You already Forgot about Bundles in Minecraft
HTML-код
- Опубликовано: 8 дек 2023
- Mojang plans to implement Bundles into the game, any day now. But they were already doomed to fail from their first teaser in 1.17.
- Socials -
🐦Twitter (or X lmao): / xayxayyt
-Specific Credits to-
► Me, for editing this video!
► timeforcrime, for making the Yae Miko Minecraft skin I use:
www.planetminecraft.com/skin/...
► TheFliyngFire for their Super Thanks!
►@skyboimc for lending his beautiful voice.
-Support me! -
► Epidemic Sounds (referral): share.epidemicsound.com/712v0q
► Support the channel through Super Thanks and Memberships!
-External Sources (in video order)-
Inventory Organization Guide For Terraria 1.4
• Inventory Organization... (By beaverrac)
Strongest Weapons in Zelda Breath of the Wild | What, Why & Where • Strongest Weapons in Z... (By 100 Percent Zelda)
Manage Your Inventory in No Man's Sky Easily With This Trick
• Manage Your Inventory ... (By Dread Captain James)
Red Dead Redemption 2 - THE BEST UPGRADE! Carry 99 Of Every Item!
• Red Dead Redemption 2 ... (By Saintsfan)
Stardew Valley how to increase inventory (2023) | Stardew Valley how to increase inventory
• Stardew Valley how to ... (By Udisen Games)
[Factorio] Working buttons for Inventory Grid
• [Factorio] Working but... (By NindyBun)
Don't Starve Together with Unlimited Players was a Mistake
• Don't Starve Together ... (By RTGame)
We Gathered The Irish Lads to Make A New Ireland in Raft
• We Gathered The Irish ... (By RTGame)
Minecraft Live 2023
ruclips.net/user/liveDnY5xz11... (By Minecraft)
Minecraft: 1.3 Easy XP/Enchant Guide! | iJevin
• Minecraft: 1.3 Easy XP... (By iJevin)
Elden Ring Boss Bar Transparent for those who have been looking for one for some goofy photoshops
/ elden_ring_boss_bar_tr... (By u/Relevant-Step-8188)
Minecraft Live: Caves & Cliffs - First Look
• Minecraft Live: Caves ... (By Minecraft)
Why Bundles Don't Fix the Inventory Issue
• Why Bundles Don't Fix ... (By SimplySarc)
-Music used in the video (in order)-
Alec Slayne - Nemesis
• Nemesis
Nintendogs - Walking the Dog
(© Nintendo)
Persona 5 - Suspicion
(By Shoji Meguro) (© Atlus)
Plants VS Zombies - Brainiac Maniac
• Brainiac Maniac (In-Game) (By Laura Shigihara) (© Popcap)
Minecraft - Mellohi
• Mellohi (By C418) (© Mojang)
Plants VS Zombies - Rigor Mormist
• Rigor Mormist (In-Game) (By Laura Shigihara) (© Popcap)
Deltarune - Rude Buster [Electro House Remix]
• Deltarune - Rude Buste... (By The Musical Ghost)
ELFL - Last Odyssey
• Last Odyssey
Yu Gi Oh Master Duel - Climax Theme 7
(By Yasunori Nishiki) (© Konami)
OcularNebula - Stay Inside Me
• Stay Inside Me
Minecraft - Danny
• Danny (By C418) (© Mojang)
Minecraft - Strad
• Strad (By C418) (© Mojang)
Minecraft - Aria Math
• Aria Math (By C418) (© Mojang)
Xenoblade Chronicles - You Will Know Our Names
(By ACE+) (© Monolith Soft)
Plants VS Zombies - Graze the Roof
• Graze the Roof (In-Game) (By Laura Shigihara) (© Popcap)
Marten Moses - Drops
• Drops
-Viktor, Arcane (Season 1 Episode 2)-
"When you’re going to change the world, don’t ask for permission.” 
Игры
They should remove the inventory as a whole! No inventory, no problem (I'm waiting to be hired for Mojang)
So the April fool's update?
The one block at a time wants to know your location
You'll do great as a Mojang employee
Let's remove phantoms, yeah?
they already made that update smh
You will suffer for removing the Minding
It's ridiculous that an adventuring game doesn't have the one thing by default that almost every modpack includes: Backpacks.
Most adventuring survival games have backpacks too! So its weird that Minecraft doesn't.
you do its called inventory!
@@vinportobga back pack that can hold 64 blocks in the same slot but not two tools in one slot
That already exists, shulker boxes.
@@EmperorPenguin1217But that is a block
Minecraft alpha-beta didn't really have this issue to be fair because of the lack of item variety. You could only really get seeds from hoeing grass, mobs only dropped one thing typically, and there was only one type of wood, saplings, stone and two types of flowers
Then go play alpha and beta and have little to nothing.
Have fun
@@stratejic1020 Many old players actually prefer to, including myself.
There's an issue tho... food is unstackable
@stratejic1020 Don't shit yourself, kid.
@@symmetries_ guess you like only 15 items
Honestly, mojang should add an item which makes the inventory bigger, something like a backpack
That already exists. Shulker boxes.
@@EmperorPenguin1217 except that shulkers are late game and while a good amount of people can get through the end rather quickly, it still takes time. If a backpack adds a double chest worth of inventory without you needing to place it down and just acts like another page, that would be awesome
@@tonkofwisdom3788 If you want the best tools you need to progress further, you can't just have immediate access to every option at once. Not only would a backpack would be broken but it wouldn't even solve the "issue" (Which doesn't exist)
@@EmperorPenguin1217 but it does though. While I agree that progression matters, I think it would be smarter to give players something like backpacks in the late early game. Wouldn’t be as secure as say an end chest with shulkers but point being, it makes sense to give players more inventory space to manage more misc. items that they may want, but is clogging their inventory space. Minecraft clearly has a push for exploration and building so while your play style might be to settle in one area, someone else might like to explore and keep walking just because. I know for me I do a lot of exploration first before finding a good build location. I respect the fact that you think the current inventory is fine as is, but if anything, expanding on the current system allowing for players to manage misc items better, or to store unstackables would be extremely useful. Bundles are not an outright answer, especially for mid game players.
@@tonkofwisdom3788It literally doesn't. There is no inventory issue, people are terrible at managing resources. Llamas and donkeys/mules already function as backpacks (And chest boats to a lesser extent).
Mojang: We recently learned that the inventory can be used to carry items that can inflict harm to animals and other people. We're removing the inventory.
Phoenix SC be like
no?
@@Mino-ex7pz
Don't wanna teach the kids to carry sword and bows around. That'd be dangerous, like feeding fireflies to frogs.
24w_oneblockatatime update:
@@mythosinfinite6736 Not as dangerous as making polar bears as aggressive as they are in real life. Letting them have an actual gameplay purpose would teach kids that polar bears are dangerous and encourage them to kill them, after all.
I think you were too harsh on ender chests and shulker boxes. They absolutely did not solve the issue, but they're really convenient tools (placing them down and having to use silk touch for ender chests is not ideal, but really not a big deal), and they definitely help.
That's fair , but their penalties are too big imo
@@XayXayYTyou replied too fast lol, I just edited it
@@HelloIAmAnExist ahhh, fair enough
lol i forgot this was minutes ago@@XayXayYT
@@XayXayYT You can also use enderchests to make sure your survermates don't steal your best stuff.
In Terraria 1.4.4, Relogic changed the maximum stack size from 999 to 9999 items for all items that aren't weapons or armour. Notably, 999 has been the maximum stack size for a large amount of Terraria's run time, but from what I've seen, no one has complained about the change, as it only added to convenience. Minecraft is a game with a lot of similarities to Terraria, so in my eyes, there is no reason for 64 to continue to be the ultimate number for stack sizes.
Agreed.
Id enjoy 128
literally the only problem I've encountered with terraria increasing the maximum stack size to 9999 is that sometimes I forget and buy like way more rope than i need or something. It's wonderful and makes everything so much more convenient.
Actually for a few years the max stack size in Terraria was 250. But even after increasing it to 999 bombs still stacked to 100 and potions still stacked to 30. Boss summon items were only 20, and I think there were some other limitations too. When they announced in 1.4.4 they would increase the max stack size for EVERYTHING to 9999 I was absolutely stoked and despite all the other spoilers, that was still my favourite upcoming feature.
@@jacksonpercy8044 yup, i remember. nothing changed about gameplay and there were no negatives imo
the solutions they introduce over time have technically solved the inventory issue but then a few updates down the line we’re back to square one cause there’s more items and more clutter and so it’s a weird case of power creep where the inventory has become an insane boss like you said and the solutions they add don’t amount to the modern game. we need a fundamental change but as for the bundle i’m actually someone who really likes how it works in its current state and always keep 1-2 on my as they are extremely useful for storing my crafting table, furnace, some torches and scaffolding and then i always leave room in it or just bring a second for clearing up clutter like seeds or other loot i get in small quantities
They are also very useful when mining with a crafting table because you Can condense ore item (raw metal, Redstone, Diamond) into block to make them take even less space in the bundles ! I love bundles with all my soul, they could use some tweak but they are already pretty cool !
honestly, if nostalgia is the reason they don't increase the number of slots...then why not add a backpack item which increase the number of slots? that way each players can choose if they want to use it or not. And the backpack would use the elytra/chest armor slot to balance things out.
Forcing you to use a boat or an horse once a while, or to travel on foot.
idk if Mojang would add smth like this. But yea, I think "nostalgia" and the fear of changing old things was bc of the 1.9 incident. Seriously the problem is us playerbase not being able to accept that some things *just CHANGES OVERTIME!*
@@LucBlocker honestly I’d like to keep the number of inventory slots, what they really need is some kinda backpack.
@@crusaderkaiser2000 I mean, if you think about it... shulker boxes are backpacks but you need to place them down to get their content and then mine it again to pick it up
@@LucBlocker honestly I find it hard to think of Shipley boxes as a backpack, mostly due to the fact that you place them down and don’t wear them.
If backpacks were implemented they should create a new inventory tab, similar to creative tabs, you can only hold one backpack and it has to be on your chest slot (or back slot if they decide to implement one which is extremely unlikely). Said backpack should also be able to be upgraded for more storage slots.
@@crusaderkaiser2000 fair point, although I mean mods already did implement this kind of stuff lol, I wouldn't mind this being added personally
I'd say a argument for a increase of the inv. Slots would be that the amount of items receivable and the variety of items has increased over the years
And btw, I think eggs, snowballs and enderpearls only stack to 16 cuz they are throwable projectiles and it would be op to throw 64 without reloading?
snowballs literally do no damage tho! (except to... blazes specifically, not even fire mobs in general, just blazes lol) and eggs are outshined by arrows to the max. I think it's safe to cap them to 64
@@LucBlocker would totally agree! Thing is prolly knock back tho. u can throw them with now cooldown really, arrows would need a bow
@@risingphoenixrl you do have a point, but then, holding mobs back wouldn't rly have a use if you can't kill them, also that wouldn't work when multiple are around :p
Snowballs and Eggs do no damage, only knockback (and can't even hit players in vanilla, currently), and Ender Pearls already have a cooldown that prevents you from spam-throwing.
@@LucBlocker yeah, ur right! It makes me question tho why ender pearls are limited to 16 then
Ender chests and shulker boxes never aimed to solve the "inventory issue". And both ender chest and shulker boxes are hingly used by players for different things, like a personal save in terms of the ender chest. But you are right about the bundle, it is now not even normally in the game anymore. If I want more inventory, I usually use mods :).
6:27 - WHAT?! WHY!!! Why on earth can you even put unstackables into your bundles if they fill them up instantly?! This makes literally no sense.
Because bundles use a weight based on stack size, which I do find to be the absolute answer to the inventory problem as they clear up the main issue: Not the unstackables but actually the Lesser valued stackable items. Bundles will help here as they'll aid you greatly by cleaning up incomplete yet needed stacks of stackable items. Also having an inventory full of unstackables is crazy to achieve on a single trip anyways so I do not find this to be an issue at all. If, for any reason, people do somehow achieve this odd feat and they're still *travelling and looting* regardless, then they should just toss out easily replaceable items or weigh the items they're holding with the new loot in that fancy chest they found and just exchange and forget. Absolutely zero problems and this whole conundrum with the inventory really isn't as bad as people make it out to be.
As a person who the last 5 years his favorite activity in Minecraft was and Right now is speed run the bundle (when they took it off around 1.18 and 1.19 I've stopped playing the game lol until they re added it as a experimental feature).
It's perfect for my style of playing (collect all flowers and saplings in early survival for example) and i love the purpose focus of the bundle.
I feel like a hacker goin for biomes that bunnies spawn and collecting dandelion (yellow flower) to breed them. No joke, it's my favorite item in the game.
Maybe they could add a "ender" or "skulk" bubdle and stack non stackable items IDK. But there's a video of Minecraft ideas academy about the bundle were they describe the problems of the inventory and how the bundle fix one of it.
As someone who plays modded with bundles, they do actually help massively, and become the most useful item when looting structures.
That right ! They are very good for looting and mining, I use multiple of them when i explore (even through i wouldn't be against buffing them just a little to make more people use them)
@@Feu_Ghost Agreed, I think the main reason people think they aren't good is because they haven't played survival worlds with them much.
Do you have them stack with shulkers? If so then i can understand how they canjust fix the inventory problem quite a bit
@@riolu477 They can, but they don't need too, you don't realize how many times you'll have one dirt block, 3 coarse dirt, 2 diamonds, 6 iron nuggets, a stone brick and some chiseled deepslate taking up a good chunk of inventory space until your on a looting spree, and then the bundle is a life saver, and dirt cheap.
As someone who did the same, I found them kinda useless. Helps with small items you don’t need but at the end of the day not much of an improvement.
I quite like the bundle actually. Somethings early game you'll want to keep if you come across it. Think potatos, carrots, string, bones, etc. But while you're off mining or traveling those items take up an entire slot of inventory space. And due to the small numbers you have of each a bundle can be used to clear the inventory slots. Though they do need to add a cycle function to take things out.
I think if there was an item similar to the bundle, but with the express purpose of compressing unstackables perhaps somewhere in the range of 4-9 unstackables that, when empty, can be stacked to 64 like the bundle would maaaaaybe work???? It WOULD be really hard to communicate its purpose, though.
Like the main draw of the bundle is its portablility, have three bundles and your inventory can often stay pretty clean. But right now, the bundle is held back by its recipe and the fact that the only mobile control scheme on bedrock capable of fully using it is the most recently added one, that too few players currently use to justify having a feature designed around. It's now the current default setting, so the more new players come to bedrock, the moment those controls form maybe 30-40% of the playerbase, they would be able to implement the bundle. Those controls came out... last year.
Which is exactly why the bundle is stuck in stasis. RIP bundle, for the next 5-10 years.
I think the 64 stack does make SOME sense, too, as players have the ability to divide stacks in halves, and so an exponent of 2 feels reasonable, also numbers beyond 100 clutter the item view too much, so the limit should remain under 100. As such, 64 was probably the limit created for those reasons.
One of the main issues is the cost of the bundle. It requires 6 rabbit hides, and the default per rabbit is 0-1 hides. This means on average, without looting, you need to kill TWELVE RABBITS for a SINGLE bundle. I know that having even just one would help a fair bit, but that really limits their potential for early game storage.
@@jacksonpercy8044 Now, When I played the version with those in them I had modded dungeons and such. So maybe my view is skewed. But aren't they fairly common in chests you find around the world?
@@Artrysa Dunno, I haven't played the game in years. Most of my focus is on technical aspects than the casual playing experience.
@@jacksonpercy8044 But isn't the casual gameplay where it will have it's effect most? Since if an item can't be gotten through casual play it's usefulness is limited by the amount of players it reaches.
I think mojang is afraid of adding stuff that is already in mods into the game. Come on, It wouldnt be Hard to add backpacks into the game.
And therein lies the problem that needs to be addressed; if a mod improves QoL THAT much, we shouldn't have needed a mod for it to begin with.
I thinks item such as seed and flowers should be made to go into bundle automatically so you dont have to open it and then close or maybe even better if they make it like if you put a item in into the bundle when ever you pick that item it goes straight to the bundle until you run out of strorage
YES! PLEASE THIS 1000%
Also, bundles having an early game and mid game tier with 2-4 stacks of storage (maybe requiring a nether item) would make so much sense.
Until then, I'll keep to only playing servers with the AE2 mod :/ (probably will anyway lol)
I fill ender chests with shulkers of useful stuff, it never really feels like a problem to use, pretty powerful
I don't think bundles are inherently bad. Gave them a go in my current Minecraft Survival Series and they serve their purpose well even after the early game. I think they are pretty neat!
That being a organizer for smaller items. It's not meant for non-stackable items, which is what people are upset over, even though that isn't the point of bundles.
I think Pixlriffs said it best "Even of you increase the capacity of the bundle, you will eventually run out of space or be turned away because it only keeps one non-stackable item."
There are multiple problems with inventory and I do agree it needs to be rectified, preferably increasing the amount of spaces.
So long more items are added in updates, inventory management is going to get harder and harder, and there is no silver bullet. Not even Shulker Boxes are the end all for inventory management.
Calling bundles a failure purely because they only hold a stack of items or one non-stackable item is very pessimistic IMO.
Yeah, the unstackable issue feels like the function of a separate item. The smallest brain idea is to have an item similar in function to the bundle, but with a stack size of only ~4-9 items, but that can take unstackables too.
The only difficulty I see with such an item is how to communicate its purpose. I really struggle to figure out how you would inform the player of its utility when it seeks to address such a specific issue.
Increasing the amount of inventory spaces would be a terrible idea. It wouldn’t even fix the “inventory issue” (Which doesn’t exist)
@@EmperorPenguin1217have you ever even gone out exploring your world? I have, and usually my inventory gets filled up pretty quickly. The inventory has an issue. Maybe you don’t have an issue with the inventory. But some people do.
@@EmperorPenguin1217youre delusional if you think that this problem doesnt exist.
@@kiwidood1706 It literally doesn't though. Inventory management is integral to the game and that's why shulker boxes exist. Increasing the inventory space across the board would literally break the entire game.
The reason there's so much disappointment surrounding the enderchest and shulkerbox is because (going in line with the way you presented them) most people think that one storage item / improvement will completely solve the issue, when in reality inventory management will always be an issue. These items were introduced to mitigate the issue, not solve it. Inventory management is always going to be an aspect of the game, these items are just added to try and make that easier to handle, and in some ways they did well and other ways they failed when dealing with this issue.
While they certainly could and should do more QoL updates surrounding this issue, there's no true way to "solve" this issue completely, only reduce its impact.
I think a good way to improve the situation is to add more functions with the left hand. Since we have problems with inventory space, we can make something like a backpack item to put in your left slot to increase the amount of slots in you inventory.
or a craftable item that attatches to the back of your chestplate and then your inventory has like (X) amount of slots
how about a backpack enchantment
Didn’t Mojang say they would not add back packs to Minecraft? Why is Mojang restricting themselves like that?
@@luxsolis95 I think it’s because they don’t want the inventory to fill the screen as deaf people wouldn’t be able to notice that they’re in danger.
@@DogeHalo398 Having a backpack on your back slot would be interesting... Because it would mean giving up both extra armor protection AND the elytra in return for more inventory slots.
adding more inventory slots seem like a band-aid solution imo. I much prefer if Mojang finds multiple creative ways to help with inventory issue with their own pros and cons, and players had to pick. I like having options.
It's kind of like when they added the Elytra, and it made it so Horses and Minecarts kinda went useless. I don't like having one option that's just better in every way, I want to use a horse or make a railway track depending on the situation because that makes me interact with the world and motivates me to play. The inventory issue should be taken in a similar way. I definitely agree that the sheer amount of unstackables and horrible hotbar management are the two biggest problems with the inventory, but "more slots" don't entirely fix those issues.
How about a toolbelt that you can put your tools in? Once a tool is in a toolbelt, punching a block will automatically put the correct tool for that block in your hand, and it'll go back to the belt when you let go? This way we can free up 4-5 slots from your hotbar. Or a quiver that holds arrows so you're encouraged to use lots of different types of arrows without worrying about them clogging up your inventory? Similar smart solutions can be made for stuff that you constantly have to move in an out of your hotbar: totems, potions, building blocks etc.
That reminds me of the shift click feature in Terraria to use whatever tool is appropriate based on the block your cursor is hovered over. That would be a great feature in Minecraft too
The thing is that the inventory is adapted to the early versions of the game like a lot of features (minecarts / horse) that become obsolete with the newest updates
But what if you have Silk Touch and Fortune pickaxe? How it supposed to know which one to use? So, it has to have some kind of active choosing system. For now I can only think of vertical or separate small hot-bar pop-up, which will contain your tools and scrolls separately, when you hold the tool kit or with crouch key.
You're right, I didn't think of that. Maybe when it looks for a tool, it prioritizes the "top slot" over the bottom slot, and inverses the priority if you press a button? So you can have your silk touch at the top, fortune at the bottom, and change it out as you play. I kinda dislike having to go to UI's all the time for games.
@@Agean05 sadly, we have keep in mind the mobile editions. So the only button will be "sneak" one and when you'll be working somewhere high or in the Ancient City, you'd hold the button to not fall or allert sensors, but that also would change your tool, as you suggest.
Multi-platforming is a blessing and a curse of game development
I have enabled this on every single friend group server and can't imagine playing without it, it's just such a big relieve as an inventory hoarder
I have an idea for the bundle UI that works across platforms. When you have a bundle in your inventory there will be a bundle button which when pressed will add the 64 bundle slots on the side of your inventory which you will then be able to transfer items between
Great video man ! The editing on this was so nice, love watching your content ^^
Terraria had the same issue, stacks of your stuff that eventually fill up and took another slot. but they did basically a x10 maximum capacity to almost all consumables and blocks, the best exaple of this problem was ammo, you could have just 4000 ammo in the dedicated slots, and then you would waste space. but with 9999 per stack of the same ammo type, you can go arround without worrying. same with blocks. and your tools, equip and valuabnle items remain unstackable
I still surprised that the bundle is still an experimental feature and that since almost 3 yeats of exisiting, Mojang hasn't improved it at least a bit, i think rabbit leather is maybe a bit complicated to get in early game for just having 64 slots
I think you are wrong, I recently added bundles to my survival minecraft server at their current state and they are fabolous, yes I had to craft 3 of them, but I think it's just the progress system, if I had 3 bundles with 128 slots it would have been overkill.
Personally i think the main problem is that items only stack to 64, and sometimes only to 16. Do you know how little 64 is when it cames to inventories?
that line
ONE SHOT THE ENDER DRAGON USING A SADDLE
was epic😁🤣🤣
The Blockheads had a good bundle system. Baskets of baskets of baskets, etc.
Wow i loved that game
I like how Animal Crossing New Horizon did it, you upgrade to get your inventory larger. When starting a world on Minecraft you start with 36 and throughout the game you can find things to upgrade your inventory. Maybe have a villager trade to get 10 more slots. Things like this you can find around the world would be cool.
Shulker boxes already do that
@@EmperorPenguin1217 And yet they still haven't solved the inventory issue.
@@jacksonpercy8044Because there is no inventory issue in the first place. People are bad at managing their items
@@timohara7717 ???
@@EmperorPenguin1217no, not really. They don’t extend your inventory, and definitely not gradually. You seem to have problem with understanding written text
Great premiere man, happy it was a success. Great video but I don't think many more inventory slots are needed, only the 4 ones coming to the hotbar having a 0 slot. For the rest it's like you said, they should think outside of 8-unit increments and go with the terraria way: KILL STACK LIMITS (with exceptions lol)
I don't think the unstackability of potions make sense, they aren't extremely valuable, actually, honestly the unstackability TAKES OUT their value, because for example, damage potions are almost never used in survival, and that's because it's impractical to use, since they are unstackable. Sure, if it stacked at 16 it would be extremely OP, but it could be only 5 or even 3 that it would honestly make it more practical to use and useful.
Bundles are REALLY GOOD for the early game, bundles will NOT solve the inventory problem as a whole.
My biggest problem with inventory is when building, specialy in survival, having full blocks, stairs, slabs from differents blocks is horible to manage, you may not even have enough inventory to have them all.
For exploring after a while in a world, Shulkers are REALLY GOOD, they could recieve some improvement but they were massive game changers.
That left us with the early game, it's almost imposible to play without droping items or without saving them in a chest, but bundles... Bundles are amazing to save you space in the early game, I really think they do pretty well what they were made to do.
I dont know what Mojang will do, but the inventory problem is pretty hard to solve while staying true to "vanilla". Adding some extra slots wont solve the problem from its roots.
there could be a really interesting solution to this, which I'll just call "palette packs". they are like bundles, but they have multiple slots, and the caveat is that they can only contain blocks/items of the same set, with one slot for each.
For example, a palette could hold the normal, polished, wall, slab, stair etc. of a block, or all of the color variations of an item.
There could also somehow be a way of having alternate sets, such as having all wood colors of one block, or just stairs of various materials.
This kind of ties in with the other additions people have mentioned like toolbelts and quivers.
These could be future proof (kinda), as there are generally more variations of items implemented than entirely new categorizations.
Loved the TF2 reference at 8:15, very fitting!
I remember back when Terraria had a max stack for some items of only 250. You would have entire chests full od dirt, mud and stone from a couple hours of mining. But they increased it to 999. This was of course better, but it was still an issue, especially since some items were still capped at only 100 or 30. So in 1.4.4 they just increased the stack limit of pretty much every stackable in the game to 9999, and it's way better! Personally I think Minecraft should just increase the universal stack limit to 256 and add another row or two in your inventory.
How I think this could be fixed: also make bundles able to hold at least 3 unstackable items... Done, 3 totems in a slot, 3 filled buckets in a slot, 3 tnt minecarts in a slot... I think this will do it honestly
Or just make them hold 64 of ANY item, including unstackables
@@tulenich9948 no that's too insane and unbalanced
@@skulkingshadow just 3 items is way too little too. It's basically useless for me. At least make it 16.
@@tulenich9948 16 can hold all your armor, your tools and a bunch of totems to spare. In a single slot. That's still completely broken.
First off, I think it should be a separate item that can hold unstackables. Otherwise, it just becomes kind of confusing communicating the stack limit of the bundle.
I think a good carry value is indeed 3 or 4. Probably 4, since it would allow you to carry a full suit of armor and it's an exponent of 2. If you carry 2-3 of them, you can massively prolong the time you spend out in the world exploring. In combination with the bundle and with shulker boxes to take care of bulk items like dirt or stone, the time you can be out exploring gets truly ridiculous.
This is clearly a fairly end-game item though.
@@timohara7717 There are very valid reasons why most of those are limited. Potions are powerful items, and stacking them to such a high number would have devastating effects in pvp.
Stews and saddles are perhaps the only one of these that may be reasonable.
Any type of armor being stackable would create a logical conflict between all the other armor types.
and carpets and chests??? stack to 64 already???
when i heard "this is a bucket" i am not ashamed to say i said Soldier's part in his voice out loud
You hit the nail on the head. I only have one thing that makes me turn around when I'm exploring: Running out of inventory space. I really don't feel like pulling out dozens of shulker boxes.
Make a new item: The Backpack
You craft it with 5 Leather, a chest, a copper ingot and 2 rabbit hyde
It goes in the Chest Armor slot and gives you 3 extra rows of inventory space.
If you take it off it stores what's in those 3 rows like a shulker box; however: you cannot place shulker boxes inside the 3 rows and you can't place backpacks on the ground. You can place backpacks filled with items inside shulker boxes though.
you can also use a shulker box as a backpack. (if you do you can actually place backpacks inside the extra 3 rows)
Oh you can also dye backpacks and look inside them by right clicking with them in hand
This sound’s genius
@@Justcallmerosa because its a mod that existed for a long time now
@@djinnspalace2119 it sounds genius because it just makes sense
@@Rabi2in agreed
Please just regular leather, I don't want to have to find a rabbit when there's a cow sitting right in front of me
I think bundles could be more like a backpack putting it in with your armor and giving you more slots
It would fix the mobile problem and the inventory problem
Even if the inventory problem did exist it was already solved with shulker boxes.
@@EmperorPenguin1217 yeah, but you need to place shulker boxes. I’m not gonna place a box to get my op sword will I? I’ll just use a backpack.
@@Varun-jz6pw So what? It takes less than three seconds to place it down and get your item
@@EmperorPenguin1217 did you even watch the video? It didn’t fix anything. Bozo.
@@Varun-jz6pw Yes, I did. There is no "inventory problem", people are terrible at managing their inventory and not hoarding.
Sadly I had to leave just when the countdown reached zero, but I watched it now that I have time. Really like your editing, keep up the good work!
I use one every time I play. You can see it in my live world. I LOVE THEM! I NEVER forgot and kept waiting, then found it could be added with experimental features and worked to get them into my existing world.
I never forgot about bundles. i was just talking about them the other day. y hope is they will still be added any way. It would help a lot because when you "beat" the game, while I know that isn't really the whole objective, for many it feels like the world is complete now and there's not any reason to continue, so only jut getting more inventory pace then is.... silly, honestly.
3:15 didn't see that coming
Love the videos! do you think you'll ever do a vid on modpacks?
As I'm currently playing create above and beyond, that modpack has great inventory management. First you've got the create toolboxes, which has 8 inventory slots, but around 258 of each item in that slot. And you can access it remotely, and will always try and give you a stack of 32 in your hotbar when you select an item.
Then you have the upgradable backpack, that goes from 9 slots to like 54 slots, which can first be upgraded with just leather, then gold, and finally diamond.
Then you have the "surprisingly substantial satchel" which out the box has 72 slots, but needs some in depth exploration of it's mod pack to create.
Then you have the occultism remote storage, which can easily get 1024 slots mid game, can be accessed anywhere in the world with just one item, and works with physical item movement in loaded chunks.
And with the curios mod allowing you to wear most of these solutions outside your general inventory, I'm probably walking around with a good 2,000 slots ready to go at a moments notice.
So I open inventory with E, then I do shift E for my occult storage. Then I press B for the backpack holding tools, and shift B for my satchel holding work blocks. And then hold alt to access my toolboxes holding my most used items.
Now, obviously I don't expect vanilla Minecraft to go this extreme, but an upgradable backpack would fit the current upgrade to the smithing table. And then later when you unlock shulkers, its basically a final upgrade to the backpack, just by shulkers being themselves.
My solution for bundle problem:
Add belt, which by itself gives you 1 slot. Placing bundle in the belt gives you 3 slots instead.
Terraria too faces inventory issues but theirs is way worse because they have 5078 unique items (Source: terraria.wiki.gg/wiki/Item_IDs ). They continuously increased stack sizes from 100x items per stack up to 250, 999 and most recently 9999. They doubled the size of all chests. They added vanity item slots for storing unstackable items as well as 3 equipment loadouts (basically triple the slots). They added ammo/coin slots. They added three "Ender Chests", two being easily accessible on the fly without "placing down" and one that fills automatically when your inventory is full. They made nearly all items stackable. But guess what: the inventory STILL fills up to the brim!
This shows that resolving Minecraft's inventory issues requires at least similarly drastic changes, however this would destroy the way how Minecraft Survival feels. Bundles as "trash collectors"? An "Ammo" slot? Tools, weapons and armor become unbreakable? Increased max stack sizes for all items? An early game Ender Chest that is also more fluent to use? These things are clearly not gonna happen!
I personally like the way how the inventory is very limited. It adds to the experience and makes you think twice on what items you REALLY need. It adds another level of "difficulty", which makes it fun to work with. I don't think it would need big changes, however I think it's sad the Bundles didn't make it because in some cases they can be useful, especially when exploring.
Also, 9:33 you watch too much Peenix! 😂
Let's be honest, we are all inspired by that guy, he's great fun.
But yeah, limited inventory is part of minecraft. by having such an inventory, players NEED to store things, and around those storages spots, they'll build structures that they can return to. It sort of feeds back into the game loop. The thing that people hate though, is when they have to do it far too frequently.
As you showed with terraria, ReLogic just dropped a nuke on the issue whenever started rising, but minecraft definitely wants to be more careful about it. The real limitations of the bundle, their latest fix, is:
1) its crafting recipe
2) bedrock mobile controls (they need more players to use the new control scheme)
3) that it needs a partner item to exist: an item to compress unstackables
The last clearly doesn't exist yet. but with the way Mojang has compartmentalized the issues of inventory, it is likely to come into existence eventually. With such an item, exploring can last an incredible amount of time, with the proper management of the inventory. Such an item would probably be limited to just a few slots, because it means that your inventory can be multiplied by that amount. Honestly, this items screams END GAME ITEM. It would need to be not TOO difficult to obtain, but still hard to get in bulk. Just imagine if each slot could store 8 unstackables, condensing the inventory would get ridiculous. Multiple sets of tools, armor, totems and other would be possible to carry with you with ease.
Thinking about it, 8 might be too powerful. 4, then? I think an item carrying 4 unstackables could work...
And yet, Terraria still does it better than Minecraft.
I don't think terraria has a inventory issue imo, because you can use the flying pig vault thing and it's very easy to fill your chest (since theres TP potions/items unlike Minecraft). And yeah most of the "ender chests" are Pre hardmode so I don't see the issue
@@yorugua4377 Good point, I forgor the TPs and quick stacking options.
The limitations on inventory were made in an era of minecraft where the only way of healing was bringing unstackable food. And you didnt need food if you didnt take damage. That introduced a risk and reward element to preparing for a trip that was lost in the adventure update
I played a server that had a datapack with bundles, put allowed any unstackable item to be added to it, with 64 being the total number of items. This works.
6:07 geometry dash practice song
You know what would help? Something like a "toolbelt", which would allow the player to store their tools until they are needed.
pretty sure that's the hotbar
i have an idea for mojang
they can make a kind of chest which are internally connected and when placed they share the same slots as ender chest(ONKY THE TWO CHESTA ARE CONNECTED AND NOT ALL CHESTS LIKE ENDER CHESTS) but one of the chest can placed in a hopper and one chest in the player's hotbar whenever the player is lacking inventory issues the player can just keep the chest and place the items in tit and the items will we stored throufgh the hoppers where the first chest was placed
a simple fix could be to make the modified inventry be a player option you can toggle when making the world like how you can toggle spawn chests and keepinventy on death, while also talking about it so people actually know it exists and gage player reactions from it while also keeping players from getting the big mad as its "just another optional toggle"
9:30
XD
Honestly, this is why a Terraria (no hate intended to Minecraft) player has no inventory problems.
You have 50 inventory slots, 10 of which are for the hotbar.
And you also have 4 ammo and 4 coin slots.
But the real deal is the junk slot. It gives the player the ability to dispose of trash. If you accidentally put a valuable item in there, don't worry, items are only disposed of when you put anorher item atop of former on the junk slot.
From 1.4.4 forward, we have loadouts, to alternate between different loadouts, armors and accessories. You can have 3 loadouts at a time.
We also have two ender chests, the safe and the defender's forge, and they have indipendent inventory from each other. Lastly we have two easily accessible handheld shulker boxes: the piggy bank and the void vault, which, again, have indipendent inventory from each other.
Other than from the piggy bank and the void vault, i think Minecraft can also benefit from a junk slot to eliminate from your inventory useless junk, though I think trash isn't as much of a hassle in Minecraft.
P.s.: i forgot about the encumbering stone, an item which stops you from picking up items from the ground.
27/12/23:Also i forgot to mention that most items in terraria except tools and stuff can be stacked up to 9999
woah how did you make the like button glow when you said that at 2:42 I'm on pc
nvm its an ai thing
I hate shulker box since I lost 1 important Shulker box in cave mining tunnel some where, and I can't remember where I put it down.
Inventory issue? You meant to say skill issue.
Let bro cook 🔥
Only issue i have with bundles is their craft and mechanic, would be cool to be able to scroll bundle contents
While the favourite part of it is right click functional. Would be great to place chests in boats with right click, or maybe some upgrades on equipment.
It could become smoother yeah, not needing to be placed down already puts it ahead but having a scroll to empty function would be amazing
the player is able to craft a jukebox, reform diamonds into amour without them shattering and yet the player doesn't know how to craft a backpack, instead they opt to kill a dragon and go on a quest for a BOX
I made a modded gui that has 105 inventory slots and from my experience playing with it, finding certain items is pretty confusing. More space in the inventory would be pretty useful, but like you also said having the number of items stack higher than 64 would make it even better.
I think you were being a bit harsh on ender chests and shulker boxes, but you are right on the money about the inventory.
In addition to an expanded inventory, I think Mojang should add backpacks to further increase the inventory size. I don’t personally mind if these occupy the torso armor slot, but if I had it my way, there’d be a new back slot for the backpack and potentially other back-worn items.
i've never had a problem with inventory. i've only had a problem with unstackables like beds. when my inventory fills, it's usually because of junk that i dont need. my inventory is usually empty. tools from slots 1-4, food in 9th slot and water bucket in 8th slot(because hotkeys). everything else in my inventory is just silk pick, elytra, and torches, with shield or totem in my offhand. i think beds should stack to 16, but i do agree that trash like seeds should have more stack. same with signs and throwables. i think we should stop worrying about having less inventory, because it adds the aspect of sorting out inventory management in game. managing your inventory is rewarding, and i personally think shulkers are great because inventory DOES become an issue when gathering things in bulk. bundles i think will not be a faliure because when your inventory gets filled up with stuff that you dont have a lot of, but you need, you can chuck it in the bundle. i dont see an inventory issue here. just an issue with stacking items
The encumbering stone in question
"Lower stack counts for more powerful items..."
Crystals:
Enchanted golden apples:
Respawn anchors:
-------------------------------------------------------
I think that bundles should open a GUI like chests so they are easier to use and can be used properly on mobile
-------------------------------------------------------
Unstackables should take like half the bundle but not the whole thing and bundles should have more space in them
true
what if bundles can store 64 items, but ANY item? (like you can have a pickaxe, 16 ender pearls and the rest be filled with random flowers). (I think this would be hell to implement tho)
@@LucBlocker 1. It wouldn't, the items aren't even there
2. Nice idea but 64 totems IN A SINGLE SLOT does not sound balanced at all
@@Vetrical ok, I didn't think this through with that 2nd point ngl. In this case, let's just say that some items can't be put in bundles (although this would be unintuitive... gosh xD)
0:59 - Unbelievable, I can't fathom this reaction. Doesn't cost enough? You need a ender chest and then- ANOTHER ENDER CHEST just to use it, you will be carrying this goofy thing around with you to use on the go assuming it dropped itself on use, and would need one anytime you wanted to access your permanent ender chest.
This guy has a perfect chance at making his channel grow :
-Fun content
-Interresting to watch
-Probably not boring/forced for him to make
-Detailed
-Good SFX
-Good Animations
-Great jokes
-Understandable
Good luck in your way! You have a talent!
I remember when i made a vault in Minecraft wii u edition. My brother broke through my security but in the vault was an enderchest. He was so mad
its easy to make then for mobile, just make that when u select an item and then tap on bundle in your inventory, that item gets in, but when u hold on bundle, u get a dropdown menu of all items and you can remove some of them if you want
Bro thought he could use the practice mode music (stay inside me) and thought we wouldnt notice🔥💀
I actually used it on purpose because people would comment "omg geometry dash practice music" heh. (and also because the song is a banger)
The shoulder boxes combined with the Enders chest is a go to on adventures
Love the TF2 reference with the bucket lmao, good vid
or they can make the thing that all te moders did 10 YEARS ago, add backpacks, small backpacks, maybe only 9 slots.
sometimes the simplest solution is the best
The simplest solution already exists, better organization and shulker boxes
i agree with the extra slots above the hotbar but i think there should be arrows that fold in and out the extra slots to archive it or something like that or in the setting u can turn on a thing where u dont pick up the things by walking over them and u have to press like something to pick it up while u can turn on the ability to pick up other items when u just walk over them
Ive been waiting for bundles for years! As someone who always has random crap in my inventory bundles would be so useful for inventory management of my random 💩
A solution to the inventory problem bags , you could add up 5 per character and different types of bags could be equipped the early game ones would have about13 slots and the end game ones can have as much as a double chest they dont take up armor slots no visual indicator and drop with all the stuff in the bag upon death they have a special thing in the inventory when clicked on it will show your bags if you click the button next to the bag it will open it click the slot with the bag to remove the bag an put in the normal inventory and sandwiches that you can craft you take bites out of the sandwich if you take a bite it gives you a certain amount of hunger depending on what type of sandwich you eat it also varies on how many bites you get per type of sandwich
"we should increase maximum limit of item stack"
Terraria: "Here's 9999 of almost everything you can carry in each of your slots. Oh and you can also use the garbage slot as long as you don't put another item in it"
i have few ideas, but whatever; in Minecraft in an adventure we pick up multiple drops(not same item and they are multiple. that's why inventory is an issue)
I imagine clicking one slot and then clicking on the bundle will transfer an item from our inventory to the bundle's inventory.
and clicking on the bundle will open the inventory similar to a 4x4 crafting grid with the difference that I can scroll it like a recipe list and small (3 inventory in a row) convenient.
now it seems way harder.
The fact that backpacks mods have existed for as long as I remember modding the game, tells you a lot
Useful backpacks mod is a really great solution to inventory solution. Backpacks has 3 lvls with bigger capacities each time you upgrade them.
Also why dafuq mojang still didn't make an infinite inventory with weight as a limit if they're so afraid of backpacks
Thanks to data packs I use bundles on Java all the time, they’re really fantastic for expeditions where you find a bunch of miscellaneous treasure items that would normally fill your whole inventory in just a couple chests.
And when you are mining, you Can put ore into block for them to take even less space in bundles !
@@Feu_Ghost yep, it’s pretty great! Instead of having several slots taken up by ores and ore blocks you can have everything in a single slot
i remember ages ago playing modded, i decided to add an absurd backpack mod that let me put backpacks in backpacks
in a few real world days i had like an 18x24x9 multipage inventory and wow yeah it was really nice basically not having to worry about space and finally feeling like i can breath, while still somehow completely filling my super inventory anyways
given the chance i would far prefer this
but i can see pretty easily why having a functionally infinite inventory is a turn off for alot of people
i'm relatively okay with the inventory as is, throwing away anything that's not critical to me, but i'd definitely love an update to it
They should add some sort of item that will reject certain items from ever coming into your inventory (i.e. rotten flesh, bones, flowers, etc.). I think that's at least part of the solution
Why make it an item when you could just make a filter button for the inventory
The inventory rework proposals overlook the most obvious rework solution.
It doesn't need to be offset.
It doesnt need to expand on columns.
You can just add another row or two.
I mean look at chests. Absolute units in rows
A upgrade to increase inventory size could be rlly cool, I'm fine with being limited early game but after a few in game days or something like that I'd like to get something that makes it bigger
i want you to know that i god damn love your video essays so much
There's another one planned at the moment so look forward to that :)
Bundles would have been fine with leather, but they had to make it a rabbit because those spawn less and are harder to catch.
how did i already forget
Heres another change they can add if they are overhauling inventory: Sorting and dumping. A big problem I have is searching through the chest and trying to remember what items go in what chest, but so many other games solved this with the dump feature that takes all the items in your inventory and moves it into the chest with the same items. If you allow sorting then it will also improve inventory as a whole, and less desirable items will be grouped together so you can throw them out easier.
They can literally just make packbacks or bags that can go on your back with a feature trinkets add. All they add is 6 extra slots, unless you upgrade it getting 12 slots with iron.
You underestimate my ability to have inventory issues in Stardew Valley
the background music at 0:28.......my poor dogs.....those who dont know its from nintendogs when you take the dog for a walk very old game and this got me sad
they should take notes from dragon quest builders 2 on this, were you gan virtually carry all items at once or you need to place special chests to increase said limit.
If i was mojang this will be my fix: add an item, a bag or backpack,which you wear , and you can wear it over things like chestplates and elytras ,and there is going to be a button in the inventory, under the crafting system which will open your bag
Sounds like that inventory change already exists in the game… it’s the creative inventory just not full for survival purposes.
Also a defrag/sort option would do wonders for people that never seem to realize they have 3+ stacks of an item that when combined don’t make up a stack
Tap hold bundle on mobile, then issue solved as you would grab specific amount of items within mobile with tap and hold.
just add backpack slot over the offhand slot. and backpacks can be crafted with leather rand ores-gold , diamond, netherite with requirng 6ores with netherite being different gold one has 8 slots diamond one has 16 and netherite one has 32 and the netherite one can be crafted by using the upgrade template like armors do in the smitthing table.
u click on the back packs and a side bar of items pops up and u can bring items to ur main inventory using tht. i think its a very simple solution
There are chests, double chests, ender chests, Shulker boxes, inventory, and a not yet released bundle