I like to think the only times Galbatorix ever lost his composure (aside from when the final battle at the end of Inheritance swung out of his control) was when Murtagh let Eragon go free after he defeated him at the Battle of the Burning plains, circumventing Galbatorix's magic that forced obedience, and whenever Galbatorix got updates on Roran. Roran had no magic and no dragon. He was just one guy. And yet he fought off the Ra'zac, motivated a small village to fend off an entire company of soldiers, traversed the Spine when Galbatorix's own army couldn't, lit the entire Teirm docks on fire, helped a known spy of the Varden go into hiding, added about 200 new recruits to the Varden, killed close to 200 men on his own in a single battle and conquered a city with a garrison of thousands with only 800 men. Like seriously, Galbatorix may have been angry at Murtagh after Eldest but he at least understood how Murtagh had tricked him. But every time Galbatorix heard about Roran he must have been thinking "What hacks has this man downloaded and where the hell do I get them because this is some BS."
Dont worry disney and amazon are in a race to see who can make the wokest garbage entertainment on tv so im sure disney will knock it out of the park with eragon, then we will be talking about how good the movie really was.
To be fair. I love what disney did with the star wars TV shows they released. The Star Wars sequels OK not so much. The TV shows they make though are pretty good from what I wat he'd so far.
Eragon going woke would be the final nail in the coffin for Disney in my books. I'm hoping eragon is done faithfully in regards to the books. If disney messes it up though and makes it woke. I will go out of my way to make sure disney does get a cent from my pocket and I will try my best to make sure none of my family do either
I don't see how this could be a good idea since they will never find another young actor as talented or beautiful as Ed Speleers. The writing may have ruined the film back then, which is a shame, but actors are everything and I feel like it would just be empty without a great central character to drive the story.
I’m such a fan of Eragon and the all the books , I’m excited about them making a show , but I’m also worried , if they can focus on the story and keep all the politics and propaganda out of the show , it could turn out ok , but if they choose to focus only on inclusion instead of the story , which Disney totally does , it will turn out like all the other stuff and be a failure ! Please don’t ruin it for me , keep the politics for politicians , leave entertainment alone , people want to enjoy the fantasy , not live in the bullshit we are dealing with everyday in our country !
YES!!!! If I wanted politics, I’d just watch the news! I just finished the first book of the series, and I want a series 100% true to the book! Legitimate Urgals, Durza, etc!!
I'd love to see a better portrayal of the magic system. The movie got the basics down but missed a lot of the finer details, like tasks done with magic taking just as much energy as it would if you did it by conventional means and the importance of magically protecting your mind from invasion.
I want a good adaptation and I simply do not think for one second that Disney is the company that can give it to us. Amazon or HBO maybe. MAYBE. But Amazon's track record for adaptations is shaky and HBO already has a dragon show that will keep them occupied for at least another decade. Honestly I'd prefer no adaptation over another bad one. And no, Netflix is not the answer. We've seen what they did with the Witcher. They are not even allowed in this conversation.
I was beyond excited when I read it was getting a show ....then heartbroken when I read it would be from Disney....Now Eragon is going to be cast as a black lesbian female 😒
Now that I’ve read the Murtagh book, I really want to see that adapted into a movie. But since it’s a follow-up, the full Inheritance cycle would probably have to be brought on screen first for that to happen.
I honestly never lost the love for this series. Paolinis world of Alagaesia truly is one of the most amazing fantasy worlds out there. When the movie came out I left the cinema in shock, seeing Arya with the wrong haircolor, Brom entirely different from how he was described and those Ra'zac truly were aweful. Where did the beaks go? Also Urgals that have been perfectly described by the time the movie came up, so anyone would know in detail what exactly those look like. Not to mention the battle of Tronjheim being out in the open.... What idiot would change this amazing location? Breaking the entire thing. Without all those mistakes it would have been a success no doubt and we could have seen all the books adapted into movies by now. Please do the remake and finally get the shame off of this amazing series. I will watch it the moment it airs. But stick to the descriptions this time. Can't be so hard to find actors who actually match the correct haircolor or give them some fake hair. What would get me really angry however, would be an ultra woke adaptation, hope Paolini wont let that happen. I truly dont want to see a black transgender Eragon falling in love with a nonbinary Arya and pledging allegiance to "ens Nasuadens", befriending Orik and Hrothgar not being dwarves. Remember even their actual size is described, stick to it or at least make them significantly smaller than humans and elves, thats the whole purpose. Just like Urgals stand way taller than both. And do not change locations of the end battle, how could Saphira mend Isidar Mithrin if the star sapphire was never broken???? That's an essential piece of the plot.
First the movie was ok not the awesome movie of the year but the dragon models and actors were in the right place but should have put work in directing and script.
It's was... very average, when the books are EPIC. Love the model of the dragons and... some if the actors. Costumes. Mostly hated and content that was adapted from book to movie 10%. Rest its all crap in the movie.
In order for it to be good they would need a budget like Game of Thrones 😅 it would have to be on that level in order to be successful. That's what I believe. But my hopes are up
It's off the table.. Disney is under pressure to get away from endless reboots and remakes. No one even got attached to it so at least no careers got ended..
I don't trust Disney with this given their track record of late, but IF they learned from their mistakes(BIG IF) and they do this one right, then I will be more optimistic for when they do the Prydain Chronicles which is very dear to me. In the movie, the Urgals were hornless, elves didn't have tipped ears, the mountains weren't staggeringly high as Paolini described in an interview(10 miles high), Saphira just magically ages into full maturity by flying up into the sky. That's really to say the least, but I mean if Disney avoids those and pays very good attention to detail, they've at least started in a right direction. I guess the best hope will be how much direction they take from Paolini exec producing.
Honestly, idgaf about a reboot. What I'd like is a game set in the time before the fall of the dragonriders. It could be singleplayer, co-op, or even MMO, where players get to create their own dragonriders and dragons. Cuz lets face it, the books are a boring rehash of a rehash of another story. To give it to Disneys mediocre show writers isn't going to help it in the slightest.
I actually think it could work better as a series for the simple reason that the writers would have more time to flesh things out. And from what I hear Chris Paolini is actually heavily involved this time so there's at least a chance that this could make up for the movie. The Percy Jackson series, while certainly not without its deviations, has been pretty good so far in my opinion, so there's a chance for Eragon, especially if they stick to one book per season.
You said young boy. It starts about a half year before he comes of age. So probably best young man or adolescent. Young boy I think of someone who isn't even a teen.
Not sure if id rather it be disney or netflix, i guess atleast with disney atleast eragon might still be straight and atleast look like the original character. Hopefully Paolini actually gets to be involved this time and disney doesnt just shut him out and ruin his ideas like fox.
Nooooooooooooooooooooooo .. Someone please put a jihad on Disney, they are destroying everything they touch!! No way this will be good, ffs I love the books.
I swear, I SWEAR, if they make ONE PERSON GAY in the Eragon tv show, I WILL SCREAM AND THROW MY REMOTE IN THE TRASH. You complained about not having enough gay representation, now you have too much of it and not enough straight representation! If Paolini lets it stand that Disney will make it gay and incorrect, I have lost all my faith in humanity. My thing also is, people complained about Grover being black in the Percy Jackson movie, and they also complained about Annabeth having brown hair, but why is it NOT a problem now to have an Indian Grover and a black Annabeth??? The ONLY person they got right was Percy! They made every other character a race other than white by what I understand, and it drives me NUTS. There are PLENTY of roles for black/racial minority groups out there, but NOT in Percy Jackson!! And Rick Riordan BACKS this???? What sort of GARBAGE is Disney making nowadays???
Lol fully and strongly agree and because there is no gay characters in the books. If you want gay characters write your own book. Leave Eragon as it is. Don't ruin the memory I have of it please.
Well as far as i can remember there werent any gay couples in eragon, but if they have to which there are rules to follow there will be representation in everything that shows up on the screen. So its very possible that there will be gay couples or characters that are gay in Disneys version of eragon. However i do hope that they create a new character for that reason instead of re writing an already existing character just to have someone represent a minority.
you seem really homophobic and racist. as long as it doesn’t alter the story, i don’t see the issue. it would be different if a character was obviously asian and they made them black or white or latino. but nothing says an elf can’t be any of those people or colors. as for romantic relationships, it would be bad if they made eragon gay but if there’s a side character that isn’t specified and they use them for representation then again, that’s not an issue.
@@imjustdoingmybest6236 okok listen. Annabeth is white. Did you even read the books? It's not racist for me to defend my own race, is it? If we made Tiana white that would be considered extremely racist and riots would most likely happen, same thing if we made a gay character straight. You can't deny that would upset some people, and the show or movie would most likely get canceled. I'm not saying black or other colored people can't act, that would be racist. I'm not saying gay people can't act, that would be hateful towards gay people. Just make different characters for skin colors and whether they're gay or not. Don't hijack a character and twist it around to make it fit the ideals of what people want. They did that for a historical character because apparently white people can't act now and the only actors available are colored people. How would you feel if you wrote something like Snow White and made Snow White a white person and then years later someone's like "no, she's actually Latino" when you wrote her to be white? I'd be pretty ticked off. See what I mean?
I just finished the last book. I had a big break after reading the first one years ago. I don't like the idea that Disney is even thining about it. They will make it worse, will put too many black actors into leads.
![Sean Rii, Karyon, Sharzkii - Taungule [My Love] (Official Music Video)](http://i.ytimg.com/vi/eJoMuypbSzQ/mqdefault.jpg)
Hopefully the Urgals look like Urgals this time
hopefully they get at least 1 detail right
I'm not sure if it's possible to make it even worse, but I have a feeling that Disney would be able to achieve that.
Hahah, hopefully they get it right this go around! 😅
Oh it can be made worse. Much worse
I m keeping my fingers cross for this one cause I waited over a decade for a remake of this.
@@fantasyworld8993 Especially with Christopher helping
In this case, I refuse to be pessimistic.
I think Paolini should make the casting decisions !
Disney desecrated Eragon… I don’t even want to know what they’d do to Murtagh
Please make it an animation/anime series. It is truly the only way to achieve all the wild characteristics of the Eragon universe
If they made it an animation, then Ed Speleers could voice Eragon.
I like to think the only times Galbatorix ever lost his composure (aside from when the final battle at the end of Inheritance swung out of his control) was when Murtagh let Eragon go free after he defeated him at the Battle of the Burning plains, circumventing Galbatorix's magic that forced obedience, and whenever Galbatorix got updates on Roran. Roran had no magic and no dragon. He was just one guy. And yet he fought off the Ra'zac, motivated a small village to fend off an entire company of soldiers, traversed the Spine when Galbatorix's own army couldn't, lit the entire Teirm docks on fire, helped a known spy of the Varden go into hiding, added about 200 new recruits to the Varden, killed close to 200 men on his own in a single battle and conquered a city with a garrison of thousands with only 800 men.
Like seriously, Galbatorix may have been angry at Murtagh after Eldest but he at least understood how Murtagh had tricked him. But every time Galbatorix heard about Roran he must have been thinking "What hacks has this man downloaded and where the hell do I get them because this is some BS."
193 soldiers
Yeah rorans by far my favourite character. Like how he just made a literal mountain of dead enemies
Rorans hill is such a cool scene in the books
Their are a few powerful female characters in the book and I already know Disney is going to make the entire show a yasss queen convention
Dont worry disney and amazon are in a race to see who can make the wokest garbage entertainment on tv so im sure disney will knock it out of the park with eragon, then we will be talking about how good the movie really was.
Hahaha 🤣, point taken
To be fair. I love what disney did with the star wars TV shows they released. The Star Wars sequels OK not so much. The TV shows they make though are pretty good from what I wat he'd so far.
Eragon going woke would be the final nail in the coffin for Disney in my books. I'm hoping eragon is done faithfully in regards to the books. If disney messes it up though and makes it woke. I will go out of my way to make sure disney does get a cent from my pocket and I will try my best to make sure none of my family do either
The movie was great! What more people want?
Could not agree more.
I don't see how this could be a good idea since they will never find another young actor as talented or beautiful as Ed Speleers. The writing may have ruined the film back then, which is a shame, but actors are everything and I feel like it would just be empty without a great central character to drive the story.
I'm a huge fan of this series, I even have all the novels hope it really comes to reality
They did Roran dirty in the movie hopefully they make up for it here he was such a hard ass 😂
Agreed
If they do this they gotta bring Jeremy Irons back as Brom he did an amazing job of being the wise old mentor.
What about the bald galbatorix bro HAHAHAHAHA
@@killards2085 I'm not so sure about they'll probably find someone else to play Galbatorix.
All new cast, please
I’m such a fan of Eragon and the all the books , I’m excited about them making a show , but I’m also worried , if they can focus on the story and keep all the politics and propaganda out of the show , it could turn out ok , but if they choose to focus only on inclusion instead of the story , which Disney totally does , it will turn out like all the other stuff and be a failure ! Please don’t ruin it for me , keep the politics for politicians , leave entertainment alone , people want to enjoy the fantasy , not live in the bullshit we are dealing with everyday in our country !
YES!!!! If I wanted politics, I’d just watch the news! I just finished the first book of the series, and I want a series 100% true to the book! Legitimate Urgals, Durza, etc!!
@@MichaelCreech97 wait till you read eldest ! It’s my favorite one !
I'd love to see a better portrayal of the magic system. The movie got the basics down but missed a lot of the finer details, like tasks done with magic taking just as much energy as it would if you did it by conventional means and the importance of magically protecting your mind from invasion.
I want a good adaptation and I simply do not think for one second that Disney is the company that can give it to us. Amazon or HBO maybe. MAYBE. But Amazon's track record for adaptations is shaky and HBO already has a dragon show that will keep them occupied for at least another decade. Honestly I'd prefer no adaptation over another bad one. And no, Netflix is not the answer. We've seen what they did with the Witcher. They are not even allowed in this conversation.
I was beyond excited when I read it was getting a show ....then heartbroken when I read it would be from Disney....Now Eragon is going to be cast as a black lesbian female 😒
I also don't trust Netflix to make it a clean movie. But, I think that maybe DreamWorks or Warner Bros. could make it a good movie
@@bradleyhendricks8606wait, seriously? Disney is not thinking about anything here
Now that I’ve read the Murtagh book, I really want to see that adapted into a movie. But since it’s a follow-up, the full Inheritance cycle would probably have to be brought on screen first for that to happen.
I honestly never lost the love for this series. Paolinis world of Alagaesia truly is one of the most amazing fantasy worlds out there. When the movie came out I left the cinema in shock, seeing Arya with the wrong haircolor, Brom entirely different from how he was described and those Ra'zac truly were aweful. Where did the beaks go? Also Urgals that have been perfectly described by the time the movie came up, so anyone would know in detail what exactly those look like. Not to mention the battle of Tronjheim being out in the open.... What idiot would change this amazing location? Breaking the entire thing. Without all those mistakes it would have been a success no doubt and we could have seen all the books adapted into movies by now.
Please do the remake and finally get the shame off of this amazing series. I will watch it the moment it airs. But stick to the descriptions this time. Can't be so hard to find actors who actually match the correct haircolor or give them some fake hair. What would get me really angry however, would be an ultra woke adaptation, hope Paolini wont let that happen. I truly dont want to see a black transgender Eragon falling in love with a nonbinary Arya and pledging allegiance to "ens Nasuadens", befriending Orik and Hrothgar not being dwarves. Remember even their actual size is described, stick to it or at least make them significantly smaller than humans and elves, thats the whole purpose. Just like Urgals stand way taller than both.
And do not change locations of the end battle, how could Saphira mend Isidar Mithrin if the star sapphire was never broken???? That's an essential piece of the plot.
the Eragon movie was almost in the same tier as dragon ball evolution
First the movie was ok not the awesome movie of the year but the dragon models and actors were in the right place but should have put work in directing and script.
Yeah, I thought it was a pretty good movie. Let’s see what they do with the remake!
@@fantasyworld8993 i loved eragon the movie before i see it i read it the first book the other i will read too
It's was... very average, when the books are EPIC. Love the model of the dragons and... some if the actors. Costumes. Mostly hated and content that was adapted from book to movie 10%. Rest its all crap in the movie.
I agree
Eragon original was absolutely amazing, I just know the remake will be a disgrace ....
If you didn't read the books it's actually a good movie 🤷🏽♂️
I'm a little bit disappointed about the film, too. In a first book I've discovered at least 7 elvish spells. In the entire film there were only two
This should have never been made as a movie, it should have been a series or even better a mini series.
In order for it to be good they would need a budget like Game of Thrones 😅 it would have to be on that level in order to be successful. That's what I believe. But my hopes are up
Did you even read the books? Most of what you say is either not true or half true.
You know, I would love to have a remake, but I hope they have the same guy play Brom, unless he died without my knowledge
This is a chance for Disney to turn around. These books are some of the best I’ve ever read.
I've been re reading them recently just for old times sake and it absolutely deserves to have a show to fix the atrocity that was the movie
And let me guess they'll Jack their prices up again on top of that
It's off the table.. Disney is under pressure to get away from endless reboots and remakes. No one even got attached to it so at least no careers got ended..
We’ll see. If the quality and writing is bad, I’ll just watch for the dragons.
I don't trust Disney with this given their track record of late, but IF they learned from their mistakes(BIG IF) and they do this one right, then I will be more optimistic for when they do the Prydain Chronicles which is very dear to me. In the movie, the Urgals were hornless, elves didn't have tipped ears, the mountains weren't staggeringly high as Paolini described in an interview(10 miles high), Saphira just magically ages into full maturity by flying up into the sky. That's really to say the least, but I mean if Disney avoids those and pays very good attention to detail, they've at least started in a right direction. I guess the best hope will be how much direction they take from Paolini exec producing.
I do still want Jeremy Irons cast
Honestly, idgaf about a reboot.
What I'd like is a game set in the time before the fall of the dragonriders. It could be singleplayer, co-op, or even MMO, where players get to create their own dragonriders and dragons.
Cuz lets face it, the books are a boring rehash of a rehash of another story. To give it to Disneys mediocre show writers isn't going to help it in the slightest.
I actually think it could work better as a series for the simple reason that the writers would have more time to flesh things out. And from what I hear Chris Paolini is actually heavily involved this time so there's at least a chance that this could make up for the movie. The Percy Jackson series, while certainly not without its deviations, has been pretty good so far in my opinion, so there's a chance for Eragon, especially if they stick to one book per season.
You said young boy. It starts about a half year before he comes of age. So probably best young man or adolescent. Young boy I think of someone who isn't even a teen.
I enjoyed it as a kid.
Is it strange that for the past week now I have been reading Eragon and daydreaming of directing an Eragon TV/movie series and then this pops up?
We might be the same person living different realities lmfao😂
Why Disney betrayed the cable companies and movie theaters companies why ?
Yes but why?
$250 million sounds pretty good when you compare it to todays absolute garbage! Disney still pushed out movies that LOSE 100million
WOOHOOOOOOO!!!!!
I actually liked the movie as a kid 😭😭😭
Not sure if id rather it be disney or netflix, i guess atleast with disney atleast eragon might still be straight and atleast look like the original character. Hopefully Paolini actually gets to be involved this time and disney doesnt just shut him out and ruin his ideas like fox.
Disney *WILL* ruin it, that's guaranteed! 🙄👎
think Jennifer Love Hewitt would perfect for Saphria
They should just leave it alone. They gonna messed it up and there fans.
INGL, i haven't read the books, but i actually love the movie it wasnt until a couple of years ago where i heard it was bad, but that's just me
Yeah it skipped over alot of the characters, but I didn't hate it that much.
Way to advertise Disney, not what the title suggests
Why show movie pics
Shame Movie
Dude! I loved that movie! And the game is related to the movie. I’m so stoked for the sequel man.
Nooooooooooooooooooooooo .. Someone please put a jihad on Disney, they are destroying everything they touch!! No way this will be good, ffs I love the books.
Paolini is codirecting it
Can't be worse than that garbage of a movie tbh ... Do it like G.O.T and this would be an amazing show
I swear, I SWEAR, if they make ONE PERSON GAY in the Eragon tv show, I WILL SCREAM AND THROW MY REMOTE IN THE TRASH. You complained about not having enough gay representation, now you have too much of it and not enough straight representation! If Paolini lets it stand that Disney will make it gay and incorrect, I have lost all my faith in humanity. My thing also is, people complained about Grover being black in the Percy Jackson movie, and they also complained about Annabeth having brown hair, but why is it NOT a problem now to have an Indian Grover and a black Annabeth??? The ONLY person they got right was Percy! They made every other character a race other than white by what I understand, and it drives me NUTS. There are PLENTY of roles for black/racial minority groups out there, but NOT in Percy Jackson!! And Rick Riordan BACKS this???? What sort of GARBAGE is Disney making nowadays???
They recently got a new CEO, maybe they’ll back off some of that for now.
Lol fully and strongly agree and because there is no gay characters in the books. If you want gay characters write your own book. Leave Eragon as it is. Don't ruin the memory I have of it please.
Well as far as i can remember there werent any gay couples in eragon, but if they have to which there are rules to follow there will be representation in everything that shows up on the screen. So its very possible that there will be gay couples or characters that are gay in Disneys version of eragon. However i do hope that they create a new character for that reason instead of re writing an already existing character just to have someone represent a minority.
you seem really homophobic and racist. as long as it doesn’t alter the story, i don’t see the issue. it would be different if a character was obviously asian and they made them black or white or latino. but nothing says an elf can’t be any of those people or colors. as for romantic relationships, it would be bad if they made eragon gay but if there’s a side character that isn’t specified and they use them for representation then again, that’s not an issue.
@@imjustdoingmybest6236 okok listen. Annabeth is white. Did you even read the books? It's not racist for me to defend my own race, is it? If we made Tiana white that would be considered extremely racist and riots would most likely happen, same thing if we made a gay character straight. You can't deny that would upset some people, and the show or movie would most likely get canceled. I'm not saying black or other colored people can't act, that would be racist. I'm not saying gay people can't act, that would be hateful towards gay people. Just make different characters for skin colors and whether they're gay or not. Don't hijack a character and twist it around to make it fit the ideals of what people want. They did that for a historical character because apparently white people can't act now and the only actors available are colored people. How would you feel if you wrote something like Snow White and made Snow White a white person and then years later someone's like "no, she's actually Latino" when you wrote her to be white? I'd be pretty ticked off. See what I mean?
Oh joy….
I just finished the last book. I had a big break after reading the first one years ago. I don't like the idea that Disney is even thining about it. They will make it worse, will put too many black actors into leads.
Black lgbtq elfes incoming