Lament for Boromir - Clamavi De Profundis

Поделиться
HTML-код
  • Опубликовано: 10 июл 2024
  • We are now on Patreon! Please check out our page! We are very grateful for your support!
    / clamavideprofundis
    Here is our verison of the Lament for Boromir! We hope you enjoy it:)
    We are unable to get permission to sell this song so we are posting it here free for your enjoyment. If you want a copy of the mp3, we are offering it to those who support us on Patreon!
    Due to having a broad range of voices, each of us was able to play a "character" so to speak in the song, giving it our own unique touch.
    My brother composed and arranged the piece. My family sang it.
    We are also now on Twitter:
    / clamavide
    Lyrics:
    The Lament for Boromir was a song sung by Aragorn and Legolas as the funeral-boat of Boromir drifted away:
    Aragorn sang:
    Through Rohan over fen and field where the long grass grows
    The West Wind comes walking, and about the walls it goes.
    ‘What news from the West, O wandering wind, do you bring to me tonight?
    Have you seen Boromir the Tall by moon or by starlight?
    ‘I saw him ride over seven streams, over waters wide and grey,
    I saw him walk in empty lands until he passed away
    Into the shadows of the North, I saw him then no more.
    The North Wind may have heard the horn of the son of Denethor,
    ‘O Boromir! From the high walls westward I looked afar,
    But you came not from the empty lands where no men are.’
    Then Legolas sang:
    From the mouths of the Sea the South Wind flies, from the sandhills and the stones,
    The wailing of the gulls it bears, and at the gate it moans.
    ‘What news from the South, O sighing wind, do you bring to me at eve?
    Where now is Boromir the Fair? He tarries and I grieve.
    ‘Ask not of me where he doth dwell - so many bones there lie,
    On the white shores and the dark shores under the stormy sky,
    So many have passed down Anduin to find the flowing Sea.
    Ask of the North Wind news of them the North Wind sends to me!’
    ‘O Boromir! Beyond the gate the seaward road runs south,
    But you came not with the wailing gulls from the grey sea’s mouth’.
    Then Aragorn sang again:
    From the Gate of the Kings the North Wind rides, and past the roaring falls,
    And clear and cold about the tower its loud horn calls.
    ‘What news from the North, O mighty wind, do you bring to me today?
    What news of Boromir the bold? For he is long away.’
    ‘Beneath Amon Hen I heard his cry. There many foes he fought,
    His cloven shield, his broken sword, they to the water brought.
    His head so proud, his face so fair, his limbs they laid to rest,
    And Rauros, golden Rauros-falls, bore him upon its breast.
    ‘O Boromir! The Tower of Guard shall ever northward gaze,
    To Rauros, golden Rauros-falls, until the end of days.
    Gimli then comments that they left the east wind to him, but he would not sing it. Aragorn responds that the people of Gondor endure the east wind but do not ask it for tidings, because in that direction lies Mordor and the Evil in the East.
  • ВидеоклипыВидеоклипы

Комментарии • 1,8 тыс.

  • @ClamaviDeProfundis
    @ClamaviDeProfundis  6 лет назад +617

    Check out the posts on our Patreon page for a free download of the sheet music to our version of the "Song of Durin!" goo.gl/2sSw1u

    • @kyleduncan2373
      @kyleduncan2373 6 лет назад +5

      I know this sounds like an odd question. I am a big fan of your work! I also play a game called Lord of the Rings Online. In it you can play music in character. I would love to be able to play your song in gane. That being said I would really like to know what notes/pitch you use for the voices in the song. I have been trying to match it by ear but it isn't the easiest thing to do. Again, I really appreciate your work and look forward to hearing more in the future!

    • @TheWolfElder
      @TheWolfElder 6 лет назад +3

      Clamavi De Profundis If I ever get the chance, I want to sing with you all once. You are all very talented.

    • @hackfail7660
      @hackfail7660 5 лет назад

      Clamavi De Profundis sub español? Pls 🙏

    • @user-pn1en7cd1l
      @user-pn1en7cd1l 5 лет назад

      А есть перевод?)

    • @musicfuel5419
      @musicfuel5419 5 лет назад +2

      In the description, you typed "verison" instead of "version".

  • @TheMonkeygoneape
    @TheMonkeygoneape 4 года назад +2436

    most bro move of Aragorn in the books, doesn't expose Boromir's fall to the corruption to the ring so he may be remembered with honor

    • @guyincognito7188
      @guyincognito7188 3 года назад +475

      As he should, because whilst Boromir fell, momentarily, he also redeemed himself.

    • @craemac
      @craemac 3 года назад +301

      Aragorn understood the power and evil of the Ring. And as Guy Incognito points out, Boromir redeemed himself in the saving of Merry and Pippen....

    • @TheTriforceofRubiks
      @TheTriforceofRubiks 2 года назад +146

      It really does show the respect he had for Boromir. I'm glad they visualized it in the films by him donning his vambraces

    • @sapherno11
      @sapherno11 2 года назад +89

      I believe in the books it also was said that Aragorn going did not speak of that for many years because he wanted to protect boromir

    • @TheGreatDearLeaderJimPickens
      @TheGreatDearLeaderJimPickens 2 года назад +46

      @@sapherno11 I think you're right, though I think it specifically says he never revealed Boromir's fall to anyone

  • @marshallcoleman4406
    @marshallcoleman4406 2 года назад +1583

    A lot of people mock Boromir, in the movies especially, but those people project themselves as perfect and incorruptible. Boromir is the only human to me in the fellowship, as Aragorn spent most his extended life with elves and the Dunedain rangers. Boromir has fought on the front lines his whole life, thrust into a leadership role that wasn’t destined for him. You see his love for his country and people, and it’s painful to see his great strength and heart fail.

    • @Poopenheiner
      @Poopenheiner 2 года назад +114

      I totally agree. That’s why I’m almost moved to tears when I see him tear through the forest to get to the hobbits when the orcs attack. He has to fail because that’s the only way he can be redeemed. And he does redeem himself and in the end he’s better than he was before he fell. That’s what makes it so beautiful to me. That’s where his true strength and heart shows itself. His ability to get back up is so inspiring.

    • @damianrehbein3992
      @damianrehbein3992 2 года назад +50

      He is Humanity in person.
      Brave, strong, beliving he does good and meaning so but filled with Hybris.

    • @sangralknight3031
      @sangralknight3031 2 года назад +38

      @@Poopenheiner
      Humanity, and men in particuler, cannot rise above themselves with out the humiliation of falling, failing, and defeat. The bitterness of being crushed is when we discover if we are clay that shatters, or gold refined.

    • @player-fp9tz
      @player-fp9tz 2 года назад +7

      Beautifully said. Great song around a campfire

    • @Poopenheiner
      @Poopenheiner 2 года назад +14

      @@sangralknight3031 Well Said. That kinda goes with something my English teacher always said, that humanity is doomed to fail. We always will. It’s only in falling that we can get back up.

  • @janhammekenbuch142
    @janhammekenbuch142 4 года назад +557

    "They found him lying atop a small mound of fallen foes, pierced by the dark arrows of the Uruk-Hai Lurtz. The broken bodies of the dead Uruk-Hai, strewn in a winding path for more than one hundred paces, showing his route through the forest. A grim testament to his skill and dedication as a warrior.

    • @SAMUEL-bb2ig
      @SAMUEL-bb2ig 2 года назад +8

      Lurtz wasn’t in the books only movies

    • @JanHBuch
      @JanHBuch 2 года назад +12

      @@SAMUEL-bb2ig i’m not quoting the books, just trying to make a description of the scene, with a little flourish.

    • @SAMUEL-bb2ig
      @SAMUEL-bb2ig 2 года назад +6

      @@JanHBuch yeah no problem

  • @Lunarice98
    @Lunarice98 4 года назад +793

    Boromir went to the council of Elrond in search of hope for his people, and although it was not the hope he thought and he did not deliver it himself he made sure to send hope to Gondor

    • @brookerichard6260
      @brookerichard6260 4 года назад +30

      And helped his little brother find peace.

    • @henrypaleveda7760
      @henrypaleveda7760 3 года назад +22

      the hope of peoples and kings, a sullen man named strider

    • @ryanyuen8245
      @ryanyuen8245 3 года назад +39

      Amazing reference - Boromir strengthened the will of Aragorn to lead Gondor as a returning King. Aragorn's alias before coming to age was Estel which meant "hope" in Elvish.

    • @glishev
      @glishev 3 года назад +14

      He sent Estel, the Hope.

    • @Beregond1861
      @Beregond1861 3 года назад +8

      Many things my captain's did, and I have faith they knew just how terrible the evil eas which they went against. Their reaction to this evil in the end was what truly made them who they were.

  • @themanemperorofmankind5207
    @themanemperorofmankind5207 7 лет назад +3393

    ‘You left the East Wind to me,’ said Gimli, ‘but I will say naught of it.’
    ‘That is as it should be,’ said Aragorn. ‘In Minas Tirith they endure the East Wind, but they do not ask it for tidings.'

    • @mattaffenit9898
      @mattaffenit9898 6 лет назад +173

      The Motherfucking Emperor of Motherfucking Mankind
      Aye.
      This should've been in the movies.
      Songs created Tolkien's world, and they play a huge role within it.
      *_FOR RUSS AND THE ALLFATHER!!!!!!_*
      - Varagyn Agnarr "the Bastard" Salventius of Harald Deathwolf's Deathwolves

    • @MushVPeets
      @MushVPeets 6 лет назад +877

      O'er the Dark Lord's lands the East Wind roars, though Gondor heeds it not,
      Its voice is iron, its mouth is flame, its odors reek and rot.
      'What tidings of the East, O deathly wind, do you bring me from the Dark?
      Gondor asks after Boromir, but to you I alone shall hark.
      'Has Mordor taken this strong man, for the Dark Lord to have his way,
      Where shadows lie upon the land, and night has vanquished day?
      Nay, for he refused 'till his end came, though the Night will soon take all,
      By the hordes of the Orcs this fool was slain, for he heeds not Mairon's call.'
      O Boromir! Behind the Black Gate, armies muster great and strong,
      But still you would fight 'neath the banners of Light 'till the final rays are gone.’

    • @1Korlash
      @1Korlash 6 лет назад +76

      Mush V. Peets By Eru, it is beautiful.

    • @TrueMaskGames
      @TrueMaskGames 6 лет назад +70

      Wow. Did you write this yourself? Really well done!

    • @MushVPeets
      @MushVPeets 6 лет назад +74

      Yes

  • @Indoor_Carrot
    @Indoor_Carrot 5 лет назад +3269

    To think, Tolekin's first deployment in the First World War was in the Somme. We could have lost a genius artist back then. I am forever thankful for his survival and encouragement to write such beauty.

    • @gabrielclausse2121
      @gabrielclausse2121 5 лет назад +457

      We lost probably a lot of goods artists in the first and second war...

    • @hellothere9407
      @hellothere9407 5 лет назад +463

      @@gabrielclausse2121Heard there was some Austrian painter that killed himself near the end of it all

    • @gabrielclausse2121
      @gabrielclausse2121 5 лет назад +71

      @@hellothere9407 you made me laugh so hard 😂

    • @VikingBadass94
      @VikingBadass94 5 лет назад +23

      @@hellothere9407 Classic. XD

    • @sholkvenkat1616
      @sholkvenkat1616 5 лет назад +16

      @@gabrielclausse2121 just got it

  • @StratPulse
    @StratPulse 7 лет назад +4421

    It is said that just one arrow is enough to kill the most powerful man, he was pierced by three

    • @dallindunn1186
      @dallindunn1186 7 лет назад +287

      In the 70s he was pierced by 7-9

    • @joshuamillins5389
      @joshuamillins5389 7 лет назад +361

      StratPulse such is the might of the mighty men of gondor that they stand defiant even when all hope is lost and only life will break under such strain

    • @marekslazak1003
      @marekslazak1003 7 лет назад +130

      in the 2030s he will have to be pierced by 20 to die, you know the cinema of this days :)

    • @dallindunn1186
      @dallindunn1186 7 лет назад +167

      only to come back in next one
      oh wait that's Gandalf

    • @Muffins121000
      @Muffins121000 7 лет назад +151

      It is said we was pierced by many, very true. But his enemies spoke of him highly, one of them said the mighty warrior is now dead. Or whatever, can't truly remember.. ;o

  • @sapherno11
    @sapherno11 5 лет назад +611

    Thus did Boromir fall.
    Captain of Gondor, Loyal son of a failing city, heir of a crumbling Kingdom.
    Yet Boromir's heart was strong, as was his love for Gondor, for he was a True Son.
    Sent on a hopeless quest, lead by an ancient leader to destroy the enemies ancient weapon.
    Met by a Witch with a piercing eye, which laid bare his heart.
    Fear. Despair. A hopeless dread that none could stand against the Shadow.
    Yet a Mighty heart had Boromir, Son of the White Tower.
    A mighty heart could not protect him from the Enemy's Power.
    The Ring...Turned his Love of Gondor....to Madness.
    To redeem that madness, he fought with shield and sword to protect the Little Ones.
    Foe he struck down, again and again.
    Yet no sword could save him from the black arrows, nor could his cloven shield.
    And so did Boromir the Fair journey across the sea to join his Kin.
    "Be at peace...Son of Gondor"

  • @Catasros
    @Catasros 4 года назад +239

    I'm highly impressed by how Aragon and Legolas apparently ad-libbed this entire song. Must be an elf-thing.

    • @jonathanbradley4896
      @jonathanbradley4896 3 года назад +48

      Maybe they knew Boromir was gonna die and had been writing it for weeks. Lol

    • @sabretoothstudios9142
      @sabretoothstudios9142 3 года назад +20

      I went to a performance once where some actors would draw random ideas from a hat written by the audience and then immediately improv a song from them, but I’m pretty sure they at least already knew all the notes. I have no idea if it’s possible to just pull a whole song out of the air though

    • @11Survivor
      @11Survivor 2 года назад +4

      @@sabretoothstudios9142 probably not realistic, but it's a fantasy world so who gives a F? Amirite?

    • @sapherno11
      @sapherno11 2 года назад +67

      It 100% was an elvish thing. If you look at the books elves sing constantly. Even the elvish language is very musical. And actually the old elves would wield their power in terms of song. That is how tinuviel put morgoth to sleep. With a song. That is how finrod dueled against sauron, with songs of power.
      Again singing is very much so an Elven thing.

    • @anthonyhayes1267
      @anthonyhayes1267 2 года назад +19

      I'm imagining Boromir coming back from getting firewood and walking in on them rehearsing.

  • @ottovonbismarck7646
    @ottovonbismarck7646 6 лет назад +119

    One does not simply forget Boromir...

  • @Bradgilliswhammyman
    @Bradgilliswhammyman 6 лет назад +358

    These are poems in the book, but your choral group has really turned them into beautiful songs.

    • @dfed324
      @dfed324 3 года назад +29

      Poems yes, but I want to say that the poems Tolkien made were typically meant to double as lyrics for songs and people to sing them as music is everywhere in the legendarium.

  • @dimonwhite02
    @dimonwhite02 4 года назад +455

    The reason I loved Boromir, was because he was a mortal, a man, with no superpowers just like us.

    • @williamconnors2418
      @williamconnors2418 3 года назад +2

      Well said my friend!

    • @theshadow7937
      @theshadow7937 3 года назад +4

      i don't know about you chief, but most mortal men don't have superpowers

    • @kazikmajster5650
      @kazikmajster5650 3 года назад +1

      And yet, he was powerful.

    • @mucurovic4665
      @mucurovic4665 3 года назад +46

      @@theshadow7937 Aragorn was a Numenorean thus had better physical prowess,more years to live by thus more experience and better mental prowess.Legolas was an elf,an undying race with eternal grace and like-Numenorean physical prowess.Gimli was a dwarf with increased lifespan and stronger physicall prowess then a normal human.Gandalf was an angel.Merry,Pippin,Sam and Frodo had all inner resistance to corruption.Boromir was literally the only one in the fellowship without a heavenly gift.

    • @theshadow7937
      @theshadow7937 3 года назад +1

      @@mucurovic4665 do you know what a joke is good person?, i know what they said, i also know that boromir was just a mortal man.

  • @dakotabaker628
    @dakotabaker628 7 лет назад +103

    "Ask not of me where doth he dwell, So many bones there lie" I just love this line . . . so chilling . . . 3:51

  • @wwmandalore
    @wwmandalore 3 года назад +154

    I always picture the soldiers of Gondor singing this after hearing of the fate of their beloved captain.

    • @Zazou_96
      @Zazou_96 Год назад +4

      "O Boromir from the high walls" they would chant

    • @Giles29
      @Giles29 6 месяцев назад +1

      The Fellowship actually sings this in the book.

  • @mrthetheooo
    @mrthetheooo 6 лет назад +56

    " I would have followed you, my brother. My captain. My king"

  • @xavisalomobarrios3951
    @xavisalomobarrios3951 7 лет назад +1106

    the west wind is powerful, the southern cunning and the northern ominous. The east wind we endure, and do not ask tidings from it

    • @jackattack9118
      @jackattack9118 5 лет назад

      Xavi Salomó Barrios 👌

    • @juliaharano9548
      @juliaharano9548 5 лет назад +2

      why, what is wrong with the East wind?

    • @Pineapocalypse
      @Pineapocalypse 5 лет назад +113

      @@juliaharano9548 The East wind comes from Mordor and nothing good ever comes from there

    • @juliaharano9548
      @juliaharano9548 5 лет назад +6

      @@Pineapocalypse oh undertood thanks, so sad I enjoy so much the East

    • @HTMR-de8gz
      @HTMR-de8gz 5 лет назад +23

      @@juliaharano9548
      Remember Tolkien was from England
      He wrote this in france.
      Nazi Germany was east of him.

  • @Darquirrin
    @Darquirrin 2 года назад +52

    "You left the East Wind to me," Said Gimli "But I will say naught of it." "That is as it should be," said Aragorn. "In Minas Tirith they endure the East Wind, but they do not ask it for tidings."

  • @chloelouisebotha2563
    @chloelouisebotha2563 6 лет назад +196

    This is incredible, and genuinely made me cry. Boromir's death hits hard every single time, in book and movie, and to hear Legolas and Aragorn's lament for him sung so true to how I always imagined it is breathtaking. May the Son of Denethor and Brother of Faramir forever live on in our hearts...🍃

  • @Sephoris
    @Sephoris 7 лет назад +337

    I really appreciate that this has a different feel to it than the Dwarven songs. One of the big weaknesses of other interpretations of LotR music that I've heard is that the songs are often stylistically very similar, despite the intent that they be from very different sources.

    • @lgodproductions9064
      @lgodproductions9064 2 года назад +14

      That's one of the most interesting things about Tolkien, he had each culture having different poetic rhythms and styles

  • @ClamaviDeProfundis
    @ClamaviDeProfundis  7 лет назад +1414

    Here is our version of the Lament for Boromir. We hope you enjoy it!

    • @numberboxgamer
      @numberboxgamer 7 лет назад +26

      Will this be put on Spotify?
      Also, I just want to say that I absolutely love your adaptations of Tolkien's works. Song of Durin is a song I've listened to nearly daily, and at least weekly, since its release. Please keep up the absolutely amazing work!

    • @numberboxgamer
      @numberboxgamer 7 лет назад +9

      Also tell your brother that his composition skills are impeccable. He would, if he doesn't already, have a fantastic career in composition should he ever try his hand at it.

    • @meleardil
      @meleardil 7 лет назад +20

      Clamavi De Profundis. I enjoyed it immensly. You bring me back to the time, when I was young, and still dreamed about... the first time I read The Lord of the rings. Please upload it to google, so I can buy it.
      Also, I have a humble wish. You made the songs... so you have to have the high resolution, high quality, lossless versions. The ones I bought are compressed CD quality versions. No way to have anything better. I wish to purchase from you the best quality version available. At least Durin's song I would like to have in studio quality. Is it possible to buy that some way?

    • @aenorist2431
      @aenorist2431 7 лет назад +12

      I was waiting for this song for the last weeks.
      Love your song of Durin, my neighbors must hate you, as i enjoy singing along in your chorus.
      You guys are great!

    • @_just.luxa_
      @_just.luxa_ 7 лет назад +5

      Clamavi De Profundis I love this accent in your English! 😍😍

  • @Shadowpack95
    @Shadowpack95 6 лет назад +2660

    Boromir the most realistic character in the entire series

    • @thatchannel195
      @thatchannel195 5 лет назад +309

      Also probably the most relatable

    • @demilung
      @demilung 4 года назад +384

      Indeed. He was a human in the age of heroes.

    • @shawnthompson2303
      @shawnthompson2303 4 года назад +198

      Thorin, Theoden and Boromir are the best

    • @mrhalfwit972
      @mrhalfwit972 4 года назад +43

      Shawn Thompson denethor, Theodred, that Rohan guy I forgot the name of,

    • @dannyjames8894
      @dannyjames8894 4 года назад +27

      @@mrhalfwit972 Eomir

  • @MushVPeets
    @MushVPeets 6 лет назад +1157

    O'er the Ephel Duath the East Wind roars, though Gondor heeds it not,
    Its voice is iron, its mouth is flame, its odors reek and rot.
    'What tidings of the East, O deathly wind, do you bring me from the Dark?
    Gondor asks after Boromir, but to you I alone shall hark.
    'Has Mordor taken this strong man, for the Dark Lord to have his way,
    Where shadows lie upon the land, and night has vanquished day?
    Nay, for he refused 'till his end came, though the Night will soon take all,
    By the hordes of the Orcs this fool was slain, for he heeds not Mairon's call.'
    O Boromir! Behind the Black Gate, armies muster great and strong,
    But still you would fight 'neath the banners of Light 'till the final rays are gone.’

  • @JediJoe-ml5kn
    @JediJoe-ml5kn 7 лет назад +2956

    Rest in peace Boromir. May your meme live on for all eternity...

    • @rainbowcharcoal4315
      @rainbowcharcoal4315 7 лет назад +342

      One does not simply forget the meme.

    • @JediJoe-ml5kn
      @JediJoe-ml5kn 7 лет назад +183

      One does not simply take this scene seriously anymore

    • @anthoniesantic4325
      @anthoniesantic4325 7 лет назад +146

      JediJoe2001 one will not simply let Sean Bean survive

    • @judithmarie6571
      @judithmarie6571 7 лет назад +68

      He does like to die in every possible movie/show ^^

    • @Uryel99
      @Uryel99 7 лет назад +33

      Did he not survive in The Martian ?

  • @b3cir490
    @b3cir490 7 лет назад +883

    They have a cave troll
    -Boromir

  • @severalcakes3267
    @severalcakes3267 2 года назад +36

    It’s fitting that the voice of the North, the spirit of Arnor, for now thought long past, provides the final lament for the passing of such a noble soul.

  • @Bpwr06
    @Bpwr06 5 лет назад +302

    Me: Singing along, happy with having a deeper voice.
    NW: "Beneath Amon Hen.."
    Me: What??!

    • @anabube
      @anabube 4 года назад +7

      hahah you made me laugh

    • @marlene144
      @marlene144 4 года назад +20

      And then I like to sing the songs and notice I have a higher voice, because I m a female, ahahah :(

    • @stormblade3408
      @stormblade3408 4 года назад +11

      My voice can turn into a really deep bass so I can pull off those parts perfectly but in exchange I have to deepen a bunch of the higher parts to keep them in my range. Win some, lose some

    • @hyperionwarship8170
      @hyperionwarship8170 3 года назад +8

      @@stormblade3408 same, sadly. I can sing deep, but anything higher than maybe half an octive above my normal voice is near impossible

    • @WhiteTiger950
      @WhiteTiger950 3 года назад +5

      Sing it in your octaves. Whichever pitch works for you. There's no harm in that.

  • @wulfthemountaindragon5432
    @wulfthemountaindragon5432 3 года назад +65

    Boromir was the one to say you cannot simply march into Mordor.
    It is my belief, that he could.

  • @theshaydedlotus3128
    @theshaydedlotus3128 5 лет назад +162

    To this day, the Orcs tell stories of Boromir OrcBane.

    • @manishkumardivekar4836
      @manishkumardivekar4836 3 года назад +14

      WELL SAID!!!!!

    • @depressedgwyndolin
      @depressedgwyndolin 3 года назад +15

      You going to make me cry

    • @11Survivor
      @11Survivor 2 года назад +13

      It is said that the Orcbane slew a thousand orcs by only his hand.
      It is said that the Orcbane was pierced by a thousand arrows before he fell.

  • @altair91100
    @altair91100 4 года назад +3740

    God: creates human
    Human: creates Lord of The Rings
    God: *smiles*

    • @mattbernacki9282
      @mattbernacki9282 4 года назад +208

      altair91100 Tolkien was a very devout Catholic, and LotR is full of Catholic themes and imagery, so methinks you are spot on!

    • @unbelievablytrash9458
      @unbelievablytrash9458 4 года назад +108

      @@mattbernacki9282 Also Norse themes. Heavy Norse themes.

    • @saltyprepper5518
      @saltyprepper5518 4 года назад +111

      @@unbelievablytrash9458 Yes. but Tolkien did say he wrote as an exposition of Catholicism, his aim was to show how myth in general is part of the larger truth myth which is Christianity. His words

    • @unbelievablytrash9458
      @unbelievablytrash9458 4 года назад +52

      @@saltyprepper5518 Tolkien also said that he "cordially dislikes allagory" as it was the forceful impression of the author's will and meaning on the reader and preferred readers to draw their own conclusions. As a member of Asatru, I'll take some Norse themes.

    • @Gotterdammerung05
      @Gotterdammerung05 4 года назад +29

      @@unbelievablytrash9458 He literally considered it a part of the real world and Eru as God. There can be Norse themes because Norse culture is simply a more recent part of Middle Earth's history, but his creation story is similar to Genesis for a reason.

  • @trevorx7872
    @trevorx7872 5 лет назад +20

    I like how it says "His cloven shield, his broken sword, they to the water brought." And then it shows a picture of Boromir in the elven-boat with a perfectly intact sword and shield.

  • @MrAppomatox
    @MrAppomatox 4 года назад +37

    The North wind may have heard the horn of the son of Denethor... chills

  • @blackkittyfreak
    @blackkittyfreak 7 лет назад +507

    One does not simply dislike this video!

    • @rogeliomata1503
      @rogeliomata1503 7 лет назад +8

      tearing, and listening and this comment puts a smile in my face, hahaha.

    • @mattaffenit9898
      @mattaffenit9898 6 лет назад

      blackkittyfreak
      (Random Uruk #452)
      Orly?
      *Dislikes*
      Wot naow, beetch?

    • @jonathanakersreed3142
      @jonathanakersreed3142 6 лет назад +7

      As of January 9th, 2018 at 7:36 AM Pacific Time, 196 people just don't know good music when they find it.

    • @northproductions6104
      @northproductions6104 6 лет назад +2

      +Jon Akers And now the dislike number just went up 2 more.

    • @jonathanakersreed3142
      @jonathanakersreed3142 6 лет назад +2

      How can this be?!?!?!

  • @gabrielgonach6330
    @gabrielgonach6330 4 года назад +20

    One of my dogs just died in my arms yesterday, after a long fight trying to survive. I put this song for him...

  • @key2laif
    @key2laif 4 года назад +29

    The mightiest man may be slain with one arrow, but Boromir was pierced by many

  • @jimidle6168
    @jimidle6168 4 года назад +35

    This song is my seccond favorite song of all the LOTR saga right under "Song of Durin". Boromir was accually my favorite character, he's so human. Even though he was taken by greed and coruption from the ring, he's love for the Gondor was so high.

    • @davidsmith8787
      @davidsmith8787 3 года назад +1

      In the end he made the right choice, its not your mistakes that count, but how you die

    • @parinpatel3275
      @parinpatel3275 3 года назад +2

      Actually he wasn't taken by greed and corruption. He was taken by fear and despair. You see Gondor was in war with the orcs for years probably decades. And Boromir was at the centre of it. He has seen first hand what the might of Sauron is. And he believed that none can fight that might. So he saw the ring as weapon that Gondor needed.....

  • @propheccy
    @propheccy 7 лет назад +115

    yesterday night I was walking home on the empty streets having the full moon and stars above me while listening to this - what a great walk that was.

    • @eevs8595
      @eevs8595 7 лет назад +2

      propheccy feel you

    • @Alquano
      @Alquano 4 года назад +2

      Sure trust you, I can only imagine that feeling

  • @VocaloidWangYao
    @VocaloidWangYao 5 лет назад +45

    As I was listening, the skies began raining. Surely, the Earth weeps for Boromir.
    Or something. A bit of coincidence, is all.

  • @stealthgladius
    @stealthgladius 6 лет назад +208

    I hereby move that all future viewings of The Fellowship of the Ring conclude with the viewing of this video. All those in favor?

  • @throrinbassilisk2551
    @throrinbassilisk2551 7 лет назад +96

    Go in peace, son of Gondor. Waiting for your arrival from the White Tower, but will never return.

    • @monkekun3033
      @monkekun3033 5 лет назад +3

      Thrórin hernandez now I'm gonna cry

  • @robinthomasson6630
    @robinthomasson6630 5 лет назад +24

    "-and what's about the east wind?
    -gondor's men dont ask news from the east wind."

  • @geonite2072
    @geonite2072 4 года назад +27

    Boromir may not have been the perfect character, but he was the most human.😢

  • @UNOwenWasMe
    @UNOwenWasMe 7 лет назад +143

    You, the group that are making this music into existence, are a group of genius. You're a gem of this world, more so than you probably realize yourselves

  • @alucard347
    @alucard347 6 лет назад +20

    I remember reading the Lord Of The Rings at the age of 10, and feeling like a punch in the gut when Boromir died.
    And while reading those lines, and imagening the scene, I felt also a weird magic in the air, deep sorrow for the mighty who fallen, yet a mysterious, almost toxicating calmness and joy.
    I had those same feelings now, while listening to that song, and looking a the pictures.

  • @fglo
    @fglo 7 лет назад +83

    I love how you "talk" with each other through this song. It makes it even better (and sadder).

  • @yourfavoriteshiba7645
    @yourfavoriteshiba7645 2 года назад +11

    Boromir was so loved that even the winds themselves sung for him. For even the greatest of heroes have flaws and so we cannot judge them too harshly.

  • @franklin9509
    @franklin9509 5 лет назад +19

    “But now Boromir has taken his road, and we must make haste to choose our own...”

  • @tunch90
    @tunch90 6 лет назад +36

    I would have followed you my brother, my captain, my king

  • @Alquano
    @Alquano 4 года назад +29

    I like the fact, that the characters are just singing to each other and then this singing choir comes in and sounds so epic
    Just a masterpiece!

  • @balintvasvari7573
    @balintvasvari7573 2 года назад +23

    I'm so happy to see the CDP songs becoming so popular over the years, this incredible art really deserves to reach this many people.

  • @doctorarb
    @doctorarb 7 лет назад +28

    I sobbed so hard during my first playthrough of his final battle on LotRO... Namárië, son of Gondor.

  • @epipsychidionozymandias5021
    @epipsychidionozymandias5021 4 года назад +14

    I consider Boromir my favourite character in all the books I read. I'm crying because this is such a perfect adaptation, exactly as it should have been in the book.

  • @esthermg3029
    @esthermg3029 4 года назад +150

    It was only when I reread he books that I realized how much I loved Boromir. He was tempted and fell but then rose again and laid down his life in defense of his friends and companions. The movies didn't do him justice.

    • @ifyouloveChristyouwillobeyhim
      @ifyouloveChristyouwillobeyhim 3 года назад +19

      Same except I think the movies did him justice.

    • @dfed324
      @dfed324 3 года назад +15

      I'm really curious how you came to this conclusion.
      I am just reading the books for my 1st time and recently completed Fellowship. His death is actually the beginning of Two Towers, and we come from Aragorn's perspective who shows up after the orcs have left. Boromir's last stand is then only mentioned briefly.
      The movies, however, show him fighting front and center protecting Merry and Pippin.

    • @anthonyhayes1267
      @anthonyhayes1267 2 года назад +2

      How could one ever die in a more noble fashion than defending the defenseless?

  • @felixgemund7249
    @felixgemund7249 7 лет назад +163

    I wish I could thumb this up more than once, that's how good this is. Especially the North Wind part is just chilling.

  • @ghidorahs1fan209
    @ghidorahs1fan209 4 года назад +26

    Crying I absolutely love this song you guys did it so well.
    As a odd and lonely kid I pretty much lived in middle earth in my mind and rambling the 1st time I read Boromirs death I cryed for days as he reminded me of my father a lot who was in Vietnam and by the time I came along only a security guard but in my mind he was this big strong worrior who battled in a grate battle and now kept the steelworks and mines safe again in my mind the steelworks and mines were like the misty mountains or mordor. It probably didn't help that my dad read me fantasy books ever since I was born the 1st being the hobbit and my earliest memory is walking around with this tattered old hobbit book looking for my dad. Boromir might not have been the smartest or most resilient man when it came to the ring but that's some of the reasons he was more like my farther than any other man in the lotr my father wasn't overly smart but had a lot of street smarts I guess and he had his own demons as Boromir had the ring my farther had his past and a drink.

  • @user-xb3uu8jx2b
    @user-xb3uu8jx2b 7 лет назад +13

    Reading Of Nirnaeth Adroniad in the Silmarillion while listening to this song. At Fingon's death a few tears came out.

  • @Rol-E-Roll-da_real_1
    @Rol-E-Roll-da_real_1 2 года назад +17

    Whole song is great, but when the "North Wind" sings "Rauros... Golden Rauros Falls, bore him upon its breast" just gives me the chills every time

  • @VictorAnsem
    @VictorAnsem 7 лет назад +562

    This channel is pure gold, you deserve at least ten times your subscribers! I have finally seen my favourite parts of The Lord of the Rings and The Hobbit come to life, the parts they neglected in the movies; the parts that made me love that work. Keep it up, huge applause from Italy. That female voice, whoever it belongs to, adds a wonderful touch, it would be a pleasure to hear it lots of times again!!

    • @JusTGiaH
      @JusTGiaH 7 лет назад +5

      Ansemthewise94 ah ma allora non sono l'unico italiano che li ascolta :D

    • @rikillerholyman2927
      @rikillerholyman2927 6 лет назад +3

      Hai perfettamente ragione, ADORO, sono contento che in italia non sono l'unico fan che capisce la bellezza di queste poesie/canzoni

    • @TheBlackFrog79
      @TheBlackFrog79 5 лет назад

      Gli italiani applaudono meglio :)

    • @c.e.m.0325
      @c.e.m.0325 5 лет назад

      La parte che intendi tu è cantata da un ragazzino.

    • @elizabethciaccio636
      @elizabethciaccio636 5 лет назад +1

      @Marysol Alvarez it does indeed belong to a young woman, of 17 years.

  • @janekgaganek3871
    @janekgaganek3871 7 лет назад +826

    As always, you guys are AMAZING
    Tolkien would be proud
    So what now? Song of Beren and Luthien, The fall of Gil-Galad, or maybe something else?

    • @nakenmil
      @nakenmil 7 лет назад +79

      Oooo, the Fall of Gil-Galad is a favorite of mine.

    • @janekgaganek3871
      @janekgaganek3871 7 лет назад +7

      yeah, it is nice, but ther versions that can be currently found on yt, in my opinion, are not meeting the lyrics potential

    • @undertakernumberone1
      @undertakernumberone1 7 лет назад +18

      how about the "King beneath the Mountains" to complete the Dwarven Songs... or "Chip the glasses and crack the plates"

    • @undertakernumberone1
      @undertakernumberone1 7 лет назад +3

      Want me to callGotrek Gurnisson?

    • @MirrorscapeDC
      @MirrorscapeDC 7 лет назад +17

      Yes, Gil-Galad please!

  • @loftus8046
    @loftus8046 7 лет назад +41

    Didn't think much when I first heard this, but now it's really growing on me. Love 5:49 onwards, it just sounds so mellow and beautiful.

    • @zairaner1489
      @zairaner1489 5 лет назад +6

      My thoughts exactly. And I get chills from "rauros golden raus falls"...

  • @thetau4866
    @thetau4866 3 года назад +4

    Boromir the Fair, the Bold, The Tall, felled by nay one, nay two, but three black arrows of Uruk-hai...may your fair Visage be remembered evermore

  • @skyoncloud5180
    @skyoncloud5180 5 лет назад +10

    What is going through the heads of the people who disliked the video? Its beautiful, glorious, and very true to the emotions of the characters.

  • @timpetersen2923
    @timpetersen2923 7 лет назад +31

    "They will look for him from the White Tower, but he will not return from mountain or from sea"
    To those brave soldiers who were deployed, but never returned.

  • @Itssarisado
    @Itssarisado 4 года назад +8

    His head so proud, his face so fair
    His limbs they laid to rest ...💔

  • @HumbleWolves
    @HumbleWolves 7 лет назад +65

    "We endure wind from the east. We do not ask its tidings."

  • @horacehorrible2167
    @horacehorrible2167 7 лет назад +31

    Don't ever stop creating these! You have a true gift! With thanks from Russia

  • @cardinalhamneggs5253
    @cardinalhamneggs5253 Год назад +3

    The melody of the call and that of the Wind’s response harmonize with each other surprisingly well.

  • @thebrandybuck323
    @thebrandybuck323 2 года назад +2

    The first CDP song I ever heard... still gives me shivers and tears EVERY. SINGLE. TIME. And Boromir isn't even my top fave character.

  • @rouental2093
    @rouental2093 4 года назад +7

    Boromir is my favorite member of the fellowship, without a doubt.

  • @joseloreto4284
    @joseloreto4284 3 года назад +5

    “One does not simply remember Boromir without an amazing meme. He’s a warrior leaving you with the impossible before making the journey to your own Mordor.”

  • @keithbassett4730
    @keithbassett4730 3 года назад +2

    I cry like a baby after listening to this

  • @boromirsonofdenethorii.8667
    @boromirsonofdenethorii.8667 5 лет назад +8

    I am still proud of you, my brothers

  • @heartysquid
    @heartysquid 4 года назад +4

    I dont think anyone could have portrayed Boromir on the big screen better than Sean Bean...he brought such a strength to a character that even for the people who watched the movie and were not familiar with the books, they understood his character so well

  • @LordQueezle
    @LordQueezle 5 лет назад +10

    This brings a tear to my eye, and I don't know quite why. I never really liked Boromir in the books or movies if I am being honest. But the more I listen to this, and the more I go back through the Lord of the Rings the more I appreciate Tolkien's subtle intuition into human nature. And indeed, the more I like Boromir.

  • @Melanth89
    @Melanth89 7 лет назад +16

    I feel like my birthday arrives when I see CDP post something!

  • @fatenathan
    @fatenathan 7 лет назад +26

    BOROMIR! the strongest soldier and Friend!

  • @rorschach6295
    @rorschach6295 Год назад +3

    Sorry you very much clamavi I love this song so much that I forgot to hit the like button even though I've been listening to it for more than 2 years

  • @yehudisfriedman8459
    @yehudisfriedman8459 Год назад +3

    I just realized- Aragorn sings the bits about the north wind and the west wind because his ancestors came from the west and his home is in the north

  • @emiliya3103
    @emiliya3103 6 лет назад +2

    "Rauros, golden Rauros falls" - I could listen to that line all day.
    This is so perfectly suited to the books, I've been listening to it non stop all day.

  • @river6634
    @river6634 7 лет назад +92

    You guys are awesome. Thank you for your work. Really immersive music. You can get lost in middle earth with it.

  • @kingaragornii9940
    @kingaragornii9940 5 лет назад +27

    "One does not simply die in vain." - Me

    • @depressedgwyndolin
      @depressedgwyndolin 3 года назад +1

      My lord the armys of the black Temple are yours to command

  • @n.m.dimmick194
    @n.m.dimmick194 7 лет назад +12

    Time to recommend this to every friend I have who has read The Lord of the Rings! Excellent interpretation of this song!

  • @keithadams7619
    @keithadams7619 4 года назад +2

    That first image is so powerful, Uruk-Hai warriors converging from all sides, while Boromir stands alone, blowing the Horn of Gondor as if to say "Come and get me, either you all die, or I do"

  • @gingerbrettman5665
    @gingerbrettman5665 7 лет назад +35

    Woah! I didn't even expect another release so soon. That's awesome!

  • @conorhurley5255
    @conorhurley5255 3 года назад +4

    Beneath Amon Hen I heard his cry. There many foes he fought. His cloven shield, His broken sword, They to the water brought... My favorite verse. Be at peace son of Gondor

  • @WB1813
    @WB1813 7 лет назад +72

    Been waiting for this.

  • @francescogulisano2917
    @francescogulisano2917 7 лет назад +26

    Why can I like it only once?

  • @zhongbill6936
    @zhongbill6936 5 лет назад +6

    The hero or not depends on his choice in front of the greatest justice. Boromir, you did it.

  • @sandracarlson7986
    @sandracarlson7986 4 года назад +4

    I have watched this so many times, and I still cry. Sean Bean portrayed Boromir brilliantly. Thank you.

  • @tyrtex5108
    @tyrtex5108 4 года назад +4

    Boldfaced tears were shed this day, in a new year of 2020 just as yesteryear.

  • @PhantomShock421
    @PhantomShock421 4 года назад +11

    Many people who criticize Tolkein's work do so for the black v. white nature of it. Good versus evil, nothing in between. To those critics I say one word: "Boromir." Very much a character firmly fixed in the gray area of Tolkein's world, and I love him for that.

  • @ussenterprise1394
    @ussenterprise1394 Год назад +3

    Press F to pay respects.

  • @stlurz
    @stlurz 7 лет назад +226

    Boromir, captain of Gondor.

    • @Gil-galad12
      @Gil-galad12 7 лет назад +6

      stlurz - Faramir was captain. Boromir was general. In 2 towers Faramir sad: Boromir was our general...

    • @aenorist2431
      @aenorist2431 7 лет назад +6

      Yet he used "Captain" interchangably for all other titles, to he is correct to say that.

    • @Gil-galad12
      @Gil-galad12 7 лет назад +3

      Ae Norist in czech translation is general

    • @aenorist2431
      @aenorist2431 7 лет назад +15

      And thats factually right, but in the english original he uses "captain" as a general honorific for military leaders (of various gondorians).

    • @WorkingClassic
      @WorkingClassic 7 лет назад +9

      yes, like how legolas refers to Prince Imrahil as a great captain of men

  • @zirkalda9502
    @zirkalda9502 4 года назад +3

    Boromir is easily the character I related to the most out of all the Fellowship. He doubts and struggles with himself, wanting to ensure that his people see another day. Despair sets in when it is clear that no might or will of man can avail against the inevitable, so when a chance is given, why should he not take it, so small it may seem? Surely no evil can come of good intentions?
    I've struggled and fallen more times than I can count. I've shamed myself and disappointed those who know I am better. I've bargained with evil, reasoning that the end will bear out the means. And I've learned the folly of my own pride and arrogance. No good deed will wash out the bad, but I can still live each day trying to make amends.
    I can only hope that when I reach the end, I face it like Boromir: honorably.

  • @AjaxNixon
    @AjaxNixon 4 года назад +5

    Boromir reminds us that its the end that matters, not necessarily the falls on the way (though good ends just don't magically happen, he had those virtues trained in him)

  • @r-evanw6591
    @r-evanw6591 5 лет назад +10

    This is the best version of the Lament for boromir, much respect and love to you and you're family for doing these.
    Love to hear yous singing this in person one day in the near future.

  • @MoonlightDawnMoolightDawn
    @MoonlightDawnMoolightDawn 4 года назад +11

    Tears in my eyes every time I hear this! Signed the petition to have your group to do the music for Amazon's series -- good luck, fingers crossed! ❤️

  • @cheesus7672
    @cheesus7672 6 лет назад +12

    What an underrated character :(

  • @jdrapala8478
    @jdrapala8478 7 лет назад +118

    Hitting "like" without even listening because clamavi de profundis

  • @astrotecn
    @astrotecn 4 года назад +4

    the north wind is my favourite part, such a powerful voice