@@martelraykin My HS had two jazz bands. There was the good one that was by audition and the teacher could have exactly the amount of saxophones he wanted, and the non-audition band which had... 7 saxophones and only 2 trombones.
I was just about to comment this. I'm a percussionist, and sometimes my parts would have long, tiresome rests while the rest of the band would play. Sometimes, when this happened, I would legitimately lay on the floor and nearly fall asleep, counting the measures in my head. Sure, it was _very_ loud, but I surely would've fallen asleep if I didn't have a part to play. TL;DR: I confirm this statement with strong enthusiasm.
“I forgot my instrument “ This is where the teacher would say “Then grab that pencil I know you have on your stand and do the fingerings. You don’t get to sit there and waste time.”
@@ogwankanobi6680 knew a kid that slept through band class and was very stunned since my experience is similar to Mr. Cinema Sins in that I'm too busy feeling the air vibrations and hearing them to see sleep as feasibly possible before 4th period
@@Xploshi Dang im blind But at least you're the most subscribed channel to reply to one of my comments? only the 2nd time a verified user has replied to my comment, the first was Yt Battles lol
@@nathanholmes-king3827 statistically speaking at least ONE of Jeremy's crazy stories or tales of his college girlfriend has to be true for someone on the cinemasins team
That's CinemaSins, even he himself knows that these sins don't have any meaning whatsoever, he gives them for really anything and irrationally, this is nowhere near pure fair critics, that's just squeezing out content
@@iver1343 When has this channel e v e r been about fair critique of a movie? It's just about mocking the films and pointing out even the tiniest cracks in it, not a full review of the strengths and weaknesses.
Remember how you're not able to feel touch as a soul, but when Joe initially lands in the You Seminar and gets bit on the hand by a baby soul, he hollers like it hurts.
@@snekkoheckko4466 yes but if he isn't in heaven then that would mean that it didn't go to heaven. it wasn't "all dogs don't go to hell", it was "all dogs go to heaven".
This movie made me decide to start dancing to all my music in public and I haven't been happier. Once you live for living and enjoy every moment, judgment becomes as invisible as it is irrelevant.
@@brogrammerplus7683 literally doesn't matter. However me personally my music taste is a mesh pool. But I love dance to old school hip hop and r&b while I also chill to lofi, indie, or classical music. Hilariously I do like death metal, screamo and lots of edm (specifically dubstep or riddim). International music does not get away from me either. I'll be here forever so to keep it short the majority of my music interest are underrated imo due to not keeping up with known celebrities.
I could write a full essay on why the epiphany scene is so well written and beautifully crafted, the fact that you feel all the emotions Joe feels and not a single word was spoken is amazing
- why is Marie Antoinette the only one whose spirit reflects how they died? - Joe meets a completely random soul who conveniently lives 2 blocks away from him
“Book fairs were the biggest lies our teachers ever told us”. Listen, you can have just about anything else and it’s fine, but you don’t diss book fairs, that shit was the bomb. You could walk in with $20 and leave with 3 books, a poster of a Lamborghini, and a big smile on your face, those fairs were the biggest thing I missed in high school, and I say by not getting those book fairs, we were robbed blind.
1:35, l don’t know what school you went to, but book fairs were one of the highlights of the year. We loved that we got to skip class to shop for books. It was magical, and every kid pored over the catalog for weeks in anticipation.
Book fairs were my Heaven! Dang parents never gave me an allowance so I could get anything though. Heck, they are the ones who taught me how to read at three years old! Own that shit, parents!
I love it when they sin Pixar because they're almost always going to compliment the movie and remove sins. Edit: You know, I said "almost" for a reason.
It seemed pretty obvious to me that the reason Joe had a unique experience was because he wasn't supposed to be on the conveyor, and the Jerrys were in on it the whole time.
Actually contrary to popular belief, Marie Antoinette never said “Let them eat cake”. She was actually remarkably concerned about the French public and had little power to do anything. Because she was Austrian, Marie was hated by much of xenophobic France who believed their troubles laid with her as the cause.
oh, i read somewhere that she was actually trying to be NICE, by FORCING the cake-makers to GIVE AWAY FREE CAKE. this led to a total economic collapse that she was RIGHTFULLY blamed for.
Jeremy as a person that grew up in NY I can promise u we can sleep thru ANYTHING regardless how loud. Also PLEASE DO WILLY WONKA AKD THE CHOCOLATE FATCORY W/ GENE WILDER 😊
This was such a cliche nonsense for a movie that is supposed to be deep and dealing with death, afterlife, souls and etc. So the meaning of life is to live the way you want to and be happy and all that bullshit? Yeah right. Tell that to people who can't simply "live" their lives. Tell that to millions of people who died out of starvation, who didn't have parents and happy memories to go with them, who were poor, born and died on the streets, or were killed in pointless wars constructed by heartless politicians, tell that to people who are handicapped, or brain damaged, or blind, or whatever. There's perhaps a single digit % worth of people on this planet, who can just "live" their life the way they want to and be happy, and can make this a meaning of their lives. There is more to life than just living. But this movie doesn't talk about it, it doesn't talk about anything that is death related and actually meaningful. They avoid words like God like a plague, and redesign afterlife into a weird religious kumbaya land where all religions are kinda right but actually wrong, a version that no human on the planet actually believes. The crazy need to be inclusive with something as polarized as religion killed this movie, it makes it deep to absolutely nobody, because atheists do not believe in souls, and all people who do believe in souls, do not believe in what this movie does. And the lesson is a dumb LIE that can only satisfy depressed middle class western people who watch it, and is absurd for everybody else. In result, it teaches you nothing about death or life but pointless cliches. It is well animated and gives you a few laughs. But that's about all this movie accomplishes. I cry from laughter when I hear ppl say this movie is BOLD because it took on the death topic. This was the safest movie I've ever seen.
Fun fact: it's the rope of the anchor that provides the most drag, reducing the speed of the ship and making it less likely to gain speed. The anchor itself is more to keep the rope taut. So the peace sign anchor, while not being the most optimum, would still work pretty well as a normal anchor not in void sand.
1:29 bold of Jeremy to assume that a person whom lacks interest or is fatigued enough is incapable of sleeping through band class only to be awakened by the band teacher crashing cymbals over their head.
3:34 "Also why is the moving escalator so completly empty when Joe lands, but then an absolut mad house later?" - I mean... I think this question better stays unanswered.
The one problem I had with the "Find your spark" theory was exactly what 22 went through! How does a soul earn its pass if the spark is to experience Earth in the flesh? To experience Earthly pleasures like tasting food which they canNOT do at the YouSeminar because souls can't taste or smell. Such souls will never get an Earth pass unless they accidentally land on Earth, like 22 did.
The scene in which the girl just laid down and slept in class reminded me of my friend in high school who would do just that whenever she felt like it and no one cared enough, everyone was tired of life (students and teachers). Also, everybody slept in class from time to time, but she was the only one who dared join chairs in order to make a bed for herself lmao. This hit so deep in my memories that honestly, I was astonished to finally see a movie portraying teenage students in their finest, purest chaotic energy
1:02: It's even worse. Instruments are not all in the same key. A flute and a clarinet are both written in treble clef but a flute is in the key of C while the clarinet is in the key of Bb. What this means is that if you write the note for middle C on a treble clef staff and ask the flautist to play it, they'll play the actual note of middle C, 262 Hz. The clarinet, however, while still reading the note as middle C, calling it middle C, and thinking of it as middle C, will play a note that is actually the Bb below middle C, 233.082 Hz. Thus, even all the instruments that are written for treble clef will not be playing the same notes. The flutes and the oboes (both in the key of C) will be playing the same note and the clarinets and trumpets (both in the key of Bb) will be playing the same note, but those two groups will not be playing the same note. French horns are usually written in treble clef, but they're in the key of F. You can't just write music on the chalkboard and expect all the instruments to be able to play the same thing. The instruments don't work like that.
I'm more so on the other side. I loved the concept of the entire afterlife in this movie, but I wasn't super attached to any of the characters. It was still a decent movie though
Finally someone else agrees Joe should've gone to the great beyond. When I told my family that he should have stayed there, they said I was a psychopath for wanting him to die. Like no I don't specifically want him dead, but the sacrifice he made doesn't mean anything anymore.
But him going to the great beyond would've gone against the lesson. He learned that it's important to enjoy life as is, but there's no real use in learning that message if he doesn't get a chance to execute it. It was a choice between the sacrifice not meaning anything and the entire point of the movie not meaning anything.
His sacrifice still counts in terms of he was willing to make that choice. Plus without it, the message ends up a little dull in-universe. Two souls learn the value in how to actually "live" life but one of them's about to be a baby with no recollection and the other is going to get bugzapped.
It also would have completed his 'Teacher' arc with choosing an eternity of mentoring as his calling over his more selfish dream he had been clinging to.
While I do agree he shouldn’t have been given a second chance, I don’t think Joe should have gone to the great beyond. I think it would have been better if Joe became a mentor for the rest of eternity.
I watched this movie with my whole family. The ages were ranging from my 6 year old cousin, to my 84 year old grandma. All of us enjoyed it. To me, that's the magic of Pixar
Watched it with several friends... All of us found it very bad. I really don't understand the hype around this movie. The music and the art were great, the story and the characters' development though... ? Big yikes.
8:20 I get that this joke can be interpreted as Jeremy doesn’t care about history (or that a lot if people know very little about her ) but Mary Antoinette KICKED ASS AT DIPLOMACY And wasn’t actually as horrible as people make her out to be , she was A SCAPEGOAT A SCAPEGOAT I TELLS YA ... sorry got a bit carried away but you get my point
*Another sin* From the location Terry was sitting while counting, he should’ve seen Joe fall into the Great Before. So why was he surprised when the count was off?
10:23 I've done that...2 hour drive to the festival, unpack the tent and yep, no poles...who tf doesnt put the poles back in the bag when theyre done?!
9:26 "I can't smell. I can't taste either" When watching this film for the first time, how many people shouted CORONAVIRUS coz my family and I sure as hell did.
I love how better help chose to sponsor this channel. They were like, welp, people who love watching and finding mistakes in every little thing must be key demographic for our services. 😂
The abacus row that was entirely filled with beads and therefore couldn't be used for counting was eventually put in charge of using the other moveable rows of abacus beads whenever Terry took a filing cabinet break.
1:13: Depends upon who shows up for class. In my 7th grade band, the instructor inherited all the people who came in from 6th grade. He stared out at the players and saw a sea of licorice to his left from the near-infinite number of clarinetists but only 3 sax players to his right. For this school system (Las Vegas in the 80s), 6th grade was when you got to take your very first elective and thus could take Band. But, it was geared mostly to teach you how to play an instrument, not to play in a band. Thus, if you wanted to learn to play the clarinet, you took Band in 3rd period because that was the clarinet section. If you wanted to learn to play the trumpet, that was another period. You never saw any of the other instruments until the Christmas concert and the year-end concert. It was only in 7th grade (and a completely different school) that Band became a class of playing together as a group and thus it was only filled with those who decided to keep with it. That year, all the clarinetists from 6th grade took Band while hardly any of the saxophonists did. So if this is a jazz band in elementary school, I'm not surprised to see a bunch of saxophonists. That's who showed up.
Yeah, my experience with Better Help was getting ignored for 2 weeks by one person, and then being berated for not being able to fix myself without help up until that point. Yeah, super helpful.
@@flowgelato9133 Possibly? The two that I had were proud to show off their licenses and which region they worked in, so I guess it could be followed up on to see if they're being honest.
@kerradeph this was posted years ago, I forgot how it goes (I know the beginnings look silly but bear with him) ruclips.net/video/8PLgOaVXmGU/видео.html I basically what they wrote onthe user agreement is unreliable to show the legitimacy of mental health counsellors. Please check their website again and see if they still did this, if they do, turn off the website and dont support it
@@flowgelato9133 I think it might be able to be found without paying. I cancelled my subscription and got a refund because I didn't get any help from the month I paid for.
I absolutely loved this movie! But honestly, I had really hoped that there would be an end credit scene where we got to see what happened to 22 after. Like maybe years later a child resembling 22 would be in Joe's class or something.
Them: Would it kill him to throw in some French Horns?! Me, a French Horn player, an instrument consistently under-appreciated: (literally screams in delight)
1:24 In my Music extra class there was this asian girl that alwaysforgot her piano (I mean keyboard) and we were in elementary and weren't allowed phones, and in a music classroom there isn't much you can have fun with, so she litterally took naps between chairs like that, so I think was the only person that laughed at that scene because I felt related.
Who else thinks that they should actually release Soul in theatres sometime, and give Onward another go since it barely made it to theatres before the world fell apart.
All jokes aside (or sins haha), this movie was gooood. Really shows us all the beauty we are missing while searching for something “big” that will make us happy.
All this “time” stuff is making me think one thing: *Time is a tool you can put on the wall or wear it on your wrist. The past is far behind us, the future doesn’t exist!*
He didn't even mention the fact that there would have been *seven* sax players if the last one had remembered their instrument
Tbf my jazz band has seven sax players and we have a lot of fun.
@@martelraykin My HS had two jazz bands. There was the good one that was by audition and the teacher could have exactly the amount of saxophones he wanted, and the non-audition band which had... 7 saxophones and only 2 trombones.
My middle school beginner band has 5 altos, a tenor and a bari sax. It would be ok if they had any idea how to control their loudness
my band had like 9 saxaphones
My middle school band had 30 people and i was the only trombonist lmao. But like 8 drummers
As a musician in his last year of high school, I can tell you that we can sleep through a rehearsal, no matter how bad it is lmao
I was just about to comment this. I'm a percussionist, and sometimes my parts would have long, tiresome rests while the rest of the band would play. Sometimes, when this happened, I would legitimately lay on the floor and nearly fall asleep, counting the measures in my head. Sure, it was _very_ loud, but I surely would've fallen asleep if I didn't have a part to play.
TL;DR: I confirm this statement with strong enthusiasm.
As someone who was in band and marching band, can confirm that we will sleep through anything
I too can relate as a senior in band. We just play frisbee since there's no concerts coming.
I am a musician too, but even before that, just living in the New York City, you can sleep through anything
I can relate as well as I am also in High school Band!
its funny how Jeremy sins Disney for 45 seconds of intro when he has 41 seconds of intros
Only the sinner can sin the sinner cause he made that sin to sin
You either die a hero or you live long enough to see yourself become the villain, become the very thing you swore to destroy.
@@jtwatts7990 You're making my brain explode.
@@DavidRay_40 😂😂
Us virgos don’t count that much. So that’s a sin. I also don’t really know what is virgo’s really do so that’s also a sin.
“I forgot my instrument “
This is where the teacher would say
“Then grab that pencil I know you have on your stand and do the fingerings. You don’t get to sit there and waste time.”
YES just YES
We didn’t bring our instrument for a reason :]
So true XD
@George Corbul Joe clearly didn’t want to be a teacher. So he didn’t act like a teacher. He acted like a substitute teacher. :D
Y do I feel u
“I wake up if I feel the vibration of the air change”
That’s called hearing
Disagreed with this sin. Kids will “sleep” through anything. Especially when bored 😑
@@ogwankanobi6680 knew a kid that slept through band class and was very stunned since my experience is similar to Mr. Cinema Sins in that I'm too busy feeling the air vibrations and hearing them to see sleep as feasibly possible before 4th period
@@ogwankanobi6680 it is very easy to fall asleep in a band class💀😂
Ok but as someone who can't hear, I feel vibration changes. I can't hear when it rains, but I can feel it through the floor.
@@siriuslysam2285 that's badass
I would've added a sin for the fact that Joe is THE ONLY SOUL wearing a hat in the Great Beyond
I did actually see souls with hats in the massive soul pile
He kinda did
yeah
Abraham Lincoln’s soul has a hat
@@Xploshi Dang im blind
But at least you're the most subscribed channel to reply to one of my comments? only the 2nd time a verified user has replied to my comment, the first was Yt Battles lol
I genuinely don't know if Jeremy is making up these stories about his youth or if he's lived a wonderful life so far
This channel has multiple scriptwriters.
do we ever tho man XD
@@nathanholmes-king3827 statistically speaking
at least ONE of Jeremy's crazy stories or tales of his college girlfriend has to be true for someone on the cinemasins team
No profile picture lmao
@@burgerkingfries4941 ok ?
You forgot to sin how Terry grabbed the soul out of another guy thinking he was Joe, probably leaving the guy scarred for life.
Shang Tsung would be proud of Terry.
How is that a sin?
Near death experiences are a thing tho
Kind of like when Roxy did it to that homeless guy.
@@storm_fling1062 very little on this show actually is a sin, its just them unfairly critiquing movies and thats the joke
"That's not a sin for the movie, but it is like a million sins for New York."
*adds one sin to the movie*
Y’all never seen 29% rates? It’s the bad credit special in car sales 😂🤦♂️🥶
That's CinemaSins, even he himself knows that these sins don't have any meaning whatsoever, he gives them for really anything and irrationally, this is nowhere near pure fair critics, that's just squeezing out content
@@iver1343 When has this channel e v e r been about fair critique of a movie? It's just about mocking the films and pointing out even the tiniest cracks in it, not a full review of the strengths and weaknesses.
@@iver1343 dude, you shouldnt take it seriously, some of the sins are obviously joking. It's not a review.
420th like
Remember how you're not able to feel touch as a soul, but when Joe initially lands in the You Seminar and gets bit on the hand by a baby soul, he hollers like it hurts.
Yeah I notice that too
Maybe it was reactionary.
Have you ever played vr and really got into it? I scream in pain even if it's not real pain
Ever bump into something and say ow even though it didn't hurt? I imagine it's the same mental reaction to stimuli
@@EonlDream or dropping something
I'm surprised he didn't mention how Moonwind got to keep his beard in the soul realm, but Joe's mustache was erased.
It's cuz clearly Joe has a more spiritual connection to his hat than his mustache whereas Moonwind sees his beard as apart of him, duh /s
"All dogs go to heaven."
Cerberus the three headed dog: *"Am I joke to you??"*
but he's not IN hell he's just guarding it and hades (the place) ist really a hell or heaven Cerberus just guards the afterlife like a good boy
and he's not n animal he's a mythical creature, probably immortal
@@snekkoheckko4466 yes but if he isn't in heaven then that would mean that it didn't go to heaven. it wasn't "all dogs don't go to hell", it was "all dogs go to heaven".
Lol
Cerberus is Greek for spotted
Ok but the animation is getting so much better its insane. Aesthetically incredible too. Also can we have an Everything Wrong with Matilda?
But Matilda is too good to sin
Agreed. This movie really is a treat for the eyes.
everything wrong with king mango >:))))
@@Suckmynards9000 You have no taste, go back to watching those 80s Pixar shorts XD
How can you like this at the same time diss Matilda... what the tf are you?
I thought he would add a sin when 22 told Joe “You can’t crush a soul here. That’s what life on earth is for.”
I would have taken a sin off for that. XD
I laughed so hard at that part
That isn't a sin though
@@storm_fling1062 so is that foreign person’s dream about walruses 😂
@@Eva-me9pv exactly they aren't sins
This movie made me decide to start dancing to all my music in public and I haven't been happier. Once you live for living and enjoy every moment, judgment becomes as invisible as it is irrelevant.
That's cool and all, but what type of music?
@@brogrammerplus7683 death metal
@@RedYoshiGamer2 that would be awesome. Just walking ur way home and see someone ballerina dancing to death metal.😅
@@brogrammerplus7683 literally doesn't matter. However me personally my music taste is a mesh pool. But I love dance to old school hip hop and r&b while I also chill to lofi, indie, or classical music. Hilariously I do like death metal, screamo and lots of edm (specifically dubstep or riddim). International music does not get away from me either. I'll be here forever so to keep it short the majority of my music interest are underrated imo due to not keeping up with known celebrities.
Always looking to expand my music interest.
I could write a full essay on why the epiphany scene is so well written and beautifully crafted, the fact that you feel all the emotions Joe feels and not a single word was spoken is amazing
Ik I watched this movie today and it cleared my depression
*epiphany
@@vision5092
Sorry but if that's true then you didn't have depression
@@MaksKCS I did have depression
@Catharsis
Exactly
The main character feels like he hasn’t done anything eventful in his life. So I guess you could say he’s just an AVERAGE JOE!
bdum ching
thats a sin from me
Yes, insert rim shot here! 🥁
This is a sin "ding"
Lol nice
- why is Marie Antoinette the only one whose spirit reflects how they died?
- Joe meets a completely random soul who conveniently lives 2 blocks away from him
“Book fairs were the biggest lies our teachers ever told us”.
Listen, you can have just about anything else and it’s fine, but you don’t diss book fairs, that shit was the bomb. You could walk in with $20 and leave with 3 books, a poster of a Lamborghini, and a big smile on your face, those fairs were the biggest thing I missed in high school, and I say by not getting those book fairs, we were robbed blind.
Gotta agree. I LOVED the book fairs!
High school? Lol must have been better i only had book fairs in elementary. Still with the same result as above
...there's another can.
20 bucks? I don't think I spent $20 in all my childhood book fairs combined.
@@blazednhazed71 I definitely didn't have them in high school. Just elementary, like you. Still fun, though.
I'd have taken a sin off for how they refused to dance around saying "Hell."
When do they say this
@@rasharddavis321 is this? H e... double hockey sticks?
@@Jojo-om7uy I think so
@@Jojo-om7uy yeah but did they actually say 'Hell'
@@loganbigmo Yes Jerry says "You mean hell?" then the new souls start repeating "hell hell"
1:35, l don’t know what school you went to, but book fairs were one of the highlights of the year. We loved that we got to skip class to shop for books. It was magical, and every kid pored over the catalog for weeks in anticipation.
ding! another sin for cinema sins
I loved book fairs
Book fairs were my Heaven! Dang parents never gave me an allowance so I could get anything though. Heck, they are the ones who taught me how to read at three years old! Own that shit, parents!
Why didn’t they take a sin off for the scene with Joe playing the piano realizing the value of life? That was like the best scene in the whole movie!!
Add a sin for it being schmaltzy nonsense perhaps
Just because it’s the best doesn’t mean it’s good.
@@jackwenn_9693 true but they should have said something about it. Like anything at all
Because sins are taken off for stupid things. If you think the scene is great why would it be a sin?
@@JennifuhhGilardi when has that ever stopped Jeremy before?
Terry is an elderly woman. The loop on the back of her head is a hair bun. Also, she's voiced by the same lady who voiced the grandmother in Moana.
pretty sure terry is a thoughtform construct and it doesn't really matter.
also Topaz from Thor Ragnarok
Bro I thought he was a mouse
*I thought it was an angry incel*
Really?? I actually thought the bun was an ear at first!
Summery of this movie:
Death: *exists
Joe: No.
And then you realize that it was actually
Life: *exists
Joe: No.
Lol
@@pedrocalegari7768 underrated comment
I love it when they sin Pixar because they're almost always going to compliment the movie and remove sins.
Edit: You know, I said "almost" for a reason.
Unless it's Cars 2
Or Brave
Or Good Dinosaur. These three are why I said "almost."
And a good dinosaur
@@plipplopproductions4347 They actually removed a sin for The Good Dinosaur because of its animation.
Speaking as a person who is literally going to the mall tomorrow to put a slinky on an escalator, how could you possibly dislike escalators
How'd it go? I need weekend plans
@@MonkeyOfChaos It went surprisingly well. The mall security was really helpful.
@@presenceofthemastermtg5962 lmao-
Because they are scary and I've heard horror storys about them
@@ro_cer wtf kind of horror stories are about an escalator, tell me one
I'm surprised you didn't sin the movie for killing a cat in a cutaway joke.
The cat is seen later becuase they have 9 lives
Quite coyote is my favorite line of all for their smooth voice
How about a sin for Terry having a random person go through an out-of-body experience; nearly killing him
It seemed pretty obvious to me that the reason Joe had a unique experience was because he wasn't supposed to be on the conveyor, and the Jerrys were in on it the whole time.
Actually contrary to popular belief, Marie Antoinette never said “Let them eat cake”. She was actually remarkably concerned about the French public and had little power to do anything. Because she was Austrian, Marie was hated by much of xenophobic France who believed their troubles laid with her as the cause.
oh, i read somewhere that she was actually trying to be NICE, by FORCING the cake-makers to GIVE AWAY FREE CAKE.
this led to a total economic collapse that she was RIGHTFULLY blamed for.
@@ericb3157 Let me guess. Wikipedia?
@@caniaskyoukindofaweirdques7053 actually i got that from a novel, "the last centurion" by John Ringo.
HER HAIR WAS A BOAT
@@ericb3157 WHY WOULD YOU GET YOUR INFORMATION FROM A NOVEL. A NOVEL IS NOT REAL BY DEFINITION!
Jeremy as a person that grew up in NY I can promise u we can sleep thru ANYTHING regardless how loud. Also PLEASE DO WILLY WONKA AKD THE CHOCOLATE FATCORY W/ GENE WILDER 😊
Yes we can
He'd never do that. Trust me.
The ending of this movie genuinely made me cry. It was beautiful.
“I’m gonna live every minute of it” Joe Gardner 2020
Live every minute of 2020? Oh God no.
@@coolguyyy9071 except the people who didn't
This was such a cliche nonsense for a movie that is supposed to be deep and dealing with death, afterlife, souls and etc. So the meaning of life is to live the way you want to and be happy and all that bullshit? Yeah right. Tell that to people who can't simply "live" their lives. Tell that to millions of people who died out of starvation, who didn't have parents and happy memories to go with them, who were poor, born and died on the streets, or were killed in pointless wars constructed by heartless politicians, tell that to people who are handicapped, or brain damaged, or blind, or whatever. There's perhaps a single digit % worth of people on this planet, who can just "live" their life the way they want to and be happy, and can make this a meaning of their lives. There is more to life than just living. But this movie doesn't talk about it, it doesn't talk about anything that is death related and actually meaningful. They avoid words like God like a plague, and redesign afterlife into a weird religious kumbaya land where all religions are kinda right but actually wrong, a version that no human on the planet actually believes. The crazy need to be inclusive with something as polarized as religion killed this movie, it makes it deep to absolutely nobody, because atheists do not believe in souls, and all people who do believe in souls, do not believe in what this movie does. And the lesson is a dumb LIE that can only satisfy depressed middle class western people who watch it, and is absurd for everybody else. In result, it teaches you nothing about death or life but pointless cliches. It is well animated and gives you a few laughs. But that's about all this movie accomplishes. I cry from laughter when I hear ppl say this movie is BOLD because it took on the death topic. This was the safest movie I've ever seen.
@@mitromney cool
Kind of wished that line didn’t happen. And I didn’t watch the movie.
How the hell did you skip the piano epiphany scene and not remove a sin
Because he realized if he did it he would have to remove all the sins
When he said "skip" to that part, I literally said "wtf" outloud despite being alone in the room.
And the barber shop scene
@@vincevvn Those two scenes made me wanna burst out crying.
Ah yes, my favorite cartoon character,
D O R O T H E A E X P L O R E R.
Sexy diarrhea
@@authenticpuffer6950 wtf
@@authenticpuffer6950 it no make sense, but me like it
Even more astonishing than the Marie Antoinette cameo is the Mother Teresa one, but most people aren't ready for this conversation.
What conversation
Why does it say this comment is from 12 hours ago 0-0
The fuck
Channel member
Mother Teresa was actually a rude and self-entitled person irl.
Fun fact: it's the rope of the anchor that provides the most drag, reducing the speed of the ship and making it less likely to gain speed. The anchor itself is more to keep the rope taut. So the peace sign anchor, while not being the most optimum, would still work pretty well as a normal anchor not in void sand.
1:29 bold of Jeremy to assume that a person whom lacks interest or is fatigued enough is incapable of sleeping through band class only to be awakened by the band teacher crashing cymbals over their head.
3:34 "Also why is the moving escalator so completly empty when Joe lands, but then an absolut mad house later?" - I mean... I think this question better stays unanswered.
The one problem I had with the "Find your spark" theory was exactly what 22 went through! How does a soul earn its pass if the spark is to experience Earth in the flesh? To experience Earthly pleasures like tasting food which they canNOT do at the YouSeminar because souls can't taste or smell. Such souls will never get an Earth pass unless they accidentally land on Earth, like 22 did.
Book fairs were the greatest thrills of my childhood.
The scene in which the girl just laid down and slept in class reminded me of my friend in high school who would do just that whenever she felt like it and no one cared enough, everyone was tired of life (students and teachers). Also, everybody slept in class from time to time, but she was the only one who dared join chairs in order to make a bed for herself lmao. This hit so deep in my memories that honestly, I was astonished to finally see a movie portraying teenage students in their finest, purest chaotic energy
1:02: It's even worse. Instruments are not all in the same key. A flute and a clarinet are both written in treble clef but a flute is in the key of C while the clarinet is in the key of Bb. What this means is that if you write the note for middle C on a treble clef staff and ask the flautist to play it, they'll play the actual note of middle C, 262 Hz. The clarinet, however, while still reading the note as middle C, calling it middle C, and thinking of it as middle C, will play a note that is actually the Bb below middle C, 233.082 Hz. Thus, even all the instruments that are written for treble clef will not be playing the same notes. The flutes and the oboes (both in the key of C) will be playing the same note and the clarinets and trumpets (both in the key of Bb) will be playing the same note, but those two groups will not be playing the same note.
French horns are usually written in treble clef, but they're in the key of F.
You can't just write music on the chalkboard and expect all the instruments to be able to play the same thing. The instruments don't work like that.
A Virgo diss from CinemaSins. As a Virgo, I am honored.
I'm a left handed Virgo. He stacks me twice
Those outtakes are pure gold✨
The fuck 12 hours
HOW THE HELL DID YOU COMMENT THIS TWELVE HOURS AGO
Probably membership
channel member
@@AlfredoSauce69 BY BEING A PATREON MEMBER ITS GREAT YOU SHOULD JOIN IN ✨
The joke about the Knicks was hilarious. If this movie was in theatres, the audience would've been dying 🤣
American audiences, sure. Rest of the world, we kinda got it.
Those who make sports their life would be dying more than likely everyone else a chuckle or a heh
Knicks are good now lol
It really was. We had to pause the movie we were laughing so much.
This movie is in cinemas. Outside the USA.....
I think 22 being able to understand cat!Joe isn't anything to do with 22 herself, but the fact that the cat has Joe's soul talking to his own body.
And Moonwind. 🤣
“Is all this living really worth dying for?” - 22
Book Fairs are one of the greatest highs you can get as a child! Or was I just a nerd...?
I agree! I loved them as a child, I still do lol
Yesss!
Book Fairs are a depressive hell if your parents never gave you money to buy anything.
Everything Wrong With Soul in 17 Minutes or Less: 1 second of Joe being turned into a cat, and 16 minutes 59 seconds of outtakes.
Here’s a sin for cinema sins. 1:15 you’re talking about cello... in a jazz band *ding noise* 🔔
BRU I didn’t understand the jazzing joke until he said, “if you keep jazzing it’ll fall off” lmaooo
I loved this movie, but man, the core concept has holes when you start to actually examine it. Still in my top 5 Pixar though.
Wdym?
I agree haha. But I feel like that’s with most movies ya know? Soul is ranked at #8 for my ranking
Agreed, after all, every movie has sins, even from Disney!
I'm more so on the other side. I loved the concept of the entire afterlife in this movie, but I wasn't super attached to any of the characters. It was still a decent movie though
What are the holes in the plot? I really wanna know
"You can't eat dreams for breakfast, Joey."
Cinema Sins: Bacon deniers!
That gave me a good laugh.
500 sins for the 32 seconds of commercial time I had to watch before CinemaSins started Cinemasinning Roll credits
“The last time I blew my shot my gf ended up being overdue” there is no way this app is free 😂😂😂
It also isn't a sin of the movie which means it shouldn't be here
@@storm_fling1062 You must be new
@@storm_fling1062 this isnt a review. It's a joking commentary
@@loganbigmo no I've been here since 2016
@@loganbigmo which is why I hate the new version of this channel
i haven’t seen the movie or the video but i already know he’s gonna remove a bunch of sins
this is a fact
Yep, Jeremy is more likely to remove sins for Disney, after all!
@@trinaq Pixar to be more precise
I haven't watched it either and I expected it to be 20 minutes of nothing.
He only removed 2
I personally thought this movie was amazing. It really gives you a sentimental vibe after your done watching.
Finally someone else agrees Joe should've gone to the great beyond. When I told my family that he should have stayed there, they said I was a psychopath for wanting him to die. Like no I don't specifically want him dead, but the sacrifice he made doesn't mean anything anymore.
But him going to the great beyond would've gone against the lesson. He learned that it's important to enjoy life as is, but there's no real use in learning that message if he doesn't get a chance to execute it. It was a choice between the sacrifice not meaning anything and the entire point of the movie not meaning anything.
His sacrifice still counts in terms of he was willing to make that choice. Plus without it, the message ends up a little dull in-universe. Two souls learn the value in how to actually "live" life but one of them's about to be a baby with no recollection and the other is going to get bugzapped.
That’s what I was expecting to happen. Apparently that was supposed to happen, but the writers felt it was too dark.
It also would have completed his 'Teacher' arc with choosing an eternity of mentoring as his calling over his more selfish dream he had been clinging to.
While I do agree he shouldn’t have been given a second chance, I don’t think Joe should have gone to the great beyond.
I think it would have been better if Joe became a mentor for the rest of eternity.
"He doesn't care about anyone but himself"
Dude, he just died and got resurrected INTO A CAT. He's allowed to care about that over teenage drama.
Lmao that's what I'm saying.
6:14
"Using preschool souls to game the system." is gonna be my senior quote.
I watched this movie with my whole family. The ages were ranging from my 6 year old cousin, to my 84 year old grandma. All of us enjoyed it. To me, that's the magic of Pixar
Watched it with several friends... All of us found it very bad. I really don't understand the hype around this movie. The music and the art were great, the story and the characters' development though... ? Big yikes.
@@Libellulaire It's subtle, magical and powerful. Maybe you were not ready for it. Someday...
I absolutely loved this movie. It explored the meaning of life in such a simple yet complicated way.
As a Virgo I can confirm I like to count for no reason. I've counted my blinking since starting this video
Yeah I count everything I can
vampire
As a Leo I want to die :)
Too bad astrology is complete nonsense made up by people out of their arses
@@Scre1mingcat Haha same, except I also don’t because it would be permanent and I’m noncommittal as f*ck
8:20 I get that this joke can be interpreted as Jeremy doesn’t care about history (or that a lot if people know very little about her ) but Mary Antoinette KICKED ASS AT DIPLOMACY And wasn’t actually as horrible as people make her out to be , she was A SCAPEGOAT A SCAPEGOAT I TELLS YA ... sorry got a bit carried away but you get my point
*Another sin*
From the location Terry was sitting while counting, he should’ve seen Joe fall into the Great Before. So why was he surprised when the count was off?
Maybe Terry was too busy counting everyone to notice that Joe fell or smth
9:09 this is the kid that was on crack. (the kid that got hit in the head with a basketball and went; YEAAA)
10:23 I've done that...2 hour drive to the festival, unpack the tent and yep, no poles...who tf doesnt put the poles back in the bag when theyre done?!
I mean....my high school played the Disney theme for one of our concerts
Let not jinx that Disney finds out
I love how cinema sins took an already existing joke destroying the Knicks and just used it as an opportunity to wreck them even further 😂
“That’s Karenist”
That implies Karens deserve rights when everyone knows Karens need less of those.
Karen’s are banned by my proposed constitution
Ikr lol
@Matt McCarthy Yes
en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Karen_conflict
I have a friend named Karen at my job. So that's Karen-ist
9:26
"I can't smell. I can't taste either"
When watching this film for the first time, how many people shouted CORONAVIRUS coz my family and I sure as hell did.
I did too lol
I love how better help chose to sponsor this channel. They were like, welp, people who love watching and finding mistakes in every little thing must be key demographic for our services. 😂
The abacus row that was entirely filled with beads and therefore couldn't be used for counting was eventually put in charge of using the other moveable rows of abacus beads whenever Terry took a filing cabinet break.
wot?
This movie was so simple to understand yet so confusing at the same time
Pixar everyone
You mean the worst film in history of Pixar
@@jamesthedachshund8741 dude this isn't cars 2
@@jamesthedachshund8741 You think it's the worst?
@@jamesthedachshund8741 nah I think this is the best ever
4:26 maybe when we die we do turn into moths and mosquitos and follow that “light”
1:13: Depends upon who shows up for class. In my 7th grade band, the instructor inherited all the people who came in from 6th grade. He stared out at the players and saw a sea of licorice to his left from the near-infinite number of clarinetists but only 3 sax players to his right. For this school system (Las Vegas in the 80s), 6th grade was when you got to take your very first elective and thus could take Band. But, it was geared mostly to teach you how to play an instrument, not to play in a band. Thus, if you wanted to learn to play the clarinet, you took Band in 3rd period because that was the clarinet section. If you wanted to learn to play the trumpet, that was another period. You never saw any of the other instruments until the Christmas concert and the year-end concert.
It was only in 7th grade (and a completely different school) that Band became a class of playing together as a group and thus it was only filled with those who decided to keep with it. That year, all the clarinetists from 6th grade took Band while hardly any of the saxophonists did.
So if this is a jazz band in elementary school, I'm not surprised to see a bunch of saxophonists. That's who showed up.
YOU DON’T KNOW!! is the best ongoing cinemasins line
Soul was one of the best Pixar movies, in my opinion.
Yeah, my experience with Better Help was getting ignored for 2 weeks by one person, and then being berated for not being able to fix myself without help up until that point. Yeah, super helpful.
Was not pewdiepie talk about this before that it was a scam? The people who works there are actually not licensed therapist
@@flowgelato9133 Possibly? The two that I had were proud to show off their licenses and which region they worked in, so I guess it could be followed up on to see if they're being honest.
@kerradeph this was posted years ago, I forgot how it goes (I know the beginnings look silly but bear with him) ruclips.net/video/8PLgOaVXmGU/видео.html I
basically what they wrote onthe user agreement is unreliable to show the legitimacy of mental health counsellors. Please check their website again and see if they still did this, if they do, turn off the website and dont support it
@@flowgelato9133 I think it might be able to be found without paying. I cancelled my subscription and got a refund because I didn't get any help from the month I paid for.
2:52 I love when a film can break Jeremy's cliches. This made me laugh.
7:49 I think that soul is gonna be a serial killer when they go to Earth lol
Btw, Marie Antoinette never actually said "let them eat cake". That came from a book.
I absolutely loved this movie! But honestly, I had really hoped that there would be an end credit scene where we got to see what happened to 22 after. Like maybe years later a child resembling 22 would be in Joe's class or something.
There's a theory that 22 becomes Riley from Inside Out.
7:55 The person you gave 20 sins is anise from amazing world of gumball
XD
I loved this movie, the music is just unreal.
Engine
Shame how he didnt remove a ton of sins for that. Because the movie is AMAZING. shame how it doesnt get enough love.
7:47 Long live vaporwave?
XDDDDDDDDDD I'M DYING OF LAUGHTER!
18:30 Thanks Cinemasins for adding a part in BTTF! Works perfectly well with Joe trying to fit in with the quartet
Them: Would it kill him to throw in some French Horns?!
Me, a French Horn player, an instrument consistently under-appreciated: (literally screams in delight)
French horn is my favourite brass instrument (to listen to! No way I could play it.). Actually, it's the only one I really like.
@@MaiAolei That’s because it’s the BEST one. 😂❤️❤️❤️❤️
I’m glad to hear that!! It’s my favorite too!!!
Soul is my favorite Pixar movie! I’ve been waiting for this video on it!
1:24 In my Music extra class there was this asian girl that alwaysforgot her piano (I mean keyboard) and we were in elementary and weren't allowed phones, and in a music classroom there isn't much you can have fun with, so she litterally took naps between chairs like that, so I think was the only person that laughed at that scene because I felt related.
Who else thinks that they should actually release Soul in theatres sometime, and give Onward another go since it barely made it to theatres before the world fell apart.
Yesh I agree I was excited for onward and then COVID said Hii.
Onward is pretty meh, soul on the other hands requires a theatrical run
All jokes aside (or sins haha), this movie was gooood. Really shows us all the beauty we are missing while searching for something “big” that will make us happy.
I’ll never forgive that you didn’t remove a sin for the epiphany scene
Okay what the hell I was just thinking “I wonder when their gonna do soul.”
4:03 was perhaps one of CinemaSins best jokes.
13:29 they didn’t know Joe was the mentor, they simply recognized him from the photo and realized it’s the NOT Bjorn Börgensson
All this “time” stuff is making me think one thing:
*Time is a tool you can put on the wall or wear it on your wrist. The past is far behind us, the future doesn’t exist!*
What's the time? It's quarter to 9! Time to have a bath.
What do you mean? We're already clean!
scrub scrub scrub 'til the water's brown
Past doesn’t exist either ...
@Ｓｔｕｐｉｄ░Ｂｉｔｃｈ (代因ソ) **epic space chords**
*_LET’S GO ON A JOURNEY_*
*_A JOURNEY THROUGH TIME!_*
11:43 The cat riding the heaven conveyor belt gets me every time! 😭
All cats go to heaven 🤣