How the School-to-Prison Pipeline Functions
HTML-код
- Опубликовано: 6 сен 2017
- Suspensions, expulsions, and in-school policing are harming black students by taking them out of school and funneling them into prisons.
Subscribe to The Root: goo.gl/QMOjBE
Visit us at: www.theroot.com/
Like us at: / theroot
Follow us at: / theroot
View us: / the.root
Watch more from Fusion friends:
Fusion: fus.in/subscribe
F-Comedy: goo.gl/Q27Mf7
Fusion TV: goo.gl/1IbZ1B
Gizmodo: goo.gl/YTRLAE
Kotaku: goo.gl/OcnXv7
Deadspin: goo.gl/An7N8g
Jezebel: goo.gl/XNsnCJ
Lifehacker: goo.gl/3rNmzw
Io9: goo.gl/ismnzP
Jalopnik: goo.gl/u7sDEk
Sploid: goo.gl/4yq2UY
Terrible misrepresentation of the facts.
Can anyone else smell the bullshit
It's actually a ...home to prison pipeline!
" sorry Timmy school dress code says no black skin on a Tuesday."
Lol
The criminal justice system is not the answer to misbehavior at school. Kids shouldn’t have to live in unnecessary fear.
Is a kid pulling a knife on another kid to steal his shoes considered "misbehavior"?
You don't know what your talking about. I was one of these troubled kids I know if my father would have been there I wouldn't have done the shit I did. I also grew up with poor white kids as well as poor black kids in my neighborhood. Poor is poor no fucks given. It wasn't the government coming down on me it was awful democratic decisions keeping us down. Telling my mom she just fine making it on her own by handing out welfare instead of jobs. But we rose above that hell hole and I changed my ways. Now I got a good job and my own family race didn't keep me down
A good family foundation is the deeper issue. Without a string family foundation the kids now have more freedom and the parents have no control on their kids. This school to prison pipeline is a huge issue and all the information is surface level, there needs to be change to our system. Kids need to feel comfort and support from their peers and adults around them and a lot of that lacks in this new generation. so sad what our world is becoming for our little ones
“Black kids have absent fathers” that’s what you wanna say
The root of the problem is wrongfully incriminating young teens at an early age and leading/setting them up for failure in the future. Since being “bad” is so normal to them it will not phase them in the long run.
They can follow rules same as every other person if they fuck up it's on them. It happened to me but I changed my ways. They don't need to be coddled they need structure
A violent or disruptive child should be removed from a classroom.
Anyone know who the narrator of this piece is?
Would they want it on their resume?
Just sounds very familiar. I'm wondering if it's not the same person I heard in a TedX talk a while back: 'My Experiences with Restorative Justice | Audrey Byrne'
very intresting they have similar but different versions of this pipline all other the world. crazy how people want someone just slightly diffrent to suffer
Ignorant comment
This is something far fetched yet there is some things that are true in this video. The root cause of some of these school to prison pipeline cases is the family foundation, there needs to be a deeper dive to the root cause not just a surface view of what is happening.
As a teen i acted up not because i was mad but idk as a kid you dont know. Instead of counseling and offering resources my high school expelled me and made me go to a charter school 2 cities over! If you arevin public school and have a learning disability YOU ARE DOOMED! i have a really hard time with math but instead of help you get detention and suspensions.. I now see it for what it is. Public school just dumbs you down so you conform and never complain. Half my class works at Amazon and they look MISERABLE! Meanwhile the rich kids that could afford an education own all these businesses and dispensaries while still even IN college!
would you mind telling me what you were suspended for? what do you mean by “instead of help you get detention and suspensions”
@@Jessica-eo5hg I can answer the second question. So a lot of ppl with hearing disabilities, well, have a hard time listening. Most teaching styles revolve around listening to the teacher, so if you can't pay attention or listen properly bc of your disability, some schools, instead of offering you help and ways that might help you listen better, most students end up getting punished instead. Schools usually just don't care if you have a disability or not, if you can't listen, then to them you're a bad student
I have a learning disability and was given medication and got into trouble too. On top of that I'm LATINO (not this bull shit "latinx")
I ended up graduating college. I wasn't "DOOMED" stop telling kids they can't! That's evil. You are bad and are part of the problem with kids. Get a good work ethic and work harder than the other kids. Bottom line!
Blame your parents, not the school system.
@@missioncontrol4662 it is tough for people with disabilities. Parents do have to give extra care themselves, it's not all schools responsibility. Additional tutoring is needed for most kids especially if they have a learning disability
If they brought back the strap the school to prison pipeline would go away.
Not punishing students is more harmful to those not breaking the rules. Simple solution here. Stop breaking the damn rules!!!
💯
This video is a disgusting representation of truth. I've first hand upbringing in the same system. Most of the kids that had "basement" classes were habitual offenders and could get out of the classes of they acted proper and studied. We were on academic probation and the classes were screwball teachers with screwier juvenile delinquents. I don't know how to solve the issue but, putting animals with other animals isn't the answer.
only way to solve is having good homes for these kids. loving parents that teaches value of education and respecting elders/teachers. Parents Sending kids to school to actually learn and achieve in life instead of replacement to daycare and school lunch. This starts at home not at school.
@@WaveRider1989 solving poverty, and not sending students to the police unless it was a violent crime works.
Animals? Good Lord.
@Nate yes that's what people are, and that's is how they act.
@@ryanreynolds2169 so, are you saying the solution isn't putting people with other people? That seems... weird.
Brown vs. Board of education has "questionable" historical benefit for black students.
This is all horseshit. Lowering the bar doesn't help anything either. Parents need to step up and stop looking to the school system to raise their kids.
Yeah I’ve worked with black kids in the inner city. This isn’t honest.
So have I. Pretty honest
@Who Knows . no
@@cjzanders5430
Yeah
Nobody wants to hear the actual truth…..I grew up in the inner city
@Ol Ball Coach - kool. So what do you think?
Sacramento police had children the put in public to do this systematically attack .
Just watched this in my Sociology class. Had to see how bad the ratio was and read the comments.
What’s your take?
People actually believe this garbage? Where's the justice? Kids do bad things, let's not punish them and just let them get away with it, then when they're older they won't be criminals because we all know kids turn into criminals when you correct bad behavior with consequences. This is just a school version of defund the police.
Kwel
FIRE 46
This is a very irresponsible and misleading video. There’s a bigger problem that this video clearly omits.
Parents need to be reminded how to parent. It’s not the schools job and when it becomes the laws job, failure is in effect.
Exactly. Parental failure and the failure of the INDIVIDUAL... its called accountability.
Exactly
Schools should based the punishment on the crime not the kids ethnicity Maybe too little but schools based punishment on the crime rather than the kids ethnicity things will get better
They do. The race-grifters here just want you to believe that it's all because of racism.
I'll have to admit this video's sources are a marvel of cherry picking.
It's worse than that. A couple are completely made up.
YES. EXACTLY.
I love how all of yall have no idea what you're talking about.
Chances are if you get into fights, steal candy from your teacher and screw around enough to get expelled you weren't going to "excel" anyway. I think y'all are putting the cart in front of the horse here.
I know a racist when i see one .
What if the cause of that was deeper than u explained it?
right because white children don't do the exact same things
@@donrodeo8344 cause is issues at home. these kids dont have loving families unfortunately.
@@angelsunshinegirl00 this is in no way a racist argument.
This video is such BS 😂😂😂 as a black kid who grew up in the inner city it’s usually the behaviors that lead to the disproportionate levels of blacks in prison nothing else 🤷🏿♂️🤷🏿♂️🤷🏿♂️
We have this in Scotland but we are all white I’m confused
Ok ?
Probably "travelers"
If a kid steals anything from a teacher's desk they absolutely need to be taught through consequences, it's so powerful to teach kids lessons, if we allow them to just run the show because we fear that this narrative will make us look a certain way and put them in "danger" then we fail students in their character journey and building a moral conscious. This is politically based, not a substantial compelling argument.
You've clearly did NOT pay attention to the video and it shows.
As a teacher, I'm completely capable of providing logical consequences to my student for taking candy without permission. Usually, it would be helping me with a task in the classroom. Something that teaches a lesson, rather than being strictly punitive. Arresting students, or removing them from school for minor infractions, hurt the whole child in their identity, development, and attitude towards education. There is an opportunity for teaching accountability & responsibility, or massive over punishments.
did you actually watch the video with and critical thinking skills at all. what.
are you okay carissa? what is wrong with you. you want to throw kids into suspension/expulsion or even prison for stealing something from a desk. you need to expose yourself to the real world and understand why you are so wrong.
Maybe if those kids had fathers or real discipline in their lives they wouldn't up like this.
Thank you Root. MY SON Jojo is dealing with some things. Hopefully it gets worked out ASAP.
THANKS AGAIN, I MAY NEED THIS
"Sometimes kids are kicked out of school for basically, just being black." This is exactly the kind of ridiculous statment that makes people not take this issue seriously.
Right it’s so outlandish! WHICH IS WHY ITS SO FUCKED UP WHEN IT HAPPENS
black characteristic, values and beliefs, not just the color. Schools demand students to cutt off dreads.
At first I tilted my head like “huh” when the narrator said that. But then their are multiple cases of black children( not only in the US) having to go home because of cultural hairstyles such as (box braids, locs, natural afros, etc) I just wish they talked about that a little more and expanded on events that have happened to give more clarity and knowledge to people who don’t understand. But it’s whatever😭
But it’s true, I swear a lot white people ALWAYS look at stuff from face value instead of using critical thinking lol
Just say Latin! We dont need the X
@MARC GARCÍA BONET it's also an ethnicity. Uhm you know spread throughout three continents.
I'm fine with using Latinx
@@marioguerra7129 its a disgrace to the Latin culture.
@@Mar-ki3tf as a Latinx person I disagree and think you're being a snowflake lol
@@marioguerra7129 Well as Latin person I disagree with you Mr X lol. Youre using an ad homimen because you have no solid argument. In our culture language is made up of genders, masculine, feminine and neuter.
I do think the school-to-prison pipeline can be a little harsh. I believe there should be some in-between treatment and/or punishment options for students that are misbehaving in school. The school-to-prison pipeline can discourage delinquents from wanting to make the right choices if they are already being removed from school at such a young age.
Disliked because of pro anottion ad. Then the article is more baloney.
Why must you so blatantly lie?
There are some embellishments and generalizations in this video, but in my research for a book that talks about prison reform for two chapters, I learned that a lot of these claims are not so farfetched. I was shocked at how often teachers called police on kids under 10. Why do you need police officers for a kid under 10?
Try using more facts than anecdotes.
Thank you, The Root... For bringing this issue to the forefront!
MrAveryBrown But they lied
Hey, follow the fucking rules. 99% of kids do it....
See I can make up stats too.
@@Thexdmattx lol what
Yea they are arrested and suspended more because-- they are criminal. Thakns for proving our point
If you don’t have an authority figure in the home, you’re not going to respect authority in public. Fix that first.
Or you know, don’t arrest kids for crying?
So just let anarchy rule then huh? Makes sense.
@Samara Summers I totally agree. Their are plenty of ways to teach and discipline children. Also if a child especially a black child grows up seeing authority as a threat that factors in to their adult life which would make them prone to lash out or be more afraid. On top of all the layers of racism and discrimination . It’s a bad mix tbh.
Imagine being suspended for having hair.
Yep school to prison pipeline is a total mess not to mention how much prejudice and discrimination can cause a problem on black, hispanic, Asian, native, lgbtq and people with disabilities are being treated more harshly than others who are white and non disabled even if they couldn't been avoided.
Nope, stop being so racist
Caucasian the common denominator
Not really
👏don't👏commit👏crimes👏
Dude not wearing correct dress code isn’t a crime .
Don't criminalize normal childhood behaviors and then selectively punish "offenders."
I was unaware crying is a crime