I just realized when they shot the guy running out of the door which is how the door broke in the first place, there aren’t any bullet holes to be seen anywhere even though the guy clearly started spraying all over the place when he saw he was getting away
The reason the door shuts just fine when Mexican Bob walks out (3:37) is because Oswaldo and Joe are right behind the door to close it shut as was revealed in Chapter four.
Goggle products How does it make no sense? Makes perfect sense to me. Also if huge corporations are creating his movies wouldnt they make them so fools like u understand and like them? U sound better suited watching ur conspiracy videos on youtube
@Goggle products Lol didn't make sense? You have got to be a total idiot for this movie not to make sense. It's one of the easiest movies to understand I've even watched, and you clearly don't have a good taste in movies. Ill just assume that you only watch Toy Story and Transformers as even if I didn't like this movie, I could see why people like it. Also on another note, stop copy and pasting your comment as a reply to people who like the movie, it's kinda a dick move.
Too many Michael Bay fans in here looking for a super hero landing instead of recognizing the genius of authenticity that is this movies raw story and telling of it.
Its kindof a running joke in this channel to act like any movie they're reviewing is really boring and or terrible, regardless of whether most people liked it or not.
There's crucifixes in the road crosses, about 2-3 m tall, i think it was one of those coveref in snow, cause i don't think a tomb in the middle of nowhere has a cross made of carved stone
It's a nod to Sergio Leone's and Sergio Corbucci's old westerns, that often started with the hero walking/riding past a cross/tombstone. (Which also was a nod to old japanese samurai movies that often had the hero walking past a shrine in the beginning).
I'm told it was three hours long, but I don't know myself because I fell asleep about forty minutes in. And I really like westerns, and was really looking forward to this one. Massive disappointment.
yes and its directly borrowed from boettichers tall t where bandits hi jack a station and dump the previous people in the well.from the story by elmore leonard of whom tarantino is a fan!also the movie is a tribute to the era of tv westerns which all ran this kind of story.kurt russel acted in them and sams name charles warren is alluding to charles marquise warren who wrote most of the scripts! there is a have gun will travel with people marooned in a stage stop one out to kill paladin which is v similar the villain is in a coffin!
That's a very good point, but like Lord Voldemort said, the water was already in the haberdashery since the time from them dumping the dead bodies and going back inside to prepare for Warren, Ruth, Mannix, and Domergue was very limited, I doubt they'd have the time or the inkling to do so. The coffee was probably just old.
In a snowstorm especially, you would think they wouldn't taint the water with dead bodies. Dump them in the snow or put them in the barn, the well is a place people would frequent often enough to see blood at least.
Are y'all really all that damn dumb? There's an entirely separate water barrel inside, that came from the well, likely well before there were any bodies in it. Unless they happened to run out, at that moment. Which in winter is pretty unlikely. And he said the coffee tasted like Mexican feet, not the water it was made from.
The composer for this movie, Ennio Morricone, who also wrote the soundtrack for the Good, the Bad and the Ugly, died 4 years and 1 day after this video's release. May he rest in peace.
I dislike when probabilities in movies are being questioned, like, two people meeting each other in the middle of nowhere. If the universe has taught me anything - it is that anything is possible. And the whole point of a movie is to tell an interesting story, not a bland one.
It was probable that in the life of this totally average boy who was going home from school, nothing would happen. And that is exactly what's happened. The End. 10/10 totally probable movie, would watch again!
The letter did get the major on the stage coach, if u paid attention this wasnt their first meeting, they had a state dinner 8 months ago, the deal about protecting thr bounty came latter on after meeting mannex.
There are actually several completely different accents in England. They are as different as say, any American and Australian accent . Roth here opts for the only 2 that are familiar to Americans, standard upper class posh one and cockney (London). Newcastle, Liverpool, Birmingham, Bristol and Manchester accents sound completely different to these but they are pretty much never heard outside the UK, probably because audiences might complain they can't understand them.
In regard to Minnie's convenient hatred of Mexicans: note how, in the flashback of the gang arriving, Minnie doesn't object to Bob's presence or treat him any differently. Minnie didn't hate Mexicans and she never had a sign over the bar - it was the fact that Bob didn't know this, and believed Warren, that finally confirmed his guilt in Warren's mind.
3:47 As someone who does unnecessary research on medieval hangman’s and a bit more modern executioners for a living I think I might be able to help out (although it’s a few years too late now)! At least if the judicial system of 19th century America is comparable with the European one. The executioner was actually paid by the executions he committed. The more executions the more money for the hangman. There where certain death-sentences more profitable than others and they where sentenced over the punished one depending on their crime. The _breaking on the wheel_ (a penalty where you get chained to a wooden carriage wheel and get your extremities smashed with a metal bat one by one before you are left, hanging there and waiting for your death) was the most profitable one for the hangman. The burning on the stake was also quite money-making and the classic _hanging till death_ was actually the least lucrative death sentence for the executioner. If there were just a few death-sentences the hangman was either responsible for more than one city or he had to find another source of income, for example basic medical help, flaying or keeping the canals clean. Over all the alternatives for a professional hangman weren’t that great. So I get that Pete/Oswaldo is quite happy that his income is a bit saver thanks to John. (English isn’t my first language, so I’m terribly sorry for every mistake here. Greetings from Austria!)
Very well written and good English. Thank you for the information on the history of The Hangman helps enjoy the movie even more knowing historical context.
At 3:37, it shut "just fine" because the other two characters inside were closing and nailing it for him. We're shown this later. I don't know how you missed this considering you had the watch the entire movie all the way through at least twice just to get the bonus round edits.
@@DNotzz That's the whole point of the channel though. He's not an expert it's just for fun. He notices a thousand things we don't but occasionally it works the other way around.
@@richardzazanis4764 he does notice quite a few things though that i wouldnt really notice. The funny thing is.now, whenever me and my wife are watching a movie, we point out things that would be "sins" now lol we were watching "concussion" with Will Smith the other day and were noticing quite a few. however, you are right, some things he counts as a sin, are things that are meant to be that way for a reason, or are things that he has overlooked. My main one is when he is doing "pet sematary", and he sins it for them "misspelling the word 'cemetery'". Even though, if youve read the book, or know ANYTHING about the book, you would know that it IS purposely misspelled that way. So they didnt misspell it and not catch it like he insinuates. it was MEANT to be spelled that way
My dad and I talked about the "Minnie don't like Mexicans" / Minnie's-indiscriminate-hospitality discrepancy, and my dad suggested that the former bit was a lie, just to gauge Señor Bob's reaction. If he had actually known Minnie, he could easily dispute that; but his eyes widened instead, meaning that he bought the lie and thus did *not* know Minnie. Also, this is called a haberdashery (men's clothing store), but instead, it's a restaurant. How did this not get sinned?
No it's called minnie Haberdashery the same way you call a restaurant the great whale. Also wouldn't the blood on the chair and all the other clue enough to shoot him
Also, the haberdashery thing was in the script. "Oh. Haberdashery. I get it. That was a joke." It was also detailed in the script that Minnie thought "Haberdashery" sounded cool.
"my dad suggested that the former bit was a lie, just to gauge Señor Bob's reaction." I haven't seen this since it came out (which I saw on Christmas in its 70 mm glory, btw), but wasn't there actually a sign or something hanging somewhere that actually said no Mexicans or spicks or something? I could be wrong, but I'm pretty sure I remember seeing that.
Yep. I also think it’s Samuel L Jackson’s finest work, and when you say that about a guy who has done as many films and been in as many classics as he has, that’s saying something.
Sins jump from 29 to 31 then to 33 without extra dings. 34 to 36, 38 to 40, 51 to 48?, 48 to 54, 59 to 55?, I'm choosing to believe this is a covert homage to Tarantino's disordered time story telling technique.
John Ruth let’s Warren in so he can read the letter from “Lincoln” which they address later... He let’s in Chris Mattox because he’s scared Mattox may be telling the truth about being the new sheriff. No sins needed.
"got me on that coach didn't it?" This is actually true. Because they knew each other before then and what john respects of marquis, or rather, what has him interested in marquis as being a decent acquaintance, is the fact he found out about him having that letter from lincoln. So he sees Marquis as a man that can be trusted enough. So due to that letter, he knew he can trust him to have on the coach with him.
Like thinking dropping a dying match on a wet wooden floor of a stage coach is the same as dropping it into kerosene. Most of these sins are weak attempts at grasping for minor quibbles, many not even being problems. But eh.
Guysguysguys, may I interrupt you right there. If you are taking his sins seriously then please.just.leave. Get a sense of humor or begone. We dont need no "Mr. Right" people here, since were just having fun watching these videos. Instead of ruining that for us watch something YOU can enjoy. Maybe a bible documentary idk.
The thing that shocked me the most about this movie was how Chris Maddox ended up being the real hero of the whole thing...didn't see that coming. Also, most satisfying (fictional) hanging ever.
Dude, in that age, the odds of survival if the bullets misses the artery are still kinda shit. At least his legs won't be fixed. They might even have to cut it off. But I suppose he could live.
Loved the movie actually. Fun fact about this movie. It was originally planned to be a sequel to Django Unchained. Samuel Jackson's character was originally meant to be Django but then Tarantino realized that having Django in the film would ruin the movies atmosphere of not being able to trust anybody. If Django was in the film you'd be rooting for him the whole time because we already know his story. Instead they were all made to be strangers so you'd being thinking nobody was off limits from being the liar.
For me it was just the over feel of the movie. I am Canadian and we get a lot of snow, so a lot of the movie resonated with me. not only that but I really like how mysterious it is. I mean it's like the wild west, but you see another side to it. the movie reveals that the wild west was not only about revolvers and such but there was a whole other part to survival especially with the extreme weather.
Charles VanDergrift I loved the tension in the movie. These characters were all put in one room and you can feel in your bones how much they want to either kill each other or distrust each other but have zero idea as to why until the film reveals itself. It's great.
Agreed. The attention to detail in the movie is next level the sins guy just isn’t bright enough to see most of the threads. The only thing he’s right about is it not being 100% realistic (like Warren shooting Bob and the blood coming dramatically from above the shot) but those things are probably intentional as kind of a parody/homage to westerns like when Django kills Calvin Candy’s sister and she flies away abruptly. If there are unrealistic elements, they’re there for entertainment or fantastical story telling.
They do, you’re totally right, I guess CinemaSins needs it’s own sin counter. It’s like they just glanced over the movie and tried to make everything a sin
WhatAreYouBuyen I'm glad someone else noticed this! In chapter 4: The Four Passengers...they show Joe Gage and Oswaldo nailing the door shut after Bob goes outside to greet the "guests".
In The Hateful Eight you say that it was a sin because mini didn't give bob a mean look even though she is suppose to not like Mexicans. Major Mark West was lying about Mini hating Mexicans to see if Bob would correct him, which he didn't so he knew bob was lying.
If Mini didn't like Mexicans, that doesn't mean she would be openly prejudice to bob. Either way major mark west saying that would have made bob unsure of himself which is why he got shot.
-Dude make up your mind whether you think Minnie disliked or liked mexicans, just don't change it to the convenience of this dumb movie. "Either way major mark west saying that would have made bob unsure of himself which is why he got shot." -It wouldn't at all, by mentioning the sign he is implying she highly disliked mexicans, since she didn't did anything to Bob, he would had surely know that wasn't true.
The guy who made this video does not have the brain power to understand the subtilities of a Tarantino movie. Most of those "sins" is just him being too stupid to understand what is going on.
The guitar scene hurts my soul, lol. Everyone on set thought it was one of the props at the moment, but Jennifer knew it wasn't because she had been taking it home and playing it, she knew it was a priceless museum piece. Kurt felt so bad he nearly teared up, and Tarantino got Jennifer a similar one from the 1880s as a gift after filming because she loved that guitar so much. But yep, that's what over $40,000 of Martin guitar looks like smashed off a post.
Eh just some old crap made by some dead assholes from a couple generations ago. Plenty of old crap in the world and im sure they made a thousand of those suckers in their day. Fuck it
Plot twist: Tarantino and Russell executed a plan to destroy the real Martin all along to get the *million dollar shot* so to speak. When I watched Kurts interview about how it went down it made me think that only they knew what they were doing to solidify its place in cinema history. (Kurt is an ACTOR so it would be very easy for him to be “close to tears” and distraught. That’s literally what he does for a living.
@@josephsalmonte4995 What's bollocks? that the guitar was genuine or that it wasn't an accident? The guitar was real alright. The Martin museum no longer loan out instruments because of this very scene.
“When bob walked out the door shut just fine” - at the end of the movie we see that his partners were behind him closing the door wishing him good luck
Well, he would be good in any role in any movie, perhaps even all roles. If someone made one of thems deep fake videos where everybody was Christoph Waltz, I'd watch it.
-5 more sins for the fact that Morricone wrote and orchestrated this score in a MONTH! For scale, John Williams spent a year on The Force Awakens and didn't orchestrate it himself.
To be fair, he did re-use A LOT of his unused score from The Thing, as well as sampling stuff from classic films such as The Exorcist. It was less a score and more a remix.
+Thomas Broome-Jones "A LOT" ? No. It's 2 unused 1 minutes songs from The Thing, used 2 times each, in a 3h long movie. It's not "A LOT". It's barely "enough".
I would've sinned the fact that Minnie and her family were shot in that place. I doubt you clean off all that blood from wooden floors without anybody noticing
8:03 the reason that floorboard fella just decided to start shooting is because the sheriff was about to start executing members of his gang, it was a distraction to buy his guys some time to draw their own guns, but joe mcgruff or what ever his name was doesn’t have his gun, and apparently Oswaldo has terrible aim so ultimately it doesn’t really work and only sets up the major and the sheriff to die later
MrPonyboy95 Oh, I thought he did in the scene where he interrogated a guy who did something to Mr Wallace. Or Am I remembering the right scene and just got characters mixed up?
+Eric Breaux well Jules (Sam Jackson) and Vincent shot a guy down for something they did (I don't remember what) but it wasn't in the dick There was another scene, though, where Marcellus is raped and when Butch (Bruce Willis) comes back and saves him, he shoots the rapist in the dick with a shot gun.
+Eric Breaux there are two scenes I think you're blending together. Jules (Sam Jackson) shot a guy down for something he did to Marcellus. There's another scene where Marcellus himself is raped and when Butch (played by Bruce Willis) saves him, Marcelkus shoots the rapist in the crotch with a shotgun.
+Ron M no bro pulpfiction is cult movie and killbil is a bit quite strange but it is cool. in 5 years you would change your and will love this movie bro😉👍
3:43 YES! Tim Roth was good in this movie, sure, but try to tell me this role wasn't written for Christoph Waltz. I know that Waltz didn't want to be in this film, but Roth's character was 100% written for Waltz.
you could drop a lit match on any hardwood creation in history and as long as it isnt soaked in fing gasoline it would never catch on fire...especially in a wet coach full of wet wood...that was a lame stretch for a sin!
That's pretty much all of the "sins" he mentions, a lame stretch. This was pretty much the worst idea for a comical review idea i've ever watched. First of all, not funny just because he speaks quickly, not original either (self explanatory) and worst of all, seriously grasping for straws at almost all times.
That wasnt the point. It's just the fact that people do that for comical effect. Actually my point is that it's easy to speak quickly, escpecially while editing videos so the opposite of you're very lame "burn". I see where you draw inspiration from. Grasp at that straw.
Waiting to see if someone else caught that. Glad you did. It tripped me up the first time I saw the movie; I thought "Hey, that's a sin!" And Tarantino explains it later.
? Probably would sit their like any normal person. They just released they could make a living sinning movies? Literally 95% of the films they sin they enjoy like any other person.
Also keep in mind that most of the sins they point out these days aren't sins at all. Unless they really consider reading a sin. Which... I don't know, they might.
Personally, despite all the racial ugliness and the woman abuse, I really liked this movie. I just chalk it up to the fact that that's pretty close to how things were back then. I picked up on the pen pal thing, too, though, lol!
I also picked up on the fact that Minnie was just as friendly to Senor Bob as she was to the rest of Jody's gang. Still....her random dislike of Mexicans can be for a whole variety of reasons. Many people have unreasonable aversions towards other people. It's not right, but that's how it is. People are irrational sometimes, and sometimes, what seems irrational to us may be perfectly justifiable to the person.
9:20 I am almost certain the cellar is just that, a cellar not a full blown basement it’s only below the trap door and does not extend to the rest of the floor, while floorboard fella could take a shot at the sheriff he would almost certainly miss.
I can't believe he left it in the movie because her reaction immediately took me out of the story. I was watching this at home the first time I saw it, not in a movie theater, so when I saw that, I immediately paused the thing and Googled "hateful eight real guitar" and found the story about it. It's a shame it happened but at that moment, JJL was no longer acting and it showed.
Maybe not, but I can definitely see him and six of my wiseass friends sitting on a couch watching a DVD, knocking back brews and having a good old time with him.
+KomodoDojo No, it was not the best movie of 2015. Fury Road, Inside Out, The Revenant, The Big Short, Joy, Jurassic World, The Walk, Black Mass, ... you know what ... name a genre and I'll name a better movie from 2015 off the top of my head. Snow? Revenant. Action? Fury Road. Western? Western starring Kurt Russell? Bone Tomahawk. Look it up. 50 times better and it is both a western and stars Kurt Russell. And it was released in 2015. I can throw out better 70mm movies. I can name two movies with Sam Jackson that are better (Chi-Raq and Age of Ultron). You can't even spell Tarantino's name. You don't know shit about movies. Go home kid. Lay down in bed and cry.
+Rhys Clark Interactive Media (RhysClark97) Fury Road was my second favorite film of the year. Ive seen 7/8 Tarantino films, but death proof. I loved Hateful, IMO he's never done a bad film and I enjoyed the hell out of it like all the rest. No need to play favorites. All unique and wonderful.
+Speeetz Eaasy dude your entitled to your opinion but I can't take what youre saying seriously when you think JW, Ultron, Revenant, Joy are good films.
+Speeetz Eaasy i saw the big short (really liked it) the revenant (snoozefest, but incredible cinematography/direction) in 2016 at the cinema, so thats a different list for me
+Zack Radakovich When and where? I searched RUclips for "Cinemasins Zootopia" and I scrolled through their video list, going over 6 months back, and couldn't find anything.
If you're talking about the channel, they do that as a joke, this is obvious. Now if people wants to deny reality, the so called "safe space" that we have nowadays... Well, it's their retardation, just leave it be lol
Because it's his favorite word and any time he can use it in a movie, he does. It's sort of like how in a lot of movies, if they briefly show a shot of someone's bare feet, you ignore it. In a Tarantino movie, you say "Wow, here we go again."
I know, right? Do these same people complain about Lil Wayne saying nigga or virtually all the current “rap stars” using the “n” word? It’s total bullshit. It gives people the opportunity to express outrage whenever they choose whether or not they are experiencing outrage thus they use it as a crutch to vent their frustrations - Black OR White
I just saw this movie on Netflix! And I noticed you sinned at 3:40 how the door closed just fine, and after watching the extended version in the last chapter it shows that Pete and Grouch closed the door behind Marco when he walked outside to meet Ruth when they arrived to Minnie’s. Not a big deal but I finally have a reason to comment on one of your videos lol. Love the content!
brandon242 I mean the song was very upbeat and like a pop song that it felt more of this day and age music than what enio did with the score to make it feel like a western
It was boring in the first half because it tried to be a mystery movie and failed. Then it sucked in the second half because I don't know what he was trying to do there. Make an advertisement for blood squibs I guess. It certainly wasn't tense or anything like that. What a worthless movie.
I think this movie was good. I mean the ending was satisfying and the acting was great but I don't consider it one of Quentin Tarantino's best films. Django Unchained, Inglorious Bastards, & Pulp Fiction are his best to me by far.
"Inglorious basterds" one of his best ? HAHAHAHA, dude no. Pulp Fiction and Django, yeah, but also Kill Bill and Reservoir Dogs. Tho I agree with you on the Hateful 8.
PHNeutre49 While Kill Bill & Reservoir Dogs is his absolute best work, Inglorious Bastards is *to me* one of *my* favorite films. It's well shot, Hans Landa is the best and terrifying character, the ending is beautiful, and the dialogue though in a different language is solid.
wonder mike cant you just fuck off you were literally just making a joke about the other guys mom like what are you 12, you know what, you probably are
Jams m XD, he's just like, " oh shucks jilerkers mom, please give it back, I need to hate more comments.... GODAMMIT MOM, YOU NEVER LET ME DO THINGS, YOUR NOT EVEN MY REAL DAD, GODAMMIT!!!"
This movie is essentially a fantasy. It's hyper-stylish, overwritten and tightly wound in its plot. I don't think necessarily pointing out anachronistic or bizarre plot holes-just appreciate it for the weird, trippy film it is. That's what I think, anyway.
That's why I hate this video. Yes the movie as all tarantino movies are prolonged and can be seen as boring but have many things to be respected for and cherry picking every fucking scene for sins on realism and sound effects and personal preferences to make a 10 minute video, when you can actually critisise the many faults the movie has is very ironic. Completely loses a point expect comedic value , which he fails to be good at. I'd prefer to rewatch the movie twice than this video again.
Is sinning every single use of the N- word really fair? That wasn't as much a racial slur as just common speech for when this movie is supposed to take place, also the use of it in excess is one of Tarantino's staples
2:14 I'm pretty sure that's intentional. Tarantino banks a lot on coincidental encounters, like when Butch found Marcellus casually walking the street in Pulp Fiction. I don't think I could really admit that sin.
The whole way the introduction chapter was set up had a feeling of self-awareness about how coincidental it is that they all met up on the road. I know Tarantino was being cheeky,but it kind of just felt like a lazy way to deliver exposition and to introduce the characters.
More sins (regarding language): - The use of “yonder” is a hypercorrectionism. - The accent of Chris Mannix didn’t exist back in the day in South Carolina. - The Kiwi woman in this movie also has an accent that not yet emerged (New Zealand accent) at that time.
I'm surprised you sinned for John taking the cuff off to let her eat, but not for when they are laying out in the snow after she gets punched out for spitting on the letter, and then fucking WALKS AWAY, leaving her laying way back behind them and the wagon while they look away from her.
If you're only counting movies from the 90s and onward, sure. If you count every movie then no. Unless you're one of those people who thinks IMDB votes matter.
The only sin I’ll pay for is the sin of watching this movie over again and over again, this movie was cinematic goddesses levels and I will not apologize for perfectly every second of it. Quentin Tarantino opens the inside of his mind and we are so blessed to enjoy it
Cinematic goddesses? What the hell are those? Sounds to me like a bunch of movie theater Karens who won't shut up or stop texting during the movie. I think what you meant to say was Cinematic God, especially since all deities are men. If any gods were female, the universe would have imploded just seconds after it came into existence purely out of spite.
![Felix "Unfair" | [Stray Kids : SKZ-PLAYER]](http://i.ytimg.com/vi/Oswujxm2Ag0/mqdefault.jpg)
The only sin of this movie, is that it made me pay for a whole seat, but I only used the edge of it for the whole 3 hours of it
Pastor of Muppets very underrated comment!
Amazing comment, thats quotable .
I don't get it
Lol
@@JulianFikry he meant that he was at the edge of his seat for the whole time since it was so enthralling.
The reason the door was fine when Bob walked out is because you later find out that the two other gang members were nailing it shut
Oswaldo Mobray & Joe Gage were nailing it behind Bob
I think he dont watch the entire movie....
Jeremy feigns ignorance sometimes to pad the sin count.
I just realized when they shot the guy running out of the door which is how the door broke in the first place, there aren’t any bullet holes to be seen anywhere even though the guy clearly started spraying all over the place when he saw he was getting away
Well obviously, I think most people actually watch it immediately realize it. But the video maker just couldn’t.
The reason the door shuts just fine when Mexican Bob walks out (3:37) is because Oswaldo and Joe are right behind the door to close it shut as was revealed in Chapter four.
Goggle products go bait elsewhere
Sin for @CinemaSins +1
Goggle products How does it make no sense? Makes perfect sense to me. Also if huge corporations are creating his movies wouldnt they make them so fools like u understand and like them? U sound better suited watching ur conspiracy videos on youtube
@Goggle products Lol didn't make sense? You have got to be a total idiot for this movie not to make sense. It's one of the easiest movies to understand I've even watched, and you clearly don't have a good taste in movies. Ill just assume that you only watch Toy Story and Transformers as even if I didn't like this movie, I could see why people like it. Also on another note, stop copy and pasting your comment as a reply to people who like the movie, it's kinda a dick move.
Too many Michael Bay fans in here looking for a super hero landing instead of recognizing the genius of authenticity that is this movies raw story and telling of it.
I had no problems sitting through this movie. Wasn't boring to me at all.
some people are, idk stupid? lmao
Same
@@mysticaltenderman749 they can go watch a film with The Rock in it.
Its kindof a running joke in this channel to act like any movie they're reviewing is really boring and or terrible, regardless of whether most people liked it or not.
@@nukacolacompany2534 I see
Major sin for not knowing the roadside cross is a grave.
There's crucifixes in the road crosses, about 2-3 m tall, i think it was one of those coveref in snow, cause i don't think a tomb in the middle of nowhere has a cross made of carved stone
It is extremely rare to mark a grave with a crucifix; a cross, yes, a crucifix, no.
It's a nod to Sergio Leone's and Sergio Corbucci's old westerns, that often started with the hero walking/riding past a cross/tombstone. (Which also was a nod to old japanese samurai movies that often had the hero walking past a shrine in the beginning).
@@madselmvig1457 thank you
@@madselmvig1457 Can't believe the guy who runs this channel acts like he's a film buff but can't een recognize blatant stuff like that lol
I give you 10 sins for complaining about the 70mm landscape shots.
Nolan and PTA did it better.
@@Onmysheet haha no
Why's that so funny for you to disagree?
@@Onmysheet the only thing that Nolan is better than Tarantino is the mediocrity
What makes Nolan better is he doesn't create self absorbed characters.
Well to be honest, there’s about 28 people in all of Wyoming and yes, we do know most of each other.
Only state with lower population density than Wyoming is Alaska, which would easily move past Wyoming if they weren't too proud to count caribou.
What's a Wyoming?
now that's gold
Not to mention it's late 1800's early 1900's so cut that in half
Michael Nuss that’s a beautiful place if anyone tries to destroy it I’m running out in that country and shooting them like a cowboy
the fact that a whole 3 hour movie is shot in a single room that gets you hooked shows what a great film this is
I'm told it was three hours long, but I don't know myself because I fell asleep about forty minutes in. And I really like westerns, and was really looking forward to this one. Massive disappointment.
Ew I just remembered that Kurt’s character said the water tasted like shit, and then they dumped the bodies in the well 🤢🤢🤢
yes and its directly borrowed from boettichers tall t where bandits hi jack a station and dump the previous people in the well.from the story by elmore leonard of whom tarantino is a fan!also the movie is a tribute to the era of tv westerns which all ran this kind of story.kurt russel acted in them and sams name charles warren is alluding to charles marquise warren who wrote most of the scripts! there is a have gun will travel with people marooned in a stage stop one out to kill paladin which is v similar the villain is in a coffin!
That's a very good point, but like Lord Voldemort said, the water was already in the haberdashery since the time from them dumping the dead bodies and going back inside to prepare for Warren, Ruth, Mannix, and Domergue was very limited, I doubt they'd have the time or the inkling to do so. The coffee was probably just old.
Plus Russell used the well water to make the new Bach of coffee so the new batch would have been tainted the same way
In a snowstorm especially, you would think they wouldn't taint the water with dead bodies. Dump them in the snow or put them in the barn, the well is a place people would frequent often enough to see blood at least.
Are y'all really all that damn dumb? There's an entirely separate water barrel inside, that came from the well, likely well before there were any bodies in it. Unless they happened to run out, at that moment. Which in winter is pretty unlikely. And he said the coffee tasted like Mexican feet, not the water it was made from.
the sin at 3:40 is nullified because of what we find out later about the 2 guys nailing it shut after he walked out
yuup
Yea, they're kinda the worst at what they do
I personally thought this movie was incredibly well done and fantastic
I'd leave out the narration and make the movie at least 30 minutes shorter by cutting out most of the cinematic scenes.
@Goggle products i guess u dont know anything about cinematic art....or culture....or life
Goggle products ur IQ is obviously too low. i’m surprised you even managed to construct a well written paragraph
@@balkanianslav7213 if you think this is cinematic art, you must know as little yourself.
bunetoff Okay, what do you consider cinematic art?
The composer for this movie, Ennio Morricone, who also wrote the soundtrack for the Good, the Bad and the Ugly, died 4 years and 1 day after this video's release. May he rest in peace.
Damn I knew this movies soundtrack had the same feeling as the man with no name trilogy.
Also The Thing!
I dislike when probabilities in movies are being questioned, like, two people meeting each other in the middle of nowhere. If the universe has taught me anything - it is that anything is possible. And the whole point of a movie is to tell an interesting story, not a bland one.
Just because it's a movie doesn't mean every person in Wyoming knows each other
It was probable that in the life of this totally average boy who was going home from school, nothing would happen. And that is exactly what's happened. The End. 10/10 totally probable movie, would watch again!
Stop defending faulty writing.
"faulty writing"
lmao
Stuff like that just stands out more in a shitty movie.
Beginning reminds me of the 2hour intro to rdr2
ik
True
It's not that long
W*l*d Kh4n it was definitely flex on the graphics
@@wk5867 whoosh
4:40
You are correct. There are only 20 people in Wyoming.
That's about right, sounds lovely.
Still more than North Dakota .
2msvalkyrie actually Wyoming is the least populated state
Wyoming doesn’t exist
@@skoll6007 I think you're onto something
The letter did get the major on the stage coach, if u paid attention this wasnt their first meeting, they had a state dinner 8 months ago, the deal about protecting thr bounty came latter on after meeting mannex.
u r rite
Exactly and it was John Roth that brought up the letter, so he knew before hand
"Tim Roth isn't Christoph Waltz in this scene." Yes, yes, and yes.
Even though i really like tim roth
Exactly. :)
+Noize Saitama🙌🏼💯
Christoph Waltz was two busy helping Jamie Foxx become a badass. But I totally agree.
+westnile21 🙌👏 BOI
I always thought it was funny that Tim Roth’s character is pretending to have a different English accent then his real English accent
I found it boring he's always flexing that ability in Tarantino movies... Gets old, just like the Red Apple.
It’s pretty easy doing a British accent if you’re already British. Still a talented actor though.
Maurice Haynes America is much larger than Britain. And the British language doesn’t change that much in different places.
There are actually several completely different accents in England. They are as different as say, any American and Australian accent . Roth here opts for the only 2 that are familiar to Americans, standard upper class posh one and cockney (London). Newcastle, Liverpool, Birmingham, Bristol and Manchester accents sound completely different to these but they are pretty much never heard outside the UK, probably because audiences might complain they can't understand them.
There’s north then south. Not difficult.
In regard to Minnie's convenient hatred of Mexicans: note how, in the flashback of the gang arriving, Minnie doesn't object to Bob's presence or treat him any differently. Minnie didn't hate Mexicans and she never had a sign over the bar - it was the fact that Bob didn't know this, and believed Warren, that finally confirmed his guilt in Warren's mind.
Never noticed, thank you for point that out
Same with the likely real events of smithers son. Either he did kill him quickly or he knew enough about him to fabricate the story and kill him
3:47 As someone who does unnecessary research on medieval hangman’s and a bit more modern executioners for a living I think I might be able to help out (although it’s a few years too late now)! At least if the judicial system of 19th century America is comparable with the European one.
The executioner was actually paid by the executions he committed. The more executions the more money for the hangman. There where certain death-sentences more profitable than others and they where sentenced over the punished one depending on their crime. The _breaking on the wheel_ (a penalty where you get chained to a wooden carriage wheel and get your extremities smashed with a metal bat one by one before you are left, hanging there and waiting for your death) was the most profitable one for the hangman. The burning on the stake was also quite money-making and the classic _hanging till death_ was actually the least lucrative death sentence for the executioner.
If there were just a few death-sentences the hangman was either responsible for more than one city or he had to find another source of income, for example basic medical help, flaying or keeping the canals clean. Over all the alternatives for a professional hangman weren’t that great. So I get that Pete/Oswaldo is quite happy that his income is a bit saver thanks to John.
(English isn’t my first language, so I’m terribly sorry for every mistake here. Greetings from Austria!)
You speak very good english
Your English is better than most people I know lmao. Thx for the history on executioners, was pretty interesting
Güten tag, abent oder morgen von die Niederlande!
Very well written and good English. Thank you for the information on the history of The Hangman helps enjoy the movie even more knowing historical context.
For someone knowing English as a second language, you speak it very fluently
3:38 that's a sin one you guys CinemaSins ... later in the movie we see they nailed the door behind him
Gdrgm yep
No that's not it. The door won't shut correctly (so got to nail it shut) but it shuts just fine earlier.
And at 1:17 and 5:58 as we later learn it was because of the Lincoln Letter and they completely forget.
nope. that was marquis showing ruth his bounty papers for the dead guys in the road. :)
+Iosif I Yep, I think that the letter is the reason John let Warren on the coach.
At 3:37, it shut "just fine" because the other two characters inside were closing and nailing it for him. We're shown this later. I don't know how you missed this considering you had the watch the entire movie all the way through at least twice just to get the bonus round edits.
Sir Duckyweather because he is a pretentious idiot who doesn’t know half of what he pretends to.
@@DNotzz That's the whole point of the channel though. He's not an expert it's just for fun. He notices a thousand things we don't but occasionally it works the other way around.
@@richardzazanis4764 But he clearly overanalyzed this entire movie.
@@richardzazanis4764 he does notice quite a few things though that i wouldnt really notice. The funny thing is.now, whenever me and my wife are watching a movie, we point out things that would be "sins" now lol we were watching "concussion" with Will Smith the other day and were noticing quite a few.
however, you are right, some things he counts as a sin, are things that are meant to be that way for a reason, or are things that he has overlooked. My main one is when he is doing "pet sematary", and he sins it for them "misspelling the word 'cemetery'". Even though, if youve read the book, or know ANYTHING about the book, you would know that it IS purposely misspelled that way. So they didnt misspell it and not catch it like he insinuates. it was MEANT to be spelled that way
My dad and I talked about the "Minnie don't like Mexicans" / Minnie's-indiscriminate-hospitality discrepancy, and my dad suggested that the former bit was a lie, just to gauge Señor Bob's reaction. If he had actually known Minnie, he could easily dispute that; but his eyes widened instead, meaning that he bought the lie and thus did *not* know Minnie.
Also, this is called a haberdashery (men's clothing store), but instead, it's a restaurant. How did this not get sinned?
No it's called minnie Haberdashery the same way you call a restaurant the great whale. Also wouldn't the blood on the chair and all the other clue enough to shoot him
just like the sin where he said accidently meeting the father of a man he killed cause i think that was a lie too
Dorian Valkenhoff no Warren knew the son's name without eavesdropping
Also, the haberdashery thing was in the script. "Oh. Haberdashery. I get it. That was a joke." It was also detailed in the script that Minnie thought "Haberdashery" sounded cool.
"my dad suggested that the former bit was a lie, just to gauge Señor Bob's reaction."
I haven't seen this since it came out (which I saw on Christmas in its 70 mm glory, btw), but wasn't there actually a sign or something hanging somewhere that actually said no Mexicans or spicks or something?
I could be wrong, but I'm pretty sure I remember seeing that.
This in my opinion is his finest movie. It is perfect. Top to bottom. Cast, dialogue, music, action, lighting. Absolutely perfect
Yep. I also think it’s Samuel L Jackson’s finest work, and when you say that about a guy who has done as many films and been in as many classics as he has, that’s saying something.
The random pop music was shit
You made a mistake, when you gave a sin, it went from 38 right to 40, thats a Cinema Sins sin
1
and 31 to 33
29 to 31
*ding* 3
59 to 55
and from 34 to 36
Claims to enjoy Tarantino movies then sins all of his trademark features. *DING*
Claims to like in order to avoid the obvious fact that he manifested most of the sins himself.
He loves the tarantino movies below 90 sins he really likes em, between 90
Have you ever watched this channel before?
Everyone knows this channel isn’t a serious movie review channel it’s comedy
Yea but this movie was utter shite. The dialogue wasn't even good and that's what I expected when watching a Q.T film.
Film was so boring.
If you think the movie is boring than you're an action movie fan not a Tarantio fan.
Sins jump from 29 to 31 then to 33 without extra dings. 34 to 36, 38 to 40, 51 to 48?, 48 to 54, 59 to 55?,
I'm choosing to believe this is a covert homage to Tarantino's disordered time story telling technique.
or his way to count his movie, deathproof happened
huh, yes they do
Street Hierarchy ....Which Tarantino wrote and directed. But yes, I understand that stylistically it is not one of "his" movies.
Four Rooms is great too, but Tarantino's segment just blows the others completely out of the water.
Just about to say this. This bothered me a lot
*REMIND ME TO NEVER WATCH A MOVIE WITH YOU*
Ever ever ..
At least on first viewing lol
Too late; he's in my head. Half of GoG2 was *ding* they survive this.
John Ruth let’s Warren in so he can read the letter from “Lincoln” which they address later...
He let’s in Chris Mattox because he’s scared Mattox may be telling the truth about being the new sheriff. No sins needed.
He let’s him in because otherwise he’d be indirectly committing murder. It’s Mannix btw
you are correct. this channel just nit picks for views sometimes
You do realize he can do what he wants right?
@@obiwan25_ and we can also do what we want.
@@josefernandez4423 voila
"got me on that coach didn't it?"
This is actually true. Because they knew each other before then and what john respects of marquis, or rather, what has him interested in marquis as being a decent acquaintance, is the fact he found out about him having that letter from lincoln. So he sees Marquis as a man that can be trusted enough. So due to that letter, he knew he can trust him to have on the coach with him.
@Goggle products this isn't even a good copypasta
sins of this video: too many forced reasons for sins
You must be new hear.
I am new hear but I here what you're implying
Fine taste, gentlemen. Mighty fine.
Jazmine Wallace I here you mate
+Jazmine Wallace Americans*
3:39 we later see the door shuts because Joe and Oswaldo shut it from within. -1 sin
Thank you, exactly my thought.
The cross at the beginning is a roadside grave. Come on man, you never watch a western film?
Thomas Labat you don't see many of those here
+Thomas Labat This guy doesn't seem to know much about anything...
Like thinking dropping a dying match on a wet wooden floor of a stage coach is the same as dropping it into kerosene. Most of these sins are weak attempts at grasping for minor quibbles, many not even being problems. But eh.
Guysguysguys, may I interrupt you right there.
If you are taking his sins seriously then please.just.leave.
Get a sense of humor or begone. We dont need no "Mr. Right" people here, since were just having fun watching these videos.
Instead of ruining that for us watch something YOU can enjoy. Maybe a bible documentary idk.
if thats right which i am sure it is why the fuck would he show off by removing 5 sins for ennio morricone , i bet he don't even know who he is.
The thing that shocked me the most about this movie was how Chris Maddox ended up being the real hero of the whole thing...didn't see that coming.
Also, most satisfying (fictional) hanging ever.
This ending song really amplifies the ending too.
I like to think the bullet missed the artery and Maddox survived and got his $90,000 for all the corpses lol.
Christopher I like the way you think. ;-)
Dude, in that age, the odds of survival if the bullets misses the artery are still kinda shit. At least his legs won't be fixed. They might even have to cut it off. But I suppose he could live.
whutzat
Chris Maddox isn’t a character in Hateful Eight.
man that door-joke, they totally nailed it
Ha.
Opened a door didn't it?
+Rahul Dharan pay some attention to your spelling
I adore good puns
"I wouldn't have questioned this if Quinton Tarintino didn't show it to me for 3 minutes"
Shut up Jeremy, we all know you would have.
Why did you post the same fucking comment few months apart?
@@general_-rt4bt oh I guess I rewatched it and forgot I had commented it already lol
@@TheF0xskibidbopmmdada lol
Loved the movie actually. Fun fact about this movie. It was originally planned to be a sequel to Django Unchained. Samuel Jackson's character was originally meant to be Django but then Tarantino realized that having Django in the film would ruin the movies atmosphere of not being able to trust anybody. If Django was in the film you'd be rooting for him the whole time because we already know his story. Instead they were all made to be strangers so you'd being thinking nobody was off limits from being the liar.
@Zachary Hoy Holy shit who cares. It's all relevant info and he isn't gaining anything.
@@Badusername2000 worse, he gave his wife a back massage
37 white men for one hamster?! Unbelievable!
i dont know about you guys, but i honestly think this movie was a master piece.
Im with you man.
I never liked it very much because I thought it was boring. Maybe I missed something or some context; what did you guys like about it?
Let he without sin cast the first sin. hehehe. Anyway, it is a good movie, but it is not 'perfect'.
For me it was just the over feel of the movie. I am Canadian and we get a lot of snow, so a lot of the movie resonated with me. not only that but I really like how mysterious it is. I mean it's like the wild west, but you see another side to it. the movie reveals that the wild west was not only about revolvers and such but there was a whole other part to survival especially with the extreme weather.
Charles VanDergrift I loved the tension in the movie. These characters were all put in one room and you can feel in your bones how much they want to either kill each other or distrust each other but have zero idea as to why until the film reveals itself. It's great.
This might be the worst cinema sins ever made. Half of these "sins" are just the video creator misunderstanding symbolism and foreshadowing.
Agreed. The attention to detail in the movie is next level the sins guy just isn’t bright enough to see most of the threads. The only thing he’s right about is it not being 100% realistic (like Warren shooting Bob and the blood coming dramatically from above the shot) but those things are probably intentional as kind of a parody/homage to westerns like when Django kills Calvin Candy’s sister and she flies away abruptly. If there are unrealistic elements, they’re there for entertainment or fantastical story telling.
3:38 in the flash back didn't they show the other guys nailing it closed?
WhatAreYouBuyen yes
They do, you’re totally right, I guess CinemaSins needs it’s own sin counter. It’s like they just glanced over the movie and tried to make everything a sin
yes
WhatAreYouBuyen I'm glad someone else noticed this! In chapter 4: The Four Passengers...they show Joe Gage and Oswaldo nailing the door shut after Bob goes outside to greet the "guests".
They definitely did. Jeremy is too petty to research too deeply.
In The Hateful Eight you say that it was a sin because mini didn't give bob a mean look even though she is suppose to not like Mexicans. Major Mark West was lying about Mini hating Mexicans to see if Bob would correct him, which he didn't so he knew bob was lying.
Yeah but Bob could have corrected him because Minnie didn't gave him a bad look.
If Mini didn't like Mexicans, that doesn't mean she would be openly prejudice to bob. Either way major mark west saying that would have made bob unsure of himself which is why he got shot.
-Dude make up your mind whether you think Minnie disliked or liked mexicans, just don't change it to the convenience of this dumb movie.
"Either way major mark west saying that would have made bob unsure of himself which is why he got shot."
-It wouldn't at all, by mentioning the sign he is implying she highly disliked mexicans, since she didn't did anything to Bob, he would had surely know that wasn't true.
Ross Ramsay his name is not Mark West, it is Major Marquis, it's just southern pronunciation.
The guy who made this video does not have the brain power to understand the subtilities of a Tarantino movie. Most of those "sins" is just him being too stupid to understand what is going on.
Still to scared to take on Pulp Fiction, Reservoir Dogs and Basterds, eh?
too*
+Will Edwards you used the correct to the first time
Might want to check up on your to/too/two rules, the correction was correct.
+MyBrothersTeeth no he didn't why did people like your comment...
Those movies are too good. What sins would be marked down for those?
This movie just never gets old. I watch it at least twice a year. Once in the summer and once in the winter.
"Having a brit decide how we divide up geography, always leads to trouble"
Fact.
@Goggle products sounds like you take this movie as a personal insult
@Goggle products So life isn't going great, eh?
Goggle products that’s either a huge bait or you got some serious problems
we irish know about brits deciding geography
@Goggle products nice copy and paste comment
The guitar scene hurts my soul, lol. Everyone on set thought it was one of the props at the moment, but Jennifer knew it wasn't because she had been taking it home and playing it, she knew it was a priceless museum piece. Kurt felt so bad he nearly teared up, and Tarantino got Jennifer a similar one from the 1880s as a gift after filming because she loved that guitar so much. But yep, that's what over $40,000 of Martin guitar looks like smashed off a post.
Eh just some old crap made by some dead assholes from a couple generations ago. Plenty of old crap in the world and im sure they made a thousand of those suckers in their day. Fuck it
Plot twist: Tarantino and Russell executed a plan to destroy the real Martin all along to get the *million dollar shot* so to speak. When I watched Kurts interview about how it went down it made me think that only they knew what they were doing to solidify its place in cinema history. (Kurt is an ACTOR so it would be very easy for him to be “close to tears” and distraught. That’s literally what he does for a living.
I never understood why they needed an original guitar for the set? I mean, how many people would have noticed that's just a replica? Five?
Absolutely Bollocks. Someone would've said something. There's a tale with every movie & I swear they're bullshit to add more interest
@@josephsalmonte4995 What's bollocks? that the guitar was genuine or that it wasn't an accident? The guitar was real alright. The Martin museum no longer loan out instruments because of this very scene.
Kurt Russell actually smashed an 1870 guitar I think hurts me the most.
Not just any guitar...a Martin!! Good lord...that right there should have been about 50 sins on the counter!
Life will go on.
J Silva Although crushing they destroyed the guitar, this comment made it all worth it.
it was a MARTIN? jesus christ add like 100 sins fuck
That was real?!?!
“When bob walked out the door shut just fine” - at the end of the movie we see that his partners were behind him closing the door wishing him good luck
oh, I was wondering why she freaked out so much for the Guitar.
yep, and after it museums across the globe have stopped loaning out antique guitars.-
sin 28: Oswaldo and joe gage shut the door behind him. They show it in the later part of the movie
THANK YOU!
Unpopular opinion: Probably my favorite Tarantino movie.
I think Django unchained is his best. Best soundtrack ever and not a dull moment and huge payoff at the end
Dude I agree with you
I love it to
Any Tarantino film is incredible so it’s hard for an opinion to unpopular plenty will always agree
@Icebane thats about right
sin 30: yup I was thinking that would be a good Waltz role right there.
me toooo
Well, he would be good in any role in any movie, perhaps even all roles. If someone made one of thems deep fake videos where everybody was Christoph Waltz, I'd watch it.
-5 more sins for the fact that Morricone wrote and orchestrated this score in a MONTH!
For scale, John Williams spent a year on The Force Awakens and didn't orchestrate it himself.
To be fair, he did re-use A LOT of his unused score from The Thing, as well as sampling stuff from classic films such as The Exorcist. It was less a score and more a remix.
Thomas Broome-Jones True, although given he's the oldest recipient of a competitive Oscar because of this film, I'll cut him some slack :)
Dima Vasilev No doubt, Ennio is G.O.A.T. film composer.
And for the record I adored his score.
+Thomas Broome-Jones "A LOT" ? No.
It's 2 unused 1 minutes songs from The Thing, used 2 times each, in a 3h long movie. It's not "A LOT". It's barely "enough".
"I wouldn't question this if it wasn't on screen for 3 minutes"
_Actually, I'm fairly sure you would..._
I would've sinned the fact that Minnie and her family were shot in that place. I doubt you clean off all that blood from wooden floors without anybody noticing
Who says they needed to clean it? Clearly you've never murdered anybody in a log cabin before.
@@User0000000000000004 lmao what a amateur
Well, you are supposed to use cold water to clean up blood. They're in a snowy area so that's easy as heck.
8:03 the reason that floorboard fella just decided to start shooting is because the sheriff was about to start executing members of his gang, it was a distraction to buy his guys some time to draw their own guns, but joe mcgruff or what ever his name was doesn’t have his gun, and apparently Oswaldo has terrible aim so ultimately it doesn’t really work and only sets up the major and the sheriff to die later
Years after Sam Jackson shoots someone in the dick in Pulp Fiction, he gets the same treatment in this movie.
Sam Jackson never shot anyone in the dick in Pulp Fiction. That was Marsellus Wallace played by Ving Rhames
MrPonyboy95 Oh, I thought he did in the scene where he interrogated a guy who did something to Mr Wallace. Or Am I remembering the right scene and just got characters mixed up?
+Eric Breaux well Jules (Sam Jackson) and Vincent shot a guy down for something they did (I don't remember what) but it wasn't in the dick
There was another scene, though, where Marcellus is raped and when Butch (Bruce Willis) comes back and saves him, he shoots the rapist in the dick with a shot gun.
+Eric Breaux there are two scenes I think you're blending together. Jules (Sam Jackson) shot a guy down for something he did to Marcellus. There's another scene where Marcellus himself is raped and when Butch (played by Bruce Willis) saves him, Marcelkus shoots the rapist in the crotch with a shotgun.
No, it was Butch who shot the cop in the crotch.
Finally a Quentin Tarentino film that isn't Django. We need an everything wrong with pulp fiction and reservoir dogs, though. Maybe Kill Bill.
I second that motion
I think he should give "The Godfather" a try too
100 sins for Kill Bill still not being 1 movie no matter how much Tarentino thinks so.
Arent these Quarantino movies overrated? Ok, killl bill is kinda cool. But pulp fiction. Isnt that basicly an overrated wannabe cool movie?
+Ron M no bro pulpfiction is cult movie and killbil is a bit quite strange but it is cool. in 5 years you would change your and will love this movie bro😉👍
That fucking bonus round lmaoo
*hamster*
love your channel name haha
I DON'T ACKNOWLEDGE BANKERS
Then shoot that ... lobster
You joined the war to keep *gawkers* in chains
3:43 YES! Tim Roth was good in this movie, sure, but try to tell me this role wasn't written for Christoph Waltz. I know that Waltz didn't want to be in this film, but Roth's character was 100% written for Waltz.
For sure
you could drop a lit match on any hardwood creation in history and as long as it isnt soaked in fing gasoline it would never catch on fire...especially in a wet coach full of wet wood...that was a lame stretch for a sin!
That's pretty much all of the "sins" he mentions, a lame stretch. This was pretty much the worst idea for a comical review idea i've ever watched. First of all, not funny just because he speaks quickly, not original either (self explanatory) and worst of all, seriously grasping for straws at almost all times.
Jimmy bergvall awwww he speaks too quickly for you, poor-Jimbo can't keep up..
That wasnt the point. It's just the fact that people do that for comical effect. Actually my point is that it's easy to speak quickly, escpecially while editing videos so the opposite of you're very lame "burn". I see where you draw inspiration from. Grasp at that straw.
I thought the video was hilarious. And he talks the same way in all his videos. If you don't enjoy it, why do you watch it?
CJ Laity exactly
Hey! One sin down because the door didn't close herself! Later we see the three gangstars closed and nailed it! That's cheating!
Waiting to see if someone else caught that. Glad you did. It tripped me up the first time I saw the movie; I thought "Hey, that's a sin!" And Tarantino explains it later.
lol i just made a comment about that
Did you see how he skipped sin 30 and sin 32??
Really?! Well, that makes three sins down! Cheaters!
Only now I notice he does this all the time! Does he hate Tarantino or something? Why?
Wow, it must be just absolutely excruciating to sit through a movie with you.
? Probably would sit their like any normal person. They just released they could make a living sinning movies? Literally 95% of the films they sin they enjoy like any other person.
Also keep in mind that most of the sins they point out these days aren't sins at all. Unless they really consider reading a sin. Which... I don't know, they might.
Personally, despite all the racial ugliness and the woman abuse, I really liked this movie. I just chalk it up to the fact that that's pretty close to how things were back then. I picked up on the pen pal thing, too, though, lol!
I also picked up on the fact that Minnie was just as friendly to Senor Bob as she was to the rest of Jody's gang. Still....her random dislike of Mexicans can be for a whole variety of reasons. Many people have unreasonable aversions towards other people. It's not right, but that's how it is. People are irrational sometimes, and sometimes, what seems irrational to us may be perfectly justifiable to the person.
Why the fuck do they count reading as a sin?
9:20 I am almost certain the cellar is just that, a cellar not a full blown basement it’s only below the trap door and does not extend to the rest of the floor, while floorboard fella could take a shot at the sheriff he would almost certainly miss.
I'm honestly curious how you either knew or had the presence of mind to look up when the term "pen pals" originated
STILL CAN'T BELIEVE THAT KURT ACTUALLY SMASHED A NINETEENTH CENTURY GUITAR🤣
Apparently the museum they borrowed it from doesn't lend out instruments anymore.
@@leelongvideo i wonder why
I can't believe he left it in the movie because her reaction immediately took me out of the story. I was watching this at home the first time I saw it, not in a movie theater, so when I saw that, I immediately paused the thing and Googled "hateful eight real guitar" and found the story about it. It's a shame it happened but at that moment, JJL was no longer acting and it showed.
Yeah, that absolutely SUCKED. What an awful thing to do.
@@leelongvideo Yeah, I think they have all the Martin guitars and they absolutely do not. I love this movie, but what a monstrous thing to do.
No sins removed for L. Jacksons Dingus speech? Lame
I was hoping for a sin removal for the ending song, Roy Orbison was a beautiful choice.
I was hoping all sins removed because tarantino
3:37 the door closing behind him in the beginning is explained later in the flashback to when they were planning before they showed up
i cant imagine sitting in a movie theater with this guy
Zorcvin oh, really?!
Maybe not, but I can definitely see him and six of my wiseass friends sitting on a couch watching a DVD, knocking back brews and having a good old time with him.
Marcos Torrez he is a little bit stupid
I bet he carries a little bell around with him to ding every sin he comes across.
turns out he's not joking either. he really is this much of douche
Racial Tension: the movie
And despite there being a single non-white he instigates near all of it lmao.
did you watch the movie?
and who says non-white you hitler boy
Theroux Mexican is white now?
Firebender 117 It frequently is, yes. There are actually quite a number of fair-skinned Mexicans.
Best movie of 2015. Saw this film in 70mm and loved every second. Sam Jackson's finest performance. Tarentino is a legend.
+KomodoDojo No, it was not the best movie of 2015. Fury Road, Inside Out, The Revenant, The Big Short, Joy, Jurassic World, The Walk, Black Mass, ... you know what ... name a genre and I'll name a better movie from 2015 off the top of my head. Snow? Revenant. Action? Fury Road. Western? Western starring Kurt Russell? Bone Tomahawk. Look it up. 50 times better and it is both a western and stars Kurt Russell. And it was released in 2015. I can throw out better 70mm movies. I can name two movies with Sam Jackson that are better (Chi-Raq and Age of Ultron). You can't even spell Tarantino's name. You don't know shit about movies. Go home kid. Lay down in bed and cry.
??? really dude? the year mad max fury road came out you chose one of the worst Quinton Tarantino films
+Rhys Clark Interactive Media (RhysClark97) Fury Road was my second favorite film of the year. Ive seen 7/8 Tarantino films, but death proof. I loved Hateful, IMO he's never done a bad film and I enjoyed the hell out of it like all the rest. No need to play favorites. All unique and wonderful.
+Speeetz Eaasy dude your entitled to your opinion but I can't take what youre saying seriously when you think JW, Ultron, Revenant, Joy are good films.
+Speeetz Eaasy i saw the big short (really liked it) the revenant (snoozefest, but incredible cinematography/direction) in 2016 at the cinema, so thats a different list for me
Adding 10 sins to cinemasins for calling “Apple Blossom” by the White Stripes a pop song.
Pop is really anything that isn't classed as classical so yeah, pop song.
@@thewickedwizard lol
Pop is short for "popular", bud.
@ThisHandleFeatureIsStupid Well done for keeping up. Pop is short for popular which is classed as anything that isn't classical.
@@thewickedwizard Incorrect.
Pop music is classified as anything in the mainstream. There are no excluded subgenres, as in your claim.
@@ThisHandleFeatureIsStupid Any Classical in the mainstream right now? Tchaikosky storming up the charts??
I'm absolutely shocked that Samuel l Jackson yelling in slo mo wasn't in this
Ikr? "You gon make a deal with this diabolical beeeeeitch?" xD
I'm guessing Zootopia is on Thursday
He already did it
+Zack Radakovich when?
+Zack Radakovich no he didn't
+Zack Radakovich When and where? I searched RUclips for "Cinemasins Zootopia" and I scrolled through their video list, going over 6 months back, and couldn't find anything.
No they didn't do Zootopia yet. I literally just checked.
Why do people complain about Quentin using the n word in his movies when they're set in the 1800s and it was used a lot back then
Alex Neck Skrub Boy I think counting the n-words in Tarantino's movies is just sort of a parlor game now. You do it because that's what you do.
If you're talking about the channel, they do that as a joke, this is obvious. Now if people wants to deny reality, the so called "safe space" that we have nowadays... Well, it's their retardation, just leave it be lol
I ain't black but he uses it so unnecessarily. not just in this movie, but in every single movie he made.
Because it's his favorite word and any time he can use it in a movie, he does. It's sort of like how in a lot of movies, if they briefly show a shot of someone's bare feet, you ignore it. In a Tarantino movie, you say "Wow, here we go again."
I know, right? Do these same people complain about Lil Wayne saying nigga or virtually all the current “rap stars” using the “n” word? It’s total bullshit. It gives people the opportunity to express outrage whenever they choose whether or not they are experiencing outrage thus they use it as a crutch to vent their frustrations - Black OR White
I just saw this movie on Netflix! And I noticed you sinned at 3:40 how the door closed just fine, and after watching the extended version in the last chapter it shows that Pete and Grouch closed the door behind Marco when he walked outside to meet Ruth when they arrived to Minnie’s. Not a big deal but I finally have a reason to comment on one of your videos lol. Love the content!
That guitar smash should've been worth 3 sins.
That whole line made me LOL.
I went and saw that movie with my grandfather, neither of us knew any real details about the movie. Most awkward experience of my life.
yeah I went with my dad. *shudders*
But did y'all like it though??
Ur fault
+FreshBro8 Eh, it was okay. it took place all in one setting so it was a tad boring.
+Alexes Snow Yh, but then again reservoir dogs....
Mate, Apple Blossom is a fantastic song anf fits perfectly in that scene.
1:18 John ruth knows him.and also want to see the lincoln letter again ;)
this video's greatest sin is for adding 3 sins for apple blossom.
brandon242 I love this film a lot, but apple blossoms feels very out of place
Broski Movies not to me it just felt ironic..not out of place.
brandon242 I mean the song was very upbeat and like a pop song that it felt more of this day and age music than what enio did with the score to make it feel like a western
Came looking for this as soon as i saw the Sins!
It's not the first time he's added a poppy song to a historical movie. Rick Ross in Django...
Absolutely nothing wrong with that movie.
yep lots wrong
+Edward Kenway 144 things wrong, to be specific
Besides boring as hell and Quentin Tarantino jerking off to it?
+Christopher Lehmann it was borig in the First half but in the Second half it was fucking awsome
It was boring in the first half because it tried to be a mystery movie and failed. Then it sucked in the second half because I don't know what he was trying to do there. Make an advertisement for blood squibs I guess. It certainly wasn't tense or anything like that. What a worthless movie.
I think this movie was good. I mean the ending was satisfying and the acting was great but I don't consider it one of Quentin Tarantino's best films. Django Unchained, Inglorious Bastards, & Pulp Fiction are his best to me by far.
I join you on this one
"Inglorious basterds" one of his best ? HAHAHAHA, dude no.
Pulp Fiction and Django, yeah, but also Kill Bill and Reservoir Dogs. Tho I agree with you on the Hateful 8.
PHNeutre49 While Kill Bill & Reservoir Dogs is his absolute best work, Inglorious Bastards is *to me* one of *my* favorite films. It's well shot, Hans Landa is the best and terrifying character, the ending is beautiful, and the dialogue though in a different language is solid.
dynamite Perfectionist I agree that there are plenty good things in the movie, but overall it wasn't that great. But fair enough it's your tastes.
PHNeutre49 Thank you. Also you don't have bad taste yourself.
Imagine not ever doing anything with your life and you have the gall to criticise a cinematic genius
Idk. I loved the movie!
You need to get out more and I don't count going to the movies as getting out.
wonder mike cant you just fuck off you were literally just making a joke about the other guys mom like what are you 12, you know what, you probably are
wonder mike why would his mom be watching cinema sins
wonder mike fuck you talking about, goofy ass 12 year old
Jams m XD, he's just like, " oh shucks jilerkers mom, please give it back, I need to hate more comments.... GODAMMIT MOM, YOU NEVER LET ME DO THINGS, YOUR NOT EVEN MY REAL DAD, GODAMMIT!!!"
Movie was actually masterful storytelling.
Sinjin Smyth its based on a play
@Sinjin Smyth what!?
@Sinjin Smyth sir I said what because I didn t knew that not because I didn t understand
+ Sinjin Smyth You're right, you are being too defensive. Chill out, dude.
Dam straight chipy a great film
That Tim Roth/Monty Python line was perfect. Best joke you have ever made in all your videos...
7:25 you get one Jeremy.
7:56 damn it. You get another one.
Actually, Minnie didn't actually hate Mexicans. It was just Warren's way of finding out if Bob was lying
John allows the other men to ride his carriage because he is not a murderer so he will help people
WinterSplinterM.II where is your pic from
WinterSplinterM.II John allows the other men to ride his cock because he is not a murderer so he will help people
This movie is essentially a fantasy. It's hyper-stylish, overwritten and tightly wound in its plot. I don't think necessarily pointing out anachronistic or bizarre plot holes-just appreciate it for the weird, trippy film it is. That's what I think, anyway.
Bijinius Cross wouldn’t it be fun to see a movie with this pretentious asshat? Right?
That's why I hate this video. Yes the movie as all tarantino movies are prolonged and can be seen as boring but have many things to be respected for and cherry picking every fucking scene for sins on realism and sound effects and personal preferences to make a 10 minute video, when you can actually critisise the many faults the movie has is very ironic. Completely loses a point expect comedic value , which he fails to be good at. I'd prefer to rewatch the movie twice than this video again.
"Throws a lit match on a wooden floor" you've never tried to start a fire, have you?
Is sinning every single use of the N- word really fair? That wasn't as much a racial slur as just common speech for when this movie is supposed to take place, also the use of it in excess is one of Tarantino's staples
who says this channel is ever remotely "fair"? They often sin the same sin many times. It's not math class. It's youtube entertainment.
+Firstly Lasty yeah that's fair enough.
Welcome to cinemasins, where the sins are made up and they don't matter.
The excess got kind of ridiculous in this movie with the use of the n-word
+KPstudios Or because today that word is incredibly offensive to an entire race of people and I, as a white person, don't feel comfortable saying it.
*Kill Bill* is two films. I paid twice. It's two films. End of discussion.
It was meant to be one film, the director counts it as one film, it's meant to be viewed as one film
It's one film. Tarantino wanted it that way, but the runtime of the movie would be too long to view in theaters.
James Arnold I *might* buy that if we ever get *The Whole Bloody Affair* on Blu-ray. For the time being, my wallet has spoken.
But I heard and some movie theaters when it originally came out you could see the full version part one and part two and one movie
We still paid twice, no matter what facts you throw at us.
2:14 I'm pretty sure that's intentional. Tarantino banks a lot on coincidental encounters, like when Butch found Marcellus casually walking the street in Pulp Fiction. I don't think I could really admit that sin.
*2:44 my bad
+NonExistingName +1 sin
*ding*
The whole way the introduction chapter was set up had a feeling of self-awareness about how coincidental it is that they all met up on the road. I know Tarantino was being cheeky,but it kind of just felt like a lazy way to deliver exposition and to introduce the characters.
he's been lazy
More sins (regarding language):
- The use of “yonder” is a hypercorrectionism.
- The accent of Chris Mannix didn’t exist back in the day in South Carolina.
- The Kiwi woman in this movie also has an accent that not yet emerged (New Zealand accent) at that time.
I'm surprised you sinned for John taking the cuff off to let her eat, but not for when they are laying out in the snow after she gets punched out for spitting on the letter, and then fucking WALKS AWAY, leaving her laying way back behind them and the wagon while they look away from her.
Clay Tankard where's she gunna go..
Yeah, where is she going to go? Run away and freeze to death?
Does anyone else find Tarantino kind of overrated?
Whilst this isn't his best film, most of his films can be considered for top 100 films of all time
He's definitely the most consistent director.
Lately? Yes, it wouldn't be so bad if he didn't jerk off to his own name and reputation in his new movies
you are not alone - Michael Jackson
If you're only counting movies from the 90s and onward, sure. If you count every movie then no. Unless you're one of those people who thinks IMDB votes matter.
O.B. For President.
i was so mad when he died
Right, like he was literally the only innocent character left.
HELLOOOOOO, STEPHEN MY BOY!
The only sin I’ll pay for is the sin of watching this movie over again and over again, this movie was cinematic goddesses levels and I will not apologize for perfectly every second of it. Quentin Tarantino opens the inside of his mind and we are so blessed to enjoy it
Cinematic goddesses? What the hell are those? Sounds to me like a bunch of movie theater Karens who won't shut up or stop texting during the movie. I think what you meant to say was Cinematic God, especially since all deities are men. If any gods were female, the universe would have imploded just seconds after it came into existence purely out of spite.
@@User0000000000000004 we found the incel!