I mean, Siamese cats don't tend to sing racial stereotype theme songs, she probably rehearsed that with them, or picked the most insensitive ones she could find at the shelter 😂 (She's evil, maybe she went to an unethical breeder)
@@sarafontanini7051Tbf, you can find plenty of pictures of cats who have a little black mustache pattern below their nose. Some cats just kinda look funky
Shout out to captain hook in peter pan 2 for saying he wont harm a single hair on peter's head to make a deal with Jane and then he plucks a single hair from peter's head and says that's the one he woudlnt harm
@@AK-jt9gxI mean, he’s a kid that never grows up. He’s immature. Like a sibling getting “hurt” and screaming to get the other sibling(s)in trouble. Pure immature pettiness in my opinion.
fun fact about King Candy, if you notice in the code scene, everyone and everything else has neatly sorted lines of code that fit neatly, but his is a jumbled mass of spaghetti code that's bursting at the seams.
One of the things I loved about Frollo is that while a lot of the other villains are motivated by obtaining power (Scar, Ursula, Jafar, etc) Frollo already has power. Instead we’re shown how he abuses it. While Scar is still a great villain, once he becomes king he just kinda lays around and complains. The things Frollo does are far more interesting and and honestly terrifying.
Hard agree with this. Frollo is a villain who technicly "already won". Hes in a position of power, he cleary loves his job, doesnt care if the 'guilty' die, and cleary does whatever he wants while within reason. Hes also cleary human, hes a messed up twisted human who fears the Judgement of God while believing hes Humble and Just (even thou we see plenty of evidence of otherwise, like when he gos to teach Quasi his lessons.) Him lusting after Esmeralda and wanting her, isnt the biggest or most grand goal, but when you consider that hes been a Judge for a long while... you start to wonder if Esmeralda was the only one he lusted after, and was simply the first that was denied to him for a long time.
@@peterwhite6415 I never considered that Frollo might have had women before Esmerelda. Who of course would’ve been forced to be with him. That wouldn’t be surprising and would add yet another layer of depravity to him.
@peterwhite6415 Wow...damn...I don't think i have ever considered the fact that Frollo has preyed upon other women during his career as a judge...but tha does sound like something he'd do. Then again, he freaks out in Hellfire while singjng about his lust for Esmeralda and i don't know if his old ass can handle those visions every time he gets horny
His biggest goal is to exterminate an actually real oppressed group of people, which is insane. Disney wouldn't dare pull that off today. Closest they got was the indigenous people in Frozen 2, which is heavily based on the sámi-people of Scandinavia - a group that were historically oppressed in Norway (I don't know about the other countries, I only learned about the Norwegian history)
The worst part about Callaghan is that he does actually apologize to Hiro, and admits Tadashi died because he let his actions become bitter and fueled by a deep hate, IN THE SPIN OFF SHOW. He could have been a good twist villain had he just said that in the movie! It was handled so well too, Hiro said Tadashi would have wanted him to forgive Callaghan, and he hoped someday he'd be able to.
Tadashi is the villain because he committed suicide. Literally every firefighting PSA warns people to not run into burning buildings. You aren't being a hero, you're being a complication.
@@ObjectsInMotion Pfft that doesn't make Tadashi a villain. He's a supporting character whose death is an inciting incident, caused by a good intentioned bad decision in the heat of panic. He died only a couple steps from the door, so it wouldn't complicate firefighting. Plus, if he hadn't died, Hiro wouldn't have become a hero later on and been there to stop That-Was-His-Mistake from doing his evil plan.
I feel like they could have fixed Callahan’s “That was his mistake!” line if he showed regret immediately after saying it. Like a heat in the passion moment. It would still result in Hiro getting upset and remove Baymax’s chip, and still make Callahan feel human.
I believe one dub translated that line a bit differently, and if translated back to English, would read like "I didn't ASK him to save me!", implying more of a regretful tone.
Even better, we can rewrite the line beforehand to add more precedent to that: Hiro: You let him die… Callaghan: Let him die? You think I planned for him to just run in there, without any care for his life?! Hiro: He tried to save you! Callaghan: Cue “that was his mistake* and regret
THAT WAS THE WRITER’S MISTAKE Honestly this approach is a win-win situation, Calahan would become much less of a 1 dimensional character, and we would still have the funny meme line
I can’t lie, Schaffrillas is one of the few channels that makes super long form videos that I almost always watch right on release and either fully through or in bits and pieces throughout my day. Even if I don’t always agree with some of his takes, I love hearing everything James has to say about the media he engages with
1:19:05 On that, fun fact: when Hades says “Guys, relax, it’s only half-time”, he says it at the 46-minute mark of the 92-minute film. Which means it actually was halftime 😅😂
I kinda have to assume that's just an amazing coincidence because that's only true on the newer prints of the movie starting with the 2014 DVD/Blu-ray and beyond. Replacing the 1997 Disney logo with the 2014 logo adds roughly 40 seconds or so to the beginning, meaning the theatrical release, the 1998 VHS, and 1999 DVD have that line happening roughly 40 seconds earlier. Still impressive it was that close to the halfway mark originally but I really have to assume it's just a coincidence. On the other hand Minority Report was able to pinpoint how long it was until the end credits start when they say how long until Anderton meets Crowe so it could have been intentional.
@@RENTnerd87 eh 40 seconds isn't that much of a difference... it's still roughly around the halfway point so i wouldn't use that as evidence of it being a coincidence
Seriously, though, he suuuuucks. If we were ranking the Disney parents, he'd be at the bottom. He isn't the worst parent, let's not lie, not when Mama Gothel exists. But he is the least enjoyable parent. Not just cause the parental redemption was weak, but because of wasted potential. At least in a deleted scene he helped protect Chicken from the media.
1:26:16 Funnily enough, in french both Scar and Frollo were voiced by the same actor (Jean Piat) and that's the only two roles he ever played in Disney movies. The guy left his mark
in the Brazilian version, Scar's VA also shared with Jafar and Anastasia's Rasputin (when he spoke, not when he sang) and Sykes from Oliver and Company The guy loved being mean
51:42 It gets even better when you realize there was no water in this pitcher. She put an empty pitcher there just so that the prisoner sees it's empty even if they managed to grab it by some off chance. Evil for the love of the game
"Man" is hilarious as an entry because he is a basketball stat sheet of a character, but is genuinely more effective as a diabolus ex machina than some characters with genuine personalities and arcs are as villains. He’s the perfect gatekeeper for the "real" villains
24:14 I'm probably not alone in thinking this, but Schaff's crashout over the "character" of Man is one of the funniest things I've ever seen on his channel. (I completely agree, though.)
@@DZ-DizzyDummexcept when you take in the fact he’s able to be a menacing force without even being there and that Schaff’s put villains way higher in the list for things much less grounded and significant than "representing the evil nature of man"
The voice of Chron in Dinosaur was Sam Wright. He was my drama teacher. He had Parkinson’s until he passed, but would always have a smile on his face working with young kids performing in shows. Great guy and great actor.
@@Friigus wow, no need to be such a dickhead. first of all, "minor spelling mistake, i win" is an insane thing to say when someone is reminiscing on a beloved teacher who has since passed away. second, he didn't die of parkinson's, but the original comment never said that, they just said he had parkinson's, which is fully likely since prostate cancer is much more common in people with parkinson's disease, and because he was only diagnosed with prostate cancer three years before he died, most likely after the original commenter had been taught by him. weird to just go around accusing people of lying, especially when they have no reason to at all and you have zero proof.
@@Friigus first of all, "minor spelling mistake, i win" is an insane thing to say when someone is reminiscing on their memories with a beloved teacher who has since passed on. second, he didn't die of parkinson's disease, but the original comment never said that. they just said he _had_ parkinson's disease, which is perfectly likely since a) he was only diagnosed with prostate cancer three years before his death, most likely after the original commenter had been taught by him, and b) prostate cancer is much more likely in people with parkinson's disease. it's super weird to just go around accusing people of lying like that, especially when this is a very heartfelt message, they have no reason to lie, and you have no proof to back up your claims other than easily disproven information and typos.
As someone who heavily hyperfixated on Captain Hook for a bit, it made me really happy to see how highly ranked he was considering how underrated he can be. Like fun fact, this man was planned to die as he does in the original source material. But the crew ended up liking him so much they were like “… but what if he didn’t?” This man evaded death by being a lovable villain and I think that deserved props
All of Peter Pan is a nothingburger plot propped up on fun, lovable characters, places and set pieces. A VHS copy of it was the first thing I ever bought with my own money, I've always loved it. Hook is such a perfect villain for it, and Smee and Tick Tock the croc as well (though one could argue that the villain of the villain is the hero).
I love Captain hook simply because he is a goofy villain who still does absolutely horrendous shit. Dude is silly and pompous, then proceeds to try to drown and shoot kids
watching the hunchback of notre dame is crazy…frollo is literally about to drop a baby down the well in the first 10 minutes and he justifies it so calmly-“i’m just sending it back to hell where it belongs”💀
Yeah, some older animated films in general just had NO chill. Like, Prince of Egypt literally opens with people being whipped, enslaved, and having their BABIES MURDERED.
Prince of Egypt and hunchback of Notre dame are probably the most serious animated movies i’ve seen. they have the most mature themes, even if notre dame had some tonal issues
@@p234gr8 ... I do hope you mean "most serious animated family movies" you've seen. I mean they're both phenomenal movies, but due to the requisite humor, they're never gonna be as serious as some adult animated movies.
Something else that really helps Frollo's effectiveness is that he's actually in the movie quite a lot. He actually has the most proportionate screen time out of all the Disney villains, being in about a third of Hunchback's runtime, and he doesn't waste a single second of it.
I'm pleasantly surprised Frollo still made the top of the list given Schaffrillas' video contrasting him negatively with his stage and book counterparts
@@carrotbunny5123That's true, and while I think people are allowed to look at renaissance Disney villains and hold them to a high standard, Frollo's got them all beat because he's not one dimensional. The others are like campy, sassy "oh I'll ruffle you up" mustache twirling villains. Whereas Frollo is willing to commit genocide over what he thinks is an act of righteous passage under the eyes of God. He's got layers is what I'm trying to say.
I think that it helps Frollo become the best villain because we know this guy would kill for absolutely nothing. Every scene where he's with Quasimodo or Esmerelda is one where there's tangible overwhelming tension purely due to this aspect of him.
The list (spoilers) 47: (2:20) Aunt Sasha (Lady and the Tramp) 46: (5:14) Edgar (The Aristocats) 45: (6:52) Bellwether (Zootopia) 44: (8:33) King Magnifico (Wish) 43: (11:53) Radcliffe (Pocahontas) 42: (13:35) Nalo (Moana 2) 41: (15:07) Kron (Dinosaur) 40: (15:55) Buck Cluck (Chicken Little) 39: (17:27) Prince Hans (Frozen) 38: (18:25) The Horned King (The Black Cauldron) 37: (20:14) Namaari (Raya and the Last Dragon) 36: (21:03) King Runeard (Frozen II) 35: (22:05) Professor Callaghan (Big Hero 6) 34: (24:14) Man (Bambi) 33: (26:34) Captain Gantu (Lilo and Stitch) 32: (27:23) Madame Medusa (The Rescuers) 31: (28:21) Percival C. McCleash (Rescuers Down Under) 30: (29:00) Sher Khan (The Jungle Book) 29: (30:07) Te Kā (Moana) 28: (34:23) Lady Tremaine (Cinderella) 27: (35:37) Clayton (Tarzan) 26: (37:02) Sykes (Oliver and Company) 25: (37:56) Madame Mim (The Sword in the Stone) 24: (38:42) Honest John & Gideon (Pinocchio) 23: (39:38) Alameda Slim (Home on the Range) 22: (41:43) Shan-Yu (Mulan) 21: (43:25) The Queen of Hearts (Alice in Wonderland) 20: (44:15) Amos Slade (Fox and the Hound) 19: (45:52) John Silver (Treasure Plant) 18: (47:16) Dr. Facilier (The Princess and the Frog) 17: (49:58) The Evil Queen (Snow White and the Seven Dwarfs) 16: (52:00) Prince John (Robin Hood) 15: (53:10) Mother Gothel (Tangled) 14: (54:57) Cruella De Vil (101 Dalmatians) 13: (56:32) Yzma (Emperor’s New Groove) 12: (58:26) Jafar (Aladdin) 11: (1:00:30) Lyle Tiberius Rorke (Atlantis: The Lost Empire) 10: (1:02:52) Maleficent (Sleeping Beauty) 9: (1:04:37) Goob & Doris (Meet the Robinsons) 8: (1:07:11) King Candy (Wreck It Ralph) 7: (1:09:59) Professor Ratigan (Great Mouse Detective) 6: (1:12:48) Gaston (Beauty and the Beast) 5: (1:15:12) Captain Hook (Peter Pan) 4: (1:17:46) Hades (Hercules) 3: (1:21:04) Ursula (The Little Mermaid) 2: (1:23:38) Scar (The Lion King) 1: (1:26:13) Judge Claude Frollo (The Hunchback of Notre Dame)
I am a Edgar fan. If there are one million Edgar fans, I am one, if there is only one, I am that one, if there are none, then I am no longer alive. That is all. Edit: Apparently, there are over a thousand of us. . . Stand proud!
The reason Shan Yu didn't care Mulan was a woman is because a lot of nomadic tribes in Asia had warrior women so it wouldn't be that out of the ordinary for him
Its actually interesting that most warrior based societies had more of an equal roles between men and women in thier cultures compared to more agricultural centered societys
🤣😂 RUclips comment section historians strike again with their vast intelligence... Yes warrior women existed, but claiming that they were "ordinary" in ANY type of ancient tribe/society is pure drivel.
As someone who got to play Jafar in a local stage production, I am admittedly biased towards him. His sliminess was so fun to portray. That being said, Claude Frollo is the right answer.
Something about Hellfire that I dont see mentioned enough is that the entire thing is him being given the chance to change. The "backing" vocals from the red cloaked spirits? Mea culpa, which means "through my fault" and is a part of confessions. His own delusions are being influenced by God to have him accept fault for this, to see his own guilt and move on. He asks for a solution from God, and he is literally given one. The random guard that comes in, whether a real guard or an angel, is that last chance. "She's gone, we can't find her. She won't be your problem anymore" But frollo doesnt care
Another thing I don’t think a lot of people realize is that he actually implicitly blames GOD for his sin as well when he says “He made the devil so much stronger than the man.” In other words, “it’s God’s fault that I’m giving into temptation.” Dude’s literally blaming everyone but himself and then doubling down. Excellent villain.
1:29:49 This is a Muppet movie ranking. Don’t believe me? I did all the research, check it. 1. Principal Prickly is voiced by Dabney Coleman, who played Martin Price and Murray Plotsky in The Muppets Take Manhattan. 2. King Neptune is voiced by Jeffrey Tambor, who played K. Edgar Singer in Muppets from Space. 3. Eris is voiced by Michelle Pfeiffer, who played herself in an episode of Muppets Tonight. 4. Jessie is voiced by Joan Cusack, who played Rachel Bitterman in It’s a Very Merry Muppet Christmas Movie. 5. Tamatoa is voiced by Jemaine Clement, who played the Prison King in Muppets Most Wanted. 6. Finn McMissile is voiced by Michael Caine, who played Ebenezer Scrooge in The Muppet Christmas Carol. 7. Lenny is voiced by Jack Black, who played himself in The Muppets (2011). 8. Nigel Thornberry is voiced by Tim Curry, who played Long John Silver in Muppet Treasure Island. 9. King Harold is voiced by John Cleese, who played Neville in The Great Muppet Caper. 10. Bigweld is voiced by Mel Brooks, who played Professor Max Krassman in The Muppet Movie. I’m playing 5D chess, your move, funny crab man. Edit: THE GREAT BANANA IS REAL
That isn't eris but medusa from kid icarus Luckily her voice actor, Cree Summer does appear in Kermits Swamp Years as Pilgrim and Kermits mom I would also like to mention the background is Dagobah, home of Yoda, played by Frank Oz, not even gonna explain that one
1:28:15 YES. that is EXACTLY it as a Christian myself it bothers me to NO END when people do horrible crap, whether that's racism or sexism or whatever, and then try to associate with Christianity or use it as a justification. because not only is that just completely wrong and violates dozens of Jesus' actual recorded teachings, but it also gives everyone else a completely (yet understandably) misinformed view of what Christianity actually is. not only do I wish people would stop taking bad people's religious claims at face value, but I wish religious people would go to greater lengths to demonstrate how those people completely misrepresent religion as a whole
Right here. This is what i wanted of most of religion people,and do action based on their religion isn't that preachy or bit of force just for their own religion sake.
Its thanks to those types of people that I'm convinced a lot of christians only cherrypick bible quotes they agree with while ignoring anything from the bible that says otherwise. I don't wanna get involved with Christianity because I feel like I might become one of those people if I do and there will be no turning back. It pains me too because I know not all of them are like this due to having religious grandparents.
@@easiestcc6451 As a former gentile New Yorker turned devout Christian, I hear you. Jesus was really taboo for me as well. The problem for me was that I associated imperfect so-called Christians with Jesus, therefore making Him imperfect. We all fall short of the glory of God, even myself, fortunately, all who have faith in Christ are made right with God. Just because we believe in Jesus and have our sins forgiven DOES NOT make ANY of the bad things we do all right. I know you didn't make this RUclips comment so you could start a long religious thread, but my friend, I can tell you that God wants YOU and all who read this to follow his son Jesus Christ... factually. My friend, I'm sorry that some of my brothers and sisters in Christ have let you down, truly, but Jesus is incapable of letting you down, as He knows you better than you know you, and He is always working for your good. I pray that you recieve this message well, and that you and your grandparents have an abundance of physical, mental, and spiritual health!
I imagine yall are talking about frollo, and that's why he's one of the best Disney villains in my book. He uses religion to justify his prejudice against Quazimodo, and especially his desire for Esmerelda, blaming her for his feelings that he complicates. There are real people out there who twist religion like he does, and that's what makes him so terrifying
@@Procc75 Yeah and it's pretty scary. In fact one of the most unexpected move from Disney to make Frollo a villain that is far different than any Disney Villain. Till these day,he is one of the best Disney Villain of all time.
I noticed that Ratigan is the only character in TGMD that has five fingers on each hand instead of four. Animation studios used to do the four finger thing to cut down on animation costs, so the fact that Disney made an exception for Ratigan shows how all-out they went on his character.
41:45 "we're going to hypnotize a bunch of cows to storm the capitol to make me, president" *turns to camera* "thats right were going to hypnotize a bunch of cows to storm the capitol to make me president"
The final scene with Frolo surrounded by flames actually gave me nightmares as a kid. Idk what it is, the fact his eyes and teeth are lit up yellow and his skin looking pale making him resemble a demon than any kind of judge or the crooked smile lacking any kindness or warmth. Just euggghhh, makes my skin crawl.
Hunchback, lion king, dinosaur and never ending story and the 4 movies I still refuse to watch as an adult bc I received so much trauma as a kid that still lingers to this day. Every time I’m sick I always have a nightmare that includes one of those 4 movies
Unpopular opinion: I absolutely loved Bellwether before the twist. Her interactions with Judy sounded like she genuinely supported her dream as a cop. Even with Judy and Nick, a predator that Bellwether herself is supposed to have bigoted views towards, go to her for help, she treats BOTH of them friendly and her friendliness was also genuine. How the hell am I supposed to believe this character would be a psychopathic racist when her behavior previously didn't suggest that?
I *wanna* say the idea was that she herself doesn't really mind predators, and she was just using the public's prejudice as a tool to gain power, but I kinda feel like I'm putting more thought into this than the writers ever did.
I suppose it doesn't help when you position as the assistant mayor is nothing more than a glorified secretary, you possibly got the role to secure a minority vote (Which, when you consider Judy's position was also used by the mayor to prop himself up as being a result of his "Mammal Inclusion Initiative" act, doesn't sound out of place.) and worse of all, that shoddy coffee mug job, I could see some frustration, not for ALL predators, but some frustration. And yes, I agree. Her support of Judy was unquestionably honest.
I think the reason for her previous actions and politeness is not meant to suggest a genuine lack of discriminatory motives, rather I think she is mean to be the proverbial "wolf if sheeps clothing" made more literal. Someone who has learned to act one way while secretly feeling and even acting another way when they feel they can let the mask down. Its not that unheard of, but it is not what we normally expect, most people veen villians are somewhat honest with their feelings and emotions, the two facedness of someone who acts friendly and sweet towards people while secretly hating them is uniquely deceptive. Think palpatine as he nearly weeps for democracy and the republic while in private literally cackling about infinite power. If we got more flashbacks from Bellwether in more movies or a tv series the producers likely would have given us more to show the double faced nature but without its like showing palpatine one moment talking about freedom and the next hurling jedi out of windows.
Personally, I tend to give the antagonists of a mystery story some slack, because the twist is supposed to be the *point.* I'm not saying Bellweather is great, but I understood what they were going for. I probably wouldn't put her super high in my own hypothetical ranking, either, though.
He's a foil to Tarzan in that sense. He's also a foil to Jane and the profesor because they represent the good of civilization while he represents the evil of civilization. And he's a foil to Kerchak because they both use brute strenght and hate what's different, but one does it for profit and the other for fear of any harm coming to his family.
42:43 - I do believe that this right moment in Mulan is a stark sign, that the musical era of Disney is over, at least from the narrative perspective. Just before that scene we had this troops' song and then... We cut to the burnt village. the silent moment of realisation of what Shan Yu is all about. The sheer darkness of his heart and the ruthlessness to all the fallen soldiers of Li Shang's father really cements it all. Man, I love Mulan, such a classic alongside with Hercules.
Wow. I've thought many times about how that ends the songs in Mulan (1998) but never thought about the following films. The next musical wouldn't be until Princess and the Frog (2009). (No, Tarzan and Brother Bear do not count as musicals because Phil Collins songs play in the background, even if the songs are bangers. No, Emperor's New Groove does not count as a musical because there is one song in the opening, though I do recommend you check out the deleted songs from the original musical Kingdom of the Sun version, especially Yzma's song "Snuff Out the Light")
Schaffrillas, I've got to tell you something. I have been a Edgar fan since I was four. The part on the stairs with George and the bits with the two dogs will be always one of the funniest things I have ever seen. He's no Hades sure, but he holds a place in my hart.
I love him, because the whole thing started because he's worse at both math and biology than me, which I find hilarious. He literally thinks cats live 9 lives, and that each one stacks up, so he'll be dead by the time they're gone. This is hilariously dumb, and makes me love the movie so much.
Me and my brother always found him hilarious, especially his delivery (note: we watched the movie in French). We would say some of his lines at eachover and laugh
I wrote an entire paper in high school about how “Man” did absolutely nothing wrong and was entirely within the letter of the law, assuming only that bambis mother is killed in November-December, which is hunting season. Man did not deserve to die.
This implies that the law is what defines morality which frollo pretty well disproves since he is the law and is also not exactly a great dude. More importantly, man didn’t practice proper fire safety which is absolutely doing something wrong
Another point for Shan-Yu from Mulan: He is one of the only villains to do something so severe that the movie changes genres. Mulan stops being a musical once the soldiers come across the destroyed village.
1:08:24 THE BEST PART OF KING CANDY IS REWATCHING AND CATCHING EVEN MORE HINTS EVERY TIME had a friend point out the castle makes no sense for king candy to be in. it looks like a little girl's room. that his outfit isn't as extravagant or candy-like compared to everyone else's. his entire shape and design being completely different from EVERYONE who is humanoid in that game. AAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAA
Bro I LOVE how he gets defensive when Ralph points out the color of the throne room. “I see you’re a fan of pink.” “Salmon, that’s-it’s obviously salmon.” Foreshadowing played off as a joke in the moment, gotta be one of my favorite genders.
Missed opportunity to say at the end: “Good night, House of Villains” And play “It’s Our House Now Instrumental” in the video credits. Awesome ranking Schaff!
It’s honestly one of my favorite internet rants My favorite recreation would be Akechi from Persona 5 recreating it, since it sounds like the person in the video and Akechi are the same person.
@@UltimateDespairadothe most mindblowing thing about that is the fact that the guy who recorded that video would go on to voice the Persona 3 protagonist in Reload.
Gotta step in for my boy, Edgar. I work at a boarding center where a pair of frenchies get their SEVEN beds, personal meal cooler, and full human sized travel suitcase brought in by the dog's chauffeur. Made me realize that I get where Edgar's coming from. I have never seen a man look more dead inside. Dude would 100% ship the dogs to Timbuktu if he could.
@@MarquissMasonit felt like he just didn’t like the movie so completely dismissed Edgar. Which is strange since he praises some of those same attributes in other characters. Villains who are bad at being villains can be hilarious. You can just say you don’t like the movie while also trying to take a step back to be less biased about whether he’s a decent Disney villain.
@azvee I didn’t realise at first that „frenchies“ meant French Bulldogs and read this comment as „these French people were so extra, I can see how they would drive their employees to crime“ 😂😂😂😂
Tbh I really loved The Aristocrats, Edgar included. His insane amount of glee and smugness about managing to get some CATS out of a house is entartaining as hell to me lol He also definetly benefits from the insanely expressive animation he has in the movie, adding just a cherry on top
Something else I love about Cruella de Vil is how ABSURDLY VILLIAN her name is. Cruel-la devil. That's not a name, that's a super villain moniker. We need to go back to the age of naming villians Miss Killayorfrends
I mean, machia-villan turned the whole thing from an uncompromising dumpster fire to just being "okay", so maybe it actually is the play. @An_Entire_Lime
The moment you find out such a legendary actor like Vincent Price to say his favorite performance in his life was voicing an evil rat, you know you created a fantastic movie and villain!
*Fun fact related to Captain Hook and John Silver:* When the animators of Treasure Planet were trying to see if they could pull off making a 3D arm on a 2D character like Silver, they wanted to try it on some pre-existing footage of a character making some hand movements, they thought that the better way to do it was in Hook, since both him and Silver are pirates, so they picked up the scene that Schafrillas shows at 1:17:30 and made his arm 3D and robotic, once they liked the results, they continued with the idea. You can even find that test footage on RUclips!!
@@N_o196 A question I had ever since wathing Wreck it Ralph is how Turbo survived hus game being unpluged on top of not being seen for years. It's a mystery.
@@amirgarcia547 You are probably right. That's definitely how he initially survived but it doesn't explain how he stayed hidden until Sugar Rush came to the arcade.
@@leebulger7112 According to the scarce turbo-related material there is, he escaped the game he killed and hid in Game Central for however long it took for Sugar Rush to get plugged. (for this and more fun facts about turbo, check Randomalistic's analysis on the character)
51:10 Honestly personal headcanon is that the potion is temporary, which explains: A. Why the Queen wouldn't use it on Snow White, and B. Why the Queen is willing to use it on herself. It also just feels like intuitive, normal potion mechanic in any fiction.
Frollo is my favourite villain of all time, because he’s a “good person” while being a villain. Hear me out, from what he knows everything he does is justified by his faith, he’s a believable and devoted character with real motivations, and even when he does bad things (even for him) he tries to justify himself to god!!! That’s a great character (and his song, mwah! Chefs kiss)
Christianity absolutely does NOT justify any of his actions 💀 He twists it from its true beliefs to try to make him FEEL justified about doing horrific things
Im SO GLAD you ranked King Candy/Turbo in the top 10. People never really realize how good of a villain he is. You should 100% watch Randomalistic's 2 hour analysis on him, they like, deep dive on the manipulation tatics in that scene with ralph and you realize how much MORE of a good villain he is.
I was hoping someone would mention that video essay! I already thought he was a good villain, but after watching it, I'm convinced that he's the third best WDAS villain behind Scar and Frollo!
It's too bad Tamatoa doesn't count for this list, but Any chance to hear Schaffrillas bash Mr. That Was His Mistake is still more than worth it. Hearing him praise so many other legends is also a great gift.
Well Tamatoa not only got his own hour long video talking about how amazing he is, but an entire character arc in the Schaffrillas universe. That and we all know he would automatically make number one if he did count.
That clip from SpongeBob where Patrick's song destroys Bikini Bottom is such a funny way to show what a mess This is The Thanks I Get is as a Villain song.
to add to your whole Bambi MAN rant at 25:00, remember a while back how so many people were trying to pull mental gymnastics with the character of Death from puss in boots: the last wish. Going "oh, he's not a villain, he's just an antagonistic force/cosmic force" despite the fact he takes pleasure in the fear & suffering of the hero, is purposefully going beyond what he's allowed to do in order to kill puss, and is actively, physically fighting to try and murder puss. but Man, who is entirely an unseen presence with no character and only exists through the destructive acts they cause, & who could easily just be a metaphorical placeholder for the general ideas of death/tragedy occurring in life in general? Nope, 100% active villain no debate in any way, shape or form
I think the "force of nature" thing is mostly intended as a comparison to the other two evil factions, the irredeemable Jack Horner and the sympathetic Goldilocks and her bears. Death fits in neither of these categories, he can't be defeated or redeemed because death is inevitable. That being said, the whole reason he goes after Puss to take his last life early is because he felt scorned by him. That's Maleficent levels of pettiness, it's just that the guy who wants to kill the main character over a perceived slight in this movie also just so happens to be an unavoidable force of nature that everyone has to face eventually.
This could completely wrong but usually when I hear "force of nature" character it's something that cant be reasoned with and is *almost* unstoppable the best thing you can do is get out of the way, run and hide, or just wait for the inevitable, like a tornado or a hurricane, (Like the Martians from war of the worlds or Minus One Godzilla) Death went after Puss before his time was up literally cheating the laws of nature because he was personally offended by the comments of some random cat laughing about the fact he has 9 lives while he could've just waited for Puss to inevitably get himself killed and loose his final life.
The only thing I dislike about hades is that people who know nothing about Greek stories and only know him from popular media assume he’s the villain of the pantheon. Still a great Disney villain though.
If anything, Hades is kinda the least messed-up god out of the major ones. He's probably a little grumpy about not getting to draw sticks first for his lot since he's the oldest, but he just kinda sticks to himself. Pretty chill and reasonable guy, too, as long as you don't try to mess with his turf. He's also a pretty good husband, and went through the standard traditions before taking Persephone as his bride.
Exactly. He's probably the chillest god of them all, ruling over the kingdom of the dead fairly. The only 'bad' thing he did was kidnap Persephone to be his bride, but that was Zeus's doing. Her mother Demeter blamed Zeus, not Hades.
@@AtlasBlizzard Yeah, even then, Hades didn't really do anything all that wrong by ancient Greek standards. All you really had to do was ask the husband "hey, can I marry your daughter?", pass the vibe check, and go grab her to get hitched. If I remember right, Demeter would be the most in the wrong, as (according to my admittedly rusty memory on the topic, so feel free to correct me on this) the mother was never really involved in that choice. Of course, by today's standards, her frustration is understandable (even if her rage was a bit excessive), but it's unfair to judge the past by the present's standards.
Agreed, I love Disney's Hades as a character, it's just a shame that he contributes to the common impression that gods of the underworld are automatically evil and underworld = hell. I'm mostly invested in mythological Hades as one of my favourite gods of the Greek pantheon, but I believe Anubis suffers from the same misconceptions about underworld deities. Still, if I separate Disney Hades from Greek Hades, he's one of my favourite villains ever.
Best Hades depiction IMO is from, well, Hades (the game). In that game, he's not evil, just extremely grumpy. He's stuck with an endless amount of paperwork, his wife left him, and his rebellious son keeps going on a rampage through the underworld (that leaves him with more paperwork). Also he thinks all of his extended family are idiots.
Yes, because scientifically, the color blue has a smaller wavelength than red. It means that it takes more energy to create blue light as opposed to red light. However, we have a social association of the color blue with water, which can be cold and red with fire and lava, which are hot. So, yeah, it can cause some confusion.
@@RandomDragonEXE More than that. Robin Hood and Jungle Book took advantage of rotoscoping to minimize the amount of unique animation required. Baloo and Little John share a lot of animation. I'm pretty sure Sir Hiss exists because they already had resources for Kaa, and they needed a supplemental villain for Prince John to talk to. Prince John isn't going to be revealing his plans to the Sheriff.
The Gaston Trilogy is so funny and iconic I can’t not hear it or see it when I watch Beauty. But here’s the thing, Beauty is so damn good that it doesn’t have anything taken away from it at all. It’s not often that a parody enhances or at least doesn’t detract a little from your experience watching the original.
52:11 if anyone is wondering it's because Prince John and the king who returns at the end, King Richard III the Lionheart, are actual historical figures. King Richard left England to go fight in the Third Crusade and his brother Prince John was left in charge in his absence. I won't get into their relationship or how the public views him cause that's a whole mess. But short version is that Robinhood was a preexisting folk hero long before the two of them lived. People loved Richard so much and hated John so much that later versions of the Robinhood tale graft Richard and John to the myth and have Robinhood resisting the evil Prince John and his corrupt henchmen until the true king is able to return home and restore peace and order. That's also why the king just kinda shows up at the end.
That still didn’t need to happen. For instance, in the 1938 Robin Hood film, King Richard’s retaking of his kingdom is the subject of the whole climax. But they didn’t even necessarily need to do that. Just have it show up and throw open the castle doors dramatically around the time of the final battle, don’t have him return offscreen
With Frollo the only thing is you didnt bring up his amazing vocal performance!! If I remember right you did in your villain songs ranking, but it's definitely worth a mention here!! Literally there is no one else who could have voiced him as well as Tony Jay did. It's not sassy like most of the 90's villains, or charismatic like others (which Jay is 100% capable of), it's just wretched evil. But still super great vid and I'm so happy with this ranking!!
Even 'That was his mistake' could have worked honestly. Have Callaghan say it whilst clearly holding back tears so that Hero can be mad and want to kill him, and then have him show genuine remorse at the end of the movie.
It's crazy how the single line of THAT WAS HIS MISTAKE tanked the film. If they just had a single line about how Tadashi dying was a regretful mistake and he never wanted to hurt the dude, the film would have been leaps and bounds better.
I agree. Logically, I know the callous response was meant to trigger Hiro into wanting revenge on Callahan and needing to go through his own growth of “that’s not what Tadashi would have wanted.” However, there were other ways this could have been accomplished. He could have been cold towards Hiro’s grief without saying Tadashi died because he was an idiot.
@@Rikrobat I saw another comment that said the line could stay the same, but as a heat of the moment thing where he immediately shows regret for saying it
23:18 The thing is, I think that line couldve actually still worked. if only the execution and delivery were different. Rather than it being a thoughtless bark from a frustrated Callahan, have it be a rationalization of someone whos in too deep. When Hero tells him that Tadashi went in to save him, have Callahan pause for a moment, his features softening as he processes such a thought, his prized pupils death being on his hands. But he doesnt allow himself to dwell on the thought, because it would mean that his whole mission is scrutinizd. In denial, he hesitantly mutters "That...that was his mistake." A lie, aimed inward.
jokes aside, I kinda disagree with Schaff's point about Calaghan's plan of sucking up the buildings in the portal he said it himself, Krey took everything away from him and now he's gonna take everything away from Krey also I do kinda like how Calaghan and Hero have parallels in dialogue When Baymax asked him if this is what Tadashi would've wanted, he said "Tadashi is gone!" Calaghan responded with the same thing in the movie "Abigail is gone" so it kindaaa makes sense even if it's kinda dumb it at least parallels with the protagonist's conflict
Or as another commenter suggested, have Callahan blurt out the line but immediately look pained from his own words. Just a flash of regret would've showed his humanity and kept him as a sympathetic villain.
49:26 - Dr. Facilia was in the cafe when Tianna mentioned needing money for her restaurant. That being said, that still doesn’t explain how he knew about her father but who knows.
24:42 his “THATS NOTHING!!!” And onward was so powerful! I understand where he is coming from but I seriously never thought that many people would say that 🧍♂️ is the best Disney Villian ever
As someone who's watched Atlantis about 6 times now, I didn't even notice what James pointed out of how casually he talks pre and post betrayal and how much realer that makes him seem! Also, I think Rourke is an ignored candidate for the whole "best disney villain death" competition. How the crystal's protective measure is supposed to help it and that confusing move being the setup for the climax is one of the only parts of the film I think is flimsy, but that little reveal of what it can do was SO SICK
When you think about it, Judge Claude Frollo is the only villain who got away with murder on screen in the first 10 minutes of the movie in disney history
5:30 Ok hear me out on Edgar. The scene where he does the math on how long it’ll take him to get the money is so funny. “Each cat only lives about twelve years… and they each nine lives! Four times twelve times nine times…”
Edgar is fun. He's not a peak Disney villain, but I would argue that he's quite entertaining. Strong B tier villain imo. I didn't get Schaff's placement at all for him.
Yeah I also don't think Edgar is the best villain, hell he isn't even that good, but yk he is at least funny and well animated in some scenes, that should be enough to at least bup him up above the thanos guy from moana 2 imo.
What scares me most about Frollo is that he doesn't need to be a magical creature, have a powerful trident or even a genie's lamp to be scary... Frollo is scary for the simple fact that he is 100% human.
He's not only human, but a human in a position of power, only barely superseded by the church. It takes a full-on revolt to stop him after he arrested a lot of romani, tried to kill an innocent family, and then tried to execute Esmerelda.
Kinda like Umbridge in Harry Potter, he's a very cruel, petty, and sanctimonious person with no special powers that others don't have, but in a position of power, there's people in history that were like them and people you've probably encountered that are like them, they're very real villains
Something that I think goes under appreciated (or maybe I just never see any praise for them) are the little clips that accompany every placement. It’s honestly my favorite part of a Schaffrillas ranking video. I live for that little half second where I try to rapidly figure out what movie/character is getting the spot based entirely on that, and the few seconds afterwards when it makes sense is so fun every time.
41:51 in the Spanish dub of Mulan, Shang Yu calls Mulan "El Soldado de la montaña", the MALE soldier from the mountains, which makes his disregard for her specific gender even cooler, in a way.
Yeah, in Portuguese they did the same "O Soldado da Montanha", It's so simple but it always makes my skin crawl. Shan Yu has one of the most chilling Disney villain lines
You hit the nail on the head on why Frollo is ultimately the best disney villain to ever be made. The Hunchback of Notre Dame is my favourite Disney film ever and for years it felt like no one else appreciated it like how I did as a kid. So to see the villain from my favourite film place top in the list genuinely makes me feel overwhelmed with happiness. I generally agree with this list as well, though I'd personally switch a few around.
1:11:21 in the Brazilian version, for some reason that I can't say why, they even changed "you are more evil than you and me" for "out of disgust he killed his parents". I mean, as if drowning orphans and widows wasn't enough, they added familicide to Ratigan's list of crimes just because EDIT: OKAY, HEAR ME OUT, I took another look at both versions that after the part "Worse than the widows and orphans you drowned?" they changed the phrase “You are the best of the worst” to “Whoever was left, you strangled”.... Like, what kind of conspiracy happened here that decided to turn Ratigan into Disney's cruelest villain, before Frollo? It's because he's a evil gay? I think that it's because he's a evil gay
The italian version instead implies he was the one who built the big ben, somehow? Instead of the song beginning with "From the mind that brought you the Big Ben caper", he just goes "From the mind that *created* the Big Ben"
I like how owning "racist cats" is attributed to Aunt Sarah as if she personally trained them to be racist depictions
I mean, Siamese cats don't tend to sing racial stereotype theme songs, she probably rehearsed that with them, or picked the most insensitive ones she could find at the shelter 😂
(She's evil, maybe she went to an unethical breeder)
hey, she's the one who bought them, she thought it was fine to have cats that resemble racist caricatures c:
@@chardude36m12 Could’ve bought any other pair of cats instead, but no she had to buy the ones that are obvious racial stereotypes.
@@sarafontanini7051Tbf, you can find plenty of pictures of cats who have a little black mustache pattern below their nose. Some cats just kinda look funky
She definitely looks like she throws around slurs
Shout out to captain hook in peter pan 2 for saying he wont harm a single hair on peter's head to make a deal with Jane and then he plucks a single hair from peter's head and says that's the one he woudlnt harm
TRUTH I always loved that. I also loved that Peter says "OW" real loud when he plucks it. Like Peter you're such a baby, it didn't hurt that much, lol
That line went absolutely hard
@@AK-jt9gxI mean, he’s a kid that never grows up. He’s immature. Like a sibling getting “hurt” and screaming to get the other sibling(s)in trouble. Pure immature pettiness in my opinion.
Based pfp
What a Chad Pirate.
fun fact about King Candy, if you notice in the code scene, everyone and everything else has neatly sorted lines of code that fit neatly, but his is a jumbled mass of spaghetti code that's bursting at the seams.
So Valve programmed King Candy?
Damn you YandereDev
@@superamogusbros5594
I like that king candy was foreshadowed in the wreck it Ralph trailer that he was the villain of the movie.
*Owl City flashbacks...*
@@edenetesantana7879 If YanDev collabed with Paradox Interactive
“They’re so deliciously, unapologetically…”
Me: Gay!
Schaffrillas: “evil”
Me: oh yeah that too
King Magnifico not being in rock bottom is the highest achievement Wish has ever done
Probably the ONLY achievement Wish has
Still not great for Wish, because it took me a hot second to remember who he was 😅😂
He's the only character people remember tbf
@@jeepmega629 How is he so low when he got his genes from outer space
their weirdest achievement was inverting the roles of the protagonist and villain 💀 girl protagonist was the villain and he was the hero
One of the things I loved about Frollo is that while a lot of the other villains are motivated by obtaining power (Scar, Ursula, Jafar, etc) Frollo already has power. Instead we’re shown how he abuses it. While Scar is still a great villain, once he becomes king he just kinda lays around and complains. The things Frollo does are far more interesting and and honestly terrifying.
Scar is unique cause he’s such a brat, and not a brat that doesn’t get anything, he gets everything he wanted and still bitches. Fun!!!
Hard agree with this. Frollo is a villain who technicly "already won". Hes in a position of power, he cleary loves his job, doesnt care if the 'guilty' die, and cleary does whatever he wants while within reason. Hes also cleary human, hes a messed up twisted human who fears the Judgement of God while believing hes Humble and Just (even thou we see plenty of evidence of otherwise, like when he gos to teach Quasi his lessons.)
Him lusting after Esmeralda and wanting her, isnt the biggest or most grand goal, but when you consider that hes been a Judge for a long while... you start to wonder if Esmeralda was the only one he lusted after, and was simply the first that was denied to him for a long time.
@@peterwhite6415 I never considered that Frollo might have had women before Esmerelda. Who of course would’ve been forced to be with him. That wouldn’t be surprising and would add yet another layer of depravity to him.
@peterwhite6415 Wow...damn...I don't think i have ever considered the fact that Frollo has preyed upon other women during his career as a judge...but tha does sound like something he'd do. Then again, he freaks out in Hellfire while singjng about his lust for Esmeralda and i don't know if his old ass can handle those visions every time he gets horny
His biggest goal is to exterminate an actually real oppressed group of people, which is insane. Disney wouldn't dare pull that off today. Closest they got was the indigenous people in Frozen 2, which is heavily based on the sámi-people of Scandinavia - a group that were historically oppressed in Norway (I don't know about the other countries, I only learned about the Norwegian history)
The worst part about Callaghan is that he does actually apologize to Hiro, and admits Tadashi died because he let his actions become bitter and fueled by a deep hate, IN THE SPIN OFF SHOW. He could have been a good twist villain had he just said that in the movie! It was handled so well too, Hiro said Tadashi would have wanted him to forgive Callaghan, and he hoped someday he'd be able to.
ikr
so unfortunate that both Callaghan AND the writers realized this too late
Tadashi is the villain because he committed suicide. Literally every firefighting PSA warns people to not run into burning buildings. You aren't being a hero, you're being a complication.
@@ObjectsInMotion Pfft that doesn't make Tadashi a villain. He's a supporting character whose death is an inciting incident, caused by a good intentioned bad decision in the heat of panic. He died only a couple steps from the door, so it wouldn't complicate firefighting.
Plus, if he hadn't died, Hiro wouldn't have become a hero later on and been there to stop That-Was-His-Mistake from doing his evil plan.
@@AK-jt9gxThat was their mistake
Ain't no way you said Mother gothel's song isn't memorable. I'm a dude and '' mother knows best'' instinctively started to play in my head.
Personally I think the reprise sounds awesome & menacing, even though it’s really short.
Agreed I was left clutching my pearls
I also have to respectfully disagree with Schaff here. That song is a bop
there’s not a bad song in that movie but mother knows best is PEAK it’s so fun and campy and tells you everything you need to know about her
What does being a dude have to do with anything
I feel like they could have fixed Callahan’s “That was his mistake!” line if he showed regret immediately after saying it. Like a heat in the passion moment. It would still result in Hiro getting upset and remove Baymax’s chip, and still make Callahan feel human.
I believe one dub translated that line a bit differently, and if translated back to English, would read like "I didn't ASK him to save me!", implying more of a regretful tone.
@@LloydTheZephyrian Thats phenomenally better
Even better, we can rewrite the line beforehand to add more precedent to that:
Hiro: You let him die…
Callaghan: Let him die? You think I planned for him to just run in there, without any care for his life?!
Hiro: He tried to save you!
Callaghan: Cue “that was his mistake* and regret
THAT WAS THE WRITER’S MISTAKE
Honestly this approach is a win-win situation, Calahan would become much less of a 1 dimensional character, and we would still have the funny meme line
Callahans plan is kinda stupid
Recent events have shown is that all he needed to take revenge is a handgun
I can’t lie, Schaffrillas is one of the few channels that makes super long form videos that I almost always watch right on release and either fully through or in bits and pieces throughout my day. Even if I don’t always agree with some of his takes, I love hearing everything James has to say about the media he engages with
I mean I watch long essays but I know Schaffrialls makes good long vidoes
I love it, I was cleaning the house and just playing the whole thing lol
Same, he really makes my day
me two. even if i disagree with him [I.E Cars 2]
I wonder will he rank all the Dreamworks animated movie villains along with Don Bluth and Illumination villains
1:19:05 On that, fun fact: when Hades says “Guys, relax, it’s only half-time”, he says it at the 46-minute mark of the 92-minute film. Which means it actually was halftime 😅😂
I kinda have to assume that's just an amazing coincidence because that's only true on the newer prints of the movie starting with the 2014 DVD/Blu-ray and beyond. Replacing the 1997 Disney logo with the 2014 logo adds roughly 40 seconds or so to the beginning, meaning the theatrical release, the 1998 VHS, and 1999 DVD have that line happening roughly 40 seconds earlier. Still impressive it was that close to the halfway mark originally but I really have to assume it's just a coincidence. On the other hand Minority Report was able to pinpoint how long it was until the end credits start when they say how long until Anderton meets Crowe so it could have been intentional.
Half time is 20 minutes long @@RENTnerd87
@@RENTnerd87 eh 40 seconds isn't that much of a difference... it's still roughly around the halfway point so i wouldn't use that as evidence of it being a coincidence
Gotta love that attention to detail!
I know this has nothing to do with it, but what did his VA (James Wood) do?
Putting Buck Cluck on a villain tier list is peak comedy.
Seriously, though, he suuuuucks. If we were ranking the Disney parents, he'd be at the bottom. He isn't the worst parent, let's not lie, not when Mama Gothel exists. But he is the least enjoyable parent. Not just cause the parental redemption was weak, but because of wasted potential. At least in a deleted scene he helped protect Chicken from the media.
@@WillieManga He's the worst because he's unintentionally terrible in a way the villainous parents aren't
genuinely when he said it was a joke i was like “no go back. you were cooking”
Because where's the lie
As someone who actually likes Chicken Little (mostly because of nostalgia, but that's besides the point) I totally agree with that.
1:26:16 Funnily enough, in french both Scar and Frollo were voiced by the same actor (Jean Piat) and that's the only two roles he ever played in Disney movies. The guy left his mark
@@adrienponcet2610 real talk the French dub of Hellfire is so peak
In Spain, Frollo shares a VA with Mufasa!
In poland, frollo’s and kerchak from Tarzan have the same VA. Also Hagrid from HP
And outside of Disney, Jean Piat (the French VA) voices Gandalf in The Lord of the rings and Magneto in the first X-Men trilogy.
in the Brazilian version, Scar's VA also shared with Jafar and Anastasia's Rasputin (when he spoke, not when he sang) and Sykes from Oliver and Company
The guy loved being mean
8:35 gave me the mental image of Magnifico being the one cheering "WOO! NOT LAST! NOT LAST! NOT LAST!" And I'd like to thank Schaff for that
The idea of him celebrating and happily saying "This is the thanks I get!" because he is so hyped to not be last- 😂
Fr, like good for him. I enjoyed Magnifico (not his song) and he IS attractive. But thank god he’s not last
@katherinesmallbean3594 like the moment, Aunt Sarah gets announced as last he just recreates that one SpongeBob meme
I'm just imagining all the villains sitting in like an amphitheater watching Schafrillas rank them now
Literally that 3rd place Olympian meme
51:42 It gets even better when you realize there was no water in this pitcher. She put an empty pitcher there just so that the prisoner sees it's empty even if they managed to grab it by some off chance.
Evil for the love of the game
Or the water in the bucket dried up and it was barely out of the person's reach and they never got it. Either way, it's evil!
I think the water just evaporated, given the dudes been dead for so long that he's just bones
No way on the Disney Villain song does the Superior of the In-between, Lord Xemnas, appear. O_O
Girl set the standard
"Man" is hilarious as an entry because he is a basketball stat sheet of a character, but is genuinely more effective as a diabolus ex machina than some characters with genuine personalities and arcs are as villains. He’s the perfect gatekeeper for the "real" villains
24:14
I'm probably not alone in thinking this, but Schaff's crashout over the "character" of Man is one of the funniest things I've ever seen on his channel.
(I completely agree, though.)
You're not😃
This isn't even the first time either, Man is just that rediculously stupid as a villain concept and it is NOT done well in bambi
Any time Shaffrillas is angry is always hilarious!
@@DZ-DizzyDummexcept when you take in the fact he’s able to be a menacing force without even being there and that Schaff’s put villains way higher in the list for things much less grounded and significant than "representing the evil nature of man"
Schaff is kind of scary when he’s angry ngl
I love that
The voice of Chron in Dinosaur was Sam Wright. He was my drama teacher. He had Parkinson’s until he passed, but would always have a smile on his face working with young kids performing in shows. Great guy and great actor.
That's so cool!
@@Friigus wow, no need to be such a dickhead. first of all, "minor spelling mistake, i win" is an insane thing to say when someone is reminiscing on a beloved teacher who has since passed away. second, he didn't die of parkinson's, but the original comment never said that, they just said he had parkinson's, which is fully likely since prostate cancer is much more common in people with parkinson's disease, and because he was only diagnosed with prostate cancer three years before he died, most likely after the original commenter had been taught by him. weird to just go around accusing people of lying, especially when they have no reason to at all and you have zero proof.
@@Friigus first of all, "minor spelling mistake, i win" is an insane thing to say when someone is reminiscing on their memories with a beloved teacher who has since passed on. second, he didn't die of parkinson's disease, but the original comment never said that. they just said he _had_ parkinson's disease, which is perfectly likely since a) he was only diagnosed with prostate cancer three years before his death, most likely after the original commenter had been taught by him, and b) prostate cancer is much more likely in people with parkinson's disease. it's super weird to just go around accusing people of lying like that, especially when this is a very heartfelt message, they have no reason to lie, and you have no proof to back up your claims other than easily disproven information and typos.
@@Friiguswell, the comment didn’t say he died from parkinsons. he just had it.
@@courtneyevieOkay. Sorry again.
As someone who heavily hyperfixated on Captain Hook for a bit, it made me really happy to see how highly ranked he was considering how underrated he can be. Like fun fact, this man was planned to die as he does in the original source material. But the crew ended up liking him so much they were like “… but what if he didn’t?”
This man evaded death by being a lovable villain and I think that deserved props
What was it like being Hook’s biggest fan?
All of Peter Pan is a nothingburger plot propped up on fun, lovable characters, places and set pieces. A VHS copy of it was the first thing I ever bought with my own money, I've always loved it. Hook is such a perfect villain for it, and Smee and Tick Tock the croc as well (though one could argue that the villain of the villain is the hero).
I love Captain hook simply because he is a goofy villain who still does absolutely horrendous shit. Dude is silly and pompous, then proceeds to try to drown and shoot kids
Just like Bowser 😄
@@barbararab6390 Ain't he a stinker?
24:15 The fact that Schaff had a massive crash out because of a character named “Man”, but DIDN’T put him in last place is just insane.
watching the hunchback of notre dame is crazy…frollo is literally about to drop a baby down the well in the first 10 minutes and he justifies it so calmly-“i’m just sending it back to hell where it belongs”💀
When I watched Hunchback my jaw actually dropped when I saw that scene 😭 I was like “This IS still a Disney film right?”
Yeah, some older animated films in general just had NO chill. Like, Prince of Egypt literally opens with people being whipped, enslaved, and having their BABIES MURDERED.
Prince of Egypt and hunchback of Notre dame are probably the most serious animated movies i’ve seen. they have the most mature themes, even if notre dame had some tonal issues
@hibiscuspetals02 Since it's based on an actual biblical story it'd be disappointing if they watered it down. I'm so glad they didn't
@@p234gr8 ... I do hope you mean "most serious animated family movies" you've seen. I mean they're both phenomenal movies, but due to the requisite humor, they're never gonna be as serious as some adult animated movies.
Something else that really helps Frollo's effectiveness is that he's actually in the movie quite a lot. He actually has the most proportionate screen time out of all the Disney villains, being in about a third of Hunchback's runtime, and he doesn't waste a single second of it.
I'm pleasantly surprised Frollo still made the top of the list given Schaffrillas' video contrasting him negatively with his stage and book counterparts
@@jamesa.romano8500 To be fair, Schaff has always framed that as: "Movie: 9/10, Stage: 10/10" sort of comparison.
Because here Frollo's being contrasted with the other Disney Villains, which is something he rocks the socks off at
@@carrotbunny5123That's true, and while I think people are allowed to look at renaissance Disney villains and hold them to a high standard, Frollo's got them all beat because he's not one dimensional.
The others are like campy, sassy "oh I'll ruffle you up" mustache twirling villains. Whereas Frollo is willing to commit genocide over what he thinks is an act of righteous passage under the eyes of God. He's got layers is what I'm trying to say.
I think that it helps Frollo become the best villain because we know this guy would kill for absolutely nothing. Every scene where he's with Quasimodo or Esmerelda is one where there's tangible overwhelming tension purely due to this aspect of him.
Hades invented the ”what are those” meme so he deserves high spot
I just realized that line is also in Hercules omg
Reason #74 why Hades is one of the best characters
No, T'challa invented that in Black Panther!!!!
Truly ahead of his time
@@pastarizzoto Hercules came before Black Panther, my man
The list (spoilers)
47: (2:20) Aunt Sasha (Lady and the Tramp)
46: (5:14) Edgar (The Aristocats)
45: (6:52) Bellwether (Zootopia)
44: (8:33) King Magnifico (Wish)
43: (11:53) Radcliffe (Pocahontas)
42: (13:35) Nalo (Moana 2)
41: (15:07) Kron (Dinosaur)
40: (15:55) Buck Cluck (Chicken Little)
39: (17:27) Prince Hans (Frozen)
38: (18:25) The Horned King (The Black Cauldron)
37: (20:14) Namaari (Raya and the Last Dragon)
36: (21:03) King Runeard (Frozen II)
35: (22:05) Professor Callaghan (Big Hero 6)
34: (24:14) Man (Bambi)
33: (26:34) Captain Gantu (Lilo and Stitch)
32: (27:23) Madame Medusa (The Rescuers)
31: (28:21) Percival C. McCleash (Rescuers Down Under)
30: (29:00) Sher Khan (The Jungle Book)
29: (30:07) Te Kā (Moana)
28: (34:23) Lady Tremaine (Cinderella)
27: (35:37) Clayton (Tarzan)
26: (37:02) Sykes (Oliver and Company)
25: (37:56) Madame Mim (The Sword in the Stone)
24: (38:42) Honest John & Gideon (Pinocchio)
23: (39:38) Alameda Slim (Home on the Range)
22: (41:43) Shan-Yu (Mulan)
21: (43:25) The Queen of Hearts (Alice in Wonderland)
20: (44:15) Amos Slade (Fox and the Hound)
19: (45:52) John Silver (Treasure Plant)
18: (47:16) Dr. Facilier (The Princess and the Frog)
17: (49:58) The Evil Queen (Snow White and the Seven Dwarfs)
16: (52:00) Prince John (Robin Hood)
15: (53:10) Mother Gothel (Tangled)
14: (54:57) Cruella De Vil (101 Dalmatians)
13: (56:32) Yzma (Emperor’s New Groove)
12: (58:26) Jafar (Aladdin)
11: (1:00:30) Lyle Tiberius Rorke (Atlantis: The Lost Empire)
10: (1:02:52) Maleficent (Sleeping Beauty)
9: (1:04:37) Goob & Doris (Meet the Robinsons)
8: (1:07:11) King Candy (Wreck It Ralph)
7: (1:09:59) Professor Ratigan (Great Mouse Detective)
6: (1:12:48) Gaston (Beauty and the Beast)
5: (1:15:12) Captain Hook (Peter Pan)
4: (1:17:46) Hades (Hercules)
3: (1:21:04) Ursula (The Little Mermaid)
2: (1:23:38) Scar (The Lion King)
1: (1:26:13) Judge Claude Frollo (The Hunchback of Notre Dame)
I am a Edgar fan.
If there are one million Edgar fans, I am one, if there is only one, I am that one, if there are none, then I am no longer alive. That is all.
Edit: Apparently, there are over a thousand of us. . . Stand proud!
Ngl, while he's an asshole for trying to get rid of the cats, I would be pissed too if my boss gave everything to cats and left me with nothing
Aristocats is one of my comfort movies, and Edgar's slapstick with the dogs is top tier comedy. 10/10 best movie to watch when you're sick
I'm with you
Edgar is so fun imo. Aristocats was one of my favorite movies growing up so I may be biased haha
I stan Edgar
The reason Shan Yu didn't care Mulan was a woman is because a lot of nomadic tribes in Asia had warrior women so it wouldn't be that out of the ordinary for him
You know what, as someone who studies history, it makes perfect sense now. You’ve opened a new perspective for me!
Its actually interesting that most warrior based societies had more of an equal roles between men and women in thier cultures compared to more agricultural centered societys
🤣😂 RUclips comment section historians strike again with their vast intelligence... Yes warrior women existed, but claiming that they were "ordinary" in ANY type of ancient tribe/society is pure drivel.
@@KoopaTroopa-c3hever heard of "reading comprehension"?
@@Pietelt Is that your refutation of my comment? Lol, I understood the OG poster fine.
51:48 Knowing that a sequel was planned to make that skeleton Snow White’s father makes this scene all that much darker to me.
As someone who got to play Jafar in a local stage production, I am admittedly biased towards him. His sliminess was so fun to portray. That being said, Claude Frollo is the right answer.
Something about Hellfire that I dont see mentioned enough is that the entire thing is him being given the chance to change. The "backing" vocals from the red cloaked spirits? Mea culpa, which means "through my fault" and is a part of confessions. His own delusions are being influenced by God to have him accept fault for this, to see his own guilt and move on. He asks for a solution from God, and he is literally given one. The random guard that comes in, whether a real guard or an angel, is that last chance. "She's gone, we can't find her. She won't be your problem anymore"
But frollo doesnt care
Right? I adore the stage musical of Hunchback; but damn the loss of that moment hurts.
I love the angel guard theory.
Another thing I don’t think a lot of people realize is that he actually implicitly blames GOD for his sin as well when he says “He made the devil so much stronger than the man.” In other words, “it’s God’s fault that I’m giving into temptation.” Dude’s literally blaming everyone but himself and then doubling down. Excellent villain.
@@GKplus8me too
"And he shall smite the wicked and thrust them into the fiery pit"
God: *BET.*
Couldn't crumble that ledge fast enough!
1:29:49
This is a Muppet movie ranking.
Don’t believe me? I did all the research, check it.
1. Principal Prickly is voiced by Dabney Coleman, who played Martin Price and Murray Plotsky in The Muppets Take Manhattan.
2. King Neptune is voiced by Jeffrey Tambor, who played K. Edgar Singer in Muppets from Space.
3. Eris is voiced by Michelle Pfeiffer, who played herself in an episode of Muppets Tonight.
4. Jessie is voiced by Joan Cusack, who played Rachel Bitterman in It’s a Very Merry Muppet Christmas Movie.
5. Tamatoa is voiced by Jemaine Clement, who played the Prison King in Muppets Most Wanted.
6. Finn McMissile is voiced by Michael Caine, who played Ebenezer Scrooge in The Muppet Christmas Carol.
7. Lenny is voiced by Jack Black, who played himself in The Muppets (2011).
8. Nigel Thornberry is voiced by Tim Curry, who played Long John Silver in Muppet Treasure Island.
9. King Harold is voiced by John Cleese, who played Neville in The Great Muppet Caper.
10. Bigweld is voiced by Mel Brooks, who played Professor Max Krassman in The Muppet Movie.
I’m playing 5D chess, your move, funny crab man.
Edit: THE GREAT BANANA IS REAL
He did have some muppet movies on his letterboxd recently...
That isn't eris but medusa from kid icarus
Luckily her voice actor, Cree Summer does appear in Kermits Swamp Years as Pilgrim and Kermits mom
I would also like to mention the background is Dagobah, home of Yoda, played by Frank Oz, not even gonna explain that one
what
@@walrus6429 Good Cover.
Genius.
I can't wait to see how high you ranked Bob Iger!
Nah this one's crazy but true. Even I wasn't that evil.
You mean cipher
@@NintendoNerd-t2k jump
A good realistic portrayal of capitalistic greed, but I find his character a bit one-note and his design bland. 6/10 Disney villain
It's funny because he isn't even the evilest disney ceo
Can confirm, you used “Slay” perfectly when talking about the evil queen lol
56:00 - "Her goal is to murder puppies and her motivation is Coat" LMFAO that got me
1:28:15 YES. that is EXACTLY it
as a Christian myself it bothers me to NO END when people do horrible crap, whether that's racism or sexism or whatever, and then try to associate with Christianity or use it as a justification. because not only is that just completely wrong and violates dozens of Jesus' actual recorded teachings, but it also gives everyone else a completely (yet understandably) misinformed view of what Christianity actually is. not only do I wish people would stop taking bad people's religious claims at face value, but I wish religious people would go to greater lengths to demonstrate how those people completely misrepresent religion as a whole
Right here. This is what i wanted of most of religion people,and do action based on their religion isn't that preachy or bit of force just for their own religion sake.
Its thanks to those types of people that I'm convinced a lot of christians only cherrypick bible quotes they agree with while ignoring anything from the bible that says otherwise. I don't wanna get involved with Christianity because I feel like I might become one of those people if I do and there will be no turning back. It pains me too because I know not all of them are like this due to having religious grandparents.
@@easiestcc6451 As a former gentile New Yorker turned devout Christian, I hear you. Jesus was really taboo for me as well. The problem for me was that I associated imperfect so-called Christians with Jesus, therefore making Him imperfect. We all fall short of the glory of God, even myself, fortunately, all who have faith in Christ are made right with God. Just because we believe in Jesus and have our sins forgiven DOES NOT make ANY of the bad things we do all right. I know you didn't make this RUclips comment so you could start a long religious thread, but my friend, I can tell you that God wants YOU and all who read this to follow his son Jesus Christ... factually. My friend, I'm sorry that some of my brothers and sisters in Christ have let you down, truly, but Jesus is incapable of letting you down, as He knows you better than you know you, and He is always working for your good. I pray that you recieve this message well, and that you and your grandparents have an abundance of physical, mental, and spiritual health!
I imagine yall are talking about frollo, and that's why he's one of the best Disney villains in my book. He uses religion to justify his prejudice against Quazimodo, and especially his desire for Esmerelda, blaming her for his feelings that he complicates. There are real people out there who twist religion like he does, and that's what makes him so terrifying
@@Procc75 Yeah and it's pretty scary. In fact one of the most unexpected move from Disney to make Frollo a villain that is far different than any Disney Villain. Till these day,he is one of the best Disney Villain of all time.
I noticed that Ratigan is the only character in TGMD that has five fingers on each hand instead of four. Animation studios used to do the four finger thing to cut down on animation costs, so the fact that Disney made an exception for Ratigan shows how all-out they went on his character.
It also helps to show that he's different from all the mice, 'cause he's a rat.
@@AtlasBlizzardThat lizard guy in Ratigan’s gang has four fingers. I don’t think that’s why they gave Ratigan five.
@@AtlasBlizzardJust D,ont Say To Him Because He Would Not Love That
41:45 "we're going to hypnotize a bunch of cows to storm the capitol to make me, president" *turns to camera* "thats right were going to hypnotize a bunch of cows to storm the capitol to make me president"
24:15-26:34 wow I can’t believe we got another angry schaff ever since the dehydration gun incident
After finally doing all the bad villains he realized he still had this one to talk about and he just snapped lol
He was committed to the bit. Referencing the You Are Not a Gamer video by Aleks Le.
And the Toads Turnpike battle mode incident
I am absolutely speechless... that was insane! 11/10
I luv ur pfp
The final scene with Frolo surrounded by flames actually gave me nightmares as a kid. Idk what it is, the fact his eyes and teeth are lit up yellow and his skin looking pale making him resemble a demon than any kind of judge or the crooked smile lacking any kindness or warmth. Just euggghhh, makes my skin crawl.
Hunchback, lion king, dinosaur and never ending story and the 4 movies I still refuse to watch as an adult bc I received so much trauma as a kid that still lingers to this day. Every time I’m sick I always have a nightmare that includes one of those 4 movies
@ Dude the Nothing from the never ending story used to make little kid me cry lol
Agreed, that moment really reveals how insane and monstrous Frollo is behind his flaky holy facade.
Unpopular opinion: I absolutely loved Bellwether before the twist. Her interactions with Judy sounded like she genuinely supported her dream as a cop. Even with Judy and Nick, a predator that Bellwether herself is supposed to have bigoted views towards, go to her for help, she treats BOTH of them friendly and her friendliness was also genuine.
How the hell am I supposed to believe this character would be a psychopathic racist when her behavior previously didn't suggest that?
I *wanna* say the idea was that she herself doesn't really mind predators, and she was just using the public's prejudice as a tool to gain power, but I kinda feel like I'm putting more thought into this than the writers ever did.
I suppose it doesn't help when you position as the assistant mayor is nothing more than a glorified secretary, you possibly got the role to secure a minority vote (Which, when you consider Judy's position was also used by the mayor to prop himself up as being a result of his "Mammal Inclusion Initiative" act, doesn't sound out of place.) and worse of all, that shoddy coffee mug job, I could see some frustration, not for ALL predators, but some frustration. And yes, I agree. Her support of Judy was unquestionably honest.
I think the reason for her previous actions and politeness is not meant to suggest a genuine lack of discriminatory motives, rather I think she is mean to be the proverbial "wolf if sheeps clothing" made more literal. Someone who has learned to act one way while secretly feeling and even acting another way when they feel they can let the mask down. Its not that unheard of, but it is not what we normally expect, most people veen villians are somewhat honest with their feelings and emotions, the two facedness of someone who acts friendly and sweet towards people while secretly hating them is uniquely deceptive. Think palpatine as he nearly weeps for democracy and the republic while in private literally cackling about infinite power. If we got more flashbacks from Bellwether in more movies or a tv series the producers likely would have given us more to show the double faced nature but without its like showing palpatine one moment talking about freedom and the next hurling jedi out of windows.
Personally, I tend to give the antagonists of a mystery story some slack, because the twist is supposed to be the *point.* I'm not saying Bellweather is great, but I understood what they were going for. I probably wouldn't put her super high in my own hypothetical ranking, either, though.
I find that opinion valid. Me personally I never gave a damn about her from beginning to end. That’s just a me thing though.
Clayton is a good villain because he's the toxic masculinity to Tarzan's positive masculinity
He's a foil to Tarzan in that sense. He's also a foil to Jane and the profesor because they represent the good of civilization while he represents the evil of civilization.
And he's a foil to Kerchak because they both use brute strenght and hate what's different, but one does it for profit and the other for fear of any harm coming to his family.
Fear not, citizens of Schaffrillas Productions!
47: Aunt Sasha (0:49)
46: Edgar (5:14)
45: Bellwether (6:52)
44: King Magnifico (8:33)
43: Radcliffe (11:53)
42: Nalo (13:35)
41: Kron (15:07)
40: Buck Cluck (15:55)
39: Prince Hans (17:27)
38: The Horned King (18:25)
37: Namaari (20:14)
36: King Runeard (21:03)
35: Prof. Callaghan (22:05)
34: Man (24:14)
33: Cpt. Gantu (26:34)
32: Madame Medusa (27:23)
31: Percival C. McCleach (28:21)
30: Sher Khan (29:00)
29: Te Kã (30:07)
28: Lady Tremaine (34:23)
27: Clayton (35:37)
26: Sykes (37:02)
25: Madame Mim (37:56)
24: Honest John & Gideon (38:42)
23: Alameda Slim (39:38)
22: Shan-Yu (41:43)
21: The Queen Of Hearts (43:25)
20: Amos Slade (44:15)
19: John Silver (45:52)
18: Dr. Facilier (47:16)
17: The Evil Queen (49:58)
16: Prince John (52:00)
15: Mother Gothel (53:10)
14: Cruella De Vil (54:57)
13: Yzma (56:32)
12: Jafar (58:26)
11: Lyle Tiberius Rorke (1:00:30)
10: Maleficent (1:02:52)
9: Goob & Doris (1:04:37)
8: King Candy (1:07:11)
7: Prof. Ratigan (1:09:59)
6: Gaston (1:12:48)
5: Cpt. Hook (1:15:12)
4: Hades (1:17:46)
3: Ursula (1:21:04)
2: Scar (1:23:38)
1: Judge Claude Frollo (1:26:13)
Bro is the hero we needed
thank you cuh
THANK YOU
peak
Not all heroes wear capes….THANK YOU!!! Hope it gets pinned
42:43 - I do believe that this right moment in Mulan is a stark sign, that the musical era of Disney is over, at least from the narrative perspective. Just before that scene we had this troops' song and then... We cut to the burnt village. the silent moment of realisation of what Shan Yu is all about. The sheer darkness of his heart and the ruthlessness to all the fallen soldiers of Li Shang's father really cements it all. Man, I love Mulan, such a classic alongside with Hercules.
Wow. I've thought many times about how that ends the songs in Mulan (1998) but never thought about the following films. The next musical wouldn't be until Princess and the Frog (2009).
(No, Tarzan and Brother Bear do not count as musicals because Phil Collins songs play in the background, even if the songs are bangers. No, Emperor's New Groove does not count as a musical because there is one song in the opening, though I do recommend you check out the deleted songs from the original musical Kingdom of the Sun version, especially Yzma's song "Snuff Out the Light")
No need for musical songs when Run Llama Run is worth 5 on its own
Schaffrillas, I've got to tell you something. I have been a Edgar fan since I was four. The part on the stairs with George and the bits with the two dogs will be always one of the funniest things I have ever seen. He's no Hades sure, but he holds a place in my hart.
I love his little tip-toes, finger-tapping dance
I love him, because the whole thing started because he's worse at both math and biology than me, which I find hilarious. He literally thinks cats live 9 lives, and that each one stacks up, so he'll be dead by the time they're gone. This is hilariously dumb, and makes me love the movie so much.
i felt like angela from smosh meekly saying "hey what's wrong with edgar :("
Me and my brother always found him hilarious, especially his delivery (note: we watched the movie in French). We would say some of his lines at eachover and laugh
He’s the GOAT
I wrote an entire paper in high school about how “Man” did absolutely nothing wrong and was entirely within the letter of the law, assuming only that bambis mother is killed in November-December, which is hunting season. Man did not deserve to die.
At least you got a good grade out of it 😂
This implies that the law is what defines morality which frollo pretty well disproves since he is the law and is also not exactly a great dude. More importantly, man didn’t practice proper fire safety which is absolutely doing something wrong
Another point for Shan-Yu from Mulan: He is one of the only villains to do something so severe that the movie changes genres. Mulan stops being a musical once the soldiers come across the destroyed village.
That scene always gives me goosebumps. The somewhat silly song cutting off to reveal such a haunting moment… I miss old Disney so much.
That was URSULA'S CRAZY SISTER'S mistake
this comment was cooler than planet sheen (2010)
THAT WAS HIS STAKE!
1:08:24
THE BEST PART OF KING CANDY IS REWATCHING AND CATCHING EVEN MORE HINTS EVERY TIME
had a friend point out the castle makes no sense for king candy to be in. it looks like a little girl's room. that his outfit isn't as extravagant or candy-like compared to everyone else's. his entire shape and design being completely different from EVERYONE who is humanoid in that game. AAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAA
Bro I LOVE how he gets defensive when Ralph points out the color of the throne room.
“I see you’re a fan of pink.”
“Salmon, that’s-it’s obviously salmon.”
Foreshadowing played off as a joke in the moment, gotta be one of my favorite genders.
When he sees Ralph and immediately thinks he’s there to usurp the protagonist role from him, like what an oddly specific conclusion to draw my dude
@@jaredmonk9404 this AND the crowns displayed in the game are PRINCESS CROWNS LIKE,,,,, ITS ALL THERE I LOVE THE DETAIL
@@naptime1912 the crown above the throne is a tiara too
@@grandempressvicky6387 yesss I think this is the one I'm specifically remembering!!!
30:32 I love how the squirrel from Emperor's New Groove kinda counts as a Disney Villain
Missed opportunity to say at the end: “Good night, House of Villains”
And play “It’s Our House Now Instrumental” in the video credits.
Awesome ranking Schaff!
Tri State Area is a location connected to a disney villain too... just not film
@@cyancybershockSo... are you saying you would prefer, "Doofenschmertz Evil Incorporated"?
THE "You are NOT a gamer" rant in Man from Bambi is amazing
It’s honestly one of my favorite internet rants
My favorite recreation would be Akechi from Persona 5 recreating it, since it sounds like the person in the video and Akechi are the same person.
@@UltimateDespairadothe most mindblowing thing about that is the fact that the guy who recorded that video would go on to voice the Persona 3 protagonist in Reload.
For a second I thought it was Chuck's rant from Better Call Saul
Gotta step in for my boy, Edgar. I work at a boarding center where a pair of frenchies get their SEVEN beds, personal meal cooler, and full human sized travel suitcase brought in by the dog's chauffeur. Made me realize that I get where Edgar's coming from. I have never seen a man look more dead inside. Dude would 100% ship the dogs to Timbuktu if he could.
id pull an edgar on the owners if i had to constantly work with $15,000 inbred dogs that live to age 4 and get fed steak for every meal
Yeah he was tripping with Edgar
@@MarquissMasonit felt like he just didn’t like the movie so completely dismissed Edgar. Which is strange since he praises some of those same attributes in other characters. Villains who are bad at being villains can be hilarious. You can just say you don’t like the movie while also trying to take a step back to be less biased about whether he’s a decent Disney villain.
@azvee I didn’t realise at first that „frenchies“ meant French Bulldogs and read this comment as „these French people were so extra, I can see how they would drive their employees to crime“ 😂😂😂😂
omg yeah, Edgar was justified lol
“Man” was considered to be in Deadpool and Wolverine at one point
Tbh I really loved The Aristocrats, Edgar included. His insane amount of glee and smugness about managing to get some CATS out of a house is entartaining as hell to me lol
He also definetly benefits from the insanely expressive animation he has in the movie, adding just a cherry on top
His interactions with the two dogs doesn't hurt either
The way he just sputters "cATS?!" when overhearing Adelaide talking about her will always killed me
Mr. Fagin...
He's too pathetic to not find funny, if you ask me.
I remember as a kid liking him as a bad guy/finding him funny
Something else I love about Cruella de Vil is how ABSURDLY VILLIAN her name is. Cruel-la devil. That's not a name, that's a super villain moniker. We need to go back to the age of naming villians Miss Killayorfrends
I mean, Machia-Villain from Megamind Vs. the Doom Syndicate happened, no one liked that he happened but he did.
I mean, machia-villan turned the whole thing from an uncompromising dumpster fire to just being "okay", so maybe it actually is the play. @An_Entire_Lime
@@icetide9411 Only Venture Bros can pull that off.
evelyn deavor:
Oh man you're going to love Ace Attorney
Shafrillas cares more about Man from Bambi than I have ever cared about anything in my entire life
That's a very schaffrillas thing to do
heh theatre kids am i right fellas
@@firewall5189applaud
maybe there's a way to remedy that
Why is Man in Bambi? Is there a lore reason?
Nah dude, Edgar from The Aristocats is SO FUNNY, I remember always laughing my ass of about him in the movie, dude deserved some respect
The moment you find out such a legendary actor like Vincent Price to say his favorite performance in his life was voicing an evil rat, you know you created a fantastic movie and villain!
It is a crime that Rattigan is so underrated in Disney Villian terms, he is an icon
@@themixelzone9968Honest The Great Mouse Detective is just way to underrated. Nowhere near enough people have watched.
Same with John Hurt as the Horned King, Keith David as Dr. Facilier and Eartha Kitt as Yzma.
*Fun fact related to Captain Hook and John Silver:* When the animators of Treasure Planet were trying to see if they could pull off making a 3D arm on a 2D character like Silver, they wanted to try it on some pre-existing footage of a character making some hand movements, they thought that the better way to do it was in Hook, since both him and Silver are pirates, so they picked up the scene that Schafrillas shows at 1:17:30 and made his arm 3D and robotic, once they liked the results, they continued with the idea. You can even find that test footage on RUclips!!
Turbo was like Judge Doom. We already knew he was the villain, that was just a surprise of his true origins.
Actually a really good comparison
@@N_o196 A question I had ever since wathing Wreck it Ralph is how Turbo survived hus game being unpluged on top of not being seen for years. It's a mystery.
@leebulger7112 It’s never directly explained, but the most likely explanation is that he just left the game before it was unplugged.
@@amirgarcia547 You are probably right. That's definitely how he initially survived but it doesn't explain how he stayed hidden until Sugar Rush came to the arcade.
@@leebulger7112 According to the scarce turbo-related material there is, he escaped the game he killed and hid in Game Central for however long it took for Sugar Rush to get plugged. (for this and more fun facts about turbo, check Randomalistic's analysis on the character)
Honestly, I totally bought Chicken Little's Dad as a villain, I only realized he was not when you said you were not serious XD
51:10 Honestly personal headcanon is that the potion is temporary, which explains:
A. Why the Queen wouldn't use it on Snow White,
and B. Why the Queen is willing to use it on herself.
It also just feels like intuitive, normal potion mechanic in any fiction.
i thought that the magic mirror is behind the reason that the queen went all i want my own stepdaughter to unalive herself.
"THAT WAS HIS MISTAKE"-Professer Callaghan, 2014
yall its been 16 seconmds
@ColonelKalonskiUT-TPErm what the sigma????
UTTP in the big 2024
THAT WAS HIS MAKE 😂
THAT WAS HIS STEAK
24:14 Oh. Oh my god. I thought he was jokingly angry like the Buck Cluck segment. *NO.* He's *genuinely* pissed about this.
Oh no. He is. He even stated in '22 he'd make you feel unsafe if you thought he was a legit villain.
Nah, he's just echoing this video ruclips.net/video/LRsKRShkC_Q/видео.html
HOLY CRAP! Is that an OSC member my eyes are seeing?
Frollo is my favourite villain of all time, because he’s a “good person” while being a villain. Hear me out, from what he knows everything he does is justified by his faith, he’s a believable and devoted character with real motivations, and even when he does bad things (even for him) he tries to justify himself to god!!! That’s a great character (and his song, mwah! Chefs kiss)
Christianity absolutely does NOT justify any of his actions 💀
He twists it from its true beliefs to try to make him FEEL justified about doing horrific things
@ that’s exactly what I said, learn to read
As a Captain Hook lover, we CANNOT forget about his amazing voice actor, Hans Conried who adds so much personality!
@@aworldofhopes7627 And Corey Burton who does a great job carrying on the work Hans Conried laid down.
@@hunterolaughlin YES!!!!
Did you know that he's the voice of Thomas Jefferson in Ben and Me?
You gave Ratigan a fair and rightful place. I can sleep peacefully tonight. 🥰
Im SO GLAD you ranked King Candy/Turbo in the top 10. People never really realize how good of a villain he is. You should 100% watch Randomalistic's 2 hour analysis on him, they like, deep dive on the manipulation tatics in that scene with ralph and you realize how much MORE of a good villain he is.
I guarantee its never that serious
@@kwible3682 no but it's fun and interesting
@@kwible3682 some people have time to do stuff that doesnt matter. let them
I was hoping someone would mention that video essay! I already thought he was a good villain, but after watching it, I'm convinced that he's the third best WDAS villain behind Scar and Frollo!
His need for admiration and attention is actually crazy as fuck and I loved his villain reveal. THATS how you do a twist villain
18:38
Horned King: You're just a cheap (dolphin chirp)ing knock-off!
Lich: Oh no, I'm the improvement
It's too bad Tamatoa doesn't count for this list, but Any chance to hear Schaffrillas bash Mr. That Was His Mistake is still more than worth it. Hearing him praise so many other legends is also a great gift.
my brother in christ, the video has been out for like 2 minutes, can you wait on the likefarming to make it look atleast more realistic?
he confirmed that tamatoa is too powerful for this video
so we won't get to hear him sing tamatoa's praises
No they got Schaffrillas 😭
Well Tamatoa not only got his own hour long video talking about how amazing he is, but an entire character arc in the Schaffrillas universe. That and we all know he would automatically make number one if he did count.
@TheDiamondCore Well at least they're an actual person and not some stupid bot or sex lurer.
How could you forget the iconic scene where Man says “why did Bambi’s Mom get shot? Is she stupid?”
She was working for the Jonkler
That clip from SpongeBob where Patrick's song destroys Bikini Bottom is such a funny way to show what a mess This is The Thanks I Get is as a Villain song.
to add to your whole Bambi MAN rant at 25:00, remember a while back how so many people were trying to pull mental gymnastics with the character of Death from puss in boots: the last wish. Going "oh, he's not a villain, he's just an antagonistic force/cosmic force" despite the fact he takes pleasure in the fear & suffering of the hero, is purposefully going beyond what he's allowed to do in order to kill puss, and is actively, physically fighting to try and murder puss.
but Man, who is entirely an unseen presence with no character and only exists through the destructive acts they cause, & who could easily just be a metaphorical placeholder for the general ideas of death/tragedy occurring in life in general? Nope, 100% active villain no debate in any way, shape or form
Emphasis on the "shape and form"
I think the "force of nature" thing is mostly intended as a comparison to the other two evil factions, the irredeemable Jack Horner and the sympathetic Goldilocks and her bears. Death fits in neither of these categories, he can't be defeated or redeemed because death is inevitable. That being said, the whole reason he goes after Puss to take his last life early is because he felt scorned by him. That's Maleficent levels of pettiness, it's just that the guy who wants to kill the main character over a perceived slight in this movie also just so happens to be an unavoidable force of nature that everyone has to face eventually.
This could completely wrong but usually when I hear "force of nature" character it's something that cant be reasoned with and is *almost* unstoppable the best thing you can do is get out of the way, run and hide, or just wait for the inevitable, like a tornado or a hurricane, (Like the Martians from war of the worlds or Minus One Godzilla) Death went after Puss before his time was up literally cheating the laws of nature because he was personally offended by the comments of some random cat laughing about the fact he has 9 lives while he could've just waited for Puss to inevitably get himself killed and loose his final life.
The only thing I dislike about hades is that people who know nothing about Greek stories and only know him from popular media assume he’s the villain of the pantheon.
Still a great Disney villain though.
If anything, Hades is kinda the least messed-up god out of the major ones. He's probably a little grumpy about not getting to draw sticks first for his lot since he's the oldest, but he just kinda sticks to himself. Pretty chill and reasonable guy, too, as long as you don't try to mess with his turf. He's also a pretty good husband, and went through the standard traditions before taking Persephone as his bride.
Exactly. He's probably the chillest god of them all, ruling over the kingdom of the dead fairly. The only 'bad' thing he did was kidnap Persephone to be his bride, but that was Zeus's doing. Her mother Demeter blamed Zeus, not Hades.
@@AtlasBlizzard Yeah, even then, Hades didn't really do anything all that wrong by ancient Greek standards. All you really had to do was ask the husband "hey, can I marry your daughter?", pass the vibe check, and go grab her to get hitched. If I remember right, Demeter would be the most in the wrong, as (according to my admittedly rusty memory on the topic, so feel free to correct me on this) the mother was never really involved in that choice. Of course, by today's standards, her frustration is understandable (even if her rage was a bit excessive), but it's unfair to judge the past by the present's standards.
Agreed, I love Disney's Hades as a character, it's just a shame that he contributes to the common impression that gods of the underworld are automatically evil and underworld = hell. I'm mostly invested in mythological Hades as one of my favourite gods of the Greek pantheon, but I believe Anubis suffers from the same misconceptions about underworld deities.
Still, if I separate Disney Hades from Greek Hades, he's one of my favourite villains ever.
Best Hades depiction IMO is from, well, Hades (the game). In that game, he's not evil, just extremely grumpy. He's stuck with an endless amount of paperwork, his wife left him, and his rebellious son keeps going on a rampage through the underworld (that leaves him with more paperwork). Also he thinks all of his extended family are idiots.
Fun fact: When Hades gets angry, his hair fire gets colder
Yes, because scientifically, the color blue has a smaller wavelength than red. It means that it takes more energy to create blue light as opposed to red light. However, we have a social association of the color blue with water, which can be cold and red with fire and lava, which are hot. So, yeah, it can cause some confusion.
@@abdulwasey3506thank you for saying this so I didn’t have to
The idea of all the warmth of his hair going directly to him when he gets mad goes hard
@@riasicoand thank you for saying that so I didn’t have to.
did he lose his cool
Bambi caused Schaff's "You are NOT a gamer" moment
I used to think the snake in the Jungle Book was also in Robin Hood, but that was Hiss. Mistake
The animatots borrowed and drew inspiration from Kaa for Sir Hiss, plus they have the same hypnosis powers, so that's probably why.
Underrated comment.
@@RandomDragonEXEKaa and Hiss are probably of the same species and/or are cousins who just happen to both have hypnotic powers.
Nahh I see what you did there
@@RandomDragonEXE More than that. Robin Hood and Jungle Book took advantage of rotoscoping to minimize the amount of unique animation required. Baloo and Little John share a lot of animation. I'm pretty sure Sir Hiss exists because they already had resources for Kaa, and they needed a supplemental villain for Prince John to talk to. Prince John isn't going to be revealing his plans to the Sheriff.
1:12:51 so so glad you used this for the Gaston sound
The Gaston Trilogy is so funny and iconic I can’t not hear it or see it when I watch Beauty. But here’s the thing, Beauty is so damn good that it doesn’t have anything taken away from it at all. It’s not often that a parody enhances or at least doesn’t detract a little from your experience watching the original.
Dude, that fucked me up
I like how he previously calls Edgar delightfully petty and now he's ranked second lowest and called stupid.
" and You. ARe WEARING. HIS MERCHANDISE!?!?!?!?!?!?"
52:11 if anyone is wondering it's because Prince John and the king who returns at the end, King Richard III the Lionheart, are actual historical figures. King Richard left England to go fight in the Third Crusade and his brother Prince John was left in charge in his absence. I won't get into their relationship or how the public views him cause that's a whole mess.
But short version is that Robinhood was a preexisting folk hero long before the two of them lived. People loved Richard so much and hated John so much that later versions of the Robinhood tale graft Richard and John to the myth and have Robinhood resisting the evil Prince John and his corrupt henchmen until the true king is able to return home and restore peace and order. That's also why the king just kinda shows up at the end.
That still didn’t need to happen. For instance, in the 1938 Robin Hood film, King Richard’s retaking of his kingdom is the subject of the whole climax. But they didn’t even necessarily need to do that. Just have it show up and throw open the castle doors dramatically around the time of the final battle, don’t have him return offscreen
@@officialmonarchmusic ok cool but the post is just explaining why there's 2 Johns
@@skilledwarmanOops. So sorry, didn’t click the timestamp to check
Richard I, not III. Sorry
@@officialmonarchmusicExactly. There is no excuse for Robin Hood's ending.
With Frollo the only thing is you didnt bring up his amazing vocal performance!! If I remember right you did in your villain songs ranking, but it's definitely worth a mention here!! Literally there is no one else who could have voiced him as well as Tony Jay did. It's not sassy like most of the 90's villains, or charismatic like others (which Jay is 100% capable of), it's just wretched evil. But still super great vid and I'm so happy with this ranking!!
Even 'That was his mistake' could have worked honestly. Have Callaghan say it whilst clearly holding back tears so that Hero can be mad and want to kill him, and then have him show genuine remorse at the end of the movie.
Schaffrillas, your argument about comparing "The Man" being just as villainous as the finding Nemo barracuda is an excellent point
Why did Man not do a villain monologue? Is he stupid?
It's crazy how the single line of THAT WAS HIS MISTAKE tanked the film. If they just had a single line about how Tadashi dying was a regretful mistake and he never wanted to hurt the dude, the film would have been leaps and bounds better.
I agree. Logically, I know the callous response was meant to trigger Hiro into wanting revenge on Callahan and needing to go through his own growth of “that’s not what Tadashi would have wanted.” However, there were other ways this could have been accomplished. He could have been cold towards Hiro’s grief without saying Tadashi died because he was an idiot.
THAT WAS A REGRETFUL MISTAKE
@@Rikrobat I saw another comment that said the line could stay the same, but as a heat of the moment thing where he immediately shows regret for saying it
@ I agree. He could have said the same thing and show regret for it later.
23:18 The thing is, I think that line couldve actually still worked. if only the execution and delivery were different. Rather than it being a thoughtless bark from a frustrated Callahan, have it be a rationalization of someone whos in too deep.
When Hero tells him that Tadashi went in to save him, have Callahan pause for a moment, his features softening as he processes such a thought, his prized pupils death being on his hands. But he doesnt allow himself to dwell on the thought, because it would mean that his whole mission is scrutinizd. In denial, he hesitantly mutters "That...that was his mistake." A lie, aimed inward.
it could've been solved if he shit said that was his 🥩
jokes aside, I kinda disagree with Schaff's point about Calaghan's plan of sucking up the buildings in the portal
he said it himself, Krey took everything away from him and now he's gonna take everything away from Krey
also I do kinda like how Calaghan and Hero have parallels in dialogue
When Baymax asked him if this is what Tadashi would've wanted, he said "Tadashi is gone!"
Calaghan responded with the same thing in the movie "Abigail is gone"
so it kindaaa makes sense even if it's kinda dumb
it at least parallels with the protagonist's conflict
Or as another commenter suggested, have Callahan blurt out the line but immediately look pained from his own words. Just a flash of regret would've showed his humanity and kept him as a sympathetic villain.
That would of made the scene so much better and not make him look so heartless
49:26 - Dr. Facilia was in the cafe when Tianna mentioned needing money for her restaurant. That being said, that still doesn’t explain how he knew about her father but who knows.
Well his whole occupation is fortune teller and his friends are spirits from another dimension. I wouldn't question at all why he knows anything.
24:42 his “THATS NOTHING!!!” And onward was so powerful! I understand where he is coming from but I seriously never thought that many people would say that 🧍♂️ is the best Disney Villian ever
1:09:44 creepiest part is how well he took to becoming a giant bug. Or how we managed to overtake it with sheer willpower
37:56 OMG EPIC: THE MUSICAL RECOGNITION WOOOO
YUHHHH 🥶🥶🥶🥶🥶
I THOUGHT THE SAME THING!!!!!
LETS GO EPIC MOMENT WOOOOO
God that was a jump scare for me
I was about to comment the same thing. Never been happier to be jumpscared by a song
As someone who's watched Atlantis about 6 times now, I didn't even notice what James pointed out of how casually he talks pre and post betrayal and how much realer that makes him seem!
Also, I think Rourke is an ignored candidate for the whole "best disney villain death" competition. How the crystal's protective measure is supposed to help it and that confusing move being the setup for the climax is one of the only parts of the film I think is flimsy, but that little reveal of what it can do was SO SICK
When you think about it, Judge Claude Frollo is the only villain who got away with murder on screen in the first 10 minutes of the movie in disney history
5:30 Ok hear me out on Edgar. The scene where he does the math on how long it’ll take him to get the money is so funny.
“Each cat only lives about twelve years… and they each nine lives! Four times twelve times nine times…”
"ANYWAY MUCH LONGER THAN I'LL EVER LIVE"
Edgar is fun. He's not a peak Disney villain, but I would argue that he's quite entertaining. Strong B tier villain imo. I didn't get Schaff's placement at all for him.
Yeah I also don't think Edgar is the best villain, hell he isn't even that good, but yk he is at least funny and well animated in some scenes, that should be enough to at least bup him up above the thanos guy from moana 2 imo.
@InksDoesArts literally
He’s a fun dumb villain who I do kinda feel bad for that he got passed over for the will.
What scares me most about Frollo is that he doesn't need to be a magical creature, have a powerful trident or even a genie's lamp to be scary... Frollo is scary for the simple fact that he is 100% human.
He's not only human, but a human in a position of power, only barely superseded by the church. It takes a full-on revolt to stop him after he arrested a lot of romani, tried to kill an innocent family, and then tried to execute Esmerelda.
Kinda like Umbridge in Harry Potter, he's a very cruel, petty, and sanctimonious person with no special powers that others don't have, but in a position of power, there's people in history that were like them and people you've probably encountered that are like them, they're very real villains
Good job on stealing this from every other frollo related comment section
1:01:38 Now very tempted to watch Atlantis just because I’m jealous of how stupidly good that line is written and delivered
You should watch it, it's really really good
I watched it this summer with all my siblings, and gosh, I don't know why we waited so long. It's so good, and all the characters are awesome.
Awesome movie, great setting, beautiful visuals, Atlantis rocks
Ratigan is a petty king. I love him. He doesn't get the respect he deserves
Something that I think goes under appreciated (or maybe I just never see any praise for them) are the little clips that accompany every placement. It’s honestly my favorite part of a Schaffrillas ranking video. I live for that little half second where I try to rapidly figure out what movie/character is getting the spot based entirely on that, and the few seconds afterwards when it makes sense is so fun every time.
Same. The Captain Hook segment took me out when I pieced it together 😂
"I promised myself Ta co belle"
@owenaspinall2046 Ytp: Gaston goes on a mission to obtain taco bell
My personal favorite part is the Maurice raving scene.
That’s my favorite parts too
It really shows this guy’s knowledge of media very well in a way I wish I could too
My favorite clip is "because singing killed my wife Tails" from the Direct to DVD ranking
I absolutely love the real, burning, venomous, acerbic hatred for the notion that "man" from Bambi is a villain. Finally SOMEONE said it.
41:51 in the Spanish dub of Mulan, Shang Yu calls Mulan "El Soldado de la montaña", the MALE soldier from the mountains, which makes his disregard for her specific gender even cooler, in a way.
That could just be a translation error or Soldado has a unisex use, of that I am aware soldado is unisex at some degree. (Main lenguage is spanish)
Yeah, in Portuguese they did the same
"O Soldado da Montanha", It's so simple but it always makes my skin crawl. Shan Yu has one of the most chilling Disney villain lines
You hit the nail on the head on why Frollo is ultimately the best disney villain to ever be made. The Hunchback of Notre Dame is my favourite Disney film ever and for years it felt like no one else appreciated it like how I did as a kid. So to see the villain from my favourite film place top in the list genuinely makes me feel overwhelmed with happiness. I generally agree with this list as well, though I'd personally switch a few around.
1:11:21 in the Brazilian version, for some reason that I can't say why, they even changed "you are more evil than you and me" for "out of disgust he killed his parents". I mean, as if drowning orphans and widows wasn't enough, they added familicide to Ratigan's list of crimes just because
EDIT: OKAY, HEAR ME OUT, I took another look at both versions that after the part "Worse than the widows and orphans you drowned?" they changed the phrase
“You are the best of the worst” to “Whoever was left, you strangled”....
Like, what kind of conspiracy happened here that decided to turn Ratigan into Disney's cruelest villain, before Frollo? It's because he's a evil gay? I think that it's because he's a evil gay
The italian version instead implies he was the one who built the big ben, somehow?
Instead of the song beginning with "From the mind that brought you the Big Ben caper", he just goes "From the mind that *created* the Big Ben"
….hUHHHH?! Why did they actively rewrite certain lines to make him worse?!?! I kinda love that xP