Fate: The Winx Saga Vs. Winx Club (Reboot Vs. Original) [COMPARISON] | 1080p
HTML-код
- Опубликовано: 5 окт 2024
- Hi, please like and subscribe :)
This took me so long so I hope you‘ll enjoy!
Credits:
WinxClubEnglish
Netflix
-
Subscribe: / @winxclubwings
Instagram: ...
Winx Club™ created by Iginio Straffi © 2003-2020
© Rainbow S.p.A
© Rainbow S.r.l.
© Rainbow CGI
© Viacom International
© Nickelodeon
All rights reserved
DISCLAIMER:
Copyright Disclaimer Under Section 107 of the Copyright Act 1976, allowance is made for «fair use» for purposes such as criticism, comment, news reporting, teaching, scholarship, and research.
Fair use is a use permitted by copyright statute that might otherwise be infringing. Non-profit, educational or personal use tips the balance in favor
of fair use.
![KAYTRANADA - Witchy (feat. Childish Gambino) [Official Video]](http://i.ytimg.com/vi/jGK3YVmGZ3Y/mqdefault.jpg)
The reboot can’t even compare to the original
You’re not supposed to compare it idiot it’s a different show
@@EllieValentineWong ahh yes..it must be a coincidence that this "different show" is also called Winx with same characters like Bloom, Stella, Musa, Aisha
I wont even call this show winx cause it isn't they look nothing alike
@@doodledonuts9474 it’s a different take for different audiences it’s an alternate interpretation
@@shamiahireland425 because it’s supposed to be a different approach
I’m sorry the original will always be my fav
And that's okay. Nobody said that you don't have to prefer the new one or forget the old one. You know, you actually can like two things seperatly from each other or prefer one and not hate the other one.
Booo
@@ZulfitriZoolhilmeyS it's their opinion
Same. I mean I'm 24 but I still expected transformations and for it to be less dark. They're tturning every cool cartoon into live action. And they make it so dark it's awful.
Wait im confused is this show a cartoon spin off or something
What have they done to Flora ?! 😭
They white-washed her. Just like Musa.
@@serenawitch OFC. Why couldn't I expect an asian girl- just a diverse cast but they did bring a plus size... maybe to make us not argue about it much idk
She's called Terra now, apparently.
@@abcde_ghijklmnopqrstuvwyxz2188 yeah but apparently when the actress was cast, the character was still named Flora😂. Somewhere along the way the changed her name to Terra but we all basically know she's Flora
m.facebook.com/story.php?story_fbid=167728591748140&id=108406041013729
Netflix has some explaining to do.
Fr like what is this
Like where is Techna?
@@hi5the31s3 she will join in season 2
But Flora will never be in it Tessa is not Flora and I don't think that they are going to add Helia so there is no reason for me to watch it
@@melisece Flora and Helia were always my favourite too
What the hell have they done to my girl Icy
It‘s not Icy, it‘s Beatrix. She‘s probably based on the Trix (as her name says Be - a - trix) so I chose Icy to compare them but you can also compare her to Stormy or Darcy :)
@@winxclubwings w- wait, there's no bad trio? Like, they put all of them in one person? Oh no...
@@zhi_maqiu I know, that was my same reaction. The relationship between the 3 sisters was amazing, they'll never be able to replicate it with one character
@@icydelight3693 I'm not even sure if they were real sisters. I always thought they were just really really good friends. So good they call each other sisters, but I watched only up to season 4 so I may be wrong
@@zhi_maqiu yeah they're not sisters, it's clarified on S8. It doesn't change the fact that they are as close as sisters though
Brandon needs to be hotness personified, cause the animated version was my first cartoon crushh
Me too, can you believe he's not in the show
Yess I was simping sooooo hard for him lol
Abigail said that there are gonna love triangles and I just found out that Stella îs gonna be Sky's girlfriend and then Bloom îs gonna meet Stella and Sky and then BOOM a love triangle
This soundtrack is so freaking good!
Yeahhhh
are you kidding me
@@spooky8021 nope
@@zenasonic7882 u hate winx club
@@jadaoffical2011 I‘m guessing I know about Winx Club longer than you. I was 5, when I watched it for the first time in 2006. I bought all the Comics, Toys, even dishes and school supplies. And I also know, when Nickelodeon destroyed Winx Club when I was 11 in 2012 with Season 5 and later Season 6, but I didn‘t stopped watching it because they still were my heroes, even when they got a boring storyline. In 2015 I waited for the 7th Season and the third movie, I watched them. The World of Winx came, which was amazing because they acted more mature than in the whole 5&6th Season.
Then the most shocking thing about Winx came in 2019: Season 8: childish artstyle, childish acting and an illogical storyline. My heart cracked, when I saw them.
Now I have a chance to see my girls becoming alive in a live action series, where there are amazing actresses like Abigail, Hannah and Precious and etc. (I‘m aware that „Flora“ got whitewashed, but you might not know that „Terra“ isn‘t „Flora“, but her COUSIN (I know that because I read a part of the book for the series). And many of you are unhappy with the actress for Musa or excluding Tecna (which I confess, is really really sad), but iT iS wHaT iT iS now. You can‘t change a thing, but waiting what‘s going to happen in this show. You don‘t have to watch it, but you should not spread your reckless/naughty opinion all over social media because you can‘t stop us watching the series. I wouldn‘t even miss you👋🏼👋🏼.
Remember Guys: Faragonda is also not in it. She's a completely different woman. More than likely Griffin is also not there. Possibly, a lot of the teachers got replaced.
Honestly, if they wanted to do a story like this, inspired by the Original Winx Club, then they shouldn't have used the Winx Club girls. Hell: they could be the Descendants of WC. I really fucking hate that they are calling this a part of the OG Lore, with completely different characters. They had the balls to change Flora into Terra, why couldn't they do that to everyone else?
Also, I agree: I could put this on for W.I.T.C.H. than Winx because while yes, they are Pixies, they had more elemental magic than fae magic.
Where is Techna?
@@hi5the31s3 As you can see, she's not even in it. I heard rumors that she'll be in Season 2. Why? Don't ask me
@@Odd_Cinderella I've heard that they fused Tecna and Flore so they didn't need to focus on two people at once... :(
@@lunathelightfury2795 That ridiculous, Technology powers. Flower Power. Technology. Flowers. 🌻🌸🌺🌷💐/⚙️ 📱🎮🕹️ Huh?
@@katiestevenson7742 She will have some earth powers from what I've heard but will have more like tecna mind than Flora, which is sad :(.
I wish this reboot never happened
Same honestly
@@desiko.8151 ikr. Y does netflix feel the need to turn every childhood show dark? Like the whole pint if winx club is its light, cheerful, ethereal, and fun. They totally ruined it.
@@haileymay1656 i couldn't agree more... Even the schools are gonna be in one like- couldn't they do a normal remake
@@haileymay1656 Yeah, it completely ruins the experience
@@desiko.8151 honestly this Netflix winx club is closer to being witches than fairies. The transformations are a big part of what makes the winx so magical. Don’t get me wrong, because I love dark academia aesthetics. For example I loved how they made Sabrina the teenage witch into a dark, Satanic, coven theme. It matches well since she is a witch. But the winx are fairies. Like what I said, the show theme being dark doesn’t sit right w me. Let’s also talk about how they completely white washed the cast, took out a bunch of characters, and how poorly styled the winx club is💀
how come there's no tecna there? I am very disappointed
Everyone is but I guess we can‘t do anything and have to live with it :(
As you can see... no similarities
😂😂😂🙌
And I hate the winx saga
I used to be obsessed with winx 😭
Nobody says that you can't be anymore.
@@-autumnfeelings I’m rewatching it right now but idk how I feel about this new one-
@@gravityxboy3763 I will give it a try. If I don't like it at the end, it's okay and I still have the old one to enjoy and if I like the new one what have I lost? Nothing? Then I have two shows that I like.
@@gravityxboy3763 I used to be obsessed and I still kind of am but I don't watch the new seasons. After Nabu died I didn't watch it anymore since he was my fave male character from the show 😥. Also it wasn't the same anymore. It felt like it doesn't have something anymore.
I love how Asians and Latinas don’t exist in the new winx universe
What a strange world...
That is classist as well as racism... Sorry to criticize you but I needed to say it
@@izzysabitdizzy6347 Definitely
@@Songs_Stories_and_Superheros this comment was sarcasm, I really hate that they white washed this show. One of the reasons I loved the show was how diverse of the cast was, and flora was my favorite character, so the fact they white washed them is unforgivable
Bro Netflix can’t be ruining our childhoods like that bruh like keep the original and leave it like why😒😒
bc why not i guess
They cannot ruin your childhood because you already grew up hahaha
@@reinesita3687 pfffft exactly
It’s suppose to be a different take. Why can’t people see that? The creators probably told them to differentiate the reboot to the original.
@@MelianLimGachaVideos right, I actually just finished watching it yesterday and it was great
I think some people miss the point that just because there is something new now that doesn't mean that you can't prefer or love the old one. Everyone that wants can watch the new thing and still prefer the old one or maybe like both and you can decide to not like it. I don't understand why people have to hate on something just because it's different and act like are forced to watch it. If you don't like it, that's okay. Then just don't watch it and stick with the old one. That's how easy it is. No need for Drama.
I totally agree!
IDK maybe because this show is disrespecting the source material???? Duh. People have a right to stand up for the things they love, and have a right to get angry when something beloved is trashed.
@@sakuracardcaptor4709 i totally agree, it calls difference of opinions.
@@sakuracardcaptor4709 Sorry but this girl is totally right, no one forces you to watch it? Also the series isn‘t even out yet and you don‘t know if it’s good or not so don’t act like you already watched it and it was so horrible. Also this show isn‘t Winx, it‘s based on it. The creators already confirmed BEFORE the filming started that it’s going to be for young adults and that there‘s going to be a s*x scene. What did you expect? Glitter wings and fairy dust for an adult to watch? I don’t wanna pop your bubble but that’s not how things work :/
If only more people had your mindset...
Apply your logic to everything and the world would be a slightly less scary of a place.
Rip east asian n hispanic representation..
I love how the song fits not just the live action, but the earlier seasons of the cartoon as well!
I love how that wither we watched the orginal Italian, 4kids or Nick we all agree that the Cartoon is the Orginal.
Oh-my-gee! I can't believe that i have so many fellow winx fan! I thought i am the only one left! And also i love the original most and no one can change that.
This is how people must’ve felt when they watched the Avatar live action trailer
LOL
Well unlike the movie that never existed, the reboot was successful.
You mean the last airbender, cause avatar is a completely different movie which imo is a fucking master piece
@@joeramsay6269 Yeah! Avatar was amazing!
This is not a single thing like the winx
And that’s why I enjoyed it
Okay but see how they don’t have to change the colors or brightness of the show to make it seem more mature and serious? The cartoon version of the trailer still presents the same vibe as the live action. Something can still be bright and colorful, while still presenting darker themes. They didn’t have to take away all of the things we loved about the original to adapt it from a kids show to a teen drama.
The only thing I like about the trailer is the music.
I don’t know if I’m excited or scared for this series since the original was so good
Oh god. I understand that the plot and premise of the show will be dark, but that doesn’t mean the color scheme has to be. If they wanted to market the show towards adults who watched the show as a kid, they should have chosen the iconic five fairies (Bloom, Stella, Flora, Musa, Techna) and introduce Aisha/Layla in the next, already confirmed season. Changing up the characters was not a good move. Smushing the villains into one person and changing up the specialists and the relationships was also a terrible idea, since they’re so iconic as well. If they really wanted to break “gender-norms”, give us a non-binary fairy! Give us a lesbian/gay fairy! Putting guys as fairies and girls as specialists, in my opinion, ruins the entire premise Straffi created the show upon- for girls to be the main heroes of the series. The series might be good for those who are coming in expecting something that is not Winx, because this is seriously just W.I.T.C.H meets the live-action Sabrina the Teenage show.
But if they do introduce Aisha in the later seasons, they will accuse Netflix of being "racist" and getting rid of the only black character in the show. It's really no win for them.
@@xdisyurn2164 nah not if they included Flora n Musa (as poc ofc) everyone would understand that they were following how the original went
@@xdisyurn2164 everyone will understand because aisha/layla always came after season 1 I think
I like the idea of fairies and specialists being mixed, since you can always focus more on the girls, but it's kind of pointless because the colorful aura is not there.
If I wanted to see a guy with a wand and a girl with a dragon in the background I would just go to watch harry potter or something. Seeing them as FAIRIES and SPECIALISTS is what really counts.
@xdis yurn are you dumb, nobody will think Netflix is racist for adding her in season 2 of the show. In the original cartoon Aisha was a very Important character implemented in season 2 so it I would only make sense for her be in the second season of the adaptation. And even if that wasn’t the case of the cartoon nobody would be stupid enough to genuinely think thats actually racist. 🤦🏻♀️ think before you speak, Jesus🙄
Well I choose to look at this from a different point of view like a different dimension from my winx kinda view only in this dimension musa isn't asian flora is white with a few extra pounds, techna isn't part of the winx and stella doesn't dress fashionable and allows the rest of the girls to dress outdated 😐
Honestly the best way to look at it.
I call it, myself;
Winx'nt.
Are you upset because Flora and Tecna are not going to be in the remake? (Just asking if you like any of them or the ones who were present.)
Flora is Terra. The only character thats no going to be in this series is Tecna...i cant understand why so for me is a crap version
Dont understand why she isn't techna is a part of the original winx group before Aisha/Layla I don't understand why they thought it was okay to cut her out
@@MeryOFlaherty Terra is finally Flora's cousin, they confirmed it in the book fate
@@MeryOFlaherty tecna is joining in season 2
@priyam kanojiya It's actually Terra because that means earth. They did not mix the characters.
You're comparing a Diamond with glass.
Nay, gold with tin foil
When u realized musa not kiss riven but anothrer guy🤡
The cartoon will always be my favorite😞❤️
Why isn't Musa asian? Where are tecna and flora? They ruined everything
Tecna will join in season 2
Tecna and Flora have been merged as one person called Terra (they mixed their names together).
@@asi-princess Terra in italian means earth, so basically she is flora
Sorry for my english
ehh tecna is not in the reboot no?
The soundtrack can’t save this trash series
Lol, it’s quite successful tbh.
It hurt to see that it’s compared
I wonder why they left techna out when aisha/Layla was the newest member in the original
the music: wacth where you go im a animal?
me: what its suppoesed to be wacth were you im a fairy
Odlično napravljeno
At least it's better than season 8. (This is only my opinion) But Tecna isn't there...
I agree!
_Blühm_ LOL THE ACCENT CAUGHT ME BY SURPRISE
Why can they never make a reboot good and stick to the original 😭
wow liike itt!! but you should've included more scences of S4+
If this wasnt introduced as the Winx reboot but just a series on Fairies it would've been really cool.But now it is considered bad since it doesn't respect the og's storyline
I’ll take great special effects over flashy girly shit any day
To be honest I still prefer the animated Winx Club series more than the live action Netflix's "Fate: The Winx Saga". Because it's strange to do a live action series featuring the Winx Club as I'm aware the charcters and the story is going to be slightly different than the animated Winx Club series. Also the characters looked too old to play teenagers and the series is more drama rather than a magical adventure like the animated Winx Club series. I mean were's their fairy transformation form in Netflix's "Fate: The Winx Saga"?
It makes sense now if u watch it in slow motion it is exactly like winx club but the characters are older
Both are so BEAUTIFUL I LOVE IT AWWW EEEEEK
It was so GOOD I LOVED IT NGK I CANT WAIT FOR SEASON2
No Tecna no party
I didn’t know there was a live-action version......
Although I think I prefer the cartoon...
Seems very interesting though.....
i cant wait for the fate wink saga
Where’s Techna, where’s the trix, this hasn’t come out yet and it is all sort of whack!!!!!!! Ill stick to the animated series. If all six girls aren’t there and the three witch sisters aren’t there not no but hell no. There’s no show without stormy, Darcy, and icy or techna. Even in the animated series when the girls thought they lost techno to the omega portal they even said in the show the winx aren’t the winx without all of them.
*Tecna
I know it‘s sad but Tecna will probably be in the second season but it‘s not confirmed. The trix are replaced by a fairy called Beatrix (Be - a - Trix) she has air powers, I guess like Stormy so at least we have something :)
@@winxclubwings That’s disappointing that they replaced them
EPIC, OH MY GOD, I CANNOT WAIT, I’M TOO FREAKIN’ EXCITED NOW🥰
Impressionnant comme le choix des actrices est mal fait...gg Netflix
Three words
WHERE IS TECNA???
First: It‘s Tecna and not Techna
Second: She will probably be in season 2 but it‘s not confirmed
I'm sorry but I just spend my entire Christmas and New Years rewatching ALL the Winx Club series and movies, and just saw the trailer for this remake of Winx, and nothing can ever compare to the OG. OG winx just hit differently
Çok güzel olmuş eline sağlık
Im so excited for the new winx movies i love the winx
Did they totally forget Techna existed?
It is honestly like they just made a random movie and just called it winx to gain more popularity, this is absolutely nothing like the original
Am I the only one who hoped Liz Gillies would be one of them lol
If there's a battle of the Winx Club between the O.Gs vs the noobs. You better believe I backing up the O.Gs.
Im disappointed on what they did on the other characters cause if they can’t do it like the original version they should’ve never even made it
Shut up the original is much much better the original be best forever
You know, with it put side by side, it's actually kinda intriguing
The original be best forever original is the best 😍🥰🥰
Guys stop with he hate, it's not going to be the same as the original. It's a "REMAKE!" so stop.
Where is Techna?
Absolutely genius
To tell the truth, winx club was one of those cartoons I thought wasn’t going to turn into a live action, let alone by Netflix. Let see if they did it justice...
But at 0:26 is Sky not Riven. Still a really cool video!
No, I‘m pretty sure it‘s Freddie Thorp (Riven) and not Danny Griffin (Sky)
@@winxclubwings yeah sorry I was confused 🙄😂
@@damlaacll Why u replieing After 7 MONTHS KRNDNEKFKKDKD
@@winxclubwings cause RUclips just showed me now 🙍🏻♀️
Gosh....At least they didn't whitewash Aisha
They white washed musa and replaced flora with a white character
@@vsmoxs8382 Well, Atleast Aisha is the same
@@izzysabitdizzy6347 tokenism shouldn’t be applauded
Reboot is very nice that song amazing and mind blowing
Honestly I’m going to try watching this when it comes out!
There could be nicer girls in it, a real pity they don't even look like the anime
Original be win!
Fate looks nice and I would give it a shot, but the original is always gonna be my fav
Remember when the Winx broke up because they thought Tecna was dead and that it wasn’t the same without her?
Yeah, me too.
Remember when this whole series was so great because of its bright colors and futuristic style mixed with fantasy worked out so well?
Yep, me too.
Wait... what?! What episode?!
I’m exactly sure- somewhere between episodes 10-20 of season three (when Tecna got her Enchantix, basically)
The reboot lost before it even had a chance
There’s only one problem, it seems that on the part of the trix she and Beatrix are saying that it would have to be the technician
Tecna
I was looking for a new series for my daughter to watch so far this looks ok for her
I don‘t know how old your daughter is but if she‘s younger then 13 I wouldn’t recommend it because there‘s some scenes in it that aren‘t for " children ". It‘s more for teens and young adults but It‘s still so good and interesting!
WOW! AMAZING!
I hope kiko is in the new series he must be!
I’m excited for the new one they both look good to me!
I’m so exited for this!!
This is the best part for me for both of these. 0:12
Gracias, estaba re perdida y me moría
I am excited to watch
All I can think of is: No colors - Dark & Colourful - Winx
Netflix ruins childhoods when it comes to live action
Live action
Tecna might be in season 2.
I grew up watching this show. I really enjoy watching this. I get why I watched this as a toddler this show is great. Glad its getting a reboot. Hopefully it's good. But I really believe that the original is better.
Waw ang ganda
So cool
WHERE IS MY HANDSOME BRANDON
Cap: hold my shield and hammer
Ok the fact that they probably won't have transformations and wings to fly with is the ultimate sad part. THAT WAS THE BEST PART.
My sister who works with Netflix told me about this my childhood is ruined it is a disgrace
Wow like
Ugrasilmiş mukemel
This is not same one but it is different . Every one is hating this but in a different it look s good.
Had to cleanse my eyes thank you