@@SumiOccult how demeaning and cheap is your comment
@@amrut13 Is it?? Really??!! Well, compared to what Mr. Jaggi is doing, my comment is nothing.
@Jeff Wright Forgot Gujrat?
🙏 Namaste sir.Sadguru is going the "SECULAR "way!! Should find the secret behind this.either funding or popularity and wider audience????
Demography is changing very fast in India....You have to include those population in your ideas in your thoughts.
gandhi was also doing it in a "secular" way
?
Both!
JD too much excited to prove his own understanding as true and needs or approval
Funding.... he has always been a hypocrite
I was at Swami vivekanand Memorial at kanya kumari. Outside, there was a plaque saying the same thing "AUM"...as universal sound...when I read this it sounded secular nothing else.
In my understanding its English which is a funny language. 😁
Like we have great words like devi, devta, bhagwan ishwar which have wonderful meanings, and they are called "GOD" in english and Upperwaala by Bollywood and both of the words are just idiotic in meaning but still most commonly used by sanatani's.
They are right in certain way.
AUM when spelled becomes OM.
Source Mandukya upanishad
@@schneider2332 It is only that Christians and Islamists were unable to follow our essence of (ओऽम)as it was written earlier if I'm not wrong
@@prakxyz Did you read that upnishad in English only? Or can you link / tell the page number etc where it is actually detailed that it is AUM?
@@thehawkseye3412
सोऽयमात्माध्यक्षरमोङ्कारोऽधिमात्रं पादा मात्रा मात्राश्च पादा अकार उकारो मकार इति ॥
Now this the Self, as to the imperishable Word, is OM; and as to the letters, His parts are the letters and the letters are His parts, namely, A U M.
अथ, यह है 'आत्मा', और 'अक्षर-शब्द' है 'ओम्'; और 'उसके' पाद (अंश) हैं उसके वर्णाक्षर, तथा वर्णाक्षर हैं 'उसके' पादांश-'अकार', 'उकार' तथा 'मकार'।
@@prakxyz Thank you.
The energy rises from below your body to your head when you chant AUM.
Yes
The best thing is to keep quiet. Why is so much money, time and energy being wasted to defame someone
No. Govto authentic sources. Manduyka Upanishad and Manduyka kariga of Gowdapada on OM will demolish all these aum stuff.
@@mohansamant278 The debate is not to maling some one but to defend knowledge and concepts which Sadhguru malings. One should not manipulate truth to gain popularity and attract viewers in other religions and other countries. Shadguru is a master manipulator using words. Truth should not be manipulated.
@@shravani111-y9 And ultimately truth is what Sadguru said, but we will never understand because we are in attachment of physical body and bonded by all rules of Grammer .But real Irony is Om or aum is not a word to be physically pronounce ,it is a vibration in Bramharandhra so he said is absolutely correct. And if you think in physical way that is panini Grammer you may go on your way.One of the drawback of higly educated people is to use their brain to criticize and to propagate their physical knowledge which is always half...
Sanjay Dixit I Respect or support you but please don't talk about dharm you are not a capable person. if you really want to listen that "what is Dharma" then go to Osho Lecture.
It's really sad to see Hindus hitting on Hindus only. I don't know why suddenly Jaipur Dialogues is getting interested in teaching people Sanskrit!
There are other people, scholars who have devoted their lives in spirituality and sanskrit. Let them teach us.
What Sadhguru is doing is bringing the Sanatan Culture to the world. And we are busy cutting the roots of such people by nitpicking small small clips from some talk and making it a topic of discussion.
PS. Inner-Engineering is a not a one-day program that you just go and attend, that too two times. It's a way of living in harmony with oneself and nature.
I feel sorry for Jaipur Dialogues right now. 🙂
Already our scriptures said how to chant Om...it's contains 3 letter A-u-m..A(bramha) u dedicated to Vishnu m dedicated to Mahesh...
we must learn yoga from Sadguru but do not take philosophy from him.... instead, we must learn from Gita....
and for shatrubodh we must read Quran and bible....
True
Mtlb sanatani katuwa Bane .
@@sachinthakur7606 sad guru:
promotes aryan invasion, calls shri ram an invader.
uses derogatory things about maa yashoda.
says hindus shouldnt take credit of yoga
saays karna could kill shri krishna and arjun if he wanted
says he hasnt read scriptures but he will poke his nose without reading them
dances on ali maula on mahashivratri
claims onm and amen are same
😂😂😂😂😂🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣
kuch bhi bane par fraud na bano.....or tumhe itna hi accah lag rha hai to tum bhi ali mola pe nacho mahashivratiri ko
@@sachinthakur7606 o bhai ,tujhe shatru bodh ka matab pata bhi he...knowing the enemy....kamal he yar..bhai tu.....
@@mukulpal8875 shatrubodh Kai liye Gyan chahiye
Pehle atma Gyan to le badmai shatrubodh kar Varna shatru bodh sidha gupt ang mai dalega .
Sadhguru - ❌
Sad Guru - ✅
फेक गुरु
Om ॐ
आम स्वादिष्ट होता हैं मीठा है तो मुंह में मिठास लाता है
जय भारत 🇮🇳जय हिन्द 🇮🇳
Hahahaha 😆
☝️🙏☝️🙏☝️Enlightening and in-depth analysis. Thank you. Om Namah Shivaya. Sadhguru Ji must be informed to have it corrected.....or else he will been confusing everyone. 🕉️🇮🇳🕉️ Jai Hind.
Confuse nhi Hindu dharam ko sickular bna rha
@@harshpal5934 yes
@@harshpal5934 how to get the English version of this video? Please help
He's a frauddd.... he also said astrology ko fake kaha hh
No gentleman he running agenda knowing that Indians spend enormous money on their religious and spiritual quest
This is very factual, research based, realistic but candid discussions between the two Learned personalities. So many other controversial sayings often noticed but nobody discusses, actually Learned Dharmacharyas should come forward to initiate discussions with him on such issues. 👍👍👍👍👍
When I picked on this misinterpretation on fb a few years ago, i got trolled by some blind devotees.
A person is never 100 percent right on this planet.. in the material realm, we are all trying our best to find the absolute truth.,that aside..i still respect the guy cause he has transformed many atheist minds towards sanatan dharam which is more important. according to me... his sole purpose is like a bridge for this generation kids who are so full of themselves. lets not brew more hatred or critics among our own kind would be my humble request. Hari Om namah shivaya. Hare krishna.
Criticism is necessary to call a stupidity ,a stupidity. This sad guru is a kid ,so dont give him much space to become an idiot. If om & amin is same then shiva would say amin not om. Who is this stupid to say shiva said-- amin. omg . knowledge is superior to guru. Ok .
Absolutely , it is well known that if sadhguru makes his institution a hindu temple like organisation it will come under govt tax laws . So his intelligence must be actually credited to his inclusiveness yet giving Hinduism the patronage to other child religions
Its nit about 100 percent correct hyt being correct about Dharmic things
First of all he never talks nothing about sanatan dharma even though everything he teaches is from Sanatan dharma. If you closely listen what he says like forgot Ramayan, Mahabharata or the he support aarayan invasion theory, he says hindus should not ask for all temples just ask for 4-5 temples and forgot about other,how he allowed maula ali on the night of shivratri and justified it, there are so many more incidents.
After thinking and analysing Jaggi Vasudev’s statements and actions I have stopped following him.
Don’t follow anybody blindly is also taught by Sanatan dharma.
Please look into our history and you will find 100s of examples of how Hindus were fooled, manipulated and harmed.
In today’s world we can easily know about any body.
I was his follower did inner engineering session, contributed also but then realised something is really wrong and there after stopped following jaggi vasudev.
Om Namah Shivay!
This type of collective sadhana is a new phenomenon where blind followers or minions are created. Gurukul system was something else.
sadguru is secular guru with huge ego
Who has no scope of progress ,build a boundary of ego.
Ego is an essential element for gurus as its like astra . Only great beings can seek liberate and sustain yogis to live a long life
पूरा पोस्टमार्टम कर दिया 🙏💪👍
Really Good. Even I had done Inner Engineering Online and went through Shambhavi Mahamudra, though not practicing it. And the secularization of OM was where I had a problem with initially, but over a period I accepted it, as the three sounds vibrating, differenting parts. Still I never felt "a" sound vibrating naval region as claimed. Thanks for this video. I will reconsider going back to roots, as I knew before I encountered this secularized AUM when I try re-connecting with Bhagwan using simpler & more intuitive ॐ.
🙏🙏🙏
a, u and ṃ - two vowels, and the anusvara at the end
In Sanskrit phonology, a and u vowels, when placed next to each other while uttering result in a third vowel, o. That decides the matter once and for all.
Accordingly, it's a+u+ṃ → o+m → om.
About Pa, Pa has A in it.
Moreover, the process is about chanting a mantra. Which is to be pronounce correctly. There are many ways of chanting OM or AUM for specific purposes.
Exactly this is what I have also commented is Sanskrit vayakran doesn’t solve the purpose od chanting the mantra. Just OM doesn’t bring any reverberation on the navel region. And you can’t say Pa after A & U because the mouth is being closed.
What ??OM doesn't bring reverberate to navel region ..
Bro how are you chanting..🙉
Yaa make your new language… new religion now 😅
@@yosoumya I think you are 10th fail. Read Sanskrit ncert books.
@@mavericksmart I am doing graduation in Sanskrit honours in bhu 🤣
According to SADDGURU , AMERICA is named after AUM
Amen of Abrhanmics comes from "Amun", god of the air, which was one of the eight primordial Egyptian deities. All of Torah and then Quran are traceable to pagan Egyptian religion, including their concept of monotheism (which came from Akhanaten) .
Christmas guru is back
Bechare Sadhguru ko Sangyaprakaran parha diya Mishra ji ne, bahat bariya. Paramam.
Mind blowing session
It is very easy to pick up famous personalities, But Hindus Very rarely found targeting , digging verbatim of other religious personalities , trait of DNA utilised by foreigners to divide and rule . Hope we learn something from History 🙏🏻
But it's interesting to note the sanskrit scholar does not know that Pranav in Yogic Shastra is not a 'word' of sanskrit or any language but the primordial sound of the universe reverating in the Anahata Chakra which any one can hear through yog sadhana. So pranav is a Naad or Brahma Naad not a word of any language. So if it is not a sanskrit word then how can there be sandhi viched??🤔
Any way as per the Agamas pranav consists of three sounds Aakaar, Ukaar and Maakar. This sanskrit scholar should learn a bit more on agamas before commenting. Little knowledge is a dangerous thing.
*Sadhguru:* we have ola cabs and uber cabs.
To complete *ola hu uber* and make ola tala happy we need to start new cab company *hu*
Don't bring other religion my dear ., please live without uttering other religion😂😂😂
@@janujanu-mb5bn Ask Sadguru same question when he dances on Shivaratri.
just few mins ago saw sadhguru's video where he was saying he wasn't influenced by any religion but he worships shiv and have seen many of his videos specially he says this around american christians....
Paramahansa Yogananda also said AUM
🙏🙏👍👍bahut sundar video
डेढ़ चावल की खिचड़ी ,अति उपयुक्त समीकरण के साथ आपने जो समीक्षा की है , यह हमारे अनादि काल से चली आ रही सत्य सनातन संस्कृति धर्म के आधार पर सत्यपूर्ण है । हर हर महादेव। जय श्री राम। वंदे मातरम।
Why are you behind a man who's changing so many people for the better ?
I would say because of Sadhguru thousands of woke youth has become sanatanis. He is the greatest gift to our country. He filled life to our culture back. Does Jaipur Dialogue produced any sanatani? People may like your channel but it’s takes something else to become sanatani. That thing Sadhguru is doing.
Sadhguru doesn't make Sanatani, he makes people follow his own ideology.....
sad guru:
promotes aryan invasion, calls shri ram an invader.
uses derogatory things about maa yashoda.
says hindus shouldnt take credit of yoga
saays karna could kill shri krishna and arjun if he wanted
says he hasnt read scriptures but he will poke his nose without reading them
dances on ali maula on mahashivratri
claims onm and amen are saME
*ALSO MAKES THE SAME YOUTH DANCE TO ALI MAULA ALI ON MAHASHIVRATRI
Being Sanatani means to look at facts and find truth. Not blindly follow 1 person.
To answer your question - yes Jaipur Dialogue has awakened ShtruBodh in Hindus.
Now I have followed both Sadhguru and Jaipur dialogues. Even I started my meditation with him. But his knowledge is lacking and wrong.
Bro but it's wrong if you support any thing which is misleading how our great sage told us how to chant correctly who also get inner experience like sadguru and it's not good if your guru told you Aum and ameen same...I support sadguru but not everything...it's your duty if your guru teaching you something in wrong manner you correct this...For example Vagban Shiva tested his all students by doing thing that is adharm all his students accepted this but not parsuram he opposed him... what we can learn from this we can learn that if your closer one teaching in wrong manner you should correct it...
मैं तो कोई ज्ञानेश्वर नहीं हूं मगर इतना जानता हूं कि ॐ जो है वो कोई इंग्लिश से नहीं आया है।
बल्कि बहुत सारे इंग्लिश शब्द संस्कृत से निकला है।
ॐ केवल ॐ है। पृथ्वी जब घूमती है तब ऐसा ही कुछ ध्वनि आती है।🙏
Some people are unlucky enough to have attended the Inner Engineering program twice and still miss the point 🤣.
They are trying to comprehend AUM with logic which is a bridge between Physical and non physical ??? Awesome.
Chanting AUM is not something that sadhguru invented, this is common in other lineage of kriya yoga as well, also taught by paramhansa yogananda ... Pls don't disrespect spiritual guru s just because you don't know anything about those aspects of knowledge
any reference from vedas, upanishads for the claims made by sadguru ?
Aam nahi sanjay Ji AUM!! 🤦🏽♂️
Brilliant discussion!
'Aum' is not about grammar. It is about sounds and their effects on the human body. If you wish to verify it you can experiment with pronouncing 'Om' and 'Aum', and then see the effects. Many Hindu books have described it as 'Aum' instead of 'Om.' for example the Srimad Bhagavatam.
Thanks Anna for the comment
Good point about grammar, grammar follows language does not preceeds it.
However I have been to Kaivalyadham a very respected yoga school, students from all over the world.
We were taught to chant ॐ
Short ओ + अ in a second and then along as possible म as .
Same as A + U + M = ॐ
The etymology of amen linking it to ॐ is pure nonsense.
Like saying that Scotland, England, London we can all lay claim to because they contain a Hindi word.
Politicians and today's Gurus however have a certain right to spout nonsense and we shouldn't take them too seriously, nitpick I.e.
@@19683 If Amen can do similar things as AUM to some extent. That leads to similarity. The chant is supposed to activate your stomach, chest and throat region.
When we twist the sounds slightly, there is certainly going to be a difference. For large scale people to agree to this needs experimental demonstration.
@@sadhguru_snapshots Don't shift goalpost
@@19683 lol. Do you even read? Well you are criticising Sadhguru's comment on Aum and Om. What else am I talking about?
Are you guys mad? You are taking a spiritual practice of AUM chanting and rebutting it with grammar?
If you have tried AUM chanting and OM chanting even once, you will automatically feel the difference in how your body reacts.
Sadhguru is not talking about grammar or Vedas. He himself says he is not someone who has read spiritual texts.
His teachings are based on spiritual energies and their effect on Ida and Pingla. Any system he teaches are based on his experience. Please try it out before putting rubbish out on internet.
Sanjay ji 🙏🏻 Very respectfully your channel is becoming rabid and radical. Sadhguru is doing a phenomenal job of defending and spreading Hindutva. Go visit his ashrams you will only see stark Hindu practices being followed.
You are targeting him because he told Islam that Ameen is a corrupt version of Aum? I think you should be happy that someone is teaching Islam the correct history.
Shame on you Sanjay ji 🙏🏻 Respectfully.
Very informative.
Don't use grammar rules to deny what time can do naturally to how we say things.
Sadhguru makes sense and you guys instead of challenging him directly are creating divisions within Hindus.
It's Aum only, if u practice and feel it starting at the base of your stomach and travel upward ending at your aagya Chakra with the sound 'mmmm'...stop maligning somebody unless you have practiced and mastered it yourself just because they are successful!
Exactly. Now Jaipur dialogues wants to get famous by targeting sadhguru.
Why? Sadguru can never go wrong?
Stopped taking him seriously long back and unfollowed him from everywhere the moment i saw him dance on Ali Maula on the auspicious occasion of SHIV-RATRI. This man changes colour accordingly.
शत शत आभार और नमन संजय जी आपको, निरंतर समाज के चक्षु खोलने के लिए 🙏💐💐💐 जय श्रीराम 🙏🚩🚩🚩
He is indeed going a secular way.. जाको प्रभु दारुण दुख देहि ताकि मति पहिले हरी लेहि।
अति शाहणा तेचा बैइल रीकामा
I think appeasement agenda for acceptance in all communities 🙂🙂
it is temporary. wait for right time
@@rupmanyu7017 marathi bhau
Nityanand ji and Sanjay ji 🙏. Fine Analysis by learned Nityanand ji who has hit the head of the nail. Objective of Sadguru ji is Popularity which is a parameter of success.
Sadhguru doesn't say AUM equals AMEN . We end up pronouncing OM as almost AUOM in pranayama and as only OM during simple mantra ucharan. So its having words like AMEN in other scriptures with different usage
Simply illogical
U r irrational....sadhguru himself said he don't nothing about scripture
@@vikaskashov1165 Fir to buddha guru hi nahi hain tumhare hisaab se,experience is what makes them guru. 4 forms of yoga hain gyaan,karma,bhakti & kriya….Kriya yogis need not know scriptures.Paramhansa yogananda kon sa scriptures pdhe the??
@@RISHABHKUMAR-jg9dv
Kriya yogis need not know scriptures because the knowledge of scriptures lies in their heart. they already know it without reading any book. But their claims have to be consistent with scriptures or else how will one verify what they are saying is not gibberish ?
@@gauravshah89 sadhguru teaches shambhavi mahamudra kriya and his ashram raises niravan ashtakam all day , they practised bhairavi tantra and linga dhyanam consistent with shiva purana teachings. Why do u say it's not consistent
Great video especially illustrations. Great job JD team.
He is saying - what is universal... Is universal... It cannot be claimed by just one community ! Yoga is universal....
but the universal must not be distorted in that process. shastra must remain the source of truth about yoga. will muslims and christians ensure that ?
Sanjay ji, when you try to fit a sound into a language it will cause distortions. Esp if the language is a poor one like English. Focus on the sound, do not try and analyse it by the alphabet you use or Sadhguru has used. The sound (nada in Sanskrit) is important NOT the alphabet you use to try and write it in. All alphabet -even Sanskrit - is a human creation and quite inadequate to capture the real "form" of the sound. Finally, a suggestion - your forte has been and is social & political analysis and discourse - stick with it. DO NOT venture into such issues and controversies. It is quite unnecessary for you.
Perfectly said. And Sanjay doesn't realise the harm he is doing this way resulting in splitting the Hindus. As left liberals never realised how they began with Modi hate and became Bharat haters, so does people like Sanjay don't realise how they started with one thing and now reached undermining their own roots!
In Sanskrit "M" of AUM is half-sound (it has halant). In English transliteration it becomes full sound, which is technically wrong but there is no way to depict this sound without using special symbols. Sadhguru has read Hindu scriptures only in English it seems.
गुरुमां आनंदमूर्ति बहुत अच्छी है।
Absolutely, Sanjay ji!
Sad guru is trying to make OM a secular word!
Sadhguru has said multiple times that he doesn't know Sanskrit and whatever he is, comes from experiences. Not a lot of people can say that. Whatever is said by Miśra is right in the grammatical and spoken language but less to do with chants, mantras and consecration. When it comes to the true understanding of nature and Human Being, Sadhguru is definitely skilled than anyone who has come out publicly. I'm not trying to belittle anyone here. I just feel that to really raise a point against what Sadhguru has said you need to be on equal footing of him in terms of the skills he has. If you have genuine doubts then one needs to be a proper student and ask his Guru.
He is no Rishi (mantra drashta) but a popular cult guru. He should not impart distortions of ancient concepts as "experiential" knowledge which breaks down under such scholarly analysis. Why should he distort traditions which he neither understands nor respects?
If Sadhguru(????) doesn’t know Sanskrit, and still dares to dissect ॐ/प्रणव, wouldn’t that be the transgression of the highest order?
@@thrinethran2885 I don't understand on what basis anybody can conclude that he is cult guru. Every guru in our culture had followers ranging from a few people (Shiva) to a thousands (Buddha), when they were alive. Neither me nor you are seer enough to judge a man like him.
Even when Krishna was here, there were a particular set of people trying to bring him down instead of truly seeking.
All we can really do is come to the level of enlightenment first and then make accusations. This sort of blind disbelief will lead one nowhere.
@@123459136 He isn't daring to disgrace. In fact, he has done more than what 99% people have done to bring our culture to the forefront. When he is unsure about something he has openly admitted to it. Why is it wrong if he found experientially that Aum is better suited than chanting Om for people of this age. How can one be 100% sure that he is wrong.
Even in law, we have innocent until proven guilty. I think the same applies here. If you are truly seeking, you can spend the time doing dhyana and find it out yourself.
However, once you have, there will be some people waiting to accuse. It is not wrong to question, but simply unhelpful to accuse.
@@PinakBheed but that does not give him the luxury of distorting sanatana dharma ideas. shastra remains the only source of truth. not sadguru.
The logic is not about how we write (anyway writing is all about english letters 'AUM' or 'OM' whatever it is). The logic is about generating vibration at certain parts of the body
Very true
why don't you start saying ameen to generate vibrations ?
Problem with Sadhguru is, he speak lot of nonsense and irrational point of view, however when you counter with critical questions??? His plot twists and start saying I'm uneducated, never read any books, very far from logic and reasoning.
Krupya Aachrya Prashant ko laye 🙏🙏🙏
What I have gotten from Sadhguru is that....
1.when you open your mouth with sound and close it one sound comes from there that is AUM and Sadhguru saying this is the basis of all sounds that you can utter.
2. AUM, Amen, ... All these are like Dhyaan,Dhyana and Dhyanam . He trying to say that they may have their own version of AUM.
What is the authentic scriptural references without which everything is fake and false.
Nityanand ji 🙏
good analysis, good to have it be objective and not personal attack
All the scriptures in the world together don't mean anything in front of a true inner experience
Sadguru is enlighten one he might have experienced these sound like AUM but explanation grammatically might be wrong according to the evidences gathered.
Already great sage also tridev informed us through scriptures how to chant Om...I will support sadguru if this is about language pronounce prblm among continet but if you want to do ritual or japa you must chant correctly there is no problem if pronounce prblm among different language...also if you here Om sound coming from space you can here a u m sound openly...a dedicated to bramha u dedicated to Vishnu and m dedicated to Mahesh...you must chant u longer then a and m ... already our scriptures told us how to chant Om
Sadhguru also on path of secularism??
A- Parabbrahm
U- Urja(His Energy)
M-Atma
Hence aum comprises of everything there is in the universe.
What is the authentic scriptural references
@@anantyuvabharat5874 I do not have the exact location..but for me Mantra mulam guru Vakyam ..and this I have heard from Him.
I agree with your respect towards Guru but whatever we listen should go through threefold test...Guru Sadhu and Shastra. Guru says sadhu agrees but shastra doesn't support by reference in that case shastra says we should not only reject that concept but reject that guru also. E.g . Somebody follows Gandhiji as guru but in the original Vaishnav bhajan where is that sentence of ISHWAR Allah tere naam sabko sanmati de bhagvan , in that case we should reject these mental speculations and planned concoctions.
@@anantyuvabharat5874 yeah I know that sir and my guru only told me that and My guru isn't some self proclaimed old age citizen...He is from a bona fide guru param Para.. From BHAMA-Gaudiya Madhava sampraday. So be unallarmed what He would say would follow Guru Sadhu and Shastra.
Samay avirat hai, parivartan niyamit hai 🙏
Ishwar sabhi ko sadbuddi de 🙏🙏
I think u r making it a mistake. Sadhguru is not secularising sanatan dharma but universalising it.
Jay Hind Vande Mataram Hara Hara Mahadev Jay Jagannath
You 2 guys talk about hinduism here, but sadhguru alone has spread our culture across the world better than anyone else. Now many outsiders are following hindusim and india's resprect has increased more because of sadhguru. Many youth has turned into our culture, our own indian youths was westernised, he bought them back into this culture, just 4 days back he concecrated shiv linga in bangaluru and you guys are critizing him on Aum ?, So this channel is just critizing not looking at postive things thats very bad. A real guru is the person who gives us the tools, Thats the Sadhguru, not just sitting like you guys on youtube channel and giving knowledge.
Good work
We don't go in literature, but we benefited by "aa uu mm" not Om. And that is only matter. Thank You Sadhguru 🙏
मेने इन भाऊसाहेब की वीडियो लिंक शेयर की थी नीरज अत्री जी के चैनल के कॉमेंट में कि इनको अपने चैनल पर लाइए बहुत ज्ञानी मानव है।
और यह मुझे आज दिखे JD चैनल पर।
आनंद है। लगभग 10-15 दिन पहले मेने लिंक शेयर की थी।
मित्रों ऐसे ही वीडियो शेयर करते रहिए।
मेने APOSTATE IMAM की भी वीडियो अत्रिजी के साथ शेयर की थी ट्विटर पर उसके बाद वह अत्रीजी के चैनल पर भी आए थे। 🙏
जय सनातन राष्ट्र। 🚩🕉️💪😊
Satguru ki Jay Ho 👶🙏
*Listener:* What is the meaning of *sadhguru*
*Sadhguru:* sad + guru = sadhguru
*Listener:* 😳
How do I get the English version of this video?
@@manoharankrishnan5162 I don't think there is 1. @TJD please enable Subtitles so that English Audience can also understand this
@Jeff Wright He asked Hindus to uncloth the black tents wore by Muslim women.
Very clear.
mantro me vyakran ka nhi, dhwani ka mahatwa hota hai aur A-U-M mooldhwani hai om nhi .is tarah se Hindu hokar hindu guru ko criticise karna chhodiye.
Sanjay Ji good to see animations on your videos but also do make better thumbnails so that you can attract more viewers. Thanks!
A big Chameleon...each and every Sanatani should #Bollywood this dhongi.
Swami Dayananda Saraswati(Arsha vidya Gurukulam)- OM is a profound single syllable word. In sanskrit Om means that which sustains, or that such protects, अवति, रक्षति. Om is the NAME OF THE LORD who pervades everything in the form of the order नियति, that sustains. That नियति is Īśwara, the Lord and the meaning of OM. When I say Om, if you understand its meaning, you can see it is non-separate from the Lord- from "Prayer Guide" book
Swamiji has explained much more 🙏 🙏
I don't call this man Sadguru but just Jaggi Vasudev because he is not a genuinely Enlightened person.He is an imposter ...after money and more money.
instantly subscribed
He once said Shiv is Nothingness.
Wtf is he even saying !
He is clearly spreading Buddhism in the name of shiv .
Sadguru is a businessman. He said yogi is not Hindu like gravity is not Christianity. This is foolish. He said he doesn’t read Hindu scriptures but he talks sadashiv all the time, who is sadashiv? That is bhagwan Shiv. We have too many fake gurus exploiting Hinduism. This needs to stop. My respect to Jaipur dialog for speaking the truth. This is much needed. People are so blinded by these fake gurus who are greedy for money. That is not a guru
दिनारी बन चुका है सद्गुरु
अल्ला मौला वाले सद्गुरु ?
Like political parties, a Guru doesn't need votes or funds. Lakshmi is at their feet. The divine gives safbuddhi to donors who donate for noble works like Sadhguru's. Sadhguru is not using money for personal gains. Using it only to spread spirituality or to uplift mankind. His actions may not appear logical, but then saints who have conquered their minds are beyond dharma. Lord Rama also sided with Bibhishan. Sadhguru having good relationship with people disliked by right wingers is like Sadhguru' is supporting Bibhishans. Saints' behavior is beyond our comprehension.
Sharda Mata used to say " I am the mother of good as well of the evil" .For them good and bad ppl are same because both operate at the level of mind and not soul. Sadhguru is in atma consciousness, so all discrimination drops
Sadhguru trying hard to infuse some spirituality to otherwise gira hua Aam Admi party
I truly doesn't get why are people in comment section are so angry. I know about cultural digestion which is going and Sadhguru statement make it easy for them to lure people.
But try to understand it has been done by all gurus who have went to west but that doesn't mean that they don't have Self Knowledge and identity of the enemy.
Instead of this rhetoric why don't educate yourself and your community and reach out to Sadhguru at the same time about the various things which is he saying is getting used against our own civilization and tradition.
But the problem is Pranav Beej mantra should not be publicly chanted
May be that is why he chants ot differently
Super 👌 explaination and a wonderful counter. Great 👍 discussion and explaination by Shri Misra Ji and Shri Dixit Ji. 👏👏💥🔥
Wish we need not have wokes and lies to propagate anything, it will have its impact - whether we like or not. So, threading the path of Dharma is very important and lies and misrepresentation is simply a downfall. Whether it is in the name of Sadhguru or in the name of Bhagavan, better we be aware of these and stick to genuine seeking and knowledge.
Sadguru is a secular and commercial guru. He played maula maula song during Shivaratri celebrations and since then I stopped following him
Not much useful content, first time gave you dislike
Sadguru’s brain is getting pickled 😂
what is his connection with Free Mason??