Видео

I like how you can tell that he hasn’t played past the first great lighthouse bro doesn’t even mention battle plugs

I'm glad common sense is still alive and well

It has just occurred to me that brothership is getting the origami king treatment now holy-

He's right!!! Awful and boring plug characters, Minecraft looking 😂

The biggest problem is the pacing. It's awful. The game is a slog. And I agree with the load times in and out of battles.

I get and agree with a lot of the sentiments, but even then that feels a tad harsh. That being said I really hope there will be a new game in the future that falls in line a little better

I'm 12 hours in and it's just a slog to play to the point I'm done and probably gonna sell it.

I don't know how far you played the game yet, but from the stuff that you are referencing I'm gonna assume you only finished the first great lighthouse. I don't really think it's fair to make a Video saying that the game isn't good (or more specifically, not as good as the old one's) when you haven't even finished it. I can definitely see why you would dislike the stuff that you played if that was the complete game, but it isn't. This game can definitely drag, and i think that the pacing of the game is by far the worst part of it, but if you say stuff like that the game doesn't have a great variety of enemies without even playing half of it, that seems a but unfair. A lot of the problems you listed were also in the other games, like the hammer thing. I do have to agree though with the enemie (specifically boss) healthbars. I think that a lot of tension is lost with that. It was also a wierd decision to bring back the thing from paper jam, where you couldn't upgrade your stats every level up. I would recommend you to still at least finishe the game and see if your opinion might change. I'm sorry for you that you didn't enjoy the game so far though

Finally people are starting to share their real thoughts and disappointment with the game. The sales tell the real story even when Nintendo makes people say nice things online

Your problem doesn't matter and your opinion is wrong.

Sincerly, this opinion makes me think you didn't play Dream Team, Paper Jam and also didn't finish this game

Finish the game, then make a video about it. If you haven't beaten it yet, then whats the point of this review?

The claims of the rail grinding and combat are wrong

I do have to point out if anyone else hasn't... this game also has the hieght mechanic with the homing attack so... ofc it's not going to work if you don't give it a second after jumping. That aside... good stuff and quite understandable.

another trash game by a trash company - not sure what people were expecting

Boo hoo this games too hard for you then go play skylanders superchargers with your wife’s boyfriend

With the grind rail section, you are purposely dodging and purposely not boosting. I agree it feels worse but at least be real about it

It’s not too late. You still have time to delete this video

I like sticker star.

I'm doing okay with the game so far but the changes to Luigi really was a bit of a brain breaker. Mario being controlled with A and Luigi with B was such a novel thing in battle and having to control them both on the map really emphasized that Mario and Luigi were working together all throughout the games. I still had the habit of making Luigi jump until the AI Luigi started working against me when I tried to manually get him to jump over things. I've only ever played up to Bowser's Inside Story on the previous games so I don't know if the next entries changed it, but I was hoping this one would bring back the leader switching that they had all the way back in Super Star Saga letting Luigi take lead. Instead we have even less control of Luigi >_>

Waaaaaa waaaaaaaa waaaaaaaa waaaaaaaa! That's all I hear omg so pathetic

Great review

There's a lot of people being overly negative about the game. The problem is you're right, none of these issues are exaggerated. Mario & Luigi is at least a formula that can't really be screwed up, the worst you get is a game that's just ok. Heck, brothership's mediocrity has got me interested in finding a copy of paper jam. The real huge problem with this game you didn't mention is that it's running at a very inconsistent 30FPS with big input lag and tons of frame hiccups in a combat system where timing is crucial for literally everything. It's painful to play. Every other game in the series is least responsive and feels good.

I’m gonna be so honest rn I think the artstyle is intentional. With the exception of the Toads, everything from Mario’s world looks like M&L, the reason why everything else doesn’t is.. because.. It’s not Mario’s world????? Of course he’s going to look somewhat out of place, hell, they look out of place in most of their games because they’re surrounded by a whole load of unique species and locales.

“Don’t have all their moves available” Bro, the only thing you don’t have access to is the Power character’s full combo. Why are you trying to make things sound worse than they are?

10:48 this change is from Dream Team not Brothership

The chaos powers are essentially worse version of the wisp powers from colors

I mean its supposed to be a simple and undemanding game to play with small compact levels to explore and find things in. I think you kinda got the wrong idea that this game has a ton of depth in movement mechanics from being compared to mario 64. I really like this game because it really encourages you to explore every nook and cranny with the way the notes system works and the notes respawning when you die is a unique way to encourage mastery in a level. The challenges may be shallow, but each one doesn't take more than a minute to complete and then you're right on to the next thing. It's a short and sweet experience with compact world design and tight pacing. It's a game about exploring an environment finding stuff and that's about as simple as it gets.

It's a very bold choice to end the video the way you did, especially without properly finishing the game. I don't know if you HAVE to finish a game to have a proper opinion on it. In some cases, you don't even have to play it. But you have to understand what and where to critique the game if you're going to do that.

If you don't like the game that's fair but calling the game a "complete and utter failure" is laughable when you haven't even gotten past the first sea, let alone beat the game

Paper jam is better than this crap. Facts

As i die hard fan of the previous games, I sadly agree, I honestly dont understand why luigi was changed for the worse like this and the enviotments and enemies just look generic

You literally complain about what dream team had for the half of the video and the other half is some changes that one could get used to easily. And bro, you say there is no story yet you told us multiple characters arcs that you personally dont care. Just say that you didnt like their designs I guess.

Shameful. I grew up with Mario Sports games on the GBC and GBA that had personality and great writing, worlds, and characters. How far they've plummeted.

I don’t care about how nostalgic or what ever people have about the old game this is a new era for Mario and Luigi I have fond memories of super star partner in time and inside story but brothership is a new spin on it I keep the core battle mechanics and tries to bring life into a death series after 10 years nickpicking a artstyle for not being Mario characters enough feel kinda weird knowing we had to suffer through 10 plus years of generic toads with no new characters/ species to bounce off on for years the plug people look wacky and weird no which is intentional as clearly stated it a completely separate world I will agree on the animations they could have used more work but that most of the cast looks great the scenery in some places are gorgeous and a lot of effort trying to recapture the feel of the original it ain’t perfect but I mean you try to recreate a 10 year old game series that has been dead for years and need more sparks of creativity after the failure of paper jam on it release

My biggest thing with the game is the fact that the levels are so short. Like the content to me is almost non-existent. Now I just started the game not too long ago, but I've already done two islands, and it's just like maybe three or four enemies, and then you basically just get the islands plug and then you move on to a new one. There's basically like no content, & no difficulty. Where are the bosses... where is the expiration...where is the onslaught of enemies...I mean at least give me a grind, even though that annoys some people but at this point is so short you might as well just allow me to grind to Oblivion. I feel like the fan base has waited too long for a Mario and Luigi game, or something close to a paper Mario (which this would also be), just for them to basically seem like they completed the development of this game in like a week.

Have to disagree with the movement. I think I works perfectly with the levels in this game. The second game is where the movement becomes dull. Poopy poopy nicker nicker

FINISH THE DAM GAME

17 minutes of autism

My one and only issue is that this game has mobile game graphics and still cant run in 60. Makes going from pit/bis to this a nightmare

9:00 that's just a skill issue

I’ve played through every game in the series and personally? Brothership is an amazing return, granted I actually played the game from start to finish but this game isn’t that bad, while I do understand the pacing and issues with how Luigi works, I think it’s perfectly fine, it’s also fine if you don’t like the game but at the very least finish the game, it does get good, even if it takes many hours, this was an amazing return to the franchise with impressive animations, new visuals, and amazing combat, also the thing about holding your hammer for too long, I’m pretty sure that feature disappeared in Dream Team, and Paper Jam removed the stat boost each time you level up, while I do agree that Brothership should have reverted the change it didn’t introduce it, so I do understand why people have a problem with this game, but calling it trash and disappointing is a bit much, at the very least beat the game first

Play for more than 8 hours lol

I guess paper jam isnt the worst mario and luigi game anymore

ngl I think you make some valid points, however I get the vibe you've only played for a bit. Perhaps finish the game and make a follow up vid, seeing if any of your opinions are different, nice video tho

Great review! Loved that you used the previous games as a benchmark for measuring its quality. Games don’t exist in a vacuum, they exist in the context of what came before and after.

No offence but this review just screams didn’t finish the first area of the game. You can tell he hadn’t even gotten to the battle plugs yet.🥸 As a person with ADHD I’ve beaten the game fully and can’t understand why these (Mostly) tiny nitpicks are getting blown out of proportion like it’s a sin against Humanity or something lol. 😂 Only two points I agree with, the bonus stats after each level still being absent and the Luigi following you around (But honestly it didn’t bother me too much) Technically speaking you never really controlled Luigi in the previous games, you control whoever is in front and the other follows behind. They allowed Luigi to break free from just being stuck in the back and just being the B button and allowing him to do more then he could in previous games besides helping Mario be Small or help Mario dig/spin across. Though I still wish he didn’t Jump on his own and you can time that yourself but besides that it helps make Luigi be More than just a shadow of Mario and he can do things himself too and doesn’t need Mario to help him do most the of the things in game, anything Mario and do Luigi can too. Sure you just press L and he does something but in the previous games it’s like that too with just pressing B to jump or hammer. Someone Liking a story, or the graphics is always subjective because it depends on what their preferences are so if you don’t like them then that’s understandable. But this game isn’t just one story it’s multiple, there is the main objective to reconnect Concordia but each Sea has its own story to tell. And it’s not like the past games had mind blowing stories either they’re good but it always boils down to get the muguffins to get to the final boss as with most games do. The reason you only saw grass areas was because you where in the grass world, it’s like comparing the Grasslands and the Dimple Wood in BIS, they’re both grass themed areas so it’s the same by your logic. 😐 Also just Sides quests are not mandatory, they are called side quests for a reason, you don’t have to do them if you don’t want to. The enemy selection isn’t the biggest in the game sure but there are only 5-6 Reused Enemies in the game (Excluding the side quest variants iykyk) , it’s just more notable in the first Sea. Also the in battle hammer drop thing, they took that since dream team it hasn’t been in a game sense and it doesn’t even change the counters that much, most of the time people wouldn’t event have that happen so it seems nit picky like the 8 directions instead of full rotation. Lastly the Loading times, it’s not solely the games fault. It’s more of a switch problem so don’t blame the game for that.💀 Honestly seems like you’re blinded by nostalgia and are afraid of change with this review. It’s not the same studio so you can’t just expect them to nail what alpha dream did for years on the first go around. They tried their best and tried to expand upon the ideas of the previous entries. I hope you still continue to play it fully before making a review for the game since you’re leaving a Chuck that might address some other things you thought were there but at second glance it’s not as bad as you made it out to be. But if not that’s ok too. Give the Game a Chance before you jump the gun again.

Ugh! This video SUCKS! I’m convinced this guy barely played Dream Team and never touched Paper Jam! The whole no choosing stat upgrade thing was introduced in Paper Jam and choosing a rank bonus was introduced in Dream Team! Same for the Bros. Attacks being varied between both Bros. AND battles don’t give consequences since Dream Team, which I don’t mind ONE BIT! AND you gave up on the FIRST DAMN SEA! YOU ARE FAKE FAN!

Dude they just got back but now you are complaining about art style wow just wow, you just them die don't you and also let them update mario & Luigi brothership button b jump for Luigi

Am I the only one who feels like this video is very nitpicky?