Bryan Kohberger: Strength of 'Stargazing' Alibi in Idaho Student Murders
HTML-код
- Опубликовано: 3 май 2024
- If you’ve used Incognito mode in Google’s Chrome browser, find out if you have a claim in a few clicks by visiting www.incognitoclaims.com/sidebar
This episode of Sidebar is sponsored by BetterHelp. Give online therapy a try at www.betterhelp.com/sidebar and get on your way to being your best self!
The defense team for accused quadruple murderer Bryan Kohberger filed official paperwork with the court declaring his alibi for the night four University of Idaho students were brutally stabbed to death in 2022. Kohberger claims he was out driving on the night of November 13 to look at the moon and stars. Law&Crime’s Jesse Weber debates the strength of this alibi with criminal defense attorney Andrea Burkhart.
Subscribe to Law&Crime Network: bit.ly/LawAndCrimeNetwork
Listen to Law&Crime's Sidebar Podcast on Apple & Spotify:
Apple: apple.co/3wMgRgB
Spotify: spoti.fi/3wITe7b
Host:
Jesse Weber: / jessecordweber
Guest:
Andrea Burkhart: / aburkhartlaw
LAW&CRIME SIDEBAR PRODUCTION:
Head of Social Media, RUclips - Bobby Szoke
Podcast Director - Sam Goldberg
Senior Director of Social Media - Vanessa Bein
Senior Digital Producer - Savannah Williamson
Video Editing - Michael Deininger
Guest Booking - Alyssa Fisher
#BryanKoberger #Idaho4 #LawAndCrime
STAY UP-TO-DATE WITH THE LAW&CRIME NETWORK:
Watch Law&Crime Network on RUclipsTV: bit.ly/3td2e3y
Where To Watch Law&Crime Network: bit.ly/3akxLK5
Sign Up For Law&Crime's Daily Newsletter: bit.ly/LawandCrimeNewsletter
Read Fascinating Articles From Law&Crime Network: bit.ly/3td2Iqo
For Advertising Inquiries, Please Contact: sales@lawandcrime.com
For Licensing Inquiries, Please Contact: licensing@lawandcrime.com
LAW&CRIME NETWORK SOCIAL MEDIA:
Instagram: / lawandcrime
Twitter: / lawcrimenetwork
Facebook: / lawandcrime
Twitch: / lawandcrimenetwork
TikTok: / lawandcrime
LAW&CRIME NETWORK PODCASTS: lawandcrime.com/podcasts/
SUBSCRIBE TO ALL OF LAW&CRIME NETWORK RUclips CHANNELS:
Main Channel: / @lawandcrime
Law&Crime Shorts: / @lawandcrimeshorts
Channel B: / @lawandcrimetrials
Channel C: / @lawandcrimebodycam 
Развлечения
If you’ve used Incognito mode in Google’s Chrome browser, find out if you have a claim in a few clicks by visiting www.incognitoclaims.com/sidebar
This episode of Sidebar is sponsored by BetterHelp. Give online therapy a try at www.betterhelp.com/sidebar and get on your way to being your best self!
The incognito link doesn't work.
Andrea Burhart is probably, if not the only lawyer here without bias. She really is looking at it with a wide-open scope and considering the probability and evidence we actually have. We need more people like her. 🙌🏽 You did an amazing job, Andrea Thank you! 🙏🏽
Conspiracy nut just like you
It was refreshing to hear an intelligent, balanced discussion about Brian's alibi update as opposed to the ridiculously sarcastic, immature responses from others who attempt to put themselves forth as "credible" reporting entities. Thank you.
Thank you! It’s incredible how people are so against hearing opposing arguments. Even if he is guilty, why would hearing him out be bad?
Exactly. I lost my respect for the interview room channel. It's a bunch of immature super biased older men.
I see you call him buy his name, like you're in love...
@@stephanea5364 That is his literal name. He is innocent until proven guilty in a court of law. Some of us still believe in our constitutional rights in this country.
@@GardeningGems lmao imagine opposing using a persons name. What difference does it make to not be disrespectful? This comments section has so many brain dead takes
Alibi no worse than ....i was asleep...didnt hear any screaming...saw a man with eye brows!
😄 yeah. Both has phone confirming them. BK clearly location elsewhere. But frozen shock face in the crime scene.
Problem is Bethany Funke and Dylan Mortensen were cleared by Federal Bureau of Investigation expert interviewers and interrogators to an absolute,undisputed,irrefutable 100% certainty. And keep in mind those agents were brought in from the Denver Bureau to avoid any possible conflict of interest. Three of the victims were found in their beds in the prone position meaning they were most likely sleeping when attacked. One of the standing victims was stabbed in the lungs and neck (mortal wounds) which would make it literally impossible to scream let alone talk. This would be the point where i am exponentially 10 times smarter than you
😂
@@youthinkyouknowme5551Where did you read the autopsy report ?
@@GardeningGems Nowhere, just claimed the house was like strait from somekind Assasin Greed game. Dude is also apparently timetraveler strait from Marvel stories. C'moon, somekind of common sense is needed on life.
This guest is very articulate and intelligent.
Yes she is!!!
“I am made of questions” is literally how I feel
This guest does an excellent job at explaining and clarifying
She always does!!!
An excellent job sugar coating some serious Brady/giglio violations in a capital murder case involving the death penalty. This won't end well for the state.
@@Kelly_Christina Since I'm not a lawyer I had to google the SCOTUS Brady and Giglio rulings. Interesting. So, you think the prosecution will be in trouble for withholding exculpatory evidence and/or non-credible witnesses?
@@JustListen43210yessss
Andrea is amazingly intelligent & makes so many great legal points...
Andrea Burkhart is the best!
I go out to the gym at 2am or 3 am and/or running all the time. I turn my phone off all the time. I have never killed anyone.
Make sure you leave your phone on and take pictures. You never know if you'll be in this situation one day!!
Have you ever been wrongly accused? Or know anyone who has been wrongly accused?
Was your DNA found at a crime scene?
@@DJ_Cub his touch DNA was found "on an item" at the scene. I am not saying he is either guilty or innocent, but what he has claimed as an alibi, is quite normal, common. The media is suggesting otherwise. The DNA is an entirely different topic.
I don't believe you
I truly appreciate Andrea Burkart and her unbias opinions of facts.
Thanks for the unbiased coverage- hard to come by. More Andrea, please!
Yes!!
Unbiased?? He literally kept questioning the alibi, after she had explained it to him.
Andrea seemed unbiased, but the host made up his mind a long time ago. SMH.
Supposed to be innocent until proven guilty!
@@logicalcomrade7606 I know, Andrea is right. It's really normal to go for a run out of cell service at 4am in winter in idaho. Best time for it actually.
beautiful, proffessional and valuable interview! When it comes to this case, it's hard to find intelligent people who are willing to ask questions, discuss every angle without blindly jumping to conclusions and having an open mind. You are also one of the few channels that actually mentioned the defence expert! This is the healthy way to approach matters. I really appreciate this coverage!
Beautiful is a stretch
I love Andrea Burkhart. Its so refreshing to hear someone with common sense. Shes not a paid- off talkinghead like everyone else.
Andrea does an excellent job explaining things.
Its not an explanation. Its speculation about the evidence. The evidence is sealed and there is a gag order that prevents all of us including Andrea from knowing what evidence there is beyond the PCA and a few court filings that were not sealed when filed.
Refreshing to hear a non biased interview with factual information ~ Thanks Andrea
I’m really surprised to see so many legal professionals either miss the nuance of the paragraph that talks about that specific night or they’re purposefully skirting around it so they have something talk about.
Nowhere does it say on that particular night he was “stargazing”.
“….as he OFTEN DID to hike and run and see the moon and stars”. This sentence is meant to paint a picture, to explain where he routinely went and the reason he goes there.
Next sentence talks about THAT specific night, all it says is that he “drove throughout the area….”.
Everyone, including law professionals, keep referring to this hobby as if it were a ridiculous thing to even consider. All you people need to get out the house and touch some grass.
I was just wondering same thing the other day. All soo lazy people had a melt down by someone been hiker and runner. My husband run the marathon two times. He went out always night, early morning hours before work.
Andrea has made this argument that the mentioning of the stargazing and whatnot is to establish a pattern of behavior and that [BK being out at night] isn't out of the ordinary. she has previously addressed it another places too.
If you don't follow her, I highly recommend it.
Ty
Agreed. Reading is helpful.
Keep defending a serial killer.....
I’ve always had my doubts with this case in terms of the DNA evidence and other factors. I’m gonna pause any judgement on this one until it’s gone all the way through……
Stargazing on a cloudy night........ don't forget the details.
Andrea you are my hero. You are unaffected by outside influences and powers. You speak out for objectivity and truth. Thank you soooooo much. You give me hope in humanity
Did Kohberger convince you to marry him yet?
Maybe they should take a poll on the number of college students, (especially Masters and Doctoral student) who drive around at night to clear their minds. I drove down to the lake multiples times in college, because when your brain is full and you can't sleep, sitting in your car looking at the sky is very therapeutic.
When I was at university I would drive for several hours and sit by the sea until 4:00am. And I assure you that many people who are in college and suffer from insomnia do the same thing.
And does your DNA end up at a murder scene?
@@SarahShaw-zc4ww Maybe, just like yours, which should be found in all the places you visited today.
I couldnt agree more. Some people make sarcastic comments on the whole stargazing thing like it's a super weird and abnormal out of the blue thing to do. These people need to get over themselves with their arrogance
@@SarahShaw-zc4wwthe prosecution has dropped the IGG information evidence because the dna profile is too flaky. I think it will affect the dna evidence. Plus it's touch DNA which it totally unreliable.
This guest presenter was so much more helpful than most of the guest speakers! Bring her back!
Why did he have to get all the prosecution evidence to formulate an alibi? why didn’t he give his alibi immediately so they could clear him as a suspect? I certainly would have if I was innocent. Also the defenses alibi “expert” has been under scrutiny in Colorado by a judge!
Exactly
Why didn't the prosecution hand over the discovery that has been asked for 15 times?
Right!! Where is this concrete exculpatory evidence submitted alongside a motion to dismiss all charges and release this innocent person???!!!
That exculpatory evidence doesn't exist that's why
Phone tells where he was, prosecution had his phone. He said he was out driving alone, that’s still his alibi, not sure what you are stating there. Most of Moscow PD IS under investigation and has horrible track records. Seek and you shall find.
Everyone should note that she's a defense attorney. Literally her entire job is making up excuses for any and every possible bit of evidence to try to dismiss it as unimportant. You could have Kohberger on video walking into the house and walking out covered in blood and getting in his car, and this same exact woman would be on here going "Well, it's important to note that we don't actually see him kill everyone, he could have gone into the house, slipped into their blood, and then walked back out so clearly since we don't know we need to exclude this as important evidence."
As a defense attorney, she will NEVER say "Yeah, this evidence is bad and makes him look guilty". Because that goes against her entire job and source of income.
This is the exact same thought I have literally every time she speaks. Couldn't agree more.
All evidence confirms BK is innocent. No motive, No connection, No Victims DNA, No murder weapon. Hope he sues when he's freed next year
Andrea is getting on my nerves with this case. I get it, she WANTS to show her defensive skills but I mean c'mon, you cannot explain everything away. Used to like her but she is really something in this case that has really turned me that I shut her off.
Seriously, are you on here trying to explain what a defense attorneys job is supposed to be ?
"Everyone should note..." bla, bla, bla.
jeez, where do ppl like you come from ?
Alibi is an alibi, still don’t even know where Ethan and Xana were for a few hours still…
I pray that the victims get justice.
Imagine in America we are talking about the strength of an alibi instead of the strength of a bunch of circumstantial evidence. People act offended that they want a fair trial.
In America, you don't need an alibut. What you need is your DNA not showing up on a sheath that's next to a dead body.That's next to other dead bodies.That's kind of what you need....
@@roriemarie2968 I knew there would be someone...
@@roriemarie2968what about the other male dna? It wasn’t listed as touch dna from the other dnas? Whose was it? Why the secrets?
@roriemarie2968 that's really irrelevant. Look at the Lukis Anderson case.
It don't matter what anyone on internet thinks 1 way or the other. He is going to have a fair trial. Hence why its takin so long
In Idaho, “stalking” means that the victims were aware of the stalking. That’s why I think the prosecution won’t argue stalking. But suggest he had those intentions
He may not have been stalking according to their definition but he was definitely doing surveilling of some sort.
@@desert_moon exactly!
They won't argue stalking because there is zero proof he was stalking and the defence has clearly stated there is zero connection to the victims.
@@paleandbeyond the legal definition of stalking doesn’t apply here. But remember in the beginning when they said they would specify if it was the victims or the house which was the target… there doesn’t need to be a connection to the victims
No one said BK was "stargazing." The media saying that just proves that the Defense needed that survey, because the media has tainted this trial with misinformation. In fact, it doesn't state where he went or what he was doing. It only says he went West, not East. That's it.
So what? He went that direction before turning off his phone to throw off what he was doing. It shows premeditation.
@@ericpalmer3588 Guy's like that DORK always take off and never reply back. Story of his life
@@ericpalmer3588 No one ever said he turned off his phone. Again, proving my point about the media spreading misinformation. The arrest affidavit only states that his phone wasn't connecting to any towers. One of the possibilities for that is him turning his phone off. But it's also possible that he was in one of the many "dead zones" known to exist in the area.
@@ericpalmer3588 Or he was not even in the same area. If his phone wasn't turned off, when he came back into town, it would have pinged.
@@erictrott6553 there aren’t dead zones known to exist in the area, you made that up.
Everyone needs to listen again to what Bill Thompson said at the recent hearing. He said BCK was not stalking on 'social media."
I believe what Bill Thompson was getting to was that in the probable cause affidavit it wasn’t stated that he was stalking them on social media. The stalking claim came from Kaylee’s ‘s family not the prosecution.
No proof of stalking anyone, anywhere, ever.
No proof of stalking, the Goncalves lied to the media by showing an unauthenticated account in BK's name
@@Soulwarrior7 you know that for a fact? I believe that none of us know exactly what the government has due to a gag order.
except that other woman he did something with cameras.
I’d think it’s slightly weaker than claiming he was playing poker on a smooth tree stump with a talking bear named Hugo who sadly passed away before he could give a statement, but I guess he could change my mind by bringing the evidence.
that seems much more plausible....let's wait for Hugo's testimony
😂😂 Hugo , where you at?
video game education eh?
Haha My Dogs name is Hugo....😅😅😅
It’s a better alibi that “I was sleeping by myself”, whenever the guy could walk across the street in half a minute and has more of a motive
Thank you for having Andrea on your show. She is my 'go to' for clear, intelligent and level-headed explanation based on fact.
Innocent man doesn't need this long to give his alibi
Precisely. He’s guilty af
That is an ignorant statement. An alibi needs to be proven. Furthermore, if you're facing a prosecution that believes that thinks you're guilty, you don't just show all your cards right away. That gives them a chance to poke holes in everything.
Not only that, The alibi of driving around has been out for about 8 months now. What we got recently was the full alibi with details, backed up by an expert witness. This takes time.
Read up on Colorado judges views of your EXPERT witness.
Wow best guest expert ever. Objective, well versed, pulls out of the hat Maxwell! Super impressive.
Who tf is this calm after being accused of murdering 4 people! Guilty af
Someone innocent who knows how the system works
😂😂😂 riiiight!
Eh psychopaths
If he was freaking out people would be saying "Guilty af" because it would be "omg he knows he's been caught!"
Stargazing is unbelievable but frozen shock phase isn’t?
Frozen shock for 8-10 hours. Totally believable
I work as a paramedic and frozen shock is a real thing. Volunteer in an ambulance you’ll see cases real quick
@@pumpkinfield100 It never said for 8-10 hours. Reading comprehension is key. The PCA said...
" The male walked past D.M. as she stood in a "frozen shock phase. The male walked towards the back sliding glass door. D.M. locked herself in her room after seeing the male. " AS HE WALKED BY, not all night.
@@JustaGirlinClevelandThe cops were not called until noon. By then plenty of their frat/sorority friends were at the scene. DM seen the intruder at 4 am and even tried calling M & K after with no success. Even SG said people were cleared too early. BK is being railroaded.
@@JustaGirlinCleveland Than why not calling 911 for 8 hours
Great breakdown. Clear and concise. Thx. I love how you connect the dots between Cy’s work and the earlier Giglio Brady and exculpatory evidence. Your experience is impressive.❤😊
This guy is toast. The alibi is just BS
Their best defense is to portray him as an insomniac, nervous wreck, ex drug addict. Recently lost his job. Regularly was awake and exploring during the nights.
U said it EX drug addict, EX! Him being up all nite had nothing to do with drugs. Insomniac yes it had all to do with him being up. His neighbor even testified to hearing him vacuum late nites. Being an insomniac he would go driving at night to help himself be able to go home and sleep. We don't have proof that he lost his job. Msm said it but they lie all of the time. If he did it was probably really because of him being accused of murder
.....and you're a nut !!!
@@denisekoenig9479Absolutely, I do remember a neighbor saying it. I think he suffers from visual snow too, but not sure.
I think her insights are some of the smartest I've heard on this subject. I certainly wasn't expecting her to bring up Maxwell. You could also add that runners tend to be a bit nuts. Running at night in inclement weather is certainly not an impossibility. As a local to that area I would also add that there tend to be some interesting weather zones around here. You cannot look at what is happening in Moscow and say that is what is happening even 5 miles away. The cell towers in the area are set up to cover the highways. Departure from those is definitely going to result in lost cell coverage.
I imagine Jupiter and Saturn will soon take the stand to testify in his defense.
The sun and the moon would advise against that.
Possibly just Youranus
@@petergriffiinbirdistheword
Uranus says it's out too.
😂😂😂😂😂
Andrea you rock as always ! 🎉
Thank you for this intelligent unbiased discussion.
This was great, thank you ✌
The only other question is- WHO ELSE DID IT?! No one is the answer.
😂😂😂
Yes as they always say, guilty until you prove your innocence by solving the case for the government
I believe that kopeka guy was involved as well
OJ
frat boys? the vet who killed himself the next day? drug cartel peeps? relatives of LE? relative of protected persons? whoever drove the truck (fish & wildlife?) seen near there?
You guys should have Bruce Rivers as a guest one day.
Has anyone noticed how his eyebrows are now trimmed when the eye witness stated at the time of the murders the person seen had bushy eyebrows. Look at the picture when he was arrested and to today’s photo
I’m 100% convinced this man is the Grim Reaper that did it guilty
He has never had bushy eyebrows
They are trimming,band plucking. Maybe waxing
@@nellym.6555That really is subjective .
Not only are they bushy but his prtruding forehead causes shadows on his eyes which makes the eyebrows appear even bushier, it's the main feature that totally stands out on his face. That why DM said that, bc even in dim light it would be noticeable!
The night he claims to be stargazing the national weather service says the weather in that location was overcast and freezing fog. The park he claimed to be at is also closed on the weekends as well as closes at dusk in the weekdays, but the individual in question also suffers from visual snow, something that would make it for hard for the individual in question to do. Utter B.S
so a person with visual snow murdered 4 people in the early morning hours?
His alibi doesn't say he was stargazing.
It has litterally never been confirmed be suffers from visual snow lol.
@@Kevinmiller835 are you ok? type in tapatalk and bryan kohberger and enjoy reading the ten years he spoke about the medications he was on for V.S, on a website, specifically for people with V.S. christ alive.
Thought he was just driving ...now star gazing.....
From what I've heard, it was a cloudy night.
@@ettajfan5882It's not about stargazing, it's about BK not being in Moscow.
It’s about smoking green leafy substance in n a state that it’s legal!
@@Soulwarrior7 don't think murder is legal anywhere
@@kathywhitaker1042 you’d be correct in the US
You've got to be kidding me.. Stargazing.. Lol
Well, why not believe that BK was not in Moscow on the day of the murders? If the PCA places BK in Moscow Idaho, and then they say that BK was not in Moscow that day. It's not about stargazing. It's about BK not being in Moscow.
@@nellym.6555but the DNA on the knife scabbard says he was in Moscow that day
@@nellym.6555at least the knivesheet of his knive was in moscow
It is pathetic, & sickening.
@@gremsa with his DNA all over it
Enjoyed listen to Andrea. I like to hear a defense POV.
what i don’t understand though is, let’s say the alibi is true and he didn’t do it, doesn’t that mean there’s a murderer on the loose and we’re all just wasting time here??
Great interview.
Does anyone know why you can't remove your cell phone battery? So that the GPS is able to continue to track and store your location while it is turned off. The amount of data your phone tracks and keeps about you is scary. They have all that info. Never hear about it, because they don't want us to know. Shutting it off makes you look guilty!
Bingo. Removing the battery is the only way to really go off grid.
Newer cell phones don't have removable batteries.
@@polkadotsuzanne9306 And the attacks on 9/11 are the reason!
@@alexpriedite1447yeah what phone this day even has a removable battery? Surely none made in the last decade almost.
The phones track amazing amounts of information. When screen lights up, unlock times, keys pressed. The list goes on
I don't think someone that self admittedly "doesn't believe in science" is a very credible expert.
Stargazing looking up at the sky in the backyard of the house on Kings Road prior to breaking in (about the size of it)
Andrea has her own channel! She did an amazing job in the Depp v Heard case!
Noooonoonooo he said phone was OFF because it was 'low on battery' and he didnt want it to die so he turned it off. Now all of this is changing??? SUS AF!
Why bring your phone tomurder someone
😢 rest in peace 😢 victims
I never heard that they saw him get in or out of his vehicle ever
I started watching Sy Ray's RUclips channel- Socialite Crime Club- about a week ago after hearing about him on another RUclips channel, curious about his background & credibility. He & Keri are an awesome duo, both former cops. He is totally credible, no doubt in MY mind. Everyone here saying BK IS guilty- that's not how it works here in the USA! A JURY makes that decision (beyond a reasonable doubt) after hearing both sides. Every one of us who has been following this case should want the RIGHT person to be convicted- ESPECIALLY the victim's families. I'm disappointed that SG would double down before he's even heard the info from the expert witness.
Phone goes off.... DNA shows up on knife sheath...then phone turns back on🤔🤪
Well, I assure you that your DNA is found in all the places you visited today, and if a murder occurs in any of those places you were today, you could be guilty even without having committed the crime.
@@nellym.6555his DNA shows up on the sheath for the knife that was used in the crime at the crime scene. And his phone was off during the time of the killings. The odds of anyone else having committed this crime is astronomical.
@@deathguise1992wrong. Absolutely wrong.
If the prosecution thought they had a slam dunk case, they wouldn't have been trying to cheat all this time. Makes me wonder what they're so worried about.
@@deathguise1992lots of people had DNA at the crime scene, we don't know where it was found. Including unidentified males DNA. Police haven't claimed the phone was shut off, only it stopped reporting to cellular resources. It's not as clear cut as you think.
While many in here have formed their opinions, let's remember that Kohberger is currently on trial in "the court of public opinion". We remember this with the George Floyd case. That cop did not kill him, and yet he was convicted. My point is..... what if he truly is innocent? The fact that the police have probably put "all their eggs in one basket", if it turns out he is innocent, the real murderer now has a slim to no chance of ever getting caught. The families of the dead will be the most devestated. Let's just keep an open mind. You would not want the public to convict you of something you didn't do, so let's give him the same respect.
Well said. And this is a death penalty case.
It will be appealed immediately
Prosecution has to be particularly tight.
🤞🏼
I agree. He deserves a fair trial. This case & the Delphi case has the most polarized opinions in the comments
Is there a legal definition difference between stalking or surveillance?
I’ve been saying from the start it wasn’t him. It was a police officer who committed this crime.
Case closed. Thanks.
Why you think this?
"I'm earning $200 per hour on this case, so we'll need to delay as long as possible."
It’s so weird, Webster just changed the definition of “stargazing” in its dictionary to brutally murdering 4 college students in the middle of the night…
Fascinating. However, typically when a scientist discovers a valid method of scientific discovery they draw up a research report (peer reviewed), so that the methods used are transparent, tested for validity and replication is possible. I can’t find any research paper for Sy Ray.
I love Andrea! I found her through the Depp v Heard trial. She’s just amazing!
Me too! That's when I found her
Not gonna lie. I wouldn’t convict. At best, circumstantial. It’s a death penalty case and/or life imprisonment w/o parole.
Touch DNA for the sheath but none found elsewhere (2 other male DNA samples also found on said sheath)
Model of the car mismatch (pretty big differences between the 2011-2013 and 2014-2016 Elantra assuming prosecution were doing their job)
Location data
Explain only his DNA on a knife sheath under a victims body.
@@loadedhot1034 planted 😉
@@loadedhot1034 wrong. 2 others were found iirc.
@@loadedhot1034 Explain how the victim's DNA wasn't on the sheath but one bit of touch DNA from the killer was.
The sky’s were cloudy, even some would say it was foggy, that night, in his location, where he was star gazing.
Edit:word
Pertinent!
Right. I wonder how the moon was too, if it’s half+ then that’s not ideal for star gazing.
So you were there? 😂 and you remember what the sky looked like that specific night?
@@chrissyscholl816 There are such things as weather reports.
@@resurrexionco7307 weather reports aren’t accurate it’s a general guess clouds move and shift it may have been cloudy and cleared and got cloudy again
They need to get his phone records from the days he has these photos from his "drives" and prove that his phone will surely ping the towers in these locations.
This was so much better than average, a real treat to have unbiased, intelligent analysis.
It'd be amazing to have a video dedicated to this cell-tower analysis stuff; it's always coming up in trials but are we being bamboozled as with DNA data?
With all due respect, I feel like some people need to go back and read his alibi again. It didn’t say that he was star gazing, hiking or running that night. They didn’t say that he had any pictures that night.
It doesn’t say anything so how exactly is it an alibi
And it says his PHONE was not in Moscow...it deliberately &carefully never says HE wasn't in Miscow? Hmmmmm...
Imagine that!
He has an alibi. Otherwise they would have said nothing. This is very interesting because police changed original timeline to fit narrative wanted. And it has been falling apart on court documents and hearings.
@@JohannaTx-they had to submit an alibi by the deadline. This is all he could come up with, and no it does not get him off the hook in any way.
@@ericpalmer3588When you are arrested all your devices are gone. It is called discovery what your attorney needs. He still owns his items properties, that is why state needs search warrants in a first place. If they will not give it, it is violation. I say, shady prosecutor!
If it was cloudy the night of the murders, where he claimed to be, how would he STILL be driving around for hours? Why wait until the clouds cleared?
But you don't know that it was cloudy the whole night. I have a weather app that says it's going to rain and it doesn't rain.
@williamtardy8137 daily observations from the night in question are recorded cloudy from 133am- 953am Nov 13th 2022, according to Weather Underground. Temperature between 28- 30*F
There is a record of it. Now, that is in Moscow. Maybe he claims to be elsewhere but I have doubts
The weather apps around that time predicted meteor showers
Andrea Burkhart is AMAZING at explaining what's actually going on! Smartest person I've heard speak on this case and I've been following since the very beginning. Thank you Andrea for coming on the platform and preaching REASON.
This whole case is just spooky. Like how do 4 full human bodies get torn apart with a knife by himself and had time to get away AND return to the crime scene BEFORE the cops were even called. LAWD please give me the strength he got
Wait don’t iPhones record movement or activity on the phone? I remember in the Murdoch trial there was evidence the phone was in use at certain times
Yes and that’s why the alibi and phone meta data will prove his innocence.
You have to turn your cell off if it continues searching for a tower the battery goes dead and then you cant use it when you get back to where there is cell service. why dont people know this!
Because there are over a dozen cellphone towers in that area and ZERO listed deadzones.
@@XShadowAngelnot true
@@XShadowAngel Absolutely not true and someone has driven the route to the park showing how bad cell coverage is
@@paleandbeyond "Someone"? Someone who?
It also depends on your cellphone service, plus my son and I have the same cellphone service, but out by my folks where theres a group of trees and inside my folks houses my phone still get service's but my son phone will not get service. We also have different cellphone.
@Andrea Burkhart is one sharp lawyer!
Hi Andrea great to see you here. One very articulate intelligent lawyer ❤
Very articulate biased lawyer.
Love her on these! All facts and professional povs. Not biased like everyone else that’s invited on the show.
What about hIs DNA at the crime scene?
Touch DNA means nothing. You are wearing strangers touch DNA at this very moment
"Touch DNA" testing also may be causing false convictions
What don’t you understand about touch dna? It’s been explained a thousand times. Someone could have touch his car door handle and the pca says the sheath was “placed” there as his dna probably was. What about the other male dna found at the scene? They didn’t say that was touch dna
Give it a rest. If you don't know /understand that now you'll never understand transfer DNA. There is a huge difference. 🐝
Okay when has that actually happen it says 98.9 %
So all these areas that he says he’s been driving around in that night that’s where they should go look for the murder weapon🤔
Kristie only will acknowledge what she wants to be true. I bet she had zero interest in finding out what Sy Ray will bring to the table.
He’s 1000% guilty, set the trial.
LMAO.
If I was innocent and had an alibi I immediately would of gave it and argued and argued that I wasn't there at the time of the killings. Idk pretty sus to me but I guess we will see how it goes. I pray that the victims gets justice
The prosecution will easily be able to explain how they got the cars range years and when they knew it had changed. Put the detective on the stand that did those precise measurements from grainy videos and explain why they didn’t get it exactly right.
I run late at night. Night owl here. Great to have an unbiased opinion. Love Andrea
It was overcast the day in question so he certainly was not stargazing!
That's not what he said he was doing anyway.
If the sheath doesn't fit, you must acquit...
No, you must also follow common sense, that's an essential part of the work of the jury.
So if they had this info all along, why did they not sit til now to give it?
I pray they get justice.
I think he did this, I did from the start- but I do go out late at night for car rides, walks, and I do star gaze some times lol. People do do that stuff is my point. It’s not thhhhaaatttt wierd. Especially in school.
Why not believe that BK was not in Moscow on the day of the murders, if the PCA places BK in Moscow Idaho, and then they say that BK was not in Moscow that day. When I was at university I would drive for several hours and sit by the sea until 4:00 am. And I assure you that many people who are in college and suffer from insomnia do the same thing. It's not about stargazing it's about BK not being in Moscow.
Thank you! Someone with common sense finally made a comment
You understand these areas being discussed are only about a 10-15 minute drive apart, right? And that the area is littered with cellphone towers, so there aren't deadzones.
It doesn’t say stargazing as his alibi
Plus the state says he's on I forget what street at like 2:42 am then in the next sentence...We observed BK leaving his apt at 2:57... how's he on whatever street when he hasn't left his apt. yet ? Its right there in the PCA describing this mess...
@@XShadowAngel An Idahoan creator just did the drive Sy states & he lost service ! Plus the Park itself states no cell service. Hello
I’m just throwing this here out there from the point of view of a woman who’s been around a long time and has 3 adult, beautiful daughters who have had their fair share of weird men chasing them from time to time. I think he’s awkward around men and women, lonely, and has seen this household of young people who are exactly what he perceives to be as perfect and happy and everything he deserves. He decides to follow “the ultimate gentleman “ leader of the INCELS. Loneliness in young men is extremely powerful and not to be underestimated.
this is the second case I'm seeing this week where phone records will matter when, can't wait to see what is real
Excellent guest! So much respect for Andrea!!
The car changed after his arrest
Got to say - I'm really impressed by a lawyer showing an awareness of James Maxwell's work!