Видео

20:10 is from Gemara Brachos 35b

Thus it is so ironic that the reformers today love channukah. They are the modern day Hellenists!

Can anyone tell me the date of this drasha and the location it was given?

Very prescient indeed

Crazy to hear the Rav talk about this over 50 years ago. 9:03 "We may expect that even the western socialism or liberalism will be lined up against the Jew." He was 100% correct.

I tore Kriah at 2;42

The Rav says "if the halachah is placed EXCLUSIVELY in a historical perspective". The dagesh is on the word "exclusively".

Subtitles please...and a side of fried rice...just kidding...maybe not...

Thank you for providing a transcript, makes it more effective.

Wow. Just wow!

תודה רבה. שכרכם הרבה מאד

Can we please attain subtitles for this Drasha?

Can we possibly get subtitles for this Drasha?

What an amazing video. Rabbi Soloveitchik discussing Rav Kook.

According to this approach, why does the Torah instruct one to fast on the 9th of Elul if it's a day of preparation and specifically preparation by way of eating. Any why does the Gemara conclude "one who eats on the 9th it is as if he fasted"? If the whole חשיבות of the 9th is that it is a day of preparation for the fast of the 10th why is the 9th connected to fasting? If it has no חלות יום מצד עצמה, and it's whole חשיבות is הכנה then why describe it in a way which suggests parallels with the 10th rather than in way which highlights it's utility for the 10th?

B''H, Amen

I believe the rav uses the word מברר from בירור not מבער. The word בירור/separation is used in such kabalistic contexts as the rav is referring to here, to refer to man's duty to separate and elevate the good elements in the world from the mixture of good and evil.

יישר כוח איזו תורה !

הרב זצ"ל למד והבין וחי בתורת החסידות, נגלה ונסתר יחד, ובהרגש הלב ועבודת ה' בפועל

Thank u so much !! Wish you a good and sweat new year

Very powerful. Now to internalize it.

This is a MUST listen!!!! Thank you!!

I just found your channel. Thanks so much for posting this.

I can't believe this man is held in such high standing. His arguments are adolescent. No miracles took place - only deception, ethnic cleansing, and preemptive war. Bags full of money were brought to Truman for US support. Also, his recounting of the story of the Sultan and his harem, comparing it with the UN, is ludicrous. To say that both entities ended up existing only to give succor to a Jewish scholar in one instance and the emergence of the state of Israel in the other is the most outrageous chauvinistic argument on such matters I've come across.

מתוק מדבש

יישר כח

יישר כח

יישר כח

Translate please

This video has nothing really to do with the historical method of Talmud study, except in an ancillary way. It has to do with the impact of social and material phenomena on halachik rules/positions. I dont really think that most of the modern orthodox public and certainly most of the black hat public has any idea what the historical method of Talmud study is all about, other than tidbits of hearsay propoganda they once heard. They know something something Conservative, something something Lieberman, something something its ok to drive on shabbos, something something their shuls are empty save for a few members 75 and over so it shows their method is all wrong, something something mesorah, something something something something.

כצפוי, אנליזות מאלפות, מרתקות.

Phenomenal Torah knowledge, Yiras Shomayim, humility, truth and wisdom is what comes through again and again in all the Rav's talks. I can't get enough.

דברי אלוקים חיים. אושר גדול

דברי אלוקים חיים ממש

יישר כח

יישר כוח על התרגום . דברי אלוקים חיים .

Very inspiring. The Rav was at a holy level

מצוות עין תחת עין בתורה ניתנה לבני ישראל שהרגע יצאו מחברה מרושעת, והורגלו לכך שאפשר להכות כמה שרוצים ואיך שרוצים, בלי פרופורציה או צדק, אם רבת עם מישהו והוא סטר לך, עליך להרוג אותו ולשרוף את ביתו כנקמה, אך אלוהים הגביל אותם במצווה זו, אם רבת ושברו לך שן, העונש המקסימלי הוא לשבור גם לאחר את השן, לא פחות ולא יותר, אך לפי הברית החדשה שהיא הסטנדרט המושלם של אלוהים, במקום לנקום עדיף לסלוח, לרחם, ולתת לאלוהים לשפוט בינינו למי שרבנו איתו

מי יתן לנו תמורתו

יישר כח

Thank you very much. Do you have more of his actual taped videos like the one from Yom Kippur?

He acted with them without judgment and at the end he showed them love by saying to them “next time we’ll eat together”.

Love your neighbor as yourself I Am Hashem. Rav Kook "of blessed memory" walked the talk.

Thank u so much

עמוק

הכנה מופלאה לפסח וליארצייט של הרב בחול המועד פסח

זה כמו שיר. ומתורגם מאוד יפה. תודה רבה לכם , מאוד נהניתי זה היה מרתק. פסח שמח!

Yashar Koach, very deep truth, beautiful idea and mahalach. I had read the essence of this drasha in Derashot Harav by mr Lustiger; so nice to hear it in Yiddish by Rav Soloveitchik !

It seems to me that the comparison of different text, their history and their interpretation is the most natural attitude toward ancient texts we can have. If we want to understand them in their context and depth. Their sanctity its not violated!!, I think it is expanded by our efforts to understand these text with tools that are available to us. Professor Lieberman's "Tosefta Kipshuta" is one of the best examples of Talmud scholarship.

תורה רבה לכם על זה!!!! עם זאת, המילה סיפור לא באה מהפועל ספר אלה מהפועל סיפר (אכן שתי המילים הגיעו מאותו שורש ס-פ-ר)