BYD Atto3 vs Omoda E5 vs MG4 - which is best?

Поделиться
HTML-код
  • Опубликовано: 16 ноя 2024

Комментарии • 98

  • @patrickpetra-MI6
    @patrickpetra-MI6 4 месяца назад +22

    Why Omoda E5 suddenly booms sold 3800units in 3 months in Indonesia?
    - It uses BYD LFP battery
    - Less price then BYD Atto 3
    - Lifetime Warranty Battery
    - 201 HP, 340 nm(instant peak, 61kwh, 430km(WLTP)/ 505km(Dynamic)
    - Exterior & Interior minimalist and luxury

    • @aquaboy1650
      @aquaboy1650 3 месяца назад +1

      Also Omoda E5 has better performance and electric consumption than a Atto3 it self.

    • @willinoysitorus1509
      @willinoysitorus1509 2 месяца назад

      @@patrickpetra-MI6 Also Omoda E5 has way better audio quality than Atto 3. Omoda's Sony has crisp low and highs, and the double glass + smaller windows helps the sound quality.
      Suspension wise, Omoda e5 feels more expensive.
      When I test drive Ioniq 5 (my first Ev drive), I was blown away. After that I tested atto 3 and i was dissapointed. Then tried Omoda E5 and blown away again.

    • @ralesmana9684
      @ralesmana9684 Месяц назад +1

      @@patrickpetra-MI6 too bad in August, Atto 3 sold 3 times more than E5 in Indonesia.

    • @renbangbprd7236
      @renbangbprd7236 Месяц назад +1

      @@ralesmana9684 True but not very accurate, the sales in August are accumulation from previous months

    • @renbangbprd7236
      @renbangbprd7236 Месяц назад

      @@aquaboy1650 Now, you agree with me 😉

  • @UCMpDwp7VEfKXRH3NyAW7kuj
    @UCMpDwp7VEfKXRH3NyAW7kuj 4 месяца назад +22

    I trust byd's battery,if you old enough to know Nokia, byd already was the battery supplier at the time Nokia dominate the mobile phone industry

    • @TarmacLife
      @TarmacLife  4 месяца назад +2

      Yeah, the blade battery is clever tech.

    • @sheldonhumphries9492
      @sheldonhumphries9492 4 месяца назад +5

      Good thing the E5 uses blade battery technology.

    • @JTAN10ABLE
      @JTAN10ABLE 4 месяца назад +2

      Yeah I heard the OMODA also uses the same Blade battery

    • @patrickpetra-MI6
      @patrickpetra-MI6 4 месяца назад +5

      Omoda uses BYD LFP battery and Lifetime Warranty here in Indonesia

    • @HanFynn
      @HanFynn 4 месяца назад +2

      Omoda use byd blade battery and comes with lifetime warranty. Even byd didnt give lifetime warranty for their own car. For me its definetely why omoda still mile ahead against their competitors. Good job omoda

  • @ianm9677
    @ianm9677 Месяц назад +2

    We just bought the Chery E5, pick it up this Fri. Thanks for the review

    • @TarmacLife
      @TarmacLife  Месяц назад

      Good choice, let us know how it goes

  • @rowey7522
    @rowey7522 4 месяца назад +10

    Guys the cruise control on the MG is the steering wheel button right above the left star. One press. Easy.

    • @TarmacLife
      @TarmacLife  4 месяца назад

      Thanks for watching and comments. Yep we get it now, we're just pointing out that the steering wheel icon is not as obvious as the others.

  • @Avarter123
    @Avarter123 3 месяца назад +5

    Omoda E5 looks far far more luxurious than the other two. Also its exterior actually looks sleek and beautiful!

    • @TarmacLife
      @TarmacLife  3 месяца назад

      Yeah it does look a cut above

  • @MnamesJeff
    @MnamesJeff 4 месяца назад +2

    Thanks for the review! You really nailed on the top 3 Affordable EV and I can't really find any good comparison between the three except for your channel. Kudos to you!

    • @TarmacLife
      @TarmacLife  4 месяца назад

      Thanks, really appreciate the comments and support - It's something we are looking to do more of.

  • @aquaboy1650
    @aquaboy1650 3 месяца назад +2

    Here in Indonesia, Omoda E5 is selling well.
    Cheaper, better performance, better electric consumption, better equips and better interior than a Atto3.

  • @t8polestarcyan22
    @t8polestarcyan22 2 месяца назад +1

    The MG 4 is simply my pick. Omoda E5 is worth considering as long as I choose the model that have multi-link rear, yes you gotta watch out on tech specs. I'd go for E5 EX. It's hard to ignore MG 4's lower ride position as it have lower centre of gravity.

    • @TarmacLife
      @TarmacLife  2 месяца назад

      We actually really enjoyed them all and the MG4 was more of a driver's car. But day to day living, the Omoda was great.

  • @fixxundfertig
    @fixxundfertig 4 месяца назад +2

    Great video. Comparisons of the Atto and MG4 are hard to come by due to being different builds and (previously) price points. Have driven the Atto and MG4 and found they felt very different. I looking forward to the Omoda E5 being available in Australia.

    • @TarmacLife
      @TarmacLife  4 месяца назад

      Thanks for watching and great feedback. We enjoyed making the test. You should definitely check out the Omoda. I think it's Chery in Aus.

  • @teslabot6517
    @teslabot6517 Месяц назад +1

    Thanks Gents.
    ❤ all 3 ( not u guys! 😂) but the Omoda is my pick, too!
    Thanks Gents, great reviews!

    • @TarmacLife
      @TarmacLife  Месяц назад

      Thanks, appreciate the support. The Omoda was the best of the trio

  • @250980able
    @250980able 4 месяца назад +8

    omoda E5 👍

  • @bernardchupiekyong1001
    @bernardchupiekyong1001 8 дней назад

    I do love the MG4 Luxury version wish to own it what the driver car of the year 2024 🥰💯👍🏻

  • @Reddylion
    @Reddylion 4 месяца назад +1

    Waiting for facelift byd atto 3 hindustan south. That will be my choice. It must bet white exterior paint . Nice.

    • @TarmacLife
      @TarmacLife  4 месяца назад +1

      Cool, let us know when you get it

  • @hadisoewoyo8739
    @hadisoewoyo8739 17 дней назад

    I choose omoda e5 although the rear compartment is just average enough, but interior design much better than atto 3 and other.

  • @Katana50cc
    @Katana50cc 4 месяца назад

    Glad i waited. I am looking forward to test drive Neta X ~

    • @TarmacLife
      @TarmacLife  4 месяца назад

      We don't have the Neta brand here yet - but looks interesting

    • @hadisoewoyo8739
      @hadisoewoyo8739 17 дней назад

      Neta is comfort but motor is not as powerfull as those

  • @Mububban23
    @Mububban23 3 месяца назад +1

    Omoda looks hard to beat. Anyone got feedback on the company's reputation for spare parts availability, and dealing with warranty claims etc? Some car companies are terrible and some are helpful.

    • @TarmacLife
      @TarmacLife  3 месяца назад

      They seem to have good support here with 7 year warranty, but don't know the follow through

  • @dicky-duck6632
    @dicky-duck6632 4 месяца назад

    Several Aussie RUclips channel hosts have been invited to visit the factories of Geely and Zeekr, traveling in business class and staying in 5-star luxury hotels. Keep up the good work, and your turn will come.

    • @TarmacLife
      @TarmacLife  4 месяца назад

      We can only hope. Thanks for watching and comments

  • @gueritodrew
    @gueritodrew 9 дней назад

    can you confirm these are all 2024 models? I watched the video twice and didn't hear you mention the MY.

    • @TarmacLife
      @TarmacLife  9 дней назад

      They are (were) all current models, however, the Atto3 and MG4 were released earlier

  • @suhazliey
    @suhazliey 4 месяца назад +5

    I own omoda e5..good ev

    • @TarmacLife
      @TarmacLife  4 месяца назад

      Agree with you, it's very upmarket

    • @hendrytany9856
      @hendrytany9856 4 месяца назад +1

      I also own one, i love the auto lock feature, design, lightning (especially night time), the price is also acceptable. Top notch!

    • @Reddylion
      @Reddylion 4 месяца назад +1

      ​@@hendrytany9856it's not available here hindustan south, got byd atto 3, I guess I will choose that !

    • @riccistokes4454
      @riccistokes4454 2 месяца назад

      When is the omoda coming to the uk 🇬🇧

  • @kellyyuen4654
    @kellyyuen4654 2 месяца назад +1

    What about another comparison to XPeng G6?

    • @TarmacLife
      @TarmacLife  2 месяца назад

      It's not here in NZ right now

  • @jasonsplace
    @jasonsplace 3 месяца назад +2

    I have a MG4 SE, it's a fantastic car to drive. The battery in this model is fine to charge to 100% so it's a great car to have around town, to and from work. I previously owned a MG ZST Turbo. It was a bucket of crap, you wouldn't think This car was made by the same company.

    • @TarmacLife
      @TarmacLife  3 месяца назад

      Thanks for the comments, always like to hear from owners. Totally agree about the difference between the HS and MG4. Plus we really liked the rear wheel bias. Cheers again.

    • @t8polestarcyan22
      @t8polestarcyan22 2 месяца назад

      MG 4 SE (Excite 51) is the one to go for if you're quite tight on budget but it's still a very good car as you can have the same rear multi-link suspension as in.... Essence 64 (Trophy), Long Range 64 and X-Power. I don't even wanna think about MG ZST as I've already got myself a ZS EV.
      Even I'm happy to go for the MG 4 SE.

  • @tonywajong
    @tonywajong 2 месяца назад

    I choose only LFP / Steel Blade Battery, which is safe and can not explode : BYD👍

    • @TarmacLife
      @TarmacLife  2 месяца назад

      Can't argue with that

    • @hadisoewoyo8739
      @hadisoewoyo8739 22 дня назад

      Omoda e5 use byd battery and battery from other battery giant catl also safe .

  • @rakhmadana1944
    @rakhmadana1944 4 месяца назад +4

    Omoda ev😍😍😍

  • @kkiwi54
    @kkiwi54 2 месяца назад +1

    Surely the MG4 is a normal hatchback, certainly not an SUV

    • @TarmacLife
      @TarmacLife  2 месяца назад

      Kinda agree, bu marketed in NZ as an SUV

  • @mathewbunn9759
    @mathewbunn9759 4 месяца назад +1

    What was the average efficiency you achieved with the Omoda?

    • @TarmacLife
      @TarmacLife  4 месяца назад +1

      it averaged around the 16kWh mark

    • @mathewbunn9759
      @mathewbunn9759 4 месяца назад +1

      @@TarmacLife that's really impressive!

  • @paulb1951
    @paulb1951 4 месяца назад +1

    Why’s the MG4 in there? Is a hatchback not an SUV and a lot cheaper.

    • @TarmacLife
      @TarmacLife  3 месяца назад

      They call it an SUV here in NZ and it's not the cheapest of the 3

    • @paulb1951
      @paulb1951 3 месяца назад +1

      @@TarmacLife starts under $40k in Aus and certainly a hatchback. Other 2 are 10k more, so really an unfair comparison. Base model 4 has best battery and bang for buck is best there is out there currently. Not sure how NZ qualifies it as an SUV? But elevated height is what does it everywhere else in the world.

    • @TarmacLife
      @TarmacLife  3 месяца назад +1

      @@paulb1951 Thanks for following up. SUVs are a big thing here in NZ (probably the same in Aus) so manufacturers seem to like to throw whatever they can into that segment (IGNIS). As for price, the Atto3 starts at $51,990. MG4 $51,990 and Omoda E5 $47,990.

    • @t8polestarcyan22
      @t8polestarcyan22 2 месяца назад +2

      Indeed. MG4 is a hatch. MG ZS esp. ZS EV is an SUV.

  • @יצחקאביחימאגוליס
    @יצחקאביחימאגוליס 4 месяца назад +2

    What was the range on the omoda

    • @TarmacLife
      @TarmacLife  4 месяца назад +3

      Thanks for watching and comments. They all achieved between 350-370km. Omoda around 356km, Atto3 around 362km and MG4 around 370km.

  • @ronaldoelazegui7405
    @ronaldoelazegui7405 4 месяца назад +2

    i own a BYD atto 3

  • @OmegaFellowship
    @OmegaFellowship 3 месяца назад +1

    which is best Byd atto3 or Omoda ?

    • @TarmacLife
      @TarmacLife  3 месяца назад

      Watching the video will explain all

  • @UDKUntukDikenang
    @UDKUntukDikenang 4 месяца назад +1

    I am driving omoda e5

    • @TarmacLife
      @TarmacLife  4 месяца назад +1

      Nice, good to hear from an owner

  • @Jonathan2x6
    @Jonathan2x6 21 день назад

    2 reviewers were good and provided helpful feedback . The other dead pan monotonous Adams family reviewer needs to be replaced . Like a.s.a.p

  • @freedom_x5
    @freedom_x5 3 месяца назад

    neta X?

  • @prayashbhari1433
    @prayashbhari1433 4 месяца назад

    what about the Geely Galaxy E5?

    • @TarmacLife
      @TarmacLife  4 месяца назад

      We don't have it in NZ

  • @gueritodrew
    @gueritodrew 9 дней назад

    8:40 why did you cover the license plate characters with a penis shape?

    • @TarmacLife
      @TarmacLife  9 дней назад

      haha, we did not notice that - but can't unsee it now!

  • @stoop25
    @stoop25 18 дней назад

    Every 'feature' like hands-free trunk opening is something that will cost you down the the line when it fails. Give me minimal 'features'.

  • @cinnamont1224
    @cinnamont1224 4 месяца назад

    None of them are affordable.

    • @TarmacLife
      @TarmacLife  4 месяца назад

      They are in comparison to other EVs

    • @Reddylion
      @Reddylion 4 месяца назад +1

      Price should come down. Hindustan south.

    • @t8polestarcyan22
      @t8polestarcyan22 2 месяца назад

      Ok.... so what about.... a Toyota Camry V6? or a Highlander V6? As you can see EVs' price tags are now similar to everyday ICEs.

    • @Reddylion
      @Reddylion 2 месяца назад

      @@t8polestarcyan22 yes.

  • @rorge007
    @rorge007 4 месяца назад

    All EVs are rubbish. Soon to be a sorry foot note in history

    • @hadisoewoyo8739
      @hadisoewoyo8739 2 месяца назад

      @@rorge007 what is the reson?

    • @rorge007
      @rorge007 2 месяца назад

      @@hadisoewoyo8739 poor range, slow to charge, only about ten years life, spontaneously combust, expensive to maintain and repair, expensive insurance. Soon won't be allowed in parking buildings These are the most obvious ones

    • @t8polestarcyan22
      @t8polestarcyan22 2 месяца назад +2

      @@rorge007 Why did you say they have poor range when you only need to do city commutes with EVs? My daily commute to work even through motorways is less than 30Km, 150km weekly to work. Also you need to consider traffic lights or frequent intersection stops in town which can lead to dollars worths of petrol at red traffic lights or possibly face premature wear of starter motor of ICEs. If you can't charge at home, then you can go for a hybrid but I only pay $1.35 to charge my EV or at the most $3.70. Servicing is also a lot cheaper due to few moving parts compared to Internal Combustion Engines.
      I still prefer ICE but I have to pay $180 to fill my tank! My majority of driving is local commutes so my ICE will be driven on a long drive weekend.
      10 year of life? Majority will replace their cars in around 5 years. For your "interest" there are "old" Nissan Leaf around and still doing well and so too Mitsubishi iMIEV.

    • @hadisoewoyo8739
      @hadisoewoyo8739 17 дней назад +1

      ​@@rorge007i think not everyone experienced that. Ice car also has limited range but only because gas station infra years ahead of charging station make those ice can travel more.
      Fire? Ice car in percentage much higher to catch fire on its own compared to ev.
      Ev is less To maintain thus less expensive also. battery can be replaced for each module, no need to replace whole.
      Battery life and also motor life is so long. It could stand for 20 years. byd Taxi in my country can reach 400k to 600k km with original battery and still runs well.

  • @crashnreset6987
    @crashnreset6987 4 месяца назад

    Top Gear replacement wannabies testing cars no one wants or can afford.... yea, go guys ;p

    • @TarmacLife
      @TarmacLife  4 месяца назад +1

      Appreciate the comparison :)