American Reacts to Is India's ISRO the Most Successful Space Agency After NASA?
HTML-код
- Опубликовано: 12 мар 2021
- Hello! I'm an American on a quest to learn more about history, geography and the universe in general. In this video I take a first look at India's space agency, the ISRO. Why didn't I know about this before? They not only reached Mars orbit on their first try, and launch 104 satellites at one time, but they did it with the fraction of the budget of NASA. This makes them perhaps the most efficient space agency in the world. If you enjoyed this video, please like and subscribe!
Follow me for a behind-the-scenes look of my learning journey:
Instagram: / sogal.yt
Twitter: / sogal_yt
Facebook Group: / 238616921241608
Link to original video: • Is India’s ISRO the mo...
Copyright Disclaimer Under Section 107 of the Copyright Act 1976, allowance is made for "fair use" for purposes such as criticism, comment, news reporting, teaching, scholarship, and research. Fair use is a use permitted by copyright statute that might otherwise be infringing. Non-profit, educational or personal use tips the balance in favor of fair use.
#spaceflight #isro #india #spaceagency #americanreacts 
Наука
👋Namaste! Where do you think the ISRO fits in the group of space agencies? Like and subscribe if you enjoyed this video 👍🏻 Follow me on social media:
Instagram: instagram.com/sogal.yt/
Twitter: twitter.com/SoGal_YT
Facebook Group: facebook.com/groups/238616921241608
Hey🙂 please can you react to the Irish potatoe famine or battle of Rome
You may want to check out Project Skylon that's been in development for about 15 years now. Hopefully there should be a test flight in the next few years!
No we are very proud of ISRO and the thought process of resource diversion is wrong you need good implementation of resources and not more resources.
Watch the movie mission Mangal dedicated to mars mission of ISRO
Just a quick comment on your video, about the ISRO mission to Mars. No mission to Mars would have a constant rocket burn, that's why it takes months or years to get to Mars even though it's only about a 10 day flight as the Crow flies.
If crows could fly in space of course.
Fun fact: the movie "The Martian"(2015) had a budget of 108 million dollars to make compared ISRO's Mars-Orbitor-Mission(MOM)( orbit capture sept 2014) having 70 million dollars to actually send a satellite to Mars.
Edit: similarly for "Gravity"(2013) as well
Considering returns, that rocket is more beneficial.
Because of the knowledge and the data it would send about the planet for decades.
The people who worked in the mission were underpaid as compared to Nasa and CERN so that largely cut the costs of the mission. And they also succeeded in their maiden attempt. Hence, their overall cost was very low.
bhuvan raj it apreciable but both are different mission .ISRO MOM was tech demonstrater while MAVEN was real deal .It was launched after MOM but reached before MOM and its orbit is much more near to Mars than MAven . It way more advance ,has more instrument and has more fuel plus their operators on earth are decentralized and paid much more higher salaries so that adds up the cost.
@@rumaprakash3894
Why do you have so much misinformation?
They we're not underpaid
Its not the money issue , its like if we can do the same stuff with less money then why waste money.
Bro It is money issue but our isro has figured out the way to do things more efficiently . And that is very good coz now when we increase the budget isro would be able to more missions unlike other agencies who use a load of money to do one mission….proud of ISRO🇮🇳
ISRO is a fantastically capable organisation, probably the best national agency at the moment, bang-per-buck. To be honest, NASA's been lagging behind India, China and even Europe for a little while now. The private space sector is rising in importance too, albeit still very small in scale.
NASA suffers from inconsistent budget support from US governments changing, though it's also partly their own culture these days - make lots of powerpoint slides, get 95% towards completing a project, cancel it without ever launching anything, repeat.
@_ S Stark _ Hmm
The audacity 😂😂
There is a revitalization process now with Artemis.
@@BlameThande Nasa is suffering now due to budget while isro is suffering since it was created 😢 due to lack of budget.... Isro mars orbiter mission was done in just 73 m dollars while maven was launched at a budget of around 600M dollars..
I used to work at ESOC European space operations centre in Darmstadt Germany. Im well aware of ISRO and other agencies in the space game. Left some years ago but have some lovely memories and momentos.
Future project Of Isro with collaboration Nasa. (NISAR)..
Lol In nasa majority of scientists are
1) Chinese
2) Americans
3) indians
Congratulations Indian and Chinese education system for sending your brilliant people to other country
You played yourself 🤦🏻♀️🤦🏻♀️🤦🏻♀️🤦🏻♀️🤦🏻♀️
@@secretunknown2782 Wait ; What ???
Then Which kind of Talented People are working in ISRO in India ??
Are they Second Grade Scientists??
No problem you will hear about ISRO so much in future ... Because it's growing so fast.. .........
love from india 💗
What you say at the beginning about not hearing about other countries' space agencies as an American - NASA makes a bad habit of this. If you go to the museums at Cape Canaveral they never mention space achievements by other countries - contrast that with (say) the space museum in Leicester in the UK which tells the Soviet side of the space race as well. There's a reason why Canada insisted on writing its name in huge letters on the side of the arm on the space shuttle & station, as NASA used to basically never acknowledge in writing that it was made by Canada.
Yeah, no kidding...
@@Luredreier There's a reason for this. NASA has been around for many years. It was founded in 1958 and has its roots in the NACA, which dates back to 1915. It has a vast history of achievement in a aerospace going back over 100 years. It's hard for them to to squeeze in everybody else's stuff along with their own - especially in a fairly small museum.
Over its 60 plus year history, NASA has also been involved in literally hundreds of programmes - including manned spaceflight, unmanned spaceflight, aviation, human factors, engineering, environmental research etc etc.
Britain has been involved in aerospace for a long time too - but nothing like the scale of the US. Therefore, it's space centre in Leicester is more international in outlook. If was just for British projects it wouldn't have an awful lot to show.
I should also like to point out a few more significant differences between how NASA operates, what it is for and how that differs with ISRO.
NASA is a pure scientific and engineering research entity. It is not a commercial operation and does not carry payloads on behalf of commercial customers. That is left to the private, commercial, space industry.
It is also non-military - so it does not launch spy or military communications satellites. The US Department of Defense (and now the new US Space Force) launches its own payloads into space. In fact, in most years, US military and private commercial launches way outnumber NASA launches.
NASA did toy with the idea of being part funded by placing satellites into orbit for commercial customers in the early days of the Space Shuttle programme, but they backed away from that type of operation after the Challenger accident in 1986.
ISRO is a much more all encompassing effort. ISRO will launch anything for anybody, if they get enough money to do so. I attended the Farnborough Air Show in 2018 and spoke to Surrey Satellites, a leading builder of satellites in the UK (and the world) and they use ISRO a lot, because they are cheap and reliable.
ISRO is much more like the Russian programme than the fragmented American "programme" in that it is much more directly government controlled.
Launches in the US are split between multiple entities, some government (NASA and the Department of Defence) and many commercial and independent science entities.
The US (CIA for NASA ) killed the father of indian space research organisation (ISRO ) and many others and that cost us 2 decades.
@@aasamspb967 When and how did this happen? What evidence have you got?
Dates etc would be required to support such an allegation.
Man mission is still on but delayed due to pendamic. It's named 'Gaganyan'.
'Gagan' means Sky or space.
'Yan' means vehicle.
It will be like the ISS
You may find it interesting to look into what the Soviet space agency thought about the US landing on the moon.
Basically, they popped the champagne. They thought it was a great achievement for all mankind and sent umpteen congratulatory messages to their American counterparts.
it is also key to know that the space race though politicized was celebrated by all scientists on both sides. We all wanted to be first, that doesn't stop us from apreasiating the work of others that beat us. This is mainly in reference to the USSR's string of firsts in the first half of the space age.
@@cheeseninja1115
The USSR was first for everything in the Space Race, with the only exception being the moon landing.
@@AndrewD8Red yea in the early days a lot of technology transfers were given to isro by the Russians....they played a crucial role in expanding our space launching capabilities....
Indians love Maths and Science and I think all people feel that as we keep growing as an economy, we will keep adding more funds to ISRO.
That is not true for all Indians, especially the millenials.
@@gurjindersingh3843yeah i guess some millenials got everything sorted so they need to create some problems now. A space program is vital for geopolitics
1st nation water detected in the moon
1st nation moons darkside a Rover landing 98% success
I thought that the NASA Clementine mission detected water on the moon back in 1997?
@@EricIrl no
@@EricIrl chandrayan 1st detected
@@abymannady2563 When did this Indian probe detect water?
There was also a NASA impact probe that detected signs of water about ten years ago.
India did not land a rover on the far side of the moon. China did.
Russia landed rovers in 1970 and 1973.
Imedia’s only attempt to land a probe on the moon resulted in the lander crashing. I’m not knocking India’s achievements in space but people should not make claims about. Indian space achievements that aren’t true.
ISRO Discovered water on moon, India's first Moon mission - Chandrayaan-1 in 2008 - carried out the first and most detailed search for water on the lunar surface using radars. ISRO is preparing to become the first country to land a mission on the south pole of the Moon.The lunar south pole region features craters that are unique in that the near-constant sunlight does not reach their interior. Such craters are cold traps that contain a fossil record of hydrogen, water ice, and other volatiles dating from the early Solar System
Roscosmos right now building our own spacestation again) Good luck guys )
Like Dr Vikram said ISRO has no intention to compete with others but it focuses on enriching human understanding of space and beyond. Hence the concept of money wastage doesn't make sense.
It's not just that isro is number one.. I think 30-40% scientists working in NASA space are Indians 😎😎😎
Proud to be an Indian 🤟🤟🤟🙏🙏🙏
Only 1% of NASA scientists are of Indian Origin and none of them are Indian citizen.
Check Nasa Website
@@manishsaini9360 36%
ISRO is planning for the human mission named Gaganyaan, of which the selected astronauts are being trained in Russia. Admiring you from India🇮🇳 🙂.
Thank you❤🌹🙏
Training is already completed ☺️
@@Alex-hw9qz Thank you for the information!🙂
Love from India🇮🇳
ISRO is something I knew very little about .. but I like their values as a Nation too ... They take simple steps to solve problems and help advance the Space Race ... plus they have that Cool StarTrek looking Icon too ... and if you follow their values they think a lot like the Star trek Federation` because they also only worked towards advancing Humankind as a whole. I think reaching Mars orbit at the first attempt was amazing and any project of that nature is worthy of calling themselves one of the best space programs for sure. I often keep up to date with what is going on in space ... and we live in exciting times at the moment with the mars rover doing it`s thing and SpaceX doing crazy stuff .. plus the moon getting visited again .. it is all happening out there.
I always tune-in to Nasa T.V. whenever there is a spacewalk happening and a couple of years ago I had the chance to see the spacecraft that brought Tim Peake back to earth` when his craft came to The NRM in York ... forefilling a childhood dream of seeing a real spacecraft ... needless to say I took far too many photographs of it. So if I got this right` ISRO used the Slingshot Method to gain height to release stuff into a higher orbit ! ... now why did`nt NASA use that method to gain extra thrust when they were heading to mars ?. Space and all the problems humankind must first solve to visit or live on distant stars is one thing that I have always loved learning about, plus we must not forget about The Gateway Foundation too ... they have been rattling on about building a Giant wheel-like station that will Rotate to create Gravity on their station ? ... I love their plans and the idea`s they have` but it sounds a bit like a " go-fund-me " space program at the moment. I really enjoyed this video .. so please do more of them.
I would be interested to know your views on Star Trek as a whole ? .. and what do you think of all the spin-off`s and all the other stuff that has followed it ? .. I love anything to do with space in movies or on T.V. Have you ever watched Doctor Who ? ... and if so` what did you make of it. Oh yes` another great topic to cover for all you Techno-Geek Types is Motorsport ... Yes` I know .. Boring .. I hear you all scream .. but the advancements in many motorsports :- i.e. Sportscar racing .. are often even more mindblowing than some of idea`s used by NASA and ISRO put together.
1.8 billion $ is nothing big for the government to spend on ISRO. Its a very very small fraction of amount spend from a 2.87 trillion $ economy.
not for the socialist governments
we are pumping too much money in giving freebies to unproductive hordes and more than half of it too gets siphoned off by corrupt middlemen
Hi namaste ❤️ 🙏 from Assam INDIA 👍
ISRO and NASA are collaborating on first twin frequency earth observation satellite called NISAR. ISRO supplied some parts including a radar for the same 3 days ago. :)
Only heard of the indian space agency in the last few years, fun fact Australia has just started a space agency.
She is a billionaire, yes 18 billion small amount for her
Actually there were some indians who made it to the sapce -Rakesh Sharma, Kalpana Chawla,Sunita Williams,Ravish Malhotra . But it would be first by ISRO, and of course we stand for our country and sapce agency .👍❤️
Sayan Mandal Actually Sunita Williams is not an Indian . She is American citizen from birth.
Love from India 🇮🇳🇮🇳🇮🇳 🕉️🕉️🕉️🙏🙏🙏
I have just one suggestion. Please react to "How Britain looted $45 Trillion from India by VICE news
@Au Jun We don't want anything. We want rest of the people to learn history so that we can live peacefully together. And be in the same page.
@Au Jun But the same people take pride in the British empire. These are tools for cleaning up their mind.
@Au Jun We moved on but you can't deny the fact... Even the kohinoor that queen wears is Indian😒
My India, simple and powerful
ISRo is going to sent 3 astronauts to the lower earth orbit in 2022 as planned. And Indians support ISRO as much as we can. We are really proud of or it.😊
Most of the American satellites are getting launched by ISRO these day....that's quite an achievement. ISRO is not so old. Probably ISRO as an space agency launched in 1960s. ISRO was the first agency that found water on the moon...so proud of ISRO and its achievements.
We love what ISRO is doing and yes ISRO is doing a great work helping 3rd world nations in accomplishing their dream to have their own satellites in the orbit at affordable prices
1:03 We have NASA over here with mostly Indian employees 😂😂😂😂😂😂 WOW
If ISRO had NASA's budget, humans would be doing interstellar travel by now.
Dr. Vikram Sarabhai and Mr. Satish Dhawan are founder and founding member of our space agency I.S.R.O.
India's ISRO (Indian Space Research Organisation) is a giant among space agencies of the world.
Almost 35% Indian Scientists work in U.S.A.'s N-A-S-A (National. Aeronautics. and. Space. Administration.) that means NRIs or Non Resident Indians or more precisely Indians are running or Indians run N-A-S-A.
India not only developed its own launch vehicles like PSLV, GSLV and ASLV but its own satellites also.
ISRO has also developed NAVIC means its own GPS system, satellite destroyer missiles or weapons A-Sat which can destroy any satellite in the space, world's highest resolution camera satellite CARTOSAT.
India is the fourth country to reach moon and has its own flag on moon in 2008.
India is the first country to reach Mars in its first attempt in 2014. Its cost is less than Hollywood movie Gravity. India's second moon mission Chandrayan 2 was also a landmark in Indian Space Science history.
India has many future projects like Mangalyan 2, Chandrayan 3, Aditya L1, own space station in space, Shukrayan means Venus mission, Gaganyan, sending humans in space and resusable space shuttle.
India has record achievement of launching 104 satellites in just one rocket or launch vehicle to space.
India has not only developed its own cryogenic engine for launching vehicle but its first supercomputer PARAM 10000 in 90's after denial of technology transaction or partnership project or collaboration of U.S.A. with India.
India did everything alone and has capabilities do anything alone and its own.
India launched 342+ satellites till date in which most of are foreign satellites
India is the world leader of launching other countries' satellites on the lowest cost.
Indian scientists are super brain 🧠👍🙏🇮🇳
ISRO was the first to find water on moon...during its first moon mission...
i knew India had a space program but tbh i don't know anything about it
Yeah think it has caused controversy over hear in the U.K man. Cause we still help support them with payments for the poverty they have etc But then a few years ago they spent more on our support package on a space mission or something.
Personally I think we should still give them money, but that's mostly down to you know.....us Colonisng them in the past so...
See what u need to be rich
Talent and passion
And if any other country feel they are too rich
Don't forget that India was 25% of world's GDP before British colonished
And they looted 45 trillion dollars from India,
More than current GDP of any country on planet
So before calling it poor remember at least we are not thieves
And also don't underestimate what India is going to be
India gonna shine again
Keep learning mate😀
ISRO and NASA are working together for Nisar satellite (NASA ISRO synthetic aperture Radar) ISRO have completed their Radar part of satellite. It will be most expensive satellite launch by human to explore earth. ISRO is doing it's alot of work and NASA funded a major part of it.
I love space ❤️ another enjoyable video sogal 👍😃 I miss the space shuttle what a bit of kit ❤️ love to you and roger ❤️
who has discovered lunar water?
BTW I like that Coca-Cola t shirt 😍.
SPORTSKEEDA FUNTOOS BY NASA's Moon mineralogy mapper boarded on ISRO's Chandrayan.
I don't know if you like games or not, but the "Kerbal space programm" could be a fun game for you.
best way to learn about orbital mechanics, by far
You like Star Trek? More reasons to love you!!! 😊
Amazing how the props from star trek are now in every day use..E
Yeah, been a fan for a long time. Even have a Trek podcast.
If only she was single. And also not half a world away.
Alas...
And u look soo beautiful I love you ❤️
@@SoGal_YT And where would one find said podcast please? 😊 x
In NASA 36% Scientists are Indian🇮🇳 and now recently India's Bhavya lal is appointed NASA CHIEF......
ISRO Made World Recard by sending 104 sattelites of many countries through only one 🚀Rocket.....
Recently IRSO Again launched 29 sattelites including Brazil🇧🇷 sattelite some days before.....
If HAL(building situated opp to ISRO) was half patriotic as ISRO, then we would have had a 5th gen fighter by now
HAL guys chill a lot 😂😂😂😂
THOSE WHO WATCHING THIS VIDEO
FROM INDIA
WE STILL HAVE FEELING OF COLINIZATION
ISRO IS GOOD WE DON'T NEED OTHER'S OPINION
Plz make video on the Ashoka the great by kings and generals 🙏🇮🇳
THOSE WHO WATCHING THIS VIDEO
FROM INDIA
WE STILL HAVE FEELING OF COLINIZATION
ISRO IS GOOD WE DON'T NEED OTHER'S OPINION
Just To be clear isro had already sent astronauts with low earth orbit in the soviet era in there launch vehicle,This will the first time indian astronauts go to low earth orbit in a Launch vehicle built by ISRO itself
Yes the project is on tract for 2022-2023 due Covid
Namaste🙏🙏🙏
first video I am seeing.
😍🥰😘I subscribed.
🇮🇳🇮🇳🇮🇳🇺🇸🇺🇸🇺🇸
4:36 well it was "..for a man" referring to himself. It implies all he had to do was take a small step from the LEM onto the moon's surface but it signified a milestone in human achievement. Of course he was being incredibly humble, he did a heck of a lot more than take a small step.
I am from India subscribe your channel 😍😍😍😙
isro it helps India in many ways.
pretty soon we will have our own version of American GPS.
we made long distance ballistic missiles using isro technology
we launch satellites for other developing nations as well
We are Indians we are born intelligent
Thank you 👍
These are some future missions of ISRO:-
1- Chandrayan-3:
a. It is expected to launch in 2021 and is a successor to the Chandrayan-2 mission.
b. The mission will attempt a soft landing on the lunar surface and will have Lunar lander and rover.
c. According to ISRO, the total cost of the Chandrayan-3 mission will be more than 600 crores.
2- Gaganyaan:
a. India's first human spaceflight mission is expected to launch in the year 2022-2023.
b. The Gaganyaan orbital vehicle will carry three Indian astronauts to the low earth orbit - an orbit of 2,000km or less - for a period of five to seven days.
c. The spacecraft is jointly made by ISRO and HAL(Hindustan Aeronautics Limited)
3- LUPEX:
a. ISRO's Lunar Polar Exploration Mission in collaboration with JAXA (Japan Aerospace Exploration Agency) will be launched in the year 2024.
b. The mission aims at obtaining the actual data related to the quantity and forms of water present on the surface of the Moon to determine the feasibility of utilizing such resources for sustainable space exploration activities in the future.
4- Aditya-L1:
a. It is India's first solar mission and was expected to launch in the year 2020 but due to the COVID-19 pandemic, the launch has been delayed and is now expected in the year 2022.
b. The mission aims at studying solar corona in visible and near IR bands.
5- RISAT-1A:
a. It is expected to launch in the year 2021 by ISRO.
b. It is a radar-imaging satellite and will be similar to RISAT-1 satellite in terms of configuration.
c. It is a land-based mission for terrain mapping and analysis of land, ocean and water surface for soil moisture.
6- NISAR:
a. NASA-ISRO Synthetic Aperture Radar (NISAR) is expected to be launched in the year 2022 by ISRO in collaboration with NASA (US Space Agency).
b. It aims at studying global environmental change and natural disasters and will be the first dual-band (L & S) radar imaging satellite.
c. NISAR satellite is likely to be the world's most expensive Earth-imaging satellite to date with an expected cost of $1.5 billion.
d. The mission is expected to have a life of three years.
7- Mangalyaan-2:
a. Mars Orbiter Mission 2 (MOM 2) also called Mangalyaan 2 is expected to launch in the year 2024.
b. It is India's second interplanetary mission to Mars by ISRO.
c. It will consist of an orbiter and may include a lander and a rover.
8- Shukrayaan-1:
a. The inter-planetary mission is expected to launch in the year 2025 by ISRO in collaboration with CNES (National Centre for Space Studies; French Space Agency).
b. It is a proposed mission to study the atmosphere of the planet Venus-- the second planet from Sun and the hottest planet of our solar system.
c. In the year 2018, India and France issued a 'Joint Vision for Space Cooperation'.
9- India's Own Space Station:
The proposed space station is envisaged to weigh 20 tonnes and serve as a facility where astronauts can stay for 15-20 days, and it would be placed in an orbit 400 km above earth. The time frame for launch is 5-7 years after Gaganyaan.
If you want to find out more about space stuff and keep abreast of developments you might find Scott Manley is a channel worth having a look at.
Latest isro launch carried Amazonia 1 which is Brazil sattilite to space .it has carried many usa satellites for less cost
Hey SoGal, if you are interested in learning more about different cultures, you can try making a discord server where you can chat with ppl if you some confusion. It might help you a little. Also then those small things that some videos miss will be more clear. Just a suggestion. Stay Curious and don't mind nasty comments if you see any here.
2022 is not sure due to covid but ETA for Gaganyaan or man mission can be somewhere bet^n late 2022 and early 2023
1 - NASA - the National Aeronautics and Space Administration. ...
2 - RFSA - Russian Federation Space Agency. ...
2 - ESA - European Space Agency. ...
3 - ISRO - Indian Space Research Organisation. ...
4 - CNSA - China National Space Administration. ...
Isro holds the world record of launching most satellites in one go 104 satellites more than double from the previous record of Russia in mangalyan world ridiculed india that it could not launch a satellite to Mars with that tiny budget and some said we didn't have enough experience and then we proved the world wrong and India was the first to do it in one go in its first attempt 🥇🇮🇳
Wait for the manned mission next year.
Would love to see ur reaction on "Geography Now! India".. ✌🏻
Already done
Putin sir you are late. Already done.
Hi sir
Hi. Winding up using orbital passes to gain momentum is normal. They'd need a tanker full of fuel if they tried to get to Mars in one hop, and no chance for anything further. There was a mission recently where they spun off to Venus, looped back for a pass of earth, did a second Venus pass before having the speed to head off for Mercury. The mathematic 's are mind numbing, you have to calculate where all the planets are going to be, months or years in advance, to hit them at the right angle for a speedy throw on to the next target. Think it's called sling-shotting. The two voyager satellites bounced from one planet to the next over several decades to get to the outer planets. The recent Pluto fly by was similarly tortuous. It's amazingly fine calculations.
The European space agency are completing their Galileo project at the moment. It's a similar system to GPS, but they'll control it. UK has contributed a lot to it, but won't get to use it due to Brexit.
There is an attitude in UK that we shouldn't be sending aid to India, when it's spending on a space programme. I don't think the critics realise what a shoe string operation it is. Operating on a tight budget does sharpen the wits as to how to get things done cheaply and more effectively. For instance UK sent a probe to Mars called Beagle, it didn't survive the landing unfortunately, but it was a masterpiece of miniturisation.
You'll have to make a space helmet for Roger now!
ISRO is the first organization which found water at the moon
Yes people questioned a developing country having a space program.. But it only made us save money in many sectors like sending our own satellites for farming, researches, television, weather predictions. So practically ISRO saves government money in other sectors coz we don't have to outsource those jobs to other space programs which obviously costs money and the cost goes up every year. Also it helps other developing countries and some private customers around the world which cannot afford sending their satellites with nasa or SpaceX etc. In return ISRO gets business in terms of money. As the launch of 104 satellites was not to set record but just to make the flight cheaper for every customer like carpooling 😜😜 and earn some profits alongside.
India launched it's 1st satellite Aryabhatta by Russian rocket from Russia, the cost is of course bearded by government.Another example, in near future, the internet services will be provided via satellite, so if India plans to have the technology it does not have to outsource it.
And as u mentioned that the space program is not for competing other nations but u missed the second point that Mr V Sarabhai said that it is for our own development in technology and space science so that one day it benefit our country. At the same time we have to make utmost use of our limited resources and we cannot afford to fail as many times as any other space program may afford to.
Hi
You asked about ISRO man mission
So basically The first crewed flight was planned with a spacecraft called Gaganyaan for December 2021 on a GSLV Mark III rocket ,
Last month all the scientists who will go to space went for training in Russia ,
And about ISRO I think ISRO should get more Funding from gov ,
1:12
I'm pretty sure that you partner with us Europeans and ESA the most.
Although you've been forced to work with Ruscosmos quite a lot since you stopped flying your space shuttles up till when the private companies where done certifying themselves as being ready.
The Russians have a lot of experience with taking people to and from space cheaply and safely and the location of the launch matters when you're trying to rendezvous with the ISS.
Same with carrying capacity and track record of manned flights, and like I said, the price...
Europes ESA and the Japanese JAXA/NASDA have a *lot* of cool missions to other planets and moons though and we've done a lot with the US and NASA.
Basic thing is just read about top 30 countries like its Country name, Capital, Rivers,resources, Science/technology dev, GDP, Exports, Language spoken,Type of administration, their President/Prime Minister.
Being an Indian I think, the money govt. is putting in ISRO is not only being properly use but I expect the govt. funds ISRO more... because the works ISRO is doing is not only making us insanely proud but also making the nation strong. I clearly see that ISRO is one of the most key carrier of India's path to more prosperity.
Gaganyaan is the mission name for human space flight. Indian Air Force pilots have been selected to man this mission.
Interesting fact is that the diagram shown in your book about the distance from our earth to moon is wrong and it is far greater.
Nice video 🙏🙏🙏🙏
U should know that the scientist who found the isro Institution was mysteriously assassinated and same goes for the scientist who wanted to bring a nuclear mission in india both were great people.
India /ISRO is not in space fight with anyone & we proud of it...
We are jugado( means we are money efficient as it's in our DNA) that's makes us indians and we don't need money in billion we only need perfect solution and alternative thus achievement is ours.
advancement in science and technology drives the economy
NOW spacex Holds The Record Of Most Satellites launch In a Single Space Shuttle.
True. ISRO's PSLV-C37 launch put 104 satellites in total into orbit in 2017. Only this year (January 2021), SpaceX placed 143 satellites into orbit in one launch so they currently hold the record. Bear in mind that the bulk of these large volume payload type satellites are actually "nanosats" - which means they are extremely small and are often part of student projects. Minituarisation and the use of off the shelf components, means that very small satellites (shoe box size or even smaller) can be made quite cheaply and lots of them can be packed on top of a medium capacity rocket.
First one always special 😏
I wouldn't be too harsh about not keeping up with developments in space. "Space is big...." as Douglas Adams entertainingly put it in The Hitchhiker's Guide to the Galaxy. Taking up the subject can be daunting since if you're into space you're into everything. See the small blue dot by Carl Sagan... ISRO has demonstrated a good working model of a civil space agency. A careful matching of capability progress with useful civil outcomes. The largest return from space has been, still is and will be communications and information. Others have capably outlined these here. A small scale verification that ISRO has taken a sound path is the success of Rocketlab following a similarly disciplined approach. Of course this is a small company rather than a national agency, who's leadership did not promise to eat their hats if the scope extended... Meanwhile, at a small company, a small hat eating ceremony ensues...
There is a Bollywood movie biopic made on this project called "Mission Mangal" (where Mangal means Mars). You can watch it with english subs, but be careful it's a movie so it's likely to take some creative liberties instead of showing 100% correct information.
We love isro❤️
Less that 2 billion USD is spent on ISRO, which is actually very less. Compare it with 70 billion USD on Defence, which is still considered less when compared to China, India's main threat.
So hardly anyone thinks this as waste of money.
India needs to take care of its people before they leave them behind..........humanitarian wise.
Do you want to know how much Indians love ISRO? Once, the ISRO chief was flying somewhere, and the entire plane gave him a standing ovation.
7:12 only true geek will get the reference that NASA's budget is *low* with respect to fundings other Federal agencies receives from US federal government. So for Indians NASA budget may seem large but its actually smaller with respect to other US Federal agencies especially *DOD* which gets the biggest share of *700+bn $*
Space economy will be huge in the future.....i think ISRO and Indian government is investigating in it and it will not only pay out for itself but will earn from launching other countries satellite with bare minimum cost.
You rightly said about NASA's budget is not too much either. I am from India. The budget ISRO gets is also a very tiny tiny portion of total budget. If you can solve all of India's problems by utilising the money on ground, instead of in space, then by all means take it, take all of it, shut down ISRO. But if you couldn't solve the problems with 99% of the money, what more can you do with the remaining 1%. I am pretty sure it is even less than that. Space exploration itself is such a majestic endeavour that it may feel like waste of money to the untrained eye. Where as the money ISRO gets is really like breadcrumbs, and those breadcrumbs are laying down our path to the future.
Let that sink in.
Where is she from ?
Fun fact: 36% of NASA is made of Indian origin people
Wrong fact..
Extremely wrong infact only 1.1 percent people in nasa are of indian origin or indian. Have you even checked it before commenting. 😂😂😂
@@akshatsharma6172 please read the whole article, also we know after they change their citizenship. They counted as Americans in their survey, not American Indian or Indian origin. Their survey don't show or reveal these reports to their country people. Also you may have heard most spelling bee competitions winners were from Indian origin.
@@voldemort6596 brother grow up !! 😂😂
Being a Spelling bee champions and being a Scientists in Nasa has no comparison.
I pity on you 😂😂
And check the nasa website they clearly says that only 1.1% Scientists are from indian origin.
Ooooooooowwwww❤️🙏
Yes the man space mission is GAGAYAN
Orbit calculation is used with geometry. And very hard
IF ONE NEEDS TO BE A PROGRESSING NATION THEN ONE HAS TO FOCUSE ON ALL NEEDS OF THE NATION THEN TO SAY THAT INDIA SHOULD FOCUS ON OTHER THINGS PEOPLE
2022 is planned for manned test mission with no human but a robot.
With humans its planned in 2023.
He forgot that ISRO is the first space agency search water in Moon
भारत 🇮🇳🇮🇳🇮🇳🇮🇳🇮🇳♥️🚩
The plan was to put a man in earth orbit, don't know if still on track though
Hope you check out Rockets Labs from New Zealand
Best