people in comments section should not abuse a person's colour or body...I don't like Barka dutt as a journalist,, but that does not mean I use abusing language against her...it's okay to disagree...but still respect a person..
"It was a big learning". 26/11, the Talwars - all of these are "big learning's" for the media industry. "Big learning's" at the expense of peoples lives.
Last 3 NL interviews.. 1. Promoting Dilip Mehta's documentry/film. 2. Promoting Hindol Sengupta's book 'Being Hindu'. 3. Promoting Barkha Dutt's book 'The Unquiet Land'. Who is paying and who is being served?
+shobhit todi Then why the media keeps complaining about politicians not giving them interviews? Shouldn't they know? Election khatam to Promotion bhi khatam.
+Scrublord My point is if I want to get promoted by paying, I will pay times of India, Aaj Tak, Comedy Nights with Kapil etc why would I pay Newslaundry or thehoot.org
wow...i really like this woman...and the interveiwer is so attentive...and she seems really interested...she is so brave..it takes a lot of courage...you go girl!!
What is most disturbing about people of my gender now is they just don't know how to respect. Women sharing there struggle becomes politics and harassment becomes an instrument of publicity for them. I wonder if I wanted the nation in 18th year of my life to seem so repulsively depressing.
What a shocking justification for showing the live coverage of 26/11! Blaming government for not phoning the editors to stop live coverage. Where was your intelligence!? Even a small kid could have understood that in such hostage situation, not to telecast the images live. Even Madhu Trehan appears to be oblivious to common sense.
24:46 So the only explanation for the never before seen public rage towards the news coverage of 26/11 that your wily brain can come up with is class-based-anger, is it? The scale of the event, the extent of coverage, aiding the terrorists, compromising the safety of the people... these reasons never occurred to you, did they? We can really do without journalists like you who derive sustenance through damaging the social fabric of the country. I think through this interview, Madhu has very cleverly demonstrated why we need a free and fair media, not a media run through corporate interests and nepotism.
TLDR: That is just how she views 26/11. You are welcome to yours. Btw I also do not agree with her views *With all due and humble respects* It may be that this is how she viewed 26/11. She was a reporter and may be she saw some things (which she never mentioned) led her to this conclusion.
The interviewee seems to be more confident than the interviewer. It appears the interview was done smoothly without asking provocative questions as she asks other panelists. Anyway a nice interview to watch.
Amazing interview I find Madhu and Barkha to have rather similar personality. Both are intelligent, know and do their job well and also are extremely passionate ( which sometimes becomes a disadvantage ) One of the best ( and informative) interviews on this channel! Enjoyed it a lot PS: please try & interview Suhasini Haider too
+PRASHANT MISHRA But there is a major difference: you can never find Madhu in the pimping business and acting irresponsibly during terror attacks and other such emergencies. Just because the ruling political party in 2008 was in her pocket, Bdutt misused the media access in Mumbai attacks and helped terrorists with all the information about the security forces' movements.
Vijayan Thankappan You seem to think that she did it on pyrpose, as if, she wanted the innocents in Taj to die? Yes, sounds absurd right?You must be perfect in life . For me, best are the ones who accept their mistakes.The Goverenment then should have immediately stalled live coverage but I guess the then govt itself was getting all information from media!Go ask that gov for apology coz it had no idea that such a big attack was being planned on Mumbai and how badly they handled the attacks!
Prasanna S first of all, mumbai live telecast was not just being done by Barkha, i think it was collective media falut coz everyone went live. Though Barkha is the only onebtht has openly regretted it.I have followed Radia case closely and frankly speaking I don't understand the fuss( may be I missed something) Coz a) She didn't benefit money wise or power wise. Her report didn't favour the ones radia wanted etc So b) She was just playing Radia, coz Radia was the one who would get her important information, That is, the scoops that every good journalist gets by such sources. I heard the tape and I was like OK she knows how to do her job! Then after listening to a private question people started to make it look like she was lying under oath or something Just to be clear, I am not her fan, neither I think she is a saint ( I mean,who is? ) But I know that she is a damn good journalist, which is something as all the good journos are from print media.
this interview comes off as a opportunity for barkha to atone for her mistakes but instead she comes off with the holier than thou attitude. even when she apologises she makes excuses for why she did it. as for her apprehension for Modi not talking to media.... well I think he has a good reasons for not taking to msm . maybe if the msm didn't run a propaganda against BJP and Modi for the last 15yrs then this wouldn't have happened. FYI Modi & BJP do talk to non MSM
*IMHO* Our dear PM Shri Narendra Modi ji just cannot only do interviews bin MSM. He has to do some non MSM interviews (cause a significant percentage of people also follow those and it will also show how well he handles a biased media) and will show a balance
Lol ..just saw the comments! A credible , hardworking, topmost emmy nominated journo, who has the integrity to accept that she had made mistakes in journalism ( how many exceptionally thick skinned journos we find in India have done that ?) , courage to accept she was sexually abused and bravery to cover stories from the ground zero ( Gujarat, Kashmir, war ,floods etc) Is being called 1) anti family 2) feminazi( what does that mean? ) 3) presstitute 4) modi hater 5) anti national ONLY IN INDIA THIS IS POSSIBLE!
+PRASHANT MISHRA presstitute - she is. everyone knows she and her team of NDTV are hard core anti right, anti hindu. they r left leaning, everybody knows that. so no harm in calling them a presstitute or ant modi. anti national, well i am not sure. may be or may not be. feminazi, well we need more of them, india still has huge gender biases in its societies.
***** What's wrong in being left leaning ? I can name many topmost juornos in India who are quite openly ( and respect that they are open about it even though I am not right leaning in my views) right leaning? They are well educated, respected journos who have right wing views.I would never call them presstitute.Never. Also what's wrong in hating Modi? In fact , also, there is nothing wrong in liking Modi. Yes, this is the beauty of democracy!
haha... u know what happens to democracy when u 'lean' LEFT. maybe its a good old ideology, maybe it has done some good to the world. left in India has been more of a means to oppose any govt. that is in the center, supported by the chinese to destabilize India. To me LEFT in India has 2 type of subscribers - 1. the crazy old professors and shabby intellectuals who wire in yuan and take orders from beijing. they r neither loyal nor have any affection towards LEFT they just do it for money. their job - to radicalize vulnerable youth to take up arms which make up the type 2 subscribers. these youth neither know the ideology nor they know what are they fighting for, they r just fascinated by colorful talks of type 1 and like firing bullets and just want to vent out their frustration of their own failure in life. Left in India is more of an outfit to destabilize and hinder growth in India and moreover these presstitutes(the type 1 subscribers to left) lean to left for the same reason to destabilize, to shame India at a global level, their intention - hurt India's growth at any cost. Now that modi is in full swing to help India become a global power and taking radial measures to root out corruption and making good friends at international level, these presstitutes are more but hurt and getting more aggressive. but it is just my views, maybe u see it differently and i welcome ur views, it is in the true sense of democracy to consider everyone's views but do u think u would survive an open talk on democracy in a far left nation like ppl openly talking about far left survive here in a democratic country?
***** You sound autocratic, no wonder you have been so impatient about our democratic history. People used to say the same about Indira Gandhi. Nobody has damaged the face of Indian democracy more than her.Now it looks like fan boys of Narendra Modi are ready to compromise the way constitution works coz you are so impatient. India is dirtier and poorer , has worse standard of living than countries like North Korea, China, Saudi Arabia & Iran but I still think India is better coz we here can be whatever we want.Left( which I am not BTW) right centre etc My dream for India is not for it to become a developed autocracy but a developed democracy where girls, boys transgenders gays SC ST OBC everyone have equal opportunity and acceptable standard of living Where nobody dies of preventable diseases. where no one is killed becoz they were born in a particular caste or have a particular sexual orientation or eat a particular kind of food ..... Where everyone minds their own business but at the same time contribute to society I am in my twenties so I still have hope to be able to one day see that India
PRASHANT MISHRA cheers for the dreams, to urs and mine. though we may defer in views, we both wish the same for India, so lets just agree to disagree. BTW i am in the first half of my 20s as well. And i too have the same hope that u have ;)
This was so opposite of what I was expecting from Madhu for an interview of Barkha, so lame and meaningless. I think Barkha gave the script for this interview. I wasted one hour of my life which I can never get back now :(
+Svaanand Umbarje How do you know its fake? Do tell. She claims to be a victim. As a member of this society if you don't want to support her (and that's fair) , at least don't belittle her feelings. Only the people involved or a court can pass a judgement on what happened.
+vamsibg People like you spew hatred and venom without any logic or reason. So you need to get a life. I am trying to have a conversation with people here. So you should GO FUCK YOURSELF.
+Mohan Bhargava .... I repeat again, fuck off get a life which part of it didn't you understand. Secondly, Burkha Dutt is a birch, the rationale behind this belief is she sold her integrity , morals and ethics which are the important qualities a generalist should have for sake of money and fame and also for trp ratings. she is anti-Hindu, anti-bjp and anti-nationalist. given a chance, I guess, she would sell India to Pakistan. there are many examples.
+Mohan Bhargava may be you should stop explaining so much to such insensitive people who jump to conclusions just because of the pre conceived notion about a self made woman in their filthy mind!
good interview.. very nicely paced..whatever issues with Barkha and Modi (I hate her for that) , totally agree with her experiences being a women.. she should be supported instead being shouted down on her Modi agenda.. She is a women first before being journo or anything..
a unloyal indian???don't fall for her fake book trying to get sympathy and support for her anti hindu approach nice try . check out RAJEEV MALHOTRA'S THE SYSTEMATIC BREAKUP OF INDIA AND THE FIGHT FOR SANSKRIT on utube pass info on to friends and read my comments above please
Let me be the first one to say this on the completely biased comments section: She is an amazing journalist, very few journalists in India are as good. She has unfortunately found herself in very sticky situations, however, that is not something which is uncommon! Currently, there is an anti-journalist atmosphere in the country, without realizing that journalism is the backbone of free-speech and Barkha is leading the charge on that. This whole idea that Modi had called Barkha is too hard to believe, given that Modi has a lied a million times this year alone. So, for all the haters: There is no hidden agenda in any of the reportage in my opinion. Yes, they are anti-BJP, but there are a million other channels, like India TV which are anti-AAP and pro-BJP. This is the journalists' fundamental right to support an idea. In case of Barkha, she supports the idea of secularism and plurality than Modi-sycophancy and I like her for it! I wrote this comment before Madhu made the point at 35:01! This is exactly what the people who have been commenting against Barkha need to realize!
+trueKingOfLoss journalists are never supposed to support an idea or ideology. they are supposed to report plain facts and organize events where learned men and women can come over and discuss on ideas or ideologies. they are supposed to convey and present the facts, not judge on facts.
+pranavg1181 And how did we all forget rajdeep sardesai, these guys have set milestones in irresponsible and biased journalism. It will be extremely difficult for any future journalists to cross these milestones of paid journalism.
Radia tapes showed that Burkha is Congress presstitute.. she made an episode on ndtv on her own book..she even rubbishes it saying I could have only had done it.. btw she looks like Kumar Vishvash of AAP ..:)
I don't always agree with what Barkha says and am quite suspectful of her inclinations, but she is incredibly well-spoken and bloody good at her job. You just can't deny it.
I understand her perspective and the mentality of those who under influence of jingoistic politicians hate her that's what makes me respect her even more. Grow up Indo-Pakistanis !
Such an informative and helpful platform to understand and learn so much from an exceptional way of journalism and media. Glad to come across to such a platform. Great respect for the efforts. Keep spreading knowledge!
Modi gave interviews to many channels except NDTV, and Barkha is not blind to know the reason. The way NDTV helped Congress in 2002 and 10 years after that, in each in every NDTV show like LEFT RIGHT & CENTRE, etc. is not hidden. I am one of many citizens who was enjoying NDTV's dirty journalism. How do you justify yourself when you see your face in the mirror every morning?
Majority of viewers understood the way how the news is covered and how it do facilitate the politically backed ideas .The news channels need to be un biased ,should not link to any political or party Ideology.Such news channels are surely minimal.
See Barkha... When you were misunderstood it hurt you from radia tapes.. and just for 3 months when u were under pressure.. you targeted Modi for 12 years and he never broke down.. thats why he is the PM and you are jobless
If Anthony Mascarenhas had felt like Barkha about "a little bit of self-censorship" in the early 1970s, the world would have perhaps never known about the genocide in Bangladesh.
genocide was one sided whereas here hindus were killed in godhra.. u talk about gujrat not godra.. if ur son and wife were burnt alive wouldnt u be furious.. what would u do in the heat of the moment.. dont try to be the judge of peoples emotions.. just sit where u r comfortable in ur home and dont pass judgements u one sided moron
@@xandercage5004 The debate is about "a little bit of self-censorship" and how journalists could respond to this argument. Not Gujarat or West Bengal, BJP or Congress. Sorry
funny that this smart reporter !! does all the mistakes and gives the same excuses like all the politicians etc that she reports and she wants us to be kind to her !!
Even when you are on India's side says lady govinda ?? somebody do her psychoanalysis and tell on whose side she really is or was it an innocent slip of tongue.?
Did you guys even watch it before criticizing? Her take on Pakistan, Nuclear power and war are quite interesting. But then again you are paid to troll, not listen.
So what?! Please stop your bigotry. Mass communication faculty of Jamia is really prestigious. How can you call yourself an Indian while you stereotype against a nationally authorized Educational institute. How can you insult the Constitutional Seal?
Barkha got enough punishment for her faults which could be unintentional or instinctive for human. But should we not pay some heed on Arnab Gate , TRP scam and Electoral bond scam. By the way, the Golden Words of Justice Chandrachuda: *If you don't like something, then simply don't watch it*
As a young career journalist when she entered the field of journalism, she won many fans. But, she sacrificed all the basic values, ethos and expectations of journalism. She chose to work for an ideology against Bharat. She lost her career.Lost her job. Lost the love and affection people had for her. She is no more a journalist. Pity you Barkha. Prabha Dutt , as a journalist, might in deep sorrow for your forgotten journalist values. Can you keep your mother happy as a daughter, with your personal life.......
Look at her make up, and voice, I am 100 % sure she has distorted facts. Where is her so called BF, or police she tried to report or faculty or lawyers or her family friend or her mother. She is lying for fame and publicity.
Her boyfriend tried to manipulate her by slashing his wrists. And now she writes a slef pitying book to manipulate the readers and divert accusations that she is a Modi hater and vicious anti Modi troll masquerading as a media person. Shameful really. I guess Karan Thappar will soon come out with his own .
The reason for the rage against was not class. We had a congress minister claiming that this was an RSS conspiracy. This was never challenged by the media. And, this big massive intelligence blunder wasn't adequately addressed.
sound something is haunting her which she cant achieve like other experienced journalist .she just explained what she had experienced from the atmosphere she raised ............
Sad your flaws and mistakes in 26/11 cost us so dearly. Always on your own trip Barkha. Your acceptance is not good enough and the public outrage is understandable.
play time 12.40 minutes u use the word "ISLAMIST" for one group who don't prefer peace. rather than using any other word. Islam has come from the word Salam means peace so please don't use this type of word's in future for any group that affect any religious beliefs of anyone. I appreciate your work for awareness of people without any discrimination of religion.. please.....
So Innocent, So Honest, So Patriotic, So Humble, So Truthful................... She Does Need Gripe water after this interview !
Lol
+Mahender Singh Rajpurohit hahaha, I surely need gripe water after watching this interview :)
😂😂
people in comments section should not abuse a person's colour or body...I don't like Barka dutt as a journalist,, but that does not mean I use abusing language against her...it's okay to disagree...but still respect a person..
She deserves that. It's not about agreement. It's a fact.
"It was a big learning". 26/11, the Talwars - all of these are "big learning's" for the media industry. "Big learning's" at the expense of peoples lives.
Still they repeated everything in SSR case
Last 3 NL interviews..
1. Promoting Dilip Mehta's documentry/film.
2. Promoting Hindol Sengupta's book 'Being Hindu'.
3. Promoting Barkha Dutt's book 'The Unquiet Land'.
Who is paying and who is being served?
+Scrublord bhai log interview promotion ke liye hi dete hai
+shobhit todi Then why the media keeps complaining about politicians not giving them interviews? Shouldn't they know? Election khatam to Promotion bhi khatam.
+Scrublord if interviewees are paying NL then i wonder about their intelligence. Whom will you pay to mainstream or marginalised media ?
Ankur Jain or NL doesn't cost much?
+Scrublord My point is if I want to get promoted by paying, I will pay times of India, Aaj Tak, Comedy Nights with Kapil etc why would I pay Newslaundry or thehoot.org
Barkha Barka > Yes Papa !
Pimping deals? No Papa!
Telling lies? No Papa!
Shall we play the tapes?
ha ha ha!!
Hilarious😁
No kidding 🤣
Jabardast 😂😂
wow...i really like this woman...and the interveiwer is so attentive...and she seems really interested...she is so brave..it takes a lot of courage...you go girl!!
Love the way Dutt tries to be extra courteous during the goodbye, with five "thank you's."
Arey yaar itna close up shot leke darate kyu ho.
+vrajrulez Yeahm because she is in a beauty contest, and has to be pretty to be taken seriously. -_-
+shoorveer singh c is nt normal, c is scary...lol..
bhai door se bhi dar lagta hai
This is so sexist.
XD
it was more like Madhu trehan defending her on nira radia tape issue !laughable interview this one !
What is most disturbing about people of my gender now is they just don't know how to respect. Women sharing there struggle becomes politics and harassment becomes an instrument of publicity for them.
I wonder if I wanted the nation in 18th year of my life to seem so repulsively depressing.
She is lying about Surat. It was small under the tree idol in KUTCH.
What a shocking justification for showing the live coverage of 26/11! Blaming government for not phoning the editors to stop live coverage. Where was your intelligence!? Even a small kid could have understood that in such hostage situation, not to telecast the images live. Even Madhu Trehan appears to be oblivious to common sense.
Barkha repeatedly said, 'even without anyone else telling us we should have thought it iut ourselves " she completely agreed they all made mistake.
24:46 So the only explanation for the never before seen public rage towards the news coverage of 26/11 that your wily brain can come up with is class-based-anger, is it? The scale of the event, the extent of coverage, aiding the terrorists, compromising the safety of the people... these reasons never occurred to you, did they?
We can really do without journalists like you who derive sustenance through damaging the social fabric of the country. I think through this interview, Madhu has very cleverly demonstrated why we need a free and fair media, not a media run through corporate interests and nepotism.
TLDR: That is just how she views 26/11. You are welcome to yours. Btw I also do not agree with her views
*With all due and humble respects* It may be that this is how she viewed 26/11. She was a reporter and may be she saw some things (which she never mentioned) led her to this conclusion.
CLOSE UP shot mat lo yaar.
😂😂😂😂😂
No bro it’s too harsh,specially for a woman
Both actually are more beautiful than your mother.
how much madhu have taken for such easy interview???
What would you like to have seen in the interview ?
+Hit Ler How less you study and read for such dumb comment Shit ler ?
Much lesser than Sudhir chou
Madhu Trehan owns the NewsLaundry channel
The interviewee seems to be more confident than the interviewer. It appears the interview was done smoothly without asking provocative questions as she asks other panelists.
Anyway a nice interview to watch.
She went easy on because she knew Barkha is not going to take responsibilty for any decisions she made.
Amazing interview
I find Madhu and Barkha to have rather similar personality. Both are intelligent, know and do their job well and also are extremely passionate
( which sometimes becomes a disadvantage )
One of the best ( and informative) interviews on this channel!
Enjoyed it a lot
PS: please try & interview Suhasini Haider too
+PRASHANT MISHRA But there is a major difference: you can never find Madhu in the pimping business and acting irresponsibly during terror attacks and other such emergencies. Just because the ruling political party in 2008 was in her pocket, Bdutt misused the media access in Mumbai attacks and helped terrorists with all the information about the security forces' movements.
Vijayan Thankappan You seem to think that she did it on pyrpose, as if, she wanted the innocents in Taj to die? Yes, sounds absurd right?You must be perfect in life . For me, best are the ones who accept their mistakes.The Goverenment then should have immediately stalled live coverage but I guess the then govt itself was getting all information from media!Go ask that gov for apology coz it had no idea that such a big attack was being planned on Mumbai and how badly they handled the attacks!
Prasanna S first of all, mumbai live telecast was not just being done by Barkha, i think it was collective media falut coz everyone went live. Though Barkha is the only onebtht has openly regretted it.I have followed Radia case closely and frankly speaking I don't understand the fuss( may be I missed something)
Coz a) She didn't benefit money wise or power wise. Her report didn't favour the ones radia wanted etc
So b) She was just playing Radia, coz Radia was the one who would get her important information, That is, the scoops that every good journalist gets by such sources. I heard the tape and I was like OK she knows how to do her job! Then after listening to a private question people started to make it look like she was lying under oath or something
Just to be clear, I am not her fan, neither I think she is a saint ( I mean,who is? )
But I know that she is a damn good journalist, which is something as all the good journos are from print media.
+PRASHANT MISHRA Chill dude, she has you in her control, the most oppurtunistic journalism at its best and Barkha leads the pack.
+PRASHANT MISHRA Agree . Both stalwarts of journalism , ruled their profession in their prime.
Good interview! So many ethical calls to make in this profession which one can only be sure of in hindsight
this interview comes off as a opportunity for barkha to atone for her mistakes but instead she comes off with the holier than thou attitude. even when she apologises she makes excuses for why she did it.
as for her apprehension for Modi not talking to media.... well I think he has a good reasons for not taking to msm . maybe if the msm didn't run a propaganda against BJP and Modi for the last 15yrs then this wouldn't have happened. FYI Modi & BJP do talk to non MSM
Lol . What is MSM ? ( assume its main stream media ) never heard that acronym
Mohan Bhargava Main stream media
*IMHO* Our dear PM Shri Narendra Modi ji just cannot only do interviews bin MSM. He has to do some non MSM interviews (cause a significant percentage of people also follow those and it will also show how well he handles a biased media) and will show a balance
Lol ..just saw the comments!
A credible , hardworking, topmost emmy nominated journo, who has the integrity to accept that she had made mistakes in journalism ( how many exceptionally thick skinned journos we find in India have done that ?) , courage to accept she was sexually abused and bravery to cover stories from the ground zero ( Gujarat, Kashmir, war ,floods etc)
Is being called
1) anti family
2) feminazi( what does that mean? )
3) presstitute
4) modi hater
5) anti national
ONLY IN INDIA THIS IS POSSIBLE!
+PRASHANT MISHRA presstitute - she is. everyone knows she and her team of NDTV are hard core anti right, anti hindu. they r left leaning, everybody knows that. so no harm in calling them a presstitute or ant modi. anti national, well i am not sure. may be or may not be. feminazi, well we need more of them, india still has huge gender biases in its societies.
***** What's wrong in being left leaning ? I can name many topmost juornos in India who are quite openly ( and respect that they are open about it even though I am not right leaning in my views) right leaning? They are well educated, respected journos who have right wing views.I would never call them presstitute.Never. Also what's wrong in hating Modi? In fact , also, there is nothing wrong in liking Modi. Yes, this is the beauty of democracy!
haha... u know what happens to democracy when u 'lean' LEFT. maybe its a good old ideology, maybe it has done some good to the world. left in India has been more of a means to oppose any govt. that is in the center, supported by the chinese to destabilize India.
To me LEFT in India has 2 type of subscribers - 1. the crazy old professors and shabby intellectuals who wire in yuan and take orders from beijing. they r neither loyal nor have any affection towards LEFT they just do it for money. their job - to radicalize vulnerable youth to take up arms which make up the type 2 subscribers. these youth neither know the ideology nor they know what are they fighting for, they r just fascinated by colorful talks of type 1 and like firing bullets and just want to vent out their frustration of their own failure in life. Left in India is more of an outfit to destabilize and hinder growth in India and moreover these presstitutes(the type 1 subscribers to left) lean to left for the same reason to destabilize, to shame India at a global level, their intention - hurt India's growth at any cost. Now that modi is in full swing to help India become a global power and taking radial measures to root out corruption and making good friends at international level, these presstitutes are more but hurt and getting more aggressive.
but it is just my views, maybe u see it differently and i welcome ur views, it is in the true sense of democracy to consider everyone's views but do u think u would survive an open talk on democracy in a far left nation like ppl openly talking about far left survive here in a democratic country?
***** You sound autocratic, no wonder you have been so impatient about our democratic history.
People used to say the same about Indira Gandhi. Nobody has damaged the face of Indian democracy more than her.Now it looks like fan boys of Narendra Modi are ready to compromise the way constitution works coz you are so impatient.
India is dirtier and poorer , has worse standard of living than countries like North Korea, China, Saudi Arabia & Iran but I still think India is better coz we here can be whatever we want.Left( which I am not BTW) right centre etc
My dream for India is not for it to become a developed autocracy but a developed democracy where girls, boys transgenders gays SC ST OBC everyone have equal opportunity and acceptable standard of living
Where nobody dies of preventable diseases. where no one is killed becoz they were born in a particular caste or have a particular sexual orientation or eat a particular kind of food .....
Where everyone minds their own business but at the same time contribute to society
I am in my twenties so I still have hope to be able to one day see that India
PRASHANT MISHRA cheers for the dreams, to urs and mine. though we may defer in views, we both wish the same for India, so lets just agree to disagree. BTW i am in the first half of my 20s as well. And i too have the same hope that u have ;)
This was so opposite of what I was expecting from Madhu for an interview of Barkha, so lame and meaningless. I think Barkha gave the script for this interview. I wasted one hour of my life which I can never get back now :(
I did'nt expect Madhu Trehan to go soft on the Radia tapes. Clearly a fixed interview
What about Amit Shah or Modi ? All their interviews are fixed or pre-planned.
how to give your newly published book publicity?
put a fake sexual harassment incident that actually didn't happen.
+Svaanand Umbarje How do you know its fake? Do tell. She claims to be a victim. As a member of this society if you don't want to support her (and that's fair) , at least don't belittle her feelings. Only the people involved or a court can pass a judgement on what happened.
+Mohan Bhargava - fuck off and get a life.. seems you are a chamcha of that Bitch.
+vamsibg People like you spew hatred and venom without any logic or reason. So you need to get a life. I am trying to have a conversation with people here. So you should GO FUCK YOURSELF.
+Mohan Bhargava .... I repeat again, fuck off get a life which part of it didn't you understand.
Secondly, Burkha Dutt is a birch, the rationale behind this belief is she sold her integrity , morals and ethics which are the important qualities a generalist should have for sake of money and fame and also for trp ratings. she is anti-Hindu, anti-bjp and anti-nationalist. given a chance, I guess, she would sell India to Pakistan. there are many examples.
+Mohan Bhargava may be you should stop explaining so much to such insensitive people who jump to conclusions just because of the pre conceived notion about a self made woman in their filthy mind!
barkha ji....you are an excellent journalist.....you dare to show d real image of kashmir!LOVE FROM JMU KASHMIR
What nonsense are you saying? Barkha Dutt is a Pimp Journalist, she only works for those who have dirty money
good interview.. very nicely paced..whatever issues with Barkha and Modi (I hate her for that) , totally agree with her experiences being a women.. she should be supported instead being shouted down on her Modi agenda.. She is a women first before being journo or anything..
But it's just sad how people are. Blind in unnecessary following people's loyalties.
a unloyal indian???don't fall for her fake book trying to get sympathy and support for her anti hindu approach nice try . check out RAJEEV MALHOTRA'S THE SYSTEMATIC BREAKUP OF INDIA AND THE FIGHT FOR SANSKRIT on utube pass info on to friends and read my comments above please
saurabh your abs have killed me and I feel elated
Let me be the first one to say this on the completely biased comments section: She is an amazing journalist, very few journalists in India are as good. She has unfortunately found herself in very sticky situations, however, that is not something which is uncommon!
Currently, there is an anti-journalist atmosphere in the country, without realizing that journalism is the backbone of free-speech and Barkha is leading the charge on that.
This whole idea that Modi had called Barkha is too hard to believe, given that Modi has a lied a million times this year alone.
So, for all the haters: There is no hidden agenda in any of the reportage in my opinion. Yes, they are anti-BJP, but there are a million other channels, like India TV which are anti-AAP and pro-BJP. This is the journalists' fundamental right to support an idea. In case of Barkha, she supports the idea of secularism and plurality than Modi-sycophancy and I like her for it!
I wrote this comment before Madhu made the point at 35:01! This is exactly what the people who have been commenting against Barkha need to realize!
+trueKingOfLoss journalists are never supposed to support an idea or ideology. they are supposed to report plain facts and organize events where learned men and women can come over and discuss on ideas or ideologies. they are supposed to convey and present the facts, not judge on facts.
+Deeps 91 Why?
trueKingOfLoss 'why' like in'why so serious'?
+Deeps 91 No, why as in why should journalists not draw conclusions based on facts?
+trueKingOfLoss Reporter reports, listener or viewer decides.
Barkha's theory of class on the post 26/11 anti-media rage is bang on.
Just came to know that she has the blood of our soldiers in her hand after listening to J sai Deepak. I was under impression that she was good but no.
Barkha has to be the worst journalist ever in Indian journalism
+Arun Gadamsetty Why ??? Could you please enlighten us.
no there is another journalist karan thapar..difficult to say who is worst
very true bro
+Arun Gadamsetty Not at all.. she has a competition Sagarika Ghosh..!!
+pranavg1181 And how did we all forget rajdeep sardesai, these guys have set milestones in irresponsible and biased journalism. It will be extremely difficult for any future journalists to cross these milestones of paid journalism.
Radia tapes showed that Burkha is Congress presstitute.. she made an episode on ndtv on her own book..she even rubbishes it saying I could have only had done it.. btw she looks like Kumar Vishvash of AAP ..:)
she went really easy on her :P
This interview seems to be highly edited. Look at the newspapers in the background. They are different OR are they two sets ?
Big Learning!!? Fuckin' Convenient!!! Our Soldiers lost their lives thanks to the coverage!!
I don't always agree with what Barkha says and am quite suspectful of her inclinations, but she is incredibly well-spoken and bloody good at her job. You just can't deny it.
please provide a .pdf version online. barkha is not a.commercial person i hope
What ???
Loved the honesty of both these women from media. Will Mr. Modi give interview to one of them instead of giving interview to Akshay Kumar?
Commendable interview Madhu, it was so obvious how Barkha reacted to iron handed questions, exposing her reality. Well done.
Loved the honesty of both these women.
I understand her perspective and the mentality of those who under influence of jingoistic politicians hate her that's what makes me respect her even more.
Grow up Indo-Pakistanis !
"... on Kashmir, of course, which you are... really quite obsessed with..." hahaha
Its a serious damage of some server space... nearly 200MB gone for this interview and Most of the viewers data too...
Couldn't agree more !
Nice to see two stalwarts of Indian journalism on the same screen
such a liar , she knows she reported violence inciting images, u don't need rocket science degree to understand the ethics
Mothers-in -law not mother-in -laws ladies
Romesh Khardori I think you missed that there could have been an apostrophe Sherlock.
Such an informative and helpful platform to understand and learn so much from an exceptional way of journalism and media. Glad to come across to such a platform. Great respect for the efforts. Keep spreading knowledge!
Modi gave interviews to many channels except NDTV, and Barkha is not blind to know the reason.
The way NDTV helped Congress in 2002 and 10 years after that, in each in every NDTV show like LEFT RIGHT & CENTRE, etc. is not hidden. I am one of many citizens who was enjoying NDTV's dirty journalism. How do you justify yourself when you see your face in the mirror every morning?
You forgot Kargil , 26/11 etc....
These Journo has blood of many people on their hand....
"Big learning " at the cost of so many of our soldiers lives! Ridiculous Barkha!
Majority of viewers understood the way how the news is covered and how it do facilitate the politically backed ideas .The news channels need to be un biased ,should not link to any political or party Ideology.Such news channels are surely minimal.
See Barkha... When you were misunderstood it hurt you from radia tapes.. and just for 3 months when u were under pressure.. you targeted Modi for 12 years and he never broke down.. thats why he is the PM and you are jobless
you have made this channel baniya ki Dukan...conducting the interviews as gossip..still ask us to support...
If barkha reads comment she would cry
Bharka dutt never grow old ? bold and beautiful. I am your fan .
She always looks like 48
If Anthony Mascarenhas had felt like Barkha about "a little bit of self-censorship" in the early 1970s, the world would have perhaps never known about the genocide in Bangladesh.
genocide was one sided whereas here hindus were killed in godhra.. u talk about gujrat not godra.. if ur son and wife were burnt alive wouldnt u be furious.. what would u do in the heat of the moment.. dont try to be the judge of peoples emotions.. just sit where u r comfortable in ur home and dont pass judgements u one sided moron
@@xandercage5004 I'm referring to East Pakistan (now Bangladesh). Not Gujarat!
@@fredericknoronha9998 of course i know.. iam referring to u using barkha dutts name in this context... she is taken in the context of gujrat right?
@@xandercage5004 The debate is about "a little bit of self-censorship" and how journalists could respond to this argument. Not Gujarat or West Bengal, BJP or Congress. Sorry
@@fredericknoronha9998 Yup u said the self sensorship is actually not required.. whereas iam telling it is
Came to see who is madhu trehan..heard lots of bad about her.snd now I came to know they are right
funny that this smart reporter !! does all the mistakes and gives the same excuses like all the politicians etc that she reports and she wants us to be kind to her !!
Although her shrill theatrics have been offesive.. I think Barkha Dutt is a honest journalist who is committed to her profession.
barkha has such a great vocabulary .....she has such new words she is the best......
Even when you are on India's side says lady govinda ?? somebody do her psychoanalysis and tell on whose side she really is or was it an innocent slip of tongue.?
Did you guys even watch it before criticizing? Her take on Pakistan, Nuclear power and war are quite interesting. But then again you are paid to troll, not listen.
Barkha Dutt may lose all her support but I'll be there always
always
***** Always as in Severus Snape's words "ALWAYS"
+Swastik Sharma yes because ndtv's news contents are not based on trp not to create a particular propaganda in the society.. :-)
Wow Madhu.... You are just incredible!
even when you are on India's side?
BD finally agreeing that being on India's side is optional for her
+Amit Singh 38.00
Loved Brakha's Insights on women who work.
And you want us to donate for newlaundry ?
They are asking for subscriptions. They are not begging to you.
Feel like this interview poked into a lot of topics. But needed to spend more time on a few important subjects.
Great Respect Maam
barkha a true journalist.. brave lady
I just checked her wikipedia, no wonder why she is staunch supporter of congress as she received so many awards in congress raj. Now I know
whatever went wrong with Barkha has a honest reason behind it. But when it comes to others, there is no escaping..
Barkha is always correct or she is not aware ! duh
+steelnerve lol . Whe does not satisfactorily explain her mistakes
This evil lady shouldn't be let anywhere close to a conflict. She has caused more harm than anyone else
Barkha dutt and Rajdeep sardasai should be sent to Pakistan as our diwali gift .good riddence
Keep this Interview away from children. It can be dangerous bcz of Barkha
So barkha has done masters from Jamia- Enough said
So what?! Please stop your bigotry. Mass communication faculty of Jamia is really prestigious. How can you call yourself an Indian while you stereotype against a nationally authorized Educational institute. How can you insult the Constitutional Seal?
Jahil insan. There are great personalities and prestigious alumnis passed out from jamia from all religions. Gufa putr.
Im surprised Burkha didn't say Modi is directly responsible and is able to intelligently bifurcate the 2.
Barkha got enough punishment for her faults which could be unintentional or instinctive for human. But should we not pay some heed on Arnab Gate , TRP scam and Electoral bond scam.
By the way, the Golden Words of Justice Chandrachuda: *If you don't like something, then simply don't watch it*
As a young career journalist when she entered the field of journalism, she won many fans.
But, she sacrificed all the basic values, ethos and expectations of journalism. She chose to work for an ideology against Bharat.
She lost her career.Lost her job. Lost the love and affection people had for her.
She is no more a journalist.
Pity you Barkha.
Prabha Dutt , as a journalist, might in deep sorrow for your forgotten journalist values.
Can you keep your mother happy as a daughter, with your personal life.......
What about her coverage of 26/11and Kargil war
Barkha Dutt - A (once) brilliant journalist gone foolish.
B dutt is one of the worst journalist india ever seen. ,barkha get out of your proffession
Government and the journalists were committing grave mistakes during 26/11. But the question is why were they doing it....just trying to learn?
We proud of you #BarkhaDutt ma'am
Maybe nobody really knows the truth, but atleast she's trying to be on the right side. That's the best you'd get.
Standard answer to all accusations, Barkha has is, WHY DIDNT YOU ASK IT EARLIER !! RAFOLWA !!
Look at her make up, and voice, I am 100 % sure she has distorted facts. Where is her so called BF, or police she tried to report or faculty or lawyers or her family friend or her mother. She is lying for fame and publicity.
Her boyfriend tried to manipulate her by slashing his wrists. And now she writes a slef pitying book to manipulate the readers and divert accusations that she is a Modi hater and vicious anti Modi troll masquerading as a media person. Shameful really.
I guess Karan Thappar will soon come out with his own .
expected some tough questions.. u let her go easy
It's MotherS -in- law!! DaughterS-in-law!! NOT mother-in-laws!!! Why do people get it so wrong?!? Especially journalists?? Really shameful!
The reason for the rage against was not class. We had a congress minister claiming that this was an RSS conspiracy. This was never challenged by the media. And, this big massive intelligence blunder wasn't adequately addressed.
When will Indian mainstream media produce journalists who are humanists and not just slaves/apologists for the nation-state and powerful interests?
never
she must be tried in court of law for reporting and giving way location
NObody gives you india's point of view because you work stories based on pakistan's point of view burkha dutt
I have a question to @newslaundry if they can take it
sound something is haunting her which she cant achieve like other experienced journalist .she just explained what she had experienced from the atmosphere she raised ............
38:00 She says, 'Even when you are on India's side'.... slip of tongue.
If everybody is after you about Kargil war so are you and other presitutes after Modi even after he is exonerated by the courts.
It sounded more like nukkad pe charcha - street chat - then a serious interview
Some ppl need to be canned publicly...
Sad your flaws and mistakes in 26/11 cost us so dearly. Always on your own trip Barkha. Your acceptance is not good enough and the public outrage is understandable.
play time 12.40 minutes u use the word "ISLAMIST" for one group who don't prefer peace. rather than using any other word.
Islam has come from the word Salam means peace
so please don't use this type of word's in future for any group that affect any religious beliefs of anyone.
I appreciate your work for awareness of people without any discrimination of religion..
please.....