English is no longer the language of the English people only. It is today an international language and the language of communication all over the world. Those who had promoted Hindi wanted to destroy India. Gandhi, Morarji Desai, Jag Jivan Ram created a lot of problem. Gandhi was responsible for the Partition of India. Why should we listen to these people?
It is very difficult to make any conclusion whether Hindi language is dividing or uniting India. After all our country is a multi- lingual country and we should proud of it.
No it not difficult at all. It is one of the tool along with Hindutuva used since our independence to unify India as a nation. Problem is you cannot unify India and create a nation out of this w.o destroying all other individual nation's culture, language and history inside India. Thus yeah both Hindi chauvinism and Hindutuva is dividing India and hurting it. As both has it's origin northern part of India it is really up to northerners to put a stop to it and as you said "be proud of multi-lingual and multi-cultural property of India".
None of the language can replace English...bcz it is now a global language and with English India has reached this much economical growth....English only gives JOBS for us...Nowadays all European , Asian countries are taking more effort to teach English to their citizen. But at the same time we should also learn our Mother tongue to maintain our identity...
No body is talking about removing english, english should be taught is each and every school,but our link language or representative language for the nation should be hindi or better yet sanskrit.
Sivakumar Ganesan But non English speaking countries don't have official bilingual policy. They learn English based on their needs just like South Indians learn Hindi as an option. So, hindi should be offered as an option. Except Tamilians, other south Indians speak good Hindi. So, it is not an imposition. As far as link language is concerned, Sanskrit should become the link language. Nobody gets any unfair advantage because most have to learn it from scratch including Hindi speakers and devanigiri script is not the official Sanskrit script either. Sanskrit can be written in any script. European countries are united under Euro and NATO. Most European languages have 40 to 90% Sanskrit words like Indian regional languages (including Tamil). So, SANSKRIT can become the link language of future Europe. Then Indians would also accept it because they love to ape their white masters.😀😀
@@indianmilitary Sanskrit in europe???🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣 what drugs are u on??? Sanskrit is dead language long back. Its dead in India itself. No European speak sanskrit. 😂😂😂😂 What next?? Dinosaurs spoke sanskrit???🤣🤣🤣🤣 But nice joke really.....see often we ask for seperate nation but we'll surely miss this kind of humour if seperated. Atleast to watch ur funny comments we'll stay in ur India.😌😌 Thanx for the joke. Keep them coming.
Hindi as a national language you can sell pakoda in the hindi belts in all BIMARU state's. English as an official language you can sell software to the entire world and run international call centre earning dollar for the country. Even the prime minister modi addressed the NYSE as "may the phorce be with you."
murimookan If that was the case, why Japan, China, Germany, France and other non English speaking countries were not exporting "Pakodas" 😀😀 . Have some sense of shame Mr Lord Macaulay's child. I do agree that Hindi cannot become the link language. But Sanskrit can since most have to learn from the scratch including Hindi speakers. Nobody gets any unfair advantage. Devanagiri script is not the official script of Sanskrit. It also means, Sanskrit can be written in any script.
@@indianmilitary well why can't we use Marathi, they are one giving more income to this union now and at past they are one who mainly fought Gazni and Mughals. They are more intelligent/smart and open.
I think it is because Sanskrit has a really complicated grammar system. I am trying to teach myself the language and I do not know if you have…but the grammar itself takes a long time to figure out, and that is before learning all of the vocabulary.
HINDI cannot become the link language because it gives unfair advantage to Hindi speakers at least initially. Let us make Sanskrit - the link language since most have to learn it including Hindi speakers. By the way, devanagiri is NOT the official script of Sanskrit. So, hindi speakers cannot have that advantage. Sanskrit can be written in any script.
NO TO HINDI IMPOSITION. UNLESS AT LEAST 30% OF HINDI SPEAKING PEOPLE HAVE TO LEARN ANY ONE REGIONAL LANGUAGE... WHEN OUR CONSTITUTION IS NOT GOING TO RECOGNIZE ENGLISH....THEN ONLY INDI LANGUANGES SHOULD PREVAIL.
Learning Hindi is not a problem. If Hindi is a national language then even other languages should also be considered. Most of the north states when they work in south don't learn southern language and even insult them because southern states are accomodating.
Other languages are already national language, we have 22 of those, but official language should be one for easy connection and easy representation of india in global stage. Hindi is already the defacto link language of the country, it should be madfe official as its better for the country.
Yes. HINDI cannot become the link language because it gives unfair advantage to Hindi speakers at least initially. Let us make Sanskrit - the link language since most have to learn it including Hindi speakers. By the way, devanagiri is NOT the official script of Sanskrit. So, hindi speakers cannot have that advantage. Sanskrit can be written in any script.
No need to impose Hindi in South India. We are united by our culture and rich traditions and so we are tolerant. The local language and culture need to be respected and promoted. People must be given free choice and mother tongue is very important.
Hindi and a few other languages are derived from sanskrit which is a classical language and is very conjunct with ancient Indian culture and dharma. So if majority are pinning for a India to be a hindu rashtra, so wouldn't sanskrit be a good starting point to have it introduced as a compulsory subject at all schools. And in the process you can sift out a large no of anti-nationals who would almost certainly be against this.
Sanskrit is only for the conservative Brahmins and nobody else will be ready to accept Sanskrit as India's National language, because they Hate the Brahmins and the Dharma of the Ancient Hindu culture. The puristic & Classical Traditional Sanskrit is far too complicated to learn for the common Hindus and if they Hate Hindi, Sanskrit will be like Poison for them.
Nope Hindi is a language very much influenced by Urdu, Persian, Turki, and Afghani languages Compare that to South Indian languages which are all classical languages of India and has remained uninfluenced by middle eastern languages....
@@satyamanu2211 Wrong, Urdu is a language which was influenced by hindi, arabic and persian not the other way around. Urdu is our own language as well. Pure hindi is highly similar to sanskrit and is derived directly from it.
Pragasan Archary Yes, You are absolutely correct. We need Sanskrit as the link language not Hindi. So, we need both Sanskrit (regional link language) and English (international link language). We need a level playing field. Sanskrit also can be written in any script.
@@satyamanu2211 currently there's only 3 classical languages in the world viz sanskrit, tamil and latin. Other south Indian languages are derived mainly from sanskrit and tamll.
Kichad has no right to demean Hindi language. He should know that hindi is the most most spoken language in India. Nobody knows kannada out of Karnataka.
Only about 40 percent of the people of India speak Hindi which includes Maithili, Bhojpiri, Aubad dialect, Rajasthani dialect, which most Hindi speakers from Patna of Benares could not even understand.
A lie propagated by nationalist to cover the fact Hindi is most broken language in existence. 1) Hindi is only spoken in major cities in north where trade flourishes and in most other regions of any northern state it is that state's language that is spoken widely. Example Marathi. 2) Even among these hindi speaking states no two states speak the same version of Hindi. Since it is a conjunction of other language without even a script for it's own there are influence of lot from local language of each state into their spoken hindi. Which makes this trope that "majority of India speaks hindi" even more of a lie.
due to this mentality, maharashtra, gujurat, punjab and other hindi speaking states dont have a successful movie industry! Hindi speaking actors dont have jobs in bollywood and they audition in south indian movies!
We don't accept Hindi imposition by any national party or any individual. Doing this by anyone is always imposition and it is not integration in past and in future also
You are having hindi as mother tongue, as per three languages policy what's your third language. You just learn only 2 which is your mother tongue which is hindi and English. But we have to learn our mother tongue and English and your mother tongue. Is there any fair treatment. Nigeria, Rwanda, south africa, SG and lot are all well developed having multiple lingo ethno population and they have all their native languages as national languages and have one connecting language which is from outside of their land. These countries have people with senses of real democracy not like hindi population in India and any union govt of any party behaving like Han Chinese, and Chinese party's. If so let's use Bengali the language of Indian national anthem. Or lets use Marathi the language of Maharashtra a state earning more than 60% of union's income. Or lets use Kannada language of Karnataka India's silicon valley the only full techno of this union. Or let's use the language of traditional Shiva worship of Kashmir for atleast to celebrate the past of india atleast.
If Hindi is to be a national language, it should be pure and " Suddha" Hindi but not mixed with Urdu. If it is pure, as it has common words with even Southern part of India.
Can you find a book that teaches Suddha Hindi? Or a tv or radio program where all of the voices are in Suddha Hindi? It’s not something anyone can readily wrong because you can barely find any resources online.
These many days there was no problem suddenly why should we learn Hindi do North Indians learn or can they spell ne word properly if they learn South Indian language s then let us think what should we do🤣🤣🤣 with hindi
Bollywood is trying to make trouble as it’s drowning Trying to disturb peace South Indians are doing great , leave it as it is . South Indians should embrace Hindi but no imposition pl
They are enabled by our constitution and quite a few important figures in past. Both should be broken if we are ever gona get rid of this debate and shenanigans from nationalist.
But nobody knows it, If somebody says I am using this brand and many peoples are using the same brand but the greatnes is with some other brand. Most peoples will chose the former one because its a marketing Technology propagated even before Independance. Delhi was at the central during Independance and they want to communicate with South and other parts so they should have learned it but they forced and still forcing other peoples to do it . ONE of the exception is Bharathiyar.
1. Due to the common language hindi is spoken in Gujurat, Maharashtra, Punjab and many other states, they dont have their own successful movie industry! All these gujurathis, marathis, punjabis have to go to bollywood for jobs! 2. Take a look at IPL, you get commentary in English, Hindi, Tamil, Telugu, Kannada but not in Punjabi, Gujurathi, Haryanvi or other languages beacuse these people understands hindi! Tamil speaking guy gets a job as commentator but not a guy from gujurat! 3. Hollywood release their movies in Hindi, Tamil, Telugu, Kannada thus they need to hire a local experts of each language thus creating jobs! South Indians dont hate Hindi, but hindi imposition will have adverse effects on jobs in the long run! The competition in bollywood is soo high that there are soo many hindi speaking good actors with no jobs!
I think the problem lies in calling it as a national language. Why not call it just as the common communication language. People are not taking their stand via rational thinking but having taken it rationalise it. They don't seem to realise that they have no control, they can't have it at a global level, but westerners especially Americans do. They provide the larger content portion which as experienced is not appropriate to India's common culture and ancestral intellectual heritage. Not to overlook the economic implications and impact.
Mate did you hit your head somewhere or are you trying to be a smart-ass?. A common communication language is the gateway to link language or national language. Problem is Hindi should have never been one of the two official language of India. The prevalent trope that majority northern population speaks Hindi is a lie. Hindi is prevalent only in major cities of North and they too do not speak the same version of it. The other reason why no individual language can act as a national language to India is because India itself is not a nation. It doesn't has it's own culture or separate history. It's culture and history is the collection of every individual nations inside this country. This is why we call India a union of nations. And if there is any language that should act as a link / official language it should be English. Or better just make all 22 language as official language of India why split hair and let English be the link language as it is common in both in Hindi speaking region and in non-hindi speaking region. This way we all will have to share the burden of learning English instead of making Hindi as a official language and pushing the burden only to non-hindi speakers. Thus the problem is either Hindi being one of the official language of India or just Hindi being one of the official language of India. And constant attempt from northern politician and pundits to push Hindi into the south aka Hindi chauvinism.
If you wants to impose uniform civil code in country keeping aside constitutional law.Than ..Hindhi..should. be our National Launguage as well as official..Good Luck 👍.. 🙏..
ahh no. You also can do that with English or any other official recognized Indian language. Good luck to you for when you break out of that bubble mate.
No Hindi for South. We squarely don't want it. We need to learn our language. No need for Hindi. . If at all you learn the south Indian language. . If Rahul is. Proud malayalee then speak in Malayalam first. Let us hear it. As a teacher I can tell you due to this ridiculous imposition the malayalee children do not learn Malayalam and can barely read It is a language with immense depth and literature. Rahul is a chameleon who changed colour as per the situation. He lacks any depth of thinking and lacks sincerity.
what is the south Indian language? Malayalam? Tamil? telugu? Kannada? what is it? You cant expect people to learn four languages can you? I don't understand why you are speaking English of all languages and holds animosity against another Indic language
@@flextape1859 who are you to dictate what should be our ancient identity, each language have its own deep root spirituality and beauty. It's very simple to keep your mother tongue and the first language which connected whole of India.
@babulalsuryakant sharma India is already having very low IQ and it got from 86 to 75 . And film entertainment makes no good for India rather than it makes people more fools and makes outsiders to not mention. Too cringe .
We in the south are not against Hindi but the imposition of Hindi on us. This will be treated as the third language they learn not the second. Presently their mother tongue is the optional third language which is killing the language itself By this you are killing the diversity and the ability of the child to appreciate his own mother tongue. So ease do not mix up your silly agenda of national unity with language. People are already learning enough functional Hindi which is more than enough. Let them become pandits in the richness of their own mother tongue.
where are you idiots pulling these numbers from?. Because honestly there is no hard data anywhere on this planet to give a tangible value to mixing of Indian languages.
who the fk told you 30% sanskrit in tamil just another ignorant fool who has no idea about tamil baseless arugment show your mindset and knowledge fools like you are the reason we hate sanskrit supporters who has zero knowledge.
Hindi should be our national language that doesn't mean the regional or state languages are degraded. We are still in the colonial hangover or submission. We should give english to continue as one of the languages. Russia China Japan german and many other countries, their language is not english.
EINSTEIN STORY 💯 One day Einstein Makes the large hole in door for mother cat 😺 In few days, next to the large hole, he makes small hole for kitten 🐈 Then only he realised, large hole itself enough for both kitten and cat That small hole is Hindi That large hole is English English is enough to connect peoples in All over world. Assuming North India and pro hindi imposing peoples are part of world 🌍
Samskrutam has been the common language used all across our civilization North south east and west used that same language let us bring it back and let samskrutam retake the slot as the unifying language of our nation.
We are happy with our languages. There is no need to force any language on any other people. Hindi apart from the numerical advantage it doesn't add any value to people in south. So there is no need for us to learn Hindi.
*Please say no to language war* I am a Indian from the North , but I don't believe in common language . We Indians are always exception .We don't require any common language to become united , If South Indian don't wanna speek in Hindi they should be not be forced to do so. But l am also against hindi buycot . Both Hindi and English are the official language and that's why no one should try to impose other languages too. In South politicians even criticize mensoning of Hindi but not English , For Indians from South they follow different rules , let's say a tamil person if goes to Kanada (Karnataka) he will be allowed to whisper Tamil people will understand that he don't know Kannada and English but if a Bihari can't , In Bihar their exists five local languages but they don't feel shy in talking in hindi outside .
North Indians should answer this question ❓ State of HINDI & Land of Hindi... It's a Market language (mixed of Arabic, Persian, Turkish, and Indian dialets..) 700 years before... ( Sanskrit also don't have land and people group... it's a communication dialet among Arabic Persian, Indian region at that time.) most of the north Indians forget about their language (mother tongue) and support Hindi 😅 that's why most of the north Indian languages lost their identity 😢 Bihari, Oriyaa, Rajasthani, Panjabi, bengali, kaasmiri, Marathi😢 (its just like telling neighbour as their parents)
Im telugu person.i cannot speak hindhi.but i can read and write.i support hindhi.we need one common language.we need one nation one offcial language (hindhi). remaining languages people choice.
You are having hindi as mother tongue as per three languages policy what's your third language. You just learn only 2 which is your mother tongue which is hindi and English. But we have to learn our mother tongue and English and your mother tongue. Is there any fair treatment. Nigeria, Rwanda, south africa, SG and lot are all well developed having multiple lingo ethno population and they have all their native languages as national languages and have one connecting language which is from outside of their land. These countries have people with senses of real democracy not like hindi population in India and any union govt of any party behaving like Han Chinese, and Chinese party's. If so let's use Bengali the language of Indian national anthem. Or lets use Marathi the language of Maharashtra a state earning more than 60% of union's income. Or lets use Kannada language of Karnataka India's silicon valley the only full techno of this union. Or let's use the language of traditional Shiva worship of Kashmir for atleast to celebrate the past of india atleast. If best country don't behave like Han population of China and C C P of China.
All these people killing Indian language by discussion One Indian language not shining on International platform. TAMIL is not old language Sanskrit and Kannada older than Tamil. TAMIL is old language according to Politicians not the statement of Linguistics expert
Unnecessary debate, the HM should not have raised this issue at all, does our country needs the language debate Now, take the country to development path not this way
Its very surprising that European example is not at all reckoned. Despite common religion, they are divided into tiny Nations where as vast country of ours is United despite multi languages...plesse don't try to put one language over other great languages of ours
It is the reason why we need Sanskrit as the link language. Nobody gets any unfair advantage because most have to learn it from scratch including Hindi speakers and devanigiri script is not the official Sanskrit script either. Sanskrit can be written in any script. European countries are united under Euro and NATO. Most European languages have 40 to 90% Sanskrit words like Indian regional languages (including Tamil). So, SANSKRIT can become the link language of the future Europe. Then Indians would also accept it because they love to ape their white masters.😀😀
Dear Shri Rahul Shivshankar, I liked the way you have presented your own background. I am a Kannadiga, but I believe it is advisable to have national language and Hindi fits this bill more than any other language.
Sanskrit is better. Hindi as the link language gives unfair advantage to Hindi speaking people at least initially. When it comes to Sanskrit, most have to learn from scratch. Moreover, Sanskrit can be written in any script.
In today's world how we believe in Mahatma Gandhi ideology, if that is the case why BJP is not accepting Congress. It is depending upon time and change must be there. Don't say that Mahatma Gandhi told this and that
I would say govt should focus on sanskrit which has been replaced with urdu and hindustani in film industry.. no one speak pure hindi india except couple of states.. can all stop talking hindustani which is mix of hindi and urdu
didn't urdu aswell was made in India? As for sanskrit I would like it aswell but its impractical in current stage. The people who speak sanskrit in daily lives is even less than one percent, to tell you how stupid the situation is, the people of india who speak french as mother tongue are more in numbers.
@@rickycool6083 off course its... socalled hindi cenima itself lack pure hindi and we have been watching for decades. Perhaps , we could have had even urdu cenima or etc.... Had we maintained n given importance to languages at their positions this situation wouldn't have arise. Therefore , it's tough now to repair or make things fall in place, as diversity exists since years n changes took place long back...let people decide , we have managed/succeeded it till now
Our language is just like the Quran,if i as a northeast if a hindi spoken man say's kharap admi,if i says why you accuse me as kharap,then the hindi speaking person can misinterpreted like Arabic no kharap means you look so young today's, that's is why Hindi is needed to every Indians, otherwise it will be like Indian reading a quran in arabic knowing nothing out of it.
Mr.Ajay D., first of all stop advertising gutkas/liquor ., you earn a lot to ruin younger generation and you preach, you bollywood actors/actress try to ruin this country even if you feel a little way, if at all.
In Tamil Nadu, those non Tamil leaders who spearheaded agitation against Hindi learning, making innocent people believe that there is threat to mother tongue Tamil. But all schools run by DMK and ADMK party corporates are extorting money by selling Hindi and English. Only poor could not study hindi as no government school provides Hindi teaching. Crores of rupees is spent by lakhs of people to learn hindi. Other opposition ruled states also joined the chorus for petty political mileage.
We don't need a National language. You can't get all Indians to speak one language. What we need is a link language. We can have both English and Hindi as the link languages. For God's sake, the North Indians must stop starting their Hindi day speeches with the most annoying opener:- 'Hindi hamara Rashtra bhasha hai...'
Why can't we have both Hindi and English as link languages? Inspite of the hate campaign against English... many South Indians as well as North Indians like to learn and speak English. Even labourers want their children to learn English in schools. English is not a foreign language it belongs to Indians also... most of us speak Indian English as opposed to Queen's English.
English is a foreign language. And no there is no hate campaign against english, english should and will be taught to each and every student in every school however our official language should be indian language. Hindi seems most practical as nearly 70% of indians atleast understand it. Sanskrit is also a good choice, cause of our civilizational history, but its way more difficult to implement.
suraj m We need Sanskrit and English not Hindi. Sanskrit as the regional link language and English as the link language outside INDIA. Everybody has to learn Sanskrit, at least most of them from scratch and nobody gets any unfair advantage. Sanskrit also can be written in any script.
@@rickycool6083 English can even be from Mars... but the fact remains that we Indians have inherited the colonial legacy. We dress like the British and have been educated in English.
@@humanitysucks1233 : Looks like Madara pass out. We keralite (sic) loves (sic) So, this is the STANDARD of English language in Kerala. God save ,God's own country.
@@Attitudezero884 : That is the reason for your mental slavery although the slave-makers left our land 75 years ago. Nobody is thrusting Hindi upon you in Bharat but you have thrust English upon yourself only if to appear like a DARK third class copy of an Englishman.
you have it wrong Hindi is not being imposed in south,those who speak it are ethnically cleansed or converted.Investigate your facts how congress has allowed people with certain ideology cannot be challaged
Hindustan is not same as Hindistan. India doesn't need one national language. It is not about Madrasi Vs north India. Bollywood for all it's achievements and recognition earned worldwide, is the creation of Pan India from the very beginning. To proclaim that hindi is already a national language is a poor reflection and is a revelation of ignorance. Jai Hind!
We need Sanskrit as the link language not Hindi. So, we need both Sanskrit (regional link language) and English (international link language). We need a level playing field. Sanskrit also can be written in any script.
here is a difference between imposition and suggestion. It was suggested Hindi can be a national language. either take the suggesion or leave it. there ends the matter. the channels are playing the game along with politicians and prominent persons like actors. The actors of south should not dub their films in Hindi. Double standard.
@@ravichandrantns3799 These are 2 different issues. A lot of Hollywood films are dubbed in Hindi, too. Does it mean that Americans should start learning Hindi??
All Language in world has its own essence in terms of culture,dialect and it's regional strength, by imposing will destroy it So India is seen is multicultural Nation, it was going on well why sudden change
Mate the origin of this debate is our constitution. It has more than one law that favors just hindi and none towards other native languages of India. The plan for infusing these laws was to make Hindi as national to unify India as one nation some years ago. Some egocentric nationalist a-holes in the north still cling on to this huge mistake in our constitution to this day that is the problem. Congress tried it for year and it passed this mantle of responsibility to current BJP in power. So no it never was going well w.r to language or religion in our country!.
Rahul Ishwar is right . This women has lost it. Hindi as a link language should not be an issue. This does not undermine any other language. This is a psycholgical drama playing in her mind. She is sugar coating her malice for Hindu subconciously.
Hindi imposed on any other regional language is not acceptable .. it will never happen in Secular India . But not accepting Hindi as an alternative to Quinglish .. is majboori ka naam Mohan Das Karamchand Gandhi
An alternative for English meaning everyone should learn Quindy?. What you think you are a smart-ass by giving a spin on your nationalistic view?. What real value to do people think quindy have once we learn that thing?. Where is reason to put that effort?. IDIOTS 🤦♂️😡
by choice people talk in their preferred language there has been no problem .but the movement some one ask u to follow path decided by other would not go that easy... by the way who will monitor who is talking what , biggest joke of century. They govt can monitor this rather monitor public issues.
Learning another language Hindi, with enhance the brain and make life colourful. Tamilians speak Tamil with every sentences filled with English words. British left Freedom obtained Slave to the British Raj is evident. Bharat is pluralistic and colourful. The British were successful in shuffling English down our throats. To be in their good books and to survive learning English there was no objection! Is English a language of Bharat? Learning Hindi the people won’t become lesser or feel mother tongue compromised. AR Rahman composes for Hindi films, why? He should stick to his Tamil only. More languages means versatility. If Rahul can’t speak English than it’s your parents who didn’t pass it to you!
This tamilnadu peoples are dual minded. They oppose hindi in tamilnadu but when they move out of tamilnadu for jobs, business or any other purposes. Than their hindi heat goes in to bay of bangal. I couldn't understand what is problem with tamilnadu peoples!
Not only tamil nadu We keralites also can't.. Can embrace hindi,but Imposing hindi is not fair.. Hindi will be choice language in south indian education system (kerala ,tamil nadu) don't know how andra & karnataka , Tamil is pure language that made in india. Hindi is the mixed language of urdu ,parshi ,arabic .😂and saying non hindi speakers are Foreigners.. Lol..that doesn't make sense. We loves tamil than Panipuri language. Here there are many problems of inflation ,but focusing and dividing peoples by religious and language.. Well done BJP. Jai modi ji.💩
@@humanitysucks1233 what a stupid thought you got ! Hindi is chosen as official language by constitute assembly while framing our constitute . Than where is the role of modi ji ? You say that Tamil is pure language than what about sanskrit ? It's more pure than Tamil. You mentioned that kerala peoples also don't want hindi ! Than you come and meet with kerala peoples in mumbai. The problem with hindi is not with Tamil, kerala and Kanda peoples. The problem is with the mind set of kerala left and Tamil dravid mind set . Who are stick to false narrative of maikale education left propaganda and believe that hindi is language of North India and imposed on them . In fact when these peoples travel out of their states then the know hindi but when they are back they oppose hindi . What a hypocrisy and dual policy!
@@shrikantdubey63 bruh. At that time also hindi was largest speaking language is hindi in india.. And there are no National language in india.. 😂 And kerala peoples coming to north indian states?? Then do u have any idea how many Northies working in south india?? Lmao.. why can't they speak our language?? And why should we learn hindi?? Use English as link language. That's it.. No need of hindi😂 And tamil is much older than sanskriti.. Making sankrit as national language is acceptable. 🤣But making a foreign mix language as national language is unacceptable.. Sanjay nishant up leader said "non hindi speakers are not indians ,they are foreigners".. *Lol speaking foreign mixed language makes indian* *and* *speaking pure indian orgin languages makes Foreigner* 😂.. And we are not even against hindi..but we are against hindi imposing
@@humanitysucks1233 what a hypocrisy hindi is forgien language ? Than what is your great opinion about at present you and me are having conversations ? Overcome from North Indian and hindi heatered.
@@humanitysucks1233 wow what a stupid argument the north Indian to learn your language but you will not ! You wish that north people to learn Tamil Malayalam, kannada, tulu and telgu OT OK they will do now are you ready to learn dogri ,gadhwali ,panjab, hryanvi avdhi, bundelkhsndi,kanuji, maithili bsngali, bundelkhandi, oriya chharishgarhi in addition to hindi . I have left many languages which are spoken and scripts are deferential Now decide . You have to take inspiration from arunachal pradesh where more than 2000 languages are there but their state language is hindi. Pata nahi tum kub sudharenge
I am from South India Tamilnadu for me Hindi also foreign language...
Ok english is not foreign language 😂
English is no longer the language of the English people only. It is today an international language and the language of communication all over the world. Those who had promoted Hindi wanted to destroy India. Gandhi, Morarji Desai, Jag Jivan Ram created a lot of problem. Gandhi was responsible for the Partition of India. Why should we listen to these people?
It is very difficult to make any conclusion whether Hindi language is dividing or uniting India.
After all our country is a multi- lingual country and we should proud of it.
No it not difficult at all. It is one of the tool along with Hindutuva used since our independence to unify India as a nation. Problem is you cannot unify India and create a nation out of this w.o destroying all other individual nation's culture, language and history inside India. Thus yeah both Hindi chauvinism and Hindutuva is dividing India and hurting it. As both has it's origin northern part of India it is really up to northerners to put a stop to it and as you said "be proud of multi-lingual and multi-cultural property of India".
Hindi should not be imposed on the Non-Hindi speaking people unless you want to destroy India.
Unity in diversity beauty of india.. eventually it's people choice
None of the language can replace English...bcz it is now a global language and with English India has reached this much economical growth....English only gives JOBS for us...Nowadays all European , Asian countries are taking more effort to teach English to their citizen.
But at the same time we should also learn our Mother tongue to maintain our identity...
No body is talking about removing english, english should be taught is each and every school,but our link language or representative language for the nation should be hindi or better yet sanskrit.
Sivakumar Ganesan But non English speaking countries don't have official bilingual policy. They learn English based on their needs just like South Indians learn Hindi as an option. So, hindi should be offered as an option. Except Tamilians, other south Indians speak good Hindi. So, it is not an imposition.
As far as link language is concerned, Sanskrit should become the link language. Nobody gets any unfair advantage because most have to learn it from scratch including Hindi speakers and devanigiri script is not the official Sanskrit script either. Sanskrit can be written in any script.
European countries are united under Euro and NATO. Most European languages have 40 to 90% Sanskrit words like Indian regional languages (including Tamil). So, SANSKRIT can become the link language of future Europe. Then Indians would also accept it because they love to ape their white masters.😀😀
English should be declared as National Language of India.
@@beinggoodhuman846 there are no takers for English as a national language. Perhaps only TN wants!!
@@indianmilitary Sanskrit in europe???🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣 what drugs are u on??? Sanskrit is dead language long back. Its dead in India itself. No European speak sanskrit. 😂😂😂😂 What next?? Dinosaurs spoke sanskrit???🤣🤣🤣🤣 But nice joke really.....see often we ask for seperate nation but we'll surely miss this kind of humour if seperated. Atleast to watch ur funny comments we'll stay in ur India.😌😌 Thanx for the joke. Keep them coming.
Hindi as a national language you can sell pakoda in the hindi belts in all BIMARU state's. English as an official language you can sell software to the entire world and run international call centre earning dollar for the country. Even the prime minister modi addressed the NYSE as "may the phorce be with you."
This same politicians who are vouching for hindi will send their children to english medium schools
murimookan If that was the case, why Japan, China, Germany, France and other non English speaking countries were not exporting "Pakodas" 😀😀 . Have some sense of shame Mr Lord Macaulay's child. I do agree that Hindi cannot become the link language. But Sanskrit can since most have to learn from the scratch including Hindi speakers. Nobody gets any unfair advantage. Devanagiri script is not the official script of Sanskrit. It also means, Sanskrit can be written in any script.
@@indianmilitary well why can't we use Marathi, they are one giving more income to this union now and at past they are one who mainly fought Gazni and Mughals. They are more intelligent/smart and open.
@@prasad-srinivasan Have u learnt marathi?
@@mlg1279 if you ready to teach for free i m ready
Kasthuri is the only sensible conversationalist in this debate...
People can learn and speak English,German,French or any other language with one year course. Then why not Sanskrit...
Yeah why Sanskrit?. Usually there is a strong reason to put that kind of effort...what tangible reason is there to learn Sanskrit?.
Sanskrit is a dead language.
I think it is because Sanskrit has a really complicated grammar system. I am trying to teach myself the language and I do not know if you have…but the grammar itself takes a long time to figure out, and that is before learning all of the vocabulary.
Hindi is not inspiration regional language , why last 75 years forced on south indians , does north indians learn south indian language culture
REMOVE HINDI AS OFFICIAL LANGUAGE FIRST. AND ADVISE TO SOUTH. IT IS A DISCRIMINATION TO ALL SOUTH FROM INDEPENDENCE
HINDI cannot become the link language because it gives unfair advantage to Hindi speakers at least initially. Let us make Sanskrit - the link language since most have to learn it including Hindi speakers. By the way, devanagiri is NOT the official script of Sanskrit. So, hindi speakers cannot have that advantage. Sanskrit can be written in any script.
NO TO HINDI IMPOSITION. UNLESS AT LEAST 30% OF HINDI SPEAKING PEOPLE HAVE TO LEARN ANY ONE REGIONAL LANGUAGE...
WHEN OUR CONSTITUTION IS NOT GOING TO RECOGNIZE ENGLISH....THEN ONLY INDI LANGUANGES SHOULD PREVAIL.
English should be declared as National Language so that there is no debate on National Language at all.
In South India Maximum number of people speaking Kannada as their Link language after Mother tongue.
Telugu is the largest spoken Dravidian language. Not Kannada
Learning Hindi is not a problem.
If Hindi is a national language then even other languages should also be considered.
Most of the north states when they work in south don't learn southern language and even insult them because southern states are accomodating.
Other languages are already national language, we have 22 of those, but official language should be one for easy connection and easy representation of india in global stage. Hindi is already the defacto link language of the country, it should be madfe official as its better for the country.
Yes. HINDI cannot become the link language because it gives unfair advantage to Hindi speakers at least initially. Let us make Sanskrit - the link language since most have to learn it including Hindi speakers. By the way, devanagiri is NOT the official script of Sanskrit. So, hindi speakers cannot have that advantage. Sanskrit can be written in any script.
@@rickycool6083never people in south donno Hindi if you try to impose believe me india will be divided again
No need to impose Hindi in South India. We are united by our culture and rich traditions and so we are tolerant. The local language and culture need to be respected and promoted. People must be given free choice and mother tongue is very important.
Absolutely
You fucking south indian have any common language 😂😂😂 no right like we have common language hindu what about south 😂😂
Hindi and a few other languages are derived from sanskrit which is a classical language and is very conjunct with ancient Indian culture and dharma. So if majority are pinning for a India to be a hindu rashtra, so wouldn't sanskrit be a good starting point to have it introduced as a compulsory subject at all schools. And in the process you can sift out a large no of anti-nationals who would almost certainly be against this.
Sanskrit is only for the conservative Brahmins and nobody else will be ready to accept Sanskrit as India's National language, because they Hate the Brahmins and the Dharma of the Ancient Hindu culture.
The puristic & Classical Traditional Sanskrit is far too complicated to learn for the common Hindus and if they Hate Hindi, Sanskrit will be like Poison for them.
Nope
Hindi is a language very much influenced by Urdu, Persian, Turki, and Afghani languages
Compare that to South Indian languages which are all classical languages of India and has remained uninfluenced by middle eastern languages....
@@satyamanu2211 Wrong, Urdu is a language which was influenced by hindi, arabic and persian not the other way around. Urdu is our own language as well. Pure hindi is highly similar to sanskrit and is derived directly from it.
Pragasan Archary Yes, You are absolutely correct. We need Sanskrit as the link language not Hindi. So, we need both Sanskrit (regional link language) and English (international link language). We need a level playing field. Sanskrit also can be written in any script.
@@satyamanu2211 currently there's only 3 classical languages in the world viz sanskrit, tamil and latin. Other south Indian languages are derived mainly from sanskrit and tamll.
Kichad has no right to demean Hindi language. He should know that hindi is the most most spoken language in India. Nobody knows kannada out of Karnataka.
Only about 40 percent of the people of India speak Hindi which includes Maithili, Bhojpiri, Aubad dialect, Rajasthani dialect, which most Hindi speakers from Patna of Benares could not even understand.
If you don't agree with kiccha then we don't agree with gutka seller fans.
A lie propagated by nationalist to cover the fact Hindi is most broken language in existence.
1) Hindi is only spoken in major cities in north where trade flourishes and in most other regions of any northern state it is that state's language that is spoken widely. Example Marathi.
2) Even among these hindi speaking states no two states speak the same version of Hindi. Since it is a conjunction of other language without even a script for it's own there are influence of lot from local language of each state into their spoken hindi. Which makes this trope that "majority of India speaks hindi" even more of a lie.
due to this mentality, maharashtra, gujurat, punjab and other hindi speaking states dont have a successful movie industry! Hindi speaking actors dont have jobs in bollywood and they audition in south indian movies!
But all Hindi speakers can't read Hindi
We don't accept Hindi imposition by any national party or any individual. Doing this by anyone is always imposition and it is not integration in past and in future also
Ok but you accept english 😂😂😂😂
Government should Rule with English language, Plus local languages,
Hindi should not be forced to Non Hindi States, ..
Hindi is not superior. Tamil is classic and superior. So, hindi people are crows. Tamil is Peacock, National Bird. Now, how do you feel.
Too much hate for Hindi is disgusting and the same slaves like Urdu and English and even Chinese. Shame
English is king but Hindi 👎
You are having hindi as mother tongue, as per three languages policy what's your third language. You just learn only 2 which is your mother tongue which is hindi and English. But we have to learn our mother tongue and English and your mother tongue. Is there any fair treatment. Nigeria, Rwanda, south africa, SG and lot are all well developed having multiple lingo ethno population and they have all their native languages as national languages and have one connecting language which is from outside of their land. These countries have people with senses of real democracy not like hindi population in India and any union govt of any party behaving like Han Chinese, and Chinese party's. If so let's use Bengali the language of Indian national anthem. Or lets use Marathi the language of Maharashtra a state earning more than 60% of union's income. Or lets use Kannada language of Karnataka India's silicon valley the only full techno of this union. Or let's use the language of traditional Shiva worship of Kashmir for atleast to celebrate the past of india atleast.
@@Ajdjdkalw ok english come from your parent 😂😂😂😂
We southern state don't want to loose our ancient identify
U will not lose ur identity by learning a language. U learnt English - did that not rob u of ur identity?
@@mlg1279english can't destroyed our identity they give international jobs and development not hindi
😂
Well said Kasthuri shankar
Who the hell is this Malayali guy, but why hindi why not some other indian language 😂😂
that guy speaks same in all his debates..he is a BJP supporter..
If Hindi is to be a national language, it should be pure and " Suddha" Hindi but not mixed with Urdu. If it is pure, as it has common words with even Southern part of India.
Agreed, no problems. Shudh hindi is more beautiful anyway.
👍
Such a silly 🤣🤣🤣🤣
Can you find a book that teaches Suddha Hindi? Or a tv or radio program where all of the voices are in Suddha Hindi? It’s not something anyone can readily wrong because you can barely find any resources online.
I totally agree with Kasthuri ma'am 🥰
Kasthuri 💚💚
These many days there was no problem suddenly why should we learn Hindi do North Indians learn or can they spell ne word properly if they learn South Indian language s then let us think what should we do🤣🤣🤣 with hindi
Bollywood is trying to make trouble as it’s drowning
Trying to disturb peace
South Indians are doing great , leave it as it is . South Indians should embrace Hindi but no imposition pl
Mate do you know what the "should" mean. Google it and you will learn how stupid and contradictory you entire comment is.
South indians don't have to even embrace hindi
Unity in diversity has given way to unity in uniformity.
Hindi is Indias a national language ...
no hindi is not our national language
Malayalam is our National Language
@@whis6166 ok 😂😂😂😂
No doubt. Not only Hindi but any indian language as national will divide India.
Why does North India always impose their squewed views on the South.
They are enabled by our constitution and quite a few important figures in past. Both should be broken if we are ever gona get rid of this debate and shenanigans from nationalist.
Sanskrit is our national language.
Yes. But for now we need both Sanskrit (regional link language) and English (international link language). Sanskrit can also be written in any script.
Never
Solution is - Make Sanskrit as Link Language.
It's more like a question mark than a solution
But nobody knows it, If somebody says I am using this brand and many peoples are using the same brand but the greatnes is with some other brand. Most peoples will chose the former one because its a marketing Technology propagated even before Independance. Delhi was at the central during Independance and they want to communicate with South and other parts so they should have learned it but they forced and still forcing other peoples to do it . ONE of the exception is Bharathiyar.
Never happen 😂
1. Due to the common language hindi is spoken in Gujurat, Maharashtra, Punjab and many other states, they dont have their own successful movie industry! All these gujurathis, marathis, punjabis have to go to bollywood for jobs!
2. Take a look at IPL, you get commentary in English, Hindi, Tamil, Telugu, Kannada but not in Punjabi, Gujurathi, Haryanvi or other languages beacuse these people understands hindi! Tamil speaking guy gets a job as commentator but not a guy from gujurat!
3. Hollywood release their movies in Hindi, Tamil, Telugu, Kannada thus they need to hire a local experts of each language thus creating jobs!
South Indians dont hate Hindi, but hindi imposition will have adverse effects on jobs in the long run! The competition in bollywood is soo high that there are soo many hindi speaking good actors with no jobs!
If such debate not there people will will not think of divide Any traveler will learn out of necessity .
I think the problem lies in calling it as a national language. Why not call it just as the common communication language. People are not taking their stand via rational thinking but having taken it rationalise it. They don't seem to realise that they have no control, they can't have it at a global level, but westerners especially Americans do. They provide the larger content portion which as experienced is not appropriate to India's common culture and ancestral intellectual heritage. Not to overlook the economic implications and impact.
Mate did you hit your head somewhere or are you trying to be a smart-ass?. A common communication language is the gateway to link language or national language.
Problem is Hindi should have never been one of the two official language of India. The prevalent trope that majority northern population speaks Hindi is a lie. Hindi is prevalent only in major cities of North and they too do not speak the same version of it.
The other reason why no individual language can act as a national language to India is because India itself is not a nation. It doesn't has it's own culture or separate history. It's culture and history is the collection of every individual nations inside this country. This is why we call India a union of nations.
And if there is any language that should act as a link / official language it should be English. Or better just make all 22 language as official language of India why split hair and let English be the link language as it is common in both in Hindi speaking region and in non-hindi speaking region. This way we all will have to share the burden of learning English instead of making Hindi as a official language and pushing the burden only to non-hindi speakers.
Thus the problem is either Hindi being one of the official language of India or just Hindi being one of the official language of India. And constant attempt from northern politician and pundits to push Hindi into the south aka Hindi chauvinism.
What is the uses of hole in vadai ?
No uses
Just like that hindi for us 😂😂
If you wants to impose uniform civil code in country keeping aside constitutional law.Than ..Hindhi..should. be our National Launguage as well as official..Good Luck 👍.. 🙏..
The Constitution asks the government to "impose" UCC.
ahh no. You also can do that with English or any other official recognized Indian language. Good luck to you for when you break out of that bubble mate.
Goldberg + Brock Lesnar = Hindi 💪
Make cricket as India’s national sport bcoz maximum people watch cricket not hockey .. then make Hindi as national language bcz majority speak Hindi
No Hindi for South. We squarely don't want it. We need to learn our language. No need for Hindi. . If at all you learn the south Indian language. . If Rahul is. Proud malayalee then speak in Malayalam first. Let us hear it.
As a teacher I can tell you due to this ridiculous imposition the malayalee children do not learn Malayalam and can barely read It is a language with immense depth and literature.
Rahul is a chameleon who changed colour as per the situation. He lacks any depth of thinking and lacks sincerity.
what is the south Indian language? Malayalam? Tamil? telugu? Kannada? what is it?
You cant expect people to learn four languages can you? I don't understand why you are speaking English of all languages and holds animosity against another Indic language
@@flextape1859 who are you to dictate what should be our ancient identity, each language have its own deep root spirituality and beauty. It's very simple to keep your mother tongue and the first language which connected whole of India.
@babulalsuryakant sharma India is already having very low IQ and it got from 86 to 75 . And film entertainment makes no good for India rather than it makes people more fools and makes outsiders to not mention. Too cringe .
ok ricebag
We in the south are not against Hindi but the imposition of Hindi on us. This will be treated as the third language they learn not the second. Presently their mother tongue is the optional third language which is killing the language itself By this you are killing the diversity and the ability of the child to appreciate his own mother tongue. So ease do not mix up your silly agenda of national unity with language. People are already learning enough functional Hindi which is more than enough. Let them become pandits in the richness of their own mother tongue.
The Constitution said that English must be replaced by Sanskrit.
30% of tamil is sanskrit
Even Telugu ,Kannada and Malayalam has more than 50% sanskrit words
where are you idiots pulling these numbers from?. Because honestly there is no hard data anywhere on this planet to give a tangible value to mixing of Indian languages.
Tamil is not derived from Sanskrit. Ancient Tamil has no Sanskrit words. Modern spoken Tamil has..
who the fk told you 30% sanskrit in tamil just another ignorant fool who has no idea about tamil baseless arugment show your mindset and knowledge fools like you are the reason we hate sanskrit supporters who has zero knowledge.
Where did it say that?
What's the problem with status quo?
Hindi should be our national language that doesn't mean the regional or state languages are degraded. We are still in the colonial hangover or submission. We should give english to continue as one of the languages. Russia China Japan german and many other countries, their language is not english.
In all those countries you name, the regional and state languages were in fact degraded due to a national language policy.
EINSTEIN STORY 💯
One day Einstein Makes the large hole in door for mother cat 😺
In few days, next to the large hole, he makes small hole for kitten 🐈
Then only he realised, large hole itself enough for both kitten and cat
That small hole is Hindi
That large hole is English
English is enough to connect peoples in All over world. Assuming North India and pro hindi imposing peoples are part of world 🌍
Samskrutam has been the common language used all across our civilization North south east and west used that same language let us bring it back and let samskrutam retake the slot as the unifying language of our nation.
Rahul gave his CV Why he is chief of editor of times now
Actually most of indians speak hindi. But it's their call when to open up.. no one can tell , invididuals in conversation decide it
Hindi is NOT the National language. Beyond a point if Hindi is thrust down the throats of non Hindi speaking Indians it will only divide the country.
We are happy with our languages. There is no need to force any language on any other people. Hindi apart from the numerical advantage it doesn't add any value to people in south. So there is no need for us to learn Hindi.
Rahul Eashwar his name is Hindi( north indian style) Rahulan Eashwaran is proper Malayalam form
Everybody can not learn all Indian language we should have one national language and it can be commonly used hindi
What's national language ? It is too diversified and this push gives opposition fuel to them.
*Please say no to language war*
I am a Indian from the North , but I don't believe in common language . We Indians are always exception .We don't require any common language to become united , If South Indian don't wanna speek in Hindi they should be not be forced to do so. But l am also against hindi buycot . Both Hindi and English are the official language and that's why no one should try to impose other languages too. In South politicians even criticize mensoning of Hindi but not English , For Indians from South they follow different rules , let's say a tamil person if goes to Kanada (Karnataka) he will be allowed to whisper Tamil people will understand that he don't know Kannada and English but if a Bihari can't , In Bihar their exists five local languages but they don't feel shy in talking in hindi outside .
North Indians should answer this question ❓ State of HINDI & Land of Hindi... It's a Market language (mixed of Arabic, Persian, Turkish, and Indian dialets..) 700 years before... ( Sanskrit also don't have land and people group... it's a communication dialet among Arabic Persian, Indian region at that time.) most of the north Indians forget about their language (mother tongue) and support Hindi 😅 that's why most of the north Indian languages lost their identity 😢 Bihari, Oriyaa, Rajasthani, Panjabi, bengali, kaasmiri, Marathi😢 (its just like telling neighbour as their parents)
Im telugu person.i cannot speak hindhi.but i can read and write.i support hindhi.we need one common language.we need one nation one offcial language (hindhi). remaining languages people choice.
As a keralite.
I don't want kerala to leave malayalam language and accept hindi in it ...
Can embrace hindi but not hindi imposing
Pora lucha. Nuvvu nerchuko hindi kaani ma meeda force cheyyaku.
ENDUKU. ENGLISH UNDI GA., CHAALU. ENI LANGUAGE CHADAVAALI., KAANI., HINDI VAALU. EM CHADAVARU., VEDAVALU.
They give opportunities to Hindi heroines only.villains are from Hindi .They acted in reel & real.
India is the best country in the world tell that lady
You are having hindi as mother tongue as per three languages policy what's your third language. You just learn only 2 which is your mother tongue which is hindi and English. But we have to learn our mother tongue and English and your mother tongue. Is there any fair treatment. Nigeria, Rwanda, south africa, SG and lot are all well developed having multiple lingo ethno population and they have all their native languages as national languages and have one connecting language which is from outside of their land. These countries have people with senses of real democracy not like hindi population in India and any union govt of any party behaving like Han Chinese, and Chinese party's. If so let's use Bengali the language of Indian national anthem. Or lets use Marathi the language of Maharashtra a state earning more than 60% of union's income. Or lets use Kannada language of Karnataka India's silicon valley the only full techno of this union. Or let's use the language of traditional Shiva worship of Kashmir for atleast to celebrate the past of india atleast. If best country don't behave like Han population of China and C C P of China.
Yes it is being imposed
All these people killing Indian language by discussion
One Indian language not shining on International platform.
TAMIL is not old language
Sanskrit and Kannada older than Tamil.
TAMIL is old language according to Politicians not the statement of Linguistics expert
Can you tell me any source for your statement.
Unnecessary debate, the HM should not have raised this issue at all, does our country needs the language debate Now, take the country to development path not this way
When will Indian will understand, that the first man Adam is from India , all the world peoples are born out of Indian ancestors
There's no such thing as Adam
Its very surprising that European example is not at all reckoned.
Despite common religion, they are divided into tiny Nations where as vast country of ours is United despite multi languages...plesse don't try to put one language over other great languages of ours
It is the reason why we need Sanskrit as the link language. Nobody gets any unfair advantage because most have to learn it from scratch including Hindi speakers and devanigiri script is not the official Sanskrit script either. Sanskrit can be written in any script.
European countries are united under Euro and NATO. Most European languages have 40 to 90% Sanskrit words like Indian regional languages (including Tamil). So, SANSKRIT can become the link language of the future Europe. Then Indians would also accept it because they love to ape their white masters.😀😀
Dear Shri Rahul Shivshankar, I liked the way you have presented your own background. I am a Kannadiga, but I believe it is advisable to have national language and Hindi fits this bill more than any other language.
Sanskrit is better. Hindi as the link language gives unfair advantage to Hindi speaking people at least initially. When it comes to Sanskrit, most have to learn from scratch. Moreover, Sanskrit can be written in any script.
@@indianmilitary how many people know sanskrit ?
In today's world how we believe in Mahatma Gandhi ideology, if that is the case why BJP is not accepting Congress. It is depending upon time and change must be there. Don't say that Mahatma Gandhi told this and that
To hype this issue is malice. This is not public service.
OK., DIVIDE, INDIA., INTO NORTH AND SOUTH. SOUTH WILL MAKE ENGLISH AS OFFICIAL LANGUAGE. NO PROBLEM FOR US. U NORTH MAKE HINDI. THANK U INDIA.
I would say govt should focus on sanskrit which has been replaced with urdu and hindustani in film industry.. no one speak pure hindi india except couple of states.. can all stop talking hindustani which is mix of hindi and urdu
didn't urdu aswell was made in India? As for sanskrit I would like it aswell but its impractical in current stage. The people who speak sanskrit in daily lives is even less than one percent, to tell you how stupid the situation is, the people of india who speak french as mother tongue are more in numbers.
@@rickycool6083 off course its... socalled hindi cenima itself lack pure hindi and we have been watching for decades. Perhaps , we could have had even urdu cenima or etc.... Had we maintained n given importance to languages at their positions this situation wouldn't have arise. Therefore , it's tough now to repair or make things fall in place, as diversity exists since years n changes took place long back...let people decide , we have managed/succeeded it till now
Sudeep sir is correct
Don't impose Hindi no anti North Indians ground reality we all understand English let us continue
Our language is just like the Quran,if i as a northeast if a hindi spoken man say's kharap admi,if i says why you accuse me as kharap,then the hindi speaking person can misinterpreted like Arabic no kharap means you look so young today's, that's is why Hindi is needed to every Indians, otherwise it will be like Indian reading a quran in arabic knowing nothing out of it.
Make Indian English as our National language
I think Hindi should not be promoted. I think English is enough. It doesn't matter if English is used and doesn't infringe on our national spirits.
I am from Andhra Pradesh, i would like to learn Hindi
Who has stopped you do whatever you want people pleaser
Nerchuko evvadu vaddu annaadu kaani maa meda ruddadu.
Mr.Ajay D., first of all stop advertising gutkas/liquor ., you earn a lot to ruin younger generation and you preach, you bollywood actors/actress try to ruin this country even if you feel a little way, if at all.
In Tamil Nadu, those non Tamil leaders who spearheaded agitation against Hindi learning, making innocent people believe that there is threat to mother tongue Tamil. But all schools run by DMK and ADMK party corporates are extorting money by selling Hindi and English. Only poor could not study hindi as no government school provides Hindi teaching. Crores of rupees is spent by lakhs of people to learn hindi. Other opposition ruled states also joined the chorus for petty political mileage.
Stop joking no one is spending money to learn hindi
No. South cannot have its own fake identity. Hindi is a very common Indian language spoken by lots of non Hindi people
idiot "hindi is spoken by lot of non-hindi people". If you people have more than two brain cell we could at least have a argument. 🤦♂️😡
We don't need a National language. You can't get all Indians to speak one language. What we need is a link language. We can have both English and Hindi as the link languages. For God's sake, the North Indians must stop starting their Hindi day speeches with the most annoying opener:- 'Hindi hamara Rashtra bhasha hai...'
Make Sanskrit the natural link language of Bharatam.
Why can't we have both Hindi and English as link languages? Inspite of the hate campaign against English... many South Indians as well as North Indians like to learn and speak English. Even labourers want their children to learn English in schools. English is not a foreign language it belongs to Indians also... most of us speak Indian English as opposed to Queen's English.
This same politicians who are vouching for hindi will send their children to english medium schools
English is a foreign language. And no there is no hate campaign against english, english should and will be taught to each and every student in every school however our official language should be indian language. Hindi seems most practical as nearly 70% of indians atleast understand it. Sanskrit is also a good choice, cause of our civilizational history, but its way more difficult to implement.
suraj m We need Sanskrit and English not Hindi. Sanskrit as the regional link language and English as the link language outside INDIA. Everybody has to learn Sanskrit, at least most of them from scratch and nobody gets any unfair advantage. Sanskrit also can be written in any script.
@@rickycool6083 English can even be from Mars... but the fact remains that we Indians have inherited the colonial legacy. We dress like the British and have been educated in English.
@@indianmilitary Very difficult to implement.
This lady from TN doesn't know that in Europe Englush is spoken in Britain and in NO other Contry.
We keralite loves tamil than Panipuri language 😂
@@humanitysucks1233 : Looks like Madara pass out.
We keralite (sic) loves (sic)
So, this is the STANDARD of English language in Kerala.
God save ,God's own country.
@@pradeepchauhan7769 nobody needs to be professors in English,you got what he is saying right.
@@Attitudezero884 : That is the reason for your mental slavery although the slave-makers left our land 75 years ago. Nobody is thrusting Hindi upon you in Bharat but you have thrust English upon yourself only if to appear like a DARK third class copy of an Englishman.
wrong. Except Norway and probably France the second language of all the Scandinavian countries (Western European countries) is English.
you have it wrong Hindi is not being imposed in south,those who speak it are ethnically cleansed or converted.Investigate your facts how congress has allowed people with certain ideology cannot be challaged
Hindustan is not same as Hindistan. India doesn't need one national language. It is not about Madrasi Vs north India. Bollywood for all it's achievements and recognition earned worldwide, is the creation of Pan India from the very beginning. To proclaim that hindi is already a national language is a poor reflection and is a revelation of ignorance.
Jai Hind!
We need Sanskrit as the link language not Hindi. So, we need both Sanskrit (regional link language) and English (international link language). We need a level playing field. Sanskrit also can be written in any script.
here is a difference between imposition and suggestion. It was suggested Hindi can be a national language. either take the suggesion or leave it. there ends the matter. the channels are playing the game along with politicians and prominent persons like actors. The actors of south should not dub their films in Hindi. Double standard.
What's the harm if South Indian films are dubbed in Hindi?
@@mlg1279 nothing. But these actors who want Hindi rights for earning money oppose Hindi vehemently. Just think it.
@@ravichandrantns3799 These are 2 different issues.
A lot of Hollywood films are dubbed in Hindi, too. Does it mean that Americans should start learning Hindi??
All Language in world has its own essence in terms of culture,dialect and it's regional strength, by imposing will destroy it So India is seen is multicultural Nation, it was going on well why sudden change
Mate the origin of this debate is our constitution. It has more than one law that favors just hindi and none towards other native languages of India. The plan for infusing these laws was to make Hindi as national to unify India as one nation some years ago. Some egocentric nationalist a-holes in the north still cling on to this huge mistake in our constitution to this day that is the problem.
Congress tried it for year and it passed this mantle of responsibility to current BJP in power. So no it never was going well w.r to language or religion in our country!.
Rahul Ishwar is right . This women has lost it. Hindi as a link language should not be an issue. This does not undermine any other language. This is a psycholgical drama playing in her mind. She is sugar coating her malice for Hindu subconciously.
REMOVE HINDI AS OFFICIAL LANGUAGE. FIRST. OR MAKE ALL LANGUAGES AS OFFICIAL LANGUAGE
No Hindi, Never.
Art of "selling an idea" does not seem to be a virtue of the Hindikaris.
Hindi imposed on any other regional language is not acceptable .. it will never happen in Secular India . But not accepting Hindi as an alternative to Quinglish .. is majboori ka naam Mohan Das Karamchand Gandhi
An alternative for English meaning everyone should learn Quindy?. What you think you are a smart-ass by giving a spin on your nationalistic view?.
What real value to do people think quindy have once we learn that thing?. Where is reason to put that effort?. IDIOTS 🤦♂️😡
by choice people talk in their preferred language there has been no problem .but the movement some one ask u to follow path decided by other would not go that easy... by the way who will monitor who is talking what , biggest joke of century. They govt can monitor this rather monitor public issues.
Learning another language Hindi, with enhance the brain and make life colourful.
Tamilians speak Tamil with every sentences filled with English words.
British left
Freedom obtained
Slave to the British Raj is evident.
Bharat is pluralistic and colourful.
The British were successful in shuffling English down our throats.
To be in their good books and to survive learning English there was no objection!
Is English a language of Bharat?
Learning Hindi the people won’t become lesser or feel mother tongue compromised.
AR Rahman composes for Hindi films, why?
He should stick to his Tamil only.
More languages means versatility.
If Rahul can’t speak English than it’s your parents who didn’t pass it to you!
Have you learned an Indian language besides the one you were raised with? One which is totally different?
English is being imposed.
This lady is hypocrisy she heat hindi but speaks hindi
learn hindi to beg in hindi in US. Hindi theriyathu poda.
Hindi is just one of the 22 languages... nothing more, nothing less. Shameless BJP neither have common sense nor sense of constitution.
This tamilnadu peoples are dual minded. They oppose hindi in tamilnadu but when they move out of tamilnadu for jobs, business or any other purposes.
Than their hindi heat goes in to bay of bangal.
I couldn't understand what is problem with tamilnadu peoples!
Not only tamil nadu
We keralites also can't..
Can embrace hindi,but Imposing hindi is not fair..
Hindi will be choice language in south indian education system (kerala ,tamil nadu) don't know how andra & karnataka
,
Tamil is pure language that made in india.
Hindi is the mixed language of urdu ,parshi ,arabic .😂and saying non hindi speakers are Foreigners..
Lol..that doesn't make sense.
We loves tamil than Panipuri language.
Here there are many problems of inflation ,but focusing and dividing peoples by religious and language..
Well done BJP.
Jai modi ji.💩
@@humanitysucks1233 what a stupid thought you got ! Hindi is chosen as official language by constitute assembly while framing our constitute . Than where is the role of modi ji ?
You say that Tamil is pure language than what about sanskrit ? It's more pure than Tamil.
You mentioned that kerala peoples also don't want hindi ! Than you come and meet with kerala peoples in mumbai. The problem with hindi is not with Tamil, kerala and Kanda peoples. The problem is with the mind set of kerala left and Tamil dravid mind set . Who are stick to false narrative of maikale education left propaganda and believe that hindi is language of North India and imposed on them . In fact when these peoples travel out of their states then the know hindi but when they are back they oppose hindi . What a hypocrisy and dual policy!
@@shrikantdubey63 bruh.
At that time also hindi was largest speaking language is hindi in india..
And there are no National language in india..
😂
And kerala peoples coming to north indian states?? Then do u have any idea how many Northies working in south india?? Lmao.. why can't they speak our language?? And why should we learn hindi??
Use English as link language.
That's it..
No need of hindi😂
And tamil is much older than sanskriti..
Making sankrit as national language is acceptable.
🤣But making a foreign mix language as national language is unacceptable..
Sanjay nishant up leader said "non hindi speakers are not indians ,they are foreigners"..
*Lol speaking foreign mixed language makes indian*
*and*
*speaking pure indian orgin languages makes Foreigner* 😂..
And we are not even against hindi..but we are against hindi imposing
@@humanitysucks1233 what a hypocrisy hindi is forgien language ? Than what is your great opinion about at present you and me are having conversations ?
Overcome from North Indian and hindi heatered.
@@humanitysucks1233 wow what a stupid argument the north Indian to learn your language but you will not !
You wish that north people to learn Tamil Malayalam, kannada, tulu and telgu OT OK they will do now are you ready to learn dogri ,gadhwali ,panjab, hryanvi avdhi, bundelkhsndi,kanuji, maithili bsngali, bundelkhandi, oriya chharishgarhi in addition to hindi . I have left many languages which are spoken and scripts are deferential Now decide .
You have to take inspiration from arunachal pradesh where more than 2000 languages are there but their state language is hindi.
Pata nahi tum kub sudharenge