He is. But this is a risky adventure. once you are in flow, you never know what will spill out. These kind of podcasts sound adventurous but are potential security risks. Besides, there is nothing to learn except walking away with a feeling that yeah our R&AW is blah blah.
@@zfold4702 Raw agents are taught to change stories, time, places and many details while narrating a story or incident due to security purpose. Do you really think they are so stupid to make such mistake? Never underestimate any kind of secret agency, they have lot more going behind the scenes.
He was a RAW officer, He knows what to speak and what to lie. He knows how to entertain us. Only intelligent men can understand this comment. You cannot figure out how many lies and how many truths he spoke.
The guy looks like a normal harmless uncle …he projects himself and the agency as a harmless entity but we all know how much he and the agency is capable of
0:00 - Introduction 5:43 - How R&AW operates 8:43 - Key roles of R&AW 14:48 - Understanding spies 16:35 - Work distribution in R&AW 19:29 - Double agent: Ravindra Singh’s story 26:49 - R&AW's approach to double agents 28:33 - CIA's approach to double agents 33:09 - Building trust among R&AW officers 38:31 - Everyone has a price 39:43 - The highest price he paid 43:43 - Funding and budget limitations 44:14 - R&AW's recruitment process 46:21 - Qualities needed in agents 49:04 - Balancing friendship in operations 50:21 - Sacrifices made by R&AW agents 52:51 - Family life and responsibilities 57:51 - R&AW officer’s salary 59:15 - Amar Bhushan’s pre-R&AW life 1:01:39 - Misconceptions about R&AW 1:03:50 - Top intelligence agencies worldwide 1:04:54 - How ISI operates 1:06:32 - R&AW training process 1:07:29 - Beating surveillance tactics 1:10:34 - Life post-retirement 1:11:34 - The "k*lling culture" in R&AW 1:13:26 - Morality and ethics in intelligence 1:14:26 - Regret after missions 1:16:48 - Podcast conclusion 1:17:18 - Outro
bro there was no need to ask him ki 'kabhi apko bura nhi lgta innocent logo ko marne mai' 100 times. why were u trying to guilt trip him huh? show some maturity and respect Raj. I am not saying that he shouldn't have asked that, asking that question is completely fine, but y ask him 3-4 times??
Was also observing the same wrt the US interference in India's domestic politics using Protests as a tool to destabilize the country and also using CIA to perform a coup in Bangladesh after Hasina refused to give a military base to USA
Many many thanks to you for holding such a wonderful talking session with our revered EX RAW officer who described about RAW function and operation for the interest of country. Jai Hind Shekhar N Delhi
@@VikashKumar-kw5ck yes, joint secretary & field officers hote hai. Field officers agents or spies hote hai, jo apne assets & sources ka circle banaate hai, aur joint secretary ko office ke int aur information dete hai. Sochne ka aur brain lagane ka kaam joint secretary jo ki high rank officers hote hai, wei karte hai analysis wagera. Jaise ki yeh sir hai. Waise sir waakei mei bade smartly & wisely answers diye hai, kuch baatein batakar kuch deny kar diya indirectly. Kyonki yeh field officer nahi balki joint secretary or high rank officer reh chuke hai, isliye innke bolne ka bht se matlab bann sakta hai. So, bht se baaton ko deny kar diya smoothly. 😅
Many of you guys thinking that He is telling every truth about raw of not elimination enemies and he is simultaneously projecting raw's capabilities. But guys believe me he is telling a very small truth to you
Bro, then why u want to spell those which he had to be preserved, u know what many agencies are working to collect this kind of podcast to read and know the intention about Raw like agencies of india 😂😂😂
I feel petty about the host that he he think the seasoned RAW officer will share everything.. remember the first sentence he said to the host .. the reason he came to only his podcast.. and he made the host psycho…impact.. I only think that RAW sent this veteran to the podcast😊.
Huge respect for R&AW officer Vikas Yadav who came back to India safely. How difficult it would be to escape US. As sir mentioned in podcast, no legal backing, so sad for Vikas sir😢
😂😂😂😂he didnt go to u.s first of all,he juz hired gupta to kill pannu,then gupta approach dia secret officer,failed mission,usa caught red handed,the end,
@@Funny.fail.videos007 He went to US and setup everything and attempted assisination and then escaped that why CIA is furious to find him. India v ab CIA ki tarah operate karna shuru kiya. Pahle Nizzar aur Ab Pannu
Lots of students want to live this life. Thanks to you at least I could share the POV of an R&W with my students. Thank you so much for the PODCAST. Tomorrow I was telling my bhabhi about the PODCAST culture... BIG THANK YOU
I deeply urge Anchor not to invite security personnel's in such podcasts for sake of views / money. This is not only threat to national security but to all the people. As a honest citizens we need to be responsible and accountable for the job we are doing. Look minor loopholes in the system could cost huge. Just a thought..
@@zubyr2474your location is revealed.....bahar nikalna mat .....I will tell you at 11 am morning what to do ....don't be over smart ......you know my sniping ability
Stories are inspired by true events,our intention and imaginative makes it unique.. respect your job don't make judgement based on mere Stories which are for manipulating people and lead them by their thoughts
Before this podcast scene in India, i think such information was already at the public disposal through books and memoirs of the ex-RA&W agents and I think the things which they are discussing are at a very surface level which intellectuals from every other country know already
Thank you raj Its very informative n great to the one who is willing to be part R&W ❤ Even we can implement things in day to day life as he mentioned discipline he followed 🫡 for more than 3 yrs N life of people routines they had Overall its such a pleasure to watch great personalities of India 🇮🇳 ❤
Salute to these silent heroes of Bharat. Their and their families sacrifice is truly remarkable. Every Bharatiya is indebted for their safety to these silent heroes. शत शत नमन.
Lol...look at the craftsmanship of the ex officer.... he mentioned about the secret's act ...and still the host is asking questions about his actions and activities 😂😂😂
Can't believe i am listening to such people whom i planned in head chats with... Its like dream roundtable... Made possible in this channel. Gratitude.
He is a great person and self less man. You are the Hero of our country . You are inspiration of many people . Thank you to our unknown warriors. Love from heart ❤❤❤
Loved the discussion, pls bring more of the guest from intelligence department. especially how they operate within the country and some mission in neighbouring countries.
@@QuantumNinja1.9 there are already books written by ex officers which talked about operations of raw in Sikkim, Nagaland, punjab and in Srilanka etc etc. This is no big deal
@@saitama- books stay under th radar but podcast is a different thing in this volatile world. Also in Books you can write something but it's still checked by you many times for accuracy and secrecy but in podcast it's almost a one time thing you can reveal something that you don't want to. That's poses a risk on bluff techniques.
I saw many podcast...but you're the one who genuine asked the perfect questions...and i truly waiting for your next podcast desperately... love you brother 🤝❤️💯
Very depressed by watching this.. no good charter available for R&Aw like CIA, no authority do anything, No goverment backing.. our airforce & Navy is signing pact with UBER & sharing all personal details with them. Where is national security stand ? What are we doing. Countries are monitoring you by your fitness band, doing mobile & pager blasts & what are we doing? Really concerning things
Don't worry bro, we have lots of services apart from this podcast statement, and u think we are at just to do about, even we have done apart from this, don't worry, we do more than pager and internet clashes, do u ever think what was the reason behind which indicates India as top ranked on internet shutting down? Think ones, actually our civilians are so dumb and they don't want to respect our government and their policies, otherwise we had some extraordinary services which were lead to enhance identity
@@mohanj8511 definitely, he had to do that, otherwise he sounds dumb, nhi aap mujhe batao, CIA, ISIS aur jitni bhi agency hai vo sab ke sab india ki Raw bnd krna chahti h, aise ME hm apna poll kyun khole
@@shayranapoem1 bro / sis i get you. par wo ISIS nhi hai wo ISI hai , pak intel agency , ISIS wo syria ka terrorist organisation hai , jyada fark toh nhi hai un dono me but fir bhi. you are right n thats what i was trying to say , ofc wo pura sach toh nhi bolenge na? RAW ko secret service bolte hai for a reason , wo saare secrets reveal krdenge toh wo kaise secret agency hai.
I didn't wanted to say but Raj your information and questions are derived from movies and macho stories, these are the most authentic answers I have ever heard and all the working structure of our R&AW without any violence and support charter is commendable. Hats of to you Sir.
Pure podcasts are very good very informative and I like The way you put your questions upfront. Because it is informative And most of them are related to global politics and spies I like them a lot.
Raj I did not subscribe to your channel because you usually call nonsense gossip people. But today I have subscribed. Please call true patriotic guests on your show. Jai Hind!
Do you know that so many many people aren't even aware about diplomacy! I have been a diplomat in school 🎒🏫 ! People may dislike diplomats at first but gradually they start realising the importance of diplomats! All diplomats are blessed by : Jupiter! #Shukra-#Brihaspati!
Raj raise no of questions instead of stucking with one or two otherwise it ws fun watching our hero. He repeatedly said we are capable for anything depends on charter happy to hear that.
Director saheb sab jaante hai but bolna nhi chahte.......RAW ke director se information aise kaise nikaal sakte ho RAJ bhai, thats why he was a director...
The police mentality has undermined the R&AW. We can see the debacles happening around us starting from Covid, 2020, Afghanistan, Iran, Bangladesh, USA Canada. Serious reforms required to reform the agency to a professional agency. Mixing of internal security mindset of IB, police cannot be equated with R&AW. External covert ops require a very serious professional work done by hardcore experts.
His aura, his way of talking, his personality actually seems like real secret service agent, same like I used to see Interviews of former CIA directors and agents. Unlike lucky bisht 😂😂
Lucky ek field officer or Agent tha, jo apne source ka circle banaakar senior joint secretary ko inform dete. Dimaag innke jaise joint secretary high rank officials dete hai, aur field officer or agents ko bas follow karna hota hai.
@@jethiya7990bhai woh tha. Innhone bol toh diya ki Joint secretary high rank officers hote hai, aur ek field officer or agents hote hai. Lucky Bisht bhi jaise bolte hai, unnhone bht baar bola h ki, woh waise peish aate hai jis tarah se saamne waale ko khudko dikhana hota hai. Jaisa dikhta hai waisa nahi hota kuch bhi secret agencies ke world mei. Aur woh unhi baaton ka zikra karte hai jo already revealed hai aur jinpar books & stories likha gaya ho. Unnko bhi upar se instructions diya gaya hoga protocols ki kya bolna hai aur kya nahi. Aur yeh sir ne isliye kuch baaton ka deny kiya kyonki yeh joint secretary thei, aur innke baaton ko jo bhi dekhega, bht baariki se dekhega. So harmless bolna aaj ke geopolitics ka demand hai. Otherwise humare desh ke upar Unknown gunmen ke allegations lagaya gaya hai West ke kuch countries ke taraf se. So bht se andar ki baatein hai, jismei deny & accept with wise words zaruri h ek high rank official ke taraf se. Waise yes, Lucky Bisht was an secret agent or field officer, unnpe sachmei kuch books hai. Aur iss tarah ke field officer pe believe nahi h toh Ravindra Kaushik ji ke baare mei research kar lo, woh bhi ek field officer or agent hi thei, but Joint secretary or high rank officer nahi. Waise hi agents & spies kisiko bhi le sakte hai, military service se, police se, normal job person ya koi bhi, but high rank officer ke liye UPSC se ranked officer zaruri hai. Dono ke liye kuch criteria fit rehna zaruri hai, jiske baare mei innhone bataya & even Lucky bisht ne bhi kuch kuch podcast mei bataya tha. So, respect them brother, chahe innke jaise Joint secretary or high rank officer ho ya Lucky bisht jaise Field officer or agents. Jai hind🙏 🇮🇳
@@abhisheksonawane4678yes field officer jisko agents bhi bolte hai. Innhone kuch baatein smartly deny kiya, kyonki deny karna zaruri tha. Because bht se allegations lage hai west Countries ke taraf se, unknown gunmen wala. So yeh zaruri hai. Yahi toh khaasiyat hai, ki humare secret Services secret ko secret rakhna jaante hai. Jo revealed hai unnko revealed bhi rakhte hai saath mei deny bhi karte hai. Taaki duniya hi confuse mei rahe. Aur secret secret hi reh jaye
#ASKMrShamani, Please bring in Mr Dhirendra Kumar, the founder and CEO of Value Research. He is a great value addition to the podcast. Not bringing him to the podcast is a great disservice to the loyal subscribers who consistently give you their valuable time as support and value exchange. Thank you for the podcast episode
Raj pls in the last it felt like you are trying to make him feel bad.. he has served the nation with grace and honour.. the least you could do is to say Thanks for your service.. but again you were like ask ignorant questions!! But hats off to sir who gracefully answered the question without a sling of anger. A humble request is to please correct your line of questioning!!
"I just wanted to take a moment to express how much I enjoyed your recent content. It was engaging, informative, and really resonated with me. I believe that more videos like this would not only benefit your audience but also help your channel grow. Please continue to share such valuable material, as it truly makes a difference. Keep up the fantastic work-I'm looking forward to your next upload!"
R/S, has described the working of RAW in an exhaustive manner. The life of an official serving in raw ; throws up many challenges to the serving official. The biggest one is his loneliness. He cannot share, his sorrows and happiness with others. It is the highest sacrifice of the serving officials in the RAW !
Dear Raj Shamani ji 🙏🙏💕 Assalamualaikum Walekum Assalam! Peace 🕊️ isn't possible without diplomacy! Sensitive information needs to be dealt in such a manner that it helps us in becoming a more conscious being ! There is no such thing as double agent!
Although I would say the Podcast overall had a lot of knowledge and thanks for interviewing such an eminent personality. Would wish to see more. All the best
He repeated several times that R&AW is CAPABLE of doing anything for the nation's security, but he never directly confessed about any action that has been taken. He is such a smart guy.
I understand now why Sir chose you as an interviewer. He just came to fix RAW's image as a country raises questions about Nijjar's killing and thinks RAW could be behind it. Throughout the interview, he emphasized that RAW doesn’t do anything wrong-they don’t kill enemies, and they don’t even harm double agents who betray India; if they die, it’s usually in an accident. Essentially, he just came, presented RAW's stance, and then left. A RAW officer holds great power in his hands-more than you can even imagine.
German shepherd ke tatto dekh lo sun lo inki baat jo India me ho raha hai strike like khalistan,kisan andolan,CAA protest bhut se ayse hai lekin German shepherd aur congressiyon ko yeh nahi dikhta hai
" Anything you do for your country for security interest is moral . "
This is legit
Morality is not bound to the boundaries so this statement is totally wrong. Doing Immoral Actions can not be justified with this statement.
Said in Bhagavad geeta
He is so smart ...he didn't talk anything that could harm the current position of the Agency and the warriors working there
He is. But this is a risky adventure. once you are in flow, you never know what will spill out. These kind of
podcasts sound adventurous but are potential security risks. Besides, there is nothing to learn except walking away with a feeling that yeah our R&AW is blah blah.
Cuz he takes gomutr energy drink 💪
@@zfold4702 Raw agents are taught to change stories, time, places and many details while narrating a story or incident due to security purpose. Do you really think they are so stupid to make such mistake? Never underestimate any kind of secret agency, they have lot more going behind the scenes.
@@zfold4702 Correct 💯
Just like pisslam mulk isis@@SK-ne4bf
Sir please don't ask mujhe yeh batao. It seem weird while interviewing such personality. Overall great to see such podcast
Yes, I always feel disrespectful when he tells yeh batao to many seniors
you are a snowflake. bolne wale ko dikkat nahi hai aur sunne wale ko bhi nahi hai. tumko dard kyu h
Main ye baat bahut baar bol chuka hoon par koi fark nahi padta hai
Raj be like --Mujhe fadak ni padta
Change karo raj ji
He was a RAW officer, He knows what to speak and what to lie. He knows how to entertain us. Only intelligent men can understand this comment. You cannot figure out how many lies and how many truths he spoke.
Frfr 😂
@@Shreshtha.Parihar😂🤣😂🤣😂
U r in raw?
True that .. we just witnessed RA&W being described as being a sanit and I totally bought it :D
Ishwar ne saza Diya 😆😆
1.5 sal bad road accident me mara gaya😆😆
Please Learn the word "BATAIYE" 😇
Exactly I also thinking about it
Correct
Same , iska har podcast me yhi rhta h , batao😅 jaise ye unka baap ho
Basp ke paise se Bulaga to request kaisa
RAJ IS HIGHLY IMPOLITE IN HIS COMMUNICATION!
WONDER HOW KEY PROFILE GUESTS ACCEPT TO DO HIS PODCASTS!😮
The guy looks like a normal harmless uncle …he projects himself and the agency as a harmless entity but we all know how much he and the agency is capable of
Ohh ur that expert who knows what are agencies are capable of doing 🤣🤣
You know nothing lol
True we don't know anything except the news of unknown gunmen in Pakistan 😅
😂jyada hi
harmless to the good is harmless
0:00 - Introduction
5:43 - How R&AW operates
8:43 - Key roles of R&AW
14:48 - Understanding spies
16:35 - Work distribution in R&AW
19:29 - Double agent: Ravindra Singh’s story
26:49 - R&AW's approach to double agents
28:33 - CIA's approach to double agents
33:09 - Building trust among R&AW officers
38:31 - Everyone has a price
39:43 - The highest price he paid
43:43 - Funding and budget limitations
44:14 - R&AW's recruitment process
46:21 - Qualities needed in agents
49:04 - Balancing friendship in operations
50:21 - Sacrifices made by R&AW agents
52:51 - Family life and responsibilities
57:51 - R&AW officer’s salary
59:15 - Amar Bhushan’s pre-R&AW life
1:01:39 - Misconceptions about R&AW
1:03:50 - Top intelligence agencies worldwide
1:04:54 - How ISI operates
1:06:32 - R&AW training process
1:07:29 - Beating surveillance tactics
1:10:34 - Life post-retirement
1:11:34 - The "k*lling culture" in R&AW
1:13:26 - Morality and ethics in intelligence
1:14:26 - Regret after missions
1:16:48 - Podcast conclusion
1:17:18 - Outro
❤
Ty
Thanks buddy
good job bro
Good job
What an incredible officer. So balanced, so profound, so strategic....my country is proud to have such officers in her service.
bro there was no need to ask him ki 'kabhi apko bura nhi lgta innocent logo ko marne mai' 100 times. why were u trying to guilt trip him huh? show some maturity and respect Raj. I am not saying that he shouldn't have asked that, asking that question is completely fine, but y ask him 3-4 times??
Yes tuchiya question
Sahi baat h Raj bhai may be you are there because people like him are there. Kbhi kbhi your questions are very lame.
They are not having personal issue with the other person . Killing is a part of Game that game is Geo Politics
It's like every country involved in any such operations tries to avoid civilian casualties
Yes..then you are talking like woke liberal anti national elements
Old guy quite smart Didn't reveal anything just time passing😅
Toh reveal kre bhi kyu India ki security ki baat h. Tere jaiso ko sab kahani thodi sunate firenge
RAW ki baat ho rhi security guard ki agency ki nhi 😂😂
as u said old n frm raw so it z ment to b smart not goof
He is just giving a perspective...he is not here to reveal govt secrets
Dokra tej h Bhai or tej toh hoga hi raw ☠️ jo h
Accident ho gya khud se😂, Clever #chellam_sir
Yes uvr right best line is lagta to nai and anything is possible
Ha bhi kuch be ho skta h 😂achaa he hua mar gya ❤❤
😂😂
bohot logo ka accident ho gata hai aise hi
@@Taabish-l8w Right 😂
8:43 While explaining R&AW roles, he carefully also described what western agencies are doing in India.
🔥🔥✌️😜
Was also observing the same wrt the US interference in India's domestic politics using Protests as a tool to destabilize the country and also using CIA to perform a coup in Bangladesh after Hasina refused to give a military base to USA
Spot on.
Many many thanks to you for holding such a wonderful talking session with our revered EX RAW officer who described about RAW function and operation for the interest of country.
Jai Hind
Shekhar
N Delhi
I have seen few R&AW agents and officers podcast, but i found this too genuine 🍷
Bring Part -2 with this Gentleman
Lucky bisht ka dekh le, vo sabse best hai podcast 😚☺️😊😘🥰
@@VikashKumar-kw5ckwo agent tha officer nahi. Bass bakchodi karta hai
@@VikashKumar-kw5ck yes, joint secretary & field officers hote hai.
Field officers agents or spies hote hai, jo apne assets & sources ka circle banaate hai, aur joint secretary ko office ke int aur information dete hai.
Sochne ka aur brain lagane ka kaam joint secretary jo ki high rank officers hote hai, wei karte hai analysis wagera. Jaise ki yeh sir hai.
Waise sir waakei mei bade smartly & wisely answers diye hai, kuch baatein batakar kuch deny kar diya indirectly. Kyonki yeh field officer nahi balki joint secretary or high rank officer reh chuke hai, isliye innke bolne ka bht se matlab bann sakta hai.
So, bht se baaton ko deny kar diya smoothly. 😅
@@joexico773 well said
Unlike that fucker lucky bishit
Many of you guys thinking that He is telling every truth about raw of not elimination enemies and he is simultaneously projecting raw's capabilities. But guys believe me he is telling a very small truth to you
Bro, then why u want to spell those which he had to be preserved, u know what many agencies are working to collect this kind of podcast to read and know the intention about Raw like agencies of india 😂😂😂
Or not telling anything at all he's a raw Offcier dammit they are master menuplators and liers they much more capable then they show
@@shayranapoem1 nah agencies won't wast their time on podcasts they'll try to infiltrate RAW itself
They do all what circumstances demands.
*we forever remain indebted for your service to this great nation* 🙏🏼🙏🏼
Respect R and AW 🫡
Real heroes and hidden heroes 🙌
Ishwar ne saja di ❌
RA&W ne saja di ✅ 27:39
That smile says everything😅
😅
Mujhe yeh batao ...yeh tarika hain baat karne ka bhai raw officer hain thura manner main baat karo
This is not a way to talk
manners me hi to tha ?
@@mohitrsoni kaha manners main tha bhai ..yeh batao ke badle bataiye v bol sakta hai yaar
@@FUNNYVIDEOS-gn8ex He thinks this guest is his galli ka dost
That's how Hindi is spoken in many parts of the country, e.g. Mumbai. Stop preaching.@@FUNNYVIDEOS-gn8ex
He is razor-sharp in answering all the questions. Loved this podcast.
I feel petty about the host that he he think the seasoned RAW officer will share everything.. remember the first sentence he said to the host .. the reason he came to only his podcast.. and he made the host psycho…impact.. I only think that RAW sent this veteran to the podcast😊.
He RTD 2005. He knows what to share and when to share 😉😄😄
Also he mentioned about secert act..
Spot on! And Raj Shamani thinks a seasoned RAW official will disclose everything 😂😂😂😂😂
54:00 Sacrifices 😢
Sahi pakre hai 😁😁😁😁😁
At 27.24 Ishwar appears to eliminate the traitor in an accident. I am proud of the Ishwar 😂
Ishwar Lal mehta😂
@@pdemmy8709😅
😂😅
Sidha sidh thodi bolenge ki humne kiya 😂
Huge respect for R&AW officer Vikas Yadav who came back to India safely. How difficult it would be to escape US. As sir mentioned in podcast, no legal backing, so sad for Vikas sir😢
😂😂😂😂he didnt go to u.s first of all,he juz hired gupta to kill pannu,then gupta approach dia secret officer,failed mission,usa caught red handed,the end,
Raw is joke
@@ranapartap1501😂😂 joker 😂😂 hai tu look at their previous mission this man is officer not ground level man .
@@Funny.fail.videos007 He went to US and setup everything and attempted assisination and then escaped that why CIA is furious to find him. India v ab CIA ki tarah operate karna shuru kiya.
Pahle Nizzar aur Ab Pannu
@@ranapartap1501Tum police constable crack nhi kar sakta hai RAW ka mazak banata hai. We all are safe because of RAW.
Lagta toh nhi hai 😅😅
The Art of letting go
Sir ji rocked ❤
😂🤣😂🤣😂
Lekin sir toh 90's ki baat bata rahe ,, khul krr ni bol sakte humne hee kiya hai,, kuki dusri agencies peeche padd jaengi
"NO NEVER " THE last words of the Officer in the podacst.. JUST WOW...❤.
We all the INDIANS bow OUR head towards you for THE INVISIBLE SHIELD.
Lots of students want to live this life. Thanks to you at least I could share the POV of an R&W with my students. Thank you so much for the PODCAST. Tomorrow I was telling my bhabhi about the PODCAST culture... BIG THANK YOU
bhabhi maal hai ?
I deeply urge Anchor not to invite security personnel's in such podcasts for sake of views / money. This is not only threat to national security but to all the people. As a honest citizens we need to be responsible and accountable for the job we are doing. Look minor loopholes in the system could cost huge.
Just a thought..
It's good to know how our country's security work friend. Nothing wrong in it. And yes the host and the guest know what to talk and what to censor
@@zubyr2474your location is revealed.....bahar nikalna mat .....I will tell you at 11 am morning what to do ....don't be over smart ......you know my sniping ability
Bro this guy was a senior r&aw officer do you genuinely think he doesn't know what not to tell on a public podcast come on have some common sense
Stories are inspired by true events,our intention and imaginative makes it unique.. respect your job don't make judgement based on mere Stories which are for manipulating people and lead them by their thoughts
Before this podcast scene in India, i think such information was already at the public disposal through books and memoirs of the ex-RA&W agents and I think the things which they are discussing are at a very surface level which intellectuals from every other country know already
Thank you raj
Its very informative n great to the one who is willing to be part R&W ❤
Even we can implement things in day to day life as he mentioned discipline he followed 🫡 for more than 3 yrs
N life of people routines they had
Overall its such a pleasure to watch great personalities of India 🇮🇳 ❤
Bro you are doing an amazing job, and making a better country by providing knowledge love you❤❤
Raj Shamsani kya Ranveer allahbadia friends hai kya ?
42:14 both knows and laughing to each other😂
Salute to these silent heroes of Bharat. Their and their families sacrifice is truly remarkable. Every Bharatiya is indebted for their safety to these silent heroes. शत शत नमन.
Lol...look at the craftsmanship of the ex officer.... he mentioned about the secret's act ...and still the host is asking questions about his actions and activities 😂😂😂
Important knowledge and some wild information for all. GOOD.
AND CONGRATS.
Glad you enjoyed it!😌
@@rajshamani Yeah!!
Can't believe i am listening to such people whom i planned in head chats with... Its like dream roundtable... Made possible in this channel. Gratitude.
2:59 be careful be careful 🚨 while interviewing this top officers, don't ask DETAILS 💯 😡
Chill the host didn't ask all the details and the guest spoke what's required no need to get emotional
Guest bewakoof hai kya jo wo details dega. Iska kaam hai question puchna. Let him do his job
Guest is faar intelligent than his question. They know how to tackle questions in any situation.
@@vipinbhatt4393 yup
Totally right! The RUclipsr kids have made a joke of this profession.
Woww raj what a podcast.
Thank you for calling this kind of respected personallity❤❤
More power to you brother❤❤
Badhiya Jalebi Khilai Sahab aap ne isko😂
Ye itnaa dumb Bandaa hai ki sir usi time samajh gaye hongey jab unhone bola ki accident me mar gyaa aur ye dumb puchta hai ki CIA ne marwaya kyaa😂😂
😁😁😁😁😁
@@GuzzarAwanand Raj shamani thinks that he did a great job here 😁😁😁😁😁
He is a great person and self less man. You are the Hero of our country . You are inspiration of many people . Thank you to our unknown warriors. Love from heart ❤❤❤
Loved the discussion, pls bring more of the guest from intelligence department. especially how they operate within the country and some mission in neighbouring countries.
Are wo secret rakhna padta he, bollywood nahi he ye
Intelligence agency me intelligence aur secrecy chahiye, sab kuchh public chahiye kya tumhe ab🤦
@@QuantumNinja1.9 there are already books written by ex officers which talked about operations of raw in Sikkim, Nagaland, punjab and in Srilanka etc etc.
This is no big deal
@@saitama- books stay under th radar but podcast is a different thing in this volatile world.
Also in Books you can write something but it's still checked by you many times for accuracy and secrecy but in podcast it's almost a one time thing you can reveal something that you don't want to.
That's poses a risk on bluff techniques.
Raj Shamani thought he is taking a podcast, Podcast was manipulated by Officer sir😂😂😂
I saw many podcast...but you're the one who genuine asked the perfect questions...and i truly waiting for your next podcast desperately... love you brother 🤝❤️💯
You’re doing well and making everyone explore world
Specially Doctors and RAW
JAI HIND
Sir salute to you for serving our nation.
JAY HIND 🫡 🇮🇳❤
Amazing communication of a common man with the seasoned personality 🎉
Be CAREFUL While you are interviewing our 🇮🇳 EX OFFICER'S
Wasn't he?
@@zubyr2474yes he is not!
Not easy interviewing such secret agents. Hats off to u .
Very depressed by watching this.. no good charter available for R&Aw like CIA, no authority do anything, No goverment backing.. our airforce & Navy is signing pact with UBER & sharing all personal details with them. Where is national security stand ? What are we doing. Countries are monitoring you by your fitness band, doing mobile & pager blasts & what are we doing? Really concerning things
India is a joker country..i seriously doubt their competence after Pannu fiasco
Don't worry bro, we have lots of services apart from this podcast statement, and u think we are at just to do about, even we have done apart from this, don't worry, we do more than pager and internet clashes, do u ever think what was the reason behind which indicates India as top ranked on internet shutting down? Think ones, actually our civilians are so dumb and they don't want to respect our government and their policies, otherwise we had some extraordinary services which were lead to enhance identity
do you actually belive everything he said. he is SPY . he wont tell complete truth. he casually skipped the part of SG for a reason .
@@mohanj8511 definitely, he had to do that, otherwise he sounds dumb, nhi aap mujhe batao, CIA, ISIS aur jitni bhi agency hai vo sab ke sab india ki Raw bnd krna chahti h, aise ME hm apna poll kyun khole
@@shayranapoem1 bro / sis i get you. par wo ISIS nhi hai wo ISI hai , pak intel agency , ISIS wo syria ka terrorist organisation hai , jyada fark toh nhi hai un dono me but fir bhi. you are right n thats what i was trying to say , ofc wo pura sach toh nhi bolenge na? RAW ko secret service bolte hai for a reason , wo saare secrets reveal krdenge toh wo kaise secret agency hai.
I didn't wanted to say but Raj your information and questions are derived from movies and macho stories, these are the most authentic answers I have ever heard and all the working structure of our R&AW without any violence and support charter is commendable. Hats of to you Sir.
Pure podcasts are very good very informative and I like The way you put your questions upfront. Because it is informative And most of them are related to global politics and spies I like them a lot.
Raj, I must say that you are a great listener.
It's a very great quality. Keep it up 😊😊😊😊😊😊
Moral of the podcast, "Never remain Innocent".
that's why American govt keen to change Modi ji dominance
Raj I did not subscribe to your channel because you usually call nonsense gossip people. But today I have subscribed. Please call true patriotic guests on your show. Jai Hind!
@@OnlyFactsAndData4829 dude that are podcaster who just timepassing by calling random.guest on shows for no reason
These are the highest warriors who mission is above all else. Nothing matters more than the security and safety of the country.
Do you know that so many many people aren't even aware about diplomacy! I have been a diplomat in school 🎒🏫 ! People may dislike diplomats at first but gradually they start realising the importance of diplomats! All diplomats are blessed by : Jupiter! #Shukra-#Brihaspati!
Day by day you are inviting great personalities hope we learn more from your channel thank you raj sir 🫡
The take away from this podcast is RAW officers are v smart 😂. No matter if a superstar is talking to them, they will not divulge anything
Raj raise no of questions instead of stucking with one or two otherwise it ws fun watching our hero. He repeatedly said we are capable for anything depends on charter happy to hear that.
30:14 Are Bhai accident ho jate hn.. Ab khud thodi bolenge 😅😂
Sahi 😅
😂😂😂😂
😂😂😂😂
Bhagwan code name ka agent raha hoga
@@vivekraina broo 🙏🏻🙏🏻🙏🏻
Salute 🫡
Very informative podcast, Thanks Raj, keep going, Jai Hind
One should never feel bad for protecting one's own country's interest
See the uncle smile and proud to their knowledge 😂 and how joyful they are doing conversation I also want to sit with them
"Kuch nehi kiya hum log"
2 sal bad road accident... 😊😊😊😅 Well done
🗿🌚
😂😂😂😂😂
Director saheb sab jaante hai but bolna nhi chahte.......RAW ke director se information aise kaise nikaal sakte ho RAJ bhai, thats why he was a director...
Loved this podcast. One of the best I've ever seen.
1:14 really a different perspective, thought provoking...
We need more of these top individuals on this programme.
Raj you should invite one of the finest former RAW agent RK Yadav who has written a book "Mission R&AW". We are big fan of him.❤
@@23abhi23 nope Raj will ruin it, better on someone else’s podcast, someone more mature.
Chalo bhai Subscribe kar diye .... best of luck for future ... hope your team dedication get great success ahead.
The police mentality has undermined the R&AW. We can see the debacles happening around us starting from Covid, 2020, Afghanistan, Iran, Bangladesh, USA Canada. Serious reforms required to reform the agency to a professional agency. Mixing of internal security mindset of IB, police cannot be equated with R&AW. External covert ops require a very serious professional work done by hardcore experts.
Aaj kal koi bhi ch●du l●du gyan pelta hai R&AW ko 😂😂😂
Aap kis background se hain ? May I know
Raj Shamani is A Stalwart of Podcast in the world. ⚔️
Tell everything.... Expose nothing...... What a great RAW officer
Great work ! Your podcasts have elements!
The fact is that this gentleman only disclosed you less than 10 percent 😅
Or kya Poora bta dangel
@@rishabhvarshney9328poora bata toh diya,, accident mein maara gya America mein,,
Abb kya ye direct bolenge?????
Less than 1% actually.
@@rohitraghuwanshi8993 exactly
After watching a few episodes, I have subscribed. Keep rocking.
His aura, his way of talking, his personality actually seems like real secret service agent, same like I used to see Interviews of former CIA directors and agents.
Unlike lucky bisht 😂😂
Tere lagne se kuch nahi hota!! Lucky bisht is respectable officer!! Talk with respect!
@@abhisheksonawane4678abbe wo agent tha officer nahi aur agent bhi tha ki nahi ye kisko pata.
Lucky ek field officer or Agent tha, jo apne source ka circle banaakar senior joint secretary ko inform dete.
Dimaag innke jaise joint secretary high rank officials dete hai, aur field officer or agents ko bas follow karna hota hai.
@@jethiya7990bhai woh tha.
Innhone bol toh diya ki Joint secretary high rank officers hote hai, aur ek field officer or agents hote hai.
Lucky Bisht bhi jaise bolte hai, unnhone bht baar bola h ki, woh waise peish aate hai jis tarah se saamne waale ko khudko dikhana hota hai.
Jaisa dikhta hai waisa nahi hota kuch bhi secret agencies ke world mei.
Aur woh unhi baaton ka zikra karte hai jo already revealed hai aur jinpar books & stories likha gaya ho. Unnko bhi upar se instructions diya gaya hoga protocols ki kya bolna hai aur kya nahi.
Aur yeh sir ne isliye kuch baaton ka deny kiya kyonki yeh joint secretary thei, aur innke baaton ko jo bhi dekhega, bht baariki se dekhega. So harmless bolna aaj ke geopolitics ka demand hai. Otherwise humare desh ke upar Unknown gunmen ke allegations lagaya gaya hai West ke kuch countries ke taraf se. So bht se andar ki baatein hai, jismei deny & accept with wise words zaruri h ek high rank official ke taraf se.
Waise yes, Lucky Bisht was an secret agent or field officer, unnpe sachmei kuch books hai. Aur iss tarah ke field officer pe believe nahi h toh Ravindra Kaushik ji ke baare mei research kar lo, woh bhi ek field officer or agent hi thei, but Joint secretary or high rank officer nahi. Waise hi agents & spies kisiko bhi le sakte hai, military service se, police se, normal job person ya koi bhi, but high rank officer ke liye UPSC se ranked officer zaruri hai. Dono ke liye kuch criteria fit rehna zaruri hai, jiske baare mei innhone bataya & even Lucky bisht ne bhi kuch kuch podcast mei bataya tha.
So, respect them brother, chahe innke jaise Joint secretary or high rank officer ho ya Lucky bisht jaise Field officer or agents.
Jai hind🙏 🇮🇳
@@abhisheksonawane4678yes field officer jisko agents bhi bolte hai. Innhone kuch baatein smartly deny kiya, kyonki deny karna zaruri tha. Because bht se allegations lage hai west Countries ke taraf se, unknown gunmen wala. So yeh zaruri hai. Yahi toh khaasiyat hai, ki humare secret Services secret ko secret rakhna jaante hai. Jo revealed hai unnko revealed bhi rakhte hai saath mei deny bhi karte hai.
Taaki duniya hi confuse mei rahe. Aur secret secret hi reh jaye
A great person indeed such clarity of mind! We are proud to jave such RAW officials
I really felt when he said Agent's life is very lonely life.
#ASKMrShamani, Please bring in Mr Dhirendra Kumar, the founder and CEO of Value Research. He is a great value addition to the podcast. Not bringing him to the podcast is a great disservice to the loyal subscribers who consistently give you their valuable time as support and value exchange. Thank you for the podcast episode
Around 30 minutes, you'd realise why Raj was chosen for such podcast ... Grow some brain cells 🤨
😂😂😂😂😂😂
😂🤣😂🤣😂
Rightly said 👍🏼👍🏼👍🏼👍🏼👍🏼
😂
Raj’s ability to make an interesting podcast boring is underrated. Ek hi cheez baar bar puchta hai.
Raj pls in the last it felt like you are trying to make him feel bad.. he has served the nation with grace and honour.. the least you could do is to say Thanks for your service.. but again you were like ask ignorant questions!!
But hats off to sir who gracefully answered the question without a sling of anger.
A humble request is to please correct your line of questioning!!
"I just wanted to take a moment to express how much I enjoyed your recent content. It was engaging, informative, and really resonated with me. I believe that more videos like this would not only benefit your audience but also help your channel grow. Please continue to share such valuable material, as it truly makes a difference. Keep up the fantastic work-I'm looking forward to your next upload!"
What a podcast!!!!!well donee
Very very honest person, salute 🙏
Loved it bhai….people may slam you but you did a fantastic job.
One of the best podcast i ever seen thank you RaJ
Thank you soo much bro🙌🏻
invite N K Sood he is a also former R&AW officer who worked in different different countries like Iran etc etc
@@rajshamanididn't your mom teach you manners use sir/ batayiye
Your podcast is better and grounded than many more other hyped one's
Raj bhai ne puri kosis ki par sir bhi khiladi hai
R/S, has described the working of RAW in an exhaustive manner. The life of an official serving in raw ; throws up many challenges to the serving official. The biggest one is his loneliness. He cannot share, his sorrows and happiness with others. It is the highest sacrifice of the serving officials in the RAW !
This job ain't easy, but still a dream for many...
Dear Raj Shamani ji 🙏🙏💕 Assalamualaikum Walekum Assalam! Peace 🕊️ isn't possible without diplomacy! Sensitive information needs to be dealt in such a manner that it helps us in becoming a more conscious being ! There is no such thing as double agent!
Your username and comment doesn't match . Ohh fake acccount sorry
Wow! I am speechless to just see a true R&AW officer. Jai Hind!
Although I would say the Podcast overall had a lot of knowledge and thanks for interviewing such an eminent personality. Would wish to see more. All the best
Again an interesting podcast❤
He repeated several times that R&AW is CAPABLE of doing anything for the nation's security, but he never directly confessed about any action that has been taken. He is such a smart guy.
If its a secret and you know it, it was never been a secret 😂..
I understand now why Sir chose you as an interviewer. He just came to fix RAW's image as a country raises questions about Nijjar's killing and thinks RAW could be behind it. Throughout the interview, he emphasized that RAW doesn’t do anything wrong-they don’t kill enemies, and they don’t even harm double agents who betray India; if they die, it’s usually in an accident. Essentially, he just came, presented RAW's stance, and then left. A RAW officer holds great power in his hands-more than you can even imagine.
German shepherd ke tatto dekh lo sun lo inki baat jo India me ho raha hai strike like khalistan,kisan andolan,CAA protest bhut se ayse hai lekin German shepherd aur congressiyon ko yeh nahi dikhta hai
sahi kaha bhai
😂😂😂😂
😂😂😂
Gas cylinder leke sarak m baithna 😅
Kisan ke halat sudhar nahi sakte toh unko badnam kar dalo😅 aur Black laws ko implement kar do again..
Very good questions. Good interview