Sad Guru, laughs and thinks he is right. He is totally wrong as he gives lame example of bike to back up his lies in Book. most people that drink COKE and have faith in brand called COKE will not listen to a writers like the one questioning SAD_GURU. BRAND vs. NO - BRAND. People have been following BRAND sad-guru for a while so they will naturally not trust writer logic even if the logic is 100% true.
@@singhajinder501 He is just one of countless people through the ages who are speaking the same truths. Everything he speaks about is written in ancient texts.
@@kieranwhittemore1010 Well whats written in Ancient text is GOD is with in you and do not need to follow these ( or any ) people and waste time and energy. Rather use that Energy to be direct with your creator. There is living GOD in you and seek it and know all. You do not have to leave or listen to his made up stories that just shows weekness of once's mind not to make your inner GOD more prevelant in your own life. KINGDOM of heaven is with in you and you are whole and complete.
They do create contradiction through ridiculous, man-made rituals which have the purpose of taking the worshippers money or goods and replacing them with false belief.
@@tripmcfly10What's the point of enlightenment, if you can't use the knowledge to make human conscious! You should come out of your cave! By the way, what does a guru do!!!??? Live in a mountain in solidarity!? Do you even know what sadh means?? Ignorant is bliss! 🙏@
You misunderstand, first you must make a distinction between being and becoming. Humans have different ways to express their emotions, you can not lump them all together you see. That's how he appears when he's furious 😂
@@saumyaverma5188 You have realised your true self? You have acheived self- realisation?? :) Child. You dont even know what you are saying. My problem is with ignorance and believing in fairy-tales. And it is rife with this so called guru.
I think one of the reasons for this missunderstanding of the Man towards sadhguru, is that he thinks of him as a religious leader, which he is clearly not. He is not in the business of telling people what to do - that would be religious - but telling people, where to look, to see for themselves, so that would be a spiritual journey individual to each and every person listening to him. Also calling Sadhguru angry is a great missinterpretation of what is happening here, as Sadhguru only insists, when clearing up the axioms, under which both discuss, so they could come to a common understanding.
Exactly! I remember him interrupting himself once and saying "Please do not believe the nonsense I am saying, but go and see for yourself." These are the words of a man worth listening to.
Today, people like Sadhguru needed in all walks of life. What we have done with this planet, the earth... We means... Politicians, Scientists, Sociologists, Anthropologists, Doctos, Engineers, Professors, Teachers.. etc btc vtc We have ruined our country, people and fabrics of our culture.... And we have not replaced it with another good or better systemm Its a hard and long debate... I respect everyones point of view and salute to Sadhguru...😊
So true humans destroyed this earth he is trying to take us to Raam and Krishna's time which seams impossible ,but is possible cause we are admiring what impossible thing they have done
I don't think he practised what he preached. That little part about ‘respecting each other’s opinion/beliefs.’ He labelled the opposing guy’s opinion as ‘ignorant.’ That alone indicates that he believes he is entirely right and that the man’s questioning is minuscule.
@@kizito8888 If he cant take understanding what Sathguru is saying he is ignorant cause what they did Five thousand or more years ago still mesmerising the world
With due respect to Sadhguru I must say he is a escapist. Knowing his weaknesses, he afraid that he will be exposed in public. So he naver like to face any international Islamic debaters like Zakir Naik, Dr. Sabil Ahmed or others who never hesitate to dialogue or debate with any type of man/woman including atheists. Because they are confident, Sadhguru isn't
An enlightened man is bound to nothing. Your pov of an enlightened man is very limited and constipated. How would u know what an enlightened person would act like? Are you enlightened?
It's one thing to question a teacher. It's another to act like the teacher is a fool and instead try to teach him what you believe. This was the latter.
Wow! Sadhguru said" the last part of the book which is bothering you is to take you to the next place". I learned from this that, what bothers us should not be our limit but rather our starting point. Sadhguru continue in this wisdom.
@@GhanashyamSharmaSBU It's crazy. Sadhguru is very rude and disrespectful. Many times in other Q&A sessions, he will make fun of the person asking a question he does not like. And he always seems to struggle with directly answering questions he does not like.
With due respect to Sadhguru I must say he is a escapist. Knowing his weaknesses, he afraid that he will be exposed in public. So he naver like to face any international Islamic debaters like Zakir Naik, Dr. Sabil Ahmed or others who never hesitate to dialogue or debate with any type of man/woman including atheists. Because they are confident, Sadhguru isn't
The fact that critics always come from a place of anger towards their "opponent" and that anger only exists as an imbalance in their own mind and body, is a lesson which cannot be overlooked
Religion did not invent the atom bomb . Scientist are as narrowminded and ambitious and egocentric als religieus persons . It’s never their personal respondabilty. “the I have good intentions .. “ it’s easy to blame another . Seldom people look inside themselves and learn from it .
@@A-X-25 wow, did u just reveal the secret of making easy 25mil!! How come you are already not on yr way to make yr own 25million when u know how it's made..do u see the logic- ur angry, frustrated, negative, jealous cos you find yrself inadequate and inferior when confronting someone way above yr intellect/spiritual/logical/financial means...I am sure you hate Modiji too cos he is hugely popular and ur not..ru seeing a trend and an issue in yr own personality..look within, not outside- that's how u find the issue and start working on it...Jai Hind
@@A-X-25 wrong..if ur worried ABT feeding yr family, yr focus will be on finding ways to earn that good..no hard working person has the time, energy or focus to waste on seeing what others r doing n feel good/bad ABT it...
We all fell here from Heaven because we sinned and our one and only aim should be trying to return home, which is Heaven. That was Christ's message. We all have chosen to play in the mud instead of seeking the Divine....................falun dafa
Especially when millions are blindly following some self proclaimed babas and swamis and gurus. We need someone who’s not going to just take it without questioning it.
The problem with humans, especially those who take pride in their intellect, is they are always in a mode of defending their own conviction, but by doing that, they build a wall around themselves which prevents them from perceiving anything beyond. I actually was the same way, until I discovered Eckhart Tolle, then other spiritual teachers like him.
I heard the name Eckhart Tolle (power of now) ages ago. I am not into spirituality so did not read the book even though I bought it thinking I will read some day. Do you know if Mr. Tolle believes in supernatural and after life? I am 99% sure he does. I don't care what any single person's conviction is but if you take science as an entity - do you think science also has a conviction and have a wall around it - so it cannot see anything beyond? I don't follow Eckhart Tolle but clearly Sadhguru uses hyperbole and obscurantism. His personal wall perhaps is much thinner than the ones he preaches to - he deliberately wants others wall to grow thicker and thicker. Thanks.
@@jeetray11 You should read his book to find out. He doesn't refer to God as the God of the Bible, but he did not deny the existence of God. His teaching is more in the realm of spirituality. However, it also depends on the listener. If the listener is not ready to absorb what he says, then it won't work.
@@kathleenlauren Well that's certainly interesting. Maybe it's better just to hear him on RUclips. However, how we perceive things or others is also filtered through our own mind, so you might have some unpleasant experience with him. Can you give more details what led you to think of him that way ?
In life there is no wrong or right.. sadhguru has his thoughts and the guest has his.. And that’s wonderful.. A peaceful conversation is highly welcomed .. and healthy.
None Zero. Right & Wrong doesn't exist, if it existed, by now, people would have done only right, not wrong They contradict everything that's right. anyway.
Anger does us more harm than the things about which we're angry. We eat our own hearts when we give in to anger, as philosophers used to say. It's self-destructive. The consequences of our anger might harm others but we also harm
You are right but what to do if someone constantly criticising you wrongly, abusing you for his stupidity and asking you to give validation, i perhaps not angry with him ignoring him cause he is a person like that but what other people who are surrounding you will think about you in case you are getting abused .
Sadhguru many times teaches people "next time you're angry, then you are stupid". Looks like Sadhguru is stupid too.😂😜😂😂😂 He also tries to teach people that is not good to procreate because we are too many, but he was not able to adopt a child and he procreate. He teaches others not to buy so many shoes: "what are you going to to with those things?" "you buy shoes for 10 lifetimes", but he has most of the time a different outfit in his videos. He tells us that "if you think what you are doing is important, then you need a holyday" and I would say the same thing to him, because the way his volunteers and teachers treated me was definitely not like what he promotes. He is another stupid hypocrite like many others(me included, at least I admit this). The truth is there is no solution for humans. We have to accept that we are not perfect and we should live with good, bad whatever we are capable. If we are the creation of creator, then creator makes us like this: evil, good, compassionate, indifferent, sad, joyful, peaceful, revengeful, etc.. I bet his shit doesn't smell like flowers!😂😂😂
@@greenbud1695 you can not control getting angry at someone for their actions.. it is reacting angry and with that anger insult others with the goal to hurt them . That is not wise or good for our selfs or health.. it is ok to show people you are angry.we are human.. just don't respond back with ignorance and lose your position you have earned with wise decisions.. ignore the people who think you are weak because their ignorance can not see you are the stronger person...
The title of this video is misleading, there was no anger just a debate. Sadhguru is educated and wise but the man’s discourse is interesting and makes for a good clarification regarding religion Nd spirituamity
The man is Shashikumar, senior journalist and runs Asian College of Journalism. Unfortunately people nowadays don't know real people of any worth and instead run after saints and yogis whose past would reveal their true credentials.
Well said Sadguru, these people are full of themselves, can’t reach up to the level of Sadguru yet wants the love which Sadguru has earned from this world.
Sadhguru is a great orator! Very few times i have had disagreement with his views, but mostly i can relate to what he speaks. But most of what I like is he has dignified mannerism.
No he is not. For children perhaps. I see this sad guru as a great masturbator and a weak bullshiter. I can not fathom how so many people dont see through his scam.
With due respect to Sadhguru I must say he is a escapist. Knowing his weaknesses, he afraid that he will be exposed in public. So he naver like to face any international Islamic debaters like Zakir Naik, Dr. Sabil Ahmed or others who never hesitate to dialogue or debate with any type of man/woman including atheists. Because they are confident, Sadhguru isn't
@@arefinhoosain654 You are right. At least we know where we stand with Naik's Islam. It hates everybody that disagrees with it. I have no idea what Sadhguru is talking about, but at least I do know he doesn't hate me because of that.
1)As per instruction of the Holly Quaran ".....let us come to an agreement on that which is common between us,........." (Al-'Imran -Sura: 3 Verse: 63 ) Dr. Zakir Naik several times invited all, to talk /discussion/dialogue/debate face to face repeatedly as per democratic norms to find out the commonalities, & make the bridge on the gaps So that living together peacefully by accepting the differences. Which is a process & integral/ important part of modern DEMOCRACY 2) But some political & religious leaders (of both Hindu & Muslim community ) distorts this fair attempt due to their personal interest. geving religious colors & accusing him on terrorists connection
Good perspectives and debate .. An enlightened soul can never be made angry or disturbed but always convincing with the truth ! Never the less God and Faith is true and it is an individual realization and experience which cannot be depicted or substantiated 🙏
I have been involved with many beliefs and I have yet to understand hindus and this Guru understands so much and I had to subscribe. Im so glad i found him on my quest for understanding.♥️😊
Jesus is the Answer Open the bible and understand his teachings better. Dont run behind FAKE GURUS or posing as know it all, You have the answer for your problems in the BIBLE OPen today and read
@@JenniferMascarenhasDubai Jesus told many that the way is thru knowledge and he would have told you this. The way the truth and the light is thru knowledge and peace of mind. I have read the bible and there is beauty but there is slavery and hatred of those who do not fit in due to having both sexes. Do you know that 1 out of 2000 ppl have both sexes? Well in the united states thats the truth. Gnosticism and the Essene spoke about this. You must be aware that is the way of Joshua not judgement.
@@JenniferMascarenhasDubaidid you miss the part of the the Bible that teaches thou shalt not judge others especially before understanding where they're coming from? 😊
This man is so prejudiced that it's almost too much distasteful to hear his vested outbursts. Absolutely pathetic, I am so anguished that why Sadguru ji should even meet or debate such reckless and cheap people carrying such hateful mindset ? He should not waste his energy instead keep talking to people who wants to seek something. Sadguruji you're always soothing and inspiring to watch. Please keep it up. हरी ॐ
Yes why sadguru continues to battle with apparently less wise crowd. Is it to establish his supremacy creating fan base in social media..... I don't understand
We all fell here from Heaven because we sinned and our one and only aim should be trying to return home, which is Heaven. That was Christ's message. We all have chosen to play in the mud instead of seeking the Divine....................falun dafa
Part of our reality is accepting that some people don’t have the intention to raise their consciousness or simply cannot. Everyone is on their own journey in this life. It’s valid to question these things as they are impossible to comprehend without directly experiencing them for yourself. Often times words get lost in translation; however, these debates are necessary.
I'm three minutes in and the man still hasn't asked a question, so he did not come to learn and deepen his understanding, he came to preach and have his BELIEFS reinforced.
the title of the video is misleading really. this is a good discussion. when two people with very different worldviews talk there is a always an underlying tension, but the point is to proceed with and despite that...
Agree such discussions is the need of the hour to present it b4 the new generations for igniting the curiosity amongst the youth. Provided the youth allow themselves a chance to be amongst thinkers and intellectual who are spiritually awakened. The spiritually awakened are those who have risen above material acquisition and gain. They are those who have reached the peak of materialism BUT hv decisively chosen to tk the path of self realisation. Their company will enable the Youth to understand the transmission from material success to spiritual success hopefully faster than their Peer group guiding them. AUM SRI SAI RAM ♥ Aum Sri Sai Ram.
Sadhguru many times teaches people "next time you're angry, then you are stupid". Looks like Sadhguru is stupid too.😂😜😂😂😂 He also tries to teach people that is not good to procreate because we are too many, but he was not able to adopt a child and he procreate. He teaches others not to buy so many shoes: "what are you going to to with those things?" "you buy shoes for 10 lifetimes", but he has most of the time a different outfit in his videos. He tells us that "if you think what you are doing is important, then you need a holyday" and I would say the same thing to him, because the way his volunteers and teachers treated me was definitely not like what he promotes. He is another stupid hypocrite like many others(me included, at least I admit this). The truth is there is no solution for humans. We have to accept that we are not perfect and we should live with good, bad whatever we are capable. If we are the creation of creator, then creator makes us like this: evil, good, compassionate, indifferent, sad, joyful, peaceful, revengeful, etc.. I bet his shit doesn't smell like flowers!😂😂😂😂
I love listening to Sashguru and I don't care if he says he created this or that, because what he does create or help create in me is Peace of Mind and if you feel better after listening to someone than you did before you listened to them, just let it be good. Others trying to tear apart another's greatness is absurd. Keep being awesome Sadhguru! Simple, keep doing what you're doing please! There are many that you are helping have peace of mind and that is everything ✨
You feel better not by listening to someone talk but by making the change in yourself. It's like all these motivational videos... The trap is that people listen to these to "feel" really motivated for something they want to do but in the end they procrastinate. Same applies here
It’s only Sadhguru who can respond calm and composed to all questions, however uncomfortable they are. Surprising we don’t have such knowledge gurus from other religions to sit and debate, with intellectuals or students alike.
And only he can have that much patience, i start fighting if someone go beyond my patience limit or questions my beliefs who the fuck these people are to question our beliefs
The very first argument he put forward was absolutely true. A very valid statement. People just close their eyes the moment their religion or belief is questioned. But everything else sounds incorrect and false to them
Sadhguru many times teaches people "next time you're angry, then you are stupid". Looks like Sadhguru is stupid too.😂😜😂😂😂 He also tries to teach people that is not good to procreate because we are too many, but he was not able to adopt a child and he procreate. He teaches others not to buy so many shoes: "what are you going to to with those things?" "you buy shoes for 10 lifetimes", but he has most of the time a different outfit in his videos. He tells us that "if you think what you are doing is important, then you need a holyday" and I would say the same thing to him, because the way his volunteers and teachers treated me was definitely not like what he promotes. He is another stupid hypocrite like many others(me included, at least I admit this). The truth is there is no solution for humans. We have to accept that we are not perfect and we should live with good, bad whatever we are capable. If we are the creation of creator, then creator makes us like this: evil, good, compassionate, indifferent, sad, joyful, peaceful, revengeful, etc.. I bet his shit doesn't smell like flowers!😂😂
The problematic thing about gurus and famous people in debates in general, is that they tend to becoming famous and having followers backing them up. just see that video to understand this: guru says something sassy - the auditory applauds. the interviewer says something witty - akward silence. its not because who is ight and who is wrond, is because personal preferences, people that follow him want him to be right. It is hewarding positive afirmation for the guru no matter what, it has a psychologic effect over whoever watches it. in the end of the day these debates should only happen indoors, uncut, with a camera.
its amazing how the mind works ... the guy really understood the bicycle analogy at 5:44 "any human being who thinks what I do not know cannot exist is wearing the crown of ignorance" well said. The highest knowledge is to recognize "I do not know" so you are open to knowledge. Love from ethiopia For my Indian brothers and sisters...
Sadhguru is speaking from the realms of direct experience and the other guy is speaking from a limited perception of logic. Both are right except the one with direct experience has more profound experience than the one with logical experience. It's like riding on an actual horse versus listening to someone's analysis on how it feels to ride on a horse. The other guy is playing academic hardball. He's trying hard to stand out and outsmart sadhguru with his semantics and word games.
@@heyitsalanhere Will you pay attn and read the first 4 lines of SM's comments. Is it so difficult to identify who is being pointed out as having direct experience? Why do I feel that you r trying to undermine/challenge the perceptive ability of SM ? Let him be. As the name suggests he is a product of the so called "Peaceful Ones" whose agenda is also made obvious by them. Coming back to you it appears you are shy of exposing your identity for whatever reason. You can't say the same for SM, can you ?
@@gnair8307 Not shy at all mate. I have asked a simple question to SM. As yet, no reply here ?! I am curious as to what experiences he is talking about which a fellow man has had and what has impressed him about those experiences.
this is late great John Lennon's amazing song, " IMAGINE NO RELIGION" - Nothing to kill or die for !!! not only great music but amazing lyrics that still apply today This would have to be the greatest song of all time !!!!
Sadhguru deserves all the credit for the fact that the things that spiritual beings can perceive or deal with are not available to many beings until they seek them out with dedication and persistence. Simply stating that spirituality is not true will prevent you from coming into contact with the third dimension.
@@TIME4TRAINING fake, pretentious, cultist, fraudster, scammer, conartist, word juggler, theist, spiritualist, schizophrenic, psychotic, delusional, unscientific, irrational, mortal, imperfect, ignorant, degenerating old man with nothing to offer, just sweet sugar words of wisdom that doesn't have any practical purpose. Making Money From Free Gyan.
Sadguru’s wisdom is incredible and he is such a grinder of people’s foolish propositions, misinterpretations of religion or blaming spirituality based on present scientific advances and Sadguru also crushes people with strong egos. Someone with wisdom would approach a being like Sadguru with lots of respect and of course relish his beautiful humour which is simply divine. This humour is actual wisdom and also the state of fearlessness (Love). 🥀🌷🙏
With due respect to Sadhguru I must say he is a escapist. Knowing his weaknesses, he afraid that he will be exposed in public. So he naver like to face any international Islamic debaters like Zakir Naik, Dr. Sabil Ahmed or others who never hesitate to dialogue or debate with any type of man/woman including atheists. Because they are confident, Sadhguru isn't
With due respect to Sadhguru I must say he is a escapist. Knowing his weaknesses, he afraid that he will be exposed in public. So he naver like to face any international Islamic debaters like Zakir Naik, Dr. Sabil Ahmed or others who never hesitate to dialogue or debate with any type of man/woman including atheists. Because they are confident, Sadhguru isn't
Superb Sadhguru. We needed somebody like him to take on these holier-than-thou Macauley putras. British education has really created an intergenerational reality of limited and prejudiced minds. All the traditional elite think like this man. Having benefitted from collaboration with the British over generations, they lead comfortable lives, insulated from the complexity on the ground and parrot the same westocentric narrative, hoping the stagnation means their importance will never be undermined by the kind of revolution which the deepening perceptions which the revival of indigenous learning can bring to the country and the world.
We all fell here from Heaven because we sinned and our one and only aim should be trying to return home, which is Heaven. That was Christ's message. We all have chosen to play in the mud instead of seeking the Divine....................falun dafa
@@jeffforsythe9514 True. I listen often to Shunyamurti, (Sat Yoga), he says the same and urges us not to waver.. It is time to be in the Divine, that we all are.
I am against the opposite person as sadhguru never told that he is God, he had studied the world in his own view and wether to accept his thought is each and every individual own wish.
It's a good discussion except for the prejudice of Shasi Kumar ( I remember he used to be a doordarshan news reader). It's a discussion between half truths and the ultimate truth. Shashi Kumar point of view is correct w.r.t religion and it's vicious ways. But he fails to understand that all religions are not based on conquest and conversion . Sadhguru clearly explains the difference between faith and spirituality. The urge for seeking and humility are the pillars of religion that Sadhguru profess. He just reminds you that what we know is a bit don't get yourself confined to that.
First Hindu people need to understand who they are, what Vedas, Ramayana, Geeta saying that. Only Hinduism is connected with science. Specially our vedas told us a lot of things.
@@patel_saheb23 To the extent I understood, no religion has got anything to do with science. Both are totally different paths. Many assume certain abstracts in Hinduism may relate to science but nothing is so convincing atleast yet. However, Geetha has human psychology, it equips an inquisitive mind with all the answers for miseries of life. It enables humans to transform into a better human and thus make the world a better place to live.
Indu kumar itne umar k baad aise savaal koi gadha hi puch sakta he jis insan ko sanatan or buddh dharmo k bare me gyan he vo kabhi aise savaal nahi karte ye ek badi vidambna he ki dunia me jyadar nastik insan apne aap ko intellectual samajne lagta he
We all fell here from Heaven because we sinned and our one and only aim should be trying to return home, which is Heaven. That was Christ's message. We all have chosen to play in the mud instead of seeking the Divine....................falun dafa
That is this Sadguru's pet peeve - always offering sarcastic responses.. ridiculing subtly, belittling those that debate with him... and then laughs ha ha ha! Is that the trait of one that is a 'seeker?'
@@rameshgopinath7054 100% with you on that. Sadguru is quite adept at rambling on and on acting all cool. However, only the smart, logical folks can see through his empty talks. He’s obviously offended about the smart critique but cannot respond logically with clear, concise answers to the right questions posed. Very disappointing.
I didn't see no one question other guy why he is so worried,. Is that book or something else. Selectiveness at peaks. We need more people like Sadhguru 😂
@@ddonlee Not exactly, it is a religion that is banned only in Communist countries that teach atheism. Did someone from Falun Gong hurt you some how and that is why you treat the wonderful practice with such contempt?
Religion requires belief. Spirituality requires feeling. Reality requires experience. This all falls under a concept that we can call 'Science of the Self'.
We all fell here from Heaven because we sinned and our one and only aim should be trying to return home, which is Heaven. That was Christ's message. We all have chosen to play in the mud instead of seeking the Divine....................falun dafa
@@bigbunsclassic Buddhists believe that your soul has black karma that can be removed through suffering, the less karma you have, the more divine you become until you reach spiritual enlightenment...............falun dafa
Actually, he is kind of an idealist : "science is about questioning our certitudes" (or something like that). Most people today practice science like a religion (I do not mean spirituality) : they preach it everywhere though they have never seen nor experienced it ; they trust people that might be wrong (and regularly prove them wrong between themselves) ; they limit other people's experience with beliefs that they consider truth, though science is supposed to be constantly questioning, because they want to be right and cannot tolerate to be contradicted. Funny thing, many Richis from the past discovered many things thousands years ago before the west put the finger on it (see Vaisesika), because, I agree there are a lot of conman out there, in science and religion, but a true spiritual man is a philosopher, a scientist and seek the universal truth from his own experience. Science is also about language and code ; vedas has its system of coding and representation because it was the best way to transfer and understand the knowledge at the time, with a competent master ; but let's not forget that when Newton was technically limited by the scientific language of his time, he just "created" his own system, that we understand because it has been explained to us.
"na tasya pratima asti "There is no image of Him." "Andhatama pravishanti ye asambhuti mupaste" "They enter darkness, those who worship the natural elements" (Air, Water, Fire, etc.). "They sink deeper in darkness, those who worship sambhuti." [Yajurveda 40:9]7 Sambhuti means created things, for example table, chair, idol, Krishna,Ram etc.
@@armaan5977 Congratz you got atleast one shloka to prove something. FYI Hinduism not a simple book of rules for simple minded savages who need to be regularly punished for flouting some rules. Hinduism has 6 darshans or philosophies, Samkhya (that doesn't even believe in existence of God), Vedanta, Mimamsa (logic), Yoga, Nyaya, Vaisheshkha. One needs a general above average IQ to even go through Hindu texts, let alone translate them. And for you if GOD exists and GOD doesn't have a shape that doesn't imply GOD can't take any shape. If GOD can't take any shape then GOD is not GOD since he/she herself/himself suffers from restrictions. So there's another GOD above that GOD that has always existed without any restrictions i.e GOD is shapeless and can take any shape that GOD wants. But ofcourse a desert madman's IQ cudn't comprehend that. Excerpt from Gita (the essence of all Vedas), while showing Viratswaroop श्रीभगवानुवाच | पश्य मे पार्थ रूपाणि शतशोऽथ सहस्रश: | नानाविधानि दिव्यानि नानावर्णाकृतीनि च Meaning: Krishna's form is not a single form but made of multitude of different forms, colors, bhavs etc. As I said it'd take minimum above average IQ to first master Nirukta and Nighantu (kinda grammer and index) to translate Vedas which are not word for word tranlations.
"na tasya pratima asti "There is no image of Him." "Andhatama pravishanti ye asambhuti mupaste" "They enter darkness, those who worship the natural elements" (Air, Water, Fire, etc.). "They sink deeper in darkness, those who worship sambhuti." [Yajurveda 40:9]7 Sambhuti means created things, for example table, chair, idol, Krishna,Ram etc.
As from my own personal experiences he is correct. And I have understood one lmpotant factor. A spiritual knowledge comes directly from God and when one has attain this. It is sometimes very difficult to impart that knowledge to the people out there. So this is one of the reasons many stay hidden in this world . Away from the others whose mindset is one way
We all fell here from Heaven because we sinned and our one and only aim should be trying to return home, which is Heaven. That was Christ's message. We all have chosen to play in the mud instead of seeking the Divine....................falun dafa
If it comes from God, what business is it of yours, or Sadhguru’s, to ‘impart that knowledge’ ? Are you going to second guess God ? Also - can you be certain that God says exactly the same things to everyone ? In the end, such notions are cosmic gossip, and have NOTHING to do with self realisation, nirvana or ‘knowledge’.
"Religion has caused far more deaths than any other activity in the world. " 100% agree. Also, SG/JV is in love with his own voice... he keeps interrupting instead of allowing other person to make their statement. (you asked me a question!... no, he didn't)
The journalist is looking at Sadhguru process as a western religion that’s the problem he started wrong there for everything after that is going to be wrong 🙏🏾
When you see from front to the lady's right is Amusement and to her left is Wisdom. You can easily make it out from her facial expressions while being silent all the time but saying through her eyes, face and attention to the golden words spoken.
Most women tend to fall for soft flowery speech on love, god, fantasy, mystical, spiritual jargons. Not ready for hard hitting questions. It's upto you to wear that mask or not. Personally I wouldn't care to impress sensationalist people like her.
What you are seeing in her are the reations of a mindless brainwashed robot follower. She has to smile to show her aleigence to the sad guruji...lol Its not like she has a choice. She is following a program as per automation, and you are swallowing it all raw.
@@CT2507 Thats how you are called a Leftist and the left hand has one very big use every morning in India. Keep doing it and swallow it thereafter. lol Stupid idiots as always on a troll.
The gentleman is putting forward a very intellectual argument..just becos he is opposing satguru ..does not mean everyone shd clap without understanding a word spoken by satguru..
Worth watching. They thankfully both shared what is on their minds peacefully, one louder and angrier then the other without threats, violence etc. It would be good for the world that everyone and country could do this peacfully and respectfully. Those leaders who escalate to violence and threats aboubt their religion are not leaders they are fools, cowards and liars and those that follow them are puppets and fools.
@@custempo3040 the way of avoiding being challenged by anyone who would think he could, not wasting time, and going straight to the business, at least of preferred one. Those who debate stay in debates, and there are those who not.
"I understand, lot of things are not understood" 😂😂😂... Before questioning like a intellect do basic study of the facts... Our science is not even 1 percent of the universe...
With due respect to Sadhguru I must say he is a escapist. Knowing his weaknesses, he afraid that he will be exposed in public. So he naver like to face any international Islamic debaters like Zakir Naik, Dr. Sabil Ahmed or others who never hesitate to dialogue or debate with any type of man/woman including atheists. Because they are confident, Sadhguru isn't
@@Justin-tq9vv With due respect to Sadhguru I must say he is a escapist. Knowing his weaknesses, he afraid that he will be exposed in public. So he naver like to face any international Islamic debaters like Zakir Naik, Dr. Sabil Ahmed or others who never hesitate to dialogue or debate with any type of man/woman including atheists. Because they are confident, Sadhguru isn't
Dude get real .. as long as u don't believe someone can take you forward you don't move forward.. enjoy the journey and then questions.. may be u can be the guru .. to the person who guided you .. that's wat ..we have done .. if we did believe our primary school teacher.. were would have not learnt ABC .. it's not that .. teacher is god .
He is right. Religion has made many wars in history. May we all live in peace whether we oppose another or not. Hold everyone with eyes of love and forgiveness
Sadhguru did not address the main objection, which is the apparent contradiction between being skeptical and taking a leap of faith. Sadhfguru essentially misinterpreted the debater’s point of view as stating since I don’t understand it I don’t believe it. I wished the debater would have stuck to his main argument on this leap of faith, to explore this idea in greater depth. He has something there!
I'm not sure how this amounts to an insult. He's simply asking a question about writings that are self contradictory. And as a reply, he gets a convoluted guru word salad and moving the goal posts.
Sadhguru tried to address his first logic flaw, about religion. They're both saying the same thing you need to search. They couldn't understand each other due to the hubris of judging without understanding. Sadhguru tried to raise this as the point, the other guy couldn't understand, so the conversation failed.
It seems to me that in order to understand Sadguru, it is wise to read a biography of Tolstoy written by a Frenchman with the surname Gilles. It helped me understand Tolstoy, and I can fully use it for Sadguru.
@@RifetOkic I can't summarize previously stated further. I can only elaborate, but it has to be to a level that transcends this way of communicating. The biography is titled with the surname: Tolstoy. It is full of outwardly visible facts about Tolstoy's life. Complete these facts - taken in summary - with data that Tolstoy is a horoscope virgin (which is also Sadguru) - and here is the "revelation".Of course, it remains as a problem - knowing the conditioning carried by - virgins.
Manuel, From your comment, which is not on the line of administrative speech, I can only indirectly conclude (and indirectly - it means that mistakes are very possible). From your sentence, it is likely that you consider Sadhguru a fraudster, and maybe, less likely but maybe also, that you also consider Tostoy a fraudster (who is so different from Sadhguru that you don't want a comparison due to different levels of success in deception). My comment does not indicate that either of the two is a fraud. My comment only indicates the path for understanding Sadhguru. In addition to the mentioned text about Tolstoy's life, I could also cite two more valuable texts - but those two texts are written in my native language, and it is unlikely that you can find them in any of the languages you use. The overall theme delves into the characteristics of human individuals determined by their date of birth. For the sake of understanding, I can make the same comment in relation to Hegel, a more than well-known person - who "turned black" white philosophy a long time ago, completely without evil intentions. I know I didn't make it easy for you, but - we are actually looking for the efforts ourselves. Greeting!@@manuelscaria
Science ends when there is no logic....when logic ends, religion or spirutuality starts. ..unfortunate, and surprised as to why Sadhguru is blamed for being religious. He hasnt promoted any religion or hasnt indulged in conversions, unlike my brothers from other religions....This journalist I am sure is totally confused and is also jealous of Sadhgurus popularity. Science is For material seekers.. Religion is for the soul seekers
Religion is the biggest man-made fraud in this world. Preachers and believers claim Hinduism is special. But it isn't special at all... Its one of the thousands religions or more that have existed since dawn of humanity, all of which claim divine revelation, all of which claim perfection, all of which proclaim infinite knowledge, uniqueness, beauty etc.. So Hinduism is a religion like any other. There's no difference, it proclaims just as Qur'an did, Bible etc did.(biggest similarity being a universe creator, which is Brahma in your book, but different in others). So Hinduism is one of those thousands religions which makes the same claim but mutually inconsistent ones so that they can all be correct. So,. Probability of it being correct is just 0.1% because its one of the thousands religions. But since all of them make the same claim without evidence means they are all incorrect. Another fact is that hundreds and thousands of innocent worshippers including the imams and pandits are dying painful death in bomb blasts, terror attacks, air strikes etc. even while praying inside god's own mosques/temples. That itself proves that god doesn't exist.
@@grvjensen Hind. is universal, inner peace and scientific. Oldest civ as well. It’s a way of life. You can be non believ or nastika, multiple paths lead to same destination, others can be gurus. Yet the ones attacked as pagan or infid. The 10 avatars of Ravaan align with Darwin theory. I say as a Sik. minor.
@@grvjensen if you are talking about logic and about the figure 0.1 % ,then you must tell us about the sourcre from where you get it .And also explain us what statistics you have used to chalk out the solution. Waiting for your full answer.
I have been following Sadhguru for a while now. He has been an unexplainable help to me in my tough times. He is a source of infinite wisdom. Thats how i see him. He has brought me clarity in many things in my life which i was confused about. I am very Grateful for that.I see that this event is taking place in Kerala. And I am a Keralian. I am very happy to see this video because as a keralian I am seeing sadhguru sharing his wisdom for the first time in kerala. But I am also sad that he is sitting with this guy, who is not sure about what he is saying and is also very confident in his ignorant speech. All I want to say to Sadhguru is that, please do forgive this person for his inexcusable behaviour and please forgive us keralians(followers of Sadhguru), made you uncomfortable in any ways during this event or during your visit in Kerala. I hope you had other pleasant and memorable experiences from this place.🙏🙄
Pranam Sadguru yeah I can understand you very well your answer is absolutely clear to me My Guru too speaks like you Congratulations Satguru you are really great
I must have to say Sadhguru is a escapist. Knowing his weaknesses, he afraid that he will be exposed in public. So he naver like to face any international Islamic debaters like Zakir Naik, Dr. Sabil Ahmed or others who never hesitate to dialogue or debate with any type of man/woman including atheists. Because they are confident, Sadhguru isn't
Sadhguru's situation reminds me of what Mike Tyson once said. He said he always has to deal with people who think they have to fight him because defeating him would give them great credit. If you win, you become greater than Mike Tyson himself - this is what they think. So they are simply looking for a way to benefit from the status of whoever they are attacking. Apparently there are also many supposedly smart people who attack a man like Sadhguru just to profit from his status. There is no other way I can explain the tone of this debate. If you have a different opinion on the matter, then you can also do it respectfully and choose soft tones. But this was no argument in good faith.
His opponent was speaking the truth and raising some good points. Maybe you should know that Mike Tyson might have been a great fighter and got fame doing that, but he was not an ideal human being or anyone to idolise and follow. I am surprised people are still following and defending Sadhguru after this.
Jamais je viendrais tenir ce genre de conversation avec maître sadhguru. On doit respects aux guides spirituels. Ils faut écouter. Beaucoup. Savoir se taire quand on ne comprend pas tout aussi . Il y a une maniere de poser ses questions sans y aller par la confrontation . Il n y a que quelques mois que je visionne dans les shorts, de courts extraits de sadhguru. J éprouve un très grand respect pour cet homme. Le calme -parce que je le sens calme et non furieux-qu il sait garder devant cet impatient, c est ce que je travaille sur moi même. J admire son sang froid et sa patience. Ce n est pas donné à tout le monde. 🙏merci sadhguru🕊paix❤amour
If you do not challenge wisdom, how do you know what is and isn't wise. Putting knowledge to the test by asking questions and attempting to debunk it is apart of an intellectual conversation. Ain't nothing wrong with questioning the teacher, and if it is to you, then your missing the point the teacher is attempting to make.....or the teacher is a bad one
@@kazzythegypsy "il y a une manière de poser ses questions, sans y aller par la confrontation . " c est ce que je dis ici , les questions sont bienvenues, je suis d accord. C est de la.confrontation, que je remtes en question. Ton attitude. Maniere de parler, et que ce n est pas la place, ni le temps, justement,pour les débats. Peut être qu on ne comprends pas cette conversation de la même manière. J y vois quelque chose que vous ne voyez peut être pas.... le ton n est pas très jovial . C est tout. Et ca n à pas sa place. Ici. Désolée 🙏
Only one way you can gain knowledge by asking questions and challenging, teacher always feel proud when they are changed for their knowledge. Both need confidence in themselves the person who is asking n person who’s answering
That man failed to differentiate between the religion and fundamentalism, Sadguru never encourages fundamental elements to create chaos in the society but people like this person who is questioning Sadguru creates divisions among the people by various ways with their self styled brain which is of no use. ---Niranjan Reddy
I am happy sadhguru is of benefit for so many people! And while he does carry much of indias ancient wisdom with him, I can't shake the feeling that his understanding barely crosses the intellectual. I just can't help but cringe seeing people with "the ego of not having an ego", he believes to be so much smarter that there is no point in letting the man finish his point, and then he ones again completely obscures the fact that he never gave an asnwer to the actual question at hand. Reminds me of the way he tried to justify cruelty against animals by pointing towards plants supposedly also screaming and hurting when beeing eaten. I mean come on that's an argument I'd expect from my drunk uncle at a family gathering but not a supposed guru.
Just pointing out that spirituality and science are like oil mixing with water. I can't think of anything more.. complex? than Sadhguru or one trying to put words to it. I might credit him for that.
To be watching intellectual people debating over the abstract is like watching birds chirping in the greens. Means no business but feels sweet to listen. It's like you put your juicy mind to something that'll get nothing tangible except for a lofty aftereffect.
We all fell here from Heaven because we sinned and our one and only aim should be trying to return home, which is Heaven. That was Christ's message. We all have chosen to play in the mud instead of seeking the Divine....................falun dafa
I wonder how many people here has consentualised what Sadghuru said... I am 💯 with this man. All Sadghuru dis was "trying" to answer a question that kinda made sense for his followers and he was supported by the applause 👏🏻 🤣 from. The audience. Sadghure didn't answer the man's questions because he didn't understand it... he was trying to deal with his rage and ego... incoherence does not difuse critical thinkers...
I did not understand - Why leap of "Faith" is necessary to 'go to the next phase' as claimed/ discussed in this debate. What is Faith? What is Leap-of-Faith? and Why that is necessary? If you have understood. Please help me!
just because your 24 does not make you a mature person, so your own statement itself is not right and you are talking about understanding the words of another man.
I must have to say Sadhguru is a escapist. Knowing his weaknesses, he afraid that he will be exposed in public. So he naver like to face any international Islamic debaters like Zakir Naik, Dr. Sabil Ahmed or others who never hesitate to dialogue or debate with any type of man/woman including atheists. Because they are confident, Sadhguru isn't
@@janmejaypandey2424 I must have to say Sadhguru is a escapist. Knowing his weaknesses, he afraid that he will be exposed in public. So he naver like to face any international Islamic debaters like Zakir Naik, Dr. Sabil Ahmed or others who never hesitate to dialogue or debate with any type of man/woman including atheists. Because they are confident, Sadhguru isn't
Jaggi Vasudev needs to understand that no one in this universe is hundred percent perfect. We cannot correct our flaws unless we realize so. In engineering, no product can be realized to the absolute value. Hence we have variations or tolerances for the absolute values. The same variations are applicable to human beings also. Knowingly Jaggi Vasusev and his ISHA YOGA FOUNDATION are committing a lot of mistakes and attempting to justify the flaws. We, people need to be aware of these.
"any human being who thinks: what I do not know cannot exist, is wearing the crown of ignorance" BEST QUOTE EVER
Likewise, "any human being who thinks: what I do not know, exists" is wearing the crown of ignorance.
Sad Guru, laughs and thinks he is right. He is totally wrong as he gives lame example of bike to back up his lies in Book. most people that drink COKE and have faith in brand called COKE will not listen to a writers like the one questioning SAD_GURU. BRAND vs. NO - BRAND. People have been following BRAND sad-guru for a while so they will naturally not trust writer logic even if the logic is 100% true.
@@singhajinder501 He is just one of countless people through the ages who are speaking the same truths. Everything he speaks about is written in ancient texts.
@@kieranwhittemore1010 Repeating ancient texts do not make them true or accurate, it simply makes you a repeater of ancient texts.
@@kieranwhittemore1010 Well whats written in Ancient text is GOD is with in you and do not need to follow these ( or any ) people and waste time and energy. Rather use that Energy to be direct with your creator. There is living GOD in you and seek it and know all. You do not have to leave or listen to his made up stories that just shows weekness of once's mind not to make your inner GOD more prevelant in your own life. KINGDOM of heaven is with in you and you are whole and complete.
I promise Sadghuru’s teachings do not create division in this world 😂 What an absurd contradiction
yes that was an ignorant thing for him to say!
They do create contradiction through ridiculous, man-made rituals which have the purpose of taking the worshippers money or goods and replacing them with false belief.
he killed his wife and got away with it in a banana republic
I wouldn’t call this man Guru and adding Sadh is an insult to real enlightened person who chooses remain anonymous!!
@@tripmcfly10What's the point of enlightenment, if you can't use the knowledge to make human conscious! You should come out of your cave! By the way, what does a guru do!!!??? Live in a mountain in solidarity!? Do you even know what sadh means?? Ignorant is bliss! 🙏@
I did not see Sadhguru becoming furious, I just saw a wise man answering calmly .
Very true!
Click bait title for the views
You misunderstand, first you must make a distinction between being and becoming. Humans have different ways to express their emotions, you can not lump them all together you see. That's how he appears when he's furious 😂
I think you didn't understand the title
He said THE MAN who insulted sadhguru GOT ANGRY
Vry good
Homeboy did not insult anyone and nobody was furious. These titles are a sign of how civil discourse is breaking down and how much we delight in it
It’s also just clickbait for views
Thank for truth.
Spot on. The title is to capture people's attention.
@@christianjohnson2562No it's called emphasizing on Upscale
Was there ever a time civil discourse wasn't plagued with toxicity?
Many peoples are happy with Sadhguru.
Sadhguru made many peoples come back to their self .
Thank you 🙏 Sadhguru.
Did he now? Show me those people who have come back to realising their true self on account of this sad gurus teachings.
:)
@@CT2507 yeah I have... Whts your problem..
@@saumyaverma5188 You have realised your true self? You have acheived self- realisation?? :)
Child. You dont even know what you are saying.
My problem is with ignorance and believing in fairy-tales. And it is rife with this so called guru.
@@CT2507 You are sight, he is not Sadguru. He is Sad guru :D
Sadhguru taught me somethings, I am not the body, I’m not even the mind.
I think one of the reasons for this missunderstanding of the Man towards sadhguru, is that he thinks of him as a religious leader, which he is clearly not.
He is not in the business of telling people what to do - that would be religious - but telling people, where to look, to see for themselves, so that would be a spiritual journey individual to each and every person listening to him.
Also calling Sadhguru angry is a great missinterpretation of what is happening here, as Sadhguru only insists, when clearing up the axioms, under which both discuss, so they could come to a common understanding.
And where does spiritualalty
Stem from Religious uprise ?
Sadugru was actually a little angry.
Exactly! I remember him interrupting himself once and saying "Please do not believe the nonsense I am saying, but go and see for yourself." These are the words of a man worth listening to.
Today, people like Sadhguru needed in all walks of life.
What we have done with this planet, the earth... We means... Politicians, Scientists, Sociologists, Anthropologists, Doctos, Engineers, Professors, Teachers.. etc btc vtc
We have ruined our country, people and fabrics of our culture....
And we have not replaced it with another good or better systemm
Its a hard and long debate...
I respect everyones point of view and salute to Sadhguru...😊
So true humans destroyed this earth he is trying to take us to Raam and Krishna's time which seams impossible ,but is possible cause we are admiring what impossible thing they have done
I don't think he practised what he preached. That little part about ‘respecting each other’s opinion/beliefs.’ He labelled the opposing guy’s opinion as ‘ignorant.’
That alone indicates that he believes he is entirely right and that the man’s questioning is minuscule.
@@kizito8888 If he cant take understanding what Sathguru is saying he is ignorant cause what they did Five thousand or more years ago still mesmerising the world
@@kizito8888 can u respect an ignorant man?
With due respect to Sadhguru I must say he is a escapist.
Knowing his weaknesses, he afraid that he will be exposed in public.
So he naver like to face any international Islamic debaters like Zakir Naik, Dr. Sabil Ahmed or others who never hesitate to dialogue or debate with any type of man/woman including atheists.
Because they are confident, Sadhguru isn't
An enlightened man will never get insulted or will become furious.
I wish one day 🙂
No such thing as enlightenment.
An enlightened man is bound to nothing. Your pov of an enlightened man is very limited and constipated. How would u know what an enlightened person would act like? Are you enlightened?
@ahmonj 10:49 shut up fool😮😮eremiah7114
@ahmonjeremiah7114 there is but your ego is too strong to be able to see and understand it
This is a very justified debate. There is no insult in questioning a teacher.
Yes agree to your second statement completely because i didn't listen to the whole conversation.
Sadhguru answers were perfect 🤩 🙏❤️
Jaggi was frustrated and his dismissive laughter combined with his direct insult of Shashi Kumar's mental capacity did not befit a so-called teacher.
Yes, but the tune makes the music...
It's one thing to question a teacher. It's another to act like the teacher is a fool and instead try to teach him what you believe. This was the latter.
Wow! Sadhguru said" the last part of the book which is bothering you is to take you to the next place".
I learned from this that, what bothers us should not be our limit but rather our starting point.
Sadhguru continue in this wisdom.
His followers will find meaning in the most inane things this guy says.
@@GhanashyamSharmaSBU It's crazy. Sadhguru is very rude and disrespectful. Many times in other Q&A sessions, he will make fun of the person asking a question he does not like. And he always seems to struggle with directly answering questions he does not like.
@@GhanashyamSharmaSBU lol... yea. Just like in the comedy film "Life Of Brian".
So childish and ridiculous.
@@mags7054 Thats because he is a fake guru. Just a businesman. A member of Klaus Schwabs globalist stinky club.
With due respect to Sadhguru I must say he is a escapist.
Knowing his weaknesses, he afraid that he will be exposed in public.
So he naver like to face any international Islamic debaters like Zakir Naik, Dr. Sabil Ahmed or others who never hesitate to dialogue or debate with any type of man/woman including atheists.
Because they are confident, Sadhguru isn't
The fact that critics always come from a place of anger towards their "opponent" and that anger only exists as an imbalance in their own mind and body, is a lesson which cannot be overlooked
Religion did not invent the atom bomb . Scientist are as narrowminded and ambitious and egocentric als religieus persons . It’s never their personal respondabilty. “the I have good intentions .. “ it’s easy to blame another . Seldom people look inside themselves and learn from it .
Nobody talks about politics … science is ruled by money and politics and religion is ruled by money and politics
The anger and frustration came from Jaggi.
@@A-X-25 wow, did u just reveal the secret of making easy 25mil!! How come you are already not on yr way to make yr own 25million when u know how it's made..do u see the logic- ur angry, frustrated, negative, jealous cos you find yrself inadequate and inferior when confronting someone way above yr intellect/spiritual/logical/financial means...I am sure you hate Modiji too cos he is hugely popular and ur not..ru seeing a trend and an issue in yr own personality..look within, not outside- that's how u find the issue and start working on it...Jai Hind
@@A-X-25 wrong..if ur worried ABT feeding yr family, yr focus will be on finding ways to earn that good..no hard working person has the time, energy or focus to waste on seeing what others r doing n feel good/bad ABT it...
I could only see a charming lady sitting silently without any facial expressions amidst the argument fire 😊😊😊🤗
Name?
That may be your interest wherever you go
The lady in the middle has a level of serenity that I want in my life.
اندر باہر سے ایک ہو جاؤ۔
سکون مل جائے گا۔
She is Manju Varier
Manju Varrier has learned enough in the journey called life, that's why she is so blisfull
She did not know english much
Was told before going on stage “just sit there smile and look beautiful” ?
Such debates are required.
This make stuff more purposeful to understand and accept
We all fell here from Heaven because we sinned and our one and only aim should be trying to return home, which is Heaven. That was Christ's message. We all have chosen to play in the mud instead of seeking the Divine....................falun dafa
Especially when millions are blindly following some self proclaimed babas and swamis and gurus. We need someone who’s not going to just take it without questioning it.
But he is not ready to listen and making up things. I agree that whole game of energies and vibrations, we cant understand such things in one go.
@@simik4981 Well said they are In a stone age
@@healthwealth2155 I was scared to say it, but yeah, that's hitting the nail on the head.
The problem with humans, especially those who take pride in their intellect, is they are always in a mode of defending their own conviction, but by doing that, they build a wall around themselves which prevents them from perceiving anything beyond. I actually was the same way, until I discovered Eckhart Tolle, then other spiritual teachers like him.
I heard the name Eckhart Tolle (power of now) ages ago. I am not into spirituality so did not read the book even though I bought it thinking I will read some day. Do you know if Mr. Tolle believes in supernatural and after life? I am 99% sure he does. I don't care what any single person's conviction is but if you take science as an entity - do you think science also has a conviction and have a wall around it - so it cannot see anything beyond? I don't follow Eckhart Tolle but clearly Sadhguru uses hyperbole and obscurantism. His personal wall perhaps is much thinner than the ones he preaches to - he deliberately wants others wall to grow thicker and thicker. Thanks.
@@jeetray11 You should read his book to find out. He doesn't refer to God as the God of the Bible, but he did not deny the existence of God. His teaching is more in the realm of spirituality. However, it also depends on the listener. If the listener is not ready to absorb what he says, then it won't work.
It’s called confirmation bias
@@kathleenlauren Well that's certainly interesting. Maybe it's better just to hear him on RUclips. However, how we perceive things or others is also filtered through our own mind, so you might have some unpleasant experience with him. Can you give more details what led you to think of him that way ?
Eckhart tolle change my perspective on life
Watching from Palau! Greetings to you all people wherever you are!
I love how Sadhguru enlightening humanity. Thanks
Hello, glad to hear he's reaching Palau. My mother was born and raised there.
In life there is no wrong or right..
sadhguru has his thoughts and the guest has his.. And that’s wonderful..
A peaceful conversation is highly welcomed .. and healthy.
But the bald man was rude
Is it wrong if someone murders your family?
No right or wrong? Good gracious
Lol, what umb shit is this, there is always right and wrong in life , lmao.
None Zero. Right & Wrong doesn't exist, if it existed, by now, people would have done only right, not wrong They contradict everything that's right. anyway.
Anger does us more harm than the things about which we're angry. We eat our own hearts when we give in to anger, as philosophers used to say. It's self-destructive. The consequences of our anger might harm others but we also harm
You are right but what to do if someone constantly criticising you wrongly, abusing you for his stupidity and asking you to give validation, i perhaps not angry with him ignoring him cause he is a person like that but what other people who are surrounding you will think about you in case you are getting abused .
Sadhguru many times teaches people "next time you're angry, then you are stupid". Looks like Sadhguru is stupid too.😂😜😂😂😂 He also tries to teach people that is not good to procreate because we are too many, but he was not able to adopt a child and he procreate. He teaches others not to buy so many shoes: "what are you going to to with those things?" "you buy shoes for 10 lifetimes", but he has most of the time a different outfit in his videos. He tells us that "if you think what you are doing is important, then you need a holyday" and I would say the same thing to him, because the way his volunteers and teachers treated me was definitely not like what he promotes. He is another stupid hypocrite like many others(me included, at least I admit this). The truth is there is no solution for humans. We have to accept that we are not perfect and we should live with good, bad whatever we are capable. If we are the creation of creator, then creator makes us like this: evil, good, compassionate, indifferent, sad, joyful, peaceful, revengeful, etc.. I bet his shit doesn't smell like flowers!😂😂😂
@@greenbud1695 you can not control getting angry at someone for their actions.. it is reacting angry and with that anger insult others with the goal to hurt them . That is not wise or good for our selfs or health.. it is ok to show people you are angry.we are human.. just don't respond back with ignorance and lose your position you have earned with wise decisions.. ignore the people who think you are weak because their ignorance can not see you are the stronger person...
@@marviz5574 you are right bro otherwise paying attention to them will harm us more .
The title of this video is misleading, there was no anger just a debate. Sadhguru is educated and wise but the man’s discourse is interesting and makes for a good clarification regarding religion Nd spirituamity
Agree with you.
Well said
Yeah you are absolutely right it's a debate Sadguru is just answering and he's absolutely right I understand him clearly Sadguru isn't angry at all
True
The man is Shashikumar, senior journalist and runs Asian College of Journalism. Unfortunately people nowadays don't know real people of any worth and instead run after saints and yogis whose past would reveal their true credentials.
Well said Sadguru, these people are full of themselves, can’t reach up to the level of Sadguru yet wants the love which Sadguru has earned from this world.
Sounds like your worshipping him, which is the OPPOSITE of his teachings. Speak with more all-encompassing understanding
Stubborn arrogant laughing stock
It's always good to find flaws in ourselves
It might be good but is often very difficult to detect & often counter productive when you suppress them!!
Don't know when jagga will be enlightened and will feel the flaws
Sadhguru is a great orator!
Very few times i have had disagreement with his views, but mostly i can relate to what he speaks. But most of what I like is he has dignified mannerism.
No he is not. For children perhaps. I see this sad guru as a great masturbator and a weak bullshiter. I can not fathom how so many people dont see through his scam.
With due respect to Sadhguru I must say he is a escapist.
Knowing his weaknesses, he afraid that he will be exposed in public.
So he naver like to face any international Islamic debaters like Zakir Naik, Dr. Sabil Ahmed or others who never hesitate to dialogue or debate with any type of man/woman including atheists.
Because they are confident, Sadhguru isn't
@@arefinhoosain654 You are right.
At least we know where we stand with Naik's Islam. It hates everybody that disagrees with it.
I have no idea what Sadhguru is talking about, but at least I do know he doesn't hate me because of that.
1)As per instruction of the Holly Quaran
".....let us come to an agreement on that which is common between us,........." (Al-'Imran -Sura: 3 Verse: 63 )
Dr. Zakir Naik several times invited all, to talk /discussion/dialogue/debate face to face repeatedly as per democratic norms to find out the commonalities, & make the bridge on the gaps
So that living together peacefully by accepting the differences.
Which is a process & integral/ important part of modern DEMOCRACY
2) But some political & religious leaders (of both Hindu & Muslim community ) distorts this fair attempt due to their personal interest. geving religious colors & accusing him on terrorists connection
😂😂😂😂, a book you mentioned is pretty logical
Good perspectives and debate .. An enlightened soul can never be made angry or disturbed but always convincing with the truth ! Never the less God and Faith is true and it is an individual realization and experience which cannot be depicted or substantiated 🙏
I have been involved with many beliefs and I have yet to understand hindus and this Guru understands so much and I had to subscribe. Im so glad i found him on my quest for understanding.♥️😊
Jesus is the Answer Open the bible and understand his teachings better. Dont run behind FAKE GURUS or posing as know it all, You have the answer for your problems in the BIBLE OPen today and read
@@JenniferMascarenhasDubai Jesus told many that the way is thru knowledge and he would have told you this. The way the truth and the light is thru knowledge and peace of mind. I have read the bible and there is beauty but there is slavery and hatred of those who do not fit in due to having both sexes. Do you know that 1 out of 2000 ppl have both sexes? Well in the united states thats the truth. Gnosticism and the Essene spoke about this. You must be aware that is the way of Joshua not judgement.
@@JenniferMascarenhasDubaidid you miss the part of the the Bible that teaches thou shalt not judge others especially before understanding where they're coming from? 😊
Yes my dear. Also did you read that there should be no blasphemy too and spread of false teachings!
Open the and your quest for understanding the truth, the way and life is there!!
There is level of intelligence.... Respect each level and uplifting them is the leap of faith ...
This man is so prejudiced that it's almost too much distasteful to hear his vested outbursts.
Absolutely pathetic, I am so anguished that why Sadguru ji should even meet or debate such reckless and cheap people carrying such hateful mindset ?
He should not waste his energy instead keep talking to people who wants to seek something.
Sadguruji you're always soothing and inspiring to watch.
Please keep it up. हरी ॐ
Yes why sadguru continues to battle with apparently less wise crowd. Is it to establish his supremacy creating fan base in social media..... I don't understand
Thats correct. Sadguruji should avoid such trash garbage people of our society which is now laden with parasites
It’s because he « wastes his energy » to answer that I appreciate and follow Sadhguru
He is a communist.... That explains his attitude
We all fell here from Heaven because we sinned and our one and only aim should be trying to return home, which is Heaven. That was Christ's message. We all have chosen to play in the mud instead of seeking the Divine....................falun dafa
Part of our reality is accepting that some people don’t have the intention to raise their consciousness or simply cannot. Everyone is on their own journey in this life. It’s valid to question these things as they are impossible to comprehend without directly experiencing them for yourself. Often times words get lost in translation; however, these debates are necessary.
I agree
Most people got hung up on playing in the mud instead of seeking the Divine...............falun dafa
Without everybody would be the same.
Tell me about! Try living with my mother in law! 😂
Consciousness is overrated.
I'm three minutes in and the man still hasn't asked a question, so he did not come to learn and deepen his understanding, he came to preach and have his BELIEFS reinforced.
the title of the video is misleading really. this is a good discussion. when two people with very different worldviews talk there is a always an underlying tension, but the point is to proceed with and despite that...
She is MahimaNambiar
for views they can do anything
Respect to both humans.this type of discussions are to be promoted, so that the new generations can choose without any bias...
Agree such discussions is the need of the hour to present it b4 the new generations for igniting the curiosity amongst the youth. Provided the youth allow themselves a chance to be amongst thinkers and intellectual who are spiritually awakened. The spiritually awakened are those who have risen above material acquisition and gain. They are those who have reached the peak of materialism BUT hv decisively chosen to tk the path of self realisation. Their company will enable the Youth to understand the transmission from material success to spiritual success hopefully faster than their Peer group guiding them.
AUM SRI SAI RAM ♥
Aum Sri Sai Ram.
Sadhguru many times teaches people "next time you're angry, then you are stupid". Looks like Sadhguru is stupid too.😂😜😂😂😂 He also tries to teach people that is not good to procreate because we are too many, but he was not able to adopt a child and he procreate. He teaches others not to buy so many shoes: "what are you going to to with those things?" "you buy shoes for 10 lifetimes", but he has most of the time a different outfit in his videos. He tells us that "if you think what you are doing is important, then you need a holyday" and I would say the same thing to him, because the way his volunteers and teachers treated me was definitely not like what he promotes. He is another stupid hypocrite like many others(me included, at least I admit this). The truth is there is no solution for humans. We have to accept that we are not perfect and we should live with good, bad whatever we are capable. If we are the creation of creator, then creator makes us like this: evil, good, compassionate, indifferent, sad, joyful, peaceful, revengeful, etc.. I bet his shit doesn't smell like flowers!😂😂😂😂
Stubborn old man doesn't understand what guru says..
അപമാനം തന്നെ
Absolutely
Bias??
That black guy is a jerk
Sick man 😶😶😶
I love listening to Sashguru and I don't care if he says he created this or that, because what he does create or help create in me is Peace of Mind and if you feel better after listening to someone than you did before you listened to them, just let it be good. Others trying to tear apart another's greatness is absurd. Keep being awesome Sadhguru! Simple, keep doing what you're doing please! There are many that you are helping have peace of mind and that is everything ✨
You feel better not by listening to someone talk but by making the change in yourself. It's like all these motivational videos... The trap is that people listen to these to "feel" really motivated for something they want to do but in the end they procrastinate. Same applies here
It's like observing greatness from afar and wanting it but then not doing the actual work to reach greatness for yourself
@@spookyactionatadistance2422 oh for sure. I know what you mean and I definitely procrastinate after thinking how motivated I just became lol !!
@@julieallbright5002 But are you happy doing that ?
Well that can be dangerous. The devil will tell you what you want to hear.,...to make you feel good.
It’s only Sadhguru who can respond calm and composed to all questions, however uncomfortable they are. Surprising we don’t have such knowledge gurus from other religions to sit and debate, with intellectuals or students alike.
No religious heads will entice such challenging debates except Sadguru from Sanatana dharma. Jai Bharat.
Look up Bishop Robert Barron. There are others out there. They just haven't reached your search recommendations.
fake guru
watched this on you tube "Sadhguru: Journey of a Fake Spiritual Guru".. changed my opinion!
And only he can have that much patience, i start fighting if someone go beyond my patience limit or questions my beliefs who the fuck these people are to question our beliefs
The very first argument he put forward was absolutely true. A very valid statement. People just close their eyes the moment their religion or belief is questioned. But everything else sounds incorrect and false to them
Sadhguru many times teaches people "next time you're angry, then you are stupid". Looks like Sadhguru is stupid too.😂😜😂😂😂 He also tries to teach people that is not good to procreate because we are too many, but he was not able to adopt a child and he procreate. He teaches others not to buy so many shoes: "what are you going to to with those things?" "you buy shoes for 10 lifetimes", but he has most of the time a different outfit in his videos. He tells us that "if you think what you are doing is important, then you need a holyday" and I would say the same thing to him, because the way his volunteers and teachers treated me was definitely not like what he promotes. He is another stupid hypocrite like many others(me included, at least I admit this). The truth is there is no solution for humans. We have to accept that we are not perfect and we should live with good, bad whatever we are capable. If we are the creation of creator, then creator makes us like this: evil, good, compassionate, indifferent, sad, joyful, peaceful, revengeful, etc.. I bet his shit doesn't smell like flowers!😂😂
The problematic thing about gurus and famous people in debates in general, is that they tend to becoming famous and having followers backing them up. just see that video to understand this: guru says something sassy - the auditory applauds. the interviewer says something witty - akward silence. its not because who is ight and who is wrond, is because personal preferences, people that follow him want him to be right. It is hewarding positive afirmation for the guru no matter what, it has a psychologic effect over whoever watches it. in the end of the day these debates should only happen indoors, uncut, with a camera.
At the end , no answer was given to the actual question. 👏👏👏
That's what!
So true.. !! People are only blindly believing whatever sadguru is saying.. He has no answers... Only blah... Blah... Blah
its amazing how the mind works ... the guy really understood the bicycle analogy at 5:44 "any human being who thinks what I do not know cannot exist is wearing the crown of ignorance" well said. The highest knowledge is to recognize "I do not know" so you are open to knowledge. Love from ethiopia For my Indian brothers and sisters...
Well no know one disputes that. But sad guru doesn't say that for himself. And that's what the interviewer was saying - about contradiction
Sadhguru is speaking from the realms of direct experience and the other guy is speaking from a limited perception of logic.
Both are right except the one with direct experience has more profound experience than the one with logical experience.
It's like riding on an actual horse versus listening to someone's analysis on how it feels to ride on a horse.
The other guy is playing academic hardball. He's trying hard to stand out and outsmart sadhguru with his semantics and word games.
@Sharif Mustafa You hv advanced in your understanding of your 'SELF'. That's what counts. March ahead to your final destination. FREEDOM.
What "direct experience" are you surmising he has had ?
@@heyitsalanhere Will you pay attn and read the first 4 lines of SM's comments. Is it so difficult to identify who is being pointed out as having direct experience?
Why do I feel that you r trying to undermine/challenge the perceptive ability of SM ? Let him be. As the name suggests he is a product of the so called "Peaceful Ones" whose agenda is also made obvious by them. Coming back to you it appears you are shy of exposing your identity for whatever reason. You can't say the same for SM, can you ?
@@gnair8307 Thank you so much for your eye opening words 🙏.
Blessings to you 💚🙏
@@gnair8307
Not shy at all mate. I have asked a simple question to SM. As yet, no reply here ?!
I am curious as to what experiences he is talking about which a fellow man has had and what has impressed him about those experiences.
This is a tough debate, one takes lots of examples to structure his answers and one goes for the balls for every question. Anyway, I love Sadhguru.
And one is laughing condescendingly and getting frustrated and insulting the others intelligence...lol. A sad guru indeed.
Imagine a world where 7 +. billion people were kind,respectful and intelligently constructive ..I can 🙏🙏🏿🎩👏👏👍
I can't. Impossible planet.
I totally agree 👍
this is late great John Lennon's amazing song, " IMAGINE NO RELIGION" - Nothing to kill or die for !!! not only great music but amazing lyrics that still apply today
This would have to be the greatest song of all time !!!!
@@sclark9011 Ah yes, NO RELIGION, hell yeah brother, gotta put some hate somewhere and make the full song's message irrelevant
Sadguru around 2018 said that he knows what's going to happen everyday for next 10 years... but not sure what he was doing during covid
Sadhguru deserves all the credit for the fact that the things that spiritual beings can perceive or deal with are not available to many beings until they seek them out with dedication and persistence. Simply stating that spirituality is not true will prevent you from coming into contact with the third dimension.
Schizo.
Whatever, this guru is a fake anyway.
@@TIME4TRAINING fake, pretentious, cultist, fraudster, scammer, conartist, word juggler, theist, spiritualist, schizophrenic, psychotic, delusional, unscientific, irrational, mortal, imperfect, ignorant, degenerating old man with nothing to offer, just sweet sugar words of wisdom that doesn't have any practical purpose. Making Money From Free Gyan.
But we are in the 3rd dimension.
He Is evil he want to reduce the population i hope he and his family will be the first to go.
Sadguru’s wisdom is incredible and he is such a grinder of people’s foolish propositions, misinterpretations of religion or blaming spirituality based on present scientific advances and Sadguru also crushes people with strong egos. Someone with wisdom would approach a being like Sadguru with lots of respect and of course relish his beautiful humour which is simply divine. This humour is actual wisdom and also the state of fearlessness (Love). 🥀🌷🙏
With due respect to Sadhguru I must say he is a escapist.
Knowing his weaknesses, he afraid that he will be exposed in public.
So he naver like to face any international Islamic debaters like Zakir Naik, Dr. Sabil Ahmed or others who never hesitate to dialogue or debate with any type of man/woman including atheists.
Because they are confident, Sadhguru isn't
Well said Sadguru ji. I revere you for your wisdom and understanding. 💐💐💐💐💐
I feel sad for those who follow him. He knows nothing.
With due respect to Sadhguru I must say he is a escapist.
Knowing his weaknesses, he afraid that he will be exposed in public.
So he naver like to face any international Islamic debaters like Zakir Naik, Dr. Sabil Ahmed or others who never hesitate to dialogue or debate with any type of man/woman including atheists.
Because they are confident, Sadhguru isn't
Superb Sadhguru. We needed somebody like him to take on these holier-than-thou Macauley putras. British education has really created an intergenerational reality of limited and prejudiced minds. All the traditional elite think like this man. Having benefitted from collaboration with the British over generations, they lead comfortable lives, insulated from the complexity on the ground and parrot the same westocentric narrative, hoping the stagnation means their importance will never be undermined by the kind of revolution which the deepening perceptions which the revival of indigenous learning can bring to the country and the world.
5:23 a direct message to this man, look at his fire when he says this: "before people who are stuck in their own logic, .."
We all fell here from Heaven because we sinned and our one and only aim should be trying to return home, which is Heaven. That was Christ's message. We all have chosen to play in the mud instead of seeking the Divine....................falun dafa
@@jeffforsythe9514 True. I listen often to Shunyamurti, (Sat Yoga), he says the same and urges us not to waver.. It is time to be in the Divine, that we all are.
I am against the opposite person as sadhguru never told that he is God, he had studied the world in his own view and wether to accept his thought is each and every individual own wish.
Sad guru wants to be demi God
He himself thinks he has knowledge
@@snaik44 he does have knowledge.
It's a good discussion except for the prejudice of Shasi Kumar ( I remember he used to be a doordarshan news reader). It's a discussion between half truths and the ultimate truth. Shashi Kumar point of view is correct w.r.t religion and it's vicious ways. But he fails to understand that all religions are not based on conquest and conversion . Sadhguru clearly explains the difference between faith and spirituality. The urge for seeking and humility are the pillars of religion that Sadhguru profess. He just reminds you that what we know is a bit don't get yourself confined to that.
First Hindu people need to understand who they are, what Vedas, Ramayana, Geeta saying that. Only Hinduism is connected with science. Specially our vedas told us a lot of things.
@@patel_saheb23 To the extent I understood, no religion has got anything to do with science. Both are totally different paths. Many assume certain abstracts in Hinduism may relate to science but nothing is so convincing atleast yet. However, Geetha has human psychology, it equips an inquisitive mind with all the answers for miseries of life. It enables humans to transform into a better human and thus make the world a better place to live.
He started Asianet channel
Indu kumar itne umar k baad aise savaal koi gadha hi puch sakta he jis insan ko sanatan or buddh dharmo k bare me gyan he vo kabhi aise savaal nahi karte ye ek badi vidambna he ki dunia me jyadar nastik insan apne aap ko intellectual samajne lagta he
We all fell here from Heaven because we sinned and our one and only aim should be trying to return home, which is Heaven. That was Christ's message. We all have chosen to play in the mud instead of seeking the Divine....................falun dafa
It sure seems like the person who wrote he title didn’t watch the video.
"I think you need to educate on English language"😂😂❤️❤️❤️❤️
That is this Sadguru's pet peeve - always offering sarcastic responses.. ridiculing subtly, belittling those that debate with him... and then laughs ha ha ha! Is that the trait of one that is a 'seeker?'
@@rameshgopinath7054 I think you need to work on your language too😂happy schooling 😄
@@vinayak449 Ha ha ha dude.
@@rameshgopinath7054 100% with you on that. Sadguru is quite adept at rambling on and on acting all cool. However, only the smart, logical folks can see through his empty talks. He’s obviously offended about the smart critique but cannot respond logically with clear, concise answers to the right questions posed. Very disappointing.
I didn't see no one question other guy why he is so worried,. Is that book or something else. Selectiveness at peaks. We need more people like Sadhguru 😂
"let me explain what I meant, and what... A lot of people here knew I meant" This man knows what everyone is thinking 🕺
This guy who is asking question is worthless guy.. he has no logic
I love the patience and total demeanor of the young lady sitting there❤️
She was paid to just sit there and smile 😁
@@mrright1465 money doesn’t give you character. That woman has patience lol. If money helped Will would not have slapped
She is the lady super star of Malayalam cinema - Manju warrier
@@terrisnell1683 amen
She is Manju Warrier super star in Malayalam movie industry
Sadghuru is trying to help people and this world and he is trying to wake us up. I have a respect for him and a lot what he says resonates with me ❤
Spiritualism means understanding the self ,And understanding it is an Art, Everybody can't have it..
There is no self.
When Sadguru says, "Let's understand this", you have to sit straight to understand.
@Artime Silk The wonderful practice of Falun Gong is a vision of heavenly secrets that can make sense of earthly realities.
😆
“Isn’t it so”?!
@@jeffforsythe9514 falun gong is a cult that id totally banned from most parts of the world
@@ddonlee Not exactly, it is a religion that is banned only in Communist countries that teach atheism. Did someone from Falun Gong hurt you some how and that is why you treat the wonderful practice with such contempt?
Religion requires belief.
Spirituality requires feeling.
Reality requires experience.
This all falls under a concept that we can call 'Science of the Self'.
We all fell here from Heaven because we sinned and our one and only aim should be trying to return home, which is Heaven. That was Christ's message. We all have chosen to play in the mud instead of seeking the Divine....................falun dafa
@Artime Silk The wonderful practice of Falun Gong is a vision of heavenly secrets that can make sense of earthly realities.(Master Li Hongzhi)
Spirituality opens up alot of opportunities for human beings don't give empty quotes
U experience feelings don't u? Spirituality and reality are one and the same if you allow yourself to experience it .
@@bigbunsclassic Buddhists believe that your soul has black karma that can be removed through suffering, the less karma you have, the more divine you become until you reach spiritual enlightenment...............falun dafa
This man did not insult anyone. He simply refuses to be a sheep. Hello? Yes? Isn’t it so
He is already in herd of ship ,that's why he is following other ships😂😂😂
Actually, he is kind of an idealist : "science is about questioning our certitudes" (or something like that).
Most people today practice science like a religion (I do not mean spirituality) : they preach it everywhere though they have never seen nor experienced it ; they trust people that might be wrong (and regularly prove them wrong between themselves) ; they limit other people's experience with beliefs that they consider truth, though science is supposed to be constantly questioning, because they want to be right and cannot tolerate to be contradicted.
Funny thing, many Richis from the past discovered many things thousands years ago before the west put the finger on it (see Vaisesika), because, I agree there are a lot of conman out there, in science and religion, but a true spiritual man is a philosopher, a scientist and seek the universal truth from his own experience.
Science is also about language and code ; vedas has its system of coding and representation because it was the best way to transfer and understand the knowledge at the time, with a competent master ; but let's not forget that when Newton was technically limited by the scientific language of his time, he just "created" his own system, that we understand because it has been explained to us.
if one is not already emotionally engaged. its pretty clear that this guy has a point.
Sister just asked a beautiful question!
The guy tried to roll down over Sadguru but couldn’t site any reference to except firing in air and Sadhguru aptly pointed to his empty arguments
Can this man dare to say the same things in Zakir Naik's sessions? He'll just piss his pants before doing that.
Exactly.
Sar taan se juda sar tan se juda 😂
Never। Because all are suffering from Islamophobia
"na tasya pratima asti
"There is no image of Him."
"Andhatama pravishanti ye asambhuti mupaste"
"They enter darkness, those who worship the natural elements" (Air, Water, Fire, etc.). "They sink deeper in darkness, those who worship sambhuti."
[Yajurveda 40:9]7
Sambhuti means created things, for example table, chair, idol, Krishna,Ram etc.
@@armaan5977 Congratz you got atleast one shloka to prove something. FYI Hinduism not a simple book of rules for simple minded savages who need to be regularly punished for flouting some rules. Hinduism has 6 darshans or philosophies, Samkhya (that doesn't even believe in existence of God), Vedanta, Mimamsa (logic), Yoga, Nyaya, Vaisheshkha. One needs a general above average IQ to even go through Hindu texts, let alone translate them. And for you if GOD exists and GOD doesn't have a shape that doesn't imply GOD can't take any shape. If GOD can't take any shape then GOD is not GOD since he/she herself/himself suffers from restrictions. So there's another GOD above that GOD that has always existed without any restrictions i.e GOD is shapeless and can take any shape that GOD wants. But ofcourse a desert madman's IQ cudn't comprehend that.
Excerpt from Gita (the essence of all Vedas), while showing Viratswaroop
श्रीभगवानुवाच |
पश्य मे पार्थ रूपाणि शतशोऽथ सहस्रश: |
नानाविधानि दिव्यानि नानावर्णाकृतीनि च
Meaning: Krishna's form is not a single form but made of multitude of different forms, colors, bhavs etc. As I said it'd take minimum above average IQ to first master Nirukta and Nighantu (kinda grammer and index) to translate Vedas which are not word for word tranlations.
Journalist is as good in English as Zakir Naik is in medicine, because I've read that book twice ..
haha this is an awesome reply
"na tasya pratima asti
"There is no image of Him."
"Andhatama pravishanti ye asambhuti mupaste"
"They enter darkness, those who worship the natural elements" (Air, Water, Fire, etc.). "They sink deeper in darkness, those who worship sambhuti."
[Yajurveda 40:9]7
Sambhuti means created things, for example table, chair, idol, Krishna,Ram etc.
@@armaan5977 brother makes a good point biradar are you medikal daktar..
@Artime Silk The wonderful practice of Falun Gong is a vision of heavenly secrets that can make sense of earthly realities.(Master Li Hongzhi)
@@armaan5977 I can't describe how wrong the translation is and how out of context they are because you decided to edit the sentences
As from my own personal experiences he is correct. And I have understood one lmpotant factor. A spiritual knowledge comes directly from God and when one has attain this. It is sometimes very difficult to impart that knowledge to the people out there. So this is one of the reasons many stay hidden in this world . Away from the others whose mindset is one way
We all fell here from Heaven because we sinned and our one and only aim should be trying to return home, which is Heaven. That was Christ's message. We all have chosen to play in the mud instead of seeking the Divine....................falun dafa
Impotant Factor? We'll your autocorrect also can't correct you - that shows how stubborn you are to rectify your own mistake.
If it comes from God, what business is it of yours, or Sadhguru’s, to ‘impart that knowledge’ ?
Are you going to second guess God ?
Also - can you be certain that God says exactly the same things to everyone ?
In the end, such notions are cosmic gossip, and have NOTHING to do with self realisation, nirvana or ‘knowledge’.
Seek and you will find.......................falun dafa
"Religion has caused far more deaths than any other activity in the world. "
100% agree.
Also, SG/JV is in love with his own voice... he keeps interrupting instead of allowing other person to make their statement. (you asked me a question!... no, he didn't)
Correct!
Well of course he intervened because he got framed and so he took control.
I would do the same thing and interrupt.
I think money is up there on the list
There are people/ Terrorists who kill in the name of religion . That doesn't mean religion us go be blamed .
The journalist is looking at Sadhguru process as a western religion that’s the problem he started wrong there for everything after that is going to be wrong 🙏🏾
THIS! Yes!
Yes this is the best observation among all comments. He is lacking the subconciuos or next level awakening in his mind
Lol, it does behave like a western religion, cuz it's still a religion ,lol, west or east holds no matter.
@@eu29lex16 it matters a lot
When you see from front to the lady's right is Amusement and to her left is Wisdom. You can easily make it out from her facial expressions while being silent all the time but saying through her eyes, face and attention to the golden words spoken.
Most women tend to fall for soft flowery speech on love, god, fantasy, mystical, spiritual jargons. Not ready for hard hitting questions. It's upto you to wear that mask or not. Personally I wouldn't care to impress sensationalist people like her.
What you are seeing in her are the reations of a mindless brainwashed robot follower. She has to smile to show her aleigence to the sad guruji...lol
Its not like she has a choice. She is following a program as per automation, and you are swallowing it all raw.
@@CT2507 Thats how you are called a Leftist and the left hand has one very big use every morning in India. Keep doing it and swallow it thereafter. lol Stupid idiots as always on a troll.
The gentleman is putting forward a very intellectual argument..just becos he is opposing satguru ..does not mean everyone shd clap without understanding a word spoken by satguru..
Loud voice is not always right
They could be paid employees/ audience who clap. 😄
@@srikanthd3560 ⁰
Earth is flat is scientific 🤣🤣🤣 and you believe in it because of kallamullah that means everything what is written in that holy book is right🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣
@@gamingrocks8537 do you listen a word bhugola... Gola means round...bhugola means earth...
Why Sadhguru is angry when interviewer asked. Sadhguru is nit even allowing to complete question.
Worth watching. They thankfully both shared what is on their minds peacefully, one louder and angrier then the other without threats, violence etc. It would be good for the world that everyone and country could do this peacfully and respectfully. Those leaders who escalate to violence and threats aboubt their religion are not leaders they are fools, cowards and liars and those that follow them are puppets and fools.
Sadhguru is a 'sad' and 'angry' guru every time he gets challenged 😂😂😂
0
@@custempo3040 it's literally in the name
@@custempo3040 OMG I'm going to say it ... The Emporer has no clothes!! 🙂
@@custempo3040 the way of avoiding being challenged by anyone who would think he could, not wasting time, and going straight to the business, at least of preferred one. Those who debate stay in debates, and there are those who not.
"I understand, lot of things are not understood" 😂😂😂... Before questioning like a intellect do basic study of the facts... Our science is not even 1 percent of the universe...
"The last part of the book which is bothering you is to take you to the next place...." Yorker frm sadguru...
Pranam 🙏
I loved that statement…a little gansta-guru right there. Da da da da dee
With due respect to Sadhguru I must say he is a escapist.
Knowing his weaknesses, he afraid that he will be exposed in public.
So he naver like to face any international Islamic debaters like Zakir Naik, Dr. Sabil Ahmed or others who never hesitate to dialogue or debate with any type of man/woman including atheists.
Because they are confident, Sadhguru isn't
@@Justin-tq9vv With due respect to Sadhguru I must say he is a escapist.
Knowing his weaknesses, he afraid that he will be exposed in public.
So he naver like to face any international Islamic debaters like Zakir Naik, Dr. Sabil Ahmed or others who never hesitate to dialogue or debate with any type of man/woman including atheists.
Because they are confident, Sadhguru isn't
Sadhguru judges and says he does not judge. 😮😮😮 and people are clapping 🤦♂️🤦♂️🤦♂️
The final sentence is priceless: "The last part of the book which is bothering you is to take you to the next place".
Yes. Brought him to counter him here. SG makes good use of his gift of gab😀
Dude get real .. as long as u don't believe someone can take you forward you don't move forward.. enjoy the journey and then questions.. may be u can be the guru .. to the person who guided you .. that's wat ..we have done .. if we did believe our primary school teacher.. were would have not learnt ABC .. it's not that .. teacher is god .
@@sandeepnarayan3642 AXIOMS Sandeep... Axioms.
@@kevinwilmore3604 wanderful sir
@@kevinwilmore3604 ....u need to look into Islam an stop with this high class low class nonsense
You can tell alot about a person by how they handle conflict
Bur our souls are immortal and our soul is what we should be concerned with.
He is right. Religion has made many wars in history. May we all live in peace whether we oppose another or not. Hold everyone with eyes of love and forgiveness
exactly and you can tell a lot by someone who doesnt answer questions especially ones that are more conflicted
what can you tell in this particular situation?
Yes what can tell, please explain. Thanks
Better to read complete works of Swami Vivekananda than to waste time on these attention seekers. This SG is a successful business and brand. Period.
Sadhguru did not address the main objection, which is the apparent contradiction between being skeptical and taking a leap of faith. Sadhfguru essentially misinterpreted the debater’s point of view as stating since I don’t understand it I don’t believe it. I wished the debater would have stuck to his main argument on this leap of faith, to explore this idea in greater depth. He has something there!
I'm not sure how this amounts to an insult. He's simply asking a question about writings that are self contradictory. And as a reply, he gets a convoluted guru word salad and moving the goal posts.
So right you are
But he is not ready to listen and making up things. I agree that whole game of energies and vibrations, we cant understand such things in one go.
....and you thought अंध भक्त belongs 2 muddy only..., poor man called sadguru and dying with his own weight ! Self marketing...God help him....
The book also elaborates on Meditation skills & practice. Hope who read the book to the end read that too.
Sadhguru tried to address his first logic flaw, about religion. They're both saying the same thing you need to search. They couldn't understand each other due to the hubris of judging without understanding. Sadhguru tried to raise this as the point, the other guy couldn't understand, so the conversation failed.
It seems to me that in order to understand Sadguru, it is wise to read a biography of Tolstoy written by a Frenchman with the surname Gilles. It helped me understand Tolstoy, and I can fully use it for Sadguru.
Could you summarize it
@@RifetOkic I can't summarize previously stated further.
I can only elaborate, but it has to be to a level that transcends this way of communicating.
The biography is titled with the surname: Tolstoy.
It is full of outwardly visible facts about Tolstoy's life.
Complete these facts - taken in summary - with data that Tolstoy is a horoscope virgin (which is also Sadguru) - and
here is the "revelation".Of course, it remains as a problem - knowing the conditioning carried by - virgins.
Don't compareTolstoy with this fraud.
Manuel,
From your comment, which is not on the line of administrative speech, I can only indirectly conclude (and indirectly - it means that mistakes are very possible).
From your sentence, it is likely that you consider Sadhguru a fraudster, and maybe, less likely but maybe also, that you also consider Tostoy a fraudster (who is so different from Sadhguru that you don't want a comparison due to different levels of success in deception).
My comment does not indicate that either of the two is a fraud. My comment only indicates the path for understanding Sadhguru.
In addition to the mentioned text about Tolstoy's life, I could also cite two more valuable texts - but those two texts are written in my native language, and it is unlikely that you can find them in any of the languages you use.
The overall theme delves into the characteristics of human individuals determined by their date of birth. For the sake of understanding, I can make the same comment in relation to Hegel, a more than well-known person - who "turned black" white philosophy a long time ago, completely without evil intentions.
I know I didn't make it easy for you, but - we are actually looking for the efforts ourselves.
Greeting!@@manuelscaria
@@manuelscariabest answer..
Science ends when there is no logic....when logic ends, religion or spirutuality starts. ..unfortunate, and surprised as to why Sadhguru is blamed for being religious. He hasnt promoted any religion or hasnt indulged in conversions, unlike my brothers from other religions....This journalist I am sure is totally confused and is also jealous of Sadhgurus popularity.
Science is For material seekers..
Religion is for the soul seekers
Religion is the biggest man-made fraud in this world.
Preachers and believers claim Hinduism is special. But it isn't special at all... Its one of the thousands religions or more that have existed since dawn of humanity, all of which claim divine revelation, all of which claim perfection, all of which proclaim infinite knowledge, uniqueness, beauty etc.. So Hinduism is a religion like any other. There's no difference, it proclaims just as Qur'an did, Bible etc did.(biggest similarity being a universe creator, which is Brahma in your book, but different in others). So Hinduism is one of those thousands religions which makes the same claim but mutually inconsistent ones so that they can all be correct. So,. Probability of it being correct is just 0.1% because its one of the thousands religions. But since all of them make the same claim without evidence means they are all incorrect.
Another fact is that hundreds and thousands of innocent worshippers including the imams and pandits are dying painful death in bomb blasts, terror attacks, air strikes etc. even while praying inside god's own mosques/temples.
That itself proves that god doesn't exist.
Just remove religion words from your comment and I will agree.
@@grvjensen Hind. is universal, inner peace and scientific. Oldest civ as well. It’s a way of life. You can be non believ or nastika, multiple paths lead to same destination, others can be gurus. Yet the ones attacked as pagan or infid. The 10 avatars of Ravaan align with Darwin theory. I say as a Sik. minor.
"Spirit, spirituality are real things " and fools will shallow it and gave up money and time to these idiots.
@@grvjensen if you are talking about logic and about the figure 0.1 % ,then you must tell us about the sourcre from where you get it .And also explain us what statistics you have used to chalk out the solution.
Waiting for your full answer.
I have been following Sadhguru for a while now. He has been an unexplainable help to me in my tough times. He is a source of infinite wisdom. Thats how i see him. He has brought me clarity in many things in my life which i was confused about. I am very Grateful for that.I see that this event is taking place in Kerala. And I am a Keralian. I am very happy to see this video because as a keralian I am seeing sadhguru sharing his wisdom for the first time in kerala. But I am also sad that he is sitting with this guy, who is not sure about what he is saying and is also very confident in his ignorant speech. All I want to say to Sadhguru is that, please do forgive this person for his inexcusable behaviour and please forgive us keralians(followers of Sadhguru), made you uncomfortable in any ways during this event or during your visit in Kerala. I hope you had other pleasant and memorable experiences from this place.🙏🙄
The advantage of having a book is that u can read it as many times u need to understand.
Thanks a lot sir, I follow sadguru, I love Sadgurus episods, but can't impliments in my life, help me sir
यू नो एव्रीथिंग बुत यू अरे नोट transrorm
Try the book Falun Gong.
The beautiful lady seating in between the heated debate is giving a very very cool and lovely smile to sooth and comfort the tensed audience ❤❤✨✨
Sadhguru we love u and with u always 🙏
The Bold man got an argument
Pranam Sadguru yeah I can understand you very well your answer is absolutely clear to me My Guru too speaks like you Congratulations Satguru you are really great
I need Sadhguru's locations in Nigeria, Africa please.
I must have to say Sadhguru is a escapist.
Knowing his weaknesses, he afraid that he will be exposed in public.
So he naver like to face any international Islamic debaters like Zakir Naik, Dr. Sabil Ahmed or others who never hesitate to dialogue or debate with any type of man/woman including atheists.
Because they are confident, Sadhguru isn't
Sadhguru's situation reminds me of what Mike Tyson once said. He said he always has to deal with people who think they have to fight him because defeating him would give them great credit. If you win, you become greater than Mike Tyson himself - this is what they think. So they are simply looking for a way to benefit from the status of whoever they are attacking. Apparently there are also many supposedly smart people who attack a man like Sadhguru just to profit from his status. There is no other way I can explain the tone of this debate. If you have a different opinion on the matter, then you can also do it respectfully and choose soft tones. But this was no argument in good faith.
I understand what u mean :}
Thank you so much 💐
Well said.
His opponent was speaking the truth and raising some good points. Maybe you should know that Mike Tyson might have been a great fighter and got fame doing that, but he was not an ideal human being or anyone to idolise and follow. I am surprised people are still following and defending Sadhguru after this.
@@dotcomwhiz … and another one. But believe me Buddy, I’m no valuable target. Nothing to gain here my friend.
When we have managed to tame our egos, perhaps wisdom will set in.
Well said
Jamais je viendrais tenir ce genre de conversation avec maître sadhguru. On doit respects aux guides spirituels. Ils faut écouter. Beaucoup. Savoir se taire quand on ne comprend pas tout aussi . Il y a une maniere de poser ses questions sans y aller par la confrontation . Il n y a que quelques mois que je visionne dans les shorts, de courts extraits de sadhguru. J éprouve un très grand respect pour cet homme. Le calme -parce que je le sens calme et non furieux-qu il sait garder devant cet impatient, c est ce que je travaille sur moi même. J admire son sang froid et sa patience. Ce n est pas donné à tout le monde. 🙏merci sadhguru🕊paix❤amour
If you do not challenge wisdom, how do you know what is and isn't wise. Putting knowledge to the test by asking questions and attempting to debunk it is apart of an intellectual conversation. Ain't nothing wrong with questioning the teacher, and if it is to you, then your missing the point the teacher is attempting to make.....or the teacher is a bad one
@@kazzythegypsy "il y a une manière de poser ses questions, sans y aller par la confrontation . " c est ce que je dis ici , les questions sont bienvenues, je suis d accord. C est de la.confrontation, que je remtes en question. Ton attitude. Maniere de parler, et que ce n est pas la place, ni le temps, justement,pour les débats. Peut être qu on ne comprends pas cette conversation de la même manière. J y vois quelque chose que vous ne voyez peut être pas.... le ton n est pas très jovial . C est tout. Et ca n à pas sa place. Ici. Désolée 🙏
Only one way you can gain knowledge by asking questions and challenging, teacher always feel proud when they are changed for their knowledge. Both need confidence in themselves the person who is asking n person who’s answering
gain knowledge by questioning, but you also gain knowledge by answering said question and he rarely answers the question in this vid
That man failed to differentiate between the religion and fundamentalism, Sadguru never encourages fundamental elements to create chaos in the society but people like this person who is questioning Sadguru creates divisions among the people by various ways with their self styled brain which is of no use. ---Niranjan Reddy
I am happy sadhguru is of benefit for so many people! And while he does carry much of indias ancient wisdom with him, I can't shake the feeling that his understanding barely crosses the intellectual. I just can't help but cringe seeing people with "the ego of not having an ego", he believes to be so much smarter that there is no point in letting the man finish his point, and then he ones again completely obscures the fact that he never gave an asnwer to the actual question at hand. Reminds me of the way he tried to justify cruelty against animals by pointing towards plants supposedly also screaming and hurting when beeing eaten. I mean come on that's an argument I'd expect from my drunk uncle at a family gathering but not a supposed guru.
Just pointing out that spirituality and science are like oil mixing with water. I can't think of anything more.. complex? than Sadhguru or one trying to put words to it. I might credit him for that.
Many people needs Sadhguru speech and his time for the solution to their problems. I don't know why people calling for debate.
Laughter is the highest answer to all questions, it transcends everything and unveils the union of the whole
Gee, and I thought it was wisdom.
Laughter or fake laughter is a condescending response of the ego to threat.
@@jimberlygridder183 There is a huge difference in genuine laughter and fake laughter.
They Master has behind him a great sadhana and got blessed with spiritual knowledge and command over spiritual subjects ... Salutations.
The title isn’t accurate. There’s no insult, just questioning his book.
It's time for people to rescue themselves
To be watching intellectual people debating over the abstract is like watching birds chirping in the greens. Means no business but feels sweet to listen. It's like you put your juicy mind to something that'll get nothing tangible except for a lofty aftereffect.
We all fell here from Heaven because we sinned and our one and only aim should be trying to return home, which is Heaven. That was Christ's message. We all have chosen to play in the mud instead of seeking the Divine....................falun dafa
Beautiful
😆nice one
I wonder how many people here has consentualised what Sadghuru said... I am 💯 with this man. All Sadghuru dis was "trying" to answer a question that kinda made sense for his followers and he was supported by the applause 👏🏻 🤣 from. The audience. Sadghure didn't answer the man's questions because he didn't understand it... he was trying to deal with his rage and ego... incoherence does not difuse critical thinkers...
I'm 24 & even I can understand what Sadhguru is projecting
Why can't this educated man
I did not understand - Why leap of "Faith" is necessary to 'go to the next phase' as claimed/ discussed in this debate. What is Faith? What is Leap-of-Faith? and Why that is necessary? If you have understood. Please help me!
just because your 24 does not make you a mature person, so your own statement itself is not right and you are talking about understanding the words of another man.
He is anti hindu thats why such people will never raise questions on other religions their prophets their beliefs their myths
@@hemantkumayan3663 mature ? Were he said that , he only said he can understand but this old educated experienced fellow cant.
If you are sincerely interested in spiritual enlightenment, Falun Gong is for you.
Fake title...😂😂😂Sadhguru no angry...interlocutor is angry😂😂😂
I thought Sadhguru thought us not to get angry 🥺🙂🙂🙂
Sadhguru never taught us anything..He told us to act as the situation demands 😂
I must have to say Sadhguru is a escapist.
Knowing his weaknesses, he afraid that he will be exposed in public.
So he naver like to face any international Islamic debaters like Zakir Naik, Dr. Sabil Ahmed or others who never hesitate to dialogue or debate with any type of man/woman including atheists.
Because they are confident, Sadhguru isn't
@@janmejaypandey2424 I must have to say Sadhguru is a escapist.
Knowing his weaknesses, he afraid that he will be exposed in public.
So he naver like to face any international Islamic debaters like Zakir Naik, Dr. Sabil Ahmed or others who never hesitate to dialogue or debate with any type of man/woman including atheists.
Because they are confident, Sadhguru isn't
If you wanna understand Sadguru's lines then you've to make sure that you are a better human than common people..
Wow. Calling people common is very judgmental. No one is above another or below.
Better? I think you want to say dumber.
It's good to have this,we all are learning from each other Sorry sir I stand with Sadghuru.Peace is allways the Best.
Jaggi Vasudev needs to understand that no one in this universe is hundred percent perfect. We cannot correct our flaws unless we realize so.
In engineering, no product can be realized to the absolute value. Hence we have variations or tolerances for the absolute values.
The same variations are applicable to human beings also. Knowingly Jaggi Vasusev and his ISHA YOGA FOUNDATION are committing a lot of mistakes and attempting to justify the flaws. We, people need to be aware of these.