George Floyd Murder Case | Is Derek Chauvin Guilty of First Degree Murder?
HTML-код
- Опубликовано: 3 июн 2020
- This video answers the questions: Can I analyze the George Floyd murder case? Should Derek Chauvin be charged with premeditated murder? Support Dr. Grande on Patreon: / drgrande
www.kare11.com/article/news/l...
www.revisor.mn.gov/statutes/c...
www.revisor.mn.gov/statutes/c...
minnesota.cbslocal.com/2020/0...
![How Sweet - NewJeans ニュージーンズ 뉴진스 [Music Bank] | KBS WORLD TV 240524](http://i.ytimg.com/vi/UEELqlGOl_k/mqdefault.jpg)
As a black guy, I can find nothing wrong with your analysis. Chauvin was clearly high on his own power and felt that satisfying himself was more important than doing his job properly as a police officer. The other officers are almost as guilty because they, unlike the regular citizens, could have stepped in and pulled Chauvin off of Floyd. Regardless of what Floyd did or his general state of mind, he did not deserve to be suffocated to death. The lack of empathy on the part of the officers was clear and unfortunate. People like that have no business being cops. If they used to be better people, perhaps it is the culture you mentioned that has to be changed.
I live in a country with mostly white folk. Since hearing about this case, I've been so sad. Mostly because when I want something to change, I just take control over it. In this case, I can't. And I am afraid of poc falsely believing every white person is an enemy. It hurts me so much to see this divide between us. Every life is valuable. I wish you all the best and if you are in the US, I hope you can stay safe.
@@willnill7946 What are you talking about exactly?
Error Code:WTF I agree 💯 with you!
@@TheMapman01 you are what is wrong with the world and why police get away with this.The cop was not judge and executioner,his sole job was to make an arrest.Who is to say Floyd even knew the money was counterfeit?
Cop had 18 complaints of misconduct and should have long been relieved of duty as he proved himself a menace to society-as are you.
@Ella Blun Speaking of unnecessary comments....
If you want to test a man's character, give him Power
-Robert Ingersoll on Lincoln
trump
@@johnd6734 Obummer = ISIS = Moderates = Double the National debt = Obummer care aka more Taxes lol = was useless to his "brothas" & Sistas for 8 yrs
Michael Manrahan Nobody even cares to respond to Russian trolls anymore. I gave you one response so you don’t get sent to Siberia lol
Speaking of which, lincoln was a racist but at least he emancipated an oppressed peoples, but the oppression still continues.
Or money
Love how calm and level you are:) it’s so soothing..
Thank you for once again explaining these hard cases in a no nonsense manner for everyone to understand. I knew you’d get a lot of subscribers. You definitely deserve it!!
Excellent Analysis
Thank You Dr. Todd Grande for Calling it like it is. You are a Good Man. Thank You for Seeing What truly was going on.
Watching him readjust his knee on the victim's neck, hands in his pockets, looking around casually made me think he had done this before...
no hand in pocket, he has black gloves on, watch as he lifts hand off pants then you see the truth.
@@crystalinedreams6039 oh so its ok then . Here i thought he was a sociopathic murderer.
@@daveyboy_ @Daveyboy -😂😂
Pure jealousy!!!! He was mad because George was more handsome than him!!😄
Yes he had this before because he even hands of his pocket
Dr Grande you are absolutely Brilliant l really wish you were called as an Expert in cases that are uncertain or unsure as to what really happen in this case or any case.😉👍👍👍
Please notice the utter lack of humor when the topic is truly serious and beyond funny! Our good Doctor has real scruples! Unlike some police officers! Thank you Dr. Grande for your humanity!
The first time I saw the video what stood out to me was that he not only lacked compassion, he seemed to enjoy not only killing Floyd but making sure that all the witnesses knew that they too were powerless. Dr. Grande has described this perfectly.
I agree!
I almost didn't watch this one, my stress, anger and absolute horror of this murdered man has been too much on top of a deadly pandemic. But you nailed it!! Great Job.
+Kathy Teschner ~ I know Kathy. I’ve been having chest pains.
@therandom3591 but did they kill her? NO. NO. NO.
GET IT?
People need to stop mentioning that as if she HAD BEEN MURDERED! Yes, it was awful to do this but they did their theft and left. Many times such an assault ends in murdering the homeowner for the sheer thrill of murdering - NONE OF THESE MEN KILLED HER, THEY DID NOT EVEN. KNOCK HER UNCONSCIOUS WITH THE BUTT OF A GUN, NOR DID THEY BLIND HER OR TIE HER HANDS DOWN NOR TIE HER TO A CHAIR NOR DID THEY RAPE HER. PUTTING THE GUN TO HER BABY MAY IN FACT HAVE HELPED HER STAY CALM AND NOT DO ANYTHING STUPID WHICH COULD HAVE ESCALATED THE SITUATION - BECAUSE the gun being on her belly helped her remember she had to keep quiet to protect her baby (which kept both of them safe). So, contrary to what a gun to the belly of a pregnant woman first may strike us as, it actually was a very helpful thing for them to have done that. They were not wearing masks either, which would have been more terrifying. There was actually a sane method to this action. They were black men and she a black woman, so there was a level of understanding each other culturally as well, which helped keep the situation calm and a clean theft ONLY so to speak. Neither did they taunt her even with the threat of rape, nor did they cut her face up with a knife nor trash her home for the thrill of it. This puts this act, though fully unlawful, in a whole better light than what many truly awful perpetrators have done.
Good analysis, Doctor Grande. I haven't been able to watch the trial, because it's just too painful. My son will be 18, in a couple of weeks, and I'm praying that he never has a bad encounter with the police.
Perhaps you should tell your son not to resist the cops. The place to fight injust police is in the court room. Every single police shooting video has a common denominator, people fighting and resisting the police.
@@PanzerAce760 but Floyd wasnt resisting arrest, he panicked in the car. Regretted it pretty quickly and then didnt do anything other than communicate that he couldn't breath. That is not resisting arrest. Stop trying to find excuses for what these four men did because clearly they enjoyed taking that mans life
@@hanwirtz4305 have you watched the entire video? Dude clearly is resisting. And appears to be under rhe influence and it appears he had something in his mouth.
@@PanzerAce760 I just went back and watched it again, he kinda resists getting in the car (at which point he is already handcuffed) he keeps saying he has anxiety and cant breath. He was obviously intoxicated and entering a very high state. Honestly after watching it again I feel like the correct course of action at this point wozld habe been to call an ambulance due to a possible suspect oberdose and place his againt the wall again ect. He wasnt physically trying to stop anyone, he was just making a bit of a scene. The cops didnt dry to calm the situation, the took a person probably in need of medical assistance and restrained him and applied considerable pressure to his neck. Despite the fact he lay there telling them he couldnt breath. They did this until he stopped breathing. .... update sorry for all the typos, my phone is in two languages and gets confused all the time.
@@hanwirtz4305 so can we agree that mr floyd is at least partially at fault for his own demise? Can we agree the media has lied and mislead about this situation to fit a narrative? I dont feel mr floyd was a great outstanding citizen by any stretch of the imagination and in no way deserves to be martyred by the black community.
Best analysis of the topic of I ever heard. And it was done 10 months before the conviction!!
Great intellectual honesty. Just listened yesterday to Judge Andrew Napolitano's assessment on this case and he said the exact same thing. First degree murder and aiding and abetting a murder on the part of the other officers. You're a true professional. 👍
Thank you Dr. Grande for your analysis it helps me. I was a biracial child who was treated horribly in a small town in Texas during the sixties. Your analysis helps us, as you agree we are all human beings and equals.
still whining after 50 years plus ?
@@Sean-st5ud My aren't you the charmer. Your lack of basic empathy says nothing derogatory about her but lots about you.
one of the police (Kueng) on Floyd is also biracial.
I am white and born in the mid 50's, I was raised to see everyone as equal and respect all . I had friends of many colors and any were welcome to visit after school and stay for dinner . This type of upbringing would solve a lot of problems .
@@briandavis7811 SIR,IF THE WORLD SAW EVERYONE AS YOU DID,THE WORLD WOULD BE A TRUE UTOPIA! THANK YOU FOR YOUR KNOWLEDGE
Your analyses are always so well thought out and easy to follow.
Dr. Grande, I love your communication style and I think you are BRILLIANT! Thank You for your perspective and professionalism.
"Chauvin did not consider Floyd worthy of even the most basic human dignity"
A summary of the case in 13 words.
Really wish the prosecution gets an expert to assess this side of the crime who is even half as good as you are Dr.
I also applaud your assertive, even angry tone in this one.
+Algo1 Floyd was wacked out of his mind on meth and fentanyl. Fentanyl increases your chance of having a heart attack 100x. George says that he can't breathe before being pinned down. This is a symptom of a heart attack. He also said he was claustrophobic and his stomach hurt. Two more symptoms of a heart attack. George is 6 foot 6 and muscular. He freaked out in the back of the police car. That is why they pulled him out and pinned him to the ground. The medics didn't give any medical care when they arrived. Seconds count. Instead they loaded into the ambulance and drove to a different location to look at him. He wasn't pronounced dead at the hospital until an hour later. The medics probably could have revived him had they started resuscitation immediately. I think everyone thought that he had just passed out and wasn't dying.
Dude is in jail for murder, fuck yes. And his 3 buddy cops, complicit cops
@@Islamisthecultofsin Those cops might as well top themselves off. Because when they get locked up they are in for hell on earth. I for one will applaud that.
Also, as the Dr mentioned, it has been medically deemed as death by asphyxiation. So your own hollow explanation is moot.
Neither you nor Dr Grande knows what Chauver "considered" so let's not speculate. Dr Grande outright lies in the video by saying Floyd died from neck compressions. That is *not* what the autopsy report says. It says he had a heart condition, covid-19 and loads of fentyal in his system.
Domination... don't forget his tone and words of "get in the car" while he was at the same time making it impossible to comply.
He even made fun of the man he just was about to kill
@Sandrina Otelli Jesus was definitely into alcohol and he robbed a lot of people of their sanity.
@MW thanks for the despicable attempt at redirection.
it’s called a taser. It’s called pepper spray. It’s NOT called murdering someone with your knee and asphyxiating them to death by holding that knee for nearly nine minutes-two of which he was fully unconscious. It was a heinous act of brutality and murder. And should have never happened and could have been prevented had they used different methods. It doesn’t matter if the victim was a saint or not. Who among us has never sinned? Let them cast the first stone. Who among us has never loved someone who was in a dark place in their life and made horrible choices and paid the consequences for those choices? Do we love them less because they make mistakes? Who has never hurt because someone we loved broke our hearts with their mistakes? If you cannot relate to what I’m writing, you may not have a soul, a conscience or you’re devoid of empathy. Because He was a human being. A life. And he had the right to live and go on living. Most people have done regrettable, some even unlawful, things in their past. And many people have turned their lives around. I turned my life around. When I was a teen and young adult I made many regrettable decisions. Then I made a decision to turn my life around. And I went to college and became a social worker got married and am raising a family. I got my education and have a fantastic family and career and life now. Every day is another chance to turn it all around. Who knows what better things he could have done had he lived. He moved to a new city for a fresh start and was in process of doing that very thing. But he was murdered and that chance to do better was horrifically extinguished. Redemption is possible. People are not just the sum of their mistakes. He was loved. He is mourned. He was someone’s son. He was someone’s father. He was someone’s brother. HE WAS A HUMAN BEING. A WHOLE HUMAN BEING. NOT JUST THE MISTAKES HE HAD MADE. BUT A WHOLE HUMAN BEING. Someone who loves him is crying at the loss of him right this very moment. What he did in his past is irrelevant. He did not sit before a jury of his peers and be found guilty and sentenced to death for a counterfeit $20 bill. He was denied any due process whatsoever. He was MURDERED. And Murder is murder. His past is irrelevant and it’s disgusting for people to act like his past transgressions somehow excuse the fact that he was murdered. Like that makes it ok to take his life. He is the victim of a homicide. Victim shaming is a shameful act in and of itself. Period. And for those who do it, you’re making a disgrace of yourself. Not the victim. YOURSELF. George Floyd, I stand for you. I stand for justice✊
Lord Ronin, The Compassionate 👍
tHANKS very helpful analysis . As a former officer I have been conflicted by this case, These facts have been very helpful
Yes! Yes! Yes! You hit it right on the bullseye! Watching the entire video of George Floyd’s murder at the beginning of Chauvin’s trial was the most disturbing and disgusting display that I have ever seen. It was narcissism and complete disregard of a human life. I don’t know how anyone could live with themselves after that… and then to just return to work. You did a superb job breaking it down.
Thank you for taking this on, Dr. Grande. Calm, compassionate, reasoned (and reasonable) voices such as yours are in desperate need at this juncture in history. And congrats on the subs! You deserve it.
I wish your analysis would be heard at the trial.
It will.
Mel Simeons👍Yes!
Thank you. I really appreciate how you pointed out each policemans frame of mind. Thank you
Very insightful and interesting. You’re professional and rational while pointing out what could -and probably is - happening. I’m addicted!
Dr. Grande, "it's not what you know; it's what you can prove". This is the reality of the criminal justice system.
He knows that, captain obvious.
Yes, we need laws to help the innocent being lied on by these monsters. Why can't they at least educate the legal system especially judg s on the tactics and behavior of these demons. I believe they have laws in Great Britain now for emotional abuse , it is after all as damaging as the physical abuse. I'm glad the word is spreading of the dangers these narcissist types are capable of! Evil
@@rullmourn1142 if you can't be nice don't talk how's that captain dung. I don't want to see your negative crap when the rest of us are having a interesting conversation about real problems. We don't need your small mind here.
Yes,that truly sums it up,this is why so many criminals get way with their crime on inssuficient evidence,and also what the court holds back as "inadmissible" because the information was obtained "illigally" or not "according to the book".So can we really call this justice?
@@runningthunder6923 this law is for domestic abuse. It has long been recognised for children. Only recently has the law been changed for partner violence to extend it fully beyond only the physical aspect.
I expect it will be applied more generally in time via the laws against incitement to hate crimes.
I just think about how they treated George in broad daylight, while being recorded. How do you think these officers treat civilians when they're not on camera?
Crazy, eh?
Very scary
Exactly
Some, but not all, of course.
Worst than a vicious bull dog. They are capable of alot.
I always look forward to seeing you analyze a case bc you have been able to get to the most critical aspects & present them in an informative manner easily understood. Ty Dr. Grande!
It's interesting seeing the psychology behind it. The hands in pocket whilst the knee on neck is very interesting observation.
Your analogy of using his knee instead of his hands. Brilliant!
There is recent news footage of his beautiful 6 yr old daughter saying "Daddy changed the world".
How true these words are. ❤️
Thank you Dr Grande for your analysis and calling Chauvin out for what he is...a sadist.
@Ernestine Yes, I tend to agree there,it could have traumatised that child.
@Ernestine I don't think anyone attacked the 6 yo here. She said she kinda missed him
Floyd was a violent criminal who was high on meth and fentanyl when he died.
Your analysis was spot on as usual. Thank you ✊
Thank you for telling it like it is. It’s shocking that there are still swathes of people who, despite the evidence you described, believe Chauvins actions were in any way reasonable or warranted. I think you really highlighted the pervasive problems inherent in current US policing.
We need flashlight cops with detention slips to distribute to the criminals and a required PLEASE stated..... And if you don't want to go through the court system , great , it's the criminals call . It's our fault he is commiting crimes anyways.,.....
Being ridiculous to highlight the ridiculousness
@@lbardocz actually , they are wanting you to kiss their ass .... And give them all the money you've earned 🤔
Chaivin was following protocol and he did not kill George Floyd fentanyl did
This analysis needs to go to trial! Right on Dr. Grande
The excuse they are using for the black officer not trying to stop it is that he was a rooky.
Conjecture !
@@johnnysays5879 you must be just like Chauvin!
@@radrook4481 They need to teach all of the rookies how to take a stand, and be an upstanding police officer with a lot of backbone and courage!! And let the ones who have been in law enforcement for years, that if the young new ones, see despicable behavior, they are allowed to step in, and take charge!!! This law needs to change immediately!
Brilliant summary and analysis as always! This particular case is especially touchy, as all our hearts are cut ✂️ to the core as one human being shows zero regard or compassion for another. I cannot imagine the trauma that the bystanders must have experienced as they watched this murder take place. Thank you, Dr. Grande, for help keeping the world level-headed and focused on what is important.
Mermaid Mansion totally in agreement.💜🌻
My sentiments exactly! Our hearts were broken...we’re so greatly pained. Many of us are experiencing PTSD...black people, white people, people of all colors, nationally and internationally.
Thank you for your comment and for your compassionate and loving heart. 😘
@@lemostjoyousrenegade OH my goodness, my dear, the VERY SAME gratitude, appreciation and love to YOU!!!!!
@@cindyrhodes Thank you, Cindy.
This is the most emotional I've ever heard Dr Todd.
Wow very well said , you break it all down in a very methodical way . Great analysis and couldn’t agree more
9 minutes and 29 seconds. It's absolutely unbelievable! Please update now with the trial
Just watch it or pay attention to the news.
@ElGato Volador You don’t have to watch the news to watch the trial. You can watch the full trial live, as well as any other news story you can go to the actual source yourself and get the full story without anyone’s opinion added. It’s not that hard to find real information from the actual source.
@D C The police chief of Minneapolis has testified that ex-officer Derek Chauvin violated the agency's policy on force during the arrest of George Floyd.
Chief Medaria Arradondo said the way Mr Chauvin restrained Mr Floyd was not in line with training and "certainly not part of our ethics and our values".
The chief fired Mr Chauvin and the three other officers involved days after Mr Floyd's death last May.
@D C Mercil testified the restraint Chauvin used was unnecessary.
And has since been banned.
"An expert witness testified in the trial of Derek Chauvin on Tuesday that officers used excessive force against George Floyd during his fatal May 2020 arrest. LAPD Sergeant Jody Stiger, an expert in tactics and de-escalation training, reviewed the case and testified for the prosecution..... Earlier, more Minneapolis police officials took the stand. Their testimony came a day after Minneapolis Police Chief Medaria Arradondo testified Chauvin's actions violated department policy.
Tuesday's first witness, Minneapolis Police Sergeant Ker Yang, explained how the department's crisis intervention team responds to people suffering behavioral or mental health crises. He said officers are trained to de-escalate a situation whenever "safe and feasible." Next up, Lieutenant Johnny Mercil, who trains officers in use of force and defensive tactics, took the stand. A martial arts practitioner, he said he incorporated Brazilian jiu-jitsu techniques into the department's police training. He said officers are trained to use the least amount of force possible to gain a person's compliance."
At the time of Floyd's death, Mercil testified officers were authorized to use neck restraints by applying pressure to the side of a person's neck to gain compliance, but only for people who were actively resisting or assaultive, and only if other techniques had not worked. Looking at a a picture of Chauvin kneeling on Floyd's neck, Mercil said it was not an authorized neck restraint. He said such a restraint is not authorized to be used against someone who is handcuffed and under control. All neck restraints at the department have since been banned." It's very doubtful Mercil's testimony will clear Mr. Chauvin.
@D C I am in very good health and not sure I could survive with a knee applied to my neck for 10 minutes. The neck is a very venerable area of the body. This technique has been banned in MN as a result of Chauvin's actions so probably very dangerous. "At least 32 of the nation's 65 largest police departments have banned or strengthened restrictions on the use of neck restraints since the Memorial Day death of George Floyd after a Minneapolis police officer held his knee to Floyd's neck for more than seven minutes, a Washington Post analysis shows."
Yes, yes, yes. We need your logical, calm analyzes on this. Thank you 🙏🏼
Thank yiu for your intellect and education on narcissism ! It should be taught in schools and churches , to protect the youth and adults from these evil monsters 🖤👺 So, we must encourage home schooling on behavioral health ‼️
Now that we have a guilty verdict on all three counts, it turns out your analysis was spot on. I now understand more about the psychopathy of the other officers involved. We still don't know yet how their trials will turn out. It seems like they will be convicted too if all goes appropriately and there are no technicalities.
Those others will plea they already know the leader is gone
"they didn't appear to be shaken" that's so creepy
When the bystanders were begging Chauvin to get off of Floyd he looked up at them with an expression that I can only liken to a wild animal, it was blood chilling.
please don't compare this monster to a wild animal.
His face was blank, no sign of any emotion at all. It was as if he wasn't even there. Look, the more I look at that and think about it, the worse it is. When we found out they KNEW each other, that they had worked security at the same club, I really do think there was an issue of some type between them.
That makes me feel even more sure that it was intentional. Chauvin knew what he was doing, and he intended to kill George Floyd.
Either sociopath or dissociation
You are right it was like he was hypnotized or possessed, scary.
Maybe the Police with his knee in My Floyd's neck was on drugs
Wonderful and clear analysis. To be honest and made situation even more clear to me because of how detailed it was. Thank you.
I WISH everyone could watch this explanation.
Brilliant. If only you were an expert witness for the prosecution. Your genuine horror at witnessing the murder adds such power to your analysis. The restraint with which you express your thoughts on this atrocity is genuinely moving. What a great writer you are. Thanks.
@Leo Pard You sound like you need to google expert witness. The same way they have Forensics, the same way they have an expert examine the polygraph test, same way they have experts decipher someone's handwriting...etc. I could go on, but im sure you are intelligent enough to get it now.
@Leo Pard bot 🤖
You know you dun goofed when Dr. Grande isn't having any of your s***. "Yeah this was first degree murder, case closed".
You should watch the lawyers analysis on this. Great vid on whether it is 1 2 or 3 degree murder
Thank you Dr Grande for this very excellent analysis.
I remember when the bystanders were asking chauvin to stop because Floyd said he couldn’t breathe, Chauvin just glared at them in a trance-like state. He glared right into the camera while Floyd was dying. This behavior to me was very sadistic.
Did it ever occur to you, in the FULL context of those sidewalk cam thugs (who commonly harass cops during arrests) that Chauvin was sick of the whole scene for a good reason? Why do you care so much about the death of an evil home invasion robber, anyhow? If cops (or anyone) had killed him when he held the woman at gunpoint in 2007, would his death still be so sacred? How you live your life matters.
Those bystanders were also cursing at him and threatening him. Seeing as how Geroge Floyd was saying he couldn't breathe before he was even on the ground, and how Derek Chauvins weight was on his right knee,and not his left knee which was on geroges neck. I'm willing to bet George OD
why do you defend an animal who brutalized and killed an unarmed person who was complying. the crowd was comprised of ordinary citizens there is no evidence of anyone here being a thug other than you. the only thing these so called cops knew about Floyd was that he was ACCUSED of passing a fake $20 bill@@DefundTheFringes
@@DefundTheFringes Floyd was convicted and did the time for his past crime.
How could he ask people ANYTHING if he couldn’t breathe?
We all saw what happened but its so different from a psychologists point of view. Great analysis
He is not a psychologist. He has a PhD in "counselor education." For example, he cannot conduct assessments and evaluations (e.g. MMPI) like a registered clinical psychologist could.
He certainly gives clarity with an educated, apparently unbiased perspective. Very appreciated.
Bella Hammer....And yet it's not so different ! Dr. Grande is basically saying that this cop knowingly and willfully decided to and carried out the murder of George Floyd, and was willfully assisted by the other two cops who held Floyd down, and the fourth who stood watch to further facilitate their crime. Any layman watching that horrific video comes to that conclusion themselves, especially when you get the side view behind their patrol car and a full view of George's body and the other two thug cops on top of him. Dr. Grande goes on to conclude that sadism, narcissism and total domination were the psychological factors in play here with Chauvin primarily, and the others to a lesser degree, as well as racism and conspiracy of all them to commit murder. This analysis is pretty spot on. Thank you for covering such a timely event in such a timely manner. I would have just preferred a more in depth analysis of the psychological factors of this case...i.e these killer cops, but I guess you might have time constraints with these videos.
Doctor - I find your analysis to be short-sighted and incomplete. You dismiss out of hand the first initial autopsy findings - why? Bias of some kind? The way you describe the perpetrator may be somewhat accurate in that very moment but you fail to examine this person in light of their apparently long career.....Why? According to your analysis and assumptions, this cop was out there killing people routinely with a smile on his face. Your disappointing assessment that this was definitely racially motivated has no evidence to support it unless you know something that hasn't yet been reported.......I heard a report that these men knew each other but you don't mention that......
Doctor - please excuse me but I've noticed a bit of an agenda in this and other videos - I still like your vids though!!
The other officers were apparently very new so could it be that they didn't want to go against the senior officer?? Seems likely that was in play too.....
Hideous! Absolutely heartbreaking to watch that video. I cannot understand the type of mentality those officers displayed. You described this horrific incident extremely well. I had no words. Devastating. 😭
In America, this sort of no-feelings behavior is the norm. If you show feelings, people generally take you for an incompetent and crazy person. People don't show care for other people in this country and when in trouble most friends will say "hang on in there." The whole society has psychopathy in its blood. Take healthcare, for example, why don't we have universal healthcare?
by the power of the white girl i am offended on your behalf .... you are the classic example of gullible facebook manipulated person
Their minds were in a dark EVIL place and it's sickening.
@@Gr8Success you're weird!🙄
At least we can prove it has nothing to do with BLM and you can’t prove it statistically but I can. 9 unarmed POC k* vs 19 whites k* by police.
Great insight. One girl's video captured the cops misconduct. I hope this inspires others to step in when they see injustice. I praise the bravery of that one girl. Thank you
It’s not brave to record cops. People do it all the time. Lol.
That's fine but....Chaivin was following protocol and he did not kill George Floyd, fentanyl did
7:10 is when this episode gets really intense.That should have been the closing argument at the trial
This!!!!
It definitely was first degree. He had NINE minutes to decide to lift his leg off his neck! Sucks that they have to lessen the charge to convict them
If they trie him and no conviction gets charged...he's free instead..more riots..
Yeah, but it helps get him in prison, and thats where the real punishment will happen, you know someone will get to him eventually.
@@mugger1 awwww....😂😂😂😂😂😂😈
@@mugger1
I was just thinking the same thing....those ex cops are likely going to be toyed with then eventually killed in prison or they're going to commit suicide before anyone can get to them.
It's the end for them.
Hope no way these charges will stay. They are inappropriate to the max. First Degree. Murder.
I thought he seemed sadistic. I love all your videos Dr.Grande!
You should be in the courtroom as an expert witness evaluating mental state of assailant.
unfortunately julie, the rules of evidence would not allow him to testify and as such, the judge has ruled in this case. so much so, that the judge restricted testimony about psychological evidence relating to George Floyd around the moments of his death. i understand the rules of evidence. but having heard grande’s analysis, i am convinced that a major portion of the analysis and truth is being missed.
This psycevalve is spot on, it helped me to understand the Demeanor of Chauvin while watching the trial
The more I watch Dr Grande's analysis of current topics the more I appreciate his calm, even handed approach and his measured delivery. In this chaotic, mile a minute culture we inhabit it may take a minute to slow our minds and hearts down to absorb such carefully thought out explanations as Dr Grande's but it is more than worth it to do so. Thank you, Dr Grande for sharing your thoughts. I come away from your channel enlightened and somehow soothed at the same time.
Well stated @beth williams!
“Justice will not be served until those who are unaffected are as outraged as those who are.”
-BENJAMIN FRANKLIN
You really mean there are excuses for all the riots, violence and all the murders that has followed...?
a bird in the hand is worth two in the bush.
we get it.
zip it.
"Each man's death diminishes me,
For I am involved in
mankind. Therefore, do not
send to know for whom the bell
tolls,
It tolls for thee."
--John Donne
@@Stroheim333 No! Literally nowhere in this post does it excuse the looting. But I will! What did people like you think was going to happen when the authorities initially refused to even charge Chauvin, the DA states "I don't even see a crime commited here". If they'd just arrested and charged the four men as soon as a suspected murder had been committed, none of this would have happened. It you don't accept this you are part of the problem and will have to accept your not going to be getting your way from now on.
Books in Review....Wow...What a timely and relevant quote for all the protests going on now, or rather specifically for all the non Black people who are outraged and out there protesting as well. Benjamin Franklin was a privileged white man so I'm sure he wasn't referring to the issue of racism when he said this. I'm also sure he would be dumbfounded, if not straight out displeased, that his words would be applied to this issue ! Nevertheless, it's a great and fitting quote for our current national events.
Excellent analysis Dr. Grande. I think you covered all aspects of the dynamics in this murder. The sadism, narcissism, psychopathy of the officer was enabled by a terribly flawed system. Reforming the current police it is of utmost importance so monsters like him don’t have a license to murder with impunity and thrive in their depravation, while feeling entitled and totally protected by the PD.
Where is the "murder"?
What do you think about Mohammed Noor who killed Justine an unarmed and innocent citizen in Minneapolis? He’s about to be pardoned
actually the person who was killed was NOT a citizen of the USA but rather an Australian and Grande HAS done an analysis of the case.@@robinpigeon2070 unfortunately she approached the police car. When I called 911 regarding a possible break in of my parents house after they died, they told me police were on the way, asked me where I was , (in my car in their driveway), and to remain there and not approach the police car, that they - the cops - would approach me. As a black woman I know I am particulary vulnerable around cops, their delusions, bigotry, assumptions and racism. Something innocent can go south and become life threatening in a moment.
I will not call them unless there is a potential threat to life- in this case there was to me and my son. our properties are in a majority white area with the number of non-white families being less than 10%.
@@robinpigeon2070 oh he wasn't pardoned he had his conviction vacatedto a lesser charge but still was convicted for a shorter time than that cop who killed the guy who was eating ice cream in the his own livingroom
@@user-xg3uy6hq9g why was it bumped to a lesser charge? He shot the poor woman dead on the spot!
Your analysis as usual, right on the money, and eloquently said, the best summation of this horrifying case
A controversial topic, but I don't see (many) controversial comments. This gives me hope. Thank you for your analysis.
For you, it is probably "controversial" to point out a very obvious thing: The murder of Mr Floyd doesn't excuse anything of all the violence and all the murders that has followed.This is something we should never ever need to discuss or point out -- but now there are riots and violence apologists to be found everywhere.
Dr Grande's watchers are people who like nuance and analysis, that's why we're here :)
@@eev14 What are your nuances about the riots and violence? Do YOU have any?
@Michael Alber Of course. And you also write that pointless comment only to deflect from my questions. For example: What are your nuances about the riots and violence? Are there any excuses for them...?
I think Dr. Grande must be a big Dragnet fan, "Just the facts, ma'am."
One other aspect of this is that they know they are being recorded on peoples's cell phones. Yet they acted in a way that is completely normal to them. That suggests two things. One, they are supremely confident of their immunity form any consequences of their actions. And second, they did not see anything wrong with what they were doing. This is not a problem of a few bad apples. Its a broken corrupt system that needs to be torn down and rebuilt.
I don't think the didn't see anything wrong; that would actually help the defense.
Absolutely..... Such a shame.....
Dont forget third, this was all a set up to stir up the masses in order to create chaos, then bring martial law, then public unrest, that's how marxists get things done.
@Gem Rose I saw that they've done this before, Chavin and the Chinese. They were in power mode, and dared anyone who challenge or cross them. 3 youngsters hurried away crying traumatised for life.
Very good points Dennis.
Good man Todd, saying it exactly as it was 💕
This case is so very sickening.
Thank you for your assessment.
Holy bang.. i learned more in this 12 minute video than an entire week of protests, riots and looting...
Round of applause for Dr. Grande. .
You mean someone calmly speaking is more efficient than mindless violence?
I can’t watch the rest of this video without saying, every human on earth watching the video of George’s death cannot say he didn’t die of suffocation. God bless him and his family. Been watching your videos for sometime andI think your fair. RIP Perry. 💕
J.L.W I know. It’s ridiculous. I am a retired RN.
@J.L.W They did two more autopsies that agree it was murder. The first one had a telling sentence that said something about 'whatever drugs he had in his system' if they that found any they would have been stipulated. That coroner likely didn't know about the video and he was going to fix his friends up with an excuse. The question is would he have died of any of his underlying conditions if he hadn't had a cops knee on his neck for nine minutes.
J.L.W He died because he couldn’t breathe.
SFP Exactly! Someone says they can’t breathe....then back off. Those other officers were trained! They should have known better.
+Lisa Floyd was wacked out of his mind on meth and fentanyl. Fentanyl increases your chance of having a heart attack 100x. George says that he can't breathe before being pinned down. This is a symptom of a heart attack. He also said he was claustrophobic and his stomach hurt. Two more symptoms of a heart attack. George is 6 foot 6 and muscular. He freaked out in the back of the police car. That is why they pulled him out and pinned him to the ground. The medics didn't give any medical care when they arrived. Seconds count. Instead they loaded into the ambulance and drove to a different location to look at him. He wasn't pronounced dead at the hospital until an hour later. The medics probably could have revived him had they started resuscitation immediately. I think everyone thought that he had just passed out and wasn't dying.
Great analysis! This is exactly how I feel about it all as well
This video should be played in every police department in the US, once a month
Holy moly...are you stepping on a land mine!? Nope just the refined logic and balanced opinions of Dr Grande... 👍👌
Well said David.
He likes this.. gives him a good window to look through at his viewers 😄😅 you aren't only "watching" him, but viceversa.
Surprisingly, really not all that balanced on this one, in my opinion.
@@arbez101 Elaborate.. Are you going to tell me this was not murder committed out of sadism? Because if so maybe you should (re)watch the video and take a better look at Chauvin. He is smirking while doing this.
This one isn't particularly controversial, at least to me. It's obviously police misconduct, I just don't like how it's being used as a spring board into all these race narratives when there's no real reason to think race even had anything to do with this.
Thank you for presenting the facts of this case in such an unbiased and indisputable manner. Sure wish a jury could hear you speak on this case.
Dr. Grande thank you for having the courage to speak the truth without mincing words. An attack on one is an attack on us all!
Wow, I’m not used to hearing this level of emotion in Dr. G’s voice. It’s clear this incident moved him as it has millions of others...
He got caught up in the hype and he's 100% wrong. Chauvin will appeal
@@default123default2 and he'll lose once again
When you spoke about how the other officers didn’t feel moved to intervene on their own really hit me. The lack of their empathy is inexcusable. I know the 17 year old girl who recorded the incident as well as the other bystanders received a lot of backlash for not stepping in. You made it clear that they had no option for the sake of their own safety and I feel the same. I really appreciate everything you said here.
Surely the bystanders don't need any help exacerbating their survivor's guilt. They were all victims of police brutality that day.
They would have been beaten, killed etc they were powerless. And the cop knew that.
Those innocent bystanders.who have been turmaised
watching a psycho kill a man, right in front of them. I pray they don't get. Or have PTSD , also. They must be terrified too, for their lives as they have to now testify in court against those cops , and all cops stick together ...They could really make those peoples lives very miserable
Or they feared him.
Horrifying. I do not want to put words here. Only imagine how the witnesses are going to suffer a lifetime. Wondering about their implication. Wondering of own guilt or own not guilt.
I cried while watching the video of Floyd. And I cried while hearing you repeat what happened. It’s unimaginable how someone can do this
Same here. I had to pause the video and sob before being able to continue for another minute.
I also cried after seeing the video when it came out, it left me lying awake through the night and this horrible situation and the uprising coming from it have preoccupied my days.
Horrible. And I think of the bystanders there. This is going to be a lasting trauma on them.
I will not watch it.
I have to admit I didn’t watch the whole way through. Someone told me he was crying out for his mom. I’m a mom of 3 boys and it hit too close to my worse fears.
As a retired police officer, I can agree that Dr. Grande's analysis is correct and knowledgeable. A tragic and frightening day indeed.
you are awesome Sir. Your tone, delivery, and especially your intellect and depth of personality is wicked good! up heeya from Maine. Yesah! hearts a many to you.
Just watched this again now after watching 3 days of the trial. What a beautiful job Dr Grande did here. He absolutely tells it like it is.
Freakin same. He makes such good points
AND so are all the others!
He tells it like what "is"? His opinions? Opinions aren't fact, tho.
Excellent, I wish he was the prosecutor, the way he broke it down was amazing, I would definitely want to convince all of them after listening to this.
Not so sure I agree with first degree murder. 1st degree requires planning in advanced and intent. I think this happened more spontaneously with intent. Chauvin arrived at a chaotic scene and then murdered Floyd. Surprised Dr Grande would go with 1st degree.
This is a very sad story. It's strange to think that Mr. Floyd is only a year younger than Dr. Grande. You never know when it's your last day on earth. Every day is a gift.
If you think this murder is sad look up the story of Daniel Shaver by a Arizona police officer. Sadly that police officer was never convicted of anything and given $34k a year early retirement. The video is on You Tube is chilling.
@@felixthecat4584 ty I'll watch. What a world... There doesn't seem to be much joy in this world. Probably just my PTSD rearing it's ugly head🤔
@@felixthecat4584 - The Shaver case was horrifying.
@@felixthecat4584 there's tons of police who have wrongfully murdered innocent people that have gotten away with it. The police officer who murdered my brother didn't even get reprimanded. 😑
@@rebeccaspratling2865 I'm so sorry for your loss. It sickens me that this is happening, and as I understand it has been going on for years and at such extent.
I'm from Norway, and truth be told the norwegian news rarely report on police brutality outside Norway. It's something we find it hard to relate to, as it just about never happens here. I've simply not been made aware of this unjust, unfair, racist, power induced, sickening conduct.
Now I'm made aware. And I'll use my voice, wherever I'm able, to make my stance clear, that this is unacceptable. I demand change!
I really appreciate your analysis especially on describing the case for 1st degree murder and the timelines and details involved because I could not watch more than a few seconds of the video footage. It is horrendous that someone like Chauvin and his accomplices were ever allowed onto a police force.
Excellent assessment. At the very end, after Mr. George was taken away, Chauvin had to know that Floyd was dead or going to die and he comes up to Thao and gives him a fist bump. As to say “good job”.That speaks to his intent and carelessness of his actions and underlines your precise and truthful analysis of him. I hope they show that in court.
These details are horrific. Thank you for covering this in such an eloquent and succinct way.
He went unconscious within two minutes, he was no longer a threat! This is the worst show of power I've ever seen!
And yet his attorney says that he did exactly what he was trained to do as a police officer, disgusting 😖
@@DANIEL-ls5ku it sickens me, at the same time this was going on my son was arrested, tazed seven times and kicked in the face and ribs while in handcuffs! It took five cops to subdue a 130 lbs man? No, they're power hungry and think they're badasses because they can do this and get away with it over and over again!
worse, before he "went unconscious" he was already handcuffed.... really he was never a threat after that moment .
@@freewayrick1 he was kicking the cops the part the media hasn't shown
If he was ever even a threat at any time in this situation, which seems really doubtful. It was all over a counterfeit $20... And he certainly wasn't going to be a threat to anyone once they'd cuffed him. They could've just let him walk away at that point, what's he gonna do with hands cuffed behind his back? There's no way to explain any of it with logic & reason.
Chauvin wanted that crowd to know that not only was this going to go down but that it has gone down before and, further, just try him: because it will go down, again. The total disdain on Chauvin's face as he surveyed the scene around him was unbelievably psychotic. That he is now guilty of all 3 counts is the LEAST amount of justice he deserves.
I honestly believe he was having a sexual thrill, couldn't stop until he climaxed and wasnt going to, see they had to pull him off.
Amen 👏🏾👏🏾👏🏾👏🏾
@@sandysegree7271 geez it is the same impression I had the first time ever I saw Frazier video... I hope I am wrong because otherwise it is super creepy to death
It was Chauvin looking straight at the cameras with no fear or shame is what got me in the gut.
Chaivin was following protocol and he did not kill George Floyd, fentanyl did
I'm watching this again after today's verdict. This is one of the best summarizations of how sadist and disturbing were the actions of those former policemen. U even said it was frightening and intentional. Agreed. The guilty verdict today was just clearing the lowest bar of standards of decency for authorities in the US.. It is frightening if he was acquitted, it would mean police could literally, unjustifiably, and undisguisedly kill whomever they choose, without consequence. I THANK GOD he was found quilty.
I am a white, retired police officer and I agree with Dr. Grande's assessment of this case.
Thank You for Your Service Mr. Duke.
Can you answer a question, why is it that in these lethal cases law enforcement are never seen trying to administer First aid, is it policy, procedure or lack of training ?
As a POLICE OFFICER, you MUST agree....these are basic traits inherent in every police officer...your color does not matter. The traits Dr. Grande talks about correspond with self-selection traits in the "Police" profession.
@@fh346 How do you know that he hasn't hurt or killed innocents? Why would you presume he is a good cop...if there is such a thing as a Good Cop!
@@abba747 You sound like a criminal.
As a fellow mental health professional and mixed ethnicity woman, I want to thank you so much for taking the time to look at this case. I found your analysis to be professional, logical and concise. I’d love to know whether you feel that dark triad and dark tetrad personality traits are a systemic problem within the police force, and whether or not you feel that they are purposely sought after. This has been something I’ve been researching for quite some time, and I’d love to hear your take on the subject.
I've caught wind of how the hiring and psych eval has changed over the years, with the emergence of new titles. From police officer, to law enforcement officer. They used to be officers of the peace.
I saw a research data about in which positions the most of narcissist or psychopaths are to be found. Im pretty sure law inforcement was one of them. I don´t know if the system is looking for these people intentionally, I presume not because they only follow their own authority and cause more problems in the long run than bring the value in. I am pretty sure that these positions are attracting such personalities because they are officially allowed to execute often an unquestionable power and this is exactly what they are after.
I remember reading an article years ago about a man's application to be a cop in CT rejected bc his IQ was too high. So they are looking for certain types...
@@vaiciciaku Yes you are right. Psychopaths are attracted to positions of power. Off topic but nurses are another area where psychopaths are drawn to as a career.
@@suras8984 As a former RN of 18 years, I agree with you, sadly. For some reason, those with the title of RN think/feel they're "deserving" of respect because of their title and what they went through to get said title. I worked with other RNs who wouldn't do something as simple as refill a patient's water jug per the patient's request because said patient wasn't assigned to them. I witnessed one RN in a hospital I worked at advising a patient, who asked them to please refill their water jug, that they'd get their CNA/aide to fill it up for them and then walk away. After that RN left, I followed up by telling the patient that I'd fill it up for them. This patient wasn't assigned to me, either. But what's the big deal about filling up a water jug for someone? Ugh! The smile that came across that patient's face is something I'll never forget. Doctors fall into this category as well. I've worked with a handful of doctors in my 18 years as a RN who thought and acted like MD stands for Medical Deity. At the same time, let's please remember that not all nurses/doctors/police officers are bad.
Wow the way you explained the situation was very highly professional you should have been Floyds lawyer. 👍👍👍👍👍👍👍👍👍👍👍👍👍👍👏👏👏 🤝🤝🤝🤝🙏🙏🙏
I like your clinical analysis in general and particularly here. Yours could've been the concluding arguments of the prosecution. That something like this is allowed to happen in the country of exceptionalism is beyond anyone's imagination.
I like your vids and continue to watch them. Kudos!
This is the best video I’ve seen so far. You don’t add sensationalism, just facts and your opinion. This case is really disturbing. I found it very telling that the killer seemed so relaxed the whole time. I figured it was because it’s not his first time.
I don't think it was his first time.
@Hieronymus Bosch I hope the attorneys representing Mr. Floyd's family does investigate Derek Chauvin past with the Police Department. If there are other deaths related with Derek Chauvin line of duty, they should ask other victims family members if they can exhume these victims to do an autopsy on these other victims. If it proves Derek Chauvin used excessive force which cause their death; now they can charge Derek Chauvin for first Degree Murder and in fact they have a serial killer wearing a Badge!
@Hieronymus Bosch absolutely amazing if this is true, how this jerk could have kept his job . If this was racist act it should be exposed during the trial. Also his union reps , supervisors that allowed him to stay in job .
@jet guy that would be a huge mistake for this man to "get off" .I personally do not believe it's possible at this point .
Same
7:16 yeah that bothers me a lot how he had no expression on his face,it was 2nd nature for him to kill someone in public ....just strange
Likely the same face that stone cold gangbangers have when they kill another black man. That is strange indeed.
well said doctor grande!! im currently watching the trial and i am glad to hear your opinion and facts! thank you for an informative video
Your account and the words you used to describe those events go beyond my ability to express my feelings... barbarism, sadistic, domination... how very eloquently and powerfully you summed up my thoughts. I feel shock, sorrow, anxiety, and even hatred...
Thank you...
That murder was one of the saddest, most disturbing things I've seen in recent memory.
I found your analysis excellent, Dr. Grande, and it contained some new material and surprises for me, and I'm very glad I tuned in and tuned in early.
I've heard that they knew one another, that they worked together as security in a nightclub, but I can't confirm that; if true, it would add a new dimension to this case, and could support a charge of first degree murder.
I get some of my perspective on things like this from Jimmy Dore and, more seriously, from Chris Hedges (both prominent presences on RUclips), and Hedges recently said that police murder over a thousand people in this country every year.
Thanks, again. I appreciate your candor and professional expertise.
Look up TONY TIMPA RUclips
They worked at the same bar, but it’s unclear if they knew each other. Floyd worked inside security (there was apparently a large team of guards) and Chauvin worked outside. It was interesting though that the bar owner said Chauvin didn’t like working events when there was going to be a large Black crowd.
@@patrickcameron2950
Thanks.
These details will be clarified during the trials, I suppose. There could be more things we don't yet know.
The Asian cop who stood there and did nothing is Chauvin's brother-in-law.
@@CC-mr5xq
That complicates his case.
It seems they just got too comfortable with the excessive power they had over people.
I admire how dr grande let us know ehere he stood on this immediatley when he says he is going to talk about the MURDER of george floyd. Not alleged. MURDER.🤗💜🤗💜🤗💜🤗💜
a lot of people use the word 'alleged' even wneh someone has confessed..they don't want to be accused of influencing anyone when it comes to adjudication.........
Thanks stay strong on this journey called life. Continue to educate very needed this day and age, almost the negative different types of conspiracy theories.
Excellent analysis Dr. Grande!
This was the best breakdown I have heard of this case.
I feel the same way i like this dr. Hes smart and easy to understand
For REAL! All of it is what I'd said from the start.
I wish he could be a juror on the case.
chillinebony that's so right. The news is kind of making it hard to understand
Except that it is lawfully wrong in its conclusions.
The paramedic asked Derek to get off he refused. It was only when he tapped his knee he casually stepped off. With a nonchalant look on his face.. He really thought there would be no repercussions to his action. Walking casually around with no remorse and so much pride.. Even the way the paramedics dealt with George dragging his body up and across the floor throwing him without care down on the gurney. His lifeless body.. They didn't seem to care their was no urgency no attempt to resuscitate George.. Because they knew he was dead. There has to be justice for this.. Day light lynching.
Quiche Lorraine we don’t need your false flag conspiracy theories here.
Well put. I was wondering on the moments after he had killed him and this is the first Iv learned of the aftermath. It’s like a nightmare. Every part of what they did. I can’t believe the paramedics just tossed him with no regard . The world has shown that this is where it must end
After I thought about that I thought it was odd. They usually work on the person before moving to a gurney and into the ambulance. The whole thing is so outrageous.
Watch Civil Shepherd
Those were not paramedics but officer's check the video again they were wearing body armour and side pieces. In my opinion they were attempting a cover up but were not expecting the posting of the video and the actions that followed.
i appreciate the distillation of the issues in the chauvin trial. it was good to hear a psychological perspective, and i had been watching the trial in its entirety. the judge, has declined to allow any evidence of psychological issues, perhaps validly (per rules of evidence) but i think we miss out on the big picture when we do.
I couldn’t watch the video of Floyd it was so sad I think the verdict was just. Thank you for sharing on this.