The Luminox Navy SEAL: Tool Watch Or Toy Watch?
HTML-код
- Опубликовано: 7 апр 2020
- thetimetellershop.com
My Watchmaker: www.tictocwatchrepairs.com
Affiliate links to some great watch gear:
Watch Tool Kit: amzn.to/2XoqM8x
Spring bar kit: amzn.to/2CRdw2G
Barton sailcloth strap: amzn.to/2rTZ0oQ
Hadley roma ostrich strap: amzn.to/2XnUCdi
Mancave leather rally strap: www.etsy.com/shop/ManCaveLeather
Caliper tool: amzn.to/37oXIT8
Poly watch: amzn.to/2Ktc2Qn
Microfiber cloth: amzn.to/2OnaloT
Watch Roll: amzn.to/35hNzWx
Watch Pod: amzn.to/2Ok5e97
Wolf carrying case: amzn.to/2XvoHb6
A Man And His Watch: amzn.to/2prIAmF
G-Shock DW5600: amzn.to/2OpRfyz
www.amazon.com/shop/thetimete...
I've had my Luminox USAF 3400 for 17 years. I wore it everyday through military service, and for years after. It's still ticking without any issues whatsoever. I've swam with it, went through SERE school, and even a water survival class in Pensacola with it. It does have a screw down crown, AR sapphire, and steel case though. The tritium is still better than any other lume I have for reading all night.
@@jaex9617 Just look at Sorrel boots since Columbia has bought them... I would not buy a new Luminox, as they seem to be drastically reduced quality in the last 15 years or so. I called to ask about getting new end links for the PVD bracelet I have for it, and they still wanted $200 for a bracelet with hollow end links and a stamped clasp...
@@jaex9617 It's somehow even shittier than just buying the competition and closing them down.
I gave a Luminox Navy Seals as a present to my girl 12 years ago, the case is stainless steel, it has a screwdown crown, sapphire crystal, good trithium lume ... when I looked last year for a similar watch - no chance - only plastic ones. I myself wear a Steinhart Ocean One on a jubilee bracelet and an Orient Kamasu (well it's red 😎) on a Bond Nato, both cool watches 🐠
How much r they bud I'm grant from Durham England 🏴
@@fontainenick Most people say otherwise. That Luminox watches years ago were not so great and they improved in quality over the years.
When I was in the Navy (many years ago), the 3051's were standard issue to the teams. They were very well made during the time and few out there were better. You had your G-shock fans, and some even wore Timex's, but Luminox was THE brand to have back then. I wore mine every day and only replaced the band because the rubber had deteriorated. I have a newer 3051 made in about 2015 which does not have ANY of the issues you mentioned. It is a tough watch. Went snorkeling, diving, and SCUBA with it and never had an issue. There is an inner rubber seal at the crown so when it is pushed down, no water gets in there. The tritium glow is still as bright as the day I bought it. The only thing even close to comparable regarding lume, in this price range is a Seiko SRP777, or Victorinox Airboss. Higher end, maybe an Omega Seamaster. The Tritium is designed for NO LIGHT, not low light. Why? Because it's nuclear. Mine glows all night in a dark room. No charging needed. EVERY night. Try that with another watch in this price range and within 20 minutes, their lume is non-existent. Is it a toy? Absolutely NOT. This watch is NOT a "kids watch." No disrespect to the OP pooping all over 'Nox, but this watch is bad-ass. Contrary to the OP's opinion video, just because it is lightweight, doesn't mean it's cheap. Many watches are lightweight and cheaply made. This is NOT one of them. Besides, is a Titanium Omega Seamaster cheap because it's light weight? Rhetorical question, as we all KNOW it isn't cheap. Lightweight, sure....but does that make it a "toy?" Absolutely not. Additionally, the Luminox is a Swiss movement, so right off the bat, that makes it more accurate than about 75% of the junk on the market today. This is a terrific watch, and gets a lot of attention whenever I wear mine.
i have a 3051 given me by a student on the teams and its still ticks beautifully i did replace the rubber band with a steel clasp one and its been great! its my daily and i have no complaints... maybe its just me but stainless case screw down crown does everything i want and nothing i dont
As a Swiss - Thank you for sharing your experience! :-) The swiss movement (even if it's just Quarz) is pretty nice though...
Back then? They were wearing Rolex Submariners in the SEALs (90’s). The Luminox is total garbage.
An inexpensive alternative is the Casio MRW-200, it only costs 20 USD. 100M water resistance, rotating bezel, 43mm and a very strong material, I highly recommend it.
Can you fit different bands on that Casio?
Both my sons are Military, both wear G Shocks day to day. All their buddy's wear G Shocks day to day.
This watch is as tactical and useful as my lazy brother-in-law.
I'd like to think that MTG and mrg are better since there steel or titanium, but obviously not really practical when you're out on a mission
My army service watch was also a G-shock, I would never change it. And 15 years later it still works.
You know, as well as I, that what military personnel wear has mostly to do with cost 99% of the time.
do you own one?
@@Joeyczhu analog frogman or digital frogman would probably be the best for a seal due to ISO certification and the ability to use under water.
I'm a professional diver and have had many many Dive watches over my 30 years of diving. For me, my Luminox is definitely a tool. It does have a screw in crown, sapphire crystal and plenty of lum on deep low viz dives. I like the bezel because it is easy to use it with thick dive gloves - I actually use the bezel as back up to my dive computer - I'm old school. It is light, comfortable and reliable. Definitely a Tool for me!
John Rand I use the 3051 navy seal for diving, never had a problem, a great tool easy to read, easy to use
I am agree with you! Luminox is very durable and reliable. Cosidering this reviewer comment inthis clip--- the watch cannot make him feel like the tool. I wonder did he ever really use the watch for diving?
@@kitsunemuraadmin7267His watch does seem kind of chintzy though, with it's back fastening down with four little screws. The back on my Luminox 3025 Coronado is a screw-in type with 6 detents on the back for a watch wrench, and is gasketed.
@@spzrrome too, its a great tool for diving
Gotta say, I like the increased focus on quartz watches.
I was thinking the exact same thing.... I like it
Definitely. Love my automatics first and foremost, but any true watch enthusiast wants a few various types of quartz watches for more function, durability, casual style, all for a reasonable price! My SS Bertucci Ventara 11083 rocks style/value with time as accurate as my iPhone for $70 w/ 100m WR. The G-Shock DW5600 and Casio “Royale” speak for themselves!!!
I second that!
@@Holt333 And accuracy .
@@Holt333 And accuracy .
Bought a Luminox 3050/3950 about 15 years ago. Love it. Fits great on my wrist (42mm) with the rubber wrist strap ( Endmill) after market, and keeps fantastic time! Love the outstanding lume! Very happy.
I’ve worn my luminox everyday for 7 deployments on a submarine. I absolutely love it. Yes there are other options. My only issue with it was the band has broken twice in 4 years.
rubber band or bracelet?
Rubber one breaks all the time.
Happends to mine as well
I went through a few rubber bands from them. Switched to a NATO and its been solid ever since.
i thought tritium was banned for submariners?
Thanks God, finally someone is telling the truth about Luminox. I feel like some casio watches is much better than Luminox and much cheaper.
You at least get a day-date on the Casio's Luminox lookalikes.
I HAVE a Casio that totally looks like a Luminox. The bezel is cheap, BUT it has day/date and is dead on accurate. AND you can buy them all day on eBay for $20.00 new in a box!!!
@@bobklumpp8698 Lol True !!!!
I’ve had three Luminox’s. The only thing great they offer is the tritium in the lume.
@@appalachiangunman9589 yeah bro.
I have had mine for years and have worn it throughout my whole service in the army and have never had a single problem with it, keeps accurate time and the tritium is still bright have tried out many g shock and seiko watches and have always came back to my luminox I just liked the fact that in the field holding a rifle I could tell the time when it was dark without needing to hit any button for a back light or some shity glowing letter that need to be charged from the some and an hour after the sun sets can’t even read it
I´ve had several Mudmaster G-Shocks, GWG 1000, GG 1000 and GG B100. The lume was a piece of shit. Really bright in the sun. After 2 or 3 minutes i couldn´t see shit.
During my enlistment in the Marine Corps I served with Force Recon. Most of us preferred Marathon watches. When I went on embassy duty, I usually wore my Hamilton because it looked better with my dress uniform. These days, I think G-Shock is the go to brand. As for the Luminox, I totally agree with you.
Yup, me, too. Marathon are far better, a bit more money but worth getting repaired. G-Shocks are great but they are disposable, after all.
@@mcalax5901 Who are you talking to?
@Greg Alonzo. I was also an MSG. I stood post in both Poland and the Czech Republic. Semper Fi
@@jasonkeith1725, what watch did you wear while on post?
@@gregalonzo747, in the field I wore a Bertucci. While on embassy duty I wore my Glycine GMT.
The tool is the one buying this watch
jesus christ
I'm a former tool. Its been two years since I bought a luminox watch and with the help of people such as yourselves, I'll never buy another. Just horrible 😞
@@williamfarley8434 Glad you found the light, brother.
@@XavierAncarno thank you!
I did that lol , bought one luminox and it leaked ,, soooooo i sent it in and they sent me a second one aaaannnndddd it leaked too (both colormark watches) 🤬 💩
Got a Reactor Gryphon and 3 years later it has never had a problem.
Milspec = Mall-spec.
For the guy with the Jeep rubicon on 37 inch tires and 20 inch rims and harbor freight winch.
Win!
Milspec = it works but just barely for you and 200 other people before we even think about replacing it
I have a titanium luminox with a screw down crown. I think all their metal watches have screw down crowns but not the plastic ones. I also love the tritium lights, always on and no need to push any buttons.
You are very straightforward, I was considering a Luminox but after watching this vid, not any more. In 10 min you covered the whole matte. Thnaks, Sal from Honduras
I used to wear a 3150 at work as an ER nurse. Eventually switched over to a g-shock 5610 and have been very happy with the switch. The 3150 was just a bit too thick under my scrub jacket.
Mike Wenger GW5610, all the watch the world needs!
My recommended retail price for this watch is $15.95+gst aud
I came across this brand a few months ago when i was searching for an everyday watch for myself. I wanted a black housing watch and they had a bunch so that initially interested me and the designs were decent. However, the more I looked into them the lesser quality they seemed to be and when i realized they had basically plastic housing, I was done haha. Grabbed myself a hamilton khaki field watch (the new black housing and grey band) and couldn't be happier 👍
I tried it on today and thought it was ridiculously comfortable and fun summer watch.
I like them because they are lightweight and comfortable to wear. I also like to be able to read the time when it’s dark. But I agree, more of a toy watch. I have 3. The original has been perfect since day 1, almost 15 years. Another one needed to have the movement replaced and my 3rd Luminox needs to have the crystal cleaned or replaced. It’s gotten a little fogged/dull from the inside/underneath
I bought the Luminox Sentry and love it. I wasn't expecting it to be anywhere near as durable as a G-Shock. It's got regular lume on the 12,2,4,6,8 and 10 but the hands and the 1,3,5,7,9 and 11 are the gas tubes and in a dark room I can see them from 15 feet. No matter the condition I have never not been able to tell the time. It was one my most worn watches until I got my GD-350. I've worn a G-Shock since 1986 and you just can't beat them in durability.
I have 3 Luminox, all 3 bought used over 15 years ago, and all 3 still have good visibility at night. They have better visibility than any non-tritium watch I've ever owned including a lot of the Seiko famous divers. My 2 Navy Seals watches came to me already all beat up and well worn. I continue to wear them as beaters because they are already beyond being pretty. Most watch enthusiasts won't wear their beater watches where they might get dirty or beat up, but since mine are already beat up I don't baby them or protect them. Both run reliably and serve the tool function because I wear one or the other of them every night so I can see the time at any time of night. Granted I don't take mine diving but I do wear them when doing things like washing the car. All 3 of my Luminox watches continue to run well. So yes as far as I'm concerned they are definitely legitimate tool watches. And I also agree that they are overpriced for a quartz watch. Since I bought mine well used they were very low priced.
I think the SEALS might actually use G-Shocks
I'm sure they do.
the "SEALS" don't all use the same watch. They wear a variety of things, based upon their individual interests desires, just like regular people.
RP Jake Damm,the G-Shock king is enormous in size.I was thinking maybe a DW-9052 or DW-5600E.
Either Gs or Timex digitals
Kinda strange they don’t all wear the same watches. You’d think just in case they had to “synchronize” watches on some operation that there would be pre-requirement that they all had to wear the same proven extremely accurate, durable, and probably waterproof timepiece.
Thanks for the luminox vid. Havent seen anyone talk about them until now. Thought they were a good company but after this and tons of product reviews im finally off that train.
Thanks for the info. I was looking at this watch long and hard but now I’m not as convinced. I liked the looks but I really need a durable/dependable watch so I’ll have to keep on looking.
Buy a Marathon quartz, you can get some for 200$ with the hardened plastic case the tritium tubes is why I wear it every single night as the most consistent easy to read in the dark. It’s so light and pretty thin, on a good quality nato, it’s a perfect easy to read beater.
My Luminox F-117 has a threaded crown and it has one of the best tritium glowing hands on any watch I’ve owned. Maybe they’ve changed over time ? I really love mine.
hey may i know what movement does it use? im planning to buy 1 now. that tritium is so big hahaha..
@@ganbatte1260 it’s a quartz movement, don’t know which one ?
A little over a year ago, this would've been my "grail watch", when I first got bitten by the watch collecting bug. When I tried it on, it felt so light and "high end" (I was clearly caught up in the moment). I'm so thankful to people like you who've taught me so much about quality watches. I finally saved up the dough for a good watch and invested it into a Seiko PADI Turtle, best decision ever. I would've regretted buying a Luminox. There are way too many reviews of these watches with the same negatives you've pointed out. There's also a bunch of buyers who've complained about the tritium tubes fading away into nothingness merely a couple of years after purchase. And heck, you can't all be wrong. And yea, that "lightness" when I first wore it? It did feel cheap, now that I think of it 😄
...but it wasn't cheap. You get what you pay for. Swiss > Japanese...any day of the week and twice on Sunday. Turtles are great watches...but not nearly as accurate or reliable as a Swiss movement. Unless, of course it's a Japanese quartz and a Grand Seiko...which it's not. It's just a 4R36. Although the 4R36 is a terrific movement, it doesnt hold a candle to a Swiss quartz in terms of accuracy.
@@peteygnyc Agreed, but it's subjective, I guess. At this price point, I'd take the 4R36 any day over a similarly priced Swiss quartz and even if my preference was for a Swiss quartz, there are a lot of better alternatives, from Tissot, for example. And if the "Swiss" part wasn't a priority, there are a ton of quartz offerings from the likes of Seiko, Orient and Citizen with comparable accuracy to their Swiss counterparts. It all comes down to what you're looking for in a watch, at the end of the day. I'd already had a few G-Shocks before I'd picked up the Turtle to scratch the quartz itch. So for me, the Turtle was the way to go.
the best alternative i can think of is an entry level Citizen diver. they basically cost the same as an SKX but they have better automatic movements and decent quartz eco-drive options.
Better than what? A Swiss? Not on your life, my friend.
I prefer the Trasers, made by Microtec the people who make the the actual tritium tubes. They have no pretense of military spec just light weight rugged watches.
I second that!
I’m tough on everything due to my line of work and my luminox has somehow survived. The band has broken once due to silicone rot and the quartz bezel has chipped, but it doesn’t leak. Would love to get another one but also give Gshock a shot.
I own 2 luminox watches, I bought them at steep discount at a TJ Maxx because of how cool the tritium lume is. Mine work fine in the dark but the half life of Tritium is 11 years or so. I sleep with one on the wrist because they are so light and comfortable. Definitely more toy than tool but i know a patrol man who wore one on duty for years and while it looks chewed up it still runs.
Finally someone actually reviewing the Luminox brand. I've always been a g shock fan when it comes to toughness, but when I heard of luminox, I couldn't find much user information about them besides there own marketing. Thank you for clearing this up.
Don´t buy everything that he said. Luminox watches are good. Most people and i mean a LOT of people that complaint about Luminox bought fakes. The tritium tubes work for many years, water doesn´t get inside and it feals cheap because it´s so light due to the carbon case. Carbon is way stronger than metal and its magnetic resistant.
$30 for the watch, $470 for the navy seal name?
A Casio MRW200 is about $20. Maybe $10 for the ratcheting bezel?
I paid $150 for mine NEW!
@@Alias_Anybody wait which one
I bought one about 10 years ago spent 140.00 and love it and yes the tritium works perfect
Excellent choice.
Bought mine and even though I have others, I love this one also!
I’ve had two for more than 20 years they keep great time and still glow
I've had mine for about the same time. Light on the wrist, never had a problem with it, and the lume is outstanding!
Most people that complaint about Luminox bought fakes on Ebay and Amazon.
I've had mine for probably 15, and I agree. And my Luminox Navy Seal does indeed have a threaded crown as well. Maybe the newer ones aren't as well made or he got a cheaper model, but my watch is very durable and I enjoy it very much.
I’ve had mine for 15 years and it is still going strong. I like it.
Even the cheapest g-shock would be better than the luminox for a tool watch
yeah mate, can’t beat the base model 5600 for $40 USD
Even some regular Casio watch would better this watch
How do you start your chronograph underwater while scuba diving on a G shock ?
santiago pizarro g shock buttons can be pushed underwater
Alexandre I have to tell you that it is not possible, go to the official website and they say that you can't press the buttons underwater or while the watch is wet
I was gifted a Luminox 1594 back in 2001. It has a steel case and bezel as well as a screw down crown. Minus a battery replacement or two, and a clasp repair, that watch is still functioning great. When new, the lume was sufficiently bright that you needed to cover it up when in a movie theater or when going to sleep. Now, when I happen to open my watch box in the mornings and don't turn the lights on, it is still glowing cheerfully, brighter than its more modern lume neighbors. This doesn't invalidate your thoughts on Luminox at all, this was just an excuse for me to share my good experience with a watch my parents gave me a long time ago that I still enjoy and get good service from to this day. Thanks for the great videos.
I really like my Lumi Nox. It is light and looks great. I have had many problems with mine though. Broken bands, broken crystal and the bezel fell off. I am rough on my stuff but I thought it would be tougher.
My grandmother brought me one from Switzerland as a kid, I frigging loved it. Reminds me of my childhood. I'll buy another one someday.
I have a stainless steel 3502 navy seal my dad gave me from the 90’s about ten years back. The crown is threaded and feels very sturdy, it also clicks well. The bezel movement feels good. Tritium is a bit faded, but the watch is around 30 years old so I suppose that’s to be expected. It’s sapphire as well. I believe when he bought it it was the same price as this one.I guess they don’t make ‘em like they used to. If you can find an older one, I highly recommend it!
I should also mention that he wore it everyday for 20 years while working as a paramedic and I’ve worn it the majority of 10 years. This watch has definitely taken a beating but it’s still looking great and going strong.
Really helpful video. I didn't expect your answer. You changed my opinion for these watches. Thanks.
I have an older Luminox with a sapphire crystal, stainless steel case back, screw down crown and it’s 15 years old going strong. It no longer glows though.
Mine is also 15 yeas old and still going strong. Still glows even although it may be a little dimmer. I think they are over priced but other than that I like mine
FYI, if you still love the watch, you can still replace the tubes. With a bit of cost, of course. Had mine replaced... Felt 'new' & fell in love with it again. Atacama Field Day Date 1921
I always liked victorinox for a good quartz watch. The inox series is super tough
I’ve had mine for a few years now and have beat it up still looks good and is very bright at night
I have 2 getting repaired for the 3rd time!! They last around 2 years if you use it every day and are always out. Also good luck getting it fixed! If you’re in US you have to send it in to the official repair in RI. I Am looking into a G-Shock..
In the army I wore a luminox or a gshock or pathfinder depending on my mood and mission. Most seals I know/knew wore sins or sea dwellers. Seals have a long history with Rolex and get a great deal on them direct from Rolex to the teams where they are “permanently issued” to the teams.
They haven't permanantly issued Rolex's to the teams since the 1980's, my dude. Actually, it was issued during 1962-1983. In 1983, they switched to Omega Sea-dwelers and were quickly replaced in 1988 with Luminox. In 1996, the US Navy no longer issued watches to the teams.
I own several and you are absolutely right! I’ve taken mine on several deployments and they are not mil spec! Let alone the glow absolutely zero 24hr glow
"Mil-Spec" always means "bare minimum for grunts". It's a whole another thing when you name your model "The Navy SEAL"...
It's a toy. Don't buy. I have two. Regret both
@Jesus Christ Thanks Jesus. Means a lot to me that you have been duped as well. G Shocks and Seiko. Please don't let Satan place these others in our path
i have one, i regret even spending $110 on it while on sale
also, g-shock gang member here
the worst thing is that that exact watch was the first one that i bought and one that got me into this expensive hobby :(
@@4nhk066 I got the BO version. Almost cried when I saw the crystal had fogged. Paid $400 for it.
now THAT is bad...
Thanks for the honest review. Im a bit cooled off now to go and get one for me. What do you think abot Traser?
I have the blackout Navy Seal chronograph. Got mine used for about 100 bucks, changed out the strap for a 23mm NATO strap; the mineral glass was already scratched so I changed it for a sapphire. The tritium tubes are still glowing, and when they wear out, I will try to remove and glue new ones. Of course I've got some watch repair tools, and this sort of dorking around with the watch is not for everybody. but I'm very satisfied with my Luminox as a backpacking watch: very light. However I would not have paid full retail price for it.
From what I saw with the Luminox, I would prefer a G-Shock, or a Timex Shock type watch for the money invested. For durability and taking punishment the G-Shock watches have been the best for me. I tend to buy the G-Shock watches in the $400 to $600 range. The G-Shock and Timex watches I have are very accurate keeping within about +-4 to +-6 seconds per month.
My Luminox 3051 is accurate to about 12-18 seconds a YEAR.
I had a carbon fiber Luminox for a while. When the battery went dead, first thing I noticed when opening is that one of the screw inserts that holds the back on is stripped out. Second was the rather generic Ronda movement with no apparent special shock protection at all (by contrast with my various G Shocks which have special purpose movements and evidence of careful protection design). Anyhow, even after the battery change, it stopped again. At that point it wound up in a drawer.
Btw, on the note of military based quartz watches... Any chance you can take a crack at CWC navy diver(s)?
Royals and Special Boat Service still wear them?
Excellent review hopefully people will take note
Imhad a Luminox F16 that I wore daily for a decade. I also did a ton of diving with it during that time. They don’t glow at all??? I don’t know what you’re looking at. No, they don’t glow like Seiko’s Lumibrite, but they don’t need charged before night use. I won’t get tritium tubes again unless they are t100 (the brightest tritium tubes). The F16 also jas a stainless case and bracelet, so it feels much more substantial than the plastic cased Luminox models. The mineral crystal really is a drag. I scratched mine in the first couple of weeks of wear. Finally, I flipped it when I started getting interested in automatic divers. But, I would never consider my Luminox F16 a toy. It was a serious daily wearer and dive watch for me. I have good memories associated with it.
I got a good deal on a SS case 3202 or something. It was ok in 2004. Still works after cracking the sapphire crystal and flooding it the shower after surfing. Got it fixed up and gave it to my 13 year old who thinks its cool. Lum is shot, but that’s expected. Heavy on marketing for sure. I had friends in the teams and they always gave me a hard time about it. Seiko SKX these days.
well I wear one for close to 15 years and it never let me down.still solid as day one. maybe the bezel is a bit stiff. beat the shit out of it. paid 100$ for it. just my 2 cents
You've clarified some questions. Thanks.
I own a 3051 BO. It’s an awesome looker, it gets a lot of attention, but the strap fell apart after about 2 yrs, and that’s not a daily wearer either. I really struggled to find a replacement.
The strap doesn’t have any lugs either so the strap band constantly comes off.
On the point of thickness, to be fair, my G-Shocks are just as thick, if not, thicker!
Thanks for the review. I was going to buy it but not anymore. Could you advise some watch similar to this one?
Good honest review. I wish I would of seen this years ago before buying 6 of their watches.
Have you ever tried a Traser P6600 Mil-G? Are they any better than the Luminox? Similar price point.
Yep, I heard about the Navy Seal association and thought it was cool, but I’d read about them steaming up, when used in the sea etc. Forces personnel will use G shocks in theatre most of the time, they’ll take a beating and from only £45 or so. I have a 1984 DW5200 and it still looks immaculate and it’s been to two conflicts, at least. If folk want to go down a mechanical route and have a timepiece that’ll last and look good in Mess dress, then something like a Seiko SKX007 would be a good choice. Rolex lookalikes can be a good choice if made well. I’ve been keeping an eye on Enoksen watches, lately, they look great! Great video BTW.
Currently there are no standard issue Navy Seal watches.They are worn by preference and individually owned.Most wear Casio DW6600,but aside from Luminox, they also wear Timex,Tudor,Rolex,Seiko Diver,and Suunto
Thanks for the advice
Dude, your sound has gotten much better. Did you buy a new mic or something? The consonants are not as sharp in this video as they usually are. I haven't been able to use earphones while watching even on low sound without hurting my ears. You could probably make it a little softer in post but it really is a lot better! Thanks!
Have to agree. I enjoy my Luminox 3051 but the only reason I have one is the retailer I work for had it available and I get a 40% discount. I got my 3051 for about 180.00. I wear it on the thick velcro Luminox strap and it is ridiculously comfortable. For an additional 30 bucks, I installed a sapphire crystal. So, it's pretty sturdy now. I have had it in the shower but that's the extent of the water exposure. I wouldn't trust this in the pool with the flimsy crown. Also, having popped the mineral crystal out, it doesn't sit super tight in the case like a stainless dive watch press-in crystal. My tritium works fantastic but only in total darkness.
Thank you for this great review!! Before watching this video, I already ordered a LUMINOX Navy SEAL Steel 3257 model with the white face and grey webbing strap. In contrast to the LUMINOX you showed us, the watch I ordered is said to have a "Stainless steel case, screw down crown & case back" and a "Sapphire Crystal". However, it does have the "Carbon reinforced polycarbonate bezel" - Oh Sh-t!! Aside from the bezel, might you say the watch I ordered is less sucky than the one you reviewed?
I can attest to the virtues of screw-down crowns. I had the crown fall out of a watch one time and never found it. Luckily it was a Timex Expedition that was only $37, I liked the look of it but since it was cheap I wore it as a work watch, now I usually wear my G-Shock to work.
Thank you. I am taking this watch off my list. I always wanted one but always bought other watches.
For next to nothing you could've bought the Casio MRW-200H which is very similar and with a day/date complication.
MagicThighs great watches, I’ve had three of them, I just give them away when I get bored with them, they don’t break. Lume is rubbish and there is no warning when battery runs out, otherwise the best analogue bargain watch out there......ultra accurate, too!
now there is MRW 210H which is bigger in diameter for those who have bigger wrist. very comfortable
A lot of good points. Glad I just ordered a Seiko.
This could have been a review for my Tag Heuer Formula 1. It has all the same grips as the luminox.
Glad I came across your vid. I was thinking about buying a Luminox, but not anymore. What's the best, most accurate analog quartz watch under $250?
I totally agree with you The Time Teller. That's why I bought KHS tactical watch
Sounds like a professional review with quite serious arguments. I purchased a Luminox 3051 BO (before watching this vid !) to practice kayak as an alternative to wearing my Rolex Deepsea for fear of damaging it. We’ll see how it behaves, but I basically agree with the cons : non screw able bezel, not a sapphire glas, it also seems battery life decreases a lot after initial battery replacement on Luminox. Perhaps a G shock would have been a better choice…Thank you !
Great review -- thanks!😀
I've been a diver since 1987 and served in the Navy for 20 years as an aircrewman. Recently, I was l looking for a replacement for my personal dive watch, a Citizen Aqualand. I was replacing it not because I lost it or of failure, but because I have it for close to 20 years and recently had the batteries replaced by a local jeweler that would not ensure that he pressure tested it. Rather than risk a possible leak, I decided to replace it. I went with the Luminox 4221 ANU, and could not have been happier with my decision. Currently I have 10 dives with it, with a max depth of 80'. The stainless steel case measures 45mm making it a "larger watch", but with my 7 3/4" I don't have a problem with it. The 23mm rubber strap distributes the weight nicely and secures it regardless of diving with a wet suit or on the skin. I do not have any issues with the 4221 ANU's crown or bezel as this is a stainless steel watch.
I get T3's gripes about the 25th edition of the "Navy Seal" watch... but if you're going buy a "diver", buy a diver and not commemorative edition. The original Navy Seal 3001 currently on Amazon for $350, and I have seen it for as low as $268.00. Yes, it has the double security gasket (vice screw down), and a polyurethane case. I will put it to T3 and everyone else this way; "Don't take anything in ocean you're not willing part with."
Just my 2¢.
Well what's the best toughest watch to wear I work around Steel
Any suggestions ??
I’d like a watch similar to Luminox weight and style but thinner and around 39-41mm but higher quality.
This makes me appropriate my Gshocks even more.
Had one of these for about 3 months before the hands fell off. I didn't beat it up at all either.
I have the BlackOps 8881; basically the Navy Seal but with a sapphire crystal. I don't know how long you've had yours but the tritium on mine can light up a dark room. I paid $325, which is about $100 more than the Navy Seal but the sapphire crystal was worth it to me. The 'Navy Seal' or 'Black Ops' licensing doesn't mean anything to me as I think most special forces are using G-shocks. I bought mine because I think it looks really good, I love the tritium and I believe it's a very tough watch.
I just retired from the Navy last November. I can tell you the go to watch is the G-Shock. I never wore one because I'm not a fan of plastic or digital watches. However, Boatswain mates and Deck department, who due some of the dirtiest and arduous jobs a ship wear them and swear by them. The about of shocks they get from activities like needle gunning should be a certification for any "tough watch"
what is needle gunning?
@@JinKee it's a pneumatic tool used to remove paint and rust off of metal surfaces. It's has a lot of vibration and impact.
@@seanthomxx2694 ah sounds like an endless job on a ship exposed to saltwater
@@JinKee it is.
I got one as a gift so I keep it for sentimental value. It's comfortable to wear but yeah, agreed on everything. The sad part is that it doesn't live up to the image its trying to have. That's the worst failing in any product.
I have been agonizing the last two months on purchasing a Luminox Navy SEAL watch for no other reason other than I like the style, but watching videos like this really put me off the asking price for the two models I like, both around £400. I've just purchased a Pulsar PM3129X1 for less than £60, looks so much like the watch I had issued whilst serving in the British Army, and its such a sturdy and heavy watch along with a great look, so comparing that to a Luminox, I think I'll wait until I have spare cash to throw away and then purchase a Luminox. Thanks for the honest review.
I wanted a luminox in the worst way but I was a bit skeptical due to the many reviews of shotty craftsmanship. It sounds like they have a bit of a quality control issue. Instead of a Luminox, I went with a KHS Dark Commander Pro II. This thing is the real deal. You should look into getting one and doing a review.
What's the production year of your luminox limited edition?
i just a luminox in trade 5 years old new in box and it lights up at night really well trituim only soft glows like night sights
My Luminox will light up a room with the damn tritium tubes. I got the seaturtle off ebay in like new condition for $150 and couldn't be happier. I am SO happy with it, I JUST purchased the 7250 Series with the Saphire crystal and steel case. Wanna borrow it and see if the steel seems better?
I have had one for 10 years with no complaints. Wear it in a manufacturing environment and the case has been bulletproof - crystal not so much. Tritium still bright. No issues with water resistance or the crown. Paid about half of what you did brand new.
Thanks!!
I have the 2017 Luminox 821 800 Ultimate Field Watch (currently discountinued)and it's a pip. Steel case and simple steel bezel. Xtra-thick Sapphire, 200m, Tritium that works (it does have a 12 yr half-life so it doesn't last forever), screw-down crown, 23 jewel ETA 241 Chrono movement. Top-quality leather strap. They've upped their game in recent years..on some models anyway.
This sounds crazy, but I have two Ronda quartz watches. Initially the second hand on both didn’t line up with the chapter markers like you mentioned. I found a fix was to use a Renata brand battery. I have no clue why, but it worked. I’ve even gone back and forth from Maxell to the Renata and sure enough it was the battery. Give it a shot, they don’t really cost all that much more.
After owning several Luminox quartz and then really getting into watches, I settled on Armourlite watches for daily "hard use". They have decent tritium, can be had as autos, and won't break my heart if I destroy one and have to throw it away.
As a guy who has routinely gotten my hands dirty (and bloody), I have two automatic AL watches as "beater" watches. I now own a couple CrhWard autos, a Junghans MaxBill, a 1960's E. Borel, etc. But when I'm going to the field or putting out a house fire, I typically wear one of my AL autos. They are a good compromise of having a reliable auto that is fairly durable, but won’t break the bank or the heart.
Jacob Phillips Junghans Max Bill, you have class, Christopher Ward, nice, too.
I got the same one but in blue had it for a year good watch and lightweight
Have worn mine everyday for the last 5 years and other than replacing the strap haven’t had an issue. Taken it off maybe 10-12 times to give my wrist a break.
I got a leatherback sea turtle for a daily yesterday. I like it a lot so far. Seems more durable than average. Time will tell. I also paid $200 on Amazon and not the $350 retail. So I’m happy overall.
So what is the best tool watch 500 or under if you dont like luminox and dont say gshock?